Individual decision · NCFM · 10 Nov 2026 · 62/17
The National Commission of Financial Market rejects the preliminary request of Mr. [...] to annul its letter No. 04-5/4190/1 dated 09.09.2026. The NCFM found that the arguments presented did not contain sufficient factual or legal elements to justify overturning its previous findings. While acknowledging a procedural deficiency by BC „MOLDOVA-AGROINDBANK” SA in handling an initial complaint, the NCFM determined this did not constitute a systemic breach. This decision enters into force on the date of adoption and can be contested within 30 days.
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA
NATIONAL COMMISSION of FINANCIAL MARKET
10 November 2026
No. 62/17
On the Preliminary Request of Mr. [...] regarding the contestation of the letter of the National Commission of Financial Market No. 04-5/4190/1 dated 09.09.2026
On 05.10.2026, within the National Commission of Financial Market (NCFM/supervisory authority), was registered (under No. 9064) the Preliminary Request of Mr. [...] (participant/consumer), with the documents attached thereto, regarding the contestation of the NCFM letter No. 04-5/4190/1 dated 09.09.2026 concerning the completion of the administrative procedure (Contested Letter), by which it is requested, primarily, the full re-examination of the case and the performance of an effective verification of the manner in which BC „MOLDOVA-AGROINDBANK” SA (bank) managed the reported incidents (Preliminary Request).
In this case, it is to be noted that, in order to ensure a full, objective and transparent investigation, which would offer the real possibility to analyze the claim, the participant is informed that the examination of the factual and legal circumstances, relevant to the case, in preliminary order, is carried out by distinct enforcement officers within the supervisory authority. In this context, the Preliminary Request is found to be satisfied in the part where the participant requested, in the alternative, that it not be remitted for resolution to the same person who drafted the Contested Letter.
In fact, on 27.07.2026, within the NCFM, was registered (under No. 6396) the letter of the National Bank of Moldova No. 26-01109/1804/4129 dated 27.07.2026, by which was forwarded, for examination, according to competence, the petition of Mr. [...], with the documents attached thereto.
In this case, on 02.07.2026, the consumer performed, through the bank's ATM, a withdrawal operation of the amount of 400 USD, being dispensed four banknotes with the nominal value of 100 USD each.
Subsequently, during the currency exchange operation, performed at the same ATM, one banknote of the 4 dispensed was rejected, repeatedly, being registered the technical message „FAILED SERIAL NUMBER READS”.
As a result of the complaint filed by the consumer, on 02.07.2026, with subsequent completions from 06.07.2026, 09.07.2026, 16.07.2026, 18.07.2026, 27.07.2026 and 28.07.2026, the claim was resolved by presenting, on 05.08.2026, the rejected banknote to the bank and replacing it with another banknote, which was exchanged for the equivalent in MDL.
Consequently, following the investigations carried out, the analysis of the materials/evidence presented by the participants in the procedure, in light of the normative framework incident to the legal relationship, established between the parties, the respective administrative procedure was
bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, no. 77, mun. Chișinău, MD 2012, tel: (373 22) 859 401, www.cnpf.md, e-mail: office@cnpf.md
finalized by issuing the NCFM letter No. 04-5/4190/1 dated 09.09.2026, communicated to the participant in accordance with the legislation. Disagreeing with the NCFM findings, the participant filed a Preliminary Request, with the request of the aforementioned.
In law, art. 19 of the Administrative Code provides that „The preliminary request is the institution that offers a way of prejudicial resolution of administrative disputes.”, and art. 162 para. (1) and para. (3) of the same law stipulate that „(1) The preliminary procedure aims to verify the legality of individual administrative acts. [...] (3) The preliminary request may be directed towards: a) the annulment in whole or in part of an illegal or null individual administrative act; b) the issuance of an individual administrative act.”.
In accordance with art. 20 of the Administrative Code, „If through an administrative activity a legitimate right or a freedom established by law is violated, this right may be claimed through an action in administrative contentious, [...]”, and according to art. 17 „Injured right is any right or freedom established by law to which is brought harm through administrative activity.”.
In this case, art. 78 para. (1) of the Administrative Code establishes that „(1) The administrative procedure is finalized by performing an administrative operation or by issuing an individual administrative act, respectively by concluding an administrative contract.”.
Under the conditions of art. 166 of the Administrative Code, „The preliminary request may be filed only if the person claims their rights violated by the issuance or rejection of the issuance of an individual administrative act.”, and in accordance with art. 167 para. (1) and para. (3) of the same law, „(1) If it considers the preliminary request as admissible and well-founded, the issuing public authority annuls in whole or in part the contested individual administrative act or issues the requested individual administrative act. [...] (3) The issuing public authority resolves the preliminary request within 15 calendar days. The provisions of art. 60 para. (2)–(5) apply accordingly.”.
At the same time, from the systemic interpretation of art. 17, art. 20, art. 166 and art. 207 of the Administrative Code, it results that the admissibility of a preliminary request is determined by the claiming of an injured right through administrative activity.
Primarily, the participant invokes the fact that the subsequent replacement of the banknote does not remove the need to clarify the circumstances of the incident and the manner in which it was managed by the bank, considering, at the same time, that the NCFM response essentially took over the bank's explanations, without a sufficient verification of the repetitive nature of the incidents and of possible deficiencies in the organization of banking services.
Analyzing the arguments set out in the Preliminary Request, in light of the legal provisions, applicable to the case, it will be assessed whether they are of such a nature as to overturn the findings of the supervisory authority, as follows:
1. With regard to the incident of 02.07.2026 concerning the refusal of the 100 USD banknote, it should be noted that the subject of the examination is not exclusively the fact that the banknote was subsequently replaced by the bank, but, principally, the circumstances in which it was dispensed through the ATM, the manner in which the bank managed cash, as well as the measures taken to examine and resolve the consumer's complaint.
In this respect, from the explanations provided by the bank it follows that, in the investigation carried out, the ATM's electronic logs, the video recordings relating to the transactions of 02.07.2026, and the sequence of transactions carried out by the consumer were analysed.
At the same time, the bank stated that the equipment used does not ensure the recording and association of the individual serial number of each dispensed banknote with the specific cash withdrawal operation, so that the origin of the banknote subsequently presented by the consumer could not be established with technical certainty.
In this context, it is found that the absence of an individualised record of the serial numbers of banknotes dispensed through the ATM cannot, in itself, be classified as a breach of the bank's legal obligations, given that the applicable regulatory framework does not establish an express requirement regarding the association and storage of the serial number of each banknote with the specific cash dispensing operation.
Therefore, the impossibility of identifying the origin of the banknote by means of the individual serial number does not, in itself, constitute sufficient evidence of improper cash management by the bank, and this circumstance is to be assessed in relation to the other information and evidence available.
At the same time, regarding the technical message "FAILED SERIAL NUMBER READS", according to the bank's explanations, it indicates a difficulty in reading the banknote's serial number by the automated equipment, without in itself constituting a finding as to its authenticity or non-authenticity, since the rejection of the banknote by the equipment may have several technical causes. In these circumstances, the mere rejection of the banknote by the ATM does not, in itself, demonstrate that the bank dispensed an unsuitable banknote.
02.07.2026, from the materials in the administrative file, it follows that the consumer submitted, on 02.07.2026, a handwritten complaint, in which he mentioned, among other things, that the bank's representative refused to take over the banknote. Subsequently, by the supplement of 09.07.2026, the petitioner stated that he had been contacted by telephone by the bank and informed of the need to present the banknote for physical verification and for the drawing up of the handover report.
However, a distinct aspect is the fact that the banknote was not taken over by the branch's employees at the time of the first presentation, a circumstance acknowledged by the bank itself in its reply of 17.07.2026 and noted in the contested Letter.
In this connection, it should be found that the subsequent presentation of the banknote by the consumer, on 05.08.2026, and its replacement by the bank do not remove the procedural deficiency that occurred at the time of the first contact. On the contrary, taking over the banknote from the first presentation would have allowed the necessary verifications to be initiated without delay and would have avoided additional steps on the part of the consumer.
At the same time, although the bank claims that, subsequently, the consumer refused to present the banknote for examination, this circumstance is to be assessed in the light of the fact that the banknote had already been presented at the branch on 02.07.2026, without being taken over by its employees. In these conditions, the delay in taking over the banknote for examination cannot be placed exclusively on the consumer.
At the same time, it should be noted that, according to Art. 82 para. (6) of Law No. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market (Law No. 192/1998), the time limit for resolving complaints is 15 working days from the date of its registration by the entity concerned, that time limit being extendable only if this is expressly provided by law.
From the materials examined, it follows that the bank communicated to the consumer, on 17.07.2026, the results of the verifications carried out up to that point and the information concerning the continuation of the examination of the situation.
At the same time, the subsequent correspondence was conducted in the context of the need to present the banknote for examination, the latter being effectively taken over by the bank on 05.08.2026.
Therefore, in assessing compliance with the obligations relating to the resolution of the complaint, it is necessary to distinguish compliance with the time limit for communicating a reply from the effective and complete nature of the examination of the consumer's claims, since, in the present case, although the bank communicated a reply within the legal time limit, the taking over of the banknote for examination was not ensured at the time of the first presentation, an aspect which made additional steps on the part of the consumer necessary.
Consequently, the finding regarding the existence of a deficiency in the application of the bank's internal procedures at the time of the initial receipt of the complaint is to be maintained, without this circumstance being capable, in the absence of other elements, of being associated with a systemic breach of the obligations regarding cash management.
In this context, it is considered that the recommendation made by the CNPF in the contested Letter regarding the examination of the appropriateness of consolidating the manner of applying internal procedures relating to non-standard situations occurring at ATMs, so that the actions necessary for examining incidents are undertaken consistently from the consumer's first contact, without the need for repeated steps, corresponds to the circumstances found.
Moreover, such an approach seeks to prevent the recurrence of similar situations and to ensure a prompt and appropriate examination of complaints, without anticipating the existence of infringements for which sufficient evidence has not been identified.
Therefore, the participant's claim that the CNPF ignored the deficiency acknowledged by the bank does not correspond to the content of the contested Letter, in which this circumstance was noted and constituted the basis for the recommendation addressed to the bank.
art. 8 letter f1 ) of Law no. 192/1998, the CNPF is empowered to carry out control activities in relation to banks, within the limits of the competences assigned and in accordance with the procedure established by its own normative acts.
At the same time, according to art. 16 of the Administrative Code, the discretionary right of the public authority represents its possibility to choose between several possible solutions, corresponding to the purpose of the law, when applying a legal provision.
In this sense, art. 22 para. (1) of the same Code establishes that public authorities investigate the factual situation ex officio, determining the type and volume of investigations, without being bound by the participants' submissions or their requests for evidence.
Correlatively, according to point 3 of the Regulation on the administrative control procedure (CNPF Decision no. 60/10/2023), "3. In the case of petitions requesting the authority's intervention by carrying out a control, the CNPF initially carries out the administrative procedure by ex officio investigation of the factual situation, based on the circumstances reflected in the petition.".
Therefore, the CNPF's legal competence to carry out controls does not establish an obligation for the supervisory authority to initiate such a procedure in every case in which it is notified of a possible infringement of consumer rights. The exercise of this competence presupposes an assessment of the concrete circumstances, of the available information and of the existence of indications justifying the necessity and proportionality of the supervisory intervention.
Subsequently, according to point 3 of CNPF Decision no. 60/10/2023, until the elaboration and approval of the Methodology for selecting entities subject to control, their establishment is carried out taking into account several indicators, including the size of the entity, the volume and nature of the activities carried out, the existence of suspicious developments, the number of petitions in relation to the entity, the frequency of previous controls, the types of infringements found and the number of sanctions previously applied.
Thus, it is found that the number of petitions addressed to the supervisory authority constitutes one of the indicators taken into account when determining the opportunity of carrying out controls, but does not represent, individually, a sufficient basis for initiating them.
In this sense, the information regarding the reported incidents is to be assessed in light of the nature and gravity of the facts, their repetitive character, any similarities between the signaled situations and the existence of indications regarding non-compliance with the applicable normative framework.
From the perspective of those invoked by the participant, it is found that the mentioned incidents concern different factual situations, relating to distinct operations, carried out in the relationship with the bank, whose examination presupposes reporting each of them to the concrete circumstances and the applicable legal obligations.
Therefore, the mere enumeration of situations in which the participant considers that his rights have been affected, without these being supported by sufficient elements indicating the existence of similar infringements or of a non-compliant practice, does not, in itself, lead to the conclusion of the existence of systemic deficiencies in the bank's activity.
At the same time, the supervisory authority does not deny the relevance of information regarding previous incidents, nor the possibility that these, assessed cumulatively with other information held by the CNPF, may indicate the existence of risks requiring supervisory intervention.
Precisely from this perspective, in the contested Letter, it was mentioned that the information presented by the participant, including that referring to previous incidents and their invoked repetitive character, will be taken into account within the supervisory activities carried out by the CNPF. This approach does not represent an avoidance of examining the aspects signaled, but reflects the delimitation between the resolution of an individual petition and the process of risk assessment and selection of entities to be subjected to control activities.
At the same time, contrary to what the participant claims, the examination of a petition does not presuppose the unconditional adoption of the explanations of the entity concerned.
In accordance with art. 22 of the Administrative Code, the public authority has the obligation to investigate the factual situation ex officio, and according to art. 92 of the same Code, evidence is assessed as a whole, objectively and in all respects.
In this context, it should be noted that the object of the administrative procedure was the examination of the aspects complained of from the perspective of the legal competences of the supervisory authority in the field of protecting the rights of consumers of financial services, based on the materials and information available.
In the present case, the bank's explanations were assessed by reference to the circumstances directly complained of by the consumer, to the circumstances of the operations carried out, to the correspondence conducted with the participant and to the procedural deficiency acknowledged by the bank. The fact that certain circumstances could not be established with certainty does not equate to the uncritical acceptance of the bank's position, but reflects the evidentiary limits of the situation examined.
Furthermore, the fact that the participant does not have direct access to the bank's technical information and internal documents does not remove the CNPF's obligation to use its legal powers to obtain the relevant information, an obligation which, in this case, was fulfilled, within the administrative procedure, by requesting the submission, through CNPF letter no. 05-5/3389 of 07.08.2026, of the necessary explanations and documents from the entity concerned.
The CNPF's powers in the field of protecting the rights of consumers of financial services concern the manner in which supervised entities, including banks, fulfil their obligations towards consumers when providing financial services. In this context, the CNPF may examine aspects relating to the bank's conduct towards the consumer and compliance with the legal and contractual obligations related to the service provided, without this entailing the substitution of the competent authority in verifying the technical conformity of banking equipment. Moreover, under the conditions of Art. 42¹ of Law no. 62/2008 on foreign exchange regulation, verification of compliance with the special requirements regarding currency exchange machines falls within the competence of the National Bank of Moldova, under the conditions of Art. 62 of the same law.
4. With reference to the request to verify the activity of the responsible person within the CNPF, it should be noted that the participant's dissatisfaction with the adopted solution and disagreement with the authority's assessments do not, in themselves, constitute sufficient grounds to conclude that the official duties were improperly exercised or that there are circumstances that would cast doubt on the impartiality of the executor.
In this regard, it should be reiterated that the Preliminary Request was assigned for examination to an executor distinct from the person who handled the administrative procedure, concluded by the contested Letter, thus ensuring that the arguments put forward by the participant were examined by another person within the supervisory authority.
Following the repeated examination of the factual circumstances that formed the basis for issuing the contested Letter, it should be noted that no factual grounds are found to justify ordering liability measures against the person responsible for the initial examination of the petition.
Regarding the preliminary procedure, it should be noted that, according to CNPF President's Order no. 1123 of 15.10.2026 on the extension of the term of the preliminary procedure, initiated by the Preliminary Request submitted by Mr. [...], the preliminary procedure was extended until 04.11.2026.
Subsequently, by CNPF President's Order no. 1215 of 02.11.2026 on the suspension of the preliminary procedure, initiated by the Preliminary Request of Mr. [...] (Order no. 1215/2026), the preliminary procedure was suspended for a period of 7 days, in this case, until 09.11.2026 inclusive.
In the alternative, by letter no. 06-5/5553 of 02.11.2026, the CNPF notified the participant of Order no. 1215/2026, and informed him about the exercise of the right to be heard, in accordance with Art. 94 para. (2) of the Administrative Code, including the fact that the hearing was to be conducted in writing, by submitting an opinion as a hearing, until 09.11.2026 inclusive.
In this context, on 03.11.2026, the opinion as a hearing, with the documents annexed thereto, submitted by the consumer, was registered with the CNPF (under no. 10200).
Consequently, as a result of examining the arguments invoked in the Preliminary Request, the CNPF finds that they do not contain elements of fact or law that would justify the annulment of CNPF letter no. 04-5/4190/1 of 09.09.2026.
For the reasons set out above, pursuant to Art. 18 para. (3), Art. 20 para. (1), para. (6) and para. (7) and Art. 22 para. (3) of Law no. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market, Law no. 105/2003 on consumer protection, Art. 17, Art. 19, Art. 164 para. (1) and para. (2) lit. b), Art. 167 para. (3), Art. 169 para. (2) and para. (3) of the Administrative Code, pt. 16 and pt. 19 of the Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision no. 57/11/2022),
1. The Preliminary Request of Mr. [...] regarding the contestation of CNPF letter no. 04-5/4190/1 of 09.09.2026 (registered with the CNPF under no. 9064 on 05.10.2026) is rejected.
2. This Decision may be contested by an administrative contentious action, filed with the Chișinău District Court, Râșcani office (MD-2068, mun. Chișinău, str. Kiev 3), within 30 days from the date of its communication.
3. This Decision enters into force on the date of adoption, is communicated to the recipients in accordance with the legislation and is published on the official website of the CNPF (www.cnpf.md).
Dumitru BUDIANSCHI,
PRESIDENT
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision no. 57/11/2022)”
More like this from NCFM
NCFM published 25 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Commission for Financial Markets Moldova — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added