Consultation · FCA · 13 Dec 2018
The Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority propose amendments to mortgage reporting requirements for mortgage lenders and home finance administrators. The proposals require administrators to submit Product Sales Data performance reports on mortgages owned by unregulated entities every six months, and lenders to submit sales reports on internal product transfers and further advances. Additional data fields are introduced to capture information on outstanding debt, contractual reversion rates, and second charge mortgages, with comments requested by 22 March 2019.
Consultation Paper
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
December 2018
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements We are asking for comments on this Consultation Paper (CP) by 22 March 2019. You can send them to us using the form on our website at: www.fca. org.uk/cp18-41-response-form Or in writing to:
Katherine Smith
Financial Conduct Authority
12 Endeavour Square
London E20 1JN
Telephone:
020 7066 1103
Email:
cp18-41@fca.org.uk
How to respond Contents
1 Summary 3
2 Product sales data: performance reports (PSD007) 6 3 Product sales data: sales reports (PSD001) 8 4 Mortgage lending and administration return (MLAR) 15
Annex 1
Questions in this paper 18
Annex 2
FCA cost benefit analysis 20
Annex 3
FCA compatibility statement 26
Annex 4
The PRA’s statutory obligations 30
Annex 5
Abbreviations used in this paper 33
Appendix 1
Draft Handbook text
Appendix 2
Draft Rulebook text
Appendix 3
PRA Amendments to notes for completion of the Mortgage Lenders & Administrators Return (MLAR) returns you to the contents list takes you to helpful abbreviations How to navigate this document onscreen
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements 1 Summary In this joint Consultation Paper (CP), the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) set out proposals for new reporting requirements that would apply to mortgage lenders1 and home finance administrators.2 3 The CP contains proposals made solely by the FCA in relation to our objectives as well as joint proposals that are given effect through a combination of PRA and FCA rules. To make the proposed requirements clear for firms, the proposals are presented under the relevant reporting return or template. The respective FCA and PRA rule instruments, cost benefit analysis and statutory undertakings are set out separately in the annexes and appendices. Why we are consulting
1.1 Home finance lenders and administrators are required to submit regular reports
to the FCA. These include aggregated data, such as that reported in the Mortgage Lending and Administration Return (MLAR), and data on individual products, such as that reported in Product Sales Data (PSD). These data support the FCA in meeting our operational objectives by allowing us to identify and address potential harm to consumers as part of on-going firm supervision. They also support wider thematic work and competition studies, for example the recently published Mortgage Market Study (MMS).
1.2 The FCA also shares these data with the Bank of England (the Bank) and the PRA. The
Bank and the PRA use these data to monitor macro-prudential risk in the housing market, including informing the considerations of the Financial Policy Committee (FPC). The PRA also uses these data to support firm supervision.
1.3 The PRA and the FCA have identified a number of areas where we believe further data
are needed from firms. This CP seeks to address those gaps by setting out proposals to increase the data mortgage lenders and administrators are required to submit via PSD and MLAR.
1.4 We appreciate that changes to reporting systems can be costly for firms. We are
making every effort to limit the frequency of changes to MLAR and PSD. This is why the FCA and PRA are consulting on these proposals as a package. 1 Firms with permission to enter into regulated mortgage contracts. 2 Firms with permission to administer regulated mortgage contracts. 3 Where the CP is discussing MLAR the proposals will apply to all home finance administrators, all other proposals apply to mortgage administrators only.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Who this applies to
1.5 This consultation will be directly relevant to:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements 2 Product sales data: performance reports (PSD007) The FCA proposes to require mortgage administrators to submit PSD performance reports on mortgages owned by entities which are not authorised home finance lenders. Why are we proposing this?
2.1 Some mortgage books are sold to firms that are not authorised to conduct mortgage
business. This can arise, for example, where a lender’s business model involves originating mortgages and later selling them on to investors. The MMS estimated that there are 260,000 accounts in mortgage books owned by firms that are not themselves authorised for lending. We expect this number to increase as lenders continue to sell on mortgage books and the sale of assets of lenders that failed during the financial crisis continues.
2.2 We do not currently receive loan-level data about how these mortgages are
performing, as we do for other loans. This is because it is the authorised lender which is required to submit reports on the performance of the individual loan, not the administrator.
2.3 We believe that it is important to receive performance data on these mortgages so
that we can identify any potential consumer harm. This is especially significant given that the MMS estimated that around 120,000 of the borrowers in these books would benefit from switching to a lower-cost mortgage, and another 20,000 are in arrears.
2.4 The data could help us identify the following potential harms:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements What do mortgage administrators need to know?
2.6 We propose to require administrators to submit the current PSD performance report
on the relevant mortgages, as is laid out in the Supervision Manual (SUP) 16 Annex 21R.
2.7 We propose to amend SUP 16.11.1R to clarify that:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements 3 Product sales data: sales reports (PSD001) The FCA proposes to require mortgage lenders to submit PSD sales reports on internal product transfers. Why are we proposing this?
3.1 As set out in the MMS, the mortgage market has developed so that approximately 42%
of mortgage sales are now internal product transfers. An internal product transfer is where a customer remains with their existing lender but switches products to obtain a different, normally lower, interest rate (with no additional borrowing). This typically follows the expiry of the introductory deal period.
3.2 Lenders are not currently required to report PSD to us on internal product transfers.
PSD tells us important information about the nature of the sale. For example, whether the sale is advised, which firm sold the product, and the fees and charges associated with the product. Receiving these data on internal transfers could help us to identify the following potential harms:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
3.8 In June 2014, the FPC recommended that the PRA and the FCA ‘should ensure
that mortgage lenders do not extend more than 15% of their total number of new residential mortgages at Loan to Income (LTI) ratios at or greater than 4.5’ (the ‘LTI flow limit’). The LTI flow limit is a macroprudential measure, calibrated by the FPC on its view of the outlook for the housing and mortgage market. It applies to regulated mortgage debt only.
3.9 The LTI flow limit addresses a common risk to which many PRA and FCA firms are
exposed, namely macroprudential risks arising from the high LTI elements of mortgage lending carried out by firms. The primary purpose of the FPC’s recommendation is to insure against a significant rise in the number of highly indebted households and a marked loosening in mortgage underwriting standards. These could be a threat to the wider economy and so in turn threaten the safety and soundness of firms.
3.10 The PRA uses data from PSD to determine (i) whether a firm is continually below the
de minimis threshold at which the LTI flow limit applies5 and (ii) whether a firm has complied with the LTI flow limit. Further advances are excluded from the LTI flow limit as they are not subject to PSD reporting.
3.11 Further advances are also subject to the FPC’s affordability test recommendation (the
‘affordability test’). The affordability test specifies that lenders should assess whether borrowers could still afford their mortgage if, at any point over the first 5 years of the loan, their mortgage rate were to be 3 percentage points higher than the reversion rate given in the mortgage contract at origination. Collecting sales data for further advances would allow the PRA to better assess whether the affordability test is being followed for further advances, and contribute to the FPC’s assessment of whether the recommendation remains appropriate.
3.12 The PRA proposes to require PRA-authorised mortgage lenders to submit sales
reports on further advances. The proposed rule is set out in the PRA’s draft instrument in Appendix 2. Q7: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to require PRAauthorised mortgage lenders to submit sales reports on further advances? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
3.13 The PRA expects that providing these data within PSD sales reports will be less
burdensome for firms than submitting data through a new collection mechanism or through regular ad hoc requests. On this basis, the PRA proposes to require submission of the data to the FCA, and the FCA proposes a related rule that would require firms that submit the data to do so as part of the PSD sales report.
3.14 This will allow firms to use existing reporting forms and systems to submit the data.6
The FCA would collect these data from PRA-authorised lenders on behalf of the PRA.7 The FCA considers that this will support the PRA in assessing risk from household indebtedness and judging whether firms are adhering to the affordability test. The FCA 5 See the Housing Part of the PRA rulebook, section 1. 6 The requirement to submit the data is set out in the PRA rule, the FCA rule deals only with the format of the submission. 7 Section 3R of FSMA permits the FCA and the PRA to enter into arrangements for the FCA to supply services to the PRA.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements wishes to support the PRA in monitoring risks to the financial system, where doing so is compatible with our operational objectives.8
3.15 The FCA believes that collecting further advance data from PRA-authorised firms
will further our ability to identify and monitor harm in the mortgage market. This is both from a market integrity perspective, in understanding how the limit is addressing macro-prudential risk, but also from a consumer protection perspective. Having the data would enable the FCA to identify and monitor potential harm during the sale of further advances.9 Overall the regulators believe that the combined proposals support both their objectives, and do so in the most efficient way available. Q8: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require PRA-authorised firms that will be subject to the PRA requirement to submit sales reports on further advances, to do so via PSD? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
3.16 The FCA also proposes to collect the PSD sales data report on further advances from
FCA-authorised mortgage lenders.
3.17 The proposal would also allow the FCA to better identify harm occurring during
the sales of further advances. This includes harm occurring as a result of lenders disregarding the affordability test, as required by Mortgages and Home Finance:
Conduct of Business sourcebook (MCOB) 11.6.18R.
3.18 Along with our proposal to include product transfers in PSD001, the proposal will help the
FCA build a more holistic picture of the market and compare sales practices across the full market of products. This furthers the FCA’s ability to supervise in an informed manner. Q9: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require FCAauthorised mortgage lenders to submit PSD sales reports on further advances? If not, what amendments would you suggest? What do mortgage lenders need to know?
3.19 We propose to require mortgage lenders to submit the PSD sales report, as laid out in SUP
16 Annex 21R, on further advances. We propose the following amendments to the report:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Contractual reversion rate offered at point of sale
3.26 The affordability test specifies that lenders should assess whether borrowers could
still afford their mortgage if, at any point over the first 5 years of the loan, their mortgage rate were to be 3 percentage points higher than the reversion rate specified in the mortgage contract at origination.
3.27 Firms are not currently required to report reversion rates in PSD, only to report the
type of reversion rate. This limits the PRA’s ability to calculate the stress applied by lenders as part of the affordability test.
3.28 Collecting reversion rate data would allow the PRA to better assess whether the FPC’s
affordability test is being followed, and contribute to the FPC’s assessment of whether the recommendation remains appropriate. Q11: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to require PRAauthorised home finance lenders to submit the 3 additional fields outlined above? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
3.29 As with data on further advances, the PRA expects that providing these data within
PSD sales reports will be less burdensome for firms than submitting data through a new collection, or through regular ad hoc requests. On this basis, the PRA proposes to require submission of the data to the FCA, and the FCA proposes a related rule that would require firms that submit the data to do so as part of the PSD sales report. This will allow firms to use the existing reporting forms and systems to submit the data.10 The FCA would collect these data from PRA-authorised lenders on behalf of the PRA,11 which the FCA considers will support the Bank in monitoring overall indebtedness in the market. As with further advances, the FCA wishes to support the PRA and the Bank in monitoring risks to the financial system, where doing so is compatible with our operational objectives.12
3.30 The FCA believes that collecting the data from PRA-authorised firms will further our
ability to identify and monitor harm in the mortgage market. Having the data will support the FCA in understanding lender’s responsible lending practices and how customers structure their debt.13 This will support the FCA in identifying and addressing any harm arising in those areas. It will also enable the FCA to work alongside the PRA in monitoring the FPC’s housing policies and assessment of macroprudential risk.
3.31 The FCA proposes to require PRA-authorised mortgage lenders to submit the current
PSD001 sales report with the 3 additional fields containing the information required by the PRA. Q12: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require PRAauthorised mortgage lenders to submit the information required by the PRA in PSD sales reports? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
3.32 The FCA is also proposing to require FCA-authorised mortgage lenders to report
these data for the reasons outlined below.
10 The requirement to submit the data is set out in the PRA rule, the FCA rule deals only with the format of the submission. 11 Section 3R of FSMA permits the FCA and the PRA to enter into arrangements for the FCA to supply services to the PRA 12 Under Section 3Q of FSMA, the FCA is required to ‘take such steps as it considers appropriate to co-operate with the Bank…in connection with [its] pursuits of its Financial Stability Objective’ 13 The FCA will pass the data on to the PRA, but the PRA would allow the FCA to retain the data for its own purposes.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Other outstanding regulated mortgage debt with the same lender and with other lenders
3.33 Knowing the outstanding regulated mortgage debt of the customer when they are
sold a further advance or second charge mortgage will help the FCA better understand lenders’ responsible lending practices. For example, by giving more insight into how lenders are assessing customer debt to ensure that they can afford the mortgage. This will enable us to identify potential harm to customers sooner.
3.34 These data will show us the makeup of the market more clearly in terms of how
customers structure their mortgage debt and how it is split across lenders. Second charge lending especially is spread across the population of both PRA-authorised and FCA-authorised firms.
3.35 This will also help the FCA understand how well the LTI flow limit is working across the
market and enable the FCA to help inform the FPC housing policies. Contractual reversion rate offered at point of sale
3.36 These data will enable the FCA to better supervise lenders. MCOB 11.6.18R (2) requires
lenders to take into account any prevailing FPC recommendation on appropriate interest-rate stress tests, including the affordability test.
3.37 By receiving the reversion rate directly from lenders, we can accurately monitor
whether lenders are taking into account the affordability test.
Q13: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require FCAauthorised lenders to submit 3 more data fields in PSD sales reports? If not, what amendments would you suggest? What do mortgage lenders need to know?
3.38 The FCA proposes to add 3 fields to the PSD sales report:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements 4 Mortgage lending and administration return (MLAR) The FCA proposes to require second charge administrators to report on the number and value of loans they administer. Why are we proposing this?
4.1 The FCA began regulating second charge mortgage firms in 2016. In the lead-up to
this change, we created a new MLAR form so that second-charge firms were required to report aggregated returns data separately from any first charge reporting. However, one form, asking for the number and value of second charge loans being administered, was omitted. We propose requiring second charge firms to submit this. This will further our ability to monitor the second charge mortgage market and assess potential harms. Q14: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require second charge administrators to report on the number and value of loans they administer? If not, what amendments would you suggest? What do second charge administrators need to know?
4.2 We propose adding the new form, MLA-G1, to the MLAR sub forms in SUP 16 Annex
19AAR. We propose that administrators submit the new form from the date we confirm the new rules (if indeed we do confirm them), but not for past returns. The FCA and PRA propose to clarify guidance on the reporting of the MLAR Why are we proposing this?
4.3 The FCA and PRA are proposing some changes to the MLAR forms and guidance
to ensure that firms better understand where loans, especially loans sold on or securitised, should be reported. These changes are primarily driven by queries firms have made to the FCA Contact Centre when they have been unsure of how to report the data items.
4.4 The FCA believes that these changes are important given our proposal to collect PSD
on loans sold on to unregulated entities. The FCA aims to ensure aggregate data on these loans are also reported accurately and consistently in MLAR. The proposed improvements will further support FCA and PRA supervision. What do home finance administrators and lenders need to know?
4.5 The FCA and PRA propose to amend the wording in MLA-G and MLA-G1 to ensure it is
accurate. Where administrators report the number or value of loans administered for:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Chapter 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
4.8 For clarity, we have included the table below which lays out examples of how firms
should report loans in both MLAR and PSD007, depending on who owns the loan and who has the relevant permissions. For the context of the table:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Annex 1
Questions in this paper
Q1: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require mortgage administrators to submit PSD performance reports on mortgages owned by entities which are not authorised home finance lenders? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q2: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to amend SUP 16.11.1R as per paragraph 2.7? If you do not agree with the proposal, what other amendments would you suggest? Q3: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to add these fields to the PSD performance report? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q4: Do you agree with the FCA proposal that mortgage administrators submit nil returns where they do not administer any relevant mortgages? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q5: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require mortgage lenders to submit PSD sales reports on internal product transfers? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q6: Do you agree with the FCA proposals to add fields, drop-down options and guidance to the sales report to adapt for internal product transfer reporting? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q7: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to require PRA-authorised mortgage lenders to submit sales reports on further advances? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q8: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require PRA-authorised firms that will be subject to the PRA requirement to submit sales reports on further advances, to do so via PSD? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q9: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require FCA-authorised mortgage lenders to submit PSD sales reports on further advances? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Q10: Do you agree with the FCA proposals to amend drop-down options and guidance to the sales report to adapt for further advance reporting? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q11: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to require PRA-authorised home finance lenders to submit the 3 additional fields outlined above? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q12: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require PRA-authorised mortgage lenders to submit the information required by the PRA in PSD sales reports? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q13: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require FCA-authorised lenders to submit 3 more data fields in PSD sales reports? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q14: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to require second charge administrators to report on the number and value of loans they administer? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q15: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to change the category labels on MLA-G and MLA-G1 in SUP 16 Annex 19AR and 19AAR? If not, what amendments do you suggest? Q16: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to change the category labels on the MLA-G and MLA-G1 templates and add a footnote clarifying that the templates refer to FCA glossary definitions? If not, what amendments do you suggest? Q17: Do you agree with the FCA proposal to amend the guidance in SUP 16 Annex 19B G to make clear how firms with the administering permission should complete MLAR? If not, what amendments would you suggest? Q18: Do you agree with the PRA proposal to amend its ‘Notes for the completion of the Mortgage Lenders and Administrators Return (‘MLAR’)’ as set out in Appendix 3? If not, what amendments would you suggest?
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Annex 2
FCA cost benefit analysis
Introduction
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Figure 1: Causal chain
FCA makes informed interventions eg �rm speci�c supervision, industry workshops, policy changes, to remedy harm Harm reduced FCA analyses data to identify and diagnose potential harm FCA analyses better quality data to identify and diagnose potential harm Firms submit more data to FCA Firms submit better quality data to FCA Amend rules to require �rms to submit more data to us Amend guidance so that �rms more clearly understand the reporting requirements Baseline and key assumptions
6. It is necessary to establish a baseline, or counterfactual, against which to assess the
costs and benefits of an intervention, to ensure that we consider only those costs associated with that intervention.
7. We use the counterfactual of firms meeting our current reporting rules to measure
the costs and benefits of our proposals. In the counterfactual scenario, we might undertake ad-hoc data requests to collect the information we want. To note that:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
9. The first is the information small14 and medium15 firms gave us regarding the costs of
implementing our initial reporting proposals as part of the Mortgage Market Review (MMR) in 2013. Those reporting changes included adding and amending fields in PSD001, setting up PSD007, and introducing new MLAR forms.
10. We have adjusted the figures for inflation16 and to reflect that actual costs are likely
to be lower, as firms adapt to our reporting requirements and make efficiencies in the design of their systems to meet those requirements. The respondent firms include smaller building societies, banks and 1 administrator.
11. The second set of data we have used is the information firms gave to the PRA
regarding the resources required and cost of implementing a number of changes to PSD001 reports in 2018. The respondent firms were large firms.17
12. We have given estimates of both one-off and ongoing costs. These include
personnel costs such as training staff, project management and personnel time on IT development. They also include systems costs, such as development and testing of the reporting systems. In some cases, we assume that ongoing costs can be subsumed into firms’ current outgoings on the maintenance of their reporting systems.
13. We welcome any views on the approach taken and assumptions we have made.
Costs of our proposals
PSD: performance reports (PSD007) changes
14. Our first proposal is that administrators report PSD007 on loans they administer on
behalf of unregulated entities. To meet this requirement, some administrators may have to set up systems to start reporting PSD007.
15. Some administrators already submit PSD007 on behalf of authorised lenders. They
would therefore be likely to already have the reporting systems in place and so incur lower costs. We also consider that administrators will already hold the information required to produce a PSD007 report. This is because that information is necessary to enable administration of a customer’s account. For example, information required in PSD007 includes the balance outstanding and the date of the customer’s most recent arrears.
16. We are aware that a relatively small number of administrators administer loans on behalf
of unregulated entities. We estimate that this number is between 5 to 10 administrators. In the absence of relevant cost survey data, we assume that the implementation of this proposal would necessitate IT projects at these firms. Using the FCA’s standard cost methodology, we assume that it would require 234 days of personnel time per firm across teams including business analysis, programming, testing and project management. We estimate ongoing costs as a tenth of that per year as we consider that some continued IT changes may be necessary on an ongoing basis. This results in estimated one off costs of £82,381 and average ongoing costs of £8240. 14 Less than 1% market share of gross mortgage lending 15 Between 1% and 7% market share of gross mortgage lending 16 We use the Retail Price Index: www.ons.gov.uk/economy/inflationandpriceindices/timeseries/chaw/mm23 17 Over 7% market share of gross mortgage lending
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
17. Administrators which do not administer loans on behalf of unregulated entities will
still be required to submit a nil PSD007 return. However, we consider that this will be a minimal cost that can be subsumed into ongoing compliance costs.
18. Based on these assumptions, we estimate that reporting PSD007 on loans
administered on behalf of unregulated entities would give rise to a maximum industry total one-off cost for administrators of £824,000, and ongoing costs of £0.08m per year.18
19. If lenders also administer loans on behalf of unregulated entities, we estimate that the
cost to start reporting PSD007 on those loans will be minimal. This is because they will already be required to report PSD007 on the loans which they own. We also consider that they will already hold the information required in a PSD007 report on the relevant loans, as would administrators.
20. The proposal to require lenders to include the new fields in PSD007 would result in
lenders having to update their systems to enable submissions of a new version of the PSD007 report. Based on the MMR cost survey, we estimate that these would be on average £5,000 for smaller lenders and £14,000 for medium lenders. To estimate the costs for large lenders, we have scaled these estimates based on a ratio of cost estimates for larger firms, relative to medium firms, derived from our estimates for the proposed changes to PSD1 (see paragraph 23 below). This produces an average cost of £44,000 for large lenders and an industry total one-off cost of £1.8m.19 The incremental on-going costs are likely to be minimal as the additional fields could be addressed by firms’ existing efforts to maintain PSD007. PSD: sales reports (PSD001) changes
21. The second set of proposals relates to PSD001 changes. As set out in paragraph
1.4 the PRA and FCA have made these changes jointly to reduce costs for firms by
spreading the fixed costs of the necessary change projects across changes that will be implemented in a single change. The proposed changes are that:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
23. The MMR cost survey contains estimates from small and medium lenders about the
cost and resources required to add further fields to, and change, PSD001, including reporting new information. We have used these to estimate the costs of these changes. These are on average £24,000 for a small lender and £80,000 for a medium lender with ongoing costs subsumed into general maintenance costs.
24. The PRA has also received costs estimates from large lenders covering the proposed
changes to PSD001. These are on average £250,000 per firm with average on-going costs of £25,000 per firm per annum.
25. Using these responses, we estimate that upgrading systems to the new PSD001
version would give rise to an industry one-off cost to lenders of £9m. Total industry ongoing costs are estimated at £150,000 per annum.
