Rule · CBI · 22 Jan 2025 · Dreifibréf
Pension funds must build climate-risk knowledge in risk management, asset management staff and managers, and assign clear responsibility in their organizational chart. They must identify important climate-risk factors, exposure and vulnerability, use forward-looking analysis, and if using financed emissions as a metric, record its causal relationship to the asset portfolio and actuarial position and set limits reflecting risk appetite. Limits must also be defined for risk indicators, and maximum risk-taking and mitigation defined.
22 January 2025
Ref.: 2411135
Circular no. 4/2025
To pension funds
According to law, pension funds must have adequate risk management and their investments shall be based on a satisfactory analysis of the risk associated with the investments.1 Sustainability risk, or risk related to environmental, social and governance factors, often called ESG risk, is no exception. An important sub-component of sustainability risk is climate risk, i.e. financial risk that can be traced to climate change. Climate risk is in certain respects different from other risk, as its assessment must rely on a new approach to risk management and risk assessment, since little can be based on historical experience. Furthermore, a longer-term perspective must be taken in the risk assessment, as climate risk can be expected to increase in the coming years.
As the pension funds' liabilities extend over a long term and their investments are to a large extent foreign, they are the party in the Icelandic financial market that is most likely to be affected first by climate risk.
In 2024, the Financial Supervisory Authority carried out an examination of the status of pension funds' management of risk that can be traced to climate change.2 The main findings of the examination are set out below.
The Financial Supervisory Authority's examination was based on the guidelines of the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) for financial supervision. 3 At the beginning of the examination, the NGFS questionnaire was sent to pension funds to obtain information on the status of climate risk management within them, the funds' views on the risk and the role of the Central Bank of Iceland in this field. The aim of the questionnaire was also to prompt the funds to reflect on climate risk management.
Following the information gathering, meetings were held with the four largest pension funds, where the funds' risk management was reviewed in more detail, and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision's paper
[1] Cf. point 3 of the first paragraph of Article 36 of Act No. 129/1997 on mandatory insurance of pension rights and the activities of pension funds.
[2] The review was undertaken following a 2023 recommendation from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) that Icelandic pension funds were somewhat behind pension funds in Europe when it comes to managing climate risk. See Financial Sector Assessment Program: Technical Note on Pension Fund Regulation and Supervision, July 2023, pp. 7 and 8.
[3] Network for Greening the Financial System, "Guide for Supervisors: Integrating climate-related and environmental risks into prudential supervision," 2020.
(BCBS) on core principles for the management of climate risk was taken into account.4 Emphasis was placed on reviewing risk management, internal control and reporting.
It is relatively recently that the Financial Supervisory Authority began regular supervision of sustainability risk at supervised entities, and this review is the first step in systematic supervision of pension funds' management of sustainability risk. A comparable review has been carried out on the management of sustainability risk at domestic commercial banks, and the experience from it was useful for this review, but the Financial Supervisory Authority's procedures for supervision of sustainability risk are still under development, and the reviews have been useful for the Financial Supervisory Authority in that respect. During the examination, the pension funds expressed a wish for fuller guidance on the assessment and management of climate risk. The Financial Supervisory Authority will seek to use the institution's oversight of the Icelandic financial market and to share knowledge on the field in order to support effective management of climate risk.
One of the main findings of the review is that most of the pension funds are close to the starting point when it comes to assessing climate risk, although some are further along than others, especially the larger funds. The importance of climate risk is generally recognised, and the funds expect that physical risk and especially transition risk will materialise. Generally, the funds have not identified important risk factors of climate risk that can have a substantial impact on the portfolio and thereby the actuarial position. Consideration is given to the risk being managed, among other things, through active dialogue with the managers of those domestic companies and funds in which the pension funds have invested. There are also examples of climate risk assessment being part of the risk assessed in new investments. There are examples of certain types of investments and issuers having been excluded by the large funds due to their negative impact on sustainability.
Generally, domestic banks are somewhat further along, as they have more resources for risk management and more manpower. However, the assets and liabilities of pension funds are generally for a much longer term than those of the banks, and such assets are generally considered more vulnerable to the effects of climate change. This makes the management of climate risk at pension funds extremely important. Furthermore, the assets of pension funds are to a large extent foreign, which may make them more exposed to climate risk.
The main findings of the examination are set out in the following points that the Financial Supervisory Authority wishes to communicate to the pension funds.
Governance: Although the governance and risk management of the pension funds do not separately distinguish climate risk from other risk, its importance is recognised, as are its possible effects on the actuarial position. Emphasis should be placed on building up increased knowledge of climate risk and its derived effects on the funds' assets and liabilities.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that knowledge of climate risk is a prerequisite for being able to manage it, and it is therefore important to build
[4] Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, "Principles for the effective management and supervision of climate-related financial risks," 2022.
up knowledge. This applies in particular within the funds' risk management, among asset management staff and at the funds' managers.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that although climate risk is not treated separately from other risk, it must be clear in the funds' organizational chart who is responsible for its management.
Risk analysis: Pension funds have generally not identified important risk factors of climate risk, but many nevertheless treat the cost of emissions indirectly as such a risk factor through the measurement of financed emissions.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that analysis of important risk factors of climate risk should be prioritized, since it is a prerequisite for their management. It is necessary to identify important risk factors of climate risk, whether significant parts of the asset portfolio are exposed to those risk factors, and assess how vulnerable those assets are to those risk factors. In this connection, it is important to keep in mind that although the risk can materialize in individual assets, it can also originate in the value chain or in the economy as a whole. Physical risk is often delimited by geographical areas while transition risk is often delimited by jurisdictions.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds to keep in mind that when analyzing climate risk, limited information is often available from historical experience and that climate risk can materialize over a long time. Therefore, a longer-term perspective is needed in its analysis and to base it on a forecast of the development of risk factors instead of historical development. Then scenario analysis can be useful.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that if they use a measurement of financed emissions as a metric, because they consider the cost of emissions to be an important risk factor, then they should treat financed emissions as a metric of exposure to that risk factor and record the possible causal relationship of financed emissions to the asset portfolio and thereby the actuarial position. They should also define limits for the financed emissions metric that reflect the fund's risk appetite.
Risk indicators: The funds have generally not established risk indicators for climate risk, if financed emissions are excluded, since they have not been analyzed as stated above.
o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that identifying the important risk factors of climate risk facilitates risk indicators that are clear, reliable, verifiable, neutral and stable over time, monitoring those risk factors. Then the possible causal relationship of the risk indicator and its impact on the asset portfolio must be available, since risk is a measure of the pension fund's ability to meet its obligations. It is also important that limits have been defined for the risk indicator that reflect the funds' risk appetite. o The Financial Supervisory Authority points out to the pension funds that following the analysis of important risk factors of climate risk, that risk must be managed, including defining maximum risk-taking and possible mitigation.
The above points only cover those items considered most urgent now. It can be expected that requirements for the management of sustainability risk will increase as time goes on. To respond to and organize the management of climate risk, various publications can be used, such as:
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, "Principles for the effective management and supervision of climate-related financial risks", 2022.
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, "Climate-related risk drivers and their transmission channels", 2021.
Bank of England, "Enhancing banks' and insurers' approaches to managing the financial risks from climate change," 2019.
European Banking Authority, "Draft Guidelines on the management of ESG risk," 18.1.2024
Yours faithfully,
CENTRAL BANK OF ICELAND
Gísli Óttarsson managing director prudential supervision
Guðmundur Örn Jónsson specialist prudential supervision
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from CBI
CBI published 7 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Central Bank of Iceland — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added