Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision Resolution SMV
No. 095-2022-SMV/11
Summary: Sanction Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A. with a total fine of 20 UIT, for having incurred two (02) infractions of a serious nature classified in item 2.10 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | CORPORACIÓN ACEROS AREQUIPA S.A. |
| Matter | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2022002061 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2022002061 and Report No. 510-2022-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Function and competence of the SASCM
- That administrative file No. 2022002061 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervision function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Legislative Decree No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to impose sanctions at first administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control corresponds to the aforementioned Deputy Superintendency. Likewise, the SASCM has the powers to issue corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infraction;
- That, with respect to the charges referring to the non-communication of material events, it corresponds to two (02) administrative instances in accordance with article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, and to the provisions of numeral 26 of article 12 of the ROF-SMV, which establish that the Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves appeals against resolutions issued at first instance by the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct of the SASCM, with the exception of single-instance procedures;
- Facts, charges and arguments of the administered entity
- Facts
- That it was evaluated whether Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) complied or not with timely communicating two (02) material events to the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV;
- Charges
- That, as a result of said evaluation, through Official Letter No. 227-2022-SMV/11.2 of January 21, 2022 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), charges were formulated against the Issuer because it would not have complied with communicating the following:
- The material event referring to the start of activities of the audit firm for fiscal year 2019, which should have been communicated as soon as such event occurs or knowledge thereof is taken, and in no case beyond the day on which it occurred or was known; however, to date, it has not been informed;
- The material event referring to the start of activities of the audit firm for fiscal year 2020, which should have been communicated as soon as such event occurs or knowledge thereof is taken, and in no case beyond the day on which it occurred or was known; however, to date, it has not been informed;
- That the aforementioned non-compliances are classified in item 2.10 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Arguments
- That, through a brief dated January 28, 2022, the Issuer presented its arguments stating the following:
«Through material events No. GAF-0043-2019 published on May 30, 2019 and No. GAF0031-2020 published on July 23, 2020, the Market was informed that the Board of Directors of Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A. appointed as External Auditors the firm Paredes, Burga & Asociados S. Civil de R.L., a member firm of EY International.
These events occurred within the term provided by the Rules; in that sense we must specify that the audit activities began on the same day on which the audit firm was appointed by the Board of Directors, that is, on May 30, 2019 and July 23, 2020 respectively, dates on which the corresponding material events were published. Likewise, it should be taken into account that in the document “Management Discussion and Analysis” published on July 23, 2020 on the SMV portal it is stated that the external financial audit began in July 2020.
It should be mentioned that article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation does not specify the term in which the publication of the start of operations of the external audit must be made.»;
- That, through Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures. Likewise, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG indicates the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction: (a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, (b) The probability of detection of the infraction, (c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, (d) The economic harm caused, (e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, (f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction and, (g) The existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender;
- That the charges formulated and the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been submitted to the knowledge of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 2029-2022-SMV/11 of May 3, 2022, the Report was sent to the Issuer, so that it may submit its arguments within five (5) business days of notification of said report; the same that have been presented and will be evaluated in this Resolution;
- Issues to be determined
- That, in this PAS it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether the Issuer incurred or not in the infractions indicated in the Letter of Charges and Report; and
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on the Issuer.
- Analysis
- Applicable Regulations
- That article 28 of the LMV establishes that: «The registration of a certain security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of the material events, including ongoing negotiations, about itself, the security and the offer made of it, as well as to disclose such events in a truthful, sufficient and timely manner. The information must be provided to said institutions and disclosed as soon as the event occurs or the issuer becomes aware of it, as the case may be.» (Underline added)*;
- That, as established by article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10, modified by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Financial Information Regulation): «Companies obligated to present audited financial information must communicate, as a material event, the designation of their independent auditors no later than June 30 of each year. Likewise, they must communicate as a material event the date on which the audit work will begin. (…)» (Underline added);
- That, in addition, numeral 9.1 of article 9 of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Regulation of Material Events), states that: «The Issuer must report its material event as soon as such event occurs or the Issuer becomes aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it has occurred or has been known (…)» (Underline added);
- That the non-compliance with the indicated rules is classified in item 2.10 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a serious infraction: «Not communicating material events or not presenting audited individual or consolidated financial information, interim individual or consolidated financial statements, management report or special audit report and annual reports» (Underline added);
- That, according to article 34 of the Sanctions Regulation, said infraction is punishable with a fine of no less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT, or suspension of the negotiation of securities for up to one (1) year or of the public offering placement;
- That, according to the provisions of recital 2 of this Resolution, this type of non-compliance corresponds to two (02) administrative instances for its evaluation and resolution, the first before the Deputy Superintendent of the SASCM, and the second and final instance, before the Superintendent of the Securities Market;
- Evaluation of the case
- That, in administrative file No. 2022002061, which contains the documentation of this PAS, it is observed that through Memorandum No. 2067-2021-SMV/11.1 (File No. 2021024009), the General Intendancy for Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, IGSC) —an organ of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV that has within its functions and powers, the supervision of compliance with the rules applicable to audit firms contracted by companies with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market – RPMV, evaluating the indications of possible infractions, and forwards, for its consideration, the respective reports of indications of infraction, to the IGCC—, forwarded to the IGCC, the result of its evaluation, and specifically referred to the present case;
- That it must be kept in mind that the procedures and legal forms with which the IGSC conducts its inspection and/or supervision activity and upon concluding it with a report of indications of infraction, determine that its pronouncement or opinion on a specific supervision issue —which may even contain a decision, such as, for example, the adoption of corrective measures—, is an opinion on the merits of the matter; it being necessary to specify that said opinion and the report of indications of infraction of the IGSC is not binding for the IGCC, as established in the second paragraph of article 9 of the Sanctions Regulation[1] [2];
- That, in this way, in the evaluation of the facts related to this PAS, two (02) other organs or administrative instances of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, functionally independent from each other and from this Office, have intervened and participated prior to the issuance of this Resolution: first the IGSC which in due course reported the indications of infraction through Memorandum No. 2067-2021-SMV/11.1, and then the IGCC which, as a result of its evaluation, formulated the Letter of Charges and the Report; and at this point of the PAS, it corresponds to the Office of the SASCM to issue a pronouncement and decision regarding the mentioned charges, it being necessary to indicate that due to their nature, it will be a first administrative instance decision;
- That the Office of the SASCM declares and establishes that all the briefs presented by the Issuer, which are in this file, have been analyzed to issue this resolution; likewise, it expressly records that extracts of the arguments and allegations are also transcribed as a reference, which does not imply that all extremes thereof have not been analyzed; and even less assume that by not transcribing them in their entirety, it could later be argued that the right of defense and due process have been impaired. In any case, all the documentation contained in said arguments and allegations are in this administrative file;
- That, prior to the corresponding analysis, it must be noted that the formulation of the charges of this PAS was based on the fact that the Issuer did not communicate the material events referring to the start of activities of the audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, which should have been communicated as soon as such events occurred or knowledge thereof was taken, and in no case beyond the day on which they occurred or were known; however, to date, the Issuer has not complied with the referred communication, thus evidencing the failure of the duty of diligence on the part of the Issuer;
- That compliance with the obligation regarding the timely presentation of periodic or eventual information by issuers of securities registered in the RPMV is necessary for the transparency and proper functioning of the securities market, and in that sense the transparency of information is a protected legal interest, it being necessary to point out that the non-observance of said obligation harms or affects it;
- That, likewise, non-compliances in the presentation of periodic or eventual information within the terms established in the regulations constitute infractions that are configured and appreciated objectively with the passage of time from the day following the deadline on which the issuers were obligated to present the information to the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV;
- That, in relation to the arguments presented by the Issuer, the following must be indicated:
- Regarding the fact that the audit activities began on the same day on which the audit firm was appointed by the Board of Directors, that is, on May 30, 2019 and July 23, 2020, dates on which the corresponding material events were published; it should be noted that, from the reading of the referred material events[3], it is observed that the Issuer only informed the designation of the referred audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, but not the start of audit work for these periods, which represent different obligations. In this sense, according to article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation, the Issuer should have communicated as material events the date on which the audit work would begin for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, however, it has not been presented to date.
It should be remembered that the Issuer, by maintaining securities registered in the RPMV, is obligated to observe and comply with the regime of communication and disclosure of information[4] strictly, regarding the presentation of periodic and eventual information in a timely manner;
-
- Regarding the fact that the document “Management Discussion and Analysis”, disseminated on July 23, 2020, should be taken into account; it should be reiterated that article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation establishes that the Issuer must communicate as a material event the start of its audit work, which implies informing a precise date of the start of audit work, a situation that was not done in the present case referring to periods 2019 and 2020;
2. On the other hand, regarding what the Issuer stated in its arguments regarding the fact that article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation does not specify the term in which the publication of the start of operations of the external audit must be made; it should be noted that this is not correct, since the referred article, by mentioning that this communication is made through a material event, implies that it must be made complying with the provisions of numeral 9.1 of article 9 of the Regulation of Material Events, which establishes that the Issuer must report its material event as soon as such event occurs or the Issuer becomes aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it has occurred or has been known;
3. Given the above, it can be seen that what the Issuer stated in its arguments does not justify the non-compliances incurred nor disprove the charges formulated, since based on its duty of diligence, the Issuer should have adopted adequate measures in order to timely communicate the material events regarding the start of audit work for fiscal years 2019 and 2020;
1. That, likewise, through a brief dated May 10, 2022, the Issuer submitted its allegations referring to the Report, stating the following:
- The alleged infractions would not have generated an economic harm or repercussion in the market, so the legal interest protected by the Regulation of Material Events would not have been violated, as has been stated in the Report. In this sense, the SASCM must analyze and review this point in light of the Principle of Material Truth provided in the TUO of the LPAG; otherwise, a lack of motivation could be incurred;
- The alleged infractions could not be classified as «Serious» infractions consisting of the non-compliance with the presentation of a material event, because they do not fit within said infraction type, since the Issuer would have presented incompletely the material event applicable to the Financial Information Regulation to the extent that it omitted, involuntarily, to incorporate the specific date of the start of the audit work for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, in the material events of May 30, 2019 and July 23, 2020, respectively. In this sense, a violation of the Principle of Typicality would be incurred, which prescribes the extensive or analogical interpretation of infraction types and of the Political Constitution of Peru;
- In the denied assumption that the SASCM does not accept the claim for the archiving of this PAS, it requests that a graduation be made for each of the alleged infractions and that they be sanctioned with the lowest sanction provided for Minor infractions in the Sanctions Regulation, which would consist of a warning or, alternatively, with the lowest monetary sanction applicable to said type of infractions.
2. That, regarding said allegations, the following must be indicated:
- Regarding the Issuer's argument that the infractions subject of the Letter of Charges have not generated economic harm or repercussion in the market, so the legal interest protected in the Regulation of Material Events would not have been violated; it should be noted that the transparency of the securities market is a supra-individual legal interest or diffuse interest, insofar as it safeguards the interests of investors and potential investors, which may be affected when the rules for the presentation of periodic and/or eventual information that must be disclosed to the market are transgressed so that they adopt investment decisions duly informed about the issuer and its securities traded in the centralized negotiation mechanisms. In this sense, when the disclosure of material events is omitted —as in the present case—, the issuer is in an advantageous position vis-à-vis the investor and/or potential investor, thus generating a situation of information asymmetry and an affectation to the legal interest protected by the Regulation of Material Events, that is, the transparency of information.
It should be noted that the start of the audit work is an event that gives security to investors, creating the expectation that the issuer will prepare and present its audited annual financial information, this being vital for decision-making. In this sense, when the Issuer becomes aware of the start of the audit work, within the framework of due diligence, it must proceed to disclose such decision as soon as it occurs or has become aware, in accordance with numeral 9.1 of article 9 of the Regulation of Material Events; since an action to the contrary —that is, the non-timely disclosure of the material event— would entail a detriment to the transparency of the securities market and, consequently, an affectation to the investor.
Therefore, what the Issuer stated regarding the fact that the infractions subject of the Letter of Charges have not generated a violation of the legal interest protected in the Regulation of Material Events is not accurate; consequently, this argument does not disprove the charges imputed in this PAS.
-
- Regarding the Issuer's argument that the alleged infractions could not be classified as «Serious» infractions consisting of the non-compliance with the presentation of a material event, because they do not fit within said infraction type; it should be noted that article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation contains two (02) different obligations, one refers to communication as a material event of the designation of the independent auditors and the other obligation refers to the communication as a material event of the date on which the audit work will begin.
In this regard, from the reading of the material events disclosed on May 30, 2019[5] and July 23, 2020[6], it is observed that the Issuer only informed the designation of the referred audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, respectively, but not the start of audit work for these periods, which, as previously indicated, qualify as different obligations.
In this manner, within the framework of Article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation, the Issuer did not communicate, as material events, the dates on which the audit work for fiscal years 2019 and 2020 would begin. In this regard, said omissive conduct is duly typified in subsection 2.10 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a serious infraction: «Failure to communicate material events or failure to present audited individual or consolidated financial information, interim individual or consolidated financial statements, management report or special audit report and annual reports» (Underline added); but not in the infraction type that the Issuer erroneously indicated in its arguments; consequently, the Principle of Typicality has not been violated nor has an extensive or analogical interpretation of the infraction types been made;
-
- Regarding the Issuer's request that a gradation be made for each of the alleged infractions so that it be sanctioned with the lowest sanction provided for minor infractions in the Sanctions Regulation; it should be noted that this argument will be evaluated at the time of determining the corresponding sanction;
- That, consequently, to the extent that the Issuer did not communicate, as material events, the start dates of the audit firm's activities for fiscal years 2019 and 2020; and, having carried out the corresponding analysis of the discharges and arguments presented; it is concluded that the conducts constituting infractions have been accredited, as the material events subject of the Letter of Charges were not presented within the established term. Therefore, the administrative responsibility of the Issuer in this PAS is determined, so it is appropriate to take into consideration the circumstances of the commission of the infractions for the evaluation of the sanction that may correspond;
- Determination of the Sanction
- That, having determined the commission of the infractions, it is appropriate to determine the sanction for these types of non-compliance by evaluating the sanction criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV, in accordance with numeral 3) of Article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which the following criteria must be taken into consideration: (i) the sanction history of the administered party; (ii) recidivism for the commission of the same infraction; (iii) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; (iv) the economic harm caused; (v) the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; (vi) the probability of detection of the infraction; (vii) the severity of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; and, (viii) the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria);
- That, regarding the sanction history, it is established that the offender's antecedents are the sanctions imposed by the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV that became final within the four (4) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned. In application of said criterion, the Report has stated that the Issuer has no sanction history;
- That, regarding recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, it is established that the final sanction imposed by the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV within a period of one (01) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned is taken into account. In this regard, the Report has stated that there is no recidivism on the part of the Issuer in the commission of the same infraction;
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE COMMISSION OF THE INFRACTION
- That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that the Report has verified that the Issuer, to date, has not submitted the material events subject of the Letter of Charges. Likewise, it should be noted that from the verification of the material events and financial information disseminated by the Issuer on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, it is observed that through material events of May 30, 2019 and July 23, 2020[7], it communicated the designation of the audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, respectively; likewise, the Issuer complied with timely presenting its Annual Separate Financial Statements corresponding to said fiscal years[8]. In this sense, it can be concluded that a reasonable investor would take into account in their analysis that the audit work effectively began, since subsequently the Issuer complied with timely presenting said financial statements. Therefore, these facts must be evaluated in order to determine whether it is appropriate to impose on the Issuer a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided;
- That, in addition, without prejudice to the analysis and conclusions previously exposed, and as additional grounds, in the sense that all relevant information required by applicable regulations, which must be disseminated through material events by issuers; and in particular, the relevant information and/or material events related to the external audit of their financial statements, are of the highest necessity, relevance and usefulness for the securities market and its development, and that precisely for this reason, among other reasons, in the regulations non-compliances directly linked to information related to the external audit —as in the particular case of not communicating as material events the start of activities of the audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020—, their non-compliance qualifies as a Serious infraction, and therefore deserves from the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV —as the securities market authority—, special attention and the application of measures or liability consequences for the offending issuer that generate an effective disincentive for the repetition or appearance of infractions of a similar nature. In this sense, it is necessary to keep in mind the following:
EXTERNAL FINANCIAL AUDIT AND ITS ROLE AS A GENERATOR OF TRUST
- That, with the objective of fostering and reinforcing trust in the financial information that is disseminated among stakeholders and the general public, financial statements are subjected to external financial audits through which qualified independent professionals collect, analyze and structure the information of an entity with the necessary rigor in order to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial statements, as a whole, are free from material errors, due to fraud or error, and to issue a professional opinion on whether said financial statements are presented fairly in accordance with the applicable financial information framework;
- That, to achieve such objectives, it is necessary that audits be performed under international quality standards oriented to the public interest, such as the International Standards on Auditing (hereinafter, ISA), issued by the International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB);
- That, in this sense, ISA 200 «Overall Objectives of the Independent Auditor and the Conduct of an Audit in Accordance with International Standards on Auditing» clearly establishes that the objective of an audit is to increase the degree of confidence of users in the financial statements through the expression of a professional opinion on whether the financial statements have been prepared in accordance with an applicable financial information framework. To achieve this objective, it is important that the auditor in charge complies with the applicable ethical requirements;
- That, the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) contemplates among its objectives and principles of securities regulation the obligation that auditors be independent of the audited entity;
- That, likewise, the Handbook of the Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants 2014 Edition, issued by the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA), in its Section 290 «Independence – Audit and Review Engagements» establishes that the independence that an auditor must have implies having an independent mental attitude to issue an opinion without influences that compromise professional judgment and having an apparent independence, this supposes avoiding relevant facts and circumstances that a third party with judgment and well informed could probably conclude that the integrity, objectivity or professional skepticism of the firm or the audit team member have been compromised;
- That, in that order of ideas, in Peru, the Code of Professional Ethics for Public Accountants, in its Article 42, states that an auditor and/or an audit firm in charge of an audit must have independence which implies reaching a conclusion without influences that compromise professional judgment, allowing an auditor to act with integrity, objectivity and professional skepticism;
- That, therefore, financial audits play a role of vital importance to maintain credibility in the veracity and integrity of financial information; however, to achieve an adequate level of trust, auditors must conduct their audits at the highest level of quality and with a strong ethical and professional attitude. Consequently, it is necessary that audits be performed under international quality standards oriented to the public interest, such as the ISA issued by the IAASB;
- That, thus, under the scope of the considerations exposed in the preceding paragraphs, it is a fact that such information —the start date of an issuer's external audit—, is of utmost necessity for the stakeholders of an issuer, who can know with certainty and revealed by the issuer's own transparency, what was the start date of the external audit work. That knowledge of that date together with the date of the respective external audit report, is of utmost usefulness, among others, because it allows measuring or estimating with a certain degree of objectivity or to have at least an idea, about the period of time during which the external audit was executed, which could be days, weeks or months; and from that estimate one could also derive the obtaining of other information or other types of information also useful for the securities market;
- That, in addition, it is necessary to indicate that the dissemination of said information —the start date of an issuer's external audit— also has the character of a prudential norm or for prudential purposes, since its purpose is that the start of an issuer's external audit be on a date such that in relation to the end date of the same external audit, it determines an execution term of the external audit that is reasonable or sufficient, even for the issuer itself, in the sense that it can have a reasonable term, for example, so that, if cases arise or occur, it can appropriately attend to the requirements of the external audit; to make clarifications of audit findings or their lifting; to address key audit matters; to practice due diligence of what the external audit contracted by the issuer itself demands; and to be able to have an audit report on time considering the maximum terms established in the regulations to present its audited annual financial statements. As noted, the need to have the dissemination of this date allows the Issuer itself the best management of its risks related to the financial information that will be the main object of the financial audit. In sum, it is clearly established that the knowledge and dissemination of the start date of the external audit by the issuer is not only a regulatory necessity and requirement, but also generates a series of benefits, risk management and value, even for the issuer itself that contracts the external audit, and which we understand must always privilege the quality of an external audit —which is also a regulatory requirement due to the application of the ISA issued by the IAASB—, rather than trying to comply only with a regulatory requirement, and in this sense, we consider that referring only to the duration factor of an annual external audit, it is certainly an indicator of its quality, the effective duration of said annual external audit. Thus, for example, taking this indicated duration factor to extremes, it is reasonable to maintain that with respect to the same issuer or comparable issuers, an external audit whose duration is one (01) day or a few days is highly likely to be of lower quality than, for example, another annual external audit whose duration is more than one (01) day or more than a few days;
- That, in the specific case of this PAS; since the Issuer did not comply with its obligation to disseminate information on the start dates of the annual external audits for fiscal year 2019 and 2020, it is not possible to know or estimate the duration it would have had, and consequently the securities market or the general public, including the Issuer's stakeholders, have not been allowed [to have] all this indicated information related to its annual external audit;
EXTERNAL AUDIT AND THE OECD CORPORATE GOVERNANCE PRINCIPLES
- That, regarding this point, it is of utmost necessity to indicate that in the document called Corporate Governance Principles of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development – OECD and the G20, principles and guidelines are indicated to be taken into consideration regarding what was previously exposed and with respect to the external audit of a company or issuer, and especially in relation to the real adoption of Good Corporate Governance Practices by issuers.[9]
In this regard, in section «V. Disclosure and transparency» of said document it is expressly stated:
«C. An independent, competent and qualified auditor should carry out an annual audit in accordance with high-quality standards, in order to provide the board and shareholders with an external and objective assurance that the financial statements adequately reflect the financial situation and results of the company in all material aspects.
In addition to certifying that the financial statements faithfully reflect the financial situation of the company, the audit report will assess the manner in which they have been prepared and presented. This will favor better control of the company. In some countries, external auditors are also required to address the corporate governance of the company.
Auditors will be independent and will respond to shareholders. The designation of a regulatory authority in matters of audit that is not linked to the profession, in accordance with the Essential Principles of the International Forum of Independent Audit Regulators (IFIAR), constitutes an important factor to improve the quality of audits.
It is considered a good practice that external auditors have been recommended by an audit committee independent of the Board of Directors or an equivalent body, and that they have been appointed by it or by the shareholders directly. Furthermore, according to the IOSCO Principles for Auditor Independence and the Role of Corporate Governance in Monitoring Auditor Independence, «the rules relating to auditor independence shall provide a framework of principles, supported by a combination of prohibitions, restrictions, other policies and procedures, together with data disclosure requirements, that addresses, at least, the following threats to independence: self-interest, self-review, advocacy, close relationships and intimidation».
The audit committee, or an equivalent body, will supervise the internal audit activities, as well as the overall relationship with the external auditor, which includes the nature of the non-audit services that the latter may provide to the company. The provision of other types of tasks for the company may undermine the independence of the external auditor and could imply that the latter has to supervise their own work. To deal with the biased incentives that may arise, it will be required that payments to external auditors for services not linked to the audit be made public. Among other rules designed to contribute to the independence of auditors, one can mention the total prohibition of performing other types of tasks for their audit clients or a great restriction on the nature of these, the mandatory rotation of these professionals (between partners or, in some cases, between audit firms), the establishment of a determined duration for their appointment, joint audits, the temporary impossibility for the company to hire a former auditor and the prohibition that auditors and those who depend on them have financial interests or hold management positions in the companies they supervise. In some countries, a direct regulation strategy is chosen and the percentage of income that an auditor can obtain for non-audit services provided to a client is limited, or the total percentage of an auditor's profits that can come from a company is restricted.
In some countries, the pressing need to ensure that audit professionals are competent has arisen. As a good practice, there may be a registration procedure for auditors that allows verifying their qualification. However, this measure will be complemented with continuous training and monitoring of work experience in order to ensure an adequate level of professional competence and skepticism.
D. External auditors will respond to shareholders and will commit to the company to act with due professional diligence during the performance of the audit.
It is considered a good practice that external auditors have been recommended by an audit committee independent of the Board of Directors, or by an equivalent body, and that external auditors are appointed either by this body or committee or by the Shareholders' Meeting directly, since this emphasizes that these professionals will respond to shareholders. Likewise, it is emphasized that external auditors acquire a commitment to act with due professional diligence before the company, and not with one or several of the directors with whom they interact during the performance of their work.»[10]
- That, continuing with the evaluation of the other sanction criteria, it should be noted that with respect to the harm caused and impact on the market, it has not been evidenced that the non-compliance has produced a quantifiable harm, understood as economic damage caused to one or several investors. However, it should be highlighted that this does not exclude the configuration of non-compliances that directly affect market transparency;
- That, regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been proven that the infraction incurred by the Issuer has generated an illegal benefit;
- That, in relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that the detection of non-compliances in the presentation of material events, such as the one dealt with in this PAS, are non-compliances whose detection requires a greater degree of supervision, since there is no single express date or deadline for their presentation;
- That in relation to the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it should be indicated that this refers to the severity of the damage that is directly linked to the affectation of market transparency, a protected legal interest, which when transgressed affects the public interest. In this context, it should be indicated that the communication of material events by issuers of securities registered in the RPMV constitutes a fundamental obligation in the transparency of the securities market, since it seeks to guarantee that market participants make their investment decisions on such or such security adequately informed;
- That, in the present case, the Issuer, by not communicating as material events the start of the audit work for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, affected market transparency, which is considered a protected legal interest;
- That, regarding the intentionality in the conduct of the offender, the existence of malice or intentionality in the conduct of the Issuer has not been verified, in accordance with the acceptance of responsibility by the Issuer; however, a lack of diligence is proven by not sending the material events required by the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV;
- That, in attention to the Sanction Criteria, that is, that the Issuer has no antecedents nor the condition of recidivist, it is not observed that an economic harm or a serious repercussion in the market has been generated, it has not obtained an illegal benefit and there was no malice in the commission of the infraction, it is considered that in the present PAS, by exception, the provisions of the second paragraph of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation[11] would be applicable; since, in this case, it is noted that there would be no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed (fine of not less than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT) and the imputed fact; it should be noted that although the Issuer did not comply with communicating as material events the dates on which the audit work began for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, in addition to the aforementioned criteria, it is also important to highlight that through material events of May 30, 2019 and July 23, 2020[12], it communicated the designation of the audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, respectively; likewise, the Issuer complied with timely presenting its Annual Separate Financial Statements corresponding to said fiscal years;
- That, it is considered that in application of the principle of reasonableness referred to in numeral 3 of article 248[13] of the TUO of the LPAG, it corresponds to impose two (02) fines between twenty-five (25) and fifty (50) UIT, each. In this regard, attending to the nature of the infraction and in accordance with what is indicated in the Report, it is considered that in this extreme a fine sanction of the range corresponding to minor infractions must be imposed, which according to article 35 of the Sanctions Regulation, are punishable with a warning or fine of not less than one (1) UIT and up to twenty-five (25) UIT;
- That, finally, in attention to said principle of reasonableness referred to above which states that the measures imposed (sanction) be proportional and not excessive, the IGCC in its Report has proposed that two (02) fines of five (05) UIT be imposed, each, equivalent to S/ 21,500.00 (Twenty-One Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 Soles), for the non-compliances committed that have been the subject of the Charge Letter, it being reiterated that the Report is not binding for this Deputy Superintendency[14];
- That, regarding the recommendations of the Report, although we share the essence of the analysis carried out by the IGCC regarding the configuration of the non-compliances of the charges developed in the Report and that the sanctions to be imposed must be two (02) fines corresponding to the level of minor infractions (from one (01) to twenty-five (25) UIT), we do not share regarding the amount of the fines proposed by the IGCC in the present PAS;
- That, from the analysis of the Sanction Criteria detailed in the previous recitals and the evaluation carried out by this Deputy Superintendency developed and exposed in this Resolution, it has been possible to determine the responsibility of the Issuer for not communicating as material events the start dates of the audit work for fiscal years 2019 and 2020; and having verified that in the present PAS as a result of the non-communication of the information subject of the Charge Letter a serious affectation has been produced to the legal interests protected by the securities market rules (market transparency, investor protection, public interest, confidence of market participants), it has been determined that it corresponds to impose on the Issuer a fine of ten (10) UIT for each infraction committed. In that sense, it corresponds to sanction the Issuer with a total fine of twenty (20) UIT[15][16] equivalent to S/ 85,000.00 (Eighty-Five Thousand and 00/100 Soles);
ON THE NEED TO ISSUE A CORRECTIVE MEASURE
- That, in the evaluation of the present PAS it has been determined that the serious infractions committed by the Issuer, referring to the fact that it did not comply with communicating, as material events, the start of the activities of its audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020, has generated harm to the public interest, to information transparency and to investor protection, as indicated in this Resolution;
- That, it is the duty of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV to do what is necessary so that the market knows the consequences that have been generated for the Issuer regarding the infraction in which it has incurred. Thus, it corresponds to the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV to apply a measure that prevents more time from passing without the market knowing the consequences that have been generated for the Issuer. This with the purpose of respecting the principle of opportunity. In addition, it corresponds to reinforce information transparency and investor protection, which are two (02) of the fundamental principles of the securities market that the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV must safeguard;
- That, it must be reiterated that the present PAS refers to the fact that the Issuer did not comply with communicating, as material events, the start of the activities of its audit firm regarding fiscal years 2019 and 2020; therefore, in merit to what is exposed in this Resolution, it is necessary and timely for the market to know about the result of the evaluation of said infractions, even if it is the pronouncement of the first administrative instance of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV;
- That, in that line of reasoning, having determined in the present PAS that the Issuer has affected the information transparency of the securities market and the protection of its investors, it is necessary to issue an administrative measure, in addition to the imposition of a sanction for the determined infraction. Said additional measure must have the purpose of correcting, repairing or trying to repair the altered situation, so it corresponds to issue a corrective measure;
- That, in accordance with article 1 of both the LOSMV and the LMV, it is the purpose and duty of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV «to ensure the adequate protection of investors». Thus, article 1 of the LOSMV provides:
«Article 1. Definition, purpose and functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV)
The Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) is a specialized technical body attached to the Ministry of Economy and Finance whose purpose is to ensure the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through regulation, supervision and promotion. It has legal personality under internal public law and enjoys functional, administrative, economic, technical and budgetary autonomy, constituting a budget pliego. Its operation is governed in accordance with the provisions contained in this Law and its organization and functions regulations. The functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) are the following: (…)» (Underlining and emphasis added)
- That, in article 1 of the LMV it is established:
«Article 1.- Purpose and Scope of the Law.- The purpose of this law is to promote the orderly development and transparency of the securities market, as well as the adequate protection of the investor.
The public offerings of securities and their issuers, the publicly offered securities, the brokerage agents, the stock exchanges, the securities clearing and settlement institutions, the securitization companies, the mutual funds of investment in securities, the investment funds and, in general, the other participants in the securities market, as well as the supervision and control body, are included in this law. Unless expressly mentioned otherwise, its provisions do not reach private offerings of securities. (…)»
- That, regarding the function and responsibility of the SMV, it is necessary to take into account that article 7 of the LMV provides:
«Article 7.- Control and Supervision.
The National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is the public institution entrusted with the supervision and control of compliance with this law. (…)» (Underlining and emphasis added).
- That, regarding the power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV to issue corrective measures, the provisions of article 358 of the LMV are available:
«Article 358.- Precautionary, provisional and corrective measures
CONASEV is empowered to issue precautionary, provisional and corrective measures with respect to natural or legal persons under its competence, regardless of whether or not a sanctioning procedure has been initiated. (…)» (Underlining and emphasis added).
- That, regarding the definition or scope of corrective measures, the provisions of article 19 of the Sanctions Regulation are available:
«Article 19.- DEFINITION.- Corrective measures are those mandates aimed at restoring, reversing, repairing, or restituting that situation altered by the non-compliance with the regulations under the supervision of the SMV. These measures can be issued prior to the initiation of an administrative sanctioning procedure or at the time of the determination of administrative responsibility.
Corrective measures can consist of obligations to give, do and not do, and must establish in a precise and indubitable manner the task in charge of the administered, identifying those obligated to comply. Corrective measures must be issued by a duly motivated decision and observing the principles of Proportionality and Reasonableness.» (Underlining and emphasis added).
- That, likewise, regarding corrective measures, it is necessary to refer to the provisions of article 251 of the TUO of the LPAG:
«Article 251. -Determination of responsibility
251.1 The administrative sanctions imposed on the administered are compatible with the issuance of corrective measures conducive to ordering the restoration or reparation of the situation altered by the infraction to its previous state, including that of the affected goods, as well as with compensation for damages and losses caused, which are determined in the corresponding judicial process. Corrective measures must be previously typified, be reasonable and adjust to the intensity, proportionality and needs of the protected legal interests that are intended to be guaranteed in each specific case. (…)» (Underlining and emphasis added).
- That, regarding the typification of corrective measures in Annex XX of the Sanctions Regulation, it is established:
«ANNEX XX
On Corrective Measures
In accordance with the provisions of article 21 of the Regulation, the SMV, when determining administrative responsibility, may issue the following corrective measures:
(…)
2) The presentation as a material event of the information determined by the SMV.»
- That, regarding the competence or power of the SASCM to issue corrective measures, in numeral 12 of article 43 of the ROF-SMV it is established:
«ARTICLE 43.- The specific functions of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision are:
(…)
12. Issue, modify or revoke, precautionary, corrective and/or provisional measures, ex officio or at the request of a party, in cases submitted to its knowledge; (…)». (Underlining and emphasis added).
- That, in accordance with the previous article, regarding the competence or power of the SASCM to issue corrective measures, numeral 13 of article 43 of the ROF-SMV establishes the following:
«ARTICLE 43.- The specific functions of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision are:
(…)
13. In the scope of its competence, impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control corresponds to the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, with the exception of infractions to the rules on the opportunity in the presentation of periodic or eventual information. The respective sanction resolution may order the application of corrective measures tending to reverse the situation altered by the commission of the infraction; (…)» (Underlining and emphasis added)
- That, therefore, based on the above, and in observance of the principles of proportionality and reasonableness, the purpose of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV and of the LMV to ensure the adequate protection of investors must be complied with. Considering this, for transparency, it is necessary that the market knows in a timely manner (principle of opportunity) about the consequences and responsibilities that have been generated for the Issuer developed in this Resolution;
- That, in that sense, based on what is exposed in this Resolution, it corresponds to issue the corrective measure consisting of ordering the Issuer to proceed to disseminate through the channel of material events, this Resolution, as it is relevant information that must be known by the securities market, considering the principles of information transparency and investor protection; within the term of five (05) business days, counted from the day following the notification of this Resolution;
- That, the IGSC, being the body of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV that has the function of supervising the material events and other information that Issuers must disseminate in the securities market, in accordance with the provisions of article 45[17] and numerals 17 and 43 of article 46[18] of the ROF-SMV, is the one that must verify compliance with what is ordered to the Issuer;
- That, upon the expiration of the term indicated in the recital prior to the previous one, the IGSC will verify the observance of the corrective measure issued. In the event of non-compliance by the Issuer, based on the provisions of article 27 of the Material Events Regulation, the IGSC of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, will formulate a requirement to the Issuer indicating that if it does not proceed with the dissemination of this Resolution, through the channel of material events, on the business day of having notified its requirement, it will proceed to disseminate it on the following business day through the channel of material events;
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 12, 13 and 36 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A. has incurred in two (02) infractions of a serious nature typified in subsection 2.10 of numeral 2 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for not communicating as material events the start dates of the activities of its audit firm for fiscal years 2019 and 2020.
- Sanction Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A. with a fine of 20 UIT equivalent to S/ 85,000.00 (Eighty-Five Thousand and 00/100 Soles).
- Issue as a corrective measure that Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A., in accordance with article 21 and numeral 2 of Annex XX «On Corrective Measures» of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, disseminate through the channel of material events, this Resolution within the term of five (05) business days, counted from the day following the notification of this Resolution.
- Order that the General Intendancy of Conduct Supervision of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV verify or execute the dissemination ordered in article 3 of this Resolution, in accordance with what is indicated in its recitals, and that in accordance with the exercise of its competences and bearing in mind the applicable regulatory framework, inform the competent body of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, about the compliance with the corrective measure issued.
- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and it may be challenged before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration or appeal, administrative remedies recognized in article 218 of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, within the term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a double administrative instance procedure. In case this Resolution is not challenged, it may avail itself of the corresponding sanction reduction regime.
- In case this Resolution is not subject to challenge, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe), in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on Dissemination of Regulatory Projects, General Legal Norms, Regulatory Agenda and Other Administrative Acts of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01, and by the provisions of the last paragraph of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe this Resolution to Corporación Aceros Arequipa S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision
-
In article 245 of the TUO of the LPAG, the following are indicated as forms or modes in which the inspection activity could be concluded: 1) Constancy of conformity of the activity developed by the administered; 2) Recommendation of improvements or corrections of the activity developed by the administered; 3) The warning of the existence of non-compliances not susceptible to merit the determination of administrative responsibilities; 4) The recommendation of the initiation of a procedure in order to determine the corresponding administrative responsibilities; 5) The adoption of corrective measures and 6) Other forms as established by special laws. ↑
-
«Article 9.- PRELIMINARY INQUIRIES AS A CONSEQUENCE OF SUPERVISION ACTIONS
(…)
When said bodies conclude that there are sufficient indications of possible administrative infractions, they send the corresponding reports to the General Intendancies of Compliance, which determine whether or not to initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure. If applicable, the General Intendancies of Compliance may carry out additional inspections or investigations of the reported indications.
(…)». ↑
-
File No. 2019022131.
Web link: https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={10D60A6B-0000-CC17-B5D8-2431A303D5EA}
File No. 2020025142.
Web link:
https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={606E7E73-0000-CA19-B862-868F20856406} ↑
-
Article 1 of the Material Events Regulation provides the following:
«Article 1.- Purpose
Establish the regime of communication and disclosure of material events and reserved information that obligated persons must observe in accordance with the Securities Market Law and its regulatory norms, in order to protect investors and promote efficient and transparent markets.» ↑
-
File No. 2019022131.
Web link: https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={10D60A6B-0000-CC17-B5D8-2431A303D5EA} ↑
-
File No. 2020025142.
Web link: https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={606E7E73-0000-CA19-B862-868F20856406} ↑
-
File No. 2020025130.
Web link: https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={00457E73-0000-CF1C-8361-E472F4680903} ↑
8. Files Nos. 2020021714, 2020023317 and 2021011206. ↑
9. See: OECD/G20 Principles of Corporate Governance, OECD Editions, Paris. Available at web link: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264259171-es ↑
10. The underlines are added. ↑
11. «Article 25.- SANCTION CRITERIA
*(…)*
*When, from the evaluation of the aforementioned criteria, it is noted that there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the facts imputed, by exception and by reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided for may be imposed.»* [↑](#footnote-ref-11)
12. File No. 2020025130.
Web link: [https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc={00457E73-0000-CF1C-8361-E472F4680903}](https://www.smv.gob.pe/ConsultasP8/documento.aspx?vidDoc=%7b00457E73-0000-CF1C-8361-E472F4680903%7d) [↑](#footnote-ref-12)
13. «Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
*The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following principles: (…)*
***3. Reasonableness.-*** *The authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed rules or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, observing the following criteria that are indicated for the purposes of their graduation:*
*The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;*
*The probability of detection of the infraction;*
*The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right;*
*The economic harm caused;*
*Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the date on which the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final;*
*The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and,*
*The existence or not of intent in the conduct of the offender...»* [↑](#footnote-ref-13)
14. In this regard, it should be noted that in recital 49 of Superintendency Resolution No. 083-2021-SMV/02 of August 24, 2021 (File No. 2018044191), which is a resolution of second and final administrative instance, it is stated: «49. That, although the instructing body may make recommendations on the graduality of the sanction to be imposed, it is the sanctioning body that ultimately weighs the facts that constitute the alleged infractions, qualifies them and graduates them, according to the assessment made, and the recommendation of the instructing body cannot be considered binding on the sanctioning body» ↑
15. Value of the UIT (2019): S/ 4,200 (Supreme Decree No. 298-2018-EF). ↑
16. Value of the UIT (2020): S/ 4,300 (Supreme Decree No. 380-2019-EF). ↑
17. «Article 45.- The General Intendancy of Conduct Supervision depends hierarchically and functionally on the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, and has under its supervision scope the entities mentioned in article 42 of this Regulation, with respect to which it has competence for their supervision, evaluation and for the granting of authorizations and registrations, except those reserved to other bodies, as well as for the detection and investigation of practices and conducts that undermine the integrity or transparency of the markets.
*Likewise, this organic unit is competent for the supervision of public offerings and the information submitted by issuers, as well as with respect to actions linked to the registrations and exclusions of securities and programs in the Public Registry of the Securities Market and, if applicable, their registration in the centralized negotiation mechanism. Such attributions are not exercised with respect to those entities under the competence of the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision ».* (Underline and emphasis added). [↑](#footnote-ref-17)
18. «Article 46.- The specific functions of the General Intendancy of Conduct Supervision are:
*(…)*
*17.* *Conduct and carry out the supervision and monitoring of the entities under its competence with a risk-based approach;*
*(…)*
*43.* ***Others that are delegated or entrusted*** *to it by the Superintendent, the Board of Directors, the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision or are assigned to it by substantive legislation.»* [↑](#footnote-ref-18)