26. In addition, lenders may outsource reporting to third parties, who may report on behalf
of multiple firms. Therefore, it is possible those third parties would spread the cost across their clients and the cost to those lenders may be lower. To the extent that this occurs in practice, the actual costs may be lower than the estimates presented here. MLAR changes
27. We are proposing to require administrators who administer second charge loans to
report a new MLAR form. We asked smaller lenders about the cost of introducing new MLAR forms in 2013. Using the data they provided about costs to introduce the MLAR liquidity form and based on the number of firms that will have to report the new form, we estimate that industry total one-off costs would amount to £21,00020 and ongoing costs to £15,000.21
28. We consider that there would be minimal cost arising from our proposed guidance
changes. These are intended to make the MLAR reporting requirements clearer and should make the MLAR submissions process easier for firms. Overall costs of the proposals set out in this CP
Table 2: Overall costs to the industry
Firm type One-off On-going
Lenders £10.76m £0.15m
Administrators £0.85m £0.10m
Total £11.61m £0.25m
Note: figures in the text may not add to total in this table due to rounding.
29. These cost figures presented are driven by the large number of firms affected by
the proposals.22 The costs are also likely to be conservative estimates. Firms should consider their own systems and costs in responding to the CP. 20 Based on one off costs of c. £90 for 234 firms. 21 Based on on-going costs of c. £62 for 234 firms. 22 The proposals to amend PSD set out in this CP affect 303 firms
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Costs to the FCA
30. The proposals will also require the FCA to amend systems so that firms can submit
the information via GABRIEL and so that the information can be stored on our internal systems. The estimated costs to amend GABRIEL are laid out below:
Table 3: Costs to the FCA
Item Name Cost
PSD001 £82,000
PSD007 £35,500
MLAR £57,500
Total £175,000
Benefits of our proposals
31. We believe that the proposals will have an indirect benefit for consumers. This is
because having the data will enable us to better identify, diagnose and monitor harm in the mortgage market. As a result, we will be able to better remedy those harms and supervise in a more effective manner. Ultimately, this should result in us better:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Annex 3
FCA compatibility statement
Compliance with legal requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements The general principle that consumers should take responsibility for their decisions
16. The proposals do not directly relate to consumer behaviour.
The responsibilities of senior management
17. The senior managers’ regime will not be impacted by our proposals.
The desirability of recognising differences in the nature of, and objectives of, businesses carried on by different persons including mutual societies and other kinds of business organisation
18. We have considered differences between firms and we believe there is insufficient
evidence to merit the differing application of our proposals to mutual societies, including building societies. This is because we understand that the relative cost to meet our proposed requirements will not be higher for such organisations. The desirability of publishing information relating to persons subject to requirements imposed under FSMA, or requiring them to publish information
19. Our proposals are compatible with this principle.
The principle that we should exercise of our functions as transparently as possible
20. In developing our proposals, we have had regard to the importance of acting as
transparently as possible.
21. In formulating these proposals, the FCA has had regard to the importance of taking
action intended to minimise the extent to which it is possible for a business carried on (i) by an authorised person or a recognised investment exchange; or (ii) in contravention of the general prohibition, to be used for a purpose connected with financial crime (as required by s. 1B(5)(b) FSMA). We do not consider this relevant to our proposals. Expected effect on mutual societies
22. The FCA does not expect the proposals in this paper to have a significantly different
impact on mutual societies.
Equality and diversity
23. We are required under the Equality Act 2010 in exercising our functions to ‘have
due regard’ to the need to eliminate discrimination, harassment, victimisation and any other conduct prohibited by or under the Act, advance equality of opportunity between persons who share a relevant protected characteristic and those who do not, and to foster good relations between people who share a protected characteristic and those who do not.
24. As part of this, we ensure the equality and diversity implications of any new policy
proposals are considered. We do not consider our proposals will adversely affect people with protected characteristics, but seek views on this.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 (LRRA)
25. We have had regard to the principles in the LRRA for the parts of the proposals that
consist of general policies, principles or guidance and consider that our proposals are:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Annex 4
The PRA’s statutory obligations
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
9. The proposals set out in this paper will also result in the PRA incurring costs. The PRA
will cover the cost to the FCA of updating systems to receive and store additional PSD001 data requested by the PRA from firms. The PRA will also incur costs as a result of updating its own systems to receive the new PSD001 dataset. It is estimated these costs will sum to approximate £70k. The PRA does not expect to incur material costs as a result of changes to MLAR.
10. The proposed changes will assist the PRA in monitoring the LTI flow limit and the
affordability test, existing requirements on firms, and therefore will help to realise the benefits of these policies. For more information about these policies, see PRA CP 11/14, the Record of the Financial Policy Committee Meetings 17 and 25 June 2014, and the Record of the Financial Policy Committee Meeting held on 21 June 2017.
11. The proposed MLAR reporting definitional changes are minor and the PRA does not
expect any increased costs for firms. The improved clarity in the reporting definitions should benefit firms by making the MLAR reporting process easier. The changes will benefit the PRA by improving data quality and allowing it to better monitor risks to its safety and soundness objective by enabling the PRA to better monitor new mortgage lending by PRA-regulated firms. Compatibility with the PRA’s objectives
12. The PRA considers that these reporting changes are compatible with the PRA’s
primary objective to promote the safety and soundness of firms it regulates by supporting the prudential supervision of PRA-authorised firms through monitoring parts of their business that have been identified as having the potential to adversely affect the stability of the UK financial system. The changes will also support the prudential supervision of firms by enabling the PRA to see a more complete picture of mortgage lending practices by PRA-authorised firms. The changes would also improve the PRA’s cooperation with the Bank in the Bank’s pursuit of its financial stability objective of protecting and enhancing the stability of the UK financial system.
13. The PRA’s objective to contribute to securing an appropriate degree of protection for
policyholders is not engaged by these changes.
14. The PRA has assessed the potential impact of the proposed rules on facilitating
effective competition. The proposals are not expected to have a material effect on competition. Regulatory principles
15. In developing the proposal in this CP, the PRA has had regard to the regulatory
principles. Two principles of particular relevance to the proposals set out above are:
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 4
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements CP, by only requiring the regulated debt with other lenders to be reported for second charge mortgages.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 5
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Annex 5
Abbreviations used in this paper
CBA Cost Benefit Analysis
CP Consultation Paper
FCA Financial Conduct Authority
FPC Financial Policy Committee
FSMA Financial Services and Markets Act
LRRA Legislative Regulatory Reform Act 2006 LTI Loan to Income MCD Mortgage Credit Directive MCOB Mortgages and Home Finance: Conduct of Business sourcebook MLAR Mortgage Lending and Administration Return MMR Mortgage Market Review MMS Mortgage Market Study PRA Prudential Regulation Authority PSD Product Sales Data SUP the Supervision manual
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Annex 5
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements We have developed the policy in this Consultation Paper in the context of the existing UK and EU regulatory framework. The Government has made clear that it will continue to implement and apply EU law until the UK has left the EU. We will keep the proposals under review to assess whether any amendments may be required in the event of changes in the UK regulatory framework in the future. We make all responses to formal consultation available for public inspection unless the respondent requests otherwise. We will not regard a standard confidentiality statement in an email message as a request for non-disclosure. Despite this, we may be asked to disclose a confidential response under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. We may consult you if we receive such a request. Any decision we make not to disclose the response is reviewable by the Information Commissioner and the Information Rights Tribunal. All our publications are available to download from www.fca.org.uk. If you would like to receive this paper in an alternative format, please call 020 7066 7948 or email: publications_graphics@fca.org.uk or write to: Editorial and Digital team, Financial Conduct Authority, 12 Endeavour Square, London E20 1JN By responding to this consultation, you provide personal data to the Bank of England. This may include your name, contact details (including, if provided, details of the organisation you work for), and opinions or details offered in the response itself. The response will be assessed to inform our work as a regulator and central bank, both in the public interest and in the exercise of our official authority. We may use your details to contact you to clarify any aspects of your response. The consultation paper will explain if responses will be shared with other organisations (for example, the Financial Conduct Authority). If this is the case, the other organisation will also review the responses and may also contact you to clarify aspects of your response. We will retain all responses for the period that is relevant to supporting ongoing regulatory policy developments and reviews. However, all personal data will be redacted from the responses within five years of receipt. To find out more about how we deal with your personal data, your rights or to get in touch please visit bankofengland.co.uk/legal/privacy. Information provided in response to this consultation, including personal information, may be subject to publication or disclosure to other parties in accordance with access to information regimes including under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 or data protection legislation, or as otherwise required by law or in discharge of the Bank’s functions. Please indicate if you regard all, or some of, the information you provide as confidential. If the Bank of England receives a request for disclosure of this information, we will take your indication(s) into account, but cannot give an assurance that
confidentiality can be maintained in all circumstances. An automatic confidentiality disclaimer generated by your IT system on emails will not, of itself, be regarded as binding on the Bank of England. Responses are requested by 22 March 2019. Please address any comments or enquiries to:
Macroprudential Toolkit Team
Prudential Regulation Authority
20 Moorgate
London
EC2R 6DA
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Appendix 1
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Appendix 1
Draft Handbook text
FCA 2019/XX
MORTGAGES (REGULATORY REPORTING) INSTRUMENT 2019 Powers exercised A. The Financial Conduct Authority makes this instrument in the exercise of the following powers and related provisions in the Act:
(1) section 137A (The FCA’s general rules); (2) section 137T (General supplementary powers); and (3) and section 139A (The FCA’s power to give guidance). B. The rule-making powers listed above are specified for the purpose of section 138G(2) (Rule-making instruments) of the Act. Commencement
C. This instrument comes into force on [date].
Amendments to the Handbook
D. The Supervision manual (SUP) is amended in accordance with the Annex to this instrument. Citation E. This instrument may be cited as the Mortgages (Regulatory Reporting) Instrument 2019. By order of the Board [date]
FCA 2019/XX
Annex
Amendments to the Supervision manual (SUP)
In this Annex, underlining indicates new text and striking through indicates deleted text. 16 Reporting requirements …
16.11 Product Sales Data Reporting
Application
16.11.1 R This section applies:
…
(2) in relation to performance data reports,:
(a) to a the firm in (“A”) which the rights and obligations of the lender under a entered into the regulated mortgage contract are vested; or (b) where the right of the lender to receive payments under the regulated mortgage contract has passed to another person (“B”) by legal or equitable assignment or by operation of law:
(i) where B is a firm with permission for administering a regulated mortgage contract, firm B (and it is immaterial for this purpose whether B makes arrangements for A or another person to administer the mortgage or to exercise the lender’s rights under it); or (ii) where B is not a firm with permission for administering a regulated mortgage contract and B enters into an agreement with a firm (“C”) to administer the contract, firm C (it is immaterial for this purpose whether firm C is firm A, or whether firm C enters into an arrangement with another person to outsource or delegate the performance of some of those administration activities). 16.11.1 A G Where a regulated mortgage contract has been sold or securitised, the firm responsible for the performance data report should be the ‘principal administrator’ submitting the MLAR (see section G of SUP 16 Annex 19AR and the guidance notes on section G in SUP 16 Annex 19BG). Purpose
16.11.2 G …
FCA 2019/XX
(3) Certain of the information is required under PRA rules: see SUP 16.11.7R(2) to (5). This information is collected by the FCA for the PRA, but the PRA allows the FCA to retain the information for the FCA’s purposes. Reporting requirement
16.11.3 R …
(3
B)
A firm must submit a nil return in respect of performance data reports if it does not own any rights of a lender under a regulated mortgage contract, and only carries on the regulated activity of administering a regulated mortgage contract for firms which are themselves obliged to submit performance data reports under SUP 16.11.1R(2). … … Content of the report
16.11.5 R A sales data report must contain sales data in respect of the following
products:
…
(3) regulated mortgage contracts (but not including further advances (see SUP 16.11.7R(3)) and internal product transfers and internal remortgages, irrespective of whether there is a new mortgage contract); … …
16.11.7 R (1) A data report must comply with the provisions of SUP 16 Annex
21R.
(2) But (3) to (5) apply where a firm which is required to submit a sales data report under SUP 16.11.3R(1)(a) is a PRA-authorised person which is also required to submit information to the FCA under
chapter 22 (regulatory mortgage contract reporting) of the PRA’s
Regulatory Reporting rules.
(3) Where the sales data report relates to a further advance, SUP 16.11.3R(1)(a) and SUP 16 Annex 21R apply to the firm only in relation to the format in which the data elements in the report are to be submitted to the FCA. (4) Where the sales data report does not relate to a further advance, SUP 16.11.3R(1)(a) and SUP 16 Annex 21R apply to the firm in respect
FCA 2019/XX of the data elements listed in (5) only in relation to the format in which the data elements are to be submitted to the FCA. (5) The data elements are:
(a) the total amount owed by the borrower to the firm under the regulated mortgage contract; (b) for a second charge regulated mortgage contract, the total amount owing to third parties secured on the property; and (c) the contractual reversion rate. …
16.12 Integrated Regulatory Reporting
…
16.12.18
C
R …
Description of data item
Data item (note
1)
Frequency Submission deadline
…
Second charge lending - arrears analysis
… … …
Second charge mortgage administration
– business profile
Section G1
MLAR
Quarterly 20 business days
…
…
Annex
19AR
Mortgage Lenders & Administrators Return (‘MLAR’) … G (1) MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION: Business profile …
FCA 2019/XX
G1
.1
Number of loans administered for:
a) Firms Firms with a mortgage lender’s permission mortgage lender’s permission … … b) Other firms persons (but not special purpose vehicles – see c) below) … … c) SPVs special purpose vehicles … … d) Total … … G1 .2 Balance outstanding on loans administered for:
a) Firms Firms with a mortgage lender’s permission mortgage lender’s permission … … b) Other firms persons (but not special purpose vehicles – see c) below) … … c) SPVs special purpose vehicles … … d) Total … … G (2) MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION: Business profile G2 Lenders Persons for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at end of quarter … G2 .1 Firms Firms with a mortgage lender’s permission mortgage lender’s permission:
[top 5 only]
…
G2 Other firms persons (but not special purpose vehicles – see …
FCA 2019/XX
.2 G2.3 below):
[top 5 only]
G2
.3
SPVs special purpose vehicles:
[top 5 only]
…
Annex
19AAR
Mortgage Lenders & Administrators Return (‘MLAR’) – sub-forms for second charge regulated mortgage activity … MLA-G1 Second Charge Mortgage Administration – business profile Second or subsequent charge mortgage contracts administered at end of quarter As Principal administrator As Other administrator 1 Total number of residential loans to individuals administered 2 Total balance outstanding on all residential loans to individuals administered (£000’s) …
Annex
19BG
Notes for Completion of the Mortgage Lenders & Administrators Return (‘MLAR’) …
SECTION G: MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION – BUSINESS PROFILE
…
You should also note, however, that if you have both a mortgage lender’s activity and a mortgage administrator’s activity to administer your own book and do not
FCA 2019/XX have any off-balance sheet loans to administer, then you should not complete this
section answer only the first question of section G of the MLAR (“Do you need to
complete tables G and H?”), leaving the rest of section G and section H blank. ‘Principal’ and ‘Other’ Administrators …
FCA 2019/XX lender’s activity, for other firms persons (i.e. lenders including unauthorised purchasers of your off-balance sheet mortgages for which whom you administer mortgages but they who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity) and for special purpose vehicles (‘SPVs’) (i.e. firms that fall within the Handbook definition of a special purpose vehicle). You should also detail the number of non-regulated loans administered as at the end of the quarter for firms firms with a mortgage lender’s activity, for other firms persons (i.e. lenders including unauthorised purchasers of your off-balance sheet mortgages for which whom you administer mortgages but they who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity) and for SPVs special purpose vehicles. The total (all loans) is the sum of regulated mortgage contracts and nonregulated loans. G2 Lenders Persons for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at quarter end Collects data only on the top five lenders for each category by value (i.e. the largest five firms by value, based on balances outstanding on regulated loans) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarter end. (Details on other lenders persons are not required to be shown, over and above the top five listed in each category.) The analysis required in G2 covers all mortgage administration activity undertaken by your firm firm, irrespective of whether your firm firm is acting as a ‘principal’ or ‘other’ administrator. The final column of the analysis, however, asks you to indicate your status for each firm person listed, namely whether acting as ‘Principal’ or as ‘Other’ administrator. … G2.2 Other firms persons who own loans Please detail the top five other firms persons who own beneficially the rights of the lender under the relevant mortgage contracts (by value) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarter end (but who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity; these persons may be authorised persons or unauthorised persons). You should indicate the value of regulated mortgage contracts and nonregulated loans for each of the top five other firms persons who own beneficially the rights of the lender under the relevant mortgage contracts and for whom you administer. The total (all loans) for each firm person listed is the sum of regulated mortgage contracts and non-regulated loans. G SPVs Special purpose vehicles
FCA 2019/XX
2.3
Please detail the top five SPVs special purpose vehicles (by value) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarter-end. If your firm has off-balance sheet loans (which it has reported in G1.1 c) and G1.2 c)) then please show your firm as one of these five SPVs special purpose vehicles as follows:
FCA 2019/XX
(iii) where your firm has a mortgage lender’s activity, loans that represent your firm’s off-balance sheet loans and which you have reported in section A3 of table A as “gross balances” under “Securitised balances” [deleted]. NB: loans in (ii) and (iii) are all those shown in G1.2c of table G. …
Annex
20G
Products covered by the reporting requirement in SUP 16.11 … In the case of mortgage transactions, the reporting requirement only applies to loans for house purchase, and remortgages, internal product transfers (including those effected by a new mortgage contract and those effected as contract variations) and (in the case of sales data only) not to further advances. In the case of sales data, a reportable mortgage transaction applies where the mortgage transaction has completed (i.e. funds have been transferred and have been applied for the purpose of the mortgage). …
Annex
21R
Reporting fields
This is the annex referred to in SUP 16.11.7R.
1 GENERAL REPORTING FIELDS
The following data reporting fields must be completed, where applicable, for all reportable transactions and submitted in a prescribed format. Data reporting field Code (where applicable) Notes … … … Transaction reference (regulated mortgage contracts, high cost short term loans and home credit loan agreements only) Numeric / Alphanumeric A unique reference for the transaction, internal to the reporting firm, that will enable the firm to provide the FCA with more information concerning the transaction if required, e.g. the account number, application number etc. Original Transaction reference (regulated mortgage contracts only) Numeric / Alphanumeric Where there is a further advance or an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage, this should be the
FCA 2019/XX transaction reference of the mortgage when originally reported. If the mortgage predates sales data reporting, this box should be left blank. … … … 2 SPECIFIC REPORTING FIELDS … (c) Mortgages … Notes … (3) In the case of sales data only, reporting fields should not be completed in relation to further advances. [deleted] … Data reporting field Code (where applicable) Notes Sales Data (report for all regulated mortgage contracts) Date mortgage account opened or of further advance or of internal product transfer or other internal remortgage DD/MM/YYYY Date of mortgage completion or drawdown of the funds. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage (irrespective of whether additional borrowing is taken), this should be the date the new account is opened, or the rate change or product switch is effected. In the case of a further advance, this should be the date of draw-down of the funds. Date previous mortgage account opened, or of most recent further advance, or of most recent internal product transfer or other internal remortgage DD/MM/YYYY In the case of a further advance, this should be the date of the most recent further advance. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage which is effected by means of a new mortgage contract, this should be the date on which the previous mortgage
FCA 2019/XX account was opened or, if later, the date of the most recent internal product transfer or other internal remortgage which was effected by a variation to that mortgage. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage which is effected by a variation to the existing mortgage contract, this should be the date of the most recent product transfer or other internal remortgage effected by a variation. For first time buyers, or other cases where there is no relevant most recent event, this data element should be left blank. … … … Date incentivised rate ends … … Contractual reversion rate Numeric % Report the reversion rate specified in the contract, i.e. the interest rate which is currently expected to apply at the end of any initial incentive or fixed rate period. If there is no reversion rate, e.g. for mortgages sold on a SVR or a rate that is fixed for the term, this should be the same as the initial gross charging rate of interest. … … … Type of mortgage L = lifetime mortgage SA = shared appreciation mortgage SO = shared ownership mortgage BM = business loan Use code to indicate mortgage type. Report all relevant codes. Report ‘NA’ to denote ‘not applicable’ where codes do not apply. Report ‘FA’ for a further advance under the same mortgage contract. Report ‘FN’ for a further advance, where the further advance is under a new mortgage contract. A further advance is a further loan to an existing borrower of the firm and which is secured on the
FCA 2019/XX
BL = bridging loan
FA = further advance under an existing mortgage contract FN = further advance under a new mortgage contract GM = guarantor mortgage HN = loan to a high net worth mortgage customer BR = buy-to-let mortgage (regulated) LO = low start mortgage PT = internal product transfer RI = retirement interest-only mortgage SB = self-build mortgage SE = secured overdraft SC = second charge regulated mortgage contract VN = contract variation with no affordability assessment same property – under a new mortgage contract, or by variation to an existing mortgage contract – including a loan secured by a second or subsequent charge where the firm has the benefit of the first charge (or other charge ranking in priority to that on which the further advance is secured). Report a ‘guarantor mortgage’ where the income of a guarantor has been included in the affordability assessment. Report a ‘low start mortgage’ where payments are made on an interest-only basis for a set period at the start of the mortgage, but payments contractually revert to a repayment basis after this set period. Report ‘PT’ where a customer internally transfers to a new product to obtain a different interest rate, with no additional borrowing (other than where application or reservation fees are being added to the outstanding amount), whether or not this involves a new mortgage contract. Report ‘SC’ for a second charge regulated mortgage contract. Where relevant, report both ‘FN’ and ‘SC’ where the firm is entering into a second charge regulated mortgage contract and the borrower also has amounts owing to the firm secured by a first charge on the property, or ‘FA’ and ‘SC’ where there is a further advance under a second charge regulated mortgage contract. Report ‘VN’ for contract variations that result in a new regulated mortgage contract, where no affordability assessment has been undertaken in accordance with MCOB 11.6. Where relevant, report as both ‘VN’ and ‘PT’. Report ‘L’ if the mortgage is a lifetime mortgage of the type described in MCOB 9.4.132AR.
FCA 2019/XX
NA = not applicable
… … …
… … …
Type of borrower F = first time buyer
M = home movers (2 nd or subsequent buyers) R = remortgagors C = council/ registered social landlord tenant exercising their right to buy O = other Use code to indicate type of borrower. A mortgage taken on a previously unencumbered property should be reported as a remortgage. An internal product transfer, even if entered through a contract variation rather than a new contract, should be reported as a remortgage. Only 1 code should be entered. Report ‘O’ for lifetime mortgages, bridging loans, further advances and second charge regulated mortgage contracts that are not for remortgage purposes. … … … Term of mortgage in months Numeric Report the mortgage term in months. For an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage, or for a further advance, report the remaining term at the time of the transfer, remortgage or advance. Where the loan is split into more than one part, report the term applying to the largest part of the loan. Size of loan Numeric £ The original balance when the mortgage was completed. For an internal product transfer, report the balance immediately after the transfer. For a further advance, report the size of the advance. This amount should include fees and charges added to the loan. … . … Type of valuation at I = internal Report the type of valuation undertaken
FCA 2019/XX origination of mortgage inspection E = external inspection only, including driveby A = automated valuation model, indexed or desktop valuation O = other to obtain the market value of the mortgaged property. An internal inspection is where a valuer has carried out an internal inspection of the property. An external inspection is where the property has been inspected (including by drive-by inspection), but without an internal inspection of the property. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage, this data element may be left blank if the answer is not known. … … … The purpose of a second charge regulated mortgage contract, further advance or extra money withdrawn for remortgages H = home improvements D = debt consolidation O = other Use codes to indicate the purpose(s) of the second charge regulated mortgage contract, further advance or the extra money withdrawn for first or second charge remortgages. Report all that apply. … … … County court judgments (CCJs) – first borrower (Value) Numeric £ Report where the first borrower has been the subject of one or more CCJs, with a total value greater than £500, within the last three years (whether satisfied or unsatisfied). Report ‘0’ where the borrower does not have any CCJs. Where a CCJ is registered against the first and second borrower, report for both. A reference to the ‘county court’ is a reference to the county court in England and Wales, the county court in Northern Ireland and the sheriff court in Scotland. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage, this data element may be left blank if the answer is not known.
FCA 2019/XX
County court judgments
(CCJs) – second borrower
(Value)
Numeric £ Report where the second borrower has been the subject of one or more CCJs, with a total value greater than £500, within the last three years (whether satisfied or unsatisfied). Report ‘0’ where the borrower does not have any CCJs. Where a CCJ is registered against the first and second borrower, report for both. A reference to the ‘county court’ is a reference to the county court in England and Wales, the county court in Northern Ireland and the sheriff court in Scotland. In the case of an internal product transfer or other internal remortgage, this data element may be left blank if the answer is not known. Impaired credit history of first borrower A = arrears V = IVA B = bankruptcy D = debt relief order NA = not applicable Use code/s to indicate applicable credit history of first borrower. Report all that apply. A = applies where within the last two years, the first borrower has owed overdue payments, of an amount equivalent to three months payments, on a mortgage or other loan (whether secured or unsecured). V = applies where the first borrower has been subject to an individual voluntary arrangement (IVA) at any time within the last three years. B = applies where the first borrower has been subject to a bankruptcy order at any time within the last 3 three years. D = applies where the first borrower has been subject to a debt relief order any time within the last three years. Where the impaired credit item relates to both the first and second borrower, report for both.
FCA 2019/XX
Report ‘NA’ to denote ‘not applicable’ where the borrower has no relevant impaired credit history items. For the purposes of this note:
FCA 2019/XX report for both.
Report ‘NA’ to denote ‘not applicable’ where the borrower has no relevant impaired credit history items. For the purposes of this note:
FCA 2019/XX
…
… … …
Total outstanding credit commitments for all borrowers … … The total amount owed by the borrower to the firm under regulated mortgage contracts secured on the property immediately prior to the new borrowing Numeric £ For a new mortgage contract, report the total amount owing to the firm and secured on the property under other regulated mortgage contracts that is outstanding immediately prior to the mortgage advance. For a further advance under an existing regulated mortgage contract (which constitutes a variation to that mortgage contract), report the amount owed to the firm under that mortgage contract immediately prior to the making of that further advance. Where there is a further advance under an existing regulated mortgage contract which is a second charge regulated mortgage contract, report the amount owed to the firm under that mortgage contract and the other regulated mortgage contracts immediately prior to the making of that further advance. For a second charge regulated mortgage contract, the total amount owing to third parties secured on the property Numeric £ Report the total amount owing to third parties and secured on the property at the time of the mortgage advance or further advance, as relevant. (Amounts owing to the firm secured by charge ranking in priority to the second charge regulated mortgage contract should be included in the data element above.) … … … Data reporting field Code (where applicable) Notes Performance Data (report for all regulated mortgage contracts) Reference number of the firm which owns beneficially the rights of Numeric Where the mortgage contract is owned beneficially by the firm submitting the report, this should be the reference
FCA 2019/XX the lender under the mortgage contract number of the firm. Where the mortgage is owned beneficially by a firm other than the firm submitting the report, this should be the reference number of the other firm. If the mortgage is owned beneficially by an unauthorised person, leave this data element blank. Legal name of the unauthorised person which owns beneficially the rights of the lender under the mortgage contract Alphanumeric Where the mortgage contract is owned beneficially by an unauthorised person, this should be the legal name (rather than a trading name) of that person. If the mortgage contract is owned beneficially by an authorised person, leave this data element blank. Reference number of lender that currently holds the mortgage Numeric This Where legal title to the mortgage contract is held by a firm which is not the beneficial owner of the lender’s rights under the mortgage contract, this field must contain the firm reference number of the lender that currently holds the mortgage that firm, whether they originated the mortgage or have bought it from another firm not. Where the mortgage is securitised, this includes the lender that retains an interest in the mortgage. Where legal and beneficial title to the mortgage contract are held by the same firm, report the same reference number as in the data element in the first row of this table. Is the account part of a closed book? Y = yes N = no Report ‘Y’ if the mortgage account (or collection of accounts of which the account is treated as part, i.e the mortgage book) is closed to new business. This will be the case where the only new funds transferred to the account or the book are further advances to the customer (or existing customers within the book), but the customer is not able to change to a new product type or switch interest rate types. This would include mortgage books owned by unauthorised persons, mortgage books owned by authorised persons whose permission does not
FCA 2019/XX include on the regulated activity of entering into a regulated mortgage contract, and mortgage books where the owner has permission to carry on the regulated activity of entering into a regulated mortgage contract but is not exercising it in relation to the mortgage book or customers within the book. Reference number of administrator Numeric Where the mortgage is administrated by a third party that is an authorised person, this field must contain the firm reference number of that firm. (This should be the Principal administrator rather than the Other administrator: see
Section G of SUP 16 Annex 19BG.)
… … …
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Appendix 2
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Appendix 2
Draft Rulebook text
PRA RULEBOOK: CRR FIRMS: REGULATORY REPORTING AMENDMENT INSTRUMENT 2018 Powers exercised A. The Prudential Regulation Authority (“PRA”) makes this instrument in the exercise of the following powers and related provisions in the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (“the Act”):
(1) section 137G (The PRA’s general rules); AND (2) section 137T (General supplementary powers). B. The rule-making powers referred to above are specified for the purpose of section 138G(2) (Rulemaking instrument) of the Act. Pre-conditions to making
C. In accordance with section 138J of the Act (Consultation by the PRA), the PRA consulted the
Financial Conduct Authority. After consulting, the PRA published a draft of proposed rules and had regard to representations made. PRA Rulebook: CRR Firms: Regulatory Reporting Amendment Instrument 2018 D. The PRA makes the rules in the Annex to this instrument. Commencement E. This instrument comes into force on [DATE]. Citation F. This instrument may be cited as the PRA Rulebook: CRR Firms: Regulatory Reporting Amendment Instrument 2018. By order of the Prudential Regulation Committee [DATE]
Annex A
Amendments to the Regulatory Reporting Part In this Annex, unless otherwise indicated, new text is underlined and deleted text is struck through.
Part
REGULATORY REPORTING
Chapter content
…
22 REGULATORY MORTGAGE CONTRACT REPORTING
…
1 APPLICATION AND DEFINITIONS
…
1.2 …
further advance means a further loan to an existing borrower of the firm and which is secured on the same property, made either under a new regulated mortgage contract or by variation to an existing regulated mortgage contract, and including a loan secured by a second or subsequent charge where the firm has the benefit of the first charge (or other charge ranking in priority to that on which the further advance is secured), … internal product transfer means where a borrower under a regulated mortgage contract internally transfers to a new product to obtain a different interest rate but with no additional borrowing (other than application or reservation fees added to the outstanding amount), regardless of whether or not the transfer involves a new regulated mortgage contract. … regulated mortgage contract means the investment specified in Article 61(3)(a) of the Regulated Activities Order. … reversion rate means the interest rate on a regulated mortgage contract to which the interest rate which applies upon origination will change at the end of any initial incentive or fixed rate period. … second charge regulated mortgage contract means a regulated mortgage contract which is not a legal mortgage ranking in priority ahead of all other mortgages (if any) affecting the property in question, where ‘mortgage’ includes charge and (in Scotland) a heritable security. … 2 REPORTING REQUIREMENTS – DATA ITEMS …
2.10 A firm permitted to carry on the regulated activity of entering into a regulated mortgage
contract, except an incoming EEA firm with permission for cross border services only, must also submit data items as required by Chapter 22.
…
11 REGULATED ACTIVITY GROUP 5
…
11.2 …
(1) When submitting the completed data item required, a firm must use the format of the data item data item set out in Chapter 18 16. … 16 DATA ITEMS AND OTHER FORMS …
16.21 MLAR can be found here here.
…
[All of the following Chapter is new and therefore not underlined.] 22 REGULATORY MORTGAGE CONTRACT REPORTING Application
22.1 This Chapter applies to every firm permitted to carry on the regulated activity of entering into
a regulated mortgage contract, except an incoming EEA firm with permission for cross border services only. Reporting Requirement
22.2 If a firm makes a further advance under a regulated mortgage contract, the firm must submit
to the FCA a ‘sales data report’ within the meaning of SUP 16.11 of the FCA Handbook which contains the data elements set out in SUP 16 Annex 21 of the FCA Handbook.
22.3 If a firm :
(1) makes an advance under a regulated mortgage contract which is not a second charge regulated mortgage contract; or (2) carries out an internal product transfer the firm must submit the data elements specified in 22.6 to the FCA as part of a ‘sales data report’ under SUP 16.11 of the FCA Handbook.
22.4 If a firm makes an advance under a second charge regulated mortgage contract the firm
must submit the data elements specified in 22.7 to the FCA as part of a ‘sales data report’ under SUP 16.11 of the FCA Handbook.
22.5 (1) A firm may appoint another person to submit the ‘sales data report’ under 22.2 or the
data elements under 22.3 or 22.4 on the firm’s behalf if the firm has informed the PRA and the FCA of that appointment in writing. (2) Where (1) applies, the firm must ensure that the submission complies with the requirements of this Chapter and identifies the originator of the transaction. Data Elements
22.6 The data elements referred to in 22.3 are:
(1) the total amount owed by the borrower to the firm under any other regulated mortgage contract secured on the same property, unless the advance is a further advance made by variation of an existing regulated mortgage contract, in which case the data element is the amount owed under that regulated mortgage contract immediately prior to the making of the further advance; (2) the reversion rate specified in the regulated mortgage contract.
22.7 The data elements referred to in 22.4 are:
(1) the total amount owed by the borrower to the firm under any other regulated mortgage contract secured on the same property, unless the advance is a further advance made by variation of an existing regulated mortgage contract, in which case the data element is the amount owed under that regulated mortgage contract immediately prior to the making of the further advance; (2) the total amount owed by the borrower to third parties secured on the property; and (3) the reversion rate specified in the second charge regulated mortgage contract. Mode of Reporting
22.7 A firm must submit the ’sales data report’ required by 22.2 and the data elements required
by 22.3(1) and 22.4(1) in accordance with the procedure and format for a ‘sales data report’ set out in SUP 16.11 of the FCA Handbook.
FCA – CP18/41
PRA – CP30/18
Appendix 3
Financial Conduct Authority
FCA and PRA changes to mortgage reporting requirements
Appendix 3
PRA Amendments to notes for completion of the Mortgage Lenders & Administrators Return (MLAR)
SECTION G: MORTGAGE ADMINISTRATION – BUSINESS PROFILE
Introduction
…
You should also note, however, that if you have both a mortgage lender’s activity and a mortgage administrator’s activity to administer your own book and do not have any off-balance sheet loans to administer, then you should not complete this section answer only the first question of section G of the MLAR, leaving the rest of section G and section H blank. In this section ‘persons’ and ‘special purpose vehicle’ refers to the FCA glossary definition. ‘Principal’ and ‘Other’ Administrators … Principal administrator: this is where your firm:
(a) is administrating its own off-balance sheet mortgages; or (b) this is where your firm is authorised to undertake a mortgage administrator’s activity, and is exercising that activity on behalf of either a lender or another firm person that is not itself authorised to undertake a mortgage administrator’s activity; , or has entered into a contract to do so but has outsourced the mortgage administrator’s activity to another person. Other administrator: this is where your firm (although authorised to undertake a mortgage administrator’s activity) is undertaking loan administration for either a lender or another firm which itself is also authorised to undertake a mortgage administrator’s activity. In this situation, your firm is not regarded as the ‘principal administrator’, and you are merely acting on behalf of an authorised mortgage administrator. G1 Mortgage contracts administered at end quarter Where your firm is acting as Principal administrator (columns1-3) Collects data on mortgage contracts administered as at the end of the quarter, but only where you are formally acting as principal in exercising a mortgage administrator's activity. It therefore excludes the reporting of:
administrator's activity and which is exercising it in respect of those loans. … G1.1 Number of loans You should detail the number of regulated mortgage contracts administered as at the end of the quarter for firms with a mortgage lender’s activity, for other firms persons (i.e. lenders including unauthorised purchasers of your off-balance sheet mortgages for which whom you administer mortgages but they who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity) and for special purpose vehicles (‘SPVs’). You should also detail the number of non-regulated loans administered as at the end of the quarter for firms with a mortgage lender’s activity, for other firms persons (i.e. lenders including unauthorised purchasers of your off-balance sheet mortgages for which whom you administer mortgages but they who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity) and for SPVs special purpose vehicles. The total (all loans) is the sum of regulated mortgage contracts and non-regulated loans. … G2 Lenders Persons for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at quarter end Collects data only on the top five lenders for each category by value (i.e. the largest five firms by value, based on balances outstanding on regulated loans) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarter end. (Details on other lenders persons are not required to be shown, over and above the top five listed in each category.) The analysis required in G2 covers all mortgage administration activity undertaken by your firm, irrespective of whether your firm is acting as a ‘principal’ or ‘other’ administrator. The final column of the analysis, however, asks you to indicate your status for each firm person listed, namely whether acting as ‘Principal’ or as ‘Other’ administrator. … G2.2 Other firms persons who own loans Please detail the top five other firms persons who own beneficially the rights of the lender under the relevant mortgage contracts (by value) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarter end (but who themselves do not have a mortgage lender’s activity; these persons may be authorised persons or unauthorised persons).
You should indicate the value of regulated mortgage contracts and non- regulated loans for each of the top five other firms persons who own beneficially the rights of the lender under the relevant mortgage contracts and for whom you administer. The total (all loans) for each firm person listed is the sum of regulated mortgage contracts and non-regulated loans. G2.3 SPVs Special purpose vehicles Please detail the top five SPVs special purpose vehicles (by value) for whom mortgage administration was being carried out at the quarterend. If your firm has off-balance sheet loans (which it has reported in G1.1 c) and G1.2 c)) then please show your firm as one of these five SPVs as follows:
group together all SPVs special purpose vehicles for which your firm is the originator and show the aggregated amounts on a single line (irrespective of whether the total of regulated loans for all such SPVs special purpose vehicles would rank within the top five);
under “Securitised balances”). These loans are also reported at G1.2 b) in table G. (ii) loans administered for third party SPVs. These loans are reported at G1.2 c) in table G. (iii) where your firm has a mortgage lender's activity, loans that represent your firm's off-balance sheet loans and which you have reported in section A3 of table A as "gross balances" under "Securitised balances". NB loans in (ii) and (iii) are all those shown in G1.2c of table G. The information presented in table H should represent the total of all such loan types listed above, in a single version of the table. …
© Financial Conduct Authority 2018
12 Endeavour Square London E20 1JN
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7066 1000
Website: www.fca.org.uk
All rights reserved
Pub ref: 005724
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“The Prudential Regulation Authority (“PRA”) makes this instrument in the exercise of the following powers and related provisions in the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000”
“Second charge mortgage contracts are now recorded on a standalone basis in PSD, following the Mortgage Credit Directive (see PS 15/09 for more information).”
More like this from FCA
FCA published 10 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Financial Conduct Authority — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and reviewed before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added