Consultation · DNB · 19 Nov 2024
De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) updates its guidance on Systematic Integrity Risk Analysis (SIRA) to address the mechanical application of previous standards by supervised institutions. The document replaces the 2015 Good Practices and establishes a four-step cycle for integrity risk management: risk identification, risk analysis, risk management, and risk monitoring and review. It clarifies that these good practices are indicative recommendations rather than a normative framework, allowing institutions flexibility in their approach provided they comply with integrity legislation. The guidance applies to financial institutions, trust offices, and pension funds subject to DNB's integrity supervision.
DNB SIRA Good Practices
Consultation version
DNB SIRA Good Practices
Contents
1 Introduction 2 Integrity risk management 3 Risk identification 4 Risk analysis 5 Risk management 6 Risk monitoring and review
Annex
DNB SIRA Good Practices 1 Introduction 3 Contents 1 Introduction 1 DNB also conducts integrity supervision of institutions in the Caribbean Netherlands. This supervision is subject to other laws and regulations. 2 Section 10 of the Bpr, Section 10 of the Decree on the Supervision of Trust Offices (Besluit toezicht trustkantoren – Btt 2018).
1.1 DNB’s integrity supervision
In addition to solidity, integrity is a prerequisite for a sound and reliable financial system. De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) conducts integrity supervision of a wide range of financial and other institutions. DNB’s integrity supervision is based in particular on the Financial Supervision Act (Wet op het financieel toezicht – Wft), the Anti-Money Laundering and AntiTerrorist Financing Act (Wet ter voorkoming van witwassen en financieren van terrorisme – Wwft), the Sanctions Act (Sanctiewet 1977 – Sw), the Pensions Act (Pensioenwet – Pw), the Mandatory Occupational Pension Scheme Act (Wet verplichte beroepspensioenregeling – Wvb) and the Act on the Supervision of Trust Offices (Wet toezicht trustkantoren 2018 – Wtt) (collectively referred to below as integrity legislation).1 A sound and ethical financial sector starts with sound and ethical financial institutions. DNB supervises financial institutions to ensure they conduct their business in such a way that sound and ethical business operations are guaranteed. Essentially, ensuring ethical business operations is about managing the integrity risks to which an institution is exposed. Pursuant to the Wft, this particularly concerns:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 1 Introduction 4 Contents
1.3 Link between Wwft risk assessment and SIRA
The Wwft stipulates that an institution must take measures to identify and assess risks of money laundering and terrorist financing (the Wwft risk assessment). These measures must be proportionate to the nature and size of the institution in question. In identifying and assessing Wwft risks, an institution must consider the risk factors relating to its specific types of customers, products, services, transactions and supply channels, as well as to the countries or geographic areas in which it operates. The Wwft also requires institutions to document the results of their Wwft risk assessment. In addition, they must keep their risk assessment up to date and make the results available to the supervisory authority upon request.3 The SIRA analyses integrity risks in a broad sense, while the Wwft risk assessment specifically targets the risk of money laundering and terrorist financing – see also DNB’s Wwft Q&As and Good Practices.4 The SIRA therefore has a broader scope than the Wwft risk assessment. If an institution is also required to prepare a SIRA, it makes sense to include the Wwft risk analysis in the SIRA, but this is not mandatory.5
1.4 Rationale, status and structure of this document
1.4.1 Rationale for the review of the SIRA Good Practices
With the SIRA Good Practices, DNB aims to provide guidance to supervised institutions for preparing and using a SIRA. In 2015, we published our first good practices on preparing a SIRA.6 We decided to do so after we found that many institutions lacked such an analysis, and that we assessed over 80% of the SIRAs that we did examine as inadequate. 3 Section 2b of the Wwft. 4 DNB’s Wwft Q&As and Good Practices, par. 2.1. 5 Parliamentary Papers II, 2017-2018, 34 808, no. 3, p. 43 6 DNB (2015), The integrity risk analysis. More where necessary, less where possible. These new good practices replace the 2015 document. Almost all institutions have now prepared a SIRA. In recent years, however, we found that in many cases, institutions’ SIRAs focus only on the elements described in our good practices, and that their own reflection on the relevant integrity risks remains limited. Because institutions rigidly adhere to the SIRA process as described in the 2015 good practices, they often fail to take more recent insights and opportunities into account in practice. Due to this mechanical approach, there is often insufficient understanding of the specific integrity risks the institution faces. And, as a result, the institution is unable to verifiably and effectively mitigate its integrity risks. To summarise, although many institutions now have a SIRA, we see that in many cases it is not or insufficiently used as a (dynamic) steering document for identifying, analysing and mitigating integrity risks. This prompted us to review our SIRA Good Practices document.
