Report · EBA · 30 Nov 2023
The AMF conducted a qualitative study on the readability of pre-contractual disclosures for Article 8 and Article 9 funds under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation. The research involved 27 savers with financial assets between €20,000 and €200,000 who reviewed mock-up documents from April 24 to 28, 2023. Participants found revised templates more readable but identified persistent confusion regarding the distinction between Taxonomy-aligned investments and sustainable investments, as well as technical terms like carbon credits. The results indicate that while simplified syntax and visual aids improved comprehension, investors still struggled with asset allocation percentages and perceived the documents as overly technical or not intended for retail users.
Consumer testing on financial product disclosures in precontractual disclosures under the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation June 2023 Authors:
Blondeau Victorien, Eon Olivier, Quintin Emilie (with Institut CSA)
Contents
Contents.............................................................................................................................................. 2
Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 3
Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................ 4
Objectives ........................................................................................................................................... 8
Methodology....................................................................................................................................... 8
Detailed results................................................................................................................................. 10
Dashboard ......................................................................................................................................... 10
Decarbonisation section.................................................................................................................... 14
Asset allocation ................................................................................................................................. 15
Taxonomy .......................................................................................................................................... 17
Recommendations ............................................................................................................................ 19
Mock-up ............................................................................................................................................ 19
Introduction
On 28 April 2022 the Commission mandated the European Supervisory Authorities (ESAs) to propose amendments to the Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 on sustainability-related disclosures in the financial services sector (hereinafter the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, or SFDR) Delegated Regulation including to add decarbonisation targets in financial product’s disclosure templates. The ESAs considered it necessary to propose targeted amendments to the financial product disclosures (hereinafter the ‘templates’) in order to improve the readability of these documents. In order to gather feedback from consumers on these draft proposals, four consumer testing on the draft proposals were conducted in four Member States, namely Poland, France, Netherlands and Italy:
The templates required under the SFDR Delegated Regulation are part of existing pre-contractual and periodic product disclosure requirements under different EU sectoral legislation 1 . The SFDR empowers the ESAs to develop draft RTS, not only to specify the details of the “content” of the information to be disclosed, but also the details of the “presentation”. This report describes the consumer research conducted on the updated SFDR template for a product promoting environmental or social characteristics, with regards to the disclosure of the dashboard, decarbonization disclosures, asset allocation and Taxonomy disclosure conducted from 24 to 28 April 2023 included in France by the AMF. See Articles 6(3) and 11(2) of the SFDR as regards the existing sectoral disclosures. This includes, for example, product disclosures provided by AIFMs, UCITS management companies, insurance undertakings, IORPs, PEPP providers etc.
Executive Summary
Objective:
The AMF conducted a qualitative study on the readability of the information appended since 1 January 2023 to the prospectus of funds promoting environmental and/or social characteristics (so-called "article 8" funds within the meaning of the SFDR Regulation) or having an objective of sustainable investment (so-called “article 9” funds). The objectives were threefold:
test the content and form of these templates;
assess the clarity of existing and revised versions and determine the elements spontaneously
understood but also those that remain clarify;
identify the points of discursive tension that would illustrate the perception of a difference in
terms of ambition between Article 8 and Article 9 products and ways of improving these revised versions. This new study made it possible to confront 27 savers holding funds (half of them holding responsible products) with the extra-financial information documents attached to these “responsible” investments. The participants expressed their perceptions of responsible investments and reacted to the handling of the documents presented (actual and revised versions for article 8 or article 9 products). Sample and methodology:
The sample consisted of 27 savers. These savers were non-experts but interested in responsible investments, and had between €20,000 of €200,000 of financial assets. Half of the savers already held responsible investments. This qualitative study was conducted by CSA research, which recruited the participants and engaged them on an individual basis through a blogging process for 5 days:
For five days, from April 24 to 28, 2023, savers individually consulted the documents presented
on an online platform. CSA asked them some questions, first to gather to collect their reactions, opinions and suggestions for improvement, and second to check their level of understanding in some cases. Participants spent approximately one hour a day on the blog.
Questions guided investors around 2 main themes: (i) Readability of the document, (ii) Their
expectations and needs to make communication clearer and not misleading.
Participants were divided in two groups: a group of 13 investors dedicated to templates
relating to Article 8 template (existing and revised versions) and 14 investors for Article 9 template (existing and revised versions).
Only the pre-contractual template was submitted to the participants (Annexes II and III of the
SFDR Delegated Regulation) .
Summary of Results:
Key takeaways:
o Spontaneous perceptions of responsible investment:
Responsible investment is a little-known subject, even though half the
participants already have SRI holding, and a novelty with which most are not very familiar. The perception is of a lack of transparency which leaves some investors sceptical. Generally, the concepts appear vague to them.
