News · AFM · 25 Oct 2026
The AFM's compliance investigation at eight pension funds and insurers found shortcomings at all providers, including failure to present all pension choices, insufficient insight into consequences, incorrect calculations in online pension planners, and information provided only after choices became final. Providers must give participants quantitative insight into the pension impact of choices and combined choices before choices are final, allow adjustment after that insight, and ensure correct, findable and understandable information. The AFM will intensify supervision of choice guidance.
REPORT
SUPERVISION
In brief – This report contains the findings from the AFM's study into choice guidance at retirement. In doing so, the AFM specifically looked at the consequences of choices. Although the pension sector has worked hard on choice guidance, the AFM sees a need for improvement. Pension providers should take participants as the starting point when drafting information and give them better insight into the consequences of choices. And this information must be correct and clear and be provided in a timely manner.
OCTOBER |2026
AFM
The AFM has conducted a study into choice guidance. The study concerns choice guidance for (former) participants at retirement, such as the choices for the moment of pension commencement and the exchange between old-age pension and partner's pension. The study was conducted from September 2025 to September 2026 at eight pension funds and insurers. In this, the AFM particularly looked at the extent to which the pension providers make the consequences of choices and combined choices transparent for participants.
The AFM found shortcomings at all pension providers examined, with serious impact for participants. For example, pension providers do not always point out to their participants all the pension choices they have, as a result of which they miss out on choice options. The AFM also sees that participants often do not get sufficient insight into the consequences of choices, that the information about the consequences of choices is not correct, or that this information is only provided after the participant's choices have already become final. Because a participant bases his choice on the information received, the shortcomings identified can lead to unsuitable pension choices and thus to financial damage for participants. In addition, choices made by participants after retirement can no longer be adjusted. It is therefore important that the choice guidance goes well in one go. The AFM expects pension providers to study the insights from this report and, where necessary, use them in improving their choice guidance. The six most important points for attention are:
Take the participant as the starting point when drafting the information. The participant is the starting point of your choice guidance. Also take into account differences between participants, for example participants who prefer to take in information digitally or rather by post. After all, choice guidance revolves around the participants: they must be enabled to make a suitable choice.
Inform about the choices participants can make and what consequences these choices have. The AFM finds that important information for making a suitable choice is missing in the participant communication. The pension provider must ensure that participants receive information about the choices they can make, the consequences of choices for the pension, and the consequences of the combination of choices for the pension. Other relevant consequences and considerations can also help the participant make a suitable choice, such as pointing out the impact of choices on tax and benefits.
Also make the quantitative impact of the choice on the pension transparent. Before his choices are final, the participant must gain insight into how much higher or lower the pension will be with a particular choice.
Give participants enough time to make their choices around retirement carefully. The choices participants can make around retirement are impactful and complex. Therefore ensure that the choice guidance starts in a timely manner. In addition, before their choices are final, participants must have gained insight into the consequences of these choices on the level of the pension. This does not always appear to be the case. It is essential that, after gaining insight into the level of the pension, the participant can still adjust his choice.
Ensure that the information provided to participants is correct. The AFM has identified errors in the calculations in the online pension planner at a number of pension providers. These errors could and should have been prevented and could have been discovered by simple checks. In addition, we also see other incorrect information appearing, such as
errors in calculations that are sent by post or information that is not in line with the pension scheme.
At the same time, the AFM sees that pension providers are motivated to guide their participants adequately. This gives the AFM confidence in how the sector will deal with the findings from the study. In this, ensure that the participant interest is central in the decision-making about choice guidance and that this is also explicitly recorded, so that the choice guidance can be continuously improved.
| Table 1: Pension choices that the AFM looked at in this study1 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Choices in the accrual phase | Choices around retirement | Choices after retirement |
| • Value transfer at start of participation • Investment freedom in the accrual phase • Registering and deregistering partner • Choices regarding risk coverages such as survivor's pension and disability pension • Choices when separating • Additional saving • Participation in net pension • Commutation of excessive pension • Commutation of small pension • Choices regarding voluntary continuation | • Direct purchase • Provisional choice of fixed or variable benefit • Choice of provider (shop right) ✓ Bringing forward pension commencement ✓ Deferring pension commencement ✓ Part-time pension ✓ Conversion of survivor's pension into old-age pension and vice versa ✓ Fixed or variable benefit ✓ High-low, low-high and level pension ✓ Fixed decrease or fixed increase | • Choice for a fixed or variable benefit during the transition • (Investment profile during the payout phase) • Choices upon separation |
[1] This table contains a non-exhaustive overview of pension choices that a participant can make under the law or that the participant can make under the pension scheme if the choice is offered therein.
Introduction 5
Research design 6
Relationship with previous publications 7
Follow-up research 7
1 Take the participant as starting point 8
1.1 Information that aligns with your participants 8
1.2 Utilizing available participant data 9
2 Provide insight into the consequences of choices 11
2.1 Information about pension choices 11
2.2 Consequences for the pension – qualitative and quantitative 12
2.3 Other relevant consequences and considerations in choices 13
2.4 Consequences of combined choices 15
3 Ensure that the participant receives the relevant information in time 16
3.1 Timely provision of information about pension choices 16
3.2 Information about consequences before choices are final 17
4 Information provision must be correct 18
4.1 Prevent errors in pension planners 18
4.2 Correct information per document and in coherence 19
5 Ensure clear information: findable and understandable for the target group 20
5.1 Findable 20
5.2 Understandable 21
6 Keep improving choice guidance 22
6.1 Participant interest in decision-making 22
6.2 From intention to measurable impact 23
Participants2 must be able to rely on adequate choice guidance by pension providers. 3 Adequate choice guidance is necessary because pension is impactful and complex for many participants. Participants must make important decisions based on the information and choice guidance they receive from their pension provider. Pension choices have a major impact on the financial situation of participants in their old age. An unsuitable choice can lead to financial disappointment. The consequences of inadequate choice guidance are immediately noticeable for participants in the payout phase. In addition, choices made are made once and may not be changed afterwards. That is why it is extra important that around retirement the choice guidance to participants is adequate, and the individual participant and his choices are central. The participant must be enabled to make a choice that suits him.
