Superintendent's Resolution
No. 083-2021-SMV/02
Lima, August 24, 2021
The Superintendent of the Securities Market
WHEREAS:
File No. 2018044191 and Report No. 816-2021-SMV/06, issued by the Legal Advisory Office;
CONSIDERING:
- That, by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 032-2019-SMV/11 (hereinafter the Appealed Resolution), a fine of ten (10) UIT was imposed on ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. (hereinafter, ICCGSA) for having incurred a minor infraction, typified in subsection 3.4, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time the facts occurred[1] (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), for not having timely designated its audit firm;
- That, by document received on April 10, 2019, ICCGSA filed an appeal against said resolution (hereinafter, the Appeal);
- That, by Report No. 816-2021-SMV/06 of July 23, 2021 (hereinafter, the REPORT), the Legal Advisory Office issued an opinion on ICCGSA's appeal[2];
- ARGUMENTS OF THE APPEAL
- That the appellant alleges that the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, SASCM) did not properly motivate said resolution and did not resolve in accordance with law, by having imposed a fine disproportionate to the infraction committed, for reasons detailed in the following recitals;
- That there was no lack of diligence in its actions, since the failure to timely designate the audit firm is due to a “fortuitous event”, unforeseeable, irresistible and extraordinary, as Ingenieros Civiles y Contratistas Generales S.A. (hereinafter, ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA) was subject to insolvency proceedings that indirectly affected ICCGSA. According to it, for that reason various audit firms it approached did not accept the engagement to analyze its financial statements;
- That, on this point, it alleges that the submission of ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA to insolvency proceedings was made on January 10, 2018, and its declaration of insolvency was made on July 23, 2018, so before that, ICCGSA could not have known of the insolvency situation of ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA;
- That the SASCM imputes facts to ICCGSA based on assumptions and not on certain and proven facts, and when establishing a sanction, the authority cannot base itself on probable facts, but on certain and proven facts; therefore, the presumption made by the SASCM in recital 23 of the Appealed Resolution should not be considered, since in the appellant's opinion, it lacks support;
- That the SASCM has not applied the attenuating condition of liability for infractions contemplated in subsection a) of numeral 2 of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, referring to the voluntary declaration of the commission of the imputed infraction, which has avoided a cumbersome sanctioning procedure for the SMV.
- That, regarding this argument, ICCGSA alleges that it has complied with the requirements demanded by law in its voluntary declaration of the commission of the imputed infraction, since, after the imputation of charges by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (IGCC), ICCGSA, through a defense brief in response to Official Letter No. 6439-2018-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Charge Letter), proceeded to make a voluntary declaration of the commission of the imputed infraction. According to it, this declaration was made in writing and expressly, with no doubt or vagueness in said declaration. Additionally, such fact has been recorded in report No. 1456-2018-SMV/11.2 of the IGCC (hereinafter, the Report), which recommends applying the attenuating circumstance;
- That it questions the amount of the sanction imposed and alleges that a correct analysis of its quantification was not made. Therefore, in the appellant's opinion, the sanction imposed is not proportional to the infraction committed by ICCGSA, in accordance with the principle of reasonableness contemplated in subsection 3 of Article 248 of the current TUO of the LPAG. On this matter, it refers to the fact that the Report proposes a sanction of 1 UIT, whereas the Appealed Resolution imposed a sanction of 10 UIT, without further justification of its differences with the criterion proposed by the IGCC;
- ANALYSIS
- That, in accordance with the second paragraph of Article 13[3] of the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV), legal entities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (hereinafter, RPMV) and the issuer of registered securities are obligated to present the information that said law and other general provisions establish;
- That, regarding issuing companies, as is the case of ICCGSA, Article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation and Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information (hereinafter, RIF), approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10, establishes that “Companies obligated to present audited financial information must communicate, as a material fact, the designation of their independent auditors no later than June 30 of each year (…)”;
- That the Sanctions Regulation establishes in its subsection 3.4 of numeral 3 of Annex I that it constitutes a minor infraction: “Not designating the audit firm, or not communicating its change, within the period provided in the regulations;” an infraction type included in section 3.4 of numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, hereinafter New Sanctions Regulation. It should be noted that infractions committed before the entry into force of said Regulation shall be substantiated in accordance with the rules in force at the time they occurred, unless the approved provisions are more favorable, it being necessary to highlight that it is not the case that the infraction type included in numeral 3.4[4] of Annex I of the New Sanctions Regulation is more favorable than the infraction type in force at the time the facts occurred;
- That, in the present case, it is observed that ICCGSA did not comply with designating, within the period established in Article 38 of the RIF, the audit firm responsible for auditing its financial information corresponding to fiscal year 2018. It should be noted that the audit firm should have been designated no later than June 30, 2018; however, it was designated on December 20, 2018, a fact that gave rise to the sanction imposed in the Appealed Resolution;
- That ICCGSA alleges that the infraction committed is due to a “fortuitous event”, related to the submission to insolvency proceedings of a third company, ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA, which would have generated that no audit firm accepts the engagement to audit its financial statements. Additionally, it alleges that it could not have known of the submission of said company to insolvency until the date on which the declaration of insolvency was published;
- That it must be kept in mind that the appellant alleges and develops in the Appeal the application of the fortuitous event regarding the submission of ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA to insolvency proceedings. However, the obligation before the SMV falls on ICCGSA, not on ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA, so the analysis of the configuration of the fortuitous event should not focus on whether ICCGSA could or could not foresee or avoid the submission to insolvency proceedings of a third party, but on whether it could or could not foresee or avoid the breach of the obligation that ICCGSA maintains before the SMV and investors, by virtue of the securities market regulations. This obligation corresponds to the designation of its independent auditors within the period established by Article 38 of the RIF;
- That, regarding fortuitous event or force majeure, subsection a, numeral 1, of Article 255 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS, hereinafter TUO of the LPAG, which governed at the time the facts occurred, now subsection a), numeral 1 of Article 257[5] of the current TUO of the LPAG, states that these may be exempting from liability provided they are duly proven in accordance with the following:
Article 255.- Exemptions and attenuating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute exempting conditions of liability for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
(…)”
- That, in this regard, it should be noted that fortuitous event or force majeure is regulated in Article 1315 of the Civil Code, which states:
“Article 1315.- Fortuitous event or force majeure is the non-imputable cause, consisting of an extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible event, that prevents the execution of the obligation or determines its partial, late or defective fulfillment.” (Underline added)
- That, although the Civil Code uses the terms ‘fortuitous event’ and ‘force majeure’ as equivalent, doctrine and jurisprudence have delimited their differences, with fortuitous event being related to events proper to the forces of nature, while force majeure enters the sphere of action of human beings[6]. Therefore, for the purposes of this case, the concept of ‘fortuitous event’ will be considered as an imputable fact and within the sphere of responsibility of ICCGSA, since it is the term used by the appellant in the Appeal;
- That, according to the cited article of the Civil Code, for a fortuitous event to be configured, the fact must have three concurrent characteristics: that it be extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible. Additionally, that the breach be due to a cause not imputable to the agent obligated to comply;
- That fortuitous event is understood as that fact that cannot be anticipated or whose occurrence cannot be noticed or, when having noticed it, compliance would have been impossible (unforeseeable); it supposes the impossibility of compliance (irresistible); it is a fact that is out of the ordinary (not usual); it cannot be imputed to the obligated party and these requirements must be duly proven. On these requirements, Felipe Osterling Parodi states the following:
“In order to avoid possible confusion, it is convenient to clarify terms. An extraordinary event is any that is out of the ordinary, that is not usual. Foreseeability, on the other hand, must be considered at the time the obligation is contracted; unlike resistibility, which appears at the time of fulfilling it. If the event were irresistible from the moment the obligation was contracted, the legal act would be null, because it would have an impossible object. The requirement of foreseeability is demanded when the debtor did not foresee what he should have, or when, having foreseen the event, he obligates himself to something that presumably was going to be impossible. In both cases the event is imputable to the debtor, as it is equivalent to a fact of his own.
But foreseeability should not be appreciated in the abstract, because if we did so practically every event would be foreseeable; and there would not be, therefore, fortuitous event or force majeure. The event is unforeseeable when the contracting parties have no reasonable grounds to presume that it will happen. The notion of unforeseeability is appreciated, then, taking into consideration all the circumstances of the obligation. The rarity, the abnormal character of the event, the remote possibilities of realization, configure the fortuitous event or force majeure.
The requirement of irresistibility, finally, supposes the impossibility of compliance. The difficulty of compliance does not exonerate the debtor, even when the performance has become more onerous than expected. Nor does the personal situation of the debtor matter; the absence of economic means to fulfill the obligation has no liberating force”[7] (Underline added)
- That, in the present case, the obligation to designate independent auditors before the date established in Article 38 of the RIF falls on ICCGSA for being registered in the RPMV and not on any other company. Therefore, the analysis on the configuration of the fortuitous event must focus on the impact and actions of ICCGSA. Therefore, it is worth asking whether the submission of a third party to insolvency proceedings influences ICCGSA's obligation to comply with the provisions of Article 38 of the RIF;
- That ICCGSA's allegation that the audit firms declined its requests for services caused by the insolvency proceedings to which a third person, ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA, was subject, has not been corroborated by any evidentiary means. However, it should be mentioned that this argument makes evident that ICCGSA knew and could foresee before the period established by Article 38 of the RIF the fulfillment of the obligation before the SMV, eliminating outright the unforeseeability of the result. Taking this into account, ICCGSA should have adopted the necessary actions to achieve the provision of the service with any of the various audit firms existing in the market;
- That, regarding the element of unforeseeability of the fortuitous event, in accordance with the doctrine presented, the fact or event is considered unforeseeable when it surpasses or exceeds the normal foresight aptitude of the obligated party. In this regard, the obligated party must comply with a minimum duty of diligence. In this context, although there is no proof that the alleged fact has caused the infraction, as previously mentioned, with ICCGSA knowing in advance of the refusal or lack of willingness of the audit firms to contract with it, unforeseeability in the breach cannot be alleged;
- That ICCGSA alleges that it was not possible for it to foresee the submission of ICCGSA CONSTRUCTORA to insolvency proceedings, so that event, in its understanding, was unforeseeable. In this sense, the appellant states that it was not possible to know said event, given that they are different legal entities, having different management personnel. In this regard, it should be noted that, although they are different legal entities and may have different management personnel, both companies are part of the same economic group. On this matter, Article 6 of the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Linkage and Economic Groups, approved by SMV Resolution No. 019-2015-SMV/01, refers to the concept of ‘control’ and defines it as: “…the preponderant and continuous influence in the decision-making of the governing bodies of a legal entity or bodies that fulfill the same purpose in the case of a legal entity”. With regard to control, it must be taken into consideration that since December 2017 both companies shared five board members[8];
- That, regarding evidentiary means, it should be noted that the rejection of any audit firm caused by the reasons indicated by ICCGSA has not been proven, nor has the diligence that an issuer must have in foreseeing that one or some of the firms might not contract with the issuer been proven, even without considering the fact that a person related to it is subject to insolvency proceedings. It should be noted that one or some audit firms might not contract with any issuer under normal conditions, which must be foreseen by said company in order to be diligent in complying with Article 38 of the RIF;
- That, on the other hand, the irresistibility of the fact argued by ICCGSA is also not proven, considering that to designate an audit firm there is not a market with reduced supply, but one can choose among a variety of audit firms, with which ICCGSA had the possibility of contracting within the corresponding period with an audit firm. Additionally, it must be kept in mind that the rule establishing the breached obligation has been in force since January 1, 2017[9];
- That, consequently, we disagree with what the issuer maintains in the sense that it could not comply with its obligation based on the fact that an event would have affected the contracting of an audit firm, without proving this fact and neither the direct relationship with the alleged fortuitous event, as well as having a known period that has not been varied since 2017 and counting on a large supply of audit firms[10];
- That, regarding the situation described by ICCGSA, in the sense that the submission to insolvency proceedings of a related company could generate an extraordinary situation in the willingness of audit firms, the elements of unforeseeability and irresistibility that suppose the existence of an exemption for fortuitous event to its obligation before the securities market regulations are not configured, in accordance with the provisions of Article 255 numeral 1 of the TUO of the LPAG that governed at the time the facts occurred and Article 1315 of the Civil Code, considering that the aforementioned three elements must converge cumulatively to configure fortuitous event or force majeure;
- That, on the other hand, ICCGSA questions recital No. 23 of the Appealed Resolution, related to the determination of the sanction and alleges that the SACSM is not based on certain and proven facts, but on assumptions to evaluate the applicable sanction. In this regard, the referred recital states:
“23. That, in relation to the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it is noted that it has been verified that the Issuer has designated its audit firm for fiscal year 2018 with one hundred seventy-three (173) calendar days of delay. It should be added that the designation in question was after the notification of the Charge Letter, and that the designation was made a few days before the end of fiscal year 2018, which in turn generated that the period that the audit firm has had or will have to perform its work is shorter, being for that reason probable that there are effects in the planning and execution of the audit, mainly in the performance of procedures and obtaining evidence or documentation that supports the opinion issued by the auditor or audit firm, all the more so if one takes into account the particular situation that the Issuer itself describes in its defense;” (the underline is ours and corresponds to the part questioned by ICCGSA in the Appeal)
- That, regarding the determination of the applicable sanction, the sanction criteria are established in Article 348 of the LMV[11], numeral 3 of Article 248 of the current TUO of the LPAG[12], Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation and Article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation (hereinafter, the Criteria);
- That, from the reading of the cited recital, it is understood that it is related to the provisions of subsection c) of numeral 3 of Article 248 of the current TUO of the LPAG, referring to the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right (principle of reasonableness), since it refers to the reduced time that the audit firm would have to perform the function and, therefore, to the harm that the market could suffer in the event that the report was not adequate. However, sufficient elements have not been found to assert, in the particular case, that there could be negative effects in the planning and execution of the audit. Therefore, the recital under question will not be taken into account for the graduation of the sanction;
- That, additionally, ICCGSA alleges that the Appealed Resolution has not considered the attenuating circumstance of liability referring to the voluntary declaration of the commission of the imputed infraction, which has avoided a cumbersome sanctioning procedure for the SMV, contemplated in subsection a) of numeral 2 of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG[13] and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation. As stated in the Appeal, ICGSSA questions that the SASCM has not applied the attenuating circumstance despite the fact that in its defense brief in response to the charge letter, it proceeded to make a voluntary declaration of the commission of the imputed infraction, which was made in writing and expressly, with no doubt or vagueness in its declaration;
- That ICCGSA filed its defenses by document of December 7, 2018. Said document states on page 1*: “In this regard, ICCGSA INVERSIONES makes a voluntary declaration of its commission, however we indicate the facts that motivated the delay in the selection and subsequent communication of the designation of our external auditors. (…)”;*
- That, on the other hand, the Report states:
“The issuer makes a voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction in question, indicating, furthermore, that one of the facts that motivated the delay is the current situation that the ISSUER is going through, among them, the number of requests for information by the Representative of Bondholders, Investors, BVL and SMV about the Bond Program.
(…)
“On the other hand, although what the ISSUER alleges is not an exempting cause of liability, the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction by the ISSUER is an attenuating condition of liability that will be applied at the time of the evaluation of the corresponding sanction.” [14]
- That, however, recital No. 28 of the Appealed Resolution states:
“28. That, regarding the alleged acknowledgment of responsibility for the infraction sustained by the Issuer, it should be noted that it must be made in an integral, precise, concise and clear, express and unconditional manner; however, in the present case, the Issuer has only justified its non-compliance in its defenses. Consequently, it does not correspond to apply the acknowledgment of the infraction as an attenuating circumstance of liability provided in subsection a) of Article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation”
- That, therefore, it corresponds to evaluate whether the declaration made by ICCGSA in its defense brief constitutes an acknowledgment of responsibility;
- That the period for compliance with the obligation expired on June 30, 2018, and ICCGSA did not comply with the provisions of the RIF. On the other hand, the New Sanctions Regulation was approved by Superintendency Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, published on December 18, 2018. In this sense, it is observed that the commission of the infraction is prior to the entry into force of the New Sanctions Regulation, so by temporal application of the rules, it corresponds to apply the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, unless the new legal body is more beneficial to the administered party, for which the following comparative table is formulated:
| |
|---|
| Former Sanctions Regulation | New Sanctions Regulation |
| Article 6 CRITERIA AND MITIGATING FACTORS TO BE CONSIDERED FOR THE IMPOSITION OF SANCTIONS The administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in Article 348 of the Law or Article 7 of Decree Law No. 21907 on Collective Fund Management Companies, as applicable; and numeral 3 of Article 230 of the Procedural Law. Likewise, the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infringement, the offender's contribution to its clarification, and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in Article 236-A of the Procedural Law shall be taken into account. | Article 26.- MITIGATING CIRCUMSTANCES OF LIABILITY FOR INFRINGEMENTS The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infringements: a) Acknowledgment of responsibility by the offender expressly and in writing, once the administrative sanctioning procedure has begun. When the applicable sanction is a fine, it shall be reduced, taking into account the following: 1. If the acknowledgment of the infringement is presented within the period granted for the submission of defenses, the reduction amount shall be fifty percent (50%). 2. If the acknowledgment is presented after the expiration of the period granted for the submission of defenses and before the expiration of the period granted to formulate allegations to the instruction report, the reduction amount shall be thirty percent (30%). 3. If the acknowledgment is presented after the expiration of the period granted to formulate allegations to the instruction report and up to before the issuance of the sanction resolution, the reduction amount shall be ten percent (10%). The acknowledgment of responsibility regarding an infringement must be made precisely, concisely, clearly, expressly and unconditionally, and must not contain ambiguous or contradictory expressions; otherwise, it shall not be understood as an acknowledgment. If defenses are presented, despite having made an acknowledgment of responsibility, it shall be understood as a non-acknowledgment, and the authority shall proceed to evaluate the defenses. |
(Underlining is added)
- That, from the comparison of both norms, it is not observed that the New Sanctions Regulation is more beneficial for the appellant, considering that it establishes more requirements for the application of the mitigating circumstance of liability. Therefore, the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time of the commission of the infringement must be applied;
- That, the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time of the commission of the infringement establishes that the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infringement shall be taken into account and does not establish greater requirements for it, unlike the New Sanctions Regulation which does establish conditions for the voluntary declaration, which are referred to in recital No. 28 of the Appealed Resolution. For the foregoing, it is not appropriate to retroactively apply the New Sanctions Regulation to the present case, as it is less favorable for the administered party;
- That, in light of the foregoing, it is appropriate to take into consideration ICCGSA's voluntary declaration as a mitigating circumstance of liability, in accordance with Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation and with the provisions of literal a) of numeral 2 of Article 255[15] of the TUO of the LPAG in force at the time of the events, reflected in literal a) of numeral 2 of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG[16], considering that ICCGSA has acknowledged the infringement expressly and in writing in the letter of December 7, 2018, addressed to the IGCC;
- That, regarding the acknowledgment of responsibility as a mitigating circumstance of the sanction, it should be noted that from our point of view the offender's statement cited in recital No. 30, regarding what was said in ICCGSA's defense brief '(...) makes a voluntary declaration of its commission (...)', implies the acknowledgment of its responsibility provided in literal a) of numeral 2 of Article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG
- That, although in the same brief ICCGSA mentions the circumstances for which it incurred the infringement imputed in the charge document, it does not elaborate on them, nor does it substantiate how such circumstances could justify its fault. In that sense, within the framework of the cited article of the TUO of the LPAG and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time of the commission of the infringement, such declaration meets the requirements of being express and in writing;
- That, consequently, in the analyzed case, the application of the provisions of literal a), numeral 2 of Article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG in force at the time of the events corresponds, reflected in literal a), numeral 2, of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG which establishes that in cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it must be reduced;
- That, finally, ICCGSA questions the amount of the sanction imposed and alleges that a correct analysis of its quantification was not carried out, so, in the appellant's opinion, the sanction imposed is not proportional to the infringement committed, in accordance with the principle of reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of Article 248 of the current TUO of the LPAG. Likewise, it refers to the fact that the Report proposes a sanction of 1 UIT, whereas the SASCM imposed a sanction of 10 UIT, without further justification for its decision to vary the criterion proposed by the IGCC;
- That, in this regard, it is appropriate to refer to Article 254 of the current TUO of the LPAG, which states:
Article 254.- Characteristics of the sanctioning procedure
254.1 For the exercise of the sanctioning power, it is mandatory to have followed the legally or regulatory established procedure characterized by:
- Differentiating in its structure between the authority that conducts the instructing phase and the one that decides the application of the sanction.
(...)
- That, the differentiation between the instructing and sanctioning bodies is a guarantee of the sanctioning procedure with which it is intended to achieve the highest level of impartiality of the decision-making body;
- That, the guarantee in question implies the existence of a separation and independence between both bodies. Said independence is evident in the functions that each carries out within the sanctioning procedure: the instructor performs all the investigative work and makes it available to the sanctioning body so that it, in turn, performs the assessment of the information produced within the instruction stage and then, within the sanctioning procedure, issues a value judgment that may materialize in an administrative sanction, based on the elements gathered within the administrative sanctioning procedure;
- That, although the instructing body may make recommendations on the gradation of the sanction to be imposed, it is the sanctioning body that ultimately weighs the facts that constitute the alleged infringements, qualifies them and grades them, according to the assessment made, and the recommendation of the instructing body cannot be considered binding for the sanctioning body;
- That, having analyzed the arguments of the Appeal and established that the application of the exemption from liability for fortuitous event or force majeure does not correspond, it is appropriate to analyze the sanction criteria in order to recalculate the applicable sanction;
- That, in relation to the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement, ICCGSA states that it could not be benefited by the late designation of external auditors; on the contrary, it could be subject to a sanction by the administration. In this regard, according to the analysis of the proceedings and the Appealed Resolution, it has not been possible to determine the existence or non-existence of an illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement;
- That, regarding the probability of detection of the infringement, considering that there is an obligation to report the appointment of the audit firm through a material event as established in Article 38 of the RIF, the probability that the SMV detects the non-compliance is high;
- That, with respect to the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it is considered that the non-compliance with the obligation affects the market's interest in knowing the designation of the external auditor, which affects market transparency and its orderly development, fundamental aspects for the correct functioning of the market that, for the present case, are provided in Article 38 of the RIF. It should be noted that the audit of, among others, the Issuer's financial information, gives the market confidence in its integrity, which is why transparency in the designation of the audit firm is fundamental for the investor, which is the reason for the requirement established in Article 38 of the RIF. It should also be highlighted that the existence of claims or the quantification of particular damages to investors is not necessary, considering that the damage to the public interest has been configured with the violation of the aforementioned principles;
- That, regarding the economic damage caused and its repercussion on the market, it has not been possible to determine the existence or not of the economic damage caused; however, as stated in the preceding recital, the market has been affected by violating the legal interest of transparency;
- That, in relation to recidivism, for the commission of the same infringement within a period of one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infringement, as well as the sanction antecedents, it should be clarified that the sanction antecedent and recidivism are two distinct concepts. Regarding recidivism for the commission of the same infringement within a period of one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infringement, there is no recidivism of ICCGSA in the commission of the same infringement. Likewise, ICCGSA has a sanction antecedent, having been sanctioned through Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 125-2017-SMV/11 of December 14, 2017;
- That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infringement, such circumstances have been analyzed, highlighting that the rejection of any audit firm for the reasons indicated by ICCGSA has not been proven. Nor has the diligent action that an Issuer must have been proven, foreseeing that one or some of the consulted firms might not contract with the Issuer;
- That, regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it is considered that it has not been proven that the infringement was committed with intentionality, it being necessary to indicate that there was a lack of diligence to comply with the mentioned obligation as stated in recital 22 of this resolution;
- That, regarding the aggravating or mitigating circumstances of liability, the mitigating circumstance for voluntary declaration of the infringement must be applied, in accordance with the provisions of literal a) of numeral 2 of Article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG in force at the time of the events, reflected in literal a) of numeral 2 of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG. Therefore, having evaluated the Criteria, it is considered that in the analyzed case the provisions of literal a), numeral 2 of Article 257 of the current TUO of the LPAG must be applied, which establishes that in cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numeral 26 of Article 12 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- To declare the appeal filed by ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. partially founded against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 032-2019-SMV/11, in the extreme referred to the application of the mitigating circumstance of liability for voluntary declaration.
Article 2.- To declare the appeal filed by ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. unfounded against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 032-2019-SMV/11, in its other extremes.
Article 3.- To reduce the fine imposed on ICCGSA Inversiones S.A., by virtue of the provisions of Article 1**°** of this resolution, setting it at five (5) Tax Units in force at the time of the commission of the infringement.
Article 4.- To consider the administrative route exhausted.
Article 5.- To transcribe this resolution to ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Article 6.- To order the dissemination of this resolution on the Stock Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Stock Market – SMV (https://www.smv.gob.pe).
Register, communicate and publish.
José Manuel Peschiera Rebagliati
Superintendent of the Stock Market
-
Approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments ↑
-
The report was brought to the attention of ICCGSA, through Official Letter No. 2991-2021-SMV/03, notified on July 26, 2021, in which a period of five (5) business days was granted from the day following the notification, for it to formulate its allegations, if it deemed it pertinent, and the administered party did not formulate any allegation. ↑
-
"Article 13.-Purpose.-The Registry is that in which the securities, securities issuance programs, mutual funds, investment funds and stock market participants indicated by this law and the respective regulations are registered, with the purpose of making available to the public the necessary information for investor decision-making and achieving transparency in the market.
The legal entities registered in the Registry and the issuer of registered securities are obliged to present the information that this law and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of said information. ↑
-
"3.4 Not designating the audit firm or not communicating its change within the period provided in the regulations or not observing the requirements or conditions established for the contracting and/or renewal of the audit firm or maintaining the audit firm, whose audit team or any of its members does not meet the requirements established by the regulations. Not designating the audit firm, or not communicating its change, within the period provided in the regulations". ↑
-
"Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infringements
1.- The following constitute exempting conditions of liability for infringements:
The duly proven fortuitous event or force majeure.
(...)" ↑
-
"The fortuitous event applies to events produced by nature and force majeure to events of man". Fifth Recital of Cassation 823-2002 LORETO ↑
-
OSTERLING PARODI, Felipe "Las Obligaciones" Editorial Grijley and the Latin American Institute of Private Law. 8th Edition, P. 234 ↑
-
From the review of available public documents, it is observed that both companies had five common board members since December 4, 2017. ↑
-
Date of entry into force of Superintendency Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV/01 (published on August 26, 2015), which approves rules on the preparation and presentation of financial statements and annual report by entities supervised by the SMV and modifies regulations of Public Registry and Mutual Funds, whose second complementary modifying provision modified the text of Article 38 of the RIF. ↑
-
The designation of ICCGSA's audit firm was made on December 20, 2018, as communicated as a material event. It should be noted that the deadline to communicate said designation expired on June 30, 2018. ↑
-
Article 348.- Criteria to Consider.- The administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the offender's antecedents, the circumstances of the commission of the infringement, the damage caused and its repercussion on the market, being classified according to the mentioned criteria as very serious, serious or minor. ↑
-
Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(...)
3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infringement, observing the following criteria indicated for their gradation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement;
b) The probability of detection of the infringement;
c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest;
d) The economic damage caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infringement within a period of one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infringement.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infringement; and
g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct. ↑
-
Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infringements
(...)
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infringements:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount. (...) ↑
-
Third paragraph and last paragraph of the third page of the referred report. ↑
-
Article 255.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infringements
(...)
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infringements:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special norm." ↑
-
Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infringements
(...)
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for infringements:
a) If, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
(...) ↑