Enforcement · SMV · 25 Apr 2022
The Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision fined Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil 25 UIT for a very serious infraction under numeral 1.4 of subsection 1 of Annex XII of the Sanctions Regulation. The auditor failed to prepare and present the 2017 audit report on JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A.'s individual annual financial statements in accordance with International Standards on Auditing 250, 700, 705, 200, 240 and 500, including omitting to describe and quantify the financial effects of material misstatements.
Lima, 25 April 2022
Summary: Sanction Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil with a fine of 25 UIT, for having incurred a very serious infraction typified in numeral 1.4 of subsection 1 of Annex XII of the Sanctions Regulation
| Administered | : | NOLES MONTEBLANCO & ASOCIADOS SOCIEDAD CIVIL |
|---|---|---|
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No.: | 2021038342 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Supervision of
Market Conduct
Administrative file No. 2021038342, Report No. 102-2022-SMV/11.2, issued by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, the Report);
1. That, administrative file No. 2021038342 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervision function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Legislative Decree No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation); the former Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), in force at the date of the imputed fact; and, in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control according to its competences corresponds to said Deputy Superintendency. Likewise; the SASCM has the powers to dictate corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infraction;
2. That, regarding this PAS, it corresponds to two
(02) administrative instances in accordance with article 15 of the New Sanctions Regulation and the provisions of numeral 26 of article 12 of the ROF-SMV, which establish that the Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves appeals against resolutions issued in the first instance by the Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct of the SASCM, with the exception of single-instance procedures;
3. That, it was evaluated whether Sociedad Auditora Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil (hereinafter, SOA Noles) complied with the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) contained in the «Manual of International Pronouncements on Quality Control, Auditing, Review, Other Assurance Engagements, and Related Services», 2013 Edition, issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB); in its audit of the Individual Annual Financial Statements of JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A., formerly Accuratio Credit Rating Agency Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. (hereinafter, JCR), corresponding to fiscal year 2017;
4. That, on 02 April 2018, JCR presented its individual annual financial statements corresponding to fiscal year 2017 (hereinafter, EEFF 2017). Likewise, it attached the audit report on the EEFF2017, issued on the same date by SOA Noles;
5. That, by Official Letter No. 2466-2018-SMV/11.1 of 07 May 2018, the General Intendancy of Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, IGSC) summoned SOA Noles in order for it to substantiate, on the basis of the working papers, the audit of the EEFF 2017 of JCR;
6. That, on 21 May 2018, at the offices of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV, the substantiation of the audit carried out by SOA Noles took place;
7. That, on 10 October 2018, JCR sent to the SMV the “Special Report at the close of the Second Quarter 2018 related to the observations to the Audited Report as of 31 December 2017”, issued by SOA Noles on 17 August 2018 (hereinafter, the Special Report), in which it states in numeral 7 the following:
“Situation of the observations of the 2017 Audit Report at the close of the following second quarter (30 June 2018) Regarding the paragraph of the audit report, “Matter to consider” in which the following is established: As of 31 December 2017, the company has deferred both its revenues and its operating costs for an amount of S/ 598,462 and S/ 682,090 respectively, because these will be perfected as of 2018”, we must mention that the company has not remedied the situation mentioned in said paragraph. Therefore, we consider that the observation made in the audit report on the financial statements as of 31 December 2017, remains as of 30 June 2018.” (Underline added);
8. That, on 31 October 2018 by Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/01, the IGSC required SOA Noles, among others, to report the financial effects, due to the lack of remediation of the qualifications indicated by said SOA in its audit report and in numeral 7 of the cited special report, in the interim financial statements of JCR as of 30 June 2018. In response, on 16 November 2018, SOA Noles indicated the following:
“The Company, had it considered the proposed adjustments, would decrease accounts receivable from S/ 603 thousand to S/. 5 thousand and accumulated results would decrease from S/ (626) thousand to S/ (1,308) thousand with a net effect on other non-financial assets of S/ 78 thousand to S/ (6) thousand. Consequently, total assets would decrease from S/. 1,782 thousand to S/ 1,100 thousand and the total equity from S/ 1,627 thousand to S/ 945 thousand.”
9. That, by means of Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/11.1 of 31 October 2018, the IGSC requested information and documentation from SOA Noles in relation to the 2017 Audit Report—specifically, regarding the reasonableness of the Installations, Furniture and Equipment line item—as well as the Special Report, which was responded to by means of writings submitted on 19, 20 and 21 November 2018 by SOA Noles;
10. That, by means of Official Letter No. 6781-2018-SMV/11.1 of 06 December 2018, the IGSC requested SOA Noles to state, among others, the grounds supporting its conclusion and opinion on the reasonableness of the Installations, Furniture and Equipment line item in the 2017 Audit Report;
11. That, on 13 December 2018, SOA Noles submitted a response to the request made by means of Official Letter No. 6781-2018-SMV/11.1;
12. That, by means of Report No. 703-2019-SMV/11.1 of 27 June 2019 (File No. 2019002901), the IGSC forwarded to the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, IGCC) evidence against SOA Noles in relation to its obligation to comply with the NIAs;
13. That, by means of Memorandum No. 3713-2019-SMV/11 (File No. 2019039733), the Deputy Superintendent of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM) accepted the abstention request submitted by the General Intendant of the IGCC, Mr. Anderson Vela Guerrero, by means of Memorandum No. 3678-2019-SMV/11.2, and designated, in the same act, Mr. Ernesto Alvarez Cisneros to exercise the functions of General Intendant of the IGCC within the framework of administrative file No. 2019039733, in which the initiation or not of a sanctioning procedure against SOA Noles is being evaluated;
14. That, by means of Memorandum No. 282-2021- SMV/11.2, the IGCC requested from the IGSC amplifying and/or complementary information in view of the fact that the Contract for the Adaptation and Conditioning of Office Spaces, entered into on 29 June 2017, between JCR and LCL Building Corporation S.A.C. would have been terminated, which could have implications for the forwarded evidence;
15. That, by means of Memorandum No. 1373-2021- SMV/11.1, the IGSC provided a response to Memorandum No. 282-2021-SMV/11.2 referred to in the preceding numeral;
16. That, after the respective evaluation carried out by the IGCC, by means of Official Letter No. 4188-2021-SMV/11.2 of 25 October 2021 (hereinafter, Charge Letter), a charge was formulated and SOA Noles was requested to submit its corresponding defenses for not having presented the 2017 Audit Report, in accordance with the NIAs;
17. That, by means of a writing of 28 October 2021, SOA Noles requested from the IGCC an extension of the term of ten (10) additional business days to the term granted by means of the Charge Letter, in order to present its defenses;
18. That, by means of Official Letter No. 4269-2021-SMV/11.2, the IGCC granted SOA Noles, for the only time, an extension of ten (10) additional business days to the term already granted by means of the Charge Letter;
19. That, by means of a writing submitted on 08 November 2021, SOA Noles requested access to File No. 2021038342, in order to become aware of the information contained in the referred file and to be able to present the corresponding defenses;
20. That, by means of Official Letter No. 4468-2021-SMV/11.2, the IGCC responded to the request of SOA Noles described in the preceding numeral, and delivered via SMV Virtual the documents contained in the file up to that date; likewise, it proceeded to redirect the request of SOA Noles to the Officer Responsible for the Delivery of Information of the SMV, Ms. Nery Salas Acosta, by means of Memorandum No. 3958-2021-SMV/11.2 (File No. 2021042882);
21. That, by means of a writing submitted on 24 November 2021, SOA Noles submitted its defenses corresponding to the breaches detailed in the Charge Letter, and requested the right to speak in order to present its arguments on the imputed infraction;
22. That, by means of Official Letter No. 5061-2021-SMV/11.2 of 23 December 2021, the IGCC granted the right to speak for 30 December 2021;
23. That, SOA Noles by means of a writing of 27 December 2021, requested the rescheduling of the hearing for the right to speak to 07 January 2022;
24. That, by means of Official Letter No. 5104-2021-SMV/11.2 of 29 December 2021, the IGCC responded to the request of SOA Noles and rescheduled the hearing for the right to speak to 07 January 2022. On that date, the proceeding for the right to speak was carried out in a non-face-to-face manner, in which Mr. Walter Rivera Vílchez, legal advisor of SOA Noles, stated, among others, his request to reschedule the referred hearing to 17 January 2022;
25. That, by means of Official Letter No. 090-2022-SMV/11.2 of 10 January 2022, the IGCC responded to what was requested by the legal advisor of SOA Noles, and rescheduled the hearing for the right to speak to 17 January 2022;
26. That, on 17 January 2022, the proceeding for the right to speak was carried out virtually with the representatives of SOA Noles; Messrs. Walter A. Noles Monteblanco and Guillermo A. López Torres, and their legal advisor, Mr. Walter Rivera Vílchez; leaving record of the respective oral report;
27. That, by means of a writing of 17 January 2022, SOA Noles stated expressly its reasons why its legal advisor, Mr. Walter Rivera Vílchez requested that the hearing for the right to speak be rescheduled to 17 January 2022;
28. That, by means of the Report of 27 January 2022, the IGCC proposed to sanction SOA Noles with 25 UIT for not having prepared and presented the 2017 Audit Report, issued on 02 April 2018, in accordance with NIAs 250, 700, 705, 200 and 500 in the audit of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for fiscal year 2017 of JCR;
29. That, by means of Official Letter No. 419-2022-SMV/11 of 31 January 2022, the SASCM notified the IGCC Report to SOA Noles;
30. That, by means of communication of 7 February 2022, SOA Noles submitted its arguments regarding the Report and requested the right to speak;
31. That, by means of Official Letter No. 510-2022-SMV/11 of 8 February 2022, the right to speak was granted to SOA Noles for 14 February 2022;
32. That, on 14 February 2022, the hearing for the right to speak was held virtually with the representatives of SOA Noles; Messrs. Walter A. Noles Monteblanco and Guillermo A. López Torres, and their legal advisor, Mr. Walter Rivera Vílchez; the respective oral report being recorded;
33. That, as a result of said evaluation, by means of an Official Letter of Charge, a charge was formulated against SOA Noles for failing to prepare and submit the 2017 Audit Report, issued on 02 April 2018; in accordance with ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500 in the audit of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR;
The facts subject to imputation are detailed below:
a) Regarding ISA 250 "Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements" and ISA 700 "Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements"
In the 2017 Audit Report, SOA Noles expressed the following opinion:
"Opinion In our opinion, giving consideration to the matters set forth in the preceding paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of ACCURATIO CREDIT RATING AGENCY EMPRESA CLASIFICADORA DE RIESGO S.A. [JCR], as of 31 December 2017, the results of its operations, and its cash flows for the year then ended, in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in Peru." (Underline added).
In this regard, SOA Noles indicated that the applicable financial reporting framework is the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP); however, the regulatory framework that SOA Noles should have applied is the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) pursuant to Article 1 of the Standards on Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Standards on preparation and presentation of FS).
In that sense, SOA Noles, in order to issue the corresponding 2017 Audit Report, did not observe the following ISAs:
"ISA 250 Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements
1. This International Standard on Auditing (ISA) deals with the auditor's responsibility to consider laws and regulations in an audit of financial statements. (...)
12. When obtaining an understanding of the entity and its environment in accordance with ISA 315 (Revised), the auditor shall obtain a general understanding of:
(a) the regulatory framework applicable to the entity and the industry in which it operates; and
(b) how the entity complies with that framework. (Ref.: Section A7).
13. The auditor shall obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding compliance with the provisions of those laws and regulations generally recognized to have a direct effect on the determination of material amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. (Ref.: Section A8)"
1. This International Standard on Auditing (ISA) deals with the auditor's responsibility to form an opinion on the financial statements. It also deals with the form and content of the auditor's report issued as a result of an audit of financial statements.
10. The auditor shall form an opinion on whether the financial statements are prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.
15. The auditor shall evaluate whether the financial statements adequately describe or refer to the applicable financial reporting framework. (Ref.: Sections A5–A10)" (Underline added).
In this regard, on 02 April 2018, JCR submitted its Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year and attached the 2017 Audit Report, issued on the same date by SOA Noles, which states the following:
"Matter to consider As of 31 December 2017, the company has deferred both its revenues and its operating costs for an amount of S/ 598,462 and S/ 682,090 respectively, because these will be perfected as from 2018." (Underline added).
In this regard, as can be observed, SOA Noles issued an opinion, which would contain a qualification although not clearly, under the subtitle of "Matters to Consider", limiting itself to stating that the recording of deferred revenues and operating costs will be perfected as from 2018, omitting to disclose the description and quantify the financial effects in the 2017 Audit Report of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, which, with respect to equity, would be the following:
| Prepared by the IGSC. |
|---|
From the foregoing, it is evident that SOA Noles omitted to disclose in the 2017 Audit Report a description and quantification of the financial effects of the material misstatements identified in the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, and the impact on its real financial situation, equity, results of operations, among others.
In accordance with the foregoing, SOA Noles did not observe the provisions of ISA 705, specifically in its paragraph 17 entitled "Basis for Qualified Opinion", which states:
17. If there is a material misstatement in the financial statements that affects specific amounts in the financial statements (including disclosures of quantitative information), the auditor shall include in the basis for modified opinion paragraph a description and quantification of the financial effects of the misstatement, unless impracticable. If quantification of the financial effects is impracticable, the auditor shall so state in the basis for modified opinion paragraph. (Ref.: Paragraph A18). (Underlining added).
It should be noted that, by letter dated 19 November 2018, SOA Noles sent a response to Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/01, reporting the financial effects of the misstatements referred to the "recording of deferred operating income and costs" that remained in the interim financial statements as of 30 June 2018 of JCR —as indicated in item 7 of the "Special Report at the Close of the Second Quarter 2018"—, specifying the following:
"Had the Company considered the proposed adjustments, it would decrease accounts receivable from S/ 603 thousand to S/. 5 thousand and accumulated results would decrease from S/ (626) thousand to S/ (1,308) thousand with a net effect on other non-financial assets from S/ 78 thousand to S/ (6) thousand. Consequently, total assets would decrease from S/. 1,782 thousand to S/ 1,100 thousand and total equity from S/ 1,627 thousand to S/ 945 thousand.".
In that regard, the uncorrected material misstatements were perfectly identified and quantified by the aforementioned audit firm upon the request of the IGSC because said misstatement continued in the separate interim financial statements as of 30 June 2018 of JCR; however, SOA Noles omitted to disclose said identification and quantification in its 2017 Audit Report of the Audited Annual Separate Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR.
In accordance with the foregoing, SOA Noles did not observe the provisions of ISA 705, paragraph 17, since it omitted to disclose in a paragraph entitled "Basis for Qualified Opinion" of the 2017 Audit Report, an identification, description and quantification of the financial effects of the material misstatements identified in the Audited Annual Separate Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, and the impact on its real financial situation, equity, results of operations, among others.
c) Regarding ISA 200 "Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing", ISA 240 "The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements" and ISA 500 "Audit Evidence"
In the Installations, Furniture and Equipment line item, under the heading Constructions and improvements, of the Audited Annual Separate Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, a significant increase of 618% was recorded compared to the previous year (from S/ 51,257 to S/ 367,828) based on the "Contract for the Adaptation and Conditioning of Office Spaces" (hereinafter, Adaptation Contract), which is detailed below:
Source: Audited Annual Separate Financial Statements for the fiscal year 2017 submitted by JCR to the SMV.
Own elaboration.
It should be noted that the aforementioned Adaptation Contract was entered into on 29 June 2017, between JCR and LCL Building Corporation S.A.C. for the purpose of implementing improvements in the JCR office. In this regard, the amount of said contract amounted to S/ 325,900.11 (not including I.G.V.) for an area of 102 m2
In consideration of the foregoing and of the briefs submitted on 19, 20 and 21 November 2018 and 16 December 2018, in response to Official Letters Nos. 6079 and 6781-SMV/11.1, SOA Noles submitted documentation in order to support the reasonableness of the significant increase in the aforementioned line item; however, it has been observed that SOA Noles did not apply the appropriate procedures to obtain sufficient audit evidence, nor did it carry out the audit with professional skepticism1, taking into consideration the following audit evidence:
(i) The Clause "Third: Purpose of the Adaptation and Conditioning, Term and Modality" establishes that LCL Building Corporation S.A.C. shall be responsible for the execution of the project and for providing the necessary resources for the correct execution of the project including, among others, the materials. However, SOA Noles presented two (02) invoices No. 000138 and 000165 dated 03/07/2017 and 08/08/2017 respectively, for a total of S/ 265,441 issued by the company Distribuidora Comercial Multinacional Perú S.A.C., which is not part of the Adaptation Contract.
[1] In accordance with ISA 200 "Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing", professional skepticism is an attitude that includes a questioning mind, being alert to conditions which may indicate possible misstatement due to error or fraud, and a critical assessment of audit evidence.
Despite the foregoing, it is observed that SOA Noles has not attached evidence of any request or inquiry made in its audit work with respect to the invoices issued by a supplier that was not part of the Adaptation Contract.
(ii) The Clause "Sixth: Forms of Payment of the Contractor", establishes the following:
(…)
The total payment shall be made through periodic payments based on partial valuations made by the Contractor according to the proportional progress of the project approved and signed by the contracting representative before the issuance of the invoice corresponding to each period. (…)
The valuations must be submitted to the Contracting Party within two (02) business days following the expiration of the corresponding weekly period for review and approval. Once the valuation is approved, the Contractor shall issue the corresponding invoice (...)» (Underlining added)
As evidence of the payments made by JCR for the execution of the project under the Adaptation Contract, SOA Noles presented the accounting vouchers and checks issued to settle four (04) invoices. However, said documentation does not evidence payment to the aforementioned supplier, since the checks were drawn in favor of JCR's workers —who are exclusively dedicated to tasks related to risk classification in accordance with securities market regulations—, as detailed below:
[A] Payment of Invoice of Distribuidora Comercial Multinacional del Perú S.A.C.
[B] Pago de Factura de LCL Building Corporation S.A.C.
| [C] Payment of Invoice of Distribuidora Comercial Multinacional del Perú | S.A.C. |
|---|
[D] Pago de Factura de LCL Building Corporation S.A.C.
It is observed that the payments for progress on the adaptation and conditioning project were drawn by check in the name of six (6) JCR workers exclusively dedicated to classification-related tasks, and not in treasury or company administration functions or similar whose task is payment to suppliers.
In view of the foregoing, by means of Official Letter No. 6781-2018-SMV/11.1, dated 06 December 2018, the IGSC requested SOA Noles to explain, among other matters, said observation. In a letter dated 12 December 2018, SOA Noles stated: “Regarding the checks issued in the name of employees, the statement received from the Management of Accuratio [JCR] was that, due to the intention to exercise greater supervision and monitoring of the progress of the work, it was decided to issue the checks in the name of its workers, who, after the respective verification of the progress, cashed them and delivered them to the supplier.” (Subrayado agregado)
Regarding the statement made by the General Manager of JCR, to the effect that checks were issued to workers in order to carry out greater supervision and monitoring of the progress of the work, who are exclusively dedicated to tasks related to risk classification; it is observed that such explanations do not constitute sufficient and adequate audit evidence to validate the payment to the supplier; consequently, SOA Noles should have acted with professional skepticism, which implied questioning the reliability of the documents and the responses of the Management of JCR, as well as evaluating the need to carry out additional audit procedures and investigations in order to obtain audit evidence that allows validating the existence of the asset.
In accordance with the foregoing, it is observed that the audit documentation presented by SOA Noles does not evidence the professional skepticism with which an auditor must act throughout the audit, as it did not pay special attention to the information that questions the reliability of the documents, which required it to carry out inquiries to obtain sufficient audit evidence. In this regard, SOA Noles did not have a critical assessment of the evidence and did not apply adequate procedures to obtain sufficient audit evidence to conclude on the reasonableness of the Plant, Furniture and Equipment account.
In accordance with the foregoing, SOA Noles failed to comply with the provisions of ISA 200, 240 and ISA 500, which state:
“ISA 200 Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing
15. The auditor shall plan and perform the audit with professional skepticism, recognizing that circumstances may exist that cause the financial statements to contain material misstatements. (Ref.: Apartados A18–A22)
A18. Professional skepticism involves special attention, for example, to:
(…)
(..)
A 20. Professional skepticism is necessary for a critical assessment of audit evidence, which involves questioning contradictory audit evidence and the reliability of documents and responses to inquiries, as well as other information obtained from management and those charged with governance of the entity. It also involves considering the sufficiency and appropriateness of the audit evidence obtained taking into account the circumstances; (…).”
ISA 240 The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements
14. When responses to inquiries of management or those charged with governance of the entity are inconsistent, the auditor shall investigate such inconsistencies.
ISA 500 Sufficient and Appropriate Audit Evidence
6. The auditor shall design and perform audit procedures that are appropriate, taking into account the circumstances, in order to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence. (Ref.: Apartados A1–A25). (Subrayado agregado).”;
34. That, in the present case, SOA Noles, by written submission of 24 November 2021, presented its defense; likewise, it requested the right to speak in order to present its arguments on the imputed infraction;
35. That, in response to the request for the right to speak submitted by SOA Noles, it was granted by Official Letters No. 5061-2021-SMV/11.2 of 23 December 2021, No. 5104-2021-SMV/11.2 of 29 December 2021, and No. 090-2022-SMV/11.2 of 10 January 2022;
36. That, likewise, on 17 January 2022, the oral report requested by SOA Noles was carried out through the SMV's electronic platform, in which it provided a descriptive explanation of the charges imputed, ratifying its arguments presented in the brief of discharges on 24 November 2021. Likewise, its legal advisor, Walter Rivera Vílchez, requested that the principle of innocence be taken into account, which was not rebutted in the administrative proceeding;
37. That, in relation to the charge contained in the Letter of Charges, SOA Noles formulates its discharges, which are detailed below:
(i) In relation to ISA 250, SOA Noles states that during the development of the 2017 audit, it has transmitted and received information regarding compliance and/or non-compliance with laws and regulations, and has evaluated their potential effect on the financial statements taken as a whole, applying procedures according to the circumstances, as indicated in its Planning Memorandum, which was reviewed by the SMV, and which forms part of its working papers, which includes, among other aspects, the Audit Risk Assessment; therefore, it has been based on the provisions of paragraph 4 of the aforementioned ISA, which states that "its purpose is to facilitate the auditor's identification of material misstatements in the financial statements due to non-compliance with legal and regulatory provisions. However, the auditor is not responsible for preventing non-compliance and cannot be expected to detect all instances of non-compliance with any legal and regulatory provision".
Likewise, SOA Noles states that it has taken into account the provisions of paragraph 6 of ISA 250 regarding laws and regulations, taking as professional criteria the materiality or the impact or effect on the financial statements in its evaluation of "Superintendent's Resolution No. 070-2017-SMV/02 dated 10 August 2017 in which the operating authorization is suspended; however, by Superintendent's Resolution No. 089-2017-SMV/02 dated 19 September 2017, the indicated suspension is left without effect by your institution. Information that is in our working papers that were reviewed by you."
In that sense, SOA Noles indicates that its working papers include a working paper referring to the adjustments and reclassifications identified, on which its observations rest, quantifying the potential financial effects, in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 6, subparagraph a) of ISA 250.
Additionally, SOA Noles states that paragraph 19 of ISA 250 provides that "If the auditor becomes aware of information concerning an instance of non-compliance, the auditor shall discuss the matter with management and, where appropriate, with those charged with governance. If management or, where appropriate, those charged with governance do not provide sufficient information that corroborates that the entity complies with the legal and regulatory provisions and, in the auditor's judgment, the effect of the possible non-compliance could be material to the financial statements, the auditor shall consider the need to obtain legal advice". (The underlining is by SOA Noles). In that sense, SOA Noles states that it held meetings with JCR's management in order to communicate the potential non-compliances incurred, which have been expressed in the Internal Control letter and in meeting minutes, which are recorded in its working papers, the same ones that were reviewed by the SMV.
(ii) On the other hand, in relation to ISA 700, SOA Noles states that its work was framed within the provisions of the aforementioned ISA, given that it issued an opinion based on its evaluation, and on the conclusions it reached, as a result of the application of its audit procedures designed and applied according to the circumstances and based on the audit evidence obtained (paragraph 6 of ISA 700).
Likewise, SOA Noles indicates that "(…) we took into account the applicable financial reporting framework, on which the company [JCR] prepared its financial statements, which were the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, which we expressed in our Audit Report. However, because the company [JCR] should have prepared its financial statements based on International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs), we proceeded to evaluate their impact, as if the IFRSs had been applied, resulting in a low (not significant) effect, which was timely shown and evidenced during the review of our working papers (Annex 12), carried out by your supervision team and which took place on 21 May 2018.
Furthermore, SOA Noles states that "(…) the engagement partner presented a report from our IFRS Division Manager Mr. Luis Montes, indicating that LA CLASIFICADORA has a low impact in the IFRS adoption process (the impact of the adaptation to the IFRSs is not significant and does not represent a distortion to the reasonableness of the financial statements at that date). Likewise, our Firm presented a Minutes of discussion of the observations (Annex 13), where it is indicated that it remains as a definitive deviation to be made according to JCR's Management in 2018, as well as the observation related to deferred income and costs."
On the other hand, SOA Noles questions the SMV's observation that states: “According to ISA 250 paragraph 29, the results of discussions with management and those charged with governance of the CLASIFICADORA regarding non-compliance with legal and regulatory provisions in the application of IFRS approved by the IASB, in accordance with the provisions of SMV Resolution No. 16-2015-SMVI01, as well as article 35, numeral 35.4 of the Regulation of Risk Rating Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 032-2015-SMVI01, have not been documented, as well as requiring written representations from the governing body of the CLASIFICADORA regarding its responsibility for such non-compliance.”, and states that it has working papers that contradict said assertion, citing its Representation Letter, Minutes of Discussion of internal control observations, and a working paper entitled “IFRS Evaluation and Impact”.
In accordance with the foregoing, SOA Noles states that it did consider and evaluate the regulatory framework under which JCR's financial statements were prepared, which was GAAP, and considered it an appropriate audit procedure to prepare a study and make an evaluation of the impact of adopting the correct regulatory framework (IFRSs), documented in a working paper referring to the IFRS evaluation and impact, resulting in a low impact, for said audit firm.
Prior to the development of its defense, SOA Noles states that the amounts expressed in the cited table, which is part of the Statement of Charges, are not thousands of soles, but only soles, which could magnify the impact of the perception of the observation, and affects the materiality criterion.
On the other hand, regarding ISA 705, paragraph 17, which provides that when there is a material misstatement the identified fact must be described and the financial effect quantified, SOA Noles states that it took this situation into account when drafting the 2017 Audit Report, since its report includes said requirement by detailing the accounting items that gave rise to the qualification, and disclosing the amounts affected in the accounting accounts; consequently, SOA Noles states that it has acted in accordance with the indicated standard, so the qualification expressed at the close of the 2017 fiscal year was drafted adequately, and ISA 705 has been complied with.
On the other hand, regarding the observation formulated by the SMV in the Statement of Charges, which states that "the uncorrected material misstatements were perfectly identified and quantified by the aforementioned audit firm upon the request of the IGSC because said misstatement continued in the individual interim financial statements as of 30 June 2018 of JCR, however, it omitted to disclose said identification and quantification in its 2017 audit report of the audited individual annual financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR."; SOA Noles states that by letter of 16 November 2018, it carried out a greater analysis of the qualification set forth in the 2017 Audit Report in the response to Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/11.1, by means of which, as it states, it was requested to provide a detailed explanation of the adjustments that JCR should make to correct the aforementioned observation.
Likewise, SOA Noles stated that for a reader of financial information, the qualification set forth in the opinion on the financial statements at the close of 2017 was correctly expressed, under the title of «Matters to Consider», a title that in its professional judgment adequately alerts the reader about a situation that affects in a certain way the reasonableness of the financial statements at the close of the 2017 fiscal year.
C) ISA 200 «Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing», ISA 240 «The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements» and ISA 500 «Audit Evidence»
Regarding the non-compliance with ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500, SOA Noles states that its audit work was duly evidenced, as can be verified in the working papers that were provided to the SMV, as well as in the subsequent explanations requested through written communications.
Likewise, regarding what is stated in the Statement of Charges that SOA Noles did not act with professional skepticism when evaluating the Furniture and Equipment line item; SOA Noles considers that this is an erroneous deduction from the review of the working papers, since these complied with the audit assertions such as completeness, accuracy, cut-off and classification. It also adds that the audit work “(…) had a scope level of 74%, and a unique characteristic, such as physical inspection, since the audit work was on-site (our team of experienced auditors was working physically in said offices and experiencing the existence and characteristics of said facilities, furniture and equipment).” Similarly, SOA Noles states that “The observations indicated that there is a supplier that does not appear in the contract, as is the case of Distribuidora Comercial Multinacional del Perú, is only a formality, since the goods provided corresponded to the execution of the work, and the contract stated that the construction materials could be provided by the contractor.
Disbursements made through company personnel were not prohibited, because Law 30730, with respect to means of payment, was published on 21 February 2018. The reason for the procedure used was, according to statements by Management, the need to exercise closer control over the execution of the work, the procedure being capable of being considered as a qualification in the internal control system.”
In this regard, SOA Noles points out that “Professional skepticism cannot be exaggerated, much less distorted; the auditor's independence improves their capacity to act with integrity, to be objective, and to maintain an attitude of professional skepticism.”
Likewise, SOA Noles adds that “Our professional judgment led us to conclude that the furniture and equipment installations line item was reasonable. This professional judgment is supported by our assessments, our audit procedures, and by our conclusions backed by the 35 years of experience that our firm has in the professional practice of auditing.
The questions raised by you were clarified through statements by management (Representation Letter), which for us, together with the other assertions satisfied and procedures applied, we consider sufficient for the issuance of our opinion.”
1. The time elapsed, subsequent audits (ISA 510) and the validity of the opinion on the audit of an entity.
In this regard, SOA Noles indicates that it issued the 2017 Audit Report with a qualified opinion, whose observations remained until the close of the first half of the 2018 fiscal year, as indicated in the report it prepared as of 30 June 2018.
Likewise, SOA Noles specifies that the opinions corresponding to the 2018 and 2019 fiscal years were issued with clean opinions; which is an indicator that the opinion on the 2017 Audit Report helped the Securities Market System by identifying situations that had to be corrected and which were subsequently remedied.
Additionally, SOA Noles indicates that in accordance with the provisions of ISA 510 "Initial Audit Engagements - Opening Balances", in its paragraphs 92 and 113, the auditors of the 2018 fiscal year assume the
[2] "Relevant information in the predecessor auditor's audit report 9. If the financial statements of the preceding period were audited by a predecessor auditor and that auditor expressed a modified opinion, the auditor will evaluate the effect that the matter giving rise to the modification has on the assessment of the risks of material misstatement in the financial statements of the current period, in accordance with ISA 315 (Revised).
[3] "Conclusions and Audit Report 11. If the auditor concludes that the opening balances contain a misstatement that materially affects the financial statements of the current period and if the effect of the misstatement is not recorded, presented or disclosed
responsibility for the reasonableness of JCR's financial statements, thereby becoming the predecessor auditors.
In view of the foregoing, SOA Noles considers that "(...) it must be understood that responsibility for the issued opinion extends until the next auditor issues its new opinion (...); therefore, we consider that any responsibility for the opinion issued on the year 2017 escapes (is outside) what is established by the same International Standards on Auditing. (...)"
On this matter, SOA Noles points out that the working papers were reviewed by the SMV, an entity that identified some observable situations, which could be qualified as remediable or differences of criteria or professional judgment, but no element that has not been ratified by the subsequent auditors of the 2018, 2019 and 2020 fiscal years, which would mean that the 2017 opinion did not correspond to the reality of JCR at the close of said fiscal year.
In this regard, SOA Noles points out that in paragraph No. 16 of the Preface of the «Manual of International Pronouncements on Quality Control, Auditing, Review, Other Assurance Engagements, and Related Services», the following is stated:
Professional judgment
"16. The nature of the International Standards requires that the professional accountant exercise professional judgment when applying them. "
In this regard, SOA Noles points out that the cited paragraph gives the professional space in the execution of audits, to apply their professional judgment when they consider it necessary, based on their experience and trajectory, which allows concluding that always [the auditor's professional judgment] will be above a standard, since from the experience in the execution of audits and the application of said professional judgment come the ISA's, standards aimed at international standardization.
In line with the foregoing, SOA Noles adds that the auditor is authorized by the same ISA's to use their professional judgment (criterion), in relation to the ISA's, when the circumstances and their professional judgment so warrant, for each specific case.
On this matter, SOA Noles indicates that in any evaluation of the quality of an audit, paragraphs 14 and 25 of ISA 320 must be taken into consideration
[4] adequately, the auditor will express a qualified opinion or an adverse opinion, as appropriate, in accordance with ISA 705."
[4] "Scope of this ISA 1. This International Standard on Auditing (ISA) deals with the auditor's responsibility to apply the concept of materiality in planning and performing an audit of financial statements. ISA 450 explains how to apply materiality, in order to evaluate the effect of identified misstatements on the audit and, where applicable, of uncorrected misstatements on the financial statements."
[5] "Materiality in the context of an audit
"Materiality or materiality in the planning and performance of an audit"6, which was reiterated in the Oral Report, and whose evaluation is also applicable to ISA 250 "Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements", paragraph 137.
Additionally, SOA Noles states that the auditor must evaluate whether the audited company is complying with the regulatory framework for the preparation of the financial statements by the entity's management. It also indicates that it must be considered that the auditor does not prepare the financial statements with one or another regulation, as referred to on page 3 of the Letter of Charges.
Likewise, SOA Noles specifies that the auditor's task is to evaluate, examine and issue an opinion, not to apply any standard on the financial statements, which is a responsibility inherent to the entity's Corporate Governance, as indicated in the second paragraph of the opinions. It also adds that it is up to the auditor to evaluate the regulatory framework under which the financial statements were prepared and, if the financial statements (prepared by the entity's Government administration) are not in accordance with the correct regulations, to measure the effect of the misstatements and, if material, to qualify the corresponding opinion.
38. That, by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the State's administrative function and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures. Likewise, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG sets out the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction: (a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, (b) The probability of detection of the infraction, (c) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, (d) The economic harm caused, (e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, (f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and, (g) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct;
39. That, the charge formulated and the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been
[2] Financial reporting frameworks often refer to the concept of materiality in the context of the preparation and presentation of financial statements. Although such financial reporting frameworks may refer to materiality in different terms, they generally indicate that: • misstatements, including omissions, are considered material if, individually or in the aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence the economic decisions that users make based on the financial statements; • judgments about materiality are made in light of the surrounding circumstances and are affected by the size or nature of a misstatement, or by a combination of both; and • judgments about the matters that are material to users of the financial statements are based on consideration of the common financial information needs of users as a group. The possible effect that misstatements may have on specific individual users, whose needs may be very varied, is not taken into account."
[6] See from 00:08:40 hours to 00:12:30 hours of the recording of the Oral Report that is part of the Record of the right to speak of 17 January 2022, which was carried out via the SMV electronic platform.
[7] "13. The auditor shall obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding compliance with the provisions of laws and regulations that, generally recognized, have a direct effect on the determination of material amounts and disclosures in the financial statements. (Ref: Section A8)."
submitted to the knowledge of the SASCM;
40. That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, by means of Official Letter No. 419-2022-SMV/11, the Report was sent to SOA Noles, so that it may submit its arguments; which have been presented and will be evaluated in this Resolution;
41. That, in the PAS it corresponds to determine the following:
(i) Whether or not SOA Noles incurred in the infraction indicated in the Letter of Charges and Report.
(ii) Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on SOA Noles;
42. That, article 1 of the LOSMV states that the SMV has the function: "(...) to supervise compliance with international auditing standards by audit firms authorized by a college of public accountants of Peru and contracted by natural or legal persons subject to the supervision of the SMV in compliance with the standards under its competence, for which it may issue general provisions consistent with the referred international auditing standards and require them any information or documentation to verify such compliance.(...)";
43. That, article 39 of the Financial Information Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF-94.10 (hereinafter, Financial Information Regulation), establishes that:
"(…) The audit report must be prepared and presented subject to the requirements and formalities established by the ISAs approved and in force in Peru and, where applicable, by the specific standards issued by the corresponding Supervisory and Control Bodies";
44. That, the SOA Noles, in order to issue the 2017 Audit Report, did not observe ISA 250 "Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements"; ISA 700 "Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements"; ISA 705 "Modifications to the Opinion in the Report of an Independent Auditor"; ISA 200 "Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing"; ISA 240 "The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements"; and ISA 500 "Audit Evidence";
45. That, non-compliance with the ISAs is typified in item 1.4 of paragraph 1 of Annex XII of the Sanctions Regulations, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, which mentions that it constitutes a very serious infringement: "To issue an opinion or any report that it is obliged to issue by the regulations or by a request from CONASEV without having complied with the International Standards on Auditing in the course of the examination, or to deny information that it is its duty to disclose". Such infringement remains a very serious infringement in paragraph 1.4 of item 1 of Annex XII of the New Sanctions Regulations;
46. That, in accordance with article 20 of the Sanctions Regulations, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, said infringement is punishable by a fine of more than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT or by disqualification; a sanction that is maintained in article 33 of the New Sanctions Regulations;
47. That, in accordance with what is stated in recital 2 of this Resolution, this type of non-compliance is subject to two (02) administrative instances for its evaluation and resolution, the first before the Deputy Superintendent of Conduct Supervision of the SASCM and the second and final instance, before the Superintendent of the Securities Market;
48. That, in accordance with the Charge and Report Memorandum, the present case refers to whether the SOA Noles observed ISAs 250, 700, 705, 200, 240 and 500; when preparing and presenting its 2017 Audit Report, corresponding to the 2017 FS of JCR;
49. That, without prejudice to the scope and application to the present case of the regulatory provisions cited in the Charge and Report Memorandum, it is necessary to point out that in accordance with the provisions of article 2718 of the LMV and the Risk Classification Companies Regulations, approved by Resolution SMV N° 032-2015-SMV-01 (hereinafter, the ECR Regulations), by definition, risk rating companies (hereinafter, ECR), such as the particular case of JCR, are entities that are authorized by the SMV to operate as such. The ECR have as their main function to issue risk ratings on debt-representative securities (short-term instruments and bonds);
50. That, in addition, it must be considered that in article 1 of CONASEV Resolution N° 102-2010-EF/94.01.1, published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on 19 October 2010, it was established that the standard for the preparation and preparation of the financial statements of risk classification companies, among other entities, is the full compliance with the IFRS issued by the IASB, internationally in force:
"(…) Article 1º.- Issuing companies with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market, risk classification companies, stock exchanges, securities clearing and settlement institutions, intermediary agents, mutual fund management companies for investment in securities, investment funds, investment fund management companies, securitization companies, collective fund management companies and other legal entities under the supervision of CONASEV shall prepare their financial statements in full compliance with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the IASB, internationally in force, specifying in the notes an explicit and unreserved statement of compliance with such standards.(…)"
51. That, subsequently, through SMV Resolution Nº 016-2015-SMV/01, published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on 26 August 2015 and
[8] The text of the provision reads: "Article 271.- Control and Supervision It is the responsibility of CONASEV to grant the authorization for the organization and operation of the rating agencies. The rating agencies shall be registered in the Registry and shall be subject to the control and supervision of said public body."
in force since 01 January 2017, the Standards on the preparation and presentation of the FS were approved, and although CONASEV Resolution N° 102-2010- EF/94.01.1 was repealed, the requirement of the standard for the preparation of the financial statements of the ECR was maintained at all times. Indeed, article 1 of the Standards establishes:
"(…)
Issuing companies with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV), legal entities registered in the RPMV, collective fund management companies, and investment funds shall prepare their financial statements in full compliance with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), internationally in force, and, to the extent applicable, the Financial Information Regulations and the Manual for the preparation of Financial Information.
For the purposes of these regulations, legal persons registered in the RPMV shall be understood to mean intermediation agents, mutual fund management companies, investment fund management companies, securitization companies, risk rating companies, price provider companies and other entities to which the Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores grants authorization to operate. (…)»;
52. That, without prejudice to the fact that the standard recognized and required of the ECRs is that of “full compliance with the IFRS issued by the IASB in force internationally”, it is necessary to highlight that paragraph 16 of International Accounting Standard 1 “Presentation of Financial Statements” (IAS 1) states:
«(…)
16. An entity whose financial statements comply with IFRS shall make, in the notes, an explicit and unreserved statement of such compliance. An entity shall not state that its financial statements comply with IFRSs unless they comply with all the requirements of IFRSs. (…)»
53. That, in accordance with the provisions of Resolution CONASEV N° 102-2010-EF/94.01.1 and the Standards, the aforementioned financial statement preparation standard — full compliance with the IFRSs issued by the IASB currently in force internationally —, has been required of the ECRs from the 2011 fiscal year to the present;
54. That, the aforementioned financial statement preparation standard required of the ECRs is expressly established and must be complied with by them;
55. That, Article 10 of the LMV establishes:
All information that by provision of this law must be presented to CONASEV, to the stock exchange, to the entities responsible for centralized mechanisms or to investors, shall be truthful, sufficient and timely. Once the information has been received by said institutions, it shall be immediately made available to the public»;
56. That, the purpose of the regulatory provisions previously indicated is: (i) to establish and ensure compliance with the principle of information transparency by the persons or obligated subjects to prepare and disseminate their financial information to the securities market, it being necessary to indicate that the principle of information transparency is a fundamental element for the normal functioning and development of the securities market and, (ii) to improve the comparability of the financial statements that are disseminated to the market, by being prepared using the same accounting and financial language, allowing its participants an adequate decision-making process;
57. That, it is necessary to highlight that the regulatory framework established and applicable to the ECR, as is the case of the provisions and the IFRS standard previously indicated, is consistent with the principle of financial information transparency which is indispensable in the securities market;
58. That, (i) the transparency of all the information that an ECR disseminates in the Peruvian securities market, (ii) the protection of investors and potential investors of said market who know that a given ECR or SOA, such as JCR or SOA Noles, participate in the securities market exercising a special function; as well as (iii) the trust and integrity that is formed and strengthened in the securities market when it is perceived and/or evidenced that all its participants, including ECRs and SOAs, self-regulate and/or adapt their conduct to compliance with the rules; are legal interests that must be protected through the exercise of the SMV's supervisory powers and the legal mandate or ius imperium imposed by law on the SMV for the development of its functions and its role as authority of the Peruvian securities market, and in that direction, so that the SMV can fulfill its duty to safeguard those legal interests;
59. That, in File No. 2021038342, which contains the documentation of this PAS, it is observed that by Report No. 703-2019-SMV/11.1 (File No. 2019002901), the IGSC —an organ of the SMV that has among its functions and powers the supervision of compliance with the rules applicable to auditing firms contracted by companies with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (hereinafter, RPMV), evaluating indications of possible infractions, and forwards, for its consideration, the respective reports of indications of infraction, IGCC—, forwarded to the IGCC the result of its evaluation, and specifically referred to the present case;
60. That, it must be borne in mind that the procedures and legal forms with which the IGSC conducts its inspection and/or supervision activity and upon concluding it with a report of indications of infraction, determine that its pronouncement or opinion on a specific supervision matter —which may even contain a decision, such as, for example, the adoption of corrective measures—, is an opinion on the merits of the matter; it being necessary to specify that said opinion and the IGSC's report of indications of infraction are not binding on the IGCC, as established in the second paragraph of article 9 of the New Sanctions Regulation 9 10;
61. That, in this way it follows that in the evaluation of the facts related to this PAS, two (02) other organs or administrative instances of the SMV, functionally independent of each other and of this Deputy Superintendency, have intervened and participated prior to the issuance of this resolution; first the IGSC which in due course reported the indications of infraction through Report No. 703-2019-SMV/11.1, and then the IGCC which, as a result of its evaluation, formulated the Statement of Charges and the Report; and at this point of the PAS it corresponds to the Office of the SASCM to issue a pronouncement and decision regarding the aforementioned charge, it being necessary to indicate that by the nature thereof, as previously stated, it will be a first-instance administrative decision;
62. That the Office of the SASCM declares and establishes that all the defenses, arguments and/or briefs submitted by SOA Noles, which are in the present file, have been analyzed by the aforementioned bodies and instances. Likewise, it is recorded that extracts of the arguments of defenses and arguments are also transcribed, by way of reference. This does not imply that the points of its defenses and arguments have ceased to be analyzed, and even less that by not transcribing all its defenses and arguments, it could later be argued that there was an impairment of the right of defense and due process. In any case, all the documentation containing said defenses and arguments is in the present PAS file;
63. That, regarding the information presented to the RPMV, the following points have been evaluated;
A) ISA 250 "Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements" and ISA 700 "Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements"
64. That, it should not be overlooked that in the Audit Report 2017 issued and signed by SOA Noles itself, it expressly states:
[9] Article 245 of the TUO of the LPAG states as forms or modes in which the inspection activity could be concluded the following: 1) Record of conformity of the activity carried out by the administered; 2) Recommendation of improvements or corrections of the activity carried out by the administered; 3) The warning of the existence of non-compliances not susceptible of warranting the determination of administrative responsibilities; 4) The recommendation of the initiation of a procedure in order to determine the corresponding administrative responsibilities; 5) The adoption of corrective measures and 6) Other forms as established by special laws.
[10] "Article 9.- PRELIMINARY INQUIRIES AS A CONSEQUENCE OF SUPERVISION ACTIONS (…) When said bodies conclude that there are sufficient indications of possible administrative infractions, they refer the corresponding reports to the General Compliance Intendancies, which determine whether or not to initiate a sanctioning administrative procedure. If applicable, the General Compliance Intendancies may carry out additional inspections or investigations of the reported indications. (…)"
(…)
65. That, in the notes to the 2017 FS of JCR, and specifically in note 3, said ECR expressly states
66. That, as can be seen and evidenced, the Audit Report 2017, issued and signed by SOA Noles itself, did not consider the financial reporting framework applicable to JCR, to issue said report;
67. That, in relation to SOA Noles' argument that, in accordance with the provisions of its working paper called Planning Memorandum, which includes the evaluation of audit risks, , the Superintendency Resolution No. 070-2017-SMV/02 and No. 089-2017-SMV/02 issued by the SMV regarding the suspension of operation authorization was taken into consideration, pursuant to paragraph 4 of ISA 250, and they held meetings with management to communicate possible non-compliances pursuant to paragraph 19 of ISA 250; it should be noted that the present PAS refers to the fact that in the Audit Report 2017, SOA Noles issued an opinion on the 2017 FS of JCR; prepared based on generally accepted accounting principles in Peru, despite the existence of an express legal provision, in article 1 of the Norms, which clearly establishes JCR's obligation to prepare its financial statements in accordance with the aforementioned IFRS, which is the standard for the preparation and presentation of financial statements that it should observe and not another concept under any denomination. In this regard, it should be taken into consideration that paragraph 16 of IAS "Presentation of Financial Statements" states that «(…) 16. An entity whose financial statements comply with IFRS shall make an explicit and unreserved statement of such compliance in the notes (…) »;
68. That, consequently, the present PAS does not question the procedures that SOA Noles may have carried out to evaluate compliance with the resolutions mentioned in the previous paragraph, nor its procedure to evaluate possible indications of non-compliance, by its client, with other legal and regulatory provisions;
69. That, in relation to the arguments referring to the fact that i) paragraph No. 2 of the Audit Report 2017 serves to mention the bases on which the financial statements are prepared "whatever the basis on which said financial statements were prepared", ii) when the regulatory framework on which the financial statements were prepared is not in accordance with the correct required regulations, the auditor's responsibility is to measure the effect of the misstatements; and iii) when the impact "of having applied the correct basis" were significant, the auditor must qualify the audit opinion in its report; it is observed that SOA Noles intends to have it accepted that in the securities market —in which the financial statements of its participants and everything related to them are an essential element for transparency and the other legal interests that must be protected—, it is legally possible and normal for an SOA to carry out an external audit and issue an audit report opining on the reasonableness of the financial statements of a securities market participant, when these have been prepared contrary to the norm or under a standard different from the one expressly established in legal norms and that must be complied with, which, as is easy to notice, has no legal basis and is even irrational;
70. That, it is necessary to add that the arguments of SOA Noles contradict the provisions of ISA 210 paragraphs 411 and 612, which indicate that it is the auditor's obligation to determine, prior to the audit, whether the financial reporting framework used by the audited entity for the preparation of its financial statements is acceptable (precondition for the audit), therefore, it is unfounded to suggest or affirm that an auditor can accept an audit engagement without having previously determined which standard corresponds to the preparation of the entity's financial statements, and even more so if said standard is established in a legal norm;
71. That, for greater precision, it should be noted that paragraph 13 letter a) of ISA 200 "Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing" and the Glossary of the Manual of Pronouncements
[11] "Definitions 4. For the purposes of the ISAs, the following term has the meaning set out below: Preconditions for an audit: the use by management of an acceptable financial reporting framework in the preparation of the financial statements and the agreement of management and, where appropriate, those charged with governance to the premise on which an audit is conducted."
[12] "Preconditions for an audit 6. In order to establish whether the preconditions for an audit are present, the auditor shall: (a) determine whether the financial reporting framework to be applied in the preparation of the financial statements is acceptable; and (Ref: Paragraphs A2-A10) (b) obtain the agreement of management that it acknowledges and understands its responsibility: (Ref: Paragraphs A11-A14, A20)"
International Standards on Quality Control, Auditing, Review, Other Assurance, and Related Services, 2013 edition, establish the following definition: "Applicable financial reporting framework - the financial reporting framework adopted by management and, where appropriate, those charged with governance in the preparation of the financial statements, and that is acceptable in view of the nature of the entity and the objective of the financial statements, or that is required by law or regulation. (...)";
72. That, in this regard, it is necessary to add that ISA 210 paragraph A413 establishes requirements and provides guidance to determine whether a financial reporting framework is acceptable. In application of said ISA, in the present case SOA Noles should have taken into consideration the following factors:
The nature of the entity: a company registered in the RPMV whose operations and financial information are regulated by the SMV, whose legislation requires, since 2010, IFRS as the sole standard for the preparation and presentation of the financial statements of the companies under its supervision.
The objective of the financial statements: the audited annual financial statements of entities supervised by the SMV are disseminated to the Securities Market for the use of investors and public access in general, which classifies them as General Purpose Financial Statements14 .
The legal or regulatory provisions: the Standards, applicable to the ECR authorized by the SMV, establish that IFRS are the only financial reporting framework that risk rating companies must apply in the preparation and presentation of their financial information.
73. That, in addition, paragraph A915 of the aforementioned ISA specifies that when legal or regulatory provisions establish the financial reporting framework to be used in the preparation of financial information of certain types of entities, unless otherwise provided, the auditor must presume that said financial reporting framework is acceptable for the financial statements of such entities;
74. That, in that line of reasoning, in accordance with article 1 of the Standards, IFRS constitute the applicable financial reporting framework for ECRs, therefore, an audit firm that accepts the audit engagement of a
[13] "Determination of the Acceptability of the Financial Reporting Framework A4. The factors relevant to the auditor's determination of whether the financial reporting framework applied in the preparation of the financial statements is acceptable include, among others: • the nature of the entity (for example, whether it is a commercial enterprise, a public sector entity or a not-for-profit organization); • the objective of the financial statements (for example, whether they are prepared to meet the common financial information needs of a wide range of users or the financial information needs of specific users); • the nature of the financial statements (for example, whether the financial statements are a complete set of financial statements or a single financial statement); and whether the legal or regulatory provisions prescribe the applicable financial reporting framework."
[14] In accordance with paragraph A5 of ISA 210, general purpose financial statements are prepared to meet the common financial information needs of a wide range of users
[15] "Financial Reporting Frameworks Prescribed by Law or Regulation A9. In accordance with paragraph 6(a), the auditor is required to determine whether the financial reporting framework to be used in the preparation of the financial statements is acceptable. In some jurisdictions, law or regulation may prescribe the financial reporting framework to be used in the preparation of general purpose financial statements of certain types of entities. Unless otherwise provided, it shall be presumed that said financial reporting framework is acceptable for the general purpose financial statements prepared by said entities. If the framework is not considered acceptable, paragraphs 19-20 shall apply.”
risk rating company must have previously determined that the financial reporting framework that said company will use in preparing its financial information is the acceptable one, that is, IFRS; and it must perform the audit work using the principles established in said standards in order to form an opinion on whether the financial statements have been prepared, in all material respects, in accordance with said framework and shall evaluate whether the financial statements describe IFRS or refer to them adequately, in accordance with paragraphs 10 and 15 of ISA 700;
75. That, in that sense and in observance of the regulations, SOA Noles should have determined that IFRS were the preparation standard for JCR's 2017 financial statements and not another, and consequently there is the fact that SOA Noles did not act in accordance with the standards and did not apply due diligence, when issuing the 2017 Audit Report opining on financial statements that were not prepared in accordance with the legally established preparation standard, and therefore breached ISA 700;
76. That, in accordance with the legal provisions applicable and enforceable against JCR, its financial statements submitted to the SMV must be prepared and presented in accordance with IFRS, and consistently with this, the audit reports that opine on such financial statements, and that are submitted to the SMV, must not refer to a financial reporting framework other than IFRS. For the foregoing, what was indicated by SOA Noles when it states that “because the company should have prepared its financial statements based on International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) we proceeded to evaluate their impact, as if IFRS had been applied” has no basis and is not supportable;
77. That, as can be seen in the previous images of the aforementioned Audit Report, SOA Noles issued an opinion that contains a qualification, although it is not clearly identified as such, since under the subtitle «Matters to Consider», it limits itself to stating that the recording of deferred operating income and costs will be perfected as of 2018, omitting to disclose a description and quantification of the financial effects of the misstatement in the 2017 Audit Report, which, with respect to equity, would be the following:
Prepared by the IGSC
29
78. That, in relation to SOA Noles' observation
that the amounts expressed in the cited table are in soles and not in thousands of soles, and that this could affect the materiality criterion; it should be noted that the aforementioned table has been prepared by the IGSC in Report No. 703-2019-SMV/11.1 of 27 June 2019 indicating that the data correspond to the Audited Individual Annual Financial Statements of fiscal year 2017 and to the 2017 Audit Report, which are expressed in soles and coincide with the data incorporated in this
table, the same ones that have been taken into consideration by the IGCC when issuing the
Letter of Charges, and are described therein;
79. That, in this regard, it should be specified that in the
present PAS it is not being questioned whether the amount of the misstatement is material or not, since SOA Noles itself considered that there were material misstatements in the Audited Individual Annual Financial Statements of JCR for fiscal year 2017, which is why it issued a modified opinion (with qualifications);
80. That, additionally, in relation to the argument of
SOA Noles referring to the fact that in the writing of 16 November 2018, in response to Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/11.1, a greater analysis of the qualification set out in the 2017 Audit Report was provided, because a detailed explanation was requested of the adjustments that JCR should make to correct the aforementioned observation; it should be noted that the present PAS refers to the fact that in the 2017 Audit Report, SOA Noles failed to include a description and quantification of the financial effects of the material misstatements, that is, it did not describe the effect of said misstatements on other accounting items, on net income and/or on the net equity of the audited entity, as follows from paragraph A18 of ISA 705. The aforementioned writing, as shown below, confirms that SOA Noles was aware of the implications of the misstatements on other items and, never theless, was not transparent or clear because it did not include it in its 2017 Audit Report:
“The Company, had it considered the proposed adjustments, would decrease accounts receivable from S/ 603 thousand to S/. 5 thousand and accumulated results would decrease from S/ (626) thousand to S/ (1,308) thousand with a net effect on other non-financial assets from S/ 78 thousand to S/ (6) thousand. Consequently, total assets would decrease from S/. 1,782 thousand to S/ 1,100 thousand and total equity from S/ 1,627 thousand to S/ 945 thousand”;
81. That, in relation to SOA Noles' argument
referring to the fact that for a reader of financial information the explanation of the adjustments in the 2017 Audit Report were correctly expressed and that the title of «Matters to Consider» adequately alerts the reader to a situation that affects the reasonableness of the financial statements; it should be noted that, in accordance with paragraph 16 of ISA 705, when an auditor issues an opinion with qualifications, the paragraph in which the description of the fact giving rise to the
modification is included must be titled «Basis for Qualified Opinion»; therefore, SOA Noles' explanation has no correlate in the ISAs and therefore lacks basis;
82. That, in relation to what was stated by SOA Noles in the oral report, which points out that “(…) one of the observations made to us indicating that we therefore do not comply with ISA 705, is because the standard says that to include a qualification paragraph you must title it “Basis for the issuance of your opinion” and under that title you must put the qualification, we put “Matters to Consider” (…) we put a title that was much more descriptive (…) and there we put the qualification (…) I consider that the application of article 16 of the preface to the Auditing Standards (…), the auditor who has experience can apply their professional judgment to try to say things better, to say things more clearly, taking into account the reader of the financial statements (…)”16;
83. That, it should be noted that the ISAs establish the structure for preparing an audit report, in order to provide clear and precise information on its content. In that sense, the statement by SOA Noles does not conform to the provisions of paragraphs 16 and 2217 of ISA 705, which establish that when it is a qualified opinion the auditor must present the description of the matter giving rise to the qualification in a paragraph that must be titled “Basis for Qualified Opinion” and the modified opinion must be contained in a paragraph that must be titled “Qualified Opinion”. Furthermore, when SOA Noles decides to place in its Opinion paragraph that «in our opinion, giving consideration to what is stated in the previous paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present fairly, in all material respects […]» (the underlining is ours), it does not take into account the provisions of paragraph A22 of ISA 705, which establishes that when an auditor expresses a qualified opinion it is not appropriate to use phrases such as «in view of the foregoing explanation» in the opinion paragraph, since they are not sufficiently clear or categorical and may lead to confusion, and all the more so if there is a specific ISA that refers to the manner in which a qualification must be presented;
84. That, the 2017 Audit Report must contain precise, complete and clear information, in accordance with article 42 of the Financial Information Regulation, which allows any reader to have an adequate analysis of the company's financial situation, which becomes more relevant when it is a company supervised by the SMV; on the contrary, the lack of complete or precise information about a fact or situation may lead to error or confusion; consequently, what was argued by SOA Noles lacks foundation;
[16] Consult from 00:27:22 hours to 00:29:18 hours of the recording of the Oral Report that forms part of the Minutes of the use of the floor of 17 January 2022, which was carried out via the SMV electronic platform.
[17] ISA 705 Modifications to the Opinion in the Independent Auditor's Report “Basis for Modification of Opinion paragraph 16. When the auditor expresses a modified opinion on the financial statements, in addition to the specific elements required by ISA 700, the auditor shall include a paragraph in the audit report that provides a description of the matter giving rise to the modification. The auditor shall place this paragraph immediately before the opinion paragraph in the audit report, with the heading “Basis for Qualified Opinion”, “Basis for Adverse Opinion” or “Basis for Disclaimer of Opinion”, as appropriate. (Ref: Paragraph A17)” “Opinion paragraph 22. When the auditor expresses a modified opinion, the opinion paragraph shall have the heading “Qualified Opinion”, “Adverse Opinion” or “Disclaimer of Opinion”, as appropriate. (Ref: Paragraphs A21, A23-A24)”
85. That, in relation to the audit work carried out on the item «Installations, furniture and equipment, net», SOA Noles did not apply the necessary procedures to obtain sufficient audit evidence, nor did it conduct the audit with professional skepticism, taking into consideration the following audit evidence:
(i) SOA Noles has not attached evidence of any request or inquiry it made in its audit work in relation to the invoices issued by a company that was not part of the Adequacy Contract.
(ii) Although SOA Noles presented the accounting vouchers and checks issued to settle four (04) invoices, as evidence of the payments made by JCR to the supplier, said documentation does not evidence payment to the supplier since the checks were made payable to six (6) JCR workers, who are dedicated exclusively to tasks related to risk classification, but not to treasury or company administration functions or similar whose work is the payment to suppliers.
On this matter, from the review of the letter of 12 December 2018, in response to Official Letter No. 6781-2018-SMV/11.1, in which SOA Noles states that the representation it received from the Management of JCR was that checks were issued in the name of workers in order to carry out greater supervision and monitoring of the progress of the work; it is observed that such explanation does not constitute sufficient and appropriate audit evidence that allows validating the payment to the supplier; consequently, in the absence of sufficient evidence and the unusual nature of the circumstances in which the payment for the acquisition of the asset would have been made, the professional skepticism that an auditor must maintain throughout the audit required the auditor to question the reliability of the documents obtained and of the responses of the Management of JCR, and to evaluate the need to perform additional audit procedures and investigations in order to obtain sufficient audit evidence to corroborate the responses of the Management of JCR in such a way that allows it to conclude on the referred item. That is, in the face of an item or increase in the item «Instalaciones, mobiliario y equipo, neto» for a significant amount, SOA Noles should not have settled for only a simple representation from Management, and due to due diligence it should have applied greater procedures. In that sense, it is necessary to point out and make clearly established that this Deputy Superintendency considers that the verification or audit procedures whose purpose is to evaluate the legitimacy, integrity or documentary support of a material item of a company's financial statements cannot remain or be reduced to obtaining a sworn statement from Management in such or such sense, since ultimately that procedure, which must be rejected outright, would generate the risk that external audits could be diminished and degraded to the mere and sole obtaining by the external auditor of sworn statements from the General Management of the auditee in a certain sense, thereby breaking the purpose and usefulness of an external audit that by definition must be impartial and independent and even more so if it is governed by legal and professional standards such as the ISAs;
86. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument that, because it was an on-site audit work, its review of the item «Instalaciones, mobiliario y equipo, neto» included a physical inspection that allowed them to observe the characteristics of the referred asset and validate its existence; it should be noted that, in accordance with ISA 500 «Audit Evidence» paragraph A1618, although a physical inspection can provide audit evidence about the existence of an asset, it does not necessarily provide sufficient evidence about other assertions, such as rights and obligations of the entity or the measurement of the asset (the amount that is recognized in the financial statements), therefore, the physical inspection of the asset does not constitute sufficient audit evidence to conclude on the referred item, and it is necessary for the auditor to perform other procedures, and all the more so in the case of an entity such as an ECR that has to comply with capital and minimum equity requirements that are related precisely to the legitimacy of the items that have an effect or relationship with such requirements;
87. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument that “The observations indicated that there is a supplier that does not appear in the contract, as is the case of Distribuidora Comercial Multinacional del Perú, is only a formality (…)”; it should be indicated that said observation has not been incorporated in the Statement of Charges, consequently, it is not appropriate to issue a pronouncement in that regard;
88. That, in the present PAS, SOA Noles is not questioned regarding the verification of the legality of the disbursements made to the workers of JCR, who are dedicated exclusively to risk classification tasks, nor the means of payment used; rather, SOA Noles does not have the audit documentation that evidences the payment made to the supplier, having limited itself to obtaining only checks issued in the name of the referred workers and the representations of Management, consequently, the validity of Law 30730 was not required for SOA Noles to have applied the additional audit procedures and due diligence in order to obtain sufficient audit evidence that allows it to conclude on the existence and valuation (measurement) of the asset;
89. That, in addition, from the review of the working papers presented by SOA Noles, no documentation has been identified that evidences the verification of payment to the supplier. Although the document called “Validación de adquisiciones del periodo – Instalaciones” has been identified, which is in the file and is attached as an Annex to the Report, and which refers to the procedures that would have been performed on the item «Instalaciones, mobiliario y equipo», in said document it is not observed that SOA Noles explains and evidences its procedure for verifying payment to the supplier, furthermore the copy of the checks issued in the name of the referred workers do not evidence the payment to the supplier that JCR would have made;
90. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument about the elapsed time, and the principle of opportunity19, cited in the Oral Report, the initiation of the present PAS; it should be noted that the Administrative authority has a period of four (4) years to determine the existence of administrative infractions, of
[18] ISA 500 "Audit Evidence" paragraph A16: The inspection of tangible assets may provide reliable audit evidence regarding their existence, but not necessarily regarding the entity's rights and obligations or the valuation of the assets [...].
[19] See from 00:03:42 hours to 00:06:40 hours of the recording of the Oral Report that is part of the Record of the right to speak of 17 January 2022, which was carried out via the SMV electronic platform.
in accordance with the provisions of article 42 of the New Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with article 252 of the TUO of the LPAG;
91. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument that the audit reports for fiscal years 2018 and 2019 were issued without qualifications, and that the auditor's responsibility extends until the next auditor issues its new audit report; it should be noted that the fact that the subsequent audit firms issued unqualified audit reports for fiscal years 2018 and 2019 does not exempt SOA Noles from responsibility, because administrative infractions for non-compliance with ISAs are committed when the audit report is issued and each audit firm is responsible for compliance with the ISAs to prepare and issue its audit report or Audit Report;
92. That, it should be noted that said situation constitutes a sanction criterion established in article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation, so this has been evaluated in section "V. Determination of the sanction".
93. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument that professional judgment will always prevail over a standard, it should be noted that such statement is not consistent with paragraph 16 of the Preface of the "Manual of International Pronouncements on Quality Control, Auditing, Review, Other Assurance Engagements, and Related Services" cited by SOA Noles, and, on the contrary, contradicts paragraph 3 of said Preface, which establishes: "The IAASB procedures govern audit, review, other assurance engagements and related services engagements performed in accordance with the International Standards. These do not override the legal and regulatory provisions governing the audit of financial statements or assurance engagements on other information in a given country, which must be respected in accordance with the national standards of that country.";
94. That, more specifically regarding the exercise of professional judgment, letter k) of paragraph 13 of ISA 200 establishes: "(k) Professional judgment: the application of relevant training, knowledge and experience, within the context of auditing, accounting and ethical standards, in making informed decisions about the appropriate course of action based on the circumstances of the audit engagement", and paragraph A27 of said standard states that "(...) professional judgment should not be applied as a justification for decisions that are otherwise not supported by the facts and circumstances of the engagement or by sufficient and appropriate audit evidence"; consequently, the aforementioned argument of SOA Noles does not take into consideration the Preface of said manual and ISA 200, so it is not admissible;
95. That, regarding SOA Noles highlighting the audit work it has performed in different companies, the accreditations and credentials of its partner, among others, to support that they exercised their professional judgment; it should be noted that since this PAS is based on the facts and charges imputed in the Charge Document, which have been evaluated with the defenses presented in previous paragraphs, and in accordance with the principle of culpability that holds responsible whoever commits the unlawful act, what SOA Noles has expressed does not exempt it from responsibility;
96. That, it should be noted that the arguments presented by SOA Noles regarding materiality have been analyzed in section "A) Regarding ISA 250 'Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements' and ISA 700 'Forming an Opinion and Reporting on Financial Statements', so we should refer to the evaluation that has been made regarding the mentioned point;
97. That, regarding SOA Noles' argument that "the auditor's work is to evaluate, examine and issue an opinion, not to apply any standard on the financial statements"; it should be specified that, in accordance with ISA 210 paragraph A2, the applicable financial reporting framework provides the criteria that the auditor must use in the audit of the financial statements, therefore, the auditor during its audit must use the applicable financial reporting framework, which in this case, as it is a risk rating company, is IFRS, which has been extensively developed in section IV, numeral 4.2. Evaluation of the Case, letter A of this Resolution;
98. That, regarding what was stated by the legal advisor of SOA Noles at the hearing of the right to speak on 17 January 2021, that the principle of presumption of innocence20 has not been rebutted; it should be noted that said principle is recognized in numeral 9 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG which establishes: "Presumption of lawfulness.- Entities must presume that the administered have acted in accordance with their duties as long as they do not have evidence to the contrary." (Underline added);
99. That, in view of the fact that sufficient evidence has been gathered regarding the facts and the authorship of SOA Noles, and a sufficient logical reasoning has also been carried out that articulates all the elements of the infraction type in previous paragraphs, it has been possible to obtain conviction that SOA Noles has administrative responsibility for the non-compliance with the aforementioned NIAs, and therefore, in the present case there is evidence to the contrary of the principle of lawfulness;
100. That, in relation to the document of 17 January 2022, in which SOA Noles records that the reason for which it requested the rescheduling of the hearing; it should be noted that on 17 January 2022 the hearing for the exercise of the right to speak was held, with the attendance of Messrs. Walter Rivera Vílchez and Walter A. Noles Monteblanco, as well as with the intervention of the Acting General Intendant despite his presence not being required in accordance with the TUO of the LPAG, a hearing in which SOA Noles presented its defense arguments and these have been evaluated in the Report and in this Resolution, by virtue of its right of defense and due process;
101. That, it is appropriate to note that the IGCC, as the instructing body, has complied with making available to SOA Noles all the evidentiary means acted upon that support each of the facts described in the Letter of Charges, observing the guarantees provided for within the framework of effective judicial protection, and within the framework of said guarantees, SOA Noles presented its discharges regarding the imputed facts, in exercise of its right to defense, the same that have been
[20] Consult from 00:20:22 hours to 00:21:18 hours of the recording of the Oral Report that forms part of the Minutes of the use of the right to speak of 17 January 2022, which was carried out via the electronic platform of the SMV.
subject of evaluation and assessment in the Report and in this resolution; consequently, this resolving body has complied with respecting the principles of the sanctioning power in the present PAS;
102. That, by document of 07 February 2021, SOA Noles formulated the following allegations, in accordance with numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG:
1. SOA Noles indicates that the evaluation of its discharges has not been correct or sufficient due to the need for knowledge of important audit fundamentals and concepts, of control evaluation and of standards that are transversal to any audit, such as materiality, selective tests and other criteria that increase diligence in the execution of procedures.
2. Regarding the evaluation of its discharges related to ISA 250 and 700
2.1 SOA Noles asserts that IFRS do not constitute a substantial change with respect to GAAP, which is why, in its understanding, the SMV continued to receive financial information under the GAAP framework during 2017, being able to draw a parallel regarding the changes in criteria applicable to some items, of which, in some cases, the balances remain intact as a consequence of applying the IFRS regulatory framework, because the criteria are similar. Regarding this observation, SOA Noles considers that the conclusion in the last paragraph of page 16 of the Report comes from an erroneous interpretation.
2.2 Additionally, SOA Noles points out that there is no ISA that indicates that an auditor of a risk rating company "could not" accept an engagement, because the ISAs are general and are not made for specific sectors or for business items in particular such as risk rating companies. The ISAs are applicable to all audit engagements, regardless of the business sector. On the other hand, SOA Noles adds that the ISAs do not regulate the contract between the parties; which is a faculty and responsibility of theirs. The auditor agrees the audit engagement with a client, generally with a prior panoramic evaluation that would serve to ratify or not its acceptance based on the level of risk to be assumed, and to establish a level of hours and fees. Upon concluding its audit or during the development of the same, it will pronounce on what it examined, and the findings resulting from its examination in the environment of ISA 320: materiality and relative importance.
2.3 SOA Noles mentions that the function of the auditor is to audit, evaluate and measure the effects of material misstatements in order, based on the postulates of the materiality ISA (ISA 320), to pronounce together with its opinion; if the magnitude of the misstatement justified it; which is the foundation of all auditing; the same that does not require greater argument than the definition and philosophical foundation of what an audit is.
2.4 SOA Noles affirms that a biased and tendentious interpretation is being made of what is established in the ISAs, without considering the conceptual frameworks of auditing. But an even greater error is that the interpretation is incorrect for being insufficient; and, in the ways of interpretation, lacking sufficient experience, which only competence in the field gives, it is intended to suggest a sanction.
2.5 SOA Noles indicates that upon being engaged with the audit
since August 2017, and having identified through the execution of the same that the regulatory framework had not yet been adapted to IFRS, we applied the procedures established by ISA 250, paragraphs 19, 20 and 22. As well as other audit procedures that we consider necessary according to the circumstances. In this regard, we decided to include in our internal control letter, the non-adaptation to IFRSs, of the financial statements prepared and presented by the entity. They made said decision in merit to the evaluation and quantification of the IFRS impact, had it been carried out by the entity. Likewise, we must mention that during 2017 and on a quarterly basis the SMV received said financial information.
2.6 Finally, with respect to ISA 700, which refers to the form and content of the audit report, SOA Noles considers that its report complies with everything established in the aforementioned ISA; moreover, with regard to the interpretation made in the evaluation of this charge, which clarifies and affirms its position in paragraph 15 of the aforementioned ISA.
3. Regarding the evaluation of point B) referring to ISA 705; the observation focuses on two aspects. The first is the observation of a greater explanation in the wording of the qualification; and the second, in the title with which the qualification is presented.
3.1 SOA Noles considers that all the elements required by the ISA referring to the form and content of an audit report have been strictly complied with, taking into consideration the indication in paragraph 16 of the preface, in the ISA manual, which establishes that the application of all ISAs must be subject to the professional judgment of the auditor; applicable both to the interpretation and to the definition of the nature, scope and timing of the audit procedures to be applied, which is why it considers that, as an alert to the reader, beyond the suggestion established by the ISA, the title “Matters to Consider” is a more effective alert to associate the drafted qualification with the interpretation of the financial statements.
This positive variation of a phrase from the ISA; is not sufficient reason to indicate that it is not complying with ISA 705, which comprises 43 pages of guidelines in relation to the modified opinion.
3.2 Regarding the wording and content of the qualification, it refers to the claim that the form of explanation given in the special report on June 2018, on the situation of the aforementioned qualification mentioned in its December 2017 report (which had not yet been corrected on 20 June 2018) be related to the wording of the 2017 audit report. When considering that the special report as of June 2018 has been drafted under the protection of article 42 of the SMV Financial Information Regulation, which corresponds to a follow-up of an observation, which must be explained in a special report, which is not in accordance with the ISAs. Therefore, it is a serious lack of knowledge to request that the wording of a special report, which could have even included accounting mechanics; and which obviously is made for other explanatory purposes of an internal nature, be intended to be applied to the wording of a professional audit report on the financial statements prepared in accordance with ISAs.
3.3 The drafting of an audit opinion requires a great deal of audit experience in order to professionally set out any qualification for the reader of the financial statements; and the firm has drafted this qualification, as ISA states, setting out the amount of the misstatement. Likewise, identifying the line items that are affected; and obviously on the understanding that an audit report is a document that will serve people knowledgeable in reading financial statements. Otherwise, any wording would be insufficient, as it has seemed to the evaluator, whose level of accounting culture, we understand, has not allowed him to understand in this way the relationship between accounting regulations and mechanics, and the impact of misstatements on the financial statements, as well as the philosophy and content of an audit opinion.
3.4 Therefore SOA Noles appeals to the high professional judgment of the Deputy Superintendent so that, in the interest of justice, he set aside this observation regarding the extent of the wording of the observation; which it considers says what it should say, since it includes the nature of the misstatement, its effect, the amounts involved and the line items affected; but which, for the evaluator, should have been expanded in its explanation; to a level that is possibly within his understanding; which enters the realm of pure interpretation of a cognitive and subjective nature.
4. Regarding point C), the following is concluded in the second paragraph of page 22 of the Report:
"It should be noted that, from the review of the working papers submitted by SOA Noles, the document evidencing verification of payment to the supplier has not been identified, although the document entitled "Validation of acquisitions of the period – Facilities" has been identified, which is in the file and is attached as an Annex to this report, in which, although reference is made to the procedures that would have been performed on the property, plant and equipment item, in this document it is not observed that SOA Noles evidences verification of payment to the supplier; furthermore, the copy of the checks issued in the name of the aforementioned workers does not evidence the payment to the supplier that JCR would have made".
5. It also states that, having applied audit procedures that it considers sufficient in accordance with its planning and professional judgment; a summary sheet of which is attached on page 31 of the Report; and since the only observation made by the evaluator concerns the evidence of payment to the supplier; it is striking that this only observation, which it does not share, and which in no way invalidates the opinion on the reasonableness of the item examined, is sufficient for its conclusions to state that ISA 200 "Overall objectives of the independent auditor and the conduct of an audit in accordance with International Standards on Auditing" was not complied with, nor ISA 240, "The auditor's responsibilities relating to fraud in an audit of financial statements"; and finally nor ISA 500, "Audit evidence"; as if the entire audit had consisted of evaluating only this single transaction to which reference is made.
6. The imbalance in this evaluation is evident, regarding which it is being proposed to qualify that such important NIAs are not complied with; so dense and that have applications for all the items of the financial statements. Therefore, it resorts to an impartial criterion to correct this situation definitively, which is only leading to the use of a significant number of hours in an alleged case, undermining the administrative principle of timeliness and usefulness; upon entering the fifth subsequent year after conducting the audit. Approximate date on which, according to article 42 of the Financial Information Regulation, the conservation of the working papers and, by analogy, the review, would prescribe.
7. SOA Noles points out that beyond this, it is considered that with its high judgment, experience and professional trajectory, this Firm has the opportunity to correct these excesses of interpretation regarding the evaluations carried out by the personnel signing this Report, who, lacking sufficient professional experience in the execution of audits, have carried out a review from a theoretical perspective.
8. Finally, SOA Noles indicates the following:
There has never been any history of sanction in the institution
There has never been any recidivism for the commission of any infraction
There has been no harm caused
There has been no illicit resulting from the commission of any infraction
All audit working papers and information subsequently requested, and especially regarding this audit, have always been made available to the SMV
No damage to the public interest arising from the alleged non-compliance with any NIA has been evidenced.
There is no willful or malicious conduct.
9. SOA Noles concludes by stating that the elements of judgment set forth in its arguments must be assessed, finding them compliant and fair, which rule out the possibility of continuing with this sanctioning process, ordering its definitive archiving, and thanking consideration that its request corresponds to a just cause; considering that the responses to the imputations have been clarified with the attached arguments.
103. That, regarding said arguments we can state the following:
1.1 In relation to what was stated by SOA Noles regarding that the SMV has received financial information prepared under the standard called GAAP because there is no substantial difference between IFRS and the aforementioned GAAP; it is necessary to point out that this indication must be rejected outright as it has no legal basis, mainly because —as has been previously supported—, it has been legally established that the preparation standard for the financial statements of an ECR is that of the IFRS approved by the IASB and internationally in force.
Therefore, it has no legal basis and it is not correct to argue or indicate, as SOA Noles does, that any other "standard" for the preparation of financial statements of an ECR, other than the referred IFRSs, is acceptable because it would not have a significant difference or material effect on said financial statements, simply we repeat because the legal norm does not allow it.
Without prejudice to this, it is necessary to indicate that companies that by legal obligation must present their financial statements in accordance with IFRS, present together with their financial information a "Sworn Statement of Compliance with IFRS" through which they state that their financial information has been prepared and presented in accordance with IFRS.
It should be added that the delivery or presentation of financial information by a company supervised by the SMV, which is even disseminated on the SMV Portal, in no way represents any approval of it by the SMV, and even less does it mean a certification that those financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the aforementioned IFRS, since that is the responsibility of that company in accordance with the legal framework that is enforceable and applicable to it.
1.2 In relation to the statement by SOA Noles that there is no NIA that indicates that the auditor of a risk rating company "could not" accept an engagement, because the NIAs are general and are not made for specific sectors, nor for particular business items such as risk rating companies[Carlos it seems to me that in green the idea is missing completion]; it should be specified that SOA Noles does not take into consideration paragraphs 7 and 8 of NIA 210, in which it is clearly stated that when the proposal of the terms of the audit engagement includes the imposition of a limitation on the scope of the audit or when it is determined that the financial information framework to be used for the preparation of the financial statements is not acceptable, the auditor shall not accept the audit engagement, unless required to do so by legal or regulatory provisions.
Therefore, what the Report indicates is that, in accordance with NIA 210, an auditor, who intends to carry out an audit applying the NIAs, will not accept an audit engagement, in certain circumstances, such as, for example, when the auditor becomes aware that the company to be audited, in the preparation of its general purpose financial statements, will use a financial information framework that does not comply with the definition of applicable financial information framework such as IFRS for risk rating companies authorized and supervised by the SMV.
In that line of reasoning, an auditor who, in exercise of their freedom of contract, decides to accept an audit engagement without complying with any of the requirements of any applicable ISA, may do so; however, they must not and cannot state, in their audit report, that they have complied with the ISAs, unless they have complied with all the applicable requirements of the ISAs, as established by ISA 200 paragraph 20 and ISA 700 paragraph A26.
In other words, it makes no sense nor is it legitimate that an external auditor who performs a highly specialized task such as an external audit —and who, as an elementary aspect of said examination—, should know the rule or standard that establishes what the preparation standard is for the financial statements on which they will issue an opinion, states that this rule does not matter and that therefore said preparation standard also does not matter, because subjectively or by their sole criterion, they have performed a materiality analysis or an analysis under any other name, which has led them to conclude that they can issue an opinion and they issue it, thereby acknowledging and admitting that under their supposed criterion or professional judgment they can do whatever they please and fail to comply with or consider the established legal standards, thereby indicating that legal standards do not matter to them.
An argument in that sense is not only dangerous because of everything it implies but also because it warns of a person who considers that their "professional" criterion and/or subjectivity is above legal standards, and this must not and cannot be overlooked.
1.3 SOA Noles indicates that the ISAs do not regulate the audit contract since this is the faculty and responsibility of the contracting parties; however, part of the functions and responsibilities that both the auditor and the audited company have, at the time of agreeing the terms of the audit engagement, are established in ISA 210 and have to do with the concurrence of the preconditions for the audit, which although it is an aspect that is under the control of the audited entity, it is the auditor's responsibility to verify that these conditions are met before accepting the engagement, as specified in paragraphs 1 and 3 of ISA 210.
1.4 SOA Noles, in its Letter No. NM 277/2021/WN dated 24 November 2021, stated that the procedure of quantifying and documenting in working papers and minutes the financial effects of JCR's non-compliance with the legal standard of applying IFRS in the preparation and presentation of its financial statements, obey or go hand in hand with paragraph 6 literal a) of ISA 250, which states the following:
1.5 According to said argument, the legal standard that establishes the obligation to apply IFRS was considered by SOA Noles as a legal and regulatory provision that, in a generally accepted manner, has a direct effect on the determination of the amounts and material information to be disclosed in the financial statements. For this type of legal and regulatory provisions, ISA 250 in its paragraphs 10 literal a), 13 and A8 clearly establishes that it is the auditor's obligation to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence regarding compliance with said legal and regulatory provisions, and that the auditor's objective is to determine that the amounts recognized and the information disclosed in the financial statements are in accordance with the legal and regulatory provisions; notwithstanding this, SOA Noles has not obtained evidence of compliance with article 1 of the standard that establishes the obligation to apply IFRS, nor has it determined that the information presented in JCR's financial statements is adequate and complies with the legal and regulatory provisions.
1.6 In letter No. NM 277/2021/WN dated 24 November 2021, SOA Noles states that, in accordance with paragraph 19 of ISA 250, they held meetings with JCR's Management to communicate the "potential non-compliances incurred". Subsequently, in its letter No. NM 030/2022/WN dated 07 February 2022, SOA Noles refers to having applied the procedures described in paragraphs 18, 19 and 21 of ISA 250, and highlights the requirement referred to obtaining additional information to evaluate the possible effect of the non-compliance on the financial statements of the audited company. In this regard, it should be noted that the aforementioned procedures are presented in ISA 250 as "Audit procedures when non-compliance is identified or suspected" and are applicable when, during the execution of the engagement, the auditor identifies a non-compliance or some indication of non-compliance; however, in the present case it was not a non-compliance that the auditor had identified during their audit work, but a non-compliance that was fully known and accepted by both parties (SOA Noles and JCR) before the audit work began, as stated in the Engagement Letter, a document that completely disproves what SOA Noles stated when it refers, in paragraph a6 of its last writing, that it would have "identified through the execution of the same (the audit) that the regulatory framework had not yet been adapted to IFRS".
1.7 On the other hand, it should be mentioned that the requirement of paragraph 18 of ISA 250 is expanded in paragraph A14 of the same standard, which establishes the following:
"Matters relevant to the auditor's evaluation (Ref.: Section 18 (b))
A14 Among the matters relevant to the auditor's evaluation of the possible effects on the financial statements are included:
The potential financial consequences of non-compliance with legal and regulatory provisions on the financial statements, including, for example, the imposition of fines, penalties, indemnities, threats of expropriation of assets, forced interruption of activities, and litigation.
That the potential financial consequences require to be disclosed.
That the potential financial consequences are so severe as to call into question the faithful presentation of the financial statements, or to make the financial statements misleading».
In this regard, the audit documentation presented by SOA Noles to support that, based on its evaluation, the effect of the non-compliance with article 1 of the Standards by JCR is a «low effect» or «non-significant impact», does not contemplate any of the relevant issues required in paragraph A14 of ISA 250; therefore, without prejudice to the charges imputed, SOA Noles would also not have complied with what is required in paragraphs 18 literal b) and A14 of ISA 250, in order to conclude that the effect of the non-compliance was low or non-significant.
Furthermore, even in the case that SOA Noles had adequately determined that the effects of the non-compliance were not material to the financial statements of JCR, SOA Noles should have evaluated the implications of said non-compliance in relation to other aspects of the audit and adopted the appropriate measures, such as considering, even, the need to resign from the engagement, as established in paragraphs 21 and A18 of ISA 250. All these evaluations have also not been included in the audit documentation presented by SOA Noles nor in its replies.
1.8 SOA Noles argues, in relation to paragraph 15 of ISA 700, the assumptions described in paragraphs A5 to A10 of ISA 700. In this regard, it is appropriate to note the following:
a. Paragraph A6 states that financial statements are considered to have been prepared in accordance with a financial reporting framework only if such financial statements comply with all the requirements of said framework; therefore, the materiality or effect of the misstatements identified as if JCR had applied IFRS, is not the correct criterion to determine that the financial statements of JCR were in accordance with IFRS.
b. The assumption of paragraph A8 of ISA 700 does not fit the case of SOA Noles because, although financial statements may indicate that they have been prepared in accordance with two (02) financial reporting frameworks, in order to do so they must comply with both frameworks simultaneously; however, in the case of the financial statements of JCR, not only do they not mention having complied with IFRS, but also in note 3 literal a) they clearly state that JCR has not prepared and presented its financial statements in full observance of IFRS; therefore, this assumption is not applicable to the audit of JCR.
c. Similarly, the assumption described in paragraph A10 of ISA 700 also does not fit the case of SOA Noles because, as explained in the two (02) previous paragraphs, the financial statements of JCR have not been prepared in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework, that is, IFRS.
2.1 SOA Noles states in paragraph b.1 of its brief that the requirement described in paragraph 16 of ISA 705 is a suggestion and that, in application of the professional judgment referred to in paragraph 16 of the preface of the ISA Manual, it considers that the title «Matters to consider» is a more effective alert than «Basis for Qualified Opinion», title expressly established in the referred paragraph.
In this regard, it must be mentioned that, in accordance with paragraphs 22 and A73 of ISA 200, the auditor must comply with each of the requirements of the ISAs, that is, their compliance is mandatory and not voluntary or discretionary or allows the auditor to do what their professional judgment determines, unless the ISA is not applicable in its entirety or the requirement is not applicable because it includes a condition and this does not concur.
Therefore, the requirement described in paragraph 16 of ISA 705 is not a suggestion, as SOA Noles incorrectly states, and the auditor is obliged to comply with it, and there is no doubt or questioning in this regard.
2.2 In relation to paragraph b.2 of the brief of SOA Noles, it is appropriate to note that in the Letter of Charges mention was made of the content of the brief of SOA Noles dated 16 November 2018, with the sole objective of highlighting that the auditor was aware of the effects of the misstatements in other accounting items, and therefore the omission of their quantification in the 2017 Audit Report was not due to the fact that the quantification of the financial effects was not feasible.
2.3 Finally, SOA Noles in paragraph b.3 of its brief states that a user with an adequate level of accounting culture can understand the incidence of the misstatements in the financial statements and the content of an opinion.
In this regard, it is appropriate to mention that the capacity and knowledge of the users of the financial statements do not exempt the auditor from their responsibility to include in their audit report all the information expressly required by the ISAs and to comply with their legal obligations referring precisely to the observance of the ISAs.
104. That, without prejudice to the analysis carried out and the conclusions previously exposed, on the other hand it is necessary to indicate that the texts of the paragraphs of the ISAs that are mentioned in the Letter of Charges, Report and in this Resolution have not been substantially modified in the 2016-2017 and 2018 Editions of the «Manual of International Pronouncements on Quality Control, Auditing, Review, Other Assurance Engagements, and Related Services» issued by the IAASB;
105. That, based on the evaluation of the defenses and arguments presented by SOA Noles, they are not sufficient to disprove the charge formulated and therefore to exempt it from responsibility; rather, on the contrary, its conduct regarding the infraction subject to charge is reprehensible insofar as it did not comply with its duty to prepare and present the Audit Report 2017, issued on 02 April 2018, observing ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500 in the audit of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, generating harm to the transparency of the information disseminated in the securities market, the protection of securities market investors and the confidence of such investors and the general public;
106. That, without prejudice to the conclusion indicated in the preceding paragraph, and as additional grounds, in the sense that external audit reports on the financial statements of a company authorized by the SMV, such as ECRs that are specialized participants in the Peruvian securities market, are of the highest necessity, relevance and usefulness for the securities market and its development, and that therefore, among other reasons, in the regulations non-compliances directly linked to such opinions—as in the particular case, not observing the ISAs—, have been reserved the highest level of infraction and sanction (they are very serious offenses), and must deserve from the SMV—as the securities market authority—, special attention and the application of measures or liability consequences for the offender that generate an effective disincentive for the repetition or appearance of infringing conducts of a similar nature. In that sense it is necessary to point out:
General purpose financial statements collect and reflect the financial reality of a company at a given date and its economic performance during a given period of time, in such a way that, through the financial statements, one can know how the company has evolved over time and mainly how it is currently, information about its viability as a going concern, and in certain cases such as the specific case of ECRs, the financial statements are the base and essential element that serves to verify compliance with basic requirements to continue operating, such as having the minimum level or amount of net equity that must not be less than the minimum capital amount required and established in the LMV.
The financial statements of a company, in addition to informing about the economic resources available to an entity, its rights and obligations with third parties, the rights of its creditors against it and the obligations with its owners; also provide information on how its Management and its other governing bodies have fulfilled their responsibilities regarding the efficient and effective use of the entity's economic resources.
Therefore, all relevant information referring to a company must and has to be collected in its financial statements, and precisely in this fact lies the importance of the information contained in the financial statements of a company, and all the more so if it is a company authorized by the SMV and that must comply with a minimum level of net equity.
In that sense, it is necessary to indicate that International Accounting Standard 1 "Presentation of Financial Statements" states that the objective of financial statements is to provide information about the financial situation, financial performance and cash flows, that is useful to a wide variety of users, for which financial statements must inform about the economic resources available to an entity and its rights against third parties (assets), obligations with third parties (liabilities), capital contributions and obligations derived from these (equity), income and expenses and cash flows.
Likewise, the notes to the financial statements, which are part of and complement the financial statements, provide relevant information of an entity such as the bases for the preparation of the financial statements and its significant accounting policies. In this regard, International Accounting Standard 8 "Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors" defines accounting policies as the specific principles, bases, conventions, rules and procedures adopted by an entity in the preparation and presentation of its financial statements; thus, accounting policies provide key information of the entity such as its measurement techniques and methods of asset valuation, the estimation of impairment of long-term assets, the parameters for determining provisions for contingencies, among others.
Another important information found in financial statements is the risk exposure of an entity. International Financial Reporting Standard 7 "Financial Instruments: Disclosures" requires that in the notes to the financial statements information be disclosed that allows knowing and evaluating the nature and extent of the risks arising from the financial instruments that an entity holds, such as credit risk, liquidity risk and market risk; and information about the techniques used to identify, measure, monitor and manage such risks.
Therefore, the information presented in the financial statements is highly useful for the different interest groups of the entity that prepares and disseminates them, including the company's personnel and the SMV as supervisor, which explains the vital importance of financial statements and the special attention they require at the time of their preparation.
The financial information of companies supervised by the SMV, such as ECRs, is available to a large number of users participating in the securities market and to the general public, which is why it must be prepared on the basis of an accounting standard that has been legally recognized, such as the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), which clearly establish the guidelines for the recognition, derecognition, measurement, classification, presentation and disclosure of a company's economic transactions.
The IASB is an independent body with worldwide recognition, through which the IFRS Foundation aims to fulfill its objective of developing high-quality, understandable, enforceable and globally accepted standards for general purpose financial information based on clearly articulated principles.21
As stated in the «Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting», on the basis of which the IASB develops and issues the standards, the objective of IFRS is to contribute to the transparency of information by improving the comparability and quality of financial statements, enabling investors and other market participants to make duly informed and appropriate economic decisions about their businesses.
In 2017, the IFRS Foundation published a study that demonstrates, on the basis of real cases, how various companies have significantly improved the communication of their information in a more effective way through the application of IFRS.
Consequently, the requirement of IFRS, as the sole standard for the preparation of financial statements of companies in Peru, and especially of those participating in the securities market, such as ECRs, has the purpose that the
[21] Constitution of the IFRS Foundation https://www.ifrs.org/content/dam/ifrs/about-us/legal-and-governance/constitution-docs/ifrs-foundation-constitution-2021.pdf
other market participants have quality financial statements that comply with fundamental requirements such as relevance and faithful representation, and that are comparable, verifiable, timely and understandable, so that in that way they constitute useful and effective tools in decision-making, including those related to the supervision of an entity authorized by the SMV.
In order to foster and strengthen trust in the financial information that is disseminated among interest groups and the general public, financial statements are subject to external financial audits through which qualified independent professionals collect, analyze and structure an entity's information with the necessary rigor in order to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatements, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue a professional opinion as to whether such financial statements are presented fairly in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.
To achieve such objectives, it is necessary that audits be performed under international quality standards oriented to the public interest, such as the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB).
In that sense, ISA 200 «Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing» clearly establishes that the objective of an audit is to increase the degree of confidence of users in the financial statements through the expression of a professional opinion on whether the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with an applicable financial reporting framework.
To achieve this objective, it is important that the auditor in charge comply with the applicable ethical requirements.
The International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) contemplates among its objectives and principles of securities regulation the obligation that auditors be independent of the audited entity.
Likewise, the Handbook of the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants 2014 Edition issued by the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) in its Section 290 «Independence—Audit and Review Engagements» establishes that the independence an auditor must have implies having an independent mental attitude to issue an opinion without influences that compromise professional judgment and having an apparent independence, this supposes avoiding relevant facts and circumstances that a third party with judgment and well informed could probably conclude that the integrity, objectivity or professional skepticism of the firm or of the audit team member have been compromised
In that order of ideas, in Peru, the Code of Professional Ethics for Public Accountants, in its article 42, states that an auditor and/or an audit firm in charge of an audit must have independence, which implies reaching a conclusion without influences that compromise professional judgment, allowing an auditor to act with integrity, objectivity and professional skepticism.
Therefore, financial audits play a vitally important role in maintaining credibility in the veracity and integrity of financial information; however, to achieve an adequate level of confidence, auditors must conduct their audits at the highest level of quality and with a strong ethical and professional attitude. Consequently, it is necessary that audits be performed under international quality standards oriented to the public interest, such as the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB).
In this regard, Ann Tarca, Professor of Accounting at the University of Western Australia and current member of the IASB, in her article "The Case for Global Accounting Standards: Arguments and Evidence 2012"22 states that various studies and research conducted following the widespread use of IFRS in the world concluded that some of the benefits of IFRS in capital markets were increased market liquidity, reduced cost of capital for companies, incentive for foreign capital investments, and improvement in analysts' ability to incorporate company and industry information into the share prices of a Company, thus reducing the advantage that shareholders have in possessing private information.
In this sense, financial statements prepared and presented in accordance with an internationally accepted financial reporting framework, such as IFRS, and accompanied by the independent opinion of an external auditor, constitute fundamental pillars of a securities market and its development, both for participants and regulators, by reinforcing the usefulness and transparency of the information they contain, while contributing significantly and evidently to the transparency, integrity, security and confidence demanded by markets.
Therefore, annual financial statements prepared in accordance with IFRS, which are subjected to external audits conducted in strict compliance with ISA, constitute the essential and constituent element of transparency, integrity and confidence in any securities market, by enabling its participants to have financial information solidly supported by the highest international standards, and evidence of this is the fact that in the highly developed securities markets of the world, the financial information of securities market participants is precisely the basis of information transparency and integrity of those markets;
107. That, as has been indicated (i) the transparency of the information that an issuer disseminates in the Peruvian securities market, (ii) the protection of investors and potential investors of said market, as well as (iii) the confidence and integrity that is formed and strengthened in the securities market when it is perceived and/or evidenced that all its participants self-regulate and/or adapt their conduct to compliance with the rules; are legal interests that must be protected through the exercise of the SMV's supervisory powers and the ius imperium, imposed by law, and in that sense the SMV must use all legal tools established for the fulfillment of its duties, especially those directly related to its duty to safeguard those legal interests, and in that direction, sanctions must be proposed and applied, albeit reasonable and proportional,
[22] Website IFRS: https://www.ifrs.org/content/dam/ifrs/around-the-world/adoption/2012-research-on-global-accounting-standards.pdf
those that are effective and consistent with the seriousness of the infraction committed;
108. That, before determining the sanction, it should be specified that, having decreed the National State of Emergency in order to face the health crisis caused by Covid-19 in accordance with the provisions of article 28 of Urgency Decree No. 029-2020, modified by article 12 of Urgency Decree No. 053-2020 and by article 2 of Supreme Decree No. 087-2020-PCM, the deadlines for the processing of administrative procedures, among which are sanctioning administrative procedures, were suspended from 21 March 2020 until 10 June 2020, with the deadlines resuming on 11 June 2020;
109. That, having determined the commission of one (01) very serious infraction corresponding to the failure to prepare and present the 2017 Audit Report, in accordance with ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500 in the audit of the Annual Individual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR, it is appropriate to determine the sanction to be imposed; considering the provisions of article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and article 348 of the LMV. In this sense, the following are analyzed: (i) the sanction background; (ii) recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, the harm caused and its repercussion in the market; (iii) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; (iv) the economic harm caused and its repercussion in the market; (v) the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; (vi) the probability of detection of the infraction; (vii) the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; and, (viii) the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria);
110. That, regarding the sanction antecedents, it is established that the antecedents of the offender are the sanctions that have been imposed by the SMV and that became final within the four (4) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned. In application of said criterion, it has been verified that SOA Noles does not have sanction antecedents according to what was evaluated in the Report;
111. That, in relation to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, it is verified that there is no recidivism on the part of SOA Noles, in the terms referred to in literal b) of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation according to what was evaluated in the Report;
112. That, in relation to the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that SOA Noles issued the 2017 Audit Report without having adhered to the International Auditing Standards, in the evaluation of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR. Likewise, it should be noted that although SOA Noles omitted to disclose the description and quantification of the financial effects in the 2017 Audit Report, this situation was corrected by letter of 19 November 2018, in response to Official Letter No. 6079-2018-SMV/01; given that SOA Noles reported the financial effects of the misstatements referred to the «recording of deferred operating income and costs» that remained in the interim financial statements as of 30 June 2018 of JCR;
113. That, in relation to the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, as follows from the foregoing, transparency, understood as the protected legal interest, has been affected, since there is a manifest conduct contrary to the securities market regulations. In the particular case, the sanctioning procedure set forth is based on the breach by SOA Noles regarding the preparation of the 2017 Audit Report of 02 April 2018 of JCR, without observing ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500;
114. That, regarding the damage caused and repercussion to the market, there are not sufficient elements to measure the damage caused by the infraction committed by SOA Noles; however, the breach incurred harms the transparency of the securities market and harms the confidence of investors and the general public;
115. That, regarding the illegally obtained benefit, there are not sufficient elements to indicate that it has been configured;
116. That, regarding the criterion of probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that to detect this type of breach the SMV has carried out various actions, among them, the diligence of supporting working papers and issuing various official letters requesting information; therefore, there is a low probability of detection of breaches of the ISAs;
117. That, in the present case, it has not been evidenced that SOA Noles has acted intentionally or with malice; however, a lack of the duty of care and diligence in the exercise of its work as an audit firm has been evidenced;
118. That, in attention to the sanction criteria indicated; that is, that SOA Noles does not have the status of issuer, does not have shares listed on the stock exchange, it is not observed that an economic damage, a serious repercussion on the market, or that it has obtained an illegal benefit or malice in the commission of the infraction has been generated; this Deputy Superintendency considers that in the present PAS, by exception, the provisions of the second paragraph of article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation23 would be applicable, since, in this case, it is noted that there would be no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, [fine not less than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT]. Therefore, it is considered that a fine sanction should be imposed in the range corresponding to a serious infraction, which, in accordance with article 34 of the New Sanctions Regulation, is punishable with a fine not less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT;
119. That, in accordance with the analysis of the Sanction Criteria set forth in this Resolution, in relation to the imputed charge, this Deputy Superintendency has determined that a fine of 25 UIT should be applied to SOA Noles, which corresponds to the minimum of the fine range to impose a serious infraction, taking into account the UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction;
120. That, consequently, attending to the Sanction Criteria previously analyzed and the evaluation carried out by the SASCM taking into consideration the Report issued by the IGCC, it is considered that a total fine of 25 UIT, equivalent to S/ 103 750.00, should be imposed on SOA Noles as a sanction
[23] 23 “Article 25.- SANCTION CRITERIA (…) When, from the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria, it is noted that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and by reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided may be imposed.”
(One Hundred Three Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles)24 for not having prepared and presented the 2017 Audit Report, issued on 02 April 2018, in accordance with ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500 in the audit of the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR;
121. That, without prejudice to the fact that up to this point it has been reliably demonstrated that SOA Noles, in effect, committed the infraction imputed in the Charge Letter, and that the principles of due process have been observed, including respect for the guarantees and rights of SOA Noles as an administered party; in addition, the need to disseminate this Resolution has been identified;
122. That, in order to preserve and comply with the duties and functions of the SMV, referring to ensuring the transparency of the securities market, safeguarding the protection of investors who may have been affected by the facts developed in this Resolution, strengthening regulatory compliance by the external audit firms under the scope of the SMV, to which article 1 of the LOSMV refers; as well as having as an additional basis, the seriousness of the infraction committed in this PAS, it must be considered that the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, legal norms of a general nature and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by Resolution SMV No. 014-2014-SMV/01, establishes:
“Article 5.- General Principle Legal norms of general scope as well as administrative resolutions issued by the decision-making bodies of the SMV that, in addition to their particular scope, have a general effect with respect to an indeterminate group of persons or whose rights may be affected by such decisions, must be subject to publicity in accordance with the provisions of the following articles.
(…)
Article 7.- Dissemination through the SMV Securities Market Portal
The following decisions must be disseminated through the SMV Securities Market Portal:
1. The final resolutions issued in the first administrative instance in a sanctioning procedure by decision-making bodies of the SMV, which, being subject to challenge by means of a reconsideration or appeal, have become final, as they were not challenged within the term of fifteen (15) business days from notification. Likewise, the final resolutions issued in the first administrative instance that, having been reconsidered, become final because no appeal is filed;
(…)
14. Any other administrative decision that, in the opinion of the decision-making body, generates the effects provided for in article 5 of this norm." (Underlining and emphasis added).
123. That the interest of the public, in general, must no longer be affected, among others, by the lack of timely disclosure of the
[24] Supreme Decree No. 380-2017-EF set the UIT for fiscal year 2018 at S/ 4,150.00.
information contained in this PAS and resolution, and especially by the facts developed and pronouncements issued in relation to the infraction committed, which is of a very serious level, and which refers to the failure by an external audit firm to prepare and present its Audit Report in accordance with the International Standards on Auditing;
124. That, in addition, the principle of opportunity and the principle of primacy of reality must be considered. In that line, it is necessary to reiterate that the transparency of the securities market is a supra-individual legal good or diffuse interest, insofar as it safeguards the interests of investors and potential investors; that is, it is of a sectoral nature, as is the case of the securities market, where investors and potential investors, individually or collectively, may be affected when the specific norms on transparency of the information disseminated in the securities market are breached. In the present case, the referred Audit Report was presented without taking into account the ISAs;
125. That it must be clearly established that any affectation to the information disseminated to the market, such as the commission of a very serious infraction, must be disclosed and also disseminated to the market, in the most immediate term possible, in safeguard of the general interest and of the fundamental principles of transparency of information and investor protection, both consubstantial to the existence and development of the Peruvian securities market;
126. That it is necessary to reiterate and highlight that according to the provisions of article 1 of both the LOSMV and the LMV, it is the purpose and duty of the SMV to ensure the adequate protection of investors and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purpose, as well as the transparency of the securities market and; furthermore, the SMV is empowered to supervise compliance with international auditing standards by the audit firms contracted by the issuers and, within that framework, to approve norms of a general nature consistent with the referred international auditing standards and to require from them any information or documentation to verify such compliance;
127. That, in that line of reasoning, in order to comply with the duties and functions of the SMV, considering the facts set forth in this Resolution; and in addition, among other elements, to the materiality of the specific case, which is a very serious infraction, the objective nature of the facts constituting the infraction that has been determined in this PAS, and that the administrative decisions that, in the opinion of the decision-making body, have a general effect with respect to an indeterminate group of persons or whose rights may be affected by such decisions, must be disseminated through the SMV Securities Market Portal, as provided in the aforementioned provision of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, legal norms of a general nature and other administrative acts of the SMV, a legal tool in force that the SMV itself has established and that must be used, which in our opinion, for all the aforementioned, is met in the present case and PAS, for which it is necessary to disseminate this Resolution;
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 13 and 36 of article 43 of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments;
Article 1.- Declare that Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil has incurred in a very serious infraction typified in numeral 1.4 of subsection 1 of Annex XII of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time the facts occurred, for failing to prepare and present the 2017 Audit Report, issued on 02 April 2018; in accordance with ISA 250, ISA 700, ISA 705, ISA 200, ISA 240 and ISA 500 in the audit of the Annual Individual Audited Financial Statements for the 2017 fiscal year of JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A., formerly Accuratio Credit Rating Agency Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A.
Article 2.- Sanction Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil with a fine of twenty-five (25) UIT equivalent to S/ 103 750.00 (One Hundred Three Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles), for the provisions of article 1 of this Resolution.
Article 3.- Order that the General Superintendence of Conduct Supervision of the Superintendence of the Securities Market-SMV —within the framework of its functions and competencies, and in accordance with the provisions of numeral 245.2 article 245 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, considering the facts set forth in this resolution—, periodically execute supervision actions with a guiding and preventive purpose regarding the external audit applicable to risk rating companies authorized and registered in the RPMV; and on the other hand, in order to safeguard the legal assets related to transparency of information and protection of investors in the securities market, among other measures, periodically execute monitoring or inspection actions in order to timely detect information on the situation of such audits and on their progress, from the appointment of the audit firm until the approval of the audited annual financial statements, containing the corresponding opinion, and if applicable until the additional audit report.
Article 4.- Order the dissemination —through the SMV Securities Market Portal (www.smv.gob.pe), in the section of imposed sanctions—, of this Resolution issued by the Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision, decision-making body of first administrative instance, in accordance with the provisions of article 5 in concordance with numeral 14 of article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01, regardless of whether it may be subject to challenge.
Article 5.- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and may be challenged through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal before this Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification. If this Resolution is not challenged, the corresponding sanction reduction regime may be applied.
Article 6.- Transcribe this Resolution to Noles Monteblanco & Asociados Sociedad Civil.
Register, communicate and publish,
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision
Reason:
Signed by: MENESES CAMARGO Carlos Enrique
Reason:
Signed by: PEREDA GALVEZ Roberto Enrique FAU 2013
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV)”
“approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS”
“Standards on preparation and presentation of FS, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV/01”
“Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation)”
“Policy on publicity of regulatory projects... approved by Resolution SMV No. 014-2014-SMV/01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added