SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 097-2017-SMV/10
Lima, October 16, 2017
Summary: Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. ex Sociedad Agente de Bolsa is sanctioned with a fine of 60 UIT, equivalent to S/ 216,000.00 (Two hundred sixteen thousand and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred three (03) infractions: One (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 and two (02) infractions of a serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraphs 2.10 and 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, for allocating funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, for not delivering account statements and for not having global account records, respectively.
Likewise, it is declared that Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. ex Sociedad Agente de Bolsa has not incurred one (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18; and, in two (02) infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraphs 3.5 and 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations, and, consequently, the administrative sanctioning procedure is concluded in these respects.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. ex Sociedad Agente de Bolsa. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2017034963 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2017034963 and Report No. 1022-2017-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and,
CONSIDERING:
- In accordance with Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
I. Facts
- By document received on February 7, 2017, Mrs. Maria Veronica Helena Mendoza Benavides (hereinafter, client), filed a complaint against Grupo Privado de Inversiones - Valores S.A. ex Sociedad Agente de Bolsa, (hereinafter, GPI), because said former intermediary would have allocated the money delivered by the Client to purposes other than those entrusted, and therefore requests the return of her investment or the execution of the Guarantee Fund;
- In this regard, as part of the preliminary inquiry stage, through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3 notified on February 10, 2017, GPI was given notice of the complaint filed by the client and was requested to provide additional information and documentation in order to clarify the facts, granting a period of three (03) business days counted from the notification thereof. To date, GPI has not complied with the requested requirement;
- On the other hand, through Official Letter No. 888-2017-SMV/10.3 notified on February 13, 2017, the client was requested to provide additional information and documentation regarding what was stated in her complaint, to which by document received on February 15, 2017, the client initially stated that she did not have more documentation and information;
- Subsequently, through Official Letter No. 1930-2017-SMV/10.3, notified on March 27, 2017, the client was requested to report on the capital advances she received from GPI. Likewise, she was required to report all other deliveries of funds by GPI other than the concepts for "returns" reported in her complaint. It should be noted that said requirement was answered by document received and sent to the SMV on March 29, 2017;
- Likewise, through Official Letter No. 2790-2017-SMV/10.3, notified on May 8, 2017, the client was reiterated the need to prove through the respective documentation the payments made in favor of GPI. In this regard, the client by document received on May 8, 2017 presented additional documentation in order to prove what was declared in her complaint;
- By Official Letter No. 3204-2017-SMV/10.3, notified on May 18, 2017, the client was informed of the observations identified in the documentation presented on May 8, 2017 and was requested to present documents proving the destination account number of the transfer and the final beneficiary thereof. In this sense, by documents received on May 18, June 5 and 12, and July 17, 2017, the client presented the additional documentation required;
- By document received on August 3, 2017, the client appointed lawyers to represent her in the processing of her complaint, who on August 22, 2017 presented additional information regarding the Client's complaint;
- As a result of the foregoing and under the provisions of the Single Text of Law No. 27444 - General Administrative Procedure Law (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), through Official Letter No. 5611-2017-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on September 7, 2017, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against GPI regarding the facts described by the client, as well as on the basis of the information and documentation that is part of this administrative file;
- Through the Letter of Charges, charges were imputed against GPI for having contravened the provisions of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Regulation) and the Regulation of Intermediation Agents approved by SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, current Regulation)[1], in force at the time the facts occurred, in aspects related to the destination of client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted; intermediating financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations; using global accounts without observing the required conditions; not delivering account statements; not collecting orders from its clients; and, not delivering policies for the operations carried out;
- It should be noted that as of the date of this resolution, GPI has not presented the respective defenses to any of the charges imputed in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
- It is appropriate to mention that by SMV Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 of January 25, 2017, it was resolved to declare unfounded the appeal filed by GPI against Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 049-2016-SV/10, which resolved to cancel the operating authorization of said former stock brokerage firm;
- The charges formulated against GPI and their evaluation have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 1022-2017-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2 of the Preliminary Title and in Article 246, subparagraph 2, of the TUO LPAG, through Official Letter No. 6117-2017-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 1022-2017-SMV/10.3 was made available to GPI for its review;
II. Issues to Determine
- In this administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter Sanctions Regulations), by allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, by intermediating financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations; referring to the signing of a contract with a client for operations in the foreign market;
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulations, for using global accounts without observing the required conditions;
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulations, for not complying with sending its clients the information to which it is obligated (account statements), or not doing so in the form and opportunity required by the regulations;
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, by not collecting orders;
- Whether GPI incurred or not in infraction of the provisions of Annex X, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulations, by not delivering policies;
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on GPI for what is indicated in the previous subparagraphs;
III. Analysis
3.1 Allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted
Of the regulations
- Literal a) of Article 195 of the LMV prohibits stock brokerage firms from allocating funds or securities they receive from their principals to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted:
- Likewise, Article 48 of the Regulation establishes that securities, financial instruments or funds delivered in custody to the agent cannot be used for a different purpose unless the corresponding express authorization is available:
"Article 48.- Basic Rules.-
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available. (...)";
- It should be noted that the first paragraph of Article 48 of the Regulation was modified by SMV Resolution No. 040-2012-SMV/01 in force as of February 1, 2013, which establishes the following:
Article 48.- Basic Rules
The assets mentioned in the preceding article, which have been delivered in custody to the Agent, cannot be used for a different purpose, unless the corresponding express authorization is available and provided that such purpose is referred to any of the operations defined in Articles 194 and 207 of the Law. *(...)".[2];
The Complaint
- By document presented to the SMV on February 7, 2017, supplemented on February 15, March 3 and 29, May 8 and 18, as well as June 5 and 12, 2017, July 17, 20017 and August 22, 2017; the client filed a complaint against GPI stating that she had been affected by the aforementioned former stock brokerage firm by not complying with her orders agreed in the client registration form of August 19, 2010, indicating that her investment amounts to US$ 238,364.46 (Two hundred thirty-eight thousand three hundred sixty-four and 46/100 United States Dollars). It should be noted that the client in her document received on March 29, 2017 declared not having made any withdrawal or received any payment from GPI for capital advance. Likewise, she indicates that GPI gave her returns, which are shown in the receipts presented in her complaint;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, in the document received on March 29, 2017, the client indicated that the amount claimed is US$ 238,524.56 (Two hundred thirty-eight thousand five hundred twenty-four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and that to said amount must also be added US$ 2,700.00 (Two thousand seven hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) that she states she did not receive and was reinvested;
- On the other hand, the client states that she came to GPI by recommendation of Mr. Manuel Castaneda Carrillo de Albornoz, a person close to her family. Likewise, the client states that Mrs. Maria Teresa Orlandini Alvarez Calderon (hereinafter, Mrs. Orlandini) and Hector Uccelli (hereinafter, Mr. Uccelli) representatives of GPI at that date, were her advisors. . Likewise, the client states that in September 2012 her capital was reduced to US$ 228,637.56 (Two hundred twenty-eight thousand six hundred thirty-seven and 56/100 United States Dollars), a situation that Mrs. Orlandini would have indicated would normalize but never happened;
- Similarly, the client indicates that in 2015 she wanted to withdraw her capital for the purchase of a property but they did not allow it. In 2016 the client states that they only paid her the first five (5) months and later the delays began, a situation that again Mrs. Orlandini would have indicated would normalize and that she could not withdraw her capital;
- On the other hand, the client states that she learned of the situation GPI was going through and went to GLB Abogados S.A.C., legal representatives of GPI, being attended by Mr. Jose Manuel Valverde on January 17, 2017 who told her: i) that her capital is US$ 159,631.00 (One hundred fifty-nine thousand six hundred thirty-one and 00/100 United States Dollars), ii) that they would pay 10% or 20% of said amount but that they did not have capital; and, iii) that the SMV had to appoint a liquidator;
- Finally, by document presented on August 22, 2017, the Client's lawyer states that as recorded in Account Statements that GPI delivered to the Client, a percentage of the investment would have been used to allegedly carry out operations on the Lima Stock Exchange (BVL); that is, in the domestic market. As can be seen from said documents, US$ 14,444.00 (Fourteen thousand four hundred forty-four and 00/100 United States Dollars) would have been allocated to the purchase of shares of the company Sienna Gold Inc;
- She adds that according to information obtained from the BVL website, Sienna Gold Inc. - now Peruvian Precious Metals Inc. - is a company that lists on the domestic market; therefore she considers that the money deposited by the Client, although it had foreign accounts as origin and destination, did enter national territory, thus complying with the main condition of the norm, "the territoriality of operations". In that order of ideas, she states that in strict application of Article 1 of the Guarantee Fund Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 013-2011-SMV/01 and its amendments, it is feasible to affirm that it is possible to subsume the Client's case within the scope of the mentioned norm, granting her protection and a replenishment of the patrimony invested in GPI;
Arguments of GPI in the preliminary inquiries
- It should be noted that through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3, GPI was given notice of the complaint presented by the client, as well as requested information and documentation regarding the commercial relationship of the former stock brokerage firm with the client and on the operations carried out on behalf of this client, granting a period of three (03) business days to present the information, which expired on February 15, 2017. To date, GPI has not sent the requested information;
Of the charges formulated
The Funds and Securities
- According to documents presented by the client, on September 23, 2010 she delivered to GPI US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds (hereinafter GM Bonds) and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds (hereinafter OP Bonds). The Client attaches as support simple copies of the documents detailed below;
- One (01) document called "MT 103 Single Customer Credit Transfer" issued by Royal Bank Plaza (hereinafter, RBC) in which a transfer of September 22, 2010 ordered by the Client to the bank account of Citigroup Global Markets Inc. at Citibank NA for final credit to account No. 428-90348-13-056, which is the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC[3] for the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars).
- Two (02) emails issued by Mrs. Silvia Rodriguez, administrative assistant of RBC, addressed to the Client, by which she attaches reports from RBC systems that prove the transfer of 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds owned by the Client to the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, made on September 21, 2010.
- One (01) document issued by GPI corresponding to the client, identified with code CLIO1655, in which a transfer of September 23, 2010 is seen and indicates as cash received the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), as well as 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds received. According to this document issued by GPI, taking into account the market prices of the securities received from the Client, the valuation of the 100,000 GM Bonds amounted to US$ 30,620.00 (Thirty thousand six hundred twenty and 00/100 United States Dollars) and of the 80,000 OP Bonds, to US$ 85,600.00 (Eighty-five thousand six hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars). These amounts added to the cash received yield a total amount of US$ 238,524.56 (Two hundred thirty-eight thousand five hundred twenty-four and 56/100 United States Dollars).
- One (01) document issued by GPI of October 26, 2010 corresponding to the client, identified with code CLIO1655, in which a cash balance in favor of the Client is seen for the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), as well as 100,000 GM Bonds[4].
- Emails of December 27 and 28, 2016 exchanged between the client and Mrs. Orlandini in which the latter indicates that her invested capital amounts to US$ 228,637.96 (Two hundred twenty-eight thousand six hundred thirty-seven and 96/100 United States Dollars) and explains the details thereof. This amount would consider the funds and the valuation of the securities delivered by the Client to GPI on September 23, 2010;
- Therefore, the client has proven that on September 23, 2010 she transferred to a global account in the name of GPI a total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) for investments, as well as transferred to a global account in the name of GPI 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds;
- Likewise, in the inspection carried out by this Superintendency at the GPI warehouse on January 11 and February 17 and 20, 2017 (hereinafter, Inspection), Excel reports and account statements of the global asset account of GPI at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC[5] for the months of July to December 2013 were collected, in which it is proven that the Client owned 100,000 GM Bonds, which were in default in said months;
- It should be noted that the old General Motors Corporation went bankrupt and a new General Motors Corporation was constituted, which since April 2011 issued shares and warrants with option to acquire shares of this company, which were delivered to the owners of securities issued by the old General Motors Corporation. These new shares and warrants are also credited as property of the Client in the Excel reports and account statements of the global asset account of GPI at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC for the months of July to December 2013;
Of the destination of the resources
-
As has been indicated, the client proved that on September 23, 2010 she delivered to GPI funds in the total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), as well as transferred to GPI's global account 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds, and points out that GPI breached its orders agreed in the client registration form of August 19, 2010, although it does not attach any documentation regarding orders instructed to GPI;
-
It should be noted that the Client attaches simple copies of the client registration forms in her name identified with client code CLIO1655, signed on August 19, 2010 and October 7, 2014 by her and by Mr. Uccelli. In this regard, in the client registration form of August 19, 2010 the investment object is not indicated and the means of instructing orders is indicated as "other modality subject to verification and confirmation" and in the client registration form of October 7, 2014 the investment objective is indicated as: "preservation" and "income/revenues" and as the means of instructing orders "other means authorized by the SMV" and in both client registration forms previously indicated, as services requested by the Client, it is indicated: "Purchase/sale of securities on the BVL", "Report Operations", "Over-the-counter operations", "Capital market advisory (Peru)" and "Capital market advisory (international)";
-
It should be noted that neither party has indicated the existence of a portfolio management contract signed between the Client and GPI, nor has a contract of that nature been obtained in the Inspection;
-
On the other hand, regarding the operations that would have been carried out with the Client's funds and securities, it should be noted that according to the information on the operations recorded in GPI's master account of the Accounting Registry administered by Cavali S.A. ICLV and the one that GPI reported daily to the SMV, there is no record regarding operations carried out by this former stock brokerage firm in the domestic and foreign market on behalf of the Client;
-
However, according to the information contained in reports issued by GPI (with seal and signature) and others that would have been issued by GPI, all presented by the Client, undated (which would be from September 2010), of October 26, 2010, of September 7, 2012 (two reports), September 19, 2012 (two reports), January 17, 2013, August 5, 2014, August 7, 2014 and October 28, 2015, it is observed that GPI supposedly would have carried out on behalf of the Client operations in the foreign market detailed in Table No. 1, some of which, as indicated by the undated reports (which would be from September 2010) and of October 26, 2010, would have supposedly been carried out through the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Interactive Brokers LLC (Interactive Brokers Bus Acount), although it is proven that the Client on September 23, 2010 transferred funds and securities to the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC;
TABLE No. 1
SUPPOSED OPERATIONS ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENT ACCORDING TO REPORTS ISSUED BY GPI (IN US$)
| DATE / PERIOD | DEPOSITS/ WITHDRAWALS | TRANSFERS OF SECURITIES | DETAIL OF OPERATIONS | | | | | | |
|---|
| Operation | Security | Maturity ; Strike Price | Quantity Securities | Price | Investment Amount/ Exposure | Premium / Gain | | | |
| 09/23/2010 | 122,304.56 | 80,000 OP Bonds and 100,000 GM Bonds | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 09/23/2010 | - | - | Sale PUT | FAS | 10/16/2010; 20.67 | 6,100 | 0.4918 | 126,087 | 2,999.98 |
| 10/14/2010 | - | - | Sale PUT | FAS | 11/20/2010; 21 | 6,000 | 0.49 | 126,000 | 2,940.0 |
| 09/23/2010 - 10/26/2010 | - | - | Sale | Ontario Province Bonds 5.125% (*) | - | 80,000 | - | 85,600 () | - |
| 09/23/2010 - 10/26/2010 | - | - | Purchase | Fleet Capital Trust 7.2% preferred shares | - | 3,560 | 24.00 | 85,440 | - |
| Nov 2010 - Sep 2011 | - | - | Options | - | Oct-11 | - | - | - | 2,700.0 |
| April 2011 | - | - | Exchange () | General Motors (GM) shares | - | - | - | - | - |
| April 2011 | - | - | Exchange () | GM Warrants A with strike price of 10 | - | - | - | - | - |
| April 2011 | - | - | Exchange () | GM Warrants B with strike price of 18.33 | - | - | - | - | - |
| April 2011 | - | - | Exchange () | Motors Liquidation Company shares | - | - | - | - | - |
| 10/19/2011 | - | - | Sale | General Motors shares | - | 791 | 23.00 | 18,193 | - |
| 11/11/2011 - 09/19/2012 | - | - | Purchase (*) | FAS | - | 345 | 60.60 | 20,893 | - |
| 09/23/2010 - July 2012 | - | - | Sale CALL | Fleet Capital Trust 7.2% preferred shares | 09/07/2012; 25 | 3,560 | - | - | - |
| 07/31/2012 | | | Sale (exercise Sale CALL) | Fleet Capital Trust 7.2% preferred shares | - | 3,560 | 25.00 | 89,000 | - |
| 09/07/2012 | - | - | Purchase | Credit Agricole Bonds | - | 72,000 | 1.0355 | 74,556 | - |
| 09/07/2012 | - | - | Sale CALL | Credit Agricole Bonds | 12/26/2014; | | | | |
| Sep 2011 - August 2012 | - | - | Sale CALL | - | - | - | - | 120,000 | - |
| 09/20/2012 - 01/17/2013 | | | Trading | - | - | - | - | 120,000 | - |
| 09/20/2012 - 01/17/2013 | - | - | Purchase | SGP (now PPX) | - | 45,000 | 0.321 | 14,444 | - |
| 04/02/2013 | - | - | Split 3:1 | FAS | - | 1,035 | - | - | - |
| 08/05/2014 | | | Sale | FAS | - | 110 | 94 | 10,340 | - |
| As of 09/20/2014 | - | - | Trading | - | - | - | - | 120,000 | - |
| 05/20/2015 | | | Split 4:1 | FAS | - | 3,700 | - | - | - |
| As of 10/28/2015 | - | - | Trading | - | - | - | - | 120,000 | - |
| Total Capital and Securities | 122,304.56 | 80,000 OP Bonds 100,000 GM Bonds | | | | | | | |
| Portfolio and securities value as of 10/28/2015 | 249,958.97 | 925 FAS (ETF), 72,000 Credit Agricole Bonds and 45,000 SGP (now PPX) | | | | | | | |
(*) Securities transferred by the Client to the global account in the name of GPI.
() Approximate amount considering the valuation as of 09/23/2010 indicated in GPI's report.
(*) Would have been purchased after the reverse split of FAS of 11/10/2011.
() As a consequence of the bankruptcy of the former General Motors and the creation of the new General Motors.
-
It should be noted that Excel reports and account statements of GPI's global asset account at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC[6] for the months of July to December 2013 have been obtained, which prove that the purchase operation supposedly on behalf and order of the Client of 72,000 (Seventy-two thousand) Credit Agricole bonds was carried out on September 7, 2012, as well as that at the closings of July to December 2013 the Client supposedly owned shares of the new General Motors (7 shares at the closing of July to November 2013 and 28 shares at the closing of December 2013), warrants types A and B with option to acquire shares of the new General Motors (7 warrants of each type A and B at the closing of July to November 2013 and 26 warrants of each type A and B at the closing of December 2013) and shares of Motors Liquidation Company (102 shares at the closing of July to December 2013), company in charge of the liquidation of the old General Motors as a consequence of the bankruptcy of the latter;
-
In that sense, the reports issued by GPI would indicate that this former stock brokerage firm supposedly would have carried out various operations with securities and options on behalf and instruction of the Client in the foreign market from September 2010 to October 2015, and some of these operations have been proven with Excel reports and account statements of the foreign intermediary obtained in the Inspection;
-
It should be noted that possibly GPI would have carried out other supposed operations until September 19, 2016, which could explain the yields paid to the client from January 2011 to September 2016, as proven by her statement in the complaint, in the reports that GPI would have issued and that she presents attached to her complaint and the receipts and vouchers of payment presented by the Client before this Superintendency;
-
In this regard, GPI has not complied with sending the information required in the preliminary inquiry stage through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3, regarding the record of orders given by the client, the policies of the operations carried out, the account statements in the name of this client, the control records of global accounts that identify the operations that supposedly would have been carried out in the foreign market through a global account and balances of securities funds and financial instruments of the Client in these accounts, the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary in charge of executing the supposed operations or of the entity of registration and custody of the securities and financial instruments, in which the supposed operations with securities and financial instruments carried out abroad in the name of GPI are recorded;
-
Considering the above, the supposed intermediation operations in the foreign market have not been proven by GPI with the account statements that the foreign intermediary, which supposedly would have executed the operations, should have issued. Likewise, if applicable, with the information provided by the entity of registration or custody of the securities and financial instruments resulting from the operations that GPI would have carried out, according to the operability of the respective global account. As has been indicated, only some operations are proven in the account statements issued by the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC regarding the global asset account in the name of GPI, according to documents obtained in the Inspection;
-
According to the Regulation, said information must support the control records of global accounts that GPI should have regarding the balances of funds, securities and financial instruments of the Client, which must be consistent with the policies issued by GPI for the supposed operations carried out. Additionally, GPI should have the records of the respective orders given by the Client by written means, email, telephone or other form of transmission of the order, in the terms made by her that would support the Client's will to allocate her funds to investments in securities and derivative financial instruments such as Put and Call options, as well as the other conditions in which said operations were executed. However, as has been indicated, said orders have not been proven by GPI;
-
In the case of other possible operations that GPI would have carried out in the local market on behalf of the Client, this former stock brokerage firm has not proven them with the records of orders, respective policies, movements of funds in its accounts as a result of these operations and documents that prove the ownership by the Client of securities and financial instruments;
-
To date, GPI has not proven with the necessary documentation indicated in the preceding recitals, the investments in the name of the client from September 2010 to September 19, 2016 with the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) received in a global account in the name of GPI, as well as the operations carried out with the 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds received in a global account in the name of GPI or the product of the intermediation operations that it supposedly would have carried out with these securities, carried out according to the instructions of this client, or that it has destined them to another destination; in none of the cases has it proven the destination of the money delivered by this client, therefore it can be concluded that it would have destined it to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
-
In relation to the above, it was imputed to GPI that it would not have complied with the provisions of article 48 of the Regulation since it received the funds and securities delivered by the client for their custody and investment indications given by said client, and it has not proven the corresponding express authorizations for the use of these funds and securities;
-
Likewise, it was imputed to GPI having infringed the provisions of article 195 numeral a) of the LMV, by allocating the funds and securities owned by the client to operations, purposes or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted;
Of the Defenses and their Evaluation
-
GPI has not complied with presenting its defenses to the charge subject to analysis in this extreme, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
-
Before evaluating the destination of the funds that GPI would have made, it should be noted that the Client Registration Forms[7] were signed on August 19, 2010 and October 7, 2014 both in the name of the Client identified with client code CLIO1655 and signed by Mr. Uccelli, Representative and Director of GPI at that time, and as stated by the client in the preliminary inquiry stage, on September 23, 2010 she transferred for investments to a global account of GPI a total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds, that is, after the signing of the first mentioned form;
-
Once the clarification is made, it should be indicated that, regarding these funds and securities delivered by the Client to GPI, as mentioned, according to various reports with logo and signature issued by GPI and others without logo and signature that this former stock brokerage firm would have issued, presented by the Client, this former stock brokerage firm supposedly would have carried out operations in the foreign market with securities and financial instruments, including financial derivatives such as options, on behalf of the referred client, for which it would have used global accounts in the name of GPI;
-
Regarding these supposed operations with securities and financial instruments, including derivatives such as options, that GPI supposedly would have carried out in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, it should be indicated that the Client Registration Form of August 19, 2010 does not indicate the investment object and in the client registration form of October 7, 2014 the investment objective is indicated as: "preservation" and "income/revenues" and in both client registration forms previously indicated, as services requested by the Client, it is indicated: "Purchase/sale of securities on the BVL", "Report Operations", "Over-the-counter operations", "Capital market advisory (Peru)" and "Capital market advisory (international)";
-
Likewise, the Client in her complaint states that she has been affected by GPI due to non-compliance with orders agreed in the client registration form signed on August 19, 2010, and denounces an illicit appropriation of assets delivered to GPI. In this regard, it should be noted that the Client has not specified the orders that she would have instructed to GPI for carrying out operations with the funds and securities delivered to GPI in the global account in the name of GPI at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, nor does she attach documentation in this regard;
-
Additionally, the client adds that Messrs. Orlandini and Uccelli were her advisors and that they offered her monthly yields that were delivered to her since 2012;
-
With the information in the administrative file as of the date of this resolution, it is not possible to evaluate the supposed investments that GPI would have made in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, according to the documents presented by her, given that, despite the requirements made by the SMV, to date GPI has not complied with providing the corresponding necessary documentation that proves the carrying out of all the operations allegedly carried out with the Client's funds and securities in the foreign market, indicated in Table No. 1, and others that it possibly would have carried out, that could explain the yields paid to the client until September 2016; that is, with the account statements of the foreign intermediaries that supposedly would have carried out the operations with the Client's funds and securities, or of the corresponding custody entity, reconciled together with the control records of global accounts, in the case of supposed investments made abroad, the policies, orders, among others;
-
However, in the Inspection, reports prepared by GPI were found with the detail of the Client's securities holdings at the closing of the months of July to December 2013, which reconciled with the information of quantity and date indicated in the account statements of GPI's global account at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC corresponding to said months, also found in the Inspection, prove that this former stock brokerage firm carried out one of the operations abroad indicated in Table No. 1[8], through the mentioned foreign broker, which is detailed in Table No. 2;
TABLE No. 2
OPERATION ON BEHALF OF THE CLIENT PROVEN WITH INSPECTION DOCUMENTS
| | | | | |
|---|
| DATE / PERIOD | DETAIL OF OPERATION | | | | |
| Operation | Security | Quantity Securities | Price | Investment Amount/ Exposure (US$) | |
| 09/07/2012 | Purchase | Credit Agricole Bonds | 72,000 | 1.0355 | 74,556 |
-
However, this operation is not evaluated either in relation to what the Client supposedly would have instructed, because to date GPI has not proven the current situation of the securities, whether they were sold, redeemed, remain in custody in an account in the name of GPI or the Client, or the destination of the funds originated by the sale or maturity of these securities;
-
On the other hand, it should be noted that in Table No. 1, prepared based on Excel reports issued by GPI, it is observed that this former stock brokerage firm supposedly would have acquired between September 2012 and January 2013 on behalf of the Client 45,000 shares of Sienna Gold Inc, now PPX Mining Corp. shares, which are traded in the foreign market and on the Lima Stock Exchange (BVL)[9].
-
Notwithstanding the above, it should be indicated that there is no record of operations carried out on the Lima Stock Exchange on behalf of the Client with this or another security, according to information in the master account that GPI maintained in the Accounting Registry of CAVALI. Likewise, GPI has not informed this Superintendency regarding operations carried out outside the Stock Exchange Trading Session of the BVL on behalf of this client. Therefore, GPI supposedly would have carried out the purchase of Sienna Gold Inc. shares in the foreign market, although it has not proven it to date, as indicated in this resolution;
-
Additionally, it should be noted that regarding withdrawals and/or capital advances, the Client was requested through Official Letter No. 1930-2017-SMV/10.3[10] to declare if she received payments from GPI other than yields, her response being that she had not made any withdrawal and/or capital advance. Likewise, through the Charge Letter said information was transferred to GPI so that it could present and support its position on the matter. Notwithstanding the above, GPI, having not responded to the previously mentioned official letter, has not disproven what was declared by the client regarding not having made any withdrawal and/or capital advance;
-
Therefore, GPI has not proven the use of the funds and securities that the Client entrusted to it for custody and investment indications given by her and that amounts to a total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds, proven from September 23, 2010 to September 19, 2016;
-
The delivery of the mentioned funds and securities is proven by the documents presented by the client and others obtained in the Inspection such as simple copies of a document issued by RBC, two (02) emails issued by RBC, reports issued by GPI and email from Mrs. Orlandini presented by the client in her complaint, detailed below:
TABLE No. 3
PROOF OF THE FUNDS AND SECURITIES BY THE CLIENT
| Date / Period | Amount Credited | Supporting documents (copies) |
|---|
| 23/09/2010 | US$ 122,304.56 and 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds | One (01) document called “MT 103 Single Customer Credit Transfer” issued by Royal Bank Plaza (hereinafter, RBC) identifying a transfer dated September 22, 2010 ordered by the Client to the bank account of Citigroup Global Markets Inc. at Citibank NA for final credit to account No. 428-90348-13-056, which is the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC for the amount of US$ 122,304.56. |
| | Two (02) emails issued by Ms. Silvia Rodriguez, administrative assistant of RBC, addressed to the Client, attaching reports from RBC systems that evidence the transfer of 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds owned by the Client to the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, effected on September 21, 2010. |
| | One (01) document issued by GPI corresponding to the client, identified with code CLIO1655, showing a transfer dated September 23, 2010 and indicating as cash received the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), as well as 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds received. According to this document issued by GPI, taking into account the market prices of the securities received from the Client, the valuation of the 100,000 GM Bonds amounted to US$ 30,620.00 (Thirty thousand six hundred twenty and 00/100 United States Dollars) and of the 80,000 OP Bonds, to US$ 85,600 (Eighty-five thousand six hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars). These amounts added to the cash received total US$ 238,524.56. |
| | One (01) document issued by GPI dated October 26, 2010 corresponding to the client, identified with code CLIO1655, showing a cash balance in favor of the Client for the amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), as well as 100,000 GM Bonds. |
| | Excel reports prepared by GPI and account statements of GPI's global asset account at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC for the months of July to December 2013, gathered in the Inspection, which evidence that the Client owned 100,000 GM Bonds, which were in default during those months. |
| | Emails of December 27 and 28, 2016 exchanged between the client and Ms. Orlandini in which the latter indicates that her invested capital amounts to US$ 228,637.96 (Two hundred twenty-eight thousand six hundred thirty-seven and 96/100 United States Dollars) and explains the details thereof. This amount would consider the funds and the valuation of the securities delivered by the Client to GPI on September 23, 2010. |
- On the other hand, it should be noted that GPI has delivered a total amount of US$ 179,355.00 (One hundred seventy-nine thousand three hundred fifty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) for yields from January 2011 to September 2016, which would be for the supposed investments that GPI would have made with her funds and securities, according to simple copies of a report issued by GPI as of October 28, 2015, vouchers and payment receipts in the name of the Client, and emails exchanged by Ms. Orlandini and the Client on December 27 and 28, 2016[11], all presented by the Client;
- As noted, GPI would have supposedly carried out operations abroad with the funds and securities delivered by the client to a global account in the name of GPI; however, it has not been possible to prove that such supposed operations were actually carried out, and with respect to a securities purchase operation supposedly instructed by the Client, having not been substantiated, its execution abroad is evidenced with documents gathered in the Inspection; however, to date the destination of these securities is unknown, which validly allows concluding that such funds and securities were used for purposes not authorized by the Client;
- It should be noted that in her brief of March 29, 2017, the Client states that US$ 2,700.00 (Two thousand seven hundred and 00/100 United States Dollars) must be added to the reported amount; however, it must be specified that said amount would be supposed premiums from October 2011 from supposed operations not received and supposedly reinvested; not funds whose delivery to GPI has been proven;
- In this sense, pursuant to article 48 of the Regulation, funds delivered in custody to the agent may not be used for a purpose other than those for which they were delivered, unless expressly authorized by the client and that such purpose is related to any of the operations indicated in articles 194 of the LMV;
- Therefore, since GPI has not proven the execution of the supposed operations with the necessary documentation, it is possible to conclude that the funds delivered by the Client were used for purposes different from those entrusted, and therefore GPI has breached articles 195 of the LMV and 48 of the RAI;
- It is then concluded that GPI has not rebutted this charge and consequently, it has been proven that GPI has incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.1 of the Sanctions Regulation;
2 Intermediating securities or financial instruments without complying with the requirements and other provisions established by the regulations related to the execution of a contract with a client for the intermediation of operations in the foreign market
Regarding the Regulations
- As established in article 37, numeral 37.4.1 of the Regulation, regarding the intervention of an agent company in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments, it is stated that:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is on its own account, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements:
37.4.1. Execute a contract with each of the clients who wish it to intermediate this type of operations for them, in accordance with the provisions of article 40 of this Regulation.
(…)”[12];
Regarding the charges formulated
- There is information in the file from which it appears that operations with securities have been carried out on behalf of the Client using the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC and that GPI would have supposedly carried out operations with options and financial instruments in the foreign market with the funds and securities delivered by the Client, all these operations are detailed in Table No. 1; and possibly GPI would have carried out other supposed operations in the foreign market until September 19, 2016;
- The foregoing shows that GPI has carried out operations abroad on behalf of the client using a global account and would have carried out other supposed operations abroad on behalf of the Client, so, considering that the Client has not indicated that she has an account opened in her name at a foreign intermediary, and having deposited the funds and securities into a global account in the name of GPI at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC on September 23, 2010, said former agent company would have also carried out the other supposed operations until September 19, 2016 through said global account or another opened in its name at another foreign intermediary;
- In this sense, since GPI has participated in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments “on its own account” in the foreign market and would have participated through this modality in other supposed operations until September 19, 2016, GPI should have previously executed with the Client the respective contract as established in article 37, numeral 37.4.1, item 37.4 of the Regulation, in which the minimum content referred to in article 40 of said regulation should have been detailed;
- However, to date GPI has not proven that it executed with the Client the contract referred to in the aforementioned regulations so that it could intervene in the intermediation of financial instruments in the foreign market on its own account until September 19, 2016, taking into account that a copy of the respective contract was requested from GPI through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3. This information has also not been gathered in the Inspection; therefore, it would have breached the cited regulations;
Regarding the Defenses and their Evaluation
- GPI, as of the date of this resolution, has not complied with submitting its defenses to the charge under analysis in this section, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- However, as mentioned in the charge regarding the destination of funds, and as shown in Table No. 1, the execution of at least one operation with Credit Agricole bonds in the foreign market using the account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney has been proven. This operation is detailed in Table No. 2;
- With respect to other supposed operations that would have been carried out with the US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and the 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds, which since September 23, 2010 were transferred by this former brokerage firm to an account in the name of GPI at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, detailed in Table No. 1, GPI has not proven with the necessary documentation and no documents have been found in the Inspection that prove the execution of these operations;
- Therefore, with regard to the purchase operation of Credit Agricole Bonds detailed in Table No. 2, carried out on September 7, 2012, since GPI has participated in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments “on its own account” in the foreign market, this former brokerage firm should have previously executed with the Client the respective contract as established in article 37, numeral 37.4.1, item 37.4 of the Regulation, in which the minimum content referred to in article 40 of said regulation should have been detailed;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, taking into account that article 250 numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG provides that the authority declares the statute of limitations ex officio, it must be indicated that the SMV's power to determine the existence of infractions regarding GPI's obligation to have the respective contract indicated in the previously cited regulations has expired[13] [14];
- On the other hand, with respect to the other operations allegedly carried out, indicated in Table No. 1, since it did not present through its defenses any evidentiary means of the operations supposedly carried out, it has not been proven that GPI has intervened in the intermediation in the foreign market in the on its own account modality, in which the execution of a contract with the client is previously required, therefore it is concluded that it has not been possible to prove that it incurred an infraction classified as very serious, as established in Annex X, numeral 1, item 1.18, of the Sanctions Regulation*[15]*;
3 Using global accounts without observing the required conditions
Regarding the Regulations
- As established in article 37, numeral 37.4.2 of the Regulation, regarding the intervention of an agent company in the intermediation of securities and financial instruments, it is a requirement:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.4. If the modality of intervention of the Agent referred to in numeral 37.1 above is on its own account, the Agent must additionally comply with the following requirements:
(…)
37.4.2. Have control records of global accounts as established in this Regulation.
(…)”[16];
- On the other hand, article 90 of the Regulation establishes regarding global accounts:
“Article 90.- Content.- The Agent, for each Global Account in its name, referred to in numeral 37.4.2. of article 37 of this Regulation, must implement control records that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts. Likewise, the aforementioned records must allow the immediate generation of the following information:
90.1. Movements of securities and financial instruments in the global account.
90.2. Movements of funds related to the global account.
90.3. Balances of financial instruments and consolidated funds and at the level of clients of the Agent.
90.4. Consolidated record of financial instruments and funds related to global accounts.
These records must contain information updated on the day and be supported by the confirmations and account statements received from the foreign intermediary that executes the operations corresponding to each account, and if applicable, in the information provided by the entity in charge of the registration or custody of the securities or financial instruments, according to the operability of each account. Likewise, they must be consistent with the policies that the Agent must issue for this type of operations.”[17];
Regarding the charges formulated
- According to the documentation appearing in the file, it is observed that GPI has carried out operations with securities in the foreign market using the global account it maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC and would have supposedly carried out operations with options and financial instruments, all these operations are detailed in Table No. 1; and would have supposedly carried out other operations in the foreign market on behalf of the Client until September 19, 2016 with the funds and securities delivered by the latter to GPI, and from the date on which this delivery would have been made, that is, from September 23, 2010, for which it would have used the global account in the name of GPI at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, to which the client transferred the funds and securities, or at another foreign intermediary. It should be considered that it has not been proven that the Client has signed a contract with any foreign intermediary to carry out operations on her behalf; nor has it been possible to gather said document in the Inspection;
- In this regard, according to the cited regulations, when the brokerage firm operates through a global account[18] it is the obligation of the company to have control records of global accounts where movements of funds and financial instruments are recorded and that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said accounts;
- In this sense, GPI has not proven, to date, to have the control records of global accounts[19] until December 31, 2016 required by the regulations, however, this was requested from the former agent company through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3;
- In this sense, it was imputed to GPI that it would not have observed the provisions of article 37, numeral 37.4.2 of the regulation that expressly requires that for these operations, the intermediation agent must have the global account records, which in accordance with article 90 of the cited regulation, must indicate the movements of securities and financial instruments, of funds, balances of financial instruments and funds, among others;
Regarding the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI, as of the date of this resolution, has not complied with submitting its defenses to the charge under analysis in this section, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- However, as referred to in the evaluation of the charge on destination of funds, the execution of a purchase operation of Credit Agricole Bonds on September 7, 2012, detailed in Table No. 2, has been proven, for which the global account that GPI maintained at the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC was used;;
- Therefore, with respect to said operation, GPI has operated through a global account, so it is the obligation of the former brokerage firm to have the control records of said global account with respect to the Client from September 7, 2012 to December 31, 2016 where the movements of funds and financial instruments are recorded and that allow identifying the final holders of the securities and financial instruments grouped in said account;
- Accordingly, charges were imputed to GPI considering that from the information in the file issued by GPI it was verified that said former agent company would have carried out operations in the foreign market with the money delivered by the client, therefore it would have used the global account that GPI had at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC, as indicated in reports signed by GPI, and because it was additionally proven that GPI had transferred funds and securities of the Client to this global account that would have served for the execution of the supposed operations;
- In this sense, with respect to the proven operation detailed in Table No. 2, GPI has not substantiated having had the global account record as required by the previously cited regulations from September 7, 2012 to December 31, 2016, therefore it is concluded that it has incurred the infraction classified as serious, typified by Annex X, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Not obtaining orders from its clients
Regarding the Regulations
- Article 175 of the LMV, in force until June 24, 2011, provides regarding orders the following:
“Article 175.- Written Orders.- Intermediation agents are obliged to obtain written orders from their clients, except for other modalities susceptible of subsequent verification that CONASEV establishes through general provisions. Likewise, they must deliver a policy accrediting the operations carried out on their behalf.”;
- Likewise, article 175 of the LMV, in force as of June 25, 2011, provides the following:
“Article 175. Orders.- Orders are instructions given to intermediation agents, through which their clients express their decisions regarding the negotiation of securities or financial instruments and other services they may provide.
Through orders, clients grant a mandate to their intermediation agent to carry out the operations set forth in articles 194 and 207, as well as for the receipt of benefits, subscription of shares or any other activity related to securities or financial instruments, prior authorization from Conasev according to items t) and i) of said articles, respectively.
Orders empower intermediation agents to exercise the mandate they contain. In the case of subscription of shares, receipt of benefits or other similar, intermediation agents are authorized by the mandate of their client to act on their behalf without the need for any additional requirement or condition, except those determined by the client himself.
In accordance with the preceding paragraphs, intermediation agents are obliged to the following:
- Obtain written or telephone orders from their clients provided that the latter are recorded, without prejudice to other modalities susceptible of subsequent verification that Conasev establishes through general provisions.
- Implement systems that allow the recording of orders when they are made by telephone so that they are registered from the moment they are received. For this purpose, they must have a system for recording orders received by telephone, as well as a system for registering and filing them in accordance with the general rules issued by Conasev.
Such recordings, as well as the referred registry, must be kept for five years and made available to Conasev in the manner it establishes through a general rule.
From the moment the client gives the order by telephone, it is understood that he has been previously informed of the conditions of registration of the orders given through this means, as well as of the acceptance of the corresponding recording.
- Use only systems, as well as means of reception and registration of orders authorized by Conasev.
Likewise, intermediation agents must make available to their clients the policy accrediting the operations carried out on their behalf.”;
- On the other hand, article 30, numeral 30.2 of the Regulation in force as of February 1, 2013, establishes the following:
“Article 30.- Reception, Registration and Transmission of Orders.- For the purpose of orders given for the purchase or sale of securities or financial instruments, the following must be observed: (…)
30.2. Orders on behalf of a client may be instructed to the Agent through the following means: (i) written, (ii) fax with subsequent confirmation, (iii) telephone, (iv) through applications implemented from the Agent's website, (v) private electronic communication network with registered users, recognized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision; (vi) email with digital signature or with subsequent confirmation; (vii) DMA in accordance with the provisions of the Direct Market Access Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 024-2012-SMV/01 or the rule that replaces it; (viii) intermediated routing in accordance with the provisions of the Integrated Market through Intermediated Routing Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 107-2010-EF/94.01.1, or, (ix) other means of communication authorized by the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, in accordance with what is agreed in its respective client registration form.
In all the above cases, the Agent is responsible for verifying the authenticity of the orders it receives through the additional means it considers.”[20];
- In turn, Article 37, numeral 37.5 of the Regulation states:
“Article 37.- Requirements.- For the Agent to be able to intervene in the intermediation of securities or financial instruments traded abroad, on its own account or on behalf of its clients, and through authorized foreign intermediaries, it must previously comply with the following conditions:
(…)
37.5. Each operation intermediated by the Agent must have the corresponding client order.”[21];
Of the Charges
- GPI received funds and securities from the client since September 23, 2010 in the global account of the former stock brokerage firm, to be used for intermediation purposes in the securities market; however, GPI has not proven the order or orders regarding the Client's investment decision when it delivered the funds and securities to GPI for carrying out operations in the securities market;
- Likewise, as has been stated, GPI has carried out securities operations on behalf of the Client in the foreign market through the global account it maintained at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC and supposedly would have carried out sale operations of the securities delivered by the client and with the proceeds of these sales and with the funds delivered by the client would have carried out operations with options and financial instruments in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, and other supposed operations in the local or foreign market from September 2010 until September 19, 2016;
- Consequently, such situation must be proven with the order records required by the regulations, which should have been instructed by the Client according to the modalities established in the regulations; however, despite the fact that this was requested from the former brokerage firm through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3, it has not been proven to date;
- It should be noted that the orders from September 23, 2010 until October 6, 2014 should have been instructed under the modality denominated by your represented party “Other modality subject to verification and confirmation”, according to the client registration form signed on that date. Subsequently, from October 7, 2014 until September 2016 the orders should have been instructed under the modality denominated by your represented party “Other means authorized by the SMV” according to the client registration form signed on that date;
- Thus, taking into account the above, according to the provisions of Article 175 of the LMV and Article 37, numeral 37.5, of the Regulation, GPI had the obligation to collect the order or orders regarding the client's decision to carry out operations in the securities market with the funds and securities delivered to GPI. However, such orders would not have been collected by GPI taking into account that they have not been proven by the former stock brokerage firm, thus breaching the securities market regulations cited above;
Of the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI as of the date of this resolution has not complied with presenting its defenses to the charge subject to analysis in this section, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- On this matter, it is appropriate to note that, as stated in the charge referring to the destination of funds for different purposes, with documents collected in the Inspection, the execution of a purchase operation of Credit Agricole bonds on September 7, 2012 on behalf of the Client in the foreign market has been proven, whose detail is shown in Table No. 2. However, it should be highlighted that GPI has not sent to date the respective order of the Client regarding such operation. Likewise, GPI has not sent to date the order or orders that it was obliged to collect at the time of receiving the funds and securities from the client in the global account in the name of GPI on September 23, 2010;
- Finally, it should be specified that the process of collecting orders from a client by a stock brokerage firm must be prior to the execution of the operations, which must be proven with the presentation of the corresponding order record according to the order instruction modality initially agreed with the Client in the Client Registration Form, in this case signed on August 19, 2010 should have been taken according to the modality chosen and in force until October 6, 2014 which is that of “Other modality subject to verification and confirmation”;;
- Notwithstanding the above, taking into account that Article 250 numeral 250.3 of the TUO LPAG provides that the authority declares prescription ex officio, it must be indicated that the SMV's power to determine the existence of infractions regarding GPI's obligation to collect the Client's order for the transfer of funds and securities that occurred on September 23, 2010 and for the purchase operation of Credit Agricole bonds of September 7, 2012 detailed in Table No. 2, has prescribed[22] [23];
- not delivering account statements in the form required by the regulations
Of the Regulations
- Regarding the client's account statements, the Regulation establishes the following:
“Article 82.- Client Account Statement.- The client account statement is a report that shows in detail the movements made during a determined period and the balances of securities, financial instruments and funds in the name of a client.
Each client must have an account statement, which must contain at minimum the following information for each transaction made:
-
- Transaction date.
- Type of transaction: Purchase, sale, collection, payment, transfer or any other.
- Description corresponding to the type of transaction: The description must be clear and sufficient to identify the nature of the transaction, especially in the case of transfers or others different from purchases, sales, collections or payments.
- Identification of the corresponding document: policy, receipt or other.
- In the case of purchase and sale operations of securities or financial instruments, for each of these:
- Denomination of the security or financial instrument.
- The quantity purchased and/or sold.
- Unit price.
- Currency of the transaction.
- Amount of the transaction.
- Monetary balance at the end of each date.
Furthermore, the client account statement must present separately and clearly, the balance of all securities and instruments owned by the client, under the control or responsibility of the Agent, specifying their availability status or any other.
In the event that a client has more than one identification code for carrying out its operations, the Agent must implement an account statement in which all the referred codes are consolidated.
In the case of financial instruments managed in global accounts in the name of the Agent, the name of the Depository or Custody Institution of said instruments must be specified.
Article 83.- Availability of the Account Statement.-The Agent must make available to its clients, account statements of their movements and balances of securities, financial instruments and funds, through the means agreed with them, as recorded in the registration form of each client.
Within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of each month, the Agent must prove that it has sent or has enabled account statements of movements to its clients, who have carried out any operation during that period, except when said movements are only placements. The Agent must keep in magnetic media a faithful copy of the account statements that were enabled to its clients.
For clients who have not carried out any operation within any of the quarters of each year, and provided they maintain balances of securities, financial instruments or funds; the Agent must prove when applicable, that it sent or enabled their account statement within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of the quarter.
In no case may the Agent exempt itself from the obligation established in this article, to provide information to its clients regarding their operations, securities and financial instruments.”;
- On the other hand, the current regulation provides the following:
“Article 18.- Account statement and its availability
The client account statement is a report that shows in detail the movements made during a determined period and the balances of Financial Instruments and resources in the name of a client. The account statement must have the information contained in Article 92. The Agent must make available to its clients the account statements through the means agreed with them as recorded in the contract with each client: within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of each month, except in periods in which the client has not carried out any operation.
In the case of clients who have not carried out an operation within any of the quarters of each year, and provided they maintain balances of Financial Instruments or resources; the Agent must send or make available their account statement within thirty (30) calendar days following the close of the quarter. In the case of clients who have balances less than one thousand soles (S/ 1,000.00) both in resources and in holdings of Financial Instruments, and provided they have not carried out operations during that period, the sending or making available of their account statement may be done annually. For this purpose the Financial Instruments must be valued at market value or failing that at nominal value.
The Agent must be able to prove compliance with this obligation.
Article 92.- Content of the account statement
Each client must have an account statement, which must contain at minimum the following information for each transaction made:
a) Transaction date.
b) Type of transaction: Purchase, sale, collection, payment, transfer or any other.
c) Description corresponding to the type of transaction: The description must be clear and sufficient to identify the nature of the transaction, especially in the case of transfers or others different from purchases, sales, collections or payments.
d) Identification of the corresponding document: policy, receipt or other.
e) In the case of purchase and sale operations of Financial Instruments, for each of these:
1. Denomination of the Financial Instrument;
2. The quantity purchased and/or sold; and,
3. Unit price.
f) Currency of the transaction.
g) Amount of the transaction.
h) Monetary balance at the end of each date.
Furthermore, the client account statement must present separately and clearly, the balance of all Financial Instruments owned by the client, under the control or responsibility of the Agent, specifying their availability status or any other.
In the case of Financial Instruments managed in global accounts in the name of the Agent, the name of the Depository or Custody Institution of said Financial Instruments must be specified.”;
Of the Charges
- As the preceding regulations have indicated, the client account statement constitutes a means that must show the balance of funds, securities and financial instruments in the name of a client, as well as reflect detailed information to know if the order given by the client was fulfilled in its entirety, that is, if it was bought or sold on the indicated date, at what price, quantity, conditions, among others; and, in the case of operations abroad, the last paragraph of Article 82 of the Regulation and 92 of the current regulation provides that the name of the depository or custody institution of the financial instruments must be indicated;
- It should also be added that Article 83 of the Regulation and 18 of the current regulation provides the frequency in which such account statements must be communicated to clients and that in no case may the stock brokerage firm exempt itself from the obligation to provide information to its clients regarding their operations, securities or financial instruments;
- It should be remembered that according to what was stated by the client and with the documentation in the file, both parties agree in stating that the former delivered funds and securities to GPI on September 23, 2010, which generates the obligation to inform said client of the balances of funds and securities owned by it with the corresponding account statement, with the frequency, form and means that correspond, in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation and current Regulation;
- It should be noted that according to the client registration form of August 19, 2010 issued in the name of the client, regarding the modes of access to the account statement, it states “pick up at the SAB office” and subsequently from October 7, 2014 according to the client registration form signed on that date it states “do not send”;
- In this regard, GPI has not proven in accordance with the provisions of the regulations that it has enabled account statements of movements to the referred client. Likewise, it should be added that, in accordance with the provisions of the Regulation, in no case could the former stock brokerage firm exempt itself from the obligation to provide information to the Client regarding its operations, securities or financial instruments;
- According to Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3, GPI was requested to present the account statements in the name of the Client and the proof of the corresponding reception. In this regard, and despite having been validly notified, GPI has not proven to date such account statements nor the respective enabling to the client or, if applicable, the respective reception;
- In this sense, it is evident that GPI should have enabled the account statements to the client from the close of September 2010 to the close of September 2014 or have delivered or enabled them from the close of October 2014 to the close of December 2016;
- Likewise, it is also evident that the former stock brokerage firm should also have the corresponding reception charges, or proofs that prove the enabling, regarding such account statements;
- In this sense, according to the above, GPI would have breached the regulations cited above;
Of the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI as of the date of this resolution has not complied with presenting its defenses to the charge subject to analysis in this section, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- As stated, it has been proven since September 23, 2010 the delivery by the Client to GPI of funds for US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 GM Bonds and 80,000 OP Bonds, to an account in the name of GPI at Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC and the execution of an operation in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, detailed in Table No. 2;
- In this sense, it should be noted that both in the preliminary investigation stage and in the charges formulated against GPI, said company has not proven, with the corresponding enabling proofs, that it has made available the account statements to the Client from the close of September 2010 to December 2016, showing the balances of funds and securities paid by the Client as of September 23, 2010 and the purchase operation of September 7, 2012, as well as the balances of funds and securities related to this operation, such as delivery of coupons, redemptions and maturities and fund movements;
- In this regard, in the Client Registration Form signed on August 19, 2010, the means agreed between the parties to make available the account statements is stated as “pick up at the SAB office” and subsequently from October 7, 2014 according to the Client Registration Form signed on October 7, 2014 the modality is “do not send”. However, this does not exempt the former stock brokerage firm from complying with the provisions of the regulations previously cited;
- Consequently, GPI breached Articles 82 of the Regulation and 92 of the Current Regulation referring to the content of the account statement, as well as Articles 83 of the Regulation and 18 of the current regulation referring to the availability of the account statement, regarding its obligation to send the account statements to the Client corresponding from the close of September 2013 to December 2016;
- In this sense, by not having disproved this charge, it is concluded that GPI incurred an infraction classified as serious, typified by Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, regarding its obligation to send the account statements to the Clients corresponding from the close of September 2013 to December 2016;
- However, taking into account that Article 233 numeral 233.3 of the LPAG provides that the authority declares prescription ex officio[24], it must be indicated that the SMV's power to determine the existence of infractions regarding the sending of account statements to the Client corresponding from the close of September 2010 to June 2013, has prescribed[25];
- Not delivering policies
Of the regulations
- Article 175 of the LMV provides regarding policies the following:
“Article 175.- Orders.-
(…)
Likewise, intermediation agents must make available to their clients the policy that proves the operations carried out on their behalf.”;
- Regarding policies, the regulation establishes the following:
“Article 79.- Policy.- The Agent for each operation it intermediates must issue the respective policy and make it available to the corresponding client, within a period no greater than three (03) days following the execution of the operation.
The Agent is responsible for the policies that are delivered to its clients having the signature of a Representative or Manager.
Article 81.- Policies of Foreign Operations.- In the case of operations executed in foreign markets, the Agent must issue a policy for each client, corresponding to each order executed through a foreign broker.
In these policies, in addition to the information detailed in the preceding article, the Agent must reveal:
81.1. Regarding the price consigned, it will be indicated if it is the price of the original operation obtained abroad, or if it is an average price assigned by the Agent. In the latter case, the relationship of prices and quantities corresponding will be detailed.
81.2. The commission of the foreign intermediary and of any other foreign entity, if applicable.
81.3. The net commission corresponding to the Agent.”[26];
Of the Charges
- In the preliminary investigation initiated in response to the complaint filed by the client, through Official Letter No. 889-2017-SMV/10.3, information was requested from GPI regarding the intermediation operations that supposedly would have been carried out on behalf of the Client, requesting, among others, a copy of the policies corresponding to said operations as well as the proofs of reception by the latter, information that has not been sent to date;
- It should be specified that for every operation carried out in the name of its clients, the stock brokerage firm is obliged to issue the respective policies that prove such operations, regardless of whether such operations were carried out in the national or foreign market, and deliver them to its clients in order to verify that what was done is in accordance with the instructions given by them, among others;
- In this sense, and taking into account the cited regulations, GPI was charged that it would have breached the delivery of policies to the client for the intermediation operations it has carried out abroad on behalf of the Client and for the supposed operations detailed in Table No. 1 that it would have carried out abroad on behalf of the Client, and for other operations that it supposedly would have carried out in the local and foreign market from September 23, 2010 until September 19, 2016, for which it would have incurred an infraction;
Of the defenses and their evaluation
- GPI has not, as of the date of this resolution, complied with submitting its defense to the charge under analysis in this section, even though it was validly notified in accordance with the regulations;
- In this case, GPI was required to provide proof of the corresponding policies for the operations that GPI allegedly carried out on behalf of the Client with shares in the local and foreign markets, and for other operations that it allegedly carried out on behalf of the Client that would explain the yields paid to the principal, as well as proof of receipt by the latter; however, said former brokerage firm has not provided proof of the respective policies as of the date of this resolution;
- Now, regarding the operations indicated in Table No. 1, it is necessary to state that charges were imputed to GPI considering that, from the information presented during the preliminary inquiry stage, it was identified that this former stock brokerage firm allegedly carried out operations in the foreign market with the money delivered by the Client and therefore should have the corresponding policies for said operations;
- However, GPI has not submitted in this administrative sanctioning proceeding its defense or any evidence of the alleged operations with securities and financial instruments carried out on behalf of the Client in the foreign market and other alleged operations with securities and financial instruments in the local and foreign market on behalf of the Client with US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), the 100,000 GM Bonds and the 80,000 OP Bonds, which further evidences the configuration of the infringement referred to the use of funds for purposes other than those entrusted as contained in this resolution;
- Moreover, it must be specified that this charge was imputed for all operations detailed in Table No. 1, including the one of September 7, 2012, which, with documents gathered in the Inspection, its execution has been proven as detailed in Table No. 2; however, with respect to said operation, it must be indicated that to the extent that the imputation of charges refers to policies linked to operations that allegedly would have been carried out on behalf of the Client, and it is not proven that the Client instructed the execution of said operation, nor is it proven that they effectively formed part of its holdings as a result of said operation, it allows concluding that no obligation was generated on the part of GPI to issue a policy for the Client for the referred operation;
- Therefore, it is concluded that it has not been possible to prove that GPI incurred an infringement classified as light, for the alleged operations in Table No. 01, as established in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.6, of the Sanctions Regulation[27];
V. Evaluation of the Sanction
- According to article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with article 246, numeral 3, of the TUO LPAG and article 255 of the aforementioned normative body, the administrative sanctions imposed must take into account the criteria set forth by the LMV, the Sanctions Regulation and the TUO LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion in the market; d) The circumstances of the commission of the infringement; e) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement; f) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; and, g) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infringement and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
- In accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, sanctions that became final within the four (4) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infringement are considered as the offender's antecedents;
- In this regard, regarding the infringement referred to the use of funds for purposes other than those entrusted, an infringement committed from September 23, 2010 to September 19, 2016, in application of the cited article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, it must be noted that GPI, with respect to said period, presents the following infringement antecedents:
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10 of June 20, 2014, it was sanctioned with a fine of four (4) UIT for having incurred two (2) infringements of a very serious nature and three (3) infringements of a serious nature, typified in Annex X, numerals 1, subsections 1.18 and 1.19 and numeral 2 subsections 2.16 and 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, respectively.
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 023-2014-SMV/10 of November 7, 2014, it was sanctioned with a fine of 3.2 UIT for having incurred one (1) infringement of a light nature, typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation.
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 034-2015-SMV/10 of December 22, 2015, it was sanctioned with a warning for having incurred one (1) infringement of a light nature, typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- It must be noted that these sanctions became final since they were not subject to any challenge;
- Regarding the infringements referred to the sending of account statements at the close of June to September 2014, GPI presents the infringement antecedent imposed by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10. Regarding the sending of account statements from the close of December 2014 to the close of September 2015, GPI presents the infringement antecedents imposed by Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 016-2014-SMV/10 and Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 023-2014-SMV/10;
- Regarding the sending of account statements from the close of December 2015 to the close of December 2016 and the obligation to have a control registry of global accounts for the proven operation of September 7, 2012, in application of the cited article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, it must be noted that GPI presents the three sanction antecedents mentioned above. It should be noted that regarding the infringements referred to the sending of account statements from September 2013 to March 2014, it does not present sanction antecedents;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, in relation to the client's funds that were used for different purposes without the respective authorization, it must be taken into account that damage has been caused to its particular interest mainly because it has affected the trust that the client had in GPI and therefore has affected its trust in the securities market, to the extent that as of the date the destination given to the resources that were delivered for the respective investments and that have been used for purposes other than those for which they were entrusted has not been proven;
- Likewise, a protected legal interest has been affected, consisting of the protection of the investor, since GPI has openly breached various obligations of intermediaries operating in the securities market according to the provisions of the LMV and the Regulation, which are intended to prevent the affectation of investors' interests and to make the operations carried out transparent; which GPI has not complied with regarding the resources entrusted by its client, in its capacity as authorized intermediary;
- Indeed, through the infringement of using funds for different purposes, the trust that investors must have in stock brokerage firms that carry out operations in the securities market is affected, as well as exposing investors and the market to unnecessary risk situations;
- It should be noted that the fiduciary role of intermediation agents is fundamental in providing confidence to the investor about the management of their funds entrusted for investments in the securities market, and it is therefore not admissible to maintain that operations have been executed, without proving them with the corresponding documents such as orders, policies and account statements of the foreign intermediary or the corresponding custody entity, if the operations were carried out abroad, especially if the client has been requesting for several months the status of the funds and to be able to dispose of them;
- As it has not proven the destination of the funds and securities delivered by the Client, and the Client cannot dispose of the funds and securities delivered or the result of the investments made, according to its instructions, the economic harm to the aforementioned principal amounts to the total cash amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars), 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds, delivered by the Client to GPI, which was used for purposes other than those entrusted, plus the yields that could have been obtained in the best investment alternative in the market according to the client's investment profile if these funds and securities had been returned at the opportunity required by the investor[28];
- It should be noted that GPI has delivered to the Client a total amount of US$ 179,355.00 (One hundred seventy-nine thousand three hundred fifty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) for yields, which would be for the alleged investments that GPI allegedly made with its funds and securities;
- Likewise, regarding the repercussion in the market, it should be noted that by having disregarded the LMV and the Regulation and having disposed of the money delivered to the stock brokerage firm for purposes other than those ordered, the securities market has been exposed, altering the trust that investors should have in the intermediaries participating in the negotiation of operations;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is appropriate to note that both the absence of taking orders in accordance with the regulations, as well as the failure to deliver information to the client, in particular, the sending of account statements, and subsequently the delay in returning the invested funds generated uncertainty regarding the updated amount of its investments and their destination;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infringement, in relation to this criterion, it should be noted that according to the information in the file, GPI had a commercial relationship with the Client since August 19, 2010 and from September 23, 2010 GPI received funds and securities from the Client for US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds to be used for investments, for which it is required according to the regulations to collect the prior orders of this client; however, GPI not only did not collect the orders corresponding to the receipt of these funds and securities, but also has not proven the destination of the same, with the documents that every stock brokerage firm must have, in addition to orders, policies, account statements of the local and foreign intermediaries in charge of executing the operations or the corresponding custody entities, some document of authorization from the client for the use of the funds, etc.;
- Likewise, it was observed in this case that GPI has not proven the receipt by the Client of the respective account statements in the client's name;
- It should also be noted that GPI, in its capacity as intermediation agent at the date of the events, knew the securities market regulations, so it is not admissible that it has not observed the various obligations contained in the LMV and the Regulation when it receives funds from its clients, taking into account that the client places its trust in the stock brokerage firm and requires knowing the destination of its investments and disposing of its funds or selling its holdings of financial instruments, which have been generated as a result of intermediation activities, at the moment it requires it, so GPI's actions reflect an inappropriate and illegal mechanism to the detriment of its clients;
- Regarding the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement in this case, it should be noted that GPI has not proven the investments made with the total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds, delivered by the principal to GPI on September 23, 2010;
- In this sense, it is concluded that the illicit benefit obtained as a result of the infringement of using funds for purposes other than those ordered is at least greater than the total amount of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds, delivered by the principal to GPI, plus the opportunity cost incurred since the client delivered the funds to GPI and/or since these funds should have been returned at the opportunity required by them;
- It should be noted that GPI has delivered to the Client a total amount of US$ 179,355.00 (One hundred seventy-nine thousand three hundred fifty-five and 00/100 United States Dollars) for yields, which would be for the alleged investments that GPI allegedly made with its funds and securities, according to simple copies of a report issued by GPI as of October 28, 2015, vouchers and payment receipts in the name of the principal, and emails exchanged by Mrs. Orlandini and the Client on December 27 and 28, 2016, all presented by the principal;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, it must be specified that in this case GPI has disposed of the client's money for purposes other than those indicated by the latter, since only the reports issued by GPI are available regarding the alleged investment of the funds and securities that the Client delivered to GPI in operations in the foreign market detailed in Table No. 1; however, these investments, with the exception of one operation detailed in Table No. 2, have not been proven and it has not been proven that the client instructed that its funds and securities be invested in that manner;
- In this sense, intentionality in GPI's actions is evidenced, which can be determined by having developed various acts that compromise GPI's actions, which, as has been pointed out in this resolution, has not submitted defenses to refute the charges imputed in this administrative sanctioning proceeding; therefore, it is considered that it is not possible to admit that an intermediary, authorized to operate as such at the date of the events, as is GPI with several years operating in the market, can ignore compliance with essential rules of intermediation in the securities market and neglect the fiduciary responsibility that should have characterized it with respect to each of its clients;
- The foregoing demonstrates GPI's intentionality to dispose of the Client's funds for purposes other than those entrusted;
- Regarding the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infringements and the offender's contribution to their clarification, it must be indicated that GPI has not submitted defenses for the infringements subject to this sanctioning proceeding;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272[29] must be taken into account, which modified, among others, article 230, numeral 3, of Law No. 27444, and introduced as additional criteria of reasonableness: (i) the probability of detection of the infringement and (ii) recidivism for the commission of the infringement within one (1) year from the finality of the resolution that sanctioned the first infringement. Additionally, article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272 modified, among others, article 236-A[30] of Law No. 27444, restructuring the exemptions and mitigating circumstances of responsibility;
- In this sense, it corresponds to evaluate the following criteria for grading the principle of reasonableness established in article 246, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG:
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infringement, it must be indicated that in this file it has not been evidenced that GPI informed the SMV prior to the execution of the alleged operations in which it states it intervened for the intermediation of the financial instruments that it states it would have bought or sold in the name of the Client, nor did GPI reflect its position in foreign accounts as a result of said operations in such a way that the prudential limit[31] established for that purpose reflected its exposure to the risks inherent in that type of operations. Additionally, to date GPI has not proven the alleged execution of operations that it states it carried out;
Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the information that GPI provided to the regulator did not reasonably evidence elements that allow knowing of the infringements subject to this administrative sanctioning proceeding. The omission in the preparation of information supporting GPI's relationship with the client such as orders or account statements increases the difficulty of detecting these infringements;
It should also be added that in the analyzed case it was possible to detect the infringements committed by GPI based on the facts exposed by the client in the complaint filed against said former stock brokerage firm;
- With reference to the recurrence of the infraction, by the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (01) year from when the resolution sanctioning the first infraction became final, it must be stated that, taking into account the period to be considered for the purpose of determining a recurrence, it has not occurred;
- Regarding the grounds for exemption and mitigation of liability, in accordance with what is determined in article 255 of the TUO LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the grounds that constitute conditions for exemption and mitigation of liability have been configured;
- From the foregoing, it is concluded that GPI has incurred in the commission of three (03) infractions: one classified as very serious and two as serious under the Regulations of Sanctions;
- In accordance with the provisions of article 20 of the Regulations of Sanctions, in force at the time the facts were committed, for the infraction referred to as allocating client funds to purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, classified as very serious, GPI is liable to be sanctioned with a fine greater than fifty (50) UIT and up to three hundred (300) UIT. It should be noted that through Superintendency Resolution No. 101-2013-SMV/02, in force since August 22, 2013, article 20 of the Regulations of Sanctions was modified, in the extent referring to that in the case of very serious infractions, they are sanctionable with a fine greater than fifty (50) and up to seven hundred (700) Tax Units (UIT);
- Likewise, according to article 21 of the Regulations of Sanctions, in force at the time the facts were committed, for the infraction referred to as not delivering account statements, classified as serious, GPI is liable to be sanctioned with a fine greater than twenty-five (25) UIT and up to fifty (50) UIT;
- Considering the analysis carried out regarding the sanction criteria, and taking into account the provisions of article 15 of the Regulations of Sanctions, in the analyzed case it corresponds to impose on GPI the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction;
- Taking into account that for the commission of the very serious infraction GPI is liable to be sanctioned with the revocation of the operating authorization, and given that as of the date of the present resolution the operating authorization of GPI has been revoked, it is meaningless to impose said sanction, as this Adjunct Superintendency considers that it would be appropriate to impose a fine sanction for the commission of the mentioned infraction;
- Regarding what the client indicated regarding being affected by GPI and that their investment in said former intermediary was a portfolio of funds and securities valued at US$ 238,524.56 (Two hundred thirty-eight thousand five hundred twenty-four and 56/100 United States Dollars) that the Client delivered to said former agent society to carry out operations in the period between September 23, 2010, and September 19, 2016, it should be noted that in the administrative file there are documents presented by the Client by which they accredited the transfer of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 bonds) made on September 23, 2010, to account No. 428-90348-13-056, which corresponds to the global account that GPI maintained with the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC. Likewise, no operations are recorded on the Lima Stock Exchange in the name of the Client, nor is there information about over-the-counter operations carried out in the local market in the name of the Client through GPI;
- In this sense, from the documents presented by the mentioned client, it is possible to conclude that the transferred money was exposed by the mentioned client's will to the risks inherent in an investment abroad, such as the operational risk of the foreign broker where it was deposited, and furthermore, since the realization of an operation in the foreign market has been accredited, part of the funds were exposed to the investment risks in the foreign market, in addition to the market and credit risks assumed by investors who invest in bonds; therefore, according to the provisions of articles 1, 24, and 28 of the Guarantee Fund Regulation, in this case, the execution of the Guarantee Fund is not appropriate;
- Notwithstanding what is stated in the preceding consideration, GPI has committed one (01) very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Regulations of Sanctions, regarding allocating funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted, two (2) serious infractions classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsections 2.10 and 2.19 of the Regulations of Sanctions regarding its obligation to remit the account statements to the Client corresponding from the close of September 2013 to December 2016 and to have the global account records at least for the operation accredited detailed in Table No. 2 from September 7, 2012, to December 2016; therefore, the corresponding sanction is imposed through the present Resolution; without prejudice to the fact that the client can resort to the appropriate legal action to obtain the return of US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars) and 100,000 (One hundred thousand) General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 Bonds and 80,000 (Eighty thousand) Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 Bonds that they delivered to GPI as accredited in the present administrative procedure;
- It should be indicated that in the case of bond investments, they are debt instruments that redeemed in January 2011 and July 2012; therefore, in the case of Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 Bonds; if the Client had held them until maturity and had not instructed GPI to carry out operations with them in the period between September 23, 2010, and the maturity date; they would have obtained from the issuer of said bonds, the payment of their nominal value and the corresponding coupons;
- On the other hand, in the case of General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 Bonds, since 2009, these values registered defaults due to the issuer's bankruptcy; therefore, as a result of a liquidation process, an exchange of said bonds for Warrants (Type A and B) and shares of the new General Motor was carried out. This situation is part of the credit risks assumed by the Client when investing in debt instruments; it should be noted that when the Client transferred the bonds to GPI, they were already in default status. In this sense, it has not been accredited that the Client instructed GPI to carry out operations with them in the period between September 23, 2010, and the maturity date so that the pertinent measures and decisions could be adopted as part of the liquidation process. In this unaccredited case, the Client would have obtained the values resulting from the exchange or the result of the negotiation of them;
- Finally, it should be indicated that the resolution of the present administrative sanctioning procedure is based on the evaluation of the information contained in the respective file, whose source is the documentation provided by the Client and that gathered during the inspection; to the extent that GPI has not pronounced itself regarding this, neither in the preliminary investigation stage, nor in the stage of presenting defenses; it should be considered in this context the role that SMV plays as an entity supervising the securities market and whose objective is to ensure the fulfillment of the purpose established in its Organic Law and in the Securities Market Law, which is to promote the orderly development and transparency and integrity of the securities market; as well as the adequate protection of the investor, among others;
Being subject to the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:*
Article 1.- To declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society has incurred in a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.1 of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms, for having contravened the provisions of article 195, letter a) of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments, and article 48 of the Regulations of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms, for allocating funds received as a consequence of its intermediation activities to operations or purposes other than those for which they were entrusted.
Article 2.- To declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society has incurred in a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms, for having contravened the provisions of articles 82 and 83 of the Regulations of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms, regarding its obligation to remit the account statements to Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides corresponding from the close of September 2013 to December 2016.
Article 3.- To declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society has incurred in a serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 2, subsection 2.19 of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms, for not having the global account records at least from September 7, 2012, to December 2016.
Article 4.- To declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society has not incurred in a very serious infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 1, subsection 1.18 of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
Article 5.- To declare that Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society has not incurred in a minor infraction classified in Annex X, numeral 3, subsection 3.6 of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10.
Article 6.- To declare that the faculty of the Securities Market Superintendency to determine the existence of an infraction regarding the obligation of Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society to collect the order or orders from Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides for the transfer of funds and securities that occurred on September 23, 2010, and for the purchase operation of Credit Agricole Bonds on September 7, 2012, the obligation to remit the account statements to Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides corresponding from the close of September 2010 to June 2013, and for having subscribed a contract with Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides for the operation in the foreign market on September 7, 2012, has prescribed.
Article 7.- To sanction Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society with a fine of 60 UIT, equivalent to S/ 216,000.00 (Two hundred sixteen thousand and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions referred to in articles 1, 2, and 3 of the present resolution.
Article 8.- To order that within three (03) business days, Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society comply with returning US$ 122,304.56 (One hundred twenty-two thousand three hundred four and 56/100 United States Dollars that Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides delivered to said former agent society to carry out operations starting from September 23, 2010, as set forth in the present resolution.
Likewise, within said period, GPI must return to Ms. Maria Verónica Helena Mendoza Benavides the proceeds from the liquidation of 100,000 General Motors Corporation 7.20% 15/01/2011 Bonds and 80,000 Ontario Province 5.125% 17/07/2012 Bonds; as these are debt instruments already redeemed. For this purpose, the specific situation of each bond must be considered as exposed in the consideration part of the present resolution.
Article 9.- The present resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless consented to, and can be challenged before the Adjunct Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal resource presented to it, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 10.- In the event that the present resolution is not subject to challenge through a reconsideration or appeal resource within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Securities Market Superintendency, in compliance with the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on Publicity of Normative Projects, General Normative Rules, and other Administrative Acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10° A of the Regulations of Sanctions, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its modifying norms.
Article 11.- To transcribe the present resolution to Grupo Privado de Inversiones- Valores S.A. ex Bolsa Agent Society, to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A., and to Cavali S.A. ICLV.
Register, communicate, and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Adjunct Superintendent
Adjunct Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
- In force as of December 31, 2016. ↑
- It should be noted that said obligation is currently maintained in article 83 of the current regulation. ↑
- Through letter dated September 15, 2010 (File 2010029743), GPI communicated to the SMV that since June 11, 2010, it began commercial relations with the foreign intermediary Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC and indicated that the account number is 428-90348-13-056. ↑
- In this report, the 80,000 OP Bonds do not appear, because they were sold by GPI and with the proceeds of the sale, 3,560 Fleet Capital Trust 7.2% preferred shares were acquired with an investment of US$ 85,440.00. This amount added to US$ 30,620.00 plus US$ 122,304.56 totals an amount of US$ 238,364.56. ↑
- No. 098-143059-056. ↑
- No. 098-143059-056. ↑
- Presented by the Client in their complaint. ↑
- Likewise, in the same information found in the Inspection, it is shown that at the closings of July to December 2013, the Client owned shares of the new General Motors (7 shares at the close of July to November 2013 and 28 shares at the close of December 2013), warrants of types A and B with the option to acquire shares of the new General Motors (7 warrants of each type A and B at the close of July to November 2013 and 26 warrants of each type A and B at the close of December 2013) and shares of Motors Liquidation Company (102 shares at the close of July to December 2013), the company in charge of the liquidation of the former General Motors as a consequence of its bankruptcy. However, these holdings were not the result of operations carried out by GPI, but rather the result of the delivery of securities by the issuer as a consequence of the aforementioned bankruptcy. ↑
- The registration date on the BVL was March 7, 2011. ↑
- Article 411 of the Penal Code, Legislative Decree No. 635.
“Article 411.- Whoever, in an administrative procedure, makes a false statement regarding facts or circumstances that they are responsible for proving, violating the presumption of veracity established by law, shall be punished with a prison sentence not less than one nor more than four years.” ↑
11. To the Client's question regarding what the concept of “withdrawals” mentioned in the previous email from Ms. Orlandini refers to, the latter explains that “withdrawals are the funds that have been delivered to you over time and are the profits obtained (or interest earned) as a consequence of the management of your capital. In other words, your capital has yielded 78.44%. These are the amounts registered for liquidation.” ↑
12. It should be noted that said obligation is currently maintained in article 63 literal d) of the current regulation. ↑
13. It should be indicated that this infraction was prescribed at the time of the Client's complaint submission (February 7, 2017). ↑
14. It should be indicated that according to article 342 of the LMV, the faculty to determine the existence of administrative infractions with respect to all natural and legal persons under the competence of the SMV prescribes after four years. ↑
15. This position was adopted by the Adjunct Superintendency of Prudential Supervision in considerations 282 and 283 of Adjunct Superintendency SMV Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10. It should be noted that said resolution was subject to an appeal by GPI, which was declared unfounded under article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02. ↑
16. It should be noted that the obligation to have global account control mechanisms is maintained in literal e) of article 63 of the current regulation. ↑
17. It should be noted that the obligation is maintained in article 93 of the current regulation. ↑
18. That is, an account opened in the name of the intermediary in a foreign broker, in order to carry out operations abroad and with its clients' funds. ↑
19. Said global account control record would identify the operations carried out with securities and financial instruments in the foreign market on behalf of the Client, and would include the positions in options, as well as the fund balances corresponding to it. ↑
20. The cited provisions are currently regulated in article 49 of the current regulation. ↑
21. It should be noted that the requirements that the agent must meet for the intermediation of financial instruments traded abroad are currently regulated in article 63 of the current regulation. ↑
22. It should be indicated that this infraction was prescribed at the time of the Client's complaint submission (February 7, 2017). ↑
23. It should be indicated that according to article 342 of the LMV, the faculty to determine the existence of administrative infractions with respect to all natural and legal persons under the competence of the SMV prescribes after four years. ↑
24. It should be indicated that according to article 342 of the LMV, the faculty to determine the existence of administrative infractions with respect to all natural and legal persons under the competence of the SMV prescribes after four years. ↑
25. It should be indicated that these infractions were prescribed at the time of the Client's complaint submission (February 7, 2017). The Client expanded their complaint and presented documentation related to it until August 22, 2017. ↑
26. The cited provisions applicable to policies and foreign operation policies are currently regulated in articles 57 and 91 of the current regulation. ↑
27. Said position was adopted by the Adjunct Superintendency of Prudential Supervision in considerations 425 and 426 of Adjunct Superintendency SMV Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10. It should be noted that said resolution was subject to an appeal by GPI, which was declared unfounded under article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02 ↑
28. Said position was adopted by the Adjunct Superintendency of Prudential Supervision in consideration 445 of Adjunct Superintendency SMV Resolution No. 049-2016-SMV/10. It should be noted that said resolution was subject to an appeal by GPI, which was declared unfounded under article 1 of Superintendency Resolution No. 006-2017-SMV/02. ↑
29. Published in the Official Gazette El Peruano on December 21, 2016. ↑
30. “Article 236-A
1.- The following constitute grounds for exemption from liability for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or force majeure duly proven. b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right to defense. c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction. d) Mandatory order from a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions. e) Error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision. f) Voluntary remediation by the potential sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the charge referred to in paragraph 3) of article 235.
2.- The following constitute conditions for mitigation of liability for infractions:
a) If a sanctioning administrative procedure has been initiated, the infringer expressly and in writing acknowledges its responsibility. In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount no less than half of its amount. b) Others established by special norm.”* ↑
31. The position of an intermediation agent in foreign accounts must at all times be less than 10 times their net worth. ↑
32. A warrant is a derivative that grants the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a security, generally shares directly from a company at a fixed price for a determined period. ↑