Rule · PA-LAW · 26 Feb 1998
English translation of the Spanish text from superbancos.gob.pa (the Spanish text is the official one). Retrieved 2026-10-26.
BANKING LAW
INDEX SINGLE TEXT OF THE BANKING LAW Systematically ordered according to the provisions of article 277 of Decree Law No. 2-2008 (Executive Decree No. 52 of 2008)
TITLE I GENERAL RULES AND DEFINITIONS
Art. 1. Scope of Application
Art. 2. Exercise of the Banking Business
Art. 3. Definitions
TITLE II THE SUPERINTENDENCY OF BANKS
Chapter I Generalities
Art. 4. Superintendency of Banks
Art. 5. Objectives of the Superintendency
Art. 6. Functions of the Superintendency
Art. 7. Bodies of the Superintendency
Chapter II Board of Directors
Art. 8. Composition, Officers and Remuneration
Art. 9. Requirements to be a Director
Art. 10. Term of Office of the Directors
Art. 11.Attributions of the Board of Directors
Art. 12.Quorum and Decisions of the Board of Directors
Chapter III The Superintendent
Art. 13.Position of Superintendent
Art. 14.Requirements to be Superintendent
Art. 15.Functions of the Superintendent
Art. 16.Attributions of the Superintendent
Chapter IV Common Provisions
Art. 17.Removal
Art. 18.Grounds for Removal
Art. 19.Conflict of Interest
Art. 20.Presumption of Legality
Art. 21.Institutional Protection
Chapter V Banking Regulation and Supervision Fee
Art. 22.Banking Regulation Fee
Art. 23.Other Resources of the Superintendency
Chapter VI Banking Supervisor Career
Art. 24.Creation of the Banking Supervisor Career
Art. 25.Principles of the Career
Art. 26.Bodies of the Career
Art. 27.Career Committee
Art. 28.Career Officials
Art. 29. Acquisition of the Status of Career Official
Art. 30. Rights of Career Officials
Art. 31. Seniority Bonus
Art. 32.Policy and Procedures Manual
Art. 33.Job Description and Position Classification
Art. 34.Determination of Remuneration and Salary Scale
Art. 35.Motivation Policies or Programs
Art. 36.Performance Evaluation System
Art. 37.Training Policies for Officials or Institutional Strengthening
Art. 38.Termination of the Employment Relationship
Art. 39.Severance Pay for Dismissal without Just Cause
Art. 40.Clarification of Rules in Case of Contradiction
TITLE III OF THE BANKING REGIME
Chapter I Of the Authorizations
Art. 41.Banking Licenses
Art. 42.Validity of Banking Licenses Already Granted
Art. 43.Authorization or Prior No Objection
Art. 44.Use of the Word Bank
Art. 45.Exercise of the Banking Business without a License
Art. 46.Publication of Orders
Chapter II Procedure for the Granting of Licenses
Art. 47.License Application
Art. 48. Criteria for the Approval or Denial of Banking Licenses
Art. 49. Temporary Permit
Art. 50. Definitive License
Art. 51. Publicity of the License Application
Art. 52. Preliminary Authorization for International Banking Business
Art. 53. Attorneys of Branches of Foreign Banks
Art. 54. Continuity of Business
Art. 55. Corporate Governance
Chapter III Cancellation of Licenses
Art. 56 Grounds for Cancellation
Art. 57 Measures Following the Cancellation of License
Art. 58 Opening and Closing of Establishments
Chapter IV Banking Supervision
Art. 59. Banking Supervision
Art. 60. Supervision of Official Banks
Art. 61. Home Country Supervision
Art. 62. Host Country Supervision
Art. 63. Supervision of Non-Banking and Non-Financial Affiliates
Art. 64. Inspection by Foreign Supervisory Entities
Art. 65. Understanding with Foreign Supervisory Entities
Art. 66. Banking Inspections
Chapter V On Capital
Art. 67. Composition of Capital
Art. 68. Minimum Paid-in Capital
Art. 69. Capital Reserve
Art. 70. Capital Adequacy Ratios
Art. 71. Capital Adequacy for Internationally Licensed Banks
Art. 72. Assessment of Other Risks
Chapter VI On Bank Liquidity
Art. 73. Liquidity Requirements
Art. 74. Modifications to the Liquidity Percentage
Art. 75. Liquid Assets
Art. 76. Structure of Assets and Liabilities
Art. 77. Liquidity Reports
Art. 78. Relationship between Local Assets and Local Deposits
Chapter VII On Bank Interest
Art. 79. Interest Rates
Art. 80. Disclosure of the Effective Interest Rate
Chapter VIII External Auditors
Art. 81. Appointment of External Auditors
Art. 82. Report of the External Auditors
Art. 83. External Auditors Appointed by the Superintendency
Art. 84. Objection to External Auditors
Art. 85. Inclusion of Banking Groups
Chapter IX Documents and Reports
Art. 86. Right to Request Information from Banks or Banking Groups.
Art. 87. Submission of Audited Financial Statements
Art. 88. Publication and Display of Audited Financial Statements
Art. 89. Submission of Unaudited Financial Statements
Art. 90. Integrity of Audited Financial Statements
Art. 91. Other Reports
Art. 92. Publication of Information
Art. 93. Information on Liabilities
Chapter X Prohibitions and Limitations
Art. 94. Prohibition of Guarantee with Own Shares
Art. 95. Concentration in a Single Person
Art. 96. Concentration in Related Parties
Art. 97. Exception on Loans to Other Banks
Art. 98. Economic Groups
Art. 99. Limitation on the Participation of a Bank in Other Companies
Art. 100. Exceptions to the Limits on Participation in Other Companies
Art. 101. Prohibition on the Purchase or Lease of Real Estate
Art. 102. Prohibition on Taking Deposits
Art. 103. Mergers and Acquisitions
Art. 104. Scope of the Prohibitions and Limitations
Art. 105. Loans with Pledging of Deposits
Chapter XI Incompatibilities
Art. 106. Incompatibilities of Accountants
Art. 107. Disqualification of Directors or Managers of Banks.
Art. 108. Disqualification from Acting as Director, Officer or Administrator of a Bank
Art. 109. Notification of Judicial Proceedings to the Superintendency
Chapter XII Right to Confidentiality
Art. 110. Administrative Confidentiality
Art. 111. Banking Confidentiality
Chapter XIII Prevention of the Crime of Money Laundering, Financing of Terrorism and Related Crimes
Art. 112. Prevention of Crimes
Art. 113. Provision of Information
Art. 114. Know Your Customer and Know Your Employee Policy
Chapter XIV Voluntary Liquidation
Art. 115. Prior Authorization
Art. 116. Requirements for Voluntary Liquidation
Art. 117. Publication
Art. 118. Cessation of Operations
Art. 119. Appointment of the Liquidator
Art. 120. Prohibition on Distribution of Assets
Art. 121. Obligations of the Liquidator
Art. 122. End of the Voluntary Liquidation
Art. 123. Unclaimed Goods and Securities
Chapter XV Corrective Measures
Art. 124. Advisor
Art. 125. Powers
Art. 126. Period of the Advisor
Art. 127. Periodic Reports
Art. 128. Final Report
Art. 129. Evaluation of the Advisor's Recommendation
Art. 130. Application of Corrective Measures
Chapter XVI Administrative and Operational Control of the Bank
Art. 131. Taking of Administrative and Operational Control
Art. 132. Grounds
Art. 133. Appointment and Period of the Interim Administrator
Art. 134. Notice and Notification of the Taking of Administrative and Operational Control
Art. 135. Means of Challenge to the Resolution that Decrees the Taking of Administrative and Operational Control
Art. 136. Powers of the Interim Administrator
Art. 137. Suspension of Terms
Art. 138. Prohibition of Sequestration, Attachment or Retention
Art. 139. Expenses of the Taking of Administrative Control
Art. 140. Termination of Administrative Control
Chapter XVII Reorganization of the Bank
Art. 141. Reorganization
Art. 142. Approval of the Reorganization
Art. 143. Notice of the Reorganization
Art. 144. Notification of the Reorganization Order
Art. 145. Powers of the Reorganizer
Art. 146. Reorganization Plan and Reports
Art. 147. Publication and Mandatory Nature of the Reorganization Plan.
Art. 148. Merger, Consolidation or Sale of the Bank
Art. 149. Disqualifications and Suspension of Terms
Art. 150. Prohibition of Sequestration, Attachment or Retention
Art. 151. Means of Challenge
Art. 152. Expenses of the Reorganization
Art. 153. Termination of the Reorganization State
Chapter XVIII Forced Liquidation
Art. 154. Liquidation Order
Art. 155. Appointment of the Liquidator or the Liquidation Board
Art. 156. Notice of Forced Liquidation
Art. 157. Notification of the Forced Liquidation Order
Art. 158. Challenge to the Liquidation Order
Art. 159. Suspension of Terms
Art. 160. Suspension of Interest
Art. 161. Payment of Primary Deposits and Other Obligations
Art. 162. Appearance of Depositors and Other Creditors at the Liquidation
Art. 163. Preliminary Report
Art. 164. Resolution on Objections
Art. 165. Liquidation Estate
Art. 166. Debts of the Estate
Art. 167. Order of Priority
Art. 168. Powers of the Liquidator or the Liquidation Board
Art. 169. Authorization of the Trust
Art. 170. Obligations of the Trustee
Art. 171. Non-Application of Securities Legislation
Art. 172. Cessation of the Liquidator or the Liquidation Board
Art. 173. Resumption of the Liquidation Process
Art. 174. Termination of Contracts
Art. 175. Stay of Proceedings
Art. 176. Obligations Secured by Pledge, Mortgage or Other Rights in Rem
Art. 177. Financial Leasing
Art. 178. Dissolution of the Bank
Art. 179. Precautionary Measures or Attachments
Art. 180. Appeal Before the Superintendency
Art. 181. Inadmissibility of Bankruptcy
Art. 182. Applicable Legal Rules
Art. 183. Costs
TITLE IV ON SANCTIONS
Art. 184. Criteria for Imposition of Sanctions
Art. 185. Fines
Art. 186. Generic Sanctions
Art. 187. Progressive Fines
Art. 188. Sanctions
Art. 189. Publicity of Sanctions
Art. 190. Administrative Procedure
Art. 191. Officials of the Superintendency
TITLE V BANKING CLIENT
Chapter I Principles
Art. 192. Principles
Art. 193. Obligations of Banks
Art. 194. Rights of Banking Clients
Chapter II Banking Contracts and Documents
Art. 195. Review of Models of Banking Contracts
Art. 196. Written Contracts
Art. 197. Blank Documents
TITLE VI BANKING CONSUMER PROTECTION
Chapter I General Provisions
Art. 198. Special Rules and Jurisdiction
Art. 199. Banking Consumer
Chapter II On Information
Art. 200. Provision of Information
Chapter III On Nullities
Art. 201. Nullity of Clauses in Adhesion Contracts
Art. 202. Nullity of Contractual Clauses
Art. 203. Grounds for Relative Nullity
Art. 204. Declaration of Nullity
Art. 205. Jurisdiction for Declaration of Nullity
Chapter IV On Claims
Art. 206. Claims Attention System
Art. 207. Rights and Obligations
Art. 208. Jurisdiction and Competence
Art. 209. Exceptions to Competence
Art. 210. Resolution of Claims
Art. 211. Claims Before the Superintendency
Art. 212. Banking Services Arbitration
Art. 213. Supplementary Rule
TITLE VII MISCELLANEOUS AND FINAL PROVISIONS
Art. 214. Days of Closing of Operations
Art. 215. Inactive Assets
Art. 216. Restitution of Funds
Art. 217. Unity of the Bank
Art. 218. Immunity of Accounts
Art. 219. Designation of Beneficiaries in Deposit Accounts
Art. 220. Deposits in Banks of International License
Art. 221. Creditors of Branches in Panama
Art. 222. Submission to Panamanian Legislation and Jurisdiction
Art. 223. Sequestration or Attachment Against Assets of Banks
Art. 224. Resources
Art. 225. Special Fiscal Period
Art. 226. References to the National Banking Commission
Art. 227. Validity of Banking Agreements
Art. 228. Microfinance
REPUBLIC OF PANAMA SINGLE TEXT OF THE BANKING LAW (DECREE LAW 9 OF 26 FEBRUARY 1998 AMENDED BY DECREE LAW 2 OF 22 FEBRUARY 2008, SYSTEMATICALLY ORDERED AS A SINGLE TEXT THROUGH EXECUTIVE DECREE 52 OF 2008)
THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC, in use of his constitutional and legal powers,
TITLE I GENERAL RULES AND DEFINITIONS
ARTICLE 1. SCOPE OF APPLICATION. This Decree Law shall apply to:
This Decree Law shall apply to:
1. Banks or any person who carries out the business of banking in or from the Republic of Panama.
2. Banking groups, as defined in this Decree Law and in the rules issued for its implementation.
3. Representation offices.
4. The non-banking or non-financial affiliates referred to in article 63 of this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 2. EXERCISE OF THE BUSINESS OF BANKING. Only those who have obtained the respective banking license may carry out the business of banking in or from the Republic of Panama.
Persons of Public Law whom the laws authorize for such purpose may also carry out the business of banking in or from the Republic of Panama.
PARAGRAPH. All persons are prohibited from capturing, in or from the Republic of Panama, directly or indirectly, public resources through the acceptance of money in deposit or any other modalities, unless: (a) they have a license or authorization for the activity issued by a competent authority or regulatory entity by law, or (b) they engage in capture activities that are expressly exempt by law from the requirement of license, regulation or authorization.
In relation to these cases, the Superintendency shall have the same powers and may follow the procedures established in article 45 of this Decree Law, without prejudice to the application of the corresponding sanctions.
ARTICLE 3. DEFINITIONS. For the purposes of this Decree Law, the following terms shall be understood as follows:
1. Productive asset. One that generates income regularly, regardless of where it is located, as provided by the Superintendency of Banks.
2. Agreement. Any decision of general application adopted by the Board of Directors of the Superintendency for the development of policies or the interpretation or setting of the scope of the provisions contained in this Decree Law.
3. Non-banking affiliate. Non-banking or non-financial company, associated with the economic group of which a banking group, a bank or an owner of bank shares is part.
4. Bank. Any person who carries out the business of banking or who acts as a representation office.
5. Foreign bank. Branch or subsidiary of a bank or of an owner of bank shares, whose head office is located outside the Republic of Panama.
6. Panamanian bank. One whose head office is located in the Republic of Panama.
7. Official bank. State-owned bank that carries out the business of banking.
8. Assigned capital. Capital funds that a foreign bank allocates or assigns to a branch in Panama.
9. Primary capital. The one composed of paid-in share capital, declared reserves and retained earnings.
10. Secondary capital. The one composed of undeclared reserves, revaluation reserves, general loan loss reserves, hybrid capital and debt instruments and term subordinated debt.
11. Tertiary capital. The one composed exclusively of short-term subordinated debt to cover market risk.
12. Career. Career of the Banking Supervisor.
13. Circular. The one issued by the Superintendent, addressed to banks established in Panama, and which conveys instructions for compliance with regulations.
14. Competence. It is the continuous demonstration of possessing the aptitude required to efficiently and effectively perform a public office in the Superintendency, in accordance with the characteristics contained in the institution's descriptive position manual.
15. Bank adhesion contract. The one whose clauses have been established unilaterally by the bank, without the client being able to negotiate its content at the time of contracting.
16. Days. Calendar days, unless expressly provided otherwise.
17. Foreign supervisory entity. Authority abroad with functions equivalent to the Superintendency of Banks.
18. Establishment. Any office, branch or agency through which a bank conducts the banking business. Excluded from this definition are those equipment, machines, systems, offices or dependencies expressly defined by the Superintendency.
19. Financial statements. The balance sheet, the profit and loss statement, the statement of changes in equity, the statement of cash flows and notes that include the most important accounting policies and other explanatory notes.
20. Evaluation. Action and effect of assessing the characteristics and performance of the officials of the Superintendency or those who aspire to be such.
21. Secured credit facility. The one that at any time is secured by a value equal to or greater than the amount owed.
22. Unsecured credit facility. The one that, at the time of its evaluation, does not enjoy any guarantee.
23. Partially secured credit facility. The one that, at any time, is backed by guarantees less than the amount owed. The Superintendency shall determine what constitutes a guarantee for the purposes of numerals 21, 22 and 23 of this article and how to establish its valuation.
24. Capital funds. The one constituted by the primary capital, secondary capital and tertiary capital of a bank.
25. Official. Public servant in the service of the Superintendency of Banks.
26. Banking group. The one constituted by a bank share owner and its subsidiaries of any level whose predominant activities consist of providing services in the banking or financial sector, including the non-banking subsidiaries of the latter that, in the judgment of the Superintendency, operate under common management, whether through this bank share owner or through different participations or agreements.
27. Economic group. Set of natural or legal persons, of any nationality or jurisdiction, whose interests are related to each other in such a way that, in the judgment of the Superintendency, they must be considered as if they were a single person.
28. Interest. Sum or sums that, in any form or under any name, are charged or paid for the use of money.
29. Board of Directors. Board of Directors of the Superintendency.
30. Banking business. Mainly, the raising of resources from the public or from financial institutions, through the acceptance of money in deposit or by any other means indicated by the Superintendency or banking practices, and the use of such resources for the account and risk of the bank, to grant loans, make investments or any other operation defined for these purposes by the Superintendency.
31. Accounting standards. Those adopted by the Superintendency as a general rule that banks must follow in their accounting.
32. Technical and prudential standards. Those issued by the Superintendency to ensure the soundness and efficiency of the banking system.
33. Representative office. The office of a bank that promotes, from the Republic of Panama, the banking business, without conducting it.
34. Bank share owner. Natural or legal person that, directly or indirectly, is predominantly the owner of shares of a bank or that exercises, in the judgment of the Superintendency, control of its administration.
35. Capital reserve. The one constituted by funds from profits that are accumulated in the books of the banks and that are destined to strengthen their financial situation.
36. Resolution. Decision adopted by the Superintendent or by the Board of Directors, in exercise of the powers conferred by this Decree Law, applicable to a particular case.
