Rule · SBP · 12 Aug 2025 · EPD Circular Letter No. 08 of 2025
Authorized Dealers must update policies by October 31, 2025, and assign separate trade risk ratings. Boards must oversee TBML risks, while senior management implements controls. Authorized Dealers must conduct focused KYC, verifying financial statements, tax returns, and trade overdues; they must not process transactions if documents are missing. Price verification is required prior to execution. Internal audit must review controls every two years. Authorized Dealers must share overdue information within seven working days and maintain records using Annexure-B templates.
EPD Circular Letter No. 08 — August 12, 2025
The President / Chief Executives
All Authorized Dealers in Foreign Exchange
Dear Sir/Madams,
Revision in Framework for Managing Risks of Trade Based Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing
Enclosed:
Yours sincerely,
Dr. Asif Ali
Director
Framework for Managing Risks of
Trade Based Money Laundering and
Terrorist Financing
FinancingProliferation ___________________
State Bank of Pakistan
Exchange Policy Department
Revised vide EPD Circular Letter No. 08 dated August 12, 2025
State Bank of Pakistan
Table of Contents
Description Page No.
State Bank of Pakistan 1
ii. “Dual Use Goods” shall mean goods, software, technologies, etc. which can be used for both civilian
and military purposes.
iii. “Fair Market Value” shall mean the price at which an asset would sell in a competitive market
assuming:
a. Both buyer and seller are acting independently as if they are unrelated, b. All relevant facts are known to both the parties,
c. Neither is under any compulsion to buy or sell, and
d. All rights and benefits inherent in (or attributable to) the item must have been included in the transfer.
iv. “Overdue Trade Bills” shall mean and include:
a. Export Bills: where export proceeds have not been realized within the prescribed period and manner, as determined by SBP. b. Import Bills: where the importer did not make payment against the goods received on collection or open account basis on due date or within one year of clearance of goods, respectively.
c. Advance Payment Export: where export proceeds are received in advance and shipment of
goods against the advance payment is not made within the prescribed period and shipping documents are not submitted by the exporters. d. Advance Payment Import: where importer does not ensure shipment into Pakistan of equivalent value of advance payment made or its repatriation within the prescribed period.
v. “Overdue” means overdue trade bills and any outstanding regulatory penalty levied under FERA.
vi. “Red Flag” means a warning sign or an indicator that suggests a potential risk of money laundering or
suspicious trade activity.
vii. “Trade Based Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing” refers to the process of disguising the
proceeds of crime and moving value through the use of trade transactions in an attempt to legitimize the illicit origin of funds or to finance terrorist activities. It involves misrepresentation of price, quantity and / or quality of imports/exports to transfer value across the border.
viii. “Trade Transactions” shall mean the transactions carried out through following modes:
a) Letter of Credit b) Documentary Collection c) Registered Contracts
State Bank of Pakistan 2 d) Open Account in Imports and Exports e) Advance Payment Import/Export f) Remittance for Import and Export of Services g) Foreign Bank Guarantee/Stand-by Letter of Credit All other terms used in the document have the same meaning as defined in the relevant laws, rules and regulations.
State Bank of Pakistan 3
2. Introduction and Objectives
i. Trade transactions have become an increasingly attractive channel for money launderers and terrorist
financiers, as they can conceal illicit activities within high volumes of legitimate international trade transactions. The main methods by which such people transfer value through legitimate trade transactions are under-invoicing, over-invoicing, multiple invoicing, short/over shipment, obfuscation of type of goods/services and fictitious trade transactions (i.e. transactions involving no shipments) etc.
ii. In order to strengthen trade related AML/CFT regime and restrict the possible misuse of banking
channel, the Framework for Managing Risks of Trade Based Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (TBML/TF) was issued by SBP in 2019. Over the period, emerging TBML/TF related typologies, global best practices and technological advancements in the domain of international trade have necessitated revisions in the existing framework for better mitigating the risks associated with trade transactions.
iii. The revised framework contains a broad set of instructions for Authorized Dealers (ADs) to build their
policies and controls that shall help them in effectively managing the risks and assist them in performing their regal & regulatory obligations under the relevant laws and regulations. However, the ADs are encouraged to adopt more robust measures and best international practices, evolving over time to effectively manage the Money Laundering, Terrorists Financing and Proliferation Financing (ML/TF/PF) risks.
iv. The prime objectives of this framework is to strengthen the trade related AML/CFT/CPF regime and
prevent the misuse of foreign exchange for unauthorized purposes. Following are key components of the framework, and ADs are required to comply with them in letter and spirit.
3. Governance and Oversight
a. Role of Board and Senior Management
i. The Board of Directors (BOD) of the ADs shall be responsible for the oversight of trade based ML/TF/PF
risks in the bank. BOD shall provide a strategic direction and necessary resources to the management to ensure identification, assessment and mitigation of TBML risks in an effective and timely manner. To this end, BOD shall develop and approve appropriate policies for managing the trade based ML/TF/PF risks in the bank, in line with the nature, scale and complexity of the AD’s trade business operations. Such policies, at the minimum, should cover the following areas:
a. Risk profiling of customers dealing in or intending to deal in trade. b. Price verification of underlying contracts related to import/export of goods/services.
c. Screening of customers, counter parties, goods, including dual used goods, etc.
d. Transaction Monitoring System for managing ML/TF/PF risks arising out of trade transactions. e. AD’s own risk profile and its periodic review.
ii. Such policies should adequately cover the instructions and requirements given in this framework.
Further, any operational procedures formulated under the policies shall clearly delineate the roles and responsibilities of all functions involved in processing, reviewing and approving the trade transactions.
State Bank of Pakistan 4
iii. The BOD shall also periodically review the TBML risk profile of the AD as part of the Internal Risk
Assessment Report (IRAR) process, already required under AML/CFT/CPF Regulations for Regulated Entities (REs). The BOD shall evaluate the performance of senior management in terms of managing TBML risks so as to ensure the effectiveness of internal controls, systems and mitigation measures put in place. The BOD may delegate this oversight responsibility to one of its sub-committees for efficient and focused oversight.
iv. In accordance with the direction and policies established by BOD, the senior management of the ADs
shall formulate and implement relevant procedures and internal controls to effectively manage the TBML/TF/PF risks. For this purpose, the responsibility of overseeing the overall trade based ML/TF/PF risk should be entrusted to a management level committee. The committee shall ensure deployment of adequate technology based solutions and allocation of necessary resources/staff among the relevant functions. However, the compliance function, being the owner of entity wide AML processes, should have a leading role in managing trade based ML/TF/PF risks.
v. The management committee shall also ensure that systems are robust enough to generate accurate &
comprehensive information/MIS reports, at their Head Office level, containing all the important data/information, thereby enabling a thorough and comprehensive portfolio level review by the ADs. b. TBML Risk Assessment – ADs Own Risk Profile
i. ADs shall periodically identify and assess the ML/TF/PF risks arising out of trade transactions and
document their findings in their IRAR document. The assessment should consider, at a minimum, the following factors:
a. Weighted average risk rating of their trade portfolio i.e. weighted average of risk ratings assigned to trade customers. b. Risks associated with various trade related products offered by the AD.
c. Number of red flags/TMS Alerts/STRs raised against trade related customers.
d. Assessment of jurisdictions, with respect to their riskiness, involved in trade transactions. e. Internal audit ratings of AD’s branches and centralized operations managing trade business. f. Enforcement actions and quantum of regulatory penalties imposed on the AD due to noncompliance with the regulatory requirements related to trade business/ foreign exchange.
c. Independent Review by Control Functions
i. Internal Audit function of ADs shall periodically review, at least once in 2 years, the robustness and
effectiveness of ADs’ systems and controls with respect to compliance with the provisions of this framework. In this regard, the internal audit function shall ensure that its audit strategy adequately focuses on trade based ML/TF/PF risks and the staff performing the audit activities has sufficient expertise/knowledge of trade products/procedures and AML/CFT processes. The frequency and scope of audit activities should be commensurate with the trade based ML/TF/PF risks identified by the ADs during the IRAR process and the volume of trade transactions handled by the AD.
ii. The deficiencies identified by internal audit, especially those relating to material weaknesses in
controls or non-compliance of regulatory instructions shall be escalated to relevant board and management committees in line with the SBP’s Guidelines on Internal Audit Function.
State Bank of Pakistan 5
iii. The internal audit may review the process of granting ADs status to the branches, along-with
subsequent review of their performance.
iv. The AD’s risk management function shall periodically conduct TBML risk assessment to identify
vulnerable products, regions, customers & trade activities and report key risks/ key risk indicators relating to trade based ML/TF/PF, in accordance with the SBP's Operational Risk Management Framework.
v. Compliance function shall periodically conduct an independent compliance risk assessment in
coordination with the trade processing units and escalate any identified gaps to relevant management committee for their resolution.
4. Customer Due Diligence (CDD)
i. In addition to the requirements specified in SBP’s AML/CFT/CPF Regulations, the ADs shall implement
focused KYC/CDD measures for the customers availing trade related services in order to assess and document their trade related risk profiles. These measures shall be applied at the time of onboarding of new trade-related customers or when the existing customers intend to undertake trade transactions.
ii. ADs shall ensure that no customer is allowed any trade related services without completion of separate
risk profiling specific to trade activities. Risk profile of the customers shall be prepared on bank-wide basis duly considering the scenario where the customer is conducting trade business through multiple branches. Further, the CNIC numbers shall serve as a primary key (unique identifier) for risk profile of sole proprietorships. The due diligence of newly on-boarded and existing customers may include, but is not limited to, the following factors:
a. Legal business structure of customer’s business i.e. sole proprietorship, limited company etc. b. Expected annual volume of trade to be carried out by the customer.
c. Financial worth and size of business of the customer, which must be supported by customer’s
financial statements and tax record / statements. d. Nature/type of goods/services that the customer usually trades in. e. Customer’s key foreign buyers/suppliers and the jurisdictions where they are located and operate from. f. Usual modes of trade and terms of payments. g. Related entities (domestic and foreign), over which the customer can exercise influence or control, due to the nature of their relationship. h. Customer’s membership of any Chamber of Commerce/Trade Associations etc.
i. Payment routed to/from third parties or third countries.
j. In case of existing customer, the number and nature of red flags raised by the AD during the period under review. k. Identification of ultimate beneficial ownership of the customer/transaction as specified in Regulation-2 of the AML/CFT/CPF Regulations.
l. Transactional behavior of customer’s PKR/FCY deposit accounts in relation to size and nature
of their business operations. m. Adverse media news, market intelligence or legal proceedings involving the customer. n. Verification of customer’s provided information through periodic on-site visits to the places of business.
State Bank of Pakistan 6
iii. ADs shall exercise due care while recording the expected annual trade volume of the customer and its
financial worth. For this purpose, particularly in case of importers, ADs shall invariably obtain financial statements, duly audited by a chartered accountant/ cost and management accountant. In case of individuals, sole proprietorships and entities where external audit of their accounts is not required, the ADs shall obtain the details of their assets, liabilities, income and expenses, which would be appropriately examined by ADs, including through onsite visits to ensure their accuracy. The ADs shall also obtain annual income tax returns (including wealth statements where applicable) from all importers who are obligated to file income tax return under Income Tax Ordinance or any other applicable laws and regulations in Pakistan. In case of non-submission of the said documents and information, trade transactions of such customers shall not be processed by the ADs. These instructions, however, will not be applicable on federal/ provincial government(s) or their allied agencies / departments.
iv. ADs shall properly review and analyze the financial statements and income tax returns submitted by
the customers and shall give due consideration to the information provided in these documents at the time of preparing or updating risk profile of such customers. Further, the AD, while processing any import transaction, shall ensure that the volume of trade and activity in the deposit accounts of the customer is commensurate with its risk profile and financial position. However, in exceptional circumstances, any deviation should be referred to senior management for approval, prior to execution of such transactions. The justification/ rationale for approving such transactions shall be explicitly recorded for later review of internal audit of AD and the SBP.
v. ADs shall obtain a declaration from customers intending to engage in trade business, whereby the
customers shall authorize their ADs to share their outstanding overdue trade obligations / default history with other ADs. Additionally, the customers shall be required to disclose the name(s) of the bank(s), in the undertaking, with which they have or previously had trade business relationship alongwith the types of trade transactions conducted with those banks. Thereafter, ADs shall verify the status of customers’ trade overdues and default history from the concerned ADs or through other available means. The trade overdues, if any, shall be given due consideration while taking the decision of onboarding the customer for trade transactions.
vi. The ADs should share their response to the requests received from other ADs, within a reasonable
time period, not exceeding seven (07) working days. A proper record of these requests and corresponding responses shall be maintained by the ADs.
vii. Based on the due diligence, the ADs shall assign a separate trade related risk rating to its customers, in
addition to the general risk rating assigned by the ADs under AML/CFT/CPF Regulations, so that the AD is able to independently/separately evaluate trade related profile of the customers. In case the customer is assigned higher risk rating, the AD shall perform enhanced due diligence.
viii. ADs shall periodically review and update trade-related risk profiles of the customers as per the
frequency determined using risk based approach or when there are any significant changes in customers’ trade activities. However, such periodic review shall not be later than 18 months of last review. The dynamic information such as major counterparties, jurisdictions and type of goods etc. may also be updated as and when required.
State Bank of Pakistan 7
ix. While taking any credit exposure on a customer, the ADs should also give due consideration to its traderelated risk profile.
5. Transactions Due Diligence & Monitoring
a. Initial Scrutiny/Screening of the Trade Transactions
i. At the time of handling a trade transaction in front offices, ADs shall ensure that adequate and
appropriate controls are in place for thorough scrutiny of the relevant documents. For this purpose, ADs shall put in place appropriate procedures, systems and deploy adequately trained personnel for carrying out scrutiny of documents and screening of all parties involved in the trade transactions including importers, exporters, jurisdictions, goods, vessels and ports etc.
ii. ADs shall also follow the provisions relating to goods and jurisdictions given in Import / Export Policy
Orders of Ministry of Commerce (MOC) as well as Control Lists of Strategic Export Control Division (SECDIV) of Ministry of Foreign Affairs. In this regard, ADs shall maintain H.S. Code wise electronic record of the goods/services, capturing specific requirements, such as, licensing requirements, import / export permits and other applicable relevant requirements. b. Price Related Due Diligence
i. The ADs shall put in place adequate procedures and systems for assessment of prices of goods and
services in trade transactions to ensure that the prices reflected in the trade documents correspond to their fair market value. For reference of fair market values of goods and services, ADs shall use reliable sources, such as chambers of commerce, local business circles, daily newspapers, historic appraisements, MOC/TDAP, international and local commodity exchanges, Customs Valuation Rulings, web searches etc. Further, ADs shall also develop their internal database of prices using historical data of trade transactions processed by them.
ii. The price verification shall invariably be performed prior to execution of the trade transactions.
However, in exceptional cases where price verification is not possible at pre-transaction stage due to non-availability of benchmark prices or other compelling reasons, ADs may perform such verification after the transaction. In such cases, verification must be completed within forty-five (45) days of approving of FIs or disbursing the amount to the exporter, as the case may be.
iii. ADs should define acceptable thresholds for variance from benchmark prices and delineate the
process of conducting additional due diligence or escalation, if needed. The transactions, where the price variation from fair market value is beyond the acceptable threshold or there is suspicion of price misrepresentation, the ADs must undertake reasonable measures to ascertain the reasons for such variances and document their findings. Where price variation is identified during post transaction assessment, it shall be considered as a red flag, warranting further evaluation. In all such cases, the AD, as part of the enhanced due diligence process, shall escalate the transaction to the senior management for a decision.
iv. In order to prevent conflict of interest, ADs shall entrust the responsibility of price verification to a
function, having reporting lines independent from the business function. Such a function should be adequately staffed with experienced officers possessing the necessary expertise.
State Bank of Pakistan 8
c. Financial Instrument (FI) Related Due Diligence
i. ADs shall implement adequate controls for issuance of Financial Instruments (FIs) for the trade
transactions. Issuance of FIs shall preferably be centralized and the principles of dual control shall be implemented. If the FIs are issued in decentralized manner, a robust monitoring mechanism should be in place for overseeing the process. In addition, the ADs shall ensure adherence to the following instructions while issuing FIs:
a. The FI must include the complete and precise specification of the goods, including the quality, varieties and sub categories. Mentioning the generic or vague/incomplete description of goods on FI should be avoided. In this regard, ADs shall require customers to provide complete details of goods along-with their H.S. codes. Further, use of H.S. codes having description as ‘others’ should be discouraged; however, in case it is necessary, the ADs shall seek proper justification from the customer. Furthermore, the full name of parties involved should be mentioned on FIs and abbreviations should be avoided. b. In case an H.S. Code includes multiple goods/products, ADs shall ensure that the particulars of each good is mentioned against that H.S. Code.
c. Units of measurement (UoM) that are inconsistent with the nature of goods or which obscures the
actual quantity of goods, such as using cartons or boxes for goods that are counted in numbers/units, shall be avoided. If UoM is not required to be declared otherwise, then it shall be declared in line with relevant Custom Valuation Rulings, where available. d. The use of brand names, trade names or trademarks of the goods must be avoided, if it is not accompanied by the generic name of such product. e. In case of export advance payment, the guidelines at (b), (c) & (d) above shall also be followed while preparing the Advance Payment Voucher (Appendix V-14). Moreover, it shall be ensured that in case of export against advance payment, declaration made on FI is strictly in accordance with the particulars declared on Advance Payment Voucher including the name of consignee. f. The expiry date of FI should be commensurate with the nature and tenor of the underlying trade transaction. d. Transaction Monitoring System
i. ADs shall implement a robust Transaction Monitoring System (TMS) for monitoring and managing the
ML/TF/PF risk arising out of the trade transactions, which should be capable of generating meaningful alerts based on pre-defined trade based ML/TF/PF related scenarios/thresholds. The alerts shall be thoroughly evaluated and complete trail, from generation of alerts till their closure, shall be maintained by the ADs for later review of internal audit or SBP.
ii. The ADs are encouraged to develop scenarios for the TMS that appropriately cover the typologies
described under this framework. The scenarios/thresholds shall be reviewed periodically by ADs, at least once in two years or more frequently if required, to ensure their effectiveness and relevance.
State Bank of Pakistan 9 e. Post Transaction Due Diligence Measures
i. The particulars of FIs shall be corroborated with all shipping documents and Goods Declaration (GD)
information to ensure their cohesion. For this purpose, the ADs shall carefully compare the GD Forms and other information received from PSW with the corresponding FIs to identify any discrepancies. In this regard, particular attention should be placed on verifying the quantity, type of goods (H.S. Codes) and per unit price recorded on FI and declared to / assessed by Customs.
ii. Where the particulars of FI are not commensurate with the declaration made on GD, AD must seek
clarification from the concerned customer. If the clarification is found to be unsatisfactory, the risk profile of customer shall be reassessed and the matter shall be escalated to senior management for a decision to consider filing of an STR or otherwise. However, in case of persistent undesired/suspicious conduct of a customer, the AD may take necessary actions as per the relevant provisions of AML Act 2010, including termination of relationship.
iii. In cases where multiple shipments are cleared by the importers under a single FI, the ADs shall
thoroughly examine the relevant information and documents to ensure that all shipping documents have been routed through them, to mitigate the risk of ML/TF/PF.
6. Enhanced Due Diligence (EDD) of High Risk Transactions
i. AD’s shall develop a criteria of monitoring the transactions falling under high risk category and ensure
that high risk trade transactions and/or customers are subject to enhanced due diligence. In this respect, following are illustrative examples of some trade transactions/activities that may pose higher trade based ML/TF/PF risks and, therefore, warrant EDD measures:
a. Sole proprietorships and other entities with low financial standings but intending to conduct high value transactions. b. Transactions on open account basis.
c. Advance Payments (Import and Export).
d. Import/Export of Services. e. Transactions involving high value services and those on free of cost basis. f. Transactions involving related parties. g. Payments and shipments from or to third parties/countries. h. Transactions with high-risk jurisdictions or jurisdictions with lax AML/CFT/CPF regulations.
i. Import of goods that are either exempt from duties or subject to duties exceeding 25%.
j. Export of goods on which export related rebates/subsidies are allowed by the Government of Pakistan, from time to time. k. Trade payments where the underlying amount was deposited predominantly in cash.
l. Transactions where a significant variation in price of goods being traded is identified that does
not align with the bank’s approved/acceptable price variance. m. Transactions where the particulars of FIs do not correspond with the shipping documents particularly with GD Forms.
ii. For the purpose of this framework, EDD measures may include, but are not limited to, one or a
combination of the following actions:
State Bank of Pakistan 10 a. Seeking justification from customer and obtaining additional information or documents that can explain or justify the transaction. b. Reviewing independent sources of information, such as creditworthiness reports.
c. Reviewing the customer’s historical transactions to identify behavioral patterns, trends, etc.
and/or assessment of previously flagged alerts. d. Obtaining feedback or information from foreign correspondent banks involved in transaction, where needed. e. Obtaining senior management’s approval for onboarding the customer, executing the transaction or continuing the relationship, as the case may be. f. Any other measure deemed appropriate by the AD.
iii. For any payments involving third parties / countries, not being a country of origin or the country of
shipment, the ADs should obtain additional documents from the customers, which may include, but are not limited to, tri-partite agreement, justifications for third party/country payments or any transaction-specific or customer-related information to understand the relationship between the beneficiary and the shipper and the reason for payment to a third party/country. ADs should maintain details of such payments for later review of internal audit and SBP inspection teams.
iv. While obtaining the creditworthiness reports of the foreign importer/exporter, ADs shall make
reasonable efforts to ensure that such reports, inter-alia include, names of sponsors and shareholders of foreign entity.
v. In case where an AD forms a suspicion regarding a transaction or customer as defined in section 7 of
AML Act, it shall be mandatory for the concerned AD to promptly file an STR with FMU. However, before reporting the STR, ADs shall undertake appropriate inquiries on transaction/customer, so as to avoid unnecessary or unwarranted STRs.
vi. If the senior management of the ADs, upon receiving an escalated transaction, does not find sufficient
grounds for filing the STR, they may consider subjecting the customer for enhanced monitoring. A database of such customers/transactions should be maintained, that have been considered as highrisk by the ADs and escalated to the senior management. This will assist the ADs in undertaking more focused and effective ongoing due diligence of their customers.
vii. In case where the anomalies in the customer’s transactional behavior persist, despite enhanced due
diligence and filing of STR, the AD may consider taking other appropriate measures including discontinuation of its relationship with the customer.
7. Deployment of Technology Based Solutions
i. ADs shall take reasonable measures to adopt technology based solutions to mitigate ML/TF/PF risks
associated with trade transactions. Following are some of the areas requiring use of technology based solutions:
a. Customer risk profiling and periodic review. b. Sanctions Screening.
c. Transaction Monitoring.
d. Verification of prices of goods and services. e. Corroboration of FIs with GDs. f. Detection of invoices and other documents already utilized by the importers/exporters.
State Bank of Pakistan 11 g. Vessel tracking to identify potential sanctions breaches. h. Regulatory reporting.
ii. ADs shall ensure integration of customer risk profiling system with trade processing/core banking
system enabling the relevant function to carry out ongoing monitoring of trade transactions effectively.
8. Trainings & Awareness
i. ADs shall provide a comprehensive, practical and targeted TBML related trainings at all levels, i.e. staff
deputed in branches, centralized trade processing units, compliance, internal audit and risk management functions to enable them to detect and report trade based ML/TF/PF related risks.
ii. ADs shall incorporate case studies based on practical examples, common typologies and red flags in
their training programs. In this regard, ADs shall develop a repository of trade related red flags and keep them updated based on their due diligence findings and international best practices. A nonexhaustive list of common red flag indicators, common typologies and sample case studies are also provided at Annexure-A, B and C, respectively, of this framework for information and guidance of ADs.
iii. ADs shall proactively collaborate with each other and arrange knowledge sharing events to share their
experience with each other. Further, such collaboration may include development of portal / helpdesk where experts of the industry can answer queries.
State Bank of Pakistan 12
Annexure-A
Common Red Flag Indicators for TBML
A- Red-Flags on Business Structure of Trade Customers
i. The corporate structure of a trade customer appears unusually complex and illogical, such as the
involvement of shell companies or companies registered in high-risk jurisdictions or tax havens.
ii. A trade customer is registered or has offices in a jurisdiction with weak AML/CFT compliance.
iii. The business activity of a trade customer does not appear to be appropriate for the stated address,
e.g. a trade customer appears to be using residential address, without having a commercial or industrial space, with no reasonable explanation.
iv. The customer reacts aggressively to due diligence related questions.
v. A trade customer is registered at an address that is likely to be a mass registration address, e.g.
residential buildings, post-box addresses, commercial buildings or industrial complexes without any reference to a specific unit.
vi. A trade customer lacks an online presence or the online presence suggests business activity
inconsistent with the stated line of business, e.g. the website of a trade customer contains mainly boilerplate text or material taken from other websites or the website indicates a lack of knowledge regarding the particular product or industry in which the customer is trading.
vii. The name of a trade customer appears to be a copy of the name of a well-known corporation or is
very similar to it, potentially in an effort to appear as part of the corporation, even though it is not actually connected to it.
viii. A trade customer displays a notable lack of typical business activities, e.g. it lacks regular payroll
transactions in line with the number of stated employees, transactions relating to operating costs, tax, etc.
ix. Owners or senior managers of a trade customer appear to be nominees acting to conceal the actual
beneficial owners, e.g. they lack experience in business management or lack knowledge of transaction details, or they manage multiple companies.
x. A trade customer, or its owners or senior managers, appear in negative news (adverse media), e.g.
past money laundering schemes, fraud, tax evasion, other criminal activities, or ongoing or past investigations or convictions.
xi. A trade customer maintains a minimal number of working staff, inconsistent with its volume of
traded commodities.
xii. A trade customer has unexplained periods of dormancy.
xiii. A customer is not compliant with regular business obligations, such as filing tax returns.
B- Red-Flags on Trade Activity
i. Trade customer involved in more than one unrelated sectors or trade activity is inconsistent with the
stated line of business of the entities involved e.g. a car dealer is exporting clothing or a precious metals dealer is importing electronic goods.
ii. The packaging of goods is inconsistent with the commodity or shipping method.
State Bank of Pakistan 13
iii. A trade customer engages in complex trade deals involving numerous third-party intermediaries with
unrelated lines of business.
iv. A trade Customer engages in transactions and shipping routes or methods that are inconsistent with
standard business practices.
v. The goods are transshipped through one or more countries/jurisdictions for no apparent economic
or logistical reason.
vi. Goods ordered do not match the profile of the supplying country.
vii. The country from which goods are being shipped is designated as “high risk” for money laundering
activities.
viii. The method of payment does not commensurate with the risk characteristics of the transaction e.g.
the remittance of funds (i.e. import advance payment) for a shipment from a new supplier in a highrisk country.
ix. The transactions involving consecutive trade discounts offered by exporters to the same importer
and vice versa.
x. A trade Customer makes unconventional or overly complex use of financial products, e.g.
transferable letter of credit, use of letters of credit for unusually long or frequently extended periods without any apparent reason, intermingling of different types of trade finance products for different segments of trade transactions.
xi. Undesirable/variant conduct of the customer, such as, frequent revision in submitted trade
documents or undue demand for expediting the processing aimed at bypassing or disrupting the banks’ due diligence process.
xii. The tenor of the transaction does not commensurate with the nature of the underlying goods e.g.
perishable goods are traded on terms involving a lengthy usance period.
xiii. A trade customer purchases commodities, allegedly on its own account, but the purchases clearly
exceed the economic capabilities of the customer, e.g. the transactions are financed through sudden influxes of cash deposits or third-party transfers to the customer’s accounts.
xiv. A newly formed or recently re-activated trade customer engages in high-volume and high value trade
activity, e.g. an unknown entity suddenly appears and engages in trade activities in sectors with high barriers to market entry.
xv. Trade transactions where shipments are not made/received against advance payments.
xvi. Trade transactions that involve import/export of dual use goods.
C- Red-Flags for Trade Documents
i. Inconsistencies across contracts, invoices or other trade documents, e.g. contradictions between the
name of the exporting entity and the name of the recipient of the payment; differing prices on invoices and underlying contracts; or discrepancies between the quantity, quality, volume, or value of the actual commodities and their descriptions.
ii. Documents such as a letter of credit is received through unverified channels such as unauthenticated
SWIFT message.
iii. The Letter of Credit (LC) or similar arrangements contains non-standard clauses or phrases or has
unusual characteristics.
State Bank of Pakistan 14
iv. Trade or customs documents supporting the transaction are missing, appear to be counterfeits,
include false or misleading information, are a resubmission of previously rejected documents, or are frequently modified or amended.
v. Contracts, invoices, or other trade documents display fees or prices that do not seem to be in line
with commercial considerations, are inconsistent with market value, or significantly fluctuate from previous comparable transactions.
vi. Obvious over or under pricing of goods/services e.g. significant discrepancies appear between the
value of the goods reported on the invoice/ financial instrument, and the known fair market value of the goods.
vii. The description of goods on the Goods Declaration Form/Transport documents significantly varies
from the description declared on financial instrument, or underlying contract. There are indications that the description of the goods is disguised. Contracts, invoices, or other trade documents have vague descriptions of the traded commodities, e.g. the subject of the contract is only described generically or non-specifically.
viii. A significant variation is found between the description of the goods on the bill of lading and the
invoice.
ix. A significant variance between declared and assessed value of goods is identified
x. Contracts supporting complex or regular trade transactions appear to be unusually simple, e.g. they
follow a “sample contract” structure available on the Internet.
xi. Commodities imported into a country within the framework of temporary importation and inward
processing regime are subsequently exported with falsified documents.
xii. Shipments of commodities are routed through a number of jurisdictions without economic or
commercial justification.
D- Red-Flags for Account and Transaction Activity
i. A trade customer makes very late changes to payment arrangements for the transaction, e.g. the
customer redirects payment to an unknown entity at the very last moment, or the entity requests changes to the scheduled payment date or payment amount.
ii. An account displays an unexpectedly high number or value of transactions that are inconsistent with
the stated business activity of the client.
iii. An account of a trade customer appears to be a “pay-through” or “transit” account with a rapid
movement of high-volume transactions and a small end-of-day balance without clear business reasons, including:
An account displays frequent deposits in cash which are subsequently transferred to persons or entities in free trade zones or offshore jurisdictions without a business relationship to the account holder. Incoming wire transfers to a trade-related account are split and forwarded to non-related multiple accounts that have little or no connection to commercial activity.
iv. Payment for imported commodities is made by an entity other than the consignee of the
commodities with no clear economic reasons, e.g. by a shell or front company not involved in the trade transaction.
v. Payments from remitters whose business activities do not align with the nature of the goods being
exported.
State Bank of Pakistan 15
vi. Repeated settlements of overdue payments with different remitters without proper documentation.
vii. Cash deposits or other transactions of a trade customer are consistently just below relevant
reporting thresholds.
viii. Transaction activity associated with a trade customer increases in volume quickly and significantly,
and then goes dormant after a short period of time.
E- Red-Flags for Trade in Services
TBML using the trade of services presents a much more significant challenge and it provides greater opportunities for money laundering than trade in goods since supply is difficult to determine. Unlike trade in goods, services are also less likely to be standard, so anomalies in value and price are less apparent and more difficult to substantiate.
i. The beneficiary does not have the capacity to fulfil the trade obligations.
ii. Unusual Pricing and Invoicing Practices: Charging too much or too little for services compared to
market rates or similar transactions.
iii. Complex and Unnecessary Service Structures: Contracts for the provision of services are
transferred between multiple parties without clear rationale.
iv. Mismatch between Service and Industry: Services rendered do not align with the importing or
exporting company’s line of business.
v. Geographical Risk Factors: involves countries known for money laundering, weak regulations, or
limited oversight.
vi. Companies involved in non-service sectors (e.g., commodities) suddenly engage in large-scale trade
of services without prior experience in that field.
State Bank of Pakistan 16
Annexure-B
Common Typologies of Trade Based Money Laundering Typologies of TBML means various methods used to launder money through trade transactions. The definitions and purposes of various methods are summarized as follows:
Methods Definition
Purpose
Import Export
Under Invoicing of
Goods/Services
The act of stating the price of goods/services on an invoice as being less than their fair market value. Receive Excess Value Transfer excess value
Over Invoicing of
Goods/Services
The act of stating the price of goods/services on an invoice as being more than their fair market value. Transfer excess value
Receive Excess Value
Short Shipment The act of shipping less than the invoiced quantity or quality of goods thereby misrepresenting the true value of goods in the documents. Transfer excess value
Receive Excess Value
Over Shipment The act of shipping more than the invoiced quantity or quality of goods thereby misrepresenting the true value of goods in the documents. Receive excess value
Transfer excess value
Obfuscation of type of Goods/Services
The act of omitting information from the relevant documentation or deliberately disguising or falsifying it. May be to:
Receive excess value
Transfer excess value
May be to:
Transfer excess value
Receive excess value
Phantom Shipment Shipping nothing at all with false invoices.
Transfer value Receive value
State Bank of Pakistan 17
Annexure-C
SAMPLE CASE STUDIES
CASE STUDY NO.1
[Misinvoicing in Import Transaction]
State Bank of Pakistan 18
The exporter was a related party of the importer.
The transaction involved third party in another country that did not have any apparent connection or role in the transaction. There was a significant mismatch between the value of traded goods as per the FI/invoice and assessment by the Customs. The shipper/manufacturer had shipped the same goods to different importers in Pakistan at much higher prices. * CASE STUDY NO.2 [Misinvoicing of Exports for Settlement of Imports]
State Bank of Pakistan 19
3. Method used for TBML:
The transaction was conducted through related parties whereby the importers/exporters tried to hide actual import price to transfer higher/lower value. The Middle East based counter-party B under-invoiced the raw materials sold to Pakistani importer and may have made full payment to the shipper D.
4. TBML Red Flags in Above Transaction:
The type of goods imported into Pakistan was inconsistent with the exporter’s regular business. The import transaction involved third party in another country that did not have any apparent connection or role in the transaction. There was a significant mismatch between the value of traded goods as per the FI/invoice and assessment by the Customs. * CASE STUDY NO.3 [Combination of Case Study No. 1 and 2]
The payment (USD 50,000) from importer ‘S’ was remitted to the exporter ‘P’ based in Middle East, however, the shipment of chemicals was actually made by the manufacturer ‘A’ from a third country. Importer-S Exporter-P (Related Party) Invoice of USD 50,000 Settlement of Shipment $50,000 Exporter-P (Related Party) Shipper-A Importer-S Shipment of Goods Payment for Goods Common Ownership
State Bank of Pakistan 20
[
The Customs assessed value of consignment for USD 110,000 in line with the assessments of similar other shipments made by the third country shipper ‘A’ of same commodity during the same period. It is clear that the consignment was under invoiced for the benefit of Importer-S and balance amount was paid to ‘A’ by his related counterparty ‘P’ in Middle East through formal or some informal channels. The difference between actual value and under-invoiced value of the imports made by importer ‘S’ in Pakistan may also have been adjusted through under-invoiced exports by another related business, ‘T’ to the related Middle East based entity ‘P’.
3. Method used for TBML:
All these transactions were conducted through related parties whereby the importers/exporters tried to hide actual import price to transfer higher/lower value. The Middle East based exporter under-invoiced the raw materials sold to its related party i.e. Pakistani importer and it may have paid full payment to the shipper ‘A’ OR the importer may have used other informal channels to transfer the differential amount. The importers/exporters used under-invoicing of imports and exports to set-off residual amounts in trade transactions and thus able to transfer value over and above the value of actual exports/imports.
4. TBML Red Flags in above transactions:
The type of goods being exported by Middle East based exporter seemed inconsistent with its regular business. The exporter was a related party of the importer. Import Settlement of $50,000 Exporter-P (Related Party) Shipper-A Importer-S Shipment of Goods worth USD 110,000 Full Payment for Goods USD 110,000 Invoice of USD 50,000 Exporter-P (Related Party) Importer-S Exporter-T (Related Party) in Pakistan Shipment of Fruits worth USD 110,000 Settlement of under-invoiced value Inter-business transactions
State Bank of Pakistan 21
The transaction involved third party in third country that did not have any apparent connection or role in the transaction. There was a significant mismatch between the value of traded goods as per the FI/invoice and assessment by the Customs. The shipper/manufacturer had shipped the same goods to different importers in Pakistan at much higher prices during exactly the same period. * CASE STUDY NO.4 [Misinvoicing in Imports]
State Bank of Pakistan 22
3. Method used for TBML:
The exporter was operating from an address that belonged to a different company indicating that the exporter did not have any physical presence of its own. A group company ‘P’, based in Middle East was engaged in both import and export transactions with Pakistan based importers and exporters containing various red flags including multiple unrelated GD declarations, mispricing etc. The group had developed a network of various trading entities including logistics companies and clearing agents, in different jurisdictions. The group entities were dealing in import and export of goods having very high and low import duties which created the possibility of under and over invoicing and netting-off import and export proceeds. Many instances of misdeclaration by Pakistani importers including these counter parties were noted indicating that these foreign entities were engaged in assisting the local traders in evading duties. The group tried to hide its true ownership structure and linkages through falsification and impersonation.
State Bank of Pakistan 23
CASE STUDY NO.5
[Misuse of Financial Instruments by importers]
Exporter Y,
Remitting (exporter’s)
Bank
Importer H, Pakistan Import of Consumer Goods
Bank B Pakistan
One Set of Transport Docs and Invoice of USD 10,000 Exporter Y Remitting Bank Importer H, Pakistan Import of Consumer Goods Bank B Pakistan Customs Clearance through PSW One Set of Transport Docs and Invoice of USD 10,000 FI Issued for USD 10,000 Declaration of 5 BLs Assessed value USD 150,000
State Bank of Pakistan 24
The imported goods did not fall under the permissible imports on open account basis, therefore, the importer was not able to remit funds against extra BLs through any authorized dealer in Pakistan. Hence, it is suspected that the importer used other illegal channels like Hawala/Hundi for remittance of proceeds against these extra BLs.
3. TBML Red Flags in Above Transactions
There was a significant variance between amount of FI, value declared against the transport document and value assessed by customs authorities. There was a variance in the nature of imported goods and quantity as per the commercial invoice and GD declaration. Multiple BLs were declared against one Financial Instrument issued for one BL only. * CASE STUDY NO.6 [Over-invoicing of Exports for Settlement of Hawala Transaction]
State Bank of Pakistan 25
2. Mode and Flow of Trade
The Pakistani exporter and an Alternate Remittance System (ARS) operator (Hawaladar) located in North America entered into an illegal arrangement for settlement of dues between him and his counterparts (Hawaldar) in Pakistan. The exporter in Pakistan over-invoiced his shipment to the importer who was based in North America. The importer in North America made excess remittance as per the over-invoiced documents to Pakistani exporter. The Pakistani exporter pays the additional funds received from the importer to the Pakistani Hawaladar and the Hawaladar in North America compensates the importer in that country for the excess remittances made to Pakistan against over-invoiced goods. The Pakistani exporter also benefited from the transaction by exaggerating the exports volume in order to gain export related rebates and discounted financing. Thereby, the financial system was exploited through over-invoicing for unauthorized settlement of illegal business dealings of Hawaladars.
3. TBML Red Flags in Above Transaction
Underlying price was not in accordance with fair market value of goods.
Local transactions of both importer and exporter with unrelated businesses i.e. settlement transactions with Hawala Operators. * CASE STUDY NO.7 [Misinvoicing through Intra Company Transfer Pricing]
State Bank of Pakistan 26
2. Mode and Flow of Trade
The importer in Scandinavia imported goods from an exporting company in Europe and asked for delivery of goods to one of its offices in Balkans. The invoice issued by exporter was settled by the Scandinavian importer. The importer subsequently sent the consignee (its office in Balkans) an invoice of significantly higher value for the goods delivered to it. The office of importer in Balkans settled the over—invoice value through cash deposits into the bank account of importer. It is assumed that the consignee (office of importer in Balkans) transferred the illicit proceeds to the importer through intra-company transfer pricing.
3. Method used for TBML
In this case, the importer “re-invoiced” the goods to significantly inflate their value. The consignee then deposited cash into the account of importer and the transaction was done without any reference to the invoice for the shipped goods complicating the comparability of invoices. Red Flags:
Involvement of third party without any plausible reason.
Price of commodity higher than normal prices. (in case of invoice issued by Importer D to its office in Balkans) Transactions between Importer and its office without any underlying consideration. * CASE STUDY NO.8 [Breach of restrictions and Vessel Tracking in imports]
State Bank of Pakistan 27
The Pakistani Importer imported goods from exporter E based in Middle East. As per the sales contract, the cargo was to be shipped by a third party shipper T also based in Middle East. The documents received from foreign bank also showed country of origin as above. Whereas, the vessel tracking indicated that the vessel had not touched any port of the country of shipment and origin. Moreover, the transponder of the vessel was turned-off near another High Risk country, known for producing and exporting such cargo.
3. Method used for TBML:
The actual origin of commodity was hidden by falsification and misdeclaration of country of origin on the documents. The difference in per unit price between cargo produced by the High Risk Country and declared country was significant. Therefore, in addition to hiding the origin, the importer also laundered money through the over-invoicing. In order to deceive the banks’ due diligence process, the vessel disabled its transponder to defeat the vessel tracking exercise.
Red Flags
Involvement of third party without any plausible reason.
Issues in tracking of vessel or abnormal behavior of vessel during the voyage. Significant difference between per unit price of goods of actual country of origin and declared country of origin. Exporter E Shipper T Importer S in Pakistan High Risk Country Payment for Imports Start of Voyage Transponder Disabled Shipper T
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“Attention of Authorized Dealers (ADs) is invited towards the “Framework for Managing Risks of Trade Based Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing” issued on October 14, 2019 vide FE Circular No. 4 of 2019.”
More like this from SBP
SBP published 13 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: State Bank of Pakistan — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated