Enforcement · SMV · 28 Dec 2016
This resolution declares the appeal filed by Weis & Asociados S.C. unfounded, thereby upholding a prior sanction of a 2 UIT fine, equivalent to S/. 7,300.00, for a very serious infraction. The infraction involved failing to issue audit opinions in accordance with International Auditing Standards for an entity supervised by the Superintendence of Securities Market (SMV). The resolution affirms SMV's competence to supervise audit firms contracted by SMV-supervised entities and rejects arguments of double sanction or misinterpretation of financial information regulations.
Superintendent's Resolution
No. 162-2016-SMV/02
Lima, December 28, 2016
The Superintendent of the Securities Market (e)
HAVING SEEN:
File N° 2013033861 and Memorandum N° 3225-2016-SMV/06 issued by the Legal Advisory Office;
WHEREAS:
That, by means of Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV N° 039-2015-SMV/11 of February 5, 2015 (hereinafter, the Sanction Resolution), the following was resolved:
"(...)
Article 2.- Declare that Weis & Asociados S.C. has incurred a very serious infraction typified in subsection 1.4 of Annex XII of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution N° 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
(...)
Article 4.- Sanction Weis & Asociados S.C. with a fine of 2 UIT in force at the time the events occurred, equivalent to S/. 7,300.00 (Seven thousand three hundred and 00/100 New Soles), as provided in Article 2 of this resolution."
That, on March 2, 2015, Weis & Asociados S.C., (hereinafter, Weis & Asociados), filed a reconsideration appeal against the Sanction Resolution;
That, by means of Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV N° 094-2015-SMV/11, notified on April 30, 2015, the Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision resolved to declare the reconsideration appeal filed by Weis & Asociados unfounded;
That, through the brief presented on May 21, 2015, Weis & Asociados filed an appeal, requesting that the provisions of the Sanction Resolution, ratified by the Resolution mentioned in the preceding paragraph, be rendered without effect;
Arguments of Weis & Asociados' Appeal
That, having stated in its opinion of April 20, 2012, that the audit of the financial statements as of December 2011 was carried out in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), it was an involuntary error that it could not detect at the time and, therefore, subsequently, at the request of the Comptroller General of the Republic (hereinafter, CGR), it corrected said error by means of a second reformulated opinion of March 1, 2013;
That, the Superintendence of the Securities Market (hereinafter, SMV) has competence to supervise audit firms subject to its supervision; however, Weis & Asociados is not under the supervision of the SMV, but of the CGR, since it is part of the National Control System and, according to Article 5 of Law N° 27785, Organic Law of the National Control System and of the Comptroller General of the Republic (hereinafter, CGR Organic Law), the provisions of said normative body prevail over any other provision that other entities, such as the SMV, may issue. Additionally, it argues that the Terms and Conditions of Public Merit Contest N° 03-2011-CG and Contract N° ES-C-014-2012 – Contract for Professional External Audit Services, in no way mention the intervention of the SMV, nor the application of its regulations;
That, as expressly established by the norms of the National Control System, as well as the terms and conditions and the Audit Contract, the competent entity to evaluate its reports is the CGR, and there cannot be two competent entities that evaluate, supervise, and sanction the same event, since if this were possible, they would be exposed to being processed and sanctioned twice for the same events by two different entities, which is prohibited by law, constituting a flagrant violation of the principles of due administrative procedure and non bis in idem. In this regard, they add that the Deputy Superintendence of Market Conduct Supervision has indicated that the SMV and the CGR protect different legal assets and interests; however, no development of said interpretation is made to the specific case, which constitutes an evident violation of due motivation;
That, Article 39° of the Financial Information Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution N° 103-99-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, has not been taken into account, which establishes that in some cases audit examinations are governed by International Auditing Standards (IAS) and in others by the corresponding Supervision and Control Bodies, the latter being the case in which Weis & Asociados would find itself, since, in its capacity as an Audit Firm integrating the National Control System, it is subject to the guidelines, directives, and regulations established by the CGR;
That, for the specific case, the Principle of Publicity of norms cannot be applied automatically without being analyzed, since in this case there would be an ambiguity in the norms of the SMV and those of the CGR that would generate reasonable doubt about the norm to be applied, a situation that would benefit the administered party;
That, finally, it states that if the SMV sanctions Weis & Asociados, despite knowing its lack of competence, it would act arbitrarily, as it would contravene the Rule of Law, which prohibits arbitrariness in the issuance of Resolutions;
Analysis of the appeal
That, the appeal filed by Weis & Asociados complies with the requirements established in Articles 113°[1], 207°[2], 209°[3] and 211°[4] of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, LPAG), given that it was filed within fifteen (15) business days of notification of the administrative act, it is substantiated and was authorized by a lawyer;
Regarding the argument that no infraction would have been configured as it was a material and involuntary error
That, Weis & Asociados states that its action would not have configured any infraction of the SMV regulations, but would simply be a material and involuntary error. In this regard, we must mention that, according to Article 3°[5] of the SMV Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution N° 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms (hereinafter, the Sanctions Regulation), an infraction is understood as any action or omission to the laws, regulations, and other general or specific provisions related to the securities market, as well as other legal or regulatory provisions whose compliance corresponds to the SMV to control or supervise, and which are typified as an administrative infraction in the annexes of said Regulation. In this sense, given that Weis & Asociados has failed to comply with the obligation to issue opinions in accordance with IAS, said audit firm has incurred an infraction typified as a very serious infraction in Annex XII, numeral 1.4, of the Sanctions Regulation;
That, likewise, it is observed that, at the time of determining the amount of the sanction, by virtue of the provisions of literal f)[6], subsection 230.3, of Article 230 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, LPAG); in considering 33 of the Sanction Resolution[7], the fact that the existence of intentionality in the infringer's conduct could not be proven was taken into account as a mitigating factor. Consequently, this fact was one of those that led to the sanction amount being 2 UIT, when, in principle, numeral 1.4 of section 1 of Annex XIII of the Sanctions Regulation classifies the imputed infraction as a “Very Serious Infraction”, which has a sanction, among others, from 50 to 300 UIT[8]. For this reason, it is considered that the fact that it has not been demonstrated that Weis & Asociados acted fraudulently at the time of the commission of the infraction has been duly considered in the Sanction Resolution;
That, additionally, it should be mentioned that although fraud in the infraction imputed to Weis & Asociados could not be proven, a lack of diligence was proven, since it could have timely noticed that the information was not adapted to IFRS. It should be noted that there is also no evidence of any element or circumstance of fortuitous event or force majeure that could lead to exemption from liability;
Regarding the SMV's lack of competence to supervise and sanction audit firms that are part of the National Control System
That, Weis & Asociados stated that the SMV is not the competent body for the supervision of audit firms that are part of the National Control System, since these are supervised by the CGR. In this regard, it should be mentioned that the penultimate paragraph of Article 1 of the Consolidated Text of the SMV Organic Law establishes the following:
"(...)
Likewise, it is the responsibility of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (SMV) to supervise compliance with international auditing standards by audit firms enabled by a college of public accountants of Peru and contracted by natural or legal persons subject to the supervision of the SMV in compliance with the norms under its competence, for which it may issue general provisions consistent with said international auditing standards and require any information or documentation to verify such compliance." (Emphasis added)
That, from reading the aforementioned norm, it follows that any audit firm that is contracted by a person supervised by the SMV is also under the supervision of the SMV regarding the work it performs by virtue of said contract. In this sense, in the case under analysis, the SMV would have the competence to supervise compliance with IAS by Weis & Asociados, since said entity is an audit firm that has been contracted by Electrosur, a company that, by having securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market, qualifies as an issuing entity, in accordance with Article 8°[9] of the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree 861 and its amending norms, and, therefore, is under the supervision of the SMV;
That, on the other hand, although the Organic Law of the National Control System and of the Comptroller General of the Republic, Law N° 27785, establishes that the CGR exercises supervision over the Audit Firms that are part of the National Control System, this does not exclude the competence that the SMV has with respect to those audit firms contracted by entities under its supervision, as previously stated;
Regarding what is stated in Article 5 of the CGR Organic Law, this refers to the fact that the provisions of said Law prevail in matters of governmental control; however, in matters related to the securities market, the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree 861, and the regulations derived from it, prevail;
Regarding what was stated by the audit firm, in relation to the fact that neither the contracts nor the terms and conditions of the contest mentioned the intervention of the SMV, we must point out that it constitutes a general principle of law that the autonomy of will or private autonomy is subordinated to public order, insofar as it declares the nullity of the act that intends to produce effects contrary to the norms and warns that the legal system recognizes the effectiveness of the autonomy of will, which allows it to create, regulate, modify or extinguish legal relationships, only if it is framed within public order, thus, public order norms are characterized by their prevalence over those originated in the autonomy of will. In this sense, regardless of whether the intervention of the SMV was not mentioned in any part of said documents, it must be taken into account that administrative competence is not determined by private agreement between the parties, but is attributed by Law, and once attributed, the exercise of competence is a direct obligation of the administrative body to which it is attributed as its own, in accordance with the provisions of Articles 61°, numeral 61.1[10], and 65°, numeral 65.1[11], of the LPAG;
Regarding a possible double sanction
That, Weis & Asociados stated that there cannot be two competent entities that evaluate, supervise, and sanction the same event, since if this were possible, they would be exposed to being processed and sanctioned twice for the same events by two different entities, which is prohibited by law, constituting a flagrant violation of the principles of due administrative procedure and non bis in idem;
That, in this regard, to determine if the principle of non bis in idem established in subsection 10 of Article 230° of the LPAG could indeed be contravened, it is necessary to prove the existence of a triple identity in the subject, fact, and basis, between the administrative procedure initiated by the SMV and that which, if applicable, the CGR would initiate. It should be mentioned that for this principle to be contravened, it is not enough to prove one of the aforementioned elements, but it is necessary to prove the existence of all three, and if any of these did not appear, the accumulation of persecutory actions against the administered party would be legally possible[12].
That, in the case under analysis, both the SMV and the CGR could initiate administrative procedures against Weis & Asociados, so there could be an identity in the subject; likewise, there could be an identity in the fact, depending on the type of infraction determined by the CGR; however, there could not be an identity of cause or basis, since this consists of the correspondence between the legal assets protected and the interests safeguarded by the different sanctioning norms, so that if the legal assets pursued turn out to be heterogeneous, there will be diversity of basis[13]. Indeed, in the case under analysis, the protected legal assets are heterogeneous, since the SMV protects the transparency of the securities market, which translates into the capacity of a market to provide investors with sufficient, truthful, and timely information about issuers and their securities with the purpose that investors can make informed and efficient decisions, in accordance with Article 1° of the SMV Organic Law; in contrast, the legal asset protected by the CGR is the timely and effective exercise of governmental control to prevent and verify, through the application of technical principles, systems, and procedures, the correct, efficient, and transparent use and management of state resources and assets, for the benefit of the Nation (Article 2° of the Organic Law of the National Control System and of the Comptroller General of the Republic, Law N° 27785);
That, additionally, it must be taken into account that Weis & Asociados bases its argumentation on a hypothesis, that is, on the probability that the CGR will sanction it, for which reason a violation of the principle of non bis in idem can hardly be alluded to, since this starts from the premise that no one can be sanctioned or prosecuted for the same facts and grounds for which they have already been sanctioned or prosecuted;
That, on the other hand, Weis & Asociados has indicated that there would be an affectation to the due motivation of the resolutions, since it does not mention the different legal assets or interests protected by the SMV and the CGR. In this regard, it should be mentioned that the protected legal assets were not delved into, since on pages 8 and 9 of Report N°179-2015-SMV/11.2 of March 9, 2015, which serves as the basis for Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV N° 094-2015-SMV/11, the different areas of supervision and protected legal assets by the SMV and the CGR are explained in detail;
That, for the reasons stated above, we consider that Weis & Asociados' argument about the possibility of a violation of the principle of non bis in idem should be dismissed;
Regarding what is established in Article 39° of the Financial Information Regulation
That, Weis & Asociados states that what is established by Article 39° of the Financial Information Regulation has not been taken into account, which states that the audit report must be prepared and elaborated, if applicable, according to the specific norms issued by the corresponding supervision and control bodies, a situation in which they find themselves, since, in their capacity as an Audit Firm integrating the National Control System, they are subject to the guidelines, directives, regulations, or other provisions established by the CGR;
That, regarding this argument, it is appropriate to point out that said article establishes that audit reports must be prepared subject to: (i) the IAS approved and in force in Peru; and, if applicable, (ii) the specific norms issued by the corresponding Supervision and Control Bodies. In this way, the two provisions established in said article must be read jointly, and not in an exclusive manner as Weis & Asociados intends to do;
That, for the foregoing, Weis & Asociados, being an audit firm, which was also under the supervision of the CGR, was required to prepare the report observing both the IAS and the specific norms issued by the CGR, so the exclusive interpretation that said audit firm gives to Article 39 of the Financial Information Regulation is not correct;
That, Article 24° of the CGR Organic Law empowers the CGR to correct audit reports and to apply the normative framework of the bodies that participate in the national control system, when it establishes that the control reports issued by said system constitute acts of the internal administration of its constituent bodies and that they can be reviewed ex officio by the CGR, which can order their reformulation when their elaboration has not been subject to the control regulations, giving precise instructions to overcome the deficiencies, without prejudice to the adoption of the corresponding corrective measures. By virtue of said competence, the CGR, by means of Official Letter N° 0040-2013-CG/AFI of February 19, 2013, requested Weis & Asociados to reformulate the opinion, since Electrosur's financial statements, as of December 31, 2011, had not been prepared fully observing IFRS, issued by the International Accounting Standards Board;
Regarding the application of the Principle of Publicity
That, Weis & Asociados mentions that the principle of publicity cannot be applied automatically, without considering that in the present case there would be an ambiguity between the norms of the CGR and those of the SMV;
That, in this regard, by virtue of the principle of publicity of norms, in accordance with Article 109° of the Political Constitution of Peru, laws are mandatory from the day following their publication in the Official Gazette El Peruano. Accordingly, Weis & Asociados had the duty to know the norms on the competence of the SMV and on the securities market, from the day following the date of their publication, which is why it cannot justify its non-compliance by ignorance of them;
That, in the present case, if Weis & Asociados considered that the norm was ambiguous, said entity could have avoided incurring an error through different means, such as by consulting experts or the entities that supervise audit firms, such as the CGR or the SMV, since the audit firm had the duty to be correctly informed about the services it provides, even more so when it is a specialized entity in auditing matters, which is presumed to have full knowledge of the different auditing norms and their application. Therefore, we consider that the error incurred by Weis & Asociados was due to its lack of diligence, which is why it cannot be exempted from responsibility;
Interdiction of arbitrariness
That, finally, Weis & Asociados has stated that if the SMV resolves to sanction said entity, despite knowing its incompetence, it would act arbitrarily, since it would contravene the Rule of Law. In this regard, according to literals c and d of numeral 3.3 of section III of Memorandum N° 3225-2016-SMV/06, the SMV is competent to resolve the case under analysis, so there is no arbitrariness; and,
In accordance with the provisions of the penultimate paragraph of Article 1° of the Consolidated Text of the Organic Law of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (SMV), approved by Legislative Decree N° 26126 and amended by Law N° 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Securities Market, and by subsection 26 of Article 12° of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendence of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree N° 216-2011-EF and its amendments; as well as by Superintendent's Resolution N° 156-2016-SMV/02;
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare the appeal filed by Weis & Asociados S.C. against Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV N° 094-2015-SMV/11 unfounded.
Article 2.- Declare the administrative process exhausted.
Article 3.- Transcribe this resolution to Weis & Asociados S.C.
Article 4.- Order the publication of this resolution on the Portal of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe).
Register, communicate and publish.
Carlos Rivero Zevallos
Superintendent of the Securities Market (e)
Every brief submitted to any entity must contain the following:
The identification of the case file of the matter, in the case of procedures already initiated. ↑
2. Article 207.- Administrative appeals:
(…)
207.2 The term for filing appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days, and they must be resolved within thirty (30) days. ↑
3. Article 209.- Appeal: The appeal shall be filed when the challenge is based on a different interpretation of the evidence produced or when it involves questions of pure law, and must be addressed to the same authority that issued the act being challenged so that it may forward the proceedings to the hierarchical superior. ↑
4. Article 211.- Requirements of the appeal: The written appeal must state the act being appealed and comply with the other requirements provided in Article 113 of this Law. It must be authorized by a lawyer. ↑
5. Article 3 CONCEPT OF INFRACTION (AMENDED BY ARTICLE 2 OF RSMV 006-2012-SMV/01, PUBLISHED ON 04/16/2012)
Any action or omission contrary to the laws, regulations and other general or specific provisions referring to the securities market, products market and collective funds system, as well as to the other legal or regulatory provisions whose compliance corresponds to the SMV to control or supervise; and, which are classified as an administrative infraction in the annexes of this Regulation, constitutes an infraction. ↑
6. Article 230.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
"3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct does not prove more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of priority for their graduation:
(…)
f) The existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender." [↑](#footnote-ref-6)
7. "33. That, regarding the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest and the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, these have been addressed and analyzed in numeral 3.2 of this resolution. On the other hand, the harm caused and repercussion in the market have not been proven, nor has the unlawfully obtained benefit, repetition and/or continuity of the infractions and the existence or not of intent, since the non-compliances of the Issuer and the Audit Firm occurred;" ↑
8. According to the regulations in force at the time of the commission of the infraction. Subsequently, Article 7 of Law No. 30050, published on June 26, 2013, amends subsection b of Article 343 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree 861 and its amending norms, establishing that the SMV may sanction up to seven hundred (700) UIT. ↑
9. Article 8.- Terms.- The terms indicated have the following scope in this law:
(…)
g) Issuer: The person of private law or public law that issues securities;
(…) ↑
10. "Article 61.- Source of administrative competence
61.1 The competence of entities has its source in the Constitution and the law, and is regulated by the administrative norms derived from them.(…)" [↑](#footnote-ref-10)
11. "Article 65.- Exercise of competence
65.1 The exercise of competence is a direct obligation of the administrative body to which it is attributed as its own, except for the change of competence for reasons of delegation or evocation, as provided in this Law.(…)" [↑](#footnote-ref-11)
12. MORÓN Urbina, Juan Carlos. Comentarios a la Ley del Procedimiento Administrativo General, p. 729. Gaceta Jurídica 2011. ↑
13. MORÓN Urbina, Juan Carlos, Ibid. ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“General Administrative Procedure Law, Law 27444 and its amending norms (hereinafter, LPAG)”
“Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree 861 and its amending norms”
“Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendence of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree N° 216-2011-EF”
“That, by means of Deputy Superintendence Resolution SMV N° 039-2015-SMV/11 of February 5, 2015 (hereinafter, the Sanction Resolution), the following was resolved:”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added