Consultation · SECP · 26 Apr 2022
SECP's concept paper reviews its Regulatory Sandbox, launched in 2019 under guidelines reissued under section 458-A of the Companies Act 2017, and reports on three cohorts. The first cohort completed testing with six of thirty-three applicants; the second has six of thirty-eight applicants still testing; the third cohort's application window is open until May 31, 2022. It proposes amendments to NBFC Regulations for P2P lending, amendments to the Securities Act for equity crowdfunding, and a regulatory framework for micro and digital-only insurers, and has issued guidelines for mutual fund digital distribution.
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN
Regulatory Sandbox (RSB) was introduced as a means to gain knowledge that can lead to pro-innovation regulation making. It provides space to test technological driven financial products and business models that falls within the regulatory domain of Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP/ Commission).
Regulatory
Sandbox
Overview
01
Regulatory
Sandbox
Life-Cycle
Regulatory
Sandbox
Journey
Testing
Outcomes
Way
Forward
Annexures
04
05
06
02
03
GLOSSARY
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION OF PAKISTAN COHORT DISTRIBUTED LEDGER EQUITY CROWDFUNDING (ECF) INSURANCE BROKERAGE FINANCIAL INCLUSION PEER-TO-PEER (P2P) LENDING ROBO ADVISORY NBFC FRACTIONALIZATION OF REAL ESTATE A cohort is an experimental cycle in which business models of applicants are evaluated and tested. A distributed ledger is a database that exists across several locations or among multiple participants. A mechanism that enables broad groups of investors to fund startup companies and small businesses through electronic platform in return for equity stake. Insurance brokerage is a business model that connect insurance sellers with buyers and get commission in return. Availability of aordable financial products in sustainable way to individuals and businesses to meet their needs such as capital, payments, savings, investment, credit and insurance. Involves creations of fractions of real asset in smaller denominations and selling the same to specified investors through electronic platform. Enable individuals to obtain loans directly from other individuals through an online digital platform without involvement of financial institutions. Automated, algorithm-based investment advisory, involving no or little human involvement. Means a non-banking finance company that provides certain bank like financial services and are licensed by the Commission under NBFC framework. FINTECH SYSTEMATIC INVESTMENT PLAN (SIP) ASSET MANAGEMENT SERVICES Integration of technology with financial products to improve and automate the delivery and use of financial services and products. SIP is a method of investing a fixed sum, regularly, in a mutual fund scheme. SIP allows one to buy units on a given date each month, so that one can implement a saving plan for themselves. MICRO-INSURERS ASSET MANAGEMENT COMPANIES (AMC) Means NBFCs licensed by the Commission to provide asset management services. Means insurers that provide micro insurance products and services. Involves pooling of funds from various individual and institutional investors and investing the same in various securities. REGULATORY SANDBOX POSITION PAPER 02
Financial inclusion and technological innovation(s) are crucial for growth of developing economies like Pakistan. Through the Regulatory sandbox SECP aims to learn about the regulatory impediments and likely risks arising from a proposed financial products/solution for test is conducted. Introduction of regulatory sandbox is an important step towards enhancing financial inclusion and introducing new financial products
Regulatory sandbox guidelines were introduced in 2019 to provide a detailed and comprehensive framework under which business models are tested in controlled environment with approval of the Commission. Regulatory framework can be accessed through following link
Financial inclusion and technological innovation(s) are crucial for growth of developing economies like Pakistan. Through the Regulatory sandbox SECP aims to learn about the regulatory impediments and likely risks arising from a proposed financial products/solution for test is conducted.
Introduction of regulatory sandbox is an important step towards enhancing financial inclusion and introducing new financial products
https://www.secp.gov.pk/docume nt/secp-regulatory-sandbox- guidelines-201 9-reissu ed-under-
section-458-a-of-the-companies-
act-201 7/? wpdmdl=4421 9&refresh=621 8a 27fefe741 645781 631
1 2
6
10 9 8 7
5
3
4 PRELIMINARY
EVALUATION
IS
APPLICATION
POTENTIALLY
SUITABLE?
DETAILED
EVALUATION
APPROVAL
ISSUED
COHORT ENDS
INCUBATION
PHASE
REPORT
SUBMISSION
TESTING AND
EXPERIMENTATION
YES
YES
NO
NO
APPLICANT
INFORMED
COHORT
OPENS
APPLICATION
SUBMISSION
DEADLINE
IS
APPLICATION
POTENTIALLY
SUITABLE?
SECP has launched three cohorts under regulatory sandbox allowing testing and experimentation of new business models/financial products.
Amongst thirty three applicants in first cohort, six participated in testing and experimentations. Life-cycle of first cohort has been completed and results have been shared with the Commission.
Amongst thirty eight applicants in second cohort, six participated in testing and experimentation. Testing phase of second cohort is on-going.
Application window for third cohort is open till May 31st, 2022.
| Cohort - I | Cohort - II |
|---|---|
| FINJA Lending Services Limited (Finja) Digital Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Lending Platform | Salaam Takaful Limited Parametric Insurance |
| YPay Financial Services (Ypay) Mutual Fund Digital Distribution | MyQasaar Private Limited Fractionalization of Real Assets through Electronic Platform |
| Finox Alpha (Finox) Robo Advisory | FracEstate Private Limited Fractionalization of Real Assets through Electronic Platform |
| Pakistan National Investor Portal (PNIP) Equity Crowdfunding Platform | Innovest Tech Private Limited Unified Digital Distribution and Central KYC for Mutual Funds |
| First Digital General Takaful (FDGT) Digital General Takaful Provider | Sahal Software Solutions Private Limited Digital Identity/AML/KYC |
| Waada Digital (Pvt) Limited (Waada)* Digital Insurance Brokerage Model | Oraan Tech Private Limited Women Focused Mutual Funds Distribution Platform |
[*] Waada took exit from the sandbox prior to testing to seek licence for commercial operations.
1
Sandbox initiative has been effective for assessing risk a new financial product poses and the likely impediments it can face. It has proved to be mutually beneficial for both regulator and the market participants. Results of first Cohort have provided a direction to SECP in terms of providing regulatory framework for introduction of tested financial products in the market. In fact this has led to SECP issuing guidelines and/or initiating the process for modifying/setting up regulatory framework.
Regulatory reforms in the following sectors within the domain of SECP are being introduced:
| P2P lending | Mutual fund digital distribution and Robo Advisory | Digital Insurance/ Takaful | Equity Crowd Funding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proposed amendments in NBFC Regulations to provide a comprehensive enabling framework for P2P Lending. | Issued guidelines1 encouraging use of FinTech for distribution and advisory purposes. | Proposed regulatory framework to regulate micro and digital only insurer. | Proposed amendments in Securities Act to formalize regulatory framework for equity crowd funding in Pakistan. |
Increase emphasis on testing readiness of the applicant during the evaluation stage. Structured and regular monitoring with applicants. Reduce time lag between the development regulatory framework, if required, and closure of testing. Increase public awareness by timely dissemination of information. Proactively identify the regulatory amendments required or development of regulatory framework during the testing phase.
[1] https://www.secp.gov.pk/document/guidelines-for-mutual-fund-digital-distribution-platform/
Test P2P Digital Lending platform, understand its practical aspect, its potential for reaching out to the MSME market with the ultimate aim to develop/adapt the regulatory framework.
FINJA opened P2P accounts of investors and borrowers digitally and verified by NADRA in real-time basis. The platform enabled that lenders could add funds to their account either via interbank funds transfer from any mobile banking application or via credit/debit card, for which 3D secure payment gateway is integrated with FINJA web platform.
Lenders then choose to disburse their capital to relevant borrowers available on the platform duly scrutinized based on their credit history, monthly turnover etc. The disbursed capital is credited to the digital account of the distributor of that particular borrower/karyana stores. The borrower repaid the loan using IBFT/mobile wallet/agent network and then the P2P account of the lender is credited with principal and profit amounts. The whole process is digitally enabled where lenders directly choose borrowers based on their credit scores.
FINJA INVEST- PAKISTAN'S FIRST P2P LENDING PLATFORM Investors Borrowers No. of Investors 48 No. of Karyana Stores 623 Total lending Portfolio Loans Funded No. of Cities 20M; 4M from FINJA 1132 Amount Returned Active Lenders Accounts 501 12 Rs 10M Accounts on Waitlist 500+ Average Investment Rs.14,000/Karyana Outstanding Portfolio 7 M Monthly Return 1.6-2.7% Delinquency (>30) 1.60% Loan Tenures offered 7, 15, 30 Days Loans Sold 14 (6 recovered)
While developing the framework to enable Non-banking finance companies with a lending license to operate a P2P Lending platform the following should be catered:
Risk due to involvement of public money Exposure to illegal / malicious activities being a technology- based platform Illegal deposit taking Protection of participants
A centralized digital mutual fund distribution platform acted as an intermediary between the Asset Management Companies and the Investors. Through such platform, the AMCs had access to individual customers in remote areas and cater needs of small savers.
An online dashboard enables customers to onboard through an online sign up using their email account (Gmail/Yahoo/Outlook) and complete the process. Subsequent to KYC and linking of Banking a risk profile of customer is created based upon risk appetite related details provided to the platform. Customers can browse a list of investment opportunities (Conventional/ Islamic), read about their summaries and market profiles and make their investment decision.
The Application Commissioner receives the request and confirm the status of investment once the background process has been completed. Redemption request can be made online as through the dashboard. YPay will forward their request to the concerned AMC, and upon successful redemption the funds will be transferred to the customer’s linked bank account and they will be duly notified via Email notification.
| YPAY FINANCIAL SERVICES – MUTUAL FUND DIGITAL DISTRIBUTION PLATFORM | |
|---|---|
| No of Customers | 100+ |
| Customer on waitlist | 3000+ |
| Total Investment | Rs. 1.7M |
| Investments per customer | 3 |
| Investment ticket size | Rs. 9,000 |
| Investor Demographics | |
| Early graduate male | 63.8% |
| Early graduate female | 25.5% |
| Housewives | 10.5% |
Testing of this model enabled better understanding of the operations of digital distribution of mutual funds, as a result of which the Commission issued guidelines for mutual fund digital distribution platforms
Feasibility of robo-advisory solution under a controlled environment. Investment advice to be given based algorithms run on the information provided by the investor.
Robo-Advisory products are for long-term, therefore, “back-testing approach” was adapted to simulate returns of Robo-Advisory product.
The response was positive as the Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) under the Robo Advisory Product outperformed KSE 100 and MCB Asset Allocation Fund, but underperformed Pakistan Stock Market Fund. Robo-Advisor with SIP increase the expected annual return of investor by at least 1.5% to 2% as compared to the benchmarks.
Customized investment solutions for investors can be formulated through Robo-Advisory with the following advantages:
Several biases including human bias can be controlled through Robo-Advisory As the product of robo-advisory is scaled, it may add to a new type of systemic risk in the market as automated services may recommend certain asset classes to investors on a similar pattern. This may result in risk of large-scale parallel behavior ultimately resulting in increase of systemic risk Good quality and affordable investment advisory services can be made available to investors to improve long-term risk-adjusted returns
To identify the risks involved in equity crowdfunding, so that regulatory framework addressing the concerned risks can be introduced
To identify optimal approach for regulating equity crowdfunding
PNIP called applications from potential companies that wanted to raise funds through crowdfunding. Companies were further shortlisted based on due diligence criteria of PNIP. After shortlisting, companies went through investment readiness program, where they were prepared for pitching the issue to eligible investors. Subsequent to the investment readiness program, platform was opened for registration of eligible investors. The platform could then match potential investors with companies seeking funds. All subscriptions were to be made through banking channels and parked in an escrow account.
PNIP identified/shortlisted potential companies for crowdfunding, however said companies could not be showcased before the investors due to time constraint, difficulty faced in marketing of crowdfunding platform and identification/registration of eligible investors.
Success of crowdfunding requires:
Stringent requirements make difficult for startups to raise funds Offer customized investment opportunities to accommodate variety of investors based on their risk appetite Liberal and disclosure-based regime
To test digital only insurer/ takaful model whereby, complete process, for a small size insurance entity, from policy issuance, policy servicing and claims settlement is to be carried out digitally, with an aim of development of a regulatory framework for introduction of dedicated digital only insurers and micro-insurers.
The applicant deployed web platform for end to end sale, delivery and settlement of takaful products. Customers can buy suitable product on the First Digital web platform. They are requested to fill details on application forms, and make payment either online or cash on delivery. The policy is then issued digitally and documents are shared with the customer through SMS and email. In case of claims, customers can digitally file claim through online claim portal available on the website. The claims are settled within 2 days of the completion of all the requirements and claims payments are disbursed to the customer as per payment instrument selected.
The products offered by the applicant includes health insurance, personal accident, home insurance and travel insurance. The participant has also obtained 100% risk transfer arrangement with existing insurer for allowed sum cover limits.
| FIRST DIGITAL GENERAL TAKAFUL – DIGITAL ONLY TAKAFUL OPERATOR | |
|---|---|
| No of policies sold | 1700+ |
| Average contribution | Rs. 880 |
| Gross contribution | Rs. 1.5 million+ |
| Amount of Claims | Rs. 169,000 |
| No. of Claims | 15 |
| Claim settlement period | 2 Days |
Testing of this model enabled better understanding of:
Operations of digital only insurer model for micro insurance Identification of suitable products that can be offered through digital only models Appropriate limits/ or caps that are needed to be placed on sum insured under various products Identification of possible issues that may arise in the products and processes
Securities and Exchange
Commission of Pakistan
WWW.SECP.GOV.PK
SECP
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
More like this from SECP
SECP published 4 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added