Consultation · FCA · 10 Sep 2021
The Financial Conduct Authority proposes introducing a new Environmental, Social and Governance Sourcebook to mandate climate-related financial disclosures for asset managers, life insurers, and FCA-regulated pension providers. The proposals require in-scope firms with at least £5 billion in relevant assets to publish annual entity-level TCFD reports and product or portfolio-level disclosures, including core metrics, on their main websites or upon request to eligible institutional clients. The consultation seeks comments on these rules by 10 September 2021, with a policy statement anticipated later in 2021.
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Consultation Paper CP21/17 June 2021
CP21/17 Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Moving around this document Use your browser’s bookmarks and tools to navigate. To search on a PC use Ctrl+F or Command+F on MACs. How to respond We are asking for comments on this Consultation Paper (CP) by 10 September 2021. You can send them to us using the form on our website at:
www.fca.org.uk/cp21-17-response-form
Or in writing to:
Louisa Chender
Financial Conduct Authority
12 Endeavour Square London E20 1JN
Telephone:
020 7066 6849
Email:
cp21-17@fca.org.uk
Sign up for our news and publications alerts See all our latest press releases, consultations and speeches. Contents 1 Summary 4 2 The wider context 10 3 Design, scope, timing of implementation and compliance basis 16 4 Entity-level disclosure rules and guidance 23 5 Product or portfolio-level disclosure rules and guidance 30
Annex 1
Questions in this paper 42
Annex 2
Cost benefit analysis 45
Annex 3
Compatibility statement 59
Annex 4
Abbreviations used in this paper 64
Appendix 1
Draft Handbook text
Appendix 2
TCFD recommendations, recommended disclosures and supplemental guidance
Appendix 3
Formulas for calculating certain core metrics
CP21/17
Contents
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Contents by sector This table sets out which chapters are particularly relevant for each sector. This is where you will find the most relevant chapter(s) for your firm. Sector Chapter Asset Managers 3, 4, 5 Life insurers 3, 4, 5 FCA-regulated pension providers 3, 4, 5
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers 1 Summary Why we are consulting
1.1 As we emerge from the pandemic, we cannot lose sight of the climate challenge
ahead. To tackle it, society needs to accelerate the transition to cleaner energy and a less carbon-intensive economy.
1.2 This will require high-quality information on how climate-related risks and
opportunities are being managed, right along the investment chain – from companies in the real economy, to institutional investors and to consumers. Better information will help clients and consumers make better informed decisions about their investments. This should, in turn, help to enhance competition in the interests of consumers, protect consumers from buying unsuitable products, and drive investment towards greener projects and activities.
1.3 In November 2020, the Government published a Roadmap towards mandatory
climate-related disclosures across the UK economy by 2025, aligned with the recommendations of the Financial Stability Board’s Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). We are playing our part in the delivery of this Roadmap.
1.4 This Consultation Paper (CP) sets out our proposals to introduce climate-related
financial disclosure rules and guidance for asset managers, life insurers, and FCAregulated pension providers, consistent with the TCFD’s recommendations and recommended disclosures (in this CP, we refer to these collectively as the ‘TCFD’s recommendations’).
1.5 We are introducing a new ‘Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) Sourcebook’
in the FCA Handbook to set out our proposed rules and guidance. While the proposals in this CP relate solely to climate-related disclosures, we anticipate that the ESG Sourcebook will expand over time to include new rules and guidance on other climaterelated and wider ESG topics. Who this applies to
1.6 Our proposed climate-related financial disclosure rules will apply to asset managers,
life insurers and FCA-regulated pension providers.
1.7 The proposals in this CP relate either to the assets the firm manages or administers
overall, at entity level, or to the assets relating to particular financial products or services. The target audience for the disclosures are the investors, including institutional clients (eg, pension scheme trustees, employers, corporate investors) and end-user consumers (eg, pension scheme members, retail investors), referred to in this CP as clients and consumers, respectively.
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
1.8 Some firms in scope of our proposals may also be subject to disclosure requirements
in their capacity as listed issuers (or entities within a listed issuer group). Those disclosures are focused on how firms in scope manage climate-related risks and opportunities in their corporate business on behalf of their shareholders.
1.9 Specifically, the types of firms in scope of our proposals are:
Asset managers
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers of their group-wide or global business activities and products, even where these activities and products may not strictly be within the scope of the proposed rules.
1.14 Better transparency through our proposed disclosure regime is therefore likely to
benefit clients’ and consumers’ decision-making internationally. Given the urgency and scale of the changes needed to support a transition to a low-carbon economy, we consider this to be a good outcome.
1.15 Our approach also aims to support the flow of information along the investment chain.
In particular, we have sought to support disclosures required under the Department for Work and Pensions’ (DWP) draft regulations and statutory guidance (‘DWP’s draft regulations’) for in-scope trustees of occupational pension schemes.
1.16 We recognise that we are consulting against the backdrop of other sustainabilityrelated disclosure initiatives. Notably, some firms subject to our proposed rules will
already be subject to the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) in respect of their cross-border EU business. We note that the Government has agreed to match the ambitions of the EU Sustainable Finance Action Plan, of which the SFDR forms part.
1.17 Accordingly, in making our proposals, we have focused on outcomes and taken into
account other related requirements that firms face internationally, including the EU SFDR. We will continue to consider the interaction with those rules as the Government further develops its policy position.
1.18 The key elements of our proposals are:
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
1.21 By introducing our proposals, we intend to reduce potential harm such as clients
engaging firms that do not adequately manage climate-related risks and opportunities, and consumers buying unsuitable products.
1.22 There may also be wider market integrity and market functioning benefits. Improved
transparency enables clients and consumers to hold their financial services providers to account. This should encourage them to manage climate-related risks and opportunities effectively and direct capital towards projects and activities that better support the transition to a more sustainable, low-carbon economy.
Figure 1: Causal chain
Implement our proposals
Framework encourages more structured dialogue within firms on matters of governance, strategy and risk management related to climate change Greater transparency about how firms are managing climate-related risks and opportunities leads to better outcomes for clients and consumers An ecosystem of service providers emerges driving innovation and thought leadership to support high-quality climate-related disclosures Clients and consumers take climate matters into account when granting investment mandates and selecting products Assessment of climaterelated risks and opportunities improves across the market. Therefore asset pricing and capital allocation decisions are better informed Financial services firms are able to develop products that better meet consumers’ climate-related preferences Proposals support onward flow of information to clients, resulting in a coordinated flow of information along the investment chain Clients and consumers can better assess which providers and products meet their needs, and hold their providers to account Harm reduced: Reduced risk of clients engaging firms that do not adequately manage climate-related risks and opportunities, and consumers buying unsuitable products Competition is more effective Capital is allocated more effectively across companies and projects; the cost of capital better reflects climate-related risks and opportunities Financial flows support the transition to net-zero carbon emissions Market integrity is enhanced
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Outcomes we are seeking
1.23 By introducing our proposals, we would be creating a regulatory framework that aims to
ensure in-scope financial services firms contribute to wider Government aims to achieve a net-zero economy by 2050. This is consistent with expectations in our remit letter from the Chancellor, clarifying that we should consider the Government’s net-zero commitments when we work to advance our objectives and perform our functions as a regulator.
1.24 We are seeking to achieve 3 outcomes:
CP21/17
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers may help to encourage the transition to a low-carbon economy. We note, however, that it may not be straightforward to isolate the impact of our measures from other complementary initiatives to support the climate transition.
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers 2 The wider context
2.1 This chapter provides an overview of the context in which we are making our proposals.
Climate change risks and opportunities
2.2 For firms managing or administering investments on behalf of clients and consumers, the
most relevant and material exposures to climate-related risks and opportunities typically lie in the assets the firm manages, rather than in the assets on its own balance sheet.
2.3 The financial risks of climate change are usually categorised as:
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers specific considerations. We refer to this document as the TCFD Annex. Extracts are reproduced in Appendix 2 for reference.
2.7 The TCFD’s recommendations provide structure to climate-related financial
disclosures along the investment chain and a ‘foundation to improve investors’ and others’ ability to appropriately assess and price climate-related risks and opportunities’.
2.8 The TCFD has also produced technical guidance to further assist preparers in
developing their disclosures. A Technical Supplement, entitled The Use of Scenario Analysis in Disclosure of Climate-related Risks and Opportunities was published alongside the final report. This was followed in 2020 by Guidance on Scenario Analysis for Non-Financial Companies and Guidance on Risk Management Integration and Disclosure.
2.9 The TCFD’s recommendations have benefited from extensive expert inputs and wideranging consultation process. The TCFD has continued to engage with stakeholders to
support the development of further guidance.
2.10 In 2020, it published a consultation on forward-looking financial sector metrics. In June
2021, the TCFD published 2 further documents for consultation:
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
2.17 DWP has also brought forward draft regulations and statutory guidance that would
see the largest occupational pension schemes, as well as authorised multi-employer schemes (master trusts) reporting in line with the TCFD’s recommendations from 1 October 2021. The draft regulations will be debated in Parliament in the coming months. Existing climate-related disclosure requirements
2.18 The firms in scope of our proposals may be subject to existing climate-related
disclosure requirements in the UK or in other jurisdictions. Since climate change is an urgent global issue, we consider it appropriate to use a widely accepted global framework as the basis for our rules and guidance. By aligning our proposals with the TCFD’s recommendations, we aim to promote consistency in disclosures, both in the UK and globally.
2.19 Given complementary and, in some cases, partially overlapping requirements under
existing climate-related disclosure rules, our proposals also aim to ensure coherence with these regimes as far as possible.
2.20 Some examples of existing disclosure regimes include:
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
CP21/17
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers How it links to our objectives
2.28 In Chapter 1, Figure 1, we set out the potential harm our proposals are seeking to
address and the potential benefits to markets for regulated financial services.
2.29 If firms do not make sufficient climate-related financial disclosures, clients and
consumers may be unable to make informed decisions. As a result, clients may engage firms that do not adequately manage climate-related risks and opportunities and consumers may buy unsuitable products. Furthermore, without good transparency of how climate-related risks and opportunities are managed along the investment chain, capital may be misallocated.
2.30 Intervention to address these harms flows directly from our strategic objective to
ensure that the relevant markets function well, as well as advancing our operational objectives to:
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers 3 Design, scope, timing of implementation and compliance basis
3.1 In this chapter, we set out the overarching design of our proposed climate-related
disclosures and details of our proposed scope, timeframe for implementation and compliance basis. We outline our entity- and product-level disclosure rules and guidance in Chapters 4 and 5, respectively, including specific proposals relating to asset managers and asset owners. Design of our proposed rules and guidance
3.2 We are proposing to introduce a climate-related financial disclosure regime for asset
managers, life insurers, and FCA-regulated pension providers consistent with the TCFD’s recommendations.
3.3 Specifically, we are proposing requirements for disclosures to be made at 2 levels:
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
3.4 We directly reference the TCFD’s recommendations in our proposed rules. This
should help to make our expectations clear and help firms to take a structured, internationally-consistent approach to reporting on climate-related matters. Scope: Firms in scope of our proposals
3.5 Our proposals at entity level would apply to FCA-regulated firms with respect to their
assets managed or administered from the UK, notwithstanding where the client, product or portfolio is based. Asset managers
3.6 Our proposals would apply to FCA-regulated firms responsible for managing
investments. These would include:
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
3.11 Our proposed rules will not apply directly to overseas firms, including those currently
in the Temporary Permissions Regime (TPR). Firms within the TPR are required to seek full authorisation by us or the PRA to continue to access the UK market. As the TPR is due to end in December 2023, firms that apply for UK (FCA) authorisation would be brought into scope of our proposed rules accordingly.
3.12 However, we are proposing flexibilities that would allow firms to make disclosures at a
group-level, in respect of their global business, if they choose to do so. Asset owners
3.13 Our proposals would apply to firms involved in investment decision-making or
investment oversight activities. The aim is to provide clients and consumers with information about how climate-related risks and opportunities are considered and managed, to enable them to make informed decisions. These firms often manage assets with longer investment horizons, such as pension savings, which may be particularly affected by the risks and opportunities associated with climate change.
3.14 The types of firms in scope would include:
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Q1: Do you agree with our proposed scope of firms, including the £5 billion threshold for asset managers and asset owners? If not, please explain any practical concerns you may have and what scope and threshold you would prefer. Scope: Products and portfolios in scope of product or portfolio‑level requirements
3.18 Our proposed rules and guidance would apply to the firm, which would be responsible
for relevant disclosures at product or portfolio level.
Asset managers
3.19 The products and portfolios directly within scope of our proposed rules for asset
managers are:
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers – This lower threshold reflects the different, more concentrated market structure of these sectors and takes a proportionate approach to introducing disclosures, while still ensuring wide market coverage within a realistic timeframe. – This would capture 12 firms with £1.2 trillion in AuM.
3.29 Publication deadline 30 June 2023 – first disclosures to be made. Subsequent
disclosures would be made by 30 June each calendar year.
CP21/17
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Compliance basis
3.32 In Chapter 1, we outline the potential harm our intervention aims to address and
the outcomes we are seeking to achieve. We note that clients rely on high-quality information to inform asset pricing, risk management and capital allocation; while consumers need clear disclosures from firms so they can choose the right products. To meet the needs of both clients and consumers, we require a ‘whole-of-market’ solution such that disclosures are complete and consistent across the investment chain.
3.33 We have framed our proposals in a manner broadly consistent with DWP’s. Given that
occupational pension scheme trustees will face mandatory TCFD-aligned obligations under DWP’s draft regulations, only a mandatory regime for asset managers will support the required flow of information. Our proposed approach also aligns with the Government’s ambition that TCFD-aligned disclosures should be mandatory across the UK economy by 2025.
3.34 Nevertheless, we are providing limited flexibility for firms to provide some disclosures
on a ‘best efforts’ basis, for example where methodologies for certain metrics are not yet widely established. We believe this will enable firms to make a reasonable judgement as to whether the data are sufficient to disclose, and also allow for continuous improvement. Data availability
3.35 We welcome global initiatives aimed at improving the consistency, coherence and
reliability of issuers’ sustainability-related disclosures. In particular, the IFRS Foundation is working towards potentially establishing the new ISSB ahead of COP 26 in November, with a view to making quick progress to introduce a corporate reporting standard for sustainability. The IFRS Foundation Trustees have signalled that the initial focus will be on climate change.
3.36 We acknowledge that initially there will be data gaps at the investee company level
for as long as relevant climate-related disclosures are not mandatory, either in the UK or internationally. However, since in-scope firms aggregate investee company data, rather than produce primary disclosures, we consider they may use proxy data or make assumptions to address any gaps. Where proxy data or assumptions are applied, these must be transparent and the methodologies briefly set out, providing relevant contextual information and explaining any limitations of the approach.
3.37 We also recognise the data limitations in respect of instruments that are not traded
on public markets, where reporting and capabilities are less advanced. Similarly, we consider that in-scope firms may use proxy data or make assumptions to fulfil their disclosure requirements, with the additional explanations as set out above. Q4: Would there be significant challenges in using proxy data or assumptions to address data gaps? If so, please describe the key challenges and implications as well as any preferred alternative approach.
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers 4 Entity-level disclosure rules and guidance
4.1 In this chapter we set out our more detailed proposals for entity-level disclosures,
including the provision and content of the TCFD entity report and specific proposals for asset managers and asset owners.
4.2 The purpose of these disclosures is to provide greater transparency to clients and
consumers about how firms manage climate-related risks and opportunities. This will enable clients and consumers to make more considered choices when granting mandates and selecting providers, resulting in further benefits and reducing potential harm as set out in the causal chain (see Chapter 1). TCFD entity report and compliance statement
4.3 In-scope firms’ asset management and administration businesses are global in nature,
often operating across jurisdictions. Given this, and the global reach of climate change impacts, we consider disclosures on climate-related risks and opportunities to be important and meaningful to a worldwide audience. We also recognise that the FCAauthorised firms in scope of our proposals may make disclosures with respect to assets managed or administered beyond the UK, and for the attention of clients and consumers outside of the UK. We are proposing flexibilities that would enable them to do so.
4.4 We therefore favour retaining the largely principles-based approach in the TCFD’s
recommendations as the basis for our proposed entity-level disclosure rules. Adding further prescription or otherwise adapting the TCFD’s recommendations would not only deviate from a globally-accepted framework, but also risk stifling innovation in this area. A principles-based approach provides flexibility to keep pace with ongoing regulatory developments and advances in climate science. It also takes into account the competitiveness of the UK asset management, life insurance and pensions sectors.
4.5 Further, referencing the TCFD’s recommendations also helps to ensure that our
approach is coherent with that of DWP (which is also aligned with TCFD) to support a consistent flow of information along the investment chain. TCFD entity report
4.6 We propose to require each in-scope firm to publish a TCFD entity report, consistent
with the TCFD’s recommendations and recommended disclosures, on an annual basis by 30 June each calendar year. The report must be published in a prominent place on the main website for the business of the firm (eg, with a link from the homepage to ensure that it is easily accessible).
4.7 For the purposes of the instrument, the TCFD entity report is defined as a public
report regarding the overall assets managed or administered by the firm in relation to its ‘TCFD in-scope business’ (see Appendix 1).
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
4.8 We are proposing a flexible approach to the TCFD entity report which allows firms
to cross-refer to disclosures made in another report where those cover the relevant content. These include circumstances where:
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
4.17 Accordingly, our rules will permit firms to make disclosures at a level of consolidation
that the group considers would be most decision-useful for clients and consumers. This will also help to manage the burden on firms by avoiding potentially costly duplication of disclosures across entities within a group.
4.18 In particular, we are proposing that an in-scope firm’s TCFD entity report may cross
refer to climate-related disclosures made by the group or an affiliate member of the group. The in-scope firm’s TCFD entity report must, however, set out the rationale for doing so and how the disclosures are relevant to its activities. It must also clearly signpost to where the disclosures can be found and include the relevant hyperlinks and cross references. This flexibility would only apply where group or affiliate disclosures are relevant to the assets managed or administered by the firm.
4.19 Where the TCFD entity report cross refers to a group report or another group
member’s report, the in-scope firm’s compliance statement (see paragraphs 4.12 to 4.15) would in effect confirm that the disclosures made in another report accurately reflected the firm’s own approach to the TCFD’s recommendations.
4.20 If a firm’s approach to the TCFD’s recommendations materially deviates from the
climate-related financial disclosures contained within the group, or another member of the group’s, report, any deviation must be clearly explained (in either the TCFD entity report or group report). This would include, for example, cases where the firm has a different governance structure, or a different approach to risk management or climate-related strategy, to that of its parent. Cross-referencing to a complementary report to the annual financial report
4.21 As noted in Chapter 1, some in-scope firms will also be, or be part of, a corporate
group that is subject to our existing or proposed TCFD-aligned Listing Rule. The existing Listing Rule (LR 9.8.6R(8)) provides for disclosures consistent with the TCFD’s recommendations to be made on a ‘comply or explain’ basis in a firm’s annual financial report. Some firms may choose to make more detailed disclosures in a complementary standalone document. The primary audience for these disclosures is the firm’s shareholders.
4.22 We are proposing that firms should have the flexibility to make shareholder and clientfocused disclosures in the same complementary report, and cross-reference to these
disclosures from their TCFD entity report. Where doing so, the firm’s TCFD entity report must set out the rationale for doing so, how the disclosures are relevant to clients, and include relevant hyperlinks. Q5: Do you agree with our proposals for the provision of a TCFD entity report, including the flexibility to cross-refer to other reports? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why?
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Contents of the TCFD entity report
4.23 The following sections refer to the TCFD’s recommendations, recommended
disclosures, all-sector and supplemental guidance for asset managers and asset owners (see Appendix 2). Governance, strategy and risk management
4.24 Investment management and administration activities span a broad spectrum of
strategies, asset classes and products. We acknowledge that disclosures made under the governance, strategy and risk management pillars (including the TCFD’s supplemental guidance) may either be broad, covering a wide range of investment strategies, asset classes or products, or may need to be more tailored.
4.25 We are proposing that firms must explain any material differences in their approach to
governance, strategy, or risk management for specific investment strategies, asset classes or products, where relevant.
4.26 Depending on the number and nature of its different investment strategies, asset
classes or products, a firm may make more tailored disclosures or highlight material differences within its product or portfolio-level disclosures (see Chapter 5). However, where this is the case, the firm must include a cross-reference so that the disclosures are easily accessible from the TCFD entity report.
4.27 We recognise that the nature and content of entity-level disclosures consistent
with the TCFD’s recommendations are likely to be most suited to a sophisticated institutional audience.
4.28 We would however encourage firms to make disclosures accessible to a less
sophisticated audience, as far as possible. For example, firms could consider providing information on the tangible outcomes from their governance and risk management arrangements via case studies. Scenario analysis (recommended disclosure (c) under the ‘strategy’ pillar)
4.29 Scenario analysis involves the consideration of various plausible future scenarios under
a set of assumptions and constraints, to arrive at a range of hypothetical outcomes.
4.30 With respect to climate change, the purpose is to explore and better understand the
potential impact of climate-related risks and opportunities over time. The process and outputs can help firms to identify key drivers of climate-related exposure and thereby enhance their risk and investment decisions.
4.31 We note that scenario analysis tools and capabilities are still evolving across the
industry. In June 2020, the CFRF’s scenario analysis working group published practical guidance on ‘how to use scenario analysis to assess climate-related financial risks to inform firms’ strategy and business decisions’. This year it is building on the recommendations in that guide, while also progressing, in conjunction with other working groups, a cross-cutting project on climate data and metrics. Until best practice is established and widely adopted, methodologies and approaches are likely to continue to differ between firms, investment strategies and asset classes.
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
4.32 Nevertheless, we consider entity-level discussion of a firm’s approach to scenario
analysis to be decision-useful to clients and consumers. In particular, this would give institutional clients reassurance that different climate-related scenarios are considered in the investment decision-making process.
4.33 We therefore propose that firms must disclose:
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Q7: Do you agree that firms not yet setting climate-related targets must explain why not? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Specific proposals for asset managers
4.40 Where an in-scope firm is an authorised fund manager (AFM), it may delegate
investment management to a third-party portfolio manager which is not in the same group (often as part of a host AFM arrangement). In this case the authorised fund manager will remain responsible for producing a TCFD entity report that sets out its approach to the TCFD’s recommendations, including a signed compliance statement.
4.41 The firm must also briefly explain the reasons for selecting the delegate, where
relevant to the TCFD’s recommendations. This must include how climate-related matters have been taken into account in selecting delegates and relying on their products and services.
4.42 However, we propose to give these firms the flexibility to include hyperlinks and cross
references in their entity-level TCFD report to relevant climate-related financial disclosures made by delegated managers, where available.
4.43 Any material deviations from the firm’s own approach must be clearly identified and
explained, as well as the firm’s rationale for relying on the delegate’s disclosures.
4.44 We recognise that it may not always be possible to link to delegated managers’
reports, for instance if these are overseas firms that do not have mandatory climaterelated disclosure obligations. Where this is the case, the firm should produce its own disclosures according to the rules and guidance set out earlier in this chapter. Q8: Do you agree with our proposals for AFMs that delegate investment management services to third-party portfolio managers? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Specific proposals for asset owners
4.45 We propose that asset owners must produce an entity-level TCFD report that sets out
their approach to managing climate-related risks and opportunities for the part of their business offering products where the performance of the underlying investments impacts the benefits accruing to consumers. This is in effect where the life insurer or FCA-regulated pension provider acts as a manager or administrator of the underlying assets for consumers.
4.46 Firms providing in-scope products would be required to produce a TCFD entity report.
However, the level of detail required in the report would largely depend on the extent to which the asset owner takes an active role in investment decisions and product design.
CP21/17
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
4.47 We propose to allow asset owners to cross-reference to other group-level, third-party
or delegate reports, where relevant. For example, where a firm’s underlying funds are managed by an external asset manager (or more than 1 asset manager), the firm would be able to cross-refer to the appointed asset manager’s TCFD disclosures.
4.48 However, the asset owner remains responsible for monitoring the asset manager and
its TCFD entity report must, at a minimum, explain how climate-related considerations have influenced its decisions, such as:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers 5 Product or portfolio-level disclosure rules and guidance
5.1 In this chapter, we outline in more detail our proposals for product or portfolio-level
disclosures. This includes the timing, location and content of the disclosures, noting in particular the core and additional metrics that we are proposing. Product or portfolio-level disclosure requirement, timing and location
5.2 We are proposing a minimum baseline set of consistent, comparable product or portfoliolevel disclosures, including a core set of metrics. This aims to meet the needs of clients
and consumers to have reliable and comparable information about the assets to which they have economic exposure. It also aims to support consistent onward disclosure to clients that may be subject to their own disclosure obligations. Public TCFD product reports
5.3 We propose that, for many firms, product or portfolio-level disclosures would be made
annually in a prominent place on the firm’s main website, using the most up-to-date data at the time of reporting.
5.4 These firms will also need to include their product or portfolio-level disclosures in the
appropriate form of client communication which follows most closely after the annual reporting deadline of 30 June. This would be either:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers On-demand TCFD product reports
5.8 In some client relationships, public disclosures are not appropriate. For example, firms
that provide discretionary portfolio management services to individuals or institutional investors. Where this is the case, and firms’ clients need the information to satisfy their own (or their clients’ or customers’) climate-related financial disclosure obligations, we are proposing that disclosures be made to the client upon request, once a year. The first disclosures under this rule would be made no earlier than 1 July 2023. We set out further details of this proposal from paragraph 5.55. Provision of data
5.9 In addition, we are proposing that all in-scope firms should provide data on the
underlying holdings of their products to clients that request it to satisfy their own climate-related financial reporting obligations.
5.10 Firms would be required to respond to a single request within the annual reporting
period, beginning no earlier than 1 July 2023 (and 1 July 2024 for firms in the second phase of implementation). However, if a client relationship starts after 1 July 2023, the client would not be able to request data that precedes the start of the relationship. Firms must also disclose the relevant climate, emissions or carbon-related data where possible eg, depending on the contractual status of the information.
5.11 This proposal aims to further support the flow of information along the investment
chain, so that clients can carry out their own scenario analysis based on consolidated holdings across their investment products and mandates. Q10: Do you agree with our proposed requirements for product or portfolio-level disclosures, including the provision of data on underlying holdings and climate-related data to clients on demand? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Content of product or portfolio-level disclosures Core metrics
5.12 We are proposing a baseline set of core, mandatory, carbon emissions and carbon
intensity metrics that in-scope firms would be required to disclose. Our approach aims to promote consistency and comparability and to support the flow of information along the investment chain, in particular to occupational pension scheme trustees.
5.13 We consider that our proposed core metrics would both provide clients and consumers
with decision-useful information about their investments and support the onward flow of information to clients. Clients and consumers would be able to compare the carbonrelated attributes of their products over time, to measure progress and hold their providers to account for any claims made. As discussed in Chapter 2, metrics and other product-level information could also be used as a basis for future product labels. These would help consumers navigate investment products in a more consumer-friendly way and make choices accordingly.
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
5.14 The metrics we are proposing are a subset of the metrics listed in the TCFD’s
recommendations. These are among the most widely established climate-related metrics in the market. Firms should refer to the TCFD’s supplemental guidance for further information, including descriptions, formulas and methodologies.
5.15 As noted in Chapter 1, there are some common elements in the TCFD’s
recommendations and the EU SFDR, including certain metrics. In some cases, there are differences in the calculation methodologies (marked with an asterisk in the table below). Further detail on the different formulas, including a side-by-side comparison, is set out in Appendix 3.
5.16 Our proposed core metrics are set out in the table below:
Table 1: Core metrics
Metric Proposal
Scope 1 and 2
Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions
These metrics are widely used in the market, including as part of disclosure regimes in the UK and internationally. We propose to mandate this metric from when our proposed rules enter into force. Scope 3 GHG emissions Although this is a widely recognised metric, we acknowledge that methodologies differ and there may be significant data gaps among investee companies, at least in the short term until the implementation of further disclosure requirements in the UK and internationally. We are therefore proposing that firms should disclose Scope 3 emissions from no later than 30 June 2024. This is 1 year later than the deadline for the first disclosures in accordance with the rest of our proposals. *Total carbon emissions As total carbon emissions are the sum of the GHG emissions referenced above, we consider it appropriate to mandate that this metric be disclosed to the same timeframes. Scope 3 emissions would therefore need to be included in the total figure from 30 June 2024. *Carbon footprint This is a widely used metric in the market. We propose that this be disclosed on a mandatory basis from when our proposed rules enter into force. *Weighted average carbon intensity (WACI) In its final report, the TCFD acknowledged limitations with this form of carbon footprinting due to data availability. As such the TCFD is currently proposing that asset managers and owners should disclose a financedemissions metric based on WACI and the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF) methodology, if relevant, or a comparable methodology. The PCAF provides methodologies for asset managers, asset owners and banks to measure or estimate financed emissions for different asset classes. It also provides for alternative solutions when data is not available.
5.17 Where prescribed calculation methodologies differ between the TCFD’s
recommendations and the final report on draft Regulatory Technical Standards (RTS) for the SFDR (eg, the choice of normalisation factors in the denominator), we are proposing that they be reported according to the formulas under both regimes. This would promote consistency and comparability with both EU and international firms and reflect the global reach of many in-scope firms’ assets under management.
5.18 We are proposing that all metrics be supported by contextual information to explain
how they should be interpreted and any limitations. This aims to ensure that all
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers disclosures are fair, clear and not misleading. This is particularly important where assumptions and proxies have been used to address data gaps.
5.19 In addition, we propose that metrics be accompanied by a historical time series for
comparison, after the first year that product or portfolio-level climate disclosures are reported in accordance with our rules.
5.20 As mentioned in paragraph 2.10, in June 2021 the TCFD published 2 documents for
consultation:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers b. The TCFD’s proposed guidance on metrics, targets and transition plans and the proposed technical supplement on measuring portfolio alignment If not, what other approach would you prefer and why? Data availability
5.24 We want to drive good data, but we also recognise the limitations that firms may
encounter.
5.25 As discussed in Chapter 3, while data limitations persist, we propose that in-scope
firms must address such gaps using assumptions and proxies. Firms must identify where they have done so and briefly explain the methodologies used, in addition to any contextual information and limitations of the approach.
5.26 We acknowledge that this approach may limit comparability between different
products offered by different providers, given the scope for a range of different methodologies to be used. Nevertheless, clients and consumers will be able to compare a single product over time, to monitor the product’s carbon profile and hold their provider to account. Additional metrics
5.27 We propose that firms must supplement the core, mandatory, metrics with certain
additional metrics on a ‘best efforts’ basis.
5.28 These are less established, mostly forward-looking, metrics for which methodologies
are still evolving. Nevertheless, they represent the direction of travel of the industry and are likely to be decision-useful to clients and consumers.
5.29 The metrics and rationale are set out below:
Table 2: Additional metrics
Metric Rationale
Climate Value-at-Risk (VaR) Climate VaR could be a useful metric for assessing the potential future financial impact of a product’s or portfolio’s climate exposure. It may be particularly helpful for institutional investors that are subject to their own regulatory obligations, particularly in supporting scenario analysis. It may also help to disclose the outcome of scenario analysis to retail investors in a more accessible way. Metrics that show the climate warming scenario with which a product or portfolio is aligned eg, Implied Temperature Rise These metrics provide a forward-looking view of a product’s or portfolio’s carbon exposure. They could provide useful visibility over the progress funds are making towards any climate-related targets they have set. Other metrics Consistent with the TCFD’s supplemental guidance, firms should provide other metrics that they consider would be helpful for decisionmaking. Firms may refer to the list of recommended metrics in the CFRF disclosure guide. The CFRF's disclosure working group is currently developing a Climate Risk Dashboard made up of a more focused list of key decision-useful metrics to be published later in 2021. We will reference any further guidance in our policy statement accordingly.
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
5.30 To support the adoption of more consistent, robust and decision-useful portfolio
alignment approaches, in June 2021 the TCFD’s Portfolio Alignment Team published a technical supplement on measuring portfolio alignment. The technical supplement sets out emerging best practice on portfolio alignment tools and forward-looking measurements of financial portfolio alignment with the goals of the Paris Agreement. It also provides recommendations and identifies future research priorities, noting that they should be viewed as a ‘first step’ as approaches will continue to evolve.
5.31 The TCFD is seeking public comment on this document. As discussed from paragraph
5.20, subject to the final version being consistent to that consulted on, we are proposing to reference this in our final guidance. Targets
5.32 Where a firm makes a claim as regards plans to achieve certain climate-related
targets at product-level, we expect the firm to determine and communicate the key performance indicators it uses to measure progress against those targets, in accordance with the TCFD’s recommendations. Q14: Do you agree with our approach to additional metrics and targets? If not, what alternatives would you suggest and why? Governance, strategy and risk management
5.33 We consider that where an overarching approach to governance, strategy and risk
management (which applies broadly across all products/portfolios, asset classes or investment strategies) has been set out in the TCFD entity report, those disclosures would provide sufficient information for a client and consumer audience.
5.34 However, we are proposing that if the approach for specific products or portfolios,
asset classes or investment strategies is materially different from any overarching approach described in the entity-level TCFD report, the deviations must be set out or referenced in the product or portfolio-level disclosures.
5.35 Our proposals will give firms the flexibility to provide more tailored or detailed
information relating to individual products or portfolios in the product-level report, particularly where the TCFD’s supplemental guidance sets out specific product-related guidance. This approach also takes into account that it may be open to clients to enter new contractual terms with firms for the provision of more detailed information.
5.36 Any disclosures on material differences, or other detailed information, provided in
product-level disclosures should be capable of being read on a standalone basis. However, firms may cross refer to further information in the entity-level TCFD report and vice versa.
5.37 All information relating to each product or portfolio should be clear and easily accessible.
Scenario analysis (recommended disclosure (c) under the ‘strategy’ pillar)
5.38 Scenario analysis involves considering various plausible future scenarios under a set
of assumptions and constraints, to arrive at a range of hypothetical outcomes. From an entity-level perspective, climate-related scenario analysis may be used to inform
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers strategic thinking. Asset managers and asset owners also conduct scenario analysis to test the resilience of their portfolios against a range of climate issues.
5.39 We consider scenario analysis at product or portfolio-level to be a useful way for
clients and consumers to understand the potential impact of climate change risks and opportunities on their products and portfolios over time. Clients and consumers will be better informed and better able to challenge their provider on their approach to any risks or opportunities that may arise.
5.40 As one of the targeted outcomes of our proposals is to support the flow of information
along the investment chain with a view to more informed investment decisions, our proposals have taken into consideration the DWP’s draft regulations and the information needs of trustees.
5.41 DWP requires trustees to assess and disclose the potential impacts and resilience
of their scheme’s assets in at least 2 climate-related scenarios, one of which is based on a temperature rise of between 1.5°C to 2°C (in line with the goals of the Paris Agreement). Further statutory guidance explains that scenario analysis may be qualitative and/or quantitative, and that trustees may find it easier to perform a ‘top down’ analysis of the scheme-level risks to their scheme’s aggregated portfolio.
5.42 DWP’s statutory guidance also states that trustees of all schemes in scope should
progress towards developing the sophistication of their scenario analysis and to using quantitative analysis, especially where they believe that climate change could pose significant risks to their scheme.
5.43 We consider that quantitative disclosures will allow comparison between an individual
firm’s products. They may also allow indicative comparisons between different firms’ products.
5.44 We want to support industry progress towards more sophisticated scenario analysis,
and to support those trustees that want to produce quantitative scenario analysis now. We would like to understand stakeholders’ views on requiring in-scope firms to provide quantitative scenario analysis outputs as soon as practicable. We would welcome feedback on: the decision-usefulness to trustees; the feasibility and cost for in-scope firms to include quantitative scenario analysis outputs in their product or portfoliolevel disclosures; and the form such outputs could take. Our proposal
5.45 We are proposing an approach that would be sufficient to support trustees in producing,
at a minimum, a qualitative, ‘top down’ scenario analysis in accordance with DWP’s draft regulations, while remaining proportionate to firms.
5.46 We propose that for portfolios with concentrated exposures or higher exposures to
more carbon-intensive sectors, firms must describe these and disclose:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Figure 2: NGFS Climate Scenarios Framework
Source: NGFS Climate Scenarios for central banks and supervisors, June 2021 Q15: Do you agree with our approach to governance, strategy and risk management, including scenario analysis at product or portfolio-level? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q16: What form(s) could quantitative scenario analysis outputs at product or portfolio-level take? What do you consider the cost and feasibility of producing such outputs might be? How useful would such outputs be for users’ decision‑making? Specific proposals for asset managers Reporting to clients on demand
5.55 We acknowledge that for some client relationships, public disclosures are not
appropriate. These are:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
5.57 Firms would be required to provide product or portfolio-level disclosures to those
clients once in each 12-month period, specifying a calculation date no earlier than 1 July 2023. However, if a client relationship starts after 1 July 2023, the client cannot request data that precedes the start of the relationship. A firm must respond to an eligible client’s request in a reasonable time and a reasonably acceptable format.
5.58 Our rules set minimum standards that firms must comply with. We note that it may
be open to clients to agree new contractual terms with firms for the provision of additional information.
5.59 As we consider this information to be decision-useful to all types of clients, we also
encourage firms to provide broadly equivalent disclosures to any client who requests them.
5.60 Clients may want to specify the format of the disclosure to meet their needs and firms
may have formats that they regularly use to provide information to clients. So, we do not intend to be prescriptive, provided that a reasonable format is used. Our aim is to give firms the flexibility to decide how best to deliver the disclosures to clients. Our proposed rules do not prevent managers from including appropriate contextual information or arranging for this communication to be combined with any other annual communication from the manager to their client.
5.61 If a manager does not have the information necessary to provide portfolio disclosures,
they should use proxies and assumptions, and briefly explain the methodologies, context and limitations. Q17: Do you agree with our proposed approach that would require certain firms to provide product or portfolio-level information to clients on request? If not, what approach and what types of clients would you prefer and why? Specific proposals for asset owners
5.62 Our proposed requirements for life insurers and FCA-regulated pension providers
as asset owners would apply at the level of an individual fund or pre-set investment portfolio within a particular investment or pension product.
5.63 As discussed, product-level disclosures are primarily numerical carbon exposure and
carbon intensity metrics. These metrics cannot always be applied at the level of the investment or pension products because most of these products are structured as investment or pension wrappers for which individual funds are selected. Metrics cannot be calculated at the product level because each investor will include different funds within their wrapper, resulting in different carbon profiles at the product level.
5.64 Therefore, we are proposing that these product-level metrics should instead be
applied at the level of the individual fund or pre-set investment portfolio within the pension or life insurance wrapper. By looking at the metrics for each separate fund or portfolio, an investor should be able to get a picture of the metrics across their product (portfolio/wrapper) as a whole.
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
5.65 The life insurer or FCA-regulated pension provider would prepare product-level
disclosures for all funds or investment strategies that they design or manage. In cases where underlying funds are managed by appointed asset managers, the in-scope firm may cross-refer to relevant disclosures. Mirroring an external asset manager’s strategy
5.66 Where a life insurer is mirroring a selected third-party asset manager’s fund strategy,
there is the possibility that the assets held by the insurer are slightly different, albeit that the intended investment outcome is the same. The insurer’s disclosures would be expected to capture any exercise of judgement by the insurer in mirroring that strategy.
5.67 However, if there is no exercise of judgement or discretion, dependent upon their
contractual arrangements with the third-party asset manager, the insurer may be able to rely solely on disclosures by the mirrored fund and simply cross-reference these. Q18: Do you agree with our proposed approach for life insurers when mirroring an external asset manager’s strategy? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Pre-selected portfolios
5.68 In many cases, investors do not select individual funds to include in their wrapper but
instead opt for an investment portfolio which is pre-selected by the provider as is, for example, the case with default pensions arrangements. This strategy might consist of a single fund or a combination of different funds. Where a strategy is a combination of funds, fund-level metrics and targets would not capture the strategy as a whole.
5.69 Therefore, we are proposing that the metrics calculated at the level of the fund
should also be reported by asset owners at the level of these pre-set strategies – such as default pension arrangements, investment pathways and pre-set investment portfolios. This would make it easier for pre-set strategy investors to access metrics for their investment choices within the wrapper.
5.70 The pre-selected investment portfolios in scope for product-level disclosures would
include:
CP21/17
Chapter 5
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers risks and opportunities which affect particular cohorts more strongly and provide at least qualitative narrative around this. Q19: Do you agree with our specific proposals for asset owners, including the proposed threshold to exclude the smallest default schemes? If not, what alternatives would you prefer and why? Q20: Do you agree with the analysis in our CBA? If not, we welcome feedback in relation to the one-off and ongoing costs you expect to incur and the potential benefits you envisage. Contextual information about your firm’s size and structure would be helpful.
CP21/17
Annex 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Annex 1
Questions in this paper
Questions
Q1: Do you agree with our proposed scope of firms, including the £5 billion threshold for asset managers and asset owners? If not, please explain any practical concerns you may have and what scope and threshold would you prefer. Q2: Do you agree with our proposed scope of products? If not, what types of products should, or should not, be in scope and why? Q3: Do you agree with our phased implementation and timings? If not, what approach and timings would you suggest and why? Q4: Would there be significant challenges in using proxy data or assumptions to address data gaps? If so, please describe the key challenges and implications as well as any preferred alternative approach. Q5: Do you agree with our proposals for the provision of a TCFD entity report, including the flexibility to crossrefer to other reports? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q6: Do you agree with our proposed approach to governance, strategy and risk management, including scenario analysis? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q7: Do you agree that firms not yet setting climate-related targets must explain why not? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q8: Do you agree with our proposals for AFMs that delegate investment management services to third-party portfolio managers? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q9: Do you agree with our proposals for asset owners to cross-refer to group-level, third-party or delegate reports, where relevant? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why?
CP21/17
Annex 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Q10: Do you agree with our proposed requirements for product or portfolio-level disclosures, including the provision of data on underlying holdings and climaterelated data to clients on demand? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q11: Do you agree with the list of core metrics, including the timeframes for disclosure? If not, what alternative metrics and timeframes would you prefer and why? Q12: Do you agree that firms should calculate metrics marked with an asterisk according to both formulas set out in columns A and B of Appendix 3? If not, please explain why, including any challenges in reporting in accordance with either or both regimes. Q13: Do you agree that, subject to the final TCFD guidance being broadly consistent with that proposed in the current consultation, our proposed rules and guidance should refer to:
a. The TCFD Final Report and TCFD Annex in their updated versions, once finalised b. The TCFD’s proposed guidance on metrics, targets and transition plans and the proposed technical supplement on measuring portfolio alignment If not, what other approach would you prefer and why? Q14: Do you agree with our approach to additional metrics and targets? If not, what alternatives would you suggest and why? Q15: Do you agree with our approach to governance, strategy and risk management, including scenario analysis at product or portfolio-level? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q16: What form(s) could quantitative scenario analysis outputs at product or portfolio-level take? What do you consider the cost and feasibility of producing such outputs might be? How useful would such outputs be for users’ decision-making? Q17: Do you agree with our proposed approach that would require certain firms to provide product or portfoliolevel information to clients on request? If not, what approach and what types of clients would you prefer and why?
CP21/17
Annex 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Q18: Do you agree with our proposed approach for life insurers when mirroring an external asset manager’s strategy? If not, what alternative approach would you prefer and why? Q19: Do you agree with our specific proposals for asset owners, including the proposed threshold to exclude the smallest default schemes? If not, what alternatives would you prefer and why? Q20: Do you agree with the analysis in our CBA? If not, we welcome feedback in relation to the one-off and ongoing costs you expect to incur and the potential benefits you envisage. Contextual information about your firm’s size and structure would be helpful.
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Annex 2
Cost benefit analysis
Introduction
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
6. We describe the problem and rationale for intervention in Chapters 1 and 2. As noted,
we consider that firms are not yet making sufficient disclosures to enable clients and consumers to make informed investment decisions. This could give rise to potential harm such as clients engaging firms that do not adequately manage climate-related risks and opportunities and consumers buying unsuitable products. There is also a risk that capital is not allocated efficiently towards less carbon intensive projects and activities.
7. These arise from a number of market failures, including:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Summary of proposals
12. Our detailed proposals are set out in Chapters 3-5.
13. We propose to consult on 2 categories of rules requiring in-scope firms to make
disclosures consistent with the TCFD’s recommendations:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers The status of asset managers’ and asset owners’ climate-related disclosures
18. Asset managers and asset owners have a fiduciary responsibility to protect and
enhance the value of assets for clients and consumers. This includes accounting for all financially-material risks. As set out in Chapter 2, asset managers and asset owners are not currently disclosing sufficient climate-related information to enable clients and consumers to make informed financial decisions and hold their providers to account.
19. According to the latest TCFD Status Report, the 2 least developed areas of disclosure
among asset managers and asset owners are:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Figure 3: Level of TCFD reporting by UK Asset Managers
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
73%
55%
31% 32%
65%
49%
32%
10% 8%
Governance Strategy Risk management Metrics
A) Describe the board’s oversight of climaterelated risks and opportunities B) Describe management’s role in assessing and managing risks and opportunities A) Describe the climate-related risks and opportunities the organisation has identified over short, medium and long term C) Describe the resilience of the organisation’s strategy, taking into consideration different climaterelated scenarios, including a 2C or lower scenario A) Describe the organisation’s processes for identifying and assessing climate-related risks C) Describe how processes for identifying, assessing, and managing climate-related risks are integrated into the organisation’s overall risk management A) Disclose the metrics used by the organisation to assess climaterelated risks and opportunities in line with its strategy and risk management process B) Disclose Scope 1, Scope 2, and if appropriate Scope 3 greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and the related risks C) Describe the targets used by the organisation to manage climate-related risks and opportunities and performance against targets Source: PRI
23. With reference to the PRI’s findings, we have considered the extent to which our
proposals will result in additional incremental costs for firms. We note that some firms that are already partially aligned with the TCFD's recommendations will incur lower costs. We have therefore included a discount factor across the different cost elements to reflect that many firms are already familiar with the TCFD framework, are likely to have relevant internal systems and processes in place, and have already developed capabilities to collate and report on key TCFD-aligned metrics. Assumptions
24. Our CBA is subject to several uncertainties and assumptions:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Calculating compliance costs to asset managers and asset owners
31. Based on our analysis of the current status of disclosures, firms will incur one-off and
ongoing costs.
32. We expect the overall aggregate cost of compliance with our proposed rules, across
the 140 in-scope asset managers, to be around £202.2 million in one-off compliance costs, and £116.3 million in ongoing annual costs. The average one-off and ongoing costs for an individual large firm are £1.7 million and £1.2 million, respectively; and for an individual medium-sized firm, these costs are £1.4 million and £0.7 million, respectively.
33. For the 34 in-scope asset owners, we estimate the overall aggregate costs to be
around £29.2 million for one-off costs, and £9.1 million for ongoing annual costs. The average one-off cost for an individual large firm is estimated to be £1 million, with ongoing annual costs of £400,000; for a medium-sized firm, these costs are estimated to be £800,000 and £200,000, respectively.
34. We consider the following to be the key areas of incremental compliance costs. The
magnitude of costs will differ between asset managers and asset owners:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
37. Following familiarisation with the proposals, we expect firms to conduct a legal
review and an accompanying gap analysis to check their current practices against our expectations. We assume that 4 legal staff at large firms and 2 legal staff at medium firms will review the legal instrument, which is around 20 pages. Using the same source as above, the hourly salary for legal staff, including 30% overheads, is estimated to be £69 at large and medium firms.
38. We therefore estimate the total industry-wide cost for familiarisation and legal review
to be around £520,000 for asset managers and £140,000 for asset owners.
39. The costs presented in this category have been estimated based on the assumption
that a firm knows very little or nothing at all about the TCFD’s reporting framework. However, as mentioned, PRI’s report notes that some asset owners and asset managers are already familiar to some extent with the TCFD’s recommendations. We have therefore applied a discounting factor for each of the relevant costs below. Calculating one-off compliance costs
40. Table 4 summarises the approach we have taken to calculating initial one-off
compliance costs for asset managers and asset owners for the first year. Each category of cost has an associated estimate of the likely aggregate cost to in-scope asset managers and asset owners.
41. As noted above in Figure 3, we recognise that some large in-scope asset managers
and asset owners are already making TCFD-aligned disclosures to some extent. We therefore applied a discount factor, to in-scope large firms only, of:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Table 4: Approach to calculating one-off compliance costs in the first year for asset
managers and asset owners
Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Familiarisation and legal review We assume that it would take all asset managers and asset owners approximately 1.5 hours to read policy documentation in this CP and understand the requirements. The draft instrument and CP are approximately 100 pages. It is further assumed that 20 staff at large firms and 5 staff at medium firms will read the document. The hourly compliance staff salary, including 30% overheads, is estimated to be £60 at large and medium firms. Following familiarisation with the proposals, we expect firms to conduct a legal review and an accompanying gap analysis to check their current practices against our expectations. We assume that 4 legal staff at large firms and 2 legal staff at medium firms will review the legal instrument, which is around 20 pages. The hourly legal staff salary, including 30% overheads, is estimated to be £69 at large and medium firms. Average cost per asset manager:
£4,000
Average cost per asset owner:
£4,000
Total cost to
Asset Managers:
£520,000
Total cost to
Asset owners:
£140,000
Coordination of disclosure inputs across functions (relevant recommended disclosures:
Governance
(a) and (b),
Strategy (a) and
(b), and Risk
Management
(a)-(c))
Based on our information request and discussions with asset managers and asset owners, we have made assumptions about the approach to coordinating inputs from across the organisation to inform recommended disclosures on governance, strategy and risk management.
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Coordination of disclosure inputs across functions (continued)
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Scenario analysis (relevant recommended disclosures:
Strategy (c))
Based on our information request and discussions with asset managers and asset owners we assume that:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Total oneoff cost (incl. familiarisation cost) Average cost per asset manager:
£1,450,000
Average cost per asset owner:
£850,000
Total cost to
Asset managers:
£202,200,000
Total cost to
Asset owners:
£29,200,000
Calculating ongoing costs
43. The below table summarises our methodological approach to calculating ongoing
costs for asset managers and asset owners. Each category of cost has an associated estimate of the likely aggregate cost.
Table 5: Approach to calculating ongoing compliance costs for asset managers and asset
owners
Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Coordination of disclosure inputs across functions Although the asset managers and asset owners we engaged with noted the difficulty of accurately quantifying the exact resource dedicated to climate financial reporting, our approach below is broadly consistent with the approximations provided. Based on our information request and discussions with asset managers and asset owners, we have used the following inputs:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Category of cost Estimation methodology Total Scenario analysis (relevant recommended disclosures:
Strategy (c))
Based on our information request and discussions with asset managers and asset owners we have used the following inputs when assessing ongoing costs related to scenario analysis:
CP21/17
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Benefits
44. This section covers the potential benefits that arise from the wider impact of our
proposals. This is a summary of the outcomes and benefits discussed in Chapters 1 and 2 of the CP.
CP21/17
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Annex 3
Compatibility statement
Compliance with legal requirements
CP21/17
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers The FCA’s objectives and regulatory principles: Compatibility statement
7. The proposals set out in this consultation are primarily intended to advance the FCA’s
operational objective of promoting competition in the interests of consumers. They are also relevant to the FCA’s consumer protection and market integrity objectives.
8. Our proposals aim to increase transparency and enable clients and consumers to make
better informed decisions. With access to the climate-related information disclosed in accordance with our proposed rules and guidance, clients and consumers will be better enabled to take climate-related information into account when selecting providers and products, and to hold their providers to account. This should support a more competitive market. Consumers will be better able to interrogate firms’ offerings and better protect themselves against unsuitable products. In addition, better information on firms’ climate-related investment policies and outcomes should improve asset pricing and capital allocation decisions. This, in turn, should contribute to the overall efficiency and stability of financial markets, and thus advance our market integrity objective.
9. We consider these proposals to be compatible with the FCA’s strategic objective
of ensuring that the relevant markets function well. For the purposes of the FCA’s strategic objective, ‘relevant markets’ are defined by s. 1F FSMA.
10. We have also had regard to the Government’s commitment to achieve a net-zero
economy by 2050. Our proposals aim to increase transparency and competition, thus encouraging capital flows towards firms that better manage climate risks and opportunities and, in turn, resource allocation towards transitioning the economy to net zero. In addition, by introducing requirements on a mandatory basis from 1 January 2022 for the largest firms and 1 January 2023 for smaller firms, we have taken account of the urgency and scale of the changes needed to support the transition to a lowcarbon economy.
11. In preparing the proposals set out in this consultation, the FCA has had regard to the
regulatory principles set out in s. 3B FSMA.
The need to use our resources in the most efficient and economic way
12. Referencing the TCFD framework in our proposals allows us to introduce new
measures in a complex and novel area of policy in the most efficient manner. The principle that a burden or restriction should be proportionate to the benefits
13. The cost benefit analysis in Annex 2 sets out the costs and benefits for the proposals
in this CP. We consider that the benefits of these proposals outweigh the costs. The desirability of sustainable growth in the economy of the United Kingdom in the medium or long term
14. Better disclosures across the investment chain will facilitate better allocation of capital
throughout the economy, facilitating a smoother transition to a net-zero economy.
CP21/17
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers The general principle that consumers should take responsibility for their decisions
15. With better climate-related information, consumers will be better able to assess how
well firms integrate climate risks and opportunities into their investment strategies and validate the climate-related characteristics of their products. This will enable them to make better-informed decisions when selecting their providers and products. The responsibilities of senior management
16. We believe our proposals will enhance the ability of senior management of in-scope
firms to take responsibility for their decisions by providing a framework that will encourage them to think about the governance, risk management and strategy of their investments in a systematic and considered way. The desirability of recognising differences in the nature of, and objectives of, businesses carried on by different persons including mutual societies and other kinds of business organisation
17. To achieve the outcomes set out in Chapter 1, we require a whole-of-market solution.
However, we have sought to be proportionate by proposing a threshold of £5 billion of AuM that would exclude the smallest firms from the scope of our proposals, while still capturing a large percentage (98%) of the AuM in both the UK asset management market and held by UK asset owners. In addition, we propose a phased implementation, recognising that smaller firms within the scope of our proposals may need longer to build capabilities. The desirability of publishing information relating to persons subject to requirements imposed under FSMA, or requiring them to publish information
18. Our proposals would require firms to make disclosures largely in the public domain,
or in some cases provide disclosures to clients upon request. We do not propose that the information be reported to the FCA. As such, this principle is not relevant to the proposals in this CP. The principle that we should exercise of our functions as transparently as possible
19. In developing our proposals, we have acted as transparently as possible. We published
a Discussion Paper on Climate Change and Green Finance in October 2018 (DP18/8) in which we sought views on climate-related disclosures by regulated firms, including asset managers and asset owners. The Feedback Statement (FS19/6) was published in 2019. We committed to consulting on TCFD-aligned disclosure rules for asset managers, life insurers and FCA-regulated pension providers in the Government’s TCFD Roadmap, published in November 2020. This commitment was reaffirmed in our Policy Statement on proposals to enhance climate-related disclosures by listed issuers and clarification of existing disclosure obligations (PS20/17).
20. We gathered evidence from asset managers, life insurers and FCA-regulated pension
providers on the costs of our proposed rules prior to publication. We also engaged closely with external stakeholders as we developed our proposals and will continue to engage as we seek to finalise our rules.
CP21/17
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
21. In formulating these proposals, the FCA has had regard to the importance of taking
action intended to minimise the extent to which it is possible for a business carried on (i) by an authorised person or a recognised investment exchange; or (ii) in contravention of the general prohibition, to be used for a purpose connected with financial crime (as required by s. 1B(5)(b) FSMA). Expected effect on mutual societies
22. The FCA does not expect the proposals in this paper to have a significantly different
impact on mutual societies.
Compatibility with the duty to promote effective competition in the interests of consumers [delete if dealt with separately]
23. In preparing the proposals discussed in this consultation paper, we have had regard
to the FCA’s duty to promote effective competition in the interests of consumers. With access to better information on climate-related risks and opportunities, both clients and consumers will be better enabled to take these factors into account when selecting providers and investment products, and to distinguish between providers. They will also be better enabled to hold their providers to account. This should support greater competition. Equality and diversity
24. We are required under the Equality Act 2010 in exercising our functions to ‘have
due regard’ to the need to eliminate discrimination, harassment, victimisation and any other conduct prohibited by or under the Act, advance equality of opportunity between persons who share a relevant protected characteristic and those who do not, to and foster good relations between people who share a protected characteristic and those who do not.
25. As part of this, we ensure the equality and diversity implications of any new policy
proposals are considered.
26. We are confident that our proposals do not have equality and diversity implications, but
we welcome your comments if you have any concerns.
Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 (LRRA)
27. We have had regard to the principles in the LRRA for the parts of the proposals that
consist of general policies, principles or guidance. We consider that our proposals are consistent with LRRA principles – that regulatory activities should be carried out in a way which is transparent, accountable, proportionate, consistent and targeted only at cases in which action is needed.
CP21/17
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
28. For example, we have followed a consistent regulatory approach in developing our
proposals. We have clearly set out our proposed rules in a transparent way. Our proposals are proportionate in referencing the TCFD’s globally adopted framework, by allowing smaller firms an additional year to prepare and excluding the very smallest firms from the scope of our proposals.
29. We have had regard to the Regulators’ Code for the parts of the proposals that consist
of general policies, principles or guidance, particularly the requirement for regulatory activity to be proportionate and targeted.
CP21/17
Annex 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Annex 4
Abbreviations used in this paper
Abbreviation Description
AFM Authorised fund manager
AIF Alternative Investment Fund
AIFM Alternative Investment Fund Manager
AuM Assets Under Management
BEIS Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy CBA Cost Benefit Analysis COP26 UN Climate Change Conference of the Parties CP Consultation Paper DB Defined Benefit DC Defined Contribution DWP Department for Work and Pensions ESG Environmental, Social and Governance FTE Full-time Employee GHG Greenhouse gas IFRS International Financial Reporting Standards IOSCO International Organization of Securities Commissions ISSB International Sustainability Standards Board KPI Key Performance Indicators NGFS Network for Greening the Financial System PCAF Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials PRI Principles for Responsible Investment
CP21/17
Annex 4
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Abbreviation Description PRA Prudential Regulation Authority RTS Regulatory Technical Standards SFDR Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation SIPP Self-invested personal pension SM&CR Senior Manager & Certification Regime TCFD Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures TPR Temporary Permissions Regime UCITS Undertakings for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities WACI Weighted average carbon intensity We make all responses to formal consultation available for public inspection unless the respondent requests otherwise. We will not regard a standard confidentiality statement in an email message as a request for non-disclosure. Despite this, we may be asked to disclose a confidential response under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. We may consult you if we receive such a request. Any decision we make not to disclose the response is reviewable by the Information Commissioner and the Information Rights Tribunal. All our publications are available to download from www.fca.org.uk. If you would like to receive this paper in an alternative format, please call 020 7066 7948 or email: publications_graphics@fca.org.uk or write to: Editorial and Digital team, Financial Conduct Authority, 12 Endeavour Square, London E20 1JN Sign up for our news and publications alerts
CP21/17
Appendix 1
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Appendix 1
Draft Handbook text
FCA 2021/XX
DISCLOSURE OF CLIMATE-RELATED FINANCIAL INFORMATION (ASSET MANAGER AND ASSET OWNER) INSTRUMENT 2021 Powers exercised A. The Financial Conduct Authority (“the FCA”) makes this instrument in the exercise of the following powers and related provisions in or under:
(1) the following sections of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (“the Act”):
(a) section 137A (The FCA’s general rules);
(b) section 137T (General supplementary powers); (c) section 139A (Power of the FCA to give guidance); (d) section 247 (Trust scheme rules); (e) section 248 (Scheme particulars rules); (f) section 261I (Contractual scheme rules); (g) section 261J (Contractual scheme particulars rules); and (2) regulation 6(1) of the Open-Ended Investment Companies Regulations 2001 (SI 2001/1228); and (3) the other rule and guidance making powers listed in Schedule 4 (Powers exercised) to the General Provisions of the FCA’s Handbook. B. The rule-making provisions listed above are specified for the purposes of section 138G(2) (Rule-making instruments) of the Act. Commencement
C. This instrument comes into force on [date].
Amendments to the Handbook
D. The modules of the FCA’s Handbook of rules and guidance listed in column (1) below are amended in accordance with the Annexes to this instrument listed in column (2) below. (1) (2) Glossary of definitions Annex A Environmental, Social and Governance Sourcebook (ESG) Annex B Collective Investment Schemes Sourcebook (COLL) Annex C Making the Environmental, Social and Governance sourcebook E. The Financial Conduct Authority makes the rules and gives the guidance in accordance with Annex B to this instrument.
FCA 2021/XX
F. The Environmental, Social and Governance sourcebook (ESG) is added to the Business Standards block within the Handbook, immediately after the Product Intervention and Product Governance sourcebook (PROD). Citation G. This instrument may be cited as the Disclosure of Climate-Related Financial Information (Asset Manager and Asset Owner) Instrument 2021. By order of the Board [date]
FCA 2021/XX
Annex A
Amendments to the Glossary of definitions
In this Annex, underlining indicates new text, unless otherwise stated. Insert the following new definitions in the appropriate alphabetical position. The text is not underlined. climate-related reports any report produced under ESG 2. on-demand information an on-demand TCFD product report or underlying asset data. on-demand TCFD product report a report produced in accordance with ESG 2.3 for a client who is entitled to such information under ESG 2.3.5R in respect of:
(1) the investments, including rights to or interests in investments, in respect of which the firm provides portfolio management to that client; or (2) assets under management in an unauthorised AIF in which the client is an investor, but only in respect of an unauthorised AIF which is not listed on a recognised investment exchange. pre-set investment portfolio a combination of investments which is selected by a firm and offered to its clients as a single investment option, for example a default arrangement in a qualifying scheme, a drawdown pension investment pathway, or a ready-made investment portfolio, but not including a default arrangement in a qualifying scheme comprising:
(a) assets which make up less than 10% of the total assets held by a firm within default arrangements in qualifying schemes; or (b) assets which are under £100m in value. public TCFD product reports a report produced in accordance with ESG 2.3 in respect of any of the following, insofar as it is a TCFD product:
(1) an authorised fund;
(2) a with-profits fund;
(3) a linked fund;
(4) a pre-set investment portfolio;
(5) a closed-ended investment fund; or
FCA 2021/XX
(6) an unauthorised AIF that is listed on a recognised investment exchange. TCFD entity report a public report regarding the overall assets managed or administered by the firm in relation to its TCFD in-scope business as per the requirements in ESG 2.2. TCFD in-scope business the following activities, as set out in more detail in ESG 1.2.1R:
(1) portfolio management;
(2) managing a UK UCITS;
(3) managing an AIF;
(4) providing insurance-based investment products; (5) operating a personal pension scheme (excluding a SIPP) or stakeholder pension scheme; and (6) operating a SIPP, but only in relation to SIPPs which contain an insurance-based investment product, a unit, an interest in a closed-ended investment fund or a pre-set investment portfolio provided by the firm. TCFD product any of the following:
(1) an authorised fund, but:
(a) excluding an authorised fund which is a feeder UCITS or a feeder AIF; and (b) where the authorised fund is an umbrella scheme, each sub-fund of the umbrella is considered to be a TCFD product; (2) in relation to an insurance-based investment product, personal pension scheme, stakeholder pension scheme or SIPP provided or operated by an insurer or pure reinsurer:
(a) with-profits fund;
(b) linked fund; or
(c) a pre-set investment portfolio;
(3) in relation to a personal pension scheme, stakeholder pension scheme or SIPP operated by a firm which is not an insurer or pure reinsurer:
(a) an authorised fund;
FCA 2021/XX
(b) a closed-ended investment fund; or
(c) a pre-set investment portfolio;
(4) an agreement or arrangement under which a firm provides the client with portfolio management; and (5) an unauthorised AIF. TCFD product report a public TCFD product report or an on-demand TCFD product report. underlying asset data basic data on asset holdings underlying a TCFD product, including unique security ID such as ISIN, name, holding size, and current price or valuation, as reasonably required by the relevant client to produce their own amalgamated scenario analysis and otherwise satisfy their own disclosure obligations in relation to climate-related financial information. Amend the following definitions as shown. closed-ended investment fund (in LR and ESG) an entity:
(a) which is an undertaking with limited liability, including a company, limited partnership, or limited liability partnership; and (b) whose primary object is investing and managing its assets (including pooled funds contributed by holders of its listed securities):
(i) in property of any description; and
(ii) with a view to spreading investment risk. portfolio management (1) managing portfolios in accordance with mandates given by clients on a discretionary client-by-client basis where such portfolios include one or more financial instruments. [Note: article 4(1)(8) of MiFID] (2) (in ESG) a service provided to a client including:
(a) managing investments; or
(b) private equity or other private market activities consisting of either advising on investments or managing investments on an ongoing basis in connection with an arrangement the predominant purpose of which is investment in unlisted securities.
FCA 2021/XX
Annex B
Environmental, Social and Governance sourcebook (ESG) In this Annex, all of the text is new and is not underlined
1.1 Purpose and application
Purpose
1.1.1 G [The ESG Sourcebook sets out rules and guidance concerning a firm’s
approach to environmental, social and governance matters.]1
1.1.2 G ESG 2 contains rules and guidance regarding the disclosure of climaterelated financial information consistent with TCFD Recommendations and
Recommended Disclosures.
1.1.3 G The disclosure requirements within ESG 2 relate to either the assets that a
firm manages or administers generally, published in a TCFD entity report, or assets relating or corresponding to particular financial products or services, disclosed via TCFD product reports.
1.1.4 G The disclosures are intended to help meet the information needs of market
participants, including a firm’s institutional clients (e.g. pension trustees, employers, corporate investors) and consumers of their products (e.g. pension scheme members, retail investors), in relation to the climate-related impact and risks of a firm’s TCFD in-scope business.
1.2 General application
1.2.1 R (1) The rules in this sourcebook apply to a firm of a type listed in
column 1 of the table in relation to the TCFD in-scope business carried out from an establishment maintained by it in the United Kingdom as described in column 2:
(2) This table belongs to ESG 1.2.1R(1).
Column 1: Type of firm Column 2: TCFD in-scope business
Part A: Asset managers
Any firm Portfolio management
1 ESG 1.1.1 remains in brackets as we are consulting on the creation of this Sourcebook and presently the Sourcebook will only contain climate related financial disclosure rules and guidance, rather than broader environmental, social and governance matters. It is anticipated that the sourcebook may be expanded in the future.
FCA 2021/XX
UK UCITS management company
Managing a UK UCITS
ICVC that is a UCITS scheme without a separate management company Managing a UK UCITS Full-scope UK AIFM Managing an AIF Small authorised UK AIFM Managing an AIF
Part B: Asset owners
Insurer or pure reinsurer Providing insurance-based investment products. Operating a personal pension scheme (excluding a SIPP) or stakeholder pension scheme. Operating a SIPP, but only in relation to SIPPs containing insurance-based investment products provided by the firm. Other asset owners (other than insurers or pure reinsurers) Operating a personal pension scheme (excluding a SIPP) or stakeholder pension scheme. Operating a SIPP, but only in relation to SIPPs containing any of the following provided by the firm:
(a) a unit;
(b) an interest in a closedended investment fund; (c) a pre-set investment portfolio.
1.2.2 R A firm is exempt from the disclosure requirements under ESG 2 if and for
as long as the assets under administration or management in relation to its TCFD in-scope business amount to less than £5bn calculated as a 3-year rolling average, on an annual assessment. 2 Disclosure of climate related financial information
2.1 Preparation of climate-related reports
FCA 2021/XX
2.1.1 R (1) A firm must prepare and publish its TCFD entity report and any
public TCFD product reports by 30 June of each calendar year.
(2) If a firm receives a request for on-demand information from a client who is entitled to make such request under ESG 2.3.5R, it must prepare and provide the on-demand information to the client within a reasonable period of time and in a format that is reasonably acceptable to the client.
2.1.2 R (1) A firm must cover a reporting period of 12 months starting no earlier
than 1 January of the previous calendar year, in preparing its TCFD entity report. (2) The reporting period in (1) may be changed by the firm in subsequent yearly reports, but the firm must ensure there is no period of time after 1 January 2022 which is not covered by its TCFD entity reports, issuing an interim report if necessary. (3) A firm must adopt a calculation date within the 12-month reporting period covered by the TCFD entity report, in calculating any metrics and targets either for inclusion in its TCFD entity report or its public TCFD product report. Publication of climate-related reports
2.1.3 R A firm must take all reasonable steps to publish its TCFD entity report and
its public TCFD product reports in a way that makes it easy for prospective readers to locate and access, including, as a minimum, by making the most recent of these reports available in a prominent place on the main website for the business of the firm.
2.1.4 G Prominence may be achieved by adding hyperlinks to the reports which are
accessible via the landing page of the main website for the business of the firm. Consistency with TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures when preparing climate-related reports
2.1.5 R A firm must ensure the climate-related financial disclosures in its climaterelated reports are consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and
Recommended Disclosures, unless otherwise specified by rules in this
Chapter.
2.1.6 R In complying with ESG 2.1.5R, a firm must take reasonable steps to ensure
its climate-related financial disclosures also reflect the following materials, to the extent they are relevant to the firm’s climate-related reports:
(1) section C of the TCFD Annex, entitled “Guidance for All Sectors”; and, as applicable, (2) part 3, section D of the TCFD Annex, entitled “Asset Owners”; or
FCA 2021/XX
(3) part 4, section D of the TCFD Annex, entitled “Asset Managers”.
2.1.7 G The FCA considers that the following supplemental documents are also
relevant in assessing whether climate-related financial disclosures are consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures:
(1) the TCFD Final Report and the TCFD Annex to the extent not already referred to in this Chapter; (2) the TCFD Technical Supplement; (3) the TCFD Guidance on Risk Management Integration and Disclosure; (4) [the TCFD Technical Supplement on Measuring Portfolio Alignment; and (5) the TCFD Guidance on Metrics, Targets, and Transition Plans.] Data considerations when preparing climate-related reports
2.1.8 R In satisfying its reporting and disclosure obligations under this Chapter, a
firm must, insofar as is reasonably practicable, use the most up to date information available.
2.1.9 R In preparing a TCFD product report or underlying asset data, a firm must
select, from within the 12-month reporting period, the most recent calculation date for which up to date information is available, unless, in relation to on-demand information, the client requests a specific calculation date.
2.1.10 R In addition, a firm must ensure its climate-related report includes an
adequate explanation of:
(1) any gaps in the underlying data relied upon to make climate-related financial disclosures consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures; and (2) how the firm has addressed these gaps, for example, by using proxy data or assumptions, and briefly setting out any methodologies used in doing so, providing relevant contextual information, and explaining any limitations of the approach. Cross-referencing climate-related financial disclosures
2.1.11 R (1) A firm may include hyperlinks and cross-references to relevant
climate-related financial disclosures contained in a third party’s climate reporting, where such information enables the firm to make climate-related financial disclosures consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures.
FCA 2021/XX
(2) The firm must set out the rationale for relying on these third party disclosures, and any deviations between the third party’s approach and that of the firm where relevant to the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures. (3) An insurer or pure reinsurer which operates linked funds which mirror funds operated by a third party (but which are not closematched by an insurer’s or pure reinsurer’s direct investment in that third party’s fund) must consider the extent to which it is appropriate to rely wholly or partly on disclosures by that third party.
2.1.12 R Where relevant, a firm may also draw links and make reference to its TCFD
product report from its TCFD entity report and vice versa.
2.2 TCFD entity report
Content of a TCFD entity report
2.2.1 R (1) Subject to ESG 2.2.4R and ESG 2.2.5R, a firm must include in its
TCFD entity report climate-related financial disclosures regarding the overall assets managed or administered by the firm in relation to its TCFD in-scope business as defined under ESG 1.2.1R. (2) A firm must explain, either in its TCFD entity report or in a crossreferenced TCFD product report, where its approach to a particular investment strategy, asset class, or product is materially different to its overall entity level approach to governance, strategy or risk management under the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures. (3) A firm must briefly explain in its TCFD entity report how the firm’s strategy under the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures has influenced the decision-making and process by which it delegates functions, selects delegates, and relies on services, strategies or products offered or employed by third parties, including delegates. Approach to climate-related scenario analysis
2.2.2 R (1) When preparing information for a TCFD entity report in a manner
consistent with recommended disclosure (c) under the strategy recommendation in the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures, a firm must explain:
(a) its approach to climate-related scenario analysis; and (b) how the firm applies climate-related scenario analysis in its investment and risk decision making process.
FCA 2021/XX
(2) Where reasonably practicable, a firm must provide quantitative examples to demonstrate its approach to climate-related scenario analysis. Approach to targets and key performance indicators (KPIs)
2.2.3 R (1) In producing its TCFD entity report and considering recommended
disclosure (c) under the metrics and targets recommendation in the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures, a firm must describe any targets it has set to manage climate-related risks and opportunities, including the KPIs it uses to measure progress against these targets, in a manner consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures. (2) Where a firm has not yet set such targets, it must explain why in its TCFD entity report. Approach to relevant climate-related financial disclosures contained in other reports at an entity-level
2.2.4 R (1) If a firm is a member of a group, it may rely on climate-related
financial disclosures consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures made by its group or a member of its group when producing its TCFD entity report, but only to the extent that those group disclosures are relevant to the firm and cover the assets the firm administers or manages as part of its TCFD inscope business. (2) If a firm does rely on such group disclosures, it must ensure that its TCFD entity report:
(a) includes cross references, including hyperlinks, to any climate-related financial disclosure contained within the group or group member’s report that relate to assets managed or administered by the firm in relation to its TCFD in-scope business on which the firm is relying to meet its disclosure obligations under this section; and (b) sets out the rationale for relying on the disclosure made by its group or a member of its group and why the disclosure is relevant to the assets managed or administered by the firm in relation to its TCFD in-scope business. (3) The firm must also ensure that any material deviations between its approach under the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures and the climate-related financial disclosures contained within the group report are clearly explained, either in its TCFD entity report or in the report made by its group or a member of its group.
FCA 2021/XX
2.2.5 R (1) If a firm or a member of its group produces a document, other than
its annual financial report, which includes climate-related financial disclosures consistent with the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures in compliance with LR 9.8.6R(8) for its TCFD in-scope business, the firm may cross refer to these disclosures in its TCFD entity report where this information is relevant to clients, including hyperlinks to where the relevant disclosures are available. (2) Where a firm so refers, it must explain in its TCFD entity report the rationale for relying on the disclosures in the supplementary document and how such disclosures are relevant to the clients of the firm’s TCFD in-scope business. Compliance statement
2.2.6 R A firm’s TCFD entity report must include a statement, signed by a member
of senior management of the firm, confirming that the disclosures in the report, including any third party or group disclosures cross-referenced in it, comply with the requirements under this Chapter.
2.3 Product-level reporting
Public TCFD product reports
2.3.1 R In addition to the publishing obligation in ESG 2.1.3R, a firm, unless it is a
firm that manages an unauthorised AIF listed on a recognised investment exchange, must include its public TCFD product report, or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, in any one of the following client communications which follow most closely after the annual reporting deadline of 30 June, as applicable:
(1) the annual report or half-yearly report of an authorised fund as required under COLL 4.5.3R or COLL 8.3.5R [or COLL 15.5.2R], provided that its public TCFD product report, or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, is always included the annual report; (2) a periodic client report under COBS 16.3.1R, COBS 16.4.1R, COBS 16A.4.2AR or COBS 16A.5.1R; (3) a report to with-profits policyholders under COBS 20.4.7R; or (4) an annual pension benefit statement or an annual drawdown pension statement under COBS 16.6.8R.
2.3.2 R A firm that manages an unauthorised AIF listed on a recognised investment
exchange must include its public TCFD product report, or an adequately
FCA 2021/XX contextualised and prominent cross reference and hyperlink to this report, in its TCFD entity report.
2.3.3 R A firm is not required to prepare a public TCFD product report in respect of
a product which is a wrapper, provided that it has issued public TCFD product reports for the TCFD products available within the relevant wrapper.
2.3.4 R A firm is not required to prepare a TCFD product report in respect of an
authorised fund, or where the authorised fund is an umbrella scheme the relevant sub-fund, which is in the process of winding up or termination. On-demand TCFD product reports and underlying data
2.3.5 R (1) A client who requires on-demand information in order to satisfy
climate-related financial disclosure obligations, whether under this
Chapter or as a result of other legal or regulatory requirements, is
entitled to request such information from and be provided with it by the firm. (2) The request by a client in (1) may specify a calculation date no earlier than 1 July 2023, or, if later, the start date of the client’s arrangements with the firm concerning the TCFD product;
2.3.6 R The client entitlement in ESG 2.3.5R(1) is limited to one request for an ondemand TCFD product report or underlying asset data or both in respect of
each TCFD product in every 12-month rolling period.
2.3.7 G A firm is encouraged to consider, where practicable, making available to a
client disclosures broadly equivalent to an on-demand TCFD product report irrespective of the client’s eligibility to request such report under ESG 2.3.5R.
2.3.8 R If a client in ESG 2.3.5R(1) requests additional climate- or carbon-related
data which is reasonably required in order to satisfy climate-related financial disclosure obligations, a firm must provide the data if doing so is reasonably practicable and permitted under any contractual arrangements governing the firm’s use of the data. Content of TCFD product reports
2.3.9 R (1) A firm must include in its TCFD product report for each TCFD
product information according to the following metrics, using the calculations contained in ESG 2 Annex 1 [and having regard to the TCFD Guidance on Metrics, Targets, and Transition Plans, as relevant]:
(a) scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions;
(b) scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions;
FCA 2021/XX
(c) total carbon emissions;
(d) total carbon footprint; and
(e) weighted average carbon intensity.
(2) A firm’s TCFD product report must also include:
(a) relevant contextual information such as explaining how the metrics should be interpreted and their associated limitations, for example if particular assumptions or proxies have been used; (b) historical annual calculations of the metrics in (1), after the first year of preparing a TCFD product report; and (c) any disclosures under the Governance, Strategy and Risk Management recommendations under the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended Disclosures, where the firm’s approach in relation to a TCFD product materially deviates from the firm’s overarching approach disclosed in the firm’s TCFD entity report.
2.3.10 R If a firm discloses material deviations under ESG 2.3.9R(2)(c), it may refer
to the relevant sections of its TCFD entity report, and similarly its TCFD entity report may refer to these disclosures in the TCFD product report.
2.3.11 R (1) Where a TCFD product report relates to a TCFD product that has
concentrated exposures or high exposures to carbon intensive sectors, the firm must describe these and disclose:
(a) a qualitative summary of how climate change is likely to impact the assets underlying the relevant TCFD product under an ‘orderly transition’, ‘disorderly transition’ and ‘hothouse world’ scenarios; (b) a discussion of the most significant drivers of impact on that TCFD product; and (c) a quantitative analysis of an ‘orderly transition’, ‘disorderly transition’ and ‘hothouse world’ scenario. (2) Where a firm manages TCFD products that do not have concentrated exposures or high exposures to carbon intensive sectors, a firm must still make the disclosures under (1)(a) and 1(b). (3) For the purposes of (1)(a) and 1(c):
(a) ‘orderly transition’ scenarios assume climate policies are introduced early and become gradually more stringent, reaching global net zero CO2 emissions around 2050 and
FCA 2021/XX likely limiting global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius on pre-industrial averages; (b) ‘disorderly transition’ scenarios assume climate policies are delayed or divergent, requiring sharper emissions reductions achieved at a higher cost and with increased physical risks in order to limit temperature rise to below 2 degrees Celsius on pre-industrial averages; and (c) ‘hothouse world’ scenarios assume only currently implemented policies are preserved, current commitments are not met and emissions continue to rise, with high physical risks and severe social and economic disruption and failure to limit temperature rise.
2.3.12 R (1) Where a firm prepares a public TCFD product report in relation to a
default arrangement in a qualifying scheme which uses life-styling or differing target retirement dates for different cohorts of members, a firm may calculate the information in ESG 2.3.9R to ESG 2.3.11R and, where relevant, ESG 2.3.13R, in relation to the most representative member profile in that default arrangement. (2) However, where relevant, the firm must include a qualitative explanation in its public TCFD product report of how this information might vary between cohorts. Other elements of a TCFD product report
2.3.13 R When preparing a TCFD product report, a firm must, on a best efforts basis,
also include the following calculations for each TCFD product:
(1) climate Value-at-Risk;
(2) metrics that show the climate warming scenario with which a TCFD product is aligned, such as using an Implied Temperature Rise metric; and (3) any other metrics that the firm considers an investor will find useful when deciding whether to select a particular TCFD product.
FCA 2021/XX
ESG 2 Annex 1 TCFD Product Report Metrics
TCFD (see page 43 of the TCFD Final Report) SFDR (please see annex I of the draft RTS) Weighted average carbon intensity (WACI) Total carbon emissions Carbon footprint Scope 1, 2 and 3 GHG emissions, disclosed separately Scope 1 refers to all direct GHG emissions. Scope 2 refers to indirect GHG emissions from consumption of purchased electricity, heat, or steam. Scope 3 refers to other indirect emissions not covered in Scope 2 that occur in the value chain of the reporting company, including both upstream and downstream emissions. Scope 3 emissions could include: the extraction and production of purchased materials and fuels, transport-related activities in vehicles not owned or controlled by the reporting entity, electricity-related activities (eg, transmission and distribution losses), outsourced activities, and waste disposal (see page 63 of the TCFD Final Report). The scope 1, 2 and 3 definitions are contained in the low carbon benchmark regulation:
(i) Scope 1 carbon emissions, namely emissions generated from sources that are controlled by the company that issues the underlying assets; and (ii) Scope 2 carbon emissions, namely emissions from the consumption of purchased electricity, steam, or other sources of energy generated upstream from the company that issues the underlying assets. (iii) Scope 3 carbon emissions, namely all indirect emissions that are not covered by points (i) and (ii) that occur in the value chain of the reporting company, including both upstream and downstream emissions, in particular for sectors with a high impact on climate change and its mitigation.
FCA 2021/XX
TP 1 Transitional provisions
(1) (2)
Material to which the transitional provision applies (3) (4) Transitional provision (5) Transitional provision: dates in force (6) Handbook provision:
coming into force
1.1 ESG 2 as it applies
to firms falling within Part A (asset managers) of the
table in ESG
1.2.1R(2)
R ESG 2 is disapplied where a firm does not meet the requirements of an enhanced scope SMCR firm pursuant to SYSC 23 Annex 1 8.2R paragraph 1. From 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2022 Effective date of instrument
1.2 ESG 2 as it applies
to firms falling within Part B (asset owners) of the table in ESG 1.2.1R(2) R ESG 2 is disapplied where a firm has assets under management or administration in relation to TCFD inscope business of less than £25bn calculated as a 3-year rolling average on an annual assessment. From 1 January 2022 to 31 December 2022 Effective date of instrument
1.3 ESG 2.1.1R(1) R (1) For a firm to
whom the disapplication in ESG TP 1.1 or ESG TP 1.2 is available, the first publication deadline for a TCFD entity report and a public TCFD product report is 30 June 2024. From 1 January Effective date of instrument (2) For other firms, the first publication
FCA 2021/XX deadline for these reports is
30 June 2023.
1.4 ESG 2.1.2R(2) R For a firm to whom
the disapplication in
ESG TP 1.1 or ESG
1.2 is available, the
reporting period that must be covered by one or more TCFD entity reports is to commence from 1 January 2023. From 1 January Effective date of instrument
1.5 ESG 2.3.5R(1) and
ESG 2.3.5R(2)
R For a firm to whom the disapplication in
ESG TP 1.1 or ESG
TP 1.2 is available:
From 1 January
Effective date of instrument
(a) the specified calculation date of on-demand information must be no earlier than 1 July 2024; and (b) the earliest a client can request ondemand information is 1 July 2024.
1.6 ESG 2.3.9R(1)(b) R The first reporting
deadline for scope 3 greenhouse gas emissions is 30 June 2024.
From 1 January
Effective date of instrument
FCA 2021/XX
Annex C2
Amendments to the Collective Investment Schemes sourcebook (COLL) In this Annex, underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text. 4 Investor Relations …
4.5 Reports and accounts
…
Contents of the annual long report
4.5.7 R (1) An annual long report on an authorised fund, other than a scheme
which is an umbrella, must contain
(a) …
…
(d) the report of the depositary in accordance with COLL 4.5.11R (Report of the depositary); and (e) the report of the auditor in accordance with COLL 4.5.12R (Report of the auditor).; and (f) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross- reference and hyperlink to where this report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R. (2) An annual long report on a scheme which is an umbrella must be prepared for the umbrella as a whole and must contain:
(a) for each sub-fund:
(i) …
(ii) the report of the authorised fund manager in accordance with COLL 4.5.9R; and (iii) comparative information in accordance with COLL 4.5.10R; and 2 Further consequential changes may be required to COLL 15.5 if the proposed rules in guidance in the LongTerm Asset Fund Instrument 2021, as part of “A new authorised fund regime for investing in long term assets” Consultation https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp21-12.pdf are made.
FCA 2021/XX
(iv) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R; … … … Contents of the half-yearly long report
4.5.8 R (1) A half-yearly long report on an authorised fund, other than for a
scheme which is an umbrella, must contain:
(a) the accounts for the half-yearly accounting period which must be prepared in accordance with the requirements of the IMA SORP; and (b) the report of the authorised fund manager in accordance with COLL 4.5.9R (Authorised fund manager’s report).; and (c) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R, where the half-yearly long report most closely follows the reporting deadline of 30 June, under ESG 2.1.1R(1). (2) A half-yearly long report on a scheme which is an umbrella, must be prepared for the umbrella as a whole and must contain:
(a) for each sub-fund:
(i) the accounts for the half-yearly accounting period which must be prepared in accordance with the requirements of the IMA SORP; and (ii) the report of the authorised fund manager in accordance with COLL 4.5.9R; and (iii) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R, where the half-yearly long report most closely follows the reporting deadline of 30 June, under ESG 2.1.1R(1). …
FCA 2021/XX
…
…
8 Qualified investor schemes
…
8.3 Investor relations
…
Contents of the annual report
8.3.5A (R) (1) An annual report, other than for a scheme which is an umbrella, must contain:
(a) …
…
(c) the report of the depositary in accordance with COLL 8.3.5DR (Report of the depositary); and (d) the report of the auditor in accordance with COLL 4.5.12R (Report of the auditor).; and (e) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R. (2) An annual report on a scheme which is an umbrella must be prepared for the umbrella as a whole and must contain:
(a) for each sub-fund:
(i) …
(ii) the report of the authorised fund manager in accordance with COLL 8.3.5CR; and (iii) comparative information in accordance with COLL 4.5.10R (1A) and (2A); and (iv) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where this report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R; …
FCA 2021/XX
…
…
Contents of the half-yearly report
8.3.5B R (1) A half-yearly report on an authorised fund or sub-fund must contain:
(a) the accounts for the half-yearly accounting period which must be prepared in accordance with the requirements of the IMA SORP; and (b) the report of the authorised fund manager in accordance with COLL 8.3.5CR.; and (c) its public TCFD product report or an adequately contextualised and prominent cross-reference and hyperlink to where the report may be found in the firm’s website, in accordance with ESG 2.3.1R, where the half-yearly report most closely follows the reporting deadline of 30 June, under ESG 2.1.1R(1). …
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Appendix 2
TCFD recommendations, recommended disclosures and supplemental guidance This Appendix sets out the TCFD’s recommendations, recommended disclosures and associated guidance (including supplemental guidance for asset managers and asset owners, as appropriate) in Figures A to E. The TCFD also provides general guidance on the approach to disclosures by way of a set of Fundamental Principles for Effective Disclosure (Figure 6, page 18 of the Final Report). These include that disclosures should contain relevant information; be specific and complete; be clear, balanced and understandable; be consistent over time; be comparable among organisations with a sector, industry or portfolio; be reliable, verifiable and objective; and be provided on a timely basis.
Figure A – the TCFD Recommendations and Recommended
Disclosures
Source: Final Report, Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, June 2017
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Figure B – Governance: Guidance for all sectors
Source: Final TCFD Annex, Implementing the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, June 2017
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Figure C – Strategy: Guidance for all sectors and supplemental
guidance for asset owners and asset managers
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners should describe how climate-related risks and opportunities are factored into relevant investment strategies. This could be described from the perspective of the total fund or investment strategy or individual investment strategies for various asset classes. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Managers Asset managers should describe how climate-related risks and opportunities are factored into relevant products or investment strategies. Asset managers should also describe how each product or investment strategy might be affected by the transition to a lower-carbon economy. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners that perform scenario analysis should consider providing a discussion of how climate-related scenarios are used, such as to inform investments in specific assets. Source: Final TCFD Annex, Implementing the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, June 2017
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Figure D – Risk Management: Guidance for all sectors and
supplemental guidance for asset owners and asset managers Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners should describe, where appropriate, engagement activity with investee companies to encourage better disclosure and practices related to climate-related risks to improve data availability and asset owners’ ability to assess climate-related risks. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Managers Asset managers should describe, where appropriate, engagement activity with investee companies to encourage better disclosure and practices related to climaterelated risks in order to improve data availability and asset managers’ ability to assess climate-related risks. Asset managers should also describe how they identify and assess material climaterelated risks for each product or investment strategy. This might include a description of the resources and tools used in the process.
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners should describe how they consider the positioning of their total portfolio with respect to the transition to a lower-carbon energy supply, production, and use. This could include explaining how asset owners actively manage their portfolios’ positioning in relation to this transition. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Managers Asset managers should describe how they manage material climate-related risks for each product or investment strategy. Source: Final TCFD Annex, Implementing the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, June 2017
Figure E – Metrics and Targets: Guidance for all sectors and
supplemental guidance for asset owners and asset managers
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners should describe metrics used to assess climate-related risks and opportunities in each fund or investment strategy. Where relevant, asset owners should also describe how these metrics have changed over time. Where appropriate, asset owners should provide metrics considered in investment decisions and monitoring. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Managers Asset managers should describe metrics used to assess climate-related risks and opportunities in each product or investment strategy. Where relevant, asset managers should also describe how these metrics have changed over time. Where appropriate, asset managers should provide metrics considered in investment decisions and monitoring Supplemental Guidance for Asset Owners Asset owners should provide the weighted average carbon intensity, where data are available or can be reasonably estimated, for each fund or investment strategy. In addition, asset owners should provide other metrics they believe are useful for decision making along with a description of the methodology used. See Table 2 (p. 43) for common carbon footprinting and exposure metrics, including weighted average carbon intensity. Note: The Task Force acknowledges the challenges and limitations of current carbon footprinting metrics, including that such metrics should not necessarily be interpreted as risk metrics. The Task Force views the reporting of weighted average carbon intensity as a first step and expects disclosure of this information to prompt important advancements in the development of decision-useful, climate-related risk metrics. The Task Force recognizes that some asset owners may be able to report weighted average carbon intensity for only a portion of their investments given data availability and methodological issues. Supplemental Guidance for Asset Managers Asset managers should provide the weighted average carbon intensity, where data are available or can be reasonably estimated, for each product or investment strategy.
CP21/17
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers In addition, asset managers should provide other metrics they believe are useful for decision making along with a description of the methodology used. See Table 2 (p. 43) for common carbon footprinting and exposure metrics, including weighted average carbon intensity. Note: The Task Force acknowledges the challenges and limitations of current carbon footprinting metrics, including that such metrics should not necessarily be interpreted as risk metrics. The Task Force views the reporting of weighted average carbon intensity as a first step and expects disclosure of this information to prompt important advancements in the development of decision-useful, climate-related risk metrics. The Task Force recognizes that some asset managers may be able to report weighted average carbon intensity for only portion of the assets they manage given data availability and methodological issues. Source: Final TCFD Annex, Implementing the Recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, June 2017
CP21/17
Appendix 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers
Appendix 3
Formulas for calculating certain core metrics In Chapter 5, we outline our proposals to require disclosure of a baseline set of core, mandatory, carbon emissions and carbon intensity metrics. We indicate that there are some overlapping metrics in the TCFD’s recommendations and the final report on draft RTS for the SFDR, and in some cases the calculation methodologies differ. We welcome stakeholders’ feedback on an approach that would require overlapping metrics to be reported according to the formulas under both regimes. This Appendix provides a comparison of the formulas in both the TCFD's recommendations and RTS for reference.
CP21/17
Appendix 3
Financial Conduct Authority
Enhancing climate-related disclosures by asset managers, life insurers, and FCA‑regulated pension providers A: TCFD B: SFDR Weighted average carbon intensity (WACI) Portfolio’s exposure to carbon-intensive companies, expressed in tons CO2e / $M revenue. Metric recommended by the Task Force. Total carbon emissions The absolute greenhouse gas emissions associated with a portfolio, expressed in tons CO2e. Carbon footprint Total carbon emissions for a portfolio normalized by the market value of the portfolio, expressed in tons CO2e / $M invested. Scope 1, 2 and 3 GHG emissions, disclosed separately Scope 1 refers to all direct GHG emissions. Scope 2 refers to indirect GHG emissions from consumption of purchased electricity, heat, or steam. Scope 3 refers to other indirect emissions not covered in Scope 2 that occur in the value chain of the reporting company, including both upstream and downstream emissions. Scope 3 emissions could include: the extraction and production of purchased materials and fuels, transportrelated activities in vehicles not owned or controlled by the reporting entity, electricity-related activities (eg, transmission and distribution losses), outsourced activities, and waste disposal (see page 63 of the TCFD Final Report). The scope 1, 2 and 3 definitions are contained in the low carbon benchmark regulation:
(i) Scope 1 carbon emissions, namely emissions generated from sources that are controlled by the company that issues the underlying assets; (ii) Scope 2 carbon emissions, namely emissions from the consumption of purchased electricity, steam, or other sources of energy generated upstream from the company that issues the underlying assets; (iii) Scope 3 carbon emissions, namely all indirect emissions that are not covered by points (i) and (ii) that occur in the value chain of the reporting company, including both upstream and downstream emissions, in particular for sectors with a high impact on climate change and its mitigation;
© Financial Conduct Authority 2021
12 Endeavour Square London E20 1JN
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7066 1000
Website: www.fca.org.uk
All rights reserved
Pub ref: 007587
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“We are consulting at the same time, in a separate consultation paper, CP 21/17, on proposals to introduce climate-related disclosure requirements for asset managers...”
More like this from FCA
FCA published 7 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Financial Conduct Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated