SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 046-2016-SMV/10
Summary: Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa is sanctioned with a fine of seven (07) UIT, equivalent to S/ 24,500.00 (Twenty-four thousand five hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred one (01) very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18, in three (03) serious infractions typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraphs 2.10, 2.13 and 2.19, and in two (02) minor infractions typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraphs 3.5 and 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations, for intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations; for using global accounts without observing the required conditions; for not delivering account statements; for not obtaining orders from its clients; for not delivering policies; and, for not signing a mutual contract for money, respectively. Likewise, it is declared that Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has not incurred one (01) very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1, and, consequently, the administrative sanctioning procedure is concluded in this respect.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | - Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa |
| Subject | : | - Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | - 2016021496 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2016021496, Report No. 851-2016-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, the defenses and arguments presented by Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By minutes of January 28, 2016 and writings sent to this Superintendency of the Securities Market (hereinafter, SMV), on February 3, April 6 and May 11, 2016, Mr. Abraham Gleiser Ludmir and Mrs. Marta Josselyn Campodónico de Gleiser (hereinafter, the Complainants) filed a complaint against Grupo Privado de Inversiones Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa (hereinafter, GPI SAB) because the aforementioned stock brokerage firm would not have delivered account statements, policies, or orders for the operations they carried out; and consequently, the aforementioned situation would not have allowed them to know the management of their investments and money delivered;
- Mr. Abraham Gleiser Ludmir (hereinafter, Mr. Gleiser) states that he withdrew approximately US$ 1.8 million of the money he delivered to the intermediary, including the shares listed on the Lima Stock Exchange, leaving a constant investment balance in the omnibus account of GPI SAB of approximately between US$ 2.5 to US$ 3.0 million in cash, a balance that should approximately exist at the date of the complaint, whether in cash or securities; however, his investment account abroad does not register funds;
- The Complainants additionally maintain that although they requested from GPI SAB various information about their operations; they have only been sent information regarding the securities (PPX) they have in CAVALI S.A. ICLV (hereinafter, CAVALI);
- On February 10, 2016, by Official Letter No. 840-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB was requested for information and documentation related to the Complainants regarding the facts denounced by them. In this regard, GPI SAB presented its comments and information previously requested by letter of February 18, 2016;
- On April 14, 2016, by Official Letter No. 2171-2016-SMV/10.3, the documentation and information presented by the Complainants on April 6, 2016 was transferred to GPI SAB and it was required to present additional documentation and information. Consequently, by letter received on April 28, 2016, GPI SAB responded to the mentioned official letter;
- As a result of the aforementioned and under the provisions of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amendatory norms (hereinafter, LPAG), by Official Letter No. 3181-2016-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter Letter of Charges), the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance initiated an administrative sanctioning procedure against GPI SAB, imputing charges for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter RAI), in aspects related to: i) the destination of client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; ii) intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements established in the regulations; iii) using global accounts without observing the required conditions; iv) not delivering account statements; v) not obtaining orders from its clients; and, vi) not delivering policies for the operations carried out;
- By writing presented on June 9, 2016, GPI SAB presented its defenses to Official Letter No. 3181-2016-SMV/10.3. By Official Letter No. 4758-2016-SMV/10.3 of August 25, 2016, it was requested to clarify such defenses without the intermediary having presented any comment regarding the clarifications requested within the period granted for it;
- By Official Letter No. 5517-2016-SMV/10.3 of September 20, 2016, additional charges were sent to GPI SAB regarding the granting of credits to the Complainants without the signing of the respective mutual contract, a situation that was noted from the presentation of its defenses. On October 5, 2016, GPI SAB presented the additional defenses required;
- The charges formulated against GPI SAB and the defenses expressed by the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 851-2016-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in Article 230, subparagraph 2, of the LPAG, by Official Letter No. 6522-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 851-2016-SMV/10.3 was made available to GPI SAB for its review;
- On November 8, 2016, GPI SAB presented its oral report;
II. Issues to Determine
- In the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, hereinafter Sanctions Regulations, by destining client funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, for intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations.
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, for using global accounts without observing the required conditions.
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulations, by not delivering account statements;
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, for granting credits to its clients without the signing of the respective mutual contract as per the regulations;
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, by not obtaining orders;
- Whether GPI SAB incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations, by not delivering policies;
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on GPI SAB for the aforementioned;
III. Analysis
3.1 Applicable Regulations
- Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, applicable at the date of the events, establishes that intermediation agents are prohibited from destining the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted:
“Article 195.- Prohibitions
Stock brokerage firms are subject to the following prohibitions, without prejudice to those contemplated in Article 177 and others emanating from this law:
- Destining the funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
(…)”;
- Likewise, Article 175 of the LMV establishes that intermediation agents are obliged to obtain written orders from their principals, except for other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that the SMV may establish through general provisions;
- Similarly, Article 75, numeral 75.5[1] of the RAI, provided that the Client Registration Form must state the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the intermediation agent and the client, so that they transmit their instructions in the form: written, telephone, telephone with subsequent written confirmation, web applications; and other means authorized by the General Management of CONASEV;
- It should be noted that said numeral 75.5 has been modified by SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01, whose text in force as of February 1, 2013, establishes the following:
- Clear indication of the modality of orders, according to the means agreed between the Agent and its client, so that instructions are transmitted on behalf of the client:
-
- Written;
- Fax, with subsequent confirmation;
- Telephone;
- Applications implemented from the Agent's web page;
- Private electronic communication network with registered users, recognized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision;
- Electronic mail with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation;
- ADM, as established in the Direct Market Access Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 024-2012-SMV/01, or norm that replaces it;
- Intermediated routing in accordance with the provisions in the Integrated Market Routing Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 107-2010-EF/94.01.1; or,
- Other means of communication authorized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision.
The enabling by the Agent of any of these modalities obliges it to implement the corresponding mechanism, which allows subsequent verification by reliable means, of the conditions under which the orders were given.
In case the Agent enables the possibility for its clients to communicate their orders via internet, the obligations that the Agent will assume regarding providing continuity, support and security of that means of communication, as well as the respective contingency plans, must be indicated in the form, which will be established in its Client Policy. (…)”
- Also, Article 77, numeral 77.5 of the RAI states that in the case of non-written orders, it is presumed, unless proven otherwise, that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client;
- On the other hand, the second paragraph of Article 78 of the RAI provides that the record of the order is the only means that evidences the conditions under which it was given by the client and must contain, among others: “78.16. Client's signature, except in the modalities of reception of orders in which it is not necessary, in accordance with the provisions of the client registration form, in which case the Agent must have the respective verification means”;
- Finally, Article 37, numeral 37.5 of the RAI indicates as one of the conditions that the intermediation agent must previously comply with so that it can intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, is: “Each operation intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order”;
- Regarding the intervention of a stock brokerage firm in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments traded abroad, Article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the RAI, establishes that:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is on its own behalf, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements:
37.4.1. Sign a contract with each of the clients who wish it to intermediate this type of operations for them, in accordance with the provisions of Article 40 of this Regulation.
(…)”;
- As for using global accounts, as established by Article 37, numeral 37.4.2 of the RAI, regarding the intervention of a stock brokerage firm in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments traded abroad, it is established that it is a requirement;
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is on its own behalf, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements:
(…)
37.4.2. Have control records of global accounts as established in this Regulation.
(…)”;
- Likewise, Article 90 of the RAI establishes regarding global accounts;
“Article 90.- Content.- The Agent for each Global Account in its name, referred to in numeral 37.4.2. of Article 37 of this Regulation, must implement control records that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts. Likewise, the mentioned records must allow the immediate generation of the following information:
90.1. Movements of securities and financial instruments in the global account.
90.2. Movements of funds related to the global account.
90.3. Balances of financial instruments and funds consolidated and at the level of clients of the Agent.
90.4. Consolidated record of financial instruments and funds related to global accounts.
These records must contain updated information on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account, and if applicable in the information provided by the entity in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account. Likewise, they must be consistent with the policies that the Agent must issue for this type of operations”;
- As for client account statements, the RAI establishes the following;
“Article 82.- Client Account Statement.- The client account statement is a report that shows in detail the movements made during a determined period and the balances of securities, financial instruments and funds in the name of a client.
Each client must have an account statement, which must contain at least the following information for each transaction made:
-
- Transaction date.
- Type of transaction: Purchase, sale, collection, payment, transfer or any other.
- Description corresponding to the type of transaction: The description must be clear and sufficient to identify the nature of the transaction, especially in the case of transfers or others different from purchases, sales, collections or payments.
- Identification of the corresponding document: policy, receipt or other.
- In case of purchase and sale operations of securities or financial instruments, for each of these:
- Denomination of the security or financial instrument.
- The quantity purchased and/or sold.
- Unit price.
- Currency of the transaction.
- Amount of the transaction.
- Monetary balance at the end of each date.
In addition, the client account statement must present separately and clearly, the balance of all securities and instruments owned by the client, under control or responsibility of the Agent, specifying their availability status or any other.
In case a client has more than one identification code for carrying out their operations, the Agent must implement an account statement in which all the referred codes are consolidated.
In the case of financial instruments managed in global accounts in the name of the Agent, the name of the Deposit or Custody Institution of said instruments must be specified.
Article 83.- Availability of the Account Statement.- The Agent must make available to its clients, account statements of their movements and balances of securities, financial instruments and funds, by the means agreed with them, as recorded in the registration form of each client.
Within thirty (30) calendar days after the close of each month, the Agent must prove that it has sent or enabled account statements of movements to its clients, who have carried out any operation during that period, except when said movements are only placements. The Agent must keep a faithful copy of the account statements that were enabled to its clients in magnetic media.
For clients who have not carried out any operation within any of the quarters of each year, and as long as they maintain balances of securities, financial instruments or funds; the Agent must prove when applicable, that it sent or enabled their account statement within thirty (30) calendar days after the close of the quarter.
In no case may the Agent exempt itself from the obligation established in this article, to provide information to its clients regarding their operations, securities and financial instruments”;
- As for the obligation to obtain orders from its clients, Article 175 of the LMV in force until June 25, 2011, established that;
“Article 175.- Written Orders.- Intermediation agents are obliged to obtain written orders from their principals, except for other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that CONASEV may establish through general provisions. Likewise, they must deliver a policy that accredits the operations carried out on their behalf”;
- Likewise, Article 175 of the LMV[2] in force as of June 25, 2011, provides regarding orders the following:
“Article 175. Orders.- Orders are instructions given to intermediation agents, through which their principals manifest their decisions regarding the negotiation of securities or financial instruments and other services they may provide.
Through orders, principals grant a mandate to their intermediation agent to carry out the operations set forth in Articles 194 and 207, as well as for the receipt of benefits, subscription of shares or any other activity related to securities or financial instruments, with prior authorization from Conasev according to subparagraphs t) and i) of said articles, respectively.
Orders empower intermediation agents to exercise the mandate they contain. In the case of subscription of shares, receipt of benefits or other similar, intermediation agents are authorized by the mandate of their principal to act on their behalf without the need for any additional requirement or condition, except those determined by the principal themselves.
In accordance with the preceding paragraphs, intermediation agents are obliged to the following:
- Obtain orders from their principals written or telephone provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification that Conasev may establish through general provisions.
- Implement systems that allow the recording of orders when made by telephone so that they are recorded from the moment they are received. For this purpose, they must have a recording system for orders received by telephone, as well as a registration and filing system for them in accordance with the general norms issued by Conasev.
Such recordings, as well as the referred registry, must be kept for five years and made available to Conasev in the manner it establishes through general norm.
From the moment the principal gives the order by telephone, it is understood that they have been previously informed of the conditions of registration of the orders given through this means, as well as the acceptance of the corresponding recording.
- Use only systems, as well as means of reception and registration of orders authorized by Conasev.
Likewise, intermediation agents must make available to their principals the policy that accredits the operations carried out on their behalf”;
- In turn, Article 37, numeral 37.5 of the RAI states:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.5. Each operation intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order”;
- As for the obligation to make available to the client the respective policies, the RAI establishes the following:
“Article 79.- Policy.- The Agent for each operation it intermediates must issue the respective policy and make it available to the corresponding client, within a period no greater than three (03) days following the execution of the operation.
The Agent is responsible for ensuring that the policies delivered to its clients bear the signature of a Representative or Manager.
Article 81.- Policies for Foreign Operations.- In the case of operations executed in foreign markets, the Agent must issue a policy for each client, corresponding to each order executed through a foreign broker.
In these policies, in addition to the information detailed in the preceding article, the Agent must disclose:
81.1. Regarding the stated price, it shall indicate whether it is the price of the original operation obtained abroad, or if it is an average price assigned by the Agent. In the latter case, the list of prices and corresponding quantities shall be detailed.
81.2. The commission of the foreign intermediary and of any other foreign entity, if applicable.
81.3. The net commission corresponding to the Agent";
- Finally, regarding the granting of credits to clients with outstanding debt, Article 194, paragraph m) of the LMV states:
"Article 194.- Operations
Brokerage firms are authorized to carry out the following operations:
(…)
m) Grant credits, with their own resources, solely for the purpose of facilitating the acquisition of securities by their principals, whether or not listed on the stock exchange and with the guarantee of such securities;
(…)”;
- In accordance with the LMV, Article 51 of the RAI establishes the following:
"Article 51.- The Agent may grant credits to its clients only so that they can acquire securities or financial instruments through it.
To do so, the Agent must sign a loan agreement with its client, in which all the conditions of the credit shall be established";
- Through Official Letters No. 3181-2016-SMV/10.3 and No. 5517-2016-SMV/10.3, the following charges were imputed to GPI SAB:
- For allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, thereby contravening the provisions of Article 195, literal a) and Article 175 of the LMV, as well as Article 37, numeral 37.5, Article 75, numeral 75.5, Article 77, numeral 77.5 and Article 78, second paragraph of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a very serious infraction: "Allocating funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
- For intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations, failing to comply with the provisions of Article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a very serious infraction: "Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations";
- For using global accounts without observing the required conditions, failing to comply with the provisions of Article 37, numeral 37.4.2 and Article 90 of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a serious infraction: "Using global accounts without observing the conditions required by the regulations or for purposes other than the corresponding one";
- For not delivering account statements, failing to comply with the provisions of Articles 82 and 83 of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a serious infraction: "Failing to send clients the information to which it is obligated, or not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations";
- For having granted credits to clients without the signing of the corresponding loan agreement, contravening the provisions established in Article 51 of the RAI; therefore, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a serious infraction: "Carrying out special operations without having the respective authorization from the SMV or without observing any of the conditions or formalities required for it";
- For not collecting orders from its clients, failing to comply with the provisions of Article 175 of the LMV and Article 37, numeral 37.5 of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a minor infraction: "Not collecting orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene";
- For not delivering policies, failing to comply with the provisions of Articles 79 and 81 of the RAI. In this regard, GPI SAB would have incurred the infraction provided in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations, which establishes as a minor infraction: "Not delivering policies to its clients for the operations carried out.";
- Charges, Discharges of the Administered and Evaluation thereof
- CHARGE: allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
- According to the provisions in the Charge Letter, in the complaint of January 28, 2016 filed before the SMV by Mr. Gleiser, on behalf of the Complainants, the following was stated: "I have been withdrawing approximately US$ 1,800,000.00 of the money I delivered including the shares listed on the Lima stock exchange, leaving a constant investment balance in the GPI omnibus account of approximately between US$ 2,500,000.00 and US$ 3,000,000.00 in cash. I should have at this date, approximately, said money, in cash or securities, however at this date I have no funds in my investment account abroad";
- On February 3, 2016, the Complainants supplemented their complaint by presenting the evidence they consider would support what was stated therein, in numeral 7 of which they indicate they attach "3 groups of Excel sheets with 5, 5 and 4 pages made by Abraham Gleiser with the information that Mr. Ucelli gave me of my accounts in GPI where it is shown that there were up to more than 2,654,000 dollars as of June 2012 and 2013 additionally to shares of my property";
- On May 11, 2016, the Complainants presented an additional group of Excel sheets that would support that as of October 16, 2012 they had a fund balance of US$ 2,180,735.00 and additionally the ownership of 2,500,000 common shares issued by Sienna Gold Inc. (SGP), 14,800 units issued by the ETF Daily Gold Miners Index Bull 3x Shares (NUGT), as well as the position as sellers of put options (PUT) of the NUGT security with expiration in December 2012;
- According to the information in the file, from January 25, 2008 to June 12, 2012 the Complainants delivered to GPI SAB a total of US$ 2,632,384.86, of which US$ 2,432,384.86 have been verified in documentation submitted by both the Complainants and GPI SAB and US$ 200,000.00 have been verified in documentation submitted by the Complainants, with GPI SAB yet to confirm the receipt of these last funds, in order to carry out operations in the foreign market. Said delivery of money was made through transfers made to accounts opened in the name of GPI SAB at foreign intermediaries Barclays PLC (which acquired Lehman Brothers), Interactive Brokers LLC and Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, accounts in which funds and securities of GPI SAB clients are managed, or to the intermediation account of GPI SAB at Banco Financiero, credited by the Complainants through the presentation of copies of money transfer request forms to the depositary banks of the funds, signed by the Complainants, and copies of interbank transfer vouchers, according to the detail shown in Table No. 1;
TABLE No. 1
BALANCES AND MOVEMENTS OF FUNDS OWNED
BY CLIENTS (IN US$)
| | | | |
|---|
| DATE | DELIVERY OF CLIENT MONEY TO GPI SAB 1 | DESTINATION ACCOUNT OF FUNDS DELIVERED BY CLIENTS 1 | DELIVERY OF MONEY FROM GPI SAB TO CLIENTS OR THIRD PARTIES 1 | CASH BALANCE 2 |
| From 01/25/2008 to 06/12/2012 | 123,486.26 | Account at Barclays3 | | |
| 35,000.00 | Account at Barclays 4 | | | |
| 1,879,810.00 | Interactive Brokers 5 | | | |
| 200,000.00 | Morgan Stanley | | | |
| 321,500.00 | Operating Account of GPI SAB at Banco Financiero | | | |
| 72,588.60 | Undocumented | | | |
| BALANCE AS OF 06/12/2012 | 2,632,384.86 | - | 1,644,537.80 | 2,614,058.11 |
| OTHER FUND MOVEMENTS | | | | |
| 09/10/2012 | - | - | 100,000.00 | |
| 10/16/2012 6 | - | - | 336,000.00 | |
| BALANCE AS OF 10/16/2012 | 2,632,384.86 | - | 2,080,537.80 | 2,180,735.00 |
| OTHER FUND MOVEMENTS | | | | |
| 01/09/2013 | 79,658.00 | Undocumented | - | |
| 04/23/2014 | - | - | 7,500.00 | |
| 06/11/2014 | - | - | 4,900.00 | |
| 07/02/2014 | - | - | 5,241.00 | |
| 08/12/2014 | - | - | 6,169.00 | |
| TOTAL FUND MOVEMENTS | 79,658.00 | - | 23,810.00 | |
1. Verified with documentation submitted by GPI SAB and the complainants.
2. Cash balance as of 06/12/2012 and 10/16/2012, indicated by the complainants in their complaint.
3. Account No. 743-13302 in the name of GPI SAB at Lehman Brothers (now Barclays).
4. Money was initially deposited in Checking Account No. 044-000317885723 at Banco Financiero (Operating Account of GPI SAB).
5. Account No. U671830 in the name of GPI SAB at Interactive Brokers.
6. Amount transferred to Norton Rose Canada LLP Dollar Trust Account for the subscription of 1,120,000 common shares issued by Sienna Gold Inc.
1. Regarding the amount of cash and date indicated by the Complainants, it is observed in the two groups of Excel sheets presented by them in their complaint, that as of June 12, 2012 the exact cash balance amounted to US$ 2,614,058.11. It should be noted that said date as well as the cash balance coincide with what was indicated by GPI SAB[3] in three of the four groups of Excel sheets of the document called "Summary of Activity of the Account of Messrs. Gleiser in the foreign market" (hereinafter, Summary of Activity), according to Annex 1-C of its writing of February 18, 2016;
2. Consequently, as observed in Table No. 1, according to the documentation presented by GPI SAB and the Complainants, from January 2008 to June 12, 2012 the latter have delivered to GPI SAB the sum of US$ 2,632,384.86 and this brokerage firm has delivered to clients or third parties, with their authorization, the sum of US$ 1,644,537.80. After these fund movements, the Complainants possessed as of June 12, 2012 a fund balance in their favor amounting to US$ 2,614,058.11. Additionally, as observed in Table No. 2, as of this date the Complainants were owners of the following shares: 1,380,000 SGP, 250,000 SUE[4] and 5,000 NUGT, as well as they had positions as sellers of PUT of the NUGT security with expirations in July and September 2012;
TABLE No. 2
BALANCES AND MOVEMENTS OF SECURITIES OWNED
BY CLIENTS
| | | | |
|---|
| DATE | SGP | SUE | NUGT | OPEN POSITION IN PUT OPTIONS OF NUGT |
| BALANCE AS OF 06/12/2012 | 1,380,000 | 250,000 | 5,000 | *Sale of 72,000 PUT at $25, exp Sep 2012. *Sale of 85,000 PUT at $16; exp Jul 2012 |
| SECURITIES MOVEMENTS | | | | |
| 07/12/2012 | - | - | 3,800 | VARIOUS |
| 08/16/2012 | - | - | 6,000 | |
| 10/16/2012 | 1,120,000 | -250,000 | - | |
| TOTAL SECURITIES MOVEMENT | 1,120,000 | -250,000 | 9,800 | VARIOUS |
| BALANCE AS OF 10/16/2012 | 2,500,000 | 0 | 14,800 | *Sale of 66,000 PUT at $25, exp Dec 2012. *Sale of 81,200 PUT at $16, exp Dec 2012. |
- Likewise, in Table No. 1 it is observed that according to the documentation presented by the Complainants and GPI SAB, as of October 16, 2012 the former had delivered to GPI SAB the sum of US$ 2,632,384.86 and this brokerage firm has delivered to the Complainants or third parties, with the authorization of the former, the sum of US$ 2,080,537.80, which includes a transfer of an amount of US$ 336,000.00 to a foreign entity to settle the purchase in the name of the Complainants of 1,120,000 SGP shares;
- After the movements of funds, securities and financial instruments, observed in the Excel groups presented by the Complainants on May 11, 2016, which also appear in the Summary of Activity presented by GPI SAB, the Complainants possessed as of October 16, 2012 a fund balance in their favor amounting to US$ 2,180,735 and additionally, as observed in Table No. 2, they were owners of 2,500,000 SGP shares and 14,800 NUGT, because they sold the 250,000 SUE shares. Likewise, they had positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012;
- It should be noted that the Complainants do not question the balance of 2,500,000 SGP shares[5]; however, they state that they should also have 14,800 NUGT purchased up to October 16, 2012. Likewise, the Complainants indicated that they would not have information on the settlements of their positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012, which appears in the group of Excel sheets presented on May 11, 2016;
- Regarding their balance of funds, securities and financial instruments, the Complainants state that they have no funds in their investment account abroad nor do they have the 14,800 NUGT shares or other securities, which has not been disproven by GPI SAB in the preliminary investigation stage;
- On this matter, in the preliminary investigations derived from the complaint filed by the Complainants, it has been learned that in the Accounting Registry administered by CAVALI, since February 29, 2016 GPI SAB has registered in its parent account 255 NUGT owned by the Complainants, which has not been indicated by said brokerage firm in the preliminary investigation stage, so the relationship it would have with the NUGT securities and the seller position of PUT options of the NUGT security held by the Complainants as of October 16, 2012 is unknown, taking into consideration also that after this date the issuer of these securities has carried out up to three (03) times "reverse split", which is a corporate process that implies the decision to reduce the number of securities in circulation, so GPI SAB was requested to specify said situation in the response to the Charge Letter;
- Likewise, after October 16, 2012, as is verified with the documents presented by GPI SAB and the Complainants, the latter made on January 9, 2013 an additional deposit to the accounts of GPI SAB for the sum of US$ 79,658.00 and the brokerage firm, with authorization from the Complainants, delivered money to them or to third parties at the indication of the former, on different dates between April 23 and August 12, 2014 for a total amount of US$ 23,810.00. In this regard, the relationship of these fund movements with the operations carried out by GPI SAB on behalf of the Complainants is unknown;
- Regarding the instructions given by the Complainants for carrying out operations in the foreign market with the funds entrusted to GPI SAB after October 16, 2012, it should be noted that the "Client Registration Form" of the Complainants signed on October 2, 2010, states that the order transmission modality agreed between GPI SAB and the clients is "other modality subject to confirmation and verification";
- According to what was stated by GPI SAB in its writing submitted on February 18, 2016, "...the clients did not opt for the type of orders: telephone with written confirmation, "email" with written confirmation, written, or fax; this was because Mr. Gleiser appeared at the offices of the brokerage firm to carry out his operations in his own and direct manner, through the trading desk";
- Likewise, through a writing submitted on April 28, 2016, GPI SAB stated that the operations with ETF and derivatives (not offered or traded in the country), were carried out directly in the foreign market, so that no policies were issued because GPI SAB did not provide the intermediation service. For these same reasons, GPI SAB states, the orders were not issued either;
- Therefore, because there is no record of the orders given by the Complainants, it has not been proven that GPI SAB received instructions from them for carrying out all or part of the operations carried out in the foreign market after October 16, 2012, or that all or part of these operations were carried out according to the specific conditions given by the Complainants;
- Likewise, it is also not proven that the Complainants received the policies for foreign operations carried out on their behalf and that they received funds or securities from the settlement of the operations carried out, other than those that are duly proven and shown in Table No. 1;
- From the above, it should be noted that the regulations cited in this charge establish that intermediation agents are obligated to collect orders from their clients in order to carry out operations in the foreign securities market on their behalf, in accordance with the order instruction modality indicated in the Client Registration Form and in accordance with the provisions of the RAI. In the case analyzed, as stated, GPI SAB has not been able to prove the existence of orders that support the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants with the funds entrusted by them to GPI SAB;
- In this regard, it is found that the Complainants state that they had a cash balance since October 16, 2012 amounting to US$ 2,180,735.00, as well as they were owners of 2,500,000 SGP, 14,800 NUGT and had positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012; after this date, it is only proven that the Clients deposited additionally US$ 79,658.00 to the account of GPI SAB and this intermediary delivered to the Complainants the sum of US$ 23,810.00, and that since February 29, 2016 this intermediary has registered in its parent account of the Accounting Registry administered by CAVALI 255 NUGT owned by the Complainants;
- Therefore, according to the imputed charge, the Complainants should currently have US$ 2,180,735.00 in cash balance and 2,500,000 SGP and 14,800 NUGT or, as a result of subsequent cash inflows and outflows, of operations carried out with these balances of funds and securities, of settlements of positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012, or with a combination of cash balance and balance of securities and financial instruments, which has not been proven in the preliminary investigations due to the non-existence of orders and policies regarding supposed operations that GPI SAB would have carried out after October 16, 2012, which are shown in the Summary of Activity, and which have been questioned by the Complainants[6];
- Likewise, it should be noted that GPI SAB would not have delivered to the Complainants policies and account statements or other proof of delivery of money that prove the use of the funds entrusted by them in returns to the Complainants or in purchases of securities and financial instruments, or other authorized purposes; likewise, it should be mentioned that, to date, GPI SAB has not sent said documentation to this Superintendency;
- Therefore, considering that the Complainants state that they have no funds or securities in their account at GPI SAB destined for operations in the foreign market, which has not been disproven by GPI SAB, with the exception of the ownership of 2,500,000 SGP shares, GPI SAB would have allocated to purposes or ends other than those for which they were entrusted the following: US$ 2,180,735.00 and 14,800 NUGT shares, or the cash and securities balance resulting from the settlements of positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012 to operations;
- Consequently, an infraction was imputed to GPI SAB for the provisions established in Article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, for allocating the funds or securities owned by the Complainants to operations, ends or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
Discharges
- In its discharge writing, GPI SAB states that the funds were allocated to fulfill purchase obligations assumed by Mr. Gleiser through the sale of PUTs;
- GPI SAB states that a sold position of a PUT contract represents an obligation to purchase the asset at a set price (exercise price) and up to a determined date (expiration date). Therefore, these sold positions that the complainant accepts having at that date imply a purchase obligation equivalent to US$ 2,949,200 in NUGT that the client also accepts having;
TABLE GPI SAB No. 1
| | | |
|---|
| DETAIL OF NUGT PURCHASES | | | |
| Execution of purchase obligations resulting from sale of PUTs, after 10/16/2012 | | | |
| DATE | NO. SHARES | PRICE | TOTAL US$ |
| 11/22/2012 | 17,700 | 25 | 442,500 |
| 01/08/2013 | 8,800 | 25 | 220,000 |
| 02/18/2013 | 36,400 | 16 | 582,400 |
| 02/18/2013 | 1,200 | 25 | 30,000 |
| 02/26 AND 02/27/2013 | 38,700 | 25 | 967,500 |
| 102,800 | | 2,242,400 |
- Regarding the fact that the complainant says "(…) not having information on the settlements of his positions (…)" of PUTs, with the tenor of the following emails between Mr. Gleiser and GPI SAB (which GPI SAB attaches as annexes to its brief of defenses), they demonstrate that this statement lacks truthfulness;
- GPI SAB points out that on November 22, 2012, a part of the purchase obligation is executed. That is, the Complainants bought 17,700 shares of NUGT at US$ 25 for a total of US$ 442,500.00. As recorded in GPI SAB's email records, that information was delivered to Mr. Gleiser and received by him;
- As proof that Mr. Gleiser was perfectly aware and informed of the situation of his purchase obligations, GPI SAB points out that on November 27, 2012, said client sent them an email requesting to change the maturities of the positions. In said email, he asks GPI SAB to do the "rollover" (that is, change the option positions to a later date) and instructed them to do it since he would be traveling and specified prices and new maturity dates to March 2013. (As support for this, GPI SAB presented a copy of said email);
- GPI SAB states that on January 8, 2013, the PUT option was executed and consequently 8,800 shares of NUGT were acquired at $25 for a total of $220,000.00; that in the same sense, on February 18, 2013, 36,400 shares of NUGT were acquired at $16 for a total of US$ 582,400.00, additionally that same day, 1,200 shares of NUGT were acquired at $25 for a total of US$30,000.00. Likewise, it indicates that Mr. Gleiser was informed that the new total balance of NUGT was 78,900 shares[7];
- GPI SAB adds that on February 26 and 27, 2013, new executions of the sold PUT options are made and consequently 38,700 shares of NUGT were acquired at US$25 for a total amount of US$ 967,500.00. Additionally, on March 5, 2013, Mr. Gleiser was informed, via email, of such executions as a complement to the information that had already been provided to him personally. As of that date, the total balance of NUGT that the client had was 117,600 shares;
- In this way, GPI SAB points out that the aforementioned information demonstrates that the total cash balance of the Complainants as of October 16, 2012 (US$ 2,180,735) was destined to meet said purchase obligations assumed by Mr. Gleiser, which he now intends to ignore;
- GPI SAB specifies that the full and permanent knowledge of the destination of the resources is corroborated by the gloss of what was declared by the complainant, which is recorded in the third paragraph of page 3 of the Letter of Charges.
"On February 3, 2016, the Clients complement their complaint by presenting the evidence they consider would support what was indicated therein, in whose numeral 7 they indicate that they attach "3 groups of Excel sheets with 5, 5 and 4 pages made by Abraham Gleiser with the information that Mr. Ucelli gave me of my accounts in GPI where it is shown that there were up to more than 2,654,000 dollars as of June 2012 and 2013 additionally to shares of my property."
- GPI SAB also mentions that it is contrary to common sense to suggest the possibility that an investor gives more than two million dollars to a stock brokerage firm and for almost four years has not destined such resources to invest or, what would be more unusual, that during that period he has not been interested in the destination of the same. It highlights for this the experience and training of the complainant, who even served as a representative of GPI SAB, duly authorized by the SMV, so it does not admit the possibility that the complainant is not interested for four years;
- Regarding the current position of NUGT shares of the Complainants, GPI SAB points out that it is 255 shares that appear in the parent account of GPI SAB in CAVALI and that were transferred at the request of Mr. Gleiser. Of that total balance, 96.7% comes from the applications of purchase obligations for the sale of PUT options;
- GPI SAB indicates that the number of shares has been diminished by the successive "reverse splits" that the value has had and which are perfectly known by Mr. Gleiser. Therefore, the complainant cannot pretend that he "should" have a balance in NUGT whose number of shares is the same as in October 2012, the detail of the balance being as follows;
GPI SAB TABLE No. 2
| | |
|---|
| CONCEPT | DATE | QUANTITY |
| Initial quantity applied by PUTs | | 117,600 |
| Applied by PUTs | | 4,400 122,000 |
| Rev Split 1 x 5 | 04/02/2013 | 24,400 |
| Purchase | 05/30/2013 | 80 |
| Purchase | 06/23/2013 | 1,040 |
| Balance | | 25,520 |
| Rev Split 1 x 10 | 08/20/2013 | 2,522 |
| Rev Split 1 x 10 | 10/01/2013 | 255 |
| Total | | 255 |
- On the other hand, without prejudice to what is expressed, GPI SAB specifies that the investments made by the Complainants do not fall within the scope of the RAI regulation on operations in the foreign market, since they are not cash operations nor are they destined to securities or instruments provided for in the RAI, as established by numerals 2.11, 2.28 and 2.29 of article 2 of the RAI and numeral 28.2.3 of the same[8];
- Likewise, GPI SAB points out that the exclusion of the operations carried out by the Complainants from the current regulatory framework is corroborated by the fact that in article 2 of the RAI that will enter into force in January 2017, the distinction of instruments and securities made by the legislator in numerals 2.11, 2.28 and 2.29 of the current RAI is not made;
Article 2.- Terms and Definitions
For the purposes of this Regulation, the terms and definitions indicated have the following scope: (…)
k) Financial Instruments: For the purposes of this regulation, the term financial instruments comprises securities and other instruments representing the liability or equity of an entity, financial derivatives, repurchase operations or other financial operations; (…)
- GPI SAB indicates that the definition given by the new RAI to the term Financial Instruments with the final allusion to "other financial operations" reveals the purpose of making the application of the regulations more dynamic, comprising the greatest diversity of instruments and securities mentioned in the current RAI, it being valid to infer that the operations of the Complainants (options) are not included in the current regulations, even more so if these have not been cash, as currently provided;
- GPI SAB adds that the charge is based on the non-existence of orders and policies that accredit the movement of funds and securities of the Complainants, which, in its understanding, departs from the requirement or objective element of the sanctionable assumption, that is, that there is a specific instruction on the part of the client (specific operation or mere custody, which, by the way, the Complainants have not expressed) and that they intentionally have breached it;
- GPI SAB points out that an infraction whose configuration requires acts that configure it cannot be supported by an omission and that this reverses the burden of proof (disregarding the principle of lawfulness), it being necessary to accredit that the Complainants were required to support their indications or explain the reasons or circumstances for which they were not interested in their funds for almost four years, adding GPI SAB that this is supported by numeral 77.5[9] of article 75 of the RAI, so the Complainants should have accredited the instructions that GPI SAB supposedly did not comply with;
- Therefore, GPI SAB considers that, strictly speaking, the charge would be supporting the non-existence of policies and orders, which in the regulatory framework mentioned in the charge referred to the latter, would also not be enforceable, due to the characteristics of the operations of the Complainants;
- GPI SAB concludes by indicating that it is not true that the Complainants ignore the destination of their funds or, even more, that it has not acted for their account and risk;
Analysis of the defenses
On the destination of the funds delivered
- In the present case, as indicated in the Letter of Charges, the Complainants had as of October 16, 2012 a balance of funds in their favor amounting to US$ 2,180,735.00 and additionally they were owners of 14,800 NUGT and 2,500,000 SGP. Likewise, they had positions as sellers of 660[10] put options (PUT) of the NUGT value at the exercise price of US$ 25 with maturity in December 2012 and 812 PUT of the NUGT value at the exercise price of US$ 16 with maturity in December 2012;
- In this sense, taking into account these considerations and based on the provisions of article IV, numeral 1.11 of the LPAG referring to the principle of material truth; the defenses of GPI SAB and the information of the Activity Summary sent by this stock brokerage firm and by the Complainants in the preliminary investigation stage will be evaluated, in order to determine if with the evidentiary documentation and information in the file, GPI SAB has complied with the will of the Complainants and if it has destined their funds and securities as of October 16, 2012 or the securities or funds received as a consequence of the intermediation activities, to operations or purposes for which they were entrusted to GPI SAB;
- Next, the holding of financial instruments and funds owned by the Complainants from October 16, 2012 to date will be analyzed, also taking into account that to determine the total balance of funds and financial instruments, the information contained in the Activity Summary, the holding of securities in the name of the Complainants in CAVALI, in the information and documentation in the file and in information whose source is financial web pages regarding the negotiation of securities and financial instruments (http://finance.yahoo.com and http://www.splithistory.com) will also be evaluated;
- SGP Value
- It should be indicated that the ownership of the 2,500,000 SGP has not been questioned by the Complainants;
- NUGT Value
- The Complainants indicate that as of October 16, 2012 they had 14,800 NUGT;
- Regarding the 660 NUGT PUT Option Contracts
- As of October 16, 2012, the Complainants acknowledge that they had the sale position of 660 "NUGT put option contracts at the exercise price of US$ 25 with maturity in December 2012" (hereinafter, PUT NUGT Dec$25);
- GPI SAB points out in its defenses that a sold position of a PUT contract represents an obligation to purchase the underlying asset at an established price (exercise price) and until a determined date (maturity date);
- This defense is supported by financial theory and the operation of options internationally; that is, each buying counterparty of a PUT NUGT Dec$25, which the Complainants sold, had the right but not the obligation to exercise their option to sell NUGT; for example, if the price of NUGT in the spot market was below the exercise price of the PUT option, each buying counterparty had the incentive to exercise on the maturity date or before the maturity date[11], their option to sell NUGT at the exercise price and the selling counterparty of the PUT options, in this case the Complainants, had the obligation to buy NUGT at the exercise price[12];
First execution of PUTs
- As GPI SAB points out, on November 22, 2012, a part of the PUT NUGT Dec$25, sold by the Complainants, is executed, that is, the counterparty(ies) exercise their option to sell the NUGT securities, so the Complainants had to buy on said date 17,700 NUGT at the price of US$25 for a total amount of US$ 442,500.00;
- As observed in Graph No. 1, as of November 22, 2012, the NUGT quote in the spot market was at approximately US$ 12, an incentive for the counterparties to exercise their option to sell NUGT at the exercise price amounting to US$ 25;
Graph No. 1
- Regarding the order record, it should be noted that in this case an instruction or conformity of the Complainants was not required to buy NUGT, because it is a purchase obligation generated at the time of selling the PUT option[13]; that is, it is an obligation that did not need another act for its execution, an operation for which the Complainants received a premium as consideration for selling to the counterparty the option to sell the underlying asset at the exercise price;
- Regarding the policy that should have been generated by said operation, although GPI SAB has not sent such document, it should be noted that GPI SAB in its defenses attaches a copy of an email from Mr. Héctor Ucelli Romero (hereinafter, Mr. Ucelli), representative of GPI SAB, addressed to the email of Mr. Gleiser, through which he informs him regarding the obligatory purchase of 17,700 NUGT at US$ 25 in the name of the Complainants, for the execution of 177 PUT NUGT Dec$25;
"On 11/22/2012, at 09:53, Héctor Ucelli hucelli@gpivalores.com wrote:
Hello Abraham
Yesterday they applied 17,700 NUGT shares from the December $25 puts to us
They are US$ 442,500
We have to see about doing the roll over right away so they don't apply more to us.
Today is a holiday for Thanksgiving, and there is no market tomorrow it only opens half a day and I will not be there.
Let's see about doing it on Monday.
Regards
HU"
Rollover
- As observed in the email, in addition to informing him about the execution of 177 PUT NUGT Dec$25, which are equivalent to the purchase obligation of 17,700 NUGT at the price of US$ 25, Mr. Ucelli recommends Mr. Gleiser to do the "rollover" right away (that is, change the option positions to a later date) so that more PUT NUGT Dec$25 are not executed[14];
- Likewise, GPI SAB attaches a copy of another email dated November 27, 2012, through which Mr. Gleiser sends instructions to Mr. Ucelli (hereinafter, instruction email):
"2012/11/27 Abraham Gleiser agleiser@gpivalores.com
Hello Héctor.
I was there yesterday but I couldn't wait for you any longer since I left on a trip.
- Please I would appreciate it if you do the rollover of the balance of my NUGT at 25 to March.
- Likewise Calls on the 14400 NUGT for March at 21 (pays around 0.55)
- Also the rollover of 82200 NUGT at 16 to March…I see that the difference between buying December and selling March is around 0.85.
- Another is Gleiser Brothers which has nothing and we could do its calls to March 21 as well.
Please let me know by mail…I am in Mexico without a telephone. Tomorrow I will be in Houston and from there I can call you (although only on Thursday)
I await your news please
Abraham Gleiser L";
- Finally, GPI SAB attaches a copy of another email dated December 6, 2012, through which Mr. Ucelli informs Mr. Gleiser of the executions carried out according to his instructions given on November 27, 2012 (hereinafter, execution email):
"From: Hector Ucelli hucelli@gpivalores.com
Date: 2012-12 09:16 GMT-05:00
Subject: Re: Portfolios. December
To: Abraham Gleiser agleiser@gpivalores
Hello Abraham
I pass you the details of the roll overs. The market is very complicated, in some cases the roll over cannot be done even at rates
The roll over of 487 Dec $25 to Mar$25 was $2,678.50
The roll over of 812 Dec $16 to Mar$16 was $62,524
The calls on what was bought impossible to do at these prices. They pay nothing.
It is complicated with the stock at $10 in some cases there will not be much left to pass them to January. As soon as I have the figures I will let you know.
In the EDC ones there will be no problem.
Regards
Hector";
- It should be noted that GPI SAB has not sent the order record with the respective verification means according to the modalities indicated in numeral 75.5 of article 75 of the RAI and established in the Client Registration Form signed on October 2, 2010; however, in the instruction email, Mr. Gleiser sends instructions to Mr. Ucelli to carry out "rollover" operations (repurchase of options that are going to expire and sale of options at another maturity date, in order to postpone the maturity date) with the balance of PUT NUGT Dec$25, which amounted to 487[15] as indicated in the Execution Email;
- Likewise, GPI SAB has not sent the policy that should have been generated by the realization of the "rollover" operations; however, in the Execution Email, Mr. Ucelli informs Mr. Gleiser that he has carried out the "rollover" of the 487 PUT NUGT Dec$25, which meant carrying out a repurchase operation of the 487 PUT NUGT Dec$25 and a sale operation of 487 "NUGT put option contracts at the exercise price of US$ 25 with maturity in March 2013" (hereinafter PUT NUGT Mar$25), so that the maturity of the 487 PUT contracts is changed from December 2012 to March 2013. The result of these operations was as follows:
11/27/2012: Repurchase of 487 PUT NUGT Dec$25 for US$ 627,012.50.
11/27/2012: Sale of 487 PUT NUGT Mar$25 for US$ 629,691.00.
Net Result: US$ 2,678.50 in favor of the Complainants;
- After the "rollover" carried out on November 27, 2012, the new sale position of these options was 487 PUT NUGT Mar$25, which was communicated to the Complainants, through the Execution Email.
Execution of the PUT balance
- Subsequently, because the NUGT quote in the spot market continued to be below the exercise price (See Graph No. 1), the buying counterparties of the 487 PUT NUGT Mar$25 exercised their option to sell NUGT at the price of US$ 25, which generated the purchase obligation of NUGT by the Complainants, on the following dates:
01/08/2013: 8,800 NUGT for US$ 220,000.00.
02/18/2013: 1,200 NUGT for US$ 30,000.00.
02/26 and 02/27/2013: 38,700 NUGT for US$ 967,500.00.
Total: Purchase of 48,700 NUGT;
- Regarding the record of the orders confirmed by the Complainants, it should be noted that in these cases an instruction or conformity of the Complainants was not required to buy NUGT, because, as indicated above, it is a purchase obligation generated at the time of selling the PUT option;
- Meanwhile, GPI SAB has not sent the policies that should have been generated by the realization of NUGT purchase operations as a consequence of the execution of these options; however, GPI SAB attaches another email dated March 5, 2013 in which Mr. Ucelli informs Mr. Gleiser of the option executions up to that date, observing in the table that, according to GPI SAB, was attached to the email, the execution of the 487 PUT NUGT Mar$25, which generated the obligatory purchase of 48,700 NUGT*;*
- Regarding the 812 NUGT PUT Option Contracts
- As of October 16, 2012, the Complainants acknowledge that they had the sale position of 812 "NUGT put option contracts at the exercise price of US$ 16 with maturity in December 2012" (hereinafter, PUT NUGT Dec$16);
Rollover
- As observed in Graph No. 1, the behavior of the NUGT price in the spot market was downward so that by November 2012 the price was also below US$ 16, which was the exercise price of these contracts. In this context, as observed in the Instruction Email, Mr. Gleiser instructs Mr. Ucelli to carry out a "rollover" operation with his position of 812[16] PUT NUGT Dec$16, so that the maturity of the 812 contracts was changed from December 2012 to March 2013 (NUGT put option contracts at the exercise price of US$ 16 with maturity in March 2013, hereinafter PUT NUGT Mar$16), The result of these operations was as follows:
11/28/2012: Repurchase of 812 PUT NUGT Dec$16 for US$ 320,252.80.
11/28/2012: Sale of 812 PUT NUGT Mar$16 for US$ 382,776.80.
Net Result: US$ 62,524.00 in favor of the Complainants.
- After the "rollover" carried out on November 28, 2012, the new option sale position was 812 PUT NUGT Mar$16;
- Regarding the order record with the respective verification means according to the modalities indicated in numeral 75.5 of article 75 of the RAI and established in the Client Registration Form signed on October 2, 2010, it should be noted that GPI SAB has not sent said document; however, the instructions of the Complainants for the realization of the "rollover" are recorded in the Instruction Email;
- Regarding the policy for this operation, it should be indicated that it has not been sent by GPI SAB; however, through the Execution Email they inform the Complainants of the result of the operations;
Execution of PUT
- Because the price of NUGT in the spot market continued below the exercise price of US$ 16, some buying counterparties of the 812 PUT NUGT Mar$16 exercised their option to sell NUGT at the price of US$ 16, which generated the purchase obligation of NUGT by the Complainants:
02/18/2013: Execution of 364 PUT NUG Mar$16: Purchase of 36,400 NUGT for US$ 582,400.00;
- Regarding the order record, it should be noted that in this case, an instruction or conformity of the Complainants was not required to buy NUGT, because, as indicated above, it is a purchase obligation generated at the time of selling the PUT option on November 28, 2012;
- Meanwhile, GPI SAB has not sent the policy of this NUGT purchase; however, it should be noted that in its defenses GPI SAB attaches another email dated March 5, 2013 in which Mr. Ucelli informs Mr. Gleiser of the option executions up to that date, observing in the table that, according to GPI SAB, was attached to the email, the execution of the 364 PUT NUGT Mar$16;
"Hector Ucelli hucelli@gpivalores.com
To Abraham 3/5/13
Abraham
I pass you the table of the position updated with the applications of the NUGT puts.
We need to repurchase the 400 NUGT Mar$16 puts
In the table you can see what the difference is to cover after the repurchase" (highlight added);
Repurchase of PUT
- Likewise, in the email dated March 5, 2013, Mr. Ucelli points out to Mr. Gleiser that 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16 remain to be repurchased. This is explained because, after the execution of 364 PUT NUGT Mar$16, the sale position of 448 PUT NUGT Mar$16 remained as of February 18, 2013;
- Therefore, as observed in the Activity Summary sent by GPI SAB in the preliminary investigation stage, 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16 were repurchased;
02/27-03/10/2013: Repurchase 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16 for US$ 499,425.57;
- Regarding this PUT repurchase operation, GPI SAB has not submitted the order record with the respective verification method according to the modalities indicated in numeral 75.5 of article 75 of the RAI and established in the Client Registration Form signed on October 2, 2010, nor has it submitted the corresponding policy for said operation;
Execution of PUT
- Likewise, as GPI SAB states in its defenses, the purchase of 4,400 NUGT was made by exercising options, which is nothing more than the execution of the balance of PUT NUGT Mar$16[17]:
02/27-03/10/2013: Execution of 44 PUT NUGT Mar$16: Purchase of 4,400 NUGT for US$ 70,400.00;
- Regarding the order record, it should be noted that in this case, no instruction or conformity from the Complainants was required to buy NUGT, because, as previously indicated, it is a purchase obligation generated at the time of selling the PUT option on November 28, 2012;
- Meanwhile, GPI SAB has not submitted the policy for this NUGT purchase;
- According to the analysis previously carried out, Table No. 3 shows the movement of funds and securities from October 16, 2012, the date on which the Complainants acknowledge ownership of funds, securities and position in sold PUT options, until March 10, 2013, when the last option contracts are executed, as well as the respective instruction from the Complainants and communication of the result of the operations;
TABLE No. 3
MOVEMENT OF SECURITIES AND FUNDS (IN US$) OF THE COMPLAINANTS 10/16/2012 - 03/10/2013
| | | | | | | | |
|---|
| Date | Movement of PUTs | Modality of instruction of Complainants' orders | Operation policy or other document informing operations | Purchases of NUGT to fulfill execution of options | Purchase Price | Movement of Funds | Fund Balance | NUGT Balance |
| 10/16/2012 | - | - | | - | - | - | 2,180,735.00 | 14,800 |
| 11/22/2012 | Execution | Not required | Email | 17,700 | 25 | -442,500.00 | 1,738,235.00 | 32,500 |
| 11/27/2012 | Rollover | Email | Email | - | - | 2,678.00 | 1,740,913.00 | |
| 11/28/2012 | Rollover | Email | Email | - | - | 62,524.00 | 1,803,437.00 | |
| 01/08/2013 | Execution | Not required | Email | 8,800 | 25 | -220,000.00 | 1,583,437.00 | 41,300 |
| 01/09/2013 1 | - | - | | | | 79,658.00 | 1,663,095.00 | |
| 02/18/2013 | Execution | Not required | Email | 1,200 | 25 | -30,000.00 | 1,633,095.00 | 42,500 |
| 02/18/2013 | Execution | Not required | Email | 36,400 | 16 | -582,400.00 | 1,050,695.00 | 78,900 |
| 02/27/2013 | Execution | Not required | Email | 38,700 | 25 | -967,500.00 | 83,195.00 | 117,600 |
| 03/10/2013 | Repurchase | ND 2 | ND 2 | - | - | -499,425.57 | -416,230.57 | |
| 03/10/2013 | Execution | Not required | ND | 4,400 | 16 | -70,400.00 | -486,630.57 | 122,000 |
1. A deposit was made by the Complainants
2. Only the email is available through which the representative of GPI SAB communicates to Mr. Gleiser that this repurchase is pending;
1. In this regard, from Table No. 3 the following is observed:
2. For the purchases of NUGT by execution of PUT options, the conformity or instruction of the Complainants was not required, because these clients were obliged to fulfill their counterparts in the foreign market when they chose to sell NUGT at the exercise price.
3. For the "rollover" operations, there are instructions given by Mr. Gleiser through the Instructions Email; it should be noted that the "rollover" operations did not generate a reduction of the Complainants' funds, but rather an increase in funds.
4. However, despite the postponement of the maturities of the option contracts through these "rollover" operations, due to the downward trend in the NUGT price and in compliance with said contracts, the Complainants' counterparts executed their options and chose to sell at prices of US$ 16 and US$ 25, forcing the Complainants to buy NUGT at these prices when in the spot market the price of this security was around US$ 6 (See Graph No. 1).
5. On January 9, 2013, the Complainants made an additional deposit to the cash balance they had as of October 16, 2012, which was also used by GPI SAB in operations on behalf of the Complainants.
6. As of February 27, 2013, the Complainants had 117,600 NUGT, which includes the 14,800 NUGT they had as of October 16, 2012, which has been acknowledged by them, plus the quantities purchased as a consequence of the executions of the sold put options (PUT). Likewise, it should be noted that due to the purchase of these securities, the Complainants' funds (including the additional deposit and the gains from "rollover" operations) as of that date amounted to US$ 83,195.00, that is, US$ 2,242,000.00 had been used in mandatory purchases of NUGT, as observed in Graph No. 2;
Graph No. 2
- After February 27, 2013, when GPI SAB had already used US$ 2,242,000.00 in NUGT purchase operations, the Complainants still had a position of sold PUTs in November 2012 (444 PUT NUGT Mar$13), so they had pending purchase obligations for 44,400 NUGT at the price of US$ 16 if the counterparts chose to execute their purchased put options (PUTs).
- However, all that balance of PUT positions was not executed because GPI SAB repurchased a part of that balance of sold PUTs. Regarding this repurchase operation of 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16 for US$ 499,425.57, there is no explicit instruction from the Complainants; however, there is the email from Mr. Ucelli addressed to Mr. Gleiser on March 5, 2013, through which he indicates that this operation is pending;
- Although the email of March 5, 2013 is an indication that Mr. Gleiser had previously ordered the repurchase of 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16, it will be evaluated below whether the execution of this operation, without instruction from the Complainants, would imply a destination of funds or securities different from that entrusted by the Complainants to GPI SAB;
Regarding the Repurchase of 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16
- As observed in Table No. 3 and Graph No. 2, as of February 27, 2013, almost all of the Complainants' funds, which includes the additional deposit of January 9, 2013 and the gains from "rollover" operations, had been used by GPI SAB without requiring the instruction or conformity of the Complainants, since the NUGT purchases had to be fulfilled by execution of the PUTs sold by the Complainants before October 16, 2012, so the fund balance was US$ 83,195.00 and, as a counterpart to the use of funds, they owned 117,600 NUGT;
- Because the spot market price was around US$ 5 (See Graph No. 1), if the repurchase of these PUTs had not been made, the counterparts would have executed their option and chosen to sell NUGT at the price of US$ 16, which would have forced the Complainants to buy 40,000 NUGT at the price of US$ 16, disbursing US$ 640,000, an amount greater than the US$ 499,425.57 used for the repurchase of 400 PUTs. Consequently, if this PUT repurchase operation had not been carried out, the purchase of 40,000 NUGT by the Complainants would have been mandatorily executed;
- Therefore, even if the Complainants had not given the instruction to repurchase the 400 PUT NUGT Mar$16, it is observed that this operation did not mean a different use of their funds from that entrusted to GPI SAB, since it was a purchase obligation generated at the time of selling the PUT option and, additionally, if this repurchase was not executed, the disbursement of the Complainants' funds would have occurred anyway due to the short position in PUTs that they instructed before October 16, 2012 and postponed in November 2012 with a "rollover". Likewise, the amount of disbursement for the mandatory purchase of 40,000 NUGT would have been greater;
- Likewise, this repurchase of PUT options did not imply the use of the securities that the Complainants had as of February 27, 2013. Regarding the fact that 40,000 NUGT was not mandatorily purchased, it should be noted that this purchase would have been mandatory by execution of sold PUT options and the Complainants' instruction was not to buy NUGT but rather they sold PUTs at the exercise price of US$ 16 hoping that the NUGT price would exceed US$ 16 and the counterparts would not exercise their put option at US$ 16, earning the premium for the sale of the PUTs. In this sense, even if the Complainants had not given the instruction, GPI SAB has not altered the clients' will by not mandatorily buying NUGT and repurchasing the sold PUTs;
- It should be noted that as of March 10, 2013, after the last PUTs were executed and the repurchase of the PUT balance was made, the Complainants' fund balance was negative. That is, after the "rollover" operations and additional cash deposit, which increased the funds; and the execution of PUTs and the repurchase of the PUT balance, which decreased the funds, all of the Complainants' funds had been used and they were also overdrawn with GPI SAB in the amount of US$ 486,630.57;
- Regarding such overdraft situation, it was communicated by GPI SAB to the Complainants through the email of March 5, 2013:
"Hector Ucelli hucelli@gpivalores.com
To Abraham 3/5/13
Abraham
I am sending you the table of the updated position with the applications of the NUGT puts.
We still need to repurchase the 400 NUGT Mar$16 puts
In the table you can see what the difference to cover is after the repurchase" (highlight added);
- It is observed that Mr. Ucelli indicates to Mr. Gleiser to see the "difference to cover after the repurchase", which is precisely the overdraft;
- Regarding a possible destination of securities different from that entrusted to GPI SAB, as of October 16, 2012, the Complainants owned 14,800 NUGT and these were not sold or used for different purposes, but were kept in custody at GPI SAB and formed part of the balance of 122,000 NUGT as of March 10, 2013;
- Therefore, the mandatory purchases of NUGT by execution of PUTs that did not require conformity or instruction from the Complainants, and the repurchase of a balance of PUTs that avoided a greater execution of these derivatives and greater disbursement of funds, explain the use of funds from October 17, 2012 to March 10, 2013;
- Consequently, until March 10, 2013, the Complainants' funds were not used by GPI SAB for operations or purposes other than those entrusted;
- Likewise, because the 14,800 NUGT that the Complainants held as of October 16, 2012 formed part of the balance of 122,000 NUGT as of March 10, 2013, neither were the Complainants' securities used by GPI SAB for operations or purposes other than those entrusted;
Situation of the Complainants' investments from March 10, 2013
- From March 10, 2013, the overdraft of the Complainants' funds is observed, that is, they owed money to GPI SAB as a result of the settlement of operations, and there is no information on other funds deposited by the Complainants after March 10, 2013[18] that cover this overdraft and that also generate a positive fund balance in favor of the Complainants. Therefore, next only the destination of securities will be evaluated to determine if the movements of securities generated funds in favor of the Complainants or if the balance of securities was used by GPI SAB;
NUGT purchase operations
- According to GPI SAB's defenses, after March 10, 2013, two (02) NUGT purchase operations were carried out on behalf of the Complainants;
05/30/2013: 80 NUGT
06/23/2013: 1,040 NUGT;
- It should be noted that GPI SAB has not submitted the order record with the respective verification method according to the modalities indicated in numeral 75.5 of article 75 of the RAI and established in the Client Registration Form signed on October 2, 2010, as well as the policies corresponding to said operations, as well as other documents through which the Complainants have instructed GPI SAB to carry out these operations and these communicate the results of the operations;
- However, it should be noted that these NUGT purchase operations did not imply a use of funds owned by the Complainants, because they were overdrawn with GPI SAB, that is, they did not have money in their favor; on the contrary, they owed money to the stock brokerage firm;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the aforementioned NUGT purchases became part of the NUGT balance owned by the Complainants, which remains in their ownership, according to what is stated in GPI SAB's defenses, which has been verified with the information in the file;
TABLE No. 4
NUGT HOLDINGS OF THE COMPLAINANTS
| | |
|---|
| CONCEPT | DATE | QUANTITY |
| Balance after execution of Puts (See Table No. 3) | 03/10/2013 | 122,000 |
| Reverse Split 1 x 5 1 | 04/02/2013 | 24,400 |
| Purchase | 05/30/2013 | 80 |
| Purchase | 06/23/2013 | 1,040 |
| Balance | | 25,520 |
| Reverse Split 1 x 10 2 | 08/20/2013 | 2,522 |
| Reverse Split 1 x 10 3 | 10/01/2015 4 | 255 |
| Total | | 255 |
1,2 and 3: Source: www.splithistory.com. For every 5 or 10 NUGT securities, the holder is given 1 NUGT security.
4: By mistake, GPI SAB indicated 10/01/2013.
- As observed in Table No. 4, the balance of 122,000 NUGT, which includes the balance of 14,800 that the Complainants acknowledge owning as of October 16, 2012 plus the mandatory purchases of NUGT by execution of the PUTs indicated above, added to the purchases of 80 and 1,040 NUGT, form part of the NUGT balance that currently amounts to 255 NUGT, because the Complainants' holding has been reduced as a consequence of the issuers of these securities carrying out three (03) "reverse split" operations reducing the number of securities in circulation;
- According to the information from the WARI System that provides information from the CAVALI Accounting Registry, the 255 NUGT were registered as property of the Complainants in the parent account of GPI SAB since February 29, 2016 from Depository Trust Company (DTC), a settlement, clearing and custody institution for foreign securities markets. Then, on July 12, 2016, these securities were transferred to the parent account of Kallpa Securities Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A. as property of the Complainants;
- Therefore, and in view of the above, it is reasonable to maintain that the securities owned by the Complainants have not been destined for operations or purposes other than those entrusted, but rather the number of securities was reduced as a consequence of issuer decisions that affected all securities in circulation and as of July 12, 2016 this number of securities continues to be owned by the Complainants in the CAVALI Accounting Registry;
On the regulation applicable to the Complainants' investments
- Regarding the legal analysis of the defenses presented in the sense that the investments made by the Complainants do not fall within the scope of the RAI regulation on foreign market operations, since they are not cash operations nor are they destined for securities or instruments provided for in the RAI, it must be indicated that literal s) of article 194 of the LMV empowers brokerage firms to carry out operations with futures, options and other derivatives, in accordance with the general provisions issued by the SMV;
- Likewise, Chapter II[19] of Title VI called "Special Operations" of the RAI establishes the regulation applicable to brokerage firms for intermediating operations with futures, options and other derivatives contracts;
- On this last point, the RAI states that for the intermediation of derivative operations on own account or on behalf of its clients, the brokerage firm must obtain prior authorization from the SMV, for which it must designate a representative (who must have experience in the matter) and have a model informative format containing information on this type of contracts that it will deliver to each client that orders these operations;
- In short, the LMV and the RAI expressly establish the possibility that brokerage firms may carry out operations with options, futures and other derivatives, indicating, manifestly, that they must comply with certain requirements to be authorized by the SMV before carrying out these special operations;
- This shows that carrying out operations with options is an activity regulated by the regulations and that it was in force at the date of the events (and in force at the date of this Report), so the legal argument that the investments made by the Complainants do not fall within the scope of the RAI regulation is not admissible;
- On the other hand, regarding GPI SAB's statement that derivative operations in the foreign market are not cash operations, citing as support numeral 28.2.3 of article 28 of the RAI, it must be indicated that indeed the financial nature of derivative operations is different from that of a cash operation[20], however this does not mean that they are not regulated by the RAI;
- Indeed, the securities market regulations regulate a distinction between cash operations, whose settlement of securities or financial instruments is made within a maximum period of three days, and forward operations, whose settlement of securities or financial instruments is made within a period greater than that established for cash operations, which may not exceed 360 calendar days;
- Likewise, for example, repurchase operations (later called stock market repurchase operations of securities) in our securities market[21] are those that comprise, in a single act, a sale of securities to be settled within the period established for cash or forward operations, and a simultaneous purchase of securities to be settled within the agreed period;
- In this sense, when article 28.2.3 of the current RAI establishes that intermediation agents may only carry out cash operations with securities and financial instruments traded abroad, it is not referring in turn to the carrying out of forward operations or repurchase operations with securities or financial instruments traded abroad; however, it must be highlighted that such precision does not prevent intermediation agents from carrying out derivative operations both in the domestic and foreign markets, since this type of operations is regulated in the "Special Operations" chapter of the current RAI, as indicated above;
- Indeed, GPI SAB's statement is striking to the extent that it is aware that derivative operations have a different legal nature from cash operations, since it knows, by definition, that derivatives constitute financial contracts and have different execution periods that are standardized in foreign trading mechanisms and that, in the case of Options, the settlement of a premium is required within a period similar to that of a cash operation and at maturity the settlement of operations with the underlying asset may or may not be executed depending on whether or not the Option is exercised;
- Likewise, the argument that the derivative operations carried out by the Complainants in the foreign market do not fall within the scope of the current RAI regulation because they are not cash operations is surprising, since in this way GPI SAB would be stating that it has intervened in the intermediation of operations that are not permitted by current regulations, which would constitute a very serious infraction according to the provisions of Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1[22] of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Therefore, the fact that derivative operations do not constitute cash operations according to the regulations contained in the norm does not imply or constitute a requirement to maintain that such operations are not subject to the provisions contained in the RAI;
- Regarding GPI SAB's statement that numerals 2.11, 2.28 and 2.29 of article 2 of the RAI, which regulates the terms "financial instruments" and "securities", do not contemplate the definition of "financial derivatives", so that operations with financial derivatives do not fall within the scope of the current RAI regulation, it must be indicated that such statement is an erroneous interpretation, because in the "Special Operations" chapter of the current RAI, operations with financial derivatives that intermediation agents may carry out are indeed regulated. Likewise, it must be indicated that numeral 2.28 of article 2 of the RAI defines the term Securities as securities, and article 3 of the LMV, in its second paragraph, establishes that for its purposes, negotiations of rights and indices referring to securities are equated to such securities;
- According to GPI SAB, when citing article 28 of the RAI, the fundamental intermediation activity of brokerage firms is circumscribed exclusively to the segments detailed in said article (referring to the primary and secondary market) and that in the case of securities and financial instruments traded abroad, the current RAI regulation does not include derivative operations such as those carried out by the Complainants, when the RAI that will enter into force as of January 1, 2017 does, and furthermore such operations have not been classified as "cash";
- On this matter, it must be indicated that the current RAI, in the cited article 28 (which is part of Chapter I "General Provisions" of Title V "Framework of Intermediation Activity"), develops the framework of the fundamental intermediation activity of the intermediation agent both in the domestic and foreign markets, whether in the primary or secondary market, establishing even that in the latter market, only securities or financial instruments issued by legal entities may be intermediated and that they may be carried out: (i) in the centralized mechanisms of the stock exchanges; (ii) outside such mechanisms, and, (iii) with securities and financial instruments traded abroad, according to the conditions established in the Title "Framework of Intermediation Activity"[23] and that only cash operations may be carried out. This point (iii) is the main argument that supports, in GPI SAB's opinion, that the derivative operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants are not included in the RAI;
- On this matter, it must be indicated that said article 28 and following of the Title "Framework of Intermediation Activity" regulate the fundamental intermediation activity of intermediation agents both in the domestic and foreign markets. However, it must be specified that the securities market regulation, that is, the LMV and the current RAI, have also established that intermediation agents may carry out operations with financial derivatives, without establishing that for carrying out these financial derivative operations the intermediation agent may bypass the fundamental phases of the intermediation framework such as the reception of orders on behalf of third parties, the execution of these orders in the case of carrying them out in local trading mechanisms, and the allocation of operations to executed orders;
- The opposite would be to maintain that such brokerage firms may carry out financial derivative operations without receiving orders and without accounting to their clients for the operations carried out through respective policies, which would undermine the principle of protection of client investments in the securities market, in which intermediation agents play a fundamental fiduciary role; which in turn would be against the provisions of article 175 of the LMV;
- In this sense, based on the legislation and arguments indicated above, it is valid to maintain that the intermediation activity with financial derivatives is an activity recognized by the regulations and that brokerage firms carry them out validly on behalf of their clients;
- On the other hand, although the new RAI in its literal k) of article 2 when defining Financial Instruments considers financial derivatives, which the current RAI does not do in its terms section, this does not deny the existence of regulation of such financial instruments in the latter regulation in force at the time of the commission of the observed events, in accordance with the application of articles 45 and 46, subsection 72.1.13 of article 72, second paragraph of article 128 and numeral 9 of Annex 9 of the RAI, especially considering that the LMV itself (literal s) of article 194) establishes as a faculty of intermediaries the carrying out of futures, options and other derivatives operations;
- The opposite would also mean that the current intermediation framework of intermediation agents would not contemplate repurchase operations because these are only contemplated in the term "financial instrument" of the new RAI, which is a legal absurdity considering that these operations are regulated and permitted currently;
- Finally, it is appropriate to mention that in addition to carrying out financial derivative operations on behalf of the Complainants, operations were also carried out with other types of financial instruments such as common shares, preferred shares and ETFs, so the argument that the investments made by the Complainants would not be regulated in the current RAI is also refuted;
Of the other defense arguments
- Regarding the other defense arguments referring to discharging the charge on the destination of funds of the Complainants for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, it must be indicated that it is not appropriate to evaluate them in view of the fact that the cited charge has been lifted according to the preceding considerations;
- For the foregoing, it is appropriate to archive the charge subject to analysis of this administrative sanctioning procedure; therefore, it is concluded that in this extreme GPI SAB has not incurred a very serious infraction established in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.1. of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction "To destine the funds or securities received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted";
-
- Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations: Not signing a contract with the client for negotiation abroad
- According to the information in the file, it is appreciated that GPI SAB has intervened, under the modality called "On own account"[24], in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the purchase and sale of various securities and financial instruments*;*
- Indeed, GPI SAB has presented before this Superintendency of the Securities Market the document called Activity Summary (which was attached to the Charge Letter), regarding the operations carried out "On own account" (in the understanding that they were carried out on behalf of the Complainants), in which it is appreciated, among others, the date of the operation, quantity, price and the financial instrument subject to operation, being that in this last item various types of derivatives, shares, etc. are evidenced, all of them traded in the foreign market;
- In this sense, regarding the Complainants, GPI SAB would not have signed with them the contract for carrying out operations in the foreign market, taking into account also that this was requested from the cited brokerage firm through Official Letter No. 840-2016-SMV/10.3 of February 10, 2016, and has not been accredited to date;
- Likewise, it appears in the file that GPI SAB has received funds from the Complainants for carrying out purchase and sale operations of financial instruments carried out from January 2008 to July 23, 2013, according to the Activity Summary and the list of funds transferred by the Complainants to the accounts opened in the name of GPI SAB in foreign intermediaries from January 2008 until July 23, 2013, as shown in Table No. 1 of the Charge Letter, so it can be affirmed that GPI SAB has intervened in the intermediation of securities traded abroad "On own account";
- Accordingly, having intervened in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments "On own account" in the foreign market through the modality of global accounts in the name of GPI SAB, this brokerage firm should have signed with the Complainants the respective contract as established in numeral 37.4.1, of subsection 37.4 of article 37 of the RAI, in which the minimum content referred to in article 40 of said regulation should have been detailed, such as the object of the contract, the client's declaration of knowing the implications of such operations, the responsibility of the brokerage firm, etc.;
Defenses
- GPI SAB states that the investments made by the Complainants are not included in the regulation referred to in article 37 and following of the RAI because they are not cash operations and the instruments subject to the investments are not included in the cited article 37 of the RAI, in accordance with numerals 2.11, 2.28 and 2.29 of said regulation;
- Likewise, GPI SAB indicates that it is only with article 67[25] of the RAI that enters into force in January 2017, that the possibility of processing options operations (such as that of the Complainants) among other derivatives is established, which GPI SAB even considers that a rigorous reading determines that the legislator is providing for these operations only for the domestic market;
- GPI SAB states that in view of the regulatory vacuum evidenced by the operations of the Complainants, in the "private contract for financial advisory and execution of orders in the financial and stock market" entered into with the Complainants, guarantee mechanisms similar to those established in the current regulation are stipulated, even providing for an arbitration process for the resolution of controversies, in accordance with the provisions of article 340[26] of the LMV;
- GPI SAB adds that in order to consider that it has intermediated in the terms established in article 37 of the RAI, it must be taken into account that for the present case the definition of intermediation established in article 29 of the RAI is linked to the segment described in numeral 28.2.3 and as it has indicated, the investments made by the Complainants are not included in the scope of said numeral, so, strictly speaking, the regulation of the cited article 37 of the RAI cannot be applied to GPI SAB;
Analysis of the Defenses
- Regarding GPI SAB's argument that the investments made by the Complainants are not covered by the regulation of Article 37 et seq. of the RAI because they are not cash transactions and the instruments subject to the investments are not included in said Article 37 of the RAI, it must be noted that the legal analysis of the application of the regulation contained in the LMV and the RAI to derivative operations has been duly supported in the analysis of the first charge regarding the destination of funds or securities, and therefore it is not appropriate to issue a ruling on what GPI SAB states on this point;
- On the other hand, regarding the fact that only with Article 67 of the new RAI is the possibility of carrying out operations with options such as those of the Complainants established, it must be noted that Article 194, literal s) of the LMV, in force since December 1996, already contemplated such faculty of brokerage firms to carry out operations with futures, options and other derivatives, which has also been reflected in Articles 45 and 46 of the RAI, among others, so such argument is not admissible;
- Regarding the fact that given the alleged regulatory gap highlighted by the operations of the Complainants, the “private contract for financial advisory and execution of orders in the financial and stock market” entered into with Mr. Gleiser provides for an arbitration process for dispute resolution, in accordance with Article 340 of the LMV, it must be noted that such power of both parties to resort to arbitration is independent of an administrative sanctioning procedure and optional for investors, so its mandatory nature for dispute resolution cannot be alleged;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the contract referred to by GPI SAB, which is in the file, is not signed by the Complainants, and even if it were, it does not limit them from filing respective complaints upon finding evidence of infringement of the regulations governing the securities market;
- Regarding the fact that to consider that GPISAB has intermediated in the terms established in Article 37 of the RAI, the definition of intermediation established in Article 29 of the RAI, linked to the segment described in numeral 28.2.3, does not contemplate the investments made by the Complainants, it should be noted that Article 175 of the LMV provides that it is the agent's obligation to collect orders from its clients according to the order transmission modality chosen by them, and it should be noted that the text of said article in force since June 25, 2011, specifies that through orders the principals express their decisions to trade securities or financial instruments and other services that brokerage firms may provide;
- Likewise, said Article 175 refers that through orders clients grant a mandate to intermediaries to carry out the operations listed in Article 194 of the LMV (where literal s) regarding the faculty of brokerage firms to carry out derivative operations is found). Also, said Article 175 of the LMV provides that it is the agent's obligation to make available to its principals the policy that accredits the operations carried out on their behalf, which include derivative operations since June 26, 2011;
- Similarly, although Article 29 of the RAI states that the intermediation activity that agents will develop in the segments indicated in Article 28 of the RAI, among others, that of securities and financial instruments traded abroad (numeral 28.2.3), is a process that fundamentally comprises the performance of some of the following actions: a) the receipt and registration of orders on behalf of third parties; b) the transmission and execution of orders on behalf of third parties, c) the allocation of operations to executed orders, this regulation does not restrict that the intermediation activity of derivative operations does not comprise those actions or phases of intermediation, since the LMV already states that intermediation agents are obliged to collect orders from their clients for carrying out derivative operations, which is the phase of collecting orders indicated in Article 29 of the RAI;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the LMV obliges the agent to make available to its principals the policy that accredits the operations carried out on their behalf, a document that reflects the result of the phase of allocating operations to executed orders;
- Therefore, the regulation of derivative operations carried out by intermediation agents does not state that they do not have to comply with the fundamental phases of intermediation, which are collecting orders from their clients, executing these orders, and allocating operations to executed orders, since, by mandate of the LMV itself, they are obliged to collect orders from their clients and to deliver policies of the operations carried out, so it is not reasonable to maintain that the execution of orders received from clients and the allocation of these operations to executed orders are not regulated, which are phases prior to informing clients of the execution of their orders through the delivery of policies;
- Likewise, it should be noted that Article 3 of the LMV states that negotiations of rights and indices related to securities are equated to such securities, and that Article 37 of the RAI regulates the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, defining in its numeral 2.28 of Article 2 the term securities as securities, so the scope of Article 37 includes derivatives;
- Consequently, in the case that intermediation agents intervene in the intermediation of derivatives in the foreign market (through foreign intermediaries), the regulation contained in Article 37 et seq. of Chapter III: “Securities and Financial Instruments Traded Abroad”, of Title III of the RAI: “Framework of Intermediation Activity”, is applicable to them, since otherwise derivative operations could be carried out, for example, in a modality unknown to the regulator (understood as the SMV and established in Article 37.1 of the RAI) and through a foreign intermediation agent not supervised by supervisory bodies with functions equivalent to the SMV (regulated in Article 39.1 of the RAI), among other regulatory guidelines aimed at providing protection to the investments of the agent's clients in the foreign market;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should also be remembered that the charge imputed in this point is not restricted only to carrying out derivative operations, as GPI SAB tries to make it appear, but also to the purchase and sale of securities such as shares, preferred shares and ETFs, according to the detail contained in the Activity Summary, regarding which the same observations have also been made, which is why the defense arguments issued by GPI SAB in this charge do not lift the observations regarding the non-compliance of said company with the provisions of Article 37 of the RAI; therefore GPI SAB has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as very serious, typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, which indicates that it is an infraction to “Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations”;
-
- using global accounts without observing the required conditions: Not having the control record
- According to the Activity Summary, it has been evidenced that GPI SAB has intervened, “In its own name”, in the intermediation of operations in the foreign market through the purchase and sale of various securities and financial instruments*,* including shares, ETFs, derivatives, etc.;
- In this sense, it has been demonstrated that with respect to the Complainants, GPI SAB would not have, for each global account in the name of the SAB, the control records of global accounts, which would allow identifying the balances of financial instruments and funds of the Complainants, taking into account also that this was requested from GPI SAB through Official Letter No. 2171-2016-SMV/10.3 of April 14, 2016, and has not been accredited to date, limiting itself to arguing that “the global account does not comprise operations with ETFs and derivatives”;
- Accordingly, having intervened in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments “In its own name” in the foreign market, GPI SAB should have control records of global accounts with respect to the Complainants, from January 2008, when - according to the Activity Summary - the first operations in the foreign market were carried out on behalf of the Complainants, until the operations carried out on July 23, 2013;
- It should be noted that if the global account records had been available, it would have been possible to verify the statement of the Clients who indicate that as of October 16, 2012 they had a balance of funds in favor of US$ 2,180,735.00, plus 2,500,000 SGP, 14,800 NUGT and positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012, purchased in the foreign market up to that date;
- Indeed, and according to the information appearing in the file, GPI SAB has or had accounts with the following foreign intermediaries: Barclays, Interactive Brokers and Morgan Stanley;
- Therefore, it has been accredited that GPI SAB would not have implemented the control records that allow identifying in its global accounts the securities and financial instruments and funds in the name of the Clients, which has not allowed it to generate the aforementioned records immediately;
Regarding the Defenses
- GPI SAB cites part of the imputed charge which, in its opinion, the fact considered an infraction is that “…it has been accredited that GPI SAB would not have implemented the control records that allow identifying in its global accounts the securities and financial instruments and funds in the name of the Clients, which has not allowed it to generate the aforementioned records immediately”;
- Likewise, GPI SAB cites another paragraph of the imputed charge stating “…that if the global account records had been available, it would have been possible to verify the statement of the Clients who indicate that as of October 16, 2012 they had a balance of funds in favor of US$ 2,180,735.00, plus 2,500,000 SGP, 14,800 NUGT and positions as sellers of 66,000 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 25 with expiration in December 2012 and 81,200 PUT of the NUGT security at the exercise price of US$ 16 with expiration in December 2012, purchased in the foreign market up to that date”;
- GPI SAB considers that the previous paragraph reveals a limitation to impute to the SAB that it has destined client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, since the instructor states that the version of the Complainants could not be verified;
- Finally, regarding this charge, GPI SAB states that the contract entered into with the Complainants, as well as the documentation attached on the evolution of their investments, determines that, even though as it has demonstrated, the current regulations are not applicable to the operations carried out by them, the financial instruments and funds thereof are identified;
Analysis of the Defenses
- Regarding the fact that having stated in this charge that “…if the global account records had been available, it would have been possible to verify the statement of the Clients…” (regarding the securities and financial instruments they had as of October 16, 2012), reveals a limitation to impute to the SAB that it has destined client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, since the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance expressed that such version of the Complainants could not be verified, it must be noted that to the extent that the charge for disposition has been lifted, it is not appropriate to issue an opinion on the aforementioned by GPI SAB;
- On the other hand, regarding the fact that the documentation supporting the evolution of the Complainants' investments (referring, we understand, to the Activity Summary) does identify the financial instruments and funds of the latter, it must be noted that this does not negate its legal obligation to have such records, especially since with them the SAB is in a position to support the holding of securities and funds of its clients;
- Indeed, according to the definition of Global Account[27] contained in numeral 2.4 of Article 2 of the RAI, it is one administered by the SAB for the control of operations of its clients in foreign markets, which allows it to identify which clients are the final holders of the rights or obligations related to said account;
- In the present case, according to the Activity Summary, it has been evidenced that GPI SAB carried out various operations with derivatives, shares and other securities in the name of the Complainants abroad from January 29, 2008 to July 23, 2013, which has not been denied by the brokerage firm itself;
- The aforementioned in the preceding paragraph is also supported by the fact that for carrying out such operations, GPI SAB used the global accounts in its name with foreign intermediaries, which is supported by the fact that the Complainants deposited funds in these accounts or the funds were transferred from the intermediation account of GPI SAB to the global accounts;
- In this sense, by not having observed the legal mandate to use global accounts as indicated by the RAI, that is, to have control records of global accounts, and by not having GPI SAB presented arguments demonstrating the contrary, it is determined that said brokerage firm has incurred in one (01) infraction classified as serious, typified in Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, which indicates that it is an infraction to “Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations”;
-
- Not delivering account statements
- According to current regulations, the client's account statement constitutes a means that will show the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments in the name of a client, as well as reflect detailed information to know if the order given by the client was fulfilled in its entirety, that is, if it was bought or sold on the indicated date, at what price, quantity, conditions, among others; and, in the case of operations abroad, the last paragraph of Article 82 of the RAI provides that the name of the depository or custody institution of the financial instruments must be indicated;
- It should be added that Article 83 of the RAI provides the periodicity in which such account statements must be communicated to clients and that in no case can the brokerage firm exempt itself from the obligation to provide information to its clients regarding their operations, securities or financial instruments;
- According to the Activity Summary document, since January 2008, GPI should have sent the Complainants the respective Account Statement informing them regarding the operations carried out both in the foreign and national markets, the balance of securities, financial instruments and available funds as well as all information, in accordance with the cited regulations, that allows them to make adequate investment decisions;
- Upon verification of the documentation in the file, it is observed that GPI SAB has not accredited that it has sent the respective account statements to the Complainants until October 1, 2010, according to the Client Registration Form signed on January 29, 2008, as well as it has not accredited that it has enabled the account statements to be collected by the Complainants at the offices of GPI SAB as of October 2, 2010, according to the Client Registration Form signed on October 2, 2010[28], a situation that was brought to the attention of GPI SAB through Official Letters No. 840-2016-SMV/10.3 and No. 2171-2016-SMV/10.3, requiring in such documents the presentation and proof of receipt thereof, however, GPI SAB has only presented the account statements of the Complainants regarding operations in the national market without the respective proof of receipt;
Regarding the Defenses
- GPI SAB states that according to the Charge Letter, it would have incurred in an infraction by not complying with sending to its clients the information to which it is obliged or not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations;
- Accordingly, since the normative element of the sanctionable assumption is that the omitted or defective information is of a mandatory nature, GPI could not be imputed for the aforementioned infraction, because with what was supported above on the inapplicability of the current regulations to the operations of the Complainants, in the present case GPI would not be required to comply with the aforementioned obligation;
Analysis of the Defenses
- Regarding the fact that GPI SAB was not obligated to deliver account statements to the Complainants because the current regulations are not applicable to its operations, it must be indicated that the application of the current regulation (LMV and RAI) to such operations has already been established in preceding recitals, so it is not appropriate to issue an additional opinion on that argument;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it must be indicated that the third paragraph of article 82 of the RAI expressly states that the client's account statement must present separately and clearly the balance of all securities and instruments owned by the client, which reflects the obligation of the brokerage firm to inform its client of their holdings in both funds and financial instruments, as well as the transactions carried out. In this sense, the intermediary must inform its client of the detail of their entire patrimony at a given date, as well as the movements of operations that explain the composition of the patrimony at a given date, and the regulatory framework does not establish any prerogative that grants brokerage firms the power to determine what they report to their clients at their discretion and what they do not, which would affect the principle of investor protection;
- Indeed, how could the brokerage firm inform, via its account statement, only the detail of the purchase or sale of certain financial instruments and omit others; or how would it inform that out of a total amount of money only 30% was spent, leaving only, for example, 10%; this would generate questioning about the situation of the remaining percentage;
- Moreover, such analysis that GPI SAB intends to validate is also not consistent with the brokerage firm's own internal accounting, since there must always, and without exception, be a reconciliation between the financial instruments (securities and others) and funds of all the firm's clients, that is, there cannot be incomplete records;
- Likewise, it should be noted that the final paragraph of article 82 of the RAI expressly provides that in the case of financial instruments managed in global accounts in the name of the Agent (as in the present case), the name of the depositary or custodian must be specified in the account statement; as well as indicating the provisions of the last paragraph of article 83 of the RAI, which states that in no case may the intermediary exempt itself from the obligation to make account statements available to its clients for the purpose of providing information to its clients regarding their operations; as mentioned, article 194, subsection s) of the LMV states that one of the operations that brokerage firms are authorized to carry out is to perform derivative operations in accordance with the general provisions issued by the SMV; in this case the RAI;
- Finally, it should be recalled that, according to the Activity Summary, GPI SAB not only carried out various derivative operations but also spot operations with shares and other securities on behalf of the Complainants abroad from January 29, 2008 to July 23, 2013, which has not been denied by the brokerage firm itself;
- In this sense, it has been demonstrated that GPI SAB should have sent account statements to the Complainants from the beginning of the commercial relationship between them until the present date, however, it has not proven compliance with such obligation until at least April 2016; therefore, GPI SAB has incurred one (01) infraction classified as serious, typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10, of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it is a serious infraction: “Failure to send clients the information to which it is obligated, or failure to do so in the form and timeframe required by the regulations.”;
-
- obtain orders from its clients
- According to the content of the Activity Summary document, it can be seen that from January 25, 2008 to July 23, 2013, GPI SAB intervened in the intermediation of a series of operations in the foreign market in which financial instruments were bought and sold on behalf of the Clients;
- Indeed, it has been evidenced that for more than five years GPI SAB participated in the intermediation of various operations carried out “In its own name”, in which they issued a series of instructions to effect the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, it being necessary to indicate that from January 25, 2008 to October 1, 2010, according to the information appearing in the client registration forms sent by GPI SAB on behalf of the Complainants, such orders should have been by telephone with written confirmation; and from October 2, 2010 to July 23, 2013 they should have been under a modality denominated by GPI SAB as “subject to verification and confirmation”;
- It should be noted that through Official Letters No. 840-2016-SMV/10.3 and No. 2171-2016-SMV/10.3 of February 10 and April 14, 2016, GPI SAB was requested to present the orders supporting the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants, however, GPI SAB has stated that it does not have such documents, except for the documents supporting the purchase order of 1,120,000 SGP shares made on October 16, 2012 in the private placement process of these shares;
- In this sense, it is reasonable to maintain that GPI SAB received funds from the Complainants, according to the detail mentioned in the charge referring to the disposal of funds for purposes other than those indicated, for the purchase and sale of the financial instruments mentioned in the list of operations referred to in the Activity Summary, therefore, GPI SAB, in accordance with the provisions of article 37.5 of the RAI, had the obligation to have the orders authorizing it to allocate the funds delivered by its clients for the purchase of the respective securities or financial instruments according to the conditions established by them, as well as to have the corresponding orders for the sale thereof. Such orders would not have been obtained by GPI SAB, thus breaching the securities market regulations;
Regarding the Defense Arguments
- In this charge, GPI SAB refers to the support regarding the inapplicability of the current regulations to the operations of the Complainants and to the terms of the contract entered into with them;
Analysis of the Defense Arguments
- Prior to evaluating the defense presented, it must be indicated that GPI SAB, as in the preceding charges, has only formulated defense arguments regarding the operations carried out by the Complainants with derivatives, however, it has not questioned the rest of the operations carried out with shares, preferred shares and other securities issued by foreign issuers and traded in the foreign market, which are described in the Activity Summary since January 29, 2008, which implies a tacit acceptance of the commission of the imputed infraction;
- Regarding the argument that the current regulations are not applicable to the operations carried out by the Complainants, in the understanding of GPI SAB that these operations have been only with derivatives, it must be indicated that such argument has already been refuted in accordance with the analysis of the charge for unauthorized disposal of funds of the Complainants and throughout this Report, which is why what GPI SAB states as a defense does not overcome the charge formulated;
- Likewise, we ratify the fact that the aforementioned contract cited by GPI SAB, which is not signed by the Complainants, does not substitute, in any way, the legal obligations derived from the LMV or the RAI, which is why such argument also does not overcome the present charge formulated;
- On the other hand, it should be noted that article 175 of the LMV expressly and without exception provides that it is the agent's obligation to obtain orders from its clients according to the order transmission modality chosen by them, a legal mandate that has been in force since 1996 to date, it being necessary to indicate that the current text of said article since June 25, 2011, specifies that through the orders the principals manifest their decisions to negotiate securities or financial instruments and other services that the brokerage firms may provide;
- Likewise, said article 175 currently in force refers to the fact that through the orders they grant a mandate to the intermediaries to carry out the operations set forth in articles 194 (where subsection s) relating to derivative operations is found) and 207 of the LMV;
- It should be noted that according to the order reception modality appearing in the client registration forms of the Complainants, from January 25, 2008 to October 1, 2010, such orders should have been by telephone with written confirmation; and from October 2, 2010 to July 23, 2013 they should have been under a modality denominated by GPI SAB as “subject to verification and confirmation”. Regarding this last modality, it should be noted that according to article 175 of the LMV the order reception modalities must be susceptible to subsequent verification;
- In sum, the LMV has provided that brokerage firms must, without exception, obtain orders for all instructions issued by their clients;
- In this sense, it is clear that GPI SAB should have, without exception, required from the Complainants the corresponding orders for each of the operations carried out on their behalf described in the Activity Summary, regardless of whether they were derivatives, securities, or other types of financial instruments; therefore, it has committed one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a minor infraction: “Failure to obtain orders from its clients, whether written or through other modalities susceptible to subsequent verification, in the stock exchange or over-the-counter operations in which they intervene.”;
- It should be noted that it is reasonable to admit, considering the nature of the operation, that only due to the operation of derivatives, GPI SAB is excluded from the obligation to obtain orders from the Complainants in cases of purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments by execution of options, carried out on behalf of the Complainants to comply with the obligation to buy or sell the underlying assets at the exercise price of the option, if the counterparty chose to exercise its option to buy or sell securities or financial instruments[29]; it being understood that this operation is an unavoidable execution as a consequence of the order given by the principal for the sale of put or call options, as the case may be;
-
- Regarding the delivery of policies
- In accordance with the provisions of the preceding points, in the preliminary investigation initiated in response to the complaint filed by the Complainants, through Official Letters No. 840-2016-SMV/10.3 and No. 2171-2016-SMV/10.3, information was requested from GPI SAB regarding the operations intermediated abroad in which said brokerage firm intervened, requesting, among others, a copy of the policies corresponding to such operations as well as the receipts of reception by the Clients;
- Said request referred to the period from January 2008 to July 23, 2013, it being necessary to specify that GPI SAB has only presented a copy of the policies corresponding to operations with the security “PPX.V” (formerly SGP), but not regarding operations with shares, ETFs and derivatives detailed in the Activity Summary;
- On this last point, GPI SAB has stated that no policies were issued because GPI SAB did not provide intermediation services in the aforementioned operations abroad;
- Taking into account the aforementioned regulations, in particular article 81 of the RAI, GPI SAB would have failed to deliver policies to the Complainants for the operations carried out abroad according to the Activity Summary document, therefore it would have incurred an infraction;
Regarding the Defense Arguments
- Regarding this charge, GPI SAB has stated as a defense that it refers to the response it gave to the charge referring to the non-delivery of account statements;
Analysis of the Defense Arguments
- On this matter, it should be noted that the defense argument issued by GPI SAB regarding the non-application of the current regulations to the investments made by the Complainants has already been evaluated and refuted in this resolution, which is why it is evident that GPI SAB has not overcome this charge, thus determining that it has incurred an infraction;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be recalled that article 175 of the LMV provides that it is the agent's obligation to make available to its principals the policy accrediting the operations carried out on their behalf;
- In this sense, regarding operations with shares, ETFs and derivatives detailed in the Activity Summary, it is therefore an obligation of GPI SAB to have sent the Complainants the corresponding policy for each operation carried out;
- Finally, GPI SAB has not questioned the rest of the operations carried out with shares, preferred shares and other securities issued by foreign issuers and traded in the foreign market, which are described in the Activity Summary since January 29, 2008, which implies a tacit acceptance of the commission of the imputed infraction; that is, GPI SAB has incurred one (01) infraction classified as minor, typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a minor infraction: “Failure to deliver policies to its clients for the operations carried out.”;
-
- the granting of credits to clients without the signing of a mutuum contract
- After evaluating the information and documentation presented in the defense arguments submitted on June 9, 2016, together with the Activity Summary, it can be seen that from November 22, 2012 to March 10, 2013, GPI SAB, on behalf of the Complainants, bought NUGT securities, due to the exercise of the counterparty's execution power in the operation with PUTs in which the Complainants participated (that is, the execution is a consequence of the put options (PUTs) on NUGT sold by the Complainants being exercised by their counterparties, generating for the Complainants obligations to purchase such NUGT securities);
- Likewise, in this period, GPI SAB carried out “rollover” operations to postpone the maturity of the option contracts from December 2012 to March 2013, due to the drop in the price of NUGT that caused the put options to be exercised by their buyers until December 2012; and, also, the Complainants made an additional deposit of US$ 79,658.00. In this sense, as of March 10, 2013, the Complainants had a fund balance of US$ 12,795.00 and 122,000 NUGT, as a result of the purchases of NUGT by execution of PUTs*,* as shown in Table No. 5:
TABLE No. 5
MOVEMENT OF SECURITIES AND FUNDS (IN US$) OF THE COMPLAINANTS 10/16/2012 – 03/10/2013
| | | | | | |
|---|
| Date | Operation | Movement of NUGT | Purchase Price | Movement of Funds | Fund Balance | NUGT Balance |
| 10/16/2012 | Balance | 14,800 | - | - | 2,180,735.00 | 14,800 |
| 11/22/2012 | Execution Puts | 17,700 | 25 | -442,500.00 | 1,738,235.00 | 32,500 |
| 11/27/2012 | Rollover Puts | 0 | - | 2,678.00 | 1,740,913.00 | 32,500 |
| 11/28/2012 | Rollover Puts | 0 | - | 62,524.00 | 1,803,437.00 | 32,500 |
| 01/08/2013 | Execution Puts | 8,800 | 25 | -220,000.00 | 1,583,437.00 | 41,300 |
| 01/09/2013 | Deposit of money | 0 | | 79,658.00 | 1,663,095.00 | 41,300 |
| 02/18/2013 | Execution Puts | 1,200 | 25 | -30,000.00 | 1,633,095.00 | 42,500 |
| 02/18/2013 | Execution Puts | 36,400 | 16 | -582,400.00 | 1,050,695.00 | 78,900 |
| 02/27/2013 | Execution Puts | 38,700 | 25 | -967,500.00 | 83,195.00 | 117,600 |
| 03/10/2013 | Execution Puts | 4,400 | 16 | -70,400.00 | 12,795.00 | 122,000 |
- However, according to the movement of operations detailed in the Activity Summary, as of March 10, 2013, 400 PUTs sold by the Complainants with maturity in March 2013 at the exercise price of US$ 16 were still pending execution;
- Regarding these 400 PUTs, no obligations to purchase NUGT were generated, because, as detailed in the Activity Summary, GPI SAB repurchased these 400 PUTs disbursing the sum of US$ 499,425.57; as can be seen, the amount of this repurchase operation of 400 PUTs exceeded the amount available in favor of the Complainants as of March 10, 2013, which amounted to US$ 12,795.00;
- Therefore, to comply with the settlement of this repurchase operation of 400 PUTs, the fund balance of the Complainants amounting to US$ 12,795.00 was fully used and additionally GPI SAB had to disburse US$ 486,630.57;
- This overdraft situation of the Complainants is acknowledged by GPI SAB in the email of March 5, 2013 from Mr. Héctor Ucelli, Representative of GPI SAB, to Mr. Abraham Gleiser, which was attached to the Defense Arguments, whereby it states that there is a difference in funds to be covered by the Complainants:
“Hector Ucelli hucelli@gpivalores.com
To Abraham 3/5/13
Abraham
I am sending you the updated position table with the applications of the NUGT puts.
We still need to repurchase the 400 NUGT Mar$16 puts
In the table you can see what the difference to be covered is after the repurchase”
(highlight added)
- Subsequently, according to the Activity Summary and the Defense Arguments, GPI SAB carried out two (02) purchase operations, one on May 30, 2013 and another on June 23, 2013, of 80 and 1,040 NUGT, respectively, disbursing in total, as detailed in the Activity Summary, an amount of US$ 9,520.00.
- Therefore, as shown in Table No. 6, GPI SAB had to disburse, between March 10 and June 23, 2013, US$ 496,150.57 that were not the property of the Complainants to comply with the settlement of the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants:
TABLE No. 6 (Figures in US$)
| | | |
|---|
| Date | Operation | Movement of Funds | Fund Balance |
| 03/10/2013 | Balance | 0.00 | 12,795.00 |
| 03/10/2013 | Repurchase 400 Puts | -499,425.57 | -486,630.57 |
| 05/30/2013 | Purchase 80 NUGT | -940.00 | -487,570.57 |
| 06/23/2013 | Purchase 1,040 NUGT | -8,580.00 | -496,150.57 |
- That is, GPI SAB would have facilitated mutuum loans of money to the Complainants for the sum of US$ 496,150.57, with the brokerage firm's own resources, however, as mentioned, such situation has not been duly explained by GPI SAB in the defense arguments;
Regarding the Defense Arguments
- Regarding the imputed charge, GPI SAB indicates that the formulation of this charge generates effects with respect to the charge for disposal of funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, since it would be contradictory because in the latter there was talk of detriment while in the present one refers to a benefit in favor of the Complainants;
- On the other hand, GPI SAB considers that the conduct described in the imputed charge regarding the granting of credits to the Complainants without the signing of the respective mutuum contract is circumscribed within what is defined as an uncovered position contemplated in article 87 of the RAI, and article 88 of said regulation excludes the possibility of imputing the existence of a mutuum of money without observing the regulations, since the conversion of the uncovered position into a mutuum of money is left to the will of the brokerage firm;
- Finally, GPI SAB reiterates that the facts considered constitutive of infraction are not comprised within the scope of the current securities market regulations;
Analysis of the Defense Arguments
- Regarding the alleged contradiction between the charge of granting credits to the Complainants without the signing of the respective loan contract and the charge of using funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, it must be indicated that both charges were formulated based on the information in the file at the time of the imputation, so the latter charge was imputed precisely due to the information provided by GPI SAB, whose defenses did not explain, much less support, the creditor balance in favor of the intermediary as a result of the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants, which were only detailed in the defenses;
- The situation described in the preceding paragraph was evidenced not only by the lack of mention of the respective facts, but also by the evidentiary support that every administered party must present in every administrative sanctioning procedure, especially considering that, according to article 56, numeral 2 of the LPAG, it is their duty to provide collaboration for the pertinent clarification of the facts, even more so if they are involved in an administrative sanctioning procedure;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it is appropriate to note that the charge of using funds for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted has been evaluated, concluding that the facts supporting such imputation did not generate an infraction of the regulations governing the securities market;
- On the other hand, regarding the conduct described in the imputed charge of granting credits to the Complainants without the signing of the respective loan contract, being circumscribed within what is defined as an uncovered position, its faculty being to convert such situation into a money loan, it must be indicated that the Uncovered Position is regulated in article 87[30] of the RAI, which specifies, among others, that an operation is uncovered when the obligation to comply with settlement or coverage thereof is borne by the brokerage agent, insofar as the purchase or sale operation has been executed without the latter having received the funds or securities and financial instruments necessary to comply with the settlement of the operation;
- According to the charges formulated, it was observed that GPI SAB, from March to June 2013, disbursed from its own resources US$ 496,150.57 to comply with the settlement of operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants (repurchase of 400 Puts and purchase of 1120 NUGT), however, such situation was not duly explained by GPI SAB in this administrative sanctioning procedure, which is why it was considered that said agent company, using the attribution contained in literal m) of article 194 of the LMV, granted credits, with its own resources, to the Complainants;
- GPI SAB has stated in its defenses of October 5, 2016[31] that the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants that involved a disbursement of US$ 496,150.57 were as uncovered positions according to article 87 of the RAI. In this sense, it must be indicated that article 88 of the RAI states that an Uncovered Position must be maintained until the situation changes, among others, because they become money loans or the uncovered position is settled, recognizing the effects of such settlement;
- In this regard, it should be noted that notwithstanding the provisions of article 195, subsection f), of the LMV, which prohibits brokerage agent companies from executing operations without verifying the existence of the resources and securities to which they refer, situations are observed in which they have been intermediating operations of principals that entail payment risk because they are basically purchase operations, whose non-compliance entails the obligation to cancel said operations with their own resources, thus originating a credit in their favor. This practice is based on the agent's trust in certain principals and on the fact that it maintains under its power the securities purchased with its resources or others that guarantee compliance by the client. In this situation, it is also a fact that the agent and its client have agreed on a credit from the very moment the former admitted the execution of a purchase operation, without the respective delivery of cash by the latter.
- For practical purposes and because in almost all cases the agent carries out the mentioned operations under the assumption that they will be honored by the client before being required, it is admissible that the mentioned agreement does not immediately materialize in a money loan contract, but rather after the credit has effectively been granted when the agent assumes such operations; or, even, that the agent liquidates the client's position, if it is not possible to comply with the formalities established for the loan; situations that are provided for in articles 176 and 194 of the LMV and that should occur immediately, if the agent acts with rationality.
- However, when the non-compliances that become uncovered positions of a certain client have been repeated and the agent has continued executing operations or when it does not liquidate in the shortest term the positions of the defaulting client to its own detriment, despite being empowered by article 176 of the Securities Market Law to do so; the agent's willingness to grant a credit to its client is evidenced. Therefore, it is not a matter of forced credits or temporary non-compliances but of agreed financing or loans;
- In the present case, as detailed in Table No. 06, GPI SAB granted on March 10, 2013 a credit to the Complainants for an amount of US$ 486,630.57, a situation that was maintained until May 30, 2013, the date on which an additional credit of US$ 940.00 was granted. Subsequently, on June 23, 2013, the intermediary financed the complainants with an additional US$ 8,580.00; that is, the intermediary granted a credit to the complainants for a period of more than three (03) months. In this sense, when GPI SAB liquidated the Complainants' operations, they ceased to be uncovered positions, and as article 88, numeral 88.3 states, the effects of such liquidation should have been recognized, that is, in this case, since the credit granted was prolonged over time and article 176 of the LMV was not applied; the respective loan contract should have been signed;
- Therefore, GPI SAB granted credits to the Complainants without having the corresponding loan contract, in which the conditions of the contract are established, including the constitution of guarantees covering the amount of the credit, contravening the provisions of article 51 of the RAI, thereby infringing Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, which establishes as a serious infraction: “Carrying out special operations without having the respective authorization from the SMV or without observing any of the conditions or formalities required for it”.;
IV. Evaluation of the Sanction
- According to article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 230[32] of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification, and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility established in article 236-A[33] of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, which includes the repercussion on the market; c) The economic damage caused; d) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; h) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification; i) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and j) The error induced by the administration by a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision;
- In accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force until April 16, 2012, sanctions imposed during the three (03) years prior to the date on which the infraction was detected are considered as offender's antecedents[34]. Likewise, said provision states that as long as the resolution imposing the sanction is not final, it will not be considered as an antecedent.
- For this particular case, taking into account that the date on which the Office of Charges was notified to GPI SAB was May 30, 2016, it should be noted that GPI SAB presents the following infraction antecedents:
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10 of June 20, 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of four (04) UIT for having incurred two (02) very serious infractions and three (03) serious infractions.
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 023-2014-SMV/10 of November 7, 2014, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a fine of 3.2 UIT for having incurred one (01) minor infraction.
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 034-2015-SMV/10 of December 22, 2015, GPI SAB was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred one (01) minor infraction;
- It should be noted that the sanctions imposed in the aforementioned resolutions became final insofar as GPI SAB did not challenge such decisions. Likewise, it should be indicated that by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10, it was resolved to sanction GPI SAB, among others, for having incurred a serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation for not having control records of global accounts; this being the same infraction type as one of the charges imputed in this sanctioning procedure;
- On the other hand, it must be taken into account that article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation has been modified through SMV Resolution No. 006-2012/SMV.10.1, in force as of April 17, 2012, which provides that sanctions imposed by the SMV and that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction are considered antecedents;
- For the present case, taking into account the oldest operation of May 14, 2012 (considering the one carried out after April 17, 2012) and the most recent operation, July 23, 2013, it should be indicated that regarding the infractions related to intermediating financial instruments without complying with the regulations, using global accounts without observing the required conditions, not collecting orders or issuing the respective policies, GPI SAB does not present sanction antecedents;
- Regarding the infraction related to not delivering account statements, taking into account the dates of commission of the infraction (from June 2012 to April 2016), GPI SAB presents the three mentioned infraction antecedents;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right, it should be noted that in the present case it has not been possible to prove that GPI SAB's actions in the commission of the infractions analyzed in this sanctioning procedure have caused damage to the public interest insofar as such damage has not been proven, although a set of operations abroad have been carried out without complying with the regulations governing the securities market;
- Regarding the protected legal right, it should be indicated that there has been an affectation to investor protection, with respect to the Complainants, since the provisions of the LMV and the RAI have not been complied with, norms that seek for the investor to have timely, truthful and sufficient information available to base their decisions on it;
- In this sense, the non-observance of the requirement to deliver the respective policies and send the corresponding account statement affects the trust that investors must have regarding the intermediaries that carry out operations in the securities market. It should also be mentioned that the fact of not having collected orders does not allow verifying whether the instructions given to the intermediaries by their clients were collected and executed according to the mandate given to the stockbroker and consequently, whether it has complied with the obligations proper to the rules of commercial commission that govern the relations between brokerage agents and their principals;
- Likewise, it should be noted that GPI SAB's action of intervening in the intermediation of operations abroad through its global accounts without previously signing a contract with the Complainants implies not providing additional information to its clients about the risks of investing in the foreign market, in addition to not alerting them that these operations are not covered by the guarantee fund and the guarantees constituted by the intermediary, which also affects investor protection;
- The fact of not including the operations and balances of securities funds of the Complainants in the control records of global accounts that allow identifying the funds and securities of these clients limits the supervision activities by the SMV over the management of funds by the intermediary of the clients abroad and the intermediary's capacity to provide the information required by the regulatory framework to its clients, as well as reflects weaknesses in its internal control system, which affects investor protection;
- Having GPI SAB granted credits to its clients without having the corresponding loan contract, in which the conditions of the contract are established, including the constitution of guarantees covering the amount of the credit; it exposed the intermediary to a risk situation that impacts its liquidity and solvency, and therefore, its capacity to meet its obligations to the market, thereby affecting its integrity;
- It should be noted that the fiduciary role of brokerage agents is fundamental in providing confidence to the investor about the management of their investments, and it is therefore not admissible to sustain the execution of operations on behalf of clients without observing the main fundamental obligations to carry out the purchase or sale of financial instruments, such as collecting the order, issuing policies and informing clients of the result of their investments in their respective account statements;
- In this sense, the need to provide security to the market originates from the confidence that the securities market must provide to investors; a situation that obliges the legislation on the matter to establish and determine the limits for intermediation, as well as its conditions. Thus, the reality of the market establishes the investor as the axis around which the dynamics of the securities market revolve, and it is therefore essential to establish an appropriate framework to prevent harm to them and to provide them with the necessary securities for their actions. The need to provide investor protection is fundamental in order to grant them the best guarantees in their performance within the market[35].
- In this context, the principle of Investor Protection is based on the investor receiving timely and adequate information. Likewise, it is necessary to establish clear and efficient rules of action for the performance of intermediaries in the market, in order to provide investors with effective protection mechanisms. This situation is not observed in the present case insofar as GPI SAB has not complied with providing information to its clients, account statements and policies, nor has it observed the requirements of the regulatory framework regarding the receipt of orders, control records of global accounts and signing of contracts
- Regarding the economic damage caused, it should be mentioned that it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions incurred by GPI SAB have caused concrete economic damage to market participants;
- Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that in the analyzed case it is not observed that this assumption has been configured;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that according to the information in the file, GPI SAB managed the investments of the Complainants in the foreign market, which were mostly destined for operations with ETF options, in which high market risk is assumed, for more than US$ 2.7 million; however, despite the significant amount of funds under the intermediary's responsibility, the complexity of the operations and the greater risk assumed by its clients and by the intermediary with its foreign counterparts, GPI SAB did not have the diligence to collect orders from its clients that support the operations carried out and did not report the result of their execution through the issuance and delivery of policies, nor did it deliver the respective account statements; being
- Without prejudice to this particular circumstance due to the type of client and operations, it should be indicated that GPI SAB, in its capacity as brokerage agent, knows the securities market regulations, in addition to the fact that it was not one or a few operations but a series of operations carried out abroad from 2008 to July 2013, with various types of financial instruments, mostly ETF options, on behalf of the Complainants, which generated various basic obligations in its capacity as brokerage agent, such as collecting orders, issuing policies and account statements, etc. however, they were not complied with;
- Likewise, carrying out operations abroad constitutes an activity in which the brokerage agent must comply, in addition to the provisions of the preceding recital, with other legal obligations, among them signing a contract with its clients in which the latter declare they know the risks of this type of operations, keeping an adequate record of their global accounts;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to mention that this situation of non-compliance extended over time for more than five (05) years and to many operations and for significant amounts;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been proven in this procedure that GPI SAB has obtained any benefit by incurring the imputed infractions;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it should be specified that in the present case GPI SAB has intermediated financial instruments without complying with the requirements established by the regulations; used global accounts without observing the required conditions; did not deliver account statements; did not collect orders in support of the operations carried out, nor did it deliver the respective policies to the Complainants; therefore, it is considered that it is not possible to admit that an intermediary such as GPI SAB with several years operating in the market can ignore compliance with essential rules of intermediation in the securities market and neglect the fiduciary responsibility that should have characterized it with respect to each of its clients;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the offender's contribution to their clarification, it should be indicated that GPI SAB has not acknowledged the commission of any of the infractions subject of this sanctioning procedure, nor has it contributed to their clarification, since it has only limited itself to presenting its defenses, indicating, as its main argument, the fact that the current regulations are not applicable to the operations carried out by the Complainants;
- Regarding the voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges, it should be indicated that GPI SAB has not proven the voluntary correction of the acts or omissions constituting the infractions evaluated in this administrative sanctioning procedure prior to the notification of the imputation of charges or to the date of this resolution;
- Likewise, it should be indicated that in the present case it has not been evidenced that the offending conduct by GPI SAB was generated by an error induced by the administration by a confusing and illegal administrative act or provision;
- Although according to the provisions of article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, in the analyzed case it would correspond to impose on GPI SAB the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction, however, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, and in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, and taking into account that no damage caused or illegally obtained benefit has been evidenced, as well as the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, it corresponds to impose on GPI SAB a sanction applicable to minor infractions, as provided in article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a very serious infraction typified in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory norms, for having contravened the provisions of article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the Regulation of Brokerage Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 2.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by having contravened the provisions of Article 37, numeral 37.4.2 and Article 90 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Article 3.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by having contravened the provisions of Articles 82 and 83 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Article 4.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by having contravened the provisions of Article 175 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and Article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Article 5.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by having contravened the provisions of Articles 79 and 81 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
Article 6.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has incurred a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.13 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by having contravened the provisions of Article 194, literal m) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and Article 51 of the Brokerage Agents Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments.
- Article 7.- Declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has not incurred a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, by not having contravened the provisions of Article 195, literal a) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments.
- Article 8.- Sanction Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa with a fine of seven (07) UIT in force at the time of the commission of the infractions, equivalent to S/ 24,500.00 (Twenty-four thousand five hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions referred to in Articles 1 to 6 of this resolution.
- Article 9.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- Article 10.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by motion for reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Securities Market Superintendency, in compliance with the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on Advertising of Regulatory Projects, General Norms and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of Article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
- Article 11.- Transcribe this resolution to Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. Sociedad Agente de Bolsa, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A. and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate, and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
In force until January 31, 2013. ↑
-
Pursuant to the amendment contained in Law No. 29720. ↑
-
Subsequently, it was determined that the cutoff date from which both parties, GPI SAB and the Complainants, coincide is up to before October 16, 2012. ↑
-
Common shares issued by Sulliden Gold Corporation Ltd. ↑
-
Subsequently renamed PPX as a consequence of the change of corporate name from Sienna Gold Inc. to Peruvian Precious Metals Corp. ↑
-
The questioning is observed as of October 16, 2012. ↑
-
Includes the 14,800 shares held as of October 16, 2012, see Table No. 2. ↑
-
Article 2.- Terms.- For the purposes of this Regulation, the following terms have the meaning indicated:
(...)
2.11. Financial Instruments: Those that represent or incorporate patrimonial or credit rights. For the purposes of this Regulation, it includes financial instruments that qualify as securities, according to the Securities Law, and foreign securities and financial instruments.
(...)
2.28. Securities: Securities.
2.19. Foreign Securities and Financial Instruments: Those issued by foreign issuers or by issuers incorporated in the country and that have been placed or admitted to trading abroad.
(...)
Article 28.- SCOPE.- The scope of action in which Agents can develop their fundamental activity of intermediation of securities and financial instruments is limited to the segments detailed below and according to the conditions established in this article for each of them:
(...)
28.2.3. Securities and Financial Instruments Traded Abroad. According to the conditions established in this title. Only cash operations can be carried out. ↑
-
77.5 In the case of unwritten orders, it is presumed, unless proven otherwise, that they have been given under the conditions indicated by the client. ↑
-
It should be noted that it is known that a standard option contract covers 100 units of the underlying asset (NUGT). ↑
-
It should be noted that it is known that so-called "American options" can be exercised at any time before the expiration date. ↑
-
Breadley Myers Marcus, Fundamentals of Corporate Finance, Fifth Edition, p. 660: "Put Option: Right to sell an underlying asset at the exercise price specified on or before the exercise date. (...) If you own a put option on a company's stock whose price becomes higher than the exercise price, you will prefer not to exercise your option to sell the shares at the exercise price. The put option will not be exercised and will expire worthless. But if the stock price turns out to be lower than the exercise price, it will be worth buying the shares available in the market at the lower price, and then exercising the option to sell them at the exercise price. Then, the value of the put option will be equal to the difference between the exercise price and the stock price." ↑
-
According to the Activity Summary, these puts were sold on September 10, 2012. ↑
-
It is considered a drafting error the text of the email "so that they apply more to us", the correct being "so that they do not apply more to us", because when recommending the "rollover" what the trader wants to avoid is that the counterparties exercise more NUGT put options. ↑
-
According to the Activity Summary, as of October 16, 2012, the balance of PUT NUGT Dec$25 amounted to 660, so when 177 were executed on November 22, 2012, the balance should be 483 contracts; therefore, it is considered an error of GPI SAB to state that the balance is 487 contracts; however, taking into account that the error is for 4 more contracts, an amount that is netted with the error of the execution of 4 fewer contracts indicated by GPI in the case of the execution of other PUT contracts that will be seen next, the total amount of NUGT purchased indicated by GPI SAB is not altered. ↑
-
By mistake, Mr. Gleiser states in this email that there are 822 contracts (covering 82,200 NUGT). ↑
-
Since the balance as of February 18, 2013 was 448 PUT NUGT Mar$16 and 400 were repurchased, the execution should be for 48, not 44 contracts. However, taking into account that the error is for 4 fewer contracts, the amount is netted with the error of an execution of 4 more contracts indicated by GPI in the case of the execution of contracts at the exercise price of US$ 25, so the total amount of NUGT purchased indicated by GPI SAB is not altered. ↑
-
As observed in Table No. 1, after March 8, 2013, only money transfers from GPI SAB to the Complainants are recorded. ↑
-
CHAPTER II
FUTURES, OPTIONS AND OTHER DERIVATIVES
Article 45.- Prior Authorization.- The Agent that wishes to intermediate operations with futures, options and other derivatives contracts, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, must obtain prior authorization from CONASEV.
(...)
Article 46.- Authorization.- For the Agent to obtain authorization to intermediate futures, options and other derivatives contracts, it must comply with the following requirements:
46.1. Designate at least one Representative responsible for managing matters related to this type of operations, who must prove experience in this area.
46.2. Model of informative prospectus to be delivered to each client that orders this type of operations, describing in a general manner, for each type of contract, the characteristics, conditions and risks inherent to each type of contract. ↑
-
Numeral 2 of Article 2 of the RAI:
-
- Cash operation: That whose settlement of securities or financial instruments and funds occurs within three (3) days of being made.
Article 15 of the Regulation of Operations on the Stock Exchange, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 021-1999-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Operations Regulation):
Article 15. Cash Operation.- It is that which results from the automatic application of purchase or sale proposals of a quantity of securities at a determined price, to be settled within the term set by the Board of Directors, which cannot exceed three (3) days. ↑
-
Article 39 of the Operations Regulation. ↑
-
1.1. Perform functions, operations, activities, acts or contracts not authorized or that do not comply with the requirements established in the regulations or that have not been registered in the Registry, when applicable. ↑
-
Which is where the intermediation activity is regulated and defined and where Articles 28 to 40 of the RAI are found. ↑
-
Understood as that in which the foreign intermediary understands that the Agent is the holder of the operations and financial instruments acquired. It should be noted that in these cases the Agent carries out operations abroad, under such modality, but on behalf of its clients. ↑
-
Article 67.- Permitted derivatives
Subject to the provisions of this subchapter, the Agent is permitted to intermediate, on its own account or for third parties, among others, the following derivatives: forwards, futures, swaps, options (...) ↑
-
Article 340.- Arbitration
Any controversy or claim that investors may have with issuers, representatives of bondholders, brokerage agents, (...), related to the rights and obligations derived from this law, may be submitted to arbitration in accordance with the General Arbitration Law. ↑
-
2.4. Global Account: Account managed by the Agent solely for the control of client operations in foreign markets and for placements, which, appearing in its name, groups clients who are the final holders of the rights or obligations related to said account. ↑
-
In the Client File it is indicated that the mode of access to account statements will be in the modality of "pickup at the SAB office" ↑
-
Examples: If the Complainants sold puts (put options) they were obligated to buy the underlying assets at the exercise price if the counterparty chose to exercise its put option on securities; if the Complainants sold calls (call options) they were obligated to sell the underlying assets at the exercise price if the counterparty chose to exercise its call option. ↑
-
Article 87.- Short Position.- Without prejudice to the Agent's obligation to verify before executing and/or registering operations, the existence of resources and financial instruments or securities to which they relate, or to process orders corresponding to operations of such nature; for the purposes of calculating the liquidity and solvency indicator established in this Regulation, an operation is considered short when the obligation to settle or cover it is borne by the Agent, to the extent that the purchase or sale operation has been executed without the Agent having received the respective funds or securities and financial instruments necessary to comply with the settlement of the operation and, on the other hand, in cases where any of the following situations occur:
-
- At the maturity of an operation whose settlement term is longer than that of a cash operation, the delivery of securities, financial instruments or respective funds necessary to comply with the settlement of the operation has not been made.
- Operations on own account until fully settled.
- The valuation of the guarantee of an operation has fallen below the coverage amount required for that type of operation.
Without prejudice to the provisions above, in all types of operations the amount of the short position is the total amount of the respective operation, while in the case referred to in numeral 87.3, it is the amount of the guarantee deficit in relation to the required coverage amount.
Operations of this type that have an express acknowledgment from the holder of the operation, which allows the Agent to execute guarantees in its favor, on the settlement date of the operation and for an amount that covers the entire obligation generated by said operation, in the event of a possible non-compliance, are excluded. Likewise, operations of Institutional Investors, whose investments are supervised by State Organizations, are excluded, provided that the Agent can reliably demonstrate that the corresponding orders were given by the representatives of said investors with respective powers. ↑
-
It should be noted that the first discharges, derived from Official Letter No. 3181-2016-SMV/10.3, were submitted on June 9, 2016.
Also, regarding the money mutual matter of charges, it is appropriate to mention that by Official Letter No. 4758-2016-SMV/10.3, GPI SAB was requested to explain the disbursements in favor of the operations carried out on behalf of the Complainants, given that it exceeded the balance of their funds; however, no response was received from said stock brokerage firm, although a period was granted for such clarifications, in addition to an extension of the latter requested by letter of August 31, 2016. ↑
-
"Article 230.- Principles of administrative sanctioning power.
(...)
3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as an infraction, and must observe the following criteria that are indicated in order of priority for their graduation:
a) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal right;
b) The economic harm caused;
c) The repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction;
d) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction;
e) The illegally obtained benefit, and;
f) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender.
(...)" ↑
-
"Article 236 - A.- Mitigating factors of liability for infractions
The following constitute mitigating conditions of liability for the commission of the administrative infraction:
1.- The voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 235.
2.- Error induced by the administration by a confusing or illegal administrative act or provision." ↑
-
For the application of this article, the provisions of Board Agreement No. 1422 dated January 18, 2010 must be taken into account, which established that sanction antecedents are generated whenever three elements concur: i) the offender had been sanctioned during the three years prior to the detection of the infraction being evaluated, ii) that said sanction or sanctions had become final in said period, and iii) that the sanctioned facts occurred prior to the infraction intended to be sanctioned. ↑
-
Aldo Reggiardo Denegri, Notes on stock market intermediation, the commercial commission contract and its relationship with stock market intermediaries, THEMIS 40, p. 49-60. ↑