1.4.2 SIRA Good Practices status
In supervisory practise, it appears that institutions regard the 2015 Good practices document as a normative framework with little or no room for individual interpretation. To disprove this perception, the reviewed document clearly states that no specific approach is prescribed. This SIRA Good Practices provides practical examples and highlights points for attention that can be used when preparing the SIRA and the Wwft risk assessment. Good practices set out suggestions or recommendations for supervised institutions. They are examples of possible applications that, in DNB’s opinion, provide a good interpretation of the obligations laid down in legislation and regulations. Good practices are indicative and institutions are free to take a different approach, as long as they comply with the laws and regulations.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 1 Introduction 5 Contents To read more about the status of our policy statements, go to the Explanatory guide to DNB’s policy statements on Open Book on Supervision. This SIRA Good Practices document replaces the 2015 Good practices document.7 In addition to this document, we have published several other policy statements on integrity legislation. An overview of all our general and sector-specific policy statements on integrity legislation is available on our Open Book on Supervision page.8 The SIRA Good Practices are intended as a practical and up-to-date tool for institutions that need to prepare a SIRA on the basis of which they can implement effective controls.
1.4.3 Structure of the SIRA Good Practices
This SIRA Good Practices document is structured as follows: Chapter 1 outlines the context and legal framework. Chapter 2 covers the basics of integrity risk management, including a cycle of process steps generally applied in practice to prepare an adequate and up-to-date SIRA. The chapters that follow describe good practices with regard to the different process steps for preparing and maintaining the SIRA. 7 DNB (2015), The integrity risk analysis. More where necessary, less where possible. 8 https://www.dnb.nl/en/sector-information/open-book-supervision/open-book-supervision-themes/supervision-of-financial-crime-prevention-integritysupervision/ 9 Section 3:10 of the Wft (payment processing service provider, payment institution, clearing institution, electronic money institution, special purpose reinsurance vehicle, bank, credit union, premium pension institution, insurer, exchange institution or branch as meant in Section 3:10(1), 3:11, 3:12, 3:12a, 3:13 or 3:14 of the Wft),
Section 14 of the Wtt (trust office), Section 143 of the Pw (pension fund).
10 Bulletin of Acts, Orders and Decrees 2006, 519, p. 104 and Bulletin of Acts, Orders and Decrees 2011, 673, p. 19. 11 Section 3:10 of the Wft and Section 10 of the Bpr apply to a payment institution, clearing institution, electronic money institution, special purpose reinsurance vehicle, bank, credit union, premium pension institution, insurer, exchange institution or branch as referred to in Section 3:10(1), 3:11, 3:12, 3:12a, 3:13 or 3:14 of the Wft. 12 Section 14 of the Wtt and Section 10 of the Btt apply to trust offices. 13 Section 1 of the Bpr.
1.5 Legal framework
1.5.1 Wft, Pw and Wtt: Systematic integrity risk analysis (SIRA)
Institutions must pursue an adequate policy to ensure ethical business operations.9 They must draft and implement this policy based on a systematic analysis of the integrity risks relevant to them.10 Laws and regulations The following laws and regulations are particularly relevant for a systematic integrity risk analysis (where applicable):
DNB SIRA Good Practices 1 Introduction 6 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 1 Introduction 7 Contents Finally, there are several other international policy statements that may be relevant to the content and application of the SIRA, e.g. from the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS), e.g. the policy statement Compliance and the compliance function in banks by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS). We expect institutions to take these policy statements into account in the design and application of their policies, procedures and measures to ensure effective management of the risks they identify. Where relevant international policy statements exist, we refer to these rather than include information from them in our own guidance. This ensures that institutions can always consult recent sources.
1.6 Risk-based approach
As noted above, ensuring ethical business operations is fundamentally about managing the integrity risks to which the institution is exposed. Ensuring ethical operational management thus assumes a risk-based approach. A risk-based approach means that the deployment and intensity of procedures and measures depend on the level of risk. More limited scrutiny in the case of low-risk situations will allow for greater capacity and attention to be focused on higher-risk situations. This strategy will make it possible to deploy scarce resources where they will be most effective. To ensure an appropriate, effective and efficient risk-based approach to integrity risks, it is therefore essential that institutions are highly aware of the relevant risks. It is also important in preventing to place an unnecessary burden on customers, unjustified derisking and countering exclusion and (indirect) discrimination.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 2 Integrity risk management 8 Contents 2 Integrity risk management Integrity risk management starts with the SIRA Integrity risk management is fundamentally about managing the integrity risks to which the institution is exposed. That starts with identifying and analysing the integrity risks at issue: what are the risks, how and where would they arise, and what possible consequences would they have – and that, in a nutshell, is what a SIRA involves. This makes the SIRA an important building block, if not the cornerstone, of integrity risk management. Integrity risks may ensue from activities, relationships and actions of almost all sections of a financial institution. Managing integrity risks In addition to documenting its integrity risks, an institution will also have to manage them adequately. To do so, based on the SIRA, the institution has to put in place policies, procedures and measures. Management focuses on reducing the probability of a risk arising and mitigating negative consequences if a risk materialises. Reviewing, updating and adjusting It is also important that the institution establishes that the controls are adequate. Two main questions are important here:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 2 Integrity risk management 9 Contents Practice shows that the integrity management process is also dynamic. For example, risks not previously identified in the ‘risk identification’ stage may still be identified in the ‘risk analysis’ stage or in the ‘risk management’ stage. The cycle can also be run for emerging or new risks. The exact sequence of process steps is not key here. What matters is that the institution has a SIRA, and corresponding and appropriate risk management that ensures ethical business operations. Risk identification Risk analysis Risk management Risk monitoring and review
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 10 Contents 3 Risk identification Introduction The SIRA is an institution-specific analysis of the integrity risks relevant to the institution, so having an accurate picture of the institution’s organisation and business should be the starting point. Conducting the SIRA therefore starts with drawing up the organisational risk profile. An organisational risk profile identifies the integrity risks as they occur at different levels within the institution, including the elements that may contribute to the extent to which these risks occur. It includes a quantitative and qualitative analysis of the risk factors to which the institution is exposed. Risk factors include the type of services provided, the customer portfolio and its related transactions, delivery channels, geographical areas, signatories, outsourcing relationships, etc. Risk identification, including drawing up an organisational risk profile, is a knowledge-intensive step – it requires knowledge and expertise. This involves knowledge of the organisation on the one hand, and knowledge of integrity risks and the way in which they could materialise on the other. Rationale Based on the organisational risk profile, the institution has a good idea of the integrity risks that may occur within its various units and the factors that may expose it to these risks. It can then further analyse the identified integrity risks – this is discussed in Chapter 4. Good practices Good practice – Preparation for the SIRA An institution starts its periodic SIRA process. Before starting the process and to gain an understanding of the potential integrity risks, the compliance officer first prepares the process and undertakes several actions, including the following:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 11 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 12 Contents Good practice - Organisational risk profile, sanctions risk A bank’s management board requests an update of the organisational risk profile with regard to sanctions risk. The officer in charge within the first line prepares the update together with a sanctions expert. For the ‘trade finance’ organisational component, an expert from that department is engaged. Together, they identify the following risk factors:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 13 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 14 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 15 Contents Based on this information, the bank identifies the risk that customers are unintentionally indirectly discriminated against in the customer due diligence (CDD) process. The bank decides to conduct a more comprehensive risk analysis to identify the steps and elements in the CDD, transaction monitoring (TM) and Sanctions process where the bank is at increased risk of customers being unintentionally discriminated against or experiencing discrimination. Based on this analysis, the bank will take appropriate measures to mitigate the risk of actual or perceived discrimination. Good practice – Identification of risks and risk factors at a trust office A trust office analyses its portfolio and identifies several relevant risks and risk factors:
1. The trust office is vulnerable to money laundering through real
estate. It has a number of target companies with an independent external director combined with activities in high-risk real estate. The trust office finds that half of these target companies have a structure involving multiple companies, with the UBO being involved in all of them. This indicates an increased risk of money laundering with real estate through ABC transactions, for example.
2. The trust office has a number of target companies with operational
activities in countries that are geographically close to sanctioned countries and have close political ties with these sanctioned countries. This indicates possible exposure to evasion of sanctions regulations.
3. The trust office also identifies potential involvement in corruption
and the receipt of funds derived from corruption. The trust office has a number of target companies with operations in countries with a poor Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) score, combined with operations in an industry prone to corruption. In this case, it concerns a state-owned company and a mining company. The trust office also finds that a PEP is involved. Good practice – Identification of risks and risk factors at a payment service provider A payment service provider (PSP) analyses its portfolio and identifies several relevant risks and risk factors:
1. The institution finds that it could potentially be involved in
circumvention of sanctions regulations. It has carried out an analysis of the risk factors in its SME portfolio related to transaction flows. In doing so, the institution has provided insight into the total number and volume of inbound and outbound international transactions to high-risk countries, and how this compares with figures from previous years. The analysis shows that the transaction volume to a particular high-risk country has risen sharply since sanctions were imposed on a neighbouring country.
2. Based on an analysis of its customer portfolio, the PSP identifies
specific factors related to money laundering risks. In its customer portfolio, the institution notes a sharp increase in customers active in crypto trading through unregistered foreign platforms – there is a group of customers with large transaction volumes flowing towards these platforms. The institution also identifies a number of customers active in the gambling industry with strongly rising transaction volumes.
3. To gain further insight into potential exposure to money laundering
risk due to the cash risk factor, the institution analyses its retail customers’ cash usage. The institution analyses which customers deposit more than a certain amount of cash per year. It does so for a number of different thresholds (€20,000, €50,000 and €100,000). The institution identifies a number of customers for which the amount of cash deposited is many times higher than that customer’s annual income.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 3 Risk identification 16 Contents Good practice – Developing new activity An institution actively seeks opportunities for growth, and for strengthening and deepening its customer relationships. The institution is considering entering into a new activity. As part of the decisionmaking process, the institution commissions an integrity risk analysis. This ‘SIRA for the new activity’ provides insight into the integrity risks involved in operationalising, implementing and running the potentially new activity. The decision of whether to enter into the new activity and under what conditions is based in part on this integrity risk analysis.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 17 Contents 4 Risk analysis 21 FATF (2016), Guidance on correspondent banking services (Guidance on Correspondent Banking (fatf-gafi.org)), p. 10. See also BCBS (2020), Guidelines on Sound management of risks related to money laundering and financing of terrorism (Sound management of risks related to money laundering and financing of terrorism (bis.org)). 22 BCBS (2020), Guidelines on Sound management of risks related to money laundering and financing of terrorism, p. 27; www.austrac.gov.au/correspondent-bankingrelationships. Nested correspondent banking: a bank’s correspondent relationship is used by a number of indirect respondent banks (‘nested banks’) through their relationships with the bank’s direct respondent bank to conduct transactions and obtain access to other financial services. Rationale After drafting the organisational risk profile, as described in the previous
chapter, the institution has an overview of the integrity risks that are
relevant to it. In order to develop, implement and prioritise appropriate controls, it is important for the institution to conduct a risk analysis. The institution analyses the identified risk factors and integrity risks and estimates the materiality and frequency at which these risks may actually occur. How the risk analysis is carried out depends on the institution and the risks. In some cases, the emphasis will be on quantitative in-depth data analysis and in other cases and/or for other risks, analysing the key manifestations, e.g. through scenario analysis, will provide the most insight. A combination of methods often proves to add value in practice. In any case, the risk analysis should make clear to the institution which risks need most attention and with what (type of) controls they can be mitigated. Good practices Good practice – use of external sources In drafting its risk analysis, a bank uses insights from the NRA, Financial Action Task Force (FATF) publications, the Anti Money Laundering Centre (AMLC) and other relevant external sources (such as risk assessments from industry associations) that provide insight into typologies and indicators related to integrity risks. The various organisational units use the same approach. For example, the compliance officer for the ‘Correspondent Banking’ department uses the FATF guidance on correspondent banking in their analysis. This FATF guidance refers to “The risk factors included in the Annex II of the BCBS Guidelines on Sound management of risks related to money laundering and financing of terrorism”.21 Based on the information from these sources, the bank considers the following factors in its risk analysis:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 18 Contents Good practice – Use of money laundering indicators at a money transaction office The organisational risk profile of an MTO states that branches in tourist areas handle comparatively more different currencies. In that context, there are also some offices in the Netherlands where many customers with a French residential address have transactions carried out once or several times a month. The AMLC’s Overview of Money Laundering Indicators used in the risk analysis shows that it is common knowledge “that various forms of crime involve large amounts of cash in various currencies.”23 Based on this, the MTO concludes that the money laundering risks associated with cash deposits are higher for transactions involving large amounts of cash in various currencies, and that this particular risk manifests itself particularly in branches in the identified tourist areas. The MTO also considers the EBA’s ML/TF Risk Factors Guidelines in its analysis. One of the factors that may contribute to higher risk is: “The customer’s needs may be better served elsewhere, for example because the money remitter is not local to the customer or the customer’s business.” On this basis, the MTO finds that the service provided by the Dutch branches to customers with a French residential address poses an increased risk of money laundering. 23 Anti Money Laundering Centre, Overview of Money Laundering Indicators, p. 4. At the time of preparing this Good Practice, the February 2024 version was the current version (in Dutch): Overzicht-witwasindicatoren-februari-2024.pdf (amlc.nl). 24 DNB (2024), Integrity Supervision in Focus 2024-2025, p. 15. Good practice – Use of money laundering indicators at a life insurer In terms of products, the organisational risk profile of a life insurer shows that the institution only offers term life insurance. Premiums are collected from a fixed contra account. Premiums average around €1,000 a year and do not exceed €5,000 a year. In its risk analysis, the institution considers the EBA’s ML/TF Risk Factors Guidelines. Based on Guideline 14.7, the institution finds that its term life insurance is a low money laundering risk. Good practice – Partial analysis of the risk of conflict of interests An insurer analyses the risk of conflict of interests at board level, and takes as a starting point the question of how directors may favour themselves and/or parties related to them using their decision-making power – the institution sees this as a major risk factor. The director responsible for ‘Compliance’ read in a DNB publication how DNB points out the risk of directors with significant powers of procuration for independently making commitments and/or payments. Assigning significant powers of procuration to a director entails an increased risk of conflict of interests.24
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 19 Contents The institution analyses various possible manifestations to specify this risk, such as:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 20 Contents Good practice – Use of scenarios – Money laundering via loanback In its organisational risk profile, an institution noted that a relatively large percentage of smaller companies in its customer base receive loans from foreign parties. The institution identifies a risk of involvement in money laundering through customer-applied loanback structures, and elaborates on this in a scenario:
With a loanback construction, a person or entity makes it appear as if it has legally obtained money at its disposal through a loan from another party. However, in fact, they are ‘lending’ money (not legally obtained) to themselves through an affiliated entity. The related entity may have partly the same directors or UBOs, for example. The loan adds an apparent legal touch to what is actually the disposal of funds obtained through crime. The scenario addresses the following series of actions:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 21 Contents Good practice – Data analysis and reference groups When analysing the customer portfolio, an institution uses reference groups: groups of customers with similar characteristics. The aim of the analysis is to detect anomalous and conspicuous behaviour (outliers) that could indicate money laundering. The institution therefore ensures that the group of customers in a reference group is sufficiently homogeneous, and has defined, for example, the following reference groups:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 22 Contents
6. How many transactions are involved What is the total transaction
volume? Does it concern a specific group of natural or legal persons?
7. What is the geographical profile of these cash withdrawals?
8. How do the cash withdrawals compare with those of the peers of
specific customer groups?
In the in-depth analysis with regard to high-risk countries, the institution looks at both the probability and the impact of the risk and includes the following factors:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 4 Risk analysis 23 Contents Good practice – In-depth data analysis with risk factors and scenarios at trust offices A trust office conducts an in-depth quantitative analysis to further examine the identified money laundering risks and properly assess the actual size and impact of this integrity risk. The trust office has several target companies in high-risk countries and high-risk sectors. The trust office analyses the transactions of all these target companies using the following risk factors, which are relevant according to the external sources consulted by the trust office:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 5 Risk management 24 Contents 5 Risk management 25 The set of policies, procedures and measures is also referred to as ‘controls’. Rationale The risk analysis described in the previous chapter provides important insights for various departments within the organisation. These insights provide guidance for management and lay the foundation for the institution’s integrity policy, based on which the institution intends to manage its integrity risks. The integrity policy is reviewed on a regular basis. Based on the risk analysis, the institution puts in place policies, procedures and measures to manage its integrity risks.25 And this reflects the purpose of risk management: by deploying controls, the institution mitigates the integrity risks revealed in its SIRA process. It also assesses whether the risks can be adequately mitigated. On this basis, the institution can then decide to accept the residual risk, reduce it further by deploying additional controls, or avoid it altogether. Risk management is about the institution applying controls that are appropriate to the risk identified. In this context, it is not only important for institutions to take more measures in the case of higher risks, but it is also appropriate for institutions to use the scope available to apply more limited measures in the case of lower risks. It also implies that a risk assessment, however judicious, may nevertheless potentially result in a decision that, in hindsight, was poor. This does not necessarily indicate a management failure. In other words, good risk management does not mean that undesirable events will no longer occur. What it does mean is that the institution has done what is reasonably possible to prevent the occurrence of such events and can adequately mitigate any negative consequences should they occur. Good practices Good practice – Establishing controls based on the scenario of ‘a director hiring their own company’ An insurer’s risk analysis includes a scenario on a conflict of interests arising from a director hiring their own company. The analysis reveals it is a material risk. The scenario allows the insurer to determine appropriate measures to manage this risk. It then deploys the following controls:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 5 Risk management 25 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 5 Risk management 26 Contents
DNB SIRA Good Practices 5 Risk management 27 Contents Good practice – Loans to directors An institution provides loans to its directors. The risk analysis shows that the risk of conflict of interests is material. To manage this risk, the institution has policies and procedures in place to ensure such loans are granted only in the context of the institution’s regular business operations and are concluded only after approval by the supervisory board. An opinion of the compliance officer is attached to the proposal to the supervisory board. Good practice – Data analysis for cash use: KRIs and transaction monitoring Based on a data analysis of its customers’ cash use, an institution has gained insight into the average cash use and outliers of its retail customers and the different reference groups within this population. Based on these insights, the institution draws up KRIs and transaction monitoring rules for each reference group. If customers deviate from the KRIs, the institution determines whether an EDR is needed. The customer is questioned only if their cash use is conspicuous and possibly illegitimate. Good practice – Country risk and risk management Based on various external sources, an institution has identified a number of countries it considers high risk. In the context of its control framework, the institution has determined that it cannot operate in some of these countries. For other countries, it has set limits for the number of (business) customers it is willing to accept from these countries. At the same time, the institution has defined KRIs for the transaction flows to and from these countries and converted them into specific business rules for the transaction monitoring system. As a result, the institution is able to adequately monitor the money flows to and from these countries. Good practice – Risk assessment of payment service providers with sub-merchants A payment institution has established that payment services are provided to customers with sub-merchants. To properly focus the controls, the payment institution decides to take the risks of the underlying sub-merchants into account when establishing a risk profile for the customers with sub-merchants. After all, the risks of the submerchants could also affect the customer’s risk profile – for example, in a situation where the customer with sub-merchants would be assigned a ‘low risk’ rating on a stand-alone basis, while the customer’s sub-merchants engage in ‘high risk’ activities such as gambling.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 5 Risk management 28 Contents Good practice – A trust office decides to part ways with customers following its risk assessment A trust office has identified target companies in its customer portfolio that have an independently authorised external director as well as no right for the trust office to inspect the target company’s bank account. The trust office finds that adequate transaction monitoring is not possible as a result and there is an increased risk of various integrity risks such as money laundering, sanctions avoidance and tax evasion – which cannot be further analysed and therefore cannot be managed. The trust office decides to part ways with these customers if the right to inspect the account is not obtained within a month – the risks cannot be adequately managed and therefore fall outside the scope of its risk tolerance. Good practice – Deciding not to hire a candidate An institution has a vacancy for a compliance officer. One of the applicants meets the criteria according to their CV and is invited for an interview. The interview goes well and the institution wants to hire this person. The institution regards the position of compliance officer as an integrity-sensitive position. The institution has set up a procedure for such positions, which involves screening and an assessment of the candidate’s propriety in advance. Part of the screening is a diploma check. The diploma check reveals that the applicant does not have the university degree indicated on their CV. When confronted, the candidate admits they do not have it. The institution decides not to proceed with the candidate.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 6 Risk monitoring and review 29 Contents 6 Risk monitoring and review Rationale By monitoring risks and the effectiveness of controls, an institution determines whether its control framework is still adequate. There are several reasons for an institution to review its organisation on an ongoing basis to identify business units at risk of integrity risks, and to adjust its SIRA and its controls where necessary:
DNB SIRA Good Practices 6 Risk monitoring and review 30 Contents Good practice – Feedback loop based on outcome of periodic review During the periodic review of a target company, an account manager of a trust office observes that the turnover from operational activities of a target company’s holding has increased sharply. The holding is based in a country bordering a sanctioned country. The account manager requests documentation from the target company to investigate the matter further. Based on the outcome of this investigation, a re-acceptance procedure is initiated. The account manager also notifies the compliance officer. The compliance officer performs a broader analysis on the portfolio to check whether this scenario also occurs in other target companies in the portfolio. The scenario is included in the SIRA. Good practice – Feedback loop following a data breach or scandal An institution continuously monitors external news sources and media releases for information that may be relevant to its risk analysis. When a new major data breach or financial scandal comes to light, the institution immediately analyses the available data and identifies potential risks and exposures within its customer base and transaction flows. These findings are then used to refine and adjust existing risk models, strengthening the institution’s financial crime prevention and detection capabilities. This approach enables the institution to respond proactively to new information and continuously improve its risk management process. Good practice – Feedback loop based on an analysis of recent exits A payment institution regularly conducts an in-depth analysis of recent exits, analysing and evaluating the underlying reasons for exiting these customers. This allows the payment institution to identify trends and patterns regarding high-risk customers and activities. Based on these insights, the institution adjusts its risk analysis by adding new risk factors, reviews existing risk models and makes improvements to its customer monitoring and due diligence procedures. By drawing lessons from recent Wwft-related exits, the payment institution can strengthen its risk management processes and proactively identify and manage risks. Good practice – Monitoring geopolitical developments An internationally operating insurer keeps a close eye on geopolitical developments and international conflicts that may affect its business activities. When an international conflict escalates and leads to the imposition of sanctions, the insurer immediately conducts a risk analysis to evaluate the potential impact on its business. This includes a thorough assessment of its exposure to risks arising from the sanctions, such as doing business (or facilitating business) with sanctioned persons or entities, and damage to its reputation. Based on this analysis, the insurer develops an updated risk management plan aimed at identifying, assessing and controlling new and emerging risks arising from the
conflict and subsequent sanctions.
DNB SIRA Good Practices 6 Risk monitoring and review 31 Contents Good practice – Using reports to and feedback from FIUNL A bank uses its reports to FIU-NL and the feedback on these reports from FIU-NL as input for its risk analysis process. It analyses this information to identify trends, patterns and risky behaviours that its own monitoring processes may not have detected before. Based on this analysis, the bank adjusts its risk models and transaction monitoring rules to improve its ability to detect and report unusual and potentially suspicious activity to FIU-NL. In addition, the bank uses the feedback received to train its staff and make them aware of the latest developments and trends in financial crime. Good practice – Analysis of transactions to high-risk countries A bank notes a significant increase in transactions from a country bordering a sanctioned country The bank conducts a more in-depth analysis into the transactions, involving indicators such as:
DNB SIRA Good Practices Annex – Main changes compared to the 2015 SIRA Good Practices 32 Contents
Annex – Main changes compared to the 2015 SIRA
Good Practices
The main changes compared to the 2015 SIRA Good Practices are the following. Topic Change Risk management cycle representation The integrity risk management cycle is shown in less detail by limiting it to the four main steps. This was prompted by the desire for less prescriptive wording. Rationale The rationale for taking the relevant step is indicated for each part of the integrity risk management cycle. At the same time, this makes it clear that it is not primarily about performing certain steps in a certain order, but much more about the outcome of the process: a good SIRA as the basis for implementing appropriate controls. Examples of integrity risks The list of examples of integrity risks is no longer included. It was intended to provide examples that could help institutions identify risks that may be relevant to them. In practice, we found that institutions used the list as a prescriptive element. In many SIRAs, the list of examples is then taken as the starting point for the analysis. Integrity risk analysis poster We have removed the poster. In practice, many institutions considered it as the method of analysis prescribed by DNB. However, it was only intended as an overview, to provide guidance.
DNB SIRA Good Practices Annex – Main changes compared to the 2015 SIRA Good Practices 33 Contents Topic Change Risk identification and risk analysis The ‘risk identification’ step involved developing an organisation outline, defining scenarios and the scoring system for probability and impact. In this new Good Practice document, the risk identification step emphasises the organisational risk profile and identification of factors that may be relevant in the context of integrity risks. The risk analysis step focuses on working out the risks in more detail. We refined the approach from the 2015 SIRA Good Practice, in which determining probability and impact for scenarios was important, because we found that institutions viewed determining probability and impact as a mandatory step, applying a mathematical precision that is less well suited to the qualitative nature of many integrity risks. Thinking about probability and impact can be helpful in the analysis stage, but there are several other ways that can also support the analysis. It is good to realise that while risk identification and risk analysis can be distinguished, they cannot be properly separated. The stages can be completed sequentially but often also simultaneously. For example, an institution may take the view that working out the risks should be done in the risk identification stage rather than in the risk analysis stage. We believe the specific stage in which this is done is of minor importance. Using scenarios With regard to using scenarios, more emphasis is now placed on the need to develop detailed scenarios that are tailored to the institution. This puts the institution in a better position to define and set effective controls. Using data analysis The new SIRA Good Practices document puts more emphasis on the fact that data analysis can be of added value when preparing a SIRA.
De Nederlandsche Bank N.V.
PO Box 98, 1000 AB Amsterdam
331 (0)20 524 91 11 dnb.nl/en
Follow us on:
LinkedIn
Twitter
Instagram
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“These new good practices replace the 2015 document.”
More like this from DNB
We email you every new DNB publication the day it's published.
Source: De Nederlandsche Bank — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated