Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV
No. 090-2023-SMV/11
Summary: Sanction JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. with a fine of three (3) UIT for having incurred one (1) serious infringement typified in subsection 2.3 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| | |
|---|
| Administrated entity | : | JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure of double instance |
| Main Type | : | Subsection 2.3 numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation SERIOUS INFRINGEMENTS |
| File No. | : | 2022050548 |
The Deputy Superintendent (e) for Market Conduct Supervision
SEEN:
The administrative file No. 2022050548 containing the administrative sanctioning procedure initiated by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV (hereinafter, the IGCC), against JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. (hereinafter, JCR Latam); as well as Report No. 0692-2023-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by said IGCC;
CONSIDERING:
- FUNCTION AND COMPETENCE OF THE SASCM
- That, the IGCC —instructing body of the administrative sanctioning procedures (hereinafter, the PAS) referred to in the present case—, has brought to the attention of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision of the SMV (hereinafter, the SASCM), the PAS of administrative file No. 2022050548 in order for it to issue a decision as the sanctioning body of first instance in said PAS. Thus, the SASCM assumes competence in observance of the exercise of the supervision function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861, approved by Supreme Decree No. 020-2023-EF-1[1] (hereinafter, TUO LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation); and, in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infringements whose compliance control corresponds to said Deputy Superintendency. Likewise, the SASCM has the powers to issue corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infringement;
- That, with respect to the charge referring to the obligation of minimum dissemination of information to the Securities Market through its corporate website, it corresponds to two (2) administrative instances in accordance with the first paragraph of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation and numeral 13 of article 43 of the ROF-SMV, which establish that, among others, it is a specific function of the Deputy Superintendent of the SASCM to impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infringements whose compliance control corresponds to the SASCM. Complementary to this, in accordance with article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation and numeral, and to the provisions of numeral 26 of article 12 of the ROF-SMV, the Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves appeals against resolutions issued in the first instance by the Deputy Superintendent of the SASCM, with the exception of single-instance procedures;
- FACTS, CHARGE AND DEFENSES OF THE ADMINISTERED ENTITY
- Facts
- That, it was evaluated whether or not JCR Latam complied with disseminating on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in article 21 of the «Common Rules for entities that require authorization of organization and operation from the SMV», approved by SMV Resolution No. 039-2016-SMV/01 and its amending rules, in accordance with the provisions of the First Complementary Final Provision of the referred rules (hereinafter, Common Rules for Entities);
- Charge
- That, as a result of said evaluation, through Official Letter No. 6331-2022-SMV/11.2 of December 21, 2022 (hereinafter, Charge Letter), a charge was formulated against JCR Latam for not having complied with the obligation to disseminate on its corporate website the minimum information required by numerals i), ii), iii), v) and vii) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, the following information:
- The full names, gender, year of birth and resumes of the directors
This information has not been published with respect to directors Guillermo Roberto Keil Montoya, Luis Roberto Keil Rojas and Jorge Eduardo Espada Salazar, who appear as ‘Directors’ in the Integrated Registry and Supervision System – SIRyS and published on the SMV Institutional Page in the Single Digital Platform of the Peruvian State for Citizen Orientation[2] (hereinafter, SMV Institutional Portal).
- Full name of the general manager
Only the second name and first surname (Roberto Keil) of the general manager are indicated.
- Audited annual individual and interim individual financial information[3]
These financial informations described on the corporate website cannot be downloaded or viewed. It is observed that each of these financial informations has the same download or viewing link URL: https://jcrlatam.com/cumplimientos-regulatorios/#.
- Annual Report
The Annual Report described on the corporate website cannot be downloaded or viewed. It is observed that this information has the same download or viewing URL as the financial informations: https://jcrlatam.com/cumplimientos-regulatorios/#.
In this sense, it is noted that JCR Latam would not have complied with disseminating on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in numerals i), ii), iii), v) and vii) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities; despite the First Complementary Final Provision of such rules providing that, as of August 1, 2020, it is enforceable for risk rating companies to disseminate said information;
- That, through a brief presented on January 6, 2023, JCR Latam presented its defenses, fundamentally stating the following:
- JCR Latam attaches emails indicating the following: “we have been diligent in requesting our provider to comply with the service within the term granted by SMV, even forwarding the requirement indicated in the official letter. However, for reasons beyond our control, the provider did not comply within the agreed time and to prove it we attach the following screenshots of exchanged emails.”
In that line of argument, JCR Latam states that due to technical difficulties the dissemination of documents related to the work team has been delayed; additionally, it indicates that “The responsibility is external to us, any technical difficulty suffered by the provider and that prevented it from complying with the agreed deadlines for the work requested by the SMV is beyond our control.”
- Likewise, JCR states: “Regarding the difference in the matter of the board of directors in which Mr. Jorge Espada appears on the web, the screen should indicate that he was a director until November 18, 2020 and that currently the director is Mr. Eduardo Juan Court Monteverde, appointed at the JGA of March 29, 2021. What is observed on the SMV platform has been adjusted, although the impossibility persists of modifying the position of chairman of the board that Mr. Luis Roberto Keil Rojas has held since March 29, 2021, who replaced me, with the undersigned becoming a director since the JGA held on that same date. This is reiterated today with contact with the SMV help desk, awaiting their response.”
- In the brief of January 22, 2023, it states: “As we had indicated opportunely and in reference to communications previously sent to your represented entity, our website (www.jcrlatam.com) is updated complying with the regulations.”;
- That, through Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures. Likewise, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG indicates the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction: (a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement, (b) The probability of detection of the infringement, (c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, (d) The economic harm caused, (e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infringement within one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infringement became final, (f) The circumstances of the commission of the infringement and, (g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the infringer;
- That, the charge formulated and the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been submitted to the knowledge of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 2533-2023-SMV/11 of June 19, 2023, the Report was sent to JCR Latam, so that it could submit its arguments within five (5) business days of notification of said Report, which were presented through briefs of July 5 and 13, 2023, which are summarized below:
- It states that “In attention to the indicated, as well as to the conformity or tacit acceptance of the IGCC of the situation (estimation) of the process followed by JCR to comply with the requirement that allows having the corporate website updated, there would be no support whatsoever for the initiation of the sanctioning process”.
- It adds that “according to the indicated, the necessary measures are being adopted to date to regularize this situation immediately, with the technical team (website service provider) despite the delays and technical failures that we prove with the attached information”.
- It states that “it is equally clear and conclusive that JCR has informed in a detailed and timely manner, as we prove with the emails sent, the progress and difficulties presented to comply with the IGCC requirement, without this having merited at the time any opinion or pronouncement from said Intendancy and only a unilateral and arbitrary as well as extemporaneous interpretation can be appreciated to date, to determine that said facts do not come from a cause beyond the will of the obligated party, or that they are an unforeseeable or irresistible fact”.
- On the other hand, it adds that “regarding the website information referring to the full names of the directors and General Manager, as well as gender and year of birth, it is appropriate to inform that being clearly remediable observations from the technical point of view of website configuration, the immediate incorporation of the information not recorded has been coordinated with the website provider”.
- It adds that “the problems arisen with the auditing firms in charge of carrying out and timely delivering the audits of JCR (SAO KRESTON) must be taken into consideration, which are widely known to the regulator (SMV) and which likewise have had an impact on the preparation and approval of the Annual Report and its delivery in due course, as well as its publication on the corporate website”.
- It adds that the SMV must have a uniform criterion, since there are websites of other risk rating companies that breach the regulations, as well as that on the SMV institutional portal the complete information of its main officers is not disseminated either.
- JCR Latam adds regarding the sanction criteria the following:
- It only has one antecedent, and is not recidivist,
- Regarding the circumstances, it states that it expressly acknowledges that JCR Latam has complied with disseminating on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in literals ii), iii), v) and vii) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities;
- Regarding the economic harm caused and its repercussion on the market, it has not been evidenced that the non-compliance has produced a quantifiable harm, understood as an economic damage caused to one or several participants of the securities market;
- Regarding the illicit benefit of the commission of the infringements, it is concluded that it is not observed that JCR Latam has obtained an illicit benefit as a consequence of the infringement;
- As for the probability of detection of the infringement, it is considered that for this type of non-compliance the probability of detection is high, since it results from the supervision tasks of the SMV;
- It adds that most of the information disseminated on its corporate website is published in the Public Registry of the Securities Market - RPMV, so a severity of damage to the public interest is not evidenced, totally contradicting the sanction proposal of the IGCC;
- In the present case, a breach of the duty of diligence by JCR Latam has not been evidenced;
- ISSUES TO DETERMINE
- That, in the present PAS it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not JCR Latam incurred in the infringements indicated in the Charge Letter and Report;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on JCR Latam;
- ANALYSIS
- Applicable regulations
- That, the second paragraph of article 13 of the TUO of the LMV states: “(…) the legal persons registered in the Registry and the issuer of registered securities are obligated to present the information that this law and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of said information”;
- That, article 270 of the TUO of the LMV, second paragraph, provides that risk rating companies that register in the RPMV are subject to the control and supervision of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV;
- That, article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities and amendments provides the following:
«Article 21.- Corporate website
All Entities with operating authorization from the SMV must have a corporate website, on which they must disseminate, at least, the following information:
i) The full names of the members of the Board of Directors, their independent status, if applicable, gender, year of birth, their status as alternate or substitute, if applicable, and their resumes;
ii) Full name of the general manager;
iii) Audited annual individual financial information;
(…)
v) Interim individual financial information;
(...)
vii) Annual report; and,
(…)
Additionally, the website must provide an online electronic access for the formulation of claims by its clients.»;
- That, article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was incorporated by article 4 of SMV Resolution No. 020-2019-SMV-01, published on August 7, 2019, which entered into force on January 1, 2020*;*
- That, in accordance with the First Complementary Final Provision of the Common Rules for Entities, modified by Superintendent Resolution No. 052-2020-SMV/02, it was provided that, as of August 1, 2020, it will be enforceable for entities authorized by the SMV to disseminate said information;
- That, JCR Latam would have incurred an infringement typified in subsection 2.3, numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a serious infringement: “Not publishing, or not doing so opportunely, the notices, communications or any other information to which they are obligated, or that they do not conform to the regulations”;
- That, in accordance with article 34 of the Sanctions Regulation[4], serious infringements are punishable with a fine of no less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT;
- Evaluation of the case
- That, in administrative file No. 2022050548, which contains the documentation of the present PAS, it is appreciated that Report 1547-2021-SMV/11.1, the General Intendancy of Conduct Supervision (IGSC) —body of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV that has among its functions and powers the supervision of compliance with the rules applicable to risk rating companies registered in the RPMV, through the performance of inspection activities and/or preliminary inquiries, evaluating the indications of possible infringements, which it remits, for evaluation, the reports of determined indications of infringement—, remitted to the IGCC the result of its evaluation (File No. 2021009979), and specifically the indications referred to the present case, because the IGCC is, within the internal and functional structure of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, the instructing body of the PAS referring to possible infringements committed by risk rating companies authorized by this Superintendency;
- That, it must be kept in mind that the procedures and legal forms with which the IGSC conducts its inspection and/or supervision activities and upon concluding them with a report of indications of infringement, determines that its pronouncement or opinion on a specific supervision topic —which may even contain a decision, such as the adoption of corrective measures—, is an opinion on the merits of the matter; it being necessary to specify that said opinion and the report of indications of infringement of the IGSC is not binding for the IGCC, as established in the second paragraph of article 9 of the Sanctions Regulation[5] [6];
- That, in this way, in the evaluation of the facts related to the present PAS, two (2) other bodies of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, functionally independent from each other and from this Office, have intervened and participated prior to the issuance of this resolution; first the IGSC which at the time reported the indications of infringement through Report 1547-2021-SMV/11.1, and then the IGCC which, as a result of its evaluation, formulated the Charge Letter and the Report; and at this point of the PAS it corresponds to the Office of the SASCM to issue a pronouncement containing its decision regarding the mentioned charges, it being necessary to indicate that by the nature of the same, it will be a first administrative instance decision;
- That, as previously stated, the formulation of the charge of the present PAS was formulated on the basis that JCR Latam did not comply with the obligation to disseminate on its corporate website the minimum information required by article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, as noted from the review of its website https://jcrlatam.com, which is in the annexes of the Charge Letter, observing that on said website the information was not disseminated as indicated in the referred article;
- That, compliance with the obligation regarding the dissemination on its corporate website of the information required by the SMV is necessary for the transparency and proper functioning of the securities market, and in this sense the transparency of information is a protected legal good, it being necessary to point out that the non-observance of said obligation harms or affects it;
- That, in this regard, through a brief presented on January 6, 2023, JCR Latam has presented its defenses regarding the commission of the infringements imputed in the Charge Letter. Therefore, it is necessary to indicate the following:
- Regarding JCR Latam's argument that technical difficulties have delayed the uploading of documents related to the work team and that “The responsibility is external to us, any technical difficulty suffered by the provider and that prevented it from complying with the agreed deadlines for the work requested by the SMV is beyond our control.” it also attaches screenshots of emails with its provider, it should be indicated that JCR Latam attaches as an annex various emails from September 5, 2022 to November 28, 2022, which are detailed in a summarized manner in the Report.
In this regard, it is appropriate to analyze the mentioned emails that are pertinent and the arguments presented in its defenses in accordance with subsection a) of article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes an exemption from responsibility: “a) Fortuitous event, force majeure or another exceptional situation that, in the opinion of the SMV, is comparable to fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven”, a rule concordant with article 257 numeral 1) subsection a) of the TUO of the LPAG, in order to determine whether the imputed non-compliance was due to a situation of force majeure or not.
- Although in administrative regulation no content has been given to force majeure as an exemption from responsibility, it is considered that recourse should be made to the sources of the procedure, such as laws and provisions of equivalent hierarchy (Article V numeral 2.3. of the TUO of the LPAG), which is developed in article 1315 of the Civil Code indicated above. In this sense, it must be considered that there will only be absence of responsibility due to force majeure when an extraordinary event is configured that strictly obeys a fact carried out by a third party; that said fact has the character of irresistible; and, whose occurrence is impossible to prevent through acts of foresight:
- It comes from a cause beyond the will of the obligated party
It must be taken into account that the causal fact of force majeure must not be located in the sphere of action of the one who alleges it, that is, the cause of force majeure must be outside the circle or field of activity of the administered entity.
It should be noted that Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was incorporated by Article 4 of SMV Resolution No. 020-2019-SMV/01, published on August 7, 2019, which entered into force on January 1, 2020. In that line, according to the recitals of Superintendent Resolution No. 052-2020-SMV/02, it is indicated that during the period of the declaration of the National State of Emergency, "with respect to the obligation to have a web page and (...), the convenience of extending said deadlines has been seen, (...) until August 1."
In that sense, according to the First Final Complementary Provision of the aforementioned Superintendent Resolution No. 052-2020-SMV/02, it was provided that, as of August 1, 2020, the dissemination of information on a corporate web page in accordance with Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities shall be enforceable.
In that sense, it is observed that from August 7, 2019, the date on which the resolution approving Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was published, until August 1, 2020, the date on which the enforceability of said obligation was extended, those obligated by this rule have obtained a prudent time of approximately one (1) year to implement the appropriate mechanisms, among them, the hiring of a provider if applicable, such that by August 1, 2020 they should have complied with their obligation to disseminate minimum information on their corporate web page, even more so considering that this deadline had been extended.
In that order of ideas, from the review of the emails dated September 5, 2022 and subsequent dates that JCR Latam attaches as an annex to its defense, it is observed that this company at that date was making arrangements for the implementation and loading of information on its corporate web page, as indicated above; however, it does not prove the circumstance of force majeure that prevented it from complying with its obligation since the applicable regulations entered into force or became enforceable (August 1, 2020), even more so considering that it had sufficient time to implement the appropriate mechanisms to timely hire a third party and comply with its obligations.
According to the foregoing, the facts alleged by JCR Latam do not arise from a cause beyond the will of the obligated party; consequently, the timely hiring and implementation by this third party is within the sphere of control of JCR Latam.
- Unforeseeable event
For a situation of force majeure to be configured, it must be unforeseeable. An event that has escaped the possible scenarios that the subjects have determined as feasible qualifies as such.
In this regard, although the IGSC through Circular No. 067-2021-SMV/11.1[7] of March 8, 2021 (File No. 2021008129) required JCR Latam to report whether it had complied with said obligation, said company in its response of March 11, 2021 indicates that it will comply with all requested requirements. However, through a writing of September 1, 2022, in response to Official Letter No. 4128-2022-SMV/11.2, issued by the IGCC so that it express what it considers convenient regarding the indication remitted by the IGSC through Report No. 1450-2021-SMV/11.1, JCR Latam indicated that it estimated that by the end of October 2022 they would fully implement what was requested, adding that "for this reason we have started work with the provider as of this week so that it proceeds to give us an action plan."
In that sense, according to said response granted by JCR Latam, it was only in the first week of September that they began work with the provider, that is, after three (3) years since Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was published in the Official Gazette El Peruano (August 7, 2019), and after two (02) years since said obligation became enforceable for all obligated parties (August 1, 2020).
Additionally, although JCR Latam in the aforementioned response writing of September 1, 2022 committed that by the end of October (2022) they would fully implement what was requested, from the writing of December 1, 2022, in response to Official Letter No. 5770-2022-SMV/11.2 issued by the IGCC, it is observed that it did not fully comply with the referred Article 21, indicating that "the most recent work plan with points that have already been implemented and others pending and delivery and loading dates."
In that sense, JCR Latam has had the opportunity over a prolonged time to foresee compliance with Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities; however, this did not occur, despite the supervision acts and the commitments regarding compliance that JCR Latam assumed in its responses to the SMV, before which the IGCC proceeded to initiate this administrative sanctioning procedure.
According to the foregoing, the hiring of a third party for JCR Latam to implement or load information on its corporate web page, as well as the schedule of this contract, was foreseeable, so it was under the responsibility of JCR Latam to adopt the appropriate mechanisms, within its ordinary actions, to comply with its obligation to timely have the minimum information required by the regulations on its corporate web page.
- Irresistible event
It should be noted that mere non-compliance due to lack of diligence at the time of carrying out the activity to which it was obligated cannot be alleged as force majeure.
It should be noted that, according to what was indicated by JCR Latam in its writing of September 1, 2022, referring to the fact that it was only in the first week of September that they began work with the provider and that the emails it presents are from September 5, 2022, it is observed that JCR Latam only had communication with its provider on that date, so this document does not prove or evidence that there has been any situation of force majeure that occurred throughout the period in which the rule is enforceable (since August 1, 2020); on the contrary, it would demonstrate a lack of diligence.
In that sense, the non-compliances incurred by JCR Latam could have been avoided had due diligence been observed in timely hiring a provider since Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on August 7, 2019, and was enforceable as of August 1, 2020. It should be noted that, even having observed minimal due diligence after this deadline, JCR Latam could have complied with said requirement before the initiation of an administrative sanctioning procedure. Consequently, JCR Latam did not deploy all the necessary mechanisms to ensure timely compliance in the dissemination of minimum information published on the corporate web page.
According to the foregoing, it should be indicated that the circumstances alleged by JCR Latam as a situation that generated the non-compliance of not disseminating on its corporate web page the minimum information indicated in Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities does not meet the requirements indicated above for a defense of force majeure to be configured.
It should be specified that although the administration bears the burden of proof in order to attribute to the administered parties the infractions that serve as a basis for sanctioning them, upon the occurrence that the administration has proven the commission of the infraction, it corresponds to the administered party to prove the facts excluding its responsibility if it alleges them, as indicated by Nieto García[8]; when referring to the jurisprudence of the Spanish Supreme Court:
"(...) as regards the burden of proof in any punitive action, it is the sanctioning body that must prove the facts that must serve as support for the possible infraction, while the accused must prove the facts that may result in excluding its responsibility." (Underline added).
In that sense, as developed above, JCR Latam has not been able to prove that it is in a situation of exemption from responsibility, being that it has limited itself to attaching as evidence various communications with its provider dated from September 2022; on the contrary, it is observed from the facts described above that JCR Latam has had a lack of diligence, because despite having a prudent time to timely hire a provider since Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities was published, even more so considering that said obligation was enforceable on August 1, 2020, however it was only in the first week of September 2022 that it began work with the provider, according to JCR Latam's writing of December 1, 2022, in response to Official Letter No. 5770-2022-SMV/11.2 issued by the IGCC.
Having evaluated each of JCR Latam's defense arguments, the conduct constituting the infraction has been accredited, by not having complied with disseminating on its corporate web page the minimum information indicated in Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities; consequently, the administrative responsibility of JCR Latam in this PAS is determined and it corresponds to determine the applicable sanction.
- Regarding what was indicated by JCR Latam about the update of the information referring to the directors published on the SMV Portal, indicating that "Regarding the difference in the matter of the board of directors in which Mr. Jorge Espada appears on the web, the screen should indicate that he was a director until November 18, 2020, and that currently the director is Mr. Eduardo Juan Court Monteverde, appointed at the JGA of March 29, 2021. What is observed on the SMV platform has been adjusted, although the impossibility persists of modifying the position of chairman of the board that Mr. Luis Roberto Keil Rojas has held since March 29, 2021, who replaced me, with the undersigned becoming a director since the JGA held on that same date."; it should be indicated that it has been verified that Mr. Jorge Espada is no longer registered as Director on the Institutional Portal of the SMV, and that through general communication of January 6, 2023 (File No. 2023000711) JCR Latam communicated the change of said director; furthermore, it is observed that Mr. Luis Roberto Keil Rojas appears as Chairman of the Board, as published on the referred Portal, detailed in the Report.
- Regarding the date after the Letter of Charges (December 21, 2022), JCR Latam presented a writing on January 22, 2023, indicating that its web page (www.jcrlatam.com) is updated complying with the regulations; however, it did not attach documentation that this can be verified. On this matter, according to the analysis carried out in the Report, it should be noted that from the review of said corporate web page, the following has been identified:
-
-
- The full names of the members of the Board of Directors, their qualification as independent, if applicable, gender, year of birth, their status as alternate or substitute, if applicable, and their resumes
It is observed that JCR Latam publishes information about its directors on its web page, missing details of gender and year of birth. In that sense, it does not fully comply with literal i) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities.
-
-
-
- Full name of the general manager
JCR Latam publishes the full name of its general manager in the "Our Team" section, so it complies with literal ii) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities.
-
-
-
- Individual audited annual and individual interim financial information[9]
It should be noted that Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities states: "The financial information mentioned above comprises the Financial Statements, the Notes and the Management Report.
The information published through the Entity's corporate web page must correspond exactly with that submitted to the SMV and must be disseminated immediately after being presented to the SMV" (Underline Added).
In this regard, JCR Latam has published its individual audited annual financial information corresponding to fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, the latter presented to the SMV on March 31, 2023 in File No. 2023014940, so as of the date it would be complying with literal iii) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities. These publications are viewed in the following links:
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/EEFFAA2020.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/EEFFAA2021.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/JCR-DICTAMEN-2022-c_c.pdf
On the other hand, JCR Latam has published on its corporate web page its Financial Statements as of September 30, 2022, December 31, 2022 and March 31, 2023, the latter presented to the SMV on May 2, 2023 in File No. 2023020414, so as of the date it would be complying with literal v) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities. These publications are viewed in the following links:
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/JCR_EEFF_30092022.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Trimestal_Dici2022_c_c.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Trimestral_Mar2023_c_c.pdf
In this regard, JCR Latam has published its Annual Reports corresponding to fiscal years 2020, 2021 and 2022, the latter presented to the SMV on March 31, 2023 in File No. 2023014940, so as of the date it would be complying with literal vii) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities. These publications are viewed in the following links:
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Mem2020.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Mem2021.pdf
https://jcrlatam.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Memoria-2022.pdf
Consequently, according to the foregoing, as of the date JCR Latam has complied with disseminating on its corporate web page the minimum information indicated in literals ii), iii), v) and vii) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, missing details of gender and year of birth of the directors, whose information is required by literal i) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities; which will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed;
- That, on the other hand, regarding the arguments presented by JCR Latam, in addition to what has already been indicated, the following should be stated:
- JCR Latam erroneously considers that the response it provided to the IGCC regarding Official Letter No. 4128-2022-SMV/11.2, indicating that it estimated that by the end of October 2022 they would implement what corresponds to comply with the obligations linked to the dissemination of minimum information on the corporate web page, was tacitly accepted by the IGCC; for which it considers that there was no basis to initiate the administrative sanctioning procedure.
In this regard, it should be noted that the obligation under analysis implies the dissemination of the minimum information indicated in Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, which cannot be understood as complied with simply by a writing from the administered party indicating a mere estimate of the date on which it would comply with adapting its web page, as has happened in this case; even more so if the obligation became enforceable as of August 1, 2020, and the response of JCR Latam indicated in the previous paragraph was dated September 1, 2022.
- Additionally, within the framework of evaluating indications of infractions, the IGCC has the power to carry out preliminary investigations aimed at verifying whether the circumstances that justify the initiation of an administrative sanctioning procedure concur, in accordance with Article 7 of the Sanctions Regulation. In that sense, the communications made by the IGCC within the framework of said investigations under no context or interpretation have the purpose of establishing agreements with the administered parties regarding the date on which they will comply with their obligations – as JCR Latam incorrectly appears to maintain – but rather, on the contrary, in its preliminary investigations, the IGCC makes such communications to gather information that serves as supply for the initiation of this PAS, in case the facts constitute an administrative infraction. In that sense, it corresponds to dismiss the argument referring to the fact that the IGCC tacitly accepted the estimate made by JCR Latam for the compliance of its obligation and that therefore the initiation of the administrative sanctioning procedure did not correspond.
- JCR Latam states that the problems arising with the auditing firms have had repercussions on the preparation, approval and dissemination of financial information through the corporate web page. Regarding said argument, it should be specified that one of the obligations that JCR Latam maintains as a risk rating company is to present within the established deadlines its audited financial information to the RPMV, said obligation being totally different from the one that is the subject of this PAS, in which the non-compliance is being evaluated for not having complied with the obligation to disseminate on its corporate web page the minimum information required by numerals i), ii), iii), v) and vii) of Article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, so if the financial information is delayed in being presented by the obligated party, this will generate the initiation of an administrative sanctioning procedure, but not a double infraction with respect to the dissemination of the audited financial information on its corporate web page.
In that sense, as long as the latest information reported to the SMV is revealed via its corporate web page, the risk rating company should be complying with the Common Rules for Entities. Therefore, it lacks foundation to refer in this PAS to what was argued by JCR Latam when referring that as a result of the problems it had with its auditing firms, which have been the subject of other sanctioning procedures, there was a repercussion on the dissemination of financial information through the corporate web page, which is inaccurate as indicated in this evaluation.
Likewise, it should be indicated that JCR Latam must adapt its processes in order to comply with the corresponding regulations, even more so if it is a company that has been authorized and is currently supervised by this SMV, in order to avoid incurring infractions such as the one analyzed in this PAS.
- Regarding the fact that the SMV must have a uniform criterion in the imputation of charges and sanction, since other supervised companies would have allegedly incurred the same infraction; and that the institutional portal of the SMV also does not comply with disseminating the complete information of its main officials, it must be noted that in this PAS only the facts imputed as charges against JCR Latam are subject to evaluation, which is an objective infraction where the bodies that have intervened before and during the processing of this PAS have done so respecting the principle of impartiality, legality and due process, among others. On the other hand, the content of the information that the SMV disseminates on its "Institutional Page of the SMV on the Single Digital Platform of the Peruvian State for Citizen Orientation (www.gob.pe/smv)" is not subject to analysis.
- On the other hand, what JCR Latam stated regarding the graduation of the sanction will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed.
- That, in this way, having evaluated the charges, discharges and arguments presented, the conduct constituting the aforementioned infraction has been accredited and the administrative responsibility of JCR Latam has been determined, so it is appropriate to analyze the sanction in accordance with the provisions of the principle of reasonableness;
- DETERMINATION OF THE SANCTION
- That, in order to analyze the applicable sanction proposal, having determined the commission of the infractions subject of this administrative sanctioning procedure, it is appropriate to determine the sanction to be imposed on JCR Latam considering the sanction criteria established in article 344 of the TUO of the LMV, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and the provisions of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria);
- That, in accordance with the provisions of the Sanction Criteria, the following are analyzed: (i) the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right; (ii) the harm caused and its repercussion on the market; (iii) the offender's sanction history; (iv) the probability of detection of the infraction; (v) recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from the date the resolution sanctioning the first infraction became final; (vi) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; (vii) the illegally obtained benefit; and, (viii) the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, article 344 of the TUO LMV and article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- That, regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, it must be indicated that risk rating companies registered in the RPMV must disseminate on their corporate website the minimum information indicated in article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, which constitutes an obligation that allows better access to information by investors or potential investors, and thus allows better transparency of the securities market and an orderly market. It should be noted that, considering that most of the information disseminated on the corporate website is published in the RPMV, no seriousness of damage to the public interest is evidenced;
- That, regarding the economic harm caused and its repercussion on the market, this criterion evaluates the quantifiable harm produced by the administrative infraction, which includes the evaluation of the economic harms caused. In this sense, it has not been evidenced that the non-compliances have produced a quantifiable harm, understood as an economic damage caused to one or several participants;
- That, regarding the sanction history, literal a) of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that these are final sanctions imposed by the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV within four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned; notwithstanding this, it is specified that the commission of the same infraction in the year prior to the infraction to be sanctioned is not considered as a history. On this matter, from the verification carried out in the Sanctions System of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, it has been noted that JCR Latam does have a sanction history, as detailed in the Report;
- That, regarding recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, literal b) of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that the final sanction imposed by the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV within one (1) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned is taken into account. In this regard, from the verification carried out in the SMV Sanctions System, it has been noted that JCR Latam does not have the status of recidivist, according to the evaluation in the Report;
- That, regarding the probability of detection of the infraction, it must be noted that the facts subject to charges are verified through the internal control systems of the SMV, so it is considered that for this type of non-compliance, the probability of detection is high, as it results from the supervision work of the SMV;
- That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it is noted that JCR Latam at the time of the imputation of charges had not disseminated on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities. Subsequently, JCR Latam submitted a brief on January 22, 2023, indicating that its website (www.jcrlatam.com) is updated in compliance with the regulations. In this regard, from the review of said corporate website as of the date of this Resolution, it is observed that JCR Latam has complied with disseminating on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in literals ii), iii), v) and vii) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, missing the detail of the gender and year of birth of the directors, information required by literal i) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities. Said omission, counting the days from the Charge Letter to the date, has gone almost nine (9) months without being remedied (https://jcrlatam.com/nosotros);
- That, regarding the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infractions, it must be noted that in this case there are not sufficient elements to indicate that JCR Latam obtained an illegal benefit as a consequence of the commission of the infractions under evaluation;
- That, regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it must be noted that there are not sufficient elements to indicate that JCR Latam acted with intent in the commission of the infractions, so this criterion is not configured. However, it is necessary to indicate that, although there are no indications of JCR Latam's action regarding its intentionality, it is affirmed that JCR Latam's conduct was negligent, it did not act with the required diligence before previously known obligations;
- That, in addition to the above, it is appropriate to analyze the exculpatory and mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 257 of the TUO of the LPAG[10], as well as the mitigating conditions of responsibility established in the second paragraph of article 26 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- That, in this case, as indicated, JCR Latam, after the date of notification of the Charge Letter, has partially regularized the infraction under analysis; however, such remediation has not been complete as already detailed in this Resolution;
- That, on the other hand, regarding the exculpatory circumstances of responsibility established in article 257 of the TUO of the LPAG, in accordance with article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation, it is not observed that in this case any of the circumstances constituting exculpatory conditions of responsibility have been configured;
- That, according to the analysis of the Sanction Criteria described above, among which it is evaluated that JCR Latam has complied with disseminating on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in literals ii), iii), v) and vii) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, missing the detail of gender and year of birth of the directors, information required by literal i) of article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities, and in attention to the principle of reasonableness that requires that the imposed measure (sanction) be proportional and not excessive; it is appropriate to impose a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided, that is, corresponding to minor infractions in accordance with the last paragraph of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation[11];
- That, regarding the recommendation of the Report on the infraction subject of the Charge Letter, although we share the essence of the analysis carried out by the IGCC regarding the configuration of the non-compliance developed in the Report, we do not share it regarding the amount of the final sanction to be imposed, which for this Deputy Superintendency should correspond to JCR Latam a total fine of three (3) UIT[12] equivalent to S/ 12,900.00 (Twelve Thousand Nine Hundred and 00/100 Soles), because according to the evaluation of the Sanction Criteria detailed in this Resolution and considering the principle of reasonableness established in numeral 1.4 of Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO of the LPAG[13], despite the time elapsed to date JCR has regularized a large part of the infraction under analysis; however, such remediation has not been complete as already detailed in this Resolution; nevertheless, such omissions do not constitute information that for this Deputy Superintendency merits a higher fine;
- That, in this sense, it is appropriate to sanction JCR Latam with a total fine of three (3) UIT[14] equivalent to S/ 12,900.00 (Twelve Thousand Nine Hundred and 00/100 Soles), for not having disseminated information on its corporate website in accordance with article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities within the term determined by the regulations on the matter, and;
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 13 and 36 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments;
RESOLVES:
- Declare that JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. has incurred in one (1) infraction of a serious nature, typified in subsection 2.3 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for not having disseminated on its corporate website the minimum information indicated in article 21 of the Common Rules for Entities.
- Sanction JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. with a fine of three (3) UIT equivalent to S/ 12,900.00 (Twelve Thousand Nine Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 1 of this Resolution.
- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and may be challenged before this Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal, administrative remedies recognized in article 218 of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a double-instance administrative procedure. If this Resolution is not challenged, it may avail itself of the sanction reduction regime.
- If this Resolution is not subject to challenge, it must be published on the "Institutional Page of the SMV on the Single Digital Platform of the Peruvian State for Citizen Orientation (www.gob.pe/smv)", in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, early agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01, and by the provisions of the last paragraph of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe this resolution to JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Carlos Rivero Zevallos
Deputy Superintendent (e)
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision
-
Through Supreme Decree No. 020-2023-EF, published on February 10, 2023 in the Official Gazette El Peruano, the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861, was approved. ↑
-
www.gob.pe/smv. ↑
-
The financial information mentioned comprises the Financial Statements and Notes. ↑
-
"Article 34.- Sanctions for serious infractions
For the commission of serious infractions, one of the following sanctions is imposed on the offender:
Fine of not less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT;
Suspension of the negotiation of securities for up to one (1) year or of the placement of the public offering;
Suspension of the authorization of operation or of the representatives of the agent companies, for up to twenty (20) days; and,
Suspension of the persons referred to in subsection i) of article 343 of the LMV and the corresponding regulations, for up to thirty (30) days." ↑
-
In article 245 of the TUO of the LPAG, the following are indicated as forms or modes in which the inspection activity could conclude: 1) Constancy of conformity of the activity developed by the administered; 2) Recommendation of improvements or corrections of the activity developed by the administered; 3) The warning of the existence of non-compliances not susceptible to merit the determination of administrative responsibilities; 4) The recommendation of the initiation of a procedure in order to determine the corresponding administrative responsibilities; 5) The adoption of corrective measures and 6) Other forms as established by special laws. ↑
-
«Article 9.- PRELIMINARY INQUIRIES AS A CONSEQUENCE OF SUPERVISION ACTIONS
(…)
When said bodies conclude that there are sufficient indications of possible administrative infractions, they send the corresponding reports to the General Compliance Intendencies, which determine whether or not to initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure. If so, the General Compliance Intendencies may carry out additional inspections or investigations of the reported indications. In the case of possible infractions in the field of the Regulation of the Participatory Financial Financing Activity and its Administrative Companies, the preliminary inquiries are carried out by the General Intendency of Research and Innovation, a dependency that, if there are sufficient indications of possible administrative infractions, will determine whether or not to initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure.
(…)». ↑
-
Said circular was notified to JCR Latam on March 9, 2021 in file No. 2021008129. ↑
-
NIETO GARCIA, Alejandro. Administrative Sanctioning Law. 4th Edition fully reformed. Madrid: Tecnos, 2005. P. 424. ↑
-
The financial information mentioned comprises the Financial Statements and Notes. ↑
-
"Article 257.- Exculpatory and mitigating circumstances of responsibility for infractions
1.- The following constitute exculpatory conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The obligatory order of competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 235.
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special norm." ↑
-
" Article 25.- Sanction Criteria
(…)
When, from the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria, it is noted that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and through a reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided may be imposed." ↑
-
Value of the UIT (2020): S/ 4,300 (Supreme Decree No. 380-2019-EF). ↑
-
"1.4. Principle of reasonableness.- The decisions of the administrative authority, when they create obligations, qualify infractions, impose sanctions, or establish restrictions on the administered, must adapt within the limits of the attributed faculty and maintaining due proportion between the means to be employed and the public ends that must be protected, so that they respond to what is strictly necessary for the satisfaction of their task." ↑
-
Value of the UIT (2020): S/ 4,300 (Supreme Decree No. 380-2019-EF). ↑