SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 110-2018-SMV/11
Summary: Sanction Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. with a fine of 72.20 UIT, for having incurred very serious and serious infractions, typified in subsection 1.1, numeral 1 of Annex I and in subsection 2.14, numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | EMPRESA AGRÍCOLA SAN JUAN S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2017039252 |
The Deputy Superintendent (e) for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2017039252 and Report No. 306-2018-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Facts
- That, on May 6, 2017, Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) published in the newspaper La República, the notice of call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting whose agenda was: (i) Approval of the Audited Economic Management, Annual Report and Financial Statements for the 2016 fiscal year; (ii) Election and/or ratification of the Company's Board of Directors; and, (iii) Establish the dividend policy for the coming years. However, it did not communicate said call as a material event to the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV), nor did it attach the documents that would be the subject of discussion at said Meeting;
- That, on May 31, 2017, the Issuer submitted the Independent Auditors' Report as part of its Individual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2016, which states the following: *"(…) 4. As explained in note 6(b) to the financial statements, the Company maintains as of December 31, 2016, a loan receivable from a Director, which amounts to approximately S/ 16,658,000. Said loan originated from advances granted in 2013, 2014 and 2015, with only a partial rendering during those years and to date with an asset of S/ 5,557,000 and a compensation with dividends of approximately S/ 1,132,000. As of the date of this report, we have not been able to obtain sufficient and appropriate evidence to conclude whether said loan is recoverable. (…)" ;
- That, on June 8, 2017, Mr. César Blademir Quintana Fernández and others, denounced before the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), the reduction of the Issuer's profits since 2015, year in which said company would have suffered a loss of S/ 1,500,000. Furthermore, they indicated that according to the publication of the individual audited financial information, the external auditors' report highlighted the existence of a loan receivable in favor of its Director, Mr. Redublino Huancaruna Perales (Mr. Huancaruna), a loan that amounted to approximately S/ 16,658,000;
- That, through Official Letter No. 3850-2017-SMV/11.2 of June 14, 2017, the IGCC forwarded the complaint to the Issuer, requesting it, among others, to inform the date of the loan in favor of Mr. Huancaruna; as well as to send copies of the Board minutes that would be linked to the agreement of said loan;
- That, through a writing dated June 26, 2017 and in response to the aforementioned Official Letter, the Issuer indicated that the disbursements of money made in favor of Mr. Huancaruna did not have the condition of a personal loan, but rather were disbursements of money for investment projects for the benefit of the company subject to rendering. They also attached a copy of the minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting of February 28, 2006, contained in the Book of Minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting No. 02, where - according to the Issuer - the financing of investment projects was approved. It should be noted that, according to the Issuer, said agreement allowed it to make loans and/or disbursements of money in favor of Mr. Huancaruna;
- That, through Official Letter No. 4773-2017-SMV/11.2 of July 26, 2017, the IGCC requested the Issuer additional information regarding the loan that would have been made in favor of Mr. Huancaruna;
- That, through Official Letter No. 4781-2017-SMV/11.2 of August 1, 2017, the IGCC requested Mr. Huancaruna information regarding the loan that the Issuer would have disbursed in his favor and that was a "Scope limitation" indicated in the Independent Auditors' Report of the financial statements as of December 31, 2016 of the Issuer;
- That, through a writing dated August 10, 2017, the Issuer responded to the requirements of Official Letter No. 4773-2017-SMV/11.2 of July 26, 2017;
- That, through a writing dated August 15, 2017 and in response to Official Letter No. 4781-2017-SMV/11.2, Mr. Huancaruna indicated that by virtue of the agreement of the General Shareholders' Meeting of February 28, 2006, he was authorized to make investments for the benefit of the Issuer in sectors related to its economic activity, for which he would have received sums of money to make investment projects viable;
- Charges and defenses formulated
- That, as a result of the preliminary inquiries carried out by the IGCC, through Official Letter No. 7122-2017-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), charges were formulated against the Issuer for:
- Carrying out acts or contracts, not authorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations; and,
- Not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market;
- That, these non-compliances are typified in numeral 1.1, subsection 1 of Annex I and numeral 2.14, subsection 2 of Annex I, respectively, of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation);
- That, through a writing presented on November 7, 2017, the Issuer requested an extension of ten (10) additional business days to the term indicated in the Letter of Charges to present its defenses;
- That, through Official Letter No. 7474-2017-SMV/11.2, the IGCC granted the Issuer the requested extension to present the corresponding defenses;
- That, through a writing presented on November 21, 2017, the Issuer submitted its corresponding defenses, stating the following:
Regarding the carrying out of acts or contracts not authorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations
- The Issuer states that the prohibition provided in subsection a) of article 51 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (LMV) is imposed on the directors and managers of the Issuer and not on the Issuer, so said obligation does not correspond to it; but rather falls on Mr. Huancaruna in his capacity as Director, so that the infraction of said norm cannot be imputed to it because it would be incurring in the violation of the principle of typicity provided in subsection 4 of article 246 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS (TUO of the LPAG). Thus, in the Issuer's opinion, an extensive interpretation would be being made, considering as active subject of the alleged infraction who has not been imposed said prohibition.
- On the other hand, the Issuer maintains that subsection a) of article 51 of the LMV is located in Title III of the same and that by legislative systematic (statements of articles 49, 50 and 52 of Chapter I of the LMV), prima facie the obligations, prohibitions, responsibilities, are provided for issuers that have made primary or secondary public offering of securities (public offering of acquisition, public offering of purchase, public offering of sale and exchange offering), procedures that it would not have carried out. In the Issuer's opinion, affirming the contrary would be failing to comply with the principle of predictability or legitimate trust and procedural good faith, which obliges the administrative authority to submit to the current legal system and not act arbitrarily, all the more, if the ratio legis of the referred regulation is aimed at safeguarding the use of financial resources captured through a primary public offering.
- The Issuer also states that the principles of causality and culpability would be being disregarded. Of causality, since it would have been sufficiently accredited that responsibility should only fall on who performs the omissive or active conduct constituting a punishable infraction. While of culpability - since administrative responsibility is subjective - it is a legal impossibility to attribute it to a legal person.
- Furthermore, the Issuer states that the SMV would not have competence to address issues such as the one described, for the following: (a) The imputation is not taxatively provided in the scope of article 253 of the General Corporations Law, Law No. 26887 (LGS) - referring to the SMV's control over open corporations -; (b) There is no corresponding section in the Sanctions Regulation for such cases, as provided and empowered to the SMV, through numeral 5 of article 253 of the LGS; and, (c) Being such infractions constrained to issuers that have made public offerings; strictly, the facts communicated as charges must be treated within the framework of intra-corporate relations, since through article 179 of the LGS it has been established that directors are jointly and severally liable to the company and third-party creditors for contracts, credits, loans or guarantees celebrated or granted.
- In relation to the loan that the Issuer would have made to Mr. Huancaruna, it states that having produced the rendering of accounts of 33.35% of the disbursements received, it is undoubted that it cannot be a loan, all the more so when there exists the "Private Document of Renewal of Commitment to Render Sum of Money and Approval of New Payment Schedule" of April 30, 2017, signed between the Issuer and Mr. Huancaruna – the latter, in his capacity as Director of the Issuer –. It also adds that regarding the support of the investment acts, these have been recorded in the financial information sent to the SMV.
- Finally, the Issuer refers that the reiteration of requiring a board agreement for the disbursement acts in favor of Mr. Huancaruna is disproportionate and excessive, even more so, if it is taken into account that in accordance with numeral 5 of article 114 and numeral 8 of article 115 of the LGS, the General Shareholders' Meeting is empowered to resolve on any other matter included in the call or another that requires the social interest. Thus, if the LGS has not provided, taxatively, powers for the Board of Directors, it is undoubted that the agreements of the General Meeting are fully valid, resulting in the application of the apothem ad majoris ad minus.
Regarding not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market
- The Issuer states that its omission to inform is framed within the discretionary margin that the securities market regulations extend to issuers, according to article 4 and numerals 5.1 and 5.2 of article 5 of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (Regulation of Material Events), which would constitute an exemption from responsibility due to confusing norm, according to literal e) of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, since according to the Issuer, it is clear that the aforementioned numerals suggest that the criterion of qualification, by the administered, of an act or fact prevails in order to be qualified as material. In this sense, it adds that according to numeral 5.1 of said Regulation, the corresponding Annex is only referential to facilitate the discretionary criterion of the Issuer.
- Likewise, the Issuer states that the confusing norm would be complemented with the provisions of article 27 of the Regulation of Material Events, since it states that it is the attribution and obligation of the SMV to require the Issuer to disseminate, eventually or periodically, through the means provided for material events, that information that, in its judgment, has the capacity to exert the significant influence referred to in articles 3 and 4 of the Regulation of Material Events and, therefore, with the non-observance of said requirement, a punishable infraction would be configured.
- Consequently, the Issuer concludes that both due to the exemption from responsibility due to confusing norm, and due to the fact that by regulation the infraction is configured with the non-compliance before the prior requirement of the SMV, its actions would not be within the scope of the sanctionable assumption, so the facts described as infraction are atypical;
- That, through Legislative Decree No. 1272, which modified, among others, numeral 3) of article 230 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (LPAG); new criteria for the graduation of the sanction were incorporated as follows: (i) the probability of detection of the infraction and (ii) recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final. Currently, these criteria of reasonableness are established in numeral 3) of article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG;
- That, the charges formulated, the defenses presented by the Issuer and the new criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been submitted to the knowledge of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 253 of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 1928-2018-SMV/11, the Report was sent to the Issuer, so that the Issuer can send its defenses within the term of five (05) business days of notification, which were sent on April 25, 2018 and are evaluated by the SASCM in this Resolution;
- That, on April 25, 2018, the Oral Report requested by the Issuer was held, with its representatives attending the SMV;
- Issues to determine
- That, in this administrative procedure it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not the Issuer incurred in the infractions indicated in the Letter of Charges and Report.
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on the Issuer;
- Analysis
- Applicable Regulations
- That, literal a) of article 51 of the LMV establishes: "Issuers with securities registered in the Registry are subject to the following norms: a) Directors and managers are prohibited from receiving in loan money or goods from the company, or using for their own benefit, or of those who have a relationship with them, the goods, services or credits of the company, without authorization from the Board of Directors. (…)";
- That, the non-compliance with the aforementioned regulation is typified in subsection 1.1 of numeral 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a very serious infraction of the participants in the securities market: "Carrying out functions, operations, activities, acts or contracts, not authorized or that do not comply with the requirements established in the regulations or that have not been registered in the Registry, when applicable.";
- That, according to article 20 of the Sanctions Regulation, very serious infractions are punishable with a fine greater than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT;
- That, article 28 of the LMV states: "The registration of a certain security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of the material events, including ongoing negotiations, about itself, the security and the offer made of it, as well as to disclose such events truthfully, sufficiently and timely. The information must be provided to said institutions and disclosed as soon as the event occurs or the issuer becomes aware of it, as the case may be;
- That, subsection 9.1 of article 9 of the Regulation of Material Events refers: "The Issuer must report its material event as soon as such event occurs or the Issuer becomes aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it has occurred or has been known (…)";
- That, the infraction for not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market is typified in subsection 2.14, numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, states that it constitutes a serious infraction of the participants in the securities market: "Not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market";
- That, according to article 21 of the Sanctions Regulation, serious infractions are punishable with a fine not less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT;
- Evaluation of the case
- That, in relation to the defenses presented by the Issuer, the following must be indicated:
Regarding the carrying out of acts or contracts not authorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations
-
That Article 51 of the LMV establishes obligations for both the Issuer and certain persons. In the particular case of subsection a), it is noted that the obligation is for the Issuer and for the directors and/or managers who may receive money or goods on loan from the company. For the Issuer, said prohibition finds its correlate in the infraction established in subsection 1.1, numeral 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, as indicated in the Letter of Charges, so it can be stated that said conduct is unlawful and, consequently, sanctionable.
-
That subsection a) of Article 51 of the LMV establishes precise rules, imposing an express prohibition for issuers with securities registered in the RPMV not to lend money or goods of the company without the proper authorization of the Board of Directors. Taking into account said prohibition, it should not be overlooked that said act is an agreement between two parties, one of them, inevitably a issuing company with securities registered in the RPMV and the other, a director of said issuing company. In the specific case, the Issuer and Mr. Huancaruna, respectively.
-
That the Issuer had the duty to verify whether the loan it would give to Mr. Huancaruna complied with the requirement of having been approved by the Board of Directors as a whole; however, it has not shown evidence of having complied with this requirement, but rather tries to justify its action with an agreement of the General Shareholders' Meeting of February 28, 2006 - which will be analyzed in detail later - which did not authorize the granting of a loan and/or disbursement of money on a personal basis to the directors of the Issuer, much less replaced the authorization required from the Board of Directors, according to subsection a) of Article 51 of the LMV. Likewise, one of the roles of the company's bodies is the defense of the interests of its shareholders, interests that may be affected when some actions of said bodies have an impact on the company's equity, by negatively affecting its profits, which may decrease or even disappear. Note that in this sanctioning procedure, the decrease in profits recorded in 2015 was what motivated the complaint of some of its shareholders.
-
That admitting that the issuing company whose securities are registered in the RPMV has no responsibility would be to conclude that any Director has absolute power in the administration of the company and in the decisions made in it and that his sole order imposes compliance with any contractual obligation, which is considered cannot be allowed in any company under the scope of the LGS, much less in a participant of the securities market and therefore, under the scope of the LMV.
-
That the Issuer questions the obligation referred to in subsection a) of Article 51 of the LMV stating that it is located in Title III of the LMV, so said obligations would be provided for issuers that have made a public offering. According to the Issuer, since it has not made any public offering, it considers that said obligation is not enforceable against it. In this regard, the Issuer has its securities registered in the RPMV to date, so the obligations indicated in Article 51 of the LMV are enforceable against it, an obligation that complies with the principle of legality and does not violate the principle of predictability nor supports arbitrary action by the SMV, but rather supports the imputation made through the Letter of Charges.
-
That it should be noted that the Issuer is mistaken in stating that it has not made a public offering of its securities, since the listing of previously issued securities on the stock exchange also implies the making of a public offering, by generating the creation of a market in which multiple buyers and sellers can trade said securities.
-
That the principle of culpability represents a guarantee and at the same time a limit to the punitive power of the State. In this sense, the degree of culpability required will depend on the type of infraction analyzed; having said this, Article 51 of the LMV does not require the violation of any legal interest nor that the conduct has produced a concrete risk to a legal interest, but considers as "risk" the simple disobedience to its provisions. In the present case, the Issuer had the duty to request the authorization of the Board of Directors in order to finalize the loan made in favor of Mr. Huancaruna. Not having done so constitutes the mere non-compliance with the norm (which the administered had the duty to know and respect) and, therefore, having incurred in negligence. Consequently, in this way, the culpability of the Issuer is demonstrated.
-
That the Issuer states that it finds disproportionate and excessive the reiteration of requiring a Board agreement for the disbursement acts in favor of Mr. Huancaruna, if one takes into account that in accordance with numeral 5 of Article 114 and numeral 8 of Article 115 of the LGS, the General Shareholders' Meeting is empowered to resolve on any other matter that requires the corporate interest consigned in the convocation.
-
That according to the writings of June 26 and August 10, 2017, presented by the Issuer, the loans of money in favor of Mr. Huancaruna would have been made by virtue of the agreement taken in the General Shareholders' Meeting held on February 28, 2006, minutes that are contained in the Book of Minutes of General Shareholders' Meeting No. 02 legalized by the Justice of the Peace of Fourth Nomination of the City of Chongoyape, and a copy of which was sent to the IGCC as part of the preliminary inquiries.
-
That according to the writing of June 26, 2017, the Issuer specifies that in the aforementioned Meeting, "the financing of investment projects was approved, under the same mechanism and conditions in which it was approved in 2012". However, when the IGCC again requested copies of the minutes of the Board sessions, this time of 2012, by which the loans and/or disbursements of money in favor of Mr. Huancaruna would have been authorized, through writing of August 10, 2017, the Issuer stated that: "there are no Board session agreements on this particular matter, since the agreement had already been adopted by the General Shareholders' Meeting in 2006."
-
That in attention to what was indicated by the Issuer, below is transcribed point 5 of the minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting of February 28, 2006, which states the following:
"5.- Financing of future investment projects.
Mr. President stated that the company, given the favorable investment conditions in the country, should invest in future projects that are profitable and benefit the company, that is, alternative agro-export products, carrying out development programs and counting on adequate technical assistance, and also authorizing it to study various external financings which will serve for projects that are duly supported.
The attendees agreed unanimously the sole resolution
SOLE RESOLUTION:
The attendees agreed unanimously to grant powers to the Board of Directors so that they make the appropriate decisions for the benefit of the company for the financing of future investment projects and also authorize it to study various external financings which will serve for projects that are duly supported before the General Meeting."
-
That from the pertinent part of the minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting of February 28, 2006, it is evident that the Shareholders' Meeting of the Issuer granted powers and authorized the Board of Directors, a collegiate body, to make appropriate decisions for the benefit of the company for the financing of future investment projects, in addition to authorizing it to study various external financings which would serve to invest in projects that are duly supported before the General Shareholders' Meeting. However, it did not authorize, in any way, the granting of a loan and/or disbursement of money on a personal basis in favor of any of the directors of the Issuer.
-
That through writing of June 26, 2017, the Issuer stated that, by agreement contained in the minutes of March 31, 2012 that would appear in the Book of Minutes of General Shareholders' Meeting No. 02 legalized by the Justice of the Peace of Fourth Nomination of the city of Chongoyape, the extension of financial and contractual powers as Special Attorney in favor of Mr. Huancaruna was approved, with the purpose of enabling the execution of the investment projects proposed for the benefit of the Issuer.
-
That the Issuer stated that the agreement described above was registered in entry C000024 of Electronic File No. 11002001 of the Registry of Legal Persons of the Registry Office of Chiclayo. In the Issuer's opinion, the registration would prove the destination of the funds for investment projects, so it sent a copy of the registry entry to the IGCC as part of the preliminary proceedings carried out by the latter.
-
That in attention to what was indicated by the Issuer, below is transcribed the pertinent part of the registry entry C000024 of which the following is noted:
"First Resolution.- Approve the extension of financial and contractual powers, proposed by the President of the Meeting, which will be exercised by the Special Attorney Redublino Olivio Huancaruna Perales, identified with DNI 16419958.
(…)
(i) Extension of financial powers
- Represent the company individually, and with sole signature before entities of the Financial System, banking and national and international insurance companies; in this sense, it may with its sole signature open and close all types of bank accounts, whether savings accounts or checking accounts in national or foreign currency, or any banking modality, it may also deposit and withdraw any amount from said accounts at any time and under any modality established by said institutions, request and receive all types of credits without limit of amounts or reason. (…)"
-
That from the transcribed extract, it is evident that although there is an extension of financial powers in favor of Mr. Huancaruna, these would be regarding acts that he could perform, as Special Attorney, always in representation of the Issuer and not on a personal basis. In this sense, the transcribed registry entry recognizes powers to deposit and withdraw money from accounts that appear in the name of the Issuer, as well as request and receive all types of credits without limit of amounts or reason, always in the name and for the benefit of the Issuer.
-
That from the documents reviewed, it can be seen that the Shareholders' Meeting: (i) Empowered its Board of Directors, and not Mr. Huancaruna, to make decisions for the financing of investment projects specifically in alternative agro-export products, and not at discretion, that are profitable and benefit the company; and, (ii) Extended the financial powers of Mr. Huancaruna so that he could withdraw money from accounts that appear in the name of the Issuer as well as request credits in the name of the latter, but not to disburse said resources as a loan, or any other figure, in favor of himself.
From the above, the delegation of decision-making from the Shareholders' Meeting to the Board of Directors and the extension of financial powers in favor of Mr. Huancaruna, would not have empowered him to receive a loan and/or disbursement of money on a personal basis, nor replace the authorization required from the Board of Directors, according to subsection a) of Article 51 of the LMV.
- That in the face of the questioning of the SMV's competences, it is necessary to remember that the SMV is a specialized technical body with legal personality of internal public law, whose purpose is to ensure the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through the regulation, supervision and promotion of the securities market. In order to achieve its purposes and in the face of non-compliance with the norms provided in the LMV and other general provisions, the SMV exercises its sanctioning power by applying the Sanctions Regulation whose scope includes natural and legal persons that must comply with the norms under the competence of the SMV, in accordance with Article 2 of the Sanctions Regulation.
That, since the Issuer is a company whose securities are registered in the RPMV, it is included under the scope of the regulation, supervision, as well as the sanctioning norms of the SMV, so the Sanctions Regulation is applicable to it.
-
That in relation to the loan that the Issuer would have made to Mr. Huancaruna, the former states that having existed the rendering of accounts of 33.35% of the disbursements received, it cannot be a loan, especially since there is the "Private Document of Renewal of Commitment of Rendering of Sum of Money and Approval of New Payment Schedule" of April 30, 2017, signed between the Issuer and Mr. Huancaruna – the latter, as Director of the company. It also adds that regarding the support of the investment acts, these have been recorded in the financial information sent to the SMV.
-
That it is necessary to reiterate that from the analysis of the "Private Document of Renewal of Commitment of Rendering of Sum of Money and Approval of New Payment Schedule" of April 30, 2017, signed between the Issuer and Mr. Huancaruna, the existence of a money loan contract that would amount to S/ 16,658,002.61 is evidenced, a contract that would not have had the authorization of the Board of Directors. It should be noted that in said private document, the payment date appears as December 31, 2017 and interest amounting to S/ 1,032,796.16 – product of the multiple disbursements that would have been carried out from 2012 to 2016, the last disbursement being made on June 27, 2016 –, also recording a payment schedule and registering an interest rate of 6.20% per year. Likewise, said document represents reliable proof of the existence of the loan granted by the Issuer to Mr. Huancaruna – as Director –, since from the objective data found in the contract, the nature of said document cannot be doubted.
-
That the Issuer has stated that it would not be a loan, but a disbursement of money, without making a clear difference between one and the other act, and maintaining that having rendered account of 33.35% of the loan – a percentage for which the Issuer has not shown evidence – would be sufficient circumstance not to qualify said act as a money loan.
-
That the Issuer states that the required support of the investment acts would have been recorded in the financial information sent to the SMV. In this regard, the Issuer has not specified what would have been the destination of the money that it would have disbursed in favor of Mr. Huancaruna in order to make investments, nor which are the assets with which the Issuer would have been benefited, so generically mentioning that the support of its investment acts would have been recorded in the financial information sent to the SMV, is insufficient and does not disprove what was imputed in the Letter of Charges.
Regarding the failure to communicate material facts that have a significant impact on the market
- That, although the discretionary nature of each Issuer's decision in classifying a material event cannot be denied, it should not be overlooked that there are reference parameters that the Material Events Regulation itself indicates: (i) The analysis that the Issuer must carry out regarding whether the act, decision, agreement, fact, ongoing negotiation or information related thereto has the capacity to significantly influence the decision of a sensible investor to buy, sell or hold a security, on the liquidity, price or quotation of the securities issued; and, (ii) The assumptions indicated in the Annex that forms part of the Material Events Regulation.
- That, taking into account the importance of the matters to be discussed at the Meeting and considering that the audited annual financial information had a "Scope Limitation" indicated by its external audit firm – on which there would be valid questions from its shareholders –, this Deputy Superintendency does not consider that the argument presented by the Issuer regarding its discretion to classify said fact as material is sufficient.
- That, the SASCM makes clear that the publication made in the newspaper La República on May 6, 2017, a copy of which was sent to the IGCC in its brief of June 26, 2017 as part of the preliminary inquiries, is not being questioned, but rather the failure to communicate as a material event the call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting attaching documentation relevant to its shareholders such as: (i) The individual audited financial statements as of December 31, 2016; and, (ii) The Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2016; documents essential to be able to attend any Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting duly informed.
- That, it should be noted that because the call and the documents that would be discussed at said Meeting were not publicized, at least seven (07) shareholders of the Issuer, duly identified, have declared that they became aware of their content only when they were presented on May 31, 2017 before the RPMV, that is, even after the holding of the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting.
- That, likewise, the Issuer states that the confusing regulation would be complemented by the provisions of article 27 of the Material Events Regulation, since it states that it is the attribution and obligation of the SMV to require the Issuer to disseminate that information that, in its judgment, has the capacity to exert significant influence referred to in articles 3 and 4 of the Material Events Regulation, through the means provided for that purpose, and only upon non-compliance with the requirement would a sanctionable infraction be configured. The Issuer concludes that both due to the exemption from liability for confusing regulation mentioned above, and due to the fact that by regulation the infraction is configured with non-compliance with the SMV's requirement, it would not be within the scope of the sanctionable assumption, the facts described as an infraction being atypical.
- That, article 27 of the Material Events Regulation refers to the SMV's power to require any Issuer to disseminate that information that it considers has the capacity to exert significant influence, in order to ensure the transparency of the securities market and investor protection; of course, provided that the SMV has knowledge of the existing fact. Otherwise, it could not exercise this power that the Material Events Regulation indicates. Precisely, due to the limitation of knowing the fact subject to charge, the SMV could not require the Issuer to disseminate the call, nor the documents that were part of it.
- That, in the specific case, the only means by which the SMV could have noticed the omission to communicate as a material event the call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting and its respective documents would have been the publication made by the Issuer – of which knowledge was had as a result of the preliminary proceedings carried out – or by complaints made by any affected party, as in fact has been detailed above.
- That, it can be stated that the Issuer did not communicate the call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, which was held on May 16, 2017, which should have contained the agenda to be discussed and the necessary documentation. Consequently, it did not communicate a material event that had significant repercussion in the market.
- That, with regard to the brief of April 25, 2018 presented by the Issuer, in accordance with numeral 5 of article 253 of the TUO of the LPAG, it is noted that it reiterates the arguments of its first brief, the same ones that have been evaluated in the preceding paragraphs;
- Determination of the Sanction
- That, having determined the commission of the imputed infractions, it corresponds to evaluate the sanction to the Issuer, in accordance with article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with numeral 3 of article 246 of the LPAG, and for these purposes the following criteria must be taken into consideration:
- That, with respect to the infraction for carrying out acts or contracts, unauthorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations, after analyzing the impact produced by the Issuer's non-compliance in granting a loan to its Director, without authorization from the Board of Directors, it can be stated that the main beneficiary of the operation was Mr. Huancaruna, who discretionally decided on the destination of the resources granted to him as a loan and obtained rates of return higher than the cost of the credit;
- That, on the other hand, the main affected parties would be the company's shareholders due to two elements: (i) Opportunity cost: since the resources granted as a loan could have had another use, such as being invested in the company's line of business; and, (ii) Credit risk: because whenever a loan is granted there is a risk that the principal or interest will not be paid. It should be noted that a group of minority shareholders have denounced that due to the loan granted to said Director, which would amount to S/ 16,658,000.00 – according to the "Private Document of Renewal of Commitment to Render Sum of Money and Approval of New Payment Schedule" –, they would have seen their profits reduced since 2012;
- That, however, although from the preliminary proceedings carried out before the issuance of the Letter of Charges, as well as from the analysis of the defenses presented by the Issuer, it can be stated that there has been an affectation to the complaining shareholders, it cannot be concluded that the Issuer has obtained an illicit benefit from the commission of said infraction;
- That, in relation to the second charge regarding the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market by the Issuer, although it can be stated that its conduct shows negligence in the communication of the call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, it cannot be concluded that there has been an illicit benefit in favor of the Issuer;
- That, with respect to the infraction for carrying out acts or contracts, unauthorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations, the legal asset sought to be protected is the transparency that every Issuer with securities registered in the RPMV must have. It should be noted that the registration of a given security and the consequent possibility of making a public offering of securities implies for the Issuer the obligation to inform about its situation permanently, that is, the obligation to be transparent, which the Issuer has not done either before the market or with its minority shareholders, who in order to know more about said loan have had to choose to report this fact to the SMV;
- That, since the infraction committed by the Issuer has been ongoing for at least five fiscal years, as part of the analysis of this criterion the period from which the loans in favor of Mr. Huancaruna began has been taken into account, which reveals the serious damage to the public interest, which is considered a protected legal asset;
- That, in relation to the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market such as the call of May 6, 2017 to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, it should be indicated that the legal asset sought to be protected is also market transparency. In this sense, not having communicated said call constitutes a serious damage to the public interest towards investors and/or potential investors; and, especially, to the interest of the minority shareholders who were deprived of the possibility of a detailed and anticipated study of the documents to be discussed at said meeting; and who later would state that the Issuer communicated – belatedly – their approval, as a material event;
- That, with respect to the infraction for carrying out unauthorized acts or contracts or without complying with the requirements of the regulations, it can be stated that, in line with the two criteria analyzed above, although the non-compliance committed by the Issuer represents a serious damage to the protected legal asset that is the transparency of information and although the investors denounced an economic detriment caused such as the reduction of their profits, it has not been proven whether said loan was the cause for which said economic detriment occurred and, therefore, such economic detriment cannot be attributed exclusively to said loan. However, this does not prevent that in the future, if the loan to the Issuer is not cancelled, this criterion may change.
- That, in relation to the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market such as the call of May 6, 2017 to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, it can also be stated that although the non-compliance committed by the Issuer represents a serious damage to the protected legal asset that is the transparency of information, it has not been proven whether this non-compliance produced any economic detriment to the minority shareholders, except for not having in a timely manner the information on which the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting would discuss;
- That, as part of the circumstances of the commission of the infraction to be taken into account, with respect to the infraction for carrying out unauthorized acts or contracts or without complying with the requirements of the regulations, the questioning that the Issuer has made of the SMV's power has been taken into account, also stating that the loans granted in favor of Mr. Huancaruna should be analyzed intra-corporately so there should be no interference by the SMV. Likewise, the Issuer has questioned the nature of the disbursement that it would have granted in favor of Mr. Huancaruna, due to the existence of an accounting of 33.36%, which has not been supported with any document by the Issuer. All the aforementioned arguments have been answered in the section regarding the evaluation of defenses;
- That, in relation to the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market such as the call of May 6, 2017 to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, it can be stated that although a notice was published in the newspaper La República on said date, this fact does not diminish the Issuer's responsibility, especially because the shareholders did not have the necessary documentation in advance, in order to study it and ask the questions they deemed necessary before said Meeting;
- That, another point to take into account for both infractions is, without a doubt, the complaint presented by the minority shareholders of the Issuer, which evidences a lack of communication on the part of the company with its shareholders. This fact has also been considered in the determination of the sanction imposed;
- That, with respect to this criterion, it should be indicated that, as part of its defenses, there was a questioning by the Issuer, according to which, as a legal person, it was not liable for culpability for granting loans to a Director, without authorization from its Board of Directors;
- That, as mentioned in response to said defense, subsection a) of article 51 of the LMV states that in order to carry out said operation, the Issuer had the duty to require authorization from the Board of Directors. Not having done so constitutes the mere non-compliance with the rule (which the administered parties had the duty to know and respect) and, therefore, incurring in negligence. Consequently, its culpability is thus evidenced;
- That, in relation to the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market, such as the call of May 6, 2017 to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, in the same sense, said non-compliance implies the mere non-observance of the rule and, therefore, incurring in negligence. Therefore, the Issuer's culpability is also evidenced with respect to this infraction;
- That, it has been verified that the Issuer has a record of sanctions, having been sanctioned through: (i) Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 294-2013-SMV/11 of August 19, 2013, confirmed by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 371-2013-SMV/11 of December 9, 2013; (ii) Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 021-2015-SMV/11 of January 21, 2015; and, (iii) Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 186-2015-SMV/11 of September 22, 2015. It should be noted that said sanctions were imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infractions under analysis;
- That, likewise, in the present case it is not observed that the Issuer has incurred in the aggravating factors referred to: (i) The accreditation of a quantifiable detriment; (ii) Serious repercussion in the market; (iii) The obtaining of an illegal benefit; and/or, (iv) Intent in the commission of the infraction;
- That, likewise, it is appropriate to note that the criterion of repetition and/or continuity of the infraction has been repealed by numeral 3) of article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG;
- That, on the other hand, it is pertinent to analyze the new criteria incorporated by numeral 3) of article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG, referring specifically to: (i) The probability of detection of the infraction; and, (ii) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final;
- That, with regard to the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that the detection of non-compliance with the obligations indicated in article 51 of the LMV, especially subsection a), not only required the use of internal control systems, but also the use of additional means or tools, so the probability of detection of the infraction is low and, therefore, should increase the sanction proposed;
- That, however, since the disclosure of said loan was made expressly in the financial statements presented by the Issuer, this Deputy Superintendency considers that in the case under analysis, this criterion should not aggravate the sanction proposed;
- That, with respect to the non-communication of material events that have significant repercussion in the market such as the call of May 6, 2017 to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting, the detection of this non-compliance is also not carried out solely through internal control systems, so the probability of detection of the infraction is low as indicated above. Thus, the SMV became aware of this non-compliance through the complaint of the affected shareholders. Consequently, with respect to this infraction, the sanction imposed must be increased;
- That, with respect to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, it is verified that there is no recidivism on the part of the Issuer in the commission of the infractions analyzed within the term of one (01) year, the term indicated by Law, so it is not applicable;
- That, therefore, in merit of all the foregoing and under the criteria of reasonableness and proportionality, this Deputy Superintendency considers that the Issuer must be imposed as a sanction a fine amounting to 76 UIT in force at the time of the commission of the facts;
- That, said amount is the product of the sum of 51 UIT[1] for carrying out unauthorized acts or contracts or without complying with the requirements of the regulations, since the last loan made to its Director, as indicated above, was made on June 27, 2016, in accordance with the detail of disbursements provided by the Issuer; and, 25 UIT[2] for not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market, such as the call to the Mandatory Shareholders' Meeting of May 6, 2017;
- That, finally, it should be noted that in this sanctioning procedure the mitigating factors indicated in article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG are applicable, because the proposed sanction is a fine;
- That, with respect to the clarification of the infraction, it should be noted that the Issuer, by presenting its defenses as well as by answering the different briefs within the framework of the preliminary inquiries, has contributed to the clarification of the infraction. Consequently, it is considered pertinent to make a reduction of five percent (5%) to the fines proposed for each infraction;
- That, attending to the Sanction Criteria in force at the time of the commission of the infractions and the New Criteria, which have been detailed in the Report, it corresponds to sanction the Issuer with a fine of 72.20 UIT equivalent to S/ 287,565.00 (Two Hundred Eighty-Seven Thousand Five Hundred Sixty-Five and 00/100 Soles). It should be noted that this amount includes the five percent (5%) reduction for the mitigating factor applied to each infraction; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numeral 14 of article 43 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, for carrying out acts or contracts, unauthorized or without complying with the requirements of the regulations.
- Sanction Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. with a fine of 48.45 UIT equivalent to S/ 191,377.50 (One Hundred Ninety-One Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-Seven and 50/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 1 of this Resolution.
- Declare that with respect to article 2 above, this Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and may be challenged before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal, administrative remedies recognized in article 216 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS, within the term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a double administrative instance procedure. The issuer may avail itself of the incentive regime indicated in article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
- Declare that Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, for not communicating material events that have significant repercussion in the market
- Sanction Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A. with a fine of 23.75 UIT equivalent to S/ 96,187.50 (Ninety-Six Thousand One Hundred Eighty-Seven and 50/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 4 of this Resolution.
- Declare that with respect to article 5 above, this Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and may be challenged only through the filing of a reconsideration before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, provided in article 216 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS, within the term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a single administrative instance procedure. The issuer may avail itself of the incentive regime indicated in article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
- In the event that this resolution is not subject to challenge through a reconsideration or appeal, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV-01 and by the provisions of article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
- Transcribe this resolution to Empresa Agrícola San Juan S.A.; and, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish,
Carlos Enrique Meneses Camargo
Deputy Superintendent (e)
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision
- Value of the UIT (2016): S/ 3,950 (Supreme Decree No. 397-2015-EF). ↑
- Value of the UIT (2017): S/ 4,050 (Supreme Decree No. 353-2016-EF) ↑