Enforcement · SMV · 16 Mar 2022
The Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision partially grants the reconsideration appeal filed by JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. against Resolution No. 007-2021-SMV/11, which had imposed a fine of 7.55 UIT (S/ 31,710.00) for two minor infractions related to the late submission of audited annual individual financial information and annual report for fiscal year 2018. The resolution evaluates the appellant's arguments and evidence, including a claim of force majeure, and decides to partially grant the appeal, thereby revoking the fine.
No. 025-2022-SMV/11
Lima, March 16, 2022
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2021-SMV/11 is declared partially founded
| Administered entity | : | JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2020001926 |
The Deputy Superintendent (e) for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2020001926, Report No. 303-2021-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report) and Report No. 921-2021-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Ampliatory Report), issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
"1. In accordance with what is stated in this report, in view that JCR has presented a new evidentiary element in its reconsideration appeal, it is reasonably considered that the exemption from liability due to force majeure has been accredited, pursuant to subsection a) of article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with article 257 numeral 1) subsection a) of the TUO of the LPAG, which states that force majeure and unforeseeable circumstances constitute an exemption from liability.
2. In this sense, this Intendancy proposes that the reconsideration appeal presented by JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2021-SMV/1 be declared founded."
"Likewise and in accordance with the foregoing, it should be noted that this Deputy Superintendency is empowered to instruct the IGCC to carry out additional actions and/or complementary reports in accordance with subsection a) of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.[1]
On this matter, it is necessary for the IGCC to expand the scope of the content of Report No. 303-2021-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report) regarding the evaluation of the reconsideration appeal filed by the company JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. (hereinafter, JCR) against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2021-SMV/11 (hereinafter, Challenged Resolution) within the framework of the administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS) contained in File No. 2020001926, considering that this PAS was initiated by imputing to JCR the infraction typified in subsection 3.1 of numeral 3 of Annex I of the approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation)[2], and that subsequently the IGCC proposed to this Office that a fine of 7.55 UIT, equivalent to S/ 31,710.00 (Thirty-One Thousand Seven Hundred Ten and 00/100 Soles), be imposed on JCR, which led this Office to proceed, after the evaluation carried out, to resolve to sanction JCR through the Challenged Resolution.
In this framework, it is necessary to evaluate the advisability of carrying out additional actions considering the prior acts (facts and pronouncements of this PAS), the documents and/or arguments presented by JCR, such as the WhatsApp transcripts and its statements about an alleged unforeseeable circumstance that would exempt it from liability, among others:
«It is also noteworthy that Mr. Walter Noles initially maintained the decision to provide services and then inexplicably communicated on February 8 his refusal, which was informed to us by telephone and he recommended we speak with another audit firm (Alfredo Rejas). This decision, whose effect is under no circumstances attributable to our company, was the origin and main cause and support, as well as the subsequent request from the firm Panez & Chacaliaza Asoc., for the request to extend the deadline for submission of the audited financial statements and the annual report, evidencing that it arises from facts outside and external to the actions of JCR LATAM, and is therefore an unforeseeable circumstance.»[3]
In this order, considering that no final resolution has been issued and that a sanction has been imposed that is suspended due to the appeal, it is necessary to motivate the required report by developing the grounds referring to the fact that in the specific case the IGCC has verified and/or reliably proven an unforeseeable circumstance exempting the administered entity from liability.
In this framework, it is necessary to keep in mind the standard of due diligence in the actions of the public administration and the scope of the principles and concepts of motivation and the search for material truth, among others."
"1. This General Intendancy proposes that the reconsideration appeal presented by JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2021-SMV/11 be declared unfounded, in consideration of the evaluation of new evidentiary elements that disprove the arguments presented by JCR in its reconsideration appeal referring to the application of the exemption from liability due to unforeseeable circumstance or force majeure.
2. Likewise, it is proposed to confirm Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 007-2021-SMV/11, which sanctions JCR Latino América Empresa Clasificadora de Riesgo S.A. with a fine of 7.55 UIT, equivalent to S/ 31,710.00 (Thirty-One Thousand Seven Hundred Ten and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred in two (02) infractions of a minor nature typified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, regarding the late submission of the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information and Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2018."
"1. That the Public Attorney's Office of the SMV take the pertinent legal actions regarding the information presented by JCR in its reconsideration appeal brief presented on February 8, 2021, as there are indications of a possible crime of false declaration.
2. Elevate this ampliatory report for the respective pronouncement."
"On this matter, I inform you that the file of reference has been received, so the processing thereof will continue. Likewise, I must inform you that due to the abstention of the titular Deputy Superintendent, Mr. Roberto Pereda Gálvez, to resolve the referred reconsideration appeal, the undersigned has been designated by Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02 to proceed with its resolution.
Therefore, the following reports issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (IGCC) are attached, through which the reconsideration appeal presented is evaluated: (i) Report No. 303-2021-SMV/11.2, and (ii) Report No. 921-2021-SMV/11.2 so that your represented entity may proceed within the term of five (05) business days, as provided in article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01."
"I address you regarding your brief JCR LATAM 081-1-2021 presented on November 18, 2021, to this Deputy Superintendency, through which you state that Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02 (hereinafter, the Memorandum) had not been sent to you; nor had the document accrediting the abstention of Mr. Alix Godos been provided; and, therefore, the assertion of compliance with numerals 147.2 and 147.3 of article 147 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, would be false. As a result, in your brief, you state that not only the General Administrative Procedure Law has been breached, but also the constitutional norms linked to due process, the right of defense and, furthermore, the Code of Ethics of the Public Official Law, Law No. 27815.
On this matter, first, it is necessary to point out that what your represented entity states is not correct when it refers to not having had access to the Memorandum. On the contrary, your represented entity did have access to said document; in addition to other documents contained in this file. In this regard, by Letter No. 025-2021-RKM of October 7, 2021, your represented entity filed with this Superintendency a request for access to public information processed in file No. 2021037838, requesting access to all documents contained in file No. 2020001926, in addition to other files. Said request was addressed and attended by the Responsible for Access to Public Information of the SMV, who responded to your access request on October 21, 2021, providing the requested documentation. Consequently, your represented entity did have access not only to the Memorandum, but to the documents contained in file No. 2020001926 in order to prepare its arguments to present in this file.
Likewise, it should be mentioned that through Official Letter No. 3567-2021-SMV/11, of September 7, 2021, sent to your represented entity, in which the sanction reports issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance were forwarded, the content of the Memorandum was also detailed, regarding the designation of Mr. Carlos Rivero, replacing Mr. Roberto Pereda to resolve this administrative sanctioning procedure. On this point, the following was stated:
"On this matter, I inform you that the file of reference has been received, so the processing thereof will continue. Likewise, I must inform you that due to the abstention of the titular Deputy Superintendent, Mr. Roberto Pereda Gálvez, to resolve the referred reconsideration appeal, the undersigned has been designated by Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02 to proceed with its resolution".
As a consequence, taking into consideration that your represented entity had access to the Memorandum and that through Official Letter No. 3567-2021-SMV/11 of September 7, 2021, you were informed about the designation of Mr. Carlos Rivero to resolve this sanctioning file; it must be specified that this Deputy Superintendency has not transgressed the Code of Ethics of the Public Official Law nor much less violated any of the rights you mention in your brief. On the contrary, these have been respected at all times, to the point of granting the additional forty-five (45) day term you requested, which expired on November 18, 2021. Likewise, without prejudice to what is mentioned in the preceding paragraphs, in this Official Letter, the Memorandum is attached as an Annex.
On the other hand, regarding the statement that documentation related to the abstention of Mr. Alix Godos has not been provided, it must be emphasized that in this file there is no record of any act referring to the referred abstention of said official. Now, in case your represented entity requires any information associated with another file that is not within the framework of this administrative sanctioning procedure, it must request it from the area responsible for the attention of public information of the SMV.
On the other hand, taking into account that through Official Letter No. 4588-2021-SMV/12.2 of November 22, 2021, the Responsible for the Delivery of Information of the SMV elevated to the Transparency and Access to Public Information Tribunal the letter 019-2021-RKM sent by Mr. Keil, as an appeal, so that it may rule on questions of pure law regarding whether or not it was appropriate to send draft documents or preliminary versions without legal effects, among which is cited, file 2020001926; an additional term of ten (10) business days is granted to you for the purpose of presenting your allegations regarding the following reports issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance through which the reconsideration appeal presented is evaluated: (i) Report No. 303-2021-SMV/11.2, and (ii) Report No. 921-2021-SMV/11.2 counted from the day following the day on which the Transparency and Access to Public Information Tribunal resolves said appeal.
Once this additional term ends, a pronouncement will be issued in accordance with the applicable regulations.
Finally, we refer to your communication JCR LATAM 082-1-2021 sent on November 25, 2021, in which you formulate arguments referring to the merits of this administrative sanctioning procedure, regarding which this Office informs you that it will proceed to evaluate them at the time of resolving this administrative sanctioning procedure, as well as any additional brief that your represented entity presents in order to guarantee strict compliance with its right of defense and due process."
4.1. Of the Reconsideration Appeal
"i) that the contract with SOA Noles was terminated in February 2019; ii) that JCR hired SOA Panez on February 18, 2020; and iii) that SOA Panez indicated to JCR that it request from the SMV an extension for the presentation of the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information for fiscal year 2018, via email of March 27, 2019, which has been presented as evidence in the reconsideration appeal; the presentation of this new evidence will be evaluated in the context of the provisions of the principle of presumption of veracity and that of material truth established in literals 1.7 and 1.11 of numeral 1 of Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO of LPAG.
(…) In this sense, considering that SOA Panez indicated to JCR that it request an extension of the legal deadline to present the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information for fiscal year 2018, due to the limited time it had due to the termination of the contract with SOA Noles, it should be noted that JCR had no possibility of anticipating the occurrence of said event." (Highlighting and underlining added).
The foregoing is framed within the principle of material truth, which provides that the competent administrative authority must fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all necessary evidentiary measures authorized by law[8].
"(…), therefore it is important to emphasize that, until that date, (excessively late), we had not presented a service proposal, nor had we signed a contract, and even less had we initiated the planning of a possible engagement; three indispensable requirements to assume an Audit commitment, which never occurred."
This has been reliably proven with the transcription of WhatsApp messages between Mr. Walter Noles, representative of Noles Monteblanco & Asociados, and the undersigned in his capacity as General Manager.
It is also worth noting that Mr. Walter Noles initially maintained the decision to provide services and then inexplicably communicated on February 8 his refusal, which was informed to us by telephone and he recommended we speak with another audit firm (Alfredo Rejas). This decision, whose effect is under no circumstances attributable to our company, was the origin and main cause and support, as well as the subsequent request of the firm Panez & Chacaliaza Asoc., for the request to extend the deadline for delivery of the audited financial statements and the annual report, evidencing that it arises from facts outside and external to the actions of JCR LATAM, being therefore a fortuitous event.
(…)
It should be noted on this point, in order not to generate future problems for JCR LATAM, that what was expressly informed is that said audit firm [SOA Noles], as usual, initially accepted to provide the service and this was informed to the SMV, and then inexplicably withdrew, which was likewise communicated and the regulator is in a position to confirm or prove, both with the WhatsApp communications provided, and directly in its files and with the Audit firm Noles Monteblanco itself." (Underlining and Highlighting added).
In this sense, JCR maintains that the request for an extension of the deadline for the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information for fiscal year 2018 was due to a request from SOA Panez. For these purposes, it attaches to its reconsideration appeal a copy of the email of March 27, 2019, sent by SOA Panez to Mr. Roberto Keil, legal representative of JCR; in which it is shown that SOA Panez indicated to JCR to request before the SMV an extension of the deadline of at least fifteen (15) days for the presentation of the referred Audited Annual Individual Financial Information for fiscal year 2018.
Likewise, JCR states that it must be considered that the referred request for an extension of the deadline originated from the inexplicable decision of SOA Noles not to provide its audit services, which is why the services of SOA Panez were urgently contracted on February 18, 2019.
Finally, JCR reiterates that the decision of SOA Noles and the request for an extension of the deadline by SOA Panez are facts that under no circumstances are attributable to it or its responsibility, since it has been proven that they arise from factors outside and external to its actions, being therefore a fortuitous event, which is recognized by Article 257 of the TUO of LPAG, in accordance with literal a) of Article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation[9].
4.2. Evaluation of the Reconsideration Appeal
Likewise, Mr. Noles states that it must be considered that JCR was not included in the list of potential clients to be audited in fiscal year 2018, information that was sent to the SMV on October 31, 2018, in response to Official Letter No. 4237-2018-SMV/11.1. He also stated that "in said information the company JCR was not included, because, despite the conversations we had been having, our Firm had not been requested up to that date to prepare an Audit proposal, and even less to sign a contract for said professional service for fiscal year 2018. Consequently, there was no withdrawal, because there was never a formal agreement for said service (…)"
It should be noted that what was reported by Mr. Noles in his document of July 22, 2021, described in the preceding paragraphs, would be corroborated with what was reported by SOA Noles in its document of November 6, 2018 presented to the SMV (File No. 2018031015), in response to the email sent by the IGSC, which are as follows:
Image No. 1: Email sent by an IGSC official to SOA Noles
Image No. 2: Document of SOA Noles of November 6, 2018 (File No. 2018031015)
In this sense, the fact described by JCR in its reconsideration appeal that SOA Noles "initially accepted to provide the service and this was informed to the SMV" has been questioned by Mr. Noles and it is striking that JCR communicates to the SMV that it designated SOA Noles as its audit firm without having signed a contract or having had prior conversations for it to provide the audit service for the referred period, as Mr. Noles states in his document of July 22, 2021, therefore, said situation evidences a lack of diligence on the part of JCR, even more so when according to evidence it would have waited until February 4, 2019 to have a first approach with SOA Noles for the performance of the audit corresponding to fiscal year 2018, being the obligation to present its audited financial information on April 1, 2019.
"(…), it is important to emphasize that, until that date, (excessively late), we had not presented a service proposal, nor had we signed a contract, and even less had we initiated the planning of a possible engagement; three indispensable requirements to assume an Audit commitment, which never occurred.
Due to this, our Firm decided to recommend other Audit companies that could have within their time schedule the possibility of providing this professional service; receiving the understanding and acceptance of the Manager of JCR, which is manifested in the last line of its own evidence (day 8 of February), where it thanks the Audit reference, and informs that it will contact them; refuting with its own evidence the imputation attributed to us." (Underlining added).
"(…) the delivery date of our audited report to the Classifier was scheduled for March 29, 2019, a situation that we will not be able to meet for the reasons set forth below:
Our hiring as External Auditors of the Classifier was made on February 18, 2019, initiating on the same date the coordination for our work. As part of the development of the work, situations arose that led us to recommend to the Classifier the incorporation of certain changes in its financial statements as of December 31, 2018, to make them understandable as required and permitted by IFRS. In this context, it is taking time for the Classifier to make said incorporations and it is in the full process of adopting IFRS, which is why they do not have the financial statements closed at that date and have requested additional time from us to perform our respective reviews.
Likewise, our client [JCR], has notified us that, in turn, it has informed the SMV office that it is engaged in a process of implementation in its financial statements and has requested an extension for the presentation of the audited information that by regulation corresponds to present to this Superintendency." (Underlining added).
According to the foregoing, although this PAS is not a matter of evaluation regarding compliance or not with IFRS, but rather regarding the late presentation of financial statements; it has been necessary to cite said information to the extent that JCR has presented as an argument to support an exemption from liability that the reasons that SOA Panez would have had to ask JCR to request before the SMV an extension of the deadline was due to the limited time it would have had to finish its audit work, which originated from the alleged withdrawal of SOA Noles from providing its audit service; however, according to the foregoing, said argument has been refuted by the document of SOA Panez indicated above.
Consequently, in the present case JCR has not proven the facts that would constitute an exemption from liability; on the contrary, with the evidentiary action carried out by the IGCC and developed in the Ampliatory Report, it is manifested that there was a lack of diligence by JCR to carry out the actions conducive to presenting in a timely manner its Audited Annual Individual Financial Statements for fiscal year 2018.
Although in administrative regulation no content has been given to this class of exemptions from liability, it is considered that recourse must be made to the sources of the procedure such as laws and provisions of equivalent hierarchy (Article V numeral 2.3. of the TUO of the LPAG), therefore this class of exemptions is developed in Article 1315 of the Civil Code, which establishes the following: «Fortuitous event or force majeure is the non-imputable cause, consisting of an extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible event, which prevents the execution of the obligation or determines its partial, late or defective fulfillment». In this sense, the following should be stated:
It comes from a cause beyond the will of the obligor
It must be taken into account that the causal fact of force majeure must not be located in the sphere of action of the one alleging it, that is, the cause of the exemption from liability for fortuitous event or force majeure must be outside the circle or field of activity of the obligor.
In this sense, according to the facts described above, despite the fact that since June 27, 2018 JCR informed the SMV of the designation of SOA Noles as audit firm, it would never have communicated with said audit firm and would have only done so for the first time on February 4, 2019 as stated by Mr. Noles in his document of July 22, 2021, in which he highlights that there was never formal information from JCR regarding the intention that the firm perform the 2018 audit, nor of the decision that would have been taken by its Shareholders' Meeting; nor of the existence of a proposal and even less of negotiation to acquire a commitment with JCR regarding the 2018 Audit and above all of the existence of a contract that supports any commitment of the firm for the 2018 audit. That is, JCR would have contacted said audit firm more than seven (07) months after it had made the decision that the firm perform the 2018 audit, and within a period close to the expiration of the presentation of the audited annual financial statements to the SMV, which evidences that the fact that would have generated the regulatory non-compliance was within the sphere of control of JCR.
Likewise, it is observed that SOA Panez performed the audit work for fiscal year 2018 approximately one (01) month and one week before the legal deadline (April 1, 2019) for JCR to submit to the SMV the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information for fiscal year 2018, due to a cause attributable to JCR and not to a third party (SOA Noles), as JCR claims in its reconsideration appeal, to the extent that diligent action would imply that JCR should have timely contracted its audit firm and coordinated the audit work with it in order to comply with its legal obligation, so that situation falls within JCR's sphere of control.
Unforeseeable event
For a situation of force majeure to be configured, it must be unforeseeable; an event that has escaped the possible scenarios that the subjects have determined as feasible qualifies as such, and it is also sudden and unexpected, an event that the obligated party, using normal diligence, could not have foreseen would occur.
In this sense, it should be noted that diligent action to timely submit to the SMV the Audited Annual Individual Financial Statements for fiscal year 2018 would imply, among other things, that the obligated party should have signed a contract with its audit firm in a timely manner, as well as that the audit work should have begun early so that the audit report is issued before the legal deadline established in the applicable regulations.
The fact that JCR contacted SOA Noles only in February 2019, that is, more than seven (07) months after JCR's Shareholders' Meeting decided that the firm would perform the 2018 audit (on June 27, 2018) and at a date close to the deadline for submitting the aforementioned financial statements, would demonstrate a lack of diligence on the part of JCR in submitting the aforementioned financial statements to the SMV in a timely manner and increased the risk of difficulties arising for any audit firm to issue its audit report within the reasonable period established by the applicable regulations.
On the other hand, regarding JCR's argument that the limited time SOA Panez had to perform the audit work for the aforementioned financial statements was due to SOA Noles inexplicably withdrawing, we must state that according to what was reported by Mr. Noles, such withdrawal, conversations, or a contract to provide audit services never existed, so the aforementioned limited time of SOA Panez would have been due to JCR only signing a contract with SOA Panez on February 18, 2019; which shows that JCR had possibilities to anticipate or foresee the occurrence of such event had it acted with diligence in the timely contracting of its audit firm and that it was under its responsibility to adopt adequate mechanisms to comply with submitting its financial information on time.
Irresistible event
It should be noted that simple non-compliance due to lack of diligence at the time of carrying out the activity to which one was obligated cannot be alleged as an exemption from liability.
In this regard, the non-compliances incurred by JCR could have been avoided had due diligence been observed, which implies that it should have deployed all necessary mechanisms to ensure timely compliance in the timely submission of the Audited Annual Individual Financial Statements for fiscal year 2018.
On the other hand, regarding JCR's argument that the IGCC, through Office No. 3424-2019-SMV/11.02, applied in a previous case the abstention from an administrative sanctioning procedure, it should be noted that on that occasion and in accordance with article 24[11] of the Sanctions Regulation (articles 32 and 33 of the previous Sanctions Regulation), the IGCC has the power to abstain from initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure, provided certain requirements are met; however, this does not imply that, in the face of subsequent non-compliances and in accordance with the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, a sanctioning procedure may be initiated.
In addition, it should be specified that article 24 of the Sanctions Regulation, referring to abstentions from the administrative sanctioning procedure, can occur in two cases: i) when a corrective measure has previously been issued by the General Supervisory Intendencies, provided they are minor infractions and the facts are of little significance, which implies that once compliance with the corrective measure is verified, the General Compliance Intendencies abstain from initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure; and ii) when minor infractions are committed, the General Compliance Intendencies, within their functional autonomy, consider that in exceptional cases they may abstain from initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure.
It should be noted that the aforementioned Special Sanction Criteria regulate how the sanction to be imposed must be determined, whether warning or fine, according to various criteria, and if it is determined that a fine should be imposed, said Special Sanction Criteria establish rules for its quantification taking into consideration the days of delay and antecedents; consequently, it should be noted that the application of the Special Sanction Criteria has been developed from recital 20 to 29 of the Challenged Resolution, observing that total compliance with said rules has been given.
"(...)
On the matter, in the first place, it should be noted that what your represented company states when it refers that it would not have accessed the Memorandum is not correct. On the contrary, your represented company did have access to said document; in addition to other documents contained in this file. In this regard, through Letter No. 025-2021-RKM of October 7, 2021, your represented company filed with this Superintendency a request for access to public information processed in file No. 2021037838, requesting access to all documents contained in file No. 2020001926, in addition to other files. Said request was addressed and attended by the Officer Responsible for Access to Public Information of the SMV, who responded to your access request on October 21, 2021, providing the requested documentation. Consequently, your represented company did have access not only to the Memorandum, but also to the documents contained in file No. 2020001926 in order to prepare its allegations to present them in this file.
Likewise, it should be mentioned that through Office No. 3567-2021-SMV/11, of September 7, 2021, sent to your represented company, in which the sanction reports issued by the General Intendency of Conduct Compliance were forwarded, the content of the Memorandum was also detailed, regarding the designation of Mr. Carlos Rivero, replacing Mr. Roberto Pereda to resolve this administrative sanctioning procedure. On this point, the following was stated:
"On the matter, I inform you that the file of reference has been received, so the continuation of its procedure will proceed. Likewise, I must inform you that following the abstention of the titular Deputy Superintendent, Mr. Roberto Pereda Gálvez, to resolve the referred reconsideration appeal, the undersigned has been designated through Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02 to proceed with its resolution".
As a consequence, taking into consideration that your represented company had access to the Memorandum and that through Office No. 3567-2021-SMV/11 of September 7, 2021, it was informed about the designation of Mr. Carlos Rivero to resolve this sanctioning file; it should be specified that this Deputy Superintendency has not transgressed the Law of the Code of Ethics of the Public Official nor much less violated any of the rights to which it refers in its writing. On the contrary, these have been respected at all times, to the point of granting the additional period of forty-five (45) days that it requested, which expired on November 18, 2021. Likewise, without prejudice to what is mentioned in the preceding paragraphs, in this Office, the Memorandum is attached as an Annex.
(...)"
As detailed, JCR was able to know the content of Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02 by which the Superintendent of the Securities Market accepts Mr. Pereda's withdrawal and designates Mr. Rivero as Deputy Superintendent of the SASCM to continue evaluating this PAS through its request for access to public information channeled through the Officer Responsible for Access to Public Information of the SMV and via Office No. 3567-2021-SMV/11 of September 7, 2021, issued by this SASCM by which it was informed about the designation of Mr. Carlos Rivero to resolve this PAS, as a result of Mr. Pereda's abstention.
Through Resolution No. 002738-2021-JUS/TTAIP-SEGUNDA SALA of December 3, 2021, the Transparency Tribunal declared the appeal filed by Mr. Keil founded; consequently, it ordered the SMV to deliver the requested documentation.
It should be noted that through Office 4630-2021-SMV/11 of November 29, 2021, Mr. Keil was informed that an additional period of ten (10) business days was granted for him to present his allegations regarding the following reports issued by the IGCC through which the reconsideration appeal presented is evaluated: (i) Report No. 303-2021-SMV/11.2, and (ii) Report No. 921-2021-SMV/11.2, counted from the day following the Transparency and Access to Public Information Tribunal's resolution of said appeal; and once said additional period ended, a pronouncement would be issued in accordance with the applicable regulations. Based on these grounds, it is clear that JCR cannot affirm that it has not had access to documents of this PAS, including Memorandum No. 126-2021-SMV/02, since it has been evidenced that the SMV has provided access and all necessary facilities for it to access them. Likewise, it cannot be affirmed that this Deputy Superintendency has transgressed the Law of the Code of Ethics of the Public Official nor much less violated any of the rights to which JCR refers in its writing. On the contrary, its right of defense has been guaranteed, attending to its requests for extensions to present its defenses, as well as providing and making available the documentation it required in this PAS.
The need to request an Ampliatory Report is consistent with article 155 of the TUO of the LPAG, which states "Administrative procedures are developed ex officio, in a simple and effective manner without recognizing determined forms, procedural phases, rigid procedural moments to carry out certain actions or respond to precedence between them, unless expressly provided otherwise by law in special procedures".
As a consequence, there is no such contradiction, much less an inexplicable decision. The request for the Supplementary Report is framed within the principle of material truth, set forth in the Single Ordered Text of the LPAG, which provides that the competent administrative authority must fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all evidentiary measures authorized by law[13]. Hence, the administrative authority is permitted to evaluate evidence regardless of the moment in which it was presented, since its mission is to ascertain the material truth in the terms set forth.
Pursuant to Memorandum 2391, the scope of the Report was requested to be expanded due to the documents and arguments presented by JCR, such as the WhatsApp transcripts and the statements about an alleged fortuitous event that would exempt it from liability. As can be seen, what this Deputy Superintendency sought to clarify were the reasons why JCR had not timely submitted the financial information that is the subject of the charges, it being necessary to consider that the IGCC, through Report No. 1404-2020-SMV/11.2 of December 30, 2020, recommended that the SASCM sanction JCR for having incurred in the late submission of the Audited Annual Individual Financial Information and Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2018, infractions of a minor nature classified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which was assessed in a single instance by the SASCM, deciding to sanction JCR through the Challenged Resolution, in line with the technical opinion of the IGCC.
For this, it was necessary to have all the evidence and analyze all the arguments presented, since the Report evaluating the reconsideration appeal proposed that the appeal be declared founded. Only in this way would it be possible to confirm whether JCR effectively complied with the requirements of the liability exemption it alleged.
Therefore, an action in accordance with law by the sanctioning body is observed when it requires the IGCC to carry out additional actions. Furthermore, JCR has also not presented any evidence to support its position that by requesting a Supplementary Report it would be acting in retaliation for the complaint it filed against it. As a result, it can be confirmed that the action of Mr. Pereda, in requesting the supplementary Report, allowed the IGCC to have greater elements of judgment in order to reevaluate its opinion contained in the Report and no harm has been generated to JCR in the exercise of its right of defense.
On the other hand, in the denied assumption that it had been verified that Mr. Pereda was in any ground for recusal; it must be indicated that, according to the regulations, the fact that the administrative authority, incurring in any of the grounds for recusal, continues to participate in the administrative procedure in question, does not imply the invalidation of the acts in which it has intervened; except in those where its arbitrariness or lack of impartiality is incontrovertible or where it would have caused defenselessness to the administered.[14] On this point, at no time has JCR been able to demonstrate that Mr. Pereda acted arbitrarily, or with lack of impartiality or that with his action he would have caused defenselessness. On the contrary, he requested the Supplementary Report in order to resolve with all the evidence and elements necessary to prove or not the existence of a liability exemption in JCR's conduct, also considering the special circumstances and facts surrounding this PAS which has been subject to reconsideration before the same administrative instance.
Thus, with the additional actions carried out by the IGCC, it was possible to verify that the problems in the timely submission of the financial information that is the subject of the charges were not due to the fact that SOA Noles untimely canceled its proposal to audit the financial statements, which supposedly constituted a liability exemption; but rather in the fact that JCR was negligent in not having considered formalizing with greater prior opportunity the contracting of an external audit firm to audit its financial information, in accordance with what was stated by SOA Noles before the IGSC and the IGCC.
Consequently, this SASCM considers that the request for a Supplementary Report has not generated any defenselessness for JCR and it has also not been proven that Mr. Pereda acted arbitrarily or impartially in this PAS.
In this way, as a result of the additional investigation activities carried out by the IGCC in order to issue the Supplementary Report, the position of SOA Noles on the statements of the reconsideration appeal was obtained, plus the information presented by the IGSC, it could be concluded that there are no elements of judgment and legal grounds for JCR to be exempted from liability and its reconsideration appeal declared founded as analyzed in this Resolution and in the Supplementary Report. On the contrary, it was possible to verify that JCR was negligent, and as a result, it failed to submit its financial information. That is why it cannot be stated that there is a contradiction between the Report and the Supplementary Report, much less that there were no reasons to require the issuance of a new Supplementary Report.
It has been proven that this procedure and JCR's rights have not been harmed by the issuance of the Supplementary Report. The Supplementary Report has allowed for greater elements of judgment to evaluate JCR's conduct and the configuration of the infraction. On the contrary, at all times JCR's right of defense has been respected; to the point of granting it a period of forty-five (45) business days to send its arguments regarding both Reports.
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments;
RESOLVES:
Register, communicate and publish.
Carlos Rivero Zevallos
Deputy Superintendent (e)
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision
Article 17.- SANCTIONING PHASE
a) The sanctioning phase is in charge of the respective Deputy Superintendent. Upon receipt of the instruction report, said official may instruct the supervision specialist or the respective General Compliance Intendancy to carry out additional actions and/or reports, as well as take, directly, statements from the persons it deems convenient. (Underline added). ↑
"To submit outside the established period, or to do so incompletely, or, without observing the technical specifications approved by the SMV or without communicating the approval by the corresponding corporate body, to the SMV, the Exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism or any other entity or subject of the securities market, the audited individual or consolidated financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report, special audit report, material events and annual reports." (Underline added). ↑
Emphasis and underline added. ↑
«Article 99.- Grounds for recusal.- The authority that has decision-making power or whose opinions on the merits of the procedure may influence the direction of the resolution must refrain from participating in matters whose competence is attributed to it, in the following cases:
3. If personally (…) it has an interest in the matter at hand or in another similar one, whose resolution may influence the situation of that one. (..)» ↑
Article 100.- Promotion of recusal
100.1.- The authority that finds itself in any of the circumstances indicated in the previous article, within two (2) business days following that on which it began to know the matter, or on which it learned of the supervening ground, raises its recusal in a reasoned writing, and remits what has been done to the immediate hierarchical superior, the president of the collegiate body or the plenary, as the case may be, so that without further procedure, it rules on the recusal within the third day.
100.2 When the authority does not recuse itself despite the existence of any of the expressed grounds, the administered can make said situation known to the head of the entity, or to the plenary, if it is a collegiate body, at any time.
Article 101.- Superior disposition of recusal
101.1 The immediate hierarchical superior orders, ex officio, or at the request of the administered, the recusal of the agent incurring in any of the grounds referred to in article 100.
101.2 In this same act it designates who will continue to know the matter, preferably among authorities of equal hierarchy, and will remit the file to them.
101.3 When there is no other public authority apt to know the matter, the superior will opt to enable an ad hoc authority, or to order that the one incurring in a ground for recusal process and resolve the matter, under its direct supervision. ↑
"Article 219.- Reconsideration appeal
The reconsideration appeal shall be filed before the same body that issued the first act that is the subject of the challenge and must be supported by new evidence. In the cases of administrative acts issued by bodies that constitute a single instance, new evidence is not required. This appeal is optional and its non-filing does not impede the exercise of the appeal. ↑
"Article 221.- Requirements of the appeal
The writing of the appeal must indicate the act being appealed and will comply with the other requirements provided in article 124." ↑
"Article IV. Principles of the administrative procedure
1. The administrative procedure is fundamentally based on the following principles, without prejudice to the validity of other general principles of Administrative Law:
(…)
1.11. Principle of material truth.- In the procedure, the competent administrative authority must fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all evidentiary measures authorized by law, even when they have not been proposed by the administered or they have agreed to exempt themselves from them.
In the case of trilateral procedures, the administrative authority will be empowered to verify by all available means the truth of the facts proposed to it by the parties, without this meaning a substitution of the evidentiary duty corresponding to them. However, the administrative authority will be obliged to exercise said power when its pronouncement could also involve the public interest." ↑
"Article 27.- Exemptions from Liability for Infractions) The fortuitous event, force majeure or another exceptional situation that, in the opinion of the SMV, is comparable to the duly proven fortuitous event or force majeure." ↑
"Article 28.- Assumptions in which the correction does not apply as an exemption from liability
The correction prior to the notification of the imputation of charges is not considered as an exemption from liability, when a communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent.
They are not subject to correction for the purposes of the provisions of literal f) of article 27:
(…)
c) The late or incomplete submission, or the non-submission of material events, financial information and annual reports.
(…)" ↑
"Article 24: Recusal:
(…)
Additionally, the General Compliance Intendancies may refrain from initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure when, at the time of detecting the minor infraction, the situation altered by the breach of the regulations has been reverted, corrected, repaired or restored by the alleged offender, the following conditions must be proven:
a) The facts are of little significance.
b) The infraction must be classified as minor.
c) The non-existence of concrete harm to investors or associates of the collective funds system.
The decision of recusal by the General Compliance Intendancies is communicated to the administered." ↑
"Article 28.- Assumptions in which the correction does not apply as an exemption from liability
The correction prior to the notification of the imputation of charges is not considered as an exemption from liability, when a communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent.
They are not subject to correction for the purposes of the provisions of literal f) of article 27:
(…)
c) The late or incomplete submission, or the non-submission of material events, financial information and annual reports." (Underline added). ↑
Article IV. Principles of the administrative procedure
1. The administrative procedure is fundamentally based on the following principles, without prejudice to the validity of other general principles of Administrative Law:
(…)
1.11. Principle of material truth.- In the procedure, the competent administrative authority must fully verify the facts that serve as the basis for its decisions, for which it must adopt all evidentiary measures authorized by law, even when they have not been proposed by the administered or they have agreed to exempt themselves from them.
In the case of trilateral procedures, the administrative authority will be empowered to verify by all available means the truth of the facts proposed to it by the parties, without this meaning a substitution of the evidentiary duty corresponding to them. However, the administrative authority will be obliged to exercise said power when its pronouncement could also involve the public interest." ↑
Single Ordered Text of the LPAG.
"Article 102.- Consequences of non-recusal
102.1 The participation of the authority in which any of the grounds for recusal concurs does not necessarily imply the invalidity of the administrative acts in which it has intervened, except in the case where manifest impartiality or arbitrariness is evident or where it would have caused defenselessness to the administered.
(…)" ↑
"4.2. GUIDELINES FOR THE APPLICATION OF THE CRITERIA
(…)
(ii) The sanction of warning may be applied when the following is concurrently met: (i) the affectation to transparency in the market is minimal; ii) the infraction committed has not caused concrete harm to investors or associates; (iii) the offending subject does not have antecedents or, having them, they are infractions classified as minor faults imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction being evaluated; (iv) the offending subject has not obtained a benefit from its illegal conduct; and (v) it has not been proven that the offender acted with malice in the commission of the infraction. ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01”
“and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to resolve reconsideration ap…”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added