Enforcement · SMV · 15 May 2018
Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos Mutuos S.A. is sanctioned with two warnings for two serious infractions: failing to timely send a participant the communication detailing the absorption merger of the mutual fund "Scotia Fondo Mixto Balanceado S/. FMIV" into "Scotia Fondo Mixto Balanceado FMIV", and failing to timely send account statements. The first infraction is classified under Annex I, numeral 2, item 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulation; the second under Annex VII, numeral 2, item 2.13.
No. 022-2018-SMV/10
| Lima, May 15, 2018 |
Summary: Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos Mutuos S.A. is sanctioned with two (02) warnings, for having incurred one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, item 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulation; and one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VII, numeral 2, item 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not timely sending the communication detailing the fund merger process, and for not timely sending the account statements, respectively.
| Administered entity | : | Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos Mutuos S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2017032269 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2017032269, Report No. 444-2018-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, and the defenses submitted by Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos Mutuos S.A. (hereinafter, Scotia Fondos); and,
CONSIDERING:
3.1 OF THE COMMUNICATION OF THE DETAIL OF THE FUND MERGER PROCESS
Of the Applicable Regulations
Of the Charge Formulated
Of the Defenses
Evaluation
This analysis must begin by stating that the imputation of the infraction is based on the obligation to communicate information to a participant, which should have been carried out no later than January 22, 2016, referring to the details of the merger by absorption of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund by the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund, which was notified to Mr. Ramírez on January 29, 2016, so Scotia Fondos should not be confused with the other letter, referring to the result of the merger by absorption process of the funds, notified on March 4, 2016, nor is the merger by absorption procedure of the aforementioned funds being questioned;
On the other hand, it should be noted that article 50, second paragraph of the Regulation states that "In case the simplified prospectus, participation regulation or administration contract of the absorbing fund is modified, and in the case of merger by incorporation, the provisions of Article 53 to Article 57 of the Regulation shall apply, as applicable". Thus, the third paragraph of article 55 of the Regulation specifies for such cases that "(…) the line body of the SMV shall require the administering company that, within a period of thirty (30) calendar days counted from the notification of said requirement, publish, at its own expense and cost, in a newspaper of national circulation or on its website, the following: (i) a summary of the modifications to be made; (ii) the effective date of the modifications; and, (iii) the indication that the participant has the right to redeem its shares without being subject to the application of the redemption commission during the period of fifteen (15) days counted from the day following said publication. (…)";
In this sense, it must be noted that article 2 of the Resolution, in accordance with the provisions of article 55, third paragraph of the Regulation, provided that the administering company must publish in the official newspaper El Peruano and another of national circulation, within a period no greater than 30 days counted from the notification of the Resolution, a notice containing the most relevant aspects of the merger, its effective date, and the indication that the participants of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund have the right to redeem their shares without being subject to the application of the redemption commission during the period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following said publication;
Likewise, in accordance with article 55 referred to, article 3 of the Resolution, subject of charges, provided that Scotia Fondos must send to the participants of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund a communication containing the information detailed in the previous recital, no later than the date on which said publication is made (January 22, 2016);
On this matter, it must be specified that the purpose of the provisions of the referred regulatory framework and reflected in article 3 of the Resolution is to grant the participants involved in the funds subject to merger the necessary and timely information to be able to make the decision most convenient to their interests, as well as the right to redeem their shares without being subject to a redemption commission. Thus, the duty contained in the norm is to safeguard the rights of the participants, which implies that the administrators send the communication in question with due diligence; that is, considering the time it may take to make the content of the communication known to the participants;
In this sense, in the present case, article 3 of the Resolution, in accordance with the provisions of article 55 of the Regulation, provided that Scotia Fondos send the communication no later than the date on which said publication is made; however, the administrator only states that "(…) the merger communication letter was sent by Scotia Fondos on January 22, 2016, being signed by the General Manager that same day (…)"; without proving that the sending was effectively carried out on that date;
Based on the above, it follows that the administrator has not complied with proving that it sent the communication subject to charge to the participant in accordance with the deadline established in article 3 of the Resolution, nor therefore that the objective of the same has been met;
On the other hand, regarding the non-observance of the principle of typicity, it must be indicated that the issuance of the Letter of Charges has not violated the mentioned principle. For this, it is necessary to indicate that, as national doctrine rightly points out, some administrative types are not autonomous. This means that incurring in infracting conduct is not evidenced by an exact description of the infraction type, but arises from the conjunction of two norms: the norm that commands or prohibits and the one that indicates that the breach of said mandate constitutes an infraction;
In this regard, and applying it to the specific case, it can be indicated that both assumptions have been met: 1) the norm that commands or prohibits, which is materialized by article 55 of the Regulation and article 3 of the Resolution, which contain a mandate from the SMV, in exercise of its functions; and, 2) the one that warns that its non-compliance is an infraction found in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulation, which establishes as an infraction: "Not complying with what is specifically provided by the SMV, in exercise of its functions";
As can be inferred from the previous recital, the principle of typicity has not been violated, since the mandate contained in article 55 of the Regulation and article 3 of the Resolution, which order clear compliance, can be recognized, whose consequence for non-compliance is perfectly identifiable through the infraction type established in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.11 of the Sanctions Regulation;
Without prejudice to the foregoing, and regarding this point, it must be noted that for the purposes of grading the sanction to be imposed in this case, it will be taken into account that the communication was sent and notified to the address appearing in the framework administration contract of Mutual Funds for Investment in Securities, signed between Mr. Ramirez and Scotia Fondos; said address being the same to which the participant's account statements were sent, and these were received, in most cases, by Mr. Ramirez or a family member, as recorded in the notification charges;
In view of the above, it must be indicated that Scotia Fondos has not disproved the charge imputed in this regard;
3.2 ON THE SENDING OF ACCOUNT STATEMENTS TO MR. RAMÍREZ
On the Applicable Regulations
Article 135[4] of the Regulation provides that it is the obligation of the administering company to send account statements, at least monthly, in the manner indicated by the participant in article 136 of the Regulation and free of charge;
Likewise, article 136, subsection a) of the Regulation establishes as an option for sending account statements, the sending of these to the address indicated in the administration contract[5];
In addition to the above, the fourth clause of the administration contract signed between Mr. Ramírez and Scotia Fondos on July 10, 2007 establishes, among others, the obligation of the administering company to send monthly account statements to the participant;
On the Charge Formulated
According to the above, it has been verified that Scotia Fondos would not have complied with timely notifying Mr. Ramírez of the account statement as of May 31, 2014, because it was notified on July 2, 2014, thus failing to comply with the provisions of the applicable regulations;
In this sense, Scotia Fondos would have incurred an infraction classified as serious, in accordance with the provisions of Annex VII, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction of a serious nature: "Failing to comply with the obligations corresponding to it in accordance with the provisions of the internal regulation or participation regulation of the fund, or in the contracts celebrated on behalf of the fund with the participants and third parties";
On the defenses
Regarding the alleged delay in the sending of account statements, Scotia Fondos states that it has complied with sending to Mr. Ramírez, in his capacity as participant, all corresponding account statements since the date of subscription of shares of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund, except for the account statement of May 31, 2014, which according to the SMV, should have been not only sent but notified by the end of June at the latest, and since it was notified on July 2, 2014, it entails a sanctionable infraction for non-compliance with the Regulation;
Indeed, Scotia Fondos states that although the Contract states that the administering company must send monthly account statements to the participant, Scotia Fondos expresses that it has demonstrated having complied with sending the respective account statements monthly during most of the time, proving this situation with the delivery of the respective charges, which in their great majority have been rejected at the address provided by the participant at the time of notification;
Therefore, according to the administered, the SMV should take into account that the delay of two (02) days in the delivery of the notification of the account statement has not harmed the participant, since the respective Account Statement would have been rejected if it arrived during the month of June 2014;
Additionally, the administering company expresses that the lack of typicity should also be applied in the present situation; it adds that the proportionality of the sanction, since the alleged delay of two (02) business days in the notification of a communication that stems from a contractual relationship does not merit the weight of a "serious" sanction, considering, furthermore, that no harm has been presented to the participant;
Finally, Scotia Fondos states that it must be considered that the participant has not made any update of his address since 2007, having the obligation to update his information upon any change of address. This obligation is regulated in the eighteenth clause of the Contract, which states that "When the information recorded in the Client Data Sheet is modified, the participant must update said information by completing and signing an additional client data sheet to the one originally signed, which will form an integral part of this Framework Contract (…)";
Evaluation
On this matter, it must be indicated that the obligation contained in article 135 of the Regulation is clear when it states that, at least monthly, the administering company must send account statements to the participants;
Likewise, said obligation is reflected in the fourth clause of the Contract when it establishes, among others, that the administering company must send monthly account statements to the participant;
In view of the above, it is corroborated that the obligation to send the account statement monthly is imperative, so within said obligation there is no possibility of a delay of two (02) days, since Scotia Fondos had the following month to send the account statement as of May 31, 2014, of Mr. Ramírez, given that it allows the participant to be informed of the situation of his investments. This is without prejudice to the fact that at the time of notification, the letter may have the status of delivery: "Rejected", as occurs in the present case;
On the other hand, regarding the lack of typicity, it is necessary to specify that the principle of typicity has not been violated, given that we are facing a normative precept that clearly and precisely establishes the conduct that constitutes the infraction, which is materialized in Annex VII, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, since an obligation (to send account statements monthly) established in the fourth clause of the Contract has been breached;
It should be noted that although the participant did not update his address since 2007 and that said obligation is established in the penultimate paragraph of the Contract, this did not exempt the administering company from the obligation to notify the participant monthly of the account statements;
Finally, it is necessary to indicate that the proportionality of the sanction regarding the delay of two (02) business days to notify the account statement as of May 31, 2014, will be analyzed at the time of evaluating the sanction;
Additionally, it must be specified that in his complaint, Mr. Ramírez indicates that only the account statements of the first three months were sent to him, and then the administrator stopped sending them. In this sense, through Official Letter No. 2386-2017-SMV/10.3, Scotia Fondos was requested to provide a copy of the charges proving the delivery of the monthly account statements of the participant, with the administrator sending a copy of the same from May 31, 2014[6] until the close of February 28, 2017; observing that out of the 34 months, only the account statement of May 31, 2014 was not sent timely;
In view of the above, it can be stated that Scotia Fondos has not disproved the charges in this regard;
3.3 Regarding the analysis of Mr. Ramírez's complaint made by Scotia Fondos
Scotia Fondos considers that there is an intention to take advantage of a merger procedure duly authorized by the SMV in 2016, and of the alleged delay of two (02) days in the delivery of the account statement for the month of May 2014;
Scotia Fondos expresses that being this situation notorious, it is up to the SMV to carry out a careful analysis of the particular case, especially of the date on which, according to article 3 of the Resolution, it should have made the sending of the merger communication, distinguishing it from the effective date of notification of the communication, so that in similar cases, participants do not find a regulatory window to not assume the consequences of the risks incurred by an investor with the acquisition of participation shares of certain mutual funds, even more so when Mr. Ramírez has made this complaint alleging that by not having learned of the merger procedure he has been harmed with the loss of his investments, which is false, as the administering company states in the following paragraphs;
In this regard, Scotia Fondos states that the merger procedure has not harmed Mr. Ramírez, since the losses that the participant claims he could have had during the validity of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund were caused by the merger of the funds;
On this matter, the administering company states that considering that the amount of Mr. Ramírez's investment in the Balanceado Soles mutual fund was transferred entirely to the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund, and that an exchange ratio of 0.257163 to 1 was applied, it led to Mr. Ramírez receiving 378.532 shares of the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund on February 15, 2016, for 1,471.9529 shares that he maintained in the Balanceado Soles mutual fund, as a result of the merger of the funds, with an entry share value of US$ 8.197853;
Thus, Scotia Fondos adds that the value of Mr. Ramírez's initial investment in the Balanceado Soles mutual fund made on May 28, 2014, for S/ 14,216.43, amounted due to the change in the share value on the date (February 15, 2016) of the merger by absorption to S/ 10,884.93. That is, the administered has verified a reduction in the value of the investment, with respect to the original value, amounting to S/ 3,331.50. Scotia Fondos states that it is important to mention that said decrease in the value of the investment corresponds to a variation of the share value as a result of market conditions and cannot be attributed to the merger by absorption process of the mutual funds involved;
As a product of the merger, Scotia Fondos indicates that the value of the shares received by Mr. Ramírez in the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund amounted to US$ 3,103.15, which at the exchange rate used for the merger process (3.5077 soles per US$) were equivalent to the amount of S/ 10,884.93. That is, the value in US dollars of the investment that Mr. Ramírez maintained remained as a product of the merger, so this merger process did not generate any loss in the value of his investment;
After the merger process, Mr. Ramírez's investment has remained in the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund, and as of August 8, 2017, it amounts to US$ 3,817.74. That is, Mr. Ramírez has obtained a positive return in the new mutual fund amounting to US$ 714.59;
In comparative terms and in order to prove that no harm has been caused to the participant, the administering company states that the value of the investment in the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund as of August 8, 2017, amounting to US$ 3,817.74, is equivalent to S/ 12,415.29 (at the BCRP exchange rate of 3.2520 Soles per US$). That is, with respect to the value of Mr. Ramírez's investment that at the merger date amounted to S/ 10,884.93, he has obtained a gain amounting to S/ 1,530.36;
In this sense, Scotia Fondos states that Mr. Ramírez has not had any loss as a result of the merger process. Instead, Mr. Ramírez has benefited by obtaining a return amounting to S/ 1,530.36, allowing him to partially reverse the loss that was occurring in the investment of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund, as a result of the reduction in the share value due to market conditions. That being so, Mr. Ramírez's statement that he allegedly "would have lost product" of not having been correctly informed of the merger is false;
Finally, Scotia Fondos states that the communication letter sent to the participants was also reported as a material fact to the Public Registry of the Securities Market, and was also published in two newspapers of national circulation El Peruano and Expreso, so Scotia Fondos complied with the provisions of the Resolution;
Evaluation
Regarding the fact that Scotia Fondos did not timely send the participant the communication of the merger process of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund into the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund, it should be noted that said communication aims to inform the participants of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund about the conditions of the merger process, characteristics of the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund, exchange factor, among others, in a timely and transparent manner;
In this way, with the participants having the relevant information, they have the possibility to make their investment decisions according to their interests and objectives; likewise, if they decide to redeem their shares, they can do so without paying the redemption commission;
However, regarding the loss in the investment mentioned by Mr. Ramírez due to the merger by absorption process of the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund into the Balanceado Soles mutual fund, it has been verified that the participant as of February 12, 2016, was obtaining a loss of S/ 3,331.50, due to the reduction in the share value of the Balanceado Soles mutual fund; considering that on May 28, 2014, Mr. Ramírez subscribed 1,471.9529 shares in the Balanceado Soles mutual fund for S/ 14,216.43, subsequently, as shown in the following table, the share value of said fund decreased to 7.3949 on February 12, 2016, before the merger date that took place on February 15, 2016. It should be noted that Mr. Ramírez indicates in his complaint that his economic damage is approximately S/ 4,000.00; given the above, said result would be linked to the reduction in the share value;
Table No. 1: Evolution of the share value of Balanceado Soles
| Date | Share value | Number of shares | Amount S/ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 05/28/2014 | 9.65821 | 1,471.8529 | 14,216.43 |
| 06/30/2014 | 9.7848 | 1,471.8529 | 14,402.76 |
| 09/30/2014 | 9.7088 | 1,471.8529 | 14,290.90 |
| 12/31/2014 | 9.4856 | 1,471.8529 | 13,962.36 |
| 03/31/2015 | 8.8021 | 1,471.8529 | 12,956.28 |
| 06/30/2015 | 9.1571 | 1,471.8529 | 13,478.82 |
| 09/30/2015 | 9.1288 | 1,471.8529 | 13,437.16 |
| 12/31/2015 | 6.9949 | 1,471.8529 | 10,296.16 |
| 02/12/2016 | 7.3949 | 1,471.8529 | 10,884.94 |
On the other hand, in the exchange process, Mr. Ramírez received 378.5320 shares of the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund equivalent to US$ 3,103.43 (at an exchange rate of 3.5077 in soles equivalent to S/ 10,884.94), this means that after the merger by absorption process, the participant's assets remained, demonstrating that he had no loss as a result of said merger;
Subsequently, after the merger process of the funds, the share value of the Balanceado Dólares mutual fund experienced an increase, as can be seen in the following table:
Table No. 2
| Date | Share Value | No. of Shares | Amount in US$ | Exchange Rate | Amount in Soles | Gain or Loss with respect to 02/13/2018 (S/) | Observation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 02-13-2016 | 8.1978 | 378.532000 | 3,103.13 | 3.5077 | 10,884.86 | Merger | |
| 02-15-2016 | 8.2115 | 378.532000 | 3,108.32 | 3.5030 | 10,888.43 | 3.57 | |
| 03-31-2016 | 9.0654 | 378.532000 | 3,431.55 | 3.3209 | 11,395.84 | 510.98 | Shares according to Account Statement |
| 06-30-2016 | 9.7530 | 378.532000 | 3,691.83 | 3.2890 | 12,142.43 | 1,257.57 | Shares according to Account Statement |
| 09-30-2016 | 10.3584 | 378.532000 | 3,920.97 | 3.3988 | 13,326.60 | 2,441.74 | Shares according to Account Statement |
| 12-31-2016 | 10.2914 | 378.532000 | 3,895.64 | 3.3560 | 13,073.76 | 2,188.90 | Shares according to Account Statement |
| 02-28-2017 | 10.1376 | 378.532000 | 3,837.40 | 3.2631 | 12,521.81 | 1,636.94 | Shares according to Account Statement |
| 03-31-2017 | 10.1319 | 378.532000 | 3,835.24 | 3.2479 | 12,456.49 | 1,571.63 | |
| 04-03-2017 | 10.1406 | 378.532000 | 3,838.53 | 3.2479 | 12,467.17 | 1,582.31 | Complaint of Mr. Ramírez |
| 06-30-2017 | 9.9397 | 378.532000 | 3,762.50 | 3.2522 | 12,236.40 | 1,351.54 | |
| 08-08-2017 | 10.0857 | 378.532000 | 3,817.74 | 3.2432 | 12,381.71 | 1,496.85 | According to Scotia Fondos, Mr. Ramírez maintains his investment |
| 09-30-2017 | 10.4956 | 378.532000 | 3,972.91 | 3.2659 | 12,975.11 | 2,090.25 | |
| 12-31-2017 | 10.9258 | 378.532000 | 4,135.77 | 3.2405 | 13,401.96 | 2,517.09 | |
| 04-24-2018 | 11.2166 | 378.532000 | 4,245.84 | 3.2321 | 13,722.97 | 2,838.11 |
3.4 EVALUATION OF THE MAIN SANCTION CRITERIA CARRIED OUT BY SCOTIA FONDOS
Evaluation
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments.
RESOLVES:
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
"Article 50.- Merger of Mutual Funds.- In the case of merger of mutual funds or their series, the management company that will manage the mutual fund resulting from the merger process must submit to CONASEV a request duly signed by the legal representative of the management company, detailing the following:
Type of merger, which may be by absorption or incorporation.
Details of the merger process;
In the case of merger by absorption, specify whether the simplified prospectus of the absorbing fund will be modified;
Exchange factor;
Treatment of investments that become non-permitted; and,
Other relevant information
(…)" ↑
"Article 3.- Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. must send to the participants of the mutual fund denominated "Scotia Fondo Mixto Balanceado S/. FMIV" a communication containing the information detailed in the previous paragraph, no later than the date on which the referred publication is made." ↑
"Article 2.- Scotia Fondos Sociedad Administradora de Fondos S.A. must publish in the official newspaper El Peruano and another of national circulation, within a period no greater than 30 days counted from the notification of this resolution, a notice containing the most relevant aspects of the merger, its effective date and the indication that the participants of the mutual fund of investment in securities denominated "Scotia Fondo Mixto Balanceado S/. FMIV" have the right to redeem their shares without being subject to the application of the redemption commission during the period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following the referred publication." ↑
"Article 135.- Account Statement.- The management company is obliged to send to the participants the account statements, at least monthly, in the manner indicated by the participant in Article 136 of the Regulation and free of charge. (….)". ↑
"Article 136.- Forms of Sending the Account Statement.- The participant may choose one of the following options for sending the account statements:
Physical delivery to the address indicated in the administration contract. (….)". ↑
On May 28, 2014, Mr. Ramírez made his first subscription on May 28, 2014 of shares of the Balanced Soles mutual fund. ↑
"1.2 Principle of due process.- Administrated persons enjoy all the rights and guarantees inherent to due administrative growth, which includes the right to present arguments, to offer and produce evidence and to obtain a motivated decision founded in law (…)". ↑
Published in the official newspaper El Peruano on December 21, 2016. ↑
"Article 236-A
1.- The following constitute exempting conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The mandatory order of competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) If once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun, the offender acknowledges their responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of its amount.
b) Others established by special norm." ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“...SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation...”
“By Intendancy Resolution No. 133-2015-SMV/10.2 of December 24, 2015 (hereinafter, the Resolution), the merger by absorption... was authorized;”
“...Regulation of Mutual Funds for Investment in Securities and their Management Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 068-2010-EF/94.01.1 and its amendments...”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added