Since 2023, the AFM has devoted several publications to choice guidance and has now conducted its first compliance investigation4.5 The investigation concerns the choice guidance to participants at retirement at eight pension funds and insurers. The outcomes are also relevant for PPIs. The AFM has specifically looked at the extent to which pension providers make the consequences of choices transparent for participants.
The AFM found shortcomings at all investigated pension providers with serious impact for participants. For example, pension providers do not always point out to their participants all pension choices they have, causing them to miss choice options. The AFM also sees that participants often do not get sufficient insight into the consequences of choices, that the information about the consequences of choices is not correct or that this information is only provided after the participant's choices have already been finalized. Despite the fact that the choice guidance standard has been in force for some time, the investigation shows that pension providers must make improvements to meet the minimum legal standard. The identified shortcomings can directly lead to unsuitable pension choices and thus to financial damage for participants. This can also lead to loss of confidence in the pension sector.
The AFM expects pension providers to study the insights from this report and, where necessary, immediately use them in improving their choice guidance. This report successively covers: the participants as starting point (chapter 1), points of attention in the consequences of choices (chapter 2), timely information provision (chapter 3), correct information provision (chapter 4), clear information provision (chapter 5) and improving choice guidance (chapter 6). This report contains text blocks with good examples that the AFM encountered in the investigation. The examples are not intended to be copied one-to-one, but serve as inspiration. After all, the choice guidance must align with your participants. In addition, text blocks with relevant information are included. These text blocks can be recognized by the icon with an 'i'.
[2] By participants we mean participants, former participants, former partners and pension beneficiaries, or a subgroup thereof.
[3] By pension providers is meant: pension funds, insurers and PPIs.
[4] In a compliance investigation, the AFM assesses whether the relevant statutory articles are complied with. If this is not the case, the AFM will in principle proceed to impose an appropriate measure.
[5] On page 7 under the heading 'Relationship with previous publication', the AFM explains what it has previously done in the field of choice guidance.
The AFM conducted a compliance investigation into choice guidance around retirement at eight pension providers. The AFM requested three participant files with different characteristics6 from each party, as well as the generic communication available about choices around retirement. The AFM assessed whether participants gain sufficient insight into the consequences of choices and whether the information is timely, correct and clear.
The AFM looked at the following choices, insofar as the pension provider offers them:
The moment of pension commencement (advancing or deferring pension commencement);
Part-time pension;
Exchange between old-age pension and partner's pension (in both directions);
Variation in the level of the pension (high-low, low-high and an increasing or decreasing benefit);
The final choice between a fixed or variable benefit.
In the study, the AFM did not assess the full choice guidance. The study was delineated to choices around retirement and the focus was on information about the consequences of choices and the combination of choices. Adequate choice guidance obviously goes further than solely providing information. Pension providers must enable participants to make an appropriate choice. To that end, they must guide the participant adequately and set up a choice environment.7 Providing insight into the choices and consequences of choices is part of this.
Pension providers must record the choice guidance provided to participants. The recording is important in order to be able to show participants how they were guided in their choices, also if participants ask questions about this at a later moment - after retirement. The AFM tested whether choice guidance to a participant had been adequate on the basis of the information recorded in the participant file.
The participant files requested by the AFM often do not contain a complete record of the contact that took place with the participant. For example, the AFM missed records of conversations, from which it can be inferred whether consequences of choices were mentioned. It was also not always recorded whether a participant made use of the online choice environment. And in one case, the online choice environment as it looked at the time of the file could no longer be reproduced. The AFM requested the information that it considered missing again from the pension providers. On the basis of the documents provided, the AFM then assessed whether a participant had gained sufficient insight into the consequences of choices and whether there was adequate choice guidance. When a pension provider does not record or cannot reproduce parts of the choice guidance to participants, the pension provider runs the risk that it cannot demonstrate that it complies with the information provision standards or the choice guidance standard.
[6] The participant files differ on the following characteristics: active participant or deferred member, with or without partner, the channels used in the choice guidance and the choices made.
[7] Article 48a of the Pension Act (Pw) and Article 59a of the Act on Mandatory Occupational Pension Schemes (Wvb).
The AFM also examined the maturity of choice guidance at five of the eight pension providers.8 The AFM did this to obtain a picture of the manner in which pension providers safeguard the participant's interest in choice guidance. The AFM sent out a self-assessment, in which the pension providers assessed their maturity level against the following three expectations:
The board has established an ambition with regard to choice guidance and has formulated an appropriate strategy for this;
The board ensures careful decision-making with regard to choice guidance, in particular with regard to the interest of the (individual) participant;
The board ensures that the choice guidance enables their participants to make an appropriate choice.
After the self-assessment, the AFM verified, on the basis of a conversation with access to documents, whether it could follow the estimated maturity level.9 The outcomes of this study have also been included in this report where relevant. In general, the AFM is satisfied with the maturity of choice guidance at the pension providers examined. This gives the AFM confidence in how the parties examined will deal with the findings in the study.
Choice guidance is an important standard and receives a great deal of attention from the AFM. In July 2023, the AFM published the Choice Guidance Guide, in which we describe the process for arriving at adequate choice guidance. This process consists of three steps: setting up choice guidance, carrying out the actual choice guidance and continuously improving choice guidance. The AFM subsequently conducted an exploratory study in 2024 into the set-up of choice guidance (the first step in the process). The study focused on the process that pension providers have gone through to arrive at adequate choice guidance. The report with findings from this study was published in early 2025. After that, in 2025 the AFM carried out an exploration of choice guidance for lump sums. The report you are now reading concerns the second step: carrying out the choice guidance.
The AFM will continue to conduct studies into choice guidance in the coming years. The AFM sees and acknowledges the large amount of work being carried out by the sector during the pension transition. For choice guidance too, the sector has made great efforts. At the same time, improvements are necessary. Participants are entitled to adequate choice guidance, regardless of the moment at which they make important pension choices. It is important here that pension providers ensure that participants can gain good insight into the consequences of (combined) choices. At the parties examined, choice guidance around retirement still does not meet the statutory minimum standard in various respects. All parties in the investigation have been pointed to violations and must implement improvements. Due to the outcomes of this investigation, the AFM will intensify its supervision of choice guidance.
[8] In its selection, the AFM took into account, among other things, relieving pension providers who were in the middle of the transition.
[9] More information about this type of investigation and the various maturity levels can be found here on the AFM's website: Borging klantbelang.
Knowledge of the needs, characteristics and skills of (groups of) participants forms the basis of good choice guidance. This is one of the main messages from the report that the AFM published in 2025 following its investigation into the design of choice guidance. This message is also relevant here. After all, choice guidance revolves around the participants: they must be enabled to make an appropriate choice. Below, the AFM lists a number of generic recommendations following the investigation, which can be used to align information about consequences with participants.
Consistency between channels prevents confusion among participants. Pension providers often use multiple channels within the same choice process. It is important that letters, brochures, websites, explainer videos, online planners and participant portals use the same terms, amounts and explanations. If, for example, terminology differs per channel, this can raise questions among participants and make the choice process unnecessarily complicated.
Participants must be able to navigate easily between different channels. Because choice guidance often takes place via multiple channels, participants must be able to easily find what the next step is and where they can take it. Think of clear links from the website to the online planner, concrete references in the letter to contact options and visible help options in the participant portal.
Do not burden participants with unnecessary thinking and calculation steps. In both online and offline channels, it occurs that participants must make calculations themselves to properly understand the consequences of a choice. It also occurs that amounts are only presented in gross annual amounts, while many participants assess their financial situation mainly on the basis of monthly net income and expenses. Pension providers will not always sufficiently promote with a gross annual amount that participants gain insight into the consequences of choices for their pension. The risk increases that participants misjudge the consequences of choices if participants must convert or interpret amounts themselves.
Good example: In the pension planner, known data of the participant is directly incorporated into the explanation. For the choice for AOW bridging, for example, it states that the participant can “supplement the pension until [month] [year], the month in which you receive AOW”. As a result, the participant does not need to look up this information themselves or translate it to their own situation, making the explanation more personal, concrete and easier to apply.
Good example: In the pension planner, the participant can save different pension plans or scenarios. This allows the participant to compare multiple choices side by side and gain low-threshold insight into the quantitative impact of different choices on the level of the pension benefit.
Ensure that visual support is easy to interpret and directly aligns with the choice the participant must make. Graphs in online planners can help participants understand the consequences of choices at a glance. A good graph clearly shows what changes due to a choice. That does require that the graph is properly readable and clearly explained. When numbers are difficult to read or explanation is missing, visual information can actually cause confusion. In that case, the graph provides limited added value. The AFM recommends testing whether visual support is well understood by the participants for whom it is intended.
Use available participant data to better align information. Pension providers have a lot of information that can be relevant for choice guidance, such as age, partner status, and communication preferences. Yet we saw that this information is not always used to guide participants in a more targeted way. For example, participants without a registered partner sometimes still first receive information or questions about their partner pension that in many cases will not be relevant. From the participant's perspective, it would be more logical to first indicate that no partner is registered, but that the possibility exists to still register a potential partner. Including an explanation of why it is important to do this. If the participant does have a partner, targeted information about the partner pension can then be shared. It also occurs that participants must look up or enter data themselves, while this data is already known (or should be known) to the pension provider. Think of information about previous relationships or disability. This causes unnecessary thinking and searching steps that make the choice process more complex. As a result, the risk increases that participants drop out, make mistakes or have to assess information that is not relevant to them.
The pension provider obtains information about a marriage or registered partnership and its termination from the Personal Records Database. This does not apply to other types of partners within the meaning of the pension scheme. These other partners must be registered as recipients of the partner pension after retirement no later than the commencement of the old-age pension. After that, this is no longer possible.
The pension provider needs up-to-date information about the participant's relationship status in order to adequately guide the participant in the choice for commutation between old-age pension and partner's pension (in both directions) at pension commencement. The relationship status has an impact on, among other things:
The standard option: partner's pension if there is a partner and no partner's pension if there is no partner;
Whether or not permission is required from the partner for choices that have a negative effect on the amount of the partner's pension;10
What information is relevant for the participant.
The pension provider must therefore call on the participant without a partner to register any partner after all, whereby it also makes clear why this is important. In the case of a participant with a partner, the pension provider must ask whether the relationship still exists or has since ended. Here too, the pension provider must make clear why this is important. It is good to explicitly include the partner's details here, so that the participant can check whether they are still up to date. The AFM recommends not only using the word 'divorce' when requesting the information as to whether the relationship has since ended, because participants may only think of ending a marriage in this regard.
Unfortunately, the AFM still regularly sees that pension providers do not actively point out to participants the possibility of adjusting the relationship status. The importance of this is also often not clearly explained. This must improve. And in this regard, the earlier the information about the relationship status is updated, the better the rest of the choice guidance can align with the participant's situation.
[10] Article 60, sixth paragraph, Pw, 62, second paragraph, Pw, Article 72, sixth paragraph, Wvb and Article 74, second paragraph, Wvb.
Segmentation can help to offer participants more relevant information and guidance. This applies in particular to non-standard situations, such as participants who are incapacitated for work, participants who have former partner(s) or participants who have not accrued a full AOW.
Good example: The pension provider that does not yet use the API of Stichting Pensioenregister11 asks the participant whether he has always lived in the Netherlands and, if this is not the case, how long the participant has lived abroad. The pension provider uses this information to show what the participant will receive in AOW and pension benefit from the pension provider.
[11] With this API, with the participant's consent, information about AOW and pension accrual at other pension providers can be included in choice guidance.
Participants must be able to have insight into their choice options and what the consequences of (combined) choices are. The pension provider must promote that the information gives participants insight into this. This concerns insight into:
the choice options that exist in the pension scheme;
the consequences of important events for the pension;
the consequences of a choice for the pension;
the consequences of a combination of choices for the pension.12
The pension provider must provide participants with information about the choices they can make around retirement. The Pension Act prescribes that information that is specifically important in the context of pension commencement must be provided to the participant.13 This also concerns information about the various choices the participant can make. The information should therefore not only be passively available, but pension providers must actively provide it to participants.
According to the law, information can be provided in various ways, namely electronically, in writing or via a website (such as a 'MijnOmgeving') combined with personal notification. 15
If the pension provider provides information in writing, because this is the participant's preference or because the pension provider chooses this when the participant has not passed on a preference, all information to be provided must be provided in writing. This also applies if a pension provider provides the information in layers. It is therefore, for example, not possible to provide the first two layers by post and to place the third layer (only) on the website if the third layer contains legally required information to be provided.
When providing via a website, the pension provider personally notifies the participant of this. The notification must be concrete enough. Concrete means that, on the basis of the notification, the participant knows what information is ready for him and why this is relevant for him. In addition, the participant must know where the information is by means of a direct link to the information on the website or 'MijnOmgeving'.
At some pension providers in the study, participants are not pointed out to all the choices they can make. This is often the case with the choice for part-time pension and with the choice to bring forward the pension commencement.
Without pointing out to participants the choice options they have, they are not enabled to make an appropriate choice. The participant is himself responsible for making his pension choices and he can only take this responsibility if he knows which choices he can make.
[12] Article 48, third paragraph, Pw and Article 59, third paragraph, Wvb.
[13] Article 43 Pw and Article 54 Wvb in conjunction with Article 7a Decree implementing the Pension Act and the Act on mandatory occupational pension schemes (BuPw).
[14] For more information about providing, see the report 'Challenges in digital provision of pension information', AFM, May 2025.
[15] Article 49, first paragraph, Pw and Article 60, first paragraph, Wvb.
At most pension providers in the study, participants do not receive sufficient qualitative information about the consequences of choices for the pension. The AFM has, for example, seen that one or more pension providers do not point out that:
the pension benefit becomes lower if the pension starts earlier;
that with the choice for high-low the participant receives a higher benefit in the first period, but thereafter a lifelong lower benefit;
with the exchange of old-age pension for a higher partner's pension, the pension benefit becomes lower.
These consequences may seem generally known to pension professionals, but that does not apply to all participants. Ensure that participants receive information about the choices they can make and the consequences of these choices for the pension. On the basis of this information, they can further delve into their choices.
The AFM points out here that the consequences of choices for the pension can also change, for example when the pension scheme is amended. For example, as a result of the pension transition, for certain pension schemes it will apply that if the pension benefit starts later than the pension age included in the regulations (hereinafter: regulatory pension age), there is temporarily no coverage for the partner's pension. This means that the partner does not receive a partner's pension if the participant dies between the regulatory pension age and the deferred pension date. For the participant, this is an important consequence of the choice to defer the pension commencement date for the pension. He must be explicitly pointed this out.
The pension provider must, at the latest when the participant considers a choice, also make clear what the quantitative impact of the choice is on the pension. A participant considers a choice, for example, when he requests a quote with certain choices. Or when the participant explores a choice in the online pension planner (hereinafter: pension planner). By quantitative impact we mean that the participant gains insight into how much higher or lower the pension becomes with a certain choice. This concerns concrete amounts. The participant must in any case receive the information about the quantitative impact before the choice is final (see also chapter 3).
Good example: In a pension planner, the participant immediately sees, with each choice he enters, what the effect of the choice is on the level of the pension benefit. Due to the clear design of the pension planner, choices can be easily adjusted, so that the participant can directly compare the quantitative impact of different choices.
For insight into the consequences of choices in the longer term, it is important that the effect of inflation is included. The combination of a qualitative explanation and quantitative insight generally works best, because the effect of inflation in the longer term is not intuitive for many people. The quantitative insight can be provided by showing real amounts in addition to nominal amounts. Especially with the choice for high-low, decreasing benefit or the choice for a fixed or variable benefit, the real amounts provide important information to the participant about the consequences of the choice.
Inform the participant about the level of the pension with and without the choice made. After all, participants cannot themselves estimate what the size of the impact of a specific choice is on the pension. When an active participant advances his pension by 3 years, the level of his annual pension benefit becomes approximately 15 % lower due to the longer benefit duration and stopping premium contributions earlier. The size of this reduction is not clear to participants on the basis of the statement that starting the pension earlier lowers the level of the pension benefit. It is therefore essential that participants receive information about what the choice for the moment of pension commencement does to the level of the pension. This can be done by indicating what the participant receives on the chosen pension commencement date and what the level of a pension benefit would be on one or more other pension commencement dates, such as the AOW age or the regulatory pension age. The quantitative impact of other pension choices for the pension must also be clear to participants. In the study, the AFM sees that not all participants receive this information, even though it is relevant to the choices they have made.
Making the quantitative consequences of a choice for the future pension clear involves uncertainty. Think of the investment return, the interest rate, the premium paid and calculation factors that can still change and have an impact on the level of the pension. State clearly if the amounts are not yet fixed and indicate what can still cause amounts to change. The AFM regards it as a good example when a pension provider actively contacts a participant and offers room to revise choices if a major change occurs in the level of his pension benefit after the choices made have been submitted and before the pension has commenced.
The uncertainty over time is greater with DC schemes than with DB schemes. This is relevant, for example, for a participant who is considering deferring his pension. The difference in the level of the pension between retiring now and retiring in three years cannot be determined with certainty in a DC scheme. Communicate this ambiguity. For example, by indicating that it concerns an estimate or by providing a bandwidth.
Information about other consequences and considerations in choices can also help participants make an appropriate choice. Examples of this are:
Indicate in what way choices can have an impact on tax and benefits. Even without knowing the participant's personal situation, the pension provider can indicate in a generic sense what the possible impact is and where the participant can find additional information. For example, when advancing the pension benefit, the participant pays more tax until the AOW date.
Indicate when it is good to enter into consultation with the employer. For example, if a participant wants to continue working part-time and wants to take partial retirement. Part-time work will not always be possible with the employer.
When choosing the distribution between old-age pension and partner's pension, the pension provider can point out that the partner's pension is relevant. If the partner receives sufficient pension themselves, consideration can be given to choosing more old-age pension and less or no partner's pension. If the partner has accrued little or no pension, consideration can be given to choosing extra partner's pension and a lower old-age pension.
Good example: The pension planner shows for each choice made what this choice all has an impact on. Consider: the amount of the pension benefit, tax and benefits, other choices that can or cannot be made.
What the relevant consequences are depends on participant characteristics or on the pension scheme. The pension provider must itself map out what a participant would need to know to make a suitable choice. Examples of situations in which additional information is needed:
Specific conditions apply when making a choice. For example:
postponement of the pension commencement date in a specific pension scheme is only possible if the participant is still employed by the employer. Despite the choice for postponement, the pension will still commence immediately when the participant stops working.
a participant with a partner can only choose to exchange partner's pension for extra old-age pension with the partner's consent. 16
Certain choice options are always offered together. For example:
Certain choices cannot be combined. For example:
Good example: A pension provider gives participants the opportunity to speak with a financial planner around retirement. The provider knows that some of its participants may also want to sell their own business. By helping these participants to view their pension choices in a broader financial picture, the guidance aligns with their personal situation and needs.
Ensure that participants know what happens if they do not make a choice. Which default options apply then? When a participant does not respond, will the pension commencement date be postponed? Or does the pension commence and can the participant no longer make choices? Until when can a participant still submit choices? To motivate participants to actively submit a choice, the AFM can imagine that this is not included in the first communication to participants. However, it is important to include this information in later communication, so that the participant knows what the consequences are of not submitting their choices.
The AFM calls for assessing whether participants receive all relevant information. Not all relevant information is consistently shared with all participants. We see differences in which choices and consequences are explained in the online choice environment and the written choice guidance. But we also see that participants who do not follow the standard process sometimes do not receive essential information. Consider participants who advance their pension benefit. Some pension providers provide information about choices and the consequences of choices in letters that are provided to all participants around age 66. When participants make contact to advance their pension, we see that pension providers do not always also provide this relevant information to these participants when they make their choices. Or participants who are 60 when they join, and therefore no longer receive important mailings. The AFM recommends that pension providers also take a number of different participant files themselves and assess whether the participant in the file had correct and complete information to make a suitable choice.
Good example: The pension fund sends all participants a document in which the choices and consequences of choices are explained. In terms of layout, language use and visual support, the document aligns with the almost
[16] Article 60, sixth paragraph, Pw, 62, second paragraph, Pw, Article 72, sixth paragraph Wvb and Article 74, second paragraph, Wvb.
retired participant population. In this way, all participants can have access to the essential information needed to understand the choices. Further in the choice process, consequences are made concrete for the participant's specific situation.
Most pension providers provide no or very limited information about the consequences of a combination of choices for the pension. In its study, the AFM sees that participants generally receive information about what the amount of the final pension will be with the set of choices made. However, this is not sufficient.
Pension providers must also provide insight into the consequences of a combination of choices for the pension. This information must in any case be provided for the choices that a participant is considering making, before these choices are final.
The AFM expects pension providers to point out to participants the consequences of choices that reinforce each other. Consider:
When a participant considers choosing to advance and to exchange old-age pension for extra partner's pension. The pension provider must then point out to the participant that both choices result in a lower pension benefit.
When a participant considers combining a high-low benefit with the choice for a fixed benefit, the pension provider must point out to the participant that both choices result in lower purchasing power in the long term.
Pension providers will have to assess what relevant effects of choices that reinforce each other are in the choices offered in the pension scheme.
Good example: After completing the pension planner, the participant is shown a summary of the choices made and the consequences of the individual choices and combination of choices.
In addition, the AFM expects that the pension provider also quantitatively clarifies the impact of a combination of choices. The participant must know what his pension benefit would be with and without the combination of choices and what the consequences of different choices are on the level of the pension benefit. This information can help participants to properly understand the combination of choices and possibly adjust choices. For example, when a participant sees what the quantitative effect is of an earlier pension commencement in combination with a higher partner pension, he can weigh the size of the quantitative effect in the decision whether this is indeed an appropriate choice. If, for example, the participant finds the old-age pension reduced by both choices insufficient, he can consider adjusting his choice or working a little longer to achieve a sufficient old-age pension and partner pension. The same insight can also be very relevant for participants with effects that actually counteract each other. For example, a variable benefit that tries to keep up with purchasing power and a high-low benefit that ensures lower purchasing power in the long term.
