Enforcement · NCFM · 20 Oct 2026 · 55/14
The National Commission of Financial Market's Decision identifies multiple instances of non-compliance and abusive clauses in a credit agreement between NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL and a consumer. The identified issues include the incorrect definition of "total amount payable", the omission of a monthly credit administration fee (78.64 EUR) from pre-contractual information, and the failure to prominently display the annual effective interest rate (52.57 percent) and total amount payable (17,439.55 EUR). Additionally, the agreement imposes a 5-working-day notice for early repayment, restricting the consumer's right, and allows for early credit maturity based on claims from other creditors, which is prohibited by Law no. 202/2013.
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA
NATIONAL COMMISSION of FINANCIAL MARKET
20 October 2026
No. 55/14
Regarding the petition of Mr. [...], submitted by his representative, Mr. [...], registered with the National Commission of Financial Market under No. 7041 on 13.08.2026, in relation to NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL
On 13.08.2026, within the National Commission of Financial Market (NCFM), the petition of Mr. [...] (debtor/consumer/borrower) was registered (under No. 7041), with the documents attached thereto, submitted by his representative, Mr. [...], requesting the NCFM's intervention with regard to the legal relationship mentioned infra. To be specified on the subject
1. The legal relationship between NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL (creditor/professional/lender) and the debtor was established based on the Credit Agreement No. [...] dated ..., concluded for a term of 60 months, having as its object the granting of a non-bank credit in the amount of 7 149,00 EUR, the total amount payable by the consumer being 17 439,55 EUR.
2. The essential terms of the Agreement include:
2.1.the total cost of the credit, which comprises:
2.1.1. the interest rate: fixed, 21,00 percent per annum;
2.1.2. the credit granting commission: 714,90 EUR (10,00 percent of the credit amount, minimum 250 EUR);
2.1.3. the monthly credit administration fee: 78,64 EUR;
2.2.the annual percentage rate: 52,57 percent per annum;
2.3.the method of payment: annuity, the credit to be repaid in installments, according to the Payment Schedule: in 60 installments;
2.4. Annex No. 1, namely:
2.4.1. the one-time late payment penalty: 10 EUR (will be calculated on the first day of delay of each monthly installment not paid on time);
2.4.2. the commission for termination of the Agreement: 5 percent of the credit balance;
2.4.3. the commission for early repayment: according to pt. 5.6. of the "General Provisions";
2.4.4. the commission for processing documents related to traffic fines, concerning the pledged asset: 2,50 EUR;
2.4.5. the commission for notifying the client, regarding late payment or termination of the Agreement: 2,50 EUR;
bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, no. 77, mun. Chișinău, MD 2012, tel: (373 22) 859 401, www.cnpf.md, e-mail: office@cnpf.md
2.4.6. the commission for re-conclusion of the Agreement: 7,5 percent of the credit balance, the first re-conclusion – free of charge;
2.4.7. the commission for parking the car, which is the object of the pledged asset: 40 EUR;
2.4.8. the fee for changing the period: 1 percent of the credit balance, minimum 50 EUR, the first time free of charge.
3. Taking into account the imperative of providing a complete response, which involves time for a thorough examination of the matters addressed in the petition, by the NCFM President's Order No. 825 dated 11.09.2026 regarding the extension of the general term of the administrative procedure, initiated by the petition of Mr. [...], submitted by his representative, Mr. [...], the general term of the administrative procedure was extended until 27.09.2026.
4. Under the conditions of the assignment of the Agreement to NBFI "SEBO CREDIT" SRL (assignee), considering that the parties to the contractual relationships in question are NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL and NBFI "SEBO CREDIT" SRL, according to the NCFM President's Order No. 858 dated 16.09.2026 regarding the ex officio joinder of NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL and NBFI "SEBO CREDIT" SRL in the administrative procedure, initiated by the petition of Mr. [...], submitted by his representative, Mr. [...], and the suspension of the administrative procedure, the creditor and the assignee were ex officio joined in the administrative procedure, being requested, by NCFM letter No. 05-5/4418 dated 17.09.2026, the presentation of the necessary explanations, a copy of the Credit File, a copy of the Assignment Agreement, as well as a copy of other documents related thereto.
At the same time, the administrative procedure was suspended until 30.09.2026 inclusive.
5. Consequently, on 29.09.2026 and subsequently, on 30.09.2026, the creditor and the assignee presented the requested documents (registered with the NCFM under No. 8840 and, respectively, 8898).
6. In this context, the assignee communicated that, pursuant to art. 21 para. (2) of Law No. 202/2013 on consumer credit agreements (Law No. 202/2013) and art. 1773 para. (1) of the Civil Code, NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL assigned the Agreement to NBFI "SEBO CREDIT" SRL, based on Assignment Agreement No. 09/12/2025 dated 09.12.2025, which, on 01.08.2026, was terminated by the Termination and Settlement Agreement No. 01/08/2026 dated 01.08.2026, concluded between the same parties. As a result of the termination, the parties reverted to the situation as of 09.12.2025, the Agreement being returned to the creditor's portfolio.
7. Concurrently, in order to ensure the exercise of NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL's right to be heard in the administrative procedure, by the NCFM President's Order No. 1082 dated 09.10.2026 regarding the suspension of the administrative procedure, initiated by the petition of Mr. [...], submitted by his representative, Mr. [...], the administrative procedure was suspended. Thus, by NCFM letter No. 05-5/5082 dated 12.10.2026, NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL was informed about the possibility of presenting, by way of hearing, explanations and a copy of additional documents related to the circumstances invoked in the petition.
8. Consequently, on 20.10.2026, NBFI "MOGO LOANS" SRL presented the requested documents (registered with the NCFM under No. 9615).
9. In accordance with Art. 37 para. (2) of Law No. 105/2003 on consumer protection (Law No. 105/2003), "(2) The National Commission of the Financial Market supervises compliance by the subjects provided for in Art. 4 para. (21) of Law No. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market with the provisions of Arts. 1069–1072, 1075–1079 and 1081 of the Civil Code in the part concerning contracts concluded with consumers and the finding of abusive clauses in contracts, at the consumer's request or ex officio, under the conditions of the law.".
10. According to Art. 1 of Law No. 105/2003, "consumer" is "any natural person who intends to order or procure, or who orders, procures or uses products, services for needs unrelated to entrepreneurial or professional activity;".
A similar definition is also contained in Art. 3 of Law No. 202/2013 on credit contracts for consumers (Law No. 202/2013).
11. According to Art. 3 para. (1) and para. (2) of the Civil Code, "(1) Any natural person who, within a civil legal relationship, acts predominantly for purposes unrelated to entrepreneurial or professional activity has the status of consumer. The natural person does not have the status of consumer if the other party to the civil legal relationship does not have the status of professional. (2) Any natural or legal person under public or private law who, within a civil legal relationship, acts for purposes related to entrepreneurial or professional activity has the status of professional, even if the person does not aim to obtain a profit from this activity.".
12. In accordance with Art. 16 letter a) and letter b) of Law No. 105/2003, "The consumer, when concluding contracts, has the following rights: a) to make free decisions when purchasing the product and the service, without being imposed in contracts abusive clauses or clauses that may favor the use of unfair commercial practices, of a nature to influence his option; b) to benefit from a clear and precise drafting of the contractual clauses, including those regarding the main characteristics and warranty conditions, from the exact indication of the price or tariff, as well as from the precise establishment of the credit conditions and interest rates;".
13. Moreover, the Civil Code establishes, in Art. 10 para. (1), that "(1) Natural and legal persons participating in civil legal relationships must exercise their rights and perform their obligations in good faith, in accordance with the law, the contract, public order and good morals. Good faith is presumed until proven otherwise.".
14. Additionally, according to Art. 11 para. (1) of the Civil Code, "(1) Good faith is a standard of conduct of a party, characterized by correctness, honesty, openness and taking into account the interests of the other party to the legal relationship.".
15. In accordance with the provisions of Art. 1072 of the Civil Code, "(1) In a contract between a professional and a consumer, a clause that has not been individually negotiated is considered abusive if it is proposed by the professional and considerably disadvantages, contrary to good faith, the consumer. (2) Articles 1077-1079 contain the list of clauses considered abusive in the contract between a professional and a consumer without the need for their assessment in accordance with para. (1) of this article and Art. 1075. (3) The lists provided for by the articles referred to in para. (2) shall not be interpreted as exhaustive lists.”.
16. In addition, pursuant to art. 1069 para. (1) of the Civil Code, “(1) A clause proposed by one of the parties is not individually negotiated if the other party was unable to influence its content, in particular because it was drafted in advance, regardless of whether it is part of standard clauses or not.”.
17. In accordance with art. 1071 of the Civil Code, “(1) The person presenting clauses that have not been individually negotiated is obliged to ensure that they are drafted and communicated in a clear and intelligible language, as well as to be legible. This requirement applies to the entire text, including footnotes, references to other texts or specifications of any nature. (2) In a contract between a professional and a consumer, a clause proposed by the professional in breach of the transparency obligation imposed by the provisions of para. (1) may be considered abusive on this sole ground.”.
18. Furthermore, art. 1075 para. (1) letter (a) of the Civil Code establishes that, “(1) When assessing the abusive nature of a contractual clause within the meaning of art. 1072 para. (1), art. 1073 and 1074, the following shall be taken into account: a) compliance with the transparency obligation provided for in art. 1071;”.
19. The provisions of art. 1075 para. (2) of the Civil Code are also relevant, according to which, “(2) The assessment of the abusive nature of clauses cannot relate to the subject matter of the contract, nor to the adequacy of the price or remuneration, on the one hand, in relation to the goods, works or services provided in exchange therefor, on the other hand, where the transparency obligation provided for in art. 1071 has been complied with. The subject matter of the contract and the relationship between price and quality may be taken into account when assessing the abusive nature of the other contractual clauses.”.
20. Under the conditions of art. 329 para. (1) of the Civil Code, “(1) In contracts with consumers, abusive clauses are null and void, as well as clauses by which derogations are made from legal provisions from which derogation is prohibited to the detriment of the consumer (protective nullity).”.
21. Analysing the contractual clauses, the information in the documents presented by the creditor and the debtor, in the light of the requirements of Law no. 105/2003, Law no. 202/2013 and the Civil Code, in particular, in relation to the normative framework set out above, CNPF notes the following:
21.1. Ab initio, the establishment of the professional capacity held by NCP “MOGO LOANS” SRL in relation to the consumer is required.
In accordance with the information in the State Register of Legal Entities, NCP “MOGO LOANS” SRL has, as its main activity, inter alia, the activity of granting non-bank loans, being registered in the Register of Authorised Non-Bank Lending Organisations.
Thus, it is concluded that NCP “MOGO LOANS” SRL carries out the activity of granting non-bank loans, on a professional basis, on the basis of the clauses and conditions offered by it, the contractual clauses being drafted in advance for a multitude of contracts.
21.2.1. In this context, the erroneous presentation of the essential conditions of the Contract is attested by the use of terms distinct from the notions provided for in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013. In this way, the creditor allows the information to be presented in a distorted manner to the consumer, which denotes the failure to fulfil the obligation to present the information in the Contract in a clear and intelligible manner.
In this regard, it should be noted that, according to the definition provided for in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, the total amount payable by the consumer is “the sum of the total value of the credit and the total cost of the credit for the consumer.”.
In the present case, it is found that the creditor incorrectly defined the total amount payable by the consumer as “total costs related to the credit”, which misleads the consumer, as, according to the notion defined in art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, the total value of the credit – the total amounts made available under a credit agreement, and the total cost of the credit are all costs, including interest, commissions, fees and any other type of costs that the consumer must bear in connection with the credit agreement and which are known to the creditor, with the exception of notarial fees.
Therefore, by referring the cited legal norms to the relevant facts, a breach by the creditor of the legal requirements for presenting, in a clear and precise manner, the information relating to the essential conditions of the Contract is attested, which caused the consumer to be erroneously informed about the total amount payable and the total cost of the credit applicable under the Contract.
21.2.2. In addition, it should be mentioned that, in the present case, a credit agreement was concluded between NCP “MOGO LOANS” SRL and the debtor. According to the definition contained in art. 1763 para. (1) of the Civil Code, this is a credit agreement, by which “(1) [...] a bank or a non-bank lending organisation (creditor) undertakes to make available to another person (debtor) a sum of money as a loan, on condition that it is repaid, together with the payment of interest and other related payments, or assumes any other undertaking to acquire a claim or to make a payment, to extend the repayment term of the debt or to issue any guarantees.”.
In this context, the use in the Contract of the words “loan”, “lender” and “borrower”, which are terms specific to a loan agreement, is inappropriate and may mislead the consumer in view of the legal effects it produces, as the regulations on loans establish more favourable conditions for the debtor, with the potential to lead him to accept the conclusion of such a contract.
At point 4 of Part I. "Special Provisions" of the Contract, "Monthly credit administration fee (78.64 €)" is established.
In this context, pursuant to Art. 5 para. (2) letter c) of Law no. 202/2013, "(2) Pre-contractual information is provided: [...] c) by means of the form presented in Annex no. 1;" and, accordingly to Art. 5 para. (4) of the same law, "(4) Any other additional information the creditor provides to the consumer in a separate document, which may be attached to the form presented in Annex no. 1.".
In the present case, referring the legal provisions to the relevant factual circumstances, it is found that, although the Payment Schedule, attached to the Pre-contractual Information, includes information regarding the monthly payment of the credit administration fee, nevertheless the cost in question is not found in the "Pre-contractual Information" form presented to the debtor.
The respective information was not included in the "Credit costs" box, depriving the debtor of the possibility of transparently analyzing the pre-contractual information, given the weight of this cost in the "Credit amount".
Pursuant to Art. 10 para. (3) letter a) and letter g) of Law no. 202/2013, "(3) The credit contract clearly and concisely specifies: a) the type of credit; [...] g) the annual effective interest rate and the total amount payable by the consumer, indicated in a prominent manner (in bold type) and calculated at the time of concluding the credit contract; all assumptions used for the calculation of this rate are mentioned;". In the present case, the Contract does not specify the type of credit granted, this being indicated only in the "Pre-contractual Information" form.
Also, in Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract, the annual effective interest rate (52.57 percent) and the total amount payable by the consumer (stated as "Total costs related to the credit" – 17 439,55 EUR) are not indicated in a prominent manner (in bold type), as required by Art. 10 para. (3) letter g) of Law no. 202/2013.
Therefore, referring the cited legal provisions to the relevant factual circumstances, a breach by the creditor of the requirements provided for in Art. 10 para. (3) letter a) and letter g) of Law no. 202/2013 is found.
Pursuant to point 5.5. of the Contract, "The Borrower is entitled, at any time, by notifying O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL thereof in writing 5 (five) working days in advance, to pay the Contractual Payments in advance in full or in part. [...]".
In accordance with Art. 20 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, the consumer has the right, at any time, to discharge, in full or in part, the obligations arising from a credit contract, benefiting, in this case, from the corresponding reduction of the total cost of the credit. From the content of the norm it results that the right to early repayment may be exercised, at any time, during the contractual relationship, the law not conditioning its exercise on compliance with a minimum notice period in favor of the creditor.
Moreover, point 5.5. of the Contract is not limited to establishing a notification obligation, but requires that the notification be made 5 working days before repayment. Consequently, the consumer who requests the early settlement of obligations does not benefit from the effects of early repayment at the chosen moment, but only after the expiry of the term established contractually.
Therefore, the 5 working day term restricts the exercise of the right recognized to the consumer by Art. 20 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, since it transforms the right of repayment "at any time" into a right exercisable only after going through a minimum waiting period, established in favor of the creditor, which also influences the amount of the reduction of the total cost of the credit.
According to point 11.2. lit. h) of the Contract, it constitutes a case of non-performance, which entitles the creditor to declare the termination of the Contract, the situation in which "third parties file claims against the Borrower, the total amount of which exceeds 20% (twenty percent) of the Credit Balance".
At the same time, point 9.6. of the Contract provides that, in the event of one of the situations established in point 11.2. of the Contract, the creditor is entitled to terminate the Contract by a written declaration of termination, granting a term of 15 days for the payment of the contractual payments.
According to the contractual definitions, "Contractual Payments" represent the payments owed by the borrower according to the Contract, including credit payments, penalties and other payments. At the same time, "Credit Payments" include, as the case may be, the monthly credit installments, the "balloon" payment or the single payment, depending on the applicable repayment method.
Additionally, point 11.3. of the Contract establishes that "The termination of the Contract suspends the use of the Credit Balance by the Borrower, who is obliged to pay to O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL within the term indicated in point 9.6 the Contractual Payments, in the amount indicated by the termination declaration".
The examination as a whole of the clauses provided in point 9.6., point 11.2. lit. h) and point 11.3. of the Contract reveals that, although the Contract uses the notion of "termination", the effect of the contractual mechanism consists in the early termination of the contractual relationship and in obliging the consumer, within a term of 15 days, to pay the contractual payments in the amount established in the termination declaration, these including also the credit payments.
Under these conditions, to the extent that the termination declaration includes the credit balance, which, according to the Payment Schedule, was to become due subsequently, and during the 15 days, the debtor is bound to pay not only the payments due at the moment of declaring the alleged termination, it is attested that the contractual mechanism determines the loss of the benefit of the term and produces, from a functional perspective, the effect of declaring the early maturity of the credit.
According to Art. 15 para. (4) lit. c) of Law no. 202/2013, it is prohibited to introduce in credit contracts clauses by which the creditor may declare the credit due early in the event that the consumer has not fulfilled his obligations according to other credit contracts, concluded with other creditors.
Moreover, point 11.2. lit. h) of the Contract has a general wording, referring to claims filed by "third parties", without excluding claims resulting from other credit contracts, concluded by the consumer with other creditors. Thus, the clause allows the application of the termination mechanism, provided in point 9.6. and point 11.3. of the Contract, including in the situation in which the respective claims arise from the non-performance of obligations related to other credit relationships.
The circumstance that the Contract qualifies the respective mechanism as "termination" is not decisive to the extent that its concrete effect consists in obliging the consumer to pay early the credit balance, under conditions specific to the declaration of early maturity. The legal qualification is to be carried out by reference to the effect produced by the contractual clauses, but not exclusively to the terminology used by the professional.
Consequently, the clause in point 11.2. lit. h), corroborated with the clauses in point 9.6. and with point 11.3. of the Contract, allowing the obliging of the consumer to early repay the credit balance, as a result of the non-performance of obligations resulting from other credit contracts, concluded with other creditors, contradicts the prohibition provided in Art. 15 para. (4) lit. c) of Law no. 202/2013.
21.7.1. Corresponding to point 1 of Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract, the credit amount constitutes 7 149,00 EUR, and, according to point 3 of the same part, the total credit amount is 7 863,90 EUR.
At the same time, point 2 of Part I "Special Provisions" establishes "Credit granting commission (10.00% of the Credit Amount, min 250 EUR) – 714.90 €".
According to Art. 1071(1) of the Civil Code, the person who presents clauses that have not been individually negotiated is obliged to ensure that they are drafted and communicated in clear and intelligible language, and in accordance with paragraph (2) of the same article, in a contract concluded between a professional and a consumer, the clause proposed by the professional, in breach of the transparency obligation, may be considered abusive on this sole ground. In this regard, the transparency obligation is not limited to the formally intelligible drafting of a clause or to the numerical indication of the amount of a payment obligation. In the case of a clause that imposes a monetary obligation on the consumer, the contract must allow the consumer to understand, by examining the clause itself and by correlating it with the other contractual provisions, the concrete mechanism for performing the obligation, including the moment at which it becomes due and the conditions under which the creditor is entitled to request payment.
In this respect, point 4.3. of Part II "General Provisions" of the Contract provides that "The Borrower agrees to pay O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL the loan origination commission, according to the Payment Schedule.".
Therefore, the contractual clause itself conditions the performance of the obligation to pay the commission on the content of the Payment Schedule, this being the contractual document in which the consumer must be able to identify the moment and manner of performance of that obligation.
However, from the examination of the Payment Schedule, it is found that it does not contain the origination commission, does not individualize a payment corresponding to the amount of 714.90 EUR and does not indicate the date or deadline by which this commission is to be paid.
Consequently, although the Contract indicates the existence and amount of the origination commission, it does not allow the consumer to determine the moment at which the payment obligation becomes due and, implicitly, the manner of performance of that obligation. The consumer cannot establish, on the basis of the contractual clauses, whether that amount must be paid on the date of conclusion of the Contract, at the time of disbursement of the loan, together with one of the installments provided in the Payment Schedule or at another time.
Moreover, the express reference in point 4.3. of Part II "General Provisions" of the Contract to the Payment Schedule legitimately creates the expectation that the payment deadline for the commission can be identified within it. The omission of the commission from the Payment Schedule thus leads to a lack of coherence between the contractual clauses and prevents the consumer from determining, unequivocally, the mechanism for performing the payment obligation.
In the same context, it should be noted that the administrative file materials contain Payment Order no. [...] dated [...], according to which the consumer was disbursed the equivalent amount of 143 595.53 MDL, which attests to the withholding of that commission at the time of disbursement, a fact that does not result from the Contract.
Therefore, point 4.3. of Part II "General Provisions", read in conjunction with point 2 of Part I "Special Provisions" of the Contract and with the Payment Schedule, does not meet the transparency requirement provided for in Art. 1071(1) of the Civil Code, since the consumer is not placed in a position to determine, clearly and predictably, the moment at which the obligation to pay the origination commission becomes due.
21.7.2. Annex no. 1 to the Contract contains a clause according to which the creditor may collect a "Commission for re-conclusion of the Contract – 7.5% of the Loan balance, first re-conclusion – free".
In accordance with Art. 1765 of the Civil Code, in addition to interest, the parties may agree on a commission for services provided in connection with the use of the credit. Therefore, the establishment of a commission presupposes the existence of an identifiable service in connection with the credit relationship, as well as the possibility for the consumer to determine its nature, the conditions under which the cost becomes owed and the extent of the payment obligation.
Although the clause establishes the amount of the commission of 7.5 percent of the loan balance, the Contract nevertheless does not define the notion of "re-conclusion of the Contract". In particular, from the contractual clauses, it does not result what circumstances may lead to the "re-conclusion of the Contract", the conditions that justify it and the situations in which it may occur, the relationship of this operation with the existing Contract, nor the moment at which the obligation to pay that commission falls on the consumer. Under the stated conditions, it is noted that the clause referred to does not meet the transparency requirement provided for in Art. 1071(1) of the Civil Code, and, under the conditions of paragraph (2) of the same article, may be considered abusive on this sole ground.
21.7.3. According to Annex no. 1 to the Contract, the creditor is entitled to charge a "Commission for termination of the contract – 5% of the Loan balance, for the Contract that was terminated at the initiative of O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL [...]" and a "Commission for notifying the client regarding late payment or termination of the Contract – 2.50 EUR".
In accordance with Art. 1765 of the Civil Code, in addition to interest, the parties may agree on a commission for services provided in connection with the use of the credit. Therefore, the charging of a commission presupposes the existence of an identifiable service, and the consumer must be able to determine, from the content of the contract, the nature of the remunerated operation and the conditions under which it gives rise to the payment obligation.
At the same time, according to Art. 1071(1) of the Civil Code, clauses that have not been individually negotiated must be drafted in clear and intelligible language. In the case of clauses that establish costs to be borne by the consumer, this requirement is not limited to indicating the name and amount of the payment, but presupposes the possibility of identifying, by examining the Contract as a whole, the transaction that generates the cost, the moment of its charging, the limits within which it may be charged, as well as its relationship with the other contractual costs.
In this respect, the Contract already distinctly establishes a "Credit administration fee", defined as the fee that must be paid "for the costs of administering the credit, intended also for advertising expenses or costs borne by the partners/distributors of O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" S.R.L.". From the wording of this definition it follows that the respective payment has a general scope, intended to cover the costs related to the administration of the credit, with certain categories of expenses borne by the creditor for this purpose being indicated by way of example.
The existence of this fee is relevant for the analysis of the transparency of the additional commissions not because it would demonstrate, by itself, that the notifications or the termination are already remunerated through the administration fee, but because it would require identifying the relationship between this general fee and the additional costs, provided for the situation of non-performance; however, the Contract does not specify, sufficiently clearly, which are the concrete activities or operations included in the administration fee and, correspondingly, which are the distinct activities for which the notification commission is charged, additionally.
Therefore, the consumer cannot determine from the contract whether the notification regarding the payment delay constitutes a distinct operation, excluded from the scope of the administration fee and remunerated separately, or represents one of the activities related to the administration of the credit relationship.
The transparency problem is amplified by the fact that the clause concerning the commission of 2,50 EUR does not establish whether this cost is charged for each notification sent, whether several notifications concerning the same delay can generate successive commissions, whether the notification of the delay and of the termination constitute distinct generating facts and whether there is a limit on the number of commissions that can be charged in connection with the same situation of non-performance.
Thus, although the individual amount of the commission is indicated, the extent of the payment obligation is not determinable, with sufficient clarity, at the time of conclusion of the Contract. The consumer can know that a notification is charged 2,50 EUR, but cannot anticipate, on the basis of the clause, how many such costs can be generated by the same contractual situation and under what conditions.
This lack of delimitation is directly relevant in light of art. 1071 of the Civil Code, since the transparency obligation concerns not only the mathematical expression of the amount, but also the contractual mechanism through which the payment obligation arises.
As regards the clause "Commission for the termination of the contract – 5% of the Credit balance [...]", it should be noted that it does not identify a service provided to the consumer in exchange for this payment. Termination represents, according to art. 921 para. (1) of the Civil Code, a right of the entitled party, exercised by declaration notified to the other party. Under these conditions, the mere carrying out of the termination does not explain, by itself, the existence of a service provided to the consumer, within the meaning of art. 1765 of the Civil Code.
If it is argued that this commission remunerates the administrative operations carried out on the occasion of the termination, the contract does not indicate the nature of these operations and does not allow the consumer to distinguish their cost from the other costs of administering the credit. If, on the contrary, the commission represents a financial consequence of the consumer's non-performance of obligations, then its legal nature must be examined and, as the case may be, its compatibility with the rules concerning clauses that establish disproportionate penalties for non-performance.
Likewise, the method of calculating the commission – 5 percent of the credit balance – does not, by itself, allow the identification of the remunerated service. The amount of the commission varies depending on the credit balance, but not depending on the nature, volume or frequency of the operations carried out by the creditor on the occasion of the termination. This circumstance is not invoked as a simple criticism of the amount of the remuneration, but as a relevant element for verifying whether the consumer can understand what contractual service constitutes the counter-performance for the amount owed.
Therefore, the analysis of the clauses must not be based on the premise that the notification or termination activities are necessarily included in the "administration of the credit". Such a conclusion does not result, sufficiently, from the contractual wording. The relevance of the administration fee consists in the fact that it creates the need for a clear contractual delimitation between the general administration costs and the additional costs charged on the occasion of non-performance.
In the absence of this delimitation, the consumer cannot determine, with sufficient certainty, the nature of the remunerated service, the conditions under which the payment obligation arises and the limits within which the costs can be cumulated.
Consequently, the clauses concerning the commission for notification of the consumer and the commission for termination of the Contract do not allow a sufficiently clear determination of the nature and limits of the costs established, of the services to which they correspond and of their relationship with the other contractual costs. To this extent, the respective clauses do not meet the transparency requirement provided for in art. 1071 para. (1) of the Civil Code, and under the conditions of para. (2) of the same article, they may be considered abusive.
21.7.4. According to point 8.2. of the Contract, "After O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL has received and analyzed the request for extension of the term, O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL decides at its own discretion whether or not to accept the modification of the loan term and regarding the Extension Fee, notifying the Borrower in this regard. The extension fee will be applied and charged to the Borrower only if the maturity date is changed by more than 30 (thirty) days.".
Point 8.5. of the Contract provides that "The extension of the loan term applies and enters into force only after O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL has collected the Extension Fee and the Borrower has signed the new Payment Schedule".
At the same time, from the examination of the Contract, it is found however that it does not establish the amount of the extension fee, its calculation formula, nor the objective and verifiable criteria on the basis of which the amount is to be determined.
In accordance with art. 1071 para. (1) of the Civil Code, clauses that have not been individually negotiated must be drafted in clear and intelligible language. In the case of a clause that imposes a cost on the consumer, compliance with this obligation entails not only indicating the existence of the cost, but also the consumer's possibility to determine, on the basis of the contract, the calculation mechanism and the extent of the financial obligation that may arise for them.
Moreover, in this case, the consumer only knows that the extension of the term by more than 30 days may generate the obligation to pay an extension fee, without being able to determine, at the time of concluding the Contract, its amount or limits. Furthermore, the wording of point 8.2. of the Contract, according to which the creditor decides "at its own discretion", including with regard to the extension fee, leaves the subsequent determination of the cost within the creditor's decision-making sphere, without indicating objective contractual criteria that would limit this margin of appreciation.
This lack of determinability is all the more relevant given that, according to point 8.5. of the Contract, payment of the extension fee constitutes a condition for the entry into force of the modification of the loan term. Thus, the consumer cannot assess in advance the cost of a possible extension, nor the economic consequences of exercising this option.
In conclusion, the clauses provided at point 8.2. and point 8.5. of the Contract do not allow the consumer to determine, on the basis of clear and intelligible criteria, the amount or the mechanism for establishing the extension fee and, respectively, the economic consequences of extending the loan term, thus failing to comply with the transparency obligation provided for in art. 1071 para. (1) of the Civil Code.
21.8.1. According to point 6.2. letter b) of the Contract, "The interest rate may be modified: [...] b) unilaterally by the Lender, depending on the evolution of the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova, the inflation rate and market developments, including a change in the USD exchange rate by more than 10% compared to the exchange rate on the date of conclusion of this Contract, taking into account the rules of equity, notifying the Borrower by e-mail and/or SMS at least 10 (ten) days before the implementation of the modified interest rate.".
In the same vein, it should be mentioned that, in the "Pre-contractual Information" form, which was made available to the debtor, under the heading "3. Costs of the loan", it is stated: "The interest rate on the loan or, if applicable, the various interest rates applicable to the credit contract: - 21.00%, per annum, fixed".
In this context, in accordance with art. 3 of Law no. 202/2013, "fixed interest rate applicable to the loan – the agreement of the parties, in the credit contract, on an interest rate applicable to the loan for the entire duration of the credit contract or on several interest rates applicable to the loan for partial terms, applying exclusively a fixed percentage established.".
Therefore, the pre-contractual information, according to which the interest rate is fixed, and the clause provided at point 6.2. letter b) of the Contract, which allows the creditor to unilaterally modify it depending on the evolution of certain economic indicators, create an inconsistency regarding the nature and mechanism for determining the interest applicable to the Contract. The consumer is presented, prior to the conclusion of the Contract, with a fixed rate, while the contractual clause allows its subsequent modification at the unilateral initiative of the creditor.
In this vein, it should be noted that the assessment of the abusive nature of the clause does not concern the adequacy of the level of the interest rate, as an element of the creditor's remuneration, but the manner in which the professional reserved the right to unilaterally modify an interest rate presented to the consumer, at the pre-contractual stage, as being fixed.
Therefore, according to art. 1072 para. (1) of the Civil Code, when assessing the potential abusive nature, it is analyzed whether the contractual clause referred to, which was not individually negotiated, is considered abusive if it is proposed by the professional and significantly disadvantages the consumer, contrary to good faith.
According to art. 1069 para. (1) of the Civil Code, "(1) A clause proposed by one of the parties is not individually negotiated if the other party was unable to influence its content, in particular because it was drafted in advance, regardless of whether it is part of standard clauses or not.", and, in accordance with para. (3) and para. (4) of the same article, if a clause was proposed as part of standard clauses by the creditor, it is presumed that it was not individually negotiated.
In assessing the imbalance created to the detriment of the consumer, the nature of the legal relationship must also be taken into account. The consumer contracts the credit, assuming the obligation of staggered repayment, and the interest rate level constitutes an essential element for determining the cost of the credit and the extent of their payment obligations. In the case of an installment presented as fixed, the consumer is entitled to rely on the stability of the percentage agreed for the period in which it is declared applicable; however, through pt. 6.2. lit. b) of the Contract, the creditor reserves the possibility of unilaterally modifying precisely this element of the credit cost, depending on the evolution of the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova (NBM), inflation, the market, and the USD exchange rate, although the interest rate was presented to the consumer, at the pre-contractual stage, as being fixed.
Thus, the clause affects the predictability of the credit cost and the stability of the obligations assumed by the consumer, being incompatible with the fixed nature of the interest rate, presented to them prior to the conclusion of the Contract.
According to art. 11 para. (1) of the Civil Code, “(1) Good faith is a standard of conduct of a party, characterized by correctness, honesty, openness, and taking into account the interests of the other party to the legal relationship.”.
21.8.2. At the same time, the clause provided in pt. 6.2. lit. b) of the Contract is to be analyzed also in light of art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013, which prohibits contractual clauses that confer upon the creditor the right to unilaterally modify the contractual conditions, without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by the consumer.
In this case, pt. 6.2. lit. b) of the Contract expressly grants the lender the right to unilaterally modify the interest rate, depending on the evolution of the NBM base rate, inflation, the market, and the USD exchange rate. Therefore, the modification of the interest can be carried out by the simple decision of the creditor, without the prior consent of the consumer being necessary. The fact that the creditor has the obligation to inform the consumer at least 10 days before the application of the new rate does not remove the unilateral nature of the modification. The notification of the consumer represents only informing them about the modification decided by the creditor and does not equate to the consumer's consent nor to the conclusion of an additional act.
Also, the Contract does not provide that the modification of the interest rate is conditioned by the express acceptance of the consumer and the signing of an additional act. On the contrary, the wording “The interest rate may be modified: […] b) unilaterally by the Lender [...]” confers upon the creditor, through the contractual clause itself, the right to unilaterally modify an essential condition of the contract.
Therefore, pt. 6.2. lit. b) of the Contract allows the creditor to unilaterally modify the interest rate, without the consumer's consent and without the conclusion of an additional act accepted by them, which contravenes the requirements of art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013.
This circumstance constitutes, at the same time, an additional element in assessing the abusive nature of the clause, since it allows the professional to unilaterally modify an essential element of the credit cost and creates, to the detriment of the consumer, an imbalance between the rights and obligations of the parties.
Pt. 6.3. of the Contract provides that, “Without prejudice to the provisions of pt. 6.2, O.C.N. ”Mogo Loans” SRL has the right to modify the Interest rate or the amount of other fees for financial services, without prior notice, if there is a justified reason, with the obligation to immediately inform the Borrower in this regard and for the Borrower to have the freedom to resort, immediately on this basis, to the termination of the Contract or, as the case may be, to the early repayment of the Contractual Payments, without any additional cost for the Borrower.”.
Through its content, the clause grants the creditor the right to unilaterally modify two essential elements of the credit cost – the interest rate and the amount of other fees for financial services – without the prior expression of the consumer's consent and without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by them. The information of the consumer occurs, according to the clause, after the modification is made, and their right to resort to the termination of the Contract or to early repayment represents a consequence of the modification already decided unilaterally by the creditor.
In this case, art. 15 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013 prohibits contractual clauses that confer upon the creditor the right to unilaterally modify the contractual conditions, without the conclusion of an additional act, accepted by the consumer. The existence of a “justified reason”, the subsequent information of the consumer, or their possibility to resort to the termination of the Contract or to early repayment does not remove the unilateral nature of the modification and cannot substitute the consumer's consent.
In accordance with pt. 7.3. of the Contract, “If upon receipt of the Borrower's notification regarding the exercise of the right of withdrawal, O.C.N. ”Mogo Loans” SRL has already disbursed to the borrower the entire amount or a part of the credit, the Borrower is obliged, within at most 3 (three) calendar days from sending the notification of exercise of the right of withdrawal, to return to O.C.N. ”Mogo Loans” SRL without any unjustified delay the amounts received and the increased interest for this period.”.
According to art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law no. 202/2013, in the case of exercising the right of withdrawal, the consumer is obliged to return the principal and the related interest without any unjustified delay and, in any case, no later than 30 calendar days from the transmission of the notification. Therefore, the legal norm regulates not only the existence of the restitution obligation, but also the temporal regime of its performance, establishing both the criterion of performance without unjustified delay and a maximum time limit of 30 days.
The phrase "without any unjustified delay" cannot be interpreted as meaning that the 30-day term is devoid of legal effect. The two elements of the norm have distinct functions: the obligation to perform without unjustified delay means that the consumer cannot unjustifiably postpone the restitution of the amounts received, while the 30-day term constitutes the maximum time limit within which the obligation must be performed as an effect of the exercise of the right of withdrawal.
Moreover, by establishing a fixed term of 3 calendar days, the creditor substantially reduces the period provided by the legislator for the performance of the restitution obligation, replacing the legal regime, which allows performance without unjustified delay but establishes, as a maximum limit, the 30-day term, with a fixed contractual term that is significantly shorter.
Such an addition does not consist in the mere fact that the 3-day term is different from the 30-day term provided by law, but in whether, through a pre-established contractual clause, the creditor can restrict, to the detriment of the consumer, the temporal regime of the restitution obligation established by Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law No. 202/2013. Such a contractual restriction must be examined in light of Art. 27 para. (1) of Law No. 202/2013, which provides that consumers cannot waive the rights conferred by this law. Insofar as the time limit established by Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law No. 202/2013 represents a legal guarantee regarding the performance of the restitution obligation, as an effect of the exercise of the right of withdrawal, the establishment by contract of a shorter term cannot have the effect of depriving the consumer of the protection conferred by the legal norm. Therefore, the contractual clause cannot be justified merely by the fact that Art. 18 para. (3) lit. b) of Law No. 202/2013 requires restitution "without any unjustified delay", since the same legal provision expressly establishes that restitution must not take place later than 30 calendar days from the transmission of the notification. The establishment of a contractual term of 3 days imposes on the consumer a temporal obligation more restrictive than that resulting from the legal regime, without the clause revealing the legal basis for such a derogation.
Point 11.2. of the Contract establishes the situations that are considered non-performance of the contractual obligation by the borrower and that entitle the creditor to declare the termination of the Contract. Thus, lit. j) qualifies as non-performance of the contractual obligation: "j) in other situations in which there has been an essential non-performance of the Contract by the Borrower".
According to point 11.2. lit. j) of the Contract, the creditor is entitled to declare termination in "other situations in which there has been an essential non-performance of the contract by the Borrower".
However, the clause does not establish the concrete circumstances, criteria or threshold of gravity on the basis of which a non-performance can be qualified as "essential". Although Art. 916 of the Civil Code establishes the criteria according to which non-performance has an essential character, the contract nevertheless does not transpose them in a manner that would allow the consumer to foresee in which concrete situations the non-performance of an obligation may lead to the termination of the contract.
Under these conditions, the consumer cannot anticipate, with sufficient clarity, the legal consequence of the non-performance of a certain obligation, namely the possibility of termination of the contract.
In particular, according to Art. 1071 para. (1) of the Civil Code, clauses not individually negotiated must be drafted and communicated in clear and intelligible language, so that the consumer can understand the extent of the obligations assumed and their legal consequences.
Therefore, the generic use of the phrase "essential non-performance", without establishing contractual criteria sufficiently clear for its determination, confers on the clause a non-transparent character, and, under the conditions of Art. 1071 para. (2) of the Civil Code, constitutes a basis for assessing it as abusive.
22. Regarding the violations admitted by OCN "MOGO LOANS" SRL, found in light of the provisions of Law No. 202/2013, it should be noted that these non-compliances are of a nature to attract the contraventional liability of the creditor. At the same time, according to the provisions of the Contraventional Code, the attraction of contraventional liability is conditioned by compliance with the general limitation period, set at 12 months from the date of commission of the act. Considering that more than 12 months have passed since the date of signing the Contract, the limitation period provided by law has been exceeded.
Therefore, CNPF is legally unable to order the application of contraventional sanctions in this case.
23. For the reasons set out above, pursuant to Art. 4 para. (21) lit. c), Art. 8 lit. t), Art. 18 para. (3), Art. 20 para. (1), para. (6) and para. (7) and Art. 22 para. (3) of Law No. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market, Law No. 202/2013 on consumer credit contracts, Law No. 105/2003 on consumer protection, the Civil Code, the Administrative Code and the Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision No. 57/11/2022),
1. The failure by OCN "MOGO LOANS" SRL to comply with art. 3, art. 5 para. (2) let. c), art. 10 para. (3) let. a) and let. g), art. 15 para. (1) and para. (4) let. c), art. 18 para. (3) let. b) and art. 20 para. (1) of Law no. 202/2013 on consumer credit contracts is found.
2. The unlawful nature of the clauses in Credit Contract no. [...] dated [...], concluded between OCN "MOGO LOANS" SRL and Mr. [...], contained in:
2.1. item 5.5., in the part concerning the text "[...] with 5 (five) working days in advance [...]";
2.2. item 6.3., which establishes that, "Without prejudice to the provisions of item 6.2, O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL has the right to modify the interest rate or the amount of other fees for financial services, without prior notice, if there is a justified reason, with the obligation to inform the Borrower immediately in this regard and for the Borrower to have the freedom to resort, immediately on this basis, to the termination of the Contract or, as the case may be, to the early repayment of the Contractual Payments, without any additional cost for the Borrower.";
2.3. item 7.3., according to which, "If upon receipt of the Borrower's notification regarding the exercise of the right of withdrawal, O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL has already released to the borrower the entire amount or a part of the credit, the Borrower is obliged, within at most 3 (three) calendar days from sending the notification of exercise of the right of withdrawal, to return to O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL without any unjustified delay the amounts received and the increased interest for this period.";
2.4. item 11.2. let. h), which stipulates that "third parties file claims against the Borrower, the total amount of which exceeds 20% (twenty percent) of the Credit balance".
3. The abusive nature of the clauses in Credit Contract no. [...] dated [..], concluded between OCN "MOGO LOANS" SRL and Mr. [...], contained in:
3.1. item 2 of Part I "Special provisions", which establishes "The commission for
granting the credit (10.00% of the Credit amount, min 250 EUR) – 714.90 €";
3.2. item 4.3. of Part II "General provisions", according to which "The Borrower agrees to pay O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL the commission for granting the credit, according to the Payment Schedule.";
3.3. item 8.2., in the part concerning the text "[...] regarding the Extension fee [...]", as well as the text "The extension fee will be applied and charged to the Borrower only if the maturity date is changed by more than 30 (thirty) days.";
3.4. item 8.5., in the part concerning the text "[...] the collection by O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL of the Extension fee [...]";
3.5. item 11.2. let. j), in the part related to the text "[...] material non-performance of the Contract by the Borrower;";
3.6. the text in annex no. 1, regarding:
3.6.1. "Commission for notifying the client regarding late payment or termination of the Contract - 2.50 EUR";
3.6.2. "Commission for termination of the Contract – 5% of the Credit balance, for the Contract that was terminated at the initiative of O.C.N. "Mogo Loans" SRL. [...]";
3.6.3. "Commission for re-concluding the Contract - 7.5% of the Credit balance, the first re-conclusion – free".
4. The unlawful and abusive nature of the clause in Credit Contract no. [...] dated [...], concluded between OCN "MOGO LOANS" SRL and Mr. [...], contained in item 6.2. let. b), in the part concerning the text "The interest rate may be modified: [...] b) unilaterally by the Lender, depending on the evolution of the base rate of the National Bank of Moldova, the inflation rate and market developments, including the modification of the USD exchange rate by more than 10% compared to the exchange rate on the date of conclusion of this Contract, taking into account the rules of equity, notifying the Borrower by e-mail and/or SMS at least 10 (ten) days before the implementation of the modified interest rate.".
5. A legal action is filed in court, in order to request the finding of the nullity of the unlawful clauses, indicated in point 2, of the abusive ones, indicated in point 3, and of the unlawful and abusive one, indicated in point 4.
6. Control over the execution of point 5 is entrusted to the Legal Department.
7. This Decision may be challenged by submitting a prior request to CNPF (MD-2012, mun. Chișinău, bd. Ștefan cel Mare și Sfânt, nr. 77), within 30 days from the date of communication.
8. This Decision enters into force on the date of adoption and is communicated to the recipients in accordance with the legislation and is published on the official website of CNPF (www.cnpf.md).
Dumitru BUDIANSCHI,
PRESIDENT
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Art. 4 para. (21) of Law No. 192/1998 on the National Commission of the Financial Market”
“Regulation on the organization and functioning of the National Commission of the Financial Market (CNPF Decision No. 57/11/2022)”
More like this from NCFM
NCFM published 27 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Commission for Financial Markets Moldova — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated