Rule · CVM · 5 Nov 2026
Credit risk rating agencies must send the CVM, by March 31 each year, a reference form reflecting Annex B, their pricing policy and a list of amounts received per rating, and must update the reference form within seven business days of replacing the administrator responsible for the agency or for compliance. They must send the rating report to the rated entity at least one business day before public disclosure, hold public consultations of at least one month for new or significantly changed methodologies, and immediately suspend or withdraw a rating where cross-participation of 10% or more is identified after issuance. The Resolution enters into force on 1 December 2026, amending CVM Resolution No. 9.
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
Amends CVM Resolution No. 9, of October 27, 2020.
THE PRESIDENT OF THE BRAZILIAN SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION – CVM makes public that the Board, in a meeting held on November 4, 2026, in view of the provisions of arts. 8, 9 and 13 of Decree No. 12.002, of April 22, 2024, based on the provisions of arts. 8, caput, item I, and 27 of Law No. 6.385, of December 7, 1976, APPROVED the following Resolution:
Art. 1 CVM Resolution No. 9, of October 27, 2020, published in the Official Gazette of the Union of October 28, 2020, shall come into force with the following amendments:
Art. 1 This Resolution provides for the credit risk rating activity within the scope of the Brazilian securities market.
§ 1 This Resolution applies only to credit risk ratings intended for publication, disclosure or distribution to third parties, even if restricted to clients.
§ 2 All references made throughout this Resolution to the credit risk rating activity are also applicable to the analysis and statement regarding the credit risk rating outlook, where applicable.
Art. 1-A For the purposes of this Resolution, the following is understood as:
I – credit risk rating agency: legal entity registered or recognized by the CVM that professionally carries out the credit risk rating activity within the scope of the securities market;
II – credit risk rating: activity of opining on the credit quality of an issuer of equity or debt securities, of a structured transaction, or any financial asset issued in the securities market; and
III – credit risk rating outlook: prospective opinion on the likely direction of a credit risk rating within a predetermined period.” (NR)
“Art. 10. ............................................. ............................................................
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
§ 1 The information disclosed by the credit risk rating agency in the exercise of its activities must:
I – be written in simple, clear, objective and concise language; and
II – be restricted to content related to the credit risk rating, avoiding the inclusion of information unrelated to this purpose.
............................................................” (NR)
“Art. 13. The credit risk rating agency must send to the CVM, by March 31 of each year, through an electronic system available on the CVM's page on the worldwide computer network:
I – reference form, whose content must reflect Annex B;
II – its pricing policy, including the criteria for setting the prices of risk ratings for the different classes of assets; and
III – list containing the amounts received for each credit risk rating issued in the previous year, with the breakdown of the respective issuers.
§ 1 The credit risk rating agency must update the corresponding fields of the reference form within seven business days counted from the replacement of the administrator responsible for the agency with the CVM or of the administrator responsible for supervising compliance with rules, procedures and internal controls and this Resolution.
§ 2 The information provided for in items II and III of the caput, when sent to the CVM, is intended exclusively for the exercise of its supervision and inspection activities, and is not subject to public disclosure.” (NR)
“Art. 14. .............................................
I – relevant changes in methodologies, as well as the reasons why they were made, procedures and criteria used for the preparation of the risk rating, as well as new methodologies, including the respective start date of effectiveness, within seven business days counted from their publication;
II – decision to discontinue monitoring the risk rating, on the date of the decision, informing the reasons for the decision; and
............................................................” (NR)
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
“Art. 15. The credit risk rating report must be prepared in strict observance of the procedures and methodologies adopted by the agency.” (NR)
“Art. 15-A. The credit risk rating report must be sent to the rated entity at least one business day in advance of the disclosure of the risk rating to the public, in order to allow a factual check by the rated entity.
§ 1 Exceptionally, the disclosure of the risk rating may occur without observing the procedure provided for in the caput, provided that the credit risk rating agency presents a reasoned justification and maintains documentary evidence of the reasons that made it impossible to carry out the prior consultation with the rated entity.
§ 2 If the rated entity has commented on the factual check or confirmed the absence of factual errors in the report sent, the disclosure of the risk rating may occur immediately after such statement.” (NR)
“Art. 16. ............................................ ............................................................
II – the relevant sources of information used in the preparation of the risk rating, including the rated entity or a party related to it, if any;
............................................................
IX – whether the assigned rating was changed after the report was sent to the rated entity, pursuant to art. 15-A;
............................................................
XI – services provided to the rated entity by parties related to the credit risk rating agency, in the last twelve months;
XII – the situations that evidence potential conflicts of interest; and
XIII – the identification of the nature of the risk classification, and it must state whether the classification was:
a) requested by the rated entity or by a party related to it;
b) requested by third parties; or
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF 5 NOVEMBER 2026
c) maintained on the initiative of the credit risk rating agency itself.
§ 1 When the credit risk classification is not requested by the rated entity or by a party related to it, the report must state:
I – whether the rated entity or a related party participated in the assessment process; and
II – whether information was obtained directly from the entity's management and internal documents relevant to the credit risk analysis were consulted.
§ 2 .................................................... ............................................................
II – if the agency, its partners, the credit risk analysts and other persons involved in the process of issuing a given risk classification, their spouses, dependents or partners, have, directly or indirectly, relevant financial and commercial interests in relation to the rated entity;
III – if the credit risk analysts or other persons involved in the process of issuing a given risk classification have a link with a natural person who works for the rated entity or a party related to it; and
IV – if the same shareholder or partner holds, directly or indirectly, a participation equal to or greater than 5% (five percent) of the share capital or voting rights of both the risk rating agency and the rated entity or a party related to it, except for participations held by diversified investment funds, without significant influence over management.
............................................................
§ 4 When a credit risk classification outlook is assigned, the report must state the time horizon during which a change in the risk classification is expected.
§ 5 A link exists, for the purposes of the provisions of item III of § 2, when the credit risk analyst or any person involved in the process of issuing the classification is a spouse, partner or relative, by blood or affinity, up to the second degree, of a natural person who works for the rated entity or a party related to it.” (NR)
“Art. 17. ............................................
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF 5 NOVEMBER 2026
............................................................ § 1 For the purposes of this Resolution, examples of structured financial products are:
I – shares of credit rights investment funds – FIDC;
............................................................ V – agribusiness receivables certificates – CRA;
VI – debentures whose payment of principal and interest comes from the financial flow resulting from the assignment of credit rights; and
VII – securitization securities, as defined in the regulation that provides for credit rights securitization companies registered with the CVM.
............................................................” (NR)
“Art. 19. ............................................ ............................................................
IV – review all relevant work of the credit risk analyst in the two years prior to their departure from the staff of the credit risk rating agency, if they went to work for rated entities or parties related to them;
V – prepare a code of conduct; and
VI – ensure that the price charged for the risk classification service and complementary services is not discriminatory and does not depend on the classification issued by the agency or on any other result of the service provided.” (NR)
“Art. 19-A. If an error is identified in a risk classification methodology or in the execution of procedures related to risk classification, which gives rise to the need to revise a risk classification already issued, regardless of whether or not such revision results in a change to the assigned rating, the risk rating agency must, without unjustified delay and as soon as it is possible to explain the impacts of said error on the risk classifications issued:
I – notify the error to the CVM and to all affected rated entities, informing the impact on the classifications, including with regard to the need for revision;
II – disclose on its website the errors that give rise to revision in risk classifications issued;
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF 5 NOVEMBER 2026
III – begin correcting the errors in its risk classification methodologies and procedures; and
IV – apply the measures referred to in art. 30 of this Resolution.” (NR)
“Art. 20-A. The risk rating agency must establish a gradual rotation mechanism for the risk analysts and for the persons who approve the risk classifications, based on the rated entities.
§ 1 The rotation mechanism must promote the rotation of persons, not of work teams.
§ 2 Exceptionally, the CVM may, upon a reasoned request, waive compliance, in whole or in part, with the requirements set forth in this article, when their application proves inadequate or excessively burdensome to the agency's activities or to the characteristics of the risk classifications issued.
§ 3 The granting of the waiver referred to in § 2 is conditioned upon the demonstration of the impossibility of complying with the provisions of the caput and that the agency adopts measures capable of mitigating the risks arising from the flexibilization, including internal control mechanisms, information communication provisions and measures aimed at ensuring the independence of the credit rating analysts and the persons responsible for approving the credit ratings.” (NR)
“Art. 22. ............................................ ............................................................
VII – .................................................... ............................................................
b) the rated entity or a party related thereto is part, directly or indirectly, of the controlling block of the credit rating agency or vice-versa;
c) the analysts, the partners of the credit rating agency, or the other persons involved in the credit rating issuance process hold, directly or indirectly, financial assets of an entity rated by them or of a party related thereto;
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
d) the analysts, the partners of the credit rating agency, or the other persons involved in the credit rating issuance process are members of the board of directors or have any power of interference over the rated entity;
e) the analysts, the partners of the credit rating agency, or the other persons involved in the credit rating issuance process have maintained any relationship with the rated entity or with a party related thereto that could cause a conflict of interest;
f) there are no reliable data or the complexity of the structure of the new type of financial asset could result in a risk to the quality of the credit rating to be issued; or
g) the same shareholder or partner holds, directly or indirectly, a participation equal to or greater than 10% (ten percent) of the capital stock or voting rights of both the credit rating agency and the rated entity or a party related thereto, except for participations held by diversified investment funds, without significant influence over management.
............................................................
§ 3 The provisions of item ‘g’ of subsection VII of the caput also apply when the cross-participation equal to or greater than 10% (ten percent) is identified after the issuance of the credit rating, in which case the agency must immediately suspend or withdraw the rating, in order to preserve the credibility of the rating process and the integrity of the capital market.” (NR)
Art. 23-A. The credit rating, the rating outlook and information related to the credit rating are presumed to be relevant information of the rated entity for purposes of trading assets in the securities market, in accordance with the regulations that provide for the disclosure of information about a relevant act or fact, the trading of securities pending an undisclosed relevant act or fact and the disclosure of information about the trading of securities.” (NR)
“Art. 23-B. The agency must adopt procedures to ensure that the public disclosure of the information referred to in Art. 23-A is made in a timely manner and does not give rise to
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
undue information asymmetry nor enable its selective use before communication to the market.” (NR)
“Art. 25-A. The credit rating agency must keep updated a list of persons linked to the agency who have access to information related to its credit ratings, rating outlooks or related information, prior to disclosure.” (NR)
“Art. 29-A. The credit rating agency that intends to introduce new methodologies or procedures, or to promote significant changes in existing methodologies or procedures used in the preparation of credit ratings, likely to impact certain credit ratings, even if such impacts do not result in a change of the assigned rating, must promote a public consultation, for a period of no less than one month, through publication on its website on the worldwide computer network.
§ 1 The publication referred to in the caput must be accompanied by a detailed explanation regarding the grounds and implications of the changes or of the new methodologies or procedures proposed.
§ 2 The credit rating agency must immediately inform the CVM when the public consultation begins and ends, as well as publish the new credit rating methodologies on its website on the worldwide computer network.
§ 3 The credit rating agency must publish the responses to the public consultation on its website on the worldwide computer network, and may present them in aggregate form, subject to the cases of requests for confidentiality by the respondent.” (NR)
Art. 2 Annex B of CVM Resolution No. 9, of October 27, 2020, published in the Official Gazette of the Union of October 28, 2020, shall come into force with the following amendments:
| “4.3 Identify the rated entities or parties related thereto that: |
|---|
| a. are responsible for more than 5% (five percent) of the annual net revenue of the agency, informing the total amount of revenues generated for the agency; |
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION www.cvm.gov.br
CVM RESOLUTION No. 251, OF NOVEMBER 5, 2026
b. have a shareholder or partner who holds, directly or indirectly, an interest equal to or greater than 5% (five percent) of the share capital or voting rights of both the credit rating agency and the rated entity or a related party, except for interests held by diversified investment funds, without significant influence over management; and
c. have a shareholder or partner who holds, directly or indirectly, an interest equal to or greater than 10% (ten percent) of the share capital or voting rights of both the agency and the rated entity or a related party, except for interests held by diversified investment funds, without significant influence over management.” (NR)
Art. 3º The following provisions of CVM Resolution No. 9, of 27 October 2020, published in the Official Gazette of the Union of 28 October 2020, are revoked:
I – art. 1º, caput, items I and II; and
II – art. 17, § 1º, item III.
Art. 4º This Resolution enters into force on 1 December 2026.
Electronically signed by
OTTO EDUARDO FONSECA DE ALBUQUERQUE LOBO
President
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
RegAlert holds no document that amends or replaces this one. This is not a check that it is in force: confirm with the regulator.
“Amends CVM Resolution No. 9, of October 27, 2020.”
“based on the provisions of arts. 8, caput, item I, and 27 of Law No. 6.385, of December 7, 1976”
“in view of the provisions of arts. 8, 9 and 13 of Decree No. 12.002, of April 22, 2024”
This document amends: CVM Resolution No. 9 of October 27, 2020, with amendments introduced by CVM Resolution No. 185/23
More like this from CVM
CVM published 8 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Comissão de Valores Mobiliários — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added