Enforcement · NCFM · 27 Oct 2026 · 57/13
The National Commission of Financial Market found that NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC violated Law No. 202/2013 by misdefining the total amount payable by the consumer, omitting the credit type, and failing to bold the 59.10% annual percentage rate and 186,135.91 lei total payable. The 5-working-day notice for early repayment and the clause allowing early maturity for third-party claims exceeding 20% of the loan amount were also found non-compliant. The single loan interest of 6,130.00 lei was assessed as an abusive commission.
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA
NATIONAL COMMISSION of FINANCIAL MARKET
27 October 2026
No. 57/13
On the petition of Mr. […], submitted by his representative, Mr. […], registered with the National Commission of Financial Market under No. 7436 on 25.08.2026, in relation to NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC
On 25.08.2026, within the National Commission of Financial Market (NCFM), was registered (under No. 7436) the petition of Mr. […] (debtor/consumer/borrower), with the documents attached thereto, submitted by his representative, Mr. […], by which the intervention of the NCFM is requested with reference to the legal relationship, mentioned infra.
1. The legal relationship between NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC and the debtor was established based on the Loan Agreement No. […] of […] (Agreement), concluded for a term of 72 months, having as object the granting of a non-bank credit in the amount of 67 430,00 lei, the total amount payable by the consumer constituting the sum of 186 135,91 lei.
2. The essential conditions of the Agreement include:
2.1. the total cost of the credit, which comprises:
2.1.1. the interest rate: fixed, 42,00 percent per year;
2.1.2. the single loan interest: 6 130,00 lei (10,00 percent of the loan amount, minimum 5 000,00 lei);
2.2. the annual effective interest rate: 59,10 percent;
2.3. the payment method: annuity, the credit repaid in installments, according to the Payment Schedule: in 72 installments;
2.4. the penalty for late payment: 0,5 percent per day of the unpaid or late-paid amount;
2.5. the penalty of 1 percent of the total loan amount for non-compliance with the obligations mentioned in points 9.1. – 9.2., in points 9.5. – 9.7.;
2.6. the penalty of 5 percent of the total loan amount for non-compliance with point 9.3., point 9.4. and point 9.15.
3. Considering that a party to the contractual relationship in question is NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC, according to the Order of the Vice-President of the NCFM No. 739 of 01.09.2026 regarding the ex officio involvement of NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC in the administrative procedure, initiated by the petition of Mr. […], submitted by
bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, no. 77, mun. Chișinău, MD 2012, tel: (373 22) 859 401, www.cnpf.md, e-mail: office@cnpf.md
the representative Mr. […], and the suspension of the administrative procedure, the creditor was ex officio involved in the administrative procedure, being requested, by NCFM letter No. 04-5/4024 of 03.09.2026, to present the necessary explanations and a copy of the Credit File.
4. At the same time, the administrative procedure was suspended until 15.09.2026 inclusive.
5. Consequently, on 15.09.2026, the creditor presented the requested documents (registered with the NCFM under No. 8297).
6. At the same time, taking into account the imperative of conducting complete investigations, which involves time for the meticulous examination of the presented evidence and the formation of objective and reasoned conclusions, by the Order of the President of the NCFM No. 1035 of 07.10.2026 regarding the extension of the general term of the administrative procedure, initiated by the petition of Mr. […], submitted by his representative, Mr. […], and the suspension of the administrative procedure, the general term of the administrative procedure was extended by 15 days.
7. Concurrently, by the aforementioned order the administrative procedure was suspended for a term of 12 days, and in order to ensure the exercise of the right of NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC to be heard within the administrative procedure, by NCFM letter No. 04-5/4976 of 08.10.2026, NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC was informed about the possibility of presenting explanations and additional documents to the circumstances invoked in the petition, as well as explanations and supporting documents regarding the conformity of the contractual clauses provided in points 2 and 4 of Part I "Special Provisions", points 4.3, 5.5, 6.4, 7.3, 8.2, 8.5, 10.2, 11.1 and 12.2.8 3 of Part II "General Provisions", as well as the provisions regarding the single loan interest, the interest rate, the extension fees and applicable penalties, with the provisions of the normative framework in force at the date of conclusion of the credit agreement.
8. As a result, on 20.10.2026, NCO "MOGO LOANS" LLC presented the requested explanations (registered with the NCFM under No. 9585).
9. In accordance with art. 37 para. (2) of Law No. 105/2003 on consumer protection (Law No. 105/2003), "(2) The National Commission of Financial Market supervises the compliance by the subjects provided in art.4 para.(21) of Law No.192/1998 on the National Commission of Financial Market with the provisions of art.1069–1072, 1075–1079 and 1081 of the Civil Code in the part referring to contracts concluded with consumers and the finding of abusive clauses in contracts, at the request of the consumer or ex officio, under the conditions of the law.".
10. In this case, the Agreement was concluded on […], respectively, the normative framework in force at that time applies to it, or, under the conditions of art. 7 para. (4) of the Civil Code, "(4) In the case of contractual legal situations in progress at the date of entry into force of the new law, the old law will continue to govern the nature and extent of the rights and obligations of the parties, as well as any other contractual effects, unless the new law provides otherwise.".
