Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV
No. 030-2019-SMV/10
Summary:CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. is sanctioned with a fine of 5 UIT equivalent to S/ 19,750.00 (Nineteen thousand seven hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred in three (03) infractions of a minor nature, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations; and, in one (01) infraction of a serious nature, typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, for not having complied with presenting three (03) material events and the Annual Special Audit Plan within the period established by the regulations, respectively.
Additionally, it is declared that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has incurred, as of the date of the events, in one (01) infraction of a minor nature, typified in Annex I, subparagraph 3, numeral 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations for not having complied with communicating the name of the audit firm in charge of performing the annual external audit work within the period established by the regulations, to which the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation contained in article 257, subparagraph 1, literal f) of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law corresponds to apply and therefore, the archiving of the administrative sanctioning procedure in this regard.
Likewise, it is declared that it is not appropriate to sanction CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C., for two (02) infractions of a minor nature, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, and, consequently, the administrative sanctioning procedure is concluded in this regard.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2018036851 |
| | |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2018036851, Report No. 481-2019-SMV/10.3 issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the defenses presented by CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C.; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
- Facts
- Within the supervision functions assigned to the SMV, a compliance evaluation was carried out by CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. (hereinafter, CA Perú SAB), in the presentation of material events, within the period established in the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, RAI), in the information established in the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and in force as of December 31, 2016 (hereinafter, New RAI), as well as in the presentation of the information required by the Norms for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Financing of Terrorism, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 033-2011-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, PLAFT Norms);
- As a result of said evaluation and under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG), through Official Letters No. 5218-2018-SMV/10.3, notified on September 18, 2018 (File No. 2018036851), No. 6415-2018-SMV/10.3 notified on November 23, 2018 (File No. 2018046054) and No. 1010-2019-SMV/10.3 notified on March 1, 2019 (File No. 2019007710) (hereinafter, Letters of Charges) charges were formulated against CA Perú SAB for infringement of the provisions established in the RAI, New RAI and the PLAFT Norms, in force at the time of the commission of the facts, for not having presented in a timely manner:
- The material event referring to the appointment of Mr. Jorge Abdiel Córdova Barrios (hereinafter, Mr. Córdova) as Internal Control Officer (FCI) made by the Board of Directors through session of November 30, 2016. Said information should have been presented until December 1, 2016; however, it was informed to the SMV on December 14, 2016[1];
- The material event referring to the cessation of functions of Mr. Percy Yamamoto Kamida (hereinafter, Mr. Yamamoto) to the position of Director, by virtue of his resignation letter in which he states that his performance in the position was until November 30, 2016; said letter was presented to the Board of Directors and accepted by it on the same November 30, 2016, according to its session minutes. Said information should have been presented until December 1, 2016; however, it was informed to the SMV on December 14, 2016[2].
- The material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Beta Capital LLC, to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, according to the agreement of the Board of Directors of August 26, 2016. Said material event should have been communicated until August 29, 2016; however, it was informed to the SMV on April 6, 2017[3].
- The material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Lek Securities Corp., to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, according to the agreement of the Board of Directors of August 26, 2016. Said material event should have been communicated until August 29, 2016; however, it was informed to the SMV on April 6, 2017[4].
- The material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Ultralat Capital Market, to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, according to the agreement of the Board of Directors of August 26, 2016. Said material event should have been communicated until August 29, 2016; however, it was informed to the SMV on April 6, 2017[5].
- The name of the audit firm in charge of performing the annual external audit work for the 2018 fiscal year, since said name should have been communicated to the SMV until July 2, 2018, notwithstanding the name of the Audit Firm Gaveglio, Aparicio y Asociados Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada was informed to the SMV on July 3, 2018[6] and subsequently on July 4[7] and 5, 2018[8] it was specified that it would be in charge of the Financial Audit Examination, Compliance Examination and Control System Evaluation Examination.
- The Annual Special Audit Plan of the money laundering and terrorist financing detection system, aimed at improving the internal control system for prevention, corresponding to the 2018 fiscal year. As established in article 32 of the PLAFT Norms, said report should have been presented within the same period for presentation of the Semi-Annual Report of the Compliance Officer corresponding to the second semester of the 2017 fiscal year. It should be added that, as provided in article 29, numerals 29.1 and 29.2 of the PLAFT Norms, CA Perú SAB had as the deadline for presentation of the referred Annual Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, February 15, 2018.
- The non-compliances detailed in literals a, b, c, d and e of the preceding consideration are typified as minor infractions in Annex X, subparagraph 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulations) according to which it constitutes an infraction: “Not communicating material events, or not doing so within the period established by the regulations” [9];
- The non-compliance detailed in literal f. of the third consideration of this resolution is typified as a minor infraction in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6, of the Sanctions Regulations: “Not providing in a timely manner or doing so incompletely, the documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 preceding to which they are obligated by the regulations or by requirement of the SMV or not sending it in accordance with the technical specifications, when applicable”[10];
- Likewise, the non-compliance detailed in literal g. of the third consideration of this resolution is typified as a serious infraction in Annex XIX, subparagraph 2, numeral 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, according to which it constitutes an infraction*: “Not presenting in a timely manner, or doing so without observing the money laundering and terrorist financing prevention regulations, to the SMV or to the UIF-Perú, as the case may be, the respective reports or the Annual Special Audit Plan” [11];*
- On September 27 and December 4, 2018, and on March 13, 2019 CA Perú SAB presented the respective defenses to the charges formulated;
- Through Resolution of the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance No. 004-2019-SMV/10.3 of May 6, 2019, it was resolved to accumulate files No. 2018036851, No. 2018046054 and No. 2019007710; for their joint resolution, which will form File No. 2018036851.
- The charges formulated as well as the defenses presented by CA Perú SAB have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 481-2019-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Report), which has been submitted to the consideration of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in article IV, subparagraph 1, numeral 1.2 of the Preliminary Title, as well as in article 248, numeral 2, of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 2467-2019-SMV/10, the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to CA Perú SAB for its review;
- Issues to be determined
- In this administrative sanctioning procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the material event of November 30, 2016, referring to the appointment of Mr. Córdova as FCI, subject of charges, within the period established in article 98 of the RAI;
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the material event of November 30, 2016, referring to the cessation of functions of Mr. Yamamoto to the position of Director, subject of charges, within the period established in article 98 of the RAI;
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Beta Capital LLC subject of charges, within the period established in article 98 of the RAI.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Lek Securities Corp, subject of charges, within the period established in article 98 of the RAI.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the material event referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Ultralat Capital Market, subject of charges, within the period established in article 98 of the RAI.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having communicated to the SMV the name of the audit firm in charge of performing the annual external audit work for the 2018 fiscal year, in accordance with the period established in article 125 of the New RAI.
- Whether CA Perú SAB incurred or not in infraction by not having presented the Annual Special Audit Plan corresponding to the 2018 fiscal year, subject of charges, within the period established in article 32 of the PLAFT Norms;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on CA Perú SAB;
- Analysis
3.1 Of the Material Events
-
-
- Of the Applicable Regulations
- Regarding material events, article 97 of the RAI[12], establishes the following:
“Article 97.- Definition of Material Events
The situations, acts, facts, decisions, agreements or contingencies that affect or may affect the agent or its economic group are considered material events of the Agent. Likewise, the information of the agent or its economic group, which by its nature it is necessary to inform to CONASEV for supervision and control purposes, has the qualification of material event, unless it is a matter of importance of a company of its economic group, whose information obligation corresponds to the same”.
- Likewise, article 98 of the RAI[13] states in relation to the information obligations of intermediation agents, the following:
“Article 98.- Communication.-
Agents must inform CONASEV of their material events within the following business day of the agreement or decision taken, of the occurrence of the fact or act or of having become aware of it, as applicable, in accordance with the means and forms established by CONASEV.
The General Manager is responsible for timely communicating the material events of the Agent.
The situations detailed in Annex 9, which occur in relation to a given Agent or its economic group, constitute material events that the Agent must communicate to CONASEV, with sufficient detail and documentation; without prejudice that by their nature other situations not listed in said Annex also have such qualification and must be informed to CONASEV”;
- On the other hand, numeral 12[14] and 24[15] of Annex 9 of the RAI indicate as material events:
“ANNEX 9
List of Material Events
(…)
12. Appointment and changes of directors, managers, Internal Control Officers, representatives, officers and legal representatives or attorneys-in-fact, and must present the list of names and positions of the removed or outgoing officers and of the officers appointed in their replacement, as well as the dates of cessation and start of functions, respectively.
(…)
24. Celebration and resolution of contracts with foreign entities to carry out intermediation operations on own account or for third parties”.
- Through Official Letters No. 5218-2018-SMV/10.3 and No. 1010-2019-SMV/10.3 charges were formulated against CA Perú SAB, for not having presented within the period established by the applicable regulations, the material events indicated in literals a, b, c, d and e of the third consideration of this resolution;
-
- Of the defenses presented for the appointment of Mr. Córdova and the cessation of functions of Mr. Yamamoto
- Introduction: Context in which the events developed
- CA Perú SAB indicates that the events subject to imputation consist of the attention to two requests formulated by the SMV in the framework of the inspection initiated on November 14 and concluded on December 2, 2016, so the SMV was perfectly aware of everything, even of its attention through the Board of Directors session of November 30, 2016. In that sense it argues that in the Inspection Finalization Act of December 2, 2016, the following was stated:
“In this regard, CA PERU SAB presented, within the established period, all the information and documentation requested by the inspection commission (…) Additionally, it presented a simple copy of the session of Directors of CA PERU SAB held on 30.11.2016, through which among the approved points of the agenda, the regularization of the two incidents found during the execution stage of this inspection was verified, which were communicated to the general management with the purpose of guaranteeing continuous compliance with the regulations and contributing to the strengthening of the internal control system of CA PERU SAB. Such aspects refer to the formalization of the appointment of the internal control officer (appointment approved by the Universal Shareholders' Meeting of 10/04/2014) and the resignation from the position of director of the current general manager, who also performs the position of representative, documentation that is part of the working papers of this inspection visit” (highlighted by CA Perú SAB).
- CA Perú SAB points out that it considered that such events did not qualify as material events or in the worst case it would be a non-compliance linked to deficient regulation (the definition contained in article 97 and following of the RAI), since they are not events that could affect it and that were also already known by the SMV, so they did not qualify as material events, nor did it correspond that they be communicated as such, likewise, it questions that if the SMV already knows them what purpose would informing them again have;
- It adds furthermore that it is important to differentiate between material events and events of importance, since the former are only brought to the knowledge of the regulator for supervision and control purposes and the latter to the knowledge of the market for the purpose of investment decision-making;
-
- Conclusion of this procedure by application of the principle of opportunity
- CA Perú SAB maintains that it is meaningless to re-inform the ratification of Mr. Córdova as FCI and the resignation of Mr. Yamamoto as director, however, it specifies that in the denied assumption that it had been necessary to inform the SMV again regarding the indicated events, it had already carried out such action on December 14, 2016, with the intention of complying with a formality, long before the notification of the Letter of Charges and that the non-communication as material events has not generated harm or affectation to third parties, to market transparency or to any legal asset;
- Likewise CA Perú SAB questions in what way attending a regularization request made by the SMV could affect it and points out that the objections made by the SMV are not only questionable to the extent that under the RAI the indicated events would not qualify as material events, but that in the denied assumption that they were, such questions would only defend a formal position;
- It adds that the SMV takes as satisfactory the communication made on December 14, 2016, when it was also not made under the form of “Material Event”, however it considers this as valid and not the one made in person and recorded in the Inspection Act, which the SMV possesses.
- In this sense, it requests that the principle of opportunity provided in article 2 of the Criminal Procedure Code be applied in a supplementary and analogical manner, a norm that allows the Administration to discard the initiation of a sanctioning procedure against it, to the extent that there has been no affectation to any person or protected legal asset, there has been no affectation to the public interest, since no negative impact has been generated on the trust and credibility of the securities intermediation system, therefore it requests that this sanctioning procedure be archived and not continued, since the sanctioning regulations of the SMV do not oblige punishing all infractions committed;
b) Situation of concurrence of infractions
- CA Perú SAB states that the provisions of article 15 of the Sanctions Regulations be applied;
-
-
-
- Necessary consideration of the facts and circumstances
- CA Perú SAB points out that the events to which the imputations refer can only be explained in the context of the inspection carried out by the SMV, since it is information that was already known to the SMV;
- Likewise, it indicates that attending to the definition of material event as well as to the purpose of its regulation, it did not consider that the events subject to analysis qualified as material events (they are not susceptible to affecting it and are known by the SMV), nor did it consider that it was necessary to inform the regulator again of something that was already known to it, without prejudice to this, although it was not obligated to do so, it informed what the SMV already knew, without being asked to do so; therefore it requests that its transparent, good faith and collaborative conduct with the SMV be taken into account;
d) Principles of administrative sanctioning law
- CA Perú SAB states that the exercise of the sanctioning power of the Administration is governed by the principles developed in article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, which are the expression in administrative headquarters of the fundamental rights recognized by the Constitutional Court and their non-observance entails the nullity of the sanction imposed;
- Principle of typicity or taxativity of infractions
- In this regard CA Perú SAB points out that said principle is regulated in the Constitution and its application is provided in numeral 4 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and that analogy or extensive interpretation is not allowed;
- In relation to this, it maintains that it is intended to sanction it for having supposedly failed to comply with its obligation to inform material events, which are defined in article 97 of the RAI and that the information that was not informed as a material event consisted of an action to attend a prior request of the SMV as recorded in the Inspection Act;
- Likewise, it highlights that without prejudice to the foregoing, the information in question was the ratification of an FCI that had already been appointed years ago as well as the resignation of the General Manager which did not affect its control situation, to that extent it indicates that it is clear that the information did not qualify as a material event even though its company decided later to inform it again;
- It also mentions that the provisions of article 98 of the RAI can only be interpreted in conjunction with the provisions of article 97. In that sense, it indicates that the situations included in Annex 9 of the RAI must be informed to the extent that they i) would affect the agent and ii) were not known by the SMV, since it is meaningless to inform something that is already known, interpreting in a different way would consist of the use of an extensive interpretation for the purposes of imposing a sanction, which is prohibited according to numeral 4 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG;
- Additionally it points out that article 48 of the TUO of the LPAG prohibits requesting information that is already held and article 66 of the same establishes the right not to present information prohibited from being requested;
- In this sense, CA Perú SAB indicates that the claim to impose a sanction lacks legal basis and if the SMV decided to continue the procedure it would be breaching the principle of typicity and incurring an irremediable vice of nullity;
- Principle of presumption of lawfulness
- CA Perú SAB states that this principle is recognized in numeral 9 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and that it has a constitutional origin; likewise, it maintains that the presumption of innocence has given rise, in criminal law, to the recognition of the principle "in dubio pro reo", that is, that in the face of doubt or insufficiency of evidence, the administered party must always be favored. This concept has been developed by the Constitutional Court. Consequently, the Administration will bear the burden of proof or evidence that proves, without a doubt, the responsibility of the administered party, since if it does not exist or is insufficient for the subjective assessment of the adjudicator, the obligation to deem the conduct of the administered party lawful will prevail;
- In light of this, it points out that the least the Administration could conclude is that there is reasonable doubt as to whether CA Perú SAB had breached its obligation to report relevant facts, which were already fully known to the SMV and which were not capable of generating any affectation, and therefore did not fit the definition of relevant fact in the RAI. Therefore, in application of the aforementioned principle, the matter must be resolved in favor of the administered party and the file must be sent to archive;
- Principle of proportionality
- CA Perú SAB maintains that according to numeral 3 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction. Likewise, it adds that Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that "when there is no proportionality between the sanction to be imposed and the facts imputed, by exception and through a reasoned resolution, a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided for may be imposed" (emphasis by CA Perú SAB);
- It also requests that the SMV take into account that the provisions of the TUO of the LPAG prevail over any administrative approval provision of lower legal rank, so that, in the event the SMV considers that a sanction should be imposed, it must take into account the provisions of the aforementioned numeral 3 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, since it has not obtained any benefit, the infraction is completely detectable, given that the SMV had full knowledge; there is no damage to the public interest or to any protected legal asset; no economic harm has been generated; there is no recidivism or continuity; the facts are linked to the attention of a request made by the regulatory body and were fully known to it, and there is no intentionality to incur infracting conduct;
- Therefore, it states that the SMV must assess the imputed conduct from the prism of proportionality;
- CA Perú SAB argues that this principle is regulated in numeral 10 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG. In this regard, it indicates that it is evident that it lacks intent or negligence in its actions, since the information did not have the quality of a relevant fact;
e) Special consideration given the existence of exonerating circumstances
- Error induced by confusing administrative provision
- Provided in subsection e), numeral 1 of Article 257 of the TUO of the LPAG. On this matter, CA Perú SAB maintains that if the SMV considers that by virtue of the provisions of Article 97 of the RAI, it should have reported the facts as relevant facts, it cannot fail to recognize that the alleged non-compliance would be due to a confusing norm included in Articles 97, 98 and Annex 9 of the RAI, and therefore administrative responsibility cannot be imputed to the company;
- Regulated in subsection f), numeral 1 of Article 257 of the TUO of the LPAG. Regarding this exonerating circumstance, CA Perú SAB indicates that for its application two circumstances must occur: the rectification must occur at any time before the initiation of the administrative sanctioning procedure and must be voluntary. In this sense, it states that in the event it is considered that it should have communicated as relevant facts, it communicated the facts in the form of relevant facts voluntarily and before the initiation of this sanctioning procedure;
- Based on the foregoing, CA Perú SAB maintains that the imputations should be dismissed and this procedure should be archived;
Evaluation of the Defenses
A. Introduction: Context in which the facts developed
- Through Official Letter No. 6815-2016-SMV/10.2, dated 10 November 2016[16], the General Superintendency of Supervision of Entities (IGSE) ordered an inspection visit to CA Perú SAB in order to evaluate compliance with the regulations applicable to the development of its functions in the securities market, specifically regarding the custody of client funds and the internal audit activity, which includes the internal control system, as pertinent. Said inspection began on 14 November 2016 and on 02 December 2016, the "Inspection Completion Certificate at CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C." (hereinafter, Completion Certificate) was signed. In said certificate, among others, the following was indicated:
"In this regard, CA PERU SAB presented, within the established term, all the information and documentation requested by the inspection commission (…) Additionally, it presented a simple copy of the session of Directors of CA PERU SAB held on 30.11.2016, through which, among the approved agenda items, the regularization of the two incidents found during the execution stage of this inspection was verified, which were communicated to the general management with the purpose of guaranteeing continuous compliance with the regulations and contributing to the strengthening of the internal control system of CA PERU SAB. Such aspects refer to the formalization of the appointment of the internal control officer (…) and the resignation from the position of director of the current general manager, who also serves as representative, documentation that is part of the working papers of this inspection visit".
- From the documents of the aforementioned inspection, the following observations are noted, among others: the omission of the registration of the appointment of Mr. Córdova as FCI in the Board of Directors' Minutes Book and that Mr. Yamamoto simultaneously held the positions of director, general manager and representative. In this sense, in order to clear these observations, CA Perú SAB held the Board meeting of 30 November 2016 in which it agreed to ratify the appointment of Mr. Córdova as FCI and the resignation of Mr. Yamamoto from the position of director;
- Likewise, from Report No. 984-2016-SMV/10.2 issued as a result of said inspection, it is noted that the IGSE indicated that the aforementioned observations were regularized;
- From the foregoing, it follows that although, through the Board meeting of 30 November 2016, CA Perú SAB cleared the indicated observations, whose minutes were presented during the inspection visit, as stated in the Completion Certificate, this sanctioning procedure was not initiated based on the results of said inspection but because the agreements taken at said board meeting qualified as relevant facts, according to Annex 9 of the RAI[17] and therefore had to be reported to the SMV by the next business day of the occurrence of the fact, in accordance with the means and forms established by the SMV, pursuant to Article 98 of the RAI;
- Specific defenses
-
- Conclusion of this procedure by application of the principle of opportunity
- Regarding the application of the principle of opportunity, provided in Article 2 of the Criminal Procedure Code, since CA Perú SAB seeks to have the initiation of a sanctioning procedure against it discarded or archived, it is necessary to mention that Title IV of the Sanctions Regulation regulates "corrective measures and abstention from initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure", however regarding its application, the IGSE did not issue any corrective measure but decided to communicate the indications of infractions to this Superintendency; likewise, it did not exercise the discretionary power indicated in Article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation**[18]**;
- Likewise, it must be specified that although CA Perú SAB reported the facts to the SMV on 14 December 2016, this does not exempt it from the initiation of the administrative sanctioning procedure since these should have been reported by 01 December 2016, an aspect that has not been accredited by CA Perú SAB in this procedure, and on the contrary it only presented the relevant facts to the SMV on the aforementioned 14 December, that is, thirteen (13) days late. In this sense, the communication made on the aforementioned 14 December was considered valid because the facts under analysis are detailed in numeral 12 of Annex 9 of the RAI, so contrary to what CA Perú SAB states, they did qualify in a concrete and specific manner as relevant facts; additionally, CA Perú SAB itself in the letter indicated that it was reporting as relevant facts and cited Article 98 of the RAI;
- Regarding the non-generation of harm or affectation to third parties, to market transparency or to any legal asset, these circumstances will be taken into account when determining the sanction to be imposed;
b) Situation of concurrence of infractions
- Regarding the application of the concurrence of infractions, Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that: "In the case of concurrence of infractions, the provisions of numeral 6 of Article 230 of the Procedure Law apply. Likewise, when several conducts qualify as more than one infraction, the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed";
- However, in this case, these are infractions for two relevant facts, each typified as minor infractions, therefore the principle of concurrence of infractions does not apply since according to it the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed, a situation that does not occur in this case.
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, since in this case a serious infraction will also be analyzed later, the concurrence of infractions will be applied in the evaluation of the sanction to be imposed.
c) Necessary consideration of the facts and circumstances
- As previously indicated, CA Perú SAB cleared the indicated observations, as stated in the Completion Certificate. However, this sanctioning procedure was initiated because the regularization of the facts subject to observation qualified as relevant facts, as will be evaluated in the principle of typicity;
d) Principles of administrative sanctioning law
- Principle of typicity or strict definition of infractions
- According to what CA Perú SAB states, the principle of typicity established in numeral 4 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG is not complied with, since the facts under analysis would not qualify as relevant facts, because Article 98 of the RAI can only be interpreted in conjunction with the provisions of Article 97 of the same;
- In this regard, it is convenient to note that Article 13 of the Securities Market Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), establishes that legal entities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market, as securities brokerage firms are, are obliged to present the information that the LMV and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of said information;
- In this sense, in accordance with the provisions of Article 97 of the RAI, situations, acts, facts, decisions, agreements or contingencies that affect or may affect the agent or its economic group are considered relevant facts. Likewise, information of the agent or its economic group that by its nature must be reported to the SMV for supervision and control purposes has the qualification of relevant fact. Consequently, according to the provisions of the indicated regulations, it is the obligation of intermediation agents to submit the information they are obliged to present, among them, that which qualifies as a relevant fact, ensuring that the information they present is truthful and timely;
- Additionally, Article 98 of the RAI indicates that the situations detailed in Annex 9 constitute relevant facts that the agent must communicate to the SMV, with sufficient detail and documentation. In this sense, according to numeral 12 of said Annex, the appointment and changes of directors, managers, Internal Control Officers, representatives, officers and legal representatives or attorneys-in-fact constitute relevant facts, and the list of names and positions of the removed or outgoing officers and of the officers appointed in their replacement must be presented, as well as the dates of cessation and start of functions, respectively;
- Therefore, since the facts under analysis refer to the appointment of Mr. Córdova as FCI agreed by Board meeting of 30 November 2016 and the cessation of functions of Mr. Yamamoto as Director by virtue of his resignation letter in which he states that his performance in the position was until said date, these fall within the provisions of numeral 12 of Annex 9, and therefore qualify as relevant facts, so that, although such facts might not be susceptible of affecting it or were known by the SMV as CA Perú SAB maintains, they had to be reported by virtue of the provisions of said Article 98, an obligation to present relevant facts that was recognized by the company itself since it was complied with by CA Perú SAB which reported the facts in question to the SMV on 14 December 2016, that is, extemporaneously;
- In addition, it should be mentioned that in accordance with the provisions of the Manual of Technical Specifications for the Remission to the SMV of Information of Intermediation Agents, approved by SMV Resolution No. 026-2012-SMV/01 and amendments, relevant facts will be sent through the MVNet System;
- Finally, in Annex X, subsection 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation according to which it constitutes an infraction: "Failure to communicate relevant facts, or failure to do so within the term established by the regulations", it is noted that non-compliance with the mandate established in Articles 97 and 98 of the RAI constitutes an infraction;
- Therefore, the imputed infraction type does not violate the principle of typicity and, contrary to what CA Perú SAB states, it does have legal support and no nullity defect has been incurred, since it is observed that the elements of the principle of typicity have occurred: i) the mandating norm is Articles 97 and 98 and Annex 9, numeral 12 of the RAI and ii) the norm indicating that non-compliance with said mandate is an infraction is developed in Annex X, subsection 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- On the other hand, regarding the prohibition of requesting information that the entity possesses and the right not to present said information, regulated in Articles 48 and 66 of the TUO of the LPAG, respectively, it must be noted that the obligation to present relevant facts does not originate from a request by the SMV but from the obligation of securities brokerage firms to present the information that the norms establish in accordance with the means and forms established by the SMV, as CA Perú SAB reported on 14 December 2016, outside the term established by the aforementioned regulations;
- Principle of presumption of lawfulness
- The presentation outside the established term of relevant facts constitutes infractions whose proof is objective based on a deadline by which the securities brokerage firm must present the information, that is, the next business day after the facts occur, an aspect that as we have already mentioned has not been accredited; in this sense, if said information has not been presented within the cited term, the commission of the infractions subject to imputation is accredited, therefore there is no doubt or insufficiency of evidence that gives rise to the presumption of lawfulness and the recognition of the principle "in dubio pro reo";
- Principle of proportionality and principle of culpability
- Regarding the principle of proportionality, regulated in numeral 3 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, as well as the provisions of Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, these criteria will be taken into account when evaluating the sanction to be imposed;
- It should be noted that according to Article 247, numeral 247.2 of the referred TUO**[19]**, the norms on the sanctioning procedure set forth in Chapter III of said normative body are applicable on a supplementary basis to the procedures established in special laws;
- On the other hand, regarding the principle of culpability alleged by CA Perú SAB, it is necessary to specify that according to numeral 10 of Article 246 of the TUO of the LPAG, the principle of culpability governs the sanctioning power, which establishes that administrative responsibility is subjective, except in cases where by law or legislative decree objective administrative responsibility is provided;
- Thus, in this case, although it cannot be determined whether CA Perú SAB acted with the will to breach the obligations provided in the RAI, according to the charges imputed, it is evident that its conduct entails the commission of infractions by negligence; that is, by the production of an unlawful result, duly typified, completely foreseeable and avoidable, since it disregarded a duty of care in its conduct by not having complied with presenting the relevant facts within the term provided, in accordance with what is required in the RAI;
- Likewise, CA Perú SAB could have avoided incurring the imputed infractions by being aware of the applicable regulations and thus mitigating the circumstances that prevented it from complying with the provisions thereof;
e) Special consideration given the existence of exonerating circumstances
- Regarding the arguments referring to the application of the exonerating circumstances established in Article 257, numeral 1, subsections e) and f) of the TUO of the LPAG, for error induced by confusing administrative provision and voluntary rectification before the imputation of charges, they will be taken into consideration when analyzing the sanction;
- Consequently, CA Perú SAB has not disproved the charges imputed for not having communicated within the term established in Article 98 of the RAI the relevant facts under analysis;
3.1.4 Of the Defenses Presented for the Execution of Contracts with Foreign Entities
- CA Perú SAB states that the alleged infractions referring to the contracts signed with Lek Securities Corp. and Ultralat Capital Market are time-barred, and therefore the imputations referring to them should be dismissed and sent to archive;
- In this regard, it indicates that from the documents attached as annexes, the contract with the company Lek Securities Corp. was signed on 18 October 2012 and the contract with Ultralat Capital Market on 20 January 2015, so if it were considered that said executions were relevant facts, they should have been communicated on the business day following that date, that is, 19 October 2012 and 21 January 2015, respectively, and not on the day following the board agreement of 26 August 2016, where only the existing relationship between CA Perú SAB and the indicated companies was acknowledged. It adds that a board agreement is a declaration of will of one of the parties and not an agreement of wills, as is the nature of contracts, according to our Civil Code;
- Therefore, it mentions that in both cases the 4-year term has already elapsed for the SMV to determine the existence of administrative infractions, in accordance with Article 342 of the Securities Market Law, Single Ordered Text approved by Supreme Decree No. 093-2002-EF;
- Consequently, CA Perú SAB states that it will only pronounce on the alleged infraction referring to the execution of a contract with Beta Capital LLC, to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or for third parties, according to the Board agreement of 26 August 2016;
- On this matter, it indicates that there is a lack of factual grounds in the imputation, since the charges letter equates the execution of an alleged contract with the alleged adoption of an agreement by its board. In this regard, it mentions that neither did the board in session of 26 August 2016 adopt any agreement regarding an alleged contract with the indicated company, according to the session minutes; nor, even if an agreement had been adopted, could such agreement in any way be equated with the execution of a contract, which is the assumption that would configure the relevant fact that would have been omitted to report;
- It adds that in the referred minutes it is stated:
"The president stated that, as part of the company's efforts, work is being done with the companies Beta Capital (Miami), Ultralat Capital Markets (Miami), FTN Financial (New York) and Lek Securities (New York).
In this sense, the Board acknowledged that CA Perú is working with the companies Beta Capital (Miami), Ultralat Capital Markets (Miami), FTN Financial (New York) and Lek Securities (New York)"
- Therefore, it states that there is no agreement nor does the minutes refer in any way to a contract; it also points out that if an agreement regarding a contract had been adopted, said agreement could not be equated to a contract, since a contract is an agreement of wills of two or more persons, so the charge must be dismissed;
- On the other hand, CA Perú SAB maintains that in the denied event that the SMV determines that it incurred the infraction, a warning sanction should be imposed, in accordance with the provisions of numeral (ii) of section 4.2 of the Sanction Criteria, in force at the time the infraction would have been committed;
- Likewise, regarding the situation of concurrence of infractions, it states that in Official Letter No. 1010-2019-SMV/10.3 it is charged with the commission of three minor infractions, so in the denied event that a sanction is considered for more than one infraction contained in said official letter, the provisions of article 29 of the New Sanctions Regulation must be applied;
- It adds that SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 repeals the previous Sanctions Regulation, and therefore all norms that develop it, including the “Criteria applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure for non-compliance with the norms that regulate the submission of periodic or occasional information” that illegally sought to disapply the rule of concurrence of infractions mentioned;
- Additionally, it refers to the principles of administrative sanctioning law, such as the principle of presumption of lawfulness and the principle of proportionality, which were detailed in its defenses presented for the appointment of Mr. Córdova and the cessation of functions of Mr. Yamamoto;
Evaluation of the Defenses
- In principle, it must be noted that through file No. 2017013919 submitted to the SMV on April 6, 2017, CA Perú SAB indicated as date of agreement: August 26, 2016 and as type of relationship: foreign intermediary to Lek Securities Corp., Ultralat Capital Market and Beta Capital LLC; charges being imputed based on said information;
- On the matter, CA Perú SAB maintains that the indicated date corresponds to the session of its Board of Directors, for which it sent the corresponding minutes, in which the following is observed:
“4. Evaluation and approval of foreign brokerage counterparties:
The president stated that, as part of the company's efforts, it has been working with the companies Beta Capital (Miami), Ultralat Capital Markets (Miami), FTN Financial (New York) and Lek Securities (New York).
In this sense, the Board took note that CA Perú has been working with the companies Beta Capital (Miami), Ultralat Capital Markets (Miami), FTN Financial (New York) and Lek Securities (New York)”;
- From the referred minutes, it can be inferred that CA Perú SAB had entered into contracts to carry out intermediation operations with Lek Securities Corp., Ultralat Capital Market and Beta Capital LLC. prior to August 26, 2016, since by that date it was already working with the cited companies;
- In this sense, CA Perú SAB states that the contract with the company Lek Securities Corp. was signed on October 18, 2012 and the contract with Ultralat Capital Market, on January 20, 2015, so the alleged infractions are time-barred, for which it attaches the referred documents;
- On the other hand, regarding the relevant fact referring to the celebration of a contract with a foreign entity, Beta Capital LLC, although CA Perú SAB indicated that August 26, 2016 is the date on which the board session was held, that no agreement was adopted regarding a contract with the indicated company and in the event that an agreement had been adopted it could not be equated to the celebration of a contract, it did not indicate on what date the contract with the cited company would have been celebrated, since from the minutes it attached it is inferred that it was already working with said company;
- However, on January 31, 2019, CA Perú SAB was requested by email to provide the contracts it would have entered into with its foreign intermediaries, including with Beta Capital LLC, and from the documents sent by it on the same date it is observed that on May 5, 2016 it would have entered into a contract with the referred company, so it should have communicated it to the SMV until May 6, 2016;
- Consequently, CA Perú SAB has not disproved the charge imputed for not having communicated within the term established in article 98 of the RAI the celebration of a contract with Beta Capital LLC, to carry out intermediation operations on its own account or on behalf of third parties;
- It should be noted that through SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 the Sanctions Regulation was approved (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation), which entered into force on December 19, 2018. Now, in accordance with the principle of non-retroactivity contained in numeral 5 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG[20], which was reflected in article 2 of the referred resolution, which provides the following: “Infractions committed before the entry into force of this resolution shall be processed in accordance with the norms in force at the time they occurred, unless the provisions approved by this resolution are more favorable to the offender”, the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the infraction was incurred apply, unless subsequent norms are more favorable;
- Considering the mentioned principle, in the present case the Sanctions Regulation (currently repealed) must be applied, unless the New Sanctions Regulation contains more favorable provisions for CA Perú SAB;
- Regarding the relevant facts subject to imputation, the New Sanctions Regulation classifies the infraction committed by CA Perú SAB in the same way as the previous regulation, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification; it being necessary to specify that the New Sanctions Regulation does not repeal the “Criteria applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure for non-compliance with the norms that regulate the submission of periodic or occasional information”; which are exclusively applicable to non-compliances with the norms that regulate the submission of periodic or occasional information and are not applied extensively to the other cases investigated by the SMV;
- In view of the foregoing, CA Perú SAB has incurred three (03) infractions classified as minor, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction “Not communicating relevant facts or not doing so within the term established by the regulations”.
3.2 On the obligation to Communicate the Name of the Audit Firm and the Annual Audit Plan
3.2.1 On the Applicable Regulations
- Regarding the name of the audit firm, article 125 of the New RAI states the following:
“Article 125.- Scope
This title establishes the provisions that must be complied with in carrying out the following annual external audit works:
- Financial audit examination. In the case that the Agent has the subsidiaries permitted by Law, the same examination is also required regarding its consolidated financial information;
- Compliance examination;
- Examination of evaluation of the control system, which must observe the conditions established in article 138.
To comply with the obligations of submitting the corresponding information, each year the Agents must contract the services of audit firms, so that they carry out said works, which may be performed by the same audit firm.
The Agents must communicate to the SMV the name of the audit firms for the performance of the mentioned works no later than June 30 of each year”.
- Regarding the Special Annual Audit Plan, article 32 of the PLAFT NORMS states the following:
Article 32.- Special Annual Audit Plan
The Internal Audit Area or the official exercising internal control functions, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 30.2 of article 30 of this norm, must prepare a Special Annual Audit Plan for the money laundering and terrorist financing detection system, aimed at improving the internal control system for prevention, which must be approved by the Board of Directors or equivalent body of the obligated subjects before December 31 of each year and submitted to CONASEV within the same term for submitting the report of the Compliance Officer corresponding to the second semester of the year, for which it must be delivered in a timely manner to the Compliance Officer (…)”.
- Regarding the term for submitting the Semi-annual Report of the Compliance Officer, article 29, numerals 29.1 and 29.2 of the PLAFT NORMS, establishes the following:
“Article 29.- Terms for the submission of semi-annual reports of the Compliance Officer
29.1 The semi-annual reports of the Compliance Officer must be brought to the attention of the Board of Directors or equivalent body of the obligated subject, within the calendar month following the expiration of the respective semi-annual period, before being submitted to CONASEV and the UIF-Perú.
29.2 The semi-annual reports must be submitted to CONASEV and the UIF-Perú no later than within fifteen calendar days following the date on which the reports have been brought to the attention of the Board of Directors or similar body of the obligated subject. Said reports must present evidence of having been submitted in advance to the Board of Directors of the obligated subject.
(…)”;
- Through Official Letter No. 6415-2018-SMV/10.3, charges were formulated against CA Perú SAB for not communicating to the SMV within the term established by the applicable regulations, the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit works for the 2018 fiscal year, and for not having complied with submitting to the SMV the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, as indicated in literals f. and g. of the third recital of this resolution;
-
- On the Defenses Presented regarding the Obligation to Communicate the Name of the Audit Firm and the Special Annual Audit Plan
- Preliminary issues
- CA Perú SAB maintains that in accordance with the provisions of the official letter of charges, it is charged with a serious and a minor infraction, so the provisions of article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation must be applied since a case of concurrence of infractions is configured;
-
- Principle of presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the administered
- In addition to what has already been indicated on the principles of administrative sanctioning law, CA Perú SAB states that the Constitutional Court itself has established that the principles governing criminal law are applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure. In this sense, it cites the principle of presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the administered, with the same arguments developed in the defenses for the relevant facts imputed;
- Principles of proportionality
- Regarding the principle of proportionality, in addition to what has already been stated above, CA Perú SAB states that the minor infraction occurred in the context in which its resources were focused mainly on complying with its regulatory obligations and that the serious infraction has not been committed and that there is no intentionality in committing infractions;
- Regarding the imputations made
- CA Perú SAB maintains that the Special Annual Audit Plan was submitted to the SMV together with the Semi-annual Report of the Compliance Officer corresponding to the second semester of 2017, which was approved by the Board of Directors on January 30, 2018 and submitted to the SMV on February 14, 2018, that is, strictly complying with the term provided in articles 32 and 29 of the PLAFT Norms;
- Likewise, it indicates that in the information submitted to the SMV on February 14, 2018, there is the “Special Annual Internal Audit Report” required by the cited article 32 of the PLAFT Norms, therefore it did not incur an infraction, thus requesting that the imputation be dismissed and adding that in case of doubt the interpretation most favorable must be chosen;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, CA Perú SAB states that the following circumstances could function as mitigating factors for a denied eventual sanction: it obtained no benefit; no damage to the public interest or to a protected legal good has been verified, since the infraction has not been committed; there was no economic harm; there is no recidivism; there are no negative circumstances and there was no intentionality;
b) Minor infraction
- CA Perú SAB states that for involuntary reasons the information could not be provided until July 2, 2018, without prejudice to this, the information was submitted just one day later, that is, on July 3, 2018. In case of doubt regarding the date of compliance in application of the principle of lawfulness, the interpretation most favorable to the administered must be applied;
- It also requests that the following circumstances be considered: it obtained no benefit from the facts under analysis; the infraction is easily detectable; no damage to the public interest or to any protected legal good has been generated; no harm has been generated and considering the type of information it appears to lack any relevance for investors and for the regulator; it is not a recidivist; it omitted to submit information in circumstances in which its resources were focused on the regularization of its representatives and there was no intentionality. It adds that in application of the principle of reasonableness the minimum possible sanction must be applied;
- By way of conclusion, CA Perú SAB maintains that it has not committed the serious infraction charged and regarding the minor infraction requests that the principle of reasonableness be applied;
Evaluation of the Defenses
A. Preliminary Issues
- Regarding the concurrence of infractions, established in article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, it will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed, since in the present procedure minor and one serious infractions were imputed;
-
- Principle of presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the administered
- Both the non-submission of the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, in accordance with the provisions of article 32 of the PLAFT Norms and the non-communication to the SMV of the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit works for the 2018 fiscal year, in accordance with the term established in article 125 of the RAI are infractions whose determination and proof is objective based on a deadline by which the stock brokerage agent company must submit the information; in this sense, if the cited information has not been submitted in accordance with the referred articles, the commission of the infraction subject to imputation is accredited, so there is no doubt or insufficiency of evidence that gives rise to the recognition of the principle “in dubio pro reo”, the presumption of lawfulness of the conduct of the stock brokerage agent company being disproved;
- Principle of proportionality
- Regarding the principle of proportionality, regulated in numeral 3 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, as well as the provisions of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, said criteria will be taken into account at the time of evaluating the sanction to be imposed;
- Regarding the imputations made
- Although CA Perú SAB maintains that on February 14, 2018 it submitted the Special Annual Audit Plan together with the Semi-annual Report of the Compliance Officer corresponding to the second semester of 2017, which was approved by the Board of Directors on January 30, 2018, that is, strictly complying with the term provided in articles 32 and 29 of the PLAFT Norms, from the review of the information recorded in the SMV's information systems such affirmation is not verified;
- In this regard, it was verified that CA Perú SAB submitted on February 14, 2018 the Semi-annual Report of the Compliance Officer corresponding to the second semester of 2017 and additionally submitted a document called “Evaluation of the internal control system, intermediation activities and comprehensive risk management” and as CA Perú SAB itself maintains it submitted the “Special Annual Internal Audit Report” for the period from January 1 to December 31, 2017, however the Special Annual Audit Plan corresponding to the 2018 fiscal year is not observed;
- It should be noted that in accordance with the provisions of subsection 30.3 of article 30 of the PLAFT Norms, the Internal Audit or the official or body exercising the attributions and responsibilities of internal control must issue a Special Annual Report, in which it evaluates the design and application of the money laundering and terrorist financing prevention system. Said report must be submitted to the SMV as an annex to the second semi-annual report of the Compliance Officer, as CA Perú SAB did;
- However, the submission of the Special Annual Audit Plan for the money laundering and terrorist financing detection system, aimed at improving the internal control system for prevention and what said plan must consider as a minimum, including a schedule of activities, is regulated in article 32 of the PLAFT Norms, that is, an obligation different from that indicated in article 30, cited above;
- On the other hand, the circumstances indicated by CA Perú SAB as mitigating factors for an eventual sanction will be evaluated at the time of imposing the corresponding sanction;
- Additionally, it must be indicated that the New Sanctions Regulation classifies the infraction committed by CA Perú SAB in the same way as the previous regulation, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification.
- By virtue of the foregoing, CA Perú SAB has not disproved the charge imputed, therefore it has incurred one (01) infraction classified as serious, according to Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction: “Not submitting in a timely manner, or doing so without observing the money laundering and terrorist financing prevention regulations, to the SMV or the UIF - Perú, as the case may be, the respective reports or the Special Annual Audit Plan”;
- Minor infraction
- According to the term established in article 125 of the New RAI, stock brokerage agent companies must communicate to the SMV the name of the audit firms for the performance of the following annual external audit works: financial audit examination, compliance examination and control system evaluation examination, no later than June 30 of each year;
- However, according to article 145, numeral 145.2 of the TUO of the LPAG, when the last day of the term or the determined date is non-business, they are understood to be extended to the first business day following. Therefore, since June 30, 2018 is a non-business day, Saturday; the deadline for submitting the referred report was July 2, 2018, Monday, which is the next business day;
- In this sense, considering that the determination and proof of the infraction for the non-communication to the SMV of the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit works for the 2018 fiscal year, in accordance with the term established in article 125 of the New RAI is objective based on a deadline, the infraction is accredited with the submission of the referred information on July 3, 2018, so there is no doubt regarding the delay in its submission; whose fact is not questioned by CA Perú SAB;
- It should be noted that the New Sanctions Regulation also classifies the infraction committed by CA Perú SAB as a minor infraction, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification;
- In this sense, it is concluded that CA Perú SAB has not disproved the charge imputed, so at the date of the events it committed one (01) infraction classified as minor, in accordance with the provisions of Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6, of the Sanctions Regulation: “Not providing in a timely manner or doing so incompletely, the documentation or information, other than that indicated in numeral 3.1 above, to which they are obligated by the regulations or by requirement of the SMV or not sending it in accordance with the technical specifications, when applicable”; however, the application of the exemption from responsibility for voluntary correction will be analyzed;
- On the Evaluation of the Sanction
- The administrative sanctions that are imposed must take into account the provisions established in the LMV, the Sanctions Regulation and the TUO of the LPAG;
Exempting assumptions of responsibility
- These assumptions are indicated in Article 257, numeral 1[21] of the TUO of the LPAG. Whose subsection f) establishes as a condition exempting from liability for infractions, the voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 255[22] of the TUO of the LPAG. In this sense, from the evaluation of the defenses, the analysis presented below is had;
- Regarding the relevant facts of November 30, 2016, referring to the appointment of Mr. Córdova as FCI and the cessation of functions of Mr. Yamamoto, although CA Perú SAB presented them on December 14, 2016, said facts originated as a response to the observations found in the inspection visit ordered by the IGSE through Official Letter No. 6815-2016-SMV/10.2, of November 10, 2016, that is, the remediation was not a voluntary act, therefore, the application of said exemption does not correspond;
- Regarding the celebration of a contract with Beta Capital LLC, CA Perú SAB to date has not complied with informing said situation as a relevant fact. Additionally, it should be indicated that the intermediary sent the contract, where it can be seen that it was celebrated on May 5, 2016, in response to the requirement made on January 31, 2019. Consequently, from the above, it follows that there was no voluntary remediation before the notification of charges and consequently the application of the cited exemption does not correspond;
- Regarding the communication of the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit work for the 2018 fiscal year, communicated outside the period established in Article 125 of the New RAI, CA Perú SAB remedied said situation voluntarily, that is, there was no prior requirement from the SMV. In this sense, it corresponds to apply the cited cause of exemption from liability for voluntary remediation;
- Regarding the obligation to present the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, in accordance with the provisions of Article 32 of the PLAFT Rules, CA Perú SAB has not remedied its omission, therefore the mentioned exemption is not applicable;
- On the other hand, regarding the application of the exemption from liability for error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision, provided in Article 255, numeral 1, subsection e), of the TUO of the LPAG, in the imputation of charges for the relevant facts occurred on November 30, 2016, since according to CA Perú SAB there would be a confusing norm (Articles 97, 98 and Annex 9 of the RAI) it must be pointed out that according to what was exposed in the evaluation of the defenses, specifically in the principle of typicity, Annex 9 of the RAI is an enunciative list of facts whose purpose is to facilitate the intermediary agent the identification and qualification of the information that qualifies as a relevant fact, not observing contradiction with what is regulated in Article 97 of the RAI;
- From the above it is concluded that it only corresponds to apply the exemption from liability referred to in Article 257, numeral 1, subsection f) of the TUO of the LPAG to the infraction for not communicating the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit work for the 2018 fiscal year, within the period established in Article 125 of the New RAI, typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6, of the Sanctions Regulation and to archive the charge formulated in the present administrative sanctioning procedure in this extreme;
- Additionally, it should be noted that Article 28 of the New Sanctions Regulation regulates the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation excluding some assumptions, among which the infraction previously cited is not included.
"Article 28.- Assumptions in which remediation is not applied as an exemption from liability
Remediation prior to the notification of the imputation of charges shall not be considered as an exemption from liability, when a communication had been sent requiring compliance with the obligation.
The following are not subject to remediation for the purposes of the provisions of subsection f) of Article 27:
- The presentation of inaccurate or false information or documentation to the SMV and/or that is disclosed to the market.
- The contravention of market abuse rules, referring to the improper use of privileged information and market manipulation.
- The late or incomplete presentation, or the non-presentation of material facts, financial information and annual reports.
- The performance of activities not permitted or providing services or performing activities not authorized by the SMV, in cases where the regulations require having the respective authorization.
- The performance of activities that imply the disposal of funds, financial instruments or any asset owned by clients without their authorization or the breach of custody, administration or fiduciary duties that entities authorized by the SMV have."
Determination of the sanction
- Regarding the other infractions, the determination of the sanction will be carried out in accordance with Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with Article 248, numeral 3[23] of the TUO of the LPAG[24] and the mitigating circumstances of liability indicated in Article 255, numeral 2 of the referred TUO;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Background of the offender; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good; c) The damage caused and the repercussion in the market; d) Recidivism[25]; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender; h) The probability of detection of the infraction; and, i) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender for its clarification;
- In this sense, in order to reconcile the criteria of the TUO of the LPAG with those indicated in the LMV and the Sanctions Regulation, as well as for these criteria to be considered adequately so that their assessment observes the principle of reasonableness and that the sanction to be imposed adapts to these, the referred criteria are analyzed;
- Regarding the background of the offender, in accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, the sanctions imposed by the SMV that became final within the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction constitute background of the offender. In this sense, from the review carried out in said period, it has been verified that, in relation to the four (4) infractions, subject of the present administrative sanctioning procedure, CA Perú SAB registers as a sanction background the Resolution of Deputy Superintendence SMV No. 011-2016-SMV/10, notified on April 15, 2016, through which it was sanctioned with a fine of 5.4 UIT, equivalent to S/ 20,520.00 (Twenty Thousand Five Hundred Twenty and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred in two (02) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsections 3.1 and 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation for having presented the Basic Financial Statements and the Audited Annual Control Annexes corresponding to the 2013 fiscal year and the Compliance Report corresponding to the 2013 Annual fiscal year outside the period established by the current regulations;
- In addition to this, regarding the infractions referred to the relevant facts of November 30, 2016 and the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, CA Perú SAB registers as background the Resolution of Deputy Superintendence SMV No. 034-2016-SMV/10, notified on August 24, 2016, through which CA Perú SAB was sanctioned with a fine of 11 UIT, equivalent to S/. 40,700.00 (Forty Thousand Seven Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in one (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.11, in three (03) infractions of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.9 and Annex X, numeral 2, subsections 2.13 and 2.14, and in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex XIX, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, for having a net worth lower than what is provided by the regulations; for providing portfolio administration service without having the respective legal requirements; for granting credits to clients without the subscription of the mutual contract; for inadequate supervision of the internal control system; and for the non-observance of the provisions contained in its Manual for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing;
- Furthermore, regarding the infraction referred to the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, CA Perú SAB registers as background:
- Resolution of Deputy Superintendence SMV No. 013-2017-SMV/10, notified on March 17, 2017, through which CA Perú SAB was sanctioned, with a fine of 04 UIT, equivalent to S/. 14,800.00 (Fourteen Thousand Eight Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in two (02) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not timely sending the file of intermediated amounts; and, for not timely sending its information on margins and conditions of liquidity and patrimonial solvency and the basic data files in real time.
- Resolution of Deputy Superintendence SMV No. 060-2016-SMV/10, notified on December 30, 2016, through which CA Perú SAB is sanctioned, with a fine of 03 UIT, equivalent to S/ 11,400.00 (Eleven Thousand Four Hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having presented the basic financial statements and control annexes corresponding to the close of January 2014.
- In this sense, it can be concluded that CA Perú SAB does register sanction background that became final within the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infractions subject of the present procedure.
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, it has not been possible to prove that the action of CA Perú SAB in the commission of the infractions analyzed in the present sanctioning procedure has caused serious damage to the public interest;
- However, the legal good referring to the protection of investors has been affected to the extent that the untimely presentation of relevant facts limits the capacity of supervision and control of the intermediary agents by the SMV. Thus, it is had that the non-communication of the celebration of contracts with foreign intermediaries for operations abroad, limits the capacity of the regulator to carry out reconciliations of funds, verifications of compliance with prudential parameters, circularizations, among others, which affects the supervision and control of intermediation activities and therefore the objective of investor protection;
- Likewise, it must be noted that it is indispensable that obligated subjects comply with all preventive measures against money laundering and terrorist financing provided in the PLAFT Rules, since these allow them to manage their money laundering risks through the establishment of procedures, policies and controls detailed in the rules, as well as those linked to the timely detection and reporting of suspicious operations;
- Consequently, the breach of the obligations established in the referred rules does not allow them to fully achieve the purpose of the money laundering prevention system and therefore does not allow an adequate prevention that must exist to safeguard the integrity of the market; likewise it affects the trust that investors may have in stock brokerage firms in the diligent development of their functions in the stock market;
- Regarding the damage caused and the repercussion in the market, it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions in which CA Perú SAB has incurred in the present sanctioning procedure have caused a concrete economic damage to the market participants or have had repercussion in the market;
- Regarding recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within the period of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, it must be stated that CA Perú SAB does not present sanctions, within the aforementioned period, for the commission of the same infractions, subject of analysis in the present administrative sanctioning procedure;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it must be noted that CA Perú SAB, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, knows the rules that regulate the stock market and in that sense the rules that oblige it to communicate to the SMV the relevant facts, as well as the obligation to present the Special Annual Audit Plan, within the established periods, in accordance with the provisions of the PLAFT Rules;
- In the present sanctioning procedure, it is had that CA Perú SAB presented the relevant facts of November 30, 2016, on December 14, 2016; that is, with 13 days of delay with respect to the deadline; and that these facts originated from the observations that the SMV made during an inspection visit;
- Likewise, the relevant fact referring to the celebration of a contract with Beta Capital LLC, occurred on May 5, 2016, has not been informed to date as a relevant fact; indicating the intermediary in its defenses that what was communicated on April 6, 2017 refers to a Board agreement of August 26, 2016 that in no way could be equated to the celebration of a contract, which is the assumption that would configure the relevant fact that would have been omitted to inform, argument that has been evaluated previously;
- Regarding the Special Annual Audit Plan for the 2018 fiscal year, it must be considered that as of the date of this report, it has not yet been presented;
- Regarding the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infractions, it has not been proven in the present administrative sanctioning procedure that CA Perú SAB has obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred in the infractions subject of analysis;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, no intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct of CA Perú SAB regarding the infractions subject of analysis;
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infractions, it must be indicated that in the present case the facts constituting infractions committed by CA Perú SAB were evidenced as a result of the supervision and control actions carried out by the SMV regarding compliance by stock brokerage firms with their obligations in accordance with the provisions of the applicable regulations;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender for its clarification, CA Perú SAB, in accordance with what was indicated in its defenses, has not recognized the commission of the four (04) infractions subject of evaluation. However, it has contributed to its clarification;
- Additionally, it is not observed that in the present procedure any of the assumptions that constitute mitigating conditions of liability, established in Article 255, numeral 2 of the TUO of the LPAG[26], has been configured;
- It should be noted that the guidelines for the application of a reprimand sanction established in numeral (II) of subsection 4.2 of the Criteria applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Breach of the Rules that regulate the remission of Periodic or Eventual Information, approved by Resolution No. 066-2012-SMV/01, modified by SMV Resolution No. 010-2014-SMV/01, invoked by CA Perú SAB, are not susceptible of application to the present case, because the infractions subject of analysis refer to relevant facts and PLAFT Rules;
- Based on the above, it corresponds to determine the sanction to be imposed on CA Perú SAB for having incurred in the commission of three (03) infractions classified as minor, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.14 and one (01) infraction classified as serious typified in Annex XIX, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- On the particular, Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation[27] states the following:
"Article 15.- Concurrence of Infractions
(...). Likewise, when several conducts qualify as more than one infraction, the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed".
- In this sense, by application of Article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, it would correspond to sanction CA Perú SAB with a fine corresponding to the infractions classified as serious;
- According to Article 21 of the Sanctions Regulation, the commission of serious infractions is sanctioned with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT or suspension of the operating authorization, for up to twenty (20) days;
- However, in accordance with Article 34 of the New Sanctions Regulation, the commission of a serious infraction, regarding the fine, is punishable with a fine not less than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) UIT, therefore in the case analyzed the provisions of said norm are applicable, as it is more favorable, in application of Article 2 of the resolution that approves the referred regulation;
- However, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, specifically the fact that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed by CA Perú SAB have caused serious damage to the public interest, nor economic damage to market participants, nor to the market, nor that it has obtained any illicit benefit; and in application of the principle of reasonableness contemplated in Article 246, numeral 3 of the TUO of the LPAG which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliances classified as infractions, this Deputy Superintendence considers that it would be possible to impose on CA Perú SAB a sanction corresponding to the classification lower than that provided for serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of Article 6, third paragraph of the Sanctions Regulation, for which it is proposed to impose a fine sanction applicable to minor infractions, in accordance with Article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendment.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as serious, typified in Annex XIX, subsection 2, numeral 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with presenting the Special Annual Audit Plan corresponding to the 2018 fiscal year, subject of the present sanctioning procedure.
- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex X, subsection 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with timely communicating the relevant fact of November 30, 2016 referring to the appointment of Mr. Jorge Abdiel Córdova Barrios as Internal Control Officer, subject of the present sanctioning procedure.
- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex X, subsection 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with timely communicating the relevant fact of November 30, 2016 referring to the cessation of functions of Mr. Percy Yamamoto Kamida to the position of Director, subject of the present sanctioning procedure.
- Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex X, subsection 3, numeral 3.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with communicating the relevant fact referring to the celebration of the contract with Beta Capital LLC, subject of the present sanctioning procedure. Declare that CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa, at the date of the events, committed one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex I, subsection 3, numeral 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10, in force at the time of the events, for not having complied with communicating the name of the audit firm in charge of carrying out the annual external audit work for the 2018 fiscal year.
- Declare that it corresponds to archive the infraction indicated in Article 5 by application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation contained in subsection f) of numeral 1 of Article 257 of the TUO LPAG.
- Sanction CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. with a fine of 5 UIT equivalent to S/ 19,750.00 (Nineteen Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of Articles 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the present resolution.
- The present resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendence of Prudential Supervision through the filing of the reconsideration or appeal resource presented before it, within the period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the case that the present resolution is not subject to challenge through reconsideration or appeal resource within the period of fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published in the Portal of the Superintendence of the Stock Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of normative projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by Superintendence Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe the present resolution to CA Perú Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
File No. 2016046225. ↑
-
File No. 2016046225. ↑
-
File No. 2017013919. ↑
-
File No. 2017013919. ↑
-
File No. 2017013919. ↑
-
File No. 2018026366 ↑
-
File No. 2018026552 ↑
-
File No. 2018026664 ↑
-
Currently, the referred infraction is provided in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.9 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, effective as of December 19, 2018 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation). ↑
-
Currently, said infraction is also provided in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
-
Currently, the cited infraction is provided in Annex XVI, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
-
Currently, provided in article 97 of the New RAI. ↑
-
Currently, provided in article 98 of the New RAI. ↑
-
Currently regulated in Annex I, numeral 15 of the New RAI. ↑
-
Currently, regulated in Annex I, numeral 26 of the New RAI. ↑
-
File No. 2016042614. ↑
-
Currently in the New RAI, it is called Annex I. In that sense, when CA Perú SAB refers to Annex I, it should be understood as its reference to Annex 9 of the RAI in force at the date of the events. ↑
-
Article 33.- Abstention from Initiating a Sanctioning Procedure
The General Compliance Intendancies may also not initiate an administrative sanctioning procedure when at the time of detecting the infraction it has been reverted or remedied, provided that the assumptions established in the preceding article 32 are also met; which must be communicated to the administered. ↑
-
Article 245.- Scope of application of this chapter
245.2.- The provisions contained in this Chapter apply on a supplementary basis to all procedures established in special laws, including tax procedures, which must necessarily observe the principles of administrative sanctioning power referred to in article 246, as well as the structure and guarantees provided for the administrative sanctioning procedure. ↑
-
Article 248.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
5.- Non-retroactivity.- The sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered incurs the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable.
Sanctioning provisions produce retroactive effect insofar as they favor the presumed offender or the offender, both in terms of the classification of the infraction and the sanction and its prescription periods, even with respect to sanctions in execution when the new provision enters into force. ↑
-
“Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting liability for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The mandatory order of a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) Error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) Voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 255
(…).” ↑
-
“Article 255.- Sanctioning procedure
Entities in the exercise of their sanctioning power adhere to the following provisions:
(…)
3. Once the initiation of the sanctioning procedure is decided, the instructing authority of the procedure formulates the respective notification of charges to the possible sanctioned party, which must contain the data referred to in numeral 3 of the preceding article so that they present their written defenses within a period that may not be less than five business days counted from the date of notification.
(…).” ↑
-
Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
-
“Article 248.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, observing the following criteria that are indicated for their graduation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;
b) The probability of detection of the infraction;
c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good;
d) The economic harm caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within the period of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and
g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender”. ↑
-
The sanction criteria referred to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infraction were introduced by article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 which modified, among others, article 230; numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
-
Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 modified article 236-A of the LPAG, and in that sense incorporates and restructures the assumptions exempting and mitigating liability. ↑
-
Currently included in article 29 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