Good example: In the pension planner, the participant sees per choice how the level of the pension changes when he makes a choice. In addition, at the end the participant is shown an overview of the choices made and a representation of the level of his pension. He can still adjust choices here and then immediately see the effect on the pension. In this way, the participant can gain insight into the way in which different choices influence the pension.
It is essential that participants are given enough time to carefully make their choices regarding retirement. The choices that participants can make regarding retirement are impactful, because the choices have a direct impact on their income in the short and longer term and because the choices cannot be adjusted later. Pension choices are also complex, because it concerns (a combination of) choices that a participant often makes only at one moment in his life, 17 based on limited knowledge of pensions. Therefore, ensure that the choice guidance starts in time and that participants have enough time to (re)consider their choices.
The pension provider must provide or make available information in time. 18 Timeliness is an open norm. In the Policy Rule on information provision, the AFM has elaborated how it determines whether information is provided in time. The AFM considers whether:
the term enables the participant to take in the information and possibly obtain advice about it;
the participant is given sufficient time to be able to make a well-considered decision;
the term accommodates the scope for action offered to the participant.
Timeliness of information provision for choices regarding pension commencement depends on various factors. This information must in any case be provided at least six months before the date of pension commencement. There are cases where the pension provider must, however, provide this information more than six months before the date of pension commencement. This depends on what the pension provider requires from the participant. If the participant must submit his choices already a few months before pension commencement, then the pension provider must provide the information earlier, so that the participant also has enough time to weigh his choices. In addition, with offline choice guidance, it can take time to send participants a calculation multiple times. The longer such processes take, the earlier the pension provider should start the choice guidance process.
Good example: A pension provider sends participants a letter explaining the choices they can make, in which some choices and combination of choices have already been calculated based on the information known about the participant. On the basis of this letter, the participant already gets a good first impression of the consequences of choices on his own pension.
Good example: In many pension schemes, 68 years is the statutory pension age. But many participants opt for pension commencement at the AOW age. A pension provider therefore sends the information that a participant needs to make pension choices well over half a year before AOW age.
Provide participants with information about a choice as soon as a participant can make this choice. For example, the pension provider must point out to participants that they can bring forward their pension commencement, when the scheme offers this option. This choice option can escape a participant if the pension provider only provides him with information about his old-age pension six months before AOW age or statutory pension age. In the study, we see that information about
[17] As a result, there is no learning effect.
[18] Article 48, first paragraph, Pw and Article 59, first paragraph, Wvb.
bringing forward (and also about the other pension choices) is often available on the websites of pension providers. Making this information available alone is not sufficient. Some pension providers also actively point out to participants the options surrounding retirement, as soon as they can start taking early retirement. In this way, these pension providers provide the information about early retirement to their participants in a timely manner. Do note that there should not be too much steering towards taking pension early if that does not suit the participant population.
Good example: A pension provider sends its participants a letter about their pension when they turn 55, with the choices they can make and the consequences of these choices. This allows participants to start orienting themselves on whether early retirement is a realistic financial option for them.
The pension provider must provide the information about the consequences of choices to participants in a timely manner. This information is not provided in a timely manner when the participant only receives this information for the first time when the choices are already final. The participant must understand what the choices entail, what the consequences of choices are, and know what the level of the pension will be with the choices the participant wants to make, before the choices made are final.
In its study, the AFM found that not all participants gain timely insight into the consequences of choices on the pension. In the digital choice environment, it is usually clear to participants in advance what pension they will receive before their choices are final. But when the participant submits their choices in writing, they often only receive a calculation afterwards. Sometimes they can still change their choices then, but with other pension providers the choices are already final by then. In the latter case, the participant has often not gained timely insight into the consequences of the choices for their pension. This insight is lacking, for example, when the participant deviates from the standard options that may already have been calculated by the pension provider in an earlier letter. It is essential that, after gaining insight into what the choice means, the participant can still adjust their choice.
Pension providers are responsible for providing this information in a timely manner. It is not sufficient to merely point out to the participant the possibility of requesting a calculation, although earlier in the choice process, when the participant is orienting themselves, that can be a valuable part of choice guidance. In addition, the pension provider must inform the participant what the level of the pension will be with the choices the participant wants to make, before the choices made are final.
In the study, the AFM identified errors in pension planners at several pension providers. 19 This concerns, for example, the following incorrect information:
A participant chooses high-low, but the pension planner then shows a low-high payout in a graph and in the associated amounts.
A participant chooses to exchange part of the partner's pension for a higher old-age pension. However, the graph and associated figures show that after the choice, the partner's pension goes up and the old-age pension goes down.
A participant exchanges 100% of their partner's pension for a higher old-age pension. In the graph, the partner's pension goes to 50% and not to 0%.
The tool shows the expected pension in three scenarios. Which can be a nice way to provide insight. However, the calculated amounts are the same in all three scenarios (bad weather, expected, good weather).
Errors in a pension planner can have major consequences. An error in the pension planner has an impact on multiple participants. They are thereby misinformed. In the worst case, they may even submit a final choice based on incorrect information.
The identified errors could and should have been prevented and could have been discovered by simple checks. The AFM expects pension providers to test their pension planner regularly: at the start, and also with every change, however small it may be. Involve different areas of expertise here. Think of a communication expert, a lawyer, an actuary and a specialist in the area of the scheme. What can help when testing is using a number of test personas, and checking whether the results are correct for them. The pension planner must not contain errors; the board of the pension provider is responsible for this, even if the planner has been outsourced. This also applies to other elements of choice guidance.
