Rule · BCRA · 25 Apr 2002 · A 3579
Natural persons potentially liable and entities covered by Law 21.526, including those whose terms were extended under art. 3, must answer charges within ten (10) days of notification, or five (5) days in lesser-severity summaries, offering all evidence and attaching available documents; witness evidence is capped at two per fact and twenty total. Fines must be deposited with the Banco Central de la República Argentina within five (5) days of notification, and payment facilities require guarantees and cannot exceed the three-year statute of limitations. Sanctions include revocation of authorization to operate.
CENTRAL BANK OF THE ARGENTINE REPUBLIC
__________________________________________________________________ COMMUNICATION " A " 3579 I 25/04/02 __________________________________________________________________
TO FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS:
Ref.: Circular
RUNOR 1 - 545
Procedure for the proceedings provided for in art.
41 of
Law
21.526.
Adaptation of procedural rules for the procedure of financial proceedings.
We are writing to inform you that this Institution has decided to adapt the rules referenced to the provisions of Decree 1311/2001; consequently, the updated consolidated text is attached.
The relevant part of Board Resolution No. 234 dated 11.04.02 is transcribed, in which it is provided:
1°) To approve the rules contained in the Annex that forms part of this resolution, relating to the conduct and sanctions in the proceedings provided for in art. 41 of Law 21.526; which shall be immediately applicable to all matters in progress.
2ø) To repeal any provision that opposes the present.
3°) To provide for its publication in the customary manner, including in the Official Gazette.
We send you our very best regards.
CENTRAL BANK OF THE ARGENTINE REPUBLIC
Ricardo H. Calissano
Juan Carlos Barale
Manager of Litigation Affairs
Deputy General Manager of
Compliance and Control
CONDUCT AND SANCTION IN THE PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A.
Section 1. Procedure for the handling of proceedings with an opening resolution
issued as of 03/09/98.
This procedural regime applies to the proceedings conducted by the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic, for the purposes of article 41 of Law 21.526, to:
1.1.1. The persons and entities covered by the regime of the aforementioned law, including those in respect of which it has been decided to extend its terms, pursuant to art. 3º of the Financial Entities Law.
1.1.2. Natural persons potentially liable for the violations that are the subject matter of the proceedings.
1.1.3. Offenders of the rules of articles 19 and 38 of the aforementioned law.
1.2.1. The proceeding is initiated by resolution of the Superintendent of Financial and Foreign Exchange Entities, who may delegate this power for certain types of offenses.
1.2.2. The adjudication of alleged offenses of lesser severity shall be conducted in a summary manner; once the formal opening of the proceeding has been ordered, preliminary and special rulings shall not be admissible; once the charges have been served, the period for submitting defenses shall be five (5) days, and at that procedural opportunity, all documentary evidence must be attached; documentary evidence shall only be admissible in those cases where documentary proof cannot be obtained by other means. These are the only admissible evidences in this type of process. Once the defense has been submitted, the established period has elapsed, or the relevant evidence has been produced, the Board may adopt a resolution without further procedure.
1.2.3. In all other cases, the Superintendent's Office shall proceed to notify the accused of the opening of the proceeding at the address referred to in point 1.5. The period to review the file, submit defenses, and offer evidence shall be ten (10) days from the day following the relevant notification. The review of the file shall be conducted at the Bank's premises.
1.3.1. The sanctions applied pursuant to the provisions of article 41 of said law, due to offenses committed by the entities or natural persons subject to its control, shall be made known by a communication addressed to the entities covered by Law 21.526, insofar as they result in the following penalties:
| Version 2 ª | Communication “A” 3579 | Effective 25/04 /02 | Page 1 |
|---|
CONDUCT AND SANCTION IN THE PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A.
Section 1. Procedure for the handling of proceedings with an opening resolution
issued as of 03/09/98.
1.3.1.1. Revocation of the authorization to operate.
1.3.1.2. Temporary or permanent disqualification from serving as promoters, founders, directors, administrators, members of supervisory boards, statutory auditors, liquidators, managers, auditors, partners, or shareholders of the entities covered by the financial entities law. In these cases, the relevant communication shall be issued immediately after the sanction is applied, even if it has not yet become final.
1.3.1.3. Fines when applied jointly with any of the preceding sanctions.
1.3.2. If for any reason a sanctioning resolution is modified, the corresponding dissemination shall be made through the same means used to communicate the original penalty.
1.4.1. Natural or legal persons may designate attorneys-in-fact to act in such capacity and represent them in all stages of the proceedings. Attorneys-in-fact must prove their standing from the first action they take on behalf of their principals, by means of a certified copy of the power of attorney executed in due legal form, or a private instrument with signatures certified by a public notary, which shall be added to the case file; or by means of a record in which the parties under investigation grant a sufficient mandate with all customary powers to carry out the entire processing of the case, drawn up before the acting official of the Superintendency of Financial and Exchange Entities. Once the power of attorney has been accepted, summons and notifications, including those of final resolutions, shall have the same effect as if they were made to the principal.
1.4.2. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the designation of an attorney-in-fact does not release the party under investigation from appearing before the investigating authority whenever it deems it necessary.
1.5.1. Notifications shall be sent to the domicile that the accused have established before the Superintendency of Financial and Exchange Entities through Form 1113 and/or its equivalent in the respective mandatory electronic submission support; failing that, they shall be carried out at the domicile ascertained by this Institution or at that provided by the acting inspection.
Version 2ª Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25/ 04 /02
Page 2
PROCEDURE AND SANCTION IN THE PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A.
Section 1. Procedure for the processing of proceedings with a resolution of opening
issued as of 03/09/98.
1.5.2. In the first action taken in the proceedings by the accused or their attorney-in-fact, they shall establish a special domicile, or ratify the one previously established in compliance with the provisions in force, which shall remain in effect for all notifications that may be required until a new one is established; otherwise, the preceding 1.5.1 shall apply.
1.5.3. If the domicile of the accused is not known in any way, notifications giving notice of the decision shall be made by edict published in the Official Gazette of the Argentine Republic for three (3) days.
Notifications may be made by any means that provides certainty of the date of receipt of the instrument in which the notification was received and, where applicable, of the contents of the sealed envelope if one is used.
They may be made:
a) By direct access of the interested party, their attorney-in-fact or legal representative to the case file, with express record and prior verification of the identity of the notified party; a complete copy of the act shall be certified if requested.
b) By spontaneous appearance of the interested party, their attorney-in-fact or legal representative, from which it results that they have actual knowledge of the respective act.
c) By notice, which shall be carried out in a manner similar to that provided for in arts. 140 and 141 of the Code of Civil and Commercial Procedure of the Nation.
d) By telegram with delivery advice.
e) By official letter sent as express certified mail with receipt advice; in this case, the official letter and the attached documents shall be exhibited in an open envelope to the authorized postal agent before dispatch, who shall seal them together with the copies to be added to the case file.
f) By registered letter.
g) By the means indicated by the postal authority, through its licensees, in accordance with the regulations it issues.
1.7.1. All terms are computed in banking business days in force in the City of Buenos Aires.
Time limits begin to run from hour 0 of the day following the notification and expire at 24:00 on the day of their expiration. Notwithstanding the foregoing, any document shall be deemed validly filed if it is delivered within the first 2 hours of banking hours on the business day following the one on which the time limit expired.
Version 2 ª Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25/04/02
Page 3
PROCEDURE AND SANCTION IN THE PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A.
Section 1. Procedure for the processing of proceedings with a resolution of opening
issued as of 03/09/98.
In order to establish due compliance with the terms, the date and time of entry of any submission in the records of the Entry Desk of the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic shall be taken into account.
1.7.2. All terms shall be peremptory and non-extendable.
1.8.1. At the time of filing the answers and alleging the pertinent defenses, all evidence intended to be produced must be offered and the documentary evidence available must be attached. If it is not at the disposal of the person under investigation, it must be individualized, indicating its content, place and person in whose possession it is found.
The Superintendency of Financial and Exchange Entities is empowered to reject evidence that is inadmissible - without any recourse for the person under investigation - with a reasoned account of the rejection in the final resolution.
The production of non-rejected evidence must be carried out within a period of fifteen (15) days, the timing of which is set by the Superintendency in accordance with the circumstances inherent to the processing of the summary proceeding.
During the evidence period, resolutions shall be deemed tacitly notified, and Tuesdays and Fridays or the following business day, if either is a holiday, shall be considered days for viewing.
The evidentiary report must concern specific, clearly individualized and disputed facts in the proceedings; its processing shall be the responsibility of the offering party, and its production should be sought within the agreed term. The official letters shall be signed, sealed and processed by the sponsoring attorney with transcription of the resolution that orders them and that sets the term within which they must be sent. When, in drafting the official letters, the professionals depart from the provisions of the order that mandates them, or from the legal forms, their disciplinary liability shall be enforced ex officio. If, upon expiration of the term set for answering the report, the public office or private entity has not sent it, the party who requested it shall be deemed to have withdrawn from that evidence, without any further proceeding, if within the third (3rd) day it does not request its reiteration.
Version 2 nd Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25 /04 /02
Page 4
SUBSTANTIATION AND SANCTION IN THE SUMMARIES PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A.
Section 1. Procedure for the processing of summaries with an opening resolution
issued as from 03/09/98.
1.8.2. When the evidence offered includes witness evidence, at the time of submitting the defenses the interrogatory must be added according to which the offered witnesses are requested to be examined.
The number of witnesses must not exceed two for each fact to be proven nor twenty in total. The offering of the same must be made stating their names, profession and updated domicile, their appearance in all cases being the responsibility of the offering party.
The witness shall be deemed withdrawn without any further proceeding, if the reported data do not make it possible to individualize him or her, or if the pertinent interrogatory is not attached at the time of submitting defenses, or if he or she does not appear without justified cause duly accredited at the time of the first scheduled hearing or its substitute.
1.8.3. Expert evidence shall be admitted when, in the Institution's judgment, there were doubts regarding the authenticity of the documentary evidence submitted or some other type of issue to be clarified by this evidentiary means.
The exceptions raised by the accused are decided in the final resolution, except when by their nature it is necessary to consider and resolve them beforehand. These resolutions are adopted by the Superintendent of Financial and Exchange Entities, reporting to the Board of Directors of the Central Bank, which shall be responsible for deciding those that imply the conclusion of the summary.
When from the summary or inspection activity there arises the existence of other infractions that, by their characteristics, have sufficient substance to justify the formulation of charges different from those already made or a significant aggravation of these, they shall be incorporated into the summary, in the manner provided for in point 1.2, as an expansion of charges or modification of those already charged, or a new summary shall be instituted by separate file.
In the case of being incorporated into the summary in progress, if the accused party or parties have already taken view of the previous charges, a new view must be granted regarding the added or modified ones, according to the procedure regulated by these rules.
Once the defenses are received, the evidence that was appropriate is produced and all those steps and proceedings considered necessary and opportune to gather records and elements of judgment are carried out, the instruction shall produce the draft resolution in which the conclusions resulting from the proceedings are formulated. The resolution that ends the proceedings is notified to the accused or to their attorneys, as the case may be.
Version 2 nd Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25 /04 /02
Page 5
SUBSTANTIATION AND SANCTION IN THE SUMMARIES PROVIDED FOR IN THE B.C.R.A. ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526
Section 2. Sanctions
The Board of Directors of the Central Bank shall issue the resolutions that imply the conclusion of the summary.
Once the summary has been opened by Mr. Superintendent, if its archiving were ordered before the issuance of the final resolution – for the corresponding reasons –, said resolution must also be issued by the aforementioned collegiate body, taking into account that it is a form of termination of the process.
In the case of a fine, the amount must be deposited in the Banco Central de la República Argentina in "Cuentas transitorias Pasivas - Multas - Ley de Entidades Financieras - Artículo 41" within the term of five (5) days following the date of notification of the resolution, under warning that its collection will be pursued through the channel provided for in Book III. Title III of the National Civil and Commercial Procedural Code (Law 17.454).
The execution is promoted on the basis of the copy of the resolution imposing the fine, signed by two authorized signatures of the Superintendency of Financial and Exchange Entities.
The appeal channels admissible for the imposition of the sanctions resolved under the terms of article 41 of Law 21.526 shall be those provided for in article 42 of the aforementioned legal body, Law 19.549 on Administrative Procedures and its regulatory decree (t.o. 1991).
2.3.1. To that end, it is appropriate not only to determine the valuation that must be attributed to each of the factors set forth in the third paragraph of article 41, but it is also convenient to define them conceptually, taking into account that they are aimed at grading sanctions applicable to infractions arising from an activity of singular characteristics such as financial activity.
i) When the infraction is constituted by facts susceptible to pecuniary appraisal, the total amount reached by the operations in infraction during the entire period in which it occurred shall be taken into account.
Version 2 nd Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25/04 /02
Page 6
SUBSTANTIATION AND SANCTION IN THE SUMMARY PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN THE B.C.R.A. ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526
Section 2. Sanctions.
ii) When the transgressions, by their characteristics, are not measurable in money, the following guidelines shall be evaluated to determine their magnitude:
1) Relevance of the breached rule within the system of rules regulating financial activity, 2) length of the period in which it occurred, 3) whether there was continuity or isolated cases of non-compliance within the verified period, 4) number of particular cases that constitute the regulatory non-compliance.
For the purposes of grading the penalty, third parties shall be understood as natural or legal persons who had a relationship with the entity under summary proceeding, or on whose account the summary proceeding is conducted when it is excluded, in matters relating strictly to financial activity, including the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic, and the damage shall be quantified on the basis of the monetary sums that, for any reason, within the characteristics of the infringing conduct, the entity under summary proceeding or on whose account the summary proceeding is conducted has failed to pay or has received in excess.
In order to evaluate it, account shall be taken of the verification of the benefit obtained by reason of the configuration of the infraction both for the financial entity and for the natural persons responsible for the transgression or for the natural or legal persons linked to them in accordance with the rules that the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic has issued on the matter or may issue in the future.
Since, as regards the financial entities of the system, this weighting factor could overlap or be confused with the quantification of the magnitude of the infraction susceptible of being appraised in money, it seems advisable to reserve its measurement, given that in general it is one of the few elements of judgment available in such cases, for setting the sanction in the summary proceedings ordered upon detecting the exercise of unauthorized financial intermediation. This is without prejudice to using, in the particular case, the remaining factors if they can be determined.
This element for appraising the situation of the financial entity, which is the computable patrimonial responsibility that each entity declares in information supplied to this Institution, is a primary means for adequately setting the fine sanction.
Version 2 nd Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25/04/02
Page 7
| B.C.R.A. | SUBSTANTIATION AND SANCTION IN THE SUMMARY PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 |
|---|---|
| Section 2. Sanctions. |
For that purpose, the amount declared by the financial entity at the time the sanction is graded or the higher amount declared during the entire period in which the infractional facts occurred shall be taken, whichever is higher.
Those sanctioned by final resolution who commit new infractions within the period of five years following said decision shall have an increase of up to 40% - forty percent - in the fines imposed on them.
In the case of second recidivism, the fines to be applied may be increased by 100% - one hundred percent -.
Version 2nd Communication “A” 3579 Effective:
25/ 04/02
Page 8
SUBSTANTIATION AND SANCTION IN THE SUMMARY PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN
ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 B.C.R.A. Section 3. Regime of payment facilities for debtors of fines im-
posed in summary proceedings.
3.1. At the request of a person sanctioned to pay a fine imposed in the summary proceedings conducted within the framework of the Law on Financial Entities and complementary provisions or under the Exchange Criminal Regime, the Central Bank of the Argentine Republic may grant facilities under the conditions set forth below.
3.2. The General Submanagement of Operations shall decide all cases that arise. All of this based on the following regulations.
3.3. A condition for the granting of facilities shall be the constitution, to the satisfaction of the Principal Credit Management of the BCRA, of personal or bank guarantees and/or sureties or real guarantees, valid during the entire period of deferral of payment of the fine. Said Principal Management shall decide on the validity of the guarantees and the solvency of the obligor or its sureties or guarantors based on the sworn statements on patrimonial situation and other instruments that may be pertinent to require from them.
3.4. The Credit Management of the BCRA shall instrument the payment commitment of the interested party, according to the number of installments, taking into consideration the amount of the sanction imposed, terms, interest and other conditions that are established, which must be approved by the Principal Credit Management and approved by the General Submanagement of Operations.
3.5. The facilities may be granted, within the number of installments and maximum term indicated below:
3.5.1. Of up to twelve (12) monthly, equal and consecutive installments, for fines lower than TEN THOUSAND pesos ($ 10,000).
3.5.2. Of up to twenty-four (24) monthly, equal and consecutive installments, for fines higher than TEN THOUSAND pesos ($ 10,000) and lower than ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND pesos ($ 100,000).
3.5.3. Of up to thirty-six (36) monthly, equal and consecutive installments, for fines higher than ONE HUNDRED THOUSAND pesos ($ 100,000) and lower than ONE MILLION pesos ($ 1,000,000).
3.5.4. Of up to forty-eight (48) monthly, equal and consecutive installments, for fines higher than ONE MILLION pesos ($ 1,000,000).
Unless there is express acknowledgment of the obligation with the effect of interrupting the statute of limitations under the terms of Article 3989 of the Civil Code, in no case may facilities be granted for a number of installments exceeding the three-year period for the statute of limitations of fines provided for in Article 42 of Law 21.526.
3.6. During the period running from the date of notification of the resolution imposing the fine until its full payment, a compensatory interest shall accrue at the rate resulting from the series referred to in point 5.5. of section 5 of the rules on "Interest rates in credit transactions" or, where applicable, by the rule that replaces it.
Version 2 ª Communication "A" 3579 Effective date:
25/04/02
Página 9
| B.C.R.A. | PROCEDURE AND SANCTION IN THE PROCEEDINGS PROVIDED FOR IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526 |
|---|---|
| Section 3. Payment facility regime for debtors of fines imposed in proceedings. |
3.7. Failure to pay any of the installments shall, without the need for prior demand, result in the automatic forfeiture of the granted payment facility plan and shall immediately render the outstanding balance due and payable, together with its interest, which shall not be eligible for new facilities.
3.8. The resolution adopted regarding the granting of facilities shall be final and not subject to appeal.
3.9. Where judicial enforcement for the collection of the fine has already been initiated, a condition for the granting of facilities shall be that the judgment debtor assumes all costs and expenses of such proceedings.
3.10. The BCRA Credit Management Department shall be responsible for the administration of the guarantees and of the resulting collections.
3.11. From the request for the granting of terms onward, all types of communication or requirement to the interested party shall be the responsibility of the BCRA Credit Management Department, which shall handle any issue that arises and shall set, in each case, a deadline whose non-compliance shall mean the implicit rejection of the request, enabling the transfer of the files from said Department directly to the Judicial Affairs Department for the purposes of its jurisdiction.
3.12. The Credit Management Department shall report monthly to Board Commission No. 3 on the application of this regime.
3.13. Upon notification of the sanctioning resolution, the existence of this payment facilities regime shall be brought to the attention of the sanctioned parties.
3.14. This body of regulations shall apply even to the payment of fines imposed prior to the effective date of this rule, with or without judicial enforcement initiated.
Version 2ª Communication “A” 3579 Effective date:
25/04/02
Página 10
B.C.R.A.
ORIGIN OF THE PROVISIONS INCLUDED IN THE ORDERED TEXT OF THE RULES ON PROCEEDINGS AND SANCTIONS IN SUMMARY PROCEEDINGS FORESEEN IN ARTICLE 41 OF LAW 21.526
| TEXTO ORDENADO | NORMA DE ORIGEN | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sección | Punto | Párrafo | Com. | Capítulo/ Anexo | Punto | Observaciones | |
| 1. | 1.1.a 1.2 | “A” 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.1 a 1.2.2.2.2. | Según Comunicación “A” 3579 y Decreto 1311/01. | ||
| 1. | 1.3.1. a 1.3.2. | “A” 2887 | RUNOR 1- 330, Cap. XVII | 1°) y 2°). | Pursuant to Communication "A" 2887 item 1°) and Communication "A" 3579. | ||
| 1. | 1.4. a 1.4.2. | “A” 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.4. a 1.2.2.4.1. | Pursuant to Communication "A" 3006 and Communication "A" 3579. | ||
| 1. | 1.5. a 1.5.3. | “A” 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.5. a 1.2.2.5.3. | Pursuant to Communication "A" 3579 and Decree 1311/01. | ||
| 1. | 1.6. | “A” 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.6. to 1.2.2.6.1. | |||
| 1. | 1.7. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.7. to 1.2.2.7.2. | |||
| 1. | 1.8. to 1.8.3. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.8. to 1.2.2.8.3. | According to Communication "A" 3579. | ||
| 1. | 1.9. to 1.9.1. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.9. to 1.2.2.9.1. | According to Communication "A" 3579. | ||
| 1. | 1.10. to 1.10.1. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.10. to 1.2.2.10.1. | |||
| 1. | 1.11. to 1.11.1. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.11. to 1.2.2.11.1. | |||
| 2. | 2.1. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.12.1. | According to Communication "A" 3579 and Decree 1311/01. | ||
| 2. | 2.2. | "A" 2762 | RUNOR 1 - 296, Cap. XVII | 1.2.2.12.2. | |||
| 2. | 2.3. to 2.3.2.5. | "A" 2124 | RUNOR 1 - 114 | According to Communication "A" 3579 and Decree 1311/01. | |||
| 3. | 3.1. to 3.14. | "A" 3122 | Points 1 to 9 of the Annex to Board Resolution 584/98 published in the Official Gazette of 6/11/98. According to Communication "A" 3579 and Decree 1311/01. |
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“We are writing to inform you that this Institution has decided to adapt the rules referenced to the provisions of Decree 1311/2001”
More like this from BCRA
BCRA published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Banco Central de la Republica Argentina — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added