Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of the SMV
No. 102-2020-SMV/11
Lima, 30 September 2020
Summary: Sanction ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. with a fine of 50 UIT, for incurring in one (01) infraction of a very serious nature classified in subsection 1.4, numeral 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| | |
|---|
| Administrative party | : | ICCGSA INVERSIONES S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2020001619 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision
HAVING SEEN:
The administrative file No. 2020001619 and Report No. 449-2020-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by the General Superintendency of Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
WHEREAS:
- Function and competence of the SASCM
- That, administrative file No. 2020001619 contains the documentation and information referring to an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervisory function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV established by the Single Consolidated Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSM), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), in force at the time of the events and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control according to its competences corresponds to said Deputy Superintendency. Likewise, the SASCM has the powers to issue corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infraction;
- That, regarding this administrative sanctioning procedure, two (02) administrative instances correspond to it in accordance with article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation and the provisions of numeral 26 of article 12 of the ROF-SMV, which establish that the Superintendent of the Securities Market resolves appeals filed against resolutions issued in the first instance by the Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct of the SASCM, with the exception of single-instance procedures;
- Facts, charge and defenses of the administrative party
- Facts
- That, it was evaluated whether ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) would have communicated inaccurate information in the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019 regarding the designation of its audit firm for fiscal year 2019 and the start of audit work;
- Charge
- That, as a result, through Official Letter No. 225-2020-SMV/11.2 of 21 January 2020 (hereinafter, the Charge Letter), a charge was formulated against the Issuer because it would have communicated inaccurate information in the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019, given that it had informed the market, in both material events, that the audit firm designated to audit the annual financial information for fiscal year 2018 as well as the information regarding the start of audit work was in charge of the audit firm Cordero y Asociados Auditores S.A.C. (hereinafter, audit firm CORDERO).
- That, only upon request of the SMV, the Issuer on 14 May 2019 informed the market that its audit firm was not Cordero y Asociados Auditores S.A.C., but rather the audit firm Cordero Carrasco Collazos y Asociados Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada (hereinafter, audit firm CARRASCO). This non-compliance is classified in subsection 1.14, numeral 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation.
- Defenses
- That, through a brief presented on 04 February 2020, the Issuer submitted its corresponding defense, stating that:
- Regarding the material event about the designation of the audit firm CARRASCO, it has at all times complied with issuing the material events that at the time were materially true, that is, it has complied with informing the market of the events as they were developing at the time, including the same day that the modification of the designation of the audit firm was agreed; such information was communicated in a timely manner, with total transparency and certainty to the temporary situation that was being handled.
- Likewise, the Issuer states that the information it provided in the various material events complies with the requirements of the applicable regulations, although subsequently the designation of the audit firm was modified to audit firm CARRASCO, such information was also brought to the attention of the market in a timely manner and in accordance with the requirements determined by the regulation.
- Furthermore, the Issuer adds that according to the applicable regulations, the content of the communication of a material event must be truthful, sufficient and complete, and must be presented in a neutral manner, without judgments or biases that distort the information or that may generate confusion in its scope or situation. According to the meaning given by the Royal Spanish Academy, "truthful" is that which says, uses or professes always the truth.
- The Issuer states that the three material events under analysis were true within their temporary application; at no time could it be considered that the information provided at that time was not true. On the contrary, the act of communicating untrue information and/or not communicating the information that was occurring would result in an attack against the material truth that occurred at the time.
- Likewise, the Issuer adds that although it is noted that the instructing body has considered truthfulness as a total meaning of "truthful" in terms of time, because it qualifies the truthfulness of the material events referred to through a subsequent event that modified the original event that was true at the time; it must be said that it is impossible in the present to know the truth of a future event that may modify the original event as to a different consideration of its nature. Considering the opposite would not only result in arbitrariness but could fall into the absurdity that any modification and/or change of any action carried out today would be labeled as "not truthful" since the "truthful" was the last action.
- In this sense, the Issuer emphasizes that truthfulness was an attribute of the material events issued, since it reported the material truth at the time it communicated them.
- In addition to the above, the Issuer adds that it issued the material events in a sufficient and complete manner, in a neutral manner, without judgments or biases, with the general tenor of the entire group of companies that issue such information.
- Under these considerations, the Issuer emphasizes that at the time of issuing the various material events, it has in no way failed to comply with article 8, numeral 1, of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information; therefore, the imputation made would fail to carry out an extensive interpretation of the punitive rule.
- On the other hand, regarding the presentation of inaccurate information in the material event referring to the start of the audit work of the financial statements for fiscal year 2018, the Issuer states that, although there was a modification regarding the name of the company that performs the corresponding audit, it is necessary to say that it was prompted by the request made by the General Superintendency of Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, IGSC), through Official Letter No. 2455-2019-SMV/11.1 dated 10 May 2019.
- Finally, the Issuer adds that it complied with the provisions of article 12 of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, which deals with the rectification of material events.
- That, through Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the new Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444 (TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures. Likewise, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG indicates the criteria referring to the graduation of the sanction: (a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, (b) The probability of detection of the infraction, (c) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, (d) The economic damage caused, (e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within a period of one (1) year from the final resolution that sanctioned the first infraction, (f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and, (g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the infringer;
- That, the charge formulated and the new criteria referring to the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 1821-2020-SMV/11, the Report was sent to the Issuer, so that it could submit its arguments within five (5) business days from notification. In this regard, it is necessary to indicate that although said Official Letter was validly notified, the Issuer, to date, has not submitted its arguments;
- That, through a request of 25 June 2020, the Issuer requested access to the digital file in order to provide a response to the Report;
- That, through Official Letter No. 1985-2020-SMV/11, the Issuer was informed that its request should be addressed to Ms. Nery Salas at the email COMV@smv.gob.pe or by calling 610-6300, extensions 2530 – 2539 in order to coordinate access to the file by its represented party;
- That, although Official Letter No. 1985-2020-SMV/11 was notified on 30 June 2020, the Issuer to date has not sent any response regarding its request;
- Issues to be determined
- That, in this administrative procedure it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not the Issuer incurred in the infraction indicated in the Charge Letter and Report.
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on the Issuer;
- Analysis
- Applicable Regulations
- That, article 10 of the LMV, which states that: "All information that by provision of this law must be presented to CONASEV, to the stock exchange, to the entities responsible for centralized mechanisms or to investors, must be truthful, sufficient and timely. Once the information is received by said institutions, it must be immediately made available to the public."
- That, article 28 of the LMV establishes that: "The registration of a certain security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of material events, including ongoing negotiations, about itself, the security and the offer made thereof, as well as to disclose such events in a truthful, sufficient and timely manner. (...)".
- That, article 6 of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter Regulation of Material Events) states the following:
"In compliance with the obligations established in this Regulation, the Issuer is responsible for:
6.1. Ensuring that the information it communicates has the capacity to significantly influence, as defined in articles 3 and 4, and that it is truthful, clear, sufficient and timely, as well as that it is not disseminated to a specific group of investors or other groups with an interest in it before it is available to the entire public, through the means established in this Regulation. (...)"
- That, in article 8 of the Regulation of Material Events the following is established:
"In the content of the communication of a material event, the Issuer must observe the following:
8.1. Be truthful, clear, sufficient and complete. It shall be presented in a neutral manner. Without judgments or biases that distort the information or that may generate confusion in its scope or situation. (...)"
- That, the infraction for presentation of inaccurate information in material events is classified in subsection 1.4, numeral 1, of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a very serious infraction: "Present to the SMV, the Stock Exchange, the entity in charge of the Centralized Mechanism, the investor and, in general, any other subject of the securities market, inaccurate or false information; or disseminate such information in the market".
- That, according to article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation, said infraction is punishable by a fine of not less than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT or exclusion of the security from the RPMV;
- That, according to the provisions of recital 2 of this Resolution, this type of non-compliance corresponds to two (02) administrative instances for its evaluation and resolution, the first before the Deputy Superintendent of Conduct Supervision of the SASCM and the second and final instance, before the Superintendent of the Securities Market;
- Evaluation of the case
- That, the communication of truthful information by issuers of securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV) constitutes a fundamental obligation in the transparency of the securities market, so its non-compliance affects the transparency of the market, which is considered a protected legal good;
- That, in relation to the defenses presented by the Issuer, the following must be indicated:
- In the defenses, the Issuer, with the purpose of disproving the charges formulated regarding the material event about the designation of the audit firm CARRASCO, states that the information it provided in the various material events complies with the requirements of the applicable regulations, although subsequently the designation of the audit firm CORDERO was modified to CARRASCO, all the information produced was brought to the attention of the market in a timely manner and in accordance with the requirements determined by the regulation.
- In addition to this, the Issuer attempts to avoid its responsibility by presenting arguments in the sense that the three material events under analysis were true within their temporary application, however, and therein lies the infraction, such material events (of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019) did not correspond or did not reflect what was happening with the designation and start of the audit work, as will be explained below.
- The same can be supported when the Issuer attempts to argue by stating that although it is noted that the instructing body has considered truthfulness as a total meaning of "truthful" in terms of time, because it qualifies the truthfulness of the material events referred to through a subsequent event that modified the original event that was true at the time; it should be noted that the truthfulness of an event is maintained over time, that is, there is a symbiotic relationship between the event and what is reported. In this case, that relationship did not exist, since in reality the audit firm CORDERO was not the one that would perform the audit and neither the one that would start the respective audit work.
- On the other hand, and regarding the argument presented by the Issuer referring to the presentation of inaccurate information in the material event of 27 February 2019, where it reports on the start of the audit work of the financial statements for fiscal year 2018, when it maintains that although there was a modification regarding the name of the company that performs the corresponding audit, it occurred as a consequence of the request by the IGSC, through Official Letter No. 2455-2019-SMV/11.1 dated 10 May 2019, this statement confirms that the information provided to the market on 27 February 2019 was not truthful, a situation that it had to recognize only due to the request made by the aforementioned Superintendency.
- Well, having said the above and objectively, it can be stated that what the Issuer argued in its defenses is not admissible by virtue of the following:
- The content expressed in the material event of 20 December 2018 is not true, where the Issuer communicated that in the board meeting held the same day, the audit firm CORDERO was designated as its audit firm for fiscal year 2018.
- The content expressed in the material event of 27 February 2019 is not true, where the Issuer communicated the start of the audit work for fiscal year 2018 by the audit firm CORDERO.
- The foregoing is corroborated when the Issuer, through writings of 07 May 2019 and 08 May 2019, responded to Official Letter No. 2109-2019-SMV/11.1, attaching, among others:
- Letter No. 301-CCC&A-2018 dated 28 November 2018, through which the audit firm CARRASCO presented to the Issuer its proposal for professional services to perform an audit as of 31 December 2018. That is, it was not CORDERO that had been contracted for the purposes of analyzing the Issuer's financial statements, yet this was reported to the market.
- The Financial Audit Proposal as of 31 December 2018, issued by the audit firm CARRASCO, in which the Issuer was included as part of the group of companies that would be audited by said audit firm.
- The Professional Services Lease Contract of 29 April 2019, signed between the Issuer and the audit firm CARRASCO, for the performance of the financial audit of the individual and consolidated financial statements for fiscal year 2018 of the Issuer and its related companies.
- That is, according to the documentation presented by the Issuer, it is corroborated that the information disseminated to the market through material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019 was not truthful, since, as stated, all information communicated to the market must comply with information quality standards, even more so when it is information linked to the issuer's financial situation.
- Likewise, from the documentation presented by the Issuer on 20 December 2018, it and its related companies accepted the financial audit proposal for fiscal year 2018 by CARRASCO, as evidenced by the Acceptance Confirmation, signed by Ms. Marta Gutiérrez Yupanqui de Salas, Administration and Finance Manager of the Issuer and related companies. Despite the aforementioned, through material event of 27 February 2019, the Issuer communicated that, on said date, the audit firm CORDERO began its audit work, a situation that does not correspond to the facts since it was fully known by the Issuer that CARRASCO would carry out the audit of the annual financial information for fiscal year 2018.
- Therefore, in the present case, there is no future change or modification of the company designation, since from 28 November 2018 the Issuer was aware that the audit firm with which it was negotiating the performance of the audit of the financial statements for fiscal year 2018 and with which it signed the contract for audit services was the audit firm CARRASCO.
- It should be noted then that it is absolutely the responsibility of the Issuer to comply with its obligation to present material events clearly and accurately according to the requirements established in article 8 of the Regulation of Material Events, as it is in the interest of investors to have such information.
- On the other hand, regarding the argument where it is stated that although there was a modification of its audit firm, it was prompted by the request made by the IGSC, through Official Letter No. 2455-2019-SMV/11.1 dated 10 May 2019, it must be emphasized that if the IGSC orders the rectification of the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019, it is because according to the documentation provided by the Issuer itself, the audit firm CARRASCO was the one designated to perform the audit of the annual financial information for 2018 and not the audit firm CORDERO.
- Likewise, regarding the correction of material events, it is stated in literals 2 and 3 of article 12 of the Regulation of Material Events the following:
12.2. The rectification must be made through the communication of a new material event, in which the original material event that is rectified is clearly identified and in what aspects it is done. The rectification does not in any case imply the substitution, withdrawal or elimination of the communication of the original material event.
12.3. The rectification is made without prejudice to the responsibilities that may arise.
-
- In this sense, although the correction of errors or omissions incurred in the communication of material events is allowed, however, the rectification or correction does not imply a substitution of the previously informed event and even less its elimination, which is why issuers are required that the information disclosed to the market must be truthful, sufficient and timely, even if it has been rectified, this is done without prejudice to the responsibility that may arise.
2. Therefore, based on its duty of diligence, the Issuer should have adopted adequate measures to avoid errors in the communication of material events.
1. That, considering the evaluation of this administrative sanctioning procedure and the analysis of the Issuer's arguments, these are not sufficient to rebut the charge formulated; rather, the Issuer's conduct is reproachable insofar as it did not act with the diligence required to avoid incorrectly informing the market about the appointment of its audit firm;
2. That it should be noted that, despite having been notified by Official Letter No. 1821-2020-SMV/11 on 25 September 2019 so that it could communicate its arguments regarding the Report, the Issuer has not submitted them;
3. Determination of the Sanction
4. That, before determining the sanction, it should be noted that, having declared the National State of Emergency in order to address the health crisis caused by Covid-19 in accordance with the provisions of article 28 of Emergency Decree No. 029-2020, as amended by article 12 of Emergency Decree No. 053-2020 and by article 2 of Supreme Decree No. 087-2020-PCM, the deadlines for processing administrative procedures, including administrative sanctioning procedures, were suspended from 21 March 2020 to 10 June 2020, with deadlines resuming on 11 June 2020;
5. That, having determined the commission of the infraction, it is appropriate to determine the sanction for this type of non-compliance by evaluating the criteria contained in article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation referring to: (i) the Issuer's sanction history; (ii) recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from the date the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, the harm caused and its impact on the market; (iii) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; (iv) the economic harm caused and its impact on the market; (v) the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; (vi) the probability of detection of the infraction; (vii) the severity of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest; and (viii) the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and article 348 of the LMV;
6. That, regarding the sanction history, it is established that the offender's history consists of the sanctions imposed by the SMV that became final within the four (4) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction being sanctioned. In application of said criterion, it has been verified that the Issuer has a sanction history, as detailed in the Report;
7. That, regarding recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, it is verified that there is no recidivism on the part of the Issuer, under the terms referred to in literal b) of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation, which provides that recidivism exists for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from the date the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final. In the present case, there is no sanction for the commission of the same infraction;
8. That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that it has been verified that the Issuer communicated inaccurate information in the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019, respectively, insofar as it had informed the market, in both material events, that the audit firm designated to audit the annual financial information for fiscal year 2018, as well as the information regarding the start of the audit work, was the audit firm CORDERO. Likewise, only at the request of the SMV, the Issuer, on 14 May 2019, informed the market that its audit firm was not CORDERO, but the audit firm CARRASCO. Likewise, only at the request of the SMV, the Issuer, on 14 May 2019, informed the market that its audit firm was not CORDERO, but the audit firm CARRASCO;
9. That, regarding the harm caused and impact on the market, it has not been evidenced that the non-compliance produced a quantifiable harm, understood as economic damage caused to one or several investors;
10. That, as regards the benefit illegally obtained, it has not been proven that the infraction incurred by the Issuer generated an illegal benefit;
11. That, in relation to the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that the failure to timely present periodic or occasional information is verified through internal control systems, so it is considered that for this type of non-compliance, such criterion is not relevant and therefore does not modify the sanction proposed;
12. That, in relation to the severity of the harm to the public interest and/or the protected legal interest, it should be noted that the presentation of clear and sufficient information has the purpose of allowing investors to adopt investment decisions on an adequately informed basis. In this way, investors are protected and the asymmetry in access to information is reduced; therefore, the protected legal interest is the transparency of the securities market. In that sense, when the present criterion refers to the severity of the harm, this is directly linked to the impairment of market transparency (the legal interest), which, when transgressed, affects the public interest. In the particular case, the Issuer has violated market transparency by presenting inaccurate information in the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019, insofar as it had informed the market, in both material events, that the audit firm designated to audit the annual financial information for fiscal year 2018, as well as the information regarding the start of the audit work, was the audit firm CORDERO, when in reality it was the audit firm CARRASCO that was designated to audit the annual financial information for fiscal year 2018;
13. That, as regards intentionality in the offender's conduct, it has not been proven that the infraction incurred by the Issuer was intentional;
14. That, having said the foregoing, it is appropriate to mention that this type of infraction is sanctioned in accordance with article 33 of the Sanctions Regulation; said infraction is punishable by a fine of no less than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT or exclusion of the security from the RPMV. In the present case, although the Issuer has a sanction history for infractions of different types, given that it is not a recidivist, there is no intentionality in the offender's conduct and there is no illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, in the present case, based on the principle of reasonableness, the minimum fine corresponding to fifty (50) UIT should be applied for the infraction;
15. That, taking into account that the commission by the Issuer of one (01) infraction of a very serious nature has been determined and based on the analysis of the Sanction Criteria detailed in the Report and in this Resolution, as well as the evaluation carried out by the SASCM, a fine of 50 UIT[1] equivalent to S/ 207,500.00 (Two Hundred Seven Thousand Five Hundred and 00/100 Soles) should be imposed on the Issuer;
In accordance with the provisions of numeral 13 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- To declare that ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a very serious nature typified in subsection 1.4, numeral 1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for having communicated inaccurate information in the material events of 20 December 2018 and 27 February 2019.
- To sanction ICCGSA Inversiones S.A. with a fine of 50 UIT, equivalent to S/ 207,000.00 (Two Hundred Seven Thousand and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 1 of this Resolution.
- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, and may be challenged before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision by filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal, administrative remedies recognized in article 218 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law – Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, within fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a double-instance administrative procedure. If this Resolution is not challenged, the sanction reduction regime may be applied.
- If this Resolution is not subject to challenge, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe), in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of the last paragraph of article 14 of SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- To transcribe this Resolution to ICCGSA Inversiones S.A.; and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision
- Value of the UIT (2018): S/ 4,150 (Supreme Decree No. 380-2017-EF). ↑