SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 017-2015-SMV/10
Summary: Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of three (03) UIT amounting to S/. 10,950.00 (Ten Thousand Nine Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for having incurred one (01) very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7, one (01) serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.16 numeral 2, and one (01) minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, for keeping in the position of Internal Control Officer an officer who simultaneously also held the position of Legal Advisor (Assistant); for not having the Internal Control System Manual include a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market; and for not reporting a relevant event within the established deadline, respectively.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2015007549 |
| | |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2015007549, Report No. 382-2015-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, the defenses and arguments presented by Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By Official Letter No. 3148-2012-EF/10.2, an inspection visit was ordered to Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., hereinafter Coril Sab, in order to verify compliance with the regulations applicable to the development of its functions related to securities intermediation;
- Said inspection began on August 14, 2012, and ended on September 17, 2012, with the respective "Inspection Completion Record" (hereinafter the Record) being signed on that date;
- By Report No. 128-2014-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision, hereinafter IGSE, forwarded the results of the evaluation of the indications of infraction of Coril Sab;
- By Official Letter No. 969-2015-SMV/10.3, the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, hereinafter IGCP, initiated a sanctioning procedure against Coril Sab, imputing charges for: i) Keeping Ms. Sandra Fiorella Castro Salcedo, hereinafter Ms. Castro, in the position of Internal Control Officer (hereinafter FCI), from October 1, 2010, to February 14, 2014, notwithstanding that the aforementioned officer simultaneously during that period also held the position of Legal Advisor (or Assistant) of the company; ii) Not having a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market in the company's Internal Control System Manual; iii) Not reporting as a relevant event the granting of guarantees in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.[1] on February 23, 2012;
- Coril Sab presented its defenses to Official Letter No. 969-2015-SMV/10.3 on March 16, 2015;
- The charges formulated against Coril Sab and the defenses presented by the latter have been evaluated in Report No. 382-2015-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, subparagraph 2, of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law and its amendments, hereinafter LPAG, by Official Letter No. 1717-2015-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 382-2015-SMV/10.3 was made available to Coril Sab for its review;
- On May 19, 2015, Coril SAB presented additional arguments;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Coril Sab incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, hereinafter Sanctions Regulation, for keeping Ms. Castro in the position of Internal Control Officer from October 1, 2010, to February 14, 2014, notwithstanding that the aforementioned officer simultaneously during that period also held the position of Legal Advisor (or Assistant) of the company;
- Whether Coril Sab incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not having in the company's Internal Control System Manual a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market;
- Whether Coril Sab incurred or not an infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not reporting as a relevant event the granting of guarantees in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A.;
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on Coril Sab for the aforementioned;
III. Analysis
3.1 Applicable Regulations
- Article 58, numeral 58.2 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, hereinafter RAI, establishes that the Internal Control Officer must perform his functions on an exclusive dedication basis, that is, he may not perform another function whose nature differs from the activities of control or monitoring of the internal control system of the intermediation agent;
- On the other hand, according to Article 37, numeral 37.4, subparagraph 37.4.3 of the RAI, it is established that in case of negotiation of securities abroad, the Internal Control System Manual of the intermediation agent must have a separate specific section describing the procedures, mechanisms, and control activities corresponding to this type of operations;
- Furthermore, Article 98 of the RAI establishes that intermediation agents must inform CONASEV of their relevant events within the following business day of the adoption of the agreement or decision, of the occurrence of the fact or act, or of having become aware of it, as appropriate. Likewise, it states that the situations detailed in Annex 9, which occur in relation to a given intermediation agent or its economic group, constitute relevant events that the intermediation agent must communicate to the SMV, with sufficient detail and documentation; without prejudice that by their nature other situations not listed in said Annex also have such qualification and must be reported to the SMV;
- In this regard, Annex 9, numeral 8 of the RAI expressly states that it constitutes a relevant event the "granting and obtaining of guarantees, indicating in each case the holder of the guaranteed credit, the guaranteed credit, the amount and type of the guarantee and other conditions agreed. Likewise, the execution of said guarantees as well as the reasons and amounts of the execution;"
- Charges
- By Official Letter No. 969-2015-SMV/10.3, the following charges were imputed to Coril Sab:
- Keeping Ms. Castro in the position of FCI from October 1, 2010, to February 14, 2014, notwithstanding that the aforementioned officer simultaneously during that period also held the position of Legal Advisor (or Assistant) of the company, whereby Coril Sab would not have complied with the provisions of Article 58, numeral 58.2 of the RAI, thus incurring a very serious infraction referred to in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, hereinafter Sanctions Regulation: "Maintaining directly or indirectly persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, not observing that they comply with the requirements established in current regulations, or allowing or facilitating them to develop activities related to those of the intermediation agent;"
- Not having the Internal Control System Manual of Coril Sab, in force at the date of the inspection, a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market, whereby it would have infringed the provisions of Article 37, numeral 37.4, subparagraph 37.4.3 of the RAI, consequently, it would have incurred the infraction classified as serious referred to in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulation: "Not having manuals, procedures, policies, or internal control systems, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with their provisions or not supervising their compliance;"
- Not reporting a relevant event within the deadline established in the regulations, whereby it would have breached the provisions of Article 98 of the RAI and would have incurred the infraction classified as minor according to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation: "Not communicating relevant events, or not doing so within the deadline established by the regulations;"
3.3 Defenses of the Administered Entity and Their Evaluation
3.3.1 Regarding the Internal Control Officer
- Coril Sab states that, for the reasons detailed below, Ms. Castro performed the position of FCI exclusively;
- It should not be confused that Ms. Castro is a professional Lawyer by training, however the position she held was FCI, as has been evidenced in the reports communicated quarterly to the Superintendency of the Securities Market, hereinafter SMV. It specifies that its legal advisors since 2011 have been the law firm Muñiz, Ramírez, Perez – Taiman and Olaya Abogados, which handle its legal consultations;
- It mentions that Ms. Castro performed the position of FCI, which was communicated within the term stipulated in the RAI to the SMV, which during the period under review was aware;
- It indicates that due to an involuntary error, the person in charge of Human Resources had not updated in the system the new position of Ms. Castro regarding her position, as she actually performed, which is FCI;
- It mentions that the alleged indication of infraction is based on an assumption that refers to persons who have a legal impediment, implying that this could cause a negative effect, but it should be considered that attending support consultations without greater direct responsibility because she is a lawyer by profession does not mean that it was part of her functions within the company, since her designation and assignment is FCI, likewise Article 56 of the RAI mentions that control activities fall on the FCI who, together with the board of directors and the general manager of the intermediation agent, ensure compliance with the control system and the evaluation of the internal control system of the intermediation agent, it being understood that the internal control system of the company was well safeguarded by different organs of the company;
- It adds that its current FCI performs its functions as prescribed by the RAI and also complies with the necessary experience in auditing and regulatory compliance;
Evaluation of the defense
1. According to the provisions of numeral 58.2 of Article 58 of the RAI, the FCI must perform its functions on an exclusive dedication basis and may only dedicate itself to control or monitoring activities of the control system;
2. In the case analyzed, by letter of October 4, 2010, Coril Sab communicated to the SMV as a relevant event that Ms. Castro assumed the position of FCI from October 1, 2010, replacing the previous FCI. Subsequently, by letter of February 14, 2014, Coril Sab communicated to the SMV as a relevant event the end of the employment relationship of Ms. Castro. Likewise, Ms. Castro appears in the Personnel List of Coril Sab updated to August 2012 with the position of Legal Advisor and not as FCI;
3. Likewise, by letter of September 24, 2010, Coril Sab communicated as a relevant event that Ms. Castro had the position of Assistant since August 26, 2010. Subsequently, by letter dated February 19, 2014, Coril Sab communicated to the SMV as a relevant event that Ms. Castro left the position of Assistant on that date. Therefore, according to Coril Sab, Ms. Castro performed the position of Assistant from August 26, 2010, to February 19, 2014;
4. Consequently, taking into account the Personnel List of Coril Sab updated to August 2012, according to which the position held by Ms. Castro was Legal Advisor, as well as the letter of September 24, 2010, communicating as a relevant event that Ms. Castro worked as Assistant, the arguments of Coril Sab that attempt to sustain that Ms. Castro performed the position of FCI exclusively during the period from October 1, 2010, to February 14, 2014, have been disproven. Additionally, it should be mentioned that Coril Sab in its defenses recognizes that Ms. Castro attended support consultations because she is a lawyer by profession;
5. Additionally, it should be noted that even if it were an involuntary error of the Human Resources area of the intermediary not having updated the position of Ms. Castro, as stated in the defenses; the general management of Coril Sab, through relevant events, indicated the beginning and end of the employment relationship of Ms. Castro as Assistant, and in other relevant events communicates the beginning and end of the employment relationship as FCI, whereby it is evident from Coril Sab's own communications to the SMV that Ms. Castro held two positions in the agent company; as observed in the graph presented below;
1. On the other hand, it should be indicated that the information sent to the SMV as relevant events has the consequence that the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV) File is modified and updated according to the information reported by the intermediation agents; information that in turn is available to the market through the SMV Portal (www.smv.gob.pe); it being considered that according to Article 13 of the Securities Market Law, the RPMV has the purpose of making available to the public the necessary information for investors' decision-making and achieving market transparency; the stockbrokers being responsible for the veracity of said information. In this sense, it is not attributable to an involuntary error on the part of Coril SAB information that once sent to the RPMV has the quality of true and was made available to the market on more than one occasion;
2. Regarding what was stated by Coril Sab that the type of infraction in which it would have incurred refers to persons who have a legal impediment, implying that this could cause a negative effect, whereby attending support consultations without greater direct responsibility because she is a lawyer by profession does not mean that it was part of her functions within the company, since her designation and assignment is FCI, it should be indicated that numeral 58.2 of Article 58 of the RAI is clear in stating that the FCI cannot perform another function whose nature differs from the activities of control or monitoring of the internal control system of the intermediation agent; that is, it cannot perform other types of activities and therefore cannot hold another position as legal advisor and attend legal consultations as Coril Sab has acknowledged in its defenses;
3. Likewise, it should be noted, as has been evidenced from the relevant events mentioned above, that Coril Sab has communicated that Ms. Castro held two positions, Assistant and FCI, and also appeared in the Personnel List of Coril Sab updated to August 2012 in the position of Legal Advisor;
4. Therefore, it is evident that Ms. Castro as FCI of Coril Sab from October 1, 2010, to February 14, 2014, did not perform her functions on an exclusive dedication basis, whereby she would have contravened the provisions of numeral 58.2 of Article 58 of the RAI;
5. Consequently, Coril Sab has not disproven the imputed charge and therefore infringed the provisions of subparagraph 1.7 of numeral 1 of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulation, by not observing that its FCI complies with the requirement established in the regulations referring to its functions being on an exclusive dedication basis;
3.3.2 Regarding the Internal Control Manual
- Coril Sab states that its internal manuals do have a detail regarding securities traded abroad for the following reasons:
- By board minutes dated March 27, 2012, the company's manuals were reviewed months before the inspection in order to evaluate the inclusion of greater aspects and create improvements to the internal control system;
- It specifies that after the inspection, the internal control manual was reviewed on March 26, 2013, and the control system corresponding to foreign operations was updated, including the specific section referring to securities traded abroad, which is complemented with the information on foreign operations found in the operating procedures manual, which details the procedure and those responsible for it;
- The FCI has the function of verifying that: i) The persons in charge of operations comply with the requirements and procedures stipulated in the internal manuals, this activity is complemented with the regulations applicable to intermediation agents and other norms that regulate the securities market, and ii) The procedures are complied with, according to its control activities established in its annual work plan and others established in the internal control manual. It specifies that the FCI reports its activities quarterly to the Board of Directors of Coril SAB and periodically attends to requests or requirements of the SMV. It also indicates that the activities for which the FCI is designated are for the control of the company and its control function was complemented by including the supervision of compliance with the operating procedures manual and its internal control manual;
- Likewise, it states that at the date of inspection, the Operating Procedures Manual did contain a detailed procedure on foreign operations, which is complemented by the control function of the internal control manual and the client policy that has precisions on supervision and detail on negotiation; it adds that to date there has been no type of claim referring to operations with securities or negotiated abroad by third parties or clients;
Evaluation of the defense
- Regarding what was stated by Coril Sab that at the date of inspection, the Operating Procedures Manual did contain a detailed procedure on foreign operations, it should be noted that the charge imputed to Coril Sab is for not having the separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market in the Internal Control System Manual and not in the Operating Procedures Manual, whereby what Coril Sab stated in this regard is irrelevant;
- Regarding what was indicated by Coril Sab that after the inspection, the Internal Control System Manual was reviewed on March 26, 2013, and the control system corresponding to foreign operations was updated, including the specific section referring to foreign operations, to the extent that this aspect could imply a voluntary correction of the infraction, it corresponds to evaluate it at the time of determining the sanction; however, this does not negate the fact that at the time of the inspection, Coril Sab did not have the separate specific section in question, which is particularly important considering that between August 2012 (start of inspection) and March 2013 (update of the manual according to Coril SAB), the monthly amount negotiated by the intermediary in the foreign market represented on average 20% of the total negotiated by it, as observed in the table and graph presented below;
Coril SAB: Share of Amounts Negotiated by Negotiation Segment – August 2012 to March 2013
- Consequently, Coril Sab infringed the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulation by not having its Internal Control System Manual, in force at the time of the inspection, include a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market;
3.3.3 Regarding the communication of relevant event
- Coril Sab mentions that the granting of guarantees (letters of guarantee) in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A., after the prior analysis carried out, were not considered as "relevant events" to the extent that according to Article 97 of the RAI, relevant events are those situations, acts, facts, decisions, agreements, or contingencies that affect or may affect the intermediation agent; under that premise, it should be considered that Coril Sab, after the analysis of a relevant event, takes into consideration a prior analysis in order to communicate the events within the company to the SMV, the corresponding events that qualify as relevant;
- It should be noted that Coril Sab also mentions that the Royal Spanish Academy defines as "relevant" those facts that are outstanding, prominent, important, and/or significant, whereby it can be summarized that the qualification as "relevant event" is that truly significant event that could bring some implication or consequence to the intermediation agent, related third parties, clients, or the market; in the present case, not communicating letters of guarantee issued with the intermediation agent's own funds does not imply that it generates any direct damage to third parties or an effect on the financial situation of the intermediation agent that generates damage;
- It mentions that the FCI in force at the time of the inspection was in charge of monitoring and at the same time coordinating with the general manager of the company what type of legal facts qualify as relevant;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that item 8 of Annex 9 of the RAI clearly and expressly establishes that the granting and obtaining of guarantees by an intermediation agent are relevant events, so the granting of said guarantees should have been communicated to the SMV on the day following their granting;
- Likewise, Article 98 of the RAI in its last paragraph expressly indicates that the situations detailed in Annex 9 of the RAI that occur in relation to a given intermediation agent or its economic group constitute relevant events;
- In this sense, considering the exposed regulations, Coril Sab's argument that in this case it was necessary to carry out a prior analysis to determine whether or not we are facing a relevant event is without purpose, since it is evident that by the express text of the rule, the granting of letters of guarantee in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. constitutes a relevant event that should have been communicated by Coril Sab to the SMV within the respective term;
Defense 2
- Likewise, Coril Sab argues that it did not consider the granting of guarantees as a relevant event, given that the information is always available to the SMV when required, since Coril Sab has these guarantees recorded in its accounting and additionally they are made known to the external audit and other related parties, as well as in each period of presentation of financial information according to the RAI;
Evaluation of the defense
- On this matter, it should be indicated that the fact that the information regarding the granting of the guarantees, subject of analysis, because Coril Sab is an entity supervised by the SMV, is available to this Institution, does not mean in any way that such circumstance can exempt Coril Sab from complying with its obligations related to the communication of relevant events;
Defense 3
- On the other hand, Coril Sab reaffirms its position that it had no intentionality or motivation to not communicate said guarantees, since within the internal analysis carried out and in accordance with the RAI and the Securities Market Law, hereinafter LMV, the guarantees granted are guarantees that do not generate a direct disbursement or an unjustified disposal of the agent's own funds, but rather are basically a guarantee granted through a bank that, making a comparison of amount, does not become relevant or generate a direct impact on the financial stability of Coril Sab, its clients, or the market;
Evaluation of the defense
- In this regard, it should be noted that in this case, it is meaningless to analyze the legal nature of the guarantees granted by Coril SAB, or whether they can generate an impact on its clients, the market, or the stock brokerage firm itself, in order to determine whether or not they constitute relevant events, since the current regulations, that is, item 8 of Annex 9 of the RAI, is clear in providing, without any distinction, that the granting and obtaining of guarantees by an intermediation agent qualify as relevant events;
Defense 4
- Likewise, Coril SAB indicates that given the provisions of Annex 9 of the RAI, which sets out some illustrative assumptions to consider an amount as relevant according to its value, since item 8 of the mentioned annex does not mention whether an amount exceeds or not, it is considered a relevant event, it mentions that in items 1, 2, 3 and 4 of Annex 9 a numerical reference is established to consider an event as relevant, from which it can be seen why they are really important, and also specifies that the guarantees granted by Coril SAB were not of a relevant amount that could bring a direct impact on the company; likewise, these amounts compared with the other illustrative assumptions as relevant events do not even come close to the amount in the previous items since together they do not exceed the limits established for other cases;
- Finally, Coril SAB states that making a comparison with other similar events where it is stipulated as a "relevant event", it considers that the guarantees granted do not qualify as events that could cause an impact on the market, its clients, or itself, taking into account the amount and form of the guarantee which, when granted, does not harm the own patrimony of the intermediation agent, as well as the resources and expenses of the issuance were not assumed by Coril SAB;
Evaluation of the defense
- With regard to this argument, it must be specified that the text of item 8 of Annex 9 of the RAI has not set an amount or numerical reference for the granting and obtaining of guarantees to be qualified as a relevant event, nor has it been indicated that the impact they may generate on the market, the clients of the agent company, or itself must be taken into account;
- It should be mentioned that according to Article 97 of the RAI, relevant events must be reported for the purposes of supervision and control carried out by the SMV on intermediation agents, such as control of liquidity and patrimonial solvency of these, and especially those that imply exposure to risks inherent in intermediation activities; without specifying a numerical reference and considering the event as relevant objectively;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in the evaluated case, the letters of guarantee were constituted by Banco Interamericano de Finanzas in favor of the SMV to guarantee the investment funds managed by Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. in support of the commitments made by the participants; however, in this case, for Banco Interamericano de Finanzas the guaranteed party was not the management company but Coril SAB, so in the event that the bank had paid the beneficiary of the letter of guarantee, the financial entity would have charged that amount to Coril SAB to whom it granted the indirect credit in the form of a letter of guarantee, so there was a risk that Coril SAB would cover with its patrimony the amounts of the letters of guarantee totaling One Hundred Thirty Thousand and/or 00/100 United States Dollars (US$ 130,000.00);
- In this sense, it should be noted that as mentioned in previous recitals, for the granting and obtaining of guarantees made by the agent company, the regulation has not established a parameter to consider it relevant, and the intermediation agent must communicate all events in which it directly or indirectly grants a guarantee for the benefit of third parties;
- Therefore, according to item 8 of Annex 9 of the RAI, any granting or obtaining of guarantees, regardless of the amount involved as well as the impact it may generate in the judgment of the stock brokerage firm, must, in any case, be communicated as a relevant event within the term established in the current regulations;
Defense 5
- On the other hand, Coril SAB adds referentially that, likewise, SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01, which approves the Regulation of Material Events, Reserved Information and Other Communications, hereinafter New Regulation of Material Events, has incorporated certain relevant modifications for issuers, defining material event as the act, decision, agreement, fact, ongoing negotiation or information related to the issuer, its securities or its businesses that may influence the decision of a sensible investor to buy, sell or keep a security; or in the price of the issued securities, as well as providing that the issuer shall be the one to consider the significance of the possible material event and that in case of doubt as to whether information qualifies as a material event, the issuer must choose to disclose it;
Evaluation of the defense
- With respect to this argument, it should be noted first that the provisions contained in the New Regulation of Material Events are not applicable to intermediation agents and therefore to CORIL SAB, since said norm governs issuers in accordance with the LMV and its regulatory norms, which are entities with a security or program registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market and that includes Management Companies, understanding by these the Management Companies of Mutual Funds of Investment in Securities, Management Companies of Investment Funds, Securitization Companies and in general any other entity whose authorization to operate has been granted by the SMV to manage autonomous patrimonies that back the issuance of securities;
- Notwithstanding the above, to the extent that the argument presented by Coril SAB attempts in some way to make a comparison between the RAI and the New Regulation of Material Events, it is pertinent to clarify that although the New Regulation of Material Events includes in its Annex an illustrative list of material events, which must be communicated as material events when they have the capacity to significantly influence, however the norm itself establishes that it is not applicable to the specific assumptions contained in the current regulations approved by the SMV, which qualifies certain assumptions as material events;
- This means that also for the New Regulation of Material Events there are assumptions that constitute material events regardless of their qualification as such by the issuer;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the RAI has also established in its Annex 9 a List of Relevant Events, among which is item 8 referring to the granting and obtaining of guarantees, which have been qualified as such by the securities market regulator, who has established parameters in some cases and in others, as in the matter of analysis (granting and obtaining of guarantees), in which it has not considered amount or the impact they may generate to consider them as relevant;
- Additionally, it should be noted, as mentioned in previous recitals, that the granting of these guarantees in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. implied a risk that Coril SAB could assume with its patrimony the payment of the amounts of the letters of guarantee;
- Therefore, by not having Coril SAB communicated as a relevant event within the term established in the current regulations, the granting of two letters of guarantee in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A., it has contravened the provisions of Article 98 of the RAI and incurred in the minor infraction referred to in Annex X, item 3, subitem 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation;
3.3.4 Other defenses
- Coril Sab requests that at the time of analyzing its defenses, the foundations of some of the sanction criteria be examined, which it then exposes:
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, Coril Sab states that the indications of the infractions mentioned in the imputation of charges did not generate any effect on the public interest and/or legal good and that no concrete damage occurred, nor was any investor affected, nor the securities market. It adds that Coril Sab is an intermediary, not an issuer of registered or listed securities, it does not manage funds or patrimonies, so there is no investor that has been seriously harmed, so the existence of caused harm and repercussion in the market has not been proven. It mentions that the provisions of SMV Resolution No. 010-2014/01 should be applied regarding imposing warning sanctions when the market repercussion is minimal;
- As for the economic harm caused, Coril Sab maintains that there is no concrete economic harm and mentions that it must be taken into account that the SMV itself has free access to Coril Sab's information, as well as its external auditors, and all this information is made known to the SMV, so since there is no economic harm, then there is also no seriousness in the damage to the public interest;
- Regarding the sanction background, Coril Sab specifies that it currently has no background of this nature, and concerning the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, Coril Sab states that it never had infractions of the same type, since it is diligent in complying with legal obligations and has external legal advisors to achieve due compliance with the norms. Likewise, about the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, Coril Sab maintains that no analysis has been made on the circumstances detailed in the previous points and indicates that the SMV had full knowledge and access to Coril SAB's information, which demonstrates total transparency in its activities;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, Coril Sab indicates that it never pursued or obtained a benefit, even more considering that the SMV had full access to Coril Sab's information and could take knowledge of the observations only with Office 969-2015-SMV/10.3, and regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, Coril Sab reaffirms that there was no intentionality in not complying with the obligation, as can be verified from the evidence;
- Coril Sab adds that the factual foundations are accredited with the evidence it offers in its defenses[2] and also indicates that it does not agree with the evaluation made in the office of imputation of charges, since it considers it necessary that a reevaluation be carried out applying the principle of reasonableness, whose criteria have been verified in this case and determine the non-ideal qualification of the alleged infractions, since no harm has been generated in the market and much less to any investor or client, so it should be considered that the voluntary correction by Coril Sab is a mitigating factor of responsibility, and the principle of legality must also be applied;
- Likewise, Coril SAB maintains that in the analyzed case the principle of legality must be applied and also mentions that the mitigating factor of responsibility regulated in Article 236 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, hereinafter LPAG, was not applied, in that it corrected without prior notification and neither was Article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation taken into account, in that it could refrain from initiating a sanctioning procedure. It also requests that the provisions of item 5 of Article 230 of the LPAG be taken into account, in the sense that the sanctions in force at the time of committing the infraction are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable;
- Coril SAB also mentions that the principle of reasonableness must be applied to the analyzed case, therefore it disagrees with the basis of the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, since it did not occur and is decisive for the non-imposition of the fine, as well as the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, in the sense that the intention to send the information in a timely manner was not taken into account. Coril SAB also states that for the purposes of determining the sanction, the criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV must be considered;
- Additionally, it specifies that in this case the principle of due procedure must be taken into account, since public entities must apply sanctions subject to the established procedure, respecting the guarantees of due process;
- Finally, Coril SAB highlights that in this case the provisions of Article 31 of the Sanctions Regulation have not been applied, which establishes that the General Compliance Intendancies shall refrain from initiating the respective sanctioning procedure, once they verify that the ordered corrective measures have been fully complied with, and also maintains that the application of the provisions of Article 33 of the referred regulation corresponds, which provides that the General Compliance Intendancies may not initiate a sanctioning procedure when at the time of detecting the infraction it has been reversed or corrected;
Evaluation of the defense
- With respect to what was stated by Coril SAB about the application of the principle of reasonableness regarding the sanction criteria, as well as the principle of legality regarding that the voluntary correction by Coril SAB without prior notification is a mitigating factor of responsibility, the application of item 5 of Article 230 of the LPAG and the criteria established in Article 348 of the LMV, it should be mentioned that these aspects will be subject to evaluation at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed;
- Regarding its invocation of the principle of due procedure, it should be noted that this sanctioning procedure is being processed in accordance with law, granting the administered the rights and guarantees inherent to due procedure, thus complying with the provisions of Article 235 of the LPAG and other regulations applicable to administrative sanctioning procedures. Therefore, this administrative sanctioning procedure has been initiated with the office of imputation of charges (Office No. 969-2015-SMV/10.3) requesting the respective defenses from Coril SAB, which are subject to evaluation by the instructing body (IGCP), which once its evaluation is concluded will formulate a sanction proposal or propose the declaration of non-existence of sanction, which will be elevated to the sanctioning body (Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision) so that it issues its respective pronouncement, so it is concluded that this procedure complies with the principle of due procedure;
- Finally, regarding the defense that corrective measures should have been applied, it should be noted that since in its defenses Coril SAB is not clear in indicating the corrected infraction, we start from the hypothesis that Coril SAB is referring to the alleged infraction committed for not containing the Internal Control System Manual with a separate and specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market, since in its defenses Coril SAB states that after the inspection, the Internal Control System Manual was reviewed on March 26, 2013, updating the control system corresponding to foreign operations;
- Regarding what was stated by Coril SAB in the sense that the provisions of Article 31 of the Sanctions Regulation have not been applied, it should be noted that in this case the IGSE did not issue a corrective measure as indicated in Article 31 of the Sanctions Regulation, so it was not appropriate according to the mentioned article for the IGCP to exercise the faculty of abstention;
- On the other hand, regarding Article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation, it should be mentioned that said article establishes that: "The General Compliance Intendancies may likewise not initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure when at the time of detecting the infraction it has been reversed or corrected, provided that the assumptions established in the preceding Article 32 are also met, which must be communicated to the administered";
- Likewise, Article 32 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date of the commission of the infraction, provides that corrective measures may be applied by the General Supervision Intendancies, as long as it is accredited that various conditions are met, one of which is that the infraction must be classified as minor in the annexes of the Sanctions Regulation;
- In the analyzed case, it has been accredited that, at the date of the inspection, the Internal Control System Manual of Coril SAB did not have the specific separate section corresponding to operations abroad, thus failing to comply with the provisions of subitem 37.4.3 of item 37.4 of Article 37 of the RAI, so the infraction classified as serious referred to in Annex X, item , subitem 2.16 of Annex X of the Sanctions Regulation has been incurred;
- For the above, it is concluded that Coril SAB has not lifted the observations set forth in the office of imputation of charges;
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
- From the foregoing, it has been determined that Coril SAB incurred the following infractions:
- For keeping Miss Castro in the position of FCI from October 1, 2010 to February 14, 2014, even though the aforementioned officer simultaneously during that period also held the position of Legal Advisor (or Assistant) of the company, Coril SAB, thereby contravening the provisions of numeral 58.2 of article 58 of the RAI, thus incurring the very serious infraction referred to in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7 of the Sanctions Regulations: “Maintaining directly or indirectly persons who have any legal or regulatory impediment, failing to observe that they comply with the requirements established in current regulations, or allowing or facilitating them to carry out activities related to those of the brokerage agent”, which is punishable with a fine greater than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT, or suspension of the operating authorization for a period of no less than ten (10) days up to forty-five (45) days or revocation of the operating authorization, according to article 20 of the Sanctions Regulations;
- For Coril SAB's Internal Control System Manual not having a separate specific section corresponding to operations in the foreign market, Coril SAB did not observe the provisions of subparagraph 37.4.3 of numeral 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI, thus incurring the infraction classified as serious referred to in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.16 of the Sanctions Regulations: “Not having manuals, procedures, policies or internal control systems, in accordance with the requirements established in the regulations; or not complying with their provisions or not supervising their compliance”, which is punishable with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT or suspension of the operating authorization for up to twenty (20) days, according to article 21 of the Sanctions Regulations;
- For not communicating the granting of guarantees in favor of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. as a relevant fact within the period established in the regulations, Coril SAB breached the provisions of article 98 of the RAI, thus incurring the infraction classified as minor as provided in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations: “Not communicating relevant facts, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations”, which is punishable with a warning or a fine of no less than one (1) and up to twenty-five (25) UIT, according to article 22 of the Sanctions Regulations;
- In accordance with article 6 of the Sanctions Regulations, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Offender's antecedents; b) Circumstances of the commission of the infraction; c) The harm caused and its repercussion on the market; d) Voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction; e) Offender's contribution to its clarification; f) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; g) Repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; h) The illegally obtained benefit; i) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; j) Voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges; k) Error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- With regard to the offender's antecedents, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulations in force at the time of the commission of the facts, sanctions imposed and that have become final during the three (03) years prior to the date on which the infractions were detected constitute antecedents;
- From the review carried out, under the previously cited article, and considering the provisions of numeral 5 of article 230 of the LPAG, it is concluded that Coril SAB has no record of infractions;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that the infractions subject to evaluation were detected in the inspection carried out on Coril SAB, which ended on September 17, 2012;
- Regarding what was stated by Coril SAB that the SMV had full knowledge and access to Coril SAB's information, which demonstrates total transparency in its activities, it should be indicated that in the case of the non-exclusive dedication of the FCI, the SMV was informed that Miss Castro held the position of Assistant and also that of FCI; however, the fact that it was not observed as an infraction until the moment of the imputation of charges does not exempt Coril SAB from non-compliance with the regulations during the period in which the facts occurred; considering in particular that the information sent by the brokerage firm to the SMV regarding the positions as FCI and as Advisor of Miss Castro was recorded in its Public Registry of the Securities Market file and made available to the general public in order to contribute to decision-making and market transparency. It should be specified that the requirement that the FCI function be performed full-time and with exclusive dedication considers the assigned responsibilities, the number of control and monitoring activities that must be carried out, as well as the reports that must be prepared;
- Additionally, it should be noted that it is the obligation of brokerage firms to prepare their manuals in accordance with the requirements demanded by the regulations, so the fact that the inspection observed that Coril SAB's Internal Control System Manual did not have a specific section for foreign market operations, and that it was regularized by Coril SAB after the inspection, does not exempt it from the infraction of having had for a period of time a manual that does not comply with the specifications established in current regulations; notwithstanding, the regularization will be taken into consideration when imposing the respective sanction;
- With regard to the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the contribution of the offenders to their clarification, it should be indicated that Coril SAB in its defenses acknowledges that Miss Castro, who held the position of FCI during the period from October 1, 2010 to February 14, 2014, attended support queries as she is a lawyer by profession; however, Coril SAB considers that this does not mean that said officer did not fulfill her functions with exclusive dedication. Likewise, regarding the infraction related to the Internal Control System Manual, Coril SAB corrected the infraction subsequently, upon acknowledging the infraction;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it should be noted that it has not been possible to prove that Coril SAB's actions caused damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest or had repercussions on the market;
- Likewise, it should be indicated that the provisions of SMV Resolution No. 010-2014/01, which modifies the Criteria applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for non-compliance with the rules regulating the submission of periodic or eventual information, approved by article 4 of SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01, are not applicable to this case, since said norm establishes the sanction parameters for cases of non-compliance in the timely submission of periodic or eventual information closely linked to the transparency of information and its dissemination to the general public and do not apply extensively to the other cases investigated by the SMV; therefore, it does not govern non-compliances such as those incurred by Coril SAB in this case;
- As for the economic harm caused, it should be mentioned that it has not been possible to evidence that the infraction incurred by Coril SAB caused concrete economic harm to market participants;
- Regarding repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that in the analyzed case it is not observed that this assumption has been configured;
- Concerning the illegally obtained benefit, it should be specified that it has not been proven in this procedure that Coril SAB obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infractions, and regarding what was stated by Coril SAB that it could only become aware of the observations with Office No. 969-2015-SMV/10.3, consideration should be given to what is indicated in recital 66 of this resolution regarding the application of the principle of due procedure, and likewise, it should be noted that regardless of the fact that the SMV as part of its supervisory duties has access to Coril SAB's information, the latter has the obligation to communicate relevant facts, to update its manuals and to observe the requirements that internal control officers must comply with and other provisions of the regulations. Furthermore, it should be mentioned that said arguments are not related to the concept of illegally obtained benefit;
- With regard to the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it should be specified that in the analyzed case intentionality in Coril SAB's conduct has not been demonstrated;
- Additionally, with regard to the evaluation of the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236 A of the LPAG, it should be noted that Coril SAB, regarding the infraction committed for not having the Internal Control System Manual with the separate specific section referring to foreign operations, corrected the observation since after the inspection carried out on the company and before the imputation of charges, it updated the control system including the aforementioned section;
- Likewise, in this case it has not been evidenced that the imputed infractions were generated by error induced by the administration through a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- Although in accordance with the provisions of article 15 of the Sanctions Regulations, in the analyzed case it would correspond to impose on Coril SAB the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction, however, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, specifically the fact that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed by Coril SAB caused economic harm to market participants, nor to the market, and that Coril SAB has no record of sanctions, and in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, as well as the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6, it is possible to impose on Coril SAB a sanction applicable to minor infractions in accordance with article 22 of the Sanctions Regulations;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.7, of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, for having contravened the provisions of numeral 58.2 of article 58 of the Regulations on Brokerage Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Declare that Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.16, of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, for having contravened the provisions of subparagraph 37.4.3 of numeral 37.4 of article 37 of the Regulations on Brokerage Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Declare that Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. has incurred a minor infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14, of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, for having contravened the provisions of article 98 of the Regulations on Brokerage Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Sanction Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. with a fine of three (3) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, equivalent to S/. 10,950.00 (Ten thousand nine hundred fifty and 00/100 Nuevos Soles) for the commission of the infractions referred to in articles 1, 2 and 3 of this resolution.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal before the same, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on Publicity of Regulatory Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10 A of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms.
- Transcribe this resolution to Grupo Coril Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A., to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to CAVALI S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
On February 22, 2012, Coril Sab guaranteed Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. by virtue of two letters of guarantee, one for USD 50,000 and another for USD 80,000, constituted by Banco Interamericano de Finanzas in favor of the SMV to guarantee the commitments assumed by the participants of Grupo Coril Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. ↑
-
Coril Sab presents the following evidentiary means: i) Copy of the minutes of the board meeting of December 16, 2010; ii) Copy of the document signed by the FCI; iii) Copy of the contract with its legal advisors, Estudio Muñiz, Ramírez, Perez - Taiman & Olaya; iv) Copies of invoices paid to Estudio Muñiz, Ramírez, Perez – Taiman & Olaya; v) Copies of the Internal Control Manual of the March 26, 2013 Review and vi) Copy of the specific chapters of Foreign Negotiation of the Operational Procedures Manual.
↑