SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 067-2022-SMV/11
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed against SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 045-2021-SMV/11 is declared unfounded.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | AGROINDUSTRIAS SAN JACINTO S.A.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2020007140 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2020007140 and Report No. 804-2021-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Function and competence of the SASCM
- That administrative file No. 2020007140 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervisory function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to resolve reconsideration appeals against the resolutions it issues;
- Facts
- That, by SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 045-2021-SMV/11 (hereinafter, the Challenged Resolution) of May 17, 2021, it was resolved to sanction Agroindustrias San Jacinto S.A.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) with a fine of twenty-five (25) UIT equivalent to S/ 103,750.00 (One Hundred Three Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred the serious infraction typified in subsection 2.10 numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, by not having communicated as a material fact the transfer of 819.3 hectares (along with various irrigation equipment located on said land) made in favor of Agrofutura Company S.A.C. (hereinafter, Agrofutura), on February 27, 2020;
- That, by writings presented on June 07 and 08, 2021, the Issuer filed a reconsideration appeal against the Challenged Resolution;
- That the arguments of the appeal filed have been evaluated in Report No. 804-2021-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), which has been submitted to the SASCM;
- That, by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, the TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures;
- That, in observance of the provisions of the second paragraph of article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation[1], by Official Letter No. 2942-2021-SMV/11, notified on July 23, 2021, the Report was sent to the Issuer, so that it could submit its arguments regarding it, within five (05) business days of notification. In this regard, it should be noted that the Issuer, through its writing of August 03, 2021, presented them and they will be evaluated in this Resolution;
- That, likewise, through the same communication of August 03, 2021, the Issuer requested the use of the word;
- That, through Official Letter No. 3539-2021-SMV/11 of September 03, 2021, the use of the word was granted to the Issuer for September 09, 2021;
- That, by minutes of September 09, 2021, it was recorded that the Issuer participated through its representatives in the oral report virtually in accordance with the “Provisions for the exercise of the use of the word to be carried out through the electronic platform by the administered entities, in the processing of administrative sanctioning procedures and others” approved by Superintendent Resolution No. 056-2020-SMV/02 and its amendments. In said oral report, the Issuer reiterated that according to its Internal Conduct Standards (hereinafter, NIC), the transfer of the 819.3 hectares, in favor of Agrofutura, was not communicated as a material fact, since it did not represent a significant variation of its assets; furthermore, it referred to the expiration of the PAS; finally, it indicated that the exemption from liability for induced error of the administration would be applicable, arguments that the Issuer has also reiterated in its reconsideration appeal, its written arguments and throughout the present PAS. Therefore, these arguments will be evaluated in numeral IV of this Resolution;
- Issue to be determined
- That it corresponds to determine whether or not it is appropriate to reconsider the sanction imposed in the Challenged Resolution;
- Analysis
- Of the Reconsideration Appeal
- That the reconsideration appeal was presented within the deadline established in subsection 218.2 of article 218 of the TUO of the LPAG. Likewise, it has observed the provisions of articles 124, 219 and 221 of the same norm referring to the admissibility of the reconsideration appeal;
- That the Issuer formulated the following arguments in its reconsideration appeal, detailed below:
Regarding the exemption from administrative liability
- Article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with literal e) of numeral 1 of article 236-A of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, LPAG), regulates the exemptions from liability for infractions, among which is: “Error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision”.
- Likewise, the Issuer points out that the aforementioned exemption is clearly related to the obligation of the administrative authority to provide truthful, complete and reliable information about the procedures under its charge, since this will allow the administered entities to form an adequate idea of the procedure and requirements they must comply with.
- According to article 4 of the Regulation of Material Facts and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Regulation of Material Facts), according to the Issuer, it is clear that the issuer is the one who evaluates the significance of an act and from that determines whether it qualifies as a material fact or not. In that sense, it made said qualification based on the parameters pre-established in its NIC submitted in 2014 to the SMV, without these having been observed to date. Said evaluation established that the transfer of the 819.3 hectares did not constitute a material fact, as it was not material with respect to the company's assets.
- On this, the Issuer also refers that it is necessary to reiterate that the transfer in question was not considered “relevant” by the company because it did not represent a significant variation of its assets, which as of December 31, 2017 amounted to S/ 515,399,000; of which, the value of the transferred assets amounted to S/ 13.083 million; that is, the transfer meant a decrease of 2.5% of the company's assets.
- For the preparation of its NIC, its Board of Directors identified cases in which the Regulation of Material Facts contained assumptions that did not have objective parameters to qualify a fact as material; therefore, only for those cases, it established parameters it considered reasonable for the company to qualify said facts, detailing them in article eight of its NIC. Although the company informed the SMV in 2014 of the parameters it was adopting to qualify a fact as material, said entity did not notice that said parameters did not correspond to those it would have adopted internally; therefore, the company has been complying with said NIC since 2014.
- On the other hand, the Issuer reiterates that the SMV at no time warned that the parameters established in its NIC were not correct or did not obey the criteria established by the SMV, to qualify when a disposal is made for a “significant amount” for a given company, since this varies from one company to another, so what is “significant” for one may not be for another; being an objective parameter a variable of 10%, which is also used by the SMV in other material facts, such as the reduction of net equity.
Regarding compliance with the Criteria for imposing sanctions
- The Issuer points out that it should have been considered that the attributed infraction would have been committed on December 27, 2018, that is, only nine (09) days before the same infraction was regulated as a minor infraction in numeral 3.1. of Annex I of the repealed Sanctions Regulation, which was approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
- Furthermore, according to the Issuer, the change has not been justified by the Administration, since the reason why the same infraction should be sanctioned with a much more onerous fine than the previous one has not been supported, considering that said infraction has the same characteristics, moreover, it is drafted exactly the same as the previous text.
- According to the Issuer, it is understood that, for this type of special cases, in which there is clearly no proportionality between the facts (alleged infraction) and the sanction provided by the Sanctions Regulation (from 25 UIT to 50 UIT), it would be appropriate to impose a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided, as indicated in the last paragraph of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation.
- Likewise, the Issuer maintains that it has noticed that other companies that had incurred the infraction typified in subsection 2.10, of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, have been sanctioned with much lower fines than the one imposed in its case; despite the fact that said companies had incurred up to sixteen (16) infractions, between minor and serious.
- Finally, the Issuer specifies that under that reasoning, in case a sanction is imposed, it considers that the most adequate, reasonable and proportional would be a reprimand, since it complies with the guidelines established for such case, such as: i) The affectation to market transparency is minimal; ii) the infraction committed has not caused a concrete detriment to investors or associates; iii) the infracting subject has no antecedents or having them, they are infractions typified as minor faults imposed in the (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction being evaluated; iv) the infracting subject has not obtained a benefit from its illegal conduct; and, v) it has not been proven that the infractor acted with intent in the commission of the infraction.
Regarding the expiration of the PAS
- On this point, the Issuer points out that the notification of the imputation of the charge was made by Official Letter No. 977-2020-SMV/11.2, on February 27, 2020, so from that date, the nine (09) month period that your office had to resolve began to count.
- Said period expired on November 27, 2020; however, considering that by Urgency Decrees No. 029-2020 and 053-2020, as well as Supreme Decree No. 087-2020-PCM; the computation of the terms of the administrative sanctioning procedures was suspended from March 21, 2020 to June 10, 2020; therefore, it resumed on June 11, 2020, with the term expiring on February 19, 2021; the Challenged Resolution not having been issued until that date.
- According to the Issuer, although, on January 13, 2021, Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2021-SMV/11 was notified, by which they extend the term to resolve the PAS by three (03) months, said Resolution is null, by not complying with the requirement demanded in subsection 1 of article 237-A of the LPAG, consisting of “issuing a duly supported resolution, justifying the extension of the term”.
- Indeed, Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2021-SMV/11 does not contain a real justification for the extension of the term; nor has it supported said justification.
- The Issuer maintains that regarding the degree of complexity of the case, the present procedure contains a single charge, consisting of not having communicated a material fact (transfer of 819.3 hectares) within the legal term established in the regulations. A fact that was also accepted by the company when presenting the corresponding defenses; where it was explained that said transfer was publicized in its audited individual Financial Statements for the 2018 fiscal year, as well as the annual report of said year, which were presented to the SMV in February 2019.
- Likewise, the Issuer emphasizes that reference cannot be made to a complex case, because there have been no evidentiary means whose action would have required summoning third parties, such as experts, etc., or the analysis of abundant information or data that could require a long time for review.
- Thus, the Issuer argues that having expired the nine (09) month term to resolve, without there being a justification for an extension of the term; it corresponds that the expiration of the present PAS be declared and consequently the proceedings be archived.
- Evaluation of the Reconsideration Appeal
- That, in relation to the arguments of the Issuer contained in its reconsideration writing, we must point out the following:
- In relation to the arguments presented by the Issuer in its appeal, it corresponds to indicate that the Issuer reiterates all of what was stated in its main defenses, the same ones that were evaluated in due course by the SASCM, whose evaluation result is contained in the Challenged Resolution;
- It should be noted that in the present appeal, the Issuer has added a new argument referring to the criteria for the determination of sanctions, provided in article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation; as well as, the corresponding evaluation of the expiration of the present PAS;
Regarding the exemption from administrative liability
- The Issuer reiterates this argument, according to which it would be in the assumption of exemption from liability for error induced by the Administration, because the law does not define what should be understood by a material fact; which is incorrect, considering that both the LMV and the Regulation of Material Facts clearly define what should be understood by a material fact.
On this, it corresponds to review article 28 of the LMV, which states the following:
“The registration of a certain security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of the material facts, including ongoing negotiations, about itself, the security and the offer made of it, as well as to disclose such facts in a truthful, sufficient and timely manner. The information must be provided to said institutions and disclosed as soon as the fact occurs or the issuer becomes aware of it, as the case may be. The importance of a fact is measured by the influence it may exert on a sensible investor to modify their decision to invest or not in the security”. (Highlight added).
- While article 3 of the Regulation of Material Facts, defines material fact as:
“(…) any act, decision, agreement, fact, ongoing negotiation or information referred to the Issuer, its securities or its businesses that have the capacity to significantly influence in:
3.1. The decision of a sensible investor to buy, sell or hold a security; or,
3.2. The liquidity, price or quotation of the issued securities.
Likewise, it comprises the information of the Issuer's economic group that it knows or should reasonably know, and that has the capacity to significantly influence the Issuer or its securities, as indicated in this Regulation”. (Highlight added).
- Thus, it is evident that both norms clearly define material fact; therefore, the argument raised by the Issuer lacks foundation and consequently, the exemption from liability provided in literal e) of article 27 of the Sanctions Regulation[2] is not configured, so the Issuer's argument lacks foundation.
Regarding compliance with the Criteria for imposing sanctions
- In relation to the normative modification indicated by the Issuer, it is relevant to review the following table:
| | |
|---|
| Repealed Sanctions Regulation CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10 | Date of commission of the infraction | Current Sanctions Regulation SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 |
| Annex I “Of General Infractions” They are common infractions to the Participants in the securities market and in the products market, as applicable: (…) 3.- Minor 3.1 Not providing timely, or doing so incompletely, or, without observing the technical specifications approved by the SMV or without communicating the approval by the corresponding corporate body, to the SMV, the Stock Exchange, the products exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism or any other entity or subject of the securities or products market, the audited individual or consolidated financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report, additional audit report, material facts, annual reports. | December 27, 2018 | Annex I “Of General Infractions” They are common infractions to the Participants and liquidators, as applicable: (…) 2.- Serious (…) 2.10 Not communicating material facts or not presenting audited individual or consolidated financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report or special audit report and annual reports Effective from December 19, 2018 |
| Minor infraction, punishable with a fine of not less than one (1) UIT and up to twenty-five (25) UIT. | | Serious infraction, punishable with a fine of not less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT. |
- In this regard, it should be noted that it was necessary to adapt the Sanctions Regulation to the modifications made to the LPAG; as well as to introduce other modifications in order to deter and avoid behaviors contrary to the current legal order.
- In that sense, the current Sanctions Regulation incorporates new infraction types, new criteria that must be applied for the graduation of sanctions; provisions on corrective measures; the prescription and expiration of the sanctioning procedure; exempting and mitigating conditions of liability; the obligation to notify the instruction reports and those containing the opinion regarding the appeals; a greater development on the content of the complaints and the condition of complainant; as well as assistance between organs of the SMV in the processing of sanctioning procedures, among others.
- Likewise, during the validity of the repealed Sanctions Regulation, new regulations were approved and various modifications were made to the regulation under the competence of the SMV that translate into obligations and responsibilities of natural and legal persons under its supervision, so that, in some cases, it was necessary to eliminate, modify and reclassify various types of infraction, in order to adapt them to the current regulations, so that there is an updated organic body that harmonizes with the regulation issued by the SMV in recent years.
- Consequently, the reclassification of the infraction type responds to a regulatory improvement, and is far from an individual action conducive to harming the Issuer.
- Now, regarding the faculty provided in the last paragraph of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation, which states:
“Article 25.- SANCTION CRITERIA
(…)
When, from the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria, it is noted that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the imputed facts, by exception and by reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided may be imposed.
- According to Marcial RUBIO CORREA[3], discretion is: "the margin of judgment that the Law gives to the organs and agencies of the State to exercise their powers in accordance with the purposes for which they were established and in accordance with the public interest." In this regard, the Constitutional Court of Peru[4] states that "administrative entities enjoy freedom to decide on a specific matter given that the Law, in a broad sense, does not determine what they should do or, failing that, how they should do it."
- In this sense, it could be established that administrative discretion is the power granted by the legal system to an administrative body to decide on a matter for which a strict solution is not contemplated in the regulation or norm, or is ambiguous.
- Likewise, the Constitutional Court in the Callegari Judgment[5] has been clear in emphasizing the importance of the "motivation" element in every discretionary act: "the exercise of a discretionary power must be accompanied by a motivation that precisely shows the coherent link between the adopted means and the general interest circumscribed to which it aims [...] Thus, the public interest, as an indeterminate concept, is built on the basis of the motivation of decisions, as a sine qua non requirement of the discretionary power of the Administration, excluding any possibility of arbitrariness."
- It should be noted that, in the present case, the motivation supports the reason for a choice, which is characterized by being plausible and related to the facts. In this regard, reference should also be made to Due Process, one of the rights of administered persons according to the TUO of the LPAG, which also requires a reasoned resolution.
- In that order of ideas, the motivation set forth in the Challenged Resolution is the result of the reasons that justify the decision and action of the Administration, which functions as a kind of guarantee of transparency of information in the securities market so that, based on it, the investor adopts their decisions.
- Finally, it can be concluded on this point that this figure helps the administrative authority determine what really benefits or harms the public interest; for which, it allows decision-making without prior conditions and directed solely by the particular evaluation of the relevant circumstances that concur in each case. From this concept, each PAS has specific facts, grounds, and legal framework that results in unique and particular decisions; in observance of the corresponding legal framework and full compliance with the principles of Law.
Regarding the expiration of the PAS
- On this point, the Issuer contradicts itself because it states that until February 19, 2021; the date on which the expiration of this PAS operates, the SMV did not issue any pronouncement.
- However, it is necessary to point out that through Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 006-2021-SMV/11 (hereinafter, Extension Resolution), notified to the Issuer on January 18, 2021, the SASCM resolved to extend by three (03) months the term to resolve the administrative sanctioning file No. 2020007140, in application of numeral 1) of article 259 of the TUO of the LPAG and literal b) of article 43 of the Sanctions Regulation.
- Now, regarding the Issuer's request for nullity because the Extension Resolution does not contain a real justification for the extension of the term; as well as, it has not supported said justification, it must be specified that what the Issuer maintains is incorrect, for the following reasons:
- The Extension Resolution states that it is necessary to extend due fundamentally to the degree of complexity of the case.
- The Extension Resolution states that it is necessary to extend due to the degree of the alleged infraction that is the subject of the PAS.
- The Extension Resolution states that it is necessary to extend due to the situation and the National State of Emergency that the country is facing due to the COVID-19 pandemic that has generated, among others, the accumulation of files corresponding to sanctioning procedures and others.
- The Extension Resolution states the need to dedicate more time to the attention and development of all these procedures; remote work and the use of telematic communications that also originate the need to dedicate more time to the different administrative procedures in charge of the SASCM.
- Having said that, it is concluded that the Extension Resolution does not incur any vice that is a cause of nullity, provided in article 10 of the TUO of the LPAG:
"Article 10.- Causes of nullity
The following are vices of the administrative act that cause its nullity of full right:
1. The contravention of the Constitution, laws or regulatory norms. 2. The defect or omission of any of its validity requirements, unless one of the assumptions of conservation of the act referred to in article 14 is present.
3. Express acts or those that result as a consequence of automatic approval or positive administrative silence, by which powers or rights are acquired, when they are contrary to the legal system, or when the requirements, documentation or essential procedures for their acquisition are not met.
4. Administrative acts that are constitutive of a criminal infraction, or that are issued as a consequence thereof."
- In addition to the evaluation carried out so far, it should be indicated that the Issuer, by maintaining securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market – RPMV, is obliged to observe and comply with the communication and information disclosure regime[6]; strictly, regarding the communication of material events in a timely manner.
- Consequently, since the Issuer did not communicate the material event subject of this PAS; it is considered that said information was presented extemporaneously to the market.
- Therefore, it is concluded that the Issuer's conduct is reprehensible to the extent that it did not observe the duty of diligence[7] required of every market participant; whose purpose is to preserve market transparency, which is a fundamental condition for the proper functioning of the securities market; which entails that participants in it access in a timely, complete, reliable and clear manner the information related to the relevant aspects of the issuing companies and the securities issued.
- Finally, regarding what the Issuer stated regarding the sanction criteria provided in article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation; it should be noted that said criteria were evaluated at the time of determining the sanction as shown in Section V of the Challenged Resolution; which has allowed the sanction to be determined under the principle of reasonableness.
- That, through a brief dated August 3, 2021, the Issuer presented its arguments regarding the Report that analyzes the Reconsideration Appeal, indicating the following:
- From the first moment, it indicates that it disclosed the transfer subject to charge and considered it non-material; even before the start of the PAS in its Financial Statements, which include the operations carried out in the year, such as sales and/or transfers; as well as in its Annual Report.
- The 2018 Financial Statements cited reveal on page 44 various purchases of assets, including land of 38 and 20 hectares, which, not being representative with respect to the total assets of the Issuer, were not reported as Material Events; which has not been observed by the SMV.
Similarly, on page 20 of the 2018 Annual Report, the Issuer reported the delivery of 1,271 work uniforms; and on page 21 it details the fraternization and integration activities carried out on Secretary's Day, Mother's Day, Labor Day, national holidays, etc., facts that do not qualify as material events because they are recorded in the aforementioned Annual Report.
- Likewise, the Issuer again states the arguments it already used in its defenses to question the position of the Challenged Resolution regarding the exemption from responsibility for inducement to error by the administration.
- On the other hand, it reiterates its arguments regarding the disproportionality of the sanction imposed. Furthermore, it affirms that the Administration has not adequately motivated the Challenged Resolution, since it does not state the reason for the application of such a burdensome fine (more than S/ 100,000) for not reporting as a material event the transfer of a piece of land, which was reported in the Financial Statements and Annual Report of the 2018 fiscal year.
- The Issuer also asserts that the Extension Resolution is null, because it contains an apparent motivation. This is because it would not have complied with the provisions of subsection 1 of article 237-A of the LPAG, consisting of "issuing a duly supported resolution", justifying the extension of the term.
Regarding the degree of complexity of the case, it states that this PAS contains a single charge, consisting of not having communicated a material event (transfer of 819.3 hectares) within the legal term established in the regulations; a fact that was also accepted by the Issuer when presenting the corresponding defenses; where it was explained that said transfer was publicized in the Audited Individual Financial Statements of the 2018 fiscal year, as well as the Annual Report of that year, which were presented to the SMV in February 2019. Likewise, it refers that it could not refer to a complex case, because there have been no evidentiary means whose action would have required summoning third parties, such as experts, etc., or the analysis of abundant information or data that could require a long time for review.
Regarding the situation and the National State of Emergency; it indicates that it cannot be considered as a justification, because, for that reason, the State had already suspended the terms of the PAS between March 21 and June 10, 2020, time that was considered sufficient for all its entities. Likewise, it is not reasonable to indicate that remote work and the use of telematic communications justify the delay in the resolution of a not at all voluminous file, which was also fully digitized; being appropriate to remember that the attention of these procedures has always been remote, since the company has its headquarters in the Department of La Libertad, province of Ascope; which has never constituted an obstacle in the development of the procedures.
Along these lines of ideas, it concludes that there was an apparent motivation in the Extension Resolution, by having limited itself to enumerating situations for which it was appropriate to extend the term by three (03) months, without specifying any of them, without having motivated in a founded manner the exercise of said exceptional power; therefore, it is appropriate to declare the nullity of said administrative act, through which the term was extended by three (03) additional months to resolve the PAS and, therefore, having expired the term of nine (09) months to resolve, without there being a justification for an extension of the term; it is appropriate to declare the expiration of this PAS and consequently file the proceedings.
- That, regarding these arguments, the following should be noted:
- Regarding the argument that the Issuer disclosed the transfer subject to charge even before the start of the PAS in its Financial Statements; it should be indicated again, as was done in the Challenged Resolution, that the central object of this PAS and of the imputed charge was that the Issuer did not disclose such transfer as a material event and at the corresponding opportunity. As a consequence, a charge was imputed to the Issuer for not communicating said transfer, so that argument in no way exempts the offender from responsibility.
- Regarding the purchases of assets, including land of 38 and 20 hectares; or the delivery of 1,271 work uniforms; and the fraternization and integration activities carried out on Secretary's Day, Mother's Day, Labor Day or national holidays; it should be noted that these purchases or activities are not part of this PAS, so it is not appropriate for us to rule on such facts.
The infraction imputed to the Issuer is related to the non-communication of a material event related to the transfer of 819.3 hectares in favor of Agrofutura. This transaction qualifies as a material event, according to numeral 16 of Annex 1 of the Material Events Regulation: "Acquisition, disposal or restructuring of assets and/or liabilities for significant amounts (...)." As a consequence, the facts indicated by the Issuer are not relevant to this PAS.
- On the other hand, it should be emphasized that the Issuer errs in asserting that the exemption from responsibility for inducement to error by the Administration would be applicable to it. This argument presented by the Issuer has already been analyzed and refuted both in this Resolution, as well as in the Report and in the Challenged Resolution and it should be indicated again that both the LMV and the Material Events Regulation are quite clear in defining what should be understood by material event. Therefore, it cannot be affirmed that the administration has induced the Issuer into error, so that argument also lacks foundation.
- In relation to the arguments, defenses and allegations of the Issuer in the sense that in its Internal Conduct Rules (NIC) it has established objective parameters, because the Material Events Regulation contains assumptions that do not have objective parameters to qualify a fact as material; it is necessary to highlight that this has no foundation in said Regulation, that is, the current and applicable norm does not enable an issuer to establish parameters or "magic numbers" from which the amount of an operation or transaction qualifies as a material event. That procedure of an issuer and of the Issuer in particular, generates the serious danger, among others, that through said parameters the purpose of the information disclosure requirement would be emptied of content, the principle of transparency of information in the securities market is harmed and the protection of investors in said market is significantly damaged, which are legal assets that the SMV must protect.
In addition, it should be noted that establishing parameters arbitrarily by an issuer, as in the particular case, so that from them the issuer itself is obliged to report material events to the securities market, not only lacks legal foundation and sense, but also harms the trust and development of the securities market. It would be a very easy mechanism to be used and taken advantage of by any issuer to establish at its sole discretion, the highest parameters or those that generate the least possible number of reporting duties, and this simply lacks support and sense, and therefore such procedure must be clearly and emphatically rejected, in all cases and specifically in this PAS.
- The Issuer also indicates that there would be a lack of reasonableness in the sanction imposed; however, this is not correct. It should be specified that the Issuer has incurred a serious infraction, to which, according to the Sanctions Regulation, a fine of 25 UIT to 50 UIT corresponds. As can be seen, the lowest amount fine has been imposed. Furthermore, this has been determined after having evaluated the Sanction Criteria, which have been explained in detail in the Challenged Resolution. Therefore, it cannot be affirmed that the fine imposed is not reasonable. Likewise, the fact that it reported in the Financial Statements and Annual Report of the 2018 fiscal year the information subject to charge, does not prevent that, despite this, it has breached its obligation to communicate it as a material event.
- Finally, regarding the assertion that the Extension Resolution would be null for lacking motivation; it should be specified, as was done in the Report and in this Resolution when analyzing the reconsideration appeal, that the Extension Resolution has been issued duly motivated and therefore no expiration has occurred as the Issuer alleges.
In this regard, the Extension Resolution based its motivation on the following facts: the degree of complexity of the case; the degree of the alleged infraction that is the subject of this PAS; the situation and the National State of Emergency in which the country was, the Covid-19 pandemic, the commission of the infraction, which generated the accumulation of files corresponding to other PAS; and the need to dedicate more time to the attention and development of all these procedures, so the arguments formulated by the Issuer to question the validity of the Extension Resolution lack foundation;
- That, in relation to the foregoing, and the facts that are the subject of this reconsideration not having changed and all the arguments of its reconsideration appeal having been analyzed, as well as its written and oral arguments presented by the Issuer, it is considered that the Challenged Resolution should be confirmed, since the appellant has not presented new documentation or argumentation that allows varying the pronouncement issued; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- Declare unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by Agroindustrias San Jacinto S.A.A., against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 045-2021-SMV/11 of May 17, 2021.
- Confirm Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 045-2021-SMV/11, which sanctions Agroindustrias San Jacinto S.A.A. with a fine of 25 UIT[8] equivalent to S/ 103,750.00 (One Hundred Three Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles), for not communicating the material event referring to the transfer of 819.3 hectares in favor of Agrofutura Company S.A.C.
- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and it may be challenged before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision through the filing of an appeal, an administrative remedy recognized in article 218 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a double-instance administrative procedure.
- In the event that this Resolution is not subject to challenge through an appeal, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of the last paragraph of article 14 of SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe this Resolution to Agroindustrias San Jacinto S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision
-
Article 18.- Reconsideration and Appeal Appeal
(...)
"If a reconsideration appeal is filed, the Deputy Superintendent notifies the administered party of the report of the General Compliance Intendency that contains the opinion on the appeal filed, so that it formulates its allegations within a period of no less than five (5) days, counted from the day following the mentioned notification." ↑
-
"Article 27.- EXEMPTIONS FROM RESPONSIBILITY FOR INFRACTIONS
(...)
e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
(...)" ↑
-
Rubio Correa, 2010. "Fundamental Rights in the Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court. Analysis of Articles 1, 2 and 3 of the Constitution". Lima: Editorial Fund of the Pontifical Catholic University of Peru. P. 152. ↑
-
File No. 0090-2004-AA/TC. ↑
-
File No. 0090-2004-AA/TC Lima
https://www.tc.gob.pe/jurisprudencia/2004/00090-2004-AA.html ↑
-
"Article 13.- Purpose
(...)
Legal entities registered in the Registry and the issuer of registered securities are obliged to present the information that this law and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of the information."
↑
-
"ARTICLE 6.- DUTY OF DILIGENCE
In compliance with the obligations established in this Regulation, the Issuer is responsible for:
6.1. Ensuring that the information it communicates has the capacity to significantly influence, as defined in articles 3 and 4, and that it is truthful, clear, sufficient and timely, as well as that it is not disseminated to a specific group of investors or other groups with an interest in it before it is available to the entire public, through the means established in this Regulation.
(...)
6.7 Comply with the obligations that are enforceable against it in this Regulation". ↑
-
Value of the UIT (2018): S/ 4, 150.00 (Four Thousand One Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles) (Supreme Decree No. 380-2017-EF). ↑