11. Thus, the Agreement is subject to the legal regime provided by the Civil Code (in the version up to 01.03.2019), by Law No. 105/2003, by Law No. 202/2013 on credit agreements for consumers (Law No. 202/2013) and by Law
No. 256/2011 on abusive clauses in contracts concluded with consumers (Law No. 256/2011), in the versions in force at the date of its conclusion.
12. At the same time, in accordance with the provisions of Art. 7 para. (5) of the Civil Code, “(5) In the situations provided for in para. (4), the provisions of the new law shall apply to the modalities of exercising rights or performing obligations, as well as of alienating, taking over, transforming or extinguishing them. Likewise, if the new law does not provide otherwise, the clauses of a legal act concluded before the entry into force of the new law that are contrary to its mandatory provisions are, from that date, devoid of any legal effect.”.
13. According to Art. 1 of Law No. 105/2003, “consumer” is “any natural person who intends to order or procure, or who orders, procures or uses products, services for needs unrelated to entrepreneurial or professional activity;”.
The same concept is also contained in Art. 3 of Law No. 202/2013.
14. According to Art. 21 of the Civil Code, “(1) Any natural person who, in a civil legal relationship, acts predominantly for purposes unrelated to entrepreneurial or professional activity has the status of consumer. The natural person does not have the status of consumer if the other party to the civil legal relationship does not have the status of professional. (2) Any natural or legal person under public or private law who, in a civil legal relationship, acts for purposes related to entrepreneurial or professional activity has the status of professional, even if the person does not aim to obtain a profit from this activity.”.
15. In accordance with Art. 16 letter a) and letter b) of Law No. 105/2003, “The consumer, when concluding contracts, has the following rights: a) to make free decisions when purchasing the product or service, without being imposed in contracts abusive clauses or clauses that may favor the use of unfair commercial practices, likely to influence his choice; b) to benefit from a clear and precise drafting of the contractual clauses, including those regarding the main characteristics and warranty conditions, the exact indication of the price or tariff, as well as the precise establishment of the credit conditions and interest rates;”.
16. Moreover, the Civil Code establishes in Art. 9 para. (1) that “(1) Natural and legal persons participating in civil legal relationships must exercise their rights and perform their obligations in good faith, in accordance with the law, the contract, public order and good morals. Good faith is presumed until proven otherwise.”.
17. At the date of conclusion of the Contract, the legislation related to abusive clauses was found in Law No. 256/2011. According to Art. 3 of the aforementioned law, “abusive clause – a contractual clause which, not being individually negotiated with the consumer, by itself or together with other provisions of the contract, creates, to the detriment of the consumer, contrary to the requirements of good faith, a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties arising from the contract;”.
18. In accordance with the provisions of Art. 4 para. (1) – (3) of Law No. 256/2011, “(1) Traders are prohibited from including abusive clauses in contracts concluded with consumers. Any abusive clause introduced in such contracts is considered null from the moment of their conclusion. (2) Any contract concluded between a trader and a consumer shall include clear, unambiguous contractual clauses, the understanding of which does not require special knowledge. (3) In the case of contracts in which all or part of the clauses are presented to the consumer in writing, they must be drafted in clear and intelligible language, be legible. This requirement applies to the document as a whole, including footnotes, references to other documents or specifications of any nature.”.
19. In accordance with Art. 5 para. (1) and para. (2) of Law No. 256/2011, “(1) A contractual clause not being individually negotiated with the consumer is abusive if it creates, contrary to the requirements of good faith, by itself or together with other provisions of the contract, to the detriment of the consumer, a significant imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties arising from the contract. (2) A clause is always considered not to have been individually negotiated when it was included by the trader in advance and, for this reason, the consumer did not have the possibility to influence its content.”.
20. Also relevant are the provisions of Art. 6 para. (2) and para. (3) of Law No. 256/2011, according to which, “(2) When assessing the abusive nature of contractual clauses, with the exception of the clauses established in Art. 5 para. (5), account shall be taken of: a) the different bargaining power of the parties; b) the nature of the goods or services; c) the fact that the consumer was encouraged to give his consent to the respective clause by the statement that he will obtain a benefit or an advantage from accepting the respective clause; d) the fact that the goods or services were sold or supplied at the special order of the consumer; e) the fact that the trader acted correctly and fairly towards the other party whose legitimate interests he must take into account. (3) The assessment of the abusive nature of the clauses does not refer to the subject matter of the contract nor to the adequacy of the price or remuneration, on the one hand, in relation to the services or goods supplied in exchange for them, on the other hand, to the extent that these clauses are expressed in clear and intelligible language. The subject matter of the contract and the relationship between price and quality may be taken into account when assessing the abusive nature of the other contractual clauses.”.
21. According to Art. 216 para. (1) of the Civil Code, “(1) The legal act is null on the grounds provided for in this code (absolute nullity).”, and according to Art. 220 para. (1) of the same law, “(1) The legal act or clause that contravene mandatory norms are null if the law does not provide otherwise.”.
22. Analyzing the contractual clauses, the information in the documents submitted by the creditor and the debtor, in light of the requirements of Law no. 105/2003, Law no. 202/2013, Law no. 256/2011 and the Civil Code, in particular, in relation to the normative framework set out above, the CNPF notes the following:
22.1. Ab initio, the establishment of the status of professional, which OCN „MOGO LOANS” SRL possesses in relation to the consumer, is complained of.
In accordance with the information in the State Register of Legal Entities, OCN „MOGO LOANS” SRL has, as its main object of activity, inter alia, the activity of granting non-bank loans, being registered in the Register of authorized non-bank lending organizations.
Thus, it is concluded that OCN „MOGO LOANS” SRL carries out the activity of granting non-bank loans, on a professional basis, based on the clauses and conditions offered by it, the contractual clauses being drafted in advance for a multitude of contracts.
In this context, the erroneous presentation of the essential conditions of the Contract is noted, by operating with terms distinct from the notions provided in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013.
In this way, the creditor allows the information to be presented in a distorted manner to the consumer, which denotes non-execution of the obligation to present the information in the contract in a clear and intelligible manner.
In this regard, it should be noted that, according to the definition provided in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, the total amount payable by the consumer is „the sum of the total amount of the credit and the total cost of the credit for the consumer.”.
In this case, it is found that the creditor, in point 8 of Part I „Special provisions” of the Contract, wrongly defined the total amount payable by the consumer as „the total costs related to the loan”, a fact which misleads the consumer, since, according to the notion defined in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, the total amount of the credit – the total sums made available under a credit contract, and the total cost of the credit - all costs, including interest, commissions, fees and any other type of costs that the consumer must bear in connection with the credit contract and which are known to the creditor, with the exception of notarial fees.
Therefore, by relating the cited legal norms to the revealed factual circumstances, it is noted that the creditor violated the legal requirements for presenting, in a clear and precise manner, the information regarding the essential conditions of the Contract, which caused the erroneous information of the consumer regarding the total amount payable by the consumer and the total cost of the credit, applicable under the Contract.
According to art. 10 para. (3) lit. a) and lit. g) of Law no. 202/2013, „(3) The credit contract specifies clearly and concisely: a) the type of credit; [...] g) the annual percentage rate of charge and the total amount payable by the consumer, indicated in a highlighted manner (in bold) and calculated at the time of conclusion of the credit contract; all the hypotheses used for calculating this rate are mentioned;”.
In this case, the Contract does not specify the type of credit granted, this being indicated only in the form „Standard information regarding the granting of a loan to a natural person”.
In this case, in Part I „Special provisions” of the Contract, the annual percentage rate of charge (59.10 percent) and the total amount payable by the consumer (indicated as „Total costs related to the loan” – 186 135.91 lei) are not presented in a highlighted manner (in bold), as required by art. 10 para. (3) lit. g) of Law no. 202/2013.
Therefore, by relating the cited legal norms to the revealed factual circumstances, it is noted that the creditor violated the requirements provided in art. 10 para. (3) lit. a) and lit. g) of Law no. 202/2013.
According to point 5.5. of the Contract, „The Borrower is entitled, at any time, before the end of the loan period, by notifying Mogo Loans in writing 5 (five) working days in advance, to repay in advance the unpaid share of the loan amount [...]”.
In accordance with art. 20 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, „(1) The consumer has the right, at any time, to discharge in full or in part his obligations arising from a credit contract. In this case, the consumer has the right to a reduction of the total cost of the credit, this reduction consisting of the interest and costs related to the period between the date of early repayment and the date provided for the termination of the credit contract.”.
From the content of the norm cited above, it follows that the right to early repayment may be exercised at any time during the contractual relationship, the law not conditioning its exercise on compliance with a minimum notice period in favor of the creditor.
Moreover, point 5.5. of the Contract is not limited to establishing a notification obligation, but requires that the notification be made 5 working days before repayment. Consequently, the consumer who requests early discharge of obligations does not benefit from the effects of early repayment at the chosen moment, but only after the expiry of the term established contractually.
Therefore, the 5 working days term restricts the exercise of the right recognized to the consumer by art. 20 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, since it transforms the right of repayment „at any time” into a right exercisable only after going through a minimum waiting period established in favor of the creditor, which also influences the amount of the reduction of the total cost of the credit.
According to point 12.2.8. of the Contract, it constitutes a case of non-performance, which entitles the creditor to declare the termination of the Contract, the situation in which "Third parties submit justified claims against the Borrower, the total amount of which exceeds 20% (twenty percent) of the total loan amount;".
At the same time, point 10.5. of the Contract provides that, in the event of one of the situations provided for in point 12.2. of the Contract, the creditor is entitled to unilaterally terminate the Contract by a written termination statement.
Additionally, according to point 12.3. of the Contract, "In case of unilateral termination of the Contract by Mogo Loans, the Borrower is obliged […] to pay, within 7 (seven) working days from the date of receipt of the notice, all contractual payments due.".
According to the contractual definitions, "Contractual payments" represent "Payments made by the Borrower in favor of Mogo Loans which include the loan interest, loan payments, interest, and, where applicable, contractual penalties and other payments specified in the Contract".
At the same time, "Loan payments" include, where applicable, the monthly installments, if the "annuity" method is applied, or the single installment, if the "bullet" method is applied.