However, savers expressed a positive image of responsible investments,
perceived as being a step in the right direction through investment in more ecological companies. Conversely, a non-sustainable investment is seen as an investment in companies performing an activity harmful for mankind or for ecology in general. It is also a product which finances projects having as their sole objective profitability, with poor redistribution of wealth.
Some are apprehensive about investing in "sustainable" or "responsible"
investments, which are regularly associated with greenwashing and that they may see as being a marketing feature of the products. o Documents not appearing to be aimed at retail investors:
At first sight, the two documents shown were considered complete, and
providing essential information.
Though being introduced to only one product during the blogging process
(either Article 8 or Article 9), investors understand that an "Article 9" product should be perceived as more ambitious than the "Article 8" product. The "green" nature and objectives of the product were generally understood.
Next, investors felt put off by the form of the document, its compact
presentation, its length and the lack of a summary.
Concerning the substance, they perceived complexity, due to the use of
technical terms and a lack of simple explanations considered deterrent.
Ultimately, they felt that the documents, described as "full of jargon", were not intended for them. o Concepts that are hard to identify:
The table presented on the first page of the existing version ("Does this
product have a sustainable investment objective?") was appreciated for its concise description of the product.
But certain formal aspects were a source of misunderstanding. The table, in
which only a single column providers information depending on the type of product, seemed not very appropriate (the part not corresponding to the product takes up space).
Concerning the substance, the understanding of the document was
satisfactory: most of the participants understood that the European Union's Taxonomy is more ambitious than what are called "sustainable investments" within the meaning of the SFDR. However, the text in the boxes including definitions on Taxonomy and Sustainable Finance was considered too full of jargon (e.g. "classification system", "Taxonomy", "good governance practices").
The definitions proposed were considered useful, especially that regarding the
Taxonomy, but too technical. Despite the contribution of these definitions, the difference between "Taxonomy" and "sustainable investments" within the meaning of the SFDR remained hard to identify, and also the distinction between "sustainable characteristics" and "sustainability objective".
Overall, the table was regarded as technical and it seemed that it could be
reorganised.
Dashboard key results
There are three main observations:
Need on continuing to refine the revised version :
o Define more precisely and with concrete examples difference between Taxonomy and Sustainable Investment; o Add images or infographics that summarize the information in a more playful way than text alone;
Need on providing details on:
o how the funds are invested, the exact breakdown as a percentage; o The risk level of the investment; o The product’s performance and profitability; o The environmental ambition of the product;
Need to keep document simple:
o Avoid long texts; o Say what the document is, not what it is not (or could be).
Decarbonisation key results
There are three main observations:
Simplify the document avoiding technical terms or explaining these terms (such as ‘carbon
credit’ or ‘reduction targets’);
Make the document more visual with a timeline;
Be more specific for figures and rules for reduction targets GHG emissions.
Asset allocation key results
The study points out:
Objectives
This report brings together the work carried out over from March to June 2023 as part of the consumer testing of the revised SFDR disclosures. Following a behavioural approach, this report provides evidence to support the ESAs in forming a view on the format and content of updated templates for disclosures for financial products disclosing under article 8 and 9 of the SFDR, which will be delivered as draft Regulatory Technical Standards following the mandate received from the European Commission in April 2022. The results outline how information should be presented in the SFDR financial product templates, because deemed to be essential or useful by consumers, and how such templates should be designed to be user-friendly. The purpose of this study was to test the consumer experience of the revised SFDR pre-contractual disclosure, with focus on the “dashboard” that presents summary/key information and subsequent
section on decarbonization objectives, as well as additionally specific disclosure on asset allocation and
on whether environmentally sustainable investments made are Taxonomy-aligned. Questions guided investors questioned around 2 main themes:
The study has been conducted in 5 days:
Detailed results
Dashboard
First impression (Q1)
The revised dashboard is a document allowing a more efficient reading.
Generally speaking, the revised dashboard is more readable than the currentversion, but problems of misunderstanding related to the Taxonomy persist. The Taxonomy could be better presented by removing the unnecessary boxes of the dashboard and icons are questionned (see below). Revised Article 8 document is a document well understood, especially regarding the limits of the product. Areas for improvement, particularly in terms of definition, are to be explored. Revised Article 8 document allows a more efficient reading than the version seen previously for several reasons:
Revised Article 8 document allows a better understanding of the objectives and limitations of the product:
Perception on implication of green colouring (Q2) Icons are quite well perceived but can induce an overvaluation of the ambition of the product:
Feedback on whether it is clear that the disclosure indicates commitments to invest (Q5) A majority of investors understand that the announced SI are commitments to invest (11 out of 12 investors in art. 8 group (resp. 8 out of 13 investosrs in art. 9 group). Feedback on decarbonisation icon (Q7) The CO₂ icon is not well understood. In addition, the CO₂ cloud is confused with the smoke escaping from the factory included in the icon concerning the consideration of PAI CO2 Proposed decarbonisation icon
Decarbonisation section
As a whole, the table format is very pleasant for the participants, who see it as a way readable and clear for quick access to information. The sentences are short and easy to understand Overall feedback (Q7 and Q8 on whether the information is understandable or too detailed) For investors in Art. 8 group, ¾ of participants understand that the 1st line of the table is the most important. The yellow background whose perceived function is to draw attention to the lack of objective of limitation of global warming, helps to understand the limits of the product Understanding of what is the GHG reduction target for the whole product by 2030 (Q9) For both investors in Art. 8 and 9 groups, the answers to the comprehension questionnaires are faultless.
Understanding of how the GHG emission reduction target is achieved (Q10) The decarbonation section could be improved:
The only black point remains the carbon credit, still nebulous for many participants (as well
as “reduction targets”, still vague);
This impression is reinforced by its unit, the tCO 2 eq/€M which is very technical;
It should in particular detail the process to reach the objective of reducing GHG emissions as
well as that of its evaluation (for the 2030 horizon with a focus on the difference between GHG removals and storage.) In the end, this section is appreciated for the clarity of its presentation and very well understood (if is not the notion of carbon credit, which could be defined in a box) and which could take the form of a more visual timeline Asset allocation As a whole, the section “Asset allocation”is deemed concise but lacking in effectiveness for transmitting the information and which could be supplemented by textual explanations. For Art.8 group:
As a whole, the graph is popular but confusing. The format of the graph is vizualizing, especially to understand a priori the "investment path":
A readable document, allowing a quick and simplified understanding;
A form that allows to follow the "path", to have the investment subsections.
But in the end, the graph hinders the message of the product:
A product announcing, in the end, a low environmental commitment only 15%;
Comprehension test scores are very low;
A little more than half, however, understood that this product will be able to make
investments that are not sustainable.
Lastly, investors still have many questions:
The distribution of percentages and their non-exclusivity are not understood in particular
because of the absence of the remaining of the fund, namely the (minimum) 85% in #2 Others
The link between the headings is sometimes problematic: is it an addition or a development?
The interest of footnotes is questioned, especially since the explanation of sustainable 1A is
missing.
The terms and acronyms VL, E/ S and Specific Assets are to be defined In the end, a graph that
is not very relevant because it does not clearly deliver the information and that could, to be easier to understand, be presented in the form of an infographic, with a single bar of 100% (or more) broken down into smaller braces For Art. 9 group, observations are quite the same. However, none of the participants understood that the percentages were not exclusive. This document has some shortcomings noted by participants:
The move from 80% (sustainable) to 15% ( Environmental ) +15% (Social) is a great source of
trouble;
The definitions of technical words such as master compartment, specific assets, actual
proportions of investments are to be developed because they are necessary for the understanding of the document. Investors suggested to improve the document with possible additions:
A mean to follow the link between sections would be appreciated;
A leaflet (notice) explaining that this product could make investments unsustainable, which
was well understood by participants;
Explanations with examples of what environmental investments are and the role/functioning
of the instruments;
A pedagogical legend explaining the distribution of percentages and non-exclusivity would be
welcome clarifying the absence of the remaining percentages of investments, namely the (minimum) 20% in # 2 Others, otherwise the box Not durable at 0 seems superfluous.
Understanding of figures ( Q11 and Q12 - investments that promote E/S characteristics but are not sustainable and investments that are not promoting E/S characteristics) Comprehension test scores are very low. A little more than half, however, understood that this product will be able to make investments that are not sustainable. Feedback on the Table Please see above. Taxonomy The absence of definitions of sovereign bonds greatly disturbs the reading and although the format (mixture of graphics and text) is deemed readable, the understanding is only average.
This revised section is much better understood. The fact that the investments in fossil gas and nuclear power and be aligned to the EU Taxonomy is better understood by participants. Nevertheless, some details may be improved:
Feedback on the footnote (Q13)
Investors didn’t make comments on the footnote. However, they understand that investments in fossil gas and nuclear power and be aligned to the EU Taxonomy. Feedback on whether the product makes Taxonomy-aligned investments (Q14) based on the text Findings are quite the opposite between investors in Art. 8 group and investors in Art.9 group. Only one out of 11 investors in Art. 8 group understand that the product Investors understand well on whether the product makes Taxonomy-aligned investments based on the text. Feedback on the graph – including understanding on whether the product makes Taxonomyaligned investments (Q15) Some investors still have difficulties to understand on whether the product makes Taxonomy-aligned investments based on the graphs. 4 out of 11 investors in Art8. group understand that there is no Taxonomy-alignement. Only 1 out of 10 investors in Art.9 group understand it. Recommendations
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from EBA
EBA published 1 document in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: European Banking Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated