Enforcement · SMV · 9 Dec 2021
Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión is fined 30 UIT (S/ 121,500.00) for six infractions: one very serious for failing to assess impairment of a fund's investments; three serious for not observing guarantee-execution provisions, audit-team composition limits, and property appraisal requirements; one serious for charging a fund instead of the administrator for third-party services; and one serious for preparing audited financial statements as of 31 December 2017 without observing applicable regulations.
PERÚ Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas
SMV
Superintendency of the Market de Valores
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Peru suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
Lima, 09 December 2021
Summary: Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión is sanctioned with a fine of 30 UIT equivalent to S/ 121,500.00 (One hundred twenty-one thousand five hundred and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred in six (6) infractions: one (1) very serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not having carried out the impairment assessment of the investments of a fund it administers; three (3) serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not having complied with observing provisions related to the process of execution of guarantees; the limitation that should have been observed in the composition of the audit team of the financial statements; and compliance with the appraisal requirement of the properties given as collateral for the approval of investments; one (1) serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulation, for having charged a Fund instead of charging the administrator for contracting third-party services; one (1) serious typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, for having prepared its audited financial statements as of 31 December 2017 without observing the regulations established for that purpose.
Administered
:
Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión Subject :
Administrative sanctioning procedure
File No.:
2021008834
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
Administrative file No. 2021008834, and Report No. 597-2021-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the defenses presented by Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión; and,
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
1. Pursuant to article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
2. Through Report No. 097-2021-SMV/10.2 the General Intendancy of Entity Supervision (IGSE) communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (IGCP), the indications of a possible infraction by Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión (hereinafter, POPULAR SAFI), inasmuch as it would have failed to comply with the provisions of the Law of Investment Funds and their administering companies, approved by Legislative Decree No. 862 and its amendments (hereinafter, LAW), the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Administering Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, REGULATION), the Norms on preparation and presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV-01 (hereinafter NORMS);
3. Under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), approved by DS No. 004-2019-JUS, through Official Letter No. 951-2021-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES), notified on 09 March 2021, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against POPULAR SAFI regarding the facts evidenced in the investigation carried out on said administering company;
4. By letter received on 22 March 2021 POPULAR SAFI requested the extension of the term granted for the presentation of its defenses; which was granted through Official Letter No. 1186-2021-SMV/10.3 notified on 24 March 2021. In this sense, by letter of 22 April 2021, the administrator presented the requested defenses;
5. The charges formulated against POPULAR SAFI and the defenses of the latter have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 597-2021-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendency;
6. In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in article 230, subparagraph 2, of the TUO LPAG, through Official Letter No. 2072-2021-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 597-2021-SMV/10.3 was made available to POPULAR SAFI for its review;
7. In the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
a. Whether POPULAR SAFI incurred or not in infraction to the provisions of Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter SANCTIONS REGULATION), in force at the time the facts occurred, for non-compliance with articles 14, 19, numerals II, literal d) and III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the Participation Regulation of the Capital Emprendedor Fund – Investment Fund” (hereinafter, FUND).
b. Whether POPULAR SAFI incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time the events occurred, by not having complied with observing articles 7 and 8 of the REGULATION.
c. Whether POPULAR SAFI incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex VI, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time the events occurred, by not having complied with observing article 83 in accordance with article 85 of the REGULATION, article 49 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND, and the provisions of paragraphs 58, 59, 63, 64 and GA84 of IAS 39.
d. Whether POPULAR SAFI incurred or not in an infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time the events occurred, by not having complied with observing article 132 of the REGULATION, article 1 of the NORMS and paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15 of the "Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting" and paragraph 91 literal a) of IFRS 13; and because furthermore the preparation and presentation of its Financial Statements as of 31 December 2017 would not be in accordance with the disclosure made by POPULAR SAFI, according to paragraphs 16, 112 and 117 of IAS 1 and paragraphs 5.102, 5.104, 5.104.02.1 in literal b) of numeral 1 and literal a) and b) of numeral 2 of the MANUAL.
e. Whether or not it is appropriate to impose a sanction on POPULAR SAFI;
8. In accordance with articles 5, 18 and 19 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND as of 5 July 2017, it is established that:
"Article 5.- Objective of the FUND The FUND has the objective of investing its resources mainly in TCHN, a debt instrument not registered in the REGISTRY that incorporates a real estate guarantee characterized by being freely negotiable by endorsement and allowing the extrajudicial execution of the guarantee. This instrument may be issued by SUNARP or by a financial system company authorized for this purpose. (...)"
"Article 18.- Diversification by Type of Instruments The maximum percentages, with respect to the total assets of the FUND, to be maintained in the different investment modalities shall be:
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
| INSTRUMENT | CLASSIFICATION | MAXIMUM LIMIT | MINIMUM LIMIT | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | Negotiable Mortgage Credit Securities | Not applicable | 100% | 75% |
(...)"
"Article 19.- Investment in TCHN
Since TCHN is the predominant investment of the FUND, it is convenient to specify the scope of the evaluation, investment and execution in these TCHN:
(...)
II. Criteria
(...)
d) Criteria for the execution of the TCHN
The FUND may initiate a process of execution of the guarantee associated with the TCHN when the EMPRENDEDOR, constituent-obligor has not complied with paying two (02) or more consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule, or the last installment thereof. The FUND shall necessarily initiate a process of execution of the guarantee associated with the TCHN when the EMPRENDEDOR, constituent-obligor has not complied with paying six (06) consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule unless there is an offer to purchase the TCHN at a price attractive to the interests of the FUND in which case the FUND may proceed with the sale thereof.
(...)".
9. In accordance with article 18 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND, TCHN are the predominant investment of the FUND, and may be invested from 75%, as a minimum, up to 100% of its total assets;
10. Likewise, according to the provisions of the aforementioned participation regulation, the sector to which the FUND will allocate its investments in these securities are those natural and legal persons qualified as entrepreneurs1, who are not necessarily owners of the properties that will be the guarantee of the TCHN, documents that will be endorsed in favor of the FUND;
11. In the same manner, literal c) of the aforementioned article 19 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND, states that the securities may be susceptible to being sold in the secondary market when it is protested by the FUND for non-payment or when an offer attractive to its interests is received;
12. Likewise, in accordance with article 19, numeral II, literal d), the FUND may initiate a process of execution of the guarantee associated with the TCHN when the debtor, constituent-obligor has not complied with paying two (2) or more consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule, or the last installment thereof; it being further established that the FUND shall necessarily initiate a process of
[1] Article 1 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND, Entrepreneur(s) is the "Natural or legal person, with a business in operation or in project, micro, small or medium entrepreneur with need for working capital, acquisition of fixed assets or restructuring of liabilities, among others, and who will ultimately be the beneficiary of the disbursement made by the FUND. The EMPRENDEDOR is not necessarily the owner of the property that will be left as guarantee with respect to which the TCHN will be issued".
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
execution of the guarantee associated with the TCHN when the constituent-obligor has not complied with paying six (06) consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule, unless there is an offer to purchase the security at a price attractive to the interests of the FUND, in which case it will proceed with the sale thereof;
13. In that regard, during the inspection carried out on POPULAR SAFI from 21 March to 11 April 2018 (hereinafter, the INSPECTION), the SMV inspection team reviewed the investments made by the FUND as of 31 December 2017, observing that POPULAR SAFI would not have carried out the corresponding guarantee enforcement procedure with respect to some cases of TCHN that are in a situation of payment default;
14. Below are shown the cases that at the time of the INSPECTION were in payment default (including principal and interest), with arrears equal to or greater than six (6) installments, and in respect of which POPULAR SAFI had not carried out the enforcement process of the guarantee associated with the TCHN;
TABLE No. 1 NEGOTIABLE MORTGAGE CREDIT SECURITIES IN PAYMENT DEFAULT WITH MORE THAN SIX OVERDUE INSTALLMENTS WHERE THE GUARANTEE HAS NOT BEEN ENFORCED
| TCHN | Disbursement Date | Due Date | No. Installment | Overdue Installments | Overdue Interest | Total Penalty | Overdue Principal | Total Capital | Judicial Indicator | Overdue principal/ Total Capital |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TCHN06424 | 19/06/2014 | 19/06/2019 | 60 | 10 | 5,689.91 | 2,943.12 | 6,972.43 | 25,048.64 | N | 28% |
| TCHN07051 | 27/10/2014 | 27/10/2019 | 60 | 11 | 16,078.70 | 7,316.11 | 17,334.29 | 71,503.08 | N | 24% |
| TCHN08222 | 20/07/2015 | 20/07/2019 | 48 | 12 | 14,486.93 | 7,456.49 | 17,162.97 | 57,431.14 | N | 30% |
15. It should be added that POPULAR SAFI has an Operations Procedures Manual - MPO (hereinafter MPO), in force at the date of the events, which in numeral 11 procedure called "Judicial Collections" details the steps to follow and the responsibilities of the SAFI's bodies in order to carry out the respective collection from the debtors via TCHN who have not timely complied with their payments to the FUND. In this regard, it is convenient to cite the "Scope" of said procedure2:
"This procedure applies to all types of debt via TCHN whose client has breached the established contract, having previously gone through the regular collection process, where, as the collection made by the company's personnel was ineffective, it is decided to collect the debt through the enforcement of the real estate property through judicial channels. It begins with the decision to enforce collection through judicial channels, after Protest of the Security, and ends with the collection of the debt with the money obtained in said enforcement";
16. It is appropriate to add that, by letter of 28 December 20183, POPULAR SAFI stated that it is not responsibility attributable to it that legal and market conditions prevent the extrajudicial enforcement of mortgage guarantees;
17. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI stated that the participants are aware of the limitations of the extrajudicial enforcement of the guarantees
[2] Pages 44 to 48.
[3] Letter PA-AC/No. 18-072 of 28 December 2018.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
constituted in the TCHN through the investment statement, and the quarterly and annual financial information of the FUND. In this regard, it should be noted that from the reading of said investment statement it is not apparent that the SAFI has informed the FUND's participants that there are cases of TCHN debtors such as those indicated, with delays of 6 installments or more, to whom the respective judicial procedure has not been initiated, in accordance with the provisions of the FUND's Internal or Participation Regulations;
18. For the foregoing, it was evidenced that in none of the cases mentioned in Table No. 1, POPULAR SAFI would have carried out the guarantee enforcement procedure, as established in article 19, subsection II, literal d) of the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
19. In addition to citing article 19, numeral II, literal d) of the FONDO's Participation Regulation referring to the fact that the FONDO must initiate the guarantee enforcement process if the obligor fails to pay six installments, POPULAR SAFI points out that said numeral recognized two assumptions: (i) the possibility of initiating a guarantee enforcement process associated with the TCHN upon the breach of paying two or more consecutive or alternate installments of the payment schedule, and, (ii) the obligation to initiate a guarantee enforcement process associated with the TCHN upon the breach of paying six or more consecutive or alternate installments of the payment schedule, specifying that both assumptions differ by the duration of the debtor's breach;
20. POPULAR SAFI states that the original version of the FONDO's Participation Regulation contained a rigidity that over time proved unnecessary, since the FONDO's collection efforts do not begin with a judicial demand and, in practice, it was demonstrated that the FONDO's interests were better served by maintaining a cordial relationship with TCHN debtors who had the willingness to pay, instead of initiating judicial processes with the strict tables provided for in the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
21. POPULAR SAFI points out that this situation was repeatedly informed to the FONDO's participants, both through the Investment Statements presented quarterly and by the email attached to its defenses, which is an example of the communication sent to the participants about the situation of the investments and the delinquency level of the FONDO's investments;
22. POPULAR SAFI adds that as a consequence of what was reported, the Participants' Assembly for fiscal year 2019, dated 03 July 2020, agreed to amend the FONDO's Participation Regulation. In the current version, the provision indicating the possibility of initiating legal actions when the breach exceeds two installments is maintained, but the obligation to initiate judicial actions for the breach of six or more installments has been completely eliminated;
23. POPULAR SAFI considers that the FONDO's Participation Regulation currently in force, therefore, provides the SAFI with a broad field of action regarding the enforcement of the guarantee associated with the TCHN. That is to say, the possibility of initiating legal action exists, but it is subject to the administrator's criteria regarding the debtor's attitude and willingness to pay, as well as the market conditions that may exist at the time of possible enforcement;
“Decade of Equality of Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
24. Therefore, POPULAR SAFI considers it important to remember that the enforcement of guarantees is the last resort in a relationship between creditor and debtor. That the FUND's business is to generate value from the investments it makes. In other words, the enforcement of the TCHN is a decision in the face of circumstances that put the investment made by the FUND at risk, and after having ruled out other alternatives or options granted to the debtor, the enforcement of the guarantee is carried out. Ignoring this would lead one to think that, if entities engaged in financial intermediation (with public funds) do not enforce the guarantees they hold in their favor upon their clients' default, they are negligent in their operations and harm their savers, which indicates that this does not correspond to reality;
25. Considering as a breach of the FUND's Participation Regulations the fact that POPULAR SAFI did not initiate actions upon the default of three debtors implies ignoring the change made to said Regulations, since the conduct alleged as an infringement is not, as of today, conduct contrary to the FUND's Regulations. On the contrary, it is conduct consistent with the FUND's Regulations, established by the investors, and which has yielded benefits for them;
26. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI states that the cases of TCHN debtors with overdue installments that were the subject of the allegation were resolved favorably in the same year the INSPECTION was carried out, indicating that in the three cases, the debtors paid the full amount owed and the operations left profits for the FUND. The details are presented below:
| TCHN Code | Operation IRR | Cancellation Date |
|---|---|---|
| TCHN06424 | 36% | 31/10/2018 |
| TCHN07051 | 35% | 03/10/2018 |
| TCHN08222 | 35% | 16/01/2018 |
27. This sample, it states, supports the commercial strategy followed by POPULAR SAFI regarding its portfolio, which, without immediately enforcing the guarantee, has generated value for the FUND. It also adds that in the ten years of the FUND's operation, no complaints have been received regarding the management carried out by POPULAR SAFI;
28. As a consequence of the above, POPULAR SAFI specifies that a ground for exemption from liability has been established in relation to the alleged conduct, provided for in article 27 of the Sanctions Regulations (hereinafter, the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS) approved by SMV Resolution N° 035-2018-SMV/01, since the charge brought by the SMV is that POPULAR SAFI would have breached the FUND's Participation Regulations by not initiating legal actions against three debtors with more than six unpaid installments;
29. POPULAR SAFI indicates that before the sending of the CHARGE MEMORANDUM, those three debtors had already settled their obligations with the FUND and, furthermore, the FUND's Participation Regulations no longer require legal actions to be initiated for the default of six or more installments;
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the Market of Securities
“Decade of Equality of Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
30. In this regard, it must be stated that in its defenses POPULAR SAFI has not denied the alleged facts: That in none of the cases detailed in Table N° 1 did it carry out the guarantee enforcement procedure, as established in article 19, paragraph II, subsection d) of the FUND's Participation Regulations in force at the time the facts occurred;
31. On the other hand, in its defenses POPULAR SAFI states that it repeatedly informed the FUND's Participants, both through the Investment Statements and an attached email dated 15 January 2019, of the situation of the investments and the level of delinquency of the FUND's investments;
32. In this regard, it must be stated that in its defenses POPULAR SAFI has not provided the aforementioned investment statements in which it informed its participants that there was a group of debtors with more than six overdue installments to whom the enforcement procedure set forth in the FUND's Internal Regulations had or had not been initiated, and thereby prove that it adequately informed of said situation;
33. Likewise, from the reading of the aforementioned email (which is dated 15/01/2019, that is, after 31/12/2017, the date on which the INSPECTION evaluated the observed compliance), it is noted that this: i) does not include the list of recipients, and ii) does not mention or inform the participants of the specific fact, that is, that there is a group of participants who have more than six installments pending payment to whom an enforcement of guarantees process has not been initiated, as established in article 19, subsection II, subsection d) of the FUND's Participation Regulations, a legal provision in force and mandatory for POPULAR SAFI;
34. Furthermore, it must be stated that the allegation is not related to the fact of whether POPULAR SAFI communicated the indicated situation to the investors or not, but whether it complied with the provisions of the FUND's Participation Regulations. It must be indicated that the aforementioned regulation contains relevant information on the operability of the funds, thereby constituting fundamental information on the basis of which an investor decides whether or not to invest in a given fund, and in doing so, proceeds from the assumption that the conditions set out therein, which in turn define the degree of exposure to the risk assumed, will be diligently complied with by the fund manager;
35. With respect to the fact that the Shareholders' Meeting of 03 July 2020 agreed to amend the FUND's Participation Regulation and that, as a consequence thereof, the management company is allowed to have better management for the decision of whether or not to initiate legal actions against debtors in arrears in the payment of their quotas, it must be indicated that said amendment is subsequent to the alleged fact, which does not imply compliance with the observed regulation;
36. Indeed, it was alleged against POPULAR SAFI that as of 31 December 2017, the manager had not complied with the FUND's Internal Regulation by initiating legal actions against those delinquent clients who had more than 6 unpaid quotas. It should be noted that said internal regulation was amended, in this respect, only in July 2020;
37. Likewise, with respect to the fact that in 2018 (it should be specified that POPULAR SAFI has not specified in which month specifically it did so) the
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
three debtor clients mentioned in Table No. 1 had already settled the respective debt, it must be indicated that this does not imply having complied with the regulation subject to the allegation, since the observation raised refers to the close of the 2017 financial year, and not to January or October 2018, dates on which said clients allegedly would have cancelled the full amount of the amounts owed, it must be added that POPULAR SAFI has only supported this with its own statement and not with the corresponding documentation;
38. Regarding the fact that an exemption from liability due to voluntary remediation would have been generated pursuant to letter f) of Article 27 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATION, since before the notification of the CHARGES MEMORANDUM the three clients mentioned in Table No. 1 had already settled their obligations and the FUND's Internal Regulation no longer requires legal actions to be initiated for non-compliance with more than six unpaid quotas, it must be indicated that the application of said exemption due to voluntary remediation is not appropriate insofar as, as has been indicated, it has not been proven with the corresponding documentation that such non-compliance has been remedied;
39. In this regard, it must be indicated that letter f) of Article 27 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATION requires that, for the configuration of the exemption due to voluntary remediation, a communication demanding compliance with the obligation issued must not have been sent.
40. In the present case, through Official Letter No. 4439-2018-SMV/10.2 of 29 November 2018, the observations detected in the Inspection were communicated to Popular SAFI, among others, the non-compliance with the provisions of the Fund's Internal Regulations, in particular those relating to the failure to carry out the procedures for the execution of guarantees for unpaid debts to the Fund4;
41. With regard to the amendment of the FUND's Internal Regulations that occurred in July 2020, whereby the obligation of POPULAR SAFI to initiate legal actions for the non-payment of more than six unpaid installments was repealed, it should be noted that this does not constitute a voluntary remediation of the alleged fact, since, as indicated above, the observation of the questioned facts was made previously by Official Letter No. 4439-2018-SMV/10.2 of 29 November 2018;
42. On the other hand, with respect to what POPULAR SAFI stated regarding the fact that the conduct alleged as an infringement is not, as of today, conduct contrary to the FUND's Regulations, it must be taken into consideration that the rule infringed is the aforementioned Fund Regulations approved by the participants, and it is not correct to state that if said rule is subsequently amended, there is no longer non-compliance on the part of the management company, since this could generate a perverse effect whereby by failing to comply with any provision of the FUND's Regulations,
[4] (…) 1. From the investment conditions in the Participation Regulations From the evaluation carried out on the investments of the Entrepreneurial Capital Fund - Investment Fund (hereinafter, the FUND), it has been determined that some investments in TCHN are in a situation of payment default; however, the MANAGEMENT COMPANY has not accredited having carried out the procedures for the extrajudicial execution of the respective guarantee, as established in article 5 of the FUND's Participation Regulations. (…) In this sense, the MANAGEMENT COMPANY would not have adequately fulfilled its functions in the execution of TCHNs with payment default (…)
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun
subsequently its amendment is promoted in order to evade the respective liability;
43. Consequently, the defenses presented have not disproved the facts alleged as charges;
44. According to article 14 of the FUND's Participation Regulations, in the case of the selection of the auditor to carry out the audit of the FUND's financial statements, the following is established:
“Article 14°.- Selection of the AUDITING COMPANY: The selection of the AUDITING COMPANY for the FUND shall be carried out annually by the GENERAL ASSEMBLY upon the proposal of the SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE. The FUND may not be audited for more than 2 (two) consecutive years by the same audit team, although it may be by the same Auditing Company, which, in this case, must change the person responsible for issuing the opinion and all members of the audit team”.
45. In accordance with the evaluation carried out by the INSPECTION, it was verified that the audit of the financial statements as of 31 December 2015, 2016 and 2017 of the FUND was carried out by the Auditing Company “Pazos, López de Romaña, Rodríguez S.C.R.L”;
46. In this regard, it was observed that in the three (03) periods mentioned, the audit report was signed by Ms. CPCC Annika Petrozzi Helasvuo, in her capacity as a partner of the aforementioned auditing company;
47. Taking into account the limitation contained in article 14 of the FUND's Participation Regulations, which restricts the intervention of the same audit team that will carry out the FUND's audit to two consecutive years, POPULAR SAFI would have failed to comply with the provisions of the aforementioned article 14;
48. Indeed, the infringement under analysis would have occurred on 28 February 2018, the date on which Ms. CPCC Annika Petrozzi Helasvuo signed the audit report of the FUND's financial statements as of 31 December 2017, thereby failing to observe the provisions of the FUND's Participation Regulations, having signed the audit report of the FUND's financial statements as of 31 December 2015 and the audit report of the FUND's financial statements as of 31 December 2016;
49. POPULAR SAFI states that, as can be seen in Annex 2 to its defense brief, on 1 August 2017 it was communicated as a matter of importance that, through a session of the FUND's Supervisory Committee held on the same date, Pazos, López de Romaña, Rodríguez Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada (BDO) was unanimously elected as the auditing company to carry out the independent external audit of the FUND's financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year. This, by virtue of the powers delegated by the participants through the
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
general assembly dated 05 April 2017, a copy of the respective minutes of which is also attached;
50. POPULAR SAFI adds that, by means of a General Assembly of Participants dated 06 March 2018, a copy of which is likewise attached, the FUND's participants unanimously approved the independent external audit report on the financial information for the 2017 fiscal year;
51. For the foregoing reasons, POPULAR SAFI considers it demonstrated that the participants of the FUND have had full knowledge and have unanimously approved, at the respective General Assembly of Participants of the FUND, the audit report for the financial statements of the 2017 fiscal year. In other words, the participants of the FUND were aware of the team in charge of the audit;
52. POPULAR SAFI adds that there has been no claim or challenge whatsoever from participants of the FUND regarding the participation of the audit team consisting of Ms. CPCC Annika Petrozzi Helasvuo during the periods mentioned in the CHARGES LETTER;
53. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI refers that it is charged with the breach of the FUND's Participation Regulations, when the selection of the audit firm was made by the FUND's Supervisory Committee -by delegation from the General Assembly- which constitutes an autonomous body, different from POPULAR SAFI and composed entirely of participants;
54. Equally, POPULAR SAFI argues that it cannot be alleged that the participants of the FUND were unaware of, or did not know about, this appointment, given that in addition to the aforementioned material fact, they have participated in the approval of the external audit report for the 2017 fiscal year. The absence of opposition from the participants demonstrates that the selection of the audit firm has not caused any harm to the FUND and its interests -nor has it benefited POPULAR SAFI in any way- being limited solely to the failure to comply with a provision of the FUND's Participation Regulations of an internal corporate nature;
55. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI points out that it must be considered that the REGULATIONS always recognized a maximum period, during which it could be audited by the same audit team, of five consecutive years. That is to say, the FUND's conduct was framed within the provisions of a public nature that regulate the appointment of external auditors;
56. Finally, POPULAR SAFI indicates that through an Ordinary General Assembly of participants held on 29 March 2019, it was agreed to modify the scope of Article 14 of the FUND's Participation Regulations. Said article now provides, aligning with what is established by the regulations, that the maximum period during which the FUND can be audited by the same audit team is five consecutive years. This is consistent with the conduct (and agreements) of its participants and the Supervisory Committee;
57. As a consequence of the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI considers that an exculpation of the liability of the management company in relation to the alleged conduct has also occurred, inasmuch as the charge formulated is that POPULAR SAFI would have breached the Participation Regulations by allowing the FUND to be audited by the same audit team for more
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun
than three fiscal years. Before the sending of the CHARGES LETTER, the FUND's Regulations had already been modified so that this conduct is no longer contrary to what is established in the FUND's Regulations;
58. In relation to the defenses expressed, it must be indicated that POPULAR SAFI has not disproved the charge formulated because it has not demonstrated that it complied with the provisions of article 14 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
59. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI has not pointed out any argument that disproves the participation of Mrs. CPCC Annika Petrozzi Helasvuo, as a partner of the Audit Firm "Pazos, López de Romaña, Rodríguez S.C.R.L", as part of the audit team that signed the audit report for the three observed fiscal years: 2015, 2016 and 2017, even though the aforementioned article 14 prohibited it; and even in the case that she had not been part of the audit team, article 14 established that from the third consecutive year, the person responsible for issuing the opinion had to be changed;
60. In relation to the fact that it was the responsibility of the Surveillance Committee and the FONDO's participants, since they were the ones who delegated to the referred Committee the appointment of the audit firm in charge of reviewing the FONDO's financial statements, it must be indicated that according to the provisions of article 295 and 30, literal c), item (iii)6 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation, which, as well as all the provisions of said Regulation, were prepared by POPULAR SAFI, it is the management company that is responsible for the control of the FONDO's activities; that the FONDO's management is carried out in accordance with the provisions of the FONDO's Participation Regulation; as well as compliance with the FONDO's accounting obligations, among them, ensuring the observance of the observed article 14, for which reason it cannot disassociate itself from the questioned obligation and attribute it to a body of the FONDO such as the Surveillance Committee, whose obligations are described in article 697 of the referred regulation and within which the compliance of the mentioned article 14 is not appreciated;
[5] Article 29.- Obligations of POPULAR SAFI POPULAR SAFI shall be in charge of the administration, control and information of the FONDO's activities, as well as the evaluation of potential INVESTMENTS for the FONDO and execution of the INVESTMENTS that the INVESTMENT COMMITTEE authorizes. The FONDO's management is carried out in accordance with the provisions of the LAW, the REGULATION, the PARTICIPATION REGULATION, as well as the corresponding complementary and supplementary norms.
[6] Article 30.- Functions of POPULAR SAFI The functions of POPULAR SAFI include the activities detailed below: (…) c) Administrative and accounting activities (…) (iii) Be in charge of compliance with the Fondo's tax, labor, legal and administrative obligations.
[7] Article 69.- Functions and obligations (…) Its functions and obligations are: a) Monitor that POPULAR SAFI complies, with respect to the FUND, with the provisions of the LAW, the REGULATION, the PARTICIPATION REGULATION and the terms of the placement of the UNITS. b) Verify that the information provided to the PARTICIPANTS is truthful and timely. c) Verify the actions taken regarding the observations and recommendations of the FUND's external auditors. d) Convene the GENERAL ASSEMBLY, to report on its management and when in the exercise of its functions it deems necessary, and in the cases indicated in the REGULATION and the PARTICIPATION REGULATION.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
61. It is appropriate to note that even though it was the FUND's Oversight Committee that appointed the aforementioned audit firm, it is POPULAR SAFI that is responsible for the management of the FUND, in accordance with the functions attributed by the FUND's Participation Regulation, among them, verifying compliance with the provisions of the latter;
62. On the other hand, regarding the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary rectification referring to the fact that before the sending of the LETTER OF CHARGES, the FUND's Participation Regulation was modified so that the imputed conduct is no longer contrary to the current provisions of the FUND, it must be indicated that the modification made in April 2019 is subsequent to the observed fact, that is, to the presentation of the fund's financial statements for the 2015, 2016 and 2017 fiscal years;
63. In this regard, we refer to what was mentioned in the evaluation of the defenses of the previous numeral regarding the fact that it must be taken into consideration that the infringed norm is the FUND's Regulation approved by the participants and it is not correct to state that if said norm is subsequently modified, there is no longer non-compliance on the part of the fund's administrator, since this could generate a perverse effect that upon breaching any provision of the FUND's Regulation, its amendment is subsequently promoted in order to evade the respective liability;
64. Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the voluntary rectification referred to in article 27, literal f) of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATION regarding the observed fact is related to the fact that it can be rectified, which could not occur since it would imply that a third person from the contracted audit firm who has not participated in the review and preparation of the opinion for the aforementioned fiscal years, signs the corresponding one for the 2017 fiscal year, which, ultimately, has not been accredited in this administrative procedure;
65. Similarly, it must be indicated that according to article 255, literal f) of the TUO LPAG, the following constitutes an exemption from liability for the infraction committed: "The voluntary rectification of the act or omission as constituting an administrative infraction", thus, as the normative text indicates, voluntary rectification is aimed at rectifying the acts or facts or omission that constitute the imputable infraction, but not the consequences of the normative infraction. Therefore, the recognition of the exemption will depend on the constitutive elements of the infraction type;
66. Now then, the infraction type, which is evaluated in the present case, states: "Fail to comply with the obligations corresponding to
e) Participate with voice but without vote in the GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
f) Review that the body or person responsible for verifying compliance with the internal rules of conduct complies with its functions.
g) Submit to the GENERAL ASSEMBLY the proposal of external auditors of the FUND.
h) Review the valuation reports of the FUND's main assets and submit them to the evaluation of the GENERAL ASSEMBLY, when it considers that the assigned values do not correspond to market parameters.
i) Contract the necessary services for the fulfillment of its functions, provided there is authorization from the GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
j) Communicate to SMV at any time any fact that it detects in the exercise of its functions that could be detrimental to the FUND.
k) The others found in this PARTICIPATION REGULATION or delegated to it by the GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
in accordance with the provisions of the fund's internal regulation, or in the contracts entered into on behalf of the fund with the participants and with third parties.". Taking this into account, said obligation was defined in article 14 of the FUND's Participation Regulation, which specifically establishes that the FUND may not be audited for more than 2 (two) consecutive years by the same audit team and that as of the third consecutive year, if the same audit firm is maintained, the person responsible for issuing the opinion and all members of the audit team must be changed. Considering said obligation, by not complying with it or by repealing it, the administering company could cease its conduct and therefore prevent it from happening again, but not reverse the very fact imputed to it, which constitutes the element required by article 255, literal f) of the TUO LPAG;
67. Therefore, in the present case, POPULAR SAFI, by repealing the obligation that the FUND may not be audited for more than 2 (two) consecutive years by the same audit team, would have ceased its conduct at that time or previously; however, it did not rectify the very fact imputed to it, so the exemption from liability is not constituted in this case. In addition, it must be indicated that the aforementioned repeal, agreed on 29 March 2019, was the result of the observation made through Official Letter No. 4439-2018-SMV/10.2 of 29 November 2018, by means of which the administrator was requested to establish an action plan leading it to adopt the pertinent measures to comply with the provisions of the FUND's Participation Regulation, regarding the provisions related to the rotation of external auditors and their audit teams that issue opinions on the FUND's financial statements;
68. Consequently, the defenses submitted have not disproved the facts imputed as charges;
69. Articles 19, numeral III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the FUND's Participation Regulation state the following:
“Article 19.- Investment in TCHN Since TCHN is the predominant investment of the FUND, it is convenient to specify the scope of the evaluation, investment and execution in these TCHN:
(…)
III. Investment Management Process in TCHN
(…)
b) Selection of financing requests: financing needs are materialized in request forms that contain information on the amount to be financed, the use of the money, family data, an initial cash flow of the investment project and of the family economy (integrated), relevant information on the guarantee, a value of the property provided by an appraiser and a tentative payment schedule which is made to measure for the EMPRENDEDOR, according to their particular cash flows. These forms may be prepared by POPULAR SAFI or by the external consultants that provide the FUND with said EMPRENDEDORES. The Forms are evaluated for their selection by the FUND's administrator according to the criteria previously indicated.”
“Article 23.- Diversification by Issuers and Economic Groups
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years have passed since its liberation"
The minimum diversification criteria to be taken into account in the FUND's INVESTMENTS shall be:
a) INVESTMENTS in SECURITIES or OPERATIONS issued or guaranteed by the same natural person shall not exceed forty percent (40%) of the realization value of the property granted as guarantee. This realization value shall be established by an appraiser registered in the Registry of Appraisers for the Financial System.”
70. According to the information gathered in the INSPECTION, an evaluation of a group of investments of the FUND was carried out, verifying that four (4) investments (TCHN No. 10842, 10557, 10549 and 10678) were approved by the Investment Committee without having the appraisal of the property associated with the investment that should have been previously obtained by POPULAR SAFI;
71. In this sense, in these four cases, it was verified that the appraisal submitted by the client requesting the FUND's financing was made on a date subsequent to the date on which the Investment Committee approved the investment in said securities. The following table details the investments that are in this situation:
TABLE No. 2
INVESTMENTS APPROVED BY THE INVESTMENT COMMITTEE WITHOUT HAVING THE PROPERTY APPRAISAL
| No. | TCHN | Disbursement Date | Total Capital | Appraisal Date | Date of Approval by Process Areas | Date of Investment Committee Minutes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | TCHN10842 | 07/12/2017 | 104,948.00 | 20/11/2017 | 22/11/2017 | 06/11/2017 |
| 2 | TCHN10557 | 31/08/2017 | 73,638.58 | 08/08/2017 | 04/08/2017 | 07/07/2017 |
| 3 | TCHN10549 | 21/08/2017 | 30,920.40 | 07/08/2017 | 04/07/2017 | 07/07/2017 |
| 4 | TCHN10678 | 29/09/2017 | 29,958.19 | 15/09/2017 | 19/09/2017 | 04/09/2017 |
72. In this regard, Article 19, paragraph III, literal b) of the FONDO's Participation Regulation establishes, in relation to the selection of financing applications, that financing needs are materialized in application forms that contain information on the amount to be financed, including "(…) relevant information on the guarantee, a value of the property provided by an appraiser and a tentative payment schedule (…)" and specifies that the forms are evaluated for selection by the administrator, according to the criteria described in the aforementioned regulation;
73. Likewise, according to Article 23, literal a) of the FONDO's Participation Regulation, the diversification criteria in the FONDO's investments take into account the realizable value established by an appraiser registered in the Registry of Appraisers for the Financial System. In that sense, for the approval of an investment by the administrator, it was necessary to have the value of the property established by an appraiser, which did not occur in the case of the investments subject to analysis;
74. In this regard, it is appropriate to note that the procedure: "4. Evaluation of Financing Applications of TCHN"8 of the Manual
[8] 4.1. Objective
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
of Operating Procedures of POPULAR SAFI (hereinafter, MPPO) states that the objective is to comply efficiently, in an orderly manner and taking into account the investment policies established in the Participation Regulation, during the process of evaluating applications from external and internal sources of client acquisition. The procedure applies to all applications received from the various internal or external sources of the company;
75. Based on the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI was charged with having allegedly breached Articles 19, numeral III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the FONDO's Participation Regulation, in that it would have presented the appraisal required for the evaluation of the client requesting financing from the FONDO, with a date subsequent to the date on which the Investment Committee approved the investment in said securities;
76. In its defenses, POPULAR SAFI states that what is indicated in the OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES is correct to the extent that -formally- certain appraisal reports recorded a date subsequent to the date of approval of the investments by the FONDO's Investment Committee;
77. However, POPULAR SAFI states that said committee did make its investment decisions with all the necessary information according to the FONDO's Participation Regulation and the MPPO. Furthermore, after having the approval of the processes area, whose dates the OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES details erroneously, the correct dates being the following:
The objective of this procedure is to comply efficiently, in an orderly manner and taking into account the investment policies established in the Participation Regulation. During the process of evaluating applications from external and internal sources of client acquisition.
4.2. Scope
This procedure applies to all applications received from the various internal or external sources of the company. The Investment Committee is responsible as the body responsible for the evaluation and approval or rejection of financing applications.
(…)
4.4 Description of activities
| Act | Description | Responsible |
|---|---|---|
| 4.4.1 | Structures financing application and sends it by email to Head of Processes and Process Assistant. To do so, it must take into account three types of necessary information. Basic information: which includes names and surnames, identity document number, age, marital status, occupation, education, employment status, dependents. Both of the applicant and of their spouse if any. Legal Information: of the owner (Infocorp data) and of the property (PU/HR, literal copy, property valuation report. Economic-financial information: Applicant's cash flows, financing schedule. (Amount, % TEA, term, currency). These data are sent in the following files: schedule and settlement, application data, inspection, Infocorp and sworn statement, and photos of the interiors of the property are also attached. (…) | Financial Sector Specialist Prestaclub |
| 4.4.4 | Compares that the amount to be financed is less than 40% of the realizable value of the property established in the real estate analysis file. (…) | Head of Processes / Process Assistant |
| 4.4.8 | Approves or rejects the application based on what is stated by the Head of Processes and the Compliance Manager. The amount to be financed, the effective interest rate and/or the term may be modified according to the investment committee. | Investment Committee |
Our emphasis.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
| N° | TCHN | Disbursement Date | Total Capital | Appraisal Date | Approval Date Processes Areas | Investment Committee Minutes Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | TCHN10842 | 07/12/2017 | 104,948.00 | 20/11/2017 | 22/11/2017 | 06/11/2017 |
| 2 | TCHN10557 | 31/08/2017 | 73,638.58 | 4/08/2017 | 8/08/2017 | 07/07/2017 |
| 3 | TCHN10549 | 21/08/2017 | 30,920.40 | 4/08/2017 | 7/08/2017 | 07/07/2017 |
| 4 | TCHN10678 | 29/09/2017 | 29,958.19 | 15/09/2017 | 19/09/2017 | 04/09/2017 |
78. In accordance with the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI points out that the TCHN, whose approval procedure is observed in the OFICIO DE CARGOS, only present the issue of the date of the minutes of the Investment Committee; however, all of them were approved by the Processes Area with a date subsequent to the appraisal. In other words, the disbursements of said investments were made after the appraisal and after having obtained the approval of the Processes Area. To prove this, POPULAR SAFI attaches to its defenses the records of the Processes Area corresponding to the TCHN detailed in rows 2 and 3, where the date of the approvals can be verified;
79. POPULAR SAFI maintains that the inconsistency in the dates of the sample detailed in the OFICIO DE CARGOS responds to errors in the drafting of the minutes of the Investment Committee, which were not prepared adequately, giving the appearance of having breached the FONDO's Participation Regulation and the MPPO;
80. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI considers it important to point out that not in all cases are the minutes of the sessions approved in the same session. This fact, perfectly usual and provided for by current regulations, may lead to errors in the dating of the document in some cases;
81. An aspect that POPULAR SAFI believes is fundamental when evaluating this imputation is whether it effectively had any incentive or benefit for approving said investments without having the corresponding prior appraisal, that is, for not complying with the corresponding procedure. On this point, POPULAR SAFI confirms that the members of the Investment Committee in charge of evaluating the investments under analysis had no type of connection with the persons benefited by the investment made (or Entrepreneurs);
82. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI indicates that if the universe of investment requests registered, evaluated and closed in 2017 is considered, the significance of the drafting error noticed in the minutes of the Investment Committee decreases:
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
83. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI points out that it must be considered that, to date, the investments under analysis have been liquidated, and the respective payments were made on terms favorable to the FONDO and the investors;
84. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI states that it has been adopting pertinent measures to better comply with the procedures established in its manuals; for this purpose, it points out that the 2015 MPPO that was subject to review by the INSPECCIÓN has been repealed, approving a new MPPO on 27 April 2018, which contains the procedures related to the management of POPULAR SAFI and the funds it administers, and the modification is made seeking a standardization of internal processes as well as limiting situations such as those described in the previous paragraphs from occurring, which will allow a better work of the Investment Committee;
85. On this matter, it must be indicated that in its defenses POPULAR SAFI has not proven that with respect to the four cases observed, at the date the respective agreements were adopted according to the corresponding minutes, the FONDO's Investment Committee had the "value of the property provided by an appraiser", as required by article 19 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
86. Instead, POPULAR SAFI has stated that with respect to said four cases the FONDO's Investment Committee did make its decisions with all the necessary information as required by the FONDO's Participation Regulation and its MPPO and with the approval of its processes area, for which it attaches a copy of two records prepared by said areas with which it supports that with respect to two of the four clients observed, the aforementioned Committee did have the necessary information;
87. In this regard, it must be indicated that article 19 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation is clear and express in requiring that as part of the necessary elements for the FONDO's Investment Committee to adopt a financing decision, it requires the value of the property provided by an appraiser, who according to article 23, literal a) of said Regulation, the appraiser must be registered in the Registry of Appraisers for the Financial System;
88. Likewise, the fact that the evaluation of POPULAR SAFI's processes area is available does not in any way replace the document called "value of the property provided by an appraiser" as required by the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
89. It is also appropriate to point out that the evaluation carried out by POPULAR SAFI's processes area was also subsequent to the date of the agreement of the FONDO's Investment Committee, which furthermore is not in accordance with the procedure "4. Evaluation of TCHN Financing Requests" of POPULAR SAFI's MPPO, in force at the date of the events, which states that prior to approval by the Investment Committee there must be the approval of the aforementioned processes area;
90. In that sense, for the approval of an investment by the administrator it was necessary to have the value of the property
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
established by an appraiser, which did not occur in the case of the investments subject to analysis;
91. On the other hand, regarding POPULAR SAFI's statement about the inconsistency of the OFFICIO DE CARGOS concerning the date of the Minutes of the FONDO's Investment Committee cited in said official letter with respect to the observed cases, which is due to errors in the drafting of said minutes, it must be noted that the management company has only supported this with its statement and has not presented instrumental evidence to support its claim;
92. As for POPULAR SAFI not having obtained an illegal benefit by approving said investments without having the corresponding prior appraisal observed and that it has not received any claim for such situation, it must be noted that this will be taken into account when evaluating the sanction to be imposed;
93. Based on the foregoing, the arguments presented do not disprove that POPULAR SAFI would have breached articles 14, 19, numerals II, literal d) and III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the FONDO's Participation Regulation, and therefore it has incurred three (03) infractions classified as serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time the events occurred, which establishes as a serious infraction “Failure to comply with the obligations that correspond to it in accordance with the provisions of the fund's internal regulation, or in the contracts entered into on behalf of the fund with the participants and with third parties.”9;
94. The LAW, in its article 17, states the following:
“Article 17.- The management company, its directors, managers, shareholders with a participation greater than ten percent (10%) of the capital, the members of the Investment Committee, as well as any person who participates in the investment decisions of the Funds or who by reason of their position or role has access to information on the investment decisions of the Funds, are prohibited from: (...) d) Making charges directly or indirectly to the Fund, for any unauthorized service provided; and, (…) The management company shall be obligated to indemnify the Funds under its management for the damages that it or any of its dependents or persons providing services to it may cause, as a consequence of the execution or omission, as applicable, of any of the prohibitions contained in this Law, the participation regulation and the general rules issued by CONASEV, in the case of Funds whose units are placed by public offering. The persons who have participated shall be jointly and severally liable for the reimbursement of the damage caused.”
[9] It should be noted that said infraction type has been included in subsection 2.24, numeral 2, of Annex VI of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by Resolution SMV N° 035-2018-SMV/01, in force as of 19 December 2018 (hereinafter, NEW SANCTIONS REGULATION) which states that it is a serious infraction to “Fail to comply with the other obligations that correspond to it in accordance with the provisions of the fund's participation regulation and regulations on the matter, or in the contracts entered into on behalf of the fund with the participants and with third parties.”
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years since it became independent"
95. In this regard, article 7 and literals b) and c) of article 8 of the REGULATION establish:
“Article 7 Contracting of third-party services. The Management Company may enter into contracts that allow it to have the support of third parties for the performance of its functions. These contracts may not replace the functions of the general manager and the board of directors.
In the event that the contract is to be entered into with companies or persons related to the Management Company, the approval of the Surveillance Committee must first be obtained, when applicable.
These contracts shall be available to the members of the Surveillance Committee and the SMV at the time they are requested.
The Management Company must verify that the contracted entity has the minimum conditions of quality of resources and security that ensure compliance with the obligations established in the applicable regulation.
The costs derived from the contracting of third-party services must be assumed by the Management Company and may not be charged to the Fund.
The contracts that the Management Company enters into with other entities for the development of certain activities do not exempt it from the responsibilities that correspond to it for the administration of the Funds under its charge.
Article 8 Transparency of Charges to the Fund:
The Participation Regulation must establish the expenses that will be assumed by the Fund, as well as the periodicity and timing in which they will be accrued and settled according to each class of units. The Participation Regulation must include the following:
(…)
b) The remuneration received by the Management Company for all its services, in accordance with the provisions of article 131 of the Regulation. This remuneration must include the fees that the Investment Committee and the External Manager, if applicable, will receive, as well as the other expenses generated by the contracting of third parties in accordance with the provisions of article 7 of the Regulation.
c) Description of the pre-operational and operational expenses related to the Fund's investments, indicating the amount or maximum percentage of the Fund's net assets that these expenses will represent.
(…)”.
96. From the review of the expenses included in the FONDO's Income Statement for the year 201710, it was evidenced that on 15 December 2017, Invoice No. E001-55 issued by the company Prestaclub S.A.C.11 (hereinafter, PRESTACLUB) to the FONDO was received for a total amount of S/ 12 849.20 (twelve
[10] Note 12 Other Operating Expenses of the audited Financial Statements of the FUND as of 31 December 2017 states that the item "Global advisory expenses" corresponds to advisory services in the credit evaluation of clients and expenses for the placement of funds provided by Prestaclub S.A.C., whose expense in 2017 is S/. 355,160 (271,152 in 2016).
[11] Company related to POPULAR SAFI.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
one thousand eight hundred forty-nine and 20/100 Soles) for global advisory and contacts;
97. Likewise, according to the document called "Transfer to third-party account BCP", also dated 15 December 2017, the bank transfer to the company PRESTACLUB from current account No. 193-1956058-0-52, whose holder is the FUND, was evidenced, for a total amount of S/ 11 564.20 (eleven thousand five hundred sixty-four and 20/100 Soles). The following table details the amounts involved in the invoice and the payment:
| TABLE No. 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| EXPENSES FOR THIRD-PARTY SERVICES CHARGED TO THE FUND | |||
| INVOICE DATA | PAYMENT DATA | ||
| Date | 15/12/2017 | Date | 15/12/2017 |
| Sale value | 10,889.15 | Total | 12,849.20 |
| IGV | 1,960.05 | Detraction | 1,284.92 |
| Total | 12,849.20 | Disbursement | 11,564.28 |
98. On the other hand, the service provided by PRESTACLUB would have been carried out within the framework of the "Service Lease Agreement" signed on 02 January 2017 between said company and the FUND represented by POPULAR SAFI (hereinafter, the CONTRACT). This proves that POPULAR SAFI subcontracted, in the name of the FUND, the aforementioned company for the provision of services as support in attracting persons who need financing from the FUND;
99. Likewise, from the review of the content of the CONTRACT, no clause referring to the economic consideration corresponding to the services provided by PRESTACLUB to the FUND is observed;
100. It should be noted that according to the letters sent by PRESTACLUB to the FUND dated 21 and 30 November 2011 and 29 January 201312, POPULAR SAFI proves that before the signing of the CONTRACT, said company had been charging the FUND commissions, which it applies even as of 28 December 2018, for the client search service and for disbursements of financing applications that the FUND makes to natural persons who require credits through the TCHN issuance mechanism;
101. In this regard, the following clauses of the CONTRACT are observed:
"First (…) 1.2 The lessor13 is a company specialized in legal and financial advisory, which is dedicated to the search, advertising and promotion of financing applications by natural persons. 1.5 If the principal14 contacts the financing applicant, with whom it is willing to close the transaction, the latter is obliged to carry out the operation through the figure of mortgage guarantee subject to the regime of the Negotiable Mortgage Credit Title TCHN. In
[12] Submitted by POPULAR SAFI as documents attached to the responses to the observations made through Official Letter No. 4439-2018-SMV/10.2 of 29 November 2018.
[13] PRESTACLUB.
[14] The FUND.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
that sense, the lessor will provide advisory services in the preparation of the contracts, public deed and their registration in the Public Registries.
(…)
Second
2.1 The parties agree that the principal has the option to contract the additional services offered by the lessor, each time the principal carries out a financing operation. If applicable, the necessary addenda may be prepared, which will be annexed to this contract, stipulating the services offered to the principal."
102. In this regard, it is observed that the service provided by PRESTACLUB to the FUND, represented by POPULAR SAFI, is for the search, advertising and promotion of clients interested in financing via TCHN granted by the FUND, also establishing that PRESTACLUB also provides legal advisory services in the process of formalizing the financing via TCHN;
103. These activities would denote an important part of the functions proper to the management company in fulfilling the objective of the FUND, which is to invest in TCHN, which as already indicated represents from 75%, at minimum, up to 100% of its total assets of its investments:
"Article 5.- Objective of the Fund
The FUND's objective is to invest its resources mainly in TCHN, a debt instrument not registered in the REGISTRY that incorporates a real estate guarantee characterized by being freely negotiable by endorsement and allowing the extrajudicial enforcement of the guarantee (…)."
104. In this line, article 7 of the REGULATION allows the management company to contract third parties for the performance of its functions; however, said norm establishes that the costs generated by such contracting must be assumed by the management company and may not be charged to the investment fund. It should be added that the provisions of said article 7 do not contemplate exceptions;
105. Additionally, numeral 22 of section III Definitions, of the MPO states: "Subcontracting: It is the process of moving or allocating resources aimed at fulfilling certain tasks, to an external company, through a contract. Popular SAFI currently has a service lease agreement with the company PRESTACLUB, which is responsible for structuring TCHN financing applications, which after being evaluated proceed to their financing through the funds managed by Popular SAFI".
106. Accordingly, it is concluded that POPULAR SAFI establishes in its Procedures Manual that it is the one that has subcontracted PRESTACLUB for certain tasks related to the processes under POPULAR SAFI's responsibility. From the review of the MPO, PRESTACLUB participates in the following procedures: 4. Evaluation of TCHN financing applications, 5. TCHN financing, 9. Debt Settlement, 10. Extension or refinancing of TCHN;
107. On the other hand, article 8 of the REGULATION establishes that the fund's participation regulation must specify the expenses that
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
will be assumed by the Fund as well as the periodicity and timing in which they will accrue. Likewise, in subsection b) of the aforementioned article, it is expressly stipulated that the remuneration received by the Management Company for all its services must also include the expenses generated by the hiring of third parties in accordance with the provisions of article 7 of the REGULATION;
108. Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that article 5715 of the FUND's Participation Regulation lists the expenses assumed by the FUND, mentioning in subsection i) that expenses involving the hiring of third-party services must be previously approved by the general assembly; however, the case evaluated does not fall within this assumption since, as explained, it is a function inherent to the management company;
109. It is appropriate to mention that the assumption contained in subsection h) of article 57 of the FUND's Participation Regulation referring to "expenses generated by obligations created or to be created chargeable to the Fund" cannot be considered to include the hiring of PRESTACLUB, since this service, in accordance with the legal nature of the purpose of such hiring, is classified as an activity inherent to the management company that is directly related to it, pursuant to the assumption contained in subsection a) of the aforementioned article 57 and in accordance with subsection b) of article 8 and article 7 of the REGULATION;
110. For the foregoing reasons, POPULAR SAFI was charged with having allegedly breached the provisions of articles 7 and 8 of the REGULATION, and incurred in the prohibition of article 17 of the LAW;
111. POPULAR SAFI considers that the starting point to determine whether it is in an irregular situation regarding the subcontracted tasks and their charging to the FUND is to determine which are the functions inherent to a management company;
112. For this purpose, POPULAR SAFI mentions article 1 of the LAW, which states that investment funds are under the management of a management company;
113. POPULAR SAFI states that the scope of the term "management" is not limited to, for example, keeping the accounting and recording of the transactions carried out, but has as its central aspect the execution of the fund's purpose, under the provisions of the respective participation regulation and applicable legislation;
[15] "Article 57 Expenses Assumed by the FUND: The expenses that will be assumed with FUND resources may not exceed ten percent (10%) per year of the FUND's net assets, excluding taxes and duties, and these expenses are the following: a) Annual Remuneration for Management of POPULAR SAFI: 3.5% nominal annual rate plus Value Added Tax, calculated on the FUND's Net Assets, which will accrue and be calculated on a daily basis from the date of commencement of the FUND's operations. Collection will be made monthly. (...) h) Expenses generated by obligations created or to be created chargeable to the FUND. i) Expenses involving the hiring of third-party services that are previously approved by the GENERAL ASSEMBLY. j) Extraordinary expenses: For the purpose of safeguarding the interests of the FUND and with the prior approval of the GENERAL ASSEMBLY. (...)".
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
114. Therefore, POPULAR SAFI states that the functions inherent to a management company - without entering into the discussion of what should be considered part of its remuneration - are those related to the analysis, execution and realization of investments. It will depend on each fund which specific activities are included in said functions of the management company;
115. In the case of the FUND, it states that the activity inherent to POPULAR SAFI's management is investment in TCHN and, complementarily, in other debt-representative instruments. It states that POPULAR SAFI is responsible for evaluating investments for the FUND and executing those authorized by the investment committee. However, it indicates that the activities necessary to carry out said purpose do not end with the analysis of the investment committee and the execution of the investment, but certain prior steps or activities complementary to POPULAR SAFI's function are necessary. Such is the case of the activities carried out by PRESTACLUB;
116. POPULAR SAFI states that PRESTACLUB's service, as acknowledged by the STATEMENT OF CHARGES, is the search, advertising and promotion of clients interested in financing via TCHN; that is, PRESTACLUB is dedicated to searching for potential TCHN debtors that the FUND might be interested in acquiring. In other words, it is a service similar to that of a broker: the search for potential counterparties for the execution of a contract. This situation would be similar to that of a FIRBI fund that hires a real estate broker to present potential properties that the fund may or may not be interested in buying;
117. In this regard, POPULAR SAFI points out that the fact that a FIRBI fund hires a real estate broker does not mean that it has outsourced its functions, insofar as the main function of the FIRBI fund's management company is not to obtain possible investments but to decide which investments are carried out and, of course, to manage said investments after they have been made and until their final realization. This is the essence of management;
118. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI states that PRESTACLUB may present various investment possibilities to the FUND but it is POPULAR SAFI that decides whether or not these investment alternatives satisfy the FUND's objectives. And that, of course, the administration of the FUND does not end with the acquisition of the TCHN. The risk management of the TCHN, the monitoring of the portfolio's delinquency, the treatment of said delinquency, the evaluation of the convenience and the initiation of enforcement actions are all functions inherent to POPULAR SAFI's activity and are carried out without any type of participation by PRESTACLUB;
119. POPULAR SAFI adds that the activities carried out by PRESTACLUB have not led the management company to entrust a third party with functions that are its own as a management company, since POPULAR SAFI's own functions, essential considering the FUND's objective, remain its responsibility and under its liability16. Considering the opposite would mean that the activity of analysis
[16] Regarding the references in the Oficio to the MPPO, from which the entity concludes that Popular SAFI has subcontracted Prestaclub for certain tasks related to processes under Popular SAFI's responsibility, it should be noted that said document has been amended in 2018 and then in 2021, to avoid confusion regarding the functions performed by Popular SAFI and Prestaclub. Notwithstanding this, the analysis should not be based solely on the wording of the MPPO - whose
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
on investment decisions has been transferred to PRESTACLUB, while POPULAR SAFI and its investment committee would merely replicate what PRESTACLUB indicates;
120. POPULAR SAFI reports that the services included in article 7 of the REGULATION are those linked to the management of the fund, such as investment and divestment decision-making, control and management of portfolio risks, among others, specifying that PRESTACLUB's tasks are not framed within articles 135 and 136 of the REGULATION, and therefore do not qualify as fund management in substitution of POPULAR SAFI;
121. POPULAR SAFI states that the structuring of TCHN is not a function inherent to the management company, not only because of the specialized knowledge required for such task, but because they are not inherent to its role as management company of the FUND. In this regard, the remuneration for the tasks carried out by PRESTACLUB must be considered as expenses linked to the investments of the FUND;
122. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI points out that letter a) of article 8 of the REGULATION already recognizes that expenses directly related to the investment made by the FUND for its acquisition are an expense assumed by it;
123. In this line, POPULAR SAFI indicates that considering the scope of the current agreement with PRESTACLUB, it provides a service directly related to the acquisition of TCHN, such as the identification of TCHN issuers and support for their issuance. This is aligned with the provisions of letter f) of section I of article 19 of the FUND's Participation Regulation, regarding that one of the sources of access to a potential Entrepreneur is consultation with consulting and/or advisory firms for Entrepreneurs;
124. POPULAR SAFI considers that even in the event that PRESTACLUB carries out any task of "investment evaluation" or "structuring of financing applications", these do not replace the work maintained by POPULAR SAFI, but rather comprise an internal evaluation process regarding the clients on which it carries out commercial prospecting. In any case, the final analysis and investment decision of the FUND's assets fall to POPULAR SAFI;
125. POPULAR SAFI adds that the analysis of this charge must consider that there are activities inherent to the management company, whose subcontracting implies that its expenses are considered part of the annual remuneration, and other activities that, although they can also be carried out by the management company, are complementary to its essential function. Such is the case of the commercial prospecting carried out by PRESTACLUB;
126. The above, the management company considers, is the reasonable parameter to define the activity inherent to POPULAR SAFI, that directly related to it. Ignoring this would mean not considering the subcontracting carried out by other management companies regarding activities complementary to their function, and increasing transaction costs
[*] the wording may not have been precise and may have generated confusion regarding the functions of Prestaclub- but the entire context and other circumstances of what both entities actually carry out must be considered.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
regarding the determination (and constant modification) of the remuneration of the management company;
127. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI reiterates that, as has been timely communicated to the SMV through the Investment Statements since the start of the FUND's activities, in accordance with the copy of the investment statements attached to its responses of 12 December 2011 to 31 March 2012, the disbursements in favor of PRESTACLUB have been considered as expenses generated by the payment obligation in the structuring of TCHN. This is understood in subsection h of article 57 of the Fund's Participation Regulation, which indicates that among the expenses assumed by the FUND are "the expenses generated by obligations created or to be created in favor of the FUND";
128. POPULAR SAFI states that the FUND's participants have full knowledge of the expenses assumed by it thanks to the Investment Statement sent to them, the information presented to them at the General Assemblies, and through the auditors' opinion on the FS. In line with the above, the Supervisory Committee knows and has been approving the Investment Statement which includes payments in favor of PRESTACLUB;
129. POPULAR SAFI indicates that, to date, article 57 of the FUND's Participation Regulation includes in its letter l) the payment to PRESTACLUB for the search, advertising, and promotion of financing applications by natural persons and advisory services for the issuance and registration of TCHN in the Public Registries. Furthermore, the form and frequency of payment are specified. In this way, it seeks to be even more transparent regarding the complementary activities that have been subcontracted;
130. Finally, POPULAR SAFI considers it essential to mention the context of PRESTACLUB's involvement in POPULAR SAFI's activities. This has a direct relationship with the request made by the Superintendency of the Securities Market itself in several in-person meetings and even in writing, through Official Letter No. 3102-2011-EF/94.06.2 of 19 July 2011 which it attaches to its responses;
131. POPULAR SAFI points out that in said Communication (section 3.2) it is indicated that the FUND was to be used exclusively for the purchase and sale of securities and that direct contact activities with debtors could be confused with the granting of direct credits, which would be an activity reserved for entities supervised by the Superintendency of Banking, Insurance and Private Pension Fund Administrators (hereinafter, SBS), indicating POPULAR SAFI that it does not agree with such a position because legally, the activity reserved for entities supervised by the SBS is the taking of deposits, not the granting of loans; in coordination with the SMV, we involve entities such as PRESTACLUB in that part of the flow of operations;
132. For this reason, POPULAR SAFI adds that since the performance of functions that by their nature are inherent to POPULAR SAFI with respect to the FUND has not been subcontracted, it cannot be required to assume the corresponding costs, and therefore, POPULAR SAFI concludes that the expenses for the services provided by PRESTACLUB are indeed covered by article 57 of the FUND's Participation Regulations, and that, consequently, the charge must be dismissed
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
of the infringement classified as serious, typified in item 2.17 numeral 2 of Annex VI of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
133. In its defenses, POPULAR SAFI has indicated that, according to article 1 of the LAW, the management carried out by management companies has as a central aspect the execution of the fund's objective in accordance with the REGULATIONS and the respective participation regulations, so its function is related to the analysis, execution and carrying out of investments, which in the case of TCHN, POPULAR SAFI's management is the investment in these financial instruments;
134. In compliance with such objective, and taking into account that these are activities complementary to POPULAR SAFI's function, it states that it contracted PRESTACLUB to search for potential TCHN debtors that the FUND might be interested in acquiring, a situation similar to that of a FIRBI fund;
135. In this regard, POPULAR SAFI considers that the contracting of PRESTACLUB is not the outsourcing of its main function as a manager, since it can present the FUND with various investment possibilities, but it is POPULAR SAFI that decides whether these investment alternatives meet the FUND's objectives or not, which implies that it is the management company that maintains the management of the FUND, in accordance with article 13517 of the REGULATIONS;
136. In this regard, it must be pointed out that article 7 of the REGULATIONS is clear in establishing that the costs derived from the contracting of third-party services must be assumed by the Management Company and may not be charged to the fund;
137. In this regard, it is important to highlight that in the present case it is not questioned that POPULAR SAFI contracted PRESTACLUB to search for potential TCHN debtors that the FUND could acquire, as the management company has set out in its defenses, but rather the fact that the cost of such outsourcing should have been assumed by POPULAR SAFI and not by the FUND, in compliance with the aforementioned article 7;
138. Indeed, in the imputed charge the facts linked to the detected infraction were detailed, among them, the hiring of PRESTACLUB, its cost, the activities to be carried out by said third party and its relationship with the fulfillment of the FONDO's objective, indicating that they are directly related to the activity proper to the administering company, since it is the one that manages the FONDO;
139. Likewise, it is appropriate to note that the imputed charge specified and developed that the contracting of PRESTACLUB cannot be considered as an expense to be assumed by the FUND under the application of article 57
[17] Article 135 On the management of the Fund The management activity of the Fund comprises investment, divestment and maintenance decisions of the Fund's operations, as well as the identification, measurement, control and management of the inherent risks of the portfolio. The management work of the Fund falls on the Management Company, however under its responsibility, it may subcontract an external manager so that, in the terms established in this chapter, it performs the activities contained in the following article.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years since it became independent"
of the Participation Regulation of said fund, in force at the date of occurrence of the fact, since according to what was observed in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS, and reiterated in the description of the facts cited above, it goes against article 7 of the REGULATION;
140. On the other hand, the fact that the cost of contracting PRESTACLUB has been considered in the investment statements of the FUND as a structuring cost of the TCHN, approved by the Surveillance Committee and that it has been informed to the participants of the FUND, does not invalidate POPULAR SAFI's compliance with the observance of article 7 of the REGULATION, which provides that the contracting of third-party services must be assumed by the management company;
141. Regarding the context of PRESTACLUB's involvement in the activities of POPULAR SAFI that relates to what was reported in numeral 3.2 of Oficio N° 3102-2011-EF/94.06.2 of 19 July 2011, it must be indicated that the statement made by the SMV does not express the recommendation to contract a third party for the search of potential debtors of TCHN, as suggested by POPULAR SAFI in its defenses;
142. Finally, regarding the fact that to date, article 57 of the Participation Regulation of the FUND includes in its literal l) the payment to PRESTACLUB for the search, advertising, promotion of financing requests by natural persons and advisory services for the issuance and registration of the TCHN in the Public Registries, it must be indicated that this is a fact subsequent to the fact observed, so its analysis does not correspond, and it must be indicated that the fact that the internal regulation has been subsequently modified in that sense does not exempt it from its observance according to the provision in force at the date that has been the subject of non-compliance. It must also be remembered that article 7 of the REGULATION provides that if third parties are to be contracted, the commission of the management company must assume that type of expenses;
143. For the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI has not disproved the imputed charge, therefore it has incurred an infraction classified as serious typified in subsection 2.17, numeral 2, of Annex VI of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time of the events, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature “Charging, or imputing commissions or expenses to the participants or to the fund that are not provided for in the regulations or not doing so in the manner established by it.”18;
144. In this regard, articles 83 and 85 of the REGULATION establish:
“Article 83.- Valuation of the Fund's Investments The valuation of the Fund's investments is the responsibility of the Management Company and must be carried out in accordance with the valuation methodology established in the Regulation
[18] It should be noted that said legal type has been included in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.16, of the NEW SANCTIONS REGULATION: “Charging or imputing commissions or expenses to the participants or to the fund that are not provided for in the regulations or not doing so in the manner established by it.”
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years have passed since its liberation"
of Participation, at least on each date of preparation of the Fund's financial statements for their submission to the Registry, referred to in article 85 of the Regulation.
The indicated valuation methodology must be prepared considering the valuation criteria established in the IFRS and others that correspond according to the nature of the asset.
(…)
The information that supports the valuation of the Fund's investments, such as the valuation methodology used by the price provider company, the financial statements of unlisted companies, the appraisal reports of real estate and other documents, must be made available to the participants in the places indicated in the Participation Regulation and will be submitted to the SMV at the time they are required.”
“Article 85.- Information of the Funds
The Management Companies once the activities of the Fund have begun must submit to the Registry, the following information for each Fund:
a) Annual audited financial statements, prepared and presented in accordance with the applicable accounting standards, on the day following their approval by the General Assembly, which must be held within the term established by article 11 of the Law.
(…)”
145. In relation to this, paragraphs 58, 59, 63, 64 and GA84 of IAS 39 Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement, in force for the 2017 fiscal year indicate:
“58 An entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets is impaired. If such evidence existed, the entity shall determine the amount of any impairment loss by applying the provisions of paragraph 63 (for financial assets carried at amortized cost) (...).
59 A financial asset or a group of them will be impaired, and an impairment loss will have been incurred if, and only if, there is objective evidence of impairment as a result of one or more events that have occurred after the initial recognition of the asset (a 'loss event') and that loss event or events have an impact on the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset or group of them, that can be estimated reliably. (...). Expected losses as a result of future events, whatever their probability, shall not be recognized. Objective evidence that an asset or a group of assets is impaired includes observable information that requires the attention of the holder of the asset to the following loss events: a) Significant financial difficulties of the issuer or obligor; b) Breaches of contractual clauses, such as defaults or delays in the payment of interest or principal; (...); f) observable data indicate that since the initial recognition of a group of financial assets there is a measurable decrease in their estimated future cash flows, although it cannot yet be identified with individual financial assets of the group, including among such data: (i) adverse changes in the payment status of borrowers included in the group (for example, an increasing number of payment delays or an increasing number of credit card borrowers who have reached their credit limit and are paying the minimum monthly amount); or (ii) local or national economic conditions that correlate with defaults in the group's assets (for example, an increase in the unemployment rate in the geographical area of the borrowers, a decrease in the price of mortgaged properties in the relevant area, a decrease in oil prices for loans granted to oil producers, or adverse changes in sector conditions that affect the group's borrowers). (...)".
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Peru suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
"63 When there is objective evidence that an impairment loss has been incurred on loans, receivables or held-to-maturity investments carried at amortized cost, the amount of the loss shall be measured as the difference between the asset's carrying amount and the present value of estimated future cash flows (excluding future credit losses that have not been incurred), discounted at the original effective interest rate of the financial asset (that is, the effective interest rate computed at initial recognition). The carrying amount of the asset shall be reduced directly, or through an allowance account. The amount of the loss shall be recognized in profit or loss for the period.
64 An entity shall first assess whether there is objective evidence of impairment individually for financial assets that are individually significant, and individually or collectively for groups of financial assets that are not individually significant (see paragraph 59). If an entity determines that there is no objective evidence of impairment for a financial asset that it has assessed individually, whether significant or not, it shall include the asset in a group of financial assets with similar credit risk characteristics, and assess its impairment collectively. Assets that have been individually assessed for impairment and for which an impairment loss has been recognized or continues to be recognized shall not be included in the collective assessment of impairment."
"GA8419 The impairment of a financial asset carried at amortized cost shall be measured using the effective interest rate of the original instrument, since discounting at market interest rates would, de facto, impose fair value measurement on those financial assets that would otherwise be carried at amortized cost. (..) The calculation of the present value of the estimated future cash flows of a collateralized financial asset shall reflect the cash flows that may result from the execution of the collateral, less the costs of obtaining and selling the collateral, regardless of whether the execution of the collateral is probable or not."
146. For its part, article 49 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation states the following:
"Article 49.- Valuation Methodology for INVESTMENTS
The assets that make up the FONDO's portfolio shall be valued daily in accordance with the provisions of the REGULATION and the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). In that sense, for the purposes of INVESTMENTS, among others, we can point out:
(...)
POPULAR SAFI shall make accounting provisions, when a notorious or irrecoverable impairment of value occurs in a given asset, in accordance with the rules set forth in the International Financial Reporting Standards. These INVESTMENTS shall be valued at their estimated recoverable value, including the realizable value of guarantees, when they exist. The greater or lesser value resulting from the valuation of the INVESTMENT, with respect to its cost value, must affect asset accounts. Supplementarily to the aforementioned valuation and accounting registration rules, the provisions established in the International Financial Reporting Standards shall apply."
147. The document called “Saldos por cobrar Diciembre 2017 - Fondo Capital Emprendedor” (hereinafter, ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE)
[19] Paragraphs GA84 to GA92 of IAS 39 provide the application guidance for the provisions in paragraphs 63 to 65 of the IAS on impairment of financial assets carried at amortized cost.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
provided by POPULAR SAFI during the INSPECTION, contains the detail of the investments in the TCHN made by the FUND for a total capital amounting to S/ 30 269 231,66 (Thirty million two hundred sixty-nine thousand two hundred thirty-one and 66/100 Soles);
148. In this regard, said investments are presented in the Audited Financial Statements of the FUND as of 31 December 2017 as “Financial Investments Held to Maturity” (current and non-current portion) which, according to Note 7 of said Financial Statements, are equivalent to 1 267 TCHN (hereinafter, FUND INVESTMENTS);
149. Taking this into account, analyzing the detail of the total balance of the “Financial Investments Held to Maturity” as of 31 December 2017, contained in the ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE document, it is observed that 61.53% of the total principal installments receivable corresponds to overdue installments, that is, past due. Within which 20.61% of the portfolio corresponds to overdue debt with more than six (6) overdue installments receivable, equivalent to S/ 6 237 363.16 (six million two hundred thirty-seven thousand three hundred sixty-three and 16/100 Soles). The following table shows the analysis of overdue installments:
TABLE No. 4 ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE BALANCES AS OF 31 DECEMBER 2017 (MATURITY BY OVERDUE INSTALLMENTS)
| Amount | % | |
|---|---|---|
| Not overdue | 11,644,092.66 | 38.47 |
| Overdue: | 18,625,139.00 | 61.53 |
| From 1 to 2 installments | 8,165,844.15 | |
| From 3 to 6 installments | 4,221,931.69 | |
| More than 6 installments | 6,237,363.16 | 20.61 |
| Total | 30,269,231.66 | 100.00 |
| Note: In judicial process | 1,558,460.35 |
150. With regard to 20.61% of the debt with more than six (6) overdue installments20, POPULAR SAFI did not present the documentation demonstrating the evaluation carried out on the estimates of the probable impairments of said investments at the close of fiscal year 2017;
151. In addition, from the evaluation carried out on a sample of the TCHN instruments that make up the investment portfolio of the FUND as of 31 December 2017, it was verified that a group of TCHN is in a situation of default in the payment of both principal and interest and in judicial proceedings. The following table shows those cases that are in payment default, including principal and interest, with arrears greater than six (6) installments. In relation to the foregoing, it is evident that 3 of the TCHN are in judicial proceedings for the enforcement of collateral;
[20] Article 19 of literal ii) of numeral d) of the FUND's participation Regulation establishes that a process of enforcement of the collateral associated with the TCHN shall be initiated when the obligated debtor has failed to pay six (6) consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun
TABLE No. 5
NEGOTIABLE MORTGAGE CREDIT SECURITIES IN SITUATION OF PAYMENT DEFAULT
| TCHN | Disbursement Date | Maturity Date | No. of Installment | Overdue Installments | Overdue Interest | Total Penalty | Overdue Principal | Total Capital | Judicial Indicator | Overdue principal/ Total Capital |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TCHN06424 | 19/06/2014 | 19/06/2019 | 60 | 10 | 5,689.91 | 2,943.12 | 6,972.43 | 25,048.64 | N | 28% |
| TCHN07051 | 27/10/2014 | 27/10/2019 | 60 | 11 | 16,078.70 | 7,316.11 | 17,334.29 | 71,503.08 | N | 24% |
| TCHN08222 | 20/07/2015 | 20/07/2019 | 48 | 12 | 14,486.93 | 7,456.49 | 17,162.97 | 57,431.14 | N | 30% |
| TCHN07763 | 26/03/2015 | 26/03/2020 | 60 | 32 | 48,779.76 | 37,413.32 | 26,239.41 | 73,155.98 | S | 36% |
| TCHN04845 | 10/07/2013 | 10/07/2018 | 60 | 33 | 47,677.79 | 61,416.42 | 65,857.63 | 88,309.73 | S | 75% |
| TCHN04538 | 13/03/2013 | 13/03/2017 | 48 | 45 | 88,830.53 | 289,193.53 | 129,286.33 | 129,286.3 | S | 100% |
152. Likewise, regarding the arrears in payments of the principal amount, it is noted that the indicated cases are between 24% and 100% of the total amount of the financed capital, and the aging of the accounts receivable dates back to March 2013;
153. Regarding the valuation of the FUND's investments, in accordance with the provisions of the REGULATIONS, the management company is responsible for this valuation and must carry it out in accordance with the methodology established in the FUND's Participation Regulations at least on each date of preparation of the FUND's financial statements for submission to the Public Registry of the Securities Market. Likewise, the indicated valuation methodology must be prepared considering the valuation criteria established in the IFRS and others that correspond according to the nature of the asset;
154. Regarding the investment valuation methodology, article 49 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation includes the treatment to be followed for the impairment of investments, and provides that POPULAR SAFI must make accounting provisions when a notorious or irrecoverable impairment of value occurs in a given asset, in accordance with the provisions of the International Financial Reporting Standards. It also indicates that these investments shall be valued at their estimated recovery value, including the realization value of the guarantees where they exist;
155. In this regard, paragraph 58 of IAS 39 provides that an entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or a group of financial assets carried at amortised cost is impaired and, if such evidence exists, shall apply paragraph 63 of the IAS to determine the amount of the impairment losses;
156. Paragraph 59 of IAS 39 establishes the objective evidence of impairment that shall be taken into account for a financial asset or a group of them;
157. Additionally, in Note 2 Accounting Policies followed by the FUND, item iii) of subsection f) and item (ii) of subsection j) of the Notes to the Audited Financial Statements of the FUND as of 31 December 2017, it is stated:
“f) Classification, Recognition and Valuation of Financial Assets
(…)
(iii) Financial Assets Held to Maturity, this category comprises Negotiable Mortgage Credit Instruments.
“Decade of Equality of Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
(…) After their initial recognition, financial investments held to maturity are carried at amortised cost using the effective interest method less the impairment estimate. (…) Losses arising from impairment are recognised in the statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income.”
j) Impairment of financial assets The Management of the Managing Company assesses at the date of each statement of financial position whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or a group of financial assets are impaired. This impairment arises from one or more events occurring after the initial recognition of the asset and when it has an impact that adversely affects the estimated expected cash flows of the financial asset or group of financial assets and can be estimated reliably.
(…)
(ii) Financial investments held to maturity The Management of the Managing Company assesses at the date of each statement of financial position whether there is objective evidence that an investment or group of investments has impairment problems. In the case of investments in negotiable mortgage credit instruments, the objective evidence is the failure to pay the amortisation instalments established in the contracts (…).”
158. On the other hand, “Note 7 Financial Investments Held to Maturity” of the Notes to the Audited Financial Statements of the FUND as of 31 December 2017, states:
“7 Financial Investments held to maturity
(…)
In the opinion of the Management of the Managing Company, it is not necessary to establish an impairment estimate for the investments since they are guaranteed with real property. As of 31 December 2017, the market value of the real property guaranteeing these investments, established in accordance with appraisals carried out by independent experts, amounts to S/ 348,143,407 (…)”
159. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI, in its response letter of 28 December 2018 to the observations made by the SMV, adds that both the provisions of the Participation Regulations and IFRS 09 Financial Instruments consider that in the measurement of impairment, the expected cash flows of the collateral guarantees, such as those received by the FUND in the form of mortgage liens, must be taken into account. It adds:
“All of the Fund's investment operations in TCHN are guaranteed with a mortgage pledge over the realization value of real property, determined according to appraisal, as recorded in the TCHN. On the other hand, the real property is covered against risks of nature, such as earthquakes and floods. In addition, TCHN whose financings exceed 40% (forty percent) of the realization value of the real property are not acquired. (…) When comparing that monetary value of the guarantee with the balance of the investment in TCHN reported in the same note of S/ 30,269,230 (Thirty million two hundred sixty-nine thousand two hundred thirty and 00/100 Soles), it is observed that the guarantee is amply sufficient. It even covers the interest accrued on TCHN of S/ 2,402,425 (Two million four hundred two thousand four hundred twenty-five and 00/100 Soles) reported in note 6 of the same financial statements”.
“Decade of Equality of Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
160. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI presents the following table in relation to the FUND's figures as of 31 December 2017 (expressed in Soles);
TABLE No. 6 ASSESSMENT OF THE IMPAIRMENT OF THE FUND'S INVESTMENTS
| INVESTMENT - TCHN BY ORIGINAL TERM | INVESTED CAPITAL | INTEREST TO COLLECT | TOTAL CAPITAL AND INTEREST | REALIZATION VALUE OF REAL PROPERTY IN GUARANTEE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Up to one year | 687,268 | 16,694 | 703,962 | 13,145,957 |
| Greater than one up to three years | 12,731,535 | 731,356 | 13,462,891 | 176,118,087 |
| Greater than three up to six years | 16,850,427 | 1,654,375 | 18,504,802 | 158,879,363 |
| TOTAL INVESTMENTS | 30,269,230 | 2,402,425 | 32,671,655 | 348,143,407 |
161. With respect to what was stated by POPULAR SAFI, it must be indicated that this does not invalidate the regulatory non-compliance that it would have incurred, as detailed below;
162. In this regard, it is concluded that POPULAR SAFI has not submitted the document where the methodology used, as part of the valuation of the FUND's investments, is evidenced, to perform the impairment test of the FUND's investments in TCHN, which should include the assumptions used, such as the detail of the amounts of the receivables arising from the TCHN that will be recovered with respect to the overdue receivables, especially those with more than six (6) overdue installments, and, likewise, the status of judicial collections, their expected completion date, the value of the guarantees, among others. Such information is necessary as evidence of the assessment of the possible or probable impairment of the investments made by the FUND in TCHN with respect to overdue and unpaid installments;
163. Thus, considering the situation of non-compliance in the payment of the amortization installments of the receivables arising from the TCHN, POPULAR SAFI should have carried out a thorough impairment assessment, discounting to present value the estimated future cash flows of its investment, taking into account the delinquency situation of its clients, including the realization of the guarantee, the costs of obtaining and selling the guarantee; that is, the costs of the judicial process being carried out for the application of the guarantee, the credit risks generated, and compare it with the carrying amount of the asset to determine if there is any loss in value. However, there is no evidence that such an evaluation21 was carried out that would allow concluding that it was not necessary to establish an impairment provision;
164. Consequently, the balances of the Held-to-Maturity Financial Investments line item included in the Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, could present distortions in their valuation, and therefore distortions in the value of the FUND's assets. Similarly, what is stated in the respective Notes to said financial information, regarding the accounting policy for investment impairment, constitutes distorted information that does not correspond to what was actually applied by POPULAR SAFI;
[21] IAS 39 in paragraphs GA84 to GA92 of IAS 39 provide the Application Guidance for the provisions of paragraphs 63 to 65 of the IAS on impairment of financial assets carried at amortized cost.
“Decade of Equality of Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
165. Based on the foregoing, in the analysis carried out by POPULAR SAFI of the Held-to-Maturity Financial Investments as of December 31, 2017, the provisions established in Article 83 in conjunction with Article 85 of the REGULATION, Article 49 of the FUND's Participation Regulation, and the provisions of paragraphs 58, 59, 63, 64 and GA84 of IAS 39 would have been breached;
166. Regarding the charge formulated, POPULAR SAFI states that the second paragraph of article 49 of the Fund's Participation Regulation should be considered “Popular SAFI must make accounting provisions when a notorious or irrecoverable impairment of value occurs in a given asset, in accordance with the provisions of the International Financial Reporting Standards. These INVESTMENTS must be valued at their estimated recoverable value, including the realizable value of guarantees, when they exist.” ;
167. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI maintains that IAS 39 states that the determination of losses due to credit risk must take into account the expected cash flows from collateral guarantees22, such as those received by the FUND in the form of mortgage liens. Thus, when determining the existence of losses, the expected flows from the realization of the real property in guarantee must be taken into account, after deducting the estimate of expenses directly related to its sale, and it indicates that this regulatory provision fully coincides with the policy adopted in the FUND's Participation Regulation, cited above;
168. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI states that the TCHN investments made by the FUND are evaluated in the market environment they serve, which is of higher risk than that served by the financial system, and of the guarantees and consequent required coverage, clearly distinctive;
169. In this regard, POPULAR SAFI adds that it is important to remember that all the FUND's TCHN investment operations are guaranteed by mortgage on the commercial value of real properties, determined according to appraisal, as recorded in the TCHN, and that the properties are covered against natural risks, such as earthquakes and floods. In addition to this, it adds that no financing is granted exceeding 40% (forty percent) of the realizable value of the property and that this realizable value is 20 percent lower than the commercial value of the property;
170. POPULAR SAFI also states that the estimate of impairment losses made with respect to TCHN investments begins with an analysis of indicators, which is consistent with the citation made in the OFFICIAL LETTER OF CHARGES, and which we reproduce below “An entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets is impaired. If such evidence existed, the entity would determine the amount of any impairment loss by applying the provisions of paragraph 63 (for assets carried at amortized cost) (…)” IAS 39, paragraph 58;
171. POPULAR SAFI adds that such evidence of impairment corresponds to events that give rise to losses due to credit risk, subsequent to the initial recognition of the TCHN investment, which include significant financial difficulties
[22] IAS 39, Application Guidance, GA84, likewise IFRS 9, Application Guidance, paragraph B5.5.55.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years since it became independent"
of the obligor, defaults in the repayment of principal or interest, economic conditions associated with the default, among others, as also described in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS;
172. POPULAR SAFI states that this evaluation is carried out in relation to the TCHN investments, beginning with a general evaluation of the environment, which for 2017 was one of global growth. The classification by age, which is evident information from a first analysis of figures, also recorded in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS, demonstrates this;
173. POPULAR SAFI ADDS that it permanently monitors the financing granted, and considers that the individualized evidence thereof results from comparing the carrying amounts to be recovered with the realizable value of the guarantees, information to which the SMV had full access on the occasion of its review. Furthermore, the classification by age itself is a demonstration of said monitoring;
174. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI adds that the external auditors have not objected to the absence of impairment, nor to the absence of procedures to evaluate its existence, and that they should have performed individual tests, as part of their examination of the financial statements;
175. POPULAR SAFI states that, consequently, when evaluating credit losses, it must be taken into account that their recognition will only proceed when the unamortized balance of principal plus accrued yields is not covered by the realizable value of the property, which provides a broad coverage margin and that this is the criterion used by POPULAR SAFI;
176. POPULAR SAFI adds that this is demonstrated by the coverage ratios of its TCHN investments, globally as follows as of 31 December 2017:
| Coverage | Principal plus Interest (In Soles) | Appraisal Value (In Soles) | Coverage Ratio (Times) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Financial (includes carrying balance and non-matured interest) | 46 015 252,00 | 348 143 407,00 | 7.57 |
| Accounting (includes carrying balances) | 32 671 655,00 | 348 143 407,00 | 10.66 |
177. POPULAR SAFI indicates that if said monetary value of the guarantee is compared with the balance of the investment in TCHN reported in the same note of S/ 30 269 230,00 (Thirty million two hundred sixty-nine thousand two hundred thirty and 00/100 Soles), it is observed that the guarantee is largely sufficient. It even covers the interest accrued for TCHN of S/ 2 402 425,00 (Two million four hundred two thousand four hundred twenty-five and 00/100 Soles) reported in note 6 of the same financial statements;
178. POPULAR SAFI adds that consequently, the mortgage guarantees provide coverage above the debts plus interest incurred by the clients of the FUND, so they do not share the view that the value reported as investments could present distortions, as stated in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS;
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: two hundred years since its liberation"
179. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI indicates that in the final part of note 7 to the audited financial statements of the Fund for 2017, it is stated that “In the opinion of the Management of the Administrating Company, it is not necessary to establish an estimate for impairment of the investments, since these are guaranteed by real estate. As of 31 December 2017, the market value that guarantees these investments, established in accordance with appraisals performed by an independent expert, amounts to S/ 348, 143,407.”;
180. POPULAR SAFI adds that the following table shows in detail the foregoing, by reference to the figures as of 31 December 2017, reviewed by SMV (which are expressed in Soles); from it, it follows that the mortgage guarantee results in coverage that is largely sufficient to cover the investment. Additionally, the quality of the guarantee is protected by insurance against risks associated with natural events;
| Investment - TCHN by original term | Invested Principal | Interest Receivable | Total Principal and Interest | Realizable Value of Properties in Guarantee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Up to one year | 687,268.00 | 16,694.00 | 703,962.00 | 13,145,957.00 |
| Greater than 1 up to 3 years | 12,731,535.00 | 731,356.00 | 13,462,891.00 | 176,118,087.00 |
| Greater than 3 up to 6 years | 16,850,427.00 | 1,654,375.00 | 18,504,802.00 | 158,879,363.00 |
| Total Investments | 30,269,230.00 | 2,402,425.00 | 32,671,655.00 | 348,143,407.00 |
181. POPULAR SAFI points out that it believes it is necessary to insist that delinquency does not entail decreeing, directly and immediately, the impairment of an asset. Even more so if it is backed by a guarantee;
182. POPULAR SAFI states that it is not unaware that there had been certain investments with overdue installments. However, it considers that the evaluation of notorious or irrecoverable impairment does not have as its only aspect to consider a possible delay. It must be borne in mind that there must be an event that has an impact that negatively affects the projected flows. It adds that such evaluation is not limited to the mere fact that there is a delay, since a comprehensive evaluation must be made and that such comprehensive evaluation necessarily includes considering the existence of a guarantee and its corresponding value, as provided in article 49 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation;
183. It states that the thorough evaluation carried out by POPULAR SAFI has considered the guarantees backing the delinquent investments; as a result of said evaluation, it was concluded that it was not necessary to establish impairment provisions;
184. POPULAR SAFI also points out that the SMV in particular refers to TCHN investments with more than 6 overdue installments for S/6,237,363, and those, in judicial proceedings, included in the previous figure for S/1,558,460, and adds that a summary of the individual coverage is shown below:
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
| Investments | TCHN - more than 6 overdue installments, without judicial proceedings | TCHN - more than 6 overdue installments, in judicial proceedings | Total TCHN - more than 6 overdue installments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total accounting principal plus interest in soles | 5,883,411.00 | 2,167,262.00 | 8,050,673.00 |
| Total financial principal plus interest (equal to accounting plus non-accrued balances at closing) in Soles | 7,103,830.00 | 2,452,954.00 | 9,556,784.00 |
| Appraisal value of real estate at realizable value (market value less 20%) in Soles | 44,517,759.00 | 9,199,202.00 | 53,716,961.00 |
| Accounting coverage ratios with real estate guarantee at realizable value | 7.57 | 4.24 | 6.67 |
185. POPULAR SAFI indicates that without prejudice to the foregoing, and in order to support its position, they attach as Annex 8 an accounting report, which states that:
“The existence of indicators does not determine the need to measure impairment, but rather when it is concluded that impairment has occurred, and its measurement is required for the recognition of the estimated loss in the financial statements. When the mortgage guarantee, measured at realizable value, exceeds the accounting value of the principal, interest and other expense balances on account of the borrower, equal to its fair value when applying the amortized cost approach, there is no impairment.”
186. POPULAR SAFI adds that along the same lines, one of the conclusions of the aforementioned report is that “When there are indicators of impairment of financial assets, such as investments held to maturity, the impairment assessment must be confirmed by comparing the guarantee received with the total accounting balance of principal, interest to be recovered and other costs on account of the borrower.”
187. POPULAR SAFI adds that with respect to the documentary basis for the impairment assessment, the report specifies that “(…) the comparison of accounting balances containing overdue amounts or amounts in judicial proceedings, with the amount of guarantees, will result in adequate, verifiable support.”;
188. In this regard, it must first be indicated that, according to the regulations whose non-compliance has been imputed, the entity, in this case POPULAR SAFI, is required to mandatorily perform an assessment at the end of the period to determine whether an asset or group of assets is impaired23;
[23] Paragraph 58 of IAS 39
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
189. Likewise, it must be mentioned that during the INSPECTION, POPULAR SAFI was requested to provide said assessment; however, the management company did not submit it;
190. The INSPECTION requested documentation for the 2017 fiscal year from POPULAR SAFI, which it designated ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE, observing that 61.53% of the total principal installments to be collected includes overdue installments, that is, past due. Within which 20.61% of the portfolio corresponds to debt that includes more than six (6) overdue installments to be collected, equivalent to S/ 6,237,363.16;
191. As has been mentioned, paragraph 58 of IAS 39 expressly regulates that the assessment determines whether there is “objective evidence” that a financial asset is impaired and, based on that, applies paragraph 63 of the aforementioned IAS 39. For its part, paragraph 59 of said IAS 39 establishes that such objective evidence constitutes “(…) breaches of contractual terms, such as defaults or delays in the payment of interest or principal”;
192. In view of the foregoing, having established that there were defaults or delays in the payment of interest or principal of the TCHN in the ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE, POPULAR SAFI was legally obligated to carry out said “Assessment” in accordance with the regulations and, for this purpose, should have valued such assets observing the methodology established in the FONDO Participation Regulations;
193. Without prejudice to the foregoing, in its defenses POPULAR SAFI substantiates why the assets under observation were not impaired assets; for this purpose, we set out the following;
194. Regarding what is established by IAS 39 on “Impairment of assets and uncollectibility of financial assets”, paragraph 58 establishes that the entity shall assess at the end of each reporting period whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or a group of financial assets is impaired and that, if such evidence exists, the entity shall determine the amount of any impairment loss by applying paragraph 63;
195. Likewise, paragraph 59 of IAS 39 establishes that a financial asset or a group of financial assets shall be impaired and an impairment loss shall have been incurred if, and only if, there is objective evidence of impairment as a result of one or more events that occurred after the initial recognition of the asset (an event that causes the loss) and that event or events have an impact on the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset or group of assets that can be reliably estimated;
196. Likewise, said paragraph 59 indicates the events that cause the loss, among others: significant financial difficulties of the issuer or the obligor; breaches of contractual terms, such as defaults or delays in the payment of interest or principal;
197. In this regard, POPULAR SAFI indicates that the objective evidence of impairment corresponds to events that give rise to credit risk losses, subsequent to the initial recognition of the TCHN, which include significant financial difficulties of the debtor, defaults in the payment of interest or principal, among others;
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
198. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI points out that the estimation of impairment losses it makes with respect to investments in TCHN begins with an analysis of indicators, mentioning that this is consistent with what is stipulated in paragraph 58 of IAS 39 and that its evaluation is carried out in relation to TCHN investments, beginning with a general assessment of the environment, which for 2017 was one of global growth. As well as the aging classification, which is clear evidence of a preliminary analysis of figures (also collected in the CHARGES LETTER);
199. POPULAR SAFI adds that it permanently monitors the financings granted, and considers that the individualized evidence of this results from comparing the accounting balances to be recovered with the realizable value of guarantees, information to which the SMV had full access during its review and that the aging classification itself is a demonstration of said monitoring;
200. In this regard, with respect to what is established in paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39, we must indicate that in the present case, in the documents provided by POPULAR SAFI to the INSPECTION with the TCHN portfolio, there are defaults in the payment of accounts receivable or installments for the financings granted, since, as has been verified during the INSPECTION and set forth in the CHARGES LETTER, as of December 31, 2017, accounts receivable with unpaid or overdue installments are observed that may have from 1 overdue installment to 54 overdue installments24, as well as financings in judicial proceedings, added to the fact that the aging of accounts receivable with overdue installments comes from loans made since 2012 and from financings with maturities since 2015. Likewise, given that these installments are unpaid and overdue, that is, defaults as of December 31, 2017, a risk of non-payment at that date is demonstrated, which will impact estimated future cash flows based on the established payment schedules, since these financings generate cash flows from their collection through agreed installments and with an agreed interest rate whose collection is carried out monthly;
201. Additionally, in numeral (ii) of letter j) of Note 2 "Accounting Policies followed by the Fund" in its audited financial statements as of 31 December 2017 it is established: "The Management of the Administradora evaluates at the date of each statement of financial position whether there is objective evidence that an investment or group of investments has impairment problems. In the case of investments in negotiable mortgage credit securities, the objective evidence is the default in the payment of the amortization installments established in the contracts (…).";
202. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of paragraphs 58 and 59 of IAS 39 and with the accounting policy of POPULAR SAFI, the conditions have been met for the determination of objective evidence of impairment of the accounts receivable for the financing granted and thereby the elements of incurred loss (incurred credit loss), so it is appropriate to estimate a provision or impairment loss;
[24] Article 19 of letter ii) of numeral d) of the FONDO's participation Regulation establishes that a process of enforcement of the guarantee associated with the TCHN shall be initiated when the obligated debtor has failed to pay six (6) consecutive or alternate installments of its payment schedule.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
203. Although POPULAR SAFI acknowledges that the objective evidence of impairment corresponds to events that give rise to credit risk losses, that it carried out evaluations, including a first analysis of the aging of accounts receivable; and in its accounting policy it has established as objective evidence of impairment of the investments in TCHN the non-payment of the established amortization installments, it has become clear that it has not carried out a measurement of the impairment loss as established by paragraph 63 of IAS 39;
204. For its part, the second paragraph of article 49 of the FONDO's Participation Regulation coincides with what is indicated in the preceding paragraphs when it mentions: “(…) Popular SAFI must make the accounting provisions, when in a given asset a notorious or irrecoverable impairment of its value occurs, in accordance with the provisions of the International Financial Reporting Standards (…)”
205. It should be added that the change in relation to impairment from IFRS 9, mandatory in Peru as of 2018, with respect to IAS 39 applicable in 2017, is the change from the incurred loss model of IAS 39 to the expected loss model of IFRS 9; the latter model does not require or need a loss event or objective evidence of impairment to have occurred for the recording or recognition of impairment, since it will recognize expected credit losses, that is, it recognizes or records a provision based on an estimate of credit risk, before a loss is incurred;
206. Regarding guarantees, POPULAR SAFI maintains that IAS 39 states that the determination of credit risk losses must take into account the expected cash flows from collateral guarantees25 and that thus, when determining the existence of losses, the expected flows from the realization of the real property in guarantee must be taken into account, after deducting the estimate of expenses directly related to its sale, such as those received by the FONDO in the form of mortgage liens, and that this fully coincides with the policy adopted in the FONDO's participation Regulation;
207. POPULAR SAFI states that the TCHN investments made by the FONDO are evaluated in the market environment they serve, which is of greater risk than that served by the financial system, and that their guarantees and consequent required coverage are clearly distinctive;
208. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI states that all investment operations in TCHN are guaranteed by mortgage on the commercial value of real properties, determined according to appraisal, as recorded in the TCHN, and that the real properties are covered against natural risks, such as earthquakes and floods. Likewise, that no financing is granted exceeding 40% of the realization value of the real property; and that this realization value is 20% lower than the commercial value of the real property;
209. Consequently, POPULAR SAFI considers that as part of its evaluation of credit losses it must be taken into account that its recognition will only proceed when the outstanding principal balance plus accrued yields is not covered by the realization value of the real property, which
[25] IAS 39, Application Guidance, GA84, likewise IFRS 9, Application Guidance, paragraph B5.5.55
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the Market in Securities
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
which grants a broad coverage margin and that this is the criterion used by the managing company;
210. Regarding what POPULAR SAFI has stated, the consideration of guarantees established by paragraph 63 of IAS 39 must be cited: “When there is objective evidence that an impairment loss on loans, receivables or held-to-maturity investments carried at amortized cost has been incurred, the amount of the loss is measured as the difference between the asset's carrying amount and the present value of estimated future cash flows (excluding future credit losses that have not been incurred) discounted at the financial asset's original effective interest rate (that is, the effective interest rate computed at initial recognition). The carrying amount of the asset shall be reduced directly, or through an allowance account. The amount of the loss shall be recognized in profit or loss for the period.”;
211. Likewise, paragraph GA8426 provides: “(…) The calculation of the present value of the estimated future cash flows of a collateralized financial asset shall reflect the cash flows that may result from foreclosure, less the costs of obtaining and selling the collateral, whether or not foreclosure is probable.”;
212. Therefore, IAS 39 takes guarantees into account at the time of measuring impairment, that is, when calculating the present value of estimated future cash flows, and not when determining the objective evidence of impairment;
213. In the same way, the second paragraph of article 49 of the FONDO's participation Regulation is aligned with the foregoing, as it states: “(…) These INVESTMENTS must be valued at their estimated recovery value, including the realization value of guarantees, when they exist.”;
214. It should be added that the estimated recovery value or recoverable amount is the one that would result from bringing the estimated future cash flows to present value;
215. It is important to bear in mind that the flow must consider the realizable value of the guarantees, which is 80% of the appraisal value, and that the realizable value of the property be established as of the current date, since this value may have varied over time; likewise, administrative, judicial, execution and sale costs of the guarantee must be deducted, as well as the time value of money such as the delay in the judicial process and the delay in the sale of the property given as collateral.
216. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI has also included in its defense tables in which it compares the total of its accounting receivables balances S/. 32, 671,655.00 and financial S/. 46, 015,252.00 with an appraisal value of the properties in guarantee for S/. 348,143,407 which would demonstrate globally that the coverage ratios are 10.66 and 7.57 respectively;
[26] Paragraph corresponding to the Application Guides for impairment and uncollectibility of financial assets carried at amortized cost (paragraphs 63 to 65 of IAS 39).
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
217. Likewise, with regard to its accounting and financial balances of the installments receivable for loans with more than 6 overdue installments without process and with judicial process, POPULAR SAFI also includes a comparison of these balances with an appraisal value of properties at realizable value, showing a coverage ratio of 7.57 and 4.24;
218. In this regard, IAS 39 does not indicate that a global (or individual) comparison of the carrying amount of financial assets (accounts receivable) with the appraised value of the properties given as collateral should be carried out, as POPULAR SAFI does to assess the existence of an impairment loss. Additionally, they carry out said comparison on 100% of the appraised value of the property given as collateral, when according to their policies they only grant financing for a maximum of 40% of the realizable value of the property, so that the total amount of the value of the collateral, if executed, would not be entirely or exclusively to cover the credit granted, since it could be the case that this collateral covers other debts;
219. In this regard, although POPULAR SAFI considers the collateral as part of its analysis (value comparisons) to assess the credit losses of the FUND specifically, to determine the objective evidence and measure the impairment loss, the application of the procedure established in IAS 39, as well as its accounting policies and its Participation Regulations, is applicable, as has been set forth in the preceding recitals;
220. Additionally, to affirm that the amount of the present value of the discounted flows will be positive, the estimate made by POPULAR SAFI would have to be reviewed, and with it the assumptions used as well as the support for them. However, during the INSPECTION, POPULAR SAFI did not present any detail of the impairment assessment including its collateral;
221. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI has also indicated that it does not deny that there have been certain investments with overdue installments. However, it considers that the assessment of obvious or irrecoverable impairment does not have as its only aspect to consider a possible delay and that it must be borne in mind that there must be an event that has an impact that negatively affects the projected flows. That said assessment is not limited to the mere fact that there is a delay, since a comprehensive assessment must be made and that said comprehensive assessment includes - necessarily - considering the existence of a collateral and its corresponding value, as provided in article 49 of the FUND's Participation Regulations;
222. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI insists on affirming that delinquency does not entail declaring, directly and immediately, the impairment of an asset. Even more so if it is backed by a collateral;
223. POPULAR SAFI refers that the diligent assessment carried out by it has considered the collateral backing the delinquent investments; as a result of said assessment, concluding that it was not necessary to establish impairment provisions;
224. Regarding the above, we consider that it cannot be indicated that it is a possible delay, since, as has been mentioned above, there are financings that have from 1 to 54 overdue installments
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
as well as financings with judicial proceedings. Likewise, a comprehensive assessment implies following the procedure indicated by the IFRS as part of the valuation of investments;
225. On the other hand, regarding the fact that in note 7 of the audited financial statements of the FUND for the 2017 fiscal year it is declared that in the opinion of the Management of POPULAR SAFI it is not necessary to establish an estimate for the devaluation of investments since they are guaranteed; and that the external auditors have not objected to the absence of devaluation, nor the absence of procedures to assess its existence, and that they would have had to perform individual tests, as part of their examination of the financial statements, it must be indicated that this does not constitute a determining element that prevents the regulator from reviewing and observing, as has been done in the present case, the financial information prepared by POPULAR SAFI;
226. Regarding the content and conclusions27 of the report issued by Mr. Alfredo Rodríguez Neira that POPULAR SAFI has submitted as an attachment to its defense, it must be indicated that, legally, it denotes opinion or interpretation of the criteria that IAS 39 has expressly regulated, so it is not binding for the application of said standard;
227. Without prejudice to the foregoing, regarding what is indicated in the conclusions of the aforementioned report, it must be indicated that IAS 39 does not establish the existence of indications of impairment, but expressly refers to “objective evidence” of impairment, even detailing what these are, which have been cited in the alleged breached regulation and have been developed and explained as indicated in the preceding recitals;
228. Likewise, regarding what is indicated in the conclusions of the aforementioned report, that to confirm the impairment assessment the collateral received must be compared with the accounting balances of the accounts receivable, and if the collateral measured at its realizable value exceeds the loan balance, cash flows are not required, it must be indicated that this is a procedure not contemplated by IAS 39 on impairment of financial assets carried at amortized cost. As has been indicated above, collateral is considered as part of the flow to perform the measurement, when there is objective evidence that an impairment loss has been incurred;
229. Regarding documentary evidence, the conclusion also indicates that the absence of this does not imply the existence of devaluation; however, as we have already indicated, POPULAR SAFI during the inspection did not provide the support or the documentation in which the methodology used as part of its impairment assessment is evidenced, as well as the estimate of the loss that allows
[27] Conclusions A. When there are indications of impairment of financial assets, such as held-to-maturity investments, the impairment assessment must be confirmed by comparing the collateral received with the total book balance of principal, interest to be recovered and other costs on behalf of the borrower. If the real estate (or other) collateral, measured at its realizable value, exceeds the loan balance, cash flow measurements are not required. B. The absence of documentary evidence does not imply the existence of devaluation, and therefore, the disclosure of complete and truthful information, or in accounting terms, a faithful representation of the facts and estimates (devaluation is an accounting estimate). Absence of documentary evidence means the impossibility of directly verifying the basis of transactions or measurement methodologies, or of deriving it from available information.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
verify28 the existence or not of an impairment provision. The aforementioned conclusion also indicates: “Absence of documentary evidence means the impossibility of directly verifying the basis of transactions or measurement methodologies (…)”;
230. For the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI has not refuted the charge imputed and has therefore incurred in an infringement classified as very serious, typified in subsection 1.5 of item 1 of Annex VI of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as an infringement of a very serious nature “Valuing the fund's units or investments with criteria other than those indicated in the valuation methodology contained in the Participation Regulation” 29;
231. Article 132 of the REGULATION provides:
“Article 132 On Accounting and Financial Information The Management Company, in its capacity as a legal entity registered in the Registry, keeps its accounts in accordance with the rules governing such entities and presents its financial information in accordance with the applicable accounting standards”.
232. In this regard, the Standards on the preparation and presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Resolution SMV N° 016-2015-SMV-01 (hereinafter the STANDARDS), establish the following:
"Article 1.-Application of IFRS by obligated subjects (...) legal entities registered in the RPMV, collective fund managing companies, and investment funds must prepare their financial statements in full observance of the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) in force internationally, and to the extent applicable, the Financial Information Regulation and the Manual for the preparation of Financial Information. For the purposes of these standards, legal entities registered in the RPMV shall be understood as brokerage agents, mutual fund managing companies, investment fund managing companies, securitization companies, risk rating companies, price provider companies and other entities to which the Superintendency of the Securities Market grants operating authorization."
233. The Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information (hereinafter, MANUAL) 30 which is part of the Information Regulation
[28] Paragraph CC27 of the Conceptual Framework on Verifiability states: "(...) Verification can be direct or indirect. Direct verification means checking an amount or other representation through direct observation, for example, counting cash. Indirect verification means checking the input data of a model, formulas or other technique, and recalculating the result using the same methodology (…)”.
[29] It should be noted that this type of infringement has been included in subsection 1.3, item 1 of Annex VI of the NEW SANCTIONS REGULATION which states that it is a very serious infringement to “value the fund's quotas or investments using criteria other than those indicated in the valuation methodology contained in the Participation Regulation.”
[30] The section “Purpose and Content” of the Manual states: “This Manual (…) complements the Financial Information Regulation and its purpose is to facilitate the preparation and presentation of financial information, as well as to periodically adapt it to the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued by the International
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Peru's Bicentennial: two hundred years since its independence"
Financial and Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF-94.10 and its amendments establishes in Section II Notes to the Financial Statements Chapter I the following:
(…)
5.102. Statement on Compliance with IFRS It must be explicitly and unreservedly disclosed that the company has observed compliance with the IFRS in force in the country in the preparation and presentation of the financial statements, provided that they have complied with all IFRS.
(…)
5.104. Accounting Policies The significant accounting policies applied by the company in the preparation of its financial statements must be disclosed, related to the following aspects, to the extent applicable:
5.104.02. Financial Instruments.
(…)
5.104.02.1 General For financial assets, financial liabilities and equity instruments, both recognized and unrecognized, the following must be disclosed:
1. Clearly and concisely all accounting policies, methods adopted, the recognition criteria and the measurement bases applied, including:
(…)
b) The measurement bases applied to financial assets and financial liabilities both at initial recognition and in subsequent periods;
(…)
2. The fair value for each class of financial assets or liabilities must be disclosed, as well as:
a) The significant methods and/or assumptions of the valuation techniques applied in determining fair values;
b) Whether the fair values have been determined in whole or in part, directly by reference to quoted prices published in an active market or have been estimated using a valuation technique;
(…)”
234. According to the “Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting”, the fundamental characteristics of financial information are “relevance” and “faithful representation”.
CC12 Financial reports represent economic phenomena in words and numbers. To be useful, financial information must not only represent relevant phenomena, but must also faithfully represent the phenomena it purports to represent. To be a perfectly faithful representation, a description would have three characteristics. It would be complete, neutral and free from error. Naturally, perfection is rarely, if ever, achievable. The Board's objective is to maximize those qualities as much as possible.
CC13 A complete description includes all the information necessary for a user to understand the phenomenon being represented, including all necessary descriptions and explanations. For example, a complete representation of a group of assets would include, at a minimum, a description of the nature of the
[*] Accounting Standard Board (IASB) and in force in the country. It should be noted that the MANUAL does not replace accounting doctrine and its application must be understood in the integral context of IFRS and its Conceptual Framework”.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: it has already been two hundred years since its liberation"
assets of the group, a numerical description of all the assets of the group, and a description of what the numerical description represents (for example, original cost, adjusted cost or fair value). For some items, a complete description may also entail explanations of significant facts about the quality and nature of the items, the factors and circumstances that may affect their quality and nature, and the process used to determine the numerical description.
(…)
CC15 Faithful representation does not mean accuracy in all respects. Free from error means that there are no errors or omissions in the description of the phenomenon, and that the process used to produce the information presented has been selected and applied without errors. In this context, free from errors does not mean perfectly accurate in all respects. For example, an estimate of an unobservable price or value cannot be said to be accurate or inaccurate. However, a representation of that estimate can be faithful if the amount is clearly and accurately described as an estimate, the nature and limitations of the estimation process are explained, and no errors have been made in selecting and applying an appropriate process to develop the estimate.”
235. Paragraphs 16, 112 and 117 of IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements indicate:
“16 An entity whose financial statements comply with IFRS shall make an explicit and unreserved statement of such compliance in the notes. An entity shall not state that its financial statements comply with IFRS unless they satisfy all the requirements of these.
(…)
112 The notes:
(a) they shall present information about the bases for the preparation of the financial statements, and about the specific accounting policies used in accordance with paragraphs 117 to 124;
(…)
Disclosure of accounting policies
117 An entity shall disclose its significant accounting policies including:
(a) the basis (or bases) of measurement used to prepare the financial statements; and
(b) the other accounting policies used that are relevant to an understanding of the financial statements.
(…)”
236. For its part, paragraph 91 on Disclosure of IFRS 13, Fair Value Measurement, establishes.
“91 An entity shall disclose information that helps users of its financial statements assess the following two elements:
(a) for assets and liabilities that are measured at fair value on a recurring or non-recurring basis in the statement of financial position after initial recognition, the valuation techniques and inputs used to develop those measurements.
(…)”
237. As part of the evaluation of the Audited Separate Financial Statements of POPULAR SAFI as of 31 December 2017 carried out during the INSPECTION, the most significant item of the “Financial investments available for sale” account was reviewed, which corresponds to the investment of
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Two Hundred Years of Our Peru: it has been two hundred years since its liberation"
POPULAR SAFI in participation quotas of the “Fondo MYPE-TCHN”31, a private investment fund managed by POPULAR SAFI;
238. Said investment amounts to S/ 17,575,994.00, which represents 84% of the balance of the “Financial investments available for sale” account and 77% of the total assets of POPULAR SAFI and corresponds to 4,557,019 participation quotas;
239. In relation thereto, POPULAR SAFI in Note 2 “Accounting policies followed by the company”, subparagraph a) “Bases of preparation” declared that it has prepared its Financial Statements in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards as well as the bases of measurement of its Financial Statements and of the financial investments available for sale and in subparagraph c) “Use of estimates and judgments” the estimates used in relation to its Financial Statements;
“Below are indicated the main accounting policies adopted by the Company in the preparation and presentation of its separate financial statements. They have been prepared in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) under criteria applied consistently for the years presented.
(a) Basis of preparation:
(i) In the preparation of the accompanying separate financial statements, the Management of the Company has complied with the IFRS issued by the International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) in force as of 31 December 2017.
(ii) The information contained in these separate financial statements is the responsibility of the Management of the Company, which expressly states that it has complied with the application of IFRS in their entirety, without restrictions or reservations.
(iii) The separate financial statements have been prepared in terms of historical costs from the accounting records maintained by the Company, except for the financial investments available for sale, which have been measured at their fair value”.
(…)
(c) Use of estimates and judgments
(…)
The estimates in relation to the accompanying separate financial statements refer to:
(…)
-The measurement of the fair value of financial assets and liabilities”.
240. Likewise, in numeral (iii) subparagraph f) “Classification, recognition and valuation of financial assets” of Note 2 “Accounting policies followed by the company” it disclosed that it classified as financial investments available for sale its investments in participation quotas in investment funds and their measurement, after initial recognition, at fair value. It also disclosed how it determines its fair value;
“(f) Classification, recognition and valuation of financial assets
[31] Private investment fund, which is dedicated to investing in Negotiable Mortgage Credit Securities, a debt instrument not registered in the Securities Market Registry that incorporates a real estate guarantee characterized by being freely negotiable by endorsement and allows the extrajudicial enforcement of the guarantee. POPULAR SAFI participated with 40.56% of the capital of FONDO MYPE-TCHN (40.56% in the year 2016).
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
(…) (iii) Financial assets available for sale This category comprises investments in shares accounted for at fair value and participation quotas in investment funds. After initial recognition at cost, the financial investments available for sale are measured at their fair value; (…) The fair value of the shares is determined on the basis of quotations in active markets (Stock Exchange). In the case of participations in investment funds, the fair value is the quota value determined at the close of the financial statements of the funds. (…)”
241. Additionally, in Note 4 “Main Financial Instruments”, section “Fair value hierarchy of financial instruments” POPULAR SAFI disclosed that for the measurement at fair value of the financial assets available for sale, participations in investment funds, it used Level 3: “Techniques that use data that are not based on observable market data and that have a significant effect on fair value”;
242. POPULAR SAFI to determine the total amount of its investment in FONDO MYPE-TCHN for S/. 17’575,994 used the quota value of S/ 3.85690611;
| Number of quotas | Quota value | Total (S/.) |
|---|---|---|
| 4,557,019 | 3.85690611 | 17,575,994 |
243. The quota value used in said valuation corresponds to a value calculated by POPULAR SAFI based on the total amount of the patrimony that would result from a present value of the investment portfolio of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN, divided by the number of quotas in circulation of said fund, as shown in the report “cálculo de valor cuota – Diciembre 2017” of the Fondo MYPE-TCHN Fondo de Inversión Privado”. However, the amounts considered as present value of the investment portfolio and the total patrimony are amounts significantly higher than the amounts appearing in the unaudited financial statements of the referred fund;
244. According to this valuation POPULAR SAFI recorded an increase in the amount of these investments of S/. 1,849,759 with respect to the initial balance as of 31 December 2016, as presented in the movement of the balance of these investments, in Note 10 “Inversiones Financieras Disponibles para la venta” (expressed in Soles) of the Audited Separate Financial Statements as of 31 December 2017;
| Number of quotas | Initial Balances | Gain in Fair Value | Final Balance |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4,557,019 | 15,726,235 | 1,849,759 | 17,575,994 |
245. On the other hand, according to the quota value report of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN prepared by the accounting unit of POPULAR SAFI, based on the information of the referred unaudited financial statements of the referred fund as of 31 December 2017, the quota value of the participation certificates at that date would be S/. 2.94165923;
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
246. Said value would be consistent with POPULAR SAFI's declaration in its accounting policy, which indicated that the fair value in the case of participations in investment funds is the quota value determined at the close of the financial statements of the funds and with the procedure established in article 39° “Valorización de la Cuota” of the Reglamento de Participación del FONDO MYPE-TCHN, which indicates the following: ”Popular SAFI will determine the quota value of the Fund, dividing its net patrimony, at least once a month, by the number of quotas in circulation. For this purpose, the value of the net patrimony resulting from the respective valuation of assets and liabilities shall be taken into account”;
247. Thus, the total value expressed in Soles of the investments in participation quotas of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN held by POPULAR SAFI, considering the quota value of S/. 2.94165923 (expressed in Soles), is as shown:
| Number of quotas | Quota value | Total (S/.) |
|---|---|---|
| 4,557,019 | 2.94165923 | 13,405,197 |
248. Therefore, the valuation of the investments in participation quotas of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN held by POPULAR SAFI would be S/ 13 405 197 (thirteen million four hundred five thousand one hundred ninety-seven and 00/100 Soles) and not S/ 17 575 994 (seventeen million five hundred seventy-five thousand nine hundred ninety-four and 00/100 Soles), with a difference of S/ 4 170 797.00 (four million one hundred seventy thousand seven hundred ninety-seven 00/100 Soles) between both valuations; therefore, in the valuation of the participation quotas held by POPULAR SAFI in the FONDO MYPE-TCHN, a higher quota value has been used with respect to the certificates held by other investors in the same fund, a situation that has not been explained by the management company;
249. Likewise, the amount obtained of S/ 13,405,197.00 (thirteen million four hundred five thousand one hundred ninety-seven and 00/100 Soles) is lower by S/ 2,321,038, with respect to the initial balance recorded as of 31 December 2016 of S/15,726,235, of the referred investments;
250. In this regard, by letter dated 28 December 2018 POPULAR SAFI states that the difference between both quota values (S/ 3,85690611 vs. S/ 2,94165923 respectively), exists and is due to the different accounting policies adopted and declared by POPULAR SAFI and in the FONDO MYPE; on the one hand POPULAR SAFI classified the investments in participation quotas of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN as “Available for sale”, while the FUND classified its investments as “Held to maturity”;
251. On this matter, it must be indicated that what POPULAR SAFI states does not explain or develop the observed non-compliance referred to the fact that it has not followed its established accounting policy to value its investments in investment funds declared in its own Financial Statements;
252. Additionally, it is observed that 49% of the portfolio that makes up the investment portfolio of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN would be in the process of judicial collection, due to non-compliance in payment by the obligor, as stated in the report “Valorización de Inversiones TCHNs” as of 31 December 2017”;
PERÚ Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas
SMV
Superintendency of the Market de Valores
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
253. Therefore, it would be appropriate for POPULAR SAFI to carry out an impairment evaluation on its investments in participations of the Fondo MYPE-TCHN and an impairment loss if applicable, contrary to the higher value assigned by the management company;
254. By letter dated 28 December 2018 regarding the impairment in investments and losses due to decrease in value, POPULAR SAFI states the following:
On this matter, we reiterate the arguments of sufficient and excess coverage by the mortgage guarantees mentioned above in the response to a similar observation made to the Fondo MYPE. This is demonstrated in the following table:
| INVESTMENT - TCHN BY ORIGINAL TERM | INVESTED CAPITAL | INTEREST RECEIVABLE | TOTAL CAPITAL AND INTEREST | REALIZABLE VALUE OF PROPERTIES IN GUARANTEE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Up to one year | 3,285,455 | 6,677 | 3,292,133 | 11,813,486 |
| Greater than one up to three years | 4,142,873 | 506,233 | 4,649,107 | 50,437,163 |
| Greater than three up to six years | 16,226,583 | 2,913,122 | 19,139,705 | 116,444,433 |
| TOTAL INVESTMENTS | 23,654,912 | 3,426,032 | 27,080,944 | 178,695,082 |
255. On this matter, according to Note 2 "Accounting policies followed by the company" in numeral (ii) literal j) on the Impairment of financial assets available for sale, it is established: "Management evaluates at the date of each separate statement of financial position, whether there is objective evidence that an investment or a group of investments has impairment problems. In the case of (...) investments in investment funds, the objective evidence is that which includes a significant or prolonged decrease in the fair value of the investment below its cost. (...)";
256. According to the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI in its Audited Separate Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, declared that they were prepared in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards in force as of December 31, 2017;
257. In particular, regarding its accounting policy "Classification, recognition and valuation of financial assets" it disclosed that it classified its investments in participation quotas in investment funds as financial assets available for sale and their measurement, after initial recognition, at fair value. In this regard, it disclosed that fair value is the quota value determined at the close of the financial statements of the funds;
258. However, it has been found that POPULAR SAFI valued its investments in participation quotas in the MYPE-TCHN Fund using a value different from that declared in its accounting policies;
259. Consequently, POPULAR SAFI has not carried out the valuation of its investments in the MYPE-TCHN FUND (classified as financial assets available for sale) in accordance with the fair value measurement provided in its accounting policy and the source information available to it, such as the financial statements of the MYPE-TCHN FUND, for which it was charged that it would have breached the provisions of article 132 of the REGULATION, article 1 of the NORMS and paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15 of the "Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting" and paragraph 91 literal a) of IFRS 13, it being necessary to add that the preparation and presentation of its Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017 would not be in accordance with the disclosure made by POPULAR SAFI, according to paragraphs 16, 112 and 117 of the
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the Market in Securities
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
IAS 1 and paragraphs 5.102, 5.104, 5.104.02.1 in literal b) of numeral 1 and literal a) and b) of numeral 2 of the MANUAL, causing distortions in the balance of the Financial Investments available for sale item in its Audited Separate Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017;
260. Regarding the valuation of financial investments, POPULAR SAFI in its discharges, indicates that the investments corresponding to the MYPE-TCHN Fund were spun off as part of a patrimonial block in favor of Popular Consultoría S.A.C.; that the request for authorization of said corporate agreement was presented through writings dated October 17 and November 08, 2018; and that the approval of the SMV was granted through Resolution of the General Superintendency of Supervision of Entities No. 133-2018-SMV/10.2 dated November 22, 2018;
261. POPULAR SAFI specifies that the spun-off patrimonial block corresponds to the book values recognized in the financial statements of the administering company as of June 30, 2018. It adds that consequently, all the financial effects of the observed situation will not have a financial impact on the corresponding financial statements;
262. It points out that notwithstanding the foregoing, the difference between both quota values (S/ 3.85690611 and S/ 2.94165923 respectively), exists and is due to the different accounting policies adopted and declared by POPULAR SAFI and in the MYPE Fund, an adoption supported –in both cases– by the IFRS;
263. It adds that while POPULAR SAFI classified the investments under comment as "Available for sale", the MYPE Fund classified its investments as "Held to maturity". These classifications resulted from the alternative categories of financial assets contained in IAS 39, in force until 201732;
264. POPULAR SAFI indicates that the financial asset category "Available for sale" resulted in a residual category by defining them as "non-derivative financial assets that are specifically designated as available for sale or that are not classified as (a) Loans and receivables, (b) investments held to maturity, or (c) financial assets carried at fair value with changes in results." (IAS 39, paragraph 9). Those financial assets available for sale must be measured both at the initial moment and in subsequent measurements, at fair value (IAS 39, paragraphs 43 and 46) and that this is the accounting policy followed by POPULAR SAFI when measuring its investments;
265. It maintains that the fair value has been determined in the measurement of the investments in POPULAR SAFI using discounted future cash flow techniques at the interest rate agreed with the beneficiaries of the MYPE Fund. These techniques are prescribed by IFRS 13 when referring to the expected present value technique (paragraphs B22 to B29) and which, furthermore, is specifically indicated in the Participation Regulation of the MYPE Fund (article 38, item b), when referring to its valuation;
[32] Although IFRS 9 has been in force since 2018, with IAS 39 required to be applied until 2017, the latter was modified over the years, so the definitions of the four categories of financial assets can be found for the last time in the 2005 version of IAS 39.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
266. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI states that the MYPE Fund valued its investments, which impact equity and consequently the unit value, at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method (IAS 39, 2005 version, paragraph 46) and that the different measurement methods used, the fair value method through discounted cash flows at POPULAR SAFI and the amortized cost at the MYPE Fund, partly explain the difference between the unit values indicated in the OFFICIO DE CARGOS;
267. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI states that the accounting policy described below adopted by the MYPE Fund also has a significant impact in explaining the difference in measurements. That, said MYPE Fund conservatively interrupts the recognition of interest on investments when the investment enters a judicial process, notwithstanding that the guarantee, as will be seen later, is sufficient to cover the agreed accrued interest, and therefore, accrued. It adds that, while the cash flows used by POPULAR SAFI in the fair value measurement of its investments in the MYPE Fund include all agreed financial interest at discounted value, regardless of the start of the judicial process, the MYPE Fund does not consider them as accrued in its accounting, affecting the unit value;
268. POPULAR SAFI indicates that the review of item (iii) of paragraph (f) of the Accounting Policies note cannot lead to the conclusion that the fair value measurement, determined by discounted cash flows, is erroneous, since, as indicated before, IAS 39 distinguishes, according to the classification of the financial asset, between assets measured at amortized cost and those measured at fair value, with changes in profit or loss;
269. POPULAR SAFI adds that the accounting argument of the CHARGES MEMORANDUM also refers to the fundamental qualitative characteristic of Faithful Representation, whose definition is contained in the Conceptual Framework for financial reporting of IFRS33, and that this same Conceptual Framework states that the objective of general purpose financial information is:
(…) to provide financial information about the reporting entity that is useful to existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors in making decisions relating to providing resources to the entity. These decisions involve buying, selling, or holding equity and debt instruments, and providing and settling loans and other forms of debt. 34
270. POPULAR SAFI adds that, while the Conceptual Framework is a single document and aims to provide coherence to the specific standards, the alleged lack of faithful representation would have to be able to affect or have affected the decisions of existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors, to make decisions, and that however, as explained earlier, the investment in the MYPE-TCHN Fund was split in favor of Popular Consultoría S.A.C., whose majority shareholder is the Participant135, and that this was the majority participant, directly and indirectly, of the MYPE-TCHN Fund as of 31 December 2017, (according to
[33] Conceptual Framework, chapter 3, Qualitative Characteristics of Useful Financial Information, paragraphs CC12 to CC16.
[34] Conceptual Framework, chapter 1, paragraph OB2.
[35] The name is specified in the defense submissions.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
shown in the following table), therefore it maintains that it could not have led to misguided decisions:
| Participant in the MYPE Fund | Quantity | % |
|---|---|---|
| Participant1 | 2,795,865 | 24.89% |
| Fondo Popular 1 - Renta Mixta (Sole participant Participant1) | 3,879,440 | 34.54% |
| Popular SAFI | 4,557,019 | 40.57% |
| Total Shares | 11,232,324 | 100% |
271. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI states the following regarding the entry into force of IFRS 9 in 2018 and regarding impairment of investments and write-down losses;
Regarding the entry into force of IFRS 9 in 2018:
272. In this regard, POPULAR SAFI states that the entry into force of IFRS 9 repealed the classification and consequent measurement of investments in financial assets provided for in the aforementioned paragraph 9 of IAS 39. From 2018 onwards, financial assets are classified according to the business model and the characteristics of the contractual cash flows (paragraph 4.1.1), and depending on this, a measurement of amortized cost with effects in profit or loss (4.1.2), or fair value with effects in equity (other comprehensive income) or profit or loss (paragraphs 4.1.2A, 4.1.4 and 4.1.5) is chosen;
273. POPULAR SAFI refers that the difference between a classification of a financial asset measured at amortized cost and a financial asset measured at fair value lies in the fact that in the first case a financial asset is held to obtain the contractual cash flows, including the financial returns on the agreed dates, while fair value measurement is necessary when, in addition to obtaining the cash flows, there is a purpose of realizing the financial asset through sale;
274. And that as a result of the adoption of IFRS 9, although without impact as of the date of this response, POPULAR SAFI must define the business model in order to proceed with the measurement of similar instruments. If it chooses to hold similar financial assets until maturity, POPULAR SAFI's unit value for similar investments must be calculated at amortized cost;
Regarding impairment of investments and write-down losses:
275. POPULAR SAFI states that the CHARGES MEMORANDUM observes regarding the MYPE Fund's investment portfolio as of 31 December 2017, that 49% (forty-nine percent) of it is in a judicial collection process for non-payment, as stated in the "Valuation of TCHN Investments" report as of 31 December 2017, and that from this it concludes that an assessment of the impairment of its value and an impairment loss on the participation certificates would be appropriate;
276. On this point, POPULAR SAFI reiterates the arguments of sufficient and excess coverage by the mortgage guarantees mentioned in its defense submissions to the third charge imputed;
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun
277. POPULAR SAFI has indicated in its submissions that the investments corresponding to the Fondo MYPE-TCHN were carved out as part of an asset block in favor of Popular Consultoría S.A.C. and that said carve-out was approved by Resolution of the General Superintendency of Supervision of Non-Financial Entities No. 133-2018-SMV/10.2 dated 22 November 2018;
278. POPULAR SAFI also specifies that the carved-out asset block corresponds to the accounting values recognized in the financial statements of POPULAR SAFI as of 30 June 2018 and that, consequently, all financial aspects of the matter under observation will have no financial impact on the corresponding financial statements;
279. In this regard, it must be specified that the objective of the present administrative sanctioning proceeding is to determine the infringement committed by POPULAR SAFI based on the observations identified as a result of the inspection carried out on it based on the financial information as of the close of the 2017 fiscal year, so that the aforementioned carve-out is a fact subsequent to said infringement and is not determinative in the present analysis;
280. In this regard, it must be indicated that the charge brought determined that POPULAR SAFI, as of 31 December 2017, did not value its investments in the FONDO MYPE-TCHN (classified as financial investments available for sale) in accordance with the fair value measurement set forth in its accounting policy and the source information available to it, such as the financial statements of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN;
281. In this regard, the charge brought indicated that POPULAR SAFI, in its audited Financial Statements as of 31 December 2017, to determine the total amount of its investment in the FONDO MYPE-TCHN, used the unit value of S/ 3.85690611, obtaining a valuation of S/. 17,575,994.00; however, the unit value consistent with the accounting policy declared by POPULAR SAFI in said financial statements and with the procedure established in Article 39° “Valuation of the Unit” of the Participation Regulations of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN is S/. 2.94165923, with which the valuation of the investments in said fund as of 31 December 2017 would be S/ 13,405,197.00; whereby said investments reflected an overvaluation of 31% (S/ 4,170,797.00)
282. Therefore, the valuation of the investments in participation units of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN held by POPULAR SAFI is S/ 13 405 197 (thirteen million four hundred five thousand one hundred ninety-seven and 00/100 Soles) and not S/ 17 575 994 (seventeen million five hundred seventy-five thousand nine hundred ninety-four and 00/100 Soles);
283. In this regard POPULAR SAFI states that the difference between the unit values of S/ 3.85690611 and S/ 2.94165923 exists and is due to the different accounting policies adopted and declared by POPULAR SAFI and the MYPE-TCHN Fund, which are based on the IFRS; and that according to IAS 39, while POPULAR SAFI classified its investments in the referred fund as “Available for sale”, the MYPE-TCHN Fund classified its investments as “Held to maturity”;
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
284. POPULAR SAFI also indicates that the accounting policy followed in measuring its investments is fair value, which is the one established by IAS 39 for available-for-sale financial assets and that said fair value has been determined using techniques of future cash flows discounted at the interest rate agreed with the beneficiaries of the MYPE-TCHN Fund and that these techniques are prescribed by IFRS 13 when referring to the expected present value technique (paragraphs B22 to B29) and that furthermore, it is specifically indicated in the Participation Regulation of the referred Fund (article 38, subsection b), when referring to its valuation;
285. POPULAR SAFI adds that the MYPE-TCHN Fund, according to IAS 39, valued its investments, which impact equity and consequently the unit value, at amortized cost using the effective interest rate method;
286. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI points out that the accounting policy adopted by the MYPE-TCHN Fund also has an important impact when explaining the difference in the measurements. Said fund conservatively interrupts the recognition of interest on investments when the investment enters judicial proceedings; it does not consider them as accrued in its accounting, affecting the unit value, however, it maintains that the guarantee is sufficient to cover the agreed matured interest, and therefore, accrued. In the case of POPULAR SAFI, it points out that the cash flows used in the fair value measurement of its investments in the MYPE Fund include all financial interest agreed at discounted value, regardless of the start of judicial proceedings;
287. As can be seen in the previous recitals, POPULAR SAFI has not explained in its defenses why it failed to carry out the valuation of its investments in accordance with what was declared in its own accounting policy for the preparation and presentation of its separate financial statements, but has only limited itself to pointing out how it determined its fair value, which confirms the commission of the infraction;
288. On this matter, it should be noted that the observation subject to charges refers to the valuation carried out by POPULAR SAFI of its investments in participation units of the aforementioned private fund, failing to comply with the provisions of its accounting policy detailed below:
(f) Classification, recognition and valuation of financial assets
(…)
(iii) Financial assets available for sale
This category comprises investments in shares accounted for at fair value and participation units in investment funds.
After initial recognition at cost, financial investments available for sale are measured at their fair value; (…)
The fair value of shares is determined on the basis of quotations in active markets (Stock Exchange). In the case of participations in investment funds, the fair value is the unit value determined at the close of the financial statements of the funds.
(…)”
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
289. In that context, article 39 “Valuation of the Unit” of the Participation Regulation of the MYPE-TCHN FUND establishes: “Popular SAFI shall determine the unit value of the Fund by dividing its net equity, at least once a month, by the number of units in circulation. For this purpose, the value of the net equity resulting from the respective valuation of assets and liabilities shall be taken into account”;
290. However, in determining the unit value of S/ 3.85690611, POPULAR SAFI did not use the value of the net equity according to the (unaudited) financial statements as of 31 December 2017 of the MYPE-TCHN FUND, as established by its accounting policy;
291. Instead, it determined an equity for the aforementioned fund that would result from a present value of the investment portfolio of the MYPE-TCHN FUND, as shown in the report “calculation of unit value - December 2017” of the MYPE-TCHN Fund Private Investment Fund”. However, the amounts considered as present value of the investment portfolio and the total equity are amounts significantly higher than the amounts appearing in the unaudited financial statements of the aforementioned fund;
292. That is why POPULAR SAFI, to explain the differences between the unit value of S/. 3.85690611 and 2.9416592336 points out the accounting policies followed by the MYPE-TCHN Fund for the preparation of its financial statements and that affect its equity, on the basis of which the unit value of 2.94165923 is obtained; however, the observation subject to charges does not refer to the valuation of the investments of the MYPE-TCHN Fund which, according to what was indicated by POPULAR SAFI, have been classified as Investments held to maturity and therefore measured at amortized cost, nor to the accounting policies followed by said private fund;
293. Regarding what was indicated by POPULAR SAFI that the unit value of S/ 3.85690611 has been determined using techniques of future cash flows discounted at the interest rate agreed with the beneficiaries of the MYPE Fund and that these techniques are prescribed by IFRS 13 (according to the expected present value technique of paragraphs B22 to B29); and that furthermore, it is specifically indicated in the Participation Regulation of the MYPE Fund (article 38, subsection b), when referring to its valuation, it should be noted that although IFRS 13 establishes the use of present value techniques to measure fair value, as already mentioned, the calculation made by POPULAR SAFI is not supported by what is indicated in its accounting policy, which states: “(…) In the case of participations in investment funds, the fair value is the unit value determined at the close of the financial statements of the funds. (…)”
294. Regarding what was indicated by the managing company that the future flow technique applied by POPULAR SAFI to value its investments is specifically indicated in article 38 subsection b) of the Participation Regulation of the Mype-TCHN Fund, it should be noted that said Participation Regulation establishes the valuation methodology for the assets that make up the Fund's investment portfolio and not the methodology that POPULAR SAFI must follow
[36] Prepared by the accounting unit of Popular SAFI based on the information from the unaudited financial statements of the aforementioned fund.
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
to value its investments. Additionally, as the management company itself has indicated, the Fund measures its investments at amortized cost using the effective interest method, while POPULAR SAFI measures its investments at fair value;
295. Additionally, POPULAR SAFI states that the review of numeral (iii) of letter (f) of the note on accounting policies cannot lead to the conclusion that measurement at fair value, determined through discounted cash flows, is erroneous, according to the classifications of financial assets indicated by IAS 39; 296.
On this matter, it must be indicated that POPULAR SAFI should have disclosed the methodology set forth because, although the management company disclosed an accounting policy referring to the methodology for determining the fair value of its investments, the preparation and presentation of the balance of these, whose amount represents 77% of total assets in its financial statements as of 31 December 2017, is not in accordance with said accounting policy;
297. It should be added that in note 2 (a) POPULAR SAFI declared that the financial statements, which include the notes, are the responsibility of the company's management and that they have been prepared in compliance with IFRS; likewise, in its defenses it states that the methodology applied for the estimation of its fair value is in accordance with IFRS; which contradicts what it discloses as a policy for the case of the valuation of its investments in the MYPE-TCHN Fund;
298. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI mentions that in the same CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK, which refers to the fundamental qualitative characteristic of Faithful Representation, to which the STATEMENT OF CHARGES refers, the objective of general purpose financial information is also included, which is to provide financial information that is useful to existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors in making decisions about providing resources to the entity and that these decisions entail buying, selling, or holding equity and debt instruments, and providing and settling loans and other forms of debt;
299. POPULAR SAFI also maintains that the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK is a single document that aims to give coherence to specific standards, and that the alleged lack of faithful representation would have to be able to affect or have affected the decisions of existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors; however, the investment in the MYPETCHN Fund was spun off in favor of Popular Consultoría S.A.C., whose majority shareholder was the majority participant, directly and indirectly, of the MYPE Fund as of 31 December 2017, so that, as it indicates, it could not have produced guidance toward erroneous decisions;
300. Regarding what POPULAR SAFI has indicated, we must indicate that although the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK states that the Financial Statements have the objective of providing useful information to their users, however it must be taken into account that in that context it also establishes the fundamental qualitative characteristics of useful financial information, which are relevance and faithful information “If financial information is to be useful, it must be relevant and
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
faithfully represent what it purports to represent”37 and in this regard the STATEMENT OF CHARGES refers to the characteristic of faithful information;
301. A complete description (paragraphs CC12 and CC13 of the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK) must include all the information necessary for the user to understand the phenomenon being represented, including all necessary descriptions and explanations. For example, for some items it may also entail explanations of significant facts about the quality and nature of the items, the factors and circumstances that may affect them and the process used for their determination;
302. In this sense, in the case of investments in participation quotas of the MYPE-TCHN Fund, POPULAR SAFI in its defenses has stated that it applied a methodology for determining its fair value, which it has not disclosed or does not coincide with its accounting policy, but on the contrary disclosed another methodology for its determination;
303. Likewise, the definition “Free from error” (paragraphs CC12 and CC15 of the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK) means that there are no errors or omissions in the description of the phenomenon and that the process used to produce the information presented has been selected and applied without errors. In this sense, free from error does not mean perfectly accurate in all respects. For example, an estimate of an unobservable price or value cannot be said to be accurate or inaccurate. However, a representation of that estimate can be faithful if the amount is described clearly and accurately as an estimate, the nature and limitations of the estimation process are explained, and no errors have been made in selecting and applying an appropriate process to develop the estimate;
304. In this aspect, in the case of investments in participation quotas of the MYPE-TCHN Fund, POPULAR SAFI selected a process or methodology for measuring its fair value, which it disclosed as an accounting policy but did not apply, but rather, as it has stated in its defenses, applies another methodology in compliance with IFRS;
305. Regarding the users of POPULAR SAFI's financial statements, these cannot be restricted only to the shareholders or investors that the company and the MYPE-TCHN Fund had, but as the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK itself maintains, it includes potential investors. Additionally, as of 31 December 2017, POPULAR SAFI managed a public fund with 72 participants in addition to 3 private funds and could manage new funds in the future. Likewise, although according to the CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK investors, lenders and other existing and potential creditors are the main users of financial statements, they are not all the users thereof;
306. Regarding POPULAR SAFI's mention of the entry into force of International Financial Reporting Standard 9 Financial Instruments (IFRS 9) in 2018, it should be noted that this standard is not applicable to the financial statements as of 31 December 2017, which is the period that is the basis for the formulation of the imputed charge, since it was not in force;
[37] Paragraph CC4 of the Conceptual Framework
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
307. Regarding what POPULAR SAFI indicated regarding the impairment of its investments in the MYPE-TCHN Fund, reiterating its defenses referring to its arguments of sufficient and excess coverage and guarantee by the mortgage guarantees, we point out that, as indicated in the preceding recitals, these investments have been classified by POPULAR SAFI as available for sale, it being found that the fair value, which according to its policy is the unit value of the MYPE-TCHN Fund, is less than its carrying amount as of 31 December 2017, so there would be a significant decrease in its value and this results in a possible impairment loss;
308. In this regard, according to Note 2 "Accounting policies followed by the company" in item (ii) letter j) on the Impairment of available-for-sale financial investments, it is established: "Management evaluates at the date of each separate statement of financial position whether there is objective evidence that an investment or a group of investments has impairment problems. In the case of (...) interests in investment funds, the objective evidence is that which includes a significant or prolonged decrease in the fair value of the investment below its cost (...).";
309. Additionally, it is observed that 49% of the portfolio that makes up the investment portfolio of the MYPE-TCHN FUND would be in the process of judicial collection, due to non-compliance in payment by the obligor, as stated in the report "Valuation of TCHN Investments" as of 31 December 2017";
310. According to paragraph 61 of IAS 39, objective evidence of impairment for an investment in an equity instrument will include information about significant changes with an adverse effect that have taken place in the technological, market, economic or legal environment in which the issuer operates and that indicate that the cost of the investment in the equity instrument may not be recoverable. A significant or prolonged decline in the fair value of an investment in an equity instrument below its cost is also objective evidence of impairment;
311. For this reason, the guarantees do not form part of the evaluation of the objective evidence of impairment, nor are they described in its aforementioned policy;
312. Therefore, POPULAR SAFI should carry out an impairment evaluation on its investments in interests of the MYPE-TCHN Fund and an impairment loss if applicable, contrary to the higher value assigned by the administrator;
313. For the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI has not refuted the charge imputed to it and has therefore committed a violation classified as serious, set out in subsection 2.12, item 2, of Annex I of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as a serious violation “Submitting to the SMV, the Stock Exchange, the Products Exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized trading mechanism, the investor or in general to any other Participant in the securities or products market, financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru or the International Financial Reporting Standards, as applicable, the technical pronouncements issued by the country's accounting profession, accounting rules
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
established by the supervisory and control bodies or without observing the rules contained in the Financial Information Regulations”38;
314. POPULAR SAFI considers it necessary to emphasize that the supervisory and sanctioning power of the public administration must always be exercised with due respect for the guarantees that our legal system recognizes for the administered;
315. POPULAR SAFI states that, in that sense, the principles set out in the TUO LPAG, especially the principles of reasonableness and presumption of lawfulness, must be taken into consideration in the evaluation of the charges and the analysis of its defenses;
316. In addition to its defenses, POPULAR SAFI considers that special attention must be given to the application of the principle of reasonableness provided for in the TUO LPAG. It adds that, as provided for in item 1.4 of Article IV of the TUO LPAG, the decisions of the entity, when classifying violations or imposing sanctions, must be adapted within the limits of the power attributed and maintaining due proportion between the means to be used and the public purposes that must be protected, so that they correspond to what is strictly necessary for the satisfaction of their purpose;
317. Furthermore, POPULAR SAFI mentions that, as provided for in item 3 of Article 248 of the TUO LPAG, the sanctioning power is also governed by the principle of reasonableness; strictly speaking, entities must ensure that the commission of the sanctionable conduct does not result in greater advantage for the offender than complying with the violated rules or assuming the sanction. Without prejudice to the foregoing, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as a violation, observing, among other criteria, the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the violation and the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or the protected legal asset;
318. POPULAR SAFI adds that, without disregarding the competence and legitimacy of the SMV to supervise and raise charges in relation to alleged non-compliance with regulations, it requests the SMV to consider in its evaluation the relevance (significance) of the alleged infringing conduct, its actual impact on investors and the market, and the potential affectation of the public interest. It appeals for the evaluation of the charges to also value the particular conditions of each of said events;
319. In line with the foregoing, POPULAR SAFI refers that, being in an administrative sanctioning proceeding, the principles recognized in criminal legislation are also applicable. Specifically the Principle of Opportunity set out in the New Code of Criminal Procedure;
320. In this regard, it indicates that, by applying the criminal provision by analogy, the administration may refrain from exercising its
[38] It should be noted that this type of violation has been included in subsection 2.8, item 2 of Annex I of the NEW SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, which indicates as a serious violation the “2.8 Submitting to the SMV, the Stock Exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized trading mechanism, the investor or, in general, any other Participant, financial information prepared without observing the International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Financial Reporting Standards Council (International Accounting Standard Board - IASB) and/or the accounting rules for the preparation and presentation of financial information issued by the SMV, as applicable.”
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
sanctioning power when dealing with violations that do not seriously affect the public interest. In that sense, if the administration does not consider that it is a case of exemption or that a certain violation has indeed been configured, it requests to evaluate the actual affectation to the protected legal asset, to the investors of the FUND and to the market;
321. POPULAR SAFI states that if it is concluded that the imposition of sanctions for the facts described in the CHARGE MEMORANDUM is appropriate, it must be taken into account that no serious affectation to the public interest has been verified, but only a minimal affectation to the protected legal asset. In that sense, it indicates that the administration should take that fact into account when considering its defenses and evaluating the application of sanctions;
322. Regarding the facts noted in the CHARGE MEMORANDUM, it states that POPULAR SAFI has not acted wilfully, or with the purpose of obtaining benefits in an irregular manner, and that it expects the actual impact of the facts imputed to POPULAR SAFI to be valued;
323. POPULAR SAFI appeals for the consideration of its defenses and the evaluation of the allegations made in the CHARGES NOTICE to take into account that the facts mentioned have not resulted in actual harm to the interests of the Fund and/or investors and/or the market;
324. Without prejudice to the arguments presented, POPULAR SAFI sets out the criteria that should govern any potential sanction. In that regard, it refers to Article 25 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes the following criteria for determining sanctions, which it considers applicable to this procedure, and which it details below:
325. Recidivism: It establishes that the alleged infringements are not repetitive with respect to previous procedures or allegations against POPULAR SAFI;
326. Circumstances of the commission of the infringement: it states that the allegations against POPULAR SAFI arise from facts under particular circumstances. It points out that they are not visibly intentional acts or aimed at obtaining an advantage at the expense of investors or the market;
327. It argues that it must be assessed how those formal observations noted in the CHARGES NOTICE developed, and how they became a fact or state that did not cause any harm to investors and the market. It adds that the conduct of POPULAR SAFI has been reasonable and consistent, as described in the preceding lines;
328. It indicates that to date, POPULAR SAFI has taken certain actions to avoid situations such as those noted in the CHARGES NOTICE, which are the subject of this procedure;
329. Economic harm caused and its impact on the market: it indicates that it must be adequately assessed that the allegations against POPULAR SAFI have not caused economic harm to its investors and/or the market, which, as it mentions, is aligned with the CHARGES NOTICE, which has not noted such a situation. In line with the above, it adds that it must also be assessed what the outcome was of certain acts attributed to POPULAR SAFI;
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the
Securities Market
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
330. Furthermore, it argues that it has not been verified that the facts alleged in the CHARGES NOTICE had a negative impact on the market or the protected legal interest; or, in any case, that the magnitude of the same was very slight, given that no harm to investors has been reported;
331. Illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement: it points out that there are no indications that, as a result of the allegations against POPULAR SAFI, it has obtained any type of benefit;
332. It adds that in this way, in the absence of indications giving rise to presume the existence of an illegal benefit, the administration must assume that no such benefits existed, and adjust any potential sanction accordingly;
333. Probability of detection of the infraction: it states that the facts supporting the imputations against POPULAR SAFI could have been known by the SMV and/or by the investors of the FUND, insofar as it is related to information that is public (as is the case of financial statements), or is delivered to investors, or is available to them;
334. Likewise, it indicates that POPULAR SAFI has already implemented certain measures (such as changes in the FUND's Participation Regulation and the MPPO) to mitigate the probabilities that such facts will occur again;
335. Seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal interest: it considers that no harm has been caused to the rights of the FUND's investors, which has also not been proven in the OFICIO DE CARGOS. Furthermore, it maintains that with respect to the alleged impact on investor protection, this must be dismissed in accordance with the fact that no economic damages and negative repercussions on the market have been evidenced, which is where the investors that the regulations protect ultimately interact;
336. Existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct: it indicates that the detailed motives and reasoning that supported POPULAR SAFI's conduct must be evaluated with respect to the imputations described in the OFICIO DE CARGOS;
337. Finally, it adds that as provided by article 25 of the ACTUAL REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES itself, it considers that it must be evaluated in the analysis that there is no proportionality between the sanctions provided for the imputed facts and the latter, especially due to their significance, minimal impact on investors and the market, and nonexistence of benefits for POPULAR SAFI. Therefore, it requests that, if it is decided to impose a sanction, the sanctions of the lower classification be considered;
338. Regarding the fact that the principle of opportunity regulated in article 2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure must be applied to this administrative sanctioning procedure, it must be indicated that the ACTUAL REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES establishes a figure similar to that of the aforementioned Code of Criminal Procedure referring to the possibility of not initiating an administrative sanctioning procedure, which implies, in
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
the light of administrative sanctioning law, not sanctioning an administered party for the infraction committed by it;
339. Indeed, article 24 of the aforementioned regulation regulates the figure of abstention from initiating the administrative sanctioning procedure. This occurs when the assumptions indicated in the first paragraph of article 22 of said regulation are present, that is, as long as they are minor infractions and whose facts are of little significance. In the present case, neither of the two requirements is met, so legally it is not possible to apply such legal figure;
340. On the other hand, with regard to the other criteria developed by POPULAR SAFI, it must be indicated that these will be considered in the following section, Evaluation of the sanction to be imposed;
341. In order to reconcile the criteria of the TUO LPAG with those indicated in the LMV and the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES and for these criteria to be considered adequately so that their assessment observes the principle of reasonableness and the sanction to be imposed adapts to them, the following criteria have been analyzed:
342. In accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, the sanctions imposed by the SMV and that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned constitute the offender's background;
343. Regarding the imputed infractions, POPULAR SAFI has the following infraction background:
a. Resolución de Superintendencia Adjunta SMV N° 025-2014-SMV/10, of 13 November 2014, through which POPULAR SAFI is sanctioned with four warnings for having incurred a minor infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Reglamento de Sanciones for having submitted periodic information outside the established deadline in accordance with the provisions of the Reglamento de los Fondos de Inversión y sus Sociedades Administradoras, approved by Resolución CONASEV N° 042-2003-EF/94.10.
b. Resolución de Superintendencia Adjunta SMV N° 014-2016-SMV/10, of 20 April 2016, through which POPULAR SAFI is sanctioned with three (03) warnings and a fine amounting to 5.6135 UIT, equivalent to S/ 21 331.30 (Twenty-one thousand three hundred thirty-one and 30/100 Soles), for having incurred five (05) minor infractions classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having submitted occasional and periodic information referring to interim financial information, audited annual financial information, management report, annual report and material event, outside the deadline established by the regulations.
c. Resolución de Superintendencia Adjunta SMV N° 065-2016-SMV/10, of 30 December 2016, through which POPULAR SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of 1.777 UIT, equivalent to S/ 6 752.60 (Six thousand seven hundred fifty-two and 60/100 Soles) and with four (04) warnings, for having incurred six (06)
PERÚ Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas
SMV
Superintendency of the Market de Valores
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
minor infractions classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation for having submitted occasional and periodic information outside the deadline established by the regulations referring to interim financial information, management report and material events.
d. Resolución de Superintendencia Adjunta SMV N° 020-2017-SMV/10, of 5 April 2017, through which POPULAR SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of 2.5 UIT amounting to S/ 9 250,00 (Nine thousand two hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) for having incurred two serious infractions classified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraphs 2.7 and 2.19, respectively, of the Sanctions Regulation for failing to comply with the rules on custody of the investments of the investment fund it manages and for the lack of agreement of the Investment Committee to maintain or not an asset of the portfolio of said investment fund;
344. It should be noted that said sanctions have become final at the administrative instance insofar as they were not subject to challenge;
345. With reference to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, the final sanction imposed by the SMV within one (1) year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned is taken into account. It has been verified that POPULAR SAFI does not present final sanctions for the commission of the infractions subject to analysis in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, therefore recidivism is not configured;
346. Regarding the infraction referring to the failure to observe the provisions of the FONDO's Participation Regulation, it should be noted that it has not been possible to prove that POPULAR SAFI's action has caused damage to the public interest; however, its non-observance by the administrator has affected the legal goods related to the transparency and integrity of the market. As noted, the referred regulation contains relevant information on the operation of the funds, therefore it constitutes fundamental information on the basis of which an investor decides whether or not to invest in a given fund, and in doing so, assumes that the conditions indicated therein, which in turn define the degree of exposure to risk assumed, will be diligently complied with by the fund administrator;
347. In the present case, Popular SAFI did not observe provisions related to i) the process of execution of guarantees; ii) the limitation that should have been observed in the composition of the audit team of the FONDO's financial statements; and iii) compliance with the appraisal requirement of the properties given as guarantee for the approval of investments. In this sense, the conditions offered to the market to invest in said fund were related to the fact that the FUND would necessarily initiate a process of enforcement of the guarantee associated with the TCHN when the grantor-obligor had failed to pay six (6) consecutive or alternating installments of its payment schedule; a situation that did not occur, that is, a basic condition related to the backing that investments would have was not met by the administrator. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI allowed the same audit team to participate in the audit work for the third consecutive year, thereby affecting the confidence the market could have in the opinions issued, precisely one of
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
the reasons for the renewal of audit teams is linked to agency problems, in particular for aspects related to moral hazard and information asymmetries. On the other hand, investors expected, given the provisions of the Participation Regulations, that the Investment Committee would adopt investment decisions considering a series of variables, seeking for the base information to be as complete as possible; however, said situation was not observed insofar as the requirement was not met that it did not previously have the respective valuations;
348. The development of the securities market is based on the confidence that investors, potential investors and the market in general may have in the diligent work that the different entities participating in it may have, in particular the administrators with respect to the obligations they must fulfill given the provisions of the Participation Regulations; a situation that, in accordance with what has been stated above, has not been observed in the present case;
349. With respect to the charge referring to the undue collection from the FUND for the contracting of PRESTACLUB in the 2017 fiscal year, it must be indicated that POPULAR SAFI also affected the legal interest relating to transparency because it did not assume a cost that corresponded to it given the very nature of such service, which should, at the time, have been included within its economic cost for the management of the FUND.
350. Indeed, in the present proceeding it has been demonstrated that the contracting of PRESTACLUB in the 2017 fiscal year constituted the contracting of a service that should have been assumed by POPULAR SAFI and not by the FUND in accordance with article 7 of the REGULATIONS, a situation which even the FUND's Participation Regulations did not expressly allow, so the interpretation or explanation given by POPULAR SAFI in its defenses cannot, in any way, go against a rule of public order such as the aforementioned article 7;
351. Likewise, said situation affected the profitability of the FUND since it had to assume an additional expense that did not correspond to it, therefore by reducing the results obtained by the FUND, the unit value was negatively affected, and therefore the profitability of the participants, with which the integrity of the market was additionally affected; situations such as those described in which the evolution of the unit value is not the result of market conditions linked to the investments made by the administrator have a negative impact on the market's confidence in the investment fund industry, which affects its development and that of the market in general;
352. With respect to the charge referring to the assessment of the impairment of the FUND's investments, it must be indicated that this affects the public interest, and the transparency and integrity of the securities market, since POPULAR SAFI did not substantiate before the regulator its assessment and estimation to determine the impairment of the FUND's financial assets, which, for the 2017 fiscal year, information was reported to the market that did not comply with the treatment that accounting standards and its own participation regulations expressly and legally required;
353. It should be noted that the information provided to the market and which serves as a basis for a prudent investor to make decisions, must meet a set of conditions among them being truthful and complete; in this sense, investors expect that the investments made for the
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
funds managed by administrators reasonably reflect the value they represent in the financial information, since POPULAR SAFI did not carry out procedures related to determining the impairment of the FUND's assets and therefore the possible related loss, the possible adjustment of the respective provision for the investments made was not estimated, this in a context in which it was observed that there were investments with 61.53% of the total principal receivable installments overdue, with delays between 24% to 100% of the total amount of the financed capital, as well as financings with judicial proceedings; so the administrator had to comply with the provisions of the IFRS in order to provide the market and investors with valuations of the FUND's investments that had to be the result of a comprehensive assessment;
354. With respect to the submission of POPULAR SAFI's financial information for the 2017 fiscal year without complying with the regulations, it must be pointed out that this affected the transparency of the securities market, inasmuch as it safeguards the right of actual and potential investors and the general public to access such information not only in a timely manner but also in compliance with the applicable rules for its preparation, in order to be able to make investment decisions or carry out a certain assessment;
355. Indeed, in the present case, POPULAR SAFI did not value its investments in the FONDO MYPE-TCHN in accordance with the fair value measurement set forth in its accounting policy and the source information available to it, such as the financial statements of the FONDO MYPE-TCHN, which caused distortions in the balance of the line item Financial Investments Available for Sale in the audited financial information as of the close of 2017, which was reflected in the fact that, instead of presenting said investments with a balance of S/ 13,405,197.00, it presented them with one of S/ 17,575,997.00, that is, it presented the information with an excess of 31.11%. Likewise, Popular SAFI did not carry out an impairment assessment of its investments in shares of the Fondo MYPE-TCHN; with 49% of the portfolio in judicial collection, nor did it make the corresponding adjustment for the respective impairment loss resulting from the application of the administrator's accounting policy, which implied a significant decrease in its value;
356. Such situations affected the general purpose that financial information must have, that is, to provide financial information that is useful to investors, lenders and other existing and potential creditors for making decisions about the provision of resources to the entity, which serves as a basis for making decisions that involve buying, selling, or holding equity and debt instruments, and providing and settling loans and other forms of debt;
357. With respect to the economic harm caused and its repercussion, it must be taken into account that the improper allocation of expenses to the Fund that should have been borne by the management company has caused harm to the fund, as it has assumed costs that did not correspond to it or that should have been included within the management fee charged by the management company;
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the
Securities Market
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” “Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun”
358. In accordance with the provisions of item 7 of Article 248 of the TUO LPAG, it is not observed that, in the present case, the circumstances that could constitute a repetition and/or continuity of the infraction subject to this administrative sanctioning procedure are present;
359. With respect to this criterion, it should be noted that POPULAR SAFI, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, knows the rules that regulate the securities market and, in that sense, is aware of the obligations contained in the LEY, the REGLAMENTO, the REGLAMENTO and the NORMAS;
360. In the INSPECTION carried out, the activities being carried out by POPULAR SAFI were evaluated, identifying that in the 2017 fiscal year it did not comply with some provisions established in the Fund's participation Regulation such as complying with the requirement of having carried out the appraisal of the properties given as collateral for the approval of investments, complying with the execution of the guarantees in cases with delays equal to or greater than six (6) installments or not having presented any support for the evaluation of impairment of investments;
361. Likewise, in the INSPECTION, information and documentation related to compliance with its obligations as administrator of a public fund was reviewed and requested, observing that in 2017 it made an improper charge to the FUND for the contracting of PRESTACLUB when this should have been assumed by the administrator itself; it should be noted that both POPULAR SAFI and PRESTACLUB belong to the same Economic Group, Berckemeyer Prado; and that according to the Fund's Participation Regulation, the annual remuneration for administration of the FUND by Popular SAFI was 3.5% plus IGV calculated on the Net Equity of the Fund, which at the close of December 2017, amounted to S/ 35 514 522,00;
362. On the other hand, it was observed that POPULAR SAFI did not comply with proving the evaluation of impairment of financial assets owned by the FUND in addition to the fact of not having prepared its financial information for said fiscal year without observing the applicable regulations, information that was even brought to the attention of its clients, the market and therefore, of the FUND's participants; this in a context in which POPULAR SAFI as of December 31, 2017 managed the FUND, which was constituted under the general regime, with 72 participants and assets as indicated by S/ 35 514 522,00; in addition to managing 3 private funds;
363. As for the illegally obtained benefit, it should be indicated that charging the FUND the cost of contracting PRESTACLUB according to the invoice of December 15, 2017 without observing the regulations implied an expense amounting to at least S/ 11 564.20 (eleven thousand five hundred sixty-four and 20/100 Soles), which should have been entirely assumed by POPULAR SAFI and not by the FUND, in accordance with what is set forth in this resolution;
364. Regarding the other imputed infractions, it should be noted that it has not been proven in this administrative sanctioning procedure that POPULAR SAFI has obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred in such infractions;
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence” "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
365. No intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct of POPULAR SAFI regarding the infractions subject of analysis;
366. On this matter, it should be noted that POPULAR SAFI was subject to the INSPECTION where it was requested a series of information and documentation related to its activities as an investment fund management company in which compliance with its obligations contained in the regulations governing it was evaluated; as a result of this on-site supervision, review of documents available and accessible only at the premises of the administered party, cross-checking of internal information and information disseminated to the market, among others, resulted in the determination of the infractions subject of the case; from which it is concluded that if in that set of activities it had not been possible to identify the indications that led to the initiation of this sanctioning procedure and that finally resulted in the determination of infractions; therefore, it is possible to conclude that the probability of detection of the same was low:
367. POPULAR SAFI has not acknowledged its responsibility in the commission of the four imputed infractions, limiting itself only to presenting its defenses;
368. Likewise, it must be indicated that POPULAR SAFI has contributed to the clarification of the imputed facts by explaining its actions and interpretation of the observed regulations. In the case of the third infraction, they have explained their procedures or criteria for the evaluation of impairment;
369. However, in the case of the fourth infraction, although they have indicated the procedure followed for the valuation of their investments, they have not specified why they breached their established policy on said valuation;
370. Regarding the exemptions and mitigating circumstances of responsibility, it must be indicated that it is not observed that in this proceeding any of the assumptions that constitute exempting and mitigating conditions of responsibility have been configured, having disproved the arguments presented by POPULAR SAFI on the matter in the evaluation of the defenses;
371. According to the foregoing, it is concluded that POPULAR SAFI has incurred in one (01) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.5 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the time of the events, by not having complied with observing the provisions of article 83 in accordance with article 85 of the REGULATIONS, article 49 of the Participation Regulations of the FUND, and the provisions of paragraphs 58, 59, 63, 64 and GA84 of IAS 39
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
372. On the other hand, POPULAR SAFI has incurred in the commission of three (03) infractions of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the time of the events, by not having complied with observing articles 14, 19, numerals II, literal d) and III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the Participation Regulations of the FUND;
373. Likewise, POPULAR SAFI has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.17 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the time of the events, by not having complied with observing the provisions of articles 7 and 8 of the REGULATIONS;
374. Similarly, POPULAR SAFI has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the time of the events, by not having complied with observing article 132 of the REGULATIONS, article 1 of the NORMS and paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15 of the "Conceptual Framework for Financial Information" and paragraph 91 literal a) of IFRS 13, it being necessary to add that the preparation and presentation of its Financial Statements as of 31 December 2017 was not in accordance with the disclosure made by POPULAR SAFI, according to paragraphs 16, 112 and 117 of IAS 1 and paragraphs 5.102, 5.104, 5.104.02.1 in literal b) of numeral 1 and literal a) and b) of numeral 2 of the MANUAL;
375. Considering the analysis carried out regarding the sanction criteria, and taking into account the provisions of article 29 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in the analyzed case it corresponds to impose on POPULAR SAFI the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction;
376. In accordance with article 20 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, in force at the date of the events, said infraction is sanctionable with a fine greater than fifty (50) and up to seven hundred (700) Tax Units (UIT) or with suspension of the operating authorization for a period of not less than ten (10) days up to forty-five (45) days;
377. It should be indicated that for the determination of the type of sanction to be imposed, it corresponds to apply the principle of non-retroactivity contained in numeral 5 of article 248 of the TUO LPAG, and consequently, apply the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, given that this is more favorable to the present case;
378. In that sense, article 33 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS provides that infractions of a very serious nature are sanctionable with a fine of not less than fifty (50) and up to seven hundred (700) Tax Units (UIT), or suspension of the operating authorization for a period of not less than ten (10) days up to forty-five (45) days;
379. In this regard, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG, which states that sanctions must be proportional to the non-compliances qualified as infractions, and, considering that no intentionality has been evidenced in its actions, that the administering company is not a repeat offender regarding the referred infractions; it is possible to impose on POPULAR SAFI a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than that provided for
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
very serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6 of the SANCTIONS REGULATIONS;
380. Finally, considering that in the present case it has been determined that rules have been infringed, resulting in the existence of illegally obtained benefits, and given the seriousness of the infringement incurred, the impact on the legal interests of transparency and market integrity, the facts set forth as part of the assessment of the sanction; as well as the provisions of Annex XX, numeral 27 of the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS, this Deputy Superintendency considers that corrective measures should be adopted aimed at repairing the harm caused to the FUND as a result of improper charges in order to repair the impact caused due to the breach of the infringed regulations;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
Article 1.- Declare that Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión has incurred an infringement of a very serious nature classified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subparagraph 1.5 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory rules, in force at the date of the events, by failing to comply with the provisions of article 49 of the FUND's Participation Regulations in accordance with articles 83 and 85 of the REGULATIONS and the provisions of paragraphs 58, 59, 63, 64 and GA84 of IAS 39, insofar as it did not carry out the impairment assessment of the investments of Fondo Capital Emprendedor – Fondo de Inversión.
Article 2.- Declare that Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión has incurred three (03) infringements of a serious nature classified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory rules, in force at the date of the events, for failing to comply with articles 14, 19, numerals II, literal d) and III, literal b) and 23, literal a), of the Participation Regulations of Fondo Capital Emprendedor – Fondo de Inversión, by not observing provisions related to the process of enforcement of guarantees; the limitation that should have been observed in the composition of the audit team for the financial statements; and compliance with the appraisal requirement of the properties given as guarantees for the approval of investments.
Article 3.- Declare that Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión has incurred an infringement of a serious nature classified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.17 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory rules, in force at the date of the events, by failing to comply with articles 7 and 8 of the Regulations on Investment Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments, by making charges to Fondo Capital Emprendedor – Fondo de Inversión that corresponded to the management company for the contracting of third-party services to perform functions proper to Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión.
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Perú suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
Article 4.- Declare that Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión has incurred an infringement of a serious nature classified in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendatory rules, in force at the date of the events, by failing to comply with article 132 of the Regulations on Investment Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments; article 1 of the Rules on the preparation and presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV-01; and, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15 of the "Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting" and paragraph 91 literal a) of IFRS 13, it being necessary to add that the preparation and presentation of its Financial Statements as of 31 December 2017 is not in accordance with the disclosure made by POPULAR SAFI, according to paragraphs 16, 112 and 117 of IAS 1 and paragraphs 5.102, 5.104, 5.104.02.1 in literal b) of numeral 1 and literal a) and b) of numeral 2 of the Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information, by having prepared its audited financial statements as of 31 December 2017 without observing the regulations established for that purpose.
Article 5.- Sanction Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión with a fine of 30 UIT equivalent to S/ 121,500.00 (One hundred twenty-one thousand five hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infringements contained in numerals 1 to 4 above.
Article 6.- Order as a corrective measure the return of S/ 11 564.20 (eleven thousand five hundred sixty-four and 20/100 Soles) to Fondo Capital Emprendedor – Fondo de Inversión. For this purpose, within a period of 30 business days from notification of this resolution, Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión must adopt the necessary actions to make said return effective.
Article 7.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 8.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by means of a reconsideration or appeal remedy within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on the dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
PERU Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the Market in Securities
"Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men" "Year of the Bicentennial of Peru: 200 years of independence" "Peru suyunchikpa Iskay Pachak Watan: iskay pachak watañam qispisqanmanta karun"
Article 9.- Transcribe this resolution to Popular S.A. Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión.
Register, communicate and publish.
Signed by: GUTIERREZ OCHOA Omar Darío Reason:
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“provided for in article 27 of the Sanctions Regulations (hereinafter, the CURRENT SANCTIONS REGULATIONS) approved by SMV Resolution N° 035-2018-SMV/01”
“approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation”
“provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.”
“the Norms on preparation and presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV-01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added