Enforcement · SMV · 21 Jul 2008
CONASEV's Board declared unfounded Banco Continental S.A.A.'s appeal against Administrative Tribunal Resolution No. 014-2007-EF/94.12, which had fined it 2 UIT (S/.6,800) as custodian of Fondo Mutuo BBVA FMIV for serious infractions under numerals 2.3 and 2.8 of Annex VII of the Sanctions Regulation. The Board found the bank lacked an automated system reporting fund instrument and bank account movements and balances at any given date, and failed to comply with its procedures manual and regulations, including the requirement that the custodian authorize redemption payments. The administrative remedy was exhausted and the resolution ordered published on CONASEV's portal and notified to the bank.
Lima, July 21, 2008
VIEWS:
File No. 2006003992, Memorandum No. 673-EF/94.04.1 dated March 3, 2008 from the Legal Advisory Office, the oral report of the representative of Banco Continental S.A.A. and its attorney;
WHEREAS:
That, by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 014-2007-EF/94.12 it was resolved to sanction Banco Continental in its capacity as custodian of the investments of Fondo Mutuo BBVA FMIV under the administration of Continental S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos, with a fine of 2 UIT equivalent to S/.6,800.00 (Six Thousand Eight Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), for having incurred the infractions indicated in numerals 2.3 and 2.8 of literal B) of Annex VII of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, hereinafter the Sanctions Regulation, which establish as serious infractions: "Not having an automated system that reports the movements and balances of the holdings of instruments and bank accounts of the funds, at any given date" and "Not complying with the provisions contained in its procedures and internal control manual and in the regulations.";
That, by document dated March 28, 2007 Banco Continental filed an appeal against the aforementioned resolution;
That, Banco Continental bases its appeal on the following arguments:
a) In relation to not having an automated system that reports the movements and balances of the holdings of instruments and bank accounts of the funds, at any given date, Banco Continental states that although the challenged Resolution itself acknowledges that the Regulation of Mutual Funds for Investment in Securities and their Management Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 026-2000-EF/94.10, hereinafter the Mutual Funds Regulation, does not establish that the custodian must have an independent system, it therefore not being prohibited that the custodian and Continental Sociedad Administradora de Fondos may have access to a shared system such as the Integral Portfolio Information System, hereinafter SIAP; however the aforementioned resolution erroneously states that the charge subsists in the extreme that there is no automated system with respect to long-term deposits, that is, that the manner in which the custodian operates is not taken into account, which is limited to verifying all information related to the investment processes in term deposits, the custodian being the only one that can issue the corresponding investment orders;
Banco Continental adds that it is not true that the supply of information to a shared automated system comes only from the management company, since that information has always passed through the review and verification of the custodian, although at the time of obtaining the reports the name of Continental Sociedad Administradora de Fondos appears, since SIAP is a shared system, both the custodian and the aforementioned management company having access to the issuance of reports;
On the other hand, Banco Continental indicates that what is relevant to comply or not with article 130 of the Mutual Funds Regulation is that the automated system has reliable information verified by the custodian, which allows it to obtain reliable reports and that is what happens with SIAP, since in said system, the information is verified by the custodian prior to its entry into the system, the custodian is the only one that can confirm the investment orders and furthermore the system is designed in such a way that after the information is entered neither the custodian nor Continental Sociedad Administradora de Fondos can modify its content;
b) Regarding not complying with the provisions contained in its procedures and internal control manual and in the regulations, Banco Continental states that given the volume of redemption operations the authorizations are made automatically in accordance with the provisions of point 9.27 of the custodian's Procedures and Internal Control Manual, that is, each time a participant wishes to carry out a redemption operation of shares, Banco Continental enters the respective order into the mutual funds system and the system automatically responds with the amount of the share value and therefore the amount that corresponds to be paid;
Likewise, Banco Continental requests that at the time of resolving the principle of reasonableness be taken into account, the non-existence of intentionality, the fact that it has no record of sanctions, that the actions subject to review are related to internal procedures and therefore have not had repercussions on the market and that the alleged infractions committed have not had as a correlate a benefit for the Bank, as well as the non-existence of harm;
That, the appeal filed by Banco Continental complies with the requirements provided by articles 207 and 211 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, hereinafter the LPAG, that is, it has been filed within the legal term and is signed by counsel;
That, regarding not having an automated system that reports the movements and balances of the holdings of instruments and bank accounts of the funds, at any given date (infraction provided in numeral 2.3 of literal B of Annex VII of the Sanctions Regulation), it must be noted that the Mutual Funds Regulation provides in subsection a) of article 129, that it corresponds to the custodian: "To be in charge of the custody of the securities that make up the patrimony of the mutual fund, whatever their form of representation, carrying out the corresponding periodic reconciliations with the information provided by the management company. The correct registration of ownership of the mutual fund's investments shall be the responsibility of the custodian, as well as the timely receipt or delivery of the corresponding securities";
That, the cited norm requires that the custodian periodically reconcile that information provided by the management company, for which it can validly be maintained that it must generate its own source of information;
That, likewise, article 130 of the Mutual Funds Regulation establishes that the custodian must have an automated system that reports both the movements and the balances of the holdings of instruments and cash of the mutual fund, at any given date, according to minimum requirements that CONASEV will establish, for which the automated system with which the custodian must operate must allow providing information on the movements and balances of the holdings of instruments and cash of the mutual fund at the date required;
That, furthermore, according to subsection d) of article 36 of the Mutual Funds Regulation, the registration of the custodian in the Registry will be requested by the interested banking company, attaching the Procedures and Internal Control Manuals used by the custody area that show its independence within the organization;
That, consequently, from the aforementioned norms it follows that the custodian must have the necessary independence for the exercise of the tasks entrusted to it by the Mutual Funds Regulation, said independence having to be reflected in its Procedures and Internal Control Manuals;
That, likewise, it must be noted that procedure 9.19 of the Procedures and Internal Control Manual of Banco Continental in its capacity as custodian, referring to the "Reconciliation of balances of term accounts and BCR deposit certificates", establishes that one of its officers (Securities Technician) must carry out the following procedures: i) Request a report of balances of term deposits and the certificates of validity of BCR deposit certificates from the institutions in which the term deposit was made and in the case of BCR certificates from the institution that acted as intermediary in the auction and ii) Enter SIAP and issue the portfolio valuation report, for which it is valid to maintain that in the case analyzed according to its own Procedures Manual, the custodian has the obligation to generate certain information and enter it into the automated system for verification actions;
That, according to the challenged resolution, the custodian would not have accredited that it was complying with the procedure described in the preceding recital, since the listing called "Valuation of Investment Portfolio – Term Deposits" was issued by SIAP, without the participation of the custodian;
That, likewise, it must be noted that although the custodian generates certain information for the issuance of said reports, such a situation does not imply that it has its own reports that serve to compare them with the information of SIAP, for which the argument formulated by Banco Continental in the sense that the manner in which the custodian operates has not been taken into account, which is limited to verifying the information related to the investment processes, as well as issuing certain investment orders, is not admissible;
That, furthermore, as follows from procedure 9.19 of the Procedures and Internal Control Manual, the Securities Technician of the custodian must, in addition to requesting the report of balances of term deposits and the certificates of validity of BCR deposit certificates, issue the portfolio valuation report, that is, it is obliged to generate information for the system and enter it in a sufficient manner that allows it to compare with the information entered by Continental Sociedad Administradora de Fondos through SIAP, for which it is not sufficient that the custodian limits itself to verifying the information related to investment processes;
That, as regards what was stated by Banco Continental regarding that what is relevant to comply or not with article 130 of the Mutual Funds Regulation is that the automated system has reliable information verified by the custodian, which allows it to obtain reliable reports, it must be specified that although the reliability of the information is a crucial aspect, this fact alone does not exempt nor release from compliance with the provisions of the aforementioned article 130, which expressly establishes the obligation of the custodian to have an automated system that allows obtaining both the movements and the balances of the holdings of instruments and cash of the mutual fund, at any given date, in accordance with what is established by the procedures in the respective Manuals; a system that furthermore, as follows from subsection a) of article 129 of the same regulation, must allow the custodian to verify the information entered by the management company with that which the custodian generates and then enter it into the system;
That, regarding not complying with the provisions contained in its procedures and internal control manual and in the regulations (infraction provided in numeral 2.8 of literal B of Annex VII of the Sanctions Regulation), it must be noted that subsection f) of article 129 of the Mutual Funds Regulation establishes that it corresponds to the custodian to make the payments for redemption of shares, distribution of profits in cash, commissions and other expenses that the management company instructs it to make;
That, from the review of procedure 9.27 titled "Verification of Subscriptions and Redemptions" of the Procedures and Internal Control Manual of the Custodian Bank, it is verified that: i) Bank personnel, other than the officers of the custody team, make the payments for redemption of shares; ii) The Bank's custody team does not participate in such operation, but rather subsequently verifies that the system has correctly processed the redemption requests and iii) The formal and express authorization of the Management Company of Funds to make the payment for redemption is not requested, for which it is concluded that the procedure described above is not in accordance with the provisions of the Mutual Funds Regulation, which expressly provides that it corresponds to the custodian to make the payments for redemption of shares;
That, as regards what was stated by Banco Continental regarding that due to the volume of redemption operations, the authorizations are made automatically, it must be indicated that although the Mutual Funds Regulation does not prohibit that the redemption of shares may be carried out through an automatic system, subsection f) of article 129 of the aforementioned legal provision establishes the obligation of the custodian to "Make the payments for redemption of shares, distribution of profits in cash, commissions and other expenses that the management company instructs it to make", for which necessarily any withdrawal of money from the funds' accounts must be previously authorized by the custodian, a situation that as has been verified in the present case Banco Continental does not comply with;
That, in relation to what was stated by Banco Continental regarding that at the time of resolving the principle of reasonableness be taken into account, the non-existence of intentionality, the fact that it has no record of sanctions, that no harm has been caused, nor is there any repercussion on the market, it must be noted that such aspects, as well as others, have been evaluated by the Administrative Tribunal at the time of issuing the challenged resolution, as follows from recitals 45 to 50, and were considered so that, in application of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, a sanction corresponding to the immediately lower classification be imposed on Banco Continental;
That, finally, it is appropriate to specify that the arguments set forth by Banco Continental in its appeal do not invalidate the grounds of the challenged resolution; and,
In accordance with the provisions of article 11 subsections k) and t) of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126, as well as what was agreed by the Board of Directors of CONASEV meeting in its session of May 26, 2008;
IT IS RESOLVED:
Article 1:- To declare unfounded the appeal filed by Banco Continental S.A.A. in its capacity as custodian against Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 014-2007-EF/94.12.
Article 2.- To consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- To order the dissemination of this resolution on the CONASEV Portal.
Article 4.- To transcribe this resolution to Banco Continental S.A.A. in its capacity as custodian of Fondo Mutuo BBVA Dólares FMIV.
Register, communicate and publish.
| [pic] |
|---|
| Nahil Liliana Hirsh Carrillo |
| President |
"YEAR OF THE WORLD SUMMITS IN PERU"
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“requirements provided by articles 207 and 211 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added