Enforcement · SMV · 28 Dec 2010
CONASEV dismissed the appeal filed by Internacional de Títulos Sociedad Titulizadora S.A. against Administrative Court Resolution No. 187-2010-EF/94.01.3, which had imposed a fine of 3.70 UIT and eighteen warnings for late filing of interim financial statements and management reports for 2007 and for untimely disclosure of two material events. The administrative remedy was exhausted, and the resolution was to be transcribed to the company and the Lima Stock Exchange and published on CONASEV's portal.
Lima, December 28, 2010
SEEN:
File No. 2009008771, Memorandum No. 2361-2010-EF/94.04.1 dated October 7, 2010 from the Legal Advisory Office, and the brief submitted by Internacional de Títulos Sociedad Titulizadora S.A. on November 19, 2010;
WHEREAS:
That, by Resolution of the Administrative Court of CONASEV No. 187-2010-EF/94.01.3, notified on July 23, 2010, hereinafter, the RESOLUTION, Internacional de Títulos Sociedad Titulizadora S.A., hereinafter, INTERTÍTULOS, was sanctioned with a fine equivalent to 3.70 UIT and eighteen (18) warnings, for having failed to timely submit to CONASEV the individual interim financial statements and management report as of September 30, 2007 corresponding to INTERTÍTULOS, as well as the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report of the acts carried out by virtue of the fiduciary ownership exercised over the Trust Estate – Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, Title XI, Supermercados Peruanos as of June 30, 2007; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate – Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, Title XI, CINEPLEX as of September 30, 2007; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate: First Securitized Bond Program Supermercados Peruanos as of September 30, 2007; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate – Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, Title XI, Graña y Montero and Subsidiaries – First Issue as of September 30, 2007; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate – Legislative Decree No. 861, Title XI, Quimpac First Issue; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report of the acts regarding the Trust Estate: Supermercados Peruanos as of September 30, 2007; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate – Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, Title XI, Public Offering of Securitized Bonds Grupo Drokasa; the individual interim financial statements and the quarterly report regarding the Trust Estate – Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF, Structured Sovereign Securitization Bonds Rendimiento – Numa; as well as the failure to timely communicate the profit distribution agreement for the 2007 period and the appointment of the new Chairman of the Board;
That, on August 17, 2010, INTERTÍTULOS filed an appeal against the aforementioned resolution, stating the following:
That the Directorate of Autonomous Estates should not have initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure, since the conditions for the application of the corrective measures established in the Sanctions Regulations were met, the Court incurring in contradiction by considering, on the one hand, that although the infractions are immaterial there was harm and repercussion in the market. Likewise, it mentions that it should have been taken into account that the company's shares are illiquid since its incorporation, have Banco Internacional del Perú S.A.A. as their sole owner and never had a listing, and that on other occasions CONASEV considered, in light of the "Sanction Criteria Applicable to Infractions Committed to the Deadlines for Submission of Information for the period June 2003 to December 2006" that the deadline is not the only criterion to be taken into account when evaluating the repercussion in the market. It concludes in that sense that the Letter of Charges No. 1094-2010-EF/94.06.2 should have been declared null for contravening the Sanctions Regulations by initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure;
That the RESOLUTION has not complied with evaluating the argument that it is incorrect to conclude that the late submission of information generates a possible harm for investors, since within these only institutional investors could be included, which do not require protection due to information asymmetry; therefore, said omission violates the due administrative procedure established in numeral 2 of article 230 of the General Administrative Procedure Law (LPAG);
That it likewise considers that the material fact regarding the appointment of the Chairman of the Board constitutes incomplete information as established in the Report prepared by the Directorate of Autonomous Estates and, therefore, the most severe sanction should not have been imposed as if the information had not been timely submitted even though INTERTÍTULOS completed the information before CONASEV sent a communication demanding it, and said circumstance was not evaluated in the RESOLUTION;
That, although the sanction criteria established in numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG were evaluated in the RESOLUTION, the Administrative Court only carried out a nominal evaluation of the mitigating factors, which is why the fine imposed must be reduced in application of said criteria;
That, by brief dated November 19, 2010, INTERTÍTULOS ratifies the arguments set forth in its appeal and jointly requests that the RESOLUTION be declared null in accordance with numeral 1 of article 10 of the LPAG, for violating the principle of due administrative procedure, and the sanction must be reduced in accordance with the mitigating factors contained in the LPAG that have not been evaluated;
That, it has been verified that the appeal filed has observed the provisions of articles 207 and 211 of the General Administrative Procedure Law (LPAG), has been filed within the established deadline, and complies with the requirements indicated in article 113 of the aforementioned law;
That, in accordance with article 31 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.1, the application of corrective measures is only appropriate when the following conditions are jointly observed: the immateriality of the infraction committed, the infraction must be minor or serious, the non-existence of repercussion in the market, and that the company does not have a record of sanction or corrective measure within a period of three (03) years;
That, in that sense, the RESOLUTION validly concluded and in application of the Sanction Criteria, approved by the Board of Directors of CONASEV on April 13, 2004, that, in the case of the submission of information, the repercussion in the market is implicit in the failure to meet deadlines, so the condition referring to the non-existence of harm in the market required by article 33 of the Sanctions Regulations was not verified, and by considering it sufficient to verify that one of the conditions of the referred article was not met, it was not necessary to analyze the immateriality of the infraction, which does not imply in any way that the infractions qualified as immaterial;
That, on the other hand, regarding the resolutions of the Administrative Court invoked by INTERTÍTULOS in which it is alleged that a different analysis parameter would have been applied, it must be noted that all of them correspond to the evaluation of infractions corresponding to the period between June 2003 and December 2006, in which the Exception Sanction Criteria were applicable, which expressly established that for the referred evaluation period a similar scheme of corrective measures would be applied, but not the same as that contained in the Sanctions Regulations;
That, as already indicated in accordance with the Current Sanction Criteria, the harm and repercussion in the market are implicit in the failure to meet deadlines, since what is sought through the requirement of timely disclosure of information is to protect the investor and thereby the efficiency of the securities market by providing all relevant information for decision-making and correct price formation, regardless of whether INTERTÍTULOS' shares are illiquid since incorporation, have Banco Internacional del Perú S.A.A. as their sole owner or never had a listing, it being necessary to take into account that what is sought to protect is the integrity and transparency of the market in general and not only the possible decisions that institutional investors may make, which, despite having a higher qualification level than small investors, still require the protection of securities market regulation;
That, regarding the argument that in this procedure INTERTÍTULOS' right to due process would have been violated, including in said right the possibility for the company to present its arguments, offer and produce evidence and obtain a reasoned decision founded in law, it should be noted that it has been verified that during the procedure the company had the opportunity to formulate its defenses, which were presented on April 5, 2010, to review the Report prepared by the Directorate of Autonomous Estates, and the possibility of exercising the right to speak at the session of the Administrative Court in which the case was evaluated, highlighting that such prerogative was not exercised, INTERTÍTULOS limiting itself to presenting its written arguments on July 16, 2010; therefore, it is concluded that throughout the procedure the company's right to defense and due process has been observed and respected, granting it the opportunities and proportional means for its exercise;
That, now then, the defenses formulated by INTERTÍTULOS were adequately evaluated by the RESOLUTION in the section referring to "Evaluation of the Sanction", affirming to the detriment of what was alleged by the company, and in attention to the Current Sanction Criteria, that the harm and repercussion regarding this type of non-compliance are implicit;
That, in relation to the non-compliance referring to the late communication of the appointment of the Chairman of the Board, agreed on August 4, 2009, it must be specified that literal C, numeral vi) of Annex I of the Regulations on Material Events in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, established that it constitutes a material event to be timely communicated the "changes and appointments of directors, managers, administrators, liquidators, as well as legal representatives or attorneys-in-fact who have powers to dispose of the issuer's assets or bind it, and must present the list of names and positions of the officials removed and of the officials appointed in their replacement, as well as the dates of cessation and start of duties, respectively"; INTERTÍTULOS on August 5, 2009 only reported as a material event the election of five principal directors without referring to the positions each would hold, it being August 7, 2009, when INTERTÍTULOS first communicated that, in the aforementioned General Meeting, it was unanimously agreed to appoint Mr. Carlos Tomas Rodríguez Pastor Persivale as Chairman of the Board of the company;
That, in that sense, the obligation to communicate the material event established in literal C, numeral vi) of Annex I of the Regulations on Material Events is understood to have been fulfilled only on August 7, 2009, with two (02) days of delay, a conclusion also reached by the Administrative Court of CONASEV, and said infraction should be sanctioned with the fines applicable to non-compliances in the communication of eventual information (such as material events) in accordance with the Current Sanction Criteria;
That, on the other hand, the fact that Mr. Rodríguez Pastor has been Chairman of the Board since the incorporation of the company does not alter the infraction for not having communicated the General Meeting agreement of August 4, 2009 appointing him Chairman of the Board, which although it would imply a ratification for the specific case, this designation constitutes a relevant material event that in accordance with the obligations established in the securities market regulations must be timely communicated;
That, the RESOLUTION took into consideration, at the time of imposing the sanction, the criteria contained both in the LMV, the Sanctions Regulations, the Current Sanction Criteria and the criteria introduced in the LPAG by Legislative Decree No. 1029, which were not contained in the Current Sanction Criteria, concluding as a result of the evaluation of the indicated criteria that regarding eighteen (18) infractions they should be sanctioned only with warnings; however, regarding the non-compliance in communicating two (02) material events, with more than one (01) day of delay, a fine should be imposed, since it considered that, in these cases, the legally protected interest, transparency and integrity of the securities market, has been affected and a greater sanction should be imposed in attention to the period of non-compliance;
That, consequently, since no violation of the principles of the administrative procedure has been verified and since the infractions incurred by INTERTÍTULOS are classified as minor in accordance with the provisions of Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 1, of the Sanctions Regulations, the arguments set forth by INTERTÍTULOS must be dismissed, in accordance with the reasons set forth above and;
In accordance with the provisions of subsection t) of article 11 of the Single Concorded Text of the Organic Law of CONASEV, approved by Legislative Decree No. 26126 and its amendments, as well as the agreement of the Board of Directors of CONASEV meeting in its session of December 6, 2010;
IT IS RESOLVED:
Article 1.- To declare unfounded the appeal filed by Internacional de Títulos Sociedad Titulizadora S.A. against Resolution of the Administrative Court of CONASEV No. 187-2010-EF/94.01.3.
Article 2.- To consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Article 3.- To transcribe this resolution to Internacional de Títulos Sociedad Titulizadora S.A. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Article 4.- To order the dissemination of this resolution on the CONASEV Portal.
Register, communicate and file
[pic]
Michel Canta Terreros
Chairman
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“in accordance with article 31 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.1”
“CONASEV Resolution No. 126-2010-EF/94.01.1 dated December 28, 2010, which declared unfounded the appeal filed by Intertítulos ST”
“CONASEV Resolution No. 126-2010-EF/94.01.2 of December 28, 2010”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 18 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added