It is essential that pension providers can assess and test their own pension planner. The AFM has understood that not all pension providers receive access from their pension administration organisation to (a dummy account of) their pension planner. Enter into discussions about this and arrive at a workable solution that enables the pension provider itself to determine whether the pension planner is in order. Adjust the outsourcing agreements accordingly where necessary. After all, the pension provider is responsible.
It is important to properly document changes to the pension planner. Keep old versions of the pension planner and document why you are adjusting the pension planner. Also record for each participant when they were served and with which version of the planner. This allows you, as a pension provider, to carry out specific remediation actions if it turns out that the relevant version of a planner contained an error. This record can also be used to demonstrate that the choice guidance was in order.
[19] The AFM did not recalculate all figures scheme-specifically, but looked at obvious inaccuracies. The AFM was also unable to study the full online choice environment at all pension providers examined. Pension providers change their pension planner during the transition. The pension planner that was used at the time of the participant files examined cannot be reproduced by all parties. In the latter case, the AFM cannot include the non-reproducible pension planner in determining whether the choice guidance is adequate (see also the introduction of this document on recording).
The information provided or made available to participants in the context of choice guidance must be correct.20 In addition to the errors in the pension planner, the AFM also encountered other incorrect information in this study. We explain three types of errors below.
The AFM identified inaccuracies in calculations and amounts shown in communications other than the pension planner. Examples that the AFM encountered are:
In calculations for active participants who are still accruing pension, future pension accrual is not included in the calculations. Only the pension accrued up to that moment is included in the calculations. As a result, the participant cannot include the full effect of possibly advancing his pension commencement in his choice. The participant does see what a longer or shorter payout period does to the level of his pension. But the participant does not see what accruing pension for longer contributes to the level of his pension.
In letters and also in the pension planner, calculations are made with pension accrual up to and including age 68 for active participants, while the pension planner states that pension accrual stops at the latest on the AOW date.
Pension providers must ensure that calculations and amounts shown in communications other than the pension planner contain no errors or inconsistencies.
The information provided does not always align with the pension scheme. In the study we see that participants are sometimes not pointed out choices they do have. But we also see that participants are pointed out choices they cannot make based on the scheme. An example of this is the low-high choice option, while the participant cannot choose this based on the pension scheme. If participants receive information about choices they cannot make in practice, this can lead to confusion and disappointment.
In our study we encountered inconsistent information. Sometimes that was within a document, but more often between different documents. For example, we saw that one pension provider writes in one document that a participant can have his pension commence from age 55, while another document states that the pension can commence at the earliest 10 years before AOW age. Another example: a pension provider writes in one place that the maximum exchange ratio between old-age pension and partner pension is 100:70, but in another place it states 100:100. At an insurer we saw that the costs for taking out a payout product differ between documents. Prevent such inconsistencies. If something changes (in the pension scheme), then adjust this consistently in all places where this appears.
[20] Article 48, first paragraph, Pw and Article 59, first paragraph, Wvb.
The information provided or made available to participants in the context of choice guidance must be clear.21 When assessing whether information is clear, the AFM looks at whether the information is findable and understandable for the target group. If participants cannot find the information relevant to them, that information is not clear. If they have found the relevant information, then this information must also be substantively followable. What is understandable will differ per subject or per group of participants.
Essential information is not always available in the place where participants need it. When assessing whether information is findable, we at least look at whether the structure of the texts is clear and a participant can easily find all relevant information. Examples from the study where information is not sufficiently findable:
The participant is referred to the pension scheme to determine whether and, if so, which correction to entitlements takes place. It states: “See the pension scheme for this.” The pension provider does not state where the pension scheme can be found and which passage from the pension scheme is relevant for the participant. In addition, the information in the pension scheme is often insufficiently understandable for participants to be able to calculate the level of entitlements independently.
In the pension planner, important information about the consequences of pension choices is behind an information icon or on another web page. This concerns, for example, information about the consequences of exchange between old-age pension and partner pension for the pension or important considerations that a participant can weigh in this choice.
This carries the risk that participants miss this information. Even an extra click or button can form a barrier, causing participants to consult the information less quickly.
Information that participants need to understand a choice should be easily findable at the moment they consider or make that choice. It helps to include essential explanations directly in the letter or online choice environment, so that participants do not have to look them up themselves. References to a website in digital communication or a previously provided attachment in written communication can be useful for participants who want more detail. Such references are less suitable for information about the consequences of a choice. By limiting references and summarizing relevant explanations accessibly yourself, the chance that participants miss important information becomes smaller. If pension providers refer to external pages or additional help, a direct link, concrete telephone number or clear follow-up step helps.
Good example: In the online choice environment, for complex choices a clearly visible help block with a telephone number of the pension provider is shown immediately. The participant can also immediately schedule an appointment themselves via a link. This way the participant does not have to look for help themselves.
[21] Article 48, first paragraph, Pw and Article 59, first paragraph, Wvb.
Information about pension choices is not always sufficiently understandable for participants. When assessing whether information is understandable, we in any case check whether:
the language use is tailored to the group of participants;
it is clear to the participant why he receives the information at that moment and what he must do with the information;
information that is offered in layers is clear as a whole and per individual information layer.22
Examples from the study in which information is not clear:
A participant must calculate for himself, on the basis of calculation examples and multiple tables with rates, what the level of his pension will be for different choices.
In the pension planner, the participant can select a choice under ‘uitruil’. The choice options include ‘25% PP uitruil naar OP’ and ‘uitruil naar PP = 70% OP’. The choice is not further explained. The abbreviations PP and OP are also not explained.
In a letter, the terms ‘loonheffingskorting’, ‘alleenstaande ouderenkorting’ and ‘uitkeringsinstantie’ are used without explanation.
In such cases, the participant must give meaning himself to information that is precisely intended to support them in making a choice. In addition, pension providers sometimes refer their participants to the pension scheme for, for example, information about their entitlements. Although the pension scheme is important, it is not a suitable means for many participants to understand the consequences of a choice. A reference to such a document requires an extra step from the participant and assumes that the participant can translate the information himself to his personal situation. This will often not be the case, which may mean that there is no adequate choice guidance.
The AFM expects pension providers to ensure that their participants can understand the information, for example by testing the information with participants. Pension providers can test letters, web texts, explanatory videos and online planners with participants from the target group. This makes clear whether participants understand the information and can use it when making a choice. It is also important to assess the language use: are concepts clear, are abbreviations explained and does the information fit the participants’ world of experience? Information about the pension scheme, economic developments and financial consequences in particular requires attention here. The AFM sees that initiatives are emerging that can contribute to understandable pension communication. An example of this is a tool that can translate, simplify and read out texts.
[22] In this context, see also Chapter 7 of the ‘Beleidsregel informatieverstrekking’, AFM, September 2024.
Choice guidance obliges the pension provider to do more than merely inform and provide insight. This is stated in the Explanatory Memorandum to the Future Pensions Act. The AFM’s compliance study mainly concerned the provision of information about the consequences of choices. It is important that pension providers integrate this information into broader adequate choice guidance. In this chapter, the AFM shares insights relating to other aspects of choice guidance from both the compliance study and the study into the maturity of choice guidance.
Advising on pension choices is permitted. The AFM notes that there are pension funds that assume that advising on pension choices is not permitted. Choice guidance does not oblige advice, but pension providers may give advice on choices in the pension scheme or pension legislation. Advice on choices can therefore be part of adequate choice guidance. Providing Wft advice is not permitted for pension funds, and other financial institutions may only do so with the correct licence. However, advice on pension choices will not quickly constitute Wft advice. In short, there is advice within the meaning of the Wft in the case of a personal recommendation to a (potential) client about a financial product of a specific provider that is new for him to take out. 23
Pension providers are aware of the importance of choice guidance and are motivated to guide their participants adequately. This is evident from the AFM’s study into the maturity of choice guidance at five pension providers. Around the time of the study, most pension providers were working on drawing up specific choice guidance policy for the first time, or on expanding it and making it more specific. The pension providers take choice guidance seriously. There is enthusiasm and willingness to organise choice guidance well. However, board-level choices, intended goals and underlying considerations can be recorded more explicitly. This enables pension funds to better monitor the effectiveness of choice guidance and to improve it continuously.
Pension providers can include the participant interest more explicitly in decision-making about choice guidance. Although balanced consideration of interests is part of the decision-making process and, at pension funds, also of the governance structure, the impact of decisions on participants often remains implicit. Transparency and verifiability of the participant interest in every step of decision-making are important. We particularly consider considerations regarding specific (vulnerable) groups of participants.
Steering can help participants to arrive at a suitable choice, but must be deployed consciously and fit the participant population. Steering is therefore one of the topics where we expect pension providers to explicitly substantiate how it is deployed and whether that also fits specific (vulnerable) groups of participants. Every choice environment exerts some steering effect. Consider, for example, the order in which choices are presented, the ease with which a participant can make a particular choice, the use of default options or pre-filled choices, and the way communication emphasizes certain choice options. It is therefore important that the way in which that steering takes place is in the interest of the participant. Pension providers would do well to, per
[23] More information about this is in the appendix to the ‘leidraad keuzebegeleiding’, AFM, July 2023.
choice and for the various customer journeys, determine what steering emanates from the choice environment and whether that steering contributes to a suitable choice for participants.
In the study, we encountered various steering elements in choice environments that will not be suitable for every participant. We saw, for example, that at one pension provider the choice to retire early is incorporated prominently and with few thresholds in the choice process, giving this option more emphasis. Steering can also arise from the use of a default option. We saw this, for example, when early retirement automatically applies a maximum AOW bridging. This can have major consequences for the amount of the old-age pension after the AOW age. There is a risk that participants interpret the default option as a recommendation, without consciously considering whether this choice is suitable. This underlines the importance of pension providers being aware of the steering effect that can emanate from the design of the choice environment.
Limitations at the pension administration organization We notice that pension providers experience limitations from the pension administration organization. They deal with this in varying ways. Some pension providers accept it. Others actively seek alternative solutions, such as developing a pension planner themselves, and outsourcing parts of the choice guidance process to another party. We call on pension providers to take the participants and their own ambition as the starting point, and not the (im)possibilities at the pension administration organization. As a pension provider, you remain responsible yourself for the choice guidance to participants.
Monitoring and evaluation are crucial for continuously ensuring that the choice guidance is adequate. The deepening step that we saw in the choice guidance policy is generally not yet reflected in concrete objectives and the monitoring of these objectives. KPIs can be sharper and decision-making can be better monitored, so that policy is not only well-intentioned but also demonstrably effective. In this context, we recommend re-reading chapter 3 of the Leidraad keuzebegeleiding on monitoring, evaluating and continuously improving choice guidance. In addition, the information on concrete and measurable objectives from the report ‘Keuzebegeleiding begint bij de deelnemer’ can be useful in this context.
Monitor developments in, for example, laws and regulations, taxation and social changes, because this can have consequences for pension choices. In the study, the AFM saw that for certain choices, conditions are imposed on participants that are no longer necessary. For example, some pension providers require participants to work fewer hours in the case of part-time pension. But part-time pension is now also fiscally permitted while the participant still works full-time.24 Such a relaxation in fiscal conditions can give the pension provider reason to revise this kind of condition, which means the choice guidance must be adjusted.
[24] Government Gazette 2011, 16384 | Overheid.nl > Official publications (officielebekendmakingen.nl).
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from AFM
AFM published 3 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Autoriteit Financiele Markten — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added