37. Merit system. Labor regime based on a performance evaluation system, whose purpose is to promote the competence, stability and productivity of the personnel required for the efficient operation of the Superintendency.
38. Subsidiary. Legal entity wholly or majority-owned by a bank or by a bank share owner. Legal entities with respect to which the bank acts as trustee are excepted from this definition.
39. Branch. Establishment of a bank that forms an integral part of it, without its own legal personality.
40. Superintendency. The Superintendency of Banks of Panama.
41. Superintendent. The Superintendent of Banks.
TITLE II THE SUPERINTENDENCY OF BANKS
CHAPTER I GENERAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 4 1 . SUPERINTENDENCY OF BANKS. The Superintendency of Banks is created as an autonomous body of the State, with legal personality, its own patrimony and administrative, budgetary and financial independence. It shall have exclusive competence to regulate and supervise banks, the banking business and other entities and activities assigned to it by other laws.
In order to guarantee its autonomy, it is established that the Superintendency:
1. Shall have funds separate and independent from the Central Government, which it shall administer exclusively with full freedom and autonomy.
2. Shall approve its revenue and expenditure budget, to be subsequently incorporated into the General State Budget.
3. Shall establish its organic and administrative structure with the power to choose, appoint and dismiss its personnel, as well as to set their remuneration and benefits.
4. Shall act independently in the exercise of its functions and shall be subject to the oversight of the Comptroller General of the Republic, as established by the Political Constitution of the Republic and this Decree Law. This oversight shall not in any way imply interference in the administrative powers of the Superintendency.
5. Shall not be subject to the payment of national taxes, duties, fees, charges, contributions or tributes, with the exception of social security and educational insurance quotas, occupational risks, fees for public services and import tax.
6. Shall enjoy the guarantees and immunities established in favor of the State and public entities.
1 By Judgment of 11 June 2014, the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Justice declared unconstitutional the expression “Shall not be subject to the payment of national taxes, duties, fees, charges, contributions or tributes” (G.O. 27731-A of 3 March 2015).
ARTICLE 5. OBJECTIVES OF THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The objectives of the Superintendency are:
1. To ensure the soundness and efficiency of the banking system.
2. To strengthen and foster conditions conducive to the development of the Republic of Panama as an international financial center.
3. To promote public confidence in the banking system.
4. To ensure the legal balance between the banking system and its clients.
ARTICLE 6. FUNCTIONS OF THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The functions of the Superintendency are:
1. To ensure that banks maintain appropriate solvency and liquidity ratios to meet their obligations, as well as adequate procedures that allow the supervision and control of their national and international activities, in close collaboration with foreign supervisory entities, if applicable.
2. To develop the provisions of the banking regime. When said function is exercised by the Board of Directors, it shall be by agreement, and when exercised by the Superintendent, by resolution.
3. To impose the corresponding sanctions on those who engage in the banking business without being duly authorized.
4. To exercise the functions assigned to it by this Decree Law or by other laws.
ARTICLE 7. ORGANS OF THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The Superintendency shall have a Board of Directors and a Superintendent, appointed by the Executive Branch.
The appointment of the directors and of the Superintendent is not subject to the ratification by the Legislative Branch established by Law 3 of 1987.
CHAPTER II BOARD OF DIRECTORS
ARTICLE 8 2 . COMPOSITION, OFFICERS AND REMUNERATION. The Board of Directors shall act as the highest body for consultation, regulation and setting of general policies of the Superintendency. It shall be composed of seven directors with the right to speak and vote.
Five of the members of the Board of Directors shall be elected in accordance with the requirements set forth in article 9 and, from among them, a president and a secretary shall be elected, who shall hold office for a term of one year. Said term may be extended for an equal period.
The other two directors shall be designated by the Boards of Directors of the Superintendency of the Securities Market and of the Superintendency of Insurance and Reinsurance, respectively, from among their own members, for a term of two years, extendable.
The directors shall not receive remuneration or representation expenses, except for per diem allowances set by the Executive Branch for their attendance at meetings or for their participation in official missions.
PARAGRAPH. Directors in office at the date of entry into force of the Law that modifies this article shall remain in their positions until the expiration of the period for which they were designated.
ARTICLE 9. REQUIREMENTS TO BE A DIRECTOR. To be a member of the Board of Directors, the following is required:
1. To be a Panamanian citizen.
2. Not to have been convicted by a competent authority for an intentional crime.
2 Amended by article 116 of Law No. 67 of 1 September 2011 “Which establishes the System of Interinstitutional Coordination and Cooperation among Financial Oversight Entities, creates the Superintendency of the Securities Market and amends, among others, articles of the Banking Law, of Decree Law 1 of 1999 and of Law 10 of 1993” and article 284 of Law No. 12 of 3 April 2012 “which regulates the insurance activity and issues other provisions”.
3. Not be related to each other or to the Superintendent, up to the fourth degree of consanguinity or second degree of affinity, nor be the spouse of another director or of the Superintendent.
4. Not hold a full-time public office, except that of professor at university centers.
5. Hold a university degree and have a minimum of ten years' experience in the banking, financial or other related sector.
6. Not have been disqualified by the Superintendency or by the National Banking Commission from serving as a banking officer.
7. Not have been judicially declared bankrupt or in creditors' proceedings, or be in a state of manifest insolvency.
8. Not be a practicing banker, nor a bank director, nor a director of a bank shareholding owner, nor a shareholder who directly or indirectly holds more than five percent of the shares of a bank or of a bank shareholding owner.
ARTICLE 10. TERM OF OFFICE OF DIRECTORS. Directors shall serve their terms for a period of eight years, extendable, only once, for an equal period.
The appointment of directors shall be made in such a way as to ensure, at all times, their staggered renewal. In the event of early termination of a director's term, their replacement shall be appointed for the remainder of the corresponding period.
TRANSITORY PARAGRAPH. Directors in office at the time this Decree Law enters into force shall remain in office for the period for which they were appointed.
ARTICLE 11. POWERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS. The Board of Directors shall have the following powers:
I. Technical in Nature:
1. Approve general rules for the identification, regulation and consolidated supervision of banks and banking groups.
2. Approve generally applicable rules for the definition and identification of credits to clients related to each other or related to banks or banking groups.
3. Approve the general criteria for the classification of risk assets and the guidelines for the establishment of reserves to cover risks.
4. Approve generally applicable rules for the suspension of interest accrual, in accordance with internationally accepted criteria.
5. Establish, in the administrative sphere, the interpretation and scope of legal or regulatory provisions on banking matters.
6. Establish the rules for conducting the inspections prescribed by this Decree Law or ordered by the Superintendency itself to banks or banking groups, as the case may be.
7. Establish accounting requirements in relation to the financial information that banks must provide and approve the chart of accounts for banking use.
8. Establish the general rules that banks must follow in their accounting.
9. Modify the banking regulation and supervision fee, including the maximum amounts established, by the affirmative vote of four of its members.
10. Issue the technical rules necessary for compliance with this Decree Law.
11. Exercise the other powers assigned to it by this Decree Law.
II. Administrative in Nature:
1. Approve the general guidelines, goals and objectives of the Superintendency.
2. Approve the draft annual budget of the Superintendency submitted for its consideration by the Superintendent, for the corresponding constitutional procedure.
3. Approve the administrative organizational structure of the Superintendency and its functions, as well as review them, when it deems pertinent.
4. Resolve appeals filed against the resolutions of the Superintendent.
5. Approve performance bonus programs for the officials of the Superintendency or any other incentive that promotes their productivity.
6. Approve the internal work rules, as well as the code of ethics and conduct and the internal regulations of the Superintendency.
7. Approve the direct contracting required by the Superintendency, for amounts greater than thirty thousand balboas and less than one hundred thousand balboas, in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law and pursuant to the grounds for exception to the contractor selection procedure provided in the Public Procurement Law and its regulations on said procedure.
8. Issue the administrative rules necessary for the fulfillment of the functions and powers of the Superintendency.
9. Assist exclusively with the Executive Branch, if necessary, to adopt a single and comprehensive regulation of this Decree Law or other legal provisions to regulate the banking system.
10. Exercise the other powers assigned to it by this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 12 3 . QUORUM AND DECISIONS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS. To constitute a quorum at Board of Directors meetings, the presence of at least four directors is required.
Decisions of the Board of Directors shall be adopted with the affirmative vote of at least four directors, except in those cases specifically established in this Decree Law.
When, due to a conflict of interest, one or more directors are prevented from voting, the decision shall be adopted with the affirmative vote of the majority of the directors not prevented from voting.
CHAPTER III THE SUPERINTENDENT
ARTICLE 13 4 . OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT. The Superintendent shall be the legal representative of the Superintendency and shall be responsible for the administration and management of its daily operations. They shall serve as a full-time public official and shall be remunerated with a salary, in accordance with what the Executive Branch provides for that purpose. The term of office of the Superintendent shall be five years, extendable only once, and they shall take office starting on January 1 after the beginning of each ordinary presidential term.
The Superintendent may participate with the right to speak at meetings of the Board of Directors, except when matters are discussed that, in the judgment of the Board, should be discussed without their presence.
In the event of the early termination of the Superintendent's term, their replacement shall be appointed for the remainder of the corresponding period.
In the absence of the Superintendent, the legal representation of the Superintendency shall fall to the president of the Board of Directors. In the event of the temporary absence of the Superintendent, the Board of Directors may appoint an interim Superintendent.
TRANSITORY PARAGRAPH. The Superintendent in office at the time the Law amending this article enters into force shall remain in office until 31 December 2014.
ARTICLE 14. REQUIREMENTS TO BE SUPERINTENDENT. To be Superintendent, the following is required:
3 Amended by article 117 of Law No. 67 of 1 September 2011 "Which establishes the System of Interinstitutional Coordination and Cooperation among Financial Supervision Entities, creates the Superintendency of the Securities Market and amends, among others, articles of the Banking Law, of Decree Law 1 of 1999 and of Law 10 of 1993".
4 Amended by article 118 of Law No. 67 of 1 September 2011 "Which establishes the System of Interinstitutional Coordination and Cooperation among Financial Supervision Entities, creates the Superintendency of the Securities Market and amends, among others, articles of the Banking Law, of Decree Law 1 of 1999 and of Law 10 of 1993" .
1. Be a Panamanian citizen.
2. Not have been convicted by a competent authority for an intentional crime.
3. Not be related by kinship to the members of the Board of Directors within the fourth degree of consanguinity or second degree of affinity, nor be the spouse of any of the directors.
4. Hold a university degree and have held executive or managerial positions in the banking, financial, commercial or other related sector, public or private, for a minimum of ten years.
5. Not be a practicing banker, director of a bank or of a bank shareholding owner, or a shareholder who, directly or indirectly, holds more than five percent of the shares of a bank or of a bank shareholding owner.
6. Not have been disqualified by the Superintendency or by the National Banking Commission from serving as a banking officer.
7. Not have been declared bankrupt or in creditors' composition proceedings by a court, or be in a state of manifest insolvency.
ARTICLE 15. FUNCTIONS OF THE SUPERINTENDENT. The Superintendent shall comply with and execute the agreements and resolutions adopted by the Board of Directors, and shall ensure that the rules and policies established in banking matters are complied with.
Likewise, they may propose to the Board of Directors that it take the decisions that correspond to it.
ARTICLE 16. POWERS OF THE SUPERINTENDENT. The Superintendent shall have the following powers:
I. Technical in Nature:
1. Approve the granting of temporary permits and banking licenses.
2. Authorize the closure or relocation of establishments, as well as the opening abroad of branches or subsidiaries of Panamanian banks or foreign banks operating in Panama.
3. Authorize the voluntary liquidation of banks.
4. Order the taking of administrative control, reorganization and forced liquidation of banks, in the cases established in this Decree Law.
5. Order the cancellation of banking licenses.
6. Authorize the merger and consolidation of banks, of bank shareholding owners and of the banking groups of which they form part.
7. Authorize the acquisition or transfer of shares of banks, of bank shareholding owners or of banking groups when, by virtue thereof, the acquirer or other persons related to them become their total or majority owners or acquire control, as defined by the Superintendency.
8. Publish or order the publication of the financial statements of banks with the frequency and content it deems appropriate.
9. Instruct banks to remove their directors, officers or executives if, in its judgment, there are grounds for doing so.
10. Issue certifications related to the existence and activities of banks, based on the information on record at the Superintendency.
11. Supervise banks in accordance with this Decree Law and the rules implementing it, as well as with internationally accepted rules and criteria that fall within the Panamanian banking legal framework.
12. Conduct consolidated supervision of banking groups in the manner established by this Decree Law and the Board of Directors.
13. Carry out the inspections ordered by this Decree Law, by the Board of Directors and those it considers necessary or prudent.
14. Establish prevention programs that allow an understanding of the financial situation of banks, as well as verify the truthfulness of the information that banks send to the Superintendency.
15. Appoint advisors, supervisors or administrators in those banks that should be subject to special attention by the Superintendency.
16. Impose the corresponding sanctions for violation of the rules of this Decree Law or of the agreements implementing it.
17. Authorize amendments to the articles of incorporation of banks.
18. Adopt measures to prevent or correct irregularities or faults in the operations of banks that, in its judgment, could endanger the interests of their depositors, the stability of the bank or the soundness of the banking system.
19. Ensure that banks provide their clients with information that ensures the greatest transparency in banking operations.
20. Establish cooperation links with foreign supervisory entities to strengthen control mechanisms, update preventive regulations and exchange information useful for the exercise of the supervisory function.
21. Establish cooperation links with public institutions or private institutions of a trade or educational nature.
22. Evaluate the financial indicators of banks and banking groups that allow monitoring of the main banking risks, such as capital adequacy, credit, liquidity, operational, market and others that the Superintendency deems appropriate.
23. Assist with the efforts of the competent public agencies to eradicate practices of unfair competition or that limit free competition in the banking market.
24. Issue the rules that, within the scope of the activities permitted by this Decree Law or laws that complement it, banks must observe so that their operations are conducted within adequate risk levels, including the ability to set limits and ratios that banks must observe in their operations.
25. Issue the necessary circulars on instructions for compliance with this Decree Law and the rules that develop it.
26. Order inspections of persons who there is reason to suppose are engaging or intend to engage in the banking business without authorization, as well as order the takeover of their operations, the suspension of such operations or the closure of the establishments involved.
27. Resolve all technical matters that are not expressly reserved to the Board of Directors or another authority.
28. Execute the other duties assigned by this Decree Law.
II. Administrative in Nature:
1. Acquire the goods and contract the services necessary for the proper functioning of the Superintendency and to execute or carry out the functions entrusted to it by this Decree Law and its regulations.
2. Prepare the draft annual budget, the annual report of the activities and projects of the Superintendency and submit them to the consideration of the Board of Directors.
3. Set the salaries, salary scale and other emoluments, as well as select, appoint, transfer, promote, grant leave and dismiss the employees and officials of the Superintendency and apply the corresponding disciplinary sanctions to them.
4. Ensure the execution and efficient administration of the annual budget of the Superintendency.
5. Approve the direct contracting required by the Superintendency, for amounts less than thirty thousand balboas, in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law and in accordance with the grounds for exception to the contractor selection procedure provided for in the Public Procurement Law and its regulations on said procedure.
6. Designate the days of suspension or mandatory provision of public services.
7. Present to the Board of Directors the unaudited financial statements of the Superintendency, within two months following the close of the first half of each fiscal year.
8. Present to the Board of Directors the financial statements of the Superintendency duly audited by independent authorized public accountants, within three months following the close of each fiscal year.
9. Delegate functions, subject to the decisions and guidelines of the Board of Directors, to officials of the Superintendency.
10. Present to the Board of Directors an annual report of activities.
11. Resolve all administrative matters that are not expressly reserved to the Board of Directors or another authority.
12. Prepare and submit, for approval by the Board of Directors, proposals for agreements, decisions and administrative reforms that it requests, including, among others, but not limited to, the Banking Supervisor Career regime and the internal regulations of the Superintendency.
13. Execute the other duties assigned by this Decree Law.
CHAPTER IV COMMON PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 17. REMOVAL. Directors and the Superintendent may only be removed from their positions for the grounds established in this Decree Law, according to a decision of the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice and in accordance with the process established in the Judicial Code. The Executive Branch and the Board of Directors are legitimized to request removal.
ARTICLE 18. GROUNDS FOR REMOVAL. The Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice may order the removal of a member of the Board of Directors or of the Superintendent who incurs any of the following grounds:
1. Permanent incapacity to perform their duties.
2. Declaration of bankruptcy or creditors' composition or a state of manifest insolvency.
3. Failure to meet the requirements established for their selection as director or Superintendent.
4. Lack of probity in the exercise of their functions.
5. Repeated and unjustified absence from meetings of the Board of Directors.
6. Breach of the obligations and prohibitions imposed by this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 19. CONFLICT OF INTERESTS. When matters are discussed at meetings of the Board of Directors in which a director or the Superintendent could have conflicts of interests, said director or the Superintendent must refrain from participating in the meeting. In the absence of voluntary abstention, the Board of Directors may formally request the director or the Superintendent, as the case may be, to refrain from participating in the meeting and, therefore, in the decision.
ARTICLE 20. PRESUMPTION OF LEGALITY. The actions of the members of the Board of Directors, of the Superintendent and the delegates of the latter, in the exercise of their functions and powers, enjoy the presumption of legality, diligence and good faith. No lawsuit against them, for their actions, will entail their separation from office until the case is decided.
ARTICLE 21. INSTITUTIONAL PROTECTION. The members of the Board of Directors, the Superintendent and his delegates, as well as any other official authorized by the Board of Directors by reasoned resolution, shall have the right for the Superintendency to cover the expenses and costs necessary for their defense, when they are subject to actions, proceedings, lawsuits or claims, derived from acts and decisions adopted in accordance with this Decree Law and in the exercise of their powers, functions or obligations.
The institutional protection referred to in this article shall apply to said officials for acts performed in the exercise of their positions, even after they have ceased their functions.
If the official is found responsible for the act or fact imputed to him, he must reimburse the Superintendency for the expenses it incurred for his defense.
The Superintendency shall be subrogated in the rights of the defendant or accused for the recovery of expenses and costs.
The Board of Directors shall establish and provide what is necessary for the faithful compliance with the provisions of this article.
CAPÍTULO V TASA DE REGULACIÓN Y SUPERVISIÓN BANCARIA
ARTÍCULO 22 5 . TASA DE REGULACIÓN BANCARIA. Create the banking regulation and supervision fee in favor of the Superintendency. Banks shall be subject to the annual payment of said fee according to the following tariff:
1. Banks with a general license: Thirty thousand balboas (B/.30,000.00) plus a sum equivalent to thirty-five (B/.35.00) balboas for each million balboas (B/.1,000,000.00) or fraction of total assets, the latter sum up to a maximum amount of one hundred thousand balboas (B/.100,000.00).
2. Banks with an international license: Fifteen thousand balboas (B/.15,000.00).
3. Banks with a representation license: Five thousand balboas (B/.5,000.00).
The amount of the fee must bear a strict relationship to the costs that the Superintendency must incur to fulfill its functions in a rational and efficient manner in accordance with its budget. For this purpose, the Superintendency may, at its discretion, increase or reduce the amount of the applicable fee.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if at the end of a budget year there are balances from the payment of the fee, the Superintendent shall transfer said balances to a special account, which must be used to cover the expenses corresponding to subsequent years. If balances exist during two consecutive budget periods, the Superintendency must reduce the fee in the manner it deems appropriate, so that in subsequent years such balances are not caused.
ARTICLE 23. OTHER RESOURCES OF THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The Superintendency shall also have the following resources:
1. The amount of inspection fees and other special services, which shall be paid by banks and other supervised entities.
2. Donations and legacies accepted.
3. The goods and rights it possesses, acquires or receives by any title.
4. The fruits and income generated by its goods.
5. Other income obtained for any reason.
CAPÍTULO VI CARRERA DEL SUPERVISOR BANCARIO
ARTICLE 24. CREATION OF THE BANK SUPERVISOR CAREER SERVICE. The Bank Supervisor Career Service is created, which shall be developed through a human resources administration system to structure, on the basis of merit and efficiency, the rules, procedures and compensation plan applicable to the public servants in the service of the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 25. PRINCIPLES OF THE CAREER SERVICE. The primary objectives of the Career Service are:
1. To guarantee that the administration of the human resources of the Superintendency is strictly based on the effective and efficient performance of the official, on their comprehensive professional development and on remuneration adequate to the needs and financial reality of the Superintendency.
2. To guarantee fair treatment of officials, without any discrimination on grounds of race, birth, disability, social class, sex, religion or political ideas.
3. To guarantee equal promotion opportunities.
4. To achieve an increase in the efficiency of the officials and of the Superintendency.
5 By Judgment of 11 June 2014, the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Justice declared this article unconstitutional. (G.O 27731-A of 3 March 2015). However, by Resolution of 7 November 2014 of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Justice, it warned of the full validity and legal force of article 20 of Law No. 97 of 21 December 1998, as long as it is not repealed by the National Assembly or declared unconstitutional.
5. To guarantee within the service of the Superintendency a work environment free of political pressures and fears.
6. To promote diversity and the free flow of ideas that allows for upright officials, aware of their role in the service of society, and guarantees the adequate competitiveness of the Superintendency.
7. To promote the entry and retention of officials distinguished by their suitability, competence, loyalty and integrity, qualities necessary to hold positions within the Superintendency.
In the event that any rule of this Chapter is not clear, it shall be interpreted on the basis of these principles and according to the definitions established in this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 26. BODIES OF THE CAREER SERVICE. The superior bodies of the Bank Supervisor Career Service are:
1. The Board of Directors, which shall be the competent instance to adopt the provisions, internal work regulations, manuals and policies necessary to implement the rules of the Bank Supervisor Career Service.
2. El Superintendente.
3. The Human Resources Directorate of the Superintendency.
PARÁGRAFO. The Board of Directors shall function as the regulatory body, and the remaining instances shall function as the executive body of the human resources policies of the Superintendency established in this Chapter, and shall adjust their actions to the provisions of the Political Constitution, those of this Decree Law and the internal regulations and policies issued for its development.
ARTICLE 27. CAREER COMMITTEE. The following are attributions of the Board of Directors, acting as the Career Committee:
1. To act as an advisory body to the executive organs of the Career in matters concerning the application and development of this Decree Law.
2. To resolve in second instance the appeals filed against sanctions of career officials.
PARAGRAPH. The functioning of the Career Committee shall be developed through a resolution adopted by the Board of Directors.
ARTICLE 28. CAREER OFFICIALS. They are those who have entered or will enter in the future the Banking Supervisor Career, according to the procedures established in this
Chapter.
The Superintendent is not a career official.
ARTICLE 29. ACQUISITION OF THE STATUS OF CAREER OFFICIAL. The official who enters the Superintendency in accordance with the recruitment and selection rules established in this Chapter and in the rules adopted to implement the Career shall acquire the status of career official as soon as he completes a probationary period of no less than two continuous years, with a satisfactory evaluation.
The selection procedures shall be designed, at least, based on professional competence, academic preparation, experience and morals, aspects that shall be verified through valid measurement instruments, previously prepared and approved in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter.
Those persons who at the time of the promulgation of this Decree Law are officials of the Superintendency shall be accredited as career officials, provided they have at least
two continuous years of working for the Superintendency and, upon prior evaluation, meet all the requirements and the profile required for the position they hold.
ARTICLE 30. RIGHTS OF CAREER OFFICIALS. Career officials have the rights established in this Chapter, in the internal regulations of the Superintendency and principally, but not exclusively, the following:
1. Stability in their position.
2. Promotions and transfers.
3. Seniority bonus.
4. Leave with or without pay.
5. Compensation for dismissal without just cause.
The stability of career officials is conditioned on effective, productive, honest, agile and responsible performance, as well as equal, impartial and respectful attention to users and citizens.
ARTICLE 31. SENIORITY BONUS. Career officials, at the time of terminating their employment relationship with the Superintendency, shall be entitled to a seniority bonus, at a rate of one week's salary for each year worked, up to a maximum of ten months' salary. In the event that any year of service is not completed in full, they shall be entitled to the corresponding proportional part.
The time of continuous service in the National Banking Commission shall be recognized to the official.
The last remuneration earned shall be taken as the basis for the calculation.
Only career officials who leave their position by resignation, unjustified dismissal, reduction of force or disability shall receive the seniority bonus.
ARTICLE 32. POLICIES AND PROCEDURES MANUAL. The Superintendency shall prepare, based on the rules adopted by the Board of Directors, a detailed manual that defines the human resources actions and the procedures to be followed to process them.
ARTICLE 33. JOB DESCRIPTION AND POSITION CLASSIFICATION. The Superintendency shall prepare a job description and classification manual. Each position shall have the specific description of the inherent tasks and the minimum requirements to fill it. The descriptions shall be reviewed and updated periodically.
The classification of positions shall have its corresponding nomenclature, in accordance with the definition of duties, responsibilities and minimum requirements. Each position shall have a grade assigned according to its complexity and hierarchy.
ARTICLE 34. DETERMINATION OF REMUNERATION AND SALARY SCALE. The Superintendency shall design a salary scale that takes into account the classification, the financial reality of the Superintendency, the conditions of the labor market and the salary standards of the Panamanian banking sector.
The Superintendency shall review, at least every two years, the remuneration policy to guarantee career officials a salary that allows them to maintain a dignified and decent standard of living, as well as respect for the principle that equal work corresponds to equal pay.
ARTICLE 35. MOTIVATION POLICIES OR PROGRAMS. The Superintendency shall establish motivation policies or programs for career officials, in order to incentivize their productivity, efficiency and competitiveness, as well as to improve their moral, social, cultural development and their work spirit.
The motivational policies or programs shall establish economic, moral and sociocultural incentives, based strictly on the performance and fulfillment of the official's objectives.
ARTICLE 36. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION SYSTEM. The Superintendency shall establish a performance and output evaluation system that serves as the basis for the remuneration, incentives, training and dismissal systems.
The performance and output evaluation system constitutes a set of rules and procedures to evaluate and rate the performance of officials. The evaluation and rating shall be based solely on performance and output, without prejudice of any kind.
This evaluation system shall be adopted by the Board of Directors.
ARTICLE 37. TRAINING POLICIES FOR OFFICIALS OR INSTITUTIONAL STRENGTHENING. The Superintendency shall establish training policies, endeavoring to give preference to training courses taught by the National Institute of Vocational Training and Human Development Training (INADEH). Nevertheless, the Superintendency in its training policies and programs shall act with full autonomy and without being subject to the approval of any other entity.
ARTICLE 38. TERMINATION OF THE EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP. The official shall terminate his employment relationship with the Superintendency in the following cases:
1. Written resignation, duly accepted.
2. Reduction of personnel.
3. Dismissal.
4. Disability declared in accordance with the public health services.
5. Separation as a result of performance evaluation.
6. Death.
ARTICLE 39. INDEMNIFICATION FOR DISMISSAL WITHOUT JUSTIFIED CAUSE. The career official, notwithstanding the right to stability granted to him in this Chapter, may be removed from his position by the Superintendent, at any time and for any cause, provided that he is paid, without prejudice to the payment of the seniority bonus, an indemnification calculated at the rate of one week's salary for each year of work, up to a maximum equivalent to ten months' salary.
In the event that the official does not complete the last year, the calculation shall be made proportionally for said period.
The time of continuous service in the National Banking Commission shall be recognized for the official.
The last remuneration earned shall be taken as the basis for the calculation.
The Superintendency shall pay this indemnification for unjustified dismissal within a term no greater than sixty working days from the time the right arises.
ARTICLE 40. APPLICATION OF NORMS IN CASE OF CONTRADICTION. For the exclusive purposes of this Chapter, in case of contradiction between the provisions established and developed herein and other norms, the provisions established in this Chapter and in the norms that specify and set, in the administrative sphere, their interpretation and scope shall apply.
Law 9 of 1994 and its amendments shall apply only in a supplementary manner.
TITLE III OF THE BANKING REGIME
CHAPTER I.
OF AUTHORIZATIONS
ARTICLE 41. BANKING LICENSES. No person may carry out the business of banking in or from the Republic of Panama without having the corresponding banking license or without being duly authorized by law.
Three classes of license shall be issued:
1. General License. It allows carrying out the business of banking anywhere in the Republic of Panama, as well as transactions that are perfected, consummated or produce their effects abroad, and carrying out those other activities that the Superintendency authorizes.
2. International License. It allows directing, from an office established in Panama, transactions that are perfected, consummated or produce their effects abroad and carrying out those other activities that the Superintendency authorizes.
3. Representation License. It allows foreign banks to establish a representation office in the Republic of Panama and carry out those other activities that the Superintendency authorizes. Representation offices must always include the expression representation office in all their actions.
The representation license must be requested directly by the bank to be represented and may only be granted to it. Once granted, the bank may exercise the activity through a branch or a subsidiary one hundred percent owned by the requesting bank.
PARAGRAPH. Banks may request from the Superintendency a change in the type of license, in which case the updated documentation on file with the Superintendency shall be recognized. For each particular case, the Superintendency shall determine the additional requirements that must be met to make the change effective.
ARTICLE 42. VALIDITY OF BANKING LICENSES ALREADY GRANTED. The full validity of the banking licenses granted by the National Banking Commission as of the date of entry into force of this Decree Law is recognized.
ARTICLE 43. PRIOR AUTHORIZATION OR NON-OBJECTION. Without prejudice to the provisions of this Decree Law, foreign banks must have the authorization or non-objection of their foreign supervisory entity to request a license to carry out the business of banking in or from Panama or to request a representation office.
ARTICLE 44. USE OF THE WORD BANK. Only banks authorized through the corresponding banking licenses, issued by the National Banking Commission or the Superintendency, as the case may be, may use the word Bank or its derivatives, in any language, whether in their name, corporate name, trade name, description, letterheads, invoices, letter paper, notices, advertisements or in any other medium or in any other form that indicates or could lead one to think that they carry out or are engaged in the business of banking. Excluded from this norm are institutions or associations of a national character engaged exclusively in humanitarian or charitable activities, state entities engaged in making sectoral loans of social interest and multilateral or international organizations recognized by the Republic of Panama.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Superintendent may, in exceptional cases, authorize the use of the word Bank or its derivatives, in any language, to a natural or legal person not engaged in the business of banking, provided that the word Bank or its derivatives is used only as part of the applicant's name and no confusion or doubt is generated thereby as to the nature of its operations and the activity to be carried out.
The Superintendency is the only institution empowered to authorize the use of the word Bank and its derivatives, in any language, in the Republic of Panama.
PARAGRAPH. Notaries are prohibited from authorizing deeds or copies thereof, acts, declarations or instruments peculiar to their office, and authentication of signatures that contravene the
provisions of this article. The same prohibition applies to the Public Registry of Panama regarding its registrations, and the Director General of the Public Registry is obligated to inform the Superintendency of the existence of any registration that may be in contravention of the provisions of this article.
The Superintendent must evaluate the report and order the annotation of a marginal note in the registration of each company that has violated the rules established in this Decree Law and, after sixty calendar days from the date of the corresponding annotation, the affected company is dissolved by operation of law or disqualified from conducting business in Panama, depending on whether it is a Panamanian or foreign company.
ARTICLE 45. EXERCISE OF THE BANKING BUSINESS WITHOUT A LICENSE. Whenever there is knowledge or well-founded reasons to suppose that a person is exercising or intends to exercise the banking business without a license, the Superintendency shall be empowered to examine its books, accounts and other documents, in order to determine such fact. Any unjustified refusal to present said books, accounts and documents shall be considered as a presumption of the exercise of the banking business without a license.
If necessary, the Superintendency may intervene the establishments where the banking business without a license is presumed to be carried out and, if such fact is proven, it must order their closure.
For these actions, the Superintendency may have the assistance of the National Police and other authorities.
The Superintendency shall order the Public Registry to annotate a marginal note in the registration of each company referred to in this article and shall impose the sanctions established in this Decree Law. After sixty calendar days from the date of the corresponding annotation, the affected company shall be dissolved by operation of law or disqualified from conducting business in Panama, depending on whether it is a Panamanian or foreign company.
The provisions of this article shall also apply to those cases in which the Superintendency has well-founded reasons to suppose that a person is raising or intends to raise funds from the public in contravention of the provisions of article 2 of this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 46. PUBLICATION OF ORDERS. In all cases in which the Superintendency orders the Director General of the Public Registry to annotate the marginal note referred to in articles 44 and 45 of this Decree Law, the Superintendency shall publish such order for three business days, in a newspaper of wide circulation throughout the Republic.
CHAPTER II PROCEDURE FOR THE GRANTING OF LICENSES
ARTICLE 47. LICENSE APPLICATION. Applications for banking licenses submitted to the Superintendent must be made in writing through a legal attorney. The Board of Directors shall establish the requirements and other conditions that applicants must meet in order to obtain a banking license.
ARTICLE 48. CRITERIA FOR THE APPROVAL OR DENIAL OF BANKING LICENSES. The Superintendent shall have a period of up to ninety days, counted from the complete submission of all documentation required by the Superintendency, to approve or deny the banking license application, based on the following criteria:
1. Identity of the principal shareholders and suitability of the administrative body based on their experience, integrity and professional history.
2. Evidence of the capacity to contribute the minimum required capital, whose origin must be clearly determinable.
3. Business plan that demonstrates the viability of the bank and its contribution to the Panamanian economy.
4. Corporate Governance policies.
5. Any other criteria that the Superintendent or the Board of Directors deems pertinent.
The term referred to in this article may be extended, at the discretion of the Superintendent, when deemed necessary for the better evaluation of the application in question.
ARTICLE 49. TEMPORARY PERMIT. Once the requirements established for the license application are met, the Superintendent shall issue a temporary permit, with the sole purpose that the applicant may register its articles of incorporation in the Public Registry of Panama using the word Bank or any of its derivatives, in any language, while the process for obtaining the definitive license is underway.
The temporary permit shall be granted for a term of ninety days.
ARTICLE 50. DEFINITIVE LICENSE. Once the applicant's company is registered or enabled in the Public Registry, within the term of validity of the temporary permit and having complied with the minimum capitalization requirement set forth in article 68 and, in the case of an international license, with the guarantee deposit indicated in the same article, the applicant shall request the definitive license for said company. The provisions of this article shall likewise apply with respect to other forms of legal organization of the applicant.
Once the corresponding documentation and requirements have been analyzed, the Superintendent shall have the power to issue or deny the requested license, which shall be done by means of a reasoned resolution, which must be personally notified to the applicant, within one hundred twenty days following receipt of the application for the definitive license.
The term referred to in this article may be extended by the Superintendent, when, at its discretion, it is necessary in light of the particular circumstances of each application.
ARTICLE 51. PUBLICITY OF LICENSE APPLICATIONS. Once the documentation of the license applicant has been received and analyzed to satisfaction, the Superintendency shall publish in a newspaper of national circulation, for three business days, a notice that must contain the following information:
1. Name of the license applicant.
2. Name of the applicant's directors and officers.
3. Operating background of the applicant.
4. Names and identification cards or passports of the bank's directors, officers and executive employees, indicating their positions.
The applicant's audited financial statements corresponding to the year prior to their submission shall be available to the public at the offices of the Superintendency.
Persons who have well-founded reasons to oppose the granting of the requested license may state them in writing to the Superintendency and submit the supporting documentation, if any, within fifteen days following the date of the last publication referred to in this article. Well-founded reasons shall be considered those that deal with the economic capacity and moral solvency of the applicant, of the entity aspiring to obtain a banking license, of the directors, officers and executive employees mentioned in the notice and, in general, those verifiable circumstances that make the establishment of the new banking entity in Panama inadvisable. The Superintendency shall not be obligated to rule on said oppositions and objections. In any case, the applicant shall have the right to refute the objections against the granting of the banking license, within fifteen days following the date on which the Superintendency notifies them.
ARTICLE 52. PRELIMINARY AUTHORIZATION FOR INTERNATIONAL BANKING BUSINESS.
Foreign banking entities that do not have a banking license to operate from
Panama may request from the Superintendency a preliminary authorization to engage in international banking business, in order to anticipate the interruption that could occur in business continuity due to force majeure or natural disasters affecting them. This authorization would eventually allow, from an office established in Panama, under an international license, directing transactions that are perfected, consummated or produce their effects abroad.
The preliminary authorization must comply with all the requirements established in this Chapter for international licenses and in the regulations that develop it. Final approval of a subsequent international banking license shall be carried out when the following requirements are completed:
1. Confirmation from its foreign supervisory body that the continuity of the applicant's business in its country of origin has effectively been interrupted.
2. Confirmation from the Banco Nacional de Panamá or the Caja de Ahorros that it has received the transfer of the funds required as a guarantee deposit for this type of license, as established in article 68 of this Decree Law.
3. Evidence that it has the minimum paid-in or assigned capital required of banks with an international license.
This authorization must be renewed annually and under no circumstances shall the preliminary authorization be considered equivalent to a license to conduct banking business from Panama. The approval and renewal of the preliminary authorization shall be subject to the payment of special service charges to be established by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 53. ATTORNEYS-IN-FACT OF BRANCHES OF FOREIGN BANKS. Branches of foreign banks must designate at least two general attorneys-in-fact, both natural persons residing in Panama and one of whom must be Panamanian.
ARTICLE 54. BUSINESS CONTINUITY. Banks shall have policies, rules and procedures to ensure that their punctual operations can be maintained or recovered in a timely manner in the event of any significant interruption affecting their operability, with the purpose of minimizing the consequences that may arise from such interruption.
The Superintendency shall develop the rules applicable to this matter.
ARTICLE 55. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE. Banks shall be obligated to comply with the Corporate Governance rules issued by the Superintendency. In case of non-compliance, they shall be sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law.
CHAPTER III CANCELLATION OF LICENSES
ARTICLE 56. GROUNDS FOR CANCELLATION. The Superintendent may cancel the license of any bank that incurs any of the following grounds:
1. Not initiating operations within six months following the granting of the definitive license. The bank may request an extension of this term based on proven justifications.
2. Ceasing to engage in the banking business.
3. Intervention of the bank's parent company, cancellation of the license or lack of effective consolidated supervision by the foreign supervisory body, in the judgment of the Superintendency.
4. Having provided false or fraudulent information, or omitted relevant information to obtain the license.
5. Serious repeated violation of the provisions of this Decree Law.
6. In the other cases provided for in this Decree Law.
Before canceling the license, the Superintendency shall personally notify the bank of its intention specifying the ground, and the bank shall have a term of thirty days, counted from its
notification, to state the reasons for opposition, accompanying the evidence it deems appropriate. Once said term has expired, the Superintendency, by reasoned resolution, shall issue its decision. This decision shall allow a motion for reconsideration and appeal before the Superintendent and the Board of Directors, respectively. The decision resolving the appeal shall exhaust the administrative remedies.
ARTICLE 57. MEASURES FOLLOWING THE CANCELLATION OF LICENSE. Once the resolution by which the license is canceled is final, the Superintendent shall immediately proceed to:
1. Communicate the measure to the Director General of the Public Registry of Panama, so that the corresponding marginal note is recorded, informing about the cancellation of the banking license.
2. Publish the resolution in a newspaper of national circulation for three business days.
3. Appoint the liquidator or the liquidation board of the bank that will be in charge of the liquidation, under the terms provided for forced liquidation.
ARTICLE 58. OPENING AND CLOSING OF ESTABLISHMENTS. No new establishments may be opened in Panama without prior notification to the Superintendency.
The prior authorization of the Superintendency shall be required for:
1. The opening abroad of subsidiaries or branches of Panamanian banks or of foreign banks operating in Panama.
2. The closing or relocation of an existing establishment, so that it may ensure the orderly closure, in a manner that protects the interests of the depositors of said establishment.
CHAPTER IV BANKING SUPERVISION
ARTICLE 59. BANKING SUPERVISION. All banks that engage in the business of banking in the Republic of Panama shall be subject to the inspection and supervision of the Superintendency, to verify their financial stability and their structure of compliance with the provisions of this Decree Law and the rules that develop it.
ARTICLE 60. SUPERVISION OF OFFICIAL BANKS. Official banks shall be subject to the inspection and oversight of the Comptroller General of the Republic under the terms established in the Political Constitution and the law, to the supervision of the Superintendency, as well as to compliance with the rules, regulations, prerogatives, rights and requirements that, in accordance with this Decree Law, are applicable to the rest of the banks for the same type of operations and situations concerned.
ARTICLE 61. HOME SUPERVISION. The Superintendency shall exclusively exercise home supervision, on a consolidated and cross-border basis, of Panamanian banks and of banking groups that consolidate in Panama, in accordance with the generally applicable rules that the Board of Directors develops on the matter.
ARTICLE 62. HOST SUPERVISION. Foreign banks, their branches and subsidiaries, shall be supervised on a consolidated basis by the corresponding foreign supervisory authority. In addition, said entities shall be subject to the supervision of the Superintendency on an individual and subconsolidated basis and to the other applicable rules in accordance with this Decree Law and the rules that develop it.
ARTICLE 63. SUPERVISION OF NON-BANKING AND NON-FINANCIAL AFFILIATES. The Superintendency shall supervise on a consolidated basis the activities of non-banking or non-financial companies that are affiliates of or related to banking groups, but that do not form part of them, as provided by this Decree Law and the rules that develop it, and by virtue thereof may require the information that is necessary, in order to know and evaluate:
1. The risks that said activities could pose for the banks belonging to those banking groups.
2. The quality and scope of the administration and control of such risks, including capital adequacy.
The Superintendency is empowered to require those banking groups, including the owners of bank shares that form part of them, to take the necessary measures to prevent or correct practices or conditions that, in its judgment, could represent a material risk for the banks belonging to such banking groups.
ARTICLE 64. INSPECTION BY FOREIGN SUPERVISORY AUTHORITIES. Exclusively for supervision purposes, foreign supervisory authorities may request information and carry out inspection visits in Panama to the foreign banks over which they exercise home supervision.
The information that is gathered shall be subject to strict confidentiality and may not be disclosed by the foreign supervisory authority or used for purposes other than banking supervision, without the prior authorization of the Superintendency, for which the latter shall require sufficient guarantees of such confidentiality.
The foreign supervisory authority shall deliver to the Superintendency a copy of all reports and documents that it prepares as a result of the inspection.
ARTICLE 65. UNDERSTANDINGS WITH FOREIGN SUPERVISORY AUTHORITIES. The Superintendency shall enter into understandings with foreign supervisory authorities, whether bilaterally or multilaterally, that allow and facilitate the consolidated and cross-border supervision referred to in this Chapter and the global assessment of the banks and banking groups subject to the regulation and supervision of this Decree Law. These agreements shall specify, among others, the criteria applicable to inspections and to the exchange of information and cooperation between authorities.
Cooperation with foreign supervisory authorities shall be based on principles of reciprocity and confidentiality, and must strictly adhere to banking supervision purposes.
ARTICLE 66. BANKING INSPECTIONS. At least every two years, the Superintendency shall conduct an inspection at each bank to determine its financial situation and whether in the course of its operations it has complied with the provisions of this Decree Law. Such inspections shall include the bank and may extend to the companies of the banking group and to the non-banking and non-financial affiliates referred to in article 63 of this Decree Law. The total cost of the inspection and its incidental expenses shall be paid by the bank.
The Superintendency may carry out the inspections with its own personnel or hire independent external auditors or qualified specialized personnel for that purpose, in which case, the report they render must be evaluated by qualified personnel of the Superintendency.
Excepted from the provisions of this article are the companies over which the bank exercises effective control of their operations as a fiduciary agent.
Any refusal by the bank to submit to the inspection referred to in this article shall be sanctioned in accordance with the provisions of Title IV of this Decree Law, without prejudice to the corresponding criminal sanction.
CHAPTER V ON CAPITAL
ARTICLE 67. COMPOSITION OF CAPITAL. Every bank must have the capital funds required by this Decree Law and the rules that develop it. The capital funds of banks shall be composed of primary capital, secondary capital and tertiary capital. The amount of the latter two, jointly, may not exceed the first.
The Superintendency shall establish the deductions from the capital base that it deems technically necessary.
ARTICLE 68. MINIMUM PAID-IN CAPITAL. The minimum amount of paid-in or assigned capital stock, net of losses, required to apply for and maintain a banking license is ten million balboas for the general license, and three million balboas for the international license. The bank may not, at any time, suffer the reduction of its capital below the minimum required amount.
In the case of the international license, two hundred fifty thousand balboas of the paid-in or assigned capital shall be maintained, as a guarantee, deposited in the Banco Nacional de Panamá or in the Caja de Ahorros. The deposit shall accrue interest at the market rates agreed upon by the depositors with either of the official banks. This guarantee is constituted in favor, exclusively and privately, of the Superintendency, for the purposes it determines, for which reason the deposit shall not be subject to sequestration, attachment or other precautionary measure by third parties.
The Superintendency shall have the power to modify, by agreement, the amount of the minimum paid-in or assigned capital stock.
ARTICLE 69. CAPITAL RESERVE. To decrease the capital reserve of a bank, the prior authorization of the Superintendency is required.
ARTICLE 70. CAPITAL ADEQUACY RATIOS. Every bank with a general license and an international license whose home supervisor is the Superintendency must maintain the following capital adequacy ratios:
1. Capital funds equivalent to at least eight percent of its total assets and off-balance-sheet operations that represent a contingency, weighted according to their risks.
2. A primary capital equivalent to no less than four percent of its assets and off-balance-sheet operations that represent a contingency, weighted according to their risks.
PARAGRAPH. When the Superintendency deems it convenient, it may, by agreement of the Board of Directors, modify, for all banks, the ratios established in this article.
The Superintendent may require a particular bank, by reasoned resolution, to maintain a higher ratio when the bank's risk profile so advises, whether temporarily or permanently.
ARTICLE 71. CAPITAL ADEQUACY FOR INTERNATIONAL LICENSE BANKS.
International license banks over which the Superintendency exercises host supervision must comply, at all times, with the capital funds adequacy ratio required by their home supervisor.
ARTICLE 72. ASSESSMENT OF OTHER RISKS. In determining the capital adequacy ratio established in this Decree Law, the Superintendency may take into account the existence of other risks, among which are market risk, operational risk and country risk, that serve as a measure to assess the capital funds requirement.
CHAPTER VI ON BANK LIQUIDITY
ARTICLE 73. LIQUIDITY REQUIREMENTS. Banks with a general license and banks with an international license whose home supervisor is the Superintendency must maintain, at all times, a minimum balance of liquid assets equivalent to the percentage of the total gross of their
deposits that shall be fixed periodically by the Superintendency. Said percentage shall not exceed thirty-five percent. Upon this Decree Law entering into force and until the Superintendency resolves otherwise, said percentage shall be thirty percent.
Deposits that general and international license banks receive from their parent company or from a branch, subsidiary or affiliate abroad shall be excluded from the computation of the total gross of their deposits, for purposes of calculating the liquidity percentage.
ARTICLE 74. MODIFICATIONS OF THE LIQUIDITY PERCENTAGE. Modifications to the liquidity percentage must be complied with within the term indicated by the Superintendency, which shall not be less than thirty days.
ARTICLE 75. LIQUID ASSETS. For the purposes of the preceding articles, the assets detailed below shall be deemed liquid, provided they are free of any charge or encumbrance and are freely transferable:
1. Gold or legal tender money in Panama.
2. Net balances in the Clearing House in the Republic of Panama.
3. Net balances in any bank in Panama, on demand or at term, whose maturity does not exceed one hundred eighty-six days from the liquidity report, and obligations payable in Panama on demand, or at term with a maturity no greater than one hundred eighty-six days from the liquidity report.
4. National Treasury bills and other securities issued by the State with a maturity no greater than one year, at their market value.
5. Net balances in banks abroad previously approved by the Superintendency, payable on demand or at term whose maturity does not exceed one hundred eighty-six days from the liquidity report, and payable in currencies that are legal tender in Panama.
6. Obligations issued by foreign governments or by international financial organizations authorized by the Superintendency, which are actively traded in securities markets, in accordance with the weighting criteria that the Superintendency develops for these purposes.
7. Obligations of private national or foreign companies approved by the Superintendency, which are actively traded in the securities market and have investment grade as determined by an internationally recognized risk rating agency, according to their market value.
8. Obligations of private national companies guaranteed by banks with a general license, provided that the issuing companies and the guaranteeing bank are not part of the same economic group.
9. Payments of obligations that are payable within one hundred and eighty-six days, counted from the liquidity report.
10. Other assets that the Superintendency authorizes.
PARAGRAPH. The Superintendency may establish the mandatory proportion that certain liquid assets may represent of the liquidity of the banks or of a particular bank. When the Superintendency does not establish said proportion, it shall be at the discretion of the banks.
Likewise, the Superintendency may define the specific characteristics that the liquid assets referred to in this article must meet.
ARTICLE 76. STRUCTURE OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES. Banks shall maintain a maturity structure of assets and liabilities that favors adequate financial liquidity. The Superintendency shall develop this matter.
ARTICLE 77. LIQUIDITY REPORTS. Banks shall submit liquidity reports to the Superintendency, in the form and with the frequency that it determines.
ARTICLE 78. RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN LOCAL ASSETS AND LOCAL DEPOSITS. Banks with a general license shall maintain assets in the country equivalent to the percentage of their local deposits
that the Superintendency determines in accordance with national economic or financial conditions. Said percentage shall be equal for all banks and shall not exceed one hundred percent of said deposits.
The Superintendency shall establish what is understood by local deposits for the purposes of this article.
PARAGRAPH. Upon the entry into force of this Decree Law and until the Superintendency decides otherwise, the percentage referred to in this article shall be eighty-five percent.
CHAPTER VII BANKING INTEREST
ARTICLE 79. INTEREST RATES. Banks may freely set the amount of active and passive interest rates for their operations, and therefore other laws or regulations that establish maximum interest rates shall not apply to them.
ARTICLE 80. INDICATION OF THE EFFECTIVE INTEREST RATE. Banks shall indicate, clearly and unequivocally, the effective interest rate of their loans and deposits in account statements, in contractual documents with their clients, or when the latter request such information.
Likewise, when a bank indicates a nominal rate in advertising announcements, it must accompany it with the indication of the corresponding effective interest rate.
The Superintendency shall establish the rules it deems appropriate to regulate this matter.
CHAPTER VIII EXTERNAL AUDITORS
ARTICLE 81. APPOINTMENT OF EXTERNAL AUDITORS. Each bank shall annually appoint, within the first three months of its fiscal year, and at its cost, external auditors, who must be authorized public accountants, specialized and with sufficient experience, in the judgment of the Superintendency, and professionally qualified, whose duty shall be to render reports to the shareholders or partners of each Panamanian bank or to its parent company, if it is a foreign bank, or official banks.
For such purposes, banks shall notify the Superintendency, within the term it establishes, of the name of the external auditors contracted by the bank.
ARTICLE 82. REPORT OF THE EXTERNAL AUDITORS. External auditors shall be responsible for issuing an independent opinion on the financial statements, in accordance with current international auditing standards, and shall state in their audit report whether, in their opinion, they show the true and fair state of the bank's financial situation, financial performance and cash flows, and whether the financial statements conform to the accounting, technical and prudential standards established by the Superintendency, assuming full responsibility for the reports they issue.
ARTICLE 83. EXTERNAL AUDITORS APPOINTED BY THE SUPERINTENDENCY. If the bank does not make the appointment referred to in article 81 within the established period, the Superintendency shall make this appointment, determining the remuneration to which the external auditors so appointed shall be entitled, such remuneration being the responsibility of the bank.
ARTICLE 84. OBJECTION TO EXTERNAL AUDITORS. The Superintendency shall have the power to reject or object to the appointment of external auditors when it considers that they do not have sufficient experience, specialization or independence.
The Superintendency shall not accept audit reports that have been prepared in contravention of this Decree Law and the accounting, technical and prudential standards established by it, in which case it shall have the power to order the removal of the external auditors.
ARTICLE 85. INCLUSION OF BANKING GROUPS. For the purposes of this Chapter, it shall be understood that any reference to banks includes the banking groups of which the bank forms part.
CHAPTER IX DOCUMENTS AND REPORTS
ARTICLE 86. RIGHT TO REQUEST INFORMATION FROM BANKS OR BANKING GROUPS. The Superintendency is empowered to request from any bank, any company of the banking group, the owner of bank shares or non-banking affiliates, the documents and reports regarding their operations and activities. For these purposes, each bank shall maintain with the Superintendency a descriptive list of the companies that make up the banking group, the owner of bank shares and the non-banking affiliates, and shall notify any variation that occurs, no later than within the five business days following the date of said variation.
The provisions of this article do not apply to companies over which the bank exercises effective control of their operations as a fiduciary agent.
ARTICLE 87. SUBMISSION OF AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. Within three months following the close of each fiscal year, banks with a general and international license must submit to the Superintendency their corresponding audited financial statements, observing the accounting, technical and prudential standards established by the Superintendency with respect to their operations. The aforementioned documentation shall bear the signature of the legal representative or of an attorney-in-fact of the bank with the authority to do so.
ARTICLE 88. PUBLICATION AND EXHIBITION OF AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. Banks shall publish, in a newspaper of national circulation in the Republic of Panama, an unsigned copy of the audited financial statements referred to in the preceding article, with their respective explanatory notes, if any, within thirty days following their submission to the Superintendency, and shall exhibit them for the next ninety days in a place accessible to the public in each of their establishments in Panama.
ARTICLE 89. SUBMISSION OF UNAUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. Banks must submit to the Superintendency their unaudited financial statements within thirty days following the close of each quarter of the year, observing the accounting, technical and prudential standards established by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 90. INTEGRITY OF AUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS. If the Superintendency determines, at any time, that the financial statements do not meet the accounting, technical or prudential requirements established for their submission, or contain false or inaccurate information, it shall order the bank, by reasoned resolution, to withdraw them from exhibition, correct them and publish the corrected version or explanatory notes that in the Superintendency's judgment may be necessary. The foregoing is without prejudice to the sanctions or other actions that may apply.
ARTICLE 91. OTHER REPORTS. All banks must send to the Superintendency, within the period and in the form that it prescribes:
1. A statement showing the assets and liabilities and results of their establishments in Panama at the close of their operations on the last business day of the preceding month.
2. A report containing: (a) an analysis and the classification of their credit and investment portfolio of their establishments in Panama at the close of their operations, and (b) the reconciliation of the capital account.
3. Any other information required by the Superintendency, with the frequency it determines, without prejudice to the provisions of article 93.
ARTICLE 92. PUBLICATION OF INFORMATION. The Superintendency shall disclose and publish financial and statistical information of the banking system and of each bank in particular, and may require banks to disclose certain financial information.
ARTICLE 93. INFORMATION ON LIABILITIES. The Superintendency may obtain from each bank information on the maturities, concentration and geographic distribution of its liabilities, in order to establish its liquidity and identify excessive risks.
The Superintendency may not request the identity of the banks' depositors, except when the deposits guarantee assets that are subject to analysis or supervision by the Superintendency.
CHAPTER X PROHIBITIONS AND LIMITATIONS
ARTICLE 94. PROHIBITION OF GUARANTEE WITH THE BANK'S OWN SHARES. Banks are prohibited from granting loans or credit facilities guaranteed exclusively by shares of the same bank or of its bank shareholding owner.
ARTICLE 95. CONCENTRATION IN A SINGLE PERSON. Banks and the bank shareholding owners in which the banking group consolidates are prohibited from granting, directly or indirectly, to a single natural or legal person, including those others that form an economic group with it, loans or credit facilities, or granting any guarantee or incurring any other obligation in favor of said person, whose total exceeds at any time, individually or jointly, twenty-five percent of the bank's capital funds.
PARAGRAPH. In the case of the banks referred to in article 97 of this Decree Law, the limit referred to in the first paragraph of this article shall be thirty percent of the capital funds.
ARTICLE 96. CONCENTRATION IN RELATED PARTIES. Banks and the bank shareholding owner in which the banking group consolidates are prohibited from:
1. Granting unsecured loans or credit facilities in favor of any of their employees, whose total exceeds the salaries, wages and other annual emoluments corresponding to the employee in question.
2. Granting loans or credit facilities, under cost and term conditions more favorable than those usual in the market for the corresponding type of operation, to their managers, officers and employees or any natural or legal person that owns five percent of the shares of the bank or of the bank shareholding owner in which the banking group consolidates, and any that forms an economic group with the foregoing.
3. Granting, directly or indirectly, unsecured credit facilities that exceed five percent of its capital funds or loans with real guarantees that are not deposits that exceed ten percent of its capital funds, in favor of:
a. One or more of its directors or any natural or legal person that directly or indirectly owns five percent or more of the shares of the bank or of the bank shareholding owner in which the banking group consolidates, whether granted jointly or severally.
b. Any legal person of which one or more of its directors is a director or officer or is a guarantor of the loan or credit facility.
c. Any legal entity or association of persons, in which the bank or the bank shareholding owner in which the banking group consolidates, or one or more of its directors or officers, holds individually or jointly an interest
significant, a predominant influence or, in any case, a shareholding greater than twenty percent of the ownership of the respective legal entity.
d. Its managers, officers, employees and their spouses, except in the case of mortgage loans for their primary residence or secured personal loans, granted in accordance with the plans established for personnel.
The accumulation of unsecured loans or loans with real security other than deposits, granted by the bank and the entities that constitute a banking group with it, to related parties of those mentioned in this article, may not in any case exceed the percentage established periodically by the Superintendency, which in no case shall be greater than twenty-five percent of the bank's capital funds.
ARTICLE 97. EXCEPTION REGARDING LOANS TO OTHER BANKS. In the case of loans and other credit facilities granted without security by mixed-capital banks headquartered in Panama, which are engaged primarily in granting loans to other banks, the Superintendency may authorize the total or partial exclusion of such loans or such credit facilities from the total amount of unsecured loans and facilities that serves as the basis for applying the limit established in numeral 3 of the preceding article.
The authorization referred to in this article requires satisfaction of the following criteria:
1. The shareholding in the debtor bank, directly or indirectly, of the common director or officer may not exceed five percent of the capital of said bank or any magnitude that could ensure majority control of the decisions of that bank.
2. The shareholding in the creditor bank, directly or indirectly, of the debtor bank represented in some manner by the common director or common officer, may not exceed five percent of the total outstanding shares of the creditor bank or any magnitude that could ensure majority control of the decisions of this bank.
3. The common director or common officer must refrain from participating in the deliberations and in the voting carried out by the creditor bank regarding the loan or credit facility submitted for the purposes of this article.
4. The loan or credit facility must strictly comply with the usual prudential parameters established in the lending policy of the granting bank.
The Superintendent shall determine the amount of the exclusion with respect to each loan or credit facility submitted for its consideration.
The Superintendent may require the certifications it deems pertinent and order the inspections necessary for the adequate supervision of the loans and other facilities submitted for the purposes of this article.
ARTICLE 98. ECONOMIC GROUPS. For the application of the prohibitions established in articles 95 and 96 of this Decree Law, the existence of economic groups shall be taken into account. However, a bank shall not be considered to have infringed the provisions of said articles if the existence of the economic group is subsequent, that is, it did not exist at the time the obligations were contracted.
In such case, the Superintendency shall grant a period to the bank to remedy the excess in the applicable limits. If it is verified that the economic group existed at the time the obligation was generated, the Superintendency shall impose a fine on the bank in question, in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law and shall order that the breach be remedied within a peremptory period.
ARTICLE 99. LIMITATION ON A BANK'S PARTICIPATION IN OTHER COMPANIES. Banks and bank shareholding owners are prohibited from acquiring or holding shares or participations in any other companies not related to the banking or
financial business, whose accumulated value exceeds twenty-five percent of their capital funds. Excepted are investments made by the bank as fiduciary agent, as well as participations or shares that the bank or the bank shareholding owner acquires for sums owed to it, in which case they must be liquidated at the earliest opportunity, consistent with the economic interests of the bank in the judgment of the Superintendency, which may establish a period for this purpose.
PARAGRAPH. Considering the aforementioned limit, banks may not acquire or invest in companies that belong to their same economic group or are a related party thereof, for amounts that exceed five percent of their capital funds.
ARTICLE 100. EXCEPTIONS TO THE LIMITS OF PARTICIPATION IN OTHER COMPANIES.
The provisions of the preceding article do not prevent the purchase or sale of shares on behalf and by order of a client. Nor does it prevent, with prior authorization from the Superintendency, the purchase or sale of shares on its own account by any corporation organized for the purpose of insuring bank deposits, promoting the development of a money or securities market in Panama, or improving the financing system for economic development.
ARTICLE 101. PROHIBITION ON THE PURCHASE OR LEASING OF REAL PROPERTY. Banks are prohibited from buying, acquiring or taking in lease real property for themselves, except in the following cases:
1. When it is necessary to carry out its operations or for the housing or recreation of its personnel.
2. When it acquires land to build any type of housing or development with the purpose of selling it and provided that the sales are made within the limits established by article 99.
3. When exceptional circumstances occur, and with prior authorization from the Superintendency.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, banks that have accepted real estate as collateral for their loans may, in the event of non-payment, acquire such real estate in order to sell it at the earliest opportunity within the term set for that purpose by the Superintendency, taking into account the bank's economic interests.
When it deems it appropriate, the Superintendency may establish, on a general basis, limits on the ability of banks to concentrate risks in certain areas or sectors of the economy.
ARTICLE 102. PROHIBITION ON TAKING DEPOSITS. Banks are prohibited from receiving deposits while they are in a state of insolvency, as well as from receiving any other funds from anyone who has not been previously informed by the bank of that state of insolvency. No officer, director or dignitary of a bank who has or should have knowledge of such insolvency shall accept or authorize the receipt of deposits or other funds in contravention of the provisions of this article.
ARTICLE 103. MERGERS AND ACQUISITIONS. No bank engaged in the banking business in or from Panama and no owner of bank shares may merge or consolidate, nor sell, in whole or in part, the assets it holds when this amounts to a merger or consolidation, without the prior authorization of the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 104. SCOPE OF THE PROHIBITIONS AND LIMITATIONS. Every bank or owner of bank shares over which the Superintendency exercises home-country supervision must comply at all times with the prohibitions and limitations established in this Chapter.
International license banks over which the Superintendency exercises host-country supervision must comply at all times with the limits on concentration of risks and investments in other companies set by the rules of the jurisdiction of their home-country supervisor.
PARAGRAPH. A term of two years is established, counted from the entry into force of this Decree Law, for international license banks that at that time do not comply with the provisions of this article to comply with them. Nevertheless, the Superintendent may extend this term by means of a reasoned resolution.
ARTICLE 105. LOANS WITH PLEDGE OF DEPOSITS. Excepted from the provisions of this Chapter are loans or credit facilities duly secured by the pledge of deposits in the same bank, up to the amount of the collateral.
CHAPTER XI INCOMPATIBILITIES
ARTICLE 106. INCOMPATIBILITIES OF ACCOUNTANTS. No certified public accountant or firm of certified public accountants in which any of its partners or officers is an employee, director or dignitary of a bank or of an owner of bank shares, or has or acquires the status of shareholder or partner, direct or indirect, of a bank or of an owner of bank shares, may act as external auditor of said bank or owner of bank shares.
The foregoing applies equally to external auditors hired to carry out bank inspections in accordance with the provisions of article 66.
ARTICLE 107. DISQUALIFICATION OF DIRECTORS OR MANAGERS OF BANKS. Without prejudice to the provisions of the Commercial Code and other laws in force, any person who holds the position of director or dignitary or who performs managerial duties in a bank shall cease to perform their duties, being disqualified from holding such position or function in any bank, when any of the following grounds occurs:
1. Is declared bankrupt or in creditors' composition proceedings.
2. Is convicted of any crime against property or public trust.
3. For serious faults in the management of the bank, as determined by the Board of Directors of the Superintendency.
This disqualification shall remain in force until such person is rehabilitated by the Board of Directors of the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 108. DISQUALIFICATION FROM ACTING AS DIRECTOR, DIGNITARY OR ADMINISTRATOR OF A BANK. No person who has been a director or dignitary of a bank at the time of its forced liquidation or who has participated in the managerial management of a bank and is responsible for acts that led to its forced liquidation may act as director or dignitary or participate in the administration of another bank.
ARTICLE 109. NOTIFICATION OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS TO THE SUPERINTENDENCY. Every affected bank shall notify the Superintendency of any civil or criminal proceeding initiated against the bank, as well as any civil or criminal proceeding initiated against any of its directors or first-level administrative officers and that is related to the exercise of banking activity or that concerns the commission of a willful crime. Such communication shall take place within fifteen days after notification of the complaint. The Superintendency may, at any time, request the pertinent information or clarification.
Failure to comply with the provisions of this article shall be sanctioned by the Superintendency in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law.
CHAPTER XII RIGHT TO CONFIDENTIALITY
ARTICLE 110. ADMINISTRATIVE CONFIDENTIALITY. The information obtained by the Superintendency in the exercise of its functions, relating to individual clients of a bank, must be kept under strict confidentiality and may only be disclosed when required by a competent authority, in accordance with the legal provisions in force, within the course of criminal proceedings.
The Superintendency, including all its personnel and the external auditors, advisors, interim administrators, reorganizers and liquidators appointed by it, must maintain due confidentiality regarding all information that has been provided to it or that it has obtained in accordance with this Decree Law. Consequently, it may not disclose it to third parties, unless it is required to do so by a competent authority in accordance with the provisions of this article. Excepted from this provision are those reports or documents that, in accordance with this Decree Law and by their nature, are public and those that it must provide in compliance with laws on the prevention of the Crimes of Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and related crimes.
Public servants who, by reason of the positions they hold, have access to the information referred to in this article, shall be obligated to maintain due confidentiality, even when they cease to perform their duties.
Excepted from the provisions of this article is the information that, by reason of consolidated supervision, the Superintendency must share with foreign supervisory entities under the protection of articles 64 and 65 of this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 111. BANKING CONFIDENTIALITY. Banks shall only disclose information about their clients or their operations with the consent of the latter. Banks shall not require the consent of clients in the following cases:
1. When the information is required of them by a competent authority in accordance with the law.
2. When, on their own initiative, they must provide it in compliance with laws related to the prevention of the crimes of Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and related crimes.
3. To rating agencies for risk analysis purposes.
4. To data processing agencies or offices for accounting and operational purposes.
In the case of numerals 3 and 4, the obligation to maintain the confidentiality of the information provided shall be transferred by operation of law.
CHAPTER XIII PREVENTION OF THE CRIME OF MONEY LAUNDERING, TERRORIST FINANCING AND RELATED CRIMES
ARTICLE 112. PREVENTION OF CRIMES. Banks and other subjects supervised by the Superintendency shall have the obligation to establish policies and procedures and internal control structures to prevent their services from being used improperly for the crime of Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and other related crimes or crimes of a similar nature or origin.
The Superintendency shall establish the framework for the scope, functions and procedures of said compliance structure.
ARTICLE 113. PROVISION OF INFORMATION. Banks and other subjects supervised by the Superintendency shall provide the information required of them by the laws, decrees and other regulations for the prevention of the crimes of Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and other related crimes or crimes of a similar nature or origin, in force in the Republic
of Panama. Likewise, they shall be obligated to provide the aforementioned information to the Superintendency when the latter so requires.
ARTICLE 114. KNOW YOUR CLIENT AND YOUR EMPLOYEE POLICY. Banks and other subjects supervised by the Superintendency shall adopt policies, practices and procedures that allow them to know and identify their clients and their employees with the greatest possible certainty, as part of the prevention process referred to in this Chapter and the rules that develop it. The Superintendency shall have the power to develop the pertinent rules, so that it adjusts to the policies and rules in force in the country.
CHAPTER XIV VOLUNTARY LIQUIDATION
ARTICLE 115. PRIOR AUTHORIZATION. Any bank may voluntarily decide its liquidation, for which purposes it must previously have the authorization of the Superintendency. The Superintendency shall grant the authorization provided that the bank possesses sufficient assets to meet its obligations.
ARTICLE 116. REQUIREMENTS FOR VOLUNTARY LIQUIDATION. The bank that requests from the Superintendency authorization for its voluntary liquidation must submit the following documents:
1. Resolution of the competent corporate body or authority approving the liquidation of the bank, duly legalized.
2. Liquidation plan.
3. Financial statements audited by an independent auditor corresponding to the last fiscal period or the period determined by the Superintendency.
4. The other documents determined by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 117. PUBLICATION. Once the liquidation is authorized, the bank must publish the resolution issued by the Superintendency in a newspaper of national circulation for five consecutive business days. The publications must be made within fifteen days following the date on which the resolution is notified to the bank. Additionally, and within thirty days following the date on which the resolution is notified, the bank must send notice of the liquidation to each depositor, creditor or interested person.
ARTICLE 118. CESSATION OF OPERATIONS. Once the authorization for its voluntary liquidation is granted, the requesting bank shall cease its operations and its powers shall be limited to those strictly necessary to carry out the liquidation, collect its credits, reimburse depositors, pay its creditors and, in general, settle all its business. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the bank may carry out the following activities for up to fifteen (15) calendar days following the date of the last publication of the resolution referred to in the previous article:
1. Pay checks that have been drawn against checking accounts.
2. Act as collecting agent for banks or other financial institutions located abroad and remit the funds so collected to said institutions.
3. The other activities that the Superintendency establishes for this purpose.
The authorization for liquidation shall not prejudice the right of depositors or creditors to receive in full the amount of their credits, nor the right of the holders of funds or other assets to have them returned. All legitimate credits of creditors and depositors must be paid, and all funds and other assets excluded from the estate that the bank has in its possession shall be returned to their owners within the term that the Superintendency designates when authorizing the liquidation.
The bank must manage the assignment to other banks of the credits of those clients who so request, under the same conditions under which they were contracted.
ARTICLE 119. APPOINTMENT OF THE LIQUIDATOR. The bank, with prior approval of the Superintendent, shall appoint its liquidator or liquidators, who may be the bank's own administrators. The appointed liquidator or liquidators must have a minimum of five years of administrative experience in the banking sector.
During the course of the voluntary liquidation, the liquidator or liquidators shall be obligated to provide the Superintendency, with the frequency it determines, the reports it requests regarding the liquidation.
ARTICLE 120. PROHIBITION ON DISTRIBUTION OF ASSETS. The bank that decides to voluntarily liquidate may not make any distribution of assets among its shareholders without first having fulfilled its obligations to all depositors and other creditors, following the liquidation plan approved by the Superintendency.
In the case of credits subject to controversy, the liquidator shall deposit the sum subject to litigation before the judge hearing the process, so that it may be delivered in accordance with what is resolved in a final judgment.
In the case of litigation in which the bank is a defendant, the liquidator shall deposit the sum subject to litigation in cash, surety bonds from insurance companies, or bank guarantee letters before the judge of the process to guarantee its outcome. If the bank is acquitted or if for any reason balances remain in favor of the bank, the corresponding funds shall be returned to the bank.
If the liquidation process has concluded and it is not possible to return the funds to the bank or its shareholders, the Superintendency shall be notified of the existence of such funds, which shall be deposited in the Banco Nacional de Panamá.
The Banco Nacional de Panamá shall be obligated to return the aforementioned funds to their owners, provided they are claimed within ten years following the date they were transferred, but the restitution shall be made without interest. Once said term has elapsed, the funds shall be transferred to the National Treasury.
ARTICLE 121. OBLIGATIONS OF THE LIQUIDATOR. During the voluntary liquidation period, the liquidator or liquidators shall be obligated to:
1. Inform the Superintendency about the course of the liquidation with the frequency it determines.
2. Notify the Superintendency if the bank's assets are insufficient to cover its liabilities, in which case proceedings shall be carried out in accordance with the provisions of Chapter XVI, entitled Administrative and Operational Control of the Bank.
ARTICLE 122. END OF VOLUNTARY LIQUIDATION. Once the liquidation process is completed, in accordance with the liquidation plan approved by the Superintendency, the latter shall cancel the respective banking license.
Once the resolution by which the license is canceled is notified, the Superintendency shall immediately proceed to send a copy of the resolution to the Director General of the Public Registry, so that the corresponding marginal note referred to in article 44 is recorded, and shall proceed to publish the resolution in a newspaper of national circulation for three consecutive business days.
ARTICLE 123. UNCLAIMED ASSETS AND SECURITIES. Unclaimed assets and securities shall be liquidated and sold on the stock exchange or by private auction, as applicable, once the first year has elapsed, and the proceeds of the sale must be deposited in the Banco Nacional de Panamá in the name of the holder.
Likewise, if at the end of the liquidation there are unclaimed credits, the liquidator shall deliver them to the Banco Nacional de Panamá.
In all the foregoing cases, the Banco Nacional de Panamá shall be obligated to return the corresponding funds to their owners, provided they are claimed within ten years following the date they were transferred, but the restitution shall be made without interest. Once said term has elapsed, the funds shall be transferred to the National Treasury.
CHAPTER XV CORRECTIVE MEASURES
ARTICLE 124. ADVISOR. If, based on the information in his possession, the Superintendent determines that there exists or may exist any deterioration or operational, administrative, or financial weakness of a bank, he may, without prejudice to the immediate measures he requires of the bank, order the bank to appoint one or more persons with adequate preparation and experience to advise the bank on the specific or general measures it should take to remedy the deficiency.
The Superintendent shall set the remuneration that the bank shall pay to the advisor.
In no case may the advisor be a director, officer, member, or employee of an external audit firm that has carried out an inspection of those referred to in article 66. Officials of the Superintendency, as well as natural persons who have conducted an inspection, their partners or employees, if any, shall likewise be barred from acting as advisors to the bank. The advisor shall be obligated to maintain strict confidentiality regarding the information and documentation to which he has access in the exercise of his duties.
ARTICLE 125. POWERS. The advisor shall have the powers determined by the Superintendent, in writing, at the time of ordering their appointment or at a later date, and those that are inherent to the task entrusted to them. In any case, it is understood that the advisor shall have access to all documents, minutes, correspondence and records of the bank, in order to carry out a full evaluation of those irregular or other aspects that affect the bank operationally, administratively or financially that have motivated the appointment of the advisor.
On their own initiative or while the advisory process lasts, the Superintendent may take or order preventive, restrictive or limiting measures for the benefit of the interests of depositors and may delegate these powers to the advisor.
ARTICLE 126. PERIOD OF THE ADVISOR. The advisor shall exercise their functions for a period of up to thirty days, unless for exceptional reasons the Superintendent decides to extend it.
During the period in which the advisor exercises their functions, the legal representation and administration of the bank shall continue to be held by its shareholders, directors and officers.
ARTICLE 127. PERIODIC REPORTS. The advisor shall render reports to the Superintendent, with a copy to the bank, with the frequency that the latter considers necessary, which must contain at a minimum a detailed and precise account of the bank's situation with respect to the irregularities that motivated their appointment. Any act or omission of the bank's employees that hinders the work of the advisor, as determined by the latter, or the execution of the preventive or corrective measures issued by the Superintendency, shall give rise to the immediate dismissal of said employees, without prejudice to other administrative sanctions that the Superintendent imposes on the bank at their discretion.
ARTICLE 128. FINAL REPORT. Upon expiration of the term of their appointment, the advisor shall issue a final report containing their supported opinion regarding the state of the bank and their recommendations to remedy the circumstances that motivated their appointment.
ARTICLE 129. EVALUATION OF THE ADVISOR'S RECOMMENDATION. The Superintendent shall have a period of fifteen days to evaluate the advisor's recommendations and adopt the measures they deem appropriate. Within this period the advisory shall continue, and the
Superintendent may summon the advisor as many times as they deem necessary so that they provide additional explanations of their management.
ARTICLE 130. APPLICATION OF CORRECTIVE MEASURES. The Superintendent shall order the bank the corrective measures they deem pertinent and the bank shall have a term of fifteen days to analyze them and present its execution schedule for the approval of the Superintendent.
Once adopted, the bank shall maintain the corrective measures, for the period determined by the Superintendent, keeping the administration under the responsibility of its board of directors, until the Superintendent evaluates the result of these. If after this period the bank fails to comply with the measures required by the Superintendent, the latter shall immediately adopt the legal or administrative measures that proceed.
CHAPTER XVI ADMINISTRATIVE AND OPERATIONAL CONTROL OF THE BANK
ARTICLE 131. TAKING OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND OPERATIONAL CONTROL. The Superintendency may assume the administrative and operational control of a bank, by means of a reasoned resolution, including the possession of its assets and the exercise of its administration, in accordance with the grounds established in article 132, for the best defense of the interests of depositors and creditors.
ARTICLE 132. GROUNDS. The Superintendent may take administrative and operational control of a bank for any of the following causes:
1. At the founded request of the bank itself.
2. If the bank cannot continue its operations without endangering the interests of depositors.
3. As a consequence of the evaluation of the report rendered by an advisor in office.
4. Non-compliance with the measures required by the Superintendency as indicated in
article 130.
5. If the bank carries out its operations in an illegal, negligent or fraudulent manner.
6. If the bank is in a state of suspension of payments.
7. If the Superintendency verifies that the capital adequacy, solvency or liquidity of the bank has deteriorated in such a way that its action is required.
ARTICLE 133. APPOINTMENT AND PERIOD OF THE INTERIM ADMINISTRATOR. At the time of taking administrative and operational control of the bank, the Superintendent shall appoint a suitable interim administrator to exclusively exercise the legal representation of the bank on behalf of the Superintendency. The period of interim administration shall not be greater than thirty days, unless, for exceptional reasons and upon founded request of the administrator, the Superintendent decides to extend it, in which case the extension shall not be greater than thirty days. The interim administrator may be an officer of the bank subject to the taking of control.
ARTICLE 134. NOTICE AND NOTIFICATION OF THE TAKING OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND OPERATIONAL CONTROL. The Superintendent shall order the posting of a notice containing the transcription of the resolution ordering the taking of administrative and operational control, as well as the appointment of the interim administrator of the bank, in a public and visible place of the bank's main establishment and its branches. The resolution shall state the time at which the taking of administrative and operational control shall enter into force, which in no case shall be prior to the time of posting of the notice.
The notice referred to in this article shall remain posted for a space of five business days, and the copy of the resolution must remain posted during the period of taking of control. Upon expiration of the five business days from the posting of the notice at the bank's main establishment, the notification shall be understood to have been made. Once the notice is posted, the resolution must be published for five business days in a newspaper of national circulation.
ARTICLE 135. MEANS OF CHALLENGING THE RESOLUTION THAT ORDERS THE TAKING OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND OPERATIONAL CONTROL. The Superintendent's resolution ordering the taking of administrative and operational control may be challenged by means of a full-jurisdiction contentious-administrative appeal before the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, in accordance with the law. Against the Superintendent's resolution ordering the taking of administrative and operational control of the bank, the suspension of the administrative act shall not be available, given that it protects a social interest.
ARTICLE 136. POWERS OF THE INTERIM ADMINISTRATOR. The interim administrator shall have the powers determined by the Superintendent at the time of their appointment or at a later date, and those inherent to the task entrusted to them. In any case, it is understood that the interim administrator shall have access to all documents, minutes, correspondence and records of the bank.
Among the powers that the interim administrator may have are:
1. To suspend or limit the payment of the bank's obligations, for a period that in no case shall exceed the term of the taking of control.
2. To employ the necessary auxiliary personnel and to remove from office those employees whose willful or negligent conduct has contributed to the taking of control.
3. To handle the bank's correspondence.
4. Any other power requested by the interim administrator and approved by the Superintendent.
5. Those additional ones that the Superintendent considers necessary.
ARTICLE 137. SUSPENSION OF TERMS. While the Superintendency keeps a bank under administrative and operational control, the prescription terms of any right or action held by the bank and the terms in the lawsuits or proceedings in which the bank is a party shall be understood to be suspended. Such terms shall remain suspended until the administrative control period ends, unless forced liquidation is ordered, in which case the provisions of article 159 of this Decree Law shall apply, except for those that pursue the enforcement of a pledge, mortgage or other real security.
ARTICLE 138. PROHIBITION OF SEQUESTRATION, ATTACHMENT OR WITHHOLDING. The bank under administrative and operational control of the Superintendency may not be subject to sequestrations, attachments, withholdings or any other precautionary measure. Likewise, the taking of administrative control suspends the prescription of the bank's credits and rights as of the date of the notice referred to in article 134, except for those attachments related to the enforcement of a pledge, mortgage or other real security.
ARTICLE 139. EXPENSES OF THE TAKING OF ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROL. All expenses caused by the taking of control, including the salaries and emoluments of the interim administrator, as fixed by the Superintendent, shall be borne by the bank under administrative and operational control.
Debts of the bank under administrative control originating prior to the taking of administrative and operational control may not be paid without the authorization of the Superintendent.
ARTICLE 140. TERMINATION OF ADMINISTRATIVE CONTROL. Upon expiration of the administrative control period, the Superintendent shall decide whether the reorganization of the bank, its forced liquidation under the terms established by this Decree Law, or the return of administrative control to its directors or legal representatives of the bank, as the case may be, is appropriate.
CHAPTER XVII REORGANIZATION OF THE BANK
ARTICLE 141. REORGANIZATION. The Superintendent shall decide the reorganization of a bank, with the purpose that the measures be taken and the changes be adopted that are necessary to protect the best interests of the depositors and creditors.
ARTICLE 142. APPROVAL OF THE REORGANIZATION. In the resolution ordering the reorganization, the Superintendent shall proceed to resolve the following:
1. The appointment of a reorganizer or a reorganization board, made up of up to three members, whose members have no direct or indirect relationship with each other up to the fourth degree of consanguinity, nor with the bank or its owner of bank shares. The reorganizer or the reorganization board shall exclusively exercise the administration and control of the bank, for as long as the reorganization lasts, and shall answer to the Superintendency. In the case of a reorganization board, at least one of its members must have a minimum of five years of experience in the banking or financial sector. In the case of a single reorganizer, they must have a minimum of five years of experience in the banking or financial sector. The Superintendency shall appoint the person who will preside over the reorganization board.
2. The instructions for the removal of any director, officer, executive, administrator or other employee that are considered necessary.
3. The period within which the reorganization must be completed, which may be brought forward or extended by the Superintendency, based on a reasoned request from the reorganizer or the reorganization board.
ARTICLE 143. NOTICE OF THE REORGANIZATION. The Superintendent shall order the posting of a notice containing the transcription of the resolution ordering the reorganization of the bank, in a public and visible place at the bank's main establishment and its branches. The resolution shall state the time at which the reorganization order shall enter into force, which in no case shall be earlier than the time of posting of the notice.
ARTICLE 144. NOTIFICATION OF THE REORGANIZATION ORDER. The notice referred to in the
previous article shall remain posted for a period of five business days, and the copy of the resolution posted must remain for the term of the reorganization. Once the five business days from the posting of the notice at the bank's main establishment have elapsed, the notification shall be deemed made. Once the notice is set, the resolution must be published for five business days in a newspaper of national circulation.
ARTICLE 145. POWERS OF THE REORGANIZER. The reorganizer or the reorganization board shall have the broadest powers to conduct the reorganization of the bank. Among said powers are:
1. Amortize losses against primary capital and secondary capital, as well as set the value of the shares at that moment.
2. Appoint new administrators.
3. Authorize the issuance of new shares of the bank, as well as their sale to third parties, at the price determined by the reorganizer or the reorganization board.
4. Manage and execute the merger or consolidation of the bank with one or more banks, the obtaining of loans, the sale or partial liquidation of its assets or the creation of liens on them, according to the criteria developed by the Superintendency.
5. Recommend to the Superintendency the compulsory liquidation process.
6. Any other powers that, upon a founded request of the reorganizer or the reorganization board, are authorized by the Superintendent for a specific purpose.
7. Those additional ones that the Superintendency considers necessary.
ARTICLE 146. REORGANIZATION PLAN AND REPORTS. The reorganizer or the reorganization board must prepare, within a maximum period of thirty days, extendable for a period of up to thirty days, a reorganization plan that shall contain the general guidelines necessary to achieve the bank's return to efficient and safe operation, taking into consideration the interest of the depositors and creditors, and that of the shareholders or partners. The plan must also contain a schedule for its execution.
The reorganization plan must be approved or rejected by the Superintendent of Banks. The approval may be subject to the conditions, modifications or instructions established by the Superintendent.
The reorganizer or the reorganization board shall render reports to the Superintendent with the frequency that the latter deems necessary, containing, at a minimum, a detailed and precise account of the bank's situation.
Whenever in the course of the reorganization situations are noticed or arise that make the reorganization plan inconvenient or unfeasible to execute, the Superintendency may modify it or decree the compulsory liquidation of the bank.
ARTICLE 147. PUBLICATION AND BINDING NATURE OF THE REORGANIZATION PLAN. The implementation of the reorganization plan shall be preceded by its publication for five consecutive business days in a newspaper of national circulation in the Republic and, during its validity, it shall be binding for all shareholders and creditors of the bank.
ARTICLE 148. MERGER, CONSOLIDATION OR SALE OF THE BANK. In the event of merger, consolidation or sale of the bank under reorganization, the reorganizer or the reorganization board may, with the approval of the Superintendent, determine a period during which pre-existing deposits may not be withdrawn, which shall generate interest at the average market rate for such period, as determined by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 149. DISQUALIFICATIONS AND SUSPENSION OF TERMS. While the Superintendency keeps a bank under reorganization, the prescriptive terms of any right or action held by the bank and the terms in the lawsuits or proceedings in which the bank is a party shall be understood to be suspended. Said terms shall remain suspended until the reorganization stage ends, unless compulsory liquidation is immediately ordered, in which case the provisions of article 159 of this Decree Law shall apply, or except those that pursue the execution of a pledge, mortgage or other real guarantee.
While the reorganization process lasts, the bank's shareholders' meeting, its directors, management and attorneys-in-fact shall be disqualified from making decisions. The Superintendency shall notify the Public Registry of Panama and other corresponding authorities about the disqualification of shareholders, directors, officers and attorneys-in-fact. The same notification must be made to the correspondent banks of the entity under reorganization.
ARTICLE 150. PROHIBITION OF SEQUESTRATION, ATTACHMENT OR RETENTION. The bank under reorganization may not be subject to sequestrations, attachments, retentions or any other precautionary measure. Likewise, the reorganization suspends the prescription of the bank's credits, rights and actions as of the date of the notice referred to in article 143.
Nor may debts of the bank under reorganization originating prior to the reorganization be paid without the authorization of the Superintendency, except those related to the execution of a pledge, mortgage or other real guarantee.
ARTICLE 151. MEANS OF CHALLENGE. The Superintendent's resolution ordering the reorganization may be challenged by means of a full-jurisdiction contentious-administrative appeal before the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, in accordance with the law. Against the Superintendent's resolution ordering the reorganization of the bank, the suspension of the administrative act shall not be available by virtue of the fact that it protects a social interest.
ARTICLE 152. EXPENSES OF THE REORGANIZATION. All expenses caused by the reorganization, including the salaries and emoluments of the reorganizer or reorganizers, as fixed by the Superintendency, shall be borne by the bank under reorganization.
ARTICLE 153. TERMINATION OF THE STATE OF REORGANIZATION. The state of reorganization shall terminate upon the expiration of the period designated for that purpose or of its extension. In those cases in which the reorganization has not been satisfactorily completed or at any time when the Superintendent considers it necessary, because the bank is in a state of insolvency or for any other reason that makes its recovery impossible or extremely difficult, the Superintendent shall terminate the reorganization and order the forced liquidation of the bank.
If the reorganization is satisfactorily concluded, the Superintendent shall hand over the administration and control of the bank to its directors or legal representatives, as the case may be.
CHAPTER XVIII FORCED LIQUIDATION
ARTICLE 154. LIQUIDATION ORDER. If the Superintendent deems the forced liquidation of a bank necessary, he shall issue a reasoned resolution in which he orders its administrative liquidation and appoints one or more liquidators who must meet the same requirements as those established to act as interim administrator of a bank.
ARTICLE 155. APPOINTMENT OF THE LIQUIDATOR OR THE LIQUIDATION BOARD. The Superintendent shall appoint, as the case may be and at his discretion, depending on the complexity of the bank, a liquidator or a liquidation board, made up of up to three members whose members have no direct or indirect relationship with the bank or with each other, up to the fourth degree of consanguinity. The liquidator or the liquidation board shall exclusively exercise the legal representation, administration and control of the bank, and shall be accountable to the Superintendent. In the case of a liquidation board, at least one of its members shall have a minimum of five years of experience in the banking or financial sector. In the case of a single liquidator, he must have a minimum of five years of experience in the banking or financial sector. The Superintendent shall appoint the person responsible for presiding over the liquidation board.
The liquidator or the liquidation board shall be functionally dependent on the Superintendent of Banks, and shall report its actions to the Board of Directors through the Superintendent. In addition, it must keep an orderly and verified account of its management.
The liquidator or the liquidation board shall guide the course of the forced liquidation process, taking into account the following criteria:
1. The speed that the process must have in order to make the bank's assets liquid as promptly as possible, and in accordance with the rules developed in that regard by the Superintendency, to satisfy the debts that may exist.
2. Diligence, simplicity and transparency in the procedure.
3. Respect for the rights and priorities recognized by this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 156. NOTICE OF FORCED LIQUIDATION. The Superintendent shall order the posting of a notice containing the transcription of the resolution ordering the forced liquidation of the bank, in a public and visible place at the bank's main establishment and its branches. The resolution shall state the time at which the liquidation order shall enter into force, which in no case shall be earlier than the time of posting of the notice.
ARTICLE 157. NOTIFICATION OF THE FORCED LIQUIDATION ORDER. The notice referred to in the previous article shall remain posted for a term of five business days, and must remain posted during the liquidation. Once the five business days from the posting of the notice at the bank's main establishment have elapsed, the notification shall be deemed made. Once the notice has been posted, the resolution must be published for five business days in a newspaper of national circulation.
ARTICLE 158. CHALLENGE TO THE LIQUIDATION ORDER. The resolution ordering the forced liquidation may be challenged by the affected party by means of a full-jurisdiction contentious-administrative appeal before the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, in
accordance with the law, within the fifteen business days following the last publication of the notice referred to in this Chapter. Against the Superintendent's resolution ordering the forced liquidation of the bank, the suspension of the administrative act shall not be available, given that it protects a social interest.
ARTICLE 159. SUSPENSION OF TERMS. When a bank is in a state of forced liquidation, the prescription terms of any right or action held by the bank and the terms in judicial or administrative proceedings in which the bank is a party shall be understood to be suspended for up to six months, except for those seeking the enforcement of a pledge, mortgage or other real security. The bank may waive this right in those cases in which it considers it advantageous for the liquidation.
ARTICLE 160. SUSPENSION OF INTEREST. As of the resolution ordering the forced liquidation, interest on the obligations of the bank in liquidation shall cease to accrue, unless they are obligations secured by a pledge or mortgage on the bank's assets, in which case the creditors may demand the current interest on their claim up to the amount of the proceeds of the encumbered property.
ARTICLE 161. PAYMENT OF PRIMARY DEPOSITS AND OTHER OBLIGATIONS. In order to help maintain confidence in the banking system, the liquidator or the liquidation board shall pay all of the deposits and other obligations described in numerals 1 and 2 of article 167 of this Decree Law, within fifteen days following the date on which the resolution ordering the liquidation becomes final. Such payment shall be made against the available liquid assets to the extent they suffice, and must be made prior to the recognition procedures referred to in articles 162 and 163 below and in accordance with the information contained in the bank's books.
ARTICLE 162. APPEARANCE OF DEPOSITORS AND OTHER CREDITORS AT THE LIQUIDATION. The resolution ordering the liquidation shall require the depositors and other creditors to appear at the bank to submit their claims. Said depositors and creditors may appear at any time until the liquidator or the liquidation board issues the report referred to in the following article, a term that in no case shall be less than thirty days or more than sixty days, counted from the last publication referred to in article 157. However, the failure to appear shall not affect the obligations duly verified in the bank's records.
ARTÍCULO 163. INFORME PRELIMINAR. The liquidator or the liquidation board shall prepare a preliminary report, which shall contain the following information:
1. Name of the bank's creditors.
2. Title or proof of the claims and their priority.
3. Identification of the bank's debtors.
4. General balance sheet, determining the losses charged to capital funds.
PARÁGRAFO. The liquidator shall publish a list of debtors and creditors so that they may appear for the liquidation, for a period of three business days in a newspaper of national circulation and on the website of the bank and of the Superintendency, where the information must remain accessible during the liquidation period. Creditors shall have a term of thirty days, counted from the last publication, to request clarifications or file any objections they deem appropriate.
ARTICLE 164. RESOLUTION ON OBJECTIONS. Upon expiration of the thirty-day term referred to in the previous article, the liquidator or the liquidation board shall issue as many reasoned resolutions as it deems necessary, in which it shall resolve the objections filed and order the following:
1. Identification of the assets that make up the liquidation estate.
2. Inventory of the deposits and other obligations that were accepted and those that were rejected, indicating their nature and amount.
3. The order of priority in which the bank's obligations shall be paid.
Likewise, in a separate record, the liquidator or the liquidation board shall issue a resolution containing the list of assets excluded from the liquidation estate.
Each of the resolutions referred to in this article must be published in a newspaper of national circulation for five business days and may be challenged by incidental proceedings before the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, within the five business days following the last publication. The proceedings shall be conducted before the liquidator or the liquidation board who, at its prudent discretion, may order the consolidation of incidents that have a common cause, parties, or claim.
Once the procedure is completed, the liquidator or the liquidation board shall send the various records to the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice, together with an explanatory report of its resolution, so that the incidents may be decided. In consideration of the social interest nature that the forced administrative liquidation must have, the challenges submitted by the liquidator or the liquidation board to the Third Chamber must be resolved with priority over any other contentious-administrative process.
ARTICLE 165. LIQUIDATION ESTATE. All present and future assets and rights of the bank in liquidation form part of the liquidation estate. The following do not form part of the liquidation estate:
1. Securities that have been delivered to the bank for collection and those it has acquired on behalf of another, provided they are issued or endorsed directly in favor of the principal or trustor.
2. Moneys or assets remitted to the bank in the course of a commission, mandate or trust, provided there is written proof of the existence of the contract as of the date on which the liquidation was ordered. Included in this numeral are severance funds, pension and retirement funds and other moneys administered by the bank. The administration of the trusts may be delegated to third parties duly qualified for that purpose.
3. In general, identifiable items that, although in the possession of the bank, belong to another person, which must be evidenced with sufficient proof.
4. The sums that the bank must return by reason of having received them as the price for securities and other third-party assets that the liquidator has disposed of.
5. Assets deposited in the bank's safe-deposit boxes and in general movable assets or securities that the bank holds as depositary or custodian.
The liquidator or the liquidation board must return to their owners the assets that do not form part of the estate as soon as reasonably possible, once identified. The liquidator shall return the assets in accordance with the bank's records.
ARTICLE 166. DEBTS OF THE ESTATE. The following are considered debts of the estate:
1. Those arising from judicial expenses or out-of-court operations incurred in the common interest of the creditors for the verification and liquidation of the assets and liabilities of the liquidation, for the administration, preservation and realization of the bank's assets and for the distribution of the price they produce, including the fees of the liquidator or of the liquidation board and the trustee referred to in articles 168 and 169, the salaries of the personnel providing services in the liquidation and the operating expenses of the bank.
2. All those resulting from acts or contracts legally executed or entered into by the liquidator or the liquidation board or the trustee.
3. The sums that the bank must return because some act or contract of the bank has been rescinded and the compensation owed to the good-faith possessor of the things that the liquidation reclaims.
4. The credits originating in favor of the banks of the system as a result of the insufficiency of funds of the bank in the clearing at the Clearing House.
5. Current national and municipal taxes.
The debts of the estate must be paid with priority over any other obligation of the bank, except for obligations secured by pledge, mortgage or other real rights referred to in
article 176.
ARTICLE 167. ORDER OF PRIORITY. Except as provided in other articles of this Decree Law, the obligations of the bank shall be paid during the liquidation in the following order:
1. New deposits constituted during the reorganization period.
2. Deposits of ten thousand balboas or less. In the event that there are two or more deposits of this category in the name of the same person, the largest of them shall be paid up to the sum of ten thousand balboas. This limit may be modified by the Superintendency.
3. Labor obligations.
4. Obligations in favor of the Social Security Fund in the form of employer-employee contributions of the bank's employees.
5. Tax obligations with the National Treasury or the municipalities, as well as fees for public services provided by the State.
6. The other deposits and other obligations.
The obligations included within each of the above categories shall be paid pro rata. Each category excludes the others according to the order established in this article to the extent that the bank's assets suffice.
Obligations recognized by judgments or arbitration awards shall be paid in the corresponding category, according to their nature and pro rata.
The order of priority or preference established in other laws shall not apply to the payment of the obligations of banks.
ARTICLE 168. POWERS OF THE LIQUIDATOR OR THE LIQUIDATION BOARD. The liquidator or the liquidation board shall have the following powers:
1. Suspend or limit the payment of the bank's obligations and the debts of the estate according to the availability of resources.
2. Employ the necessary personnel and remove from office those employees whose willful or negligent conduct has led to the liquidation, as well as those employees who, due to a reduction in the bank's activities, are unnecessary.
3. Handle correspondence and issue any document in the name of the bank.
4. Administer, control and safeguard the bank's assets.
5. Assign or sell assets in accordance with their realizable value, net of provisions, reserves and any other adjustment determined by the Superintendency, in accordance with existing prudential rules and regulations.
6. Transfer all or part of the bank's assets and liabilities to an entity licensed to engage in the trust business in Panama, with prior authorization from the Superintendency.
7. Execute the acts and enter into the contracts that fall within the scope of its powers that allow the initiation, completion and execution of the liquidation through the transfer of assets and liabilities and the trust.
8. Establish in the trust contract the mandates, terms and conditions for the proper liquidation of the transferred assets and liabilities.
9. Any other power that, upon a substantiated request from the liquidator or the liquidation board, is authorized by the Superintendent for a specific purpose.
ARTICLE 169. AUTHORIZATION OF THE TRUST. When the Superintendent considers that the realizable value of the assets in the liquidation estate and the opportunity and probability of recovery of the claims do not justify the costs of the liquidation, he may order the liquidator or the liquidation board to transfer the remaining assets and liabilities of the bank to a trust entity.
The transferred assets shall be taken in accordance with their realizable value, net of provisions, reserves and any other adjustment determined by the Superintendent in accordance with existing prudential rules and regulations.
The transferred liabilities shall be taken pro rata in accordance with the realizable value of the transferred assets.
ARTICLE 170. OBLIGATIONS OF THE TRUSTEE. The trustee shall be obligated to the following:
1. Issue negotiable participation certificates that attribute to their holders the rights set forth therein and that shall be representative of the aliquot share of the trust patrimony. The participation certificates shall be issued in registered form.
2. Pay the obligations of the liquidation.
3. Manage the disposal and realization of all the bank's goods, rights and other assets under the most advantageous conditions possible.
4. Administer the credit portfolio and carry out the corresponding collection efforts.
5. Administer, in general, the transferred assets and liabilities.
6. Issue monthly reports required by the Superintendency.
7. Any other obligations established by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 171. NON-APPLICATION OF SECURITIES LEGISLATION. The trust referred to in article 169 of this Decree Law, the negotiable participation certificates and the issuance thereof, indicated in article 170, shall not be subject to the provisions contained in Decree Law 1 of 1999.
ARTICLE 172. CESSATION OF THE LIQUIDATOR OR THE LIQUIDATION BOARD. Once the functions for which it was appointed have been fulfilled and all assets have been transferred to the trust, the liquidator or the liquidation board shall cease in its functions.
ARTICLE 173. RESUMPTION OF THE LIQUIDATION PROCESS. If after the termination of the liquidation of a bank knowledge is obtained of the existence of goods or rights owned by said bank, the Superintendent shall order the resumption of the liquidation process, shall appoint a liquidator in order to inventory such assets and transfer them to the trust to which the residual assets and liabilities of the liquidation were transferred.
Those persons who consider themselves affected by the resolution may challenge it by means of a motion for reconsideration before the Superintendent, or an appeal before the Board of Directors of the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 174. TERMINATION OF CONTRACTS. From the date on which the resolution ordering the forced liquidation becomes final, the liquidator or the liquidation board may terminate the lease, service, administrative and operational contracts, including the compromise or arbitration clauses contained in said contracts. From the finality of the resolution, the bank in liquidation may not be sued for the breach of said contracts and the penalty clauses agreed therein shall not apply.
ARTICLE 175. INHIBITION OF PROCEEDINGS. Once the resolution ordering the liquidation of a bank becomes final, the bank may not be sued or called to be a party in an arbitral proceeding.
ARTICLE 176. OBLIGATIONS SECURED BY PLEDGE, MORTGAGE OR OTHER REAL RIGHTS. Obligations secured by pledge, mortgage or other real rights shall enjoy preference over any other obligations with respect to the encumbered assets, up to the extent of their realizable value, except for amounts owed to the Treasury as real estate tax on the encumbered assets.
Creditors may present said credits in the liquidation or claim them separately through the corresponding judicial or extrajudicial proceeding.
ARTICLE 177. FINANCIAL LEASE. In relation to those assets leased by the bank in accordance with a financial lease contract for movable assets, the provisions of the legal regime regulating said matter shall be observed.
ARTICLE 178. DISSOLUTION OF THE BANK. Upon completion of the liquidation, the liquidator or the liquidation board or the trustee, as the case may be, must submit, for the approval of the Superintendency, under the terms established by it, the final liquidation report. Once approved, the Superintendency shall order the dissolution of the bank and shall send the corresponding official letter to the Public Registry.
In the case of a branch of a foreign bank, the corresponding registration in the Public Registry shall be cancelled.
ARTICLE 179. PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES OR ATTACHMENTS. The assets of a bank in liquidation are not subject to precautionary measures or attachments, unless they are based on a real right. Those already carried out shall be lifted for the benefit of the bank in liquidation.
ARTICLE 180. APPEAL BEFORE THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The resolutions issued by the liquidator or the liquidation board that are not subject to challenge before the Third Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice shall be appealable before the Board of Directors of the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 181. INADMISSIBILITY OF BANKRUPTCY. The declaration of bankruptcy of banks may not be requested.
ARTICLE 182. APPLICABLE LEGAL PROVISIONS. Banks that are in the process of liquidation upon the entry into force of this Decree Law shall be governed by the procedure established in Decree Law 9 of 1998, prior to this amendment.
ARTICLE 183. COSTS. All costs caused by the liquidation, including the salaries and emoluments of the liquidator or of the liquidation board, as fixed by the Superintendent, shall be borne by the bank in liquidation.
TITLE IV ON SANCTIONS
ARTICLE 184. CRITERION FOR THE IMPOSITION OF SANCTIONS. The Superintendent shall impose the administrative sanctions that apply for the violation of the provisions of this Decree Law and of the laws and agreements that regulate and amend it, taking into consideration the seriousness of the offense, recidivism and the magnitude of the damage and harm caused to third parties.
The Superintendency shall establish the gradation of the sanctions and the sanctioning procedure to be followed in compliance with the provisions of this Title and of special laws.
ARTICLE 185. FINES. The following sanctions are established:
1. Fine of up to one million balboas to:
a. Natural or legal persons who engage in the banking business without a license.
b. Those who fail to comply with the provisions of Chapter XIII of Title III on the Prevention of the Crime of Money Laundering, Financing of Terrorism and related crimes.
2. Fine of up to five hundred thousand balboas for the violation of the provisions of Title III of this Decree Law related to:
a. The obligation to submit to inspection, referred to in Chapter IV.
b. Capital, referred to in Chapter V.
c. Bank liquidity, referred to in Chapter VI.
d. The documents and reports, referred to in Chapter IX.
e. The prohibitions and limitations, referred to in Chapter X.
f. The confidentiality obligations, referred to in Chapter XII.
ARTICLE 186. GENERIC SANCTIONS. Acts violating this Decree Law and the rules that develop it for which no specific sanction is established shall be sanctioned by the Superintendent, at his discretion and without prejudice to any criminal action that may apply, through any of the following sanctions:
1. Private reprimand.
2. Public reprimand.
3. Fine of up to two hundred fifty thousand balboas.
ARTICLE 187. PROGRESSIVE FINES. In all cases in which the commission of acts violating the provisions of this Decree Law and the rules that develop it persists over time, the Superintendent may impose progressive fines until the violation committed is remedied.
ARTICLE 188. SANCTIONS. The special and generic sanctions established in this Decree Law may be imposed by the Superintendent on the bank, its directors, dignitaries, managers, employees and other officers, who have participated in the violation of the provisions of this Decree Law. In the case of officers or directors, the bank shall be jointly and severally liable for the fine imposed on said persons.
The fines and sanctions imposed by the Superintendent are independent and without prejudice to other fines or sanctions that may apply for acts violating any other applicable rules or laws and to the civil or criminal sanctions that may apply.
ARTICLE 189. PUBLICATION OF SANCTIONS. The Superintendent shall have the power to publish the sanctions imposed in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 190. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE. If the Superintendent considers that there is a violation of this Decree Law and of the rules or agreements that modify or supplement it, he shall notify the corresponding bank or supervised entity, so that it may present its defenses and provide the pertinent evidence, within a period not exceeding thirty days, counted from the date of notification.
The procedure for the imposition of sanctions shall be developed by the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 191. OFFICIALS OF THE SUPERINTENDENCY. Officials of the Superintendency who have incurred a violation of the provisions of this Decree Law shall be subject to the sanctions referred to in this Title, independently and without prejudice to other fines or sanctions that may apply for acts violating any other applicable rule or law and to any civil or criminal sanctions that may correspond.
TITLE V BANKING CLIENT
CHAPTER I.
PRINCIPLES
ARTICLE 192. PRINCIPLES. The principles established in Titles V and VI of this Decree Law are intended to provide the contractual relationship with the necessary and desired equity to guarantee the balance of the parties.
Banks are obliged to provide their services to banking clients with transparency, probity and equity, in accordance with the rules and principles of this Title.
ARTICLE 193. OBLIGATIONS OF BANKS. The obligations of banks are the following:
1. Inform the banking client, from the beginning of the relationship, of the terms and conditions applicable to the particular contract.
2. Refrain from using acts granted or performed by the banking client, such as the signing of blank documents, for purposes other than those announced at the time they were requested.
3. Refrain from preventing, in any way, the banking client, without undermining compliance with its obligations to the bank, from withdrawing from maintaining the relationship with the bank.
4. Not apply or charge fees for services that have not been provided by the bank and that have not been previously agreed with the banking client, and reimburse them at the time they are demanded.
5. Be diligent in attending to queries and requests of the banking client to know the status of its obligations or to prove its knowledge before third parties.
6. Inform, at no cost and within a reasonable time, about the evolution of the operations, accounts and businesses they maintain with them, as well as to issue free of charge the receipts and certifications of the transactions of the banking clients.
ARTICLE 194. RIGHTS OF BANKING CLIENTS. Banking clients shall have, among others, the following basic and non-waivable rights:
1. Know before, during and after, all information clearly, truthfully and at no cost, regarding a banking product or service.
2. Withdraw, at any time, from continuing the relationship with the bank, without undermining compliance with its obligations, nor the charges previously agreed and applicable to the early withdrawal from the relationship.
3. Confidentiality with respect to its relationship with the bank before third parties, as well as its privacy.
4. Receive a diligent and efficient service from the bank, particularly with respect to queries and requests to know the status of the obligations or rights arising from them.
CHAPTER II CONTRACTS AND BANKING DOCUMENTS
ARTICLE 195. REVIEW OF MODELS OF BANKING CONTRACTS. Banks shall keep updated models of banking contracts and other accessory documents at the disposal of the Superintendency, which may review them at any time and issue opinions on them regarding the provisions contained in this Decree Law and the rules that develop it.
The review and non-objection of models of contracts or of any documents by the Superintendency shall not inhibit a consumer from its right to resort to a jurisdictional authority in case it considers that its rights have been violated.
ARTICLE 196. WRITTEN CONTRACTS. Banking contracts shall contain, at least at the time of contracting, the following basic information:
1. Full name, nationality, domicile and personal identity card number or other valid identification document of each of the contracting parties. In the case of a legal person, the corporate name, the registry identification data or other legal equivalents, registered office plus the complete general details of its legal representative must be indicated.
2. Detailed description of the services contracted.
3. Total amount of the obligation contracted or of the transaction in question, expressed in monetary terms, in cases where applicable.
4. Indication of the frequency with which the payments or installments must be made, the amount of these and the place where they must be made.
5. Term of the obligation contracted or validity of the contract.
6. Nominal interest rate and the effective interest rate applicable with indication of its calculation method. In the case of lines of credit, the formula for determining the applicable effective interest rate must be expressed.
7. In the event that the contract or transaction contains exclusions, limitations and/or grounds for termination, these must appear highlighted within the text.
8. Date on which the contract or transaction is formalized.
9. In the same contract or in a separate document that in any case must be delivered to the banking client, a detailed description of the amounts that will be charged to a banking client must be made, indicating the concept of the charge and its expression or estimate in monetary terms. Credit investigation expenses, application processing, default interest, surcharges, commissions, notarial and registration expenses, insurance premiums, additional charges and any other of a similar nature are understood to be included.
10. The form and frequency with which the banking entity will inform the banking client about any change or modification to the terms and conditions agreed in the executed contract.
11. Any other clause or provision that the parties consider convenient to stipulate.
PARAGRAPH. The provisions of articles 72 and 73 of Law 45 of 2007 shall not apply to banking contracts and transactions.
ARTICLE 197. BLANK DOCUMENTS. The banking client may sign accessory documents in blank, provided they are related to the principal transaction to which they accede and are clearly identified as such.
A brief description of the accessory document or documents signed in blank must be specified in the principal contract or in another document signed by the bank and the banking client.
Once the contractual relationship between the banking client and the bank has ended, the unused accessory documents signed in blank must be returned to the banking client and, if within thirty business days the latter does not retrieve said documents, the bank shall proceed to their destruction.
The foregoing must be understood without prejudice to the provisions of the Law on Negotiable Documents.
TITLE VI PROTECTION OF THE BANKING CONSUMER
CHAPTER I.
GENERAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 198. SPECIAL RULES AND COMPETENCE. The protection of the consumer or user of banking services shall be governed by the special rules contained in this Title.
The Superintendency shall exclusively ensure compliance with the provisions of this Title.
Consequently, it shall have the power to develop it and establish the meaning, scope and interpretation of its rules in the manner it deems convenient to comply with what is established herein.
By reason of its banking nature, the Superintendency is granted exclusive competence to hear and protect the rights of the banking consumer.
ARTICLE 199 6 . BANKING CONSUMER. For the purposes of this Title, a banking consumer shall be considered any banking client, whether a natural or legal person, who acquires a banking service or product, active or passive, that meets the following conditions:
6 Through article 2 of Agreement No. 5-2025 of 15 July 2025, "Which updates the guidelines established in articles 199 and 208 of the Banking Law", the amounts established in this article are increased in accordance with the power granted to the Board of Directors.
1. Natural persons:
a) Financing intended for the personal consumption of the banking consumer or their family, as defined by the Superintendency, up to an amount of fifty thousand balboas per transaction.
b) Financing for the purchase, construction or improvement of the primary residence of the banking consumer or their family, up to an amount of one hundred twenty-five thousand balboas per transaction.
c) Demand deposits whose holder is the banking consumer up to an amount of twenty thousand balboas per account.
d) Savings or fixed-term deposits whose holder is the banking consumer up to an amount of fifty thousand per account.
2. Legal persons:
a) Financing received for commercial purposes, by micro and small enterprises, as defined by the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise Law, up to a total amount of two hundred thousand balboas.
b) Financing received through a legal person for the final use of its shareholders, owners, family members or their beneficiaries, up to an amount of one hundred twenty-five thousand balboas.
c) Any other transaction of a legal person, as determined by the Superintendency.
PARAGRAPH. The Board of Directors shall have the power to update the amounts established in this
article, when it deems convenient, taking into account, among other criteria, the consumer price index.
CHAPTER II ON INFORMATION
ARTICLE 200. SUPPLY OF INFORMATION. Of the content of article 36 of Law 45 of 2007, only the provisions established in numerals 1, 2, 7, 9, 12 and 13 shall be applicable to banks, which establish the obligation to supply information to their banking consumer.
For the purposes of the provisions established in said numerals, and provided that the banking contracts comply with the requirements of law, it shall be understood that the suppliers comply with the obligation to supply information to the banking consumer, with the delivery of the document containing the contract or the terms and conditions of the service or product in question.
CHAPTER III ON NULLITIES
ARTICLE 201. NULLITY OF CLAUSES IN ADHESION CONTRACTS. In banking adhesion contracts, stipulations that imply waiver or diminution of a right recognized in this Decree Law and the rules that develop it shall be considered null.
Excluded from the effects of said cause of nullity are those clauses that imply waivers of rights or procedures, expressly permitted by other laws.
ARTICLE 202. NULLITY OF CONTRACTUAL CLAUSES. The scope and interpretation of
article 74 of Law 45 of 2007, shall be as follows:
1. The abusive nature, and therefore the absolute nullity of a contractual clause, shall be assessed taking into account the nature of the products or services that are the object of the contract and considering, at the time of its execution, all the circumstances concurrent therein, as well as all the other clauses of the contract, or of another on which it depends.
2. Price fluctuations on financial products shall not be considered changes in the conditions of the contract, if so agreed therein.
3. Bank contracts drafted in a language other than Spanish shall not be considered null, provided that the user of the banking service so requests and it is not a public document.
Likewise, the drafting of a bank contract in a language other than Spanish shall be permitted in those cases in which the international nature of the contract so requires.
4. Clauses that allow the waiver of domicile, of the proceedings of the process, of the terms and of personal notifications shall not be considered null, provided that they conform to the rules contemplated in the Judicial Code, the Civil Code and/or other laws.
5. Clauses that allow the bank to change or modify the terms and conditions of the bank contract shall not be considered null, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 10 of
article 196.
ARTICLE 203. GROUNDS FOR RELATIVE NULLITY. The parameters for determining the adequate applicability in each of the grounds for relative nullity established in article 75 of Law 45 of 2007 shall be those established by special laws. In the absence of these grounds, the provisions established by the rules developed by the Superintendency shall apply and, in their absence, the banking uses and practices generally observed in the market and the principles of good faith and contractual balance.
ARTICLE 204. DECLARATION OF NULLITY. The Superintendency may not declare the nullity of a clause in a bank adhesion contract. Such power shall be the responsibility of the competent authorities.
ARTICLE 205. COMPETENCE FOR DECLARATION OF NULLITY. The declaration of nullity of clauses in contracts between banks and their clients is subject to the jurisdiction of the courts, in the manner provided by law. Accordingly, it is not the power or responsibility of the Superintendency to declare any nullity in contracts between banks and their clients.
CHAPTER IV ON CLAIMS
ARTICLE 206. CLAIMS ATTENTION SYSTEM. All banks with a general license shall have an administrative system in accordance with their activities, responsible for knowing and attending, in a personalized manner, the claims, complaints and controversies that arise from the relationship with their clients.
The executive responsible for this service shall report to the bank's management. Its decisions shall be binding for the bank and shall be issued within a term no greater than thirty days. In its response to the banking consumer, the bank must indicate that in case of disagreement, they have an additional term of thirty days to present their claim before the Superintendency, as established in
article 211.
The banks shall be responsible for informing and indicating to their clients the location of the claims attention service and of the responsible executive. The banks shall keep a detailed record of the claims presented to them.
ARTICLE 207. RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS. The banking consumer, in addition to the provisions of article 194, shall have the right to be attended by way of administrative claim by the Superintendency, with respect to the matters established in Titles V and VI of this Decree Law.
For its part, the bank shall have the obligation to appear before the Superintendency when, through the administrative channel, a claim is presented against it for the violation or non-compliance of any provision of this Title.
ARTICLE 208 7 . JURISDICTION AND COMPETENCE. The Superintendency shall have the exclusive power to know and decide in the administrative channel the claims that, for violation of the rules established in Titles V and VI of this Decree Law, banking consumers file against banks, up to an amount of twenty thousand balboas. Once the Superintendency takes knowledge of these claims for non-compliance with banking rules of banking consumer protection and by reason of the interest it protects and the nature of the activity, there shall be no intervention, simultaneous or subsequent, of any other authority.
PARAGRAPH. The Board of Directors shall have the power to update the amounts established in this
article, when it deems convenient, taking into account, among other criteria, the consumer price index.
ARTICLE 209. EXCEPTIONS TO COMPETENCE. The Superintendency shall not take knowledge of claims on those matters established in Law 6 of 1987, regarding the benefits of retirees, pensioners, the third and fourth age; Law 24 of 2002 on credit references, and Law 45 of 2007 regarding truthfulness in advertising.
ARTICLE 210. SOLUTION OF CLAIMS. Violations of the rights and obligations established in Title VI of this Decree Law shall be known and resolved through administrative recourse before the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 211. CLAIMS BEFORE THE SUPERINTENDENCY. The Superintendency shall take knowledge of the claims of banking consumers against banks, in the following cases:
1. When the bank fails to resolve the consumer's claim within a term of thirty days, and the consumer decides to file the corresponding administrative claim before the Superintendency.
2. When the bank's decision, even if timely, does not satisfy the banking consumer and they decide to file the claim before the Superintendency.
PARAGRAPH. The banking consumer shall have a term of thirty days, counted from the date on which they obtained a formal response from the bank, to submit their claim before the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 212. ARBITRATION OF BANKING SERVICES. Arbitration of banking services is instituted as an alternative method of resolution of controversies arising between banks and banking consumers. The Superintendency shall be empowered to arbitrate in conflicts between banks and banking consumers when the parties submit them to its competence, with full power to settle these conflicts, in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law and the rules that develop it.
ARTICLE 213. SUPPLEMENTARY RULE. For the purposes of this Title, in matters of consumer protection, the pertinent provisions of Law 45 of 2007 shall apply, insofar as they do not contradict the provisions of this Title.
Insofar as they are applicable, said provisions shall be interpreted in the administrative sphere and shall in all cases be applied in accordance with the rules and principles established in this Title.
TITLE VII MISCELLANEOUS AND FINAL PROVISIONS
ARTICLE 214. DAYS OF CLOSURE OF OPERATIONS. The Superintendency may, after prior notice to the public, establish the days on which banks shall not provide service to the public, without these necessarily coinciding with holidays or days of national mourning.
7 Through Article 3 of Agreement No. 5-2025 of 15 July 2025, "Which updates the guidelines established in Articles 199 and 208 of the Banking Law", the amount of the claims that the Superintendency of Banks may hear and decide is updated, in accordance with the power granted to the Board of Directors through this article.
ARTICLE 215. INACTIVE ASSETS. Every bank must notify the Superintendency of any assets, funds and securities in its possession that remain inactive for five years and belong to persons whose whereabouts are unknown. The Superintendency, after verifying this fact, shall order that their net value be transferred to the Banco Nacional de Panamá.
In the case of numbered accounts, the full identification of the client at the time of transferring the account to the Banco Nacional de Panamá shall not infringe the duty of confidentiality referred to in Law 18 of 1959.
ARTICLE 216. RESTITUTION OF FUNDS. The Banco Nacional de Panamá shall be obligated to return to their owner the funds referred to in the preceding article, provided that they are claimed within ten years following the date on which they were transferred to it, but the restitution shall be made without interest. Once said period has elapsed, the funds shall be transferred to the National Treasury.
ARTICLE 217. UNITY OF THE BANK. All establishments of a bank in Panama shall be considered as a single bank for the purposes of this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 218. IMMUNITY OF ACCOUNTS. Funds of any nature deposited in the country by Central Banks, or similar institutions when they are depositories of the international reserves of Sovereign States, may not be subject to precautionary measures, attachments or any type of retention.
ARTICLE 219. DESIGNATION OF BENEFICIARIES IN DEPOSIT ACCOUNTS. Banks may agree with their clients that in the event of the death of the holder of an account, whatever its nature, the balance thereof, regardless of its amount, may be paid by the bank directly and without any other formality or judicial proceeding, to the person or persons designated by said holder as beneficiary or beneficiaries. For these purposes, the designation of the beneficiary or beneficiaries shall be made by the holder or holders, with the formalities that the bank determines.
Each bank shall establish a procedure for the delivery of the balance of the accounts, which must be informed to the holder or holders who designate beneficiaries. The corresponding payment must be made by the bank once the beneficiary has been duly identified and the death of the holder or holders has been verified. Provided that the established formalities are complied with, the payments referred to in this article shall be considered as duly made by the bank and may not be disputed.
ARTICLE 220. DEPOSITS IN BANKS WITH AN INTERNATIONAL LICENSE. Money and other assets and securities deposited in banks with an international license shall be considered domiciled in Panama and, therefore, shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the Panamanian courts.
ARTICLE 221. CREDITORS OF BRANCHES IN PANAMA. In the event of liquidation, the assets of the branch of a bank in Panama shall serve to satisfy first the creditors of the branch, whether national or foreign.
ARTICLE 222. SUBMISSION TO PANAMANIAN LEGISLATION AND JURISDICTION. Assets transferred or deposited in banks, whether as a deposit, or by way of mandate or trust, or under any other title, shall be entirely subject to the laws and jurisdiction of the Republic of Panama, unless the instruments by which their transfer is made provide otherwise.
It is established as a rule of public order and public policy that the assets of foreigners, as defined in the paragraph of this article, are fully subject to the principle of autonomy of the will and to the regime of free disposal of assets, even when the succession laws or the matrimonial regime of the country of nationality or domicile of the holder, or of the settlor, or of the founder, or of the beneficiary, provide otherwise.
PARAGRAPH. For the purposes of this article, the assets of foreigners shall be considered to be the assets owned by, or held by settlors or beneficiaries who are, persons who are neither Panamanian nor residents of the Republic of Panama at the time the transfer of the assets is perfected.
ARTICLE 223. SEQUESTRATION OR ATTACHMENT AGAINST ASSETS OF BANKS. In the event of sequestration, attachment or any other precautionary measure against a bank's own assets, the corresponding order shall be notified to the Superintendency before its execution, so that it may adopt the pertinent provisions in accordance with the provisions of this Decree Law, for which it shall have a period of thirty days to order what is appropriate.
In the event that the Superintendency does not take any provision or measure within said period, the judge shall continue with the execution of the respective resolution, in the manner provided in the Judicial Code, without prejudice to the powers granted to the Superintendency by this Decree Law.
ARTICLE 224. RECOURSES. Except for the special cases established in this Decree Law, the resolutions of the Superintendent shall admit motions for reconsideration before the Superintendent himself and appeals before the Board of Directors, for which the affected party shall have a term of five business days, counted from the notification of the respective resolution or from the notification of the resolution that decides the motion for reconsideration, as the case may be. The resolution that decides the appeal shall exhaust the administrative remedy.
The resolutions issued by the Board of Directors in the first instance shall only admit a motion for reconsideration before the Board itself, for which the affected party shall have a term of five business days, counted from its notification. The resolution of the Board of Directors or the one that decides the appeal shall exhaust the administrative remedy.
The foregoing is without prejudice to the remedies that may correspond in the contentious-administrative jurisdiction.
ARTICLE 225. SPECIAL FISCAL PERIOD. Banks that wish to adopt a fiscal period different from the calendar year and have received the pertinent approval from the Ministry of Economy and Finance must notify said authorization to the Superintendency.
ARTICLE 226. REFERENCES TO THE NATIONAL BANKING COMMISSION. Any reference to the National Banking Commission in laws, decrees and other provisions, as well as in contracts, agreements, accords or circulars prior to this Decree Law, shall be understood as made with respect to the Superintendency, and the rights, powers, obligations and functions of the former as so established shall be deemed to be the rights, powers, obligations and functions of the latter, unless expressly provided otherwise in this Decree Law.
Likewise, any reference to the Executive Director of the National Banking Commission in laws, decrees and other provisions, as well as in contracts, agreements, accords or circulars prior to this Decree Law, shall be understood as made with respect to the Superintendent, and the powers, obligations and functions of the former shall be deemed to be the rights, powers, obligations and functions of the latter, until the Board of Directors decides otherwise.
ARTICLE 227. VALIDITY OF BANKING ACCORDS. The validity of the banking accords issued by the National Banking Commission and the Superintendency that are in force at the promulgation of this Decree Law is recognized, provided they do not contradict its letter and spirit. The same effect shall be recognized with respect to the resolutions of the Superintendent and of the Board of Directors that are in force.
ARTICLE 228. MICROFINANCE. This Decree Law shall not affect the provisions of Law 10 of 2002, which establishes rules with respect to the microfinance system.
Given in the city of Panama, on the 30th day of the month of April of two thousand eight (2008).
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“Single Text of Decree Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998 and all its modifications”
“Decree Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications, which was approved through Executive Decree No. 52”
“...Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications, which was approved by Executive Decree No. 52 of April 30, 2008, hereinafter referred to as the Banking Law;”
“single text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“systematic ordering in the form of a single text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Single Text of Decree Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of 1998 and all its modifications”
“...Single Text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications...”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998 and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“single text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Executive Branch prepared a systematic ordering in the form of a single text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“...single text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications...”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Executive Branch prepared a systematic ordering in the form of a single text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“single text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“systematic ordering in the form of a single text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“prepared a systematic compilation in the form of a Single Text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Single Text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998 and all its modifications, which was approved through Executive Decree No. 52”
“Executive Branch prepared a systematic ordering in the form of a single text of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“...single text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications...”
“Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998 and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998, and all its modifications”
“Decree-Law 9 of 1998 and all its modifications”
“in accordance with Number 2 of Article 5 of Law Decree 9 of February 26, 1998”
“in accordance with Number 30 of Article 17 of Law Decree 9 of February 26, 1998”
“in accordance with Item 7 of Article 16 of Law Decree No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“Decree-Law 9 of February 26, 1998”
“in the form of a Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of 1998 and all its modifications”
“Single Text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998”
“consolidated text of Decree-Law No. 9 of February 26, 1998 and all its amendments”
More like this from PA-LAW
We email you every new PA-LAW publication the day it's published.
Source: Asamblea Nacional de Panamá — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated