Enforcement · SMV · 27 Dec 2023
The Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision declared unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by El Clan EAFC S.A. against Resolution SMV No. 059-2021-SMV/10, which had sanctioned it with two reprimands and a fine of 2.4 UIT for three minor infractions for not timely submitting interim financial information for January, April and December 2019. The resolution holds that Article 28 of the Sanctions Regulation validly excludes voluntary correction as an exemption from liability for late submission of financial information, because the transparency of the collective funds system cannot be remedied retroactively. The appeal was filed within the fifteen-day period and did not require new evidence because the sanction was issued in a single administrative instance.
PERÚ Ministry of Economy and Finance
SMV
Superintendency of the Market in Securities
“Decade of Equal Opportunities for Women and Men” “Year of unity, peace and development”
Lima, 27 December 2023
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by El Clan EAFC S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 059-2021-SMV/10 is declared unfounded.
Administered party
:
El Clan EAFC S.A.
Subject
:
Reconsideration appeal against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 059-2021-SMV/10 File No.:
2021023158
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision (e)
Administrative file No. 2021023158, the reconsideration appeal and additional written arguments submitted by El Clan EAFC S.A., as well as Report No. 368-2022-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; and
1. Pursuant to article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
2. By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 059-2021-SMV/10 (hereinafter, the RESOLUTION), it was resolved to sanction El Clan EAFC S.A. (hereinafter, EL CLAN EAFC) with two (2) reprimands and a fine of 2.4 UIT for having incurred three (3) infractions of a minor nature classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 in force as of 19 December 2018, (hereinafter, SANCTIONS REGULATION), for not having timely submitted interim financial information of the collective funds system it administers, corresponding to the months of January, April and December 2019;
3. By document submitted on 19 January 2022, EL CLAN EAFC filed a reconsideration appeal against the RESOLUTION;
4. On 25 March 2022, the administrator submitted additional written arguments;
5. In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 27 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF OF THE SMV), it is the function of the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision to resolve reconsideration appeals against the resolutions it issues;
6. Then, article 218, numeral 218.2 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS and amendments (hereinafter, TUO OF THE LPAG), establishes that the term for filing appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days. According to the provisions of article 16 of the TUO OF THE LPAG, the aforementioned period shall begin to be counted from the day following the legal notification of the challenged administrative act;
7. In this regard, it has been verified that the challenged resolution was notified to EL CLAN EAFC via MVNet on 29 December 2021 and the “appeal” was filed on 19 January 2021, that is, within the fifteen (15) days established by article 218 of the TUO OF THE LPAG;
8. At this point it is necessary to mention that although EL CLAN EAFC classifies its appeal as an appeal, in accordance with the provisions of article 223 of the TUO OF THE LPAG the error in classification is not an obstacle to its processing provided that the true nature is deduced from the document, so it is appropriate to classify the document as a reconsideration appeal;
9. In accordance with article 219 of the TUO OF THE LPAG, the reconsideration appeal is filed before the same body that issued the act subject to challenge and must be supported by new evidence. However, in cases of administrative acts issued by bodies that constitute a single instance, new evidence is not required;
10. Likewise, in accordance with article 32, numeral 17 of the ROF OF THE SMV, the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision has the power to impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness of the submission of periodic and occasional information;
11. According to the RESOLUTION, three (3) infractions were sanctioned referring to non-compliance with the norms on the timeliness of the submission of periodic information, so that in accordance with the provisions of article 219 of the TUO OF THE LPAG the reconsideration appeal filed by EL CLAN EAFC does not require new evidence;
12. EL CLAN EAFC maintains that the RESOLUTION has been issued without considering the minimum guarantees necessary for the ex officio sanctioning procedure, by incurring serious impairments that cause its Nullity; this to the extent that the principle of Legality and what is expressly established by the TUO OF THE LPAG have not been observed;
13. Thus, it points out that the SANCTIONS REGULATION establishes in its article 28 various cases in which correction is not applied as an exemption from liability, among these, in literal c), the late or incomplete submission, or the non-submission of material facts, financial information and annual reports, however, said provision expressly violates the provisions of the TUO OF THE LPAG, which was challenged in its defenses;
14. Then, regarding recitals 30 to 41 of the RESOLUTION, EL CLAN EAFC maintains that it does not question that the SMV is empowered to issue legal norms regulating matters of the securities market; however, said power does not allow it to exceed what is regulated in the General Administrative Procedure Law (LPAG), and it must abide by the principles applicable to all sanctioning procedures;
15. In that sense, it states that the TUO DE LA LPAG expressly establishes in article 257 the conditions exempting from liability, indicating among these the voluntary correction by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 255 of the TUO DE LA LPAG. Therefore, it is not possible for the SMV's REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, a regulatory provision (that is, inferior), to attempt to delimit a provision that originates from the Law and is expressly recognized in the LPAG;
16. As a consequence, EL CLAN EAFC states, not accepting exemptions from liability violates article II of the LPAG, which states that the LPAG contains common rules for the actions of the State's administrative function and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures, and that laws that create and regulate special procedures may not impose less favorable conditions on administrated parties than those of the LPAG. In that line, the administering company points out, account must also be taken of the provisions of article 247, numeral 247.2 of the TUO DE LA LPAG;
17. Furthermore, EL CLAN EAFC continues, the SMV has powers to regulate the scope of its competence, but may in no way impose less favorable conditions on administrated parties, especially when the LPAG so states;
18. Likewise, EL CLAN EAFC maintains that the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial (SASP) cannot rely on the Principle of Reasonableness, since the TUO DE LA LPAG does not establish any limitation for the application of the ground exempting from liability, for which reason it is applicable to any type of infraction, whatever its condition, and the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES cannot create an exception. Therefore, there is an evident defect in the RESOLUCIÓN given that by regulatory norm the LPAG cannot be contravened, for which reason it requests that the RESOLUCIÓN be declared Null;
19. Then, the administering company argues that in addition to the fact that the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES contravenes the LPAG, it must be taken into account that the SASP motivates its decision in the RESOLUCIÓN by merely stating the articles that empower it to issue the norms regulating matters of the securities market, products market and the collective funds system, however, it does not rule, nor justify on what legal basis the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES may contravene the LPAG, imposing less favorable conditions than the framework norm, which makes no distinction;
20. In this regard, it refers to the provisions of article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO DE LA LPAG and states that the Constitutional Court has indicated that the lack of motivation of the administrative act or its insufficiency constitutes an arbitrariness insofar as it is a condition imposed by Law No. 27444, thus, the lack of sufficient rational basis for an administrative action is by itself contrary to the guarantees of due administrative procedure;
21. Furthermore, it states that the Constitutional Court has determined in STC 8495-2006-PA/TC that motivating a decision does not only mean expressing solely under which legal norm the administrative act is issued, but, fundamentally, setting out succinctly but sufficiently the factual reasons and the legal basis that justify the decision taken. It also states that in Exp. No. 3943-2006-PA/TC and, previously, in the singular vote of magistrates Gonzales Ojeda and Alva Orlandini (Exp. No. 1744-2005-PA-TC), the Constitutional Court has specified that the right to a duly motivated decision is violated when the motivation is nonexistent or when it is only apparent, in the sense that it does not account for the minimum reasons supporting the decision or does not respond to the allegations of the parties to the process;
22. Under that context, the administering company states that it is essential that, within the framework of an administrative procedure, the authority comply with the guarantee of motivating its acts as an expression of the duty of congruence and rule on the facts and grounds that make up the request of the administrated parties involved in the procedure, this having been omitted;
23. In that line, EL CLAN EAFC considers that it is demonstrated that the SASP has limited itself only to literally expressing the legal norm of its power without analyzing the violation that it represents to the provisions of the LPAG;
24. On the other hand, the administering company considers that the SASP incurs another violation of the duty of motivation in the RESOLUCIÓN by stating that the application of the exemption of voluntary correction is subject to the correction of the act constituting the infraction and not the consequences of the administrative infractions, thus disregarding the opinion of the Ministry of Justice in the practical Guide on the administrative sanctioning procedure (which it invoked and on which the SASP has not ruled or dismissed) regarding that the assumption of voluntary correction provided in article 257, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO DE LA LPAG is based on a punitive policy decision to protect the legal interest, in which the spontaneous reparative action of the responsible administrated party is preferred before carrying out preliminary proceedings and initiating the sanctioning procedure with all the costs that this involves. And that said assumption not only consists of the cessation of the infringing conduct, but that, when appropriate, the correction implies the reparation of the consequences or harmful effects to the protected legal interest, derived from the infringing conduct, with the purpose of not generating impunity and preventing the accused from appropriating the benefit illicitly obtained by the infraction;
25. On the other hand, EL CLAN EAFC states that at the time of resolving it was not taken into account that it is a relatively new company in the sector, being one of the last companies to receive operating authorization from the SMV and the only one that has been incorporated under the Regulation of the System of Collective Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 020-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, the REGULATION). Therefore, as any organization may be exposed to possible unintentional material errors, which cannot be considered as bad faith to evade responsibilities or omit relevant information. Therefore, a sanction such as the one the SMV proposes to impose would damage the optimal image it is building, since it is a growing company;
26. On the other hand, the management company indicates that the RESOLUTION states regarding the infraction for having submitted outside the established deadline the interim financial information corresponding to the month of January 2019, which should have been submitted by 4 March 2019, however, it was submitted on 12 March 2019; that it does not meet the requirement of minimal affectation to the principle of transparency, so a warning sanction does not apply. However, there is no development that supports such a statement. Furthermore, in the “Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Rules Regulating the Submission of Periodic or Eventual Information”, approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments1 (hereinafter, SANCTION CRITERIA) there is no objective definition regarding the referred minimal affectation;
27. In that sense, EL CLAN EAFC reiterates that it complied with submitting the interim financial information corresponding to the month of January 2019 and that the delay in its submission should be considered as minimal affectation to the principle of transparency;
28. Additionally, the management company mentions that the SASP has not considered its request for the application of the mitigating circumstance of responsibility established in article 257, numeral 2, literal a) of the TUO DE LA LPAG referring to the offender acknowledging its responsibility expressly and in writing once the administrative sanctioning procedure has begun. And that there is a contradiction between what is indicated in recital 26 and recital 90 of the RESOLUTION, in this regard;
29. In that sense, it specifies that in its brief submitted on 24 June 2021 it expressly acknowledged the commission of the infraction, since there was a delay in the submission of interim financial information corresponding to the month of January 2019;
30. Also, EL CLAN EAFC highlights that it is the only company in the sector that has not previously received any administrative or economic sanction from any administrative entity and that it has a clean client portfolio with no claims of any kind, which can be demonstrated. Which reflects its commitment to its clients and to compliance with the legal framework
[1] Amended by article 3 of SMV Resolution No. 010-2014-SMV/01 of 22 May 2014, in force as of 25 May 2014. The referred resolution amended the first paragraph of the Fourth Criterion of subsection 4.1, numerals (ii), (iv), (v) (vi) and (vii) of subsection 4.2 of the Criteria applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure for non-compliance with the rules regulating the submission of periodic or eventual information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012- SMV/01.
in force. Likewise, it reiterates that it maintains adequate, ethical, responsible and transparent behavior before the SMV, its shareholders, collaborators and clients, since it is part of its organizational culture;
31. EL CLAN EAFC maintains that the application of the exemption for voluntary correction established in article 257, numeral 1), literal f) of the TUO DE LA LPAG cannot be limited by article 28 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION, which establishes various cases for which correction as an exemption from responsibility is not applicable, among them, the late submission of financial information. That is, it is not possible for a regulatory provision (that is, inferior) to attempt to delimit a provision that arises from the Law and is expressly recognized in the LPAG. Furthermore, it maintains that not accepting exemptions from responsibility violates article II of the TUO DE LA LPAG, which states that the LPAG contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures, and that laws that create and regulate special procedures may not impose conditions less favorable to the administered than those of the LPAG. In that line, the management company states, it should also take into account the provisions of article 247, numeral 247.2 of the TUO DE LA LPAG;
32. In this regard, as stated in the RESOLUTION, according to the Principle of Legality, which is established in article IV, numeral 1.1 of the Preliminary Title of the TUO DE LA LPAG, as a general principle of the administrative procedure; and in article 248, numeral 1, as a principle of the administrative sanctioning procedure, of the referred normative body, administrative authorities must act with respect to the Constitution, the law and the right, within the powers attributed and with the purposes for which they were conferred; and by norm with rank of law the sanctioning power must be attributed to a public entity and the possible sanctions that entity is empowered to apply must be regulated;
33. In line with the foregoing, Article 1, literal a) of the Concorded Single Text of the Organic Law of the SMV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126 and its amendments (hereinafter, ORGANIC LAW), establishes that the SMV is empowered to issue the legal norms that regulate matters of the securities market, products market and the collective funds system; likewise, as provided by literal b) of Article 5 of the ORGANIC LAW, the Board of Directors of the SMV has the attribution to approve the regulations of the securities market, as well as those to which natural and legal persons subject to its supervision must adhere, among which are the collective funds management companies;
34. According to the cited norms, it is observed that by Law the SMV has been conferred the power to regulate the applicable norms to the securities market, products market and the collective funds system, therefore, upon approving the SANCTIONS REGULATION taking into consideration all the novelties introduced in the LPAG and adapting it to its field of action and the assigned competences considering the specialization of the markets and systems it regulates, the Principle of Legality is strictly complied with, which is why the provisions of Article 28 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION do not become illegal and therefore its application is mandatory;
35. In this sense, it should be specified that the SANCTIONS REGULATION, in Article 28, includes a list of facts that by their own characteristics are materially impossible to remedy in the securities market, including the one referring to the late submission of financial information, which does not imply that conditions less favorable to the administered than those set forth in the TUO OF THE LPAG have been established. That is why Article 28 of the cited regulation has the purpose of granting predictability to the subjects involved in the securities market regarding the cases in which the application of the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation regulated in the TUO OF THE LPAG is not possible;
36. Furthermore, the charges imputed to the management company are linked to infractions regarding the timely submission of periodic information that correspond to the infraction type contained in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION. In this sense, in the RESOLUTION it was explained that the constitutive elements of the infraction regarding timely submission refer to the delivery of information and/or documentation within a determined period, therefore, in this specific type of infraction the lack of timely submission could not be remedied with a late submission, since the protected legal interest, which is the transparency of the collective funds system, has been affected. Therefore, it was indicated, it is not possible to apply the exemption from liability contained in Article 257, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO OF THE LPAG to the late submission of documentation or periodic information;
37. Thus it is explained that there are conducts that are not capable of voluntary remediation, because in these cases it is not possible to revert, repair or compensate the damage produced as a consequence of the commission of the infraction. Such is the case of the infraction for not timely submitting financial information by the collective funds management companies, since its late remission causes immediate harm to the transparency of the market2, which is the protected legal interest;
38. Indeed, it is detailed in the RESOLUTION, the obligation on the part of the collective funds management companies to periodically submit their financial information, not only has the purpose that this Superintendence carries out adequate prudential supervision regarding their economic and financial situation, but also that such information be timely made available to current and potential investors and associates, as well as to the market in general, so that they become aware of the patrimonial situation of the companies that operate in the collective funds industry with public money, and in such a way, the confidence of the market in which the collective funds management companies participate is maintained. That is why such information has a deadline for submission, and its untimely submission produces misinformation in the market;
39. In this sense, a late submission could not remedy the infraction of the duty of such companies to timely submit their financial information. Therefore it is considered that in some cases, as happens with the conducts of the present procedure, the remediation of the act or omission constituting the infraction is materially impossible, which is why it is concluded that
[2] According to the principle of transparency, the information made available to investors and the general public must comply with certain conditions, such as veracity, sufficiency, and timeliness, in order to protect investors and promote transparent markets.
the charges imputed subject to analysis are not capable of being remedied3 under the assumption described in Article 257, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO OF THE LPAG, which is reflected in the scope of Article 28 of the SANCTIONS REGULATION;
40. Considering the foregoing, with respect to the fact that spontaneous remedial action should be preferred over initiating the sanctioning procedure with all the costs that this involves, considering that in this case the correction has occurred and the existence of consequences or damages has not been proven, it should be noted that the object of correction in this case is the act constituting the infraction, linked to the imputed act itself (which is not subject to reparation), but not the consequences derived from it, which does not contradict what is indicated in this regard in the "Practical Guide on the administrative sanctioning procedure" (hereinafter, the GUIDE) of the Ministry of Justice and Human Rights (MINJUS), whose second edition was approved by Directoral Resolution No. 002-2017-JUS/DGDOJ, as EL CLAN EAFC states.
41. Thus, in said GUIDE it is specified that the exemption from liability contained in Article 257, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO DE LA LPAG "not only consists of the cessation of the infringing conduct but also, where applicable, the correction implies the reparation of the harmful consequences or effects to the protected legal interest derived from the infringing conduct", that is, it is indicated that to apply said exemption in some cases not only must the infringing conduct cease but also the harmful consequences or effects thereof must be repaired, and what has been highlighted in the RESOLUTION is that the correction of the infringing conduct, in this procedure, is materially impossible and that it is also not possible to reverse, repair or compensate the damage produced as a consequence of the commission of the infraction, since the untimely submission of financial information by the collective fund management companies causes immediate harm to market transparency, which is the protected legal interest;
42. On the other hand, the management company indicates that in the RESOLUTION it is stated with respect to the infraction for having submitted outside the established deadline the interim financial information corresponding to the month of January 2019, which should have been submitted by 4 March 2019 but was submitted on 12 March 2019; that it does not meet the requirement of minimal affectation to the principle of transparency, so a warning sanction should not be applied, but that there is no development supporting such assertion. It also states that in the SANCTION CRITERIA there is no objective definition regarding said minimal affectation;
43. In this regard, it should be noted that in recitals 83 and 84 of the RESOLUTION it is indicated that any non-compliance with the regulations regarding the deadlines established for submitting periodic information affects the transparency of the collective fund system, especially if this non-compliance is prolonged over time, and that the timely submission of the interim financial information of the collective fund system administered by EL CLAN EAFC corresponding to the month of January 2019, which was submitted eight (8) days after the deadline, is important. Furthermore, it is specified that according to said interim information, EL CLAN EAFC administered five (5) groups of associates, which had contributed as capital quota a total of US$ 1 434 920.00. For those reasons
[3] Similar would be the case of administrative infractions for driving vehicles with the presence of alcohol in the blood, which by their very nature could not be corrected since it would require going back in time and not consuming alcohol before driving.
it is sustained and determined that the referred infraction does not meet the requirement of minimal affectation to the principle of transparency, so a warning sanction should not be applied;
44. On the other hand, the management company mentions that the SASP has not considered its request for application of the mitigating circumstance of liability established in Article 257, numeral 2, literal a) of the TUO DE LA LPAG referring to the offender acknowledging its responsibility expressly and in writing once the administrative sanctioning procedure has begun. And that there is a contradiction between what is indicated in recital 26 and recital 90 of the RESOLUTION, in this regard. In that sense, it specifies that in its brief submitted on 24 June 2021 it expressly acknowledged the commission of the infraction, since there was a delay in the submission of interim financial information;
45. With regard to said arguments, it should be specified that in the RESOLUTION it was determined that EL CLAN EAFC did not acknowledge the commission of the infractions subject to charges in a precise, concise, clear, express and unconditional manner and without ambiguities, insofar as in its defenses it presented a set of arguments that sought to dissociate its responsibility; which were rebutted, such as those linked to alleged limitations of the minimum guarantees recognized by the LPAG in favor of the administered, direct violation of the Principles of Legality and Reasonableness, application of spontaneous remedial action, affectation of the right to due procedure among others, detailed in the recitals of the RESOLUTION as part of the evaluation of the defenses, as set forth in recital 90. It should be noted that in recital 26 of the RESOLUTION it was indicated that "EL CLAN EAFC voluntarily declared, expressly and in writing its responsibility over the imputed charges", because that is what the management company indicated in its defenses, which was evaluated in recital 90, so no contradiction is appreciated between recitals 26 and 90 of the RESOLUTION, as EL CLAN EAFC maintains;
46. Next, the RESOLUTION details in this regard that Article 257°, item 2, letter a) of the TUO of the LPAG provides that a mitigating condition of liability for infringements constitutes "if, once an administrative sanctioning procedure has been initiated, the infringer expressly4 and in writing acknowledges their liability"; and that, in turn, the SANCTIONS REGULATION establishes in its Article 26° that "The acknowledgment of liability with respect to an infringement must be made in a precise, concise, clear, express and unconditional manner, and must not contain ambiguous or contradictory expressions; otherwise, it will not be understood as an acknowledgment. If defenses are submitted, despite having made an acknowledgment of liability, it will be understood as a non-acknowledgment, and the authority shall proceed to evaluate the defenses";
47. In this regard, the RESOLUTION argues that, as can be seen from the regulatory text, the acknowledgment of the administrative infringement will constitute a mitigating condition of liability, that is, what must be valued as the act generating mitigation is the declaration produced by the same party, expressly, that is, voluntarily, clearly and precisely acknowledging the commission of the alleged infringement; therefore, from what has been stated by the administered party, the administrative authority, in this case, this Adjunct Superintendency, cannot interpret or infer the administered party's will to acknowledge or admit liability
[4] The Dictionary of the Royal Spanish Academy states that the word expresa (express) means: "Clear, patent, specified".
of the commission of the infringement, if this is not expressly, concisely, unconditionally and without contradictory expressions, in accordance with the above;
48. That is to say, for said acknowledgment to be established as a mitigating factor of responsibility, it must be unequivocal, without ambiguities and without any doubt being able to arise as to what is expressed, that is to say, the administration cannot interpret or extract from what is stated by the administered party that it is a voluntary acknowledgment of the commission of the administrative infringement imputed in accordance with the aforementioned normative text;
49. In this way, the RESOLUTION concludes that, considering the context of the provisions of the TUO of the LPAG and the SANCTIONS REGULATION, as well as the pronouncement of the doctrine in this regard, what was stated by EL CLAN EAFC in its defenses does not express the aforementioned mitigating condition, since a precise, concise and indubitable declaration of an acknowledgment of responsibility for the commission of the administrative infringements in which the administered company has incurred, subject matter of the present sanctioning procedure, related to the lack of timeliness in the submission of information, is not observed. Indeed, EL CLAN EAFC presented arguments as defenses, such as those referred to previously, with the purpose of seeking to archive the present procedure, which, in addition, made the declaration made by the administered party of an alleged acknowledgment imprecise, ambiguous and interpretive;
50. Next, with regard to the arguments put forward by the fund management company that it is a relatively new company in the sector and may be exposed to involuntary material errors, which cannot be considered bad faith in evading responsibilities or omitting relevant information, as well as that it is the only company in the sector that has not previously received any administrative or economic sanction from any administrative entity, it should be noted that such arguments do not contradict the liability of EL CLAN EAFC for the commission of the infringements imputed;
51. Thus, the RESOLUTION detailed that, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, EL CLAN EAFC is aware of the rules that regulate the collective fund system and, in that sense, of the rules that oblige it to submit periodic information to the SMV within the time limits established therein. However, it did not timely submit the financial information that is the subject of this sanctioning procedure. In addition, it was stated that prior to the commission of the infringements imputed, through Circular Nº 047-2019-SMV/10.2, notified on 09 February 2019, the fund management company was informed of the deadlines for submitting the information subject to the charge, specifying the deadlines for submission; notwithstanding this, its lack of diligence led it to commit three infringements by submitting the financial information of the system it manages with up to 8 days of delay with respect to the deadline. It must also be specified that the RESOLUTION clearly indicated that there was no evidence that EL CLAN EAFC acted with intent in the commission of the infringements analyzed;
52. In view of the foregoing, it must be noted that in point 3.4 of Section III of the RESOLUTION, the arguments presented by EL CLAN EAFC both in the defenses and allegations it submitted were analyzed and refuted, with reasons given, and it was therefore concluded that the managing company did not refute the charges brought against it. Likewise, in Section IV of the RESOLUTION, the sanctions to be applied to the managing company for the infringements subject to the present administrative sanctioning procedure were determined in accordance with the evaluation criteria set forth in Article 248°, item 3, of the TUO DE LA LPAG, in Article 7° of Supreme Decree-Law N° 21907 on Collective Fund Companies, as amended by Law N° 276595, in Article 25° of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, as well as in subsection 4.1 and subsection 4.2, item (ii) of the CRITERIOS DE SANCIÓN. In addition, it was analyzed whether the application of the exemptions and mitigating circumstances of liability established in articles 26° and 27° of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES corresponded, in accordance with the provisions of article 257° of the TUO DE LA LPAG. Therefore, and in accordance with what has been analyzed in this resolution, it cannot be concluded that the RESOLUCIÓN has not been duly motivated by the SASP, nor that it suffers from any defect of nullity, as EL CLAN EAFC affirms, according to the arguments presented in its Reconsideration Appeal;
53. For its part, in its arguments of 25 March 2022, EL CLAN EAFC states that through Oficio No 1147-2A22-SMV/10, notified on 18 March 2022, Informe N° 368-2022-SMV/10.3, issued by the Intendencia General de Cumplimiento Prudencial, was made available to it, and that it was also indicated that in accordance with the provisions of article 17, literals b) and c) of the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, it was informed that this appeal could be resolved by the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial as of the fifth business day following this notification;
54. From the foregoing, the administrator concludes that it had a period of no more than five (5) business days to present its position, since as of the fifth business day following the notification of the aforementioned oficio, the procedure could be resolved;
55. In this regard, EL CLAN EAFC specifies that since it concerns the instruction report within the framework of a Sanctioning Procedure, the TUO de la LPAG prescribes, in its article 253, that “the report must be notified to the administered party so that it may formulate its defenses within a period NO LESS than five (5) business days”; therefore, the administrator considers that its right to due procedure in the administrative venue has been violated, since according to the LPAG it cannot be in a period of less than five days, it being understood that it may be five or more;
56. In this regard, it should be noted that what EL CLAN EAFC states does not conform to the reality of the facts, insofar as Oficio No 1147-2022-SMV/10 textually states: “(…) I inform you that the file in question may be resolved by the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial, within a period of no less than five (5) days, counted from the day following this notification (…)”, which is in accordance with what the LPAG establishes, and therefore the administrator's right to due procedure has not been violated. In addition, it must be considered that since the notification of the aforementioned oficio on 18 March 2022, to date, the only arguments presented by the administrator have been those presented on 25 March 2022;
57. It should be mentioned that article 255°, numeral 5 of the TUO de la LPAG, states that the sanctioning body must notify the final instruction report to the administered party so that it may formulate its defenses within a period of no less than five (05) business days. Likewise, the REGLAMENTO DE SANCIONES, in its article 17,
[5] By means of Ley N° 27659, article 7° of Decreto Ley N° 21907 was amended, providing that collective fund management companies that contravene the provisions of the aforementioned decree or the regulatory norms issued by the SMV shall be sanctioned taking into consideration the offender's antecedents, the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, the harm caused and its repercussion on the market.
literal b) establishes that the corresponding Superintendente Adjunto notifies the report of the instructing body to the administered party so that it may formulate its allegations within a period of no less than five (5) days, counted from the day following the aforementioned notification; that is, in both cases it is established that the sanctioning body must grant the administered party at least a period of five (5) business days within which the latter, if it deems it pertinent, may present additional allegations. In this sense, upon the completion of said period, the sanctioning body is free to resolve the respective sanctioning procedure;
58. In this regard, it should be reiterated that Oficio Nº 1147-2022-SMV/10, notified on 18 March 2022, informs EL CLAN EAFC that this file could be resolved by the Superintendencia Adjunta de Supervisión Prudencial, as of the fifth business day following the notification of said oficio; therefore EL CLAN EAFC had at least a period of up to five (05) business days to present its allegations before the pronouncement of the sanctioning body. Consequently, it can be concluded that said minimum period is the same as that established by article 225°, numeral 5 of the TUO de la LPAG, and therefore the administrator's right to due procedure and right of defense have not been affected. It should be reiterated that on 25 March 2022, EL CLAN EAFC presented additional written allegations, which form part of the evaluation of this administrative sanctioning procedure;
59. For the foregoing, it is concluded that the arguments and allegations indicated by EL CLAN EAFC in its reconsideration appeal have not invalidated the grounds of the RESOLUCIÓN, which served as the basis for the imposition of the sanctions applied to said company
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 27, of the Reglamento de Organización y Funciones de la SMV, approved by Decreto Supremo Nº 216-2011-EF;
Artículo 1º.- Declare unfounded the reconsideration appeal presented by El Clan EAFC S.A. against Resolución de Superintendencia Adjunta SMV N° 059-2021-SMV/10, for the reasons set forth in this resolution.
Artículo 2º.- Declare that the administrative avenue has been exhausted.
Article 3.- This resolution must be published on the SMV Institutional Page on the Single Digital Platform of the Peruvian State, in compliance with the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on the dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, early agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and its amendment, and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
Article 4.- Transcribe this resolution to El Clan EAFC S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Alberto Valdivia Ocampo
Deputy Superintendent (e)
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
Signed by: VALDIVIA OCAMPO Alberto FAU Reason:
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 in force as of 19 December 2018”
“Organic Law of the SMV, approved by Decree Law No. 26126”
“Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF”
“The reconsideration appeal filed by El Clan EAFC S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 059-2021-SMV/10 is declared unfounded.”
“Regulation of the System of Collective Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 020-2014-SMV/01”
“Amended by article 3 of SMV Resolution No. 010-2014-SMV/01 of 22 May 2014”
“Policy on the dissemination of regulatory projects... approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added · updated