Enforcement · SMV · 22 Oct 2009
The CONASEV Board of Directors dismissed appeals by Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A. and Claudia Romero Briceño against Administrative Tribunal Resolution No. 185-2009-EF/94.01.3, upholding fines of 250, 250 and 220 Tax Units (S/. 887,500, S/. 887,500 and S/. 781,000) for acquiring a significant stake in Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A. in concert without a prior public tender offer. It confirmed the order that Zabuck, Ducktown, Romero Briceño and the heirs to the Succession Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent sell their Andahuasi shares by public offering within two months of notification, with precautionary measures remaining in force until compliance.
Lima, 22 October 2009
File No. 2009017800, Memorandum No. 2601-2009-EF/94.04.1 dated 07 October 2009 from the Legal Advisory Office, and having heard the oral reports of the attorneys for Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño, Ducktown Holdings S.A. and Zabuck International Inc.;
That, by means of Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 185-2009-EF/94.01.3, dated 31 August 2009, hereinafter "the Resolution", it was resolved:
"1. Declare that Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A., Mr. Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent, and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño have acquired, in a concerted manner, a significant stake in Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A. without previously making a Public Tender Offer, having thus incurred the infringement provided in Annex IV, numeral 1, 1.1., of the Regulations on Sanctions in the Securities Market, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, which establishes that it constitutes a very serious infringement not to make the OPA in the cases that correspond or to increase a significant stake without observing the regulations;
2. Sanction Zabuck International Inc. with a fine of two hundred and fifty (250) Tax Units in force at the time of the commission of the infringement, equivalent to S/. 887,500.00 (Eight Hundred Eighty-Seven Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), for the commission of the infringement referred to in article 1 of this Resolution, in observance of the limit set by article 352 of the Concorded Single Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF and its amendatory norms;
3. Sanction Ducktown Holdings S.A. with a fine of two hundred and twenty (250) Tax Units in force at the time of the commission of the infringement, equivalent to S/. 887,500.00 (Eight Hundred Eighty-Seven Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), for the commission of the infringement referred to in article 1 of this Resolution, in observance of the limit set by article 352 of the Concorded Single Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF and its amendatory norms;
4. Declare that it is not possible to impose a sanction on Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent for the reasons set forth in the recital part of this Resolution, without prejudice to the corrective measures aimed at restoring the situation to the state prior to the commission of the infringement.;
5. Sanction Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño with a fine of two hundred (220) Tax Units in force at the time of the commission of the infringement, equivalent to S/. 781,000.00 (Seven Hundred Eighty-One Thousand and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), for the commission of the infringement referred to in article 1 of this Resolution, in observance of the limit set by article 352 of the Concorded Single Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF and its amendatory norms;
6. Order, under the provisions of article 72, subsection a), first paragraph, of the Concorded Single Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF and its amendatory norms, that Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A., Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño and the heirs to the Succession Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent are obligated to sell through public offering the shares of their property issued by Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A., within a period no greater than two (02) months from notification of this Resolution;
7. The precautionary measures ordered by Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 156-2009-EF/94.01.3, dated 02 July 2009, shall remain in force until Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A., Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño and the heirs or the Succession Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent have strictly complied with the public offering of sale ordered by article 6 of this Resolution;"
That, by means of Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 190-2009-EF/94.01.3, the material error contained in articles 3 and 5 of the Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 185-2009-EF/94.01.3 was rectified by means of articles 1 and 2, correcting the difference between numbers and letters thereof1 ;
That, against the Sanction Resolution Zabuck International Inc. (hereinafter, "Zabuck") Ducktown Holdings S.A. (hereinafter Ducktown) and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño, filed by means of writings dated 17, 18 and 21, respectively, appeals, whose arguments are summarized below:
It indicates that the Sanction Resolution has violated the principle of typicity, since the sanction applied is not provided in the legal system; being that there is no norm that defines what should be understood as concertation outside the mention of "systematically concerted behavior" that article 5 of the Regulations on Indirect Property, Linkage and Economic Group, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 090-2005-EF/94.10, states, so it is not possible to establish
[1] Articles 3 and 5 were rectified in the following amounts of two hundred and fifty (250) UIT and two hundred and twenty (220) UIT, respectively.
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
concertation, without necessarily such behavior being immersed within the assumptions of linkage and its presumptions;
It points out that although the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Affiliation and Economic Group recognizes CONASEV the power to determine other cases in which there is affiliation or control, according to the definitions of the Regulation on Public Offering of Acquisition and Purchase of Securities by Exclusion approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 009-2006-EF/94.10, hereinafter the ROPA, since the norm does not define the assumptions of concerted action, CONASEV is only empowered to determine the existence of indirect ownership, affiliation or economic group;
It maintains that a sanction established taxatively for cases in which economic groups or affiliated persons make purchases in concert in order to avoid a takeover bid has been applied analogically or by extension, ignoring that ZABUCK does not fit within any of the assumptions of affiliation between legal persons and between these and natural persons; in that sense, it is not possible to establish that there has been affiliation between ZABUCK and the other acquirers;
It adds that Zabuck did not seek the joint exercise of political rights because it acquired shares after the general assembly held for the purpose of electing the board of directors, and only saw a business opportunity in the purchase of Andahuasi shares; furthermore, it did not seek to achieve control in concert since, according to its final participation (18%), it would have had the right to appoint one Director;
Finally, it points out that the sanction contradicts the provisions of CONASEV Resolution No. 041-2009-EF/94.01.1 regarding that “sanctioning norms must express in an indubitable and unequivocal manner the conducts that constitute the infraction as well as the corresponding sanction”;
It requests that the Resolution be declared null and void for contravention of the principle of typicity, of prohibition of arbitrariness and of presumption of lawfulness, according to the following arguments:
It maintains that the sanction resolution has not observed the principle of typicity (legality) nor the requirements of lex scripta, lex praevia and lex certa, since there is no norm that defines in the securities market what “concertación” or “concerted acquisition” is; it supports its argument in ground 14 of the judgment of the Constitutional Court, issued in file 8957-2006-PATC2 and in the provisions of CONASEV Resolution No. 063-2009-EF/94.01.13;
[2] The principle of legality in sanctioning matters prevents attributing the commission of an offense if it is not previously determined in the law, and also prohibits applying a sanction if it is not also determined by law. As this Court has expressed (Anti-Terrorist Legislation Case, Exp. No. 010-2002-AI/TC), the principle imposes three requirements: the existence of a law (lex scripta), that the law be prior to the sanctioned act (lex praevia), and that the law describe a strictly determined factual assumption (lex certa).
It indicates that the Sanction Resolution contravenes the principle of prohibition of arbitrariness by alluding to the figure of concerted action without having defined it by regulation, as well as the principle of presumption of lawfulness since a sanction cannot be imposed based on presumptions or indications;
It adds that although according to article 9 of the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Affiliation and Economic Group CONASEV can determine other cases in which affiliation exists, this power is limited to the generic definitions of affiliation provided therein, and the extension of discretion cannot be admitted;
Finally, Ducktown warns that the appealed Resolution only demonstrates and sanctions the kinship or closeness of certain persons, since the joint action, common agreement and unity of purpose implied by concerted action have not been proven;
Subsequently, on 20 October 2009, Ducktown submits a writing summarizing the arguments set out in its oral report, in which it states that there is no kinship affiliation between Ducktown, Claudia Romero Briceño and Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent (“Los Propietarios”) with Mr. José Ignacio de Romaña Letts, José Antonio Letts Romero, Carlos Santiago Cabrera Santos, nor with Zabuck, it being proven that they have never acted jointly and in concert as a single shareholder to vote in any decision or election with Zabuck or Messrs. De Romaña, since there is no causal relationship between the operations carried out between Los Propietarios and them, and because Zabuck's acquisitions of shares as of 14 May 2009 have no effect on the guarantee operations of report and transfers of funds as the relevant operations that they have historically continuously carried out in the market;
It also states that the concertation to obtain control of Andahuasi was by “El Grupo” made up of Los Propietarios with the worker shareholders, which as of 20 April 2009 allowed them to elect five directors at the General Shareholders' Meeting of 20 April 2009 since they had a total of 68,883,261 shares; this being so, the acquisitions after said Meeting cannot be considered with the purpose of obtaining control of the company, but rather of confidence in the results of the investment made; this constituting a counter-indication of the alleged concertation to avoid making a takeover bid, since Los Propietarios would only have managed to reach holdings of 40,995,472 shares, which represent 19.7%, which does not constitute the concerted acquisition of a significant participation as a whole;
[3] Resolution that resolved the appeals of the Wong group, which states in one of its recitals: “That, in relation to the argument presented by the appellants to the effect that it is appropriate to sanction the economic group that acquired a significant participation and not each of its members, it must be pointed out that within the regulatory framework for sanctioning natural or legal persons that infringe provisions relating to the securities market, joint and several liability has not been regulated for the case of companies that make up an economic group, so it is not possible in the case analyzed to sanction an economic group as if it were a single offender as the appellants claim.”
[*] As has been pointed out, "Said principle comprises a double guarantee; the first, of a substantive nature and absolute scope, referring both to the strictly criminal sphere and to that of administrative sanctions, reflects the special importance of the principle of legal certainty in said restrictive fields and entails the imperative need for normative predetermination of the infracting conducts and of the corresponding sanctions, that is, the existence of legal precepts (lex praevia) that allow predicting with a sufficient degree of certainty (lex certa) those conducts and knowing what to expect regarding the attached responsibility and the eventual sanction; the second, of a formal nature, relating to the requirement and existence of a norm of adequate rank and which this Court has identified as law or norm with the rank of law. (Cf. Judgment of the Spanish Constitutional Court 61/1990).
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
It concludes by stating that, in accordance with subsection d) of numeral 24 of article 2 of the Constitution, regulations cannot regulate matters reserved to law nor define crimes, misdemeanors, administrative infractions, establish penalties or sanctions; in this sense, observance of the principles of reservation of law, typicity, presumption of lawfulness, causality and reasonableness make CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001- EF/94.10 inapplicable and oblige the Board of Directors to consider the sanctions imposed on Los Propietarios as non-existent because they are null pursuant to numerals 1 and 2 of article 10 of the LPAG;
The appeal is based on the following grounds:
According to the definition of concerted action contained in recital 22 of the Sanction Resolution, it is necessary to act jointly under a unity of purpose. Therefore, it is reasonable that her participation be evaluated only up to 17 April 2009, the date on which she ceased buying shares and therefore she could only have acted in concert with DUCKTOWN and Mr. Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent, since ZABUCK acquired shares subsequently, thus not meeting the objective and subjective framework of concerted action, so it is not possible to attribute joint action or unity of purpose;
It points out as inconsistencies of the Sanction Resolution the following: (i) that it is reiterated that the object of the investigation is not to determine the link between the acquirers, and nevertheless, the basis of the same rests on demonstrating parental links, exceeding what is established in article 8 of the LMV and business links, and (ii) that two criteria recently expressed by the Board of Directors of CONASEV are not observed, through Resolutions No. 041-2009-EF/94.01.1 and No. 063-2009- EF/94.01.1, by which it is necessary that sanctioning norms express in an indubitable and unequivocal manner the conducts that constitute the infraction and the sanction, enabling the administered party to know in advance which conducts will be subject to sanction, and that if something has not been regulated in the regulatory framework it is not possible to rule on it;
It states that the holding of shares determined and the period during which her purchases were made are not only not subsumable in the definition of concerted action expressed by the Administrative Court, but in no case did they contribute to reaching a significant participation, whereby the facts are atypical to the sanctionable assumptions provided in the Sanctions Regulation;
It concludes that the sanction resolution has incurred the ground for nullity provided in subsection 1 of article 10 of the LPAG because the provisions of the First Final Provision of the Organic Law of the Constitutional Court4 and article VI
[4] FIRST.- Judges and Courts interpret and apply the laws and every norm with the rank of law and the respective regulations according to the constitutional precepts and principles, in accordance with the interpretation of the same that results from the resolutions issued by the Constitutional Court in all types of processes, under responsibility.
of the Preliminary Title of the Constitutional Procedural Code5, as well as the principle of presumption of lawfulness and the principle of interdiction of arbitrariness, supporting such violations on the same terms of the appeal presented by DUCKTOWN.
That, on 15 October 2009, Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño presented a writing by which she formulates her final arguments and requests the Board of Directors to apply diffuse control so that the sanctionable infraction assumption provided in numeral 1, 1.1 of annex IV of the Sanctions Regulation be declared inapplicable, which establishes that “it constitutes a very serious infraction not to carry out the OPA in the cases that correspond or to increase significant participation without observing the regulations” for violation of the constitutional principle contained in article 2 numeral 24, literal d) of the Political Constitution of the State, as it is a generic and imprecise formula whose wording results in a blank sanctioning norm, its main arguments being the following:
It is inaccurate that article 68 of the Securities Market Law (hereinafter, LMV) establishes the obligation to carry out a Public Acquisition Offer (hereinafter, OPA) for the person or group of persons who intend to acquire a significant participation; likewise, an explanatory statement does not generate an obligation, and if the legislator had wanted to establish concerted action in the cases of obligation to carry out an OPA, it would have referred to such figure in article 4 of the OPA Regulation;
The violation of the principle of typicity on which the Constitutional Court has ruled in its judgment in File No. 2192-2004-AA/TC has not been disproven;
It states that by not establishing by regulation the cases or situations in which concerted action is incurred, the principle of typicity is contravened, since there is no express and prohibitive regulation of such conduct; and in the absence of said regulation, it would have been the legislator's will to resort to the scope of the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Linkage and Economic Group, since its purpose is to facilitate the proper application of securities market regulations;
By having stated that “(...) the infraction typified in numeral 1.1. of Annex IV of the Sanctions Regulation includes concerted action as a mechanism for acquiring significant participation (...)”, the Sanction Resolution contradicts the provisions established by the Board of Directors in CONASEV Resolution No. 041-2009-EF/94.01.1 and the provisions of Administrative Court Resolution No. 106-2004-EF/94.12, thereby violating the principle of prohibition of arbitrariness, since conducts must be previously and expressly provided for so that the administered party knows how to adjust its conduct to such parameters;
[5] Article Vl.- Diffuse Control and Constitutional Interpretation When there is incompatibility between a constitutional norm and another of lower hierarchy, the Judge must prefer the former, provided that it is relevant to resolve the controversy and it is not possible to obtain an interpretation in accordance with the Constitution. Judges cannot fail to apply a norm whose constitutionality has been confirmed in an unconstitutionality process or in a popular action process. Judges interpret and apply laws or any norm with the rank of law and regulations according to the constitutional precepts and principles, in accordance with the interpretation of them that results from the resolutions issued by the Constitutional Court.
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
That, the appeals filed by the appellants were presented within the term and in accordance with the requirements provided by articles 207 and 211 of the LPAG;
That, in order to determine whether the sanction imposed by the challenged resolution violates the principle of typicity, it is necessary to analyze the infraction type that grounds the sanction imposed on the administered parties;
That, the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, hereinafter the Sanctions Regulation, establishes in Annex IV, numeral 1, 1.1 that the following are very serious infractions of natural or legal persons who acquire or increase significant participation, of the directors, managers and shareholders of the target company, other investors, responsible for the exclusion of a security from the Registry, brokerage firms, the Exchange, ICLV, and other natural or legal persons who are related to the obligation or execution of an OPA or OPC: “Not carrying out the OPA in the cases that correspond or acquiring or increasing significant participation without observing the regulations.”;
That, this infraction is verified when there is a violation of article 68 of the LMV, which in coordination with articles 1 and 4 of the OPA Regulation establishes the obligation to carry out an OPA for the person or group of persons who intend to acquire for consideration, directly or indirectly in a single act or successive acts within a period of three years, significant participation equal to or greater than 25% of the share capital in a company that has at least one class of shares with voting rights registered on the stock exchange; acquisition that in turn can be made individually or jointly, in the latter case through the concert of wills to acquire a significant participation;
That, therefore what is sanctioned is the acquisition of shares that allows reaching significant participation in a registered company, which can be expressed in one or several acts as well as by a person or a group of persons. In the analyzed case, according to the actions contained in the administrative file, there are concrete acts, activities, behaviors and operations carried out by the appellants that, all added together, have led to declaring that the acquisition of significant participation occurred jointly and concertedly in the company Andahuasi;
That, the foregoing is corroborated by the explanatory statement of the regulation, which when referring to article 4 determines that the obligation to formulate an OPA is generated when it is a person or a group of persons acting in concert;
That, consequently, the misconducts related to concerted action in the acquisition of significant participation are recognized in article 68 of the LMV, articles 1 and 4 of the OPA Regulation as well as in the infraction type contained in the Sanctions Regulation; likewise, the sanction Resolution has specified in its recitals 183 to 187 that in the case under evaluation said principle has not been infringed because the norms infringed are the LMV and the OPA Regulation;
That, therefore, the argument that the market rules (LMV, ROPA and Sanctions Regulations) do not contain a provision that defines and sanctions concerted action in cases of acquisition of securities of a listed company is incorrect, since a harmonious and systematic reading of the provisions of article 68 of the LMV with articles 1 and 4 of the ROPA, as well as numeral 1, 1.1 of annex IV of the Sanctions Regulations, leads to the determination that the concert of wills to acquire significant participation without observing the pertinent regulations is prohibited and sanctioned in the securities market;6
That, for the foregoing, it is concluded that the arguments contained in the appeals by Ducktown, Zabuck and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño, related to the fact that: (i) there is no legal provision or rule that defines concertation, (ii) that the sanction applied is not provided for in the regulation of the securities market and (iii) that CONASEV is applying sanctions provided for Economic Groups, must be dismissed;
That, with respect to the alleged non-observance of the criteria contained in CONASEV Resolution No. 041-2009-EF/94.01.1 and CONASEV Resolution No. 063-2009-EF/94.01.1, it must be indicated that none of the cited resolutions is applicable to the present case because they refer to assumptions and rules different from those analyzed in the present administrative proceeding;
That, as regards the alleged impairment of the principle of legality because regulations cannot regulate matters reserved to law nor typify faults, administrative infractions, establish penalties or sanctions; it must be noted that in accordance with the provisions of article 353 of the LMV, “CONASEV is empowered to typify the infracting conducts of the securities market and of the other matters within its competence in accordance with the provisions of its organic law”;
That, in line with the foregoing, literal o) of article 2 of the Single Concordant Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV establishes that it is a function of CONASEV to typify the infracting conducts of the securities market, market of products and collective funds, as well as to issue the respective corrective measures when appropriate;
That, for the foregoing, it is not possible to apply the diffuse control requested by the administered parties, because no violation of the principles of legality and typicity is observed;
[6] Luis Miguel Bramont-Arias Torres points out that the “description of conducts cannot be extremely precise, given that it is impossible to describe a conduct down to its smallest details and there would always be the risk that some factual assumption remains outside the legal description. For this reason, the description has to be to a certain extent generic and abstract, in order to encompass in it all behaviors that have common characteristics”.
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
That, on the other hand, as regards the arguments of Ducktown, Zabuck and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño referring to the application of the Regulation on Indirect Ownership, Linkage and Economic Group, it must be noted that in the present case the fault attributed to the appellants is for having acted in concert, an aspect different from that which is the object of regulation by said Regulation;
That consequently the arguments of the appellants must be dismissed in the sense that in accordance with article 5 of the cited Regulation there will only be concertation when it is demonstrated that in the terms of said regulation there is linkage, since such a reading implies denying the scope of the ROPA which attributes responsibility when a person or a group of persons through a single will acquire significant participation in a company whose shares are registered on the stock exchange;
That, in relation to the argument that it is not possible to establish the existence of concerted action on the basis of commercial relationships, it must be specified that it is possible to consider this type of relationship as one of the elements to determine that a group of persons would have agreed to acquire significant participation in a concerted manner in the share capital of a company;
That, in relation to the argument that the Sanction Resolution has exceeded the scope of article 8 of the LMV, as regards the determination of relatives, it must be noted that although article 8 of the LMV considers relatives to be those included up to the second degree of consanguinity, first of affinity and the spouse, said reference does not deny the possibility of using the figure of consanguineous and affinity kinship recognized by our civil order in order to establish types of family relationships between persons in the construction of legal figures such as concerted action, even more so if it is taken into account that the definition of relatives contained in article 8 will be applicable as its text indicates, only in those cases in which the market law refers to the term relatives.
That, regarding the argument of Zabuck and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño that the operations for the acquisition of shares of Andahuasi by the acquirers were carried out in different periods of time and therefore there would be no common purpose as a defining element of the concerted action, it is necessary to point out that said circumstance does not negate the concrete fact of the acquisition; additionally, it must be considered that one of the characteristics that recurrently appears in concerted actions is the fact that hardly all the participants in said actions participate at the same time, and if the share acquisition operations were carried out simultaneously, the concertation would be more evident; therefore, it is logical to maintain that the parties allow a sufficient period of time to elapse between the concerted operations in order to make them appear as autonomous operations;
That, in the present case, it was determined that the concerted action occurred through conduct with a common purpose by several persons who, through acts that were apparently independent and unrelated to each other, sought to evade the obligation to carry out a takeover bid (OPA);
That, in light of the foregoing, the statement by Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño that it is not possible to attribute to her a concerted action with Ducktown and Zabuck is not acceptable, since she only acquired shares of Andahuasi until 17 April 2009 and never reached a significant participation, as her holding only reached 0.87% of the share capital of said company; this is because she is charged not only for the acquisition of shares but also for the operations, transfer of funds, as well as the family relationships with the other acquirers that allowed determining the existence of concerted behavior;
That, with respect to Zabuck's argument, although it would have only acquired shares as of May 2009, its intervention would have occurred to consolidate the significant participation in Andahuasi as part of the group that acted in concert, since said company began acquiring shares when their price was progressively increasing due to the struggle that would have occurred between 15 and 22 May 2009 and that had as protagonists the so-called Wong group, Ducktown and Zabuck, the latter having been willing to pay a high price for Andahuasi shares during the period of the rise, which shows that its conduct would have had an objective different from seeking benefits from a business opportunity; even more so considering that it is an investor that participates recurrently in the market;
That, the indicia used by the appealed resolution constitute valid evidentiary elements for determining that ZABUCK, DUCKTOWN, Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño and Mr. Carlos Antonio Dellepiane Costa y Laurent acted in concert in order to acquire significant participation in the share capital of Andahuasi, it being necessary to highlight that this type of behavior that contravenes the regulations regarding Public Offers of Acquisition is duly typified and sanctioned by the securities market regulation;
That, although the use of indicia and presumptions as evidence to demonstrate the existence of infractions has been questioned, arguing that it violates the principle of presumption of innocence that governs Criminal Law and sanctioning Administrative Law, this has been widely overcome by jurisprudence7 and doctrine8;
[7] The Supreme Court of Peru has expressly ruled in its judgment of 19 May 1995 (Expediente Nº 3732) on the validity of the use of indicia and presumptions as evidentiary means of crimes, provided that there is a plurality of contingent, concordant and convergent indicia in the sense of incriminating the accused, that these are analyzed based on the rules of science, technique and experience to infer a conclusion from them, and that the counter-indicia that may have been offered are also analyzed. In this sense, the Court in its judgment of 18 October 1999 (Expediente Av. 98-96) has specified that the indicia, in order to fulfill their purpose (...) must be appreciated as a whole and not individually, disregarding the circumstance or sign that, together with other evidence, acquires the necessary significance that leads the judge to certainty of the investigated fact.
[8] Modern doctrine recognizes the validity of the use of circumstantial evidence and presumptions in sanctioning procedures provided that the following requirements are met: (i) that the indicia are certain facts, (ii) that there is a reasoned causal relationship between the indicia and the facts that constitute the infraction or crime and, (iii) that the other interpretations that could be derived are analyzed and the reasons for rejecting them are justified.
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
That, for the determination of concerted action in the absence of direct evidentiary elements, the supervisor must usually rely on various elements and/or indicia that, assessed jointly, allow establishing the configuration of the referred figure, a position that is uniformly accepted in comparative legislation and doctrine;
That, therefore, it is valid that the authority responsible for supervising compliance with the Law and regulations may resort to circumstantial evidence in those aspects in which, by their nature, direct evidence may hardly be found9, rejecting the use of indications and presumptions by the competent administrative authorities would be the same as denying them the possibility of proving the commission of the infraction, preventing logical reasoning by the administrative authority in charge of the decision; in the particular case, since there is no prohibition on the use of indications based on concrete facts proven by CONASEV, it is expressly authorized to use them, which does not violate the principle of lawfulness at all, because as Professor César San Martín Castro points out10 “Direct and circumstantial evidence, both at the same level, are capable of forming judicial conviction, and it cannot be maintained that the conviction resulting from the latter is inferior to that resulting from direct evidence. Both have full jurisdictional recognition”;
That, there is a series of proven facts referring to acts, activities, behaviors and concrete operations carried out by the appellants that have not been denied, rejected or unknown by them, which, when assessed as a whole, show a single will to acquire significant participation and that finds no other logical explanation than to cross the threshold of 25% of the share capital of Andahuasi, these are: kinship relationships, commercial and business relationships, granting in guarantee operations, transfers of funds, concerted exercise of political rights, relevant purchase operations carried out in the Stock Exchange of the Lima Stock Exchange and the acquisition operations structured in a continued and concerted manner, within which it should be specified that the reception of the sale orders by Investa that allowed the change of principals so that Ducktown does not come to sell any share and Zabuck
[9] Argument supported by the provisions of the Resolution of 24/10/2001 issued by the CNMV of Spain, which agreed to close the sanctioning file opened in the framework of the struggle for control of the company Hidroeléctrica Cantábrico S.A., gathering and systematizing in said resolution the requirements set by case law for circumstantial evidence to form conviction in the deciding body, these elements are: a) it must not be a single isolated indication, but there must be several; that is, a plurality of indications is required; b) the confluence or coincidence of the same, insofar as all of them point in the same direction, since otherwise they would be annulled or distorted as opposing forces; c) the base facts generating the inference must be sufficiently accredited, that is, the indications must have been obtained through direct evidence, which necessarily entails that said evidence has been obtained lawfully and with all legal guarantees; d) the inferences must be rational and must correspond to the dictates of good sense and logic; e) between the base fact and the consequence fact there must be a precise link according to the rules of human criteria, that is, between the inference and the presumption there must be a natural connection that allows the inference to be made without any other alternative possibility that could be reasonably considered compatible with those indications.
[10] Criminal Procedural Law – Grijley. Pag. 632.
may acquire 16 624 776 shares, were carried out on 21 May in the afternoon and not on 22 May as erroneously indicated in the Sanction Resolution;
That the acquisitions made by Ducktown, Carlos Dellepiane Costa and Laurent, Claudia Romero Briceño and Zabuck as well as the commercial and kinship relationships are shown graphically in annexes I and II of this Resolution;
That, the set of these previously accredited indications (base fact) determine the concertation between the parties (consequence fact), since, although each fact analyzed in isolation is not considered the cause of the consequence fact (acquiring significant participation in a concerted manner without previously carrying out a OPA), the sum of these constitute the necessary conditions for the consequence fact to occur and the concertation to occur in violation of the provisions of the securities market regulations, therefore, having determined the concerted action, the principle of presumption of lawfulness is not violated in any way;
That, regarding the argument sustained that if the concept of “concertation or concerted action” has not been defined by regulation, any allusion to them to impose a sanction would affect the principle of prohibition of arbitrariness, what was stated in the analysis of the principle of typicity must be reiterated, this because the challenged resolution itself correctly expresses, in its ground 148, that the obligation to carry out a OPA is generated when significant participation is reached by a person or group of persons, which is provided for and adequately regulated in article 68º of the LMV, in the ROPA and in the infraction type of the Sanctions Regulation;
That, in this sense, it is not possible to sustain the arbitrary exercise of CONASEV and the violation of the principle of prohibition of arbitrariness, because as is accredited the requirement of the obligation comes from legal provisions tending to guarantee a public interest such as the right of shareholders to the control premium, being for such reasons the Resolution adjusted to law and it would not incur any of the grounds for nullity contained in article 10 of the LPAG; and
In accordance with the provisions of subsection t) of Article 11 of the Consolidated Single Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126 and its amendments, as well as with the agreement of the Board of Directors of CONASEV at its meeting of 19 October 2009;
Article 1.- To declare unfounded the appeals filed by Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A. and Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño against Resolution of the Administrative Tribunal of CONASEV No. 185-2009-EF/94.01.3.
Article 2.- To consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- To transcribe this resolution to Zabuck International Inc., Ducktown Holdings S.A., Mrs. Claudia Romero Briceño, Empresa Agraria Azucarera Andahuasi S.A.A., the Lima Stock Exchange, as well as CAVALI S.A. ICLV.
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
Article 4.- To order the dissemination of this resolution on the CONASEV Portal.
Register, communicate and file
Nahil Liliana Hirsh Carrillo
President
CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Concorded Single Text of the Securities Market Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF”
“confirmed Resolution No. 16 of March 15, 2012, which declared founded, in all its extremes, the demand filed by said company, which requested the nullity of CONASEV Resolution No. 075-2009-EF/94.01.1”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added