The examination as a whole of the clauses provided for in point 10.5., point 12.2.8. and point 12.3. of the Contract reveals that, although the Contract uses the notion of "termination", the effect of the contractual mechanism consists in the early termination of the contractual relationship and in obliging the consumer, within a term of 7 working days, to pay the contractual payments in the amount established in the termination statement, these including the loan payments.
Under these conditions, to the extent that the termination statement includes the loan balance, which, according to the Payment Schedule, was to become due subsequently, and during the 7 working days, the debtor is bound to pay not only the payments due at the time of declaring the alleged termination, it is attested that the contractual mechanism determines the loss of the benefit of the term and produces, from a functional standpoint, the effect of declaring the early maturity of the loan.
According to art. 15 para. (4) lit. c) of Law no. 202/2013, it is prohibited to introduce in credit contracts clauses by which the creditor may declare the loan due early in the event that the consumer has not fulfilled its obligations under other credit contracts, concluded with other creditors.
Moreover, point 12.2.8. of the Contract has a general wording, referring to claims submitted by "third parties", without excluding claims resulting from other credit contracts, concluded by the consumer with other creditors. Thus, the clause allows the application of the termination mechanism, provided for in point 10.5. and in point 12.3. of the Contract, including in the situation in which the respective claims arise from the non-performance of obligations related to other credit relationships.
The circumstance that the Contract qualifies the respective mechanism as "termination" is not decisive to the extent that its concrete effect consists in obliging the consumer to pay early the loan balance, under conditions specific to declaring early maturity. The legal classification is to be carried out by reference to the effect produced by the contractual clauses, but not exclusively to the terminology used by the professional.
Consequently, to the extent that the clause at point 12.2.8., corroborated with point 10.5. and with point 12.3. of the Contract, allowing the consumer to be obliged to repay early the loan balance, as a result of the non-performance of obligations arising from other credit contracts, concluded with other creditors, contradicts the prohibition provided for in art. 15 para. (4) lit. c) of Law no. 202/2013.
Corresponding to point 1 of Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract, the loan amount is 61 300,00 lei, and according to point 3 of the same part, the total loan amount is 67 430,00 lei.
At the same time, point 2 of Part I "Special Provisions" establishes "Single loan interest (10.00% of the loan amount, min. 5000 lei) – 6 130,00 lei".
In this case, according to the definition contained in point 1 of Part II "General Provisions" of the Contract, "Single loan interest – The single interest for all services provided by Mogo Loans in the loan granting process, specified in the Basic Provisions.".
In context, from the definition of the expression "single loan interest" it results that the amount claimed as such represents a commission charged by the lender for granting the loan. This conclusion is deduced from the fact that the legal norms establish the creditor's right to receive remuneration in the form of interest, which is a remuneration for making the monetary means available to the debtor, the manner and amount of which is strictly defined and regulated by legislation. Accordingly, in addition to interest, the creditor may charge other payments in the form of fees/commissions/penalties etc.
Under the conditions of the case, since point 4 of Part I "Special Conditions" of the Contract provides for a fixed interest of 42.00 percent per year, the charging of another interest in other forms and amounts is excluded.
Therefore, it is obvious that the amount imposed on the consumer under the title of "single loan interest" is nothing other than a commission charged by the creditor to cover the actual expenses borne by it in carrying out the operations related to granting the loan.
According to Art. 4(2) and (3) of Law 256/2011, any contract concluded between a trader and a consumer shall contain clear, unambiguous contractual terms, whose understanding does not require special knowledge, and in accordance with paragraph (3) of the same article, In the case of contracts in which all or part of the terms are presented to the consumer in writing, they must be drafted in clear and intelligible language and be legible.
In this regard, the transparency obligation arising from Art. 4 of Law No. 256/2011 is not limited to the formally intelligible drafting of a term or to the numerical indication of the amount of a payment obligation. In the case of a term that imposes a monetary obligation on the consumer, the contract must allow the consumer to understand, by examining the term itself and by correlating it with the other contractual provisions, the concrete mechanism for performing the obligation, including the moment at which it becomes due and the conditions under which the creditor is entitled to request payment.
In this respect, point 4.3 of Part II "General Provisions" of the Contract provides that "The Borrower agrees to pay the single loan interest by including it in the total loan amount, which is paid by the Borrower to the Lender according to the repayment schedule, being included in the monthly loan payment installments".
Therefore, the contractual term itself conditions the performance of the obligation to pay the single loan interest on the content of the Payment Schedule, which represents the contractual document in which the consumer must be able to identify the moment and manner of performance of that obligation.
However, from the examination of the Payment Schedule, it is found that it does not contain the single loan interest, does not individualize a payment corresponding to the amount of 6 130,00 lei and does not indicate the date or deadline by which this commission is to be paid.
Consequently, although the Contract indicates the existence and amount of the single loan interest, it does not allow the consumer to determine the moment at which the payment obligation becomes due and, implicitly, the manner of performance of that obligation. The consumer cannot establish, on the basis of the contractual terms, whether that amount must be paid on the date of conclusion of the Contract, at the time of disbursement of the credit, together with one of the installments provided in the Payment Schedule, or at another moment.
Moreover, the express reference in point 4.3. of the Contract to the Payment Schedule legitimately creates the expectation that the payment deadline for the single loan interest can be identified within it. The omission of the single loan interest from the Payment Schedule thus leads to a lack of coherence between the contractual terms and prevents the consumer from determining, unequivocally, the mechanism of performance of the payment obligation.
In the same context, it should be noted that the administrative file contains Payment Order No. 2 dated 08.12.2018, according to which the amount of 61 300,00 lei was disbursed to the consumer, which attests to the withholding of the single loan commission at the time of disbursement, a fact which does not result from the Contract.
Therefore, point 4.3 of Part II "General Provisions", correlated with point 2 of Part I "Special Provisions" and with the Payment Schedule, does not meet the transparency requirement provided for in Art. 4 of Law No. 256/2011, since the consumer is not placed in a position to determine, clearly and predictably, the moment at which the obligation to pay the arrangement commission becomes due.
In the same vein, according to Art. 5(2)(c) of Law No. 202/2013, "(2) Pre-contractual information is provided: [...] c) by means of the form presented in Annex No. 1;" and, correspondingly, Art. 5(4) of the same law, "(4) Any other additional information the creditor shall provide to the consumer in a separate document, which may be annexed to the form presented in Annex No. 1.".
In the present case, applying the legal norms to the relevant factual circumstances, it is attested that, although Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract includes the information regarding the payment of the single loan interest (but without specifying its due date or manner of payment), the cost in question is nevertheless not found in the "Pre-contractual Information" form presented to the debtor, nor in the Payment Schedule annexed thereto. That information was not included in the "Related costs" box, depriving the debtor of the possibility to transparently analyze the pre-contractual information, given the weight of this cost in the "Total loan amount" of 10 percent.
Additionally, it should be noted that the single loan interest was included in the total loan amount, whereas, in fact, it should have been included in the costs. By erroneously defining and unjustifiably including the "single loan interest" in the total loan amount, the creditor unjustifiably increased the loan amount (which, de facto, is 61 300,00 lei) by 6 130,00 lei, even though, through the submitted Financing Application, the debtor expressly requested the granting of a loan in the amount of 61 300,00 lei. Per a contrario, the debtor benefited from a loan in the amount of 67 430,00 lei (an amount which was used as the basis for calculating the annual interest of 42 percent, a fact also found on the basis of the Payment Schedule), the requested amount being effectively released to him.
According to point 4 of Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract, "Annual interest rate 42.00%.".
Likewise, point 6. of Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract stipulates that "Effective annual interest rate – 59.10%.".
Art. 869 para. (1) of the Civil Code (in force at the time of conclusion of the Contract), states that, "Based on the loan contract, the parties may also provide for the payment of interest, which must be in a reasonable relationship with the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova.".
For the purpose of determining the reasonable nature of the interest in relation to the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova (NBM), the Recommendation of the Supreme Court of Justice no. 13/2012 (SCJ Recommendation no. 13/2012) regarding the reasonable relationship between the interest rates practiced on the non-banking financial market and the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova establishes a reference value.
In this case, it is made up of the sum of 3 components: the value of the interbank reference rate (CHIBOR), the creditor's profit in the amount of approximately half of the value of the interbank reference rate and the expenses borne by the creditor in the amount of approximately 4 – 5 percent.
According to public information, published on the official website of the NBM, on […], the interbank reference rate (CHIBOR) was 10.43 percent.
Based on the above, the interest rate on the loan granted under the Contract in the amount of 42 percent per year exceeds the reasonable nature of the interest of 20 percent per year, calculated according to SCJ Recommendation no. 13/2012.
Additionally, SCJ Recommendation no. 13/2012 establishes that, "At the same time, the courts are warned that, in the case of loans granted by savings and loan associations of citizens or other economic agents of the non-banking financial market, the full annulment of the interest clause on the basis of art. 869 para. (2) of the Civil Code and the establishment of the interest provided by art. 585 is unfair and leads to unjust enrichment of the debtor. Fair and just will be the reduction of the interest to a reasonable rate (according to the calculation formula explained above), thus applying partial nullity, according to art. 220 para. (3) of the Civil Code.".
Therefore, it is found that the creditor violated the provisions of art. 869 para. (1) of the Civil Code.
According to point 8.2. of the Contract, "After Mogo Loans has received and analyzed the request for extension of the loan term, Mogo Loans decides on the loan term and the extension fee, notifying the Borrower in this regard, personally or through and with the use of the methods provided in this contract. The extension fee will be applied and charged to the Borrower only if the Borrower, through its request, has requested the extension of the maturity for a period longer than 30 days.".
Point 8.5. of the Contract provides that, "The extension of the loan term applies and enters into force only after Mogo Loans has received the amount of the extension fee for the loan term, and only after the transmission, receipt and signing by the Borrower of the new repayment schedule, respectively, starting from the new term or, as the case may be, the maturity terms indicated in the new Repayment Schedule".
At the same time, from the examination of the Contract, it is found however that it does not establish the amount of the extension fee, its calculation formula, nor the objective and verifiable criteria based on which the amount is to be determined.
In accordance with art. 4 para. (2) and para. (3) of Law no. 256/2011, clauses that have not been individually negotiated must be drafted in clear and intelligible language. In the case of a clause that imposes a cost on the consumer, compliance with this obligation presupposes not only indicating the existence of the cost, but also the consumer's possibility to determine, based on the contract, the calculation mechanism and the extent of the financial obligation that may result for them.
Moreover, in this case, the consumer only knows that the extension of the term by more than 30 days may generate the obligation to pay an extension fee, without being able to determine, at the time of conclusion of the Contract, its amount or limits.
Furthermore, the wording of point 8.2. of the Contract, according to which the creditor decides also regarding the extension fee, leaves the subsequent determination of the cost within the creditor's decision-making scope, without indicating objective contractual criteria that would limit this margin of appreciation.
This lack of determinability is all the more relevant as, according to point 8.5. of the Contract, payment of the extension fee constitutes a condition for the entry into force of the amendment of the credit term. Thus, the consumer cannot assess in advance the cost of a possible extension nor the economic consequences of exercising this option.
Consequently, the clauses in points 8.2. and 8.5. of the Contract do not allow the consumer to determine, based on clear and intelligible criteria, the amount or the mechanism for establishing the extension fee and, respectively, the economic consequences of extending the credit term, thus not complying with the transparency obligation provided by art. 4 para. (2) and para. (3) of Law no. 256/2011.
22.9.1. According to point 10.2. of the Contract, "If, during the performance period of the Contract, the exchange rate established by the National Bank of Moldova for the Moldovan leu against EURO or USD changes, exceeding by more than 10 percent the rate established at the date of signing, Mogo Loans has the right to unilaterally revise any agreed payments, proportionally to the changed rate, notifying the Client of the relevant changes by e-mail and/or SMS at least 30 days in advance.[…]".
In the same vein, it must be mentioned that, in the form "Standard information regarding the granting of the loan to the natural person", which was made available to the debtor, under the heading "3. Costurile împrumutului”, se indică: „Rata dobînzii la împrumut sau, daca este cazul, diferite rate ale dobînzii care se aplică contractului de împrumut: 42.00%, anual, fixă”.
The same information is disclosed at point 4 of Part I “Special Provisions” of the Contract.
In this context, in accordance with art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, “the fixed interest rate applicable to the credit – the agreement of the parties, in the credit contract, on an interest rate applicable to the credit for the entire duration of the credit contract or on several interest rates applicable to the credit for partial terms, applying exclusively a fixed percentage established. If not all interest rates applicable to the credit are established in the credit contract, the interest rate applicable to the credit is considered to be fixed only for the partial terms for which the interest rates applicable to the credit are established exclusively by a specific fixed percentage agreed at the time of concluding the credit contract; .”.
Therefore, the pre-contractual information, according to which the interest rate is fixed, and the clause provided at point 10.2. of the Contract, which allows the creditor to unilaterally modify it depending on the evolution of certain economic indicators, creates a discrepancy regarding the nature and mechanism of determining the interest applicable to the Contract. The consumer is presented, prior to the conclusion of the Contract, with a fixed rate, while the contractual clause allows for its subsequent modification at the unilateral initiative of the creditor.
In this line of reasoning, it should be specified that the assessment of the abusive nature of the clause does not concern the adequacy of the interest rate level, as an element of the creditor's remuneration, but the manner in which the professional has reserved the right to unilaterally modify an interest rate presented to the consumer as being fixed.
Therefore, pursuant to art. 5 para. (1) of Law no. 256/2011, when assessing the potential abusive nature, it is analysed whether the pre-formulated contractual clause which has not been individually negotiated is considered abusive if it is proposed by the professional and, contrary to good faith, significantly disadvantages the consumer, and, in the same line of reasoning, pursuant to para. (2) of the same article, “(2) A clause shall always be deemed not to have been individually negotiated where it has been incorporated in advance by the trader and, for this reason, the consumer has not been able to influence its content.”.
In assessing the imbalance created to the detriment of the consumer, the nature of the legal relationship must also be taken into account. The consumer takes out the loan, assuming the obligation of instalment repayment, and the interest rate level is an essential element for determining the cost of the loan and the extent of its payment obligations. In the case of a rate presented as being fixed, the consumer is entitled to rely on the stability of the agreed percentage for the period for which it is declared applicable, whereas, through the clause at item 10.2. of the Contract, the lender reserves the possibility of unilaterally modifying precisely this element of the cost of the loan, depending on the evolution of the EURO or USD exchange rate, although the interest rate was presented to the consumer, at the pre-contractual stage, as being fixed.
Thus, the clause affects the predictability of the loan cost and the stability of the obligations assumed by the consumer, being incompatible with the fixed nature of the interest rate presented to the consumer prior to the conclusion of the Contract.
22.9.2. At the same time, the clause provided in point 10.2. of the Contract is to be analyzed also in light of Art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013 (as in force at the date of signing the Contract), which prohibits contractual clauses by which the creditor is granted the right to unilaterally modify the contractual conditions, without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by the consumer.
In this case, point 10.2. of the Contract expressly grants the lender the right to unilaterally modify the interest rate, depending on the evolution of the EURO or USD exchange rate. Therefore, the modification of the interest rate can be made by the creditor's simple decision, without the consumer's prior consent being necessary. The fact that the creditor is obliged to inform the consumer at least 30 days before the application of the new rate does not remove the unilateral nature of the modification. The notification of the consumer merely represents informing them about the modification decided by the creditor, but does not equate to the consumer's consent nor to the conclusion of an additional act.
Also, the Contract does not provide that the modification of the interest rate be conditional upon the consumer's express acceptance and the signing of an additional act. On the contrary, the wording "Mogo Loans has the right to unilaterally revise any agreed payments" grants the creditor, through the contractual clause itself, the right to unilaterally modify an essential condition of the Contract. Therefore, point 10.2. of the Contract allows the creditor to unilaterally modify any cost related to the loan, without the consumer's consent and without the conclusion of an additional act accepted by them, which contravenes the requirements of Art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013.
This circumstance also constitutes an additional element in assessing the abusive nature of the clause, as it allows the professional to unilaterally modify any essential element of the credit cost and creates, to the detriment of the consumer, an imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties.
Pct. 6.4. of the Contract provides that: „The list of commissions, penalties and sanctions, as well as their effective amount, may be modified unilaterally by Mogo Loans, by placing them on the website: www.mogo.md and notifying the Borrower at least 30 calendar days in advance by sending an SMS and/or e-mail to the Borrower. If the borrower does not appear at the Mogo Loans office within 20 calendar days from receiving the notification in order to sign the updated List and, as the case may be, the new repayment schedule, it will be considered that the borrower has accepted the new amount of the payments indicated above.”.
Through its content, the clause grants the creditor the right to unilaterally modify not only the effective amount of the cost elements established in the Contract (commissions and penalties), but also the list thereof, without the prior expression of the consumer's consent and without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by the consumer.
Moreover, the respective clause operates with the mechanism of tacit acceptance, as the debtor is given 20 calendar days for receiving the notification and signing the updated List of commissions, penalties and sanctions. In principle, the debtor's action does not produce legal effects, as, upon the expiry of this term, the creditor will apply the updated List regardless of the debtor's consent.
In this case, Art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013 prohibits contractual clauses that grant the creditor the right to unilaterally modify the contractual conditions without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by the consumer.
In accordance with pct. 7.3. of the Contract, „If upon receipt of the Borrower's notification regarding the exercise of the right of withdrawal, Mogo Loans has already paid the borrower the entire amount or a part of the loan, the Borrower is obliged, within at most 3 (three) calendar days from sending the notification of exercise of the right of withdrawal, to return to Mogo Loans without any unjustified delay the amounts received and the interest accrued for this period.”.
According to Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law no. 202/2013, in the case of exercising the right of withdrawal, the consumer is obliged to return the principal and the related interest without any unjustified delay and, in any case, no later than 30 calendar days from sending the notification. Therefore, the legal norm regulates not only the existence of the restitution obligation, but also the temporal regime of its execution, establishing both the criterion of execution without unjustified delay and a maximum time limit of 30 days.
The phrase „without any unjustified delay” cannot be interpreted as meaning that the 30-day term is devoid of legal effect. The two elements of the norm have distinct functions: the obligation to execute without unjustified delay presupposes that the consumer cannot unjustifiably postpone the restitution of the amounts received, while the 30-day term constitutes the maximum time limit within which the obligation must be executed as an effect of exercising the right of withdrawal.
Moreover, by establishing a fixed term of 3 calendar days, the creditor substantially reduces the period provided by the legislator for the execution of the restitution obligation, replacing the legal regime, which allows execution without unjustified delay but establishes, as a maximum limit, the 30-day term, with a fixed contractual term that is significantly shorter.
Such a completion does not consist in the mere fact that the 3-day term is different from the 30-day term provided by law, but in whether, through a pre-established contractual clause, the creditor can restrict, to the detriment of the consumer, the temporal regime of the restitution obligation established by Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law no. 202/2013.
Such a contractual restriction must be examined in light of Art. 27 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, which provides that consumers cannot waive the rights conferred by this law.
To the extent that the time limit established by Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law no. 202/2013 represents a legal guarantee regarding the execution of the restitution obligation, as an effect of exercising the right of withdrawal, the establishment by contract of a shorter term cannot have the effect of depriving the consumer of the protection conferred by the legal norm.
Therefore, the contractual clause cannot be justified merely by the fact that Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law no. 202/2013 imposes restitution „without any unjustified delay”, since the same legal provision expressly establishes that the restitution must not take place later than 30 calendar days from sending the notification. The establishment of a contractual term of 3 days imposes on the consumer a more restrictive temporal obligation than that resulting from the legal regime, without the clause revealing the legal basis for such a derogation.
According to pct. 12.2.10. of the Contract, the creditor is entitled to declare termination in „other situations in which there has been a serious breach of the Contract by the Borrower;”.
However, the clause does not establish the concrete circumstances, criteria or threshold of seriousness based on which a breach can be qualified as „serious”.
Under these conditions, the consumer cannot anticipate, with sufficient clarity, the legal consequence of the non-performance of a certain obligation, namely the possibility of termination of the Contract.
Therefore, the generic use of the phrase “serious breach”, without establishing contractual criteria sufficiently clear for its determination, confers on the clause a non-transparent character and, under the conditions of art. 4 para. (2) and para. (3) of Law No. 256/2011, constitutes a basis for assessing it as abusive.
23. Regarding the breaches admitted by OCN “MOGO LOANS” SRL, established in light of the provisions of Law No. 202/2013, it should be stated that these non-conformities are of a nature to attract the creditor's contraventional liability.
At the same time, according to the provisions of the Contraventional Code, the attraction of contraventional liability is conditioned by compliance with the general limitation period, set at 12 months from the date the act was committed.
Considering that, from the date of signing the Contract, more than 12 months have passed, the limitation period provided by law has been exceeded.
Therefore, CNPF is legally unable to order the application of contraventional sanctions in this case.
For the reasons set out above, based on art. 4 para. (21) lit. c), art. 8 lit. t), art. 18 para. (3), art. 20 para. (1), para. (6) and para. (7) and art. 22 para. (3) of Law No. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market, Law No. 202/2013 on consumer credit contracts, Law No. 105/2003 on consumer protection, Law No. 256/2011 on abusive clauses in contracts concluded with consumers, the Civil Code, the Administrative Code and the Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision No. 57/11/2022),
1. It is found that OCN “MOGO LOANS” SRL failed to comply with art. 3, art. 10 para. (3) lit. g), art. 15 para. (1) and para. (4) lit. c), art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) and art. 20 para. (1) of Law No. 202/2013 on consumer credit contracts, as well as art. 869 para. (1) of the Civil Code (the version in force at the date of conclusion of the Contract).
2. The unlawful nature of the clauses in Credit Contract No. […] dated […], concluded between OCN “MOGO LOANS” SRL and Mr. […], contained in:
2.1. point 5.5., in the part concerning the text “[...] with 5 (five) working days in advance, [...]”;
2.2. point 6.4., according to which “The list of commissions, penalties and sanctions, as well as their effective amount, may be modified unilaterally by Mogo Loans, by placing them on the website: www.mogo.md and notifying the Borrower at least 30 calendar days in advance thereof by sending an SMS and/or e-mail to the latter. If the borrower does not appear at the Mogo Loans office within 20 calendar days from receipt of the notification in order to sign the updated List and, as the case may be, the new repayment schedule, it will be considered that the latter has accepted the new amount of the payments indicated above.”.
2.3. point 7.3., according to which, “If, upon receipt of the Borrower's notification regarding the exercise of the right of withdrawal, Mogo Loans has already paid
to the borrower the entire amount or a part of the loan, the Borrower is obliged, within at most 3 (three) calendar days from sending the notification of exercise of the right of withdrawal, to return to Mogo Loans without any unjustified delay the amounts received and the interest accrued for this period.”;
2.4. point 12.2.8., which establishes that “Third parties submit justified claims against the Borrower, the total amount of which exceeds 20% (twenty percent) of the total loan amount;”;
2.5. point 4 of Part I “Special provisions”, which provides that “The interest rate related to the loan constitutes “42%”.
3. The abusive nature of the clauses in Credit Contract No. […] dated […], concluded between OCN “MOGO LOANS” SRL and Mr. […], contained in:
3.1. point 2 of Part I “Special provisions”, according to which “Single loan interest (10.00% of the loan amount min. 5000 lei): 6 130,00 lei”;
3.2. point 4.3, which states that “The Borrower agrees to pay the Single loan interest by including it in the total loan amount, which is paid by the Borrower to the Lender according to the repayment schedule, it being included in the monthly loan payment installments”;
3.3. point 8.2, in the part concerning the text “[…] and the extension fee,”, as well as the text “The extension fee will be applied and charged to the Borrower only if the Borrower, by his request, has requested the extension of the maturity for a period longer than 30 days”;
3.4. point 8.5, in the part concerning the text “[…] the collection by Mogo Loans of the amount of the loan term extension fee [...]”.
4. The unlawful and abusive nature of the clause in Credit Contract No. […] dated […], concluded between OCN “MOGO LOANS” SRL and Mr. […] contained in point 10.2., according to which, “If, during the performance period of the Contract, the exchange rate established by the National Bank of Moldova for the Moldovan leu against EURO or USD changes, exceeding by more than 10 percent the rate established at the date of signing, Mogo Loans has the right to unilaterally revise any agreed payments, proportionally to the changed rate, notifying the client of the relevant changes by e-mail and/or SMS at the latest 30 days in advance”.
5. An action is submitted to the court of law, in order to request a finding of nullity of the illegal clauses indicated in point 2, of the abusive ones indicated in point 3, and of the illegal and abusive ones indicated in point 4.
6. Control over the execution of point 5 is entrusted to the Legal Department.
7. This Decision may be challenged by submitting a prior request to CNPF (MD-2012, mun. Chișinău, bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, nr. 77), within 30 days from the date of communication.
8. This Decision shall enter into force on the date of adoption, shall be communicated to the addressees in accordance with the legislation and shall be published on the official website of the CNPF (www.cnpf.md).
Dumitru BUDIANSCHI,
PRESIDENT
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“art.4 para.(21) of Law No.192/1998 on the National Commission of Financial Market”
More like this from NCFM
NCFM published 27 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Commission for Financial Markets Moldova — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added