Enforcement · SMV · 14 Oct 2008
CONASEV dismissed Compañía Minera Argentum S.A.'s appeal against Administrative Court Resolution No. 166-2008-EF/94.01.3, which had fined it 10 UIT (S/. 33,000.00) for late filing of financial information, annual reports and material events. The Board found 29 infringements of Articles 28 and 29 of the Securities Market Law, held that the fine was proportionate, and declared the administrative remedy exhausted.
Lima, October 14, 2008
VIEWS:
File No. 2005022531 and Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 dated August 28, 2008, from the Legal Advisory Office, and having heard the oral report of the attorney for Compañía Minera Argentum S.A.;
WHEREAS:
That, by Resolution of the Administrative Court of CONASEV No. 166-2008-EF/94.01.3 dated June 9, 2008, it was resolved to sanction Compañía Minera Argentum S.A. (hereinafter, Argentum) with a fine of 10 UIT equivalent to S/. 33,000.00 (Thirty-Three Thousand and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for having submitted to CONASEV and to the Lima Stock Exchange its financial information, annual report and material events, without observing the provisions of Articles 6 and 7 of the Financial Information Regulation, Article 4 of the Regulation for the Preparation and Presentation of Annual Reports and Article 7 of the Regulation on Material Events, Reserved Information and Other Communications;
That, by document dated July 8, 2008, Argentum filed an appeal against the aforementioned resolution;
That, Argentum bases its appeal on the following arguments:
1.) With respect to compliance with the purpose of information:
Argentum states that Article 348 of the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law (hereinafter, lmv) establishes, among the criteria to be considered for the application of sanctions, the harm caused and its impact on the market, for which it must be kept in mind that: i) there was no harm whatsoever to third parties, shareholders, investors or potential investors, since none of them has filed any subsequent claim or complaint regarding these facts, ii) Argentum complied with remedying and submitting the information and material events established, and iii) no stock exchange or over-the-counter transactions have been carried out with respect to its common shares since 2005 and a smaller number of transactions with investment shares of the company have been carried out since 2005;
Argentum adds that the appealed resolution refers to an alleged implicit harm to actual and potential investors that the law has not contemplated and, being implicit, it is not even tactically verifiable. In this sense, the commission of an infraction is being determined on the basis of a term not contemplated by a norm of legal rank such as the lmv, nor by the General Administrative Procedure Law - Law No. 27444 (hereinafter lpag);
On the other hand, the non-application of sanctions must be considered in accordance with the principle of reasonableness, which establishes that sanctions or restrictions must be adopted within the limits of the attributed power and maintaining due proportion between the means to be employed and the public purposes to be protected; likewise, for the determination of the sanction, criteria such as the existence of intentionality and the harm caused must be considered; in that sense, since Argentum complied with informing CONASEV and since there is no harm caused by the late submission of said information, it is concluded that the means employed (application of the sanction) is not proportionate to the non-compliance, given that it generated no harm whatsoever, and the sanction imposed is not reasonable;
Likewise, the principle of informality provided in numeral 1.6 of Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the lpag must be taken into account, which indicates that the rules of the procedure must ensure that rights and interests are not affected by the requirement of formal aspects that can be remedied within the procedure; in that sense, Argentum, having remedied the obligation to submit the information required by CONASEV, would have complied with the purpose of the procedure, so in application of said principle the sanction imposed in the resolution lacks any sense;
Argentum states that, by the principle of effectiveness, provided in numeral 1.10 of Article IV of the Preliminary Title of the lpag, it seeks to make prevail compliance with the purpose of the procedural act over formalities; therefore, considering that the purpose of submitting the information required by CONASEV is to ensure market transparency, said purpose has been fulfilled with the submission of the information, and the sanction imposed is not applicable;
2.) With respect to the application of the Sanction Criteria:
Argentum states that the Sanction Criteria applicable to infractions committed in the deadlines for submitting information for the period from June 2003 to December 2006 (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria by Exception) indicate that: “a) No administrative sanctioning procedure shall be initiated or those initiated shall be archived for legal entities excluded or with securities excluded from the Public Registry of the Securities Market (hereinafter, rpmv) as of April 16, 2007...”. Likewise, this norm does not specify the class of securities excluded from the rpmv, so it is understood that it refers at least to common shares, since they are the ones mainly sought to be regulated with securities market or CONASEV norms. Although Argentum still holds investment shares registered in the rpmv, the common shares had been excluded from it as of April 16, 2007, so it is appropriate to archive the sanctions established in the resolution;
3.) Regarding that the appealed resolution has not complied with resolving all the matters indicated by Argentum:
Argentum states that the Court has not ruled on the application, in the present case, of the principles of reasonableness, informality and effectiveness established in the lpag, which are mandatory for all administrative procedures; this infringes the provisions of numeral 4 of Article 5 of the lpag[1];
Analysis of the case
That, the appeal filed by Argentum complies with the requirements provided in Articles 207 and 211 of the lpag, that is, it has been filed within the legal term and is signed by counsel;
That, the Legal Advisory Office conducted an evaluation of the appeal filed by Argentum, issuing Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 of August 28, 2008, which was brought to the company's attention through Official Letter No. 4241-2008-EF/94.04.1 notified on September 3, 2008, informing it that said memorandum will be seen at the Board session to be held on September 8, 2008, as evidenced by the notification receipt appearing at folio 107;
That, by document submitted on September 5, 2008, Argentum deduces the nullity or requests that the aforementioned official letter be left without effect as it is late, inaccurate, imprecise and suffers from defects in due administrative procedure, by not clearly informing the time at which the Board session of September 8, 2008 will be held, this being an indispensable requirement to coordinate and plan legal defense in a timely manner and to properly exercise its right of defense; consequently, it requests that a new official letter be issued correctly informing the date and time of the session scheduled for the hearing of the case;
That, likewise, Argentum states that CONASEV, by not communicating Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 through the MVNet system, violates the equality of persons before the law, that is, if the administered must communicate through the MVNet system, the public sector must do the same as a matter of justice;
That, by Official Letter No. 4472-2008-EF/94.04.1 notified on September 16, 2008, CONASEV informed Argentum that Official Letter No. 4241-2008-EF/94.04.1 did not indicate a time because it is established based on the request for speaking made by the administered in order to coordinate and plan the time granted for the exercise of its right of defense, thus avoiding the scheduling of uncoordinated interventions;
That, regarding the notification through the MVNet system of Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1, Official Letter No. 4472-2008-EF/94.04.1 states that, in accordance with Article 20 of the Regulation of the MVNet System, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 008-2003-EF/94.10, any notification that CONASEV sends to an obligated entity via the MVNet system must be made to the electronic address of said entity, so the official letter was validly notified via MVNet, with which CONASEV has complied with the provisions of the norm; however, the memorandum, being an internal order document, does not constitute a notification that obliges CONASEV to send it through said system, and the administered is entitled to request the review and issuance of copies thereof;
That, likewise, Official Letter No. 4472-2008-EF/94.04.1 informs that, considering that in the present case a confusion could have been presented on the part of Argentum in the application of the norms, it was ordered, in board session of September 8, 2008, to defer the pronouncement on the appeal filed, for the next board session;
That, by document submitted on September 23, 2008, Argentum reiterates its request that the time of the hearing of the case be specified in the next board session and that Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 be notified via MVNet;
That, by Official Letter No. 4575-2008-EF/94.04.1 of September 23, 2008, CONASEV communicated that the right to speak had been granted to the legal representatives of Argentum, so that any of them may present, at 17:00 hours, the grounds of the appeal filed, for a space of 10 minutes;
That, regarding compliance with the purpose of information, it must be noted that one of the objectives of the sanctioning procedure is to be a mechanism for correcting the conduct of the administered, for which the body with sanctioning power must reliably verify whether an illicit act has been committed;
That, from the review of the documentation in File No. 2005022531, it is observed that Argentum has breached the obligation to inform set forth in Articles 28 and 29 of the lmv[2], by not having timely submitted the required information, so the instructing body and the Administrative Court determined that Argentum incurred twenty-nine (29) infractions;
That, one of the general principles of market transparency is that all information that must be submitted to CONASEV, to the Lima Stock Exchange and to the entities responsible for the centralized mechanisms or to investors, must be truthful, sufficient and timely, so the harm caused by Argentum and its impact on the market is based on the timeliness with which the required information should have been submitted, and not based on complaints or claims made by any investor, or on the stock exchange and over-the-counter transactions that could have been recorded during the sanction evaluation period;
That, the principle of reasonableness[3], alleged by Argentum, is based on the moderate and proportional application of sanctions, which must be imposed based on the proven infractions incurred by the administered and in the form and measure strictly necessary for it to fulfill its purpose; in that sense, taking into account the criteria of the severity of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal good and the economic harm caused[4], Argentum incurred the imputed infractions when the sanction criteria approved by the CONASEV board in session of April 13, 2004 were in force (hereinafter, Current Sanction Criteria); consequently, in application of said criteria, a fine amounting to S/. 170,310.00 (One Hundred Seventy Thousand Three Hundred Ten and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) should have been imposed; however, the sanction imposed by the Administrative Court, in application of the sanction criteria by exception, is within the limits of the sanctioning power and is proportionate, moderate and beneficial;
That, regarding the principle of informality[5], Argentum states that by having remedied the obligation to submit the information required by CONASEV it would have complied with the purpose of the procedure; in this regard, it must be specified that, although this principle allows the administered to subsequently comply with its obligation through remediation, this is not applicable to the present case because Argentum did not submit the required information within the established deadlines, which means that if Argentum had submitted the required information and then it had been remedied within the deadline, then no non-compliance would have been configured;
That, as for the principle of effectiveness[6], this is not applicable to the present case because Argentum did not comply with the timely submission of the required information; consequently, the Administrative Court cannot make said non-compliance prevail;
That, regarding the application of the Sanction Criteria by Exception, it must be taken into account that, although they establish that no administrative sanctioning procedure shall be initiated for legal entities excluded or with securities excluded from the rpmv, it refers to those companies that as of April 16, 2007 are not under the supervision of CONASEV; therefore, in accordance with Article 13 of the lmv, all legal entities registered in the rpmv and the issuer of registered securities are obligated to submit the information that the lmv and other general provisions establish. In that sense, Argentum, being still registered in the rpmv, is subject to said criteria;
That, regarding that the appealed resolution has not complied with resolving all the matters indicated by Argentum, it must be noted that in the recitals of the same all the discharges formulated by Argentum in due course have been collected; however, it is necessary to specify that numeral 5.4 of Article 5 of the lpag refers to the prohibition established by said law that administrative acts contain irregular objects or content, which has not occurred in the present case;
That, regarding what was indicated by Argentum about the notification of Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 of August 28, 2008, which should have been made through the MVNet system, it must be noted that CONASEV through Official Letter No. 4241-2008-EF/94.04.1 not only makes known the existence of an internal document but also makes the entire file available to the administered;
That, in accordance with numeral 2 of Article 230 of the lpag, administrative entities must apply sanctions respecting the guarantees of due process, that is, granting the administered the right to present their arguments, the right to offer and produce evidence and the right to obtain a decision motivated and founded in law; consequently, each entity is free to establish the guidelines of the administrative procedure, as long as it does not violate said rights.
That, there is no legal provision that obliges CONASEV to notify the documents generated by internal dependencies; however, in order to provide a better service to the administered, CONASEV communicates the existence of Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1 which contains the opinion of the Legal Advisory Office on the appeal filed by Argentum and reminds it that it may make use of the right to speak, for which purpose, if its response is affirmative, its oral intervention is scheduled;
That, likewise, Official Letter No. 4241-2008-EF/94.04.1 was notified 5 (five) calendar days prior to the board session scheduled for September 8, 2008, so that Argentum could carry out, with due anticipation, the review of the file and the reading of Memorandum No. 2565-2008-EF/94.04.1;
That, on the other hand, it must be taken into account that, upon Argentum's request, and despite having complied with all formalities, the Board agreed to defer the pronouncement on the appeal, to allow Argentum to have a longer period to prepare the oral report;
That, CONASEV, for efficiency, cannot schedule in advance the interventions of all cases to be resolved; therefore, it only reserves time slots in the case of those who have exercised the right conferred by the General Administrative Procedure Law to request the right to speak; for this reason, through Official Letter No. 4575-2008-EF/94.04.1, the right to speak was granted to any of the legal representatives of Argentum so that, in board session of September 29, 2008 at 17:00 hours, it may, for a space of 10 minutes, present the grounds of the appeal;
That, according to the evaluation carried out, it is noted that all the arguments presented by Argentum in its appeal do not disprove the grounds of the appealed resolution; and,
In accordance with the provisions of Article 11, subsections k) and t) of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126, as well as what was agreed by the Board of CONASEV in board session of September 29, 2008.
IT IS RESOLVED:
Article 1.- Declare unfounded the appeal filed by Compañía Minera Argentum S.A. against Resolution of the Administrative Court of CONASEV No. 166-2008-EF/94.01.3.
Article 2.- Consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- Transcribe this resolution to Compañía Minera Argentum S.A.
Register, communicate and archive
[pic]
Nahil Liliana Hirsh Carrillo
President
[1] Article 5.- Object or content of the administrative act
5.4. The content must include all the questions of fact and law raised by the administered, and may involve others not proposed by them that have been appreciated ex officio, provided that it gives the administered the possibility to present its position and, where appropriate, provide evidence in its favor.
[2] Article 28.- Material Events.- The registration of a certain security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of the material events, including negotiations in progress, about itself, the security and the offer made thereof, as well as to disclose such facts in a truthful, sufficient and timely manner (...)
Article 29.- Financial Information.- The provisions of the preceding article do not relieve the issuer of the timely delivery to CONASEV and, where appropriate, to the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of the information that either may require of it (...)
[3] It should be noted that Article 230 of the LPAG was modified by Legislative Decree 1029
Article 230.- Principles of Administrative Sanctioning Power.- The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(...)
3. Reasonableness.- The authorities must provide that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of precedence for their graduation:
a) The severity of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal good; b) The economic harm caused; c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; e) The illegally obtained benefit; and f) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender.
[4] Both based on the transparency of the securities market and the adequate protection of the investor.
[5] Article IV.- Principles of the Administrative Procedure.- 1.- The administrative procedure is fundamentally based on the following principles, without prejudice to the validity of other general principles of Administrative Law:
(...)
Principle of Informality.- The rules of procedure must be interpreted in a manner favorable to the admission and final decision of the claims of the administered, so that their rights and interests are not affected by the requirement of formal aspects that can be remedied within the procedure, provided that such excuse does not affect the rights of third parties or the public interest.
[6] Article IV.- Principles of the Administrative Procedure.-
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“nor by the General Administrative Procedure Law - Law No. 27444 (hereinafter lpag)”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added