Rule · NBK · 29 Oct 2018
Candidates for managerial positions and managerial employees of banks, bank holdings, certain banking-operation organizations, insurers, reinsurers, insurance holdings and brokers, insurance-payment guarantors, securities-market professional participants (excluding transfer agents), and major-participant applicants must respond to a draft motivated judgment within 5 working days; silence counts as agreement. Oral information is prohibited. The resolution enters into force on 1 January 2019.
| "NATIONAL BANK OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN" REPUBLICAN STATE INSTITUTION | REPUBLICAN STATE INSTITUTION "NATIONAL BANK OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTAN" | |
| RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD | RESOLUTION OF THE BOARD | |
| 29 October 2018, city of Almaty | No. 271, city of Almaty |
On approval of the Rules for the formation and use of motivated judgment
In accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 30 March 1995 "On the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan", the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan RESOLVES:
To approve the attached Rules for the formation and use of motivated judgment.
The Department for Supervision of Banks (Kizatov O.T.) shall, in the manner established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, ensure:
1) together with the Legal Department (Sarsenova N.V.), state registration of this resolution with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
2) within ten calendar days from the day of state registration of this resolution, its sending in the Kazakh and Russian languages to the Republican State Enterprise with the right of economic management "Republican Center for Legal Information" for official publication and inclusion in the Reference Control Bank of Normative Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
3) placement of this resolution on the official internet resource of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan after its official publication;
4) within ten working days after state registration of this resolution, submission to the Legal Department of information on the implementation of the measures provided for by subparagraphs 2), 3) of this paragraph and paragraph 3 of this resolution.
The Department for the Protection of the Rights of Consumers of Financial Services and External Communications (Terentyev A.L.) shall ensure, within ten calendar days after state registration of this resolution, the sending of its copy for official publication to periodical print publications.
Control over the execution of this resolution shall be entrusted to the Deputy Chairman of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Smolyakov O.A.
This resolution enters into force on 1 January 2019 and is subject to official publication.
Chairman
of the National Bank D. Akishev
Approved
by resolution of the Board
of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan
dated "29" October 2018 No. 271
Rules for the formation and use of motivated judgment
Chapter 1. General provisions
These Rules for the formation and use of motivated judgment (hereinafter - the Rules) have been developed in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 30 March 1995 "On the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan" (hereinafter - the Law) and determine the procedure for the formation and use of motivated judgment.
The Rules use the following concepts:
1) collegial body - a body of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan (hereinafter - the National Bank) that adopts motivated judgment, the composition and procedure of activity of which are approved by the Board of the National Bank;
2) supervisory unit - a unit of the National Bank that exercises control and supervision over the activities of financial organizations and forms the draft motivated judgment of the National Bank;
3) motivated judgment - a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body, which is the basis for applying supervisory response measures and making decisions in the cases provided for by the Law and the laws of 31 August 1995 "On banks and banking activity in the Republic of Kazakhstan" (hereinafter - the Law on Banks), of 23 December 1995 "On mortgage of immovable property", of 18 December 2000 "On insurance activity" (hereinafter - the Law on Insurance Activity), of 3 June 2003 "On the Fund for Guaranteeing Insurance Payments", of 2 July 2003 "On the securities market" (hereinafter - the Law on the Securities Market).
When using motivated judgment, the principles provided for by part two of paragraph 3 of Article 62-6 of the Law shall be observed.
Chapter 2. Procedure for the formation of motivated judgment
The development of the draft motivated judgment is carried out by the supervisory unit.
The draft motivated judgment is based on the information specified in part three of paragraph 3 of Article 62-6 of the Law.
For the development of the draft motivated judgment, the supervisory unit uses relevant and reliable information. At the same time, the use of oral information is not allowed.
Information is recognized as relevant if it contains information about facts that confirm, refute or cast doubt on conclusions about the existence of circumstances relevant to the formation of motivated judgment.
Information is recognized as reliable if it was obtained by the supervisory unit in a lawful manner from various sources and constitutes information about facts on the basis of which the supervisory unit establishes the presence or absence of circumstances relevant to the formation of motivated judgment, and is also confirmed in documentary form.
When developing the draft motivated judgment for the application of a supervisory response measure, the supervisory unit takes into account the explanations of the persons specified in paragraph 1 of Article 62-6 of the Law, if any. To obtain these explanations, the supervisory unit sends a corresponding request. Failure by a person specified in paragraph 1 of Article 62-6 of the Law to provide explanations within the period determined by the National Bank and constituting at least 5 (five) working days from the date of receipt of the request shall be considered as their absence.
The supervisory unit sends the draft motivated judgment to the person specified in paragraph 1 of Article 62-6 of the Law, who, within 5 (five) working days from the day of its receipt, submits to the supervisory unit a reasoned response on agreement or disagreement with the draft motivated judgment.
Failure by a person specified in paragraph 1 of Article 62-6 of the Law to submit a reasoned response within the established period shall be considered as the agreement of that person with the draft motivated judgment.
When the supervisory unit submits the draft motivated judgment for consideration by the collegial body, materials (documents) are attached to it, including the reasoned response on agreement or disagreement of the person specified in paragraph 1 of Article 62-6 of the Law with the draft motivated judgment (if any).
10. Based on the results of consideration of the draft motivated judgment and the materials (documents) attached to it, the collegial body adopts one of the following decisions:
1. motivated judgment;
2. a decision on the absence or insufficiency of grounds for the formation and use of motivated judgment.
Chapter 3. Procedure for the use of motivated judgment
1) a candidate for the position of a managerial employee of a bank, bank holding, organization carrying out certain types of banking operations, insurance (reinsurance) organization, insurance holding, insurance broker, organization guaranteeing insurance payments, professional participant of the securities market (with the exception of organizations carrying out transfer agency activity);
2) a managerial employee (or a candidate recommended for appointment or election to the position of a managerial employee) of a subsidiary organization being created or acquired by a bank, bank holding, insurance (reinsurance) organization, insurance holding;
3) a managerial employee (or a candidate recommended for appointment or election to the position of a managerial employee) of an organization in which a bank, bank holding, insurance (reinsurance) organization, insurance holding acquire a significant participation in capital;
4) an applicant (for an individual) or a managerial employee of the applicant (for a legal entity) acquiring the status of a major participant of a bank, insurance (reinsurance) organization, investment portfolio manager, bank holding, insurance holding.
1) bringing the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules to criminal liability for criminal offenses against the person, against property, in the sphere of economic activity, for corruption and other criminal offenses against the interests of public service and public administration;
2) participation of an individual specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules as an accused or defendant in criminal proceedings in connection with criminal offenses against the person, against property, in the sphere of economic activity, for corruption and other criminal offenses against the interests of public service and public administration;
3) the existence of violations of the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan or the legislation of another state regulating the professional activity in which the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules was (is) engaged;
4) evasion by the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules from complying with the requirements of international professional standards applied in the Republic of Kazakhstan in terms of ethics and exclusion of conflicts of interest;
5) recognition as insolvent of a legal entity in which the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules was an official and (or) a major shareholder (major participant), during the period of the person's activity as an official and (or) holding the status of a major shareholder (major participant) of that legal entity or within 2 (two) years after termination of his powers as an official and (or) loss of the status of a major shareholder (major participant) of that legal entity;
6) termination of an employment contract with the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules at the initiative of the employer on negative grounds;
7) submission by the person specified in paragraph 11 of the Rules of false information regarding himself (his identity, professional activity, persons affiliated with him) or his property, or evasion of submission of such information.
The provisions of part one of this paragraph also apply to cases, facts and (or) circumstances that have (had) taken place in the territory of foreign states.
Motivated judgment on the assessment of financial position is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the presence or absence of an unstable financial position of the founder of a bank, insurance (reinsurance) organization, an applicant acquiring the status of a major participant of a bank, insurance (reinsurance) organization, investment portfolio manager, bank holding, insurance holding.
When assessing the financial position of a person specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules, the following cases, facts and (or) circumstances shall be considered:
1) in relation to the person specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules, there is a court decision on recovery of debt that has not been executed on the date of filing an application for the issuance of permitting documents specified in subparagraph 1) of part two of paragraph 2 of Article 62-6 of the Law, or during its consideration, or the person specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules has overdue obligations or obligations fulfilled in violation of deadlines in the amount of more than 100,000,000 (one hundred) million tenge;
2) the legal entity specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules carried out restructuring of its obligations to creditors due to deterioration of its financial position;
3) in relation to the legal entity specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules, an accelerated rehabilitation procedure, rehabilitation procedure or insolvency settlement procedure was applied;
4) participation of an individual specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules as an accused or defendant in criminal proceedings in connection with criminal offenses against the person, against property, in the sphere of economic activity, for corruption and other criminal offenses against the interests of public service and public administration;
5) the person specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules does not have property and (or) money sufficient to ensure additional capitalization of the bank, insurance (reinsurance) organization, investment portfolio manager in order to ensure their financial stability in accordance with the requirement of the National Bank provided for by subparagraph 6) of paragraph 2 of Article 47-1 of the Law on Banks, subparagraph 6) of paragraph 2 of Article 53-4 of the Law on Insurance Activity, subparagraph 3) of paragraph 2 of Article 72-3 of the Law on the Securities Market;
6) the ratio of the obligations of the legal entity specified in paragraph 13 of the Rules to its own capital is more than 5 (five), for a financial organization - more than 10 (ten).
1) the bank, a major participant of the bank, a participant of the banking conglomerate have control over the legal entity in accordance with international financial reporting standards;
2) the cash flows and (or) principal obligations of an individual or legal entity arose as a result of a transaction with the bank and (or) a person related by special relations to the bank, which will lead to deterioration of the financial position of the bank;
3) the purpose of obtaining a bank loan and (or) its use do not correspond to the nature of the economic activity and (or) the needs of the borrower - an individual or legal entity based on his entrepreneurial or labor activity and (or) the business plan of such person;
4) information on the ownership structure of the borrower - a legal entity does not provide the possibility to establish all ultimate beneficiaries and (or) all participants owning more than 10 (ten) percent of voting shares (except for cases where the shares are in nominal holding) or a share in the charter capital of the borrower - a legal entity;
5) the expected cash flows of an individual or legal entity, taking into account collateral, are not sufficient to repay obligations under a bank loan on the date of the decision to issue it (except for cases where the bank takes measures to improve the quality of the bank's assets);
6) the decision of the corresponding body of the bank, whose powers include making decisions on alienation of assets, change of the subject of pledge and termination of pledge, decisions on the issuance of bank loans and bank guarantees, on a transaction with a borrower - an individual or legal entity (except for cases of fulfillment of obligations secured by pledge to the bank, recovery by the bank of the subject of pledge, replacement of the subject of pledge with an equivalent one) was made with a significant violation of the bank's requirements for concluded transactions provided for by the bank's internal documents, leads or has led to significant risks for the bank;
7) the terms of the bank loan agreement concluded with the borrower - an individual or legal entity presuppose restrictions on the liability of the borrower - an individual or legal entity for the fulfillment of the terms of the bank loan agreement that do not correspond to business customs, provide for events the occurrence of which terminates fully or in part the obligations of the borrower - an individual or legal entity under the bank loan agreement, and lead or have led to significant risks for the bank;
8) the terms of the bank's transaction with an individual or legal entity correspond to the criteria for recognizing transactions with preferential terms provided for by paragraph 2 of Article 40 of the Law on Banks, paragraph 20 of the Rules and additional criteria for classifying transactions as transactions with preferential terms established by a normative legal act of the National Bank in accordance with part two of paragraph 2 of Article 40 of the Law on Banks.
The cases provided for by subparagraphs 1), 2), 3), 5), 6) and 7) of part one of this paragraph are considered by the supervisory unit if the size of the transaction, including several transactions with the same person, amounts to:
more than 2 (two) percent of the bank's own capital on the date of the decision - for banks with own capital up to 100,000,000,000 (one hundred billion) tenge inclusive;
more than 1 (one) percent of the bank's own capital on the date of the decision - for banks with own capital over 100,000,000,000 (one hundred billion) tenge.
The conditions provided for by part two of this paragraph do not apply to cases of carrying out a transaction (several transactions) that provides (provide) for evasion of the specified transaction sizes.
If the bank and (or) the person have an adequate and effective risk management and internal control system that allows minimizing risks from transactions with the person in the cases provided for by part one of this paragraph, such person is not recognized as a person related by special relations to the bank.
1) the insurance (reinsurance) organization, a major participant of the insurance (reinsurance) organization, a participant of the insurance group have control over the legal entity in accordance with international financial reporting standards;
2) the decision of the corresponding body of the insurance (reinsurance) organization, whose powers include making decisions on alienation of assets, decisions on concluding transactions with an individual or legal entity, including on insurance (reinsurance), was made with a significant violation of the requirements of the insurance (reinsurance) organization for concluded transactions provided for by the internal documents of the insurance (reinsurance) organization, and leads or has led to significant risks for the insurance (reinsurance) organization;
3) the insurance (reinsurance) agreement concluded with the person contains conditions excluding the occurrence of an insured event and (or) the making of an insurance payment;
4) the terms of the transaction of the insurance (reinsurance) organization with an individual or legal entity correspond to the criteria for recognizing transactions with preferential terms provided for by paragraph 2 of Article 15-1 of the Law on Insurance Activity, paragraph 20 of the Rules and additional criteria for classifying transactions as transactions with preferential terms established by a normative legal act of the National Bank in accordance with part two of paragraph 2 of Article 15-1 of the Law on Insurance Activity.
If the insurance (reinsurance) organization and (or) the person have an adequate and effective risk management and internal control system that allows minimizing risks from transactions with the person in the cases provided for by part one of this paragraph, such person is not recognized as a person related by special relations to the insurance (reinsurance) organization.
When forming motivated judgment on recognizing a person as a person related by special relations to a bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization, in the cases provided for by subparagraph 1) of paragraph 15 and subparagraph 1) of paragraph 16 of the Rules, the National Bank considers, if available, the opinion of an independent expert, including one engaged by the bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization.
The requirements established in paragraphs 15 and 17 of the Rules apply to bank holdings (with the exception of non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan that are a bank holding or a person possessing the signs of a bank holding and meeting the requirements of paragraph 9 of Article 40 of the Law on Banks) and organizations carrying out certain types of banking operations.
The requirements established in paragraphs 16 and 17 of the Rules apply to insurance holdings, with the exception of non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan that are an insurance holding, a person possessing the signs of an insurance holding, and meeting the requirements of subparagraph 1) of paragraph 6 of Article 15-1 of the Law on Insurance Activity, and insurance holdings that are bank holdings forming part of banking conglomerates.
Motivated judgment on establishing the fact of provision by a bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization of preferential terms to persons related to them by special relations, as well as on classifying a transaction made by a bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization as a transaction with preferential terms, is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the presence of signs indicating the provision by the bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization of preferential terms to persons related to them by special relations, in the case of exceeding the size of the transaction of the internal limit established by the bank or insurance (reinsurance) organization for such type of transaction, without proper economic analysis.
Motivated judgment on assessing the quality of the risk management and internal control system in a bank is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the quality of the risk management and internal control system in the bank and is applied to assess:
1) the risk profile and risk appetite (acceptable level of risks) of the bank for compliance with the chosen business model and development strategy;
2) strategic and budget planning for compliance of the bank's budget with the economic goals determined by the bank's strategy, business model, and the risks assumed by the bank;
3) the quality of forecasting the bank's main financial indicators for:
the adequacy of the assumptions used in forming the budget (overstatement or understatement of the planned volume of assets, liabilities, capital (profit or losses);
the presence of an analysis of the compliance of the budget with actual indicators;
4) the methodology for determining the aggregated level (levels) of the bank's risk appetite and the level of risk appetite for each type of risk for:
the presence of the necessary level of own capital and liquidity to cover the established levels of risk appetite;
the adequacy of the limit value of quantitative and qualitative limits for various types of risks within the framework of a multi-level system of limits;
5) the quality of the bank's corporate governance system for:
presence and compliance with measures to manage conflicts of interest in corporate governance;
presence of facts of adoption of decisions on concluding transactions or carrying out operations in the presence of significant risks about which there was written information prepared by the bank's divisions engaged in risk management. The provisions of this paragraph apply to a transaction or a set of transactions the size of which is:
more than 1 (one) percent of the bank's equity as of the date of the decision - for banks with equity of up to 100,000,000,000 (one hundred billion) tenge inclusive;
more than 2 (two) percent of the bank's equity as of the date of the decision - for banks with equity of more than 100,000,000,000 (one hundred billion) tenge;
6) internal procedures for determining the adequacy of equity and liquidity to cover the risks inherent in the bank's activities, for:
the quality of risk assessment;
the presence in the assessment of equity adequacy of stress testing results;
the application of an appropriate risk profile in the process of determining equity adequacy;
the adequacy of assumptions in assessing potential customer outflows in stress situations and the adequacy of assessing the necessary level of liquid assets to cover them;
7) implementation of internal policies, as well as procedures for managing the risks inherent in the bank's activities, for:
compliance with regulated procedures;
compliance with internal policies on transactions concluded, including the presence of exceptions, documentation of such exceptions with informing the board of directors about the conclusion of transactions that do not comply with the procedures and policies approved by the bank;
8) procedures for identifying persons related to the bank by special relations, for:
the presence and compliance with appropriate restrictions for transactions with persons related to the bank by special relations, including the prohibition on granting them preferential terms;
identifying persons related to the bank by special relations, where the necessary information is available, in order to prevent the conclusion of transactions on preferential terms and an increase in the concentration of credit risk;
disclosure of information on transactions with persons related to the bank by special relations;
9) procedures for analyzing property accepted by the bank as collateral, for:
the correctness of the methodology for determining the market value of collateral, the correctness of the market value taken into account when issuing a bank loan and forming provisions (reserves), taking into account the use of an independent valuation in cases of disputed situations;
compliance with the deadlines for foreclosing on the collateral;
compliance of the terms of the collateral agreement with the structure of the financing provided, taking into account the financial position of the borrower (co-borrower, guarantor, surety);
the possibility of exercising the right to foreclose on the collateral;
10) the effectiveness of the bank's credit risk management, for:
the presence and compliance with internal lending policies and procedures;
the presence and compliance with procedures for identifying assets with signs of impairment in accordance with international financial reporting standards, including the submission to the bank's board of directors of information on such assets and the adoption of measures to manage them;
the adequacy of assumptions used to assess borrowers' business plans;
the frequency of monitoring of individual bank loans;
the sufficiency of the frequency and completeness of monitoring of borrowers showing signs of deterioration in financial condition;
the presence and compliance by the bank with credit administration procedures;
the ability of borrowers who have received a bank loan in foreign currency to respond adequately to changes in the exchange rate of the loan currency;
11) the quality of the bank's internal rating assessment of borrowers (scoring), for:
the adequacy of the models used for the rating assessment of the bank's borrowers (scoring);
the timeliness of making changes to the models used for the rating assessment of the bank's borrowers (scoring) in order to maintain their relevance, including with respect to the assigned weights and scores;
the implementation of periodic validation of the models for the rating assessment of the bank's borrowers (scoring);
12) compliance of the amount of formed provisions (reserves) with the requirements established by Resolution of the Board of the National Bank No. 269 of 22 December 2017 "On Approval of the Rules for Creating Provisions (Reserves) in Accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards and the Requirements of the Legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Accounting and Financial Reporting", registered in the State Registration Register of Normative Legal Acts under No. 16502;
13) the methodology for determining the fair value of financial instruments, for the reflection of their adequate value;
14) the effectiveness of the bank's funding strategy, for:
the sufficiency and necessity of diversifying funding sources by types, currencies, and terms;
the presence of high concentration in the funding structure;
the presence of alternative funding sources;
the presence of uncontrolled significant gaps between assets and liabilities by terms and currency;
15) the bank's liquidity management procedures, for:
the sufficiency of the level of liquid assets for the timely fulfillment of payment obligations, including the daily need for liquid funds taking into account unforeseen outflows;
the validity of including in liquid assets instruments available for sale in a short time under current market conditions;
the correctness of planning funding outflows;
16) the effectiveness of the bank's early warning system aimed at timely response to changes in internal and (or) external risk indicators, for:
the correctness of the early warning system indicators, including taking into account information available to the bank that potentially affects an increase in the level of risks;
the adequacy of the bank's actions when the risk identified within the early warning system increases;
the timeliness and effectiveness of the approved measures when the established levels of the early warning system are exceeded;
17) the contingency financing plan and ensuring the continuity of the bank's activities, for:
the presence in the plan of a list of effective and justified measures to restore liquidity and equity adequacy upon the realization of risks inherent in the bank's activities;
the confirmed probability of realization of stress scenarios and unforeseen circumstances;
the determination of the necessary resources to restore the bank's activities and their adequacy;
18) the effectiveness of the bank's operational risk management procedures, for:
the presence and compliance with operational risk assessment procedures for key business areas, services, processes, and information systems;
the presence and compliance with operational risk assessment procedures when introducing new financial services and products;
the presence of the necessary tools for the effective identification of operational risk and measures to manage it;
the documentation of facts of major losses due to the realization of operational risk and the implementation of measures to minimize them;
19) the effectiveness of the bank's risk management and internal control system in the area of combating the legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism, for:
the exposure of the financial organization to the risk of legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism;
the adequacy of procedures for identifying the client (its representative) and the beneficial owner, the adequacy of assessing the risk of legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism by type of client;
identifying operations subject to financial monitoring;
the effectiveness of interaction between divisions on issues of combating the legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism;
the adequacy and sufficiency of measures taken by the bank to minimize the risk of legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism;
the vulnerability of the services provided, as well as the methods of their provision, to the risk of legalization (laundering) of proceeds from crime and the financing of terrorism;
20) stress testing in the bank, for:
the completeness, correctness, and validity of the scenarios used;
the relevance of the projected change in external and internal indicators within the scenarios;
the adequacy of the models and procedures for conducting stress testing;
the application of stress testing results in the bank's risk management system and management decision-making (if necessary);
the presence of interrelation (correlation) of changes in risk factors on the structure of the bank's assets and liabilities;
21) the quality of the management information system on the risks inherent in the bank's activities, for the reliability, completeness, and timeliness of information provided to the bank's collegial bodies, as well as the completeness of reflection in such information of risks for the purposes of management decision-making;
22) the effectiveness of the functioning of the three lines of defense system, for:
the independence of divisions and compliance with qualification requirements of employees of the second and third lines of defense;
the presence and compliance with measures to manage conflicts of interest between participants of the three lines of defense system and (or) the combination of functional duties of its participants;
23) the quality of internal control procedures, for:
the compliance of the bank's internal documents with the requirements of the banking legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and (or) the untimely bringing of the bank's internal documents into compliance with the banking legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
the presence of a significant volume of transactions concluded without compliance with the bank's established internal procedures;
24) the effectiveness of the bank's internal audit division in conducting an independent assessment of the effectiveness of risk management procedures, for:
the application of a risk-oriented approach in planning the activities of the internal audit division;
the provision, based on the results of audit reviews, of recommendations aimed at improving the effectiveness of risk management procedures;
the presence of procedures for monitoring the implementation of recommendations issued by the internal audit division.
The provisions stipulated in subparagraphs 1), 2), 3), 6), 16), 17) and 21) of this paragraph apply to a banking conglomerate.
Professional judgment on assessing the quality of the risk management and internal control system in an insurance (reinsurance) organization and an insurance group, a professional participant of the securities market (except for organizations carrying out transfer-agent activities) is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the quality of the risk management and internal control system in an insurance (reinsurance) organization and an insurance group, a professional participant of the securities market (except for organizations carrying out transfer-agent activities) and is applied in the cases provided for by subparagraphs 1), 2), 3), 4), 5), 6), 7), 8), 13), 15), 16), 17), 18), 19), 20), 21), 22), 23) and 24) (for an insurance (reinsurance) organization, a professional participant of the securities market), subparagraphs 1), 2), 3), 6), 16), 17) and 21) (for an insurance group) of paragraph 21 of the Rules.
Professional judgment on assessing the adequacy of provisions (reserves) of a bank, an insurance (reinsurance) organization, a professional participant of the securities market (except for organizations carrying out transfer-agent activities) is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the compliance of the formed provisions (reserves) of a bank, an insurance (reinsurance) organization, a professional participant of the securities market (except for organizations carrying out transfer-agent activities) with international financial reporting standards, methodologies for forming provisions (reserves), including the compliance of the methodologies for their formation with the risks of the bank, insurance (reinsurance) organization, professional participant of the securities market, and on the reliability of the information used for their formation.
Professional judgment on assessing the adequacy of insurance reserves formed by an actuary holding a license to carry out actuarial activity in the insurance market (hereinafter - insurance reserves) is a reasoned professional opinion of the collegial body on the compliance of insurance reserves with international financial reporting standards, methodologies for calculating insurance reserves and their structure, including the compliance of the methodologies for their formation with the risks of the insurance (reinsurance) organization, and on the reliability of the information used for their formation.
Professional judgment on assessing the adequacy of insurance reserves is used in cases (but not limited to them):
unjustified change in the methodology for calculating insurance reserves or the parameters used in calculating insurance reserves, as a result of which there is an improvement in the indicators of prudential standards and other mandatory norms and limits established by [Resolution](jl:39366641.0.1005563806_0" \o "Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 304 of 26 December 2016 "On Establishing Normative Values and Methodology for Calculating Prudential Standards of an Insurance (Reinsurance) Organization and an Insurance Group and Other Mandatory Norms and Limits, the List, Forms, Deadlines for Submitting Reports on Compliance with Prudential Standards by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations and Insurance Groups, the Rules for Submitting Reports on Compliance with Prudential Standards by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations and Insurance Groups, Requirements for Shares (Participation Interests in the Charter Capital) of Legal Entities Acquired by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations, Subsidiary Organizations of Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations or Insurance Holdings, the List of Bonds of International Financial Organizations Acquired by Insurance Holdings, the Minimum Required Rating for Bonds Acquired by Insurance Holdings, and the List of Rating Agencies, as well as the List of Financial Instruments (Except for Shares and Participation Interests in the Charter Capital) Acquired by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations"...) of the Board of the National Bank No. 304 of 26 December 2016 "On Establishing Normative Values and Methodology for Calculating Prudential Standards of an Insurance (Reinsurance) Organization and an Insurance Group and Other Mandatory Norms and Limits, the List, Forms, Deadlines for Submitting Reports on Compliance with Prudential Standards by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations and Insurance Groups, the Rules for Submitting Reports on Compliance with Prudential Standards by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations and Insurance Groups, Requirements for Shares (Participation Interests in the Charter Capital) of Legal Entities Acquired by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations, Subsidiary Organizations of Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations or Insurance Holdings, the List of Bonds of International Financial Organizations Acquired by Insurance Holdings, the Minimum Required Rating for Bonds Acquired by Insurance Holdings, and the List of Rating Agencies, as well as the List of Financial Instruments (Except for Shares and Participation Interests in the Charter Capital) Acquired by Insurance (Reinsurance) Organizations", registered in the State Registration Register of Normative Legal Acts under No. 14794 (hereinafter - Resolution No. 304);
formation of the reinsurer's share in insurance reserves under a reinsurance agreement in the absence in the terms of the concluded reinsurance agreement of economic benefit (expediency) for the reinsured;
use of incomplete and (or) unreliable information in calculating insurance reserves, which led to a decrease (or there is a probability of a decrease) in the solvency of the insurance (reinsurance) organization and (or) violation by the insurance (reinsurance) organization of prudential standards and other mandatory norms and limits established by Resolution No. 304.
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“In accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 30 March 1995 "On the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan", the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan RESOLVES:”
More like this from NBK
NBK published 6 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Bank of Kazakhstan — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added