Individual decision · NCFM · 12 Oct 2026 · 53/1
The National Commission of the Financial Market rejected the preliminary request challenging its letter No. 05-5/4121 of 04.09.2026, which had closed the administrative procedure concerning ÎM CA "GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI" SA's handling of a damage file. The insurer paid 15,000.00 MDL, the maximum compensation for material damage under the friendly accident statement procedure set by point 3 of NCFM Decision No. 37/14/2019, although the repair estimate was 28,730.00 MDL. The 13,730.00 MDL difference results from that legal cap, not from a deductible, exclusion or limitation. The decision enters into force on adoption and may be challenged at the Chișinău Court, Râșcani office, within 30 days.
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA
NATIONAL COMMISSION OF THE FINANCIAL MARKET
12 October 2026
No. 53/1
On the Preliminary Request filed by Mr. [...], regarding the challenge of the letter of the National Commission of the Financial Market No. 05-5/4121 of 04.09.2026 regarding the completion of the administrative procedure
On 21.09.2026, within the National Commission of the Financial Market (NCFM), was registered (under No. 8519) the Preliminary Request, with the documents attached thereto, filed by Mr. [...] (petitioner), regarding the challenge of the NCFM letter No. 05-5/4121 of 04.09.2026 regarding the completion of the administrative procedure (Preliminary Request).
In this case, it is to be noted that, in order to ensure a full, objective and transparent investigation, which would offer the real possibility to analyze the petitioner's claim, the latter is informed that the examination of the factual and legal circumstances relevant to the case, in preliminary order, is carried out by distinct enforcement officers within the NCFM.
In fact, on 22.07.2026, within the NCFM, was registered (under No. 6232) the letter of the National Bank of Moldova (NBM) No. 09-02113/40/4045 of 22.07.2026, by which the petition of Mr. [...], with the documents attached thereto, is forwarded, for examination, according to competence, having as object the verification of the actions/inactions of ÎM CA "GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI" SA (insurer) in the part concerning the settlement of the Damage File No. [...], opened as a result of the road accident, which occurred on 01.07.2026.
Following the analysis of the information and documents presented by the participants in the administrative procedure, it is attested that the respective procedure was completed by issuing the NCFM letter No. 05-5/4121 on 04.09.2026 regarding the completion of the administrative procedure (Challenged Letter/Letter No. 05-5/4121).
Disagreeing with the NCFM findings, the petitioner filed a Preliminary Request, requesting, mainly, the re-examination of the Challenged Letter, considering the "incomplete character of the verification and reasoning".
In this case, the petitioner, according to the Preliminary Request, claims that "This request does not aim for the NCFM to substitute the court in the civil interpretation of the AUTOCASCO Contract, but aims to verify the complete and reasoned character of the manner in which the Insurer applied the contractual provisions, as well as whether the response of the administrative authority addresses all relevant circumstances of the case.".
bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, no. 77, mun. Chișinău, MD 2012, tel: (373 22) 859 401, www.cnpf.md, e-mail: office@cnpf.md
Analyzing the arguments set out in the Preliminary Request, through the prism of the legal provisions applicable to the case, it will be assessed whether they are of such a nature as to overturn the NCFM findings, as follows:
In law, art. 19 of the Administrative Code provides that "The preliminary request is the institution that offers a way of prejudicial resolution of administrative disputes.", and art. 162 para. (1) and para. (3) of the same law stipulate that "(1) The preliminary procedure aims to verify the legality of individual administrative acts. [...] (3) The preliminary request may be directed towards: a) the annulment in whole or in part of an illegal or void individual administrative act; b) the issuance of an individual administrative act.".
In accordance with art. 20 of the Administrative Code, "If through an administrative activity a legitimate right or a freedom established by law is violated, this right may be claimed through an administrative contentious action, [...]", and according to art. 17, "Injured right is any right or freedom established by law to which is brought harm through administrative activity.".
In this case, art. 78 para. (1) of the Administrative Code establishes that "(1) The administrative procedure is completed by performing an administrative operation or by issuing an individual administrative act, respectively by concluding an administrative contract.".
Under the conditions of art. 166 of the Administrative Code, "The preliminary request may be filed only if the person claims his/her rights violated by the issuance or rejection of the issuance of an individual administrative act.", and in accordance with art. 167 para. (1) and para. (3) of the same law, "(1) If it considers the preliminary request admissible and well-founded, the issuing public authority annuls in whole or in part the challenged individual administrative act or issues the requested individual administrative act. [...] (3) The issuing public authority resolves the preliminary request within 15 calendar days. The provisions of art. 60 para. (2) – (5) apply accordingly.".
At the same time, from the systemic interpretation of art. 17, art. 20, art. 166 and art. 207 of the Administrative Code, it results that the admissibility of a preliminary request is determined by the claiming of an injured right through administrative activity.
At the same time, taking into account the content of those formulated by the petitioner and resulting from the need to ensure an effective, transparent and exhaustive examination, the NCFM will proceed to verify the arguments invoked through the Preliminary Request, including in terms of the correctness of the assessments set out in Letter No. 05-5/4121.
In this case, the request in the petition of 22.07.2026, forwarded by the NBM, concerned, mainly, "Carrying out the appropriate verifications regarding the commercial and administrative conduct of ÎM CA "GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI" SA in connection with the management of the damage file No. [...]".
Respectively, the examination, in preliminary order, of the Preliminary Request may be carried out through the prism of the defined object of the administrative procedure, being subject to control the legality of the findings in the Challenged Letter.
In this case, on 05.02.2026, based on insurance application no. [...], between ÎM CA „GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI” SA and the petitioner was concluded the Land Vehicles Insurance Contract, series/no. [...] (AUTOCASCO Contract), having as its object the insured vehicle of model „HYUNDAI TUCSON”, with reg./id. [...], for the period 10.02.2026 – 09.02.2027.
As a result of the road accident, which occurred on 01.07.2026, in which were involved the vehicle of model „Hyundai Tucson”, with reg./id. [...], driven by Mrs. [...], and the vehicle of model „Kia Niro” with reg./id. [...], driven by Mr. [...], Mrs. [...] submitted, on 02.07.2026, to ÎM CA „GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI” SA a claim for compensation under the AUTOCASCO Contract.
Based on the submitted claim, in accordance with the applicable regulatory framework, as well as with the „Land Vehicles Insurance Conditions of 01.01.2020”, ÎM CA „GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI” SA opened, on 02.07.2026, the Damage File no. [...].
In this case, it should be noted that the accident which occurred on 01.07.2026 was documented by the form „Friendly Accident Statement”.
Consequently, according to pt. 6.9 of the AUTOCASCO Contract, „In the case of presentation of the form „Friendly Accident Statement”, completed in accordance with the legislation of the state on whose territory the insured risk occurred, the insurance compensation under the CASCO contract shall be paid: - up to the maximum amount of compensation under MTPL, established by the normative acts of the supervisory authority – if the accident occurred on the territory of the Republic of Moldova.”.
At the same time, pt. 13.9 of the „Land Vehicles Insurance Conditions (Class 3)” (Insurance Conditions) contains an identical clause.
Thus, although the repair estimate, drawn up by independent expertise no. [...] of 14.07.2026, elaborated by „EXAUTO-PLUS”, constituted the amount of 28 730,00 MDL, the insurer was bound to apply pt. 13.9 of the Insurance Conditions, corresponding to pt. 6.9 of the AUTOCASCO Contract, establishing the compensation in the amount of 15 000,00 MDL.
At the same time, from the presented materials, it results that the insurer also examined the possibility of paying the compensation to the specialized unit, however maintaining the cap of 15 000,00 MDL, or, by letter no. 4425 of 21.07.2026, the insurer reflects on the necessity of establishing the direction of transfer of the insurance compensation.
In this case, the insurer established that „the repair estimate calculated by independent expertise no. [...] elaborated by „EXAUTO-PLUS” SRL, constitutes 28 730 MDL which exceeds the maximum compensation value according to the friendly statement act according to which ÎM CA „GRAWE CARAT ASIGURĂRI” SA can pay a maximum of 15 000,00 MDL in accordance with the legislative provisions.”.
In law, according to art. 5 para. (3) of Law no. 92/2022, „In voluntary (optional) insurance, the relations between the insured and the insurance company, the rights and obligations of each party are established by the insurance contract. The provisions of the insurance contract cannot exceed the provisions of the insurance conditions. The conditions of voluntary (optional) insurance are established by the insurance company, in accordance with the legislation and with the normative acts of the National Commission of Financial Market.”.
Consequently, according to art. 13 para. (1) lit. c) of Law no. 106/2022 on mandatory motor third party liability insurance for damage caused by vehicles, „(1) The liability limits of domestic mandatory MTPL insurance are the following: c) for material damages claimed under the procedure of friendly statement of the vehicle accident, the maximum amount of compensation is established by the normative acts of the National Commission of Financial Market;”.
Additionally, according to pt. 3 of the NCFM Decision no. 37/14/2019 regarding the procedure related to the friendly statement of accident (Decision no. 37/14/2019), „3. In the case of applying the procedure of friendly statement of the motor vehicle accident in the event of damage or destruction of goods, the maximum amount of compensation is established in the amount of 15,000 lei, which is considered insignificant damage.”. Therefore, relating to the Preliminary Request and arising from the circumstances of the case, it should be noted that the actions of the insurer align with the legal provisions cited above. Thus, the alleged difference, in the amount of 13 730,00 MDL, does not represent a deductible, an exclusion or a limitation, as the petitioner invokes, but a materialized consequence of applying the compensation limit, specific to documenting the accident by the form „Friendly Accident Statement”. Moreover, the insurer's decision does not concern technical objections regarding the repair estimate, calculated by independent expertise no. [...], elaborated by „EXAUTO-PLUS” SRL, which constitutes 28 730 MDL, but represents the application of a legal and contractual mechanism. In another vein, in the circumstances of the case, although the value of the damage is greater than the maximum value of the compensation, specific to documenting the accident, by the form „Friendly Accident Statement”, the insurer's decision could not concern another value than the maximum limit, established according to pt. 3 of Decision no. 37/14/2019. Additionally, it should be specified that, at the date of conclusion of the Contract (05.02.2026), there were no specific requirements regarding the pre-contractual information, related to the insurance product, offered to the insured prior to its conclusion. In this case, regulations related to the Insurance Product Information Document were introduced in art. 891 of Law no. 92/2022 on insurance or reinsurance activity by Law no. 189/2025 amending certain normative acts (consolidation of the framework for the protection of the rights of consumers of financial services), in force as of 26.06.2026. Thus, in the absence of specific regulations, as well as of contrary evidence, compliance with the transparency obligation at the conclusion of the AUTOCASCO Contract cannot be challenged by invoking the abusive nature of those clauses. Regarding the preliminary procedure, it should be noted that, according to the Disposition of the President of the CNPF no. 993 of 01.10.2026 on the suspension of the preliminary procedure, initiated by the Preliminary Request submitted by Mr. Ion [...], the preliminary procedure was suspended until 09.10.2026. Also, the aforementioned Disposition was brought to the attention of the petitioner by CNPF letter no. 06-5/4816 of 02.10.2026. Additionally, by the same letter, in accordance with the provisions of art. 94 of the Administrative Code, the petitioner was informed about the exercise of
the right to be heard in connection with the circumstances relevant to the act to be adopted, as well as about the fact that the hearing is to be conducted in writing, by submitting, until 09.10.2026 inclusive, to the CNPF address, the opinion by way of hearing, which is to include any arguments, additional to those stated, relevant for the resolution of the Preliminary Request. Consequently, by the letter registered with the CNPF under no. 9229 on 08.10.2026, the petitioner informed that he maintains “in full the arguments and requests formulated in the Preliminary Request no. 8519 of 21.09.2026”. For the reasons set out above, pursuant to art. 18 para. (3), art. 20 para. (1), para. (6) and para. (7) and art. 22 para. (3) of Law no. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market, Law no. 105/2003 on consumer protection, art. 164 para. (1) and para. (2) lit. b), art. 167 para. (3), art. 169 para. (2) and para. (3) of the Administrative Code, pt. 16 and pt. 19 of the Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision no. 57/11/2022),
1. The Preliminary Request submitted by Mr. [...], regarding the challenge of the letter of the National Commission of the Financial Market no. 05-5/4121 of 04.09.2026 concerning the completion of the administrative procedure (registered with the CNPF under no. 8519 on 21.09.2026), is rejected.
2. This Decision may be challenged by an administrative contentious action, filed with the Chișinău Court, Râșcani office (MD-2068, mun. Chișinău, str. Kiev 3), within 30 days from the date of its communication.
3. This Decision enters into force on the date of adoption, is communicated to the addressee in accordance with the legislation and is published on the official website of the CNPF (www.cnpf.md).
Dumitru BUDIANSCHI,
PRESIDENT
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“pt. 16 and pt. 19 of the Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision no. 57/11/2022)”
More like this from NCFM
NCFM published 25 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Commission for Financial Markets Moldova — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated