Consultation · FSRA · 5 Dec 2024
The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of the Abu Dhabi Global Market proposes replacing the current approval model for Virtual Assets with a self-assessment and notification process, requiring VA Firms to notify the regulator and publish a list of accepted assets. Capital requirements are revised to remove the additional buffer for Multilateral Trading Facility operators and to set specific Base Capital Requirements and Expenditure Based Capital Minimums for other activities, such as a $250,000 minimum for custody services. The paper also proposes introducing a product intervention power to halt dealings in specific assets and an express prohibition on the use of algorithmic stablecoins and privacy tokens. The deadline for public comments on these proposals is 31 January 2025.
Confidential
CONSULTATION PAPER
NO. 11 OF 2024
PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE
DIGITAL ASSET REGULATORY
FRAMEWORK
5 DECEMBER 2024
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Table of Contents
Introduction.................................................................................................................... 3
Section A: Current regulatory framework for Virtual Assets ............................................... 5
Section B.1: Proposed revisions to the VA framework ....................................................... 7
Section B.2: Discussion points relating to the VA framework........................................... 12
Section C: Criteria for Acceptance of Fiat-Referenced Tokens ........................................ 17
Section D: Scope of investible assets for Venture Capital Funds ..................................... 18
Annexes, appendices and attachment........................................................................... 19
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Why we are issuing this consultation paper
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
VC Funds, Applicants considering undertaking any of the foregoing activities, other Persons active in the VA sector, and their respective professional advisors. How to provide comments
6. All comments should be made in writing and sent to the mail address or email
address specified below. If sending your comments by email, please put the consultation paper number in the subject line. If relevant, please identify the organisation you represent in providing your comments. The FSRA reserves the right to publish, including on its website, any comments you provide, unless you expressly request otherwise at the time of making any comments. Comments supported by reasoning and evidence will be given more weight by the FSRA. What happens next
7. The deadline for providing comments on these proposals is 31 January 2025. When
we receive your comments, we will consider whether any modifications to the proposed amendments are required. The Board of ADGM and the FSRA will then proceed to enact the proposed amendments in their final form. You should not act on the proposed amendments described in this consultation paper until the relevant Regulations and Rules are amended and we will issue a notice on our website when that happens. Comments to be addressed to:
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Financial Services Regulatory Authority
Abu Dhabi Global Market
ADGM Square
Al Maryah Island
PO Box 111999
Abu Dhabi, UAE
Email: fsra.consultation@adgm.com
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential assessing whether a VA meets the requirements of being an AVA for a specific VA Firm:
a) Traceability / monitoring: whether the VA Firm is able to demonstrate the origin and destination of the specific VA, if the VA enables the identification of counterparties to each transaction, and if on-chain transactions in the VA can be adequately monitored; b) Maturity: the sufficiency, depth and breadth of demand, the proportion of the VA that is in free float, and the controls/processes to manage volatility of the VA; c) Security: consideration of whether the VA is able to withstand, adapt, respond to, and improve on its specific risks and vulnerabilities, including relevant factors/risks relating to its on-boarding or use (including size, testing, maturity, and ability to allow the appropriate safeguarding of secure private keys); d) Exchange connectivity: whether there are exchanges that support the VA; the jurisdictions of these exchanges and whether these exchanges are suitably regulated; e) Type of distributed ledger technology (“DLT”): whether there are issues relating to the security and/or usability of the DLT used by the VA; whether the VA leverages an existing DLT for network and other synergies, and, if not, whether a new DLT has been demonstrably stress tested; f) Innovation / efficiency: whether, for example, the VA helps to solve a fundamental problem, addresses an unmet market need or creates value for network participants; and g) Practical application/functionality: whether the VA possesses quantifiable functionality.
5. A number of these criteria are considered by the FSRA having regard both to the
features of the specific VA being assessed and to the relevant VA Firm’s systems and controls. For instance, even where a VA may be sufficiently traceable, it would not be considered an AVA acceptable for use by a VA Firm not possessing the necessary surveillance tools.
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Revisions to the process whereby VAs are accepted for use in ADGM
6. When the FSRA assumed responsibility for the assessment of each VA in 2018, its
decision was based on the potentially significant risks associated with a nascent VA sector and the relatively small universe of VAs in existence, of which only a limited number could meet the FSRA’s traceability requirements. Since the launch of the AVA approval process, the FSRA has approved 91 VAs as AVAs for use in ADGM.
7. The FSRA notes that the VA sector and the global regulatory landscape in respect
of VAs have rapidly developed since the creation of the AVA approval process, and VA Firms have gained experience with operating in a regulated environment, alongside which the technical, governance, risk management and compliance systems of VA Firms have improved. Therefore, at this juncture the FSRA considers it appropriate to permit VA Firms to play a more significant role in the assessment of VAs for use as AVAs in ADGM, building upon the existing requirement on VA Firms to understand the VAs they propose to use and conduct a risk assessment prior to offering any product or service related to a VA to their clients. Self-assessment and notification
8. For this purpose, the FSRA proposes to replace the current FSRA-led AVA approval
model with a self-assessment and notification process. This would require each VA Firm to self-assess each VA it proposes to use in the conduct of a Regulated Activity against the current AVA assessment criteria, applying weighting to each criteria consistent with the risks posed by the activities undertaken by such VA Firm, in accordance with revised VA Guidance which the FSRA will publish in tandem with the proposed legislative amendments.
9. Before working with a VA, each VA Firm would also be required to notify the FSRA
and provide information describing the due diligence process that the VA Firm has conducted in respect of that VA. Such supporting information would be required to demonstrate how the VA Firm concluded that the AVA assessment criteria were satisfied in respect of that VA. The FSRA would prescribe the format of the required notification, including details of the information to accompany the notification. Non-objection by the FSRA
10. The FSRA will raise an objection to the proposed use of any VA if it is of the view that
the VA does not comply with applicable assessment requirements or, in its view,
Section B.1: Proposed revisions to the VA framework
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential the VA Firm has not conducted adequate due diligence. Where the FSRA raises an objection, the relevant VA Firm may choose to engage with the FSRA to determine whether it is possible to remediate the grounds for the FSRA’s objection.
11. Where the FSRA does not raise a written objection to a VA identified by such VA Firm
within twenty business days, or where the grounds for any FSRA objection are addressed to the FSRA’s satisfaction, the VA will qualify as an AVA for such firm. Every VA Firm must publish a current list of the AVAs it uses on its website. Ongoing obligations
12. VA Firms will be required to continuously monitor its firm-specific suite of AVAs to
ensure that such AVAs continue to satisfy AVA assessment criteria. Where the FSRA is of the view that a particular VA should no longer be considered an AVA, either for all VA Firms or a particular VA Firm, the FSRA may take appropriate regulatory action.
13. In addition, as part of the FSRA’s ongoing supervisory activities, each VA Firm is
likely to be subject to enhanced reporting requirements concerning its AVAs. Current AVAs
14. It is proposed that all AVAs approved for use by VA Firms as at the date of
implementation of these changes would retain their AVA status for such firms without the need for formal assessment or notification to the FSRA. However, such AVAs must be included on the list of AVAs published by a VA Firm on its website and will be subject to the ongoing monitoring and compliance requirements the FSRA plans to introduce.
15. The proposed amendments to COBS Rule 17.2 are set out in Appendix 1.
Question 1
Do you agree with the proposed changes to the process by which VAs are accepted for use within ADGM? Revisions to capital requirements for VA Firms Current approach
16. COBS Rule 17.3 specifies that the capital requirements set out in Rule 3.2 of MIR
apply to an Authorised Person conducting a Regulated Activity in relation to VAs. In accordance with that, an Authorised Person must hold the following amount of Capital Resources:
a) an amount equal to 6 months' operational expenses; plus
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential b) an additional capital buffer amount of up to a further 6 months' operational expenses, unless the Regulator directs otherwise.
17. In practice, as outlined in the VA Guidance, the FSRA has applied proportionality in
considering whether the additional capital buffer must be held, based on the size, scope, complexity and nature of the activities and operations of the Authorised Person. For VA Firms, the FSRA has considered that an Authorised Person Operating an MTF must hold regulatory capital equivalent to 12 months’ operational expenses, i.e. it is subject to the additional capital buffer requirement. A capital requirement of 6 months’ operational expenses has been applied to other VA Firms. Proposed Revisions
18. The VA ecosystem in ADGM has grown since the launch of the VA regulatory
framework in 2018 and now comprises a range of market participants and a variety of different business models. In the course of supervising those VA Firms, the FSRA has gained supervisory insights enabling it to calibrate capital requirements to better match the prudential risks facing those firms.
19. In respect of both VA Firms and non-VA Firms engaged in Operating an MTF, the
FSRA proposes that the relevant capital requirements remain in MIR 3.2 and that the additional capital buffer would generally not be applied, absent specific circumstances. This is considered appropriate as the FSRA requires the segregation of custody operations in a separate legal entity from MTF operations, enabling a simpler orderly wind-down of the Operator of a MTF in the event of insolvency.
20. For all other Regulated Activities conducted in relation to VAs as referred to above,
the FSRA proposes that the capital requirements be detailed in Chapter 3 of PRU. For all such Regulated Activities, other than that of Providing Custody, the FSRA considers that the same capital requirements should apply as those applicable to Authorised Persons carrying on the same Regulated Activities in relation to nonVAs, on the basis that the associated prudential risks are similar in nature.
21. For VA Firms Providing Custody, the FSRA proposes a capital requirement of the
higher of a Base Capital Requirement (“BCR”) of $250,000 or an Expenditure Based Capital Minimum (“EBCM”) of 6 months’ Annual Audited Expenditure (“AAE”). The proposed BCR is the same as that applicable to Authorised Persons Providing Custody in relation to non-VAs and the proposed ECBM is broadly aligned with the current capital requirement of 6 months’ operational expenses under MIR 3.2, although there may be some marginal differences in how “operational expenses” and AAE are calculated.
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
22. The table below summarises the FSRA’s current capital requirements for VA Firms
and the proposed amendments to Rule 3.7.1 of PRU, with the detailed amendments set out in Appendix 2. Regulated Activity Current – operational expenses Proposed Prudential Category 2 Dealing in Investments as unmatched Principal 6 months’ operational expenses (“Opex”) Higher of:
(i) BCR of $2 million
(ii) Risk Capital
Requirement (“RCR”)
Prudential Category 3A
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Do you agree with the proposed changes to the capital requirements applicable to VA Firms? Revisions to fees
24. The current formulations of FEES Rules 3.17.1(a) and 3.17.2(a) refer to an additional
fee being levied for each Regulated Activity undertaken in relation to VAs, across both application fees and annual supervision fees.
25. Based on the FSRA’s experience of, and to better reflect, both the work involved in
assessing applications and the allocation of resources for the supervision of VA Firms, it is proposed to charge the current single supplemental application or annual supervision fee regardless of the number of Regulated Activities undertaken in relation to VAs.
26. For example, an Applicant that wishes to carry on the Regulated Activities of
Dealing in Investments as unmatched Principal and of Arranging Deals in Investments, both in relation to VAs, will be subject to the following fee schedule at the application stage and thereafter as an Authorised Person. Application FEES Rule Fee (USD k) Dealing in Investments as unmatched Principal 3.4.1 40 Arranging Deals in Investments 3.8.1(c) 10 Virtual Assets activity 3.17.1(a) 20 Total 70 Annual Supervision 1 Dealing in Investments as unmatched Principal 3.4.2 50 Arranging Deals in Investments 3.8.2(c) 10 Virtual Assets activity 3.17.2(a) 15 Total 75 Note
1. Prorated for period from time of authorisation until end of first calendar year
27. The proposed amendments to FEES are set out at Annex B.
Question 3
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Do you have any comments on the proposed change to fee requirements for VA Firms? Enhancing FSRA powers in relation to VAs and introducing express prohibition on the use of privacy tokens and algorithmic stablecoins in ADGM Product intervention power
28. To enhance its supervisory powers in respect of VAs, the FSRA proposes to
introduce a new power within section 5A of FSMR enabling the FSRA to halt dealings in a particular VA. This product-specific power would apply to persons in ADGM generally, not only Authorised Persons conducting a Regulated Activity. For example, this power may be used in circumstances where, for example, the FSRA considers that a particular VA poses a risk to the public, or where AML concerns have arisen. The FSRA proposes that FRTs would also fall within the scope of this new power. Prohibited products
29. In addition, and consistent with the FSRA’s existing policy in respect of algorithmic
stablecoin tokens and privacy tokens, the FSRA proposes including an express prohibition in FSMR on the use of algorithmic stablecoin tokens, privacy tokens, or any digital asset employing similar technology in carrying on any Regulated Activity in ADGM.
30. The proposed amendments to section 5A of FSMR are set out in Annex A.
Question 4
Do you have comments on the proposals outlined in paragraphs 28 and 29? AVA assessment criteria
31. The current AVA assessment criteria in paragraph 4 above reflect certain risks,
including the ability to address AML-type risks through tracing, the ability to secure VAs held on behalf of clients as well as a consideration of VA-specific risks as a form of investment. 1 See VA Guidance, paragraphs 25 and 165.
Section B.2: Discussion points relating to the VA framework
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
32. The FSRA is of the view that the existing criteria remain appropriate: however, we
seek the views of the VA sector concerning the relevance and relative importance of those assessment criteria in the context of different Regulated Activities. The FSRA intends to issue additional guidance in future on the relevance and relative importance of such criteria alongside proposed amendments to the VA framework. Question 5 Do you agree with the current AVA assessment criteria? Question 6 Do you consider that certain criteria should only be applicable to particular Regulated Activities? Question 7 Do you consider that some or all of the AVA assessment criteria should apply to Regulated Activities other than those referred to in paragraph 2? Scope of the Regulated Activity of Providing Custody
33. The scope of the Regulated Activity of Providing Custody under FSMR currently
encompasses Financial Instruments, VAs and Spot Commodities. As outlined above, all VAs held in custody must be AVAs.
34. The FSRA welcomes feedback on whether Authorised Persons engaged in Providing
Custody should be permitted to hold digital assets other than AVAs. Question 8 Should custodians be permitted to hold a broader range of digital assets? If so, what assets should custodians be permitted to hold? Staking and other emerging business models for VA Firms
35. As the global landscape for VAs continues to evolve, new VA related activities and
business models have emerged. One such activity is that of “staking”, which is a process by which users or participants of a blockchain network or protocol participate in a Proof-of-Stake (“PoS”) consensus mechanism.
36. The FSRA has summarised the features of certain staking business models and the
key risks associated with staking activity in Attachment 1.
Key factors for regulation of staking
37. The FSRA considers that the two key factors in determining whether an activity
involving staking should be considered a Regulated Activity in future are the level of
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential intermediation involved, and the extent to which the staking activity is carried out by way of business for non-related participants. The extent to which these two factors are present in the activity would depend on whether:
(a) the intermediary has control over the staked VAs of the participants, e.g. through custodial staking; or (b) the intermediary has discretion or responsibility over the deployment of clients’ VAs in the staking activities, e.g., deploying VAs into a staking infrastructure or decentralised finance (“DeFI”) protocol.
38. Based on these key factors and having regard to the business models described in
Attachment 1, the FSRA outlines below its preliminary considerations in respect of the regulatory perimeter for staking-related activities. (a) Solo staking should not be a Regulated Activity as participants are operating without intermediation and are carrying on staking on their own account. (b) Staking-as-a-service should not be a Regulated Activity where the technology service provider is only offering technical services to set up, operate and maintain the staking infrastructure without control over the participants’ VAs. In this case, the participant selects the validator intended to validate new blockchain transactions, stakes on their own account and has control over its VAs. (c) Pool Operators and Centralised Intermediaries should be required to hold a Financial Services Permission (“FSP”), as they would have either custody of the staked VAs or discretion in respect of the deployment of such VAs. In this regard, the FSRA considers that such staking activities may come within scope of either the Regulated Activity of Providing Custody or that of Managing Assets.
39. Based on the above analysis, the FSRA is considering permitting an Authorised
Person which holds an FSP to Provide Custody and/or Manage Assets in respect of VAs to be able to undertake staking activities on behalf of their clients. Specific regulatory requirements and restrictions for staking activities
40. The FSRA may also consider introducing certain staking-specific requirements into
its regulatory framework. Such additional requirements could include a requirement to disclose to clients staking-specific risks, a requirement to conduct due diligence in respect of the custodian’s / validator’s suitability in providing the staking services for clients, a requirement to conduct due diligence and risk assessment on the relevant PoS protocol and a requirement to have insurance
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential coverage for slashing risks, penalties, and loss of staked assets that may arise from staking activities.
41. The FSRA may also consider introducing certain restrictions on the business
models of Authorised Persons undertaking staking activities to mitigate contagion and prudential risks. Other yield-generating strategies
42. The FSRA notes that other yield-generating strategies, such as yield farming and
liquidity mining, are often referred to loosely in the VA sector as staking. The FSRA considers these strategies to be distinct activities that differ significantly from staking in their risk and reward profile. While the above analysis focuses on regulatory considerations relevant to staking, the FSRA welcomes comments on the regulatory considerations which should inform its approach to yield farming and other yield-generating activities. Pending the formalisation of a regulatory framework for such activities, the FSRA will continue to work with firms interested in offering such services on a case-by-case basis. VA borrowing/lending services and margin trading
43. Finally, the FSRA is aware of other business models offering what are termed “VA
borrowing and lending services” and other financing arrangements, including “collateralised VA financing” i.e. margin trading. VA borrowing and lending activities generally involve:
(a) a VA owner (“Lender”) entering into an agreement with a VA service provider (“VA Intermediary”) to lend out the VAs custodied with the VA Intermediary for a fee or yield. The VA Intermediary will lend out the VAs to others (“Borrowers”) for liquidity or investment purposes. The Borrower is required to put up collateral in the form acceptable to the VA Intermediary; (b) The VA Intermediary charges a fee, such as a spread or premium on the loan, in return for facilitating the transaction. The borrowing and lending activities are governed by lending agreements, which set out the terms of loan including duration, interest rates, lender’s fees, and the nature of the collateral; and (c) The VA Intermediary may also allow a client to purchase VAs on margin (i.e. collateralised VA financing), or to settle VA transactions on behalf of the client as part of cash flow management or settlement obligations.
44. The FSRA considers that the key risks associated with such activities include
counterparty risk, market risk in respect of leveraged trading, liquidity risk and conduct-related risk. Certain risks may also arise due to the digital nature of VA
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential business, e.g., the risk of loss arising from cyberattacks and smart contract vulnerabilities.
45. The FSRA considers that that there are similarities of VA borrowing and lending with
Securities borrowing and lending in traditional finance. In Securities borrowing and lending, the Securities owner / lender will enter into an agreement with a dealing intermediary to lend out Securities in return for a yield payment. The borrower will enter into an agreement with the dealing intermediary to borrow Securities, setting forth the terms of the loan with appropriate collateral placed with the dealing entity.
46. Such Securities borrowing and lending activities, which include activities of
transaction execution and settlement, will generally be undertaken as part of Securities dealing activities. Based on the above analysis, the FSRA is considering permitting an Authorised Person which holds an FSP to Deal in Investments or Providing Custody in respect of VAs to be able to undertake such activities on behalf of their clients.
47. The FSRA welcomes comments on whether such models may involve activities
other than VA borrowing and lending and margin trading and seeks views on the key associated risks and regulatory considerations that should inform its approach to such business models. Question 9 Do you have any comments on the VA staking business models identified by the FSRA? Are you aware of additional business models? Question 10 Do you have any comments on the preliminary considerations outlined by the FSRA in respect of regulating VA staking, including the Regulated Activities that may apply to such activity? Question 11 Do you have any comments on the key risks that relate to VA staking? Are there are specific regulatory requirements that should be introduced for that activity? Question 12 Do you have any comments on yield farming and other yield-generating activities involving VAs? What are the considerations that should inform the FSRA’s regulatory approach to such activities?
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Question 13
Do you have any comments relating to business models offering VA borrowing and lending and other forms of financing arrangement and the key associated risks? What are the considerations that should inform the FSRA’s regulatory approach to such business models?
48. As noted in Consultation Paper No. 7 of 2024, the FSRA’s treatment of FRTs
distinguishes FRTs from VAs on the basis that FRTs are intended to operate as a stable medium of exchange, while VAs are viewed by the FSRA as a form of investment, similar to a commodity. It was noted in that consultation paper that Authorised Persons transacting in FRTs will be prohibited from using FRTs which have not been accepted by the FSRA for use within ADGM (“Accepted FRTs”), which will be identified on a list maintained and published by the FSRA, which may be relied upon by all firms.
49. The FSRA does not intend to restrict acceptance to FRTs issued only by issuers
located in ADGM (“Domestic FRTs”). However, the FSRA notes that FRTs issued by issuers outside ADGM (“Foreign FRTs”) may not be subject to standards as stringent as those applied to Domestic FRTs.
50. Given this, Foreign FRTs approved as Accepted FRTs for use within ADGM will be
categorised as such to distinguish them from Domestic FRTs, which are subject to FSRA standards. All Authorised Persons that use Foreign FRTs in conducting Regulated Activities will have to disclose to their Clients that such Accepted FRTs are not subject to the FSRA’s requirements for issuers of Domestic FRTs.
51. The FSRA proposes that Accepted FRTs will be subject to similar assessment
criteria as employed for the assessment of VAs. However, given the smaller number of such requests expected from Authorised Persons for the acceptance of FRTs, the FSRA will conduct individual assessments of FRTs. Question 14 Do you agree with the proposed approach to enabling Authorised Persons to transact in FRTs?
Section C: Criteria for Acceptance of Fiat-Referenced Tokens
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
Question 15
Do you have any view on the criteria to be applied when considering whether a Foreign FRT should be considered as an Accepted FRT? Current approach
52. The FSRA launched a dedicated regulatory framework for VC Funds in May 2017,
with the objective of supporting the development of a vibrant start-up ecosystem in ADGM. Recognising that the method of operation and risk profile of VC Funds may be distinguished from other investment funds, the framework streamlines certain regulatory requirements, while imposing investment and operating restrictions.
53. The framework means that VC Funds are restricted to operate as closed-ended
funds, available only to Professional Clients, and may currently invest only in the Securities of companies in an early stage of development, where those Securities are not admitted to trading on an exchange. Proposed revisions
54. Based on feedback from the fund management sector, as well as the emergence of
new methods used by start-ups to raise capital, the FSRA proposes to expand the scope of investments in which a VC Fund may invest to include VAs, instruments enabling the Fund to acquire Securities or VAs, certain governance tokens and utility tokens, any representation of value in the form of digital tokens and the right to buy certain tokens, where any of the foregoing have been issued by a start-up business.
55. The FSRA notes that start-up businesses may issue such tokens, as well as
agreements enabling the VC Fund to acquire Securities or digital tokens issued by the start-up business in the future, such as simple agreements for future equity (“SAFEs”), simple agreements for future tokens (“SAFTs”) and token warrants.
56. The draft legislative amendments to FUNDS are set out in Appendix 3.
Question 16
Do you agree with the proposal to allow managers of VC Funds to invest in instruments or tokens issued by start-up businesses which do not currently qualify as a Security under section 258 of FSMR?
Section D: Scope of investible assets for Venture Capital Funds
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024
Confidential
The proposed legislative amendments are set out in the following documents.
Annex A
Confidential
FINANCIAL SERVICES AND MARKETS (AMENDMENT No. [_]) REGULATIONS 2024
Annex A
Confidential
FINANCIAL SERVICES AND MARKETS (AMENDMENT NO.[ __]) REGULATIONS 2024 Regulations to amend the Financial Services and Markets Regulations 2015. Date of Enactment: [____] The Board of Directors of the Abu Dhabi Global Market, in exercise of its powers under Article 6(1) of Law No. 4 of 2013 concerning the Abu Dhabi Global Market issued by His Highness the Ruler of the Emirate of Abu Dhabi, hereby enacts the following Regulations–
Annex A
Confidential
(d) require an Authorised Person Operating a Multilateral Trading Facility that admits Accepted Virtual Assets or Accepted Spot Commodities to trading to obtain a Recognition Order to become a Recognised Investment Exchange under section 121 of these Regulations; where the Regulator is satisfied that it is in the interests of the Abu Dhabi Global Market to do so and on such terms and conditions as the Regulator considers appropriate. (3) No person may carry on a Regulated Activity in the Abu Dhabi Global Market involving the issue, sale, purchase, transfer or custody of a Virtual Asset which is an algorithmic stablecoin token, a privacy token, or any digital asset employing similar technology. (4) If the Regulator is satisfied that the issue, sale, purchase, transfer or custody of a Virtual Asset would contravene or has contravened these Regulations, or it is in the interests of the Abu Dhabi Global Market, the Regulator may issue a Direction to a person or class of persons directing that no issue, sale, purchase, transfer or custody of the Virtual Asset be made by such person or persons for such a period of time as it thinks appropriate. … 138A. Remote Members (1) An Application under section 138A by a Remote Member Applicant must comply with the Remote Member Requirements relating to Remote Members as the Regulator may specify by Rules. (12) If it appears to the Regulator that a Remote Member Applicant satisfies the Remote Member Requirements specified in its Rules, it may make a Recognition Order declaring the Applicant to be a Remote Member. …
258. Definitions
(1) In these Regulations, unless the context otherwise requires— Multilateral Trading Facility or MTF means a multilateral system, operated by an Authorised Person or a Recognised Investment Exchange, which brings together multiple third-party Buying and Selling interests in Financial Instruments or Virtual Assets, in the system and in accordance with non-discretionary rules, in a way that results in a contract in accordance with its rules. …
2. Short title, extent and commencement
(1) These Regulations may be cited as the Financial Services and Markets (Amendment No. [__]) Regulations 2024.
Annex A
Confidential
(2) These Regulations shall apply in the Abu Dhabi Global Market.
(3) These Regulations come into forceon the date of their publication.
Annex B
Confidential
Fees Rules (FEES)
*In this attachment underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text.
Annex B
Confidential
…
3.16 Regulated Activities conducted as Islamic Financial Business
3.16.1 An Applicant for a Financial Services Permission to conduct a Regulated Activity of
Islamic Financial Business, either through the operation of an Islamic Window or as an Islamic Financial Institution, must pay to the Regulator an application fee of $5,000, in addition to the application fees due in respect of eachthose Regulated ActivityActivities which the Applicant proposes to undertake in a Shari’a-compliant manner.
3.16.2 An Authorised Person with a Financial Services Permission to carry on a Regulated
Activity of Islamic Financial Business, either through the operation of an Islamic Window or as an Islamic Financial Institution must pay to the Regulator an annual supervision fee of $5,000, in addition to the supervision fees due in respect of eachthose underlying Regulated ActivityActivities which the Authorised Person undertakes. Specific asset classes
3.17 Virtual Assets
3.17.1 An Applicant for a Financial Services Permission to carry on aone or more Regulated
ActivityActivities in relation to Virtual Assets must pay to the Regulator, in addition to the application fees due in respect of eachthose Regulated ActivityActivities which the Applicant proposes to undertake, an application fee of:
(a) $20,000 for each Regulated Activityall Regulated Activities to be undertaken in relation to Virtual Assets, unless one of the Regulated Activities is Operating a Multilateral Trading Facility; or (b) $125,000 iffor all Regulated Activities to be undertaken in relation to Virtual Assets if one of the Regulated ActivityActivities to be undertaken in relation to Virtual Assets is Operating a Multilateral Trading Facility without any additional Regulated Activity.
3.17.2 An Authorised Person with a Financial Services Permission to carry on a Regulated
Activity in relation to Virtual Assets must pay to the Regulator, in addition to the supervision fees due in respect of eachthose Regulated ActivityActivities which the Authorised Person undertakes, an annual supervision fee of:
(a) $15,000 for eachall of the Regulated ActivityActivities to be undertaken in relation to Virtual Assets; or (b) $60,000 iffor all of the Regulated ActivityActivities to be undertaken in relation to Virtual Assets if one of those Regulated Activities is Operating a Multilateral Trading Facility without any additional Regulated Activity. Guidance
Annex B
Confidential
2. For additional guidance concerning the fees associated with Regulated Activities
carried on in relation to Virtual Assets, please refer to the Regulator’s “Guidance – Regulation of Virtual Asset Activities in ADGM”.
Appendix 1
Confidential
Conduct of Business Rulebook (COBS)
*In this attachment underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text.
Appendix 1
Confidential
…
17.2 Accepted Virtual Assets
17.2.1 An Authorised Person conducting aany Regulated ActivityActivities in relation to Virtual
Assets must only useshall not conduct such Regulated Activities with a Virtual Asset which is not an Accepted Virtual AssetsAsset.
17.2.2 For the purposes of determining whether, in its opinion, a Virtual Asset meets the
requirements of being an Accepted Virtual Asset, the Regulator will consideran Authorised Person conducting a Regulated Activity must adequately assess the following criteria – a) Maturity / market capitalisation: the sufficiency, depth and breadth of demand, the proportion of the Virtual Asset that is in circulation and the controls/processes to manage volatility of such Virtual Asset; b) Security: whether the Virtual Asset is able to withstand, adapt, respond to, and improve on its specific risks and vulnerabilities, including relevant factors and risks relating to its use, including testing, maturity, and ability to allow the appropriate safeguarding of secure private keys; c) Traceability / monitoring: whether Authorised Persons are able to demonstrate the origin and destination of the specific Virtual Asset, if the Virtual Asset enables the identification of counterparties to each transaction, and if on-chain transactions in the Virtual Asset can be adequately monitored; d) Exchange connectivity: whether there are exchanges that support the Virtual Asset; the jurisdictions of these exchanges and whether such exchanges are suitably regulated; e) Type of distributed ledger technology (“DLT”): whether there are issues relating to the security and/or usability of the DLT used for the purposes of the Virtual Asset; whether the Virtual Asset leverages an existing DLT for network and other synergies, and, if not, whether a new DLT has been demonstrably stress tested; f) Innovation / efficiency: whether the Virtual Asset demonstrates utility by, for instance, helping to solve a fundamental problem, addressing an unmet market need or creating value for network participants; and g) Practical application / functionality: whether the Virtual Asset possesses quantifiable functionality.
17.2.3 Upon completion of the assessment conducted in accordance with Rule 17.2.2, an
Authorised Person must submit written notification in such form as the Regulator may prescribe, together with such information as may be required to demonstrate
Appendix 1
Confidential compliance with the assessment criteria set out in Rule 17.2.2, or as may be further prescribed by the Regulator.
17.2.4 In the absence of written notification from the Regulator, either requesting additional
information or objecting to the classification of such Virtual Asset as an Accepted Virtual Asset within twenty days, an Authorised Person may consider a Virtual Asset for which it has submitted the notification required under Rule 17.2.3 as an Accepted Virtual Asset.
17.2.5 An Authorised Person conducting a Regulated Activity in relation to an Accepted Virtual
Asset must continuously monitor such Accepted Virtual Asset to ensure its continuing satisfaction of the criteria specified in Rule 17.2.2. Guidance
Appendix 1
Confidential
17.3.2 For the purposes of this paragraph 17.3Rule 17.3.1, all references in MIR Rule 3.2 to
“Recognised Investment Exchange” shall be read as references to “Authorised Person”. Guidance Authorised Persons conducting a Regulated Activity other than Operating a Multilateral Trading Facility in relation to Virtual Assets are required to satisfy the requirements relevant to such Regulated Activity as set out in PRU.
17.4 International Tax Reporting Obligations
17.4.1 An Authorised Person conducting a Regulated Activity in relation to Virtual Assets, where
applicable, should consider anymust comply with all reporting obligations in relation to, among other things – (a) FATCA, as set out in the Guidance Notes on the requirements of the Intergovernmental Agreement between the United Arab Emirates and the United States, issued by the UAE Ministry of Finance in 2015 and as amended from time to time; and (b) Common Reporting Standards, set out in the ADGM Common Reporting Standard Regulations 2017. …
Appendix 2
Confidential
Prudential – Investment, Insurance Intermediation and Banking Rules (PRU) *In this attachment underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text.
Appendix 2
Confidential
…
1.2 Glossary
1.2.1 The following terms and abbreviations bear the following meanings for the purpose of
these Rules.
Virtual Asset Has the meaning given in section 258 of FSMR.
…
3.7 Expenditure Based Capital Minimum
3.7.1 An Authorised Person, other than one that has a Financial Services Permission to carry
out the Regulated Activity of Providing Third Party Services, must calculate its Expenditure Based Capital Minimum as:
(a) in the case of an Authorised Person engaged in Providing Custody in respect of Virtual Assets, 26/52nds; (ab) in the case of an Authorised Person which holds Client Assets or Relevant Money or Insurance Money, 18/52nds; (bc) in the case of an Authorised Person in Category 3B or 3C which does not hold Client Assets or Relevant Money or Insurance Money, 13/52nds; or (cd) in the case of an Authorised Person in Category 4, which does not hold Insurance Money, 6/52nds; of the Annual Audited Expenditure, calculated in accordance with Rule 3.7.2. Guidance
Appendix 3
Confidential
Fund Rules (FUNDS)
*In this attachment underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text.
Appendix 3
Confidential
…
Venture Capital Fund
4.1.6 (1) A Fund is a Venture Capital Fund if it: -
(a) invests only in the Securities of companies which are at an early stage of development and that are not listed or admitted to trading on an exchange, either; (i) directly; or (iia) only invests directly, or indirectly as a Feeder Fund holding units of a Master Fund, in accordance with (2);, in:
(i) Securities or Virtual Assets that are not admitted to trading on an exchange, (ii) instruments enabling the Fund to acquire Securities or Virtual Assets; (iii) governance tokens that allow holders to participate in on-chain governance of a crypto project; or (iv) utility tokens to use the products and services of a project described in (iii); (v) any representation of value in the form of digital tokens, or (vi) the right to buy the tokens described in (iii), (iv) or (v), and have been issued by a company which is at an early stage of development; (b) is closed ended; (c) limits total subscriptions to an amount not to exceed $100 million or a higher amount approved by the Regulator; and (d) is either:
(i) a Domestic Fund that is either an Exempt Fund or Qualified Investor Fund; or (ii) a Foreign Fund that is not available to Retail Clients. (2) A Venture Capital Fund may consist of a Master Fund and Feeder Fund(s) structure in which:
Appendix 3
Confidential
(a) each Feeder Fund meet the requirements in (1)(a)(ii),invests in a Master Fund as described in 2(b) and (d); and (b) the Master Fund meets the requirement of (1)(a)(i), (b), (c) and (d). …
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024 Attachment 1: Business models and key risks associated with VA Staking Confidential Outline of Business Models Key Risks Staking is the process by which participants of a blockchain network contribute to the Proof-of-Stake (“PoS”) consensus mechanism. In PoS systems, network participants (“Validators”) create and validate new blocks on the blockchain in return for block rewards and transaction fees (“Rewards”) paid in the network’s native tokens. Validators pledge or stake a certain amount of the network’s native VA to the blockchain network. The probability of a Validator being chosen to create a new block often correlates with the amount of staked VAs, although many PoS systems have more complex selection algorithms that consider additional factors. Validator nodes in PoS systems allow other network participants (“Delegators”) to contribute their VAs to the Validator’s stake. When a Validator successfully creates and validates a new block of transactions, the Rewards are typically shared between the Validator and their Delegators, in proportion to each Delegator's contribution to the total stake. Where the Delegator individually is unable to raise the minimum stake to run a Validator node, it may seek to group its VAs with the contributions of other Delegators by participating in staking pools operated by third parties (“Pool Operators”). Staking Models: the FSRA understands that different staking models have emerged, including the following:
(a) Solo staking: The participant, often called a ‘Solo-Staker’, directly operates the staking infrastructure and uses only its own resources (VAs and technical infrastructure) to meet the minimum requirements of the blockchain network. A Solo-Staker sets up and maintains their own Validator node using either local or cloudbased staking infrastructure. Once properly configured and identifiable onchain, this Validator node is where the Solo-Staker stakes its VAs. The participant retains direct control over their staked VAs at all times, as well as complete responsibility for the operation and security of their Validator node. (b) Staking-as-a-Service (“SaaS”): SaaS is an option for participants who want to operate as Validators but do not wish to maintain their own hardware and software. In this model, the participant employs a technology service provider to oversee the setup, operation and maintenance of the staking infrastructure. The participant uses its own VAs to meet the minimum assets requirements for the network. While maintaining direct control over its staked VAs, the participant relies on the SaaS provider to perform the technical aspects of Validator duties, such as node operation and software updates. This model allows for active participation in network validation while outsourcing the technical complexities. (c) Pooled staking: Pooled staking is a solution that allows multiple users to combine their VAs to meet the minimum staking requirements on a PoS blockchain network. This model enables participants who may not have enough assets to stake independently, or who prefer not to manage their own staking infrastructure, to participate in the network’s consensus mechanism and earn Rewards. A staking Pool Operator is responsible Validator-related risks (a) Poor Validator performance: The Rewards earned by stakers depend on the performance and reliability of the Validator they are delegating to. If the Validator experiences downtime, fails to validate transactions properly, or engages in malicious behaviour, it can negatively impact the stakers’ Rewards. (b) Slashing penalties: Validators can be penalised / slashed for misbehaviour, such as being offline for an extended period, submitting contradictory attestations, or attempting to validate conflicting transactions (double-signing). (c) Non-compliant block building: Staking with Validators who process transactions linked to illicit finance or sanctioned entities poses compliance and reputational risks for Delegators. (d) Validator software / hardware risks: Validators rely on the proper functioning of their staking software and hardware. Bugs, misconfigurations, or hardware failures can result in missed Rewards or potential penalties. Delegator-related risks (a) Smart contract risk: Staking through smart contracts operated by staking pools introduces the risk of smart contract vulnerabilities or bugs. If the smart contract code contains errors or is exploited, stakers may lose their
staked tokens or Rewards. (b) Liquidity risk: Staking involves locking up the staked VAs, which cannot be used until the Delegator choses to withdraw their tokens. Should the Delegator need to access their tokens during the lock-up period, they may be unable to do so or may face penalties for early withdrawal. If the price of the staked VAs falls sharply during the lock-up period, the Delegator will not be able to withdraw their investment. (c) LST over issuance or under collateralization: Liquid staking pools that issue more LSTs than they hold in VA staking deposits expose stakers to the risk of not being able to redeem their LSTs for the full value in VAs staked. LST over-issuance can lead to liquidity stress, declining LST value, and loss of confidence in the staking ecosystem.
Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024 Attachment 1: Business models and key risks associated with VA Staking Confidential Outline of Business Models Key Risks for setting up, operating, and maintaining the staking infrastructure. The Pool Operator collects the pooled VAs from users and manages the allocation of these resources across multiple Validators. This process involves deciding which Validators to deploy the pooled VAs to. The Pool Operator may choose to run the staking infrastructure in-house or outsource it to a SaaS provider. The Pool Operator is responsible for securely managing the pooled VAs and distributing the earned Rewards proportionally among the pool users based on their individual contributions. In this model, pool participants relinquish direct control of their staked VAs to the Pool Operator for the duration of the staking period. In a particular model of pooled staking known as liquid staking, when the participant contributes their VAs to a staking pool, they receive another token (“Liquid Staking Token” or “LST”) in return. LSTs are fungible tokens, that represent a share of staked assets in a staking pool, and that allow a pool participant to maintain liquidity while still earning staking Rewards. To withdraw staked tokens and obtain the Rewards earned, the pool participant is required to provide the corresponding LSTs at the time of redemption. Because LSTs are fungible and can be traded, their value tracks the underlying staked tokens and Rewards earned. LSTs may be traded, used as collateral, or employed in various DeFi applications. (d) Centralised VA exchanges, dealing intermediaries or custodians: Centralised VA exchanges, dealing intermediaries or custodians (“Centralised Intermediaries”) offer one of the most accessible options for participants who wish to earn Rewards passively but lack the knowledge or ability to do so independently. The Centralised Intermediary may take on the responsibility of setting up, operating, and maintaining the staking infrastructure, or delegate these tasks to a SaaS provider. The Rewards are paid out proportionately to clients based on their staked amounts. Similar to pooled staking, participants must transfer control of their assets to the Centralised Intermediary. (d) Loss of the Delegator address private key: Losing or compromising the Delegator address private key can result in the permanent loss of staked assets and associated Rewards. Network-level risks (a) Blockchain bugs or exploits: Bugs or vulnerabilities at the network level can pose significant risks to the entire blockchain ecosystem. If a critical bug is discovered and exploited, it can lead to severe consequences, such as double-spending, loss of funds, or a complete network shutdown. (b) Validator selection risks: Stake grinding and Sybil attacks are examples of threats that target the Validator selection process. In such cases, other Validators on the network are disadvantaged by the actions of the malicious Validator,
and the Rewards earned by bona fide Delegators are adversely impacted. (c) Blockchain network takeover: Instead of exploiting a bug on the blockchain network, or attacking the Validator selection, the attacker may attempt to gain control over the blockchain network, for example by using “long-range” attacks and / or “51%” attacks.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“As noted in Consultation Paper No. 7 of 2024, the FSRA’s treatment of FRTs distinguishes FRTs from VAs on the basis that FRTs are intended to operate as a stable medium of exchange”
“In December 2024 the FSRA issued Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024 which, alongside proposing certain enhancements to its VA regulatory framework, posed a number of questions on the appropriate regulatory perimeter for staking activities.”
“Consultation Paper No. 11 of 2024 sought feedback on the assessment criteria to be applied in respect of Foreign FRTs.”
More like this from FSRA
FSRA published 3 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Financial Services Regulatory Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated