Rule · NBK · 30 Sep 2005
Second-tier banks must annually submit a compliance assessment report by 1 July and quarterly submit credit and liquidity risk matrices by the 30th day after each quarter, with stress-testing scenarios and contingency plans due by the 30th day of the following month. Banks must maintain an internal audit service reporting to the board of directors, whose head and employees cannot manage other divisions or sit on the credit committee. Employees must report transactions over five million tenge lacking source documents or paid in cash.
Source: IS PARAGRAPH, 14.09.2012 11:41:55
Resolution of the Board of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations No. 359 of 30 September 2005
On Approval of the Instruction on Requirements for the Presence of Risk Management and Internal Control Systems
in Second-Tier Banks
(with amendments and additions as of 31.01.2011)
The name is set out in the wording of the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 31.01.11 No. 8 (see previous wording)
In order to improve the regulatory legal acts regulating the activities of second-tier banks, the Board of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations (hereinafter - the Agency) RESOLVES:
To approve the attached Instruction on Requirements for the Presence of Risk Management and Internal Control Systems in Second-Tier Banks (hereinafter - the Instruction).
To recognize as having lost force:
1) Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 112 of 5 June 1998 "On Approval of the Rules for the Organization of Internal Audit (Control) in Second-Tier Banks" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan under No. 571, published on 11-17 August 1998 in the publications of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan "Qazaqstan Ulttyq Bankinin Khabarshysy" and "Vestnik Natsionalnogo Banka Kazakhstana" No. 33);
2) Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 434 of 6 December 2003 "On Approval of the Instruction on Requirements for the Presence of Risk Management and Internal Control Systems in Second-Tier Banks" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan under No. 2653, published in the newspaper "Kazakhstanskaya Pravda" of 10 February 2004 No. 27 (27337).
Has lost force in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 31.01.11 No. 8 (see previous wording)
This resolution shall enter into force upon the expiry of fourteen days from the day of its state registration with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan, with the exception of paragraph 5 of the Instruction, which shall enter into force on 1 January 2006, and paragraph 6 of the Instruction, which shall enter into force on 1 January 2007.
To the Department of Strategy and Analysis (Yedenbayev Ye.S.):
1) together with the Legal Department (Baisynov M.B.) take measures for state registration with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan of this resolution;
2) within ten days from the day of state registration with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan, bring this resolution to the attention of the interested subdivisions of the Agency, the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan, second-tier banks and the Association of Legal Entities "Association of Financiers of Kazakhstan".
To the Department of International Relations and Public Relations (Pernebayev T.Sh.) take measures for the publication of this resolution in the mass media of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
To entrust control over the execution of this resolution to the Deputy Chairman Bakhmutova Ye.L.
| Chairman | B. Zhamishev |
Approved
by resolution of the Board
of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan
on Regulation and Supervision
of the Financial Market and
Financial Organizations
No. 359 of 30 September 2005
Instruction
on Requirements for the Presence of Risk Management and
Internal Control Systems in Second-Tier Banks
This Instruction has been developed in accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan "On Banks and Banking Activity in the Republic of Kazakhstan" and establishes requirements, mandatory for compliance by second-tier banks, for the presence of risk management and internal control systems.
Chapter 1. General Provisions
Paragraph 1 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see previous wording)
The purpose of this Instruction is to determine the requirements for the formation in banks of an adequate risk management and internal control system, providing for the application by banks of risk control methods that ensure effective identification, assessment and limitation of the bank's risks, taking into account the type and volume of operations performed by them.
Excluded in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 29.12.09 No. 263 (see previous wording)
Paragraph 3 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 29.12.08 No. 235 (see previous wording); set out in the wording of the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 29.12.09 No. 263 (see previous wording)
annually, no later than 1 July of the year following the reporting year, submit to the state body exercising regulation and supervision of the financial market and financial organizations (hereinafter - the authorized body) a report prepared by them on the assessment of compliance with the requirements of this Instruction;
quarterly, no later than the 30th day of the month following the reporting quarter, submit to the authorized body:
credit risk monitoring, credit risk assessment, credit risk control matrices in accordance with Annex 10 to this Instruction;
liquidity risk monitoring, liquidity risk assessment, liquidity risk control matrices in accordance with Annex 11 to this Instruction.
See Letter of the Deputy Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations No. 04-01-14/822/12316-I of 30 June 2010 "On Entry into Force".
The Instruction has been supplemented with paragraph 3-1 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 02.11.09 No. 229; amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 29.12.09 No. 263 (see previous wording)
3-1. Scenarios, stress-testing results, as well as contingency action plans shall be submitted to the authorized body no later than the 30th day of the month following the reporting month.
The list of requirements for the presence of risk management and internal control systems is defined in Annexes 1 - 6 to this Instruction.
Excluded in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 31.01.11 No. 8 (see previous wording)
Excluded in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 31.01.11 No. 8 (see previous wording)
The Instruction has been supplemented with paragraph 6-1 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (put into effect from 1 January 2007); set out in the wording of the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 29.12.09 No. 263 (applies to relations arising from 1 January 2009) (see previous wording)
6-1. The report on the fulfillment of the criteria of the requirements established by this Instruction shall be submitted to the authorized body in the form according to Annex 9 to this Instruction. The assessment of compliance with the requirements of the Instruction is determined according to Annex 9 to this Instruction.
See Letter of the Deputy Chairman of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations No. 04-01-14/822/12316-I of 30 June 2010 "On Entry into Force".
1) back office - a subdivision of the bank whose main function is the registration of completed operations in auxiliary accounting on the basis of primary documents received from the front office;
2) back-testing - methods of verifying the effectiveness of risk measurement procedures using historical data on the bank's operations and comparing the calculated results with the current (actual) results from the performance of these operations;
3) currency risk - the risk of expenses (losses) associated with changes in foreign currency exchange rates in the course of the bank's activities. The danger of expenses (losses) arises from the revaluation of the bank's positions in currencies in value terms;
4) gap - methods of measuring the bank's interest rate risk and liquidity risk based on comparing the volume of the bank's assets and liabilities subject to changes in remuneration rates or subject to repayment within certain periods;
The paragraph has been supplemented with subparagraphs 4-1 - 4-3 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234
4-1) cash/cash position gap - the magnitude of the gap between the inflow and outflow of the bank's cash;
4-2) compliance controller - an employee of the bank whose exclusive competence includes responsibility for coordinating the activities of the compliance service and exercising control over the implementation of the compliance risk management policy by compliance participants;
4-3) compliance risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to the bank's non-compliance with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, including regulatory legal acts of the authorized body, as well as the bank's internal rules and procedures;
Subparagraph 5 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see previous wording)
5) credit risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to the client's violation of the initial terms of the agreement (contract) regarding the fulfillment of monetary obligations assumed by him during banking loan, leasing, factoring, forfaiting operations, operations on the issuance of bank guarantees and other operations;
Subparagraph 6 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 02.11.09 No. 229 (see previous wording); resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 31.01.11 No. 8 (see previous wording)
6) operational risk - the risk of losses as a result of deficiencies or errors in the course of internal processes, committed by employees, the functioning of information systems and technologies, as well as due to external events. Operational risk includes the following risks:
risks associated with an uncertain, inadequate organizational structure of the bank, including the distribution of responsibility, the structure of subordination and management;
risk caused by inadequate strategies, policies and/or standards in the field of information technology, deficiencies in the use of software;
risks associated with inadequate information or its inappropriate use;
risks associated with inappropriate personnel management and/or unqualified staff of the bank;
risks associated with inadequate construction of business processes or weak control over compliance with internal rules;
risk caused by unforeseen or uncontrollable factors of external influence on the bank's operations;
risk associated with changes in legislation, or risk associated with the presence of deficiencies or errors in internal documents/rules regulating the conduct of the bank's activities;
risk associated with incorrect actions of the bank's management and personnel, which may negatively affect the bank's activities, fraud:
7) legal risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to the bank's violation of the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan or the inconsistency of the bank's practice with its internal documents, and in relations with non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan - the legislation of other states;
8) interest rate risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to an unfavorable change in remuneration rates, including:
the risk of expenses (losses) due to the mismatch of the terms of return and repayment of placed assets and attracted liabilities of the bank (at fixed remuneration rates);
the risk of expenses (losses) due to the bank's application of different types of rates (floating or fixed) on the bank's assets, on the one hand, and liabilities, on the other;
basis risk associated with the application of various methods of accrual and adjustment of received and paid remuneration for a number of instruments which, other things being equal, have similar price characteristics;
9) reputational risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to negative public opinion or a decrease in confidence in the bank;
10) liquidity risk - the risk associated with the possible failure or untimely fulfillment by the bank of its obligations. When managing liquidity risk, the bank's current liquidity is controlled, as well as the terms of placed and attracted funds, income and expenses associated with the receipt (payment) of remuneration are compared;
11) banking activity risk - the risk of losses arising from the bank's performance of its operations;
Subparagraph 12 is set out in the wording of the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see previous wording)
12) market risk - the risk of expenses (losses) associated with unfavorable changes in market parameters (exchange rate, remuneration rate, value of financial instruments);
13) risk management system - a process including four main elements: risk assessment, risk measurement, risk control and risk monitoring;
14) internal control system - a set of internal control procedures and policies ensuring the bank's implementation of long-term profitability goals and maintenance of a reliable system of financial and management reporting, contributing to compliance with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and regulatory legal acts of the authorized body, the bank's policy, internal rules and procedures, reducing the risk of losses or damage to the bank's reputation;
15) internal audit service - a subdivision of the bank carrying out objective assessment and consulting activities for the purpose of improving the bank's activities, ensuring the organization and implementation of internal audit in the bank. Internal audit in the bank contributes to the achievement of certain goals by providing recommendations for improving risk assessment, risk management and internal control processes;
The paragraph has been supplemented with subparagraphs 15-1 and 15-2 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234
15-1) compliance service - an internal service of the bank consisting of a compliance controller and compliance participants, whose exclusive competence includes the exercise of internal control over the compliance of the bank's activities with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, including regulatory legal acts of the authorized body, as well as the bank's internal rules and procedures (compliance risk management);
15-2) aggregate limit - the maximum permissible amount of losses during operations;
16) country (transfer) risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to the insolvency or unwillingness of a foreign state or a resident of a foreign state to meet obligations to the bank for reasons not related to financial risks;
17) stress testing - methods of measuring the potential impact on the bank's financial position of exceptional but possible events that may affect the bank's activities;
The paragraph has been supplemented with subparagraphs 17-1 and 17-2 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234
17-1) trading operations - the bank's operations for the acquisition/sale of securities in its own interests and at its own expense;
17-2) compliance participants - subdivisions and/or employees of the bank whose exclusive competence includes the performance of functions for managing compliance risk;
18) front office - a subdivision of the bank whose main function is the conclusion of transactions with the bank's clients;
19) price risk - the risk of expenses (losses) due to changes in the value of portfolios of financial instruments, arising in the event of changes in financial market conditions affecting the market value of financial instruments.
Chapter 2.
Requirements for the Presence of Risk Management Systems
Paragraph 8 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see previous wording)
The presence of the bank's risk management system provides for compliance with the requirements established by this Instruction for corporate governance, the presence of a practice of conducting banking loan operations, the practice of conducting operations with financial instruments, the practice of asset and liability management, the functioning of information systems and management information systems.
The organization of the risk management system is ensured by the bank's compliance with the requirements specified in Annex 1 to this Instruction.
Paragraph 10 has been amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see previous wording)
Within the framework of risk management systems, the presence of a practice of conducting banking loan operations, including the provision of mortgage housing loans issued to individuals and mortgage loans secured by real estate or provided for the purpose of real estate construction, is ensured by the bank's compliance with the requirements specified in Annexes 3 - 4 to this Instruction.
The Instruction has been supplemented with paragraph 10-1 in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.03.09 No. 64; amended in accordance with the resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 02.11.09 No. 229 (see previous wording)
10-1. Liquidity risk management provides for the presence in banks of an adequate structure that would sufficiently take into account liquidity risks, both on an individual and consolidated basis, including a contingency plan containing clear strategies for resolving the problem of liquidity shortage in emergency situations, as well as maintaining an adequate level of liquidity.
Within the framework of risk management systems, the presence of a practice of liquidity risk management is ensured by the bank's compliance with the requirements specified in Annex 4-1 to this Instruction.
Asset and liability management provides for the implementation of measures aimed at bringing the structure of the bank's assets and liabilities in line with its strategic goals, including taking into account the risks associated with them, as well as maintaining the bank's margin at the necessary level.
Within the framework of risk management systems, the presence of a practice of conducting operations with financial instruments is ensured by the bank's compliance with the requirements specified in Annex 5 to this Instruction.
Within the framework of risk management systems, the presence of support for the bank's operational activities, the functioning of information systems and management information systems is permitted if the bank complies with the requirements specified in Annex 6 to this Instruction.
Chapter 3.
Requirements for the Presence of an Internal Control System
The board of directors and the bank's management ensure the presence of an adequate internal control system and create conditions for the bank's employees to perform their duties in the field of internal control.
The internal control system in the bank is created to achieve the following goals:
1) operational and financial efficiency of the bank's activities, which implies verification of the effectiveness and profitability of managing the bank's assets and determining the probability of losses;
2) reliability, completeness and timeliness of financial and management information. This goal implies verification of the preparation of reliable and high-quality financial statements and other financial documents used by the bank in decision-making;
3) compliance with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, which implies verification of the bank's compliance with legislation, including regulatory legal acts of the authorized body, as well as the requirements of documents defining the bank's internal policy and procedures.
1) management control;
2) identification and assessment of risk;
3) exercise of control and separation of powers;
4) information and interaction;
5) monitoring and correction of deficiencies.
The proper functioning of these components is an important condition for the effective operation of the bank, the operation of information systems and compliance with prudential standards and other norms and limits of the bank established by the authorized body.
1) formation of the internal control system (taking into account the results of the effectiveness assessment) by incorporating procedures into the bank's internal regulations;
2) implementation of the bank's internal regulations in work;
3) conducting an assessment of the effectiveness of the internal control system.
1) quarterly verification of the process of the bank's achievement of its goals and objectives, through the submission to the board of directors and management of reports on the current results of the bank's financial activities, with the attachment of planned financial performance indicators;
2) monthly verification by the heads of subdivisions of standard detailed reports on the results of the subdivision's activities, including an indication of deviations from planned indicators and the reasons for non-fulfillment of planned indicators;
3) verification for the purpose of control over the restriction of access to tangible assets, including cash and securities, control of dual custodial storage, periodic inventory;
4) verification of compliance with established risk limits and implementation of measures to eliminate identified non-compliances;
5) establishment by the bank's management of requirements for the list of operations requiring mandatory authorization;
6) verification of the terms of operations and the results of applying risk management models related to the bank's activities;
7) verification of the timeliness, correctness, completeness and accuracy of recording in accounting and reporting of banking and other operations carried out as provided for by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
8) prevention of legalization (laundering) of income obtained by illegal means and financing of terrorism.
The purpose of internal audit is to assess the adequacy and<|place_holder_mm_span_0442|> effectiveness of internal control and risk management systems in all aspects of the bank's activities, to provide timely and reliable information on the state of fulfillment by the bank's divisions of their assigned functions and tasks, as well as to provide effective and efficient recommendations for improving work.
The internal audit service is created for the purpose of solving the tasks arising in the exercise by the board of directors of its functions to ensure the presence and functioning of an adequate internal control system by providing an objective assessment of the state of the internal control system and recommendations for their improvement.
The internal audit service in its activities is guided by the bank's charter, the provisions on the organization of the internal control system and the bank's internal audit service, as well as other internal documents regulating the bank's activities, and the requirements of this Instruction.
Members of the internal audit service are appointed by the bank's board of directors.
The internal audit service appoints audits of the activities of any division or official of the bank. The internal audit service regularly reports to the board of directors.
The internal audit service draws up an internal audit plan and an internal audit program, approved by the bank's board of directors.
Clause 24 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
functioning of the internal control system;
preparation of reports for the board of directors on the activities of the internal audit service;
risk areas in the bank's operations that must be subjected to internal and external audits in the current year;
reliability and accuracy of financial information provided to management and external users;
any significant deficiencies in accounting or internal audit identified by external or internal auditors.
1) verification and assessment of the effectiveness of the internal control system;
2) verification of the completeness of application and effectiveness of the methodology for assessing banking risks and banking risk management procedures (methodologies, programs, rules, procedures and procedures for carrying out banking operations and transactions, risk management);
3) verification of the effectiveness of the functioning of automated information systems, including control of the integrity of databases and their protection from unauthorized access, the availability of contingency action plans;
4) verification of the reliability, completeness, objectivity and timeliness of accounting and reporting, as well as the reliability and timeliness of collection and submission of information and reporting;
5) verification of the reliability, completeness, objectivity and timeliness of submission of other information in accordance with the regulatory legal acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
6) verification of the applied methods (methods) of ensuring the safety of the bank's property;
7) assessment of the economic feasibility and effectiveness of operations carried out by the bank;
8) Excluded in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
9) verification of internal control processes and procedures;
10) verification of systems created for the purpose of complying with the requirements of regulatory legal acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
11) assessment of the work of the bank's personnel management service;
12) exercise of control over the effectiveness of measures taken by the bank's divisions and bodies based on the results of inspections of the bank's divisions that ensure a reduction in the level of identified risks, or documenting the adoption by the management of the division and (or) management bodies of a decision on the acceptability of the identified risks for the bank;
13) other issues provided for by the bank's internal documents.
The internal audit service carries out the preliminary selection of a candidate for external auditor independently or as part of a bank working group. The proposal on the choice of external auditor is submitted for consideration to the bank's Board of Directors.
The head and employees of the internal audit service cannot simultaneously manage (supervise) other divisions of the bank, or be members of the credit committee and other bodies of the bank.
The head and employees of the internal audit service have higher education, possess knowledge of civil and banking legislation, possess professional competence (knowledge of regulatory legal acts and at least one year of work experience (experience) in the field of provision and regulation of financial services), as well as no existing unexpunged or unremoved criminal record in accordance with the procedure established by law for crimes committed in the sphere of economic activity, for corruption and other crimes against the interests of public service and public administration.
Clause 29 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
In the process of performing their official duties, bank employees comply with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan regarding the prevention of legalization (laundering) of income obtained by illegal means and financing of terrorism.
Bank employees inform the internal audit service about the following transactions (operations):
1) any receipts (in the form of a deposit, loan, acquisition of the bank's securities) to the bank of more than five million tenge without documents confirming their sources of origin;
2) any transactions for an amount of more than five million tenge with payment in cash form;
3) speculative operations with corporate securities;
4) re-registration or assignment of rights of claim to a financial instrument without providing supporting documents;
5) other operations or transactions that raise doubts about their legality.
Chapter 4. Final provisions
Appendix 1 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 02.11.09 No. 229 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 29.12.09 No. 263 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old version)
Appendix 1
to the Instruction on requirements for the
presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier
banks
Requirements for the organization of the risk management system
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The Board of Directors has formulated a long-term corporate strategy | The Board of Directors has approved the bank's activity strategy; the bank's corporate strategy defines short-term and long-term objectives of the bank's activity. The timeframes for short-term and long-term activity objectives are determined by banks independently; the bank's short-term and long-term strategies are drawn up and continuously improved in order to exclude factors that previously had a negative impact on the bank's activity |
| The Board of Directors has established a policy for managing the bank's activity, the requirements of which ensure the effectiveness of corporate governance | The Board of Directors has approved a policy for resolving conflicts of interest in the bank; the Board of Directors approves a policy for conducting monitoring of the bank's operations related to risks (credit risk, interest rate risk, liquidity loss risk, currency risk) and carried out by the bank's Management Board, in order to exclude the possibility of carrying out operations that contradict the bank's strategy, policies and procedures or that create preferential conditions for persons connected with the bank by special relations; the Board of Directors approves a policy for monitoring the bank's operations with persons connected with the bank by special relations |
| The Board of Directors monitors the bank's activity through committees established under the Board of Directors | The Internal Audit Service exercises control over compliance with the bank's internal rules and procedures, implementation of internal and external auditors' reports, measures of influence, sanctions and other requirements of the authorized body; the Credit Committee implements the internal credit policy established in accordance with the bank's internal documents, exercises control over the quality of the loan portfolio and gives preliminary permission for the issuance of loans exceeding five percent of the bank's own capital; the Asset and Liability Management Committee establishes and approves rules and procedures for borrowing, carrying out operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments, investing and issuing bank guarantees, and also determines benchmarks for asset diversification, profitability, liquidity and capital adequacy |
| The Board of Directors periodically receives the necessary information allowing it to track the bank's financial condition, conducts analysis and assessment of the bank's activity in the reporting period | The Board of Directors monthly analyzes the following reports: the consolidated balance sheet and the report on the bank's income and expenses in comparison with the same period of the previous year and the planned activity indicators; a report on new loans received by persons connected with the bank by special relations. The Board of Directors quarterly analyzes the following reports: a brief analysis of the bank's position on interest rate risk; a brief analysis of the bank's exposure to the risk of fluctuations in foreign exchange rates; a brief analysis of the bank's current and projected needs for own capital; the Board of Directors conducts control with clarification of the reasons for non-fulfillment of measures of influence and other requirements of the authorized body, including the action plan for eliminating deficiencies in the bank's activity; reports on investments: with a grouping of financial instruments by their types and indicating the book value, market value, yield and total amount of purchases and sales; reports on the dynamics of classified loans and the volumes of provisions formed against them. |
| The Board of Directors annually analyzes possible conflicts of interest in the functional duties of the bank's executive officers | The Board of Directors analyzes annual reports on the functional duties of the bank's executive officers; the Board of Directors compares the lending conditions of members of the Board of Directors, executive officers, persons who are a major participant of the bank and other persons connected with the bank by special relations with the servicing of other borrowers of the bank, including for the purpose of verifying the fact of granting preferential conditions; the Board of Directors monthly certifies the register of persons connected with the bank by special relations; |
| The Board of Directors annually analyzes the activity of the Management Board during the reporting year | The Board of Directors annually analyzes the activity of the Management Board for the achievement by the bank of the objectives planned for the current financial year; the Board of Directors, within its powers, may apply measures to members of the bank's Management Board in the event of a discrepancy between the results of the bank's activity and the target indicators of the current year |
| The Management Board establishes procedures for forming the organizational and functional structure of the bank's management; the organizational structure (organizational structure chart) does not necessarily include every employee of the bank, but it includes all executive officers of the bank | The chart of the bank's organizational and functional structure, among other things, regulates: the powers and duties of the bank's unit or person for risk management responsible for independent assessment and analysis of the main risks related to the operations carried out by the bank; the structure of the bank's management bodies corresponding to their functional duties; the job duties and powers of each executive officer of the bank, including those containing qualification requirements for executive officers and employees directly involved in risk management, including requirements for the availability of education and work experience; the procedure for assessing the activity of an executive officer of the bank (except for members of the Management Board) during the reporting year, including the application of measures or bringing to liability for the bank's failure to fulfill the bank's target activity indicators |
| The Board of Directors approves the procedure for drawing up the annual budget/financial plan for the short-term period and strategic planning for the long-term period, taking into account the future economic conditions of the Republic of Kazakhstan, foreign countries whose residents are clients of the bank, and the situation of world financial and commodity markets | The drawing up of annual budgets and strategic plans is carried out by the Management Board taking into account the current and future competitive, economic environment and regulatory legal framework, the additionally required amount of the bank's capital and access to new long-term sources of financing of the bank's capital |
| The Management Board identifies and assesses potential and possible risks related to the operations carried out by the bank, applies regulated risk management procedures | The bank's unit performing risk management functions uses the methodology for assessing the adequacy of own capital, profitability and liquidity in the event of negative dynamics in world commodity and financial markets; the Management Board identifies and analyzes internal and external economic factors representing potential and possible risk, assesses the degree of their influence on the bank's financial indicators; in terms of the aggregate limits approved by the Board of Directors, the Management Board determines limits on the permissible amount of risks separately by types of banking operations, takes effective measures to control the bank's compliance with the specified limits |
| The Management Board exercises control over the bank's possible and potential risks | The Management Board controls compliance with aggregate limits by types of risks, on the basis of their monthly calculation; the Management Board controls compliance by the bank's units with policies in managing possible and potential risks, monitors compliance by the bank's units with the amounts of risks within the limits established for them |
| The bank has a policy for diversification (distribution) of banking risks | The Management Board applies the policy of distributing risks by types of operations carried out by it, that is, forming the structure and volume of banking operations taking into account the risk associated with them in order to maintain the necessary level of own capital adequacy and solvency, and controls their implementation by the bank's responsible units; the bank has an organizational, functional and operational structure that ensures the implementation of the diversification policy |
| The organizational and functional structure of the bank and the procedures for making decisions on the bank's financial activity are regulated by the bank's internal policy | The risk management policy provides for: provisions regulating the powers and functional duties of the bank's executive officers, including those providing for ensuring double control of the correctness of banking operations and control of the risk associated with them; the Internal Audit Service conducts checks of executive officers to identify concentration of powers and functions for managing the bank's activity with them. The policies on risk management and internal control determine the powers and functional duties for risk management of members of the Board of Directors, the Management Board and responsible employees of the bank |
| The bank has a management accounting and reporting system allowing the Management Board and the Board of Directors to periodically receive information on the bank's current financial activity and the amounts of risks assumed by the bank | The formats of information on the bank's current financial condition and the risks assumed by it are standardized in the form of specific forms of management reporting, which, among other things, identify and measure credit, interest rate risks, liquidity loss risk, currency risks, country (transfer) risks, and also determine the degree of exposure to risks and their maintenance within the established limits. The list of management information submitted to the bank's Board of Directors and Management Board is sufficient for the proper performance by the bank's Board of Directors and Management Board of their own functional duties on risk management |
| The bank's internal risk management policy, among other things, establishes qualification requirements for employees whose functions provide for the performance of risk management procedures | The personnel of the risk management unit comply with the qualification requirements, including those providing for the availability of the relevant qualification for performing functional duties on risk management. The functional duties of the bank's personnel of the risk management unit and the Internal Audit Service correspond to the operations carried out by them |
| The Management Board and heads of the bank's units responsible for carrying out banking operations conduct monthly monitoring of the bank's income (expenses) in order to keep them within the limits approved by the bank's Board of Directors | The internal policies establish the bank's unit that monthly tracks the bank's income (expenses), including in dynamics, by breakdown, by types of banking services, territorial and functional units of the bank, and also quarterly on a consolidated basis. The internal policies provide for the powers of the bank's units to manage income (expenses) related to the unit's activity within the aggregate limits established by the Board of Directors. The units assess (accrue) the bank's expected income taking into account the risk assumed |
| The Management Board monitors the distribution of financial resources among the bank's units responsible for carrying out banking operations, in compliance with the permissible limits established by the bank's Board of Directors, including in relation to risk and profitability, risk and the bank's own capital | The Management Board without fail conducts an analysis of the dynamics of own capital and potential risks related to the planned provision of new banking services. The Management Board, within the aggregate risk limits established by the Board of Directors, determines risk limits for each of the bank's units carrying out financial operations |
| The bank's internal policies provide for the establishment of the cost of the bank's services in direct dependence on the expenses related to their provision, income/expense plans, the situation of economic conditions, the financial market and risks | The Management Board has approved a policy for establishing remuneration rates on attracted deposits and issued loans. The policy for establishing remuneration rates, among other things, regulates the procedure for establishing remuneration rates |
| The risk management unit monitors the bank's financial indicators and assumed risks on a consolidated basis, that is, taking into account the activity of the bank's subsidiary organizations | The risk management policies approved by the Board of Directors, among other things, determine the procedures for monitoring the bank's financial indicators and assumed risks on a consolidated basis. The Board of Directors confirms risk limits for subsidiary organizations within the aggregate risk limits of the bank determined by the Board of Directors |
| The risk management unit conducts quarterly monitoring of the amounts of risks of the bank's subsidiary organizations and assesses the correctness and reliability of risk measurement by subsidiary organizations | The risk management unit monitors the financial activity of subsidiary organizations and bank holdings; the risk management unit has the powers to check operations carried out by the bank with bank holdings; the Board of Directors establishes requirements for the terms of transactions carried out with bank holdings; the Management Board regularly analyzes information on the risks to which persons that are a bank holding are exposed, as well as the risks assumed by bank holdings that may affect the bank's activity |
| The Management Board conducts regular monitoring of the bank's compliance with contractual relations, regulatory legal acts of the authorized body, requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, internal policies for conducting banking operations | The bank's units assess the compliance of their activity with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the bank's internal rules and documents. The Internal Audit Service assesses the possibility of the emergence of additional risks of the bank related to compliance with regulatory legal acts regulating banking activity when introducing new types of banking services |
| The Management Board submits financial and management reporting on the bank's activity to the bank's Board of Directors and shareholders | The Board of Directors has approved the forms and deadlines for submission by the Management Board to the bank's Board of Directors and shareholders of financial and management reporting ensuring the possibility of assessing the bank's financial indicators. The Board of Directors analyzes the conclusions of external auditors on improving internal control and risk management |
| The Management Board improves the bank's accounting and reporting system on the basis of the conclusions of independent international audit organizations | The bank's policies on accounting and reporting, among other things, provide for the following issues to be checked during the bank's audit: the correctness of processing daily balance sheets; compliance of the bank's accounting policy with international financial reporting standards; the presence of facts of unjustified accounting manipulation of financial statements; the correctness of forming provisions (reserves) for classified assets and contingent liabilities; compliance of accounting and reporting methods with the requirements established in the bank's accounting policy; the completeness and correctness of the bank's disclosure in the annual report of the structure and amount of risks of the bank and its subsidiary organizations |
| The Management Board quarterly conducts an analysis of critical indicators of the economic conditions of the bank's activity with subsequent submission of the corresponding report to the Board of Directors | The risk management unit forecasts the impact on own capital adequacy, profitability and liquidity of the following factors: a fall in oil prices; a downgrade of the sovereign debt rating of the Republic of Kazakhstan by one notch over three months and by two notches over one year; foreign banks raised rates and reduced the terms on loans issued to banks of the Republic of Kazakhstan; devaluation of the tenge. |
| The Management Board has developed measures to maintain own capital adequacy and liquidity upon the occurrence of any of the factors | The risk management unit conducts regular analysis of: the bank's balance sheet and off-balance sheet reports, as well as income and expense accounts sensitive to changes in economic conditions; balance sheet and off-balance sheet reports, as well as income and expense accounts of subsidiary organizations and persons that are a bank holding; an increase in rates and a reduction in the repayment terms of syndicated loans and other external loans received by the bank; a possible reduction in the volume of deposits of legal entities and individuals; a decrease in liquidity, changes in prices for financial instruments; the level of non-repayment of loans granted to subjects of the oil and gas sector and its infrastructure; the level of non-repayment of loans granted in foreign currency |
| The bank has a credit scoring model for consumer loans | Automation of the process of registering and processing applications for obtaining a consumer loan; availability of a historical database on consumer loans for the last five years; availability of an internal policy determining the conditions for granting, the approval procedure and monitoring of consumer loans; availability of an internal automated mathematical or statistical model for scoring assessment of borrowers and a rating system; annual verification of the quality of the applied scoring models |
| The bank has an internal policy determining the conditions for granting, the approval procedure and monitoring of consumer loans, approved by the bank's Board of Directors | The policy determines the procedure for: assessing the borrower's creditworthiness using credit scoring based on qualitative and quantitative characteristics, including: the presence of a permanent and sufficient income of the borrower; place of work and position; duration of work in the current profession; presence of immovable property acceptable as collateral; presence of loan debt, including to other banks; payment discipline on bank loans; presence of a credit history; establishing the borrower's internal credit rating; determining the reliability of the data submitted by the borrower; monitoring and classification of consumer loans; forming provisions for consumer loans |
| The Management Board develops, and the Board of Directors approves, an internal document containing a contingency plan for unforeseen circumstances that may affect the financial stability of the bank and its subsidiaries, providing, among other things, measures to: maintain the bank's ability to fulfill its obligations to depositors and creditors, in terms of timely ensuring the possibility of making settlements in accordance with assumed obligations; prevent and avert possible disruption of the bank's day-to-day functioning; reduce the consequences of disruption of the bank's day-to-day functioning (including the amount of financial losses and loss of business reputation); preserve the level of bank management that allows for conditions for making adequate decisions, their timely and full implementation. | When developing the contingency plan, the bank takes into account the following factors: the types and nature of possible unforeseen circumstances, the related risks that could negatively affect the bank's day-to-day functioning and its ability to fulfill its assumed obligations, as well as a quantitative assessment of the amount of financial losses; the need for resources to implement the contingency plan, that is, planning of measures representing the process of developing and implementing crisis management procedures in the bank (before the onset of crisis conditions); the sufficiency of the bank's assets in emergency circumstances; the amount of funds that, according to the bank's calculations, can be extracted from these sources, as well as the availability of time required to mobilize funds from the sources; the effectiveness of risk management procedures in the bank, which is assessed by the presence of risk identification procedures, determination of their quantitative indicators and possible consequences, implementation of measures to prevent or minimize related losses; indicators of recovery of the bank's internal processes, including such as: recovery time, acceptable amount of financial costs, acceptable amount of asset loss. The contingency plan contains preventive and operational measures aimed at reducing the impact of unforeseen circumstances on the financial stability of the bank and on its activities in general, as well as a responsibility matrix. Preventive measures are included in the contingency plan in order to prevent the occurrence of circumstances that may manifest as a result of stressful situations, and are aimed at: establishing the bank's internal policies and procedures aimed at ensuring the continuity of the bank's activities; determining the procedure for implementing the contingency plan and making a decision to transfer the bank to emergency mode; determining the strategy for identifying and monitoring the risks to which the bank is exposed; determining timely and effective measures in case of an increase in the bank's exposure to risks (by type of risk); identifying expected stress scenarios that take into |
| account possible events or future changes in economic conditions that could lead to significant losses and insufficient liquidity arising, among other things, from on-balance-sheet and off-balance-sheet claims; determining hedging instruments or other methods aimed at reducing existing risks to which the bank is exposed; other measures provided for by the bank's internal documents. For each type of risk, the bank's preventive measures include identifying the following facts: 1) credit risk: the existence of a trend of gradual deterioration in the quality of the loan portfolio over three consecutive months, including an increase in the volume of issued credits (loans) for which the overdue period on principal and (or) interest remuneration exceeds 90 (ninety) days by three or more percent per month over three consecutive months; the existence of a trend of gradual increase in the share of non-performing loans by three or more percent per month over three consecutive months; a systematic decrease in the ratio of the volume of provisions to the amount of loans classified as doubtful of the 5th (fifth) category and bad loans, and provisions for homogeneous loans by 0.05 percentage points; an increase in the ratio of the volume of issued loans for construction and acquisition of real estate to the loan portfolio by three or more percent per month over three consecutive months; the existence of a trend of increasing risk concentration in the portfolio (by sectors of the economy, by one geographic region, by a group of borrowers and by one borrower (counterparty)); insufficiency of collateral or guarantee for a loan by more than thirty percent of the loan (guarantee) value and their realizability under various stress scenarios; and other factors provided for by the bank's internal documents; 2) market risk: the existence of a trend of gradual deterioration in the quality of the investment securities portfolio under the influence of factors related to the condition of their issuers and general fluctuations in market prices for financial instruments by more than two percent per month over three consecutive months; an increase in the gap between assets and liabilities sensitive to interest rates (interest rate gap analysis); an increase in the ratio of liabilities sensitive to changes in interest rates to equity (interest position); an increase in the mismatch between the sizes of assets and liabilities in foreign currency; negative trends or increased risk for a group of financial instruments (for example, an increasing volume of overdue payments on debt securities, interbank loans); excess of the market risk indicator over the maximum permissible level; and other factors provided for by the bank's internal documents; 3) liquidity risk: a systematic decrease over three consecutive months in capital adequacy ratios by 0.03 or more points; a systematic decrease over three consecutive months in liquidity ratios by 0.03 or more points; a systematic decrease | |
| over three consecutive months in the share of liquid assets in total assets by five or more percent; a decrease in the share of attracted time deposits of legal entities and individuals, excluding deposits of special-purpose subsidiaries, in the bank's total liabilities by five or more percent; an increase in the ratio of the total volume of issued loans to attracted deposits of legal entities and individuals, excluding deposits of special-purpose subsidiaries, by seven or more percent per month over the last three months; excess of the ratio of the bank's liabilities to assets (negative gap position of the bank) with a maturity of up to one year in the amount of fifteen or more percent; significant (fifty or more percent) or complete loss of available financing options; unfavorable change in the behavior of assets and liabilities upon the occurrence of stressful situations that may affect the bank's ability to sell or securitize assets; the existence of a trend of gradual increase in liquidity concentration (by one or several sources of financing); and other factors provided for by the bank's internal documents; 4) operational risk: determination and assessment of the amount of losses caused by failures and malfunctions of information systems and technologies (software or databases, information transmission systems, as well as other systems necessary for the bank's day-to-day functioning); determination and assessment of the amount of losses due to incorrect actions of the bank's management and personnel, resulting in a narrowing of the client base, distrust or negative perception of the bank by clients and counterparties, fraud; determination and assessment of the amount of losses caused by unforeseen or uncontrollable external factors affecting the bank's operations; and other factors provided for by the bank's internal documents. Operational measures of the contingency plan are aimed at eliminating the consequences of stressful situations, and include, among other things, but not limited to: the possibility of obtaining credit lines of financing from other banks that will be available to them in unforeseen circumstances, as well as the types of resources provided, acceptable collateral; determination of the list of potential sources of financing available to the bank in emergency circumstances, as well as the amount of funds that, according to the bank's calculations, can be extracted from these sources; possible measures for making daily payments. In case of serious failures, the bank has the ability to obtain additional sources of daily liquidity, including by identifying and mobilizing additional bank assets that can be used as collateral; the list of measures necessary to restore the normal functioning of the bank disrupted as a result of emergency situations; identification of divisions (dependent, including on external service providers or other third parties) for which the earliest possible resumption of services is necessary; | |
| determination of the list of priority for restoring the bank's internal processes. The contingency plan defines alternative mechanisms allowing services to be resumed in case of a failure in a business process; the degree of protection provided (maintaining normal operation for a certain time, maintaining operation at a minimally acceptable level for a certain time, termination of operation or ensuring subsequent restoration of the normal mode of operation of the interrupted process); necessary resources in case of failure in the operation of procedures carried out by divisions to implement their assigned tasks and functions in the bank's areas of activity (qualified personnel, premises, software, equipment and other resources, if they are provided for by the bank's internal documents); procedures and necessary measures to limit risks upon the occurrence of stressful situations, including the possibility of limiting risky operations, increasing the amount of equity adequate to the level of risk taken, sufficiency of reserves created against risks; procedures for establishing priorities that detail the order of taking measures, as well as the cases when each of the measures must be performed; a set of measures that during crises ensure timely, consistent communication with internal as well as external market entities (the authorized body, the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan) to maintain general confidence in the bank; detailed instructions for the bank's divisions and employees, containing a description of actions necessary to maintain or timely resume the functioning of internal processes important for the bank's activities; procedures for working in emergency mode, including restoration of disrupted business processes, as well as the procedure for completing work in emergency mode and returning to the day-to-day functioning mode, procedures for the functioning of backup centers, including determination of the frequency and methods of creating backup copies of data; and other measures provided for by the bank's internal documents. The responsibility matrix of the contingency plan contains information in which each detailed measure of the contingency plan is linked to specific employees responsible for their implementation. The purpose of the responsibility matrix is to ensure that the tasks set in the contingency plan achieve the expected results of each planned action by establishing responsibility in the job descriptions of the bank's management and its employees. The responsibility matrix contains, among other things but not limited to, the following information: the procedure for redistributing the functions, powers and duties of the bank's employees in case of emergency situations, including the right to initiate (apply) the contingency plan; the surname, name, patronymic if available, and contact information of persons responsible for implementing the contingency plan; procedures for building effective internal coordination and | |
| communication between various employees and business divisions of the bank, the procedure for bringing to the attention of the Board of Directors information on the progress of the contingency plan and measures taken by the bank; and other information provided for by the bank's internal documents. The contingency plan is drawn up taking into account the risks assumed on a consolidated basis, taking into account the bank's subsidiaries, which corresponds to the complexity and scale of activities of the subsidiaries. When drawing up the contingency plan taking into account the risks assumed on a consolidated basis, the bank, among other things: considers as an emergency circumstance the period of financial instability and instability of a subsidiary; takes into account interdependencies caused by the presence of subsidiaries, including those located outside the Republic of Kazakhstan, the consequences of the organizational and legal separateness of legal entities for resolving problems; measures aimed at ensuring rapid restoration of key functions and resolving the problems of a subsidiary and, if necessary, the phased termination of the subsidiary's activities without prejudice to the activities of the conglomerate participants. The bank's Management Board: periodically uses the results of risk analysis (by type of risk), scenarios and assumptions used in stress testing when considering the adequacy of the contingency plan; reviews the contingency plan in order to ensure compliance with the bank's current activities and strategies; periodically, but not less than once a month, tests the contingency plan to ensure its effectiveness and operational feasibility; reviews all aspects of the contingency plan after each event that entailed a change in the initial conditions, and takes necessary measures to carry out subsequent measures. The Board of Directors ensures control over the implementation by the Management Board of the relevant measures provided for by the contingency plan. | |
| Procedure for decision-making by the bank's bodies within the risk management and internal control system | In case of meetings of the bank's board of directors and management board, the asset and liability management committee, as well as the credit committee on issues of making a decision on granting credit, changes in the terms of loan agreements submitted for consideration by the credit committee, identification, assessment and monitoring of risks to which the bank is exposed, in absentia voting, the fact of participation in voting is confirmed in writing and sent via appropriate means of communication (fax, internet and others). This requirement applies to persons who are members of the said collegial bodies who are outside the place of the meeting of the relevant body at the time of decision-making. |
Appendix 2 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 29.12.09 No. 263 (see old version)
Appendix 2
to the Instruction on requirements for
the presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for the internal control system
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| Bank management: is responsible for implementing the bank's strategy and policy approved by the board of directors; develops processes designed to identify, measure, monitor and control banking risks; maintains an organizational structure that clearly delineates areas of responsibility, authority and accountability; ensures the effective exercise of delegated powers; develops appropriate internal control rules; monitors the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system | The bank's board of directors is responsible for establishing and operating an adequate and effective internal control system. Members of the board of directors have the necessary knowledge and experience in banking and related risks. Bank management and heads of structural subdivisions are responsible for the adequate functioning of the internal control system. Management takes measures ensuring: performance of internal control work by highly qualified employees with the necessary experience and technical capabilities. The board of directors: 1) periodically discusses with bank management the effectiveness of the internal control system; 2) promptly reviews the assessment of internal control made by management, the internal audit service and external auditors; 3) conducts periodic measures ensuring prompt implementation by management of recommendations and comments made by auditors and supervisory authorities regarding deficiencies in the internal control system; 4) conducts periodic review of the adequacy of the bank's strategy and risk limits |
| Bank management develops appropriate internal control rules; monitors the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system | Management is responsible for implementing the instructions of the board of directors, including implementation of the strategy and policy, and creating an effective internal control system. The bank's internal rules describe the organizational structure with a clear indication of areas of authority, accountability and an effective information exchange system throughout the bank. Management delegates authority to develop specific rules and procedures in the area of internal control to the heads of the relevant subdivision. At the same time, management controls the development and execution of proper rules and procedures. Bank management takes measures ensuring performance of internal control work by highly qualified employees with the necessary experience and technical capabilities |
| The bank's board of directors and management are responsible for strict observance of ethical norms and standards of professional activity, for creating a corporate culture that emphasizes and demonstrates to personnel at all levels the importance of internal control. All bank employees are aware of and understand their role in the internal control process and take full part in this process | Operating procedures are described in clearly drafted internal documents accessible to all interested bank employees. Bank employees effectively perform their duties and bring to the attention of management at the appropriate level any operational problems, cases of non-compliance with professional ethics or other violations of procedures or abuses |
| Ongoing assessment of material risks that have a negative impact on achieving the bank's goals. The assessment covers all risks assumed by the bank on an individual and consolidated basis (credit risk, country risk and risk of introduction of currency restrictions, market risk, interest rate risk, liquidity risk, operational risk, legal risk and reputational risk). Making changes to the internal control system in order to effectively address problems of new or previously uncontrolled risks | Ongoing assessment by management of risks affecting the achievement of set goals, and response to changing circumstances and conditions. Review of the internal control system in order to effectively track new or previously uncontrolled risks. Assessment of new financial instruments and market operations appearing on the financial market and analysis of risks associated with such activity. Risk assessment identifies and considers internal factors (such as complexity of the organizational structure, nature of banking activity, level of employee qualifications, organizational changes and staff turnover) and external factors (such as changes in economic conditions and the situation in the banking sector, technological innovations) that may have a negative impact on the bank's achievement of its set goals |
| Internal documents provide for the creation of an appropriate control structure, including: checks carried out by management; a system of approvals and delegation of rights; proper control over various subdivisions; checks of compliance with risk limits and subsequent control of elimination of identified violations; a system of account reconciliation and cross-checking; inventory of property | The exercise of control extends to all bank employees, including management and employees working with clients. Bank management on an ongoing basis receives confirmation of compliance of all aspects of the bank's activity with the bank's internal documents, and information that the content of internal documents continues to remain adequate |
| Clear separation of employees' duties and exclusion of situations permitting a conflict of interest in an employee's area of responsibility. Identification, minimization, strict and independent control of areas of potential conflicts of interest | Separation among several employees of authority over: authorized payment of money and its actual payment; keeping accounts reflecting client operations and accounts reflecting the bank's own operations; keeping operations relating to the "banking" portfolio and the "dealer" portfolio; informal provision of information to clients about their positions while simultaneously conducting marketing operations with the same clients; assessment of the adequacy of credit documentation when granting a loan and monitoring of the borrower after loan disbursement; other areas involving the emergence of a material conflict of interest not mitigated by other factors. Areas of potential conflict of interest are identified, minimized, and an independent third party carries out their ongoing monitoring |
| Availability of adequate and comprehensive information of a financial and operational nature and information on compliance with established regulatory requirements, as well as market information received from outside about events and conditions relevant to decision-making. Information is reliable, timely, accessible and properly formatted | Availability of adequate information and its effective transmission. Information has the following qualities: relevant, reliable, timely, accessible and formatted. Information includes internal financial and operational data, data on compliance with the established requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and normative legal acts, as well as information received from the external market about events and conditions relevant to decision-making. Internal information is part of the accounting process based on the established procedure for storing accounting records |
| Availability of reliable information systems covering all main types of the bank's activity. These systems, including electronic ones, are under independent control. Appropriate measures have been developed to support information systems in emergency circumstances | Development of internal backup procedures and function recovery procedures, rules for developing and acquiring software, maintenance procedures (change control) and control over physical/logical access security. Software control consists of computer steps in software applications and other manual procedures controlling the processing of operations and other types of banking activity. Development of a contingency action plan using duplicate devices located outside the bank, including recovery of systems critical to the bank's activity supported by an external service provider. Periodic testing of the bank operations recovery program for its feasibility in cases of unforeseen circumstances |
| Availability of effective information systems enabling employees to comply with the policies and procedures governing duties, as well as bringing necessary information to the relevant employees | Bank management creates effective information transmission systems (documents defining the operational policy and procedures of the bank's activity, information on the bank's actual operational activity). Creation of the bank's organizational structure ensuring an adequate flow of information - upward, downward and horizontally. Information coming from the bottom up provides the board of directors and management with the necessary information about risks assumed in the course of activity and the current state of the bank. Information directed downward ensures that the bank's goals, its strategy, established procedures and procedures are brought to the attention of middle and lower management and ordinary employees |
| Ongoing monitoring of the effectiveness of internal control. Bank subdivisions and the internal audit service monitor key risks and conduct their periodic assessment | Employees of various subdivisions, including departments carrying out banking operations, financial control and internal audit, monitor the effectiveness of internal control. Bank management distributes the duties of employees responsible for specific aspects of monitoring. Monitoring includes periodic assessment of the entire internal control process. The frequency of monitoring of various types of the bank's operations is determined based on the risks associated with them, the frequency and nature of changes occurring in the bank's operating conditions. |
| Operationally independent and competent employees conduct an effective and comprehensive internal audit of the internal control system. The internal audit service, as part of monitoring the internal control system, is accountable to the board of directors | The internal audit service is part of the ongoing monitoring of the internal control system and provides an independent assessment of the adequacy of established rules and procedures, as well as their compliance. The internal audit service is independent of the bank's daily work and has access to all types of operations conducted by the bank, including its branches and subsidiary structures |
| Deficiencies in internal control identified by employees of the bank's subdivisions, the internal audit service or other control services are promptly brought to the attention of managers at the appropriate level and promptly eliminated. Material deficiencies in internal control are reported to the bank's management and the board of directors | Information about deficiencies in the internal control system and about ineffectively controlled risks is brought to the attention of the relevant person(s) immediately upon identification, serious issues are brought to the attention of the board of directors. Relevant managers ensure timely correction of deficiencies. The internal audit service conducts follow-up checks or carries out other types of monitoring and immediately informs the board of directors of all uncorrected deficiencies. The bank's board of directors creates a system for tracking deficiencies in internal control and measures taken to eliminate them. The board of directors periodically receives reports summarizing all problems identified by the internal control system |
| The bank's board of directors is responsible for providing the bank and maintaining, through management, an adequate and effective internal control system, a system for measuring and assessing the bank's activity risks, a system for determining risks relating to the bank's capital level, and appropriate methods for monitoring compliance with laws, normative legal acts and internal policy. Once a year the board of directors reviews the internal control system and the capital assessment procedure | The board of directors regularly reviews the internal control system to ensure orderly conduct of business (with reference to specific goals). The board of directors regularly reviews the existence of a risk management system. The board of directors ensures the existence of procedures for identifying and adequately controlling the risks to which the bank is exposed in achieving its set goals; testing the integrity, reliability and timeliness of financial information and management information; monitoring compliance with laws and normative legal acts, supervisory policy and internal plans, methodologies and procedures |
| Bank management is responsible for developing procedures for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling the risks to which the bank is exposed. Once a year management reports to the board of directors on the scale and effectiveness of the internal control system | Management maintains an organizational structure with a distribution of responsibility, authority and reporting relationships and ensuring the effective exercise of delegated powers. Management is responsible for developing risk management procedures. Management establishes appropriate internal control methodologies and monitors the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system |
| Internal audit is part of the ongoing monitoring of the bank's internal control system and the internal capital assessment procedure, since internal audit provides an independent assessment of the adequacy of and compliance with the bank's established internal policies and procedures. The internal audit service assists management and the board of directors in the effective and efficient performance of their duties | The main duties of the internal audit service are: checking and assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system; checking the application and effectiveness of risk management procedures and risk assessment methodology; checking management and financial information systems, including the electronic information system and electronic banking services; checking the accuracy and reliability of accounting records and financial reports; checking the means of preserving assets; checking the bank's system for assessing its capital in connection with its risk assessment; assessing the effectiveness of operations; testing both transactions and the functioning of specific internal control procedures; checking systems established to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, codes of conduct and implementation of methodologies and procedures; testing the reliability and timeliness of financial reporting; carrying out special checks. Management ensures ongoing and full awareness of the internal audit service about new developments, products and operational changes to ensure identification of related risks at an early stage |
| The bank provides for the existence of an internal audit service. In performing its duties, management takes all necessary measures so that the bank relies on the adequacy of internal audit corresponding to its size and nature of operations. These measures include providing adequate resources and personnel to internal audit to achieve its goals | Internal audit is carried out by an internal audit service with full-time staff |
| The bank's internal audit service is independent of the activity being audited and of the daily internal control procedure. Internal audit has the appropriate status within the bank and carries out its activity objectively and impartially | The internal audit service carries out activity on its own initiative in all departments, subdivisions and services of the bank. The internal audit service has the right to report the data and assessments it obtains and to disclose this information within the bank. The internal audit service acts under the direct control of the board of directors. The head of the internal audit service has the authority to contact directly and on his own initiative the board of directors, the chairman of the board of directors or, if necessary, external auditors in accordance with the rules defined by each bank in its Regulation on the Internal Audit Service. This informing may concern the adoption by bank management of decisions contradicting the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the bank's internal documents. The internal audit service is subject to independent review. This review is carried out by an independent party, such as an external auditor |
| The internal audit service is objective and impartial and occupies a position allowing it to perform its functions without bias and interference | Objectivity and impartiality imply that the internal audit service strives to avoid conflicts of interest. Internal audit service personnel should be periodically rotated. Auditors recruited within the bank should not audit the activity or functions they performed during the last twelve months at that bank. Impartiality requires that the internal audit service not be involved in the bank's operations or in the selection and implementation of internal control measures. Management may request the opinion of the internal audit service on specific issues concerning compliance with internal control principles. In order to achieve effectiveness, management may request an opinion when considering reorganization issues, the most important issues of activity, the creation of new subdivisions, including the creation or reorganization of risk control systems, information management or information technology systems. However, the development and implementation of these measures remains the area of ultimate responsibility of management: the advisory function is an additional task that does not interfere with the performance of the main tasks or the responsibility and independence of the internal audit service. Subsequent conclusions of the internal audit service contain recommendations concerning deficiencies and shortcomings, and proposals for improving internal control |
| Professional competence of each internal auditor and of the internal audit service | The professional competence of each internal auditor, as well as their motivation and continuous training, are necessary conditions for improving the effectiveness of the internal audit service. Professional competence is assessed taking into account the nature of the role performed and the auditor's ability to collect information, analyze, assess and communicate |
| Any activity and any subdivision of the bank are checked by the internal audit service | The internal audit service checks the bank's subdivisions, including the activity of branches and subsidiary enterprises, as well as activity involving external contractors. Internal audit includes checking and assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of internal control and risk management systems. The internal audit service assesses: the bank's compliance with policies and risk control; the reliability (including integrity, accuracy and completeness) and timeliness of financial and management information; the continuity and reliability of operation of electronic information systems; the functioning of the human resources department; the existence of norms of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the bank's internal provisions concerning the bank's operations, including methodologies, principles, rules and instructions of the authorized body regarding the organizational structure and management of the bank |
| The internal audit service periodically, but not less than once a year, conducts internal audit checks of the bank's subdivisions performing functions for carrying out banking operations, including for the purpose of improving risk management and internal control systems | The bank's internal control policy determines: all risks to which the bank is exposed; the scale and frequency of internal control; the rating system used in conducting internal control; requirements for drawing up the bank's internal control plan; the internal audit service, in accordance with audit policies, conducts regular internal checks of all bank subdivisions whose functions provide for carrying out banking operations; the personnel of the internal audit service have work experience and the necessary knowledge about the activity of the bank's subdivisions in which checks are conducted; the bank's internal policies provide for the right of the internal audit service to access all necessary documents related to the activity of the subdivision being checked, including those constituting commercial, other or confidential information; the bank's internal policies on internal control establish the independence of the performance of functional duties from management employees or other bank subdivisions and the accountability of the internal audit service to the board of directors; the internal audit service, together with the bank's external auditor, holds joint meetings to discuss deficiencies in the bank's internal control system; the internal audit service participates in discussion of issues on the introduction of new products or services |
| The management board analyzes the internal audit service's report on the results of each check and submits to the board of directors proposals on taking appropriate measures to eliminate identified deficiencies | The internal control policy provides for optimal timeframes for the internal audit service to submit the results of each check to the board of directors and the bank's management board; the powers of the internal audit service provide for the preparation of proposals based on the results of the conducted check, the implementation of which is mandatory for subdivisions, while the methods and conditions of their implementation are determined directly by the bank's subdivisions; the internal audit service monitors the ongoing and planned measures taken by the bank's subdivisions based on the results of internal control, with the aim of their optimal implementation |
| Internal audit carries out an independent check of the risk management system developed by the bank for correlating risk with the level of the bank's own capital and the method established for monitoring compliance with internal policy in relation to capital | The bank determines the person or department that is responsible for checking the own capital assessment procedure |
| The bank has a regulation on the internal audit service that provides for the status and powers of the internal audit service in the bank | The regulation on the internal audit service establishes: the goals and scope of activity of the internal audit service; the status of the internal audit service in the organization, its powers, duties and relations with other services; the accountability of the internal audit service. The regulation on the internal audit service is approved by the board of directors. In the regulation on the internal audit service, management grants the right of initiative and permits an employee of the internal audit service to have direct access to any employee of the bank, to check any activity or any division of the bank, and also to have access to any records, files or data of the bank, including management information and minutes of all advisory and decision-making bodies that may relate to the performance of his duties. The regulation on the internal audit service provides for the conditions under which the internal audit service may be engaged in the provision of consulting services or in the performance of other special assignments |
|---|---|
| Internal audit includes an audit plan, verification and evaluation of available information, communication of results and tracking the implementation of recommendations and resolution of problems | Internal audit includes, among other things: financial audit, the purpose of which is to evaluate the reliability of the accounting system and information and the financial statements prepared on their basis; compliance audit, the purpose of which is to evaluate the quality and compliance of systems created to ensure compliance with laws, regulations, methodologies and procedures; operational audit, the purpose of which is to evaluate the quality and compliance of other systems and procedures, analyze organizational structures and evaluate sufficiency for the performance of assigned duties; management audit, the purpose of which is to evaluate the quality of management's approaches to risk and control within the framework of the bank's goals. The management of the internal audit service prepares a plan for the performance of all assigned tasks. The audit plan includes the schedule and frequency of planned internal audit work. The audit plan is based on a methodological assessment of control over risks. In the risk management assessment, the internal auditor's perception of the bank's core activities and related risks is documented. The management of the internal audit service records in writing the principles of the risk assessment methodology and regularly updates them to reflect changes in the internal control system or in the work process, taking into account new areas of activity. In the risk analysis conducted by the internal audit service, the areas of activity and divisions of the bank, as well as the internal control system, are checked. Based on the results of the risk analysis, a multi-year audit plan is prepared taking into account the degree of risks inherent in a particular type of activity. The plan takes into account expected developments and innovations, the usually higher degree of risk in new types of activity and the intention to subject all important types of activity and divisions to audit within reasonable timeframes. The audit plan includes time for performing other tasks, such as specific checks, issuing conclusions and training. This plan also includes a section listing the necessary resources for staffing and other needs. The audit plan is drawn up by the internal audit service and approved by the board of directors. For each audit task, an audit program should be prepared. The audit program sets out the objectives of the audit. All procedures for performing audit tasks are documented in appropriate working papers that reflect the results of the checks performed with an emphasis on the assessments in the conclusion. For each assignment, a written audit conclusion is prepared. The audit conclusion sets out the purpose and scope of the audit. It also includes conclusions and recommendations. The bank's management should ensure |
| the timely implementation of the internal audit service's recommendations. The internal audit service tracks the implementation of its recommendations and prepares a report at least once every six months to the bank's management, the board of directors, depending on the corporate governance mechanism | |
| The head of the internal audit service is responsible for ensuring that the internal audit service complies with internal audit principles | The head of the internal audit service ensures compliance with internal audit standards. In particular, the head of the internal audit service ensures the development of the audit plan, program, methodologies and procedures for the activities of the internal audit service. The head of the internal audit service ensures the professional competence and training of personnel and the availability of necessary resources. The internal audit service regularly reports to the board of directors and advises it on the effectiveness of the internal control system and the achievement of the internal audit service's goals, including informing management and/or the board of directors about the progress of the audit plan. The board of directors reviews the organization (both in terms of personnel and in other respects) of the internal audit service, the audit plan, reports on the work done, a summary of the internal audit service's recommendations and the status of their implementation. The bank establishes a procedure for monitoring (including conducting follow-up checks) the taking of measures to eliminate violations identified by the internal audit service; the submission at least once every six months by the internal audit service of information on measures taken to implement recommendations and eliminate identified violations to the board of directors and the executive body |
| The bank's board of directors is responsible for ensuring the management of the bank's compliance risk. The board of directors has approved the compliance risk management policy, including a document establishing a permanent and effective compliance risk management function. At least once a year, the board of directors or committees under the board of directors evaluate the effectiveness of compliance risk management. | The bank's board of directors is responsible for having an appropriate compliance risk management policy. The bank's board of directors is responsible for implementing the policy by ensuring the effective resolution of compliance service issues by the bank's management board. The board of directors may delegate these powers to an appropriate committee under the board of directors. |
| The bank's management board is responsible for effective compliance risk management. | The bank's management board is responsible for implementing the compliance risk management policy and ensuring compliance with the compliance risk management policy and providing a report to the board of directors on the effectiveness of compliance risk management. The bank's management board is responsible for developing a compliance risk management policy containing the need for the management board and bank employees to comply with the basic principles of compliance risk management. The management board ensures compliance with the compliance risk management policy and takes corrective or disciplinary measures if a compliance risk is identified. The bank's management board together with the compliance service: annually identifies and assesses the problems of compliance risk occurrence and approves an Action Plan for their elimination. The Action Plan contains deficiencies in compliance risk management, the need to revise internal policies and procedures for effective compliance risk management; annually informs the board of directors about the effectiveness of compliance risk management; immediately informs the board of directors about any operations that may lead to losses or loss of business reputation as a result of non-compliance with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan. |
| The compliance service is independent in managing compliance risk in the bank. | The compliance service has access to any information necessary for the performance of compliance risk management functions, within the powers assigned to it for compliance risk management; the compliance service has an official status within the bank, an appropriate regulation, powers and independence and carries out its activities through the development and approval by the bank's board of directors of a work plan. The compliance controller is appointed to the position by the bank's board of directors. The regulation on the compliance service, among other things, provides for: accountability of the compliance controller to the bank's board of directors; accountability of compliance participants to the compliance controller in terms of compliance risk management; duties and powers of the compliance controller and compliance participants; independence of the compliance controller and compliance participants in terms of the functions assigned to them for compliance risk management; relationships of the compliance service with other divisions of the bank and the internal audit service; the right to conduct checks and identify possible violations of the compliance risk management policy and to engage internal and external specialists to perform this task; the right to freely express and disclose the results of checks to the management board and, if necessary, to the bank's board of directors. The compliance service has the right, on its own initiative, to cooperate with any division of the bank and to obtain access to any files and reports necessary for the performance of its duties. |
| The compliance service has sufficient resources to effectively perform its duties. | The resources necessary for the compliance service must be sufficient and appropriate for effective compliance risk management. The compliance controller and compliance participants have the necessary qualifications, work experience, professional and personal qualities to perform their duties. The compliance controller and compliance participants possess knowledge of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, internal rules and procedures of the bank. The professional skills of the compliance controller and compliance participants are maintained through regular and systematic training. |
| The functions and powers of the compliance service are aimed at managing compliance risk arising in the bank. | To achieve its goals, the compliance service performs the following functions: monitors the compliance of the bank's activities, as well as the actions of its employees in the financial market, with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market; monitors compliance by bank employees with the rules for carrying out activities in the financial market and standards for conducting operations (transactions) in the financial market established by the bank's internal documents, decisions of the bank's management bodies on issues of the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank investigates facts of violations by bank employees of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market, internal documents of the bank regulating the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank considers claims of clients and counterparties regarding transactions (operations) to the bank or actions of its individual employees in the performance of their official duties on issues of the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank develops and submits to management recommendations for eliminating identified violations and deficiencies in the work of individual employees and divisions of the bank whose activities are related to operations (transactions) in the financial market, as well as recommendations for optimizing the work of these divisions; monitors the organization of work in the bank to familiarize all bank employees with the requirements of the bank's internal documents regulating the bank's activities in the financial market, based on the list of official duties of employees; provides consultations upon requests regarding the compliance of a specific operation (transaction) or part thereof with the requirements of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market; monitors compliance risk. The monitoring results are presented in the form of a report in accordance with internal compliance risk management procedures; trains personnel on issues related to the occurrence of compliance risk, the need for interaction in solving problems related to the occurrence of compliance risk; develops internal guidance for bank personnel on compliance risk through the approval of internal policies and procedures. The procedure for current reporting of the compliance |
| service is determined by the bank's internal documents. The compliance controller informs the bank's management board: about identified cases of violations by employees of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market, internal documents of the bank regulating the bank's activities in the financial market; about measures taken by the heads of the audited divisions of the bank to eliminate the violations committed and their results, or about the failure to take such measures; annually submits a report on compliance risk control to the bank's board of directors. In performing their functions, the compliance controller and compliance participants: ensure full documentation of each fact of verification and issue conclusions based on the results of checks reflecting all issues studied during the check, identified deficiencies and violations, recommendations for their elimination; ensure the availability of documents (or information about their location) allowing to monitor the progress of control work and checks performed, and also verify the correctness of their results; ensure the safety and return of documents received from the relevant divisions; maintain confidentiality of the information received; submit conclusions based on the results of checks to the management and relevant divisions of the bank for taking measures to eliminate violations, as well as for the purposes of analyzing the activities of individual bank employees. |
Appendix 3 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
Appendix 3
to the Instruction on requirements for
the presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for conducting bank borrowing operations
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The bank has a credit risk control policy | The management board monitors the bank's and its subsidiaries' exposure to credit risk on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations; the board of directors has established procedures for assessing loan quality; the board of directors and the management board have established procedures for forming provisions and writing off classified assets; the management board at least once a month analyzes the quality of assets and the level of credit risk of the bank on balance sheet and off-balance sheet liabilities, determines the degree of influence of credit risk on the financial position of the bank |
| The board of directors has established procedures limiting the risk of conflict of interest of bank employees related to lending | The staff of the bank's credit division performs functional duties in compliance with procedures limiting the risk of conflict of interest; the internal audit service at least once a year checks compliance by employees of the credit division with policies and procedures limiting the risk of conflict of interest |
| The board of directors has approved the policy for control and monitoring of credit risk, including on a consolidated basis | The risk management division at least once a quarter monitors bank borrowing operations conducted during the reporting period in order to determine the concentration of the bank's credit risks and on a consolidated basis, including by borrowers, sectors of the economy, countries/regions; the risk management division monitors and provides at least once a quarter to the management board and at least once every six months to the board of directors information on the bank's credit risk, including on a consolidated basis, by borrowers, sectors of the economy, countries/regions; the board of directors has approved procedures for measuring and forecasting credit risk for short-term, medium-term and long-term periods; the procedures for measuring and forecasting credit risk, among other things, provide for the use of credit risk models including the following parameters: the level of expense (loss) upon occurrence of credit risk, distribution of assets by degree of credit risk, forecast of changes in the distribution of assets by degree of credit risk, interrelation of credit risks of various assets, forecast of the possible size of risk on assumed liabilities related to credit risk, distribution of sectors and countries with which the bank's credit risk is associated by degree of credit risk, preparation of reports on the above parameters of the credit risk model; the management board analyzes credit risks associated with the bank's offering of new banking services or provision of banking services in new sectors or regions of the economy |
| The board of directors has approved the ranking policy (distribution by levels of credit risks), and the management board - procedures for ranking loans based on the bank's ratings (levels) | The credit risk ranking policy, among other things, provides for: frequency of assigning corporate ratings based on quantitative and qualitative factors; establishment of credit limits and interest rates on loans, taking into account borrower ratings; frequency of monitoring losses by ratings; making a decision to issue a loan if the borrower meets the minimum acceptable rating level |
| The board of directors has established a policy for conducting internal credit analysis for the purposes of verifying the reliability of the ranking process (rating assessment), which among other things provide for the independence of credit analysis functions from loan issuance and formation of provisions (reserves) | The internal credit analysis policy, among other things, provides for: periodic verification of the reliability of ranking (distribution by levels) of loans, additionally on a consolidated basis; periodic verification of the reliability of formation of provisions (reserves) in accordance with the bank's internal documents and regulatory legal acts of the authorized body; periodic verification of the reliability of ranking (distribution by levels) of off-balance sheet operations of the bank related to derivative instruments, forward currency transactions, financial liabilities |
| The management board has approved internal credit analysis procedures | Internal credit analysis procedures provide for: annual review of at least fifty-one percent of the bank's loan portfolio; the division and employees of the bank performing internal analysis and responsible for verifying the results of internal credit analysis; qualification requirements for persons performing credit analysis functions |
| Credit analysis procedures establish the frequency of submitting reports on the results of credit analysis to the board of directors and the management board | Credit analysis procedures determine: the frequency of submitting reports on the results of credit analysis to the board of directors and the management board; the form and additional information indicated in the report on the results of credit analysis; the procedure for monitoring the implementation by bank divisions of decisions taken by the board of directors or the management board based on the results of consideration of reports |
| The management board has approved regulations on the bank's executive officers authorized to make decisions on loan issuance | The internal audit service checks the compliance of the powers of the bank's executive officers making decisions on loan issuance with their official powers defined in the bank's internal regulations; the regulation on the bank's executive officers authorized to make decisions on loan issuance defines qualification and professional requirements for the person authorized to make decisions on loan issuance |
| The board of directors has approved the policy for maintaining lending documentation, including providing for conditions subject to mandatory reflection in bank loan agreements | The lending documentation policy determines: conditions subject to mandatory reflection in bank loan agreements, including disclosure by borrowers of information on financial position and other information that may negatively affect the borrower's ability to timely and fully fulfill obligations under the loan; conducting legal expertise of foreign legislation - when lending to non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| The risk management division conducts analysis of an effective assessment of the borrower's creditworthiness | The board of directors approves criteria: for assessing compliance of the borrower's accounting policy with current accounting and reporting standards, reliability of borrowers' financial statements; for assessing the correctness of assessment of the financial condition of the borrower's parent and subsidiary organizations; for assessing the reputation and business image of the borrower; for assessing the state of the industry and efficiency of the borrower's production technology; for checking the use of borrowed funds by the borrower; for assessing the borrower's sources of loan repayment, including taking into account the following factors: production prospects, sales dynamics, quality of short-term assets; the amount of income that can be allocated to repay debt compared to debt service requirements; for assessing the effectiveness of the borrower's business plan |
| The board of directors has approved the policy, and the management board - procedures for monitoring borrowers, including providing for the bank's verification of the borrower's production activity indicators | The borrower monitoring policy and procedures determine the procedure for: conducting financial analysis of legal entity borrowers by the bank, including on loans provided under real estate; tracking by the bank of changes in the financial position of borrowers based on collection and analysis of data from financial statements; verification by the bank through financial analysis of the effectiveness of use of borrowed funds; checking risks the amount of which exceeds five percent of the bank's own capital, including balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations; control over the consolidated credit risk of the borrower, including taking into account its parent and subsidiary organizations |
| The board of directors has approved the policy for monitoring borrowers with an unstable financial position | The policy for monitoring borrowers with an unsatisfactory financial position determines: the concept of "borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position", including those meeting the criteria for assessing financial position provided for by regulatory legal acts of the authorized body on classification of assets; methods of controlling loans provided to a borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position; methods of recovering doubtful loans with increased risk and bad loans; the procedure for informing bank branches about borrowers whose loans are classified as doubtful with increased risk and bad; the procedure for monthly tracking of indicators of financial and production activity of a borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position, including with the involvement of independent experts or auditors; measures for developing a restructuring plan for doubtful loans with increased risk and bad loans |
| The board of directors has approved the policy for assessing the sufficiency of provided collateral | The risk management division periodically analyzes the effectiveness of procedures for assessing the sufficiency of collateral, which determine: rules for calculating the sufficiency of collateral (for example, the ratio of loan value to collateral value, revaluation of collateral); operational methods for assessing the sufficiency of collateral taking into account changes in the borrower's production activity indicators, preservation of collateral, including its exposure to force majeure circumstances; frequency of checking the collateral item; frequency of revaluation of real estate provided as collateral, in particular, for loans issued to legal entities for the acquisition of real estate, under credit lines, letters of credit and guarantees; frequency of revaluation of the value of securities held to maturity as collateral; frequency and methods of assessing the financial position of the guarantor |
| The board of directors has approved the policy for collecting and processing information on the situation in each country whose residents are borrowers of the bank | The country risk assessment policy determines: methods for assessing country risk, including taking into account sovereign ratings of international rating agencies; frequency of collecting information from external sources on the political and economic situation in each country; methods for the bank to establish its own country ratings, the possibility of their prompt adjustment; methods for establishing credit limits by country and the frequency of their revision |
Appendix 4 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
Appendix 4
to the Instruction on requirements for
the presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for the risk management system when providing
mortgage housing loans issued to individuals, and mortgage loans
secured by real estate or provided for the purpose
of real estate construction
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The bank develops an internal credit policy for mortgage housing loans issued to individuals and mortgage loans secured by real estate or provided for the purpose of real estate construction (hereinafter loans related to real estate), determining the degree of risk depending on the loan amount, interest rate and other special conditions | The bank's credit policy for loans related to real estate provides for: geographic regions of lending; diversification of the bank's loan portfolio; limits on loans related to real estate - by types and geographic regions (for example, limits on riskier loans); terms and conditions for types of loans; procedure for issuing and approving loans; procedure for managing loans, including documentation, issuance, control over collateral, repayment and analysis of the loan; program for informal and formal assessment of real estate value; obligation of the bank's management to control the loan portfolio and ensure timely and complete submission of reports to the board of directors. For experimental design and construction projects and completed commercial properties, the credit policy also provides for: requirements for conducting feasibility studies and sensitivity and risk analysis (for example, sensitivity of projected income to changes in economic variables, including interest rates, vacancy rate or operating expenses); minimum requirements for initial investment volume, technical maintenance by the borrower of own capital (for example, cash or investments, unencumbered property); minimum requirements for own capital, cash flow and degree of coverage of debt service of the borrower or the underlying asset; standards of acceptability and limits on non-amortizing loans; pre-rental and pre-sale requirements for income-producing property; pre-sale requirements and minimum requirements for commissioning of one structural unit of a constructed building for loans related to non-income assets; minimum conditions for loan agreements. The credit policy establishes minimum values of the debt service coverage ratio - how many times net operating income will cover the annual debt service amount. The debt service coverage ratio is calculated as the ratio of net operating income to the mortgage payment |
| The bank analyzes conditions in real estate markets in order to promptly respond to changes in market conditions relevant to credit decisions | Market factors of supply and demand that should be taken into account include (among others) the following: demographic indicators, including dynamics of population size and employment; zoning requirements; current and projected vacancy rates, construction and absorption rate; current and projected lease terms, rental rates and sale prices, including leasing of part of the premises; current and projected operating expenses for various types of projects; economic indicators, including trends and diversification in lending; valuation trends, including discount and direct capitalization rates. Loans related to real estate reflect all relevant credit factors, including: value of the pledged property; overall creditworthiness of the borrower; availability of secondary sources of debt repayment; availability of additional collateral or credit-enhancing funds (for example, guarantees or mortgage insurance). Loans related to real estate issued to legal entities also reflect the following credit factors: production capacity of the borrower or income from the underlying asset - for adequate debt servicing; volume of shares invested in the property |
| The credit policy for loans related to real estate reflects the degree of risk acceptable to the bank's management and provides for standards allowing the bank's credit officers to assess credit factors | The standards cover the following points: maximum loan amounts depending on the type of property; maximum loan repayment periods depending on the type of property; schedules of gradual loan repayment; structure for setting interest rates for various types of mortgage loans; limits of the loan-to-value ratio depending on the type of property |
| The bank establishes a procedure for managing loans in the real estate portfolio | The procedure for managing loans in the real estate portfolio contains: type and frequency of financial reports, including requirements for verifying information provided by the borrower; type and frequency of collateral valuations (formal and other types of value assessment); closing of the credit transaction and disbursement of loan funds; payment procedure, including interest; management of escrowed cash; management of pledged property; procedure for actions in case of non-repayment of the loan; timeframes for procedures for selling pledged real estate in judicial/extrajudicial order |
| The bank assesses the probability of successful completion of the construction project | The bank assesses the developer's ability to complete the construction project within the specified cost and timeframes. When assessing the probability of successful completion of the construction project, the bank takes into account the following risks: failure to complete the project within the agreed timeframes leads to financial penalties; bad weather, shortage of material or labor resources or work below regulatory requirements that must be redone to pass the acceptance commission may delay completion of construction, increase interest expenses and lead to exceeding the total project cost compared to the initial budget; during construction, suppliers and subcontractors begin to demand higher payment compared to what was agreed or allocated at the beginning of the project; labor disputes or inability of the general supplier or subcontractor to supply goods and provide services; uninsured destruction, demolition of completed construction or buildings under construction; overall financial potential of the borrower and its experience in development and improvement, that is, to find out whether the borrower can actually finish the project within budget and according to construction plans; assessment of the borrower's experience in development and improvement; nature, work experience and financial position of all parties involved; increase in cost of construction and other materials used in the construction process, entailing an increase in the estimated cost of the construction object; delay in processing title (title-certifying) documents in authorized state bodies (local executive authorities, architecture and urban planning, land management, etc.) for the real estate object at the final stages of its construction and commissioning; redevelopment, reconstruction of completed construction or buildings under construction. The credit file for the bank's construction financing project must contain the following documentation: financial information about the borrower justifying the borrower's experience and financial potential necessary to complete the project; construction loan agreement setting out the rights and obligations of the lender and borrower, conditions for disbursement of funds and events of default; registered mortgage agreement on property as a basis for the bank to foreclose on the pledged property, or for its transfer to the bank's ownership in cases provided by law; legal opinion on compliance with legislation of title and other documents confirming ownership (use) of land, as well as the right to the financed building (when pledging to the bank a construction object with a land plot (right of use)); insurance policies and proof of payment of insurance premiums as evidence that the builder has full and enforceable insurance coverage, including for: liability, fire, specific builder's risks and, where applicable, flood insurance; appropriate |
| assessment by specialists licensed to carry out valuation activities, or other assessment showing the market value of the property in its current state and upon completion of construction, as well as upon achieving a stable level of occupancy; project plans, feasibility study and construction budget showing development plans, project costs, marketing plans and investment shares; inspection of property, extensions and soil reports | |
| Banks assess collateral with the involvement of an independent appraiser for loans related to real estate | The criteria used by banks when assessing collateral for loans related to real estate are regulated by the banks' internal documents defining credit policy. The bank's internal documents concerning assessment of collateral for loans related to real estate contain: criteria and procedures for selecting appraisers carrying out assessment of collateral for loans related to real estate; procedures for ensuring the independence of the appraiser; procedures for carrying out the relevant assessment; criteria for the content of the assessment. The assessment: complies with generally accepted valuation standards. The assessment is carried out by an appraiser who has no financial interest in the collateral object; is drawn up in writing and contains a reasoned analysis in accordance with which a decision is made to issue a loan related to real estate; includes analysis and a report with conclusions if the collateral is provided in the form of a building under construction or reconstruction or partially leased under non-market lease terms and contains unsold space; is carried out by appraisers licensed to carry out valuation activities |
| Banks annually revalue collateral for loans related to real estate | Revaluation of collateral is carried out for loans related to real estate, the collateral value of which exceeds 35,000 monthly calculation indices, with the involvement of an independent appraiser. Based on the results of the revaluation, the bank revises the classification of the loan and the amount of provisions for it. Revaluation is not carried out in cases of: housing repair; revision of the terms of the loan agreement, as well as provision of new or additional collateral for a loan related to real estate, which may reduce the bank's risk of losses. The criteria used by banks when revaluing collateral for loans related to real estate are regulated by the banks' internal documents defining credit policy |
The Instruction was supplemented with Appendix 4-1 in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.03.09 No. 64; amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 02.11.09 No. 229 (see old version)
Appendix 4-1
to the Instruction on requirements for
the presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for liquidity risk management
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The Management Board develops, the Board of Directors approves the strategy and corresponding procedures allowing to manage liquidity risk in accordance with the established acceptable risk level and to guarantee the maintenance by the bank of sufficient liquidity. The Management Board constantly analyzes and, at least once a quarter, reports to the Board of Directors information on the current liquidity situation of the bank. | The liquidity risk management strategy is proportionate to the scale of the bank's activity and: takes into account the lines of business; takes into account liquidity needs, as well as the consequences for liquidity during periods of liquidity insufficiency, which may be specific only to the bank, or to the entire market, or upon the occurrence of both cases. The Board of Directors ensures the implementation of the Strategy through: development by the Management Board of guidelines, internal rules, procedures, control mechanisms; guarantees that members of the Management Board and the relevant personnel of the bank have the necessary work experience, processes and system for measuring, monitoring and controlling all sources of liquidity risk in the bank; reviews reports on the bank's liquidity position. The Management Board: develops a liquidity management policy, which, among other things, determines the structure, responsibilities and control mechanisms for managing liquidity risk and monitoring liquidity positions, taking into account subsidiary organizations; takes into account regulatory and operational restrictions on the transfer of funds necessary to address liquidity problems; monitors liquidity risk across the banking conglomerate if the bank is the parent organization of a banking conglomerate; develops and ensures the availability of procedures for identifying, monitoring and promptly responding to all major needs for liquid assets in the conglomerate and, if necessary, reports them to the Board of Directors; tracks current trends and possible events in the market that may create stressful liquidity situations; determines specific procedures, policies and limits, informs the Board of Directors about the measures to be taken to eliminate cases of violation of policies (limits); ensures that the conducted stress tests, the contingency plan, as well as the liquidity reserve correspond to the scale of the bank's activity; communicates to the employees of the interested divisions of the bank the liquidity risk management strategy, the main internal rules necessary for the implementation of the strategy, as well as the liquidity risk management structure; promptly informs the Board of Directors, as well as the authorized body, about current or possible liquidity problems. Such problems, in accordance with the bank's internal documents, include, among others (without being limited to them), the following: concentration, an increase in the size of the funding gap, a reduction in alternative sources of liquidity, |
| systematic violation of established limits, a significant reduction in the reserve of unencumbered, highly liquid assets, or changes in conditions in external markets that may be sources of future problems, early repayment. The Board of Directors ensures control over the implementation by the Management Board of the relevant measures to address these problems; ensures the availability in the bank of adequate internal control mechanisms guaranteeing the effectiveness of the liquidity risk management process in the bank. | |
| The Board of Directors has approved an internal document containing a funding strategy ensuring effective diversification of sources and terms of funding. The Management Board measures the bank's ability to quickly mobilize capital from all sources, identifies the main factors influencing the bank's ability to mobilize capital. | The funding strategy provides for: diversification of available funding sources in the short-, medium- and long-term perspective. Diversification benchmarks are included in the medium- and long-term funding plans and are coordinated with budgeting and business planning measures; measures to limit concentration on one specific funding source; measures to diversify wholesale funding sources in order to ensure less dependence on funds from a single source. The Management Board regularly monitors the diversification of sources of attracting liquid assets (internal and external sources) and the types of operations on the basis of which they are attracted; analysis of the composition, characteristics and diversification of the bank's assets and funding sources; regularly reviews the funding strategy taking into account changes in internal or external conditions in the interbank or stock markets. |
| The Board of Directors is responsible for the availability of an adequate liquidity risk management structure. The Board of Directors has approved an internal document containing the liquidity risk management policy. | The liquidity risk management policy regulates the system of requirements for organizing work on liquidity risk management, including: the division responsible for liquidity risk management; the separation between the bodies and divisions of the bank of powers and responsibilities for liquidity risk management; procedures for determining the bank's need for liquid funds, including determining the excess (deficit) of liquidity and the maximum permissible values of the excess (deficit) of liquidity; the requirement to maintain a liquidity reserve in the form of easily realizable assets corresponding to the scale of the bank's activity; the requirement for organizing asset and liability management from the point of view of liquidity risk management; the procedure for drawing up short-term and long-term liquidity forecasts; the procedure for analyzing the state of liquidity using scenarios of negative developments for the bank related to market conditions, or other circumstances affecting the bank's need for additional liquidity related to the fulfillment of obligations; procedures for restoring the bank's liquidity, including procedures for making decisions on mobilizing liquid assets, attracting additional resources in case of a liquidity deficit; provisions determining the mandatory availability of an information system for collecting and analyzing information on the state of liquidity in the bank on an individual and consolidated basis; the list of reporting provided by the bank's divisions responsible for liquidity risk management; internal rules and procedures for liquidity management, such as the structure and maturity of assets and liabilities, the diversity and stability of funding sources, methods of managing liquidity in various currencies; determines various quantitative and qualitative indicators of the level of liquidity risk. |
| The Board of Directors has established an acceptable level of liquidity risk corresponding to the business strategy and the role of the bank in the financial system. | The Board of Directors establishes the acceptable level of the bank's liquidity risk. The procedures for determining the acceptable level of liquidity risk reflect the ability to find sources of emergency funding; provide the bank with the opportunity to manage its liquidity and be able to manage liquidity risk during a period of liquidity crisis; are expressed in qualitative and/or quantitative ways. |
| The Board of Directors of the bank has approved limits for managing liquidity risk in accordance with the scale, ongoing activity, geographical coverage of services provided, and the nature of banking products. The Management Board regularly reviews the limits and the corresponding procedures for bringing a problem to the attention of the Board of Directors. | The bank's internal documents establish: limits for managing daily liquidity between various business lines of the bank on a solo and consolidated basis; restrictions on the size of cumulative discrepancies in contractual terms of cash flow receipt (for example, the cumulative net funding need as a share of the total amount of liabilities) for various time periods, which contains the estimated volume of outflows as a result of the fulfillment of planned financial allocations or other obligations of the bank. The limits scheme contains measures ensuring the possibility to continue its activity during periods of general market stresses, stresses characteristic only of the bank, or in both cases. |
| The Board of Directors has approved an internal document containing a policy for managing the bank's assets that may be used as collateral. | The policy for managing the bank's assets that may be used as collateral for obtaining liquid assets, among other things, regulates: identification and assessment of the bank's needs for assets that may be used as collateral; resolution of legal and operational problems underlying the use of the bank's assets that may be used as collateral; conservative determination of the bank's assets that may be used as collateral and determination of their free (unencumbered) level, which must be available at any time upon the occurrence of unexpected funding needs. The bank's division: calculates all positions on the bank's assets that may be used as collateral, including already pledged assets, correlating them with the amount of required collateral and unencumbered assets that can be pledged; tracks the volume of assets available to the bank that may be used as collateral by legal entities and jurisdictions in which the bank carries out its activity; assesses the possibility of using each major class of assets as the bank's assets that may be used as collateral and the acceptability of said assets for the main counterparties and providers of funds in the secured asset markets; determines benchmarks for diversifying the sources of the bank's assets that may be used as collateral, taking into account concentration on specific banks, price sensitivity, collateral requirements under stress conditions; assesses the possibility of attracting funds from private sector counterparties under various market stress scenarios; assesses the possibility of satisfying a wide range of needs for the bank's assets that may be used as collateral, including long-term structural, short-term and daily factors. The bank has a sufficient volume of assets that may be used as collateral to satisfy planned and unexpected borrowing needs, as well as to be ready to ensure a possible increase in margin requirements in various time periods - depending on the bank's funding profile; takes into account the possibility of the appearance of contractual requirements for the provision of additional bank assets used as collateral, changes in the bank's credit rating or its financial position, as well as other events that may entail early repayment of obligations, the need for a certain volume of liquidity, related, among other things, to off-balance sheet obligations. Information systems provide the opportunity to assess the sufficiency of the bank's unencumbered assets that may be used as collateral, of the required type and quality for unforeseen circumstances. |
| The bank's internal policy on liquidity risk management, among other things, provides for maintaining a reserve stock of unencumbered high-quality liquid assets in case of problems with liquidity insufficiency. | The liquidity management policy determines: the size of reserves of unencumbered, liquid assets that can be used to attract additional liquidity in stressful situations; when forming liquidity reserves, takes into account, among other things, assumptions about the size of cash flow mismatches, stress events, the value of assets that may be used by the bank as collateral (that is, the estimated volumes of cash that the bank can receive in case of realization of assets or their use as collateral for secured types of funding) under stress conditions; sources of formation of reserves (the most reliable liquid assets), such as cash and high-quality government bonds or similar instruments, in order to protect themselves from the most serious stress scenarios; procedures for monitoring and analyzing information affecting the bank's ability to form the necessary size of liquid assets; The Management Board analyzes the dynamics of reserves of unencumbered, liquid assets that can be sold or pledged to attract funds upon the occurrence of stress scenarios. |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling liquidity risk. The procedures include a reliable scheme for comprehensive forecasting of cash flows obtained from active, passive and off-balance sheet items during the corresponding range of time periods. | The bank's internal procedures for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling liquidity risk contain: determination of sources of unforeseen (contingent) liquidity needs; determination of the probability or forecast of the occurrence of events that may entail early repayment of obligations, the need for a certain volume of liquidity, related, among other things, to off-balance sheet items; determination and identification of liquidity risk inherent in all subsidiary organizations, if the bank is the parent organization of a banking conglomerate; assessment of each major balance sheet and off-balance sheet item, including the impact of "embedded" options and other contingent obligations that may affect the bank's funding sources and its use of these funds; analysis of the relationship between the bank's exposure to funding risk and market liquidity risk; analysis of the relationship between liquidity risk and other types of risk to which the bank is exposed; liquidity risk management methods taking into account, among other things, various factors, in particular: vulnerability to changes in liquidity needs and funding capacity during the day; daily liquidity need and funding capacity in short- and medium-term time periods up to one year; long-term liquidity need for a period of more than one year; and vulnerability to events, actions and strategies that may place a strong burden on the bank's internal ability to mobilize funds. The liquidity measurement procedures provide for periodic conduct, but at least once a month: assessment of the bank's cash inflow (in comparison with cash outflow); measurement and forecasting of future cash flows on assets, liabilities, off-balance sheet obligations and derivative financial instruments in various time periods (3 months, 6 months, 1 year and 3 years), including taking into account various stress scenarios. |
| The bank has tools for measuring and analyzing quantitative indicators of liquidity risk. | The internal procedures provide for indicators used by the bank to assess the balance sheet structure, future financial flows and the forecast of the liquidity position, taking into account off-balance sheet risks, which allow identifying: needs that may arise as a result of projected outflows of funds relative to ordinary funding sources; funding deficit in various time periods, which in turn is the basis for determining liquidity risk limits, by the size of gaps in various time periods, as well as early warning indicators; forecasting of financial flows over a certain time within several alternative scenarios; analysis of cash flow statements; analysis of "cash flow mismatch" or "liquidity deficit", which relies on assumptions (potential scenarios) about the future behavior of assets, liabilities and off-balance sheet items; gap analysis of the bank's assets and liabilities taking into account the possibility of early repayment of part or all of contingent obligations in the next 6 months; calculation of the cumulative net excess or shortage of liquidity, in certain time intervals; list of assumptions (potential scenarios) that the bank uses in identifying potential liquidity risk, including the probability of repayment of certain assets and liabilities; terms of demand deposits, assets, liabilities and off-balance sheet items with unstable financial flows; availability of alternative sources of funds during periods of liquidity tension. The assumptions used (potential scenarios) are close to potentially possible situations, with a high degree of probability of occurrence, are logical, justified, correspond to the scale of activity carried out by the bank. The selected list of assumptions (potential scenarios) is documented, periodically, but at least once a year, reviewed and approved by the bank's Board of Directors. |
| The bank's internal documents provide for liquidity risk management procedures allowing to determine future cash flows (receipts from the asset side of the balance sheet and expenses for the fulfillment of obligations assumed by the bank). | The procedures for forecasting future cash flows provide for: adoption of realistic assumptions regarding the bank's future liquidity needs (short- and long-term), reflecting the complexity of its activity, products and markets; analysis of the quality of assets that may be used as collateral, for their use as a source of coverage in stressful situations; regulation of the timing of receipt of future cash flows in conjunction with outgoing flows in order to adequately distribute the maturity of funding sources and use of funds; when assessing cash flows arising from the bank's obligations, conducting an assessment of the movement of funding sources under stressful situations. |
| The bank's internal procedures for identifying, measuring, monitoring and controlling liquidity risk, among other things, take into account potential financial flows related to off-balance sheet and other contingent obligations. | The internal procedures provide for: the availability of a forecast of possible consequences for the bank of early fulfillment of obligations, consideration of the nature of obligations and the creditworthiness of the counterparty, as well as potential risk by industries and geographical sectors; management of liquidity risks arising from the bank's off-balance sheet obligations that may occur during periods of stress (special financial companies, financial derivatives, as well as financial obligations); forecast of financial flows related to the fulfillment by the bank of its obligations, including contingent obligations, broken down by types of obligations and on an aggregated basis. The bank has reliable sources of liquidity sufficient to fulfill assumed obligations upon the occurrence of any of the contingent obligations, including upon violation of contractual obligations entailing the commission by the borrower (issuer) of certain actions or refraining from certain actions (hereinafter - covenants); forecast of financial flows related to the revaluation, execution or approaching maturity of contracts on financial derivative instruments, including the probability that counterparties will require additional collateral in case of deterioration of the bank's credit rating or its creditworthiness, or a decrease in the price of the underlying asset; weekly conduct of stress testing on contingent obligations, taking into account early repayment of part or all of the bank's contingent obligations. |
| The asset and liability management division and (or) another collegial body with the corresponding functions and powers controls the amount of necessary money, using the cash flow schedule and the liability repayment schedule to ensure, if necessary, the possibility of stable attraction of money in the market. | The asset and liability management division and (or) another collegial body with the corresponding functions and powers: weekly draws up a cash flow schedule and monitors the cash gap position for the next ten working days; weekly draws up a schedule of maturity of assets and liabilities in accordance with the settlement date and monitors the cash gap position on a daily, weekly and monthly basis; weekly monitors and manages cash gap positions for each currency without conversion into the national currency or another foreign currency; the bank exercises liquidity control taking into account the estimated volume of repayment of the bank's off-balance sheet obligations. |
| The asset and liability management division and (or) another collegial body with the corresponding functions and powers controls cash gap positions by establishing limits. | The Management Board or another collegial body with the corresponding functions and powers of the bank establishes limits on cash gap positions, taking into account the possibility of mobilizing liquid assets in the capital market, including in the interbank market. The asset and liability management division periodically, but at least once a quarter, reviews the limits on cash gap positions taking into account changes in the bank's ability to mobilize liquid assets. |
| The Management Board monitors liquidity risk and the probability of the occurrence of events that may entail early repayment of obligations and needs for a certain volume of liquidity arising in connection with the bank's contractual and non-contractual relations with its special purpose subsidiary organizations. | The Management Board periodically, but at least once a quarter, tracks liquidity positions for special financial companies created for the purposes of securitization or external funding; monthly tracks inflows (assets with approaching maturity) and outflows (liabilities with approaching maturity) of the special purpose organization within its own liquidity forecast and gap analysis, including the liquidity forecast during stress testing; analyzes the impact on the bank's liquidity of the absence (in case of absence) of the necessary level of liquidity in the special purpose organization; assesses its liquidity position taking into account the outflow of money to replenish the liquidity of the subsidiary special purpose organization; when a special financial company created for the purposes of securitization uses assets as a source of funding, analyzes the liquidity needs associated with the occurrence of conditions increasing the volume of the bank's obligations. |
| The Management Board assesses aggregate foreign currency liquidity needs and determines acceptable limits of currency mismatch. | The Management Board conducts a separate analysis of its strategy for each type of currency in which it carries on active operations, considering possible constraints in stress situations, including: access to foreign currency reserve instruments in the domestic market (concluded contracts, availability of market REPO transactions and SWAP operations); the possibility of transferring surplus liquidity from one currency to another (liquid financial instruments in foreign currency). The bank's internal procedures for managing liquidity risk, among other things, take into account: gaps between assets and liabilities in foreign currency; risks associated with concluded hedging transactions and SWAP operations. |
|---|---|
| The bank has developed early warning indicators for the emergence of liquidity risk. | The bank's internal liquidity risk management policy provides for early warning indicators (qualitative or quantitative), which include at least the following: rapid growth of assets, excluding short-term assets financed by potentially volatile liabilities; growing concentration by assets or liabilities; increase in currency mismatches; increase in the gap of the weighted average maturity of assets and liabilities; negative trends or increased risk in one specific product line (for example, increasing volume of overdue payments); significant deterioration of the bank's income, asset quality; downgrade of credit rating; increase in the spread on borrowings or the spread on credit default swaps; growing cost of wholesale or retail funding; increasing outflow of retail deposits; difficulty of access to long-term financing; difficulties with placement of short-term liabilities. The bank's internal documents establish early warning indicators signalling an approaching breach of embedded triggers in certain products or the likelihood of contingent risks occurring, which would force the bank to provide additional liquidity support to that product or transfer assets onto the balance sheet. |
| The Management Board tracks and controls potential liquidity risks and financial needs, both of the bank and of its subsidiaries, business lines and currencies, taking into account legal, regulatory and business constraints on the movement of liquidity. | The liquidity risk management policy provides for: monitoring and control of liquidity risk at the level of both the individual bank and taking into account subsidiaries, including foreign ones, including processes for collecting information to obtain a picture of liquidity risk on a consolidated basis, procedures for identifying restrictions on the transfer of liquidity between the bank and its subsidiaries; availability of the necessary knowledge of the legal and regulatory regimes in each country in which the bank operates, affecting liquidity risk management; availability of working procedures for the placement of liquidity and related resources, taking into account subsidiaries, to the extent such movement of funds is permitted by law; establishment of internal limits on intra-group liquidity risk, limits at the level of the bank's subsidiaries; assumptions (potential scenarios) regarding the transferability of funds and collateral. The bank's assumptions fully take into account regulatory, legal, accounting, credit, tax and internal restrictions for the effective movement of liquidity and collateral, the operational measures necessary for transferring funds and collateral between group members, as well as the time required to effect such a transfer within the framework of these measures. |
| The Management Board ensures active management of access to the capital market, its monitoring and verification by relevant employees. | The Management Board maintains an active presence in capital markets, in accordance with the approved funding strategy; considers the possibility of access to short- and long-term funding markets; identifies alternative sources of financing that would enhance its ability to address liquidity shortfalls during stress periods. The bank's internal procedures define possible sources of financing for the bank in the event of a liquidity shortage, which include, among others: shareholders' funds; growth of deposits; increase in maturities of liabilities; issuance of short- and long-term debt instruments; transfer of funds within the group; sale of subsidiaries; securitization of assets; sale or repo transaction with unencumbered highly liquid assets; utilization of invested funds; borrowing from the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The Management Board regularly analyses and tests its funding options, assessing their effectiveness, in order to provide the bank with liquidity in the short, medium and long term. |
| The Management Board actively manages daily liquidity positions and risks to ensure timely fulfilment of payment and settlement obligations under both normal and stress conditions, thereby contributing to the uninterrupted functioning of payment and settlement systems. | The bank's daily liquidity management strategy includes at least four operational elements: first, tracking daily liquidity positions, relating them to expected actions and available resources, monitoring key positions during the day, allowing additional daily liquidity to be attracted or liquidity outflows to be limited for making important payments; second, acquiring a sufficient volume of daily funds to achieve its daily objectives; third, managing the bank's assets that can be used as collateral, in case of the need to obtain daily borrowed funds. The bank has sufficient collateral that can be used to attract such volume of daily liquidity as is necessary to achieve daily objectives; fourth, availability of procedures in case of an unexpected disruption of daily liquidity flows, business continuity measures. |
| The bank periodically, but at least once a month, conducts stress testing on various short-term and long-term stress scenarios specific to the bank. The Management Board uses the results of the stress test to adjust its liquidity risk management policy and positions, as well as to develop effective contingency action plans. | The Management Board ensures regular stress tests or scenario analysis to identify and quantify exposure to possible liquidity risk. The Management Board periodically, but at least once a quarter, informs the Board of Directors of the results of stress tests and uses the results obtained from the discussion to take measures to eliminate or mitigate consequences in order to limit the bank's potential risks, as well as to create liquidity reserves. The results of stress tests are used in forming the bank's contingency action plan and in determining the strategy and tactics of work in the event of a liquidity shortage. The results of stress tests must be analysed in detail and taken into account when establishing internal limits. |
| The Management Board, if the bank is the parent organization of a banking conglomerate, periodically, but at least once a quarter, conducts an analysis of the impact of stress scenarios on the group-wide liquidity position, as well as on the liquidity position of individual member organizations of the conglomerate and business lines. | The bank's internal documents provide for additional stress tests for organizations that are part of the banking conglomerate and are exposed to significant liquidity risk. During the tests, the bank considers the consequences of scenarios at different time intervals, including in the daily range. The degree and frequency of testing is proportionate to the size of the bank and the potential liquidity risks facing it, as well as the relative weight of the bank in the financial system of the Republic of Kazakhstan. The bank must establish the ability to increase the frequency of testing in special circumstances. |
| When drawing up stress scenarios, the bank takes into account the nature of the business and the exposure of its activities to liquidity risk. | The Management Board considers drafts of various stress scenarios. When conducting stress testing, the bank takes into account short-term and long-term stress scenarios, as well as stress scenarios specific to an individual bank and to the entire market as a whole, including: early repayment of liabilities, taking into account the bank's contingent liabilities upon the occurrence of relevant events, including breach of covenants; simultaneous shortage of liquidity in the market; restriction of access to secured and unsecured financing; restriction of currency convertibility; takes into account the relationship between reductions in market liquidity and a deficit of funding liquidity; the results of the impact on the bank's liquidity of stress tests for other types of risk (credit, operational, market and others). |
| The bank has developed a conservative and prudent approach when establishing assumptions for stress testing. | Depending on the type of scenario, the bank considers a number of assumptions, including the following list: illiquidity of the asset market; outflow of retail funding; (un)availability of secured and unsecured sources of wholesale funding; requirements to post additional margin and collateral requirements; financing terms; contingent requirements under credit lines issued to third parties or subsidiaries; liquidity covering obligations under off-balance-sheet instruments and operations; availability of credit lines issued to the bank; currency convertibility and access to currency markets; access to credit funds of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan; level of future asset growth. The bank periodically, but at least once a year, reviews draft scenarios to ensure that the nature and severity of the tested scenarios correspond to the bank's activities. When reviewing scenarios, the bank takes into account changes in market conditions; changes in the nature and scale of the bank's activities; available actual experience of operating in stress situations. To identify and analyse factors that could have a significant impact on the liquidity profile, the bank may conduct a sensitivity analysis of the stress testing results to certain key assumptions. |
| The Management Board considers the scenarios and assumptions used in stress testing, as well as the results of stress tests. The bank's choice of scenarios and accompanying assumptions are documented and considered alongside the stress testing results. | The Management Board decides how to incorporate the stress test results into the assessment and planning of the accompanying possible funding deficit in the contingency plan. To the extent that projected funding deficits are greater (or projected funding deficits are less) than the bank's acceptable level of liquidity risk, management decides (after consulting with the Board of Directors): whether to adjust its liquidity position or to support the contingency plan |
| The Management Board ensures the functioning of a reliable liquidity risk management framework. | 28 The Management Board, in order to perform its assigned functions for liquidity risk management, among other things: ensures the implementation of necessary procedures in accordance with the liquidity risk management policy approved by the Board of Directors; ensures the bank's fulfilment of daily liquidity obligations, including during a period of liquidity shortage caused by problems within the bank or the market as a whole; ensures the maintenance of a sufficient liquidity reserve (in the form of unencumbered assets), proportionate to the maturity of the bank's balance-sheet and off-balance-sheet operations, the liquidity of its assets and liabilities. The asset and liability management unit determines and maintains the necessary level of liquid assets for their rapid transfer as collateral for loans granted; applies sufficiently prudent assumptions about the realisability of assets and the availability of funding sources for the bank during periods of liquidity tension. |
| The bank's internal documents provide for the creation of an appropriate management information system to provide the Board of Directors and the Management Board with timely information on the bank's liquidity position. The management information system makes it possible to calculate liquidity positions both of the bank and by subsidiary of the bank. | The management information system takes into account: all sources of liquidity risk, including contingent risks, as well as risks associated with the occurrence of events that may entail early repayment of liabilities and the need for a certain amount of liquidity, including those related to off-balance-sheet items; liquidity positions for one operating day, daily (for shorter periods of time), and then for a number of more distant periods of time; various scenarios that cover stress situations; the necessary information for liquidity risk management, including on a consolidated basis, taking into account differences in organizations from the point of view of the system, legal obstacles, time zones, and currencies. The bank has developed a list of reporting criteria defining the scale, form and frequency of providing reports to the Board of Directors, the Management Board and (or) other collegial bodies with relevant functions and powers. The Board of Directors periodically, but at least once a quarter, receives reports on the level of risk comparing current potential liquidity risks with established limits. The Management Board informs the Board of Directors of breaches of liquidity risk limits and takes corrective measures. |
| The Board of Directors ensures that internal control of the liquidity risk management system is carried out by functionally independent, appropriately trained and competent employees. | Employees of the internal audit service possess the necessary experience and skills to assess the effectiveness of the liquidity risk management system in the bank. The internal audit service regularly reviews the implementation by the bank's units and the effectiveness of the agreed liquidity risk management framework. |
Appendix 5 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 27.03.09 No. 64 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 29.12.09 No. 263 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the Republic of Kazakhstan dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old version)
Appendix 5
to the Instruction on requirements for the presence of risk management systems and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for conducting operations with financial instruments
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The Board of Directors has approved the internal policy for managing operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments and price risk | Internal policies for managing operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments regulate: determination of the interest rate risk associated with the structure of the bank's assets (liabilities); determination of the currency risk associated with the structure of the bank's assets (liabilities); determination of the risks inherent in operations with derivative financial instruments; methods for establishing price risk limits and the adequacy of own capital for market risk; models used in measuring the bank's market risk; frequency of submission by the risk management unit to the Board of Directors and the Management Board of a report on the bank's positions on market risk |
| The Board of Directors has approved a dual control policy for the front and back offices, based on the separation of functional duties, in particular between the front office, which carries out transactions, and the back office, which is engaged in reflecting these operations in accounting | The dual control system provides for: separation of the front and back offices; the ability of the back office to verify the terms of operations in the front office in a timely manner; measures to limit possible collusion between participants in the dual control system; prohibition on the same person performing duties simultaneously in the front and back offices and in units carrying out risk monitoring and custody activities |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for ensuring the security of the bank's operations | The internal audit service checks the bank's operations in order to identify and prevent cases of manipulation of income and acceptance of risk inadequate to the size of the bank's own capital and income |
| The bank has an automated system (management of the portfolio of financial instruments, support of operations, processing of accounts and performance of settlements, risk management) | The bank has a technical system for supporting operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments; the bank has a system for collecting information necessary for risk management; the bank has a technical system for performing settlements in money and financial instruments; the internal audit service and external auditors check the accuracy of information provided by the bank's units responsible for maintaining accounting and reporting in the risk management unit |
| The bank has a risk management system for operations with financial instruments, providing the ability to track risks in real time, including on a consolidated basis | The bank processes trading operations separately from other market operations; the bank tracks income/expenses and risks on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations exposed to price risk, including on a consolidated basis taking into account subsidiary organizations; the bank conducts a daily assessment of income/expenses based on the revaluation of futures exchange positions |
| The bank periodically assesses potential market risk and income/expenses taking into account current market prices for financial instruments | The bank excludes from the portfolio of financial instruments financial instruments that do not have a current market valuation or a calculated price determined by the bank's mathematical models; the bank regularly during each operating day conducts an assessment of income/expenses from operations with financial instruments; the risk management unit monitors the correctness of the bank's determination of the fair price for financial instruments; the bank's Board of Directors has approved procedures for determining the value of a financial instrument taking into account risk; the bank conducts an assessment of the value of financial instruments based on a risk assessment model and bringing current prices to market prices, including conducting stress-testing and back-testing; the bank uses the results of risk assessment and regular stress-testing when making decisions to carry out operations with financial instruments |
| The Board of Directors establishes the aggregate limit for operations with financial instruments, the Management Board - limits for individual financial instruments, as well as limits accepted in international practice under the "stop-loss" rule | The Board of Directors periodically determines the aggregate limit and the rules for establishing "stop-loss" limits; the bank's unit carrying out operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments submits the bank's positions on financial instruments to the bank's Management Board; the Board of Directors establishes procedures for determining limits for financial instruments and rules for determining "stop-loss" limits |
| The Management Board has approved risk management procedures for each financial instrument | The Management Board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers establishes position limits for spot, forward, and swap operations accepted in international practice for each type of foreign currency and for all currencies; the asset and liability management unit uses a daily table of maturities of assets and liabilities to manage the maturities of spot and forward operations; the Management Board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers establishes the range of "stop-loss" limits for financial instruments; the internal audit service checks the correctness of the bank's application of the rules for determining "stop-loss" limits |
| The Board of Directors has approved the policy for making decisions on determining the position on price risk, including broken down by financial instruments, taking into account the size of the market and the liquidity of the financial market | The risk management unit conducts an analysis of the adequacy of limits for financial instruments, that is, in accordance with the scale and dynamics of the market for financial instruments and the liquidity of the financial instrument |
| The Board of Directors has approved an investment policy, which defines: investment goals, powers to approve investment operations, as well as investment plans and limits; procedures for separating the functions of conducting investment operations from lending functions in order to prevent operations using confidential information; investment criteria by types of financial instruments and goals of investment activity | |
| The risk management unit analyzes the volume of investments at least once a quarter, the results of which are periodically, but not less than once a quarter, submitted to the Management Board and not less than once every six months - to the Board of Directors | The Management Board has approved procedures for daily monitoring of the bank's investment operations; the monitoring results together with a report on income/expenses on the investment portfolio are submitted monthly to the Management Board and quarterly to the bank's Board of Directors; the risk management unit monitors the bank's investment portfolio by type of financial instrument, issuer, circulation periods, types of currencies and investment goals |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for structuring the investment portfolio so that it maintains stable indicators of investment profitability in the medium and long term | The structuring procedures provide for: revaluation of the investment portfolio at market value at least once a month; assessment of the financial results of investments at least once every six months, taking into account the cost of attracting funds and income/expenses for each reporting period |
| The Board of Directors has established a policy for preventing excessive expenses from the purchase/sale of financial instruments and exercising control over the bank's compliance with this policy | The bank conducts an analysis of changes in income/expenses from operations with financial instruments taking into account the dynamics of their market value |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers monitors interest rate risk and currency risk | The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers: considers issues of asset and liability management; interacts with the risk management unit; weekly tracks interest rate and currency risks on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations; monthly informs the Management Board and quarterly - the Board of Directors on the bank's position on interest rate and currency risks, in dynamics and by types of purchase/sale operations; gives recommendations on establishing interest rates on loans issued and deposits attracted |
| The asset and liability management unit monitors interest rate and currency risk on a consolidated basis | The asset and liability management unit at least once a quarter conducts monitoring of money management in subsidiary organizations and manages the assets and liabilities of the bank and subsidiary organizations on a consolidated basis |
| The Board of Directors has approved a risk assessment policy using methodologies, including international practice for assessing financial instruments by estimated risk (VAR method) | The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers regularly, at least once a quarter, determines the levels of interest rates by maturity; the levels of interest rates are compiled taking into account the influence of factors: the share of doubtful assets with increased risk and bad assets, the size of own capital and provisions, the share of perpetual deposits |
| The asset and liability management unit has a system for collecting and analyzing data for assessing interest rate risks | The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers monitors interest rate risk, the main sources of interest rate risk (differences in maturities, rates of the loan capital market, embedded options); the Board of Directors has approved the policy for making decisions on currency positions in accordance with the analysis of changes in exchange rates |
| The asset and liability management unit and the risk management unit take measures to reduce risk in cases where, in quantitative terms, risks become excessive in comparison with the bank's capital and income | The risk management unit carries out: comprehensive risk management using various analytical methodologies; assessment of interest rate sensitivity, regularly conducts gap analysis, model analysis in which the value at risk (or risk income) is assessed; stress testing, the results of which are used in making strategic decisions in the area of risk acceptance and risk control; analyzes and controls interest rate risk from the point of view of changes in the volumes of periodically recurring income (expenses); the Management Board: has approved procedures for hedging interest rate risk using derivative instruments or other market operations; establishes limits on the gap and the size of interest rate risk, taking into account the adequacy of own capital for risks |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers assesses and analyzes the level of currency risk using methodologies approved by the Management Board | The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers: has an auxiliary system for analyzing changes in exchange rates; regularly analyzes open currency positions or models in which the value of currency instruments is assessed for risk, to determine sensitivity to changes in exchange rates |
| The Board of Directors has approved a policy for reducing risk in cases where currency risks in quantitative terms may exceed the size of the bank's own capital and income | The risk management unit, at least once every six months, conducts stress testing and uses its results in making strategic decisions when accepting risk and controlling risk; the bank uses procedures for adequate and timely hedging of currency risk using transactions with derivative instruments or other market operations in accordance with the asset and liability management policy; the Board of Directors establishes limits on open currency positions and the limit of the net currency position |
Appendix 6 has been amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version); resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old version)
Appendix 6
to the Instruction on requirements for the presence of risk management systems and internal control in second-tier banks
Requirements for ensuring the operational activities of the bank, the functioning of information systems and management information systems
| Name of requirement | Criteria of the requirement |
| The Board of Directors approves and periodically reviews an internal document regulating the operational risk management policy in the bank and containing: definition of operational risk inherent to the bank; the bank's approach to identifying, assessing, monitoring and controlling (reducing) operational risk; the acceptable level of operational risk corresponding to the bank's business strategy. | The bank's Management Board is responsible for: organizing an effective risk management system that allows identifying and assessing potential operational risks; developing and improving the operational risk management policy, internal rules and procedures for operational risk management for all important products, operations and processes; ensuring compliance by the bank's units with the operational risk management policy approved by the bank's Board of Directors. The Management Board ensures: distribution of duties and reporting systems between units responsible for operational risk management, business units and other interested units in order to avoid conflicts of interest; maintenance by employees responsible for operational risk management of interaction with employees responsible for managing credit, market and other risks, as well as with employees of the organization who are responsible for purchasing external services (insurance contracts, outsourcing (engaging third parties to perform work)); communication of the bank's operational risk management policy to the interested units of the bank exposed to significant operational risks. The Management Board reviews the report on the level of operational risk, takes corrective measures within its competence and submits to the Board of Directors a report on the level of operational risk in the bank. |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for the operational technique of providing banking services and their accounting | Internal procedures regulate: the unit providing management of the bank's production activities; the technical procedure for conducting banking operations; accounting of the bank's operations; dual control of the bank's operations and their accounting |
| The bank has an information system for working with cash | The bank reconciles the money in the cash desk with the journal entries stored in the safe (vault); the bank checks cases of surplus (shortage) of cash in the cash desk; the bank exercises control over the work of personnel responsible for providing ATMs with cash |
| The Management Board has established procedures limiting the possibility of incorrect conduct and unreliable reflection in accounting of accepted and issued deposits, receivables and payables | The internal audit service, at least once every six months, conducts checks of units in order to assess their compliance with the operational technique for conducting operations for accepting/placing deposits, receivables/payables |
| The bank has internal rules and guidelines for the planning, development and functioning of electronic data processing systems | The bank has rules and guidelines concerning the planning, development and functioning of electronic data processing systems |
| The bank's Management Board has approved procedures for internal control of the electronic processing system | The bank employee exercising control over the electronic data processing system and responsible for data processing issues has qualifications and experience corresponding to the profile of the work; checks are conducted by the internal audit service in accordance with inspection plans approved by the Management Board; the internal audit service regularly, based on the results of conducted checks, reports the results to the Management Board and the Board of Directors |
| The Management Board has approved a policy for preventing unauthorized access | The information support unit has a system for checking the level of access upon entry and exit from the automated banking system; the Management Board has approved procedures and responsibility of the information support unit for controlling important keys, including electronic keys to information databases |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for implementing planned measures to ensure the preservation of information systems and databases, including force majeure circumstances | The procedures provide for the mandatory presence of: certified software, the manufacturer of which provides subsequent technical maintenance of equipment; separate premises for technical complexes of information databases meeting fire safety requirements; seismic resistance; autonomous power supply; backup computers and network communications; the bank regularly creates backup copies of systemically important program files and data files |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for delegating powers and responsibility in the event of force majeure circumstances | The force majeure procedures provide for rules and guidelines for the computer center and branches in the event of an emergency system failure |
| The information support unit keeps records of actual system problems, taking into account which immediate measures are applied to develop security measures in order to prevent recurrence of problems | The information support unit fills out technical problem record sheets and maintains reporting on them; the information support unit tracks the causes of the problem, notifies the manufacturer of the information system about them and takes corrective measures to prevent their recurrence; the information support unit regularly analyzes the nature of such problems; the information support unit collects and records data on actual damage incurred as a result of system problems and takes measures to prevent their recurrence |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for preventing leakage of confidential information and distortion of information data | The procedures provide for: a list of information data with restricted access; the procedure for obtaining access; the procedure for controlling access to information data; a list of persons having access to information data |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for preventing failures through regular inspections of equipment and checking operation reports | The information support unit, at least once a quarter, conducts inspections of technical complexes ensuring the functioning of the automated database; the information support unit once a quarter provides the Management Board with information on the state of technical complexes |
| The Management Board has approved procedures for preventing unauthorized use of automated database management terminals | The information support unit monitors and identifies users of automated database management terminals, including controlling the types and volumes of operations performed by them for their compliance with the user's functional duties |
| The bank assesses the risks associated with the provision of new banking services or the use of new information technologies | The bank has a system allowing identification of the user's identity; the bank has a set of security measures when providing services for transferring funds via Internet communications |
| The bank's Board ensures the conduct of: the procedure for identification and assessment of operational risk inherent in all significant banking products, operations, processes, and systems; when introducing new products, operations, processes, and systems, the corresponding procedure for assessing their inherent operational risks | |
| Internal bank procedures for identifying operational risk take into account both internal factors (structure, scale of activities, quality of resources, organizational changes, staff turnover) and external factors (changes in the banking sector, technologies) that may adversely affect the achievement of the bank's goals and provide for the use, but not limited to, the following tools for identifying and assessing operational risk: self-assessment or risk assessment. The bank assesses its operational and other activities by comparing them with a list of its vulnerability to potential operational risk. The bank uses a list of control questions and/or conducting working meetings to identify strengths and weaknesses in operational risk management; a risk map, which is a graphical or textual description on which various business and organizational units or business processes are reflected by types of risk. The risk map allows the bank to identify problem areas and the priority of subsequent steps for risk management; risk indicators - quantitative indicators, often financial, that provide an idea of the degree of exposure of the bank to risk. Risk indicators are reviewed regularly and signal changes that may indicate deficiencies in operational risk management. Such indicators include the number of failed or unfinished operations or transactions, an increase in their frequency and/or volume, constant staff rotation (turnover), frequency and/or severity of errors and mistakes, and the time (duration) of downtime of information technology systems. For each indicator, limits are established in the bank to ensure the identification of significant operational risks; measurement. The bank has an internal document containing procedures that ensure the creation of a database on losses, allowing for an adequate assessment of the bank's exposure to operational risk, as well as the development of appropriate measures to control (reduce) operational risk. The bank's procedures for measuring operational risk provide for systematic monitoring and registration of the frequency, severity, and other sufficient information on specific cases of losses. | |
| The Board approves an internal document regulating the procedures for collecting information about damages in the corresponding loss database. | The bank's internal document regulating the procedures for collecting information about damages in the corresponding loss database provides for: the procedure for maintaining the operational loss database, which reflects information about their types and amounts by areas of activity, banking operations, and other, circumstances of their occurrence and identification; the form for presenting information about operational losses and the requirements for the content of the entered information; the use of external operational loss databases. External data on operational loss events include information about the amounts of losses, the business process in which the losses occurred, the causes and circumstances that caused the losses, and other information necessary for assessing operational risk in the bank. |
| --- | --- |
| The Board regularly monitors the operational risk profile and the bank's exposure to major losses (losses) for preventive operational risk management. | The operational risk management report contains: internal financial and operational data; data on compliance with established requirements (limits) for operational risks; data on operational risk events occurring outside the bank and publicly available (reports, press releases), and/or external databases of financial institution losses; results of risk indicator monitoring; identified problems for timely corrective measures to eliminate them. The bank's Board: regularly, but no less than once a quarter, receives reports from the relevant departments of the bank (operational risk management departments or internal audit services); uses reports prepared by external sources (auditors, supervisory bodies) to assess the effectiveness of the internal reporting system. The Board of Directors periodically, but no less than once a half-year, receives the necessary information to assess the level of the bank's exposure to operational risk. |
| The bank's Board reviews the operational risk assessment at the stage of: implementation of a new product (business process); making significant changes to existing products (business processes); introducing significant organizational changes. | The authorized body of the bank makes a decision to approve a product (business process), significant changes to existing products (business processes), and approval of significant organizational changes, taking into account the submitted operational risk assessment. |
| The bank's Board of Directors receives management reporting no less than once a half-year, allowing it to analyze the degree of operational risk impact on the bank. | The Board of Directors analyzes the following management reporting: on damage broken down by risk objects (areas of activity) compared to the same period of the previous year; on damage broken down by causes, types of events, consequences of operational risk compared to the same period of the previous year. |
| The bank has developed internal rules reflecting, including, risk management related to outsourcing - engaging third-party organizations and individuals to perform tasks necessary for the bank. | The internal rules reflecting, including, risk management related to outsourcing include: requirements for the outsourcing contract (agreement), including issues of ownership, data confidentiality, termination of rights, resolution of disputes; procedures for managing and monitoring risks related to outsourcing, including the financial condition of the service provider; distribution of rights, duties, and responsibilities between the bank and the external service provider. |
| The Board of Directors ensures that the internal audit service conducts an effective and comprehensive review of the operational risk management policy. | The internal audit service reviews the implementation by the bank's departments and the effectiveness of the agreed operational risk management structure at least once a year. |
In Appendix 7, changes were made in accordance with the Resolution of the Board of the AFN RK dated 10.27.06 No. 234 (see previous edition).
Appendix 7
to the Instruction on the requirements for having risk management systems and internal control in second-tier banks Basic criteria of the Instruction requirements
| Organization of the risk management and internal control system |
| The board of directors has approved the policy on managing conflicts of interest in the bank |
| The board of directors approves the policy on monitoring the bank's transactions with persons related to the bank by special relationships |
| The internal audit service exercises control over compliance with the bank's internal rules and procedures, implementation of internal and external auditors' reports, enforcement measures and other requirements of the authorized body |
| The credit committee, which establishes and approves requirements for bank borrowing operations, monitors loan quality and gives preliminary authorization for the issuance of loans exceeding five percent of the bank's own capital |
| The asset and liability management committee establishes and approves the rules and procedures for borrowing, conducting operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments, investing and issuing bank guarantees, and also determines benchmarks for asset diversification, profitability, liquidity and capital adequacy |
| The board of directors monthly analyzes the following reports: consolidated balance sheet and income and expense statement of the bank compared with the same period of the previous year and planned performance indicators; investment reports: with a grouping of financial instruments by their types and indicating book value, market value, yield and total amount of purchases and sales; reports on the dynamics of classified loans and the volumes of provisions formed against them; a report on new loans received by persons related to the bank by special relationships. The board of directors quarterly analyzes the following reports: a brief analysis of the bank's position on interest rate risk; a brief analysis of the bank's exposure to the risk of fluctuations in foreign exchange rates; a brief analysis of the bank's current and projected needs for own capital |
| The board of directors conducts control with clarification of the reasons for non-fulfillment of enforcement measures and other requirements of the authorized body, including the action plan to eliminate deficiencies in the bank's activities |
| The board of directors analyzes annual reports on the functional duties of the bank's managerial employees |
| The board of directors compares the lending terms of members of the board of directors, managerial employees, persons who are major participants of the bank, and other persons related to the bank by special relationships with the servicing of other borrowers of the bank, including for the purpose of verifying the fact of granting preferential terms |
| The board of directors monthly certifies the register of persons related to the bank by special relationships |
| The board of directors annually analyzes the activities of the management board for the achievement by the bank of the goals planned for the current financial year |
| The board of directors, within its powers, may apply measures to members of the bank's management board in the event of a discrepancy between the bank's performance results and the target indicators for the current year |
| The diagram of the bank's organizational and functional structure, among other things, regulates: the powers and duties of the bank's unit or person for risk management responsible for independent assessment and analysis of the main risks associated with the operations conducted by the bank; the structure of the bank's management bodies corresponding to their functional duties; the job duties and powers of each managerial employee of the bank |
| The procedure for assessing the performance of a managerial employee of the bank (except for members of the management board) during the reporting year, including the application of measures or bringing to liability for the bank's failure to meet the bank's performance targets |
| The preparation of annual budgets and strategic plans is carried out by the management board taking into account the current and future competitive, economic environment and regulatory legal framework, the additionally required amount of the bank's capital and access to new long-term sources of financing of the bank's capital |
| The risk management policy provides for: provisions regulating the powers and functional duties of the bank's managerial employees, including those providing for the ensuring of double control of the correctness of banking operations and control of the risk associated with them |
| The internal audit service conducts checks of managerial employees to identify concentration of powers and functions for managing the bank's activities among them |
| The risk management and internal control policies determine the powers and functional duties for risk management of members of the board of directors, the management board and responsible employees of the bank |
| The list of management information submitted to the board of directors and the management board of the bank is sufficient for the proper performance by the board of directors and the management board of the bank of their own functional duties on risk management |
| The personnel of the risk management unit meet the qualification requirements, including those providing for the presence of relevant qualifications for the performance of functional duties on risk management |
| The functional duties of the bank's personnel of the risk management unit and the internal audit service correspond to the operations they conduct |
| The bank's internal control policy determines: all risks to which the bank is exposed; the scale and frequency of internal control; the rating system used in conducting internal control; requirements for drawing up a plan for conducting the bank's internal control |
| The internal audit service, in accordance with audit policies, conducts regular internal audits of all bank units whose functions provide for conducting banking operations |
| The personnel of the internal audit service possess work experience and the necessary knowledge about the activities of the bank's units in which audits are conducted |
| The bank's internal policies provide for the right of the internal audit service to access all necessary documents related to the activities of the audited unit, including those constituting commercial, other or confidential information |
| The bank's internal policies on internal control establish the independence of the performance of functional duties from managerial employees or other bank units and the accountability of the internal audit service to the board of directors |
| The internal audit service, together with the bank's external auditor, holds joint meetings to discuss deficiencies in the bank's internal control system |
| The internal audit service participates in discussions of issues on the introduction of new products or services |
| The internal control policy provides for optimal timeframes for the internal audit service to submit the results of each audit to the board of directors and the management board of the bank |
| The powers of the internal audit service provide for the preparation of proposals based on the results of the conducted audit, the implementation of which is mandatory for the units, while the methods and conditions for their implementation are determined directly by the bank's units |
| The internal audit service monitors the ongoing and planned measures taken by the bank's units based on the results of internal control, with the aim of their optimal implementation |
| The internal policies establish the bank unit that monthly tracks the bank's income (expenses), including in dynamics, broken down by types of banking services, territorial and functional units of the bank, and also quarterly on a consolidated basis |
| The internal policies provide for the powers of the bank's units to manage income (expenses) related to the unit's activities, within the aggregate limits established by the board of directors |
| The management board without fail conducts an analysis of the dynamics of own capital and potential risks associated with the planned provision of new banking services |
| The management board, within the aggregate risk limits established by the board of directors, determines risk limits for each of the bank's units carrying out financial operations |
| The management board has approved the policy on setting interest rates on attracted deposits and issued loans |
| The policy on setting interest rates, among other things, regulates the procedure for setting interest rates |
| The risk management unit monitors the financial activities of subsidiary organizations and banking holdings |
| The risk management unit has the authority to check operations conducted by the bank with banking holdings |
| The board of directors establishes requirements for the terms of transactions conducted with banking holdings |
| The management board regularly analyzes information about the risks to which persons that are a banking holding are exposed, as well as the risks assumed by banking holdings that may affect the bank's activities |
| The bank's units assess the compliance of their activities with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, the bank's internal rules and documents |
| The internal audit service assesses the possibility of additional risks of the bank related to compliance with regulatory legal acts regulating banking activities when introducing new types of banking services |
| The board of directors has approved the forms and deadlines for the management board to submit financial and management reporting to the board of directors and shareholders of the bank, ensuring the possibility of assessing the bank's financial indicators |
| The board of directors analyzes the conclusions of external auditors on improving internal control and risk management |
| The bank's accounting and reporting policies, among other things, provide for the audit of the bank to check the following issues: correctness of processing daily balance sheets; compliance of the bank's accounting policy with international financial reporting standards; presence of facts of unjustified accounting manipulations with financial statements; correctness of forming provisions (reserves) for classified assets and contingent liabilities; compliance of accounting and reporting methods with the requirements established in the bank's accounting policy; completeness and correctness of the bank's disclosure in the annual report of the structure and size of risks of the bank and its subsidiary organizations |
| The risk management unit forecasts the impact on own capital adequacy, profitability and liquidity of the following factors: falling oil prices; lowering of the sovereign debt rating of the Republic of Kazakhstan by one notch over three months and by two notches over one year; foreign banks raised rates and shortened terms on loans issued to banks of the Republic of Kazakhstan; devaluation of the tenge |
| The risk management unit conducts regular analysis of: the bank's balance sheet and off-balance sheet reports, as well as income and expense accounts sensitive to changes in economic conditions; balance sheet and off-balance sheet reports, as well as income and expense accounts of subsidiary organizations and persons that are a banking holding; increase in rates and reduction in maturities of syndicated loans and other external loans received by the bank; possible reduction in the volume of deposits of legal entities and individuals; reduction in liquidity, changes in prices of financial instruments; level of non-repayment of loans granted to entities of the oil and gas sector and its infrastructure; level of non-repayment of loans granted in foreign currency |
| Conducting bank borrowing operations |
| The management board monitors the bank's and its subsidiary organizations' exposure to credit risk on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations |
| The board of directors has established procedures for assessing loan quality |
| The board of directors and the management board have established procedures for forming provisions and writing off classified assets |
| The management board at least once a month analyzes the quality of assets and the level of the bank's credit risk on balance sheet and off-balance sheet liabilities, determines the degree of influence of credit risk on the bank's financial position |
| The personnel of the bank's credit unit perform functional duties in compliance with procedures limiting the risk of conflict of interest |
| The internal audit service at least once a year conducts a check of compliance by employees of the credit unit with policies and procedures limiting the risk of conflict of interest |
| The management board analyzes credit risks associated with the bank's offering of new banking services or provision of banking services in new sectors or regions of the economy |
| The internal audit service checks the compliance of the powers of the bank's managerial employees making decisions on issuing a loan with their job powers defined in the bank's internal regulations |
| The regulation on the bank's managerial employees authorized to make decisions on issuing loans determines the qualification and professional requirements for the person authorized to make decisions on issuing loans |
| The lending documentation policy determines: conditions subject to mandatory reflection in bank loan agreements, including the disclosure by borrowers of information on financial position and other information that may negatively affect the borrower's ability to timely and fully fulfill obligations under the loan; conducting a legal examination of the legislation of a foreign state - when lending to non-residents of the Republic of Kazakhstan |
| The board of directors approves criteria: for assessing the compliance of the borrower's accounting policy with current accounting and reporting standards, the reliability of borrowers' financial statements; for assessing the correctness of the assessment of the financial condition of the borrower's parent and subsidiary organizations; for assessing the reputation and business image of the borrower; for assessing the state of the industry and the efficiency of the borrower's production technology; for checking the use of borrowed funds by the borrower |
| Assessments of the sources of loan repayment by the borrower, including taking into account the following factors: production prospects, sales dynamics, quality of short-term assets; the amount of income that can be allocated to repay debt compared to debt servicing requirements; assessments of the effectiveness of the borrower's business plan |
| The borrower monitoring policy and procedures determine the procedure for: the bank's conducting financial analysis of borrowers - legal entities, including for loans granted against real estate; the bank's tracking of changes in the financial position of borrowers based on the collection and analysis of data from financial statements; the bank's checking, through financial analysis, of the effectiveness of the use of borrowed funds; checking risks the amount of which exceeds five percent of the bank's own capital, including balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations; control over the consolidated credit risk of the borrower, including taking into account its parent and subsidiary organizations |
| The policy for monitoring borrowers with an unsatisfactory financial position determines: the concept of "borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position", including one meeting the criteria for assessing financial position provided for by regulatory legal acts of the authorized body on asset classification; methods of controlling loans granted to a borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position; methods of recovering doubtful with increased risk and bad loans; the procedure for informing the bank's branches about borrowers whose loans are classified as doubtful with increased risk and bad; the procedure for monthly tracking of indicators of the financial and production activities of a borrower with an unsatisfactory financial position, including with the involvement of independent experts or auditors; measures for developing a restructuring plan for doubtful with increased risk and bad loans |
| The risk management unit periodically analyzes the effectiveness of procedures for assessing the sufficiency of collateral, which determine: rules for calculating the sufficiency of collateral (for example, the ratio of the loan value to the collateral value, revaluation of collateral); operational methods for assessing the sufficiency of collateral taking into account changes in the borrower's production performance indicators, preservation of collateral, including its exposure to force majeure circumstances; frequency of checking the collateral item; frequency of revaluation of real estate provided as collateral, in particular, for loans issued to legal entities for the acquisition of real estate, for credit lines, letters of credit and guarantees; frequency of revaluation of the value of securities held to maturity as collateral; frequency and methods of assessing the financial position of the guarantor |
| Conducting operations with financial instruments |
| The double control system provides for: separation of front and back offices; the ability of the back office to timely verify the terms of operations in the front office; measures to limit possible collusion between participants in the double control system; prohibition on the same person performing duties simultaneously in the front and back offices and units carrying out risk monitoring and custody activities |
| The internal audit service checks the bank's operations in order to identify and prevent cases of manipulation of income and assumption of risk inadequate to the size of the bank's own capital and income |
| The bank has a technical system for supporting operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments |
| The bank has a technical system for conducting settlements in money and financial instruments |
| The bank has a system for collecting information necessary for risk management |
| The internal audit service and external auditors check the accuracy of information provided by the bank's units responsible for accounting and reporting to the risk management unit |
| The risk management unit monitors the correctness of the bank's determination of the fair price for financial instruments |
| The board of directors periodically determines the aggregate limit and rules for setting stop-loss limits |
| The bank unit carrying out operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments submits the bank's positions on financial instruments to the bank's management board |
| The board of directors establishes procedures for determining limits on financial instruments and rules for determining stop-loss limits |
| The management board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers establishes position limits for spot, forward, swap operations accepted in international practice for each type of foreign currency and for all currencies |
| The asset and liability management unit uses a daily maturity schedule of assets and liabilities to manage the maturities of spot and forward operations |
| The board of directors has approved the investment policy, which defines: investment objectives, powers to approve investment operations, as well as investment plans and limits; procedures for separating the functions of conducting investment operations from lending functions in order to prevent operations using confidential information; investment criteria by types of financial instruments, objectives of investment activities |
| The management board has approved procedures for daily monitoring of the bank's investment operations |
| The monitoring results together with the report on income/expenses on the investment portfolio are monthly submitted to the management board and the board of directors of the bank |
| The risk management unit monitors the bank's investment portfolio by type of financial instrument, issuer, circulation periods, types of currencies and investment objectives |
| The structuring procedures provide for: at least once a month, revaluation of the investment portfolio at market value; at least once every six months, assessment of the financial results of investments, taking into account the cost of attracting funds, income/expenses for each reporting period |
| The bank analyzes changes in income/expenses from operations with financial instruments taking into account the dynamics of their market value |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers: considers issues of asset and liability management; interacts with the risk management unit; weekly tracks liquidity risk, interest rate risk and currency risk on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations; weekly informs the management board and monthly - the board of directors on the bank's position on liquidity risk, interest rate and currency risks, in dynamics and by types of purchase/sale operations; gives recommendations on setting interest rates on issued loans and attracted deposits |
| The management board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers receives and analyzes information affecting the bank's ability to form the necessary amount of liquid assets |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers determines and maintains the necessary level of liquid assets for their quick transfer to pledge as collateral for loans provided |
| The asset and liability management unit constantly monitors sources of liquid assets, including for attracting national and foreign currencies as a result of conducting spot, forward and swap operations accepted in international practice |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers: regularly draws up a cash flow schedule daily and monitors the gap position on cash for the next ten working days; regularly (for example, weekly) draws up a maturity schedule of assets and liabilities in accordance with the settlement date and monitors the cash gap position on a daily, weekly and monthly basis; monitors and manages cash gap positions for each currency without conversion into the national currency or another foreign currency |
| The bank exercises liquidity control taking into account the expected volume of repayment of off-balance sheet banking operations |
| The management board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers establishes limits on cash gap positions, taking into account the possibility of mobilizing liquid assets from other banks |
| The asset and liability management unit regularly reviews the limits on cash gap positions taking into account changes in the bank's ability to mobilize liquid assets |
| The bank conducts daily banking operations so that the necessary amounts of money that are mobilized for each working day do not significantly exceed the daily amount of attraction of liquid assets |
| The bank regularly monitors the diversification of sources of attraction of liquid assets (internal and external sources) and the types of operations on the basis of which they are attracted |
| The bank regularly monitors the ability to form liquid assets in foreign currency necessary for repaying obligations in foreign currency |
| Asset and liability management unit and/or collegial body with relevant functions and powers: has an auxiliary system for analyzing changes in exchange rates; regularly analyzes open currency positions or models in which the value of currency instruments with risk is assessed, to determine sensitivity to changes in exchange rates |
|---|
| Ensuring the bank's operational activities, functioning of information systems and management information systems |
| Internal procedures regulate: the unit providing management of the bank's production activities; the technical procedure for conducting banking operations; accounting of the bank's operations; dual control of the bank's operations and their accounting |
| The bank reconciles cash in the vault with journal entries kept in a safe (vault) |
| The bank checks cases of surplus (shortage) of cash in the vault |
| The bank monitors the work of personnel responsible for providing cash to ATMs |
| The internal audit service, at least once every six months, conducts inspections of units to assess their compliance with the operational technique for conducting operations on accepting/placing deposits, accounts receivable/payable |
| The bank has rules and manuals concerning the planning, development and functioning of electronic data processing systems |
| The bank employee exercising control over the electronic data processing system and responsible for data processing issues has qualifications and experience corresponding to the work profile |
| Inspections are conducted by the internal audit service in accordance with inspection plans approved by the board |
| The internal audit service regularly, based on the results of inspections, reports the results to the board and board of directors |
| The information support unit has a system for checking the access level upon entry and exit from the automated banking system |
| The board has approved procedures and responsibilities of the information support unit for controlling important keys, including electronic ones, to information databases |
| The procedures provide for the mandatory presence of: certified software, the manufacturer of which provides subsequent technical maintenance of equipment; separate premises for technical complexes of information databases meeting fire safety requirements; seismic resistance; autonomous power supply; backup computers and network communications |
| The bank regularly creates backup copies of systemically important software files and data files |
| Force majeure procedures provide rules and manuals for the computer center and branches in case of an emergency system failure |
| The information support unit fills out technical problem logs and maintains reporting on them |
| The information support unit tracks the causes of problems, notifies the manufacturer of the information system about them and takes corrective measures to prevent their recurrence |
| The information support unit regularly analyzes the nature of such problems |
| The procedures provide for: a list of information data with restricted access; the procedure for obtaining access; the procedure for controlling access to information data; the list of persons having access to information data |
| The information support unit, at least once a quarter, conducts inspections of technical complexes ensuring the functioning of the automated database |
| The information support unit quarterly provides the board with information on the state of technical complexes |
| The information support unit monitors and identifies users of automated database management terminals, including controlling the types and volumes of operations performed by them for compliance with the user's functional duties |
| The bank has a system allowing identification of the user's identity |
| The bank has a set of security measures when providing services for transferring funds via Internet communications |
| The information support unit collects and records data on actual damage incurred as a result of system problems and takes measures to prevent their recurrence |
Appendix 8 was amended in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN RK of 27.10.06 No. 234 (see old version)
Appendix 8
to the Instruction on requirements for
the presence of risk management systems
and internal control in second-tier banks
Additional criteria for the requirements of the Instruction
| Organization of the Risk Management and Internal Control System |
| The bank's activity strategy has been approved by the board of directors |
| The bank's corporate strategy defines the bank's short-term and long-term activity goals. The timeframes for short-term and long-term activity goals are determined by banks independently |
| The bank's short-term and long-term strategies are drawn up and continuously improved in order to exclude factors that previously had a negative impact on the bank's activities |
| The board of directors approves the policy for monitoring the bank's operations related to risks (credit risk, interest rate risk, liquidity loss risk, currency risk) and conducted by the bank's management board, in order to exclude the possibility of carrying out operations that contradict the bank's strategy, policies and procedures or that create preferential conditions for persons connected with the bank by special relations |
| The bank's unit performing risk management functions uses the methodology for assessing capital adequacy, profitability and liquidity in the event of negative dynamics in world commodity and financial markets |
| The management board identifies and analyzes internal and external economic factors representing potential and possible risk, assesses the degree of their influence on the bank's financial indicators |
| With respect to the aggregate limits approved by the board of directors, the management board determines limits on the permissible size of risks separately by types of banking operations, and takes effective measures to control the bank's compliance with these limits |
| The management board controls compliance with aggregate limits by types of risks on the basis of their monthly calculation |
| The management board controls compliance by the bank's units with policies on managing possible and potential risks, and monitors compliance by the bank's units with the sizes of risks within the limits established for them |
| The management board applies the policy of distributing risks by types of operations it conducts, that is, forming the structure and volume of banking operations taking into account the risk associated with them in order to preserve the necessary level of capital adequacy and solvency, and controls their fulfillment by the bank's responsible units |
| The bank has an organizational-functional and operational structure that ensures implementation of the diversification policy |
| The formats of information on the bank's current financial condition and the risks assumed by it are standardized in the form of specific management reporting forms, which, among other things, identify and measure credit, interest rate risks, liquidity loss risk, currency risks, country (transfer) risks, and also determine the degree of exposure to risks and their maintenance within established limits |
| The units assess (accrue) the bank's expected income, taking into account the risk assumed |
| The risk management policies approved by the board of directors, among other things, define procedures for monitoring the bank's financial indicators and assumed risks on a consolidated basis |
| The board of directors confirms risk limits for subsidiary organizations within the aggregate risk limits of the bank determined by the board of directors |
| Automation of the process of registering and processing applications for consumer credit |
| Availability of a historical database on consumer credits for the last 5 years |
| Availability of an internal policy defining the conditions for granting, the approval procedure and monitoring of consumer credits |
| Availability of an internal automated mathematical or statistical model for scoring assessment of borrowers and a rating system |
| Annual verification of the quality of the scoring models used |
| The policy defines the procedure for: assessing the borrower's creditworthiness using credit scoring based on qualitative and quantitative characteristics, including: - presence of the borrower's permanent and sufficient income; - place of work and position; - duration of work in the current profession; - presence of immovable property acceptable as collateral; - presence of loan debt, including to other banks; - payment discipline on bank loans; - presence of a credit history; establishing the borrower's internal credit rating; determining the reliability of data submitted by the borrower; monitoring and classification of consumer credits; formation of provisions for consumer credits |
| Internal control |
| The bank's board of directors is responsible for creating and ensuring the functioning of an adequate and effective internal control system |
| Members of the board of directors have the necessary knowledge and experience in the field of banking activity and related risks |
| The bank's management and heads of structural units are responsible for the adequate functioning of the internal control system |
| Management takes measures ensuring: performance of internal control work by highly qualified employees possessing the necessary experience and technical capabilities |
| The board of directors: 1) periodically discusses with the bank's management the effectiveness of the internal control system; 2) promptly reviews the assessment of internal control made by management, the internal audit service and external auditors; 3) conducts periodic measures ensuring prompt fulfillment by management of the recommendations and comments expressed by auditors and supervisory bodies regarding deficiencies in the internal control system; 4) conducts periodic verification of the adequacy of the bank's strategy and risk limits |
| Management is responsible for fulfilling the instructions of the board of directors, including implementation of the strategy and policy, and creation of an effective internal control system |
| The bank's internal rules describe the organizational structure with a clear indication of the spheres of authority, reporting and an effective information exchange system throughout the entire bank |
| Management delegates authority to develop specific rules and procedures in the sphere of internal control to the heads of the relevant unit |
| Management controls the development and execution of proper rules and procedures |
| The bank's management takes measures ensuring performance of internal control work by highly qualified employees possessing the necessary experience and technical capabilities |
| Operating procedures are described in clearly drafted internal documents accessible to all interested employees of the bank |
| The bank's employees effectively perform their duties and bring to the attention of management at the proper level any operational problems, cases of non-compliance with professional ethics or other violations of procedures or abuses |
| Constant assessment by management of risks affecting the achievement of set goals, and response to changing circumstances and conditions |
| Review of the internal control system for the purpose of effectively tracking new or previously uncontrolled risks |
| Assessment of new financial instruments and market operations appearing on the financial market and analysis of risks associated with this activity |
| Risk assessment identifies and considers internal factors (such as complexity of the organizational structure, nature of banking activity, level of employee qualifications, organizational changes and staff turnover) and external factors (such as changes in economic conditions and the situation in the banking sphere, technological innovations) that may have a negative impact on the bank's achievement of set goals |
| The exercise of control extends to all employees of the bank, including management and employees working with clients |
| The bank's management on an ongoing basis receives confirmation of the compliance of all aspects of the bank's activity with the bank's internal documents, and information that the content of the internal documents continues to remain adequate |
| Separation among several employees of authority for: authorized payment of money and its actual payment; keeping accounts reflecting clients' operations and accounts reflecting the bank's own operations; keeping operations relating to the "banking" portfolio and the "dealer" portfolio; informal presentation of information to clients about their positions while simultaneously conducting marketing operations with the same clients; assessment of the adequacy of credit documentation when granting a loan and monitoring of the borrower after loan issuance; other areas involving the emergence of a significant conflict of interest not mitigated by other factors |
| Areas of potential conflict of interest are identified, minimized, and an independent third party carries out their constant monitoring |
| Availability of adequate information and its effective transmission |
| Information possesses the following qualities: relevant, reliable, timely, accessible and formatted |
| Information includes internal financial and operational data, data on compliance with the established requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and normative legal acts, as well as information coming from the external market about events and conditions relevant to decision-making |
| Internal information is part of the accounting process based on the established procedure for storing accounting records |
| Development of internal backup procedures and recovery procedures, rules for developing and acquiring programs, maintenance procedures (change control) and control over the security of physical/logical access |
| Control over software consists of computer steps in software applications and other manual procedures controlling the processing of operations and other types of banking activity |
| Development of a contingency action plan using duplicate devices located outside the bank, including restoration of systems critical to the bank's activity supported by an external service provider |
| Periodic testing of the bank operations recovery program for its feasibility in cases of unforeseen circumstances |
| The bank's management creates effective information transmission systems (documents defining the bank's operational policy and activity procedures, information on the bank's actual operational activity) |
| Creation of the bank's organizational structure ensuring an adequate flow of information - upward, downward and horizontally |
| Information coming from the bottom up provides the board of directors and management with the necessary information about risks assumed in the course of activity and the bank's current condition |
| Information directed downward ensures communication of the bank's goals, its strategy, established procedures and procedures to middle and lower management and rank-and-file employees |
| Employees of various units, including departments carrying out banking operations, financial control and internal audit, monitor the effectiveness of internal control |
| The bank's management distributes the duties of employees responsible for specific aspects of monitoring |
| Monitoring includes periodic assessment of the entire internal control process |
| The frequency of monitoring of various types of the bank's operations is determined based on the risks associated with them, the frequency and nature of changes occurring in the conditions of the bank's activity |
| The internal audit service is part of the constant monitoring of the internal control system and provides an independent assessment of the adequacy of established rules and procedures, as well as their compliance |
| The internal audit service is independent of the bank's daily work and has access to all types of operations conducted by the bank, including its branches and subsidiary structures |
| Information about deficiencies in the internal control system and ineffectively controlled risks is brought to the attention of the relevant person(s) immediately upon identification; serious issues are brought to the attention of the board of directors |
| The relevant managers ensure timely correction of deficiencies |
| The internal audit service conducts follow-up checks or carries out other types of monitoring and immediately informs the board of directors about all uncorrected deficiencies |
| The bank's board of directors creates a system for tracking internal control deficiencies and measures taken to eliminate them |
| The board of directors periodically receives reports summarizing all problems identified by the internal control system |
| The board of directors regularly checks the internal control system to ensure orderly conduct of business (with reference to specific goals) |
| The board of directors regularly checks the existence of a risk management system |
| The board of directors ensures the existence of procedures for identifying and adequately controlling the risks to which the bank is exposed in achieving its set goals; testing the integrity, reliability and timeliness of financial information and management information; monitoring compliance with laws and normative legal acts, supervisory policy and internal plans, methodologies and procedures |
| Management maintains an organizational structure with distribution of responsibility, authority and reporting relationships and ensures effective exercise of delegated authority |
| Management is responsible for developing risk management procedures |
| Management establishes appropriate internal control methodologies and tracks the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system |
| The main duties of the internal audit service are: checking and assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of the internal control system; checking the application and effectiveness of risk management procedures and risk assessment methodology; checking management and financial information systems, including the electronic information system and electronic banking services; checking the accuracy and reliability of accounting records and financial reports; checking the means of preserving assets; checking the bank's system for assessing its capital in connection with its risk assessment; assessing the effectiveness of operations; testing both transactions and the functioning of specific internal control procedures; checking systems established to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, codes of conduct and implementation of methodologies and procedures; testing the reliability and timeliness of financial reporting; carrying out special checks |
| Management ensures constant and complete awareness of the internal audit service about new developments, products and operational changes to ensure identification of related risks at an early stage |
| Internal audit is carried out by the internal audit service, which has full-time staff |
| The internal audit service carries out activity on its own initiative in all departments, units and services of the bank |
| The internal audit service has the right to report the data and assessments it has obtained and to disclose this information within the bank |
| The internal audit service operates under the direct control of the board of directors |
| The head of the internal audit service has the authority to contact directly and on his own initiative the board of directors, the chairman of the board of directors or, if necessary, external auditors in accordance with the rules defined by each bank in its Regulation on the Internal Audit Service. This informing may concern the adoption by the bank's management of decisions contradicting the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the bank's internal documents |
| The internal audit service is subject to independent review. This review is carried out by an independent party, such as an external auditor |
| Objectivity and impartiality imply that the internal audit service strives to avoid conflicts of interest |
| The staff of the internal audit service should be periodically rotated |
| Auditors recruited from within the bank should not engage in auditing the activity or functions they carried out during the last twelve months at this bank |
| Impartiality requires that the internal audit service not be involved in the bank's operations or in the selection and implementation of internal control measures |
| Management may request the opinion of the internal audit service on specific issues concerning compliance with internal control principles |
| In order to achieve effectiveness, management may request an opinion when considering reorganization issues, the most important issues of activity, creation of new units, including creation or reorganization of risk control systems, information management systems or information technologies |
| However, the development and implementation of these measures remains the sphere of ultimate responsibility of management: the advisory function is an additional task that does not interfere with the performance of the main tasks or the responsibility and independence of the internal audit service |
| Subsequent conclusions of the internal audit service contain recommendations concerning deficiencies and shortcomings, and proposals for improving internal control |
| The professional competence of each internal auditor, as well as their motivation and continuous training, are necessary conditions for improving the effectiveness of the internal audit service's work |
| Professional competence is assessed taking into account the nature of the role performed and the auditor's ability to collect information, analyze, assess and communicate |
| The internal audit service checks the bank's units, including the activity of branches and subsidiary enterprises, as well as activity involving external contractors |
| Internal audit includes checking and assessing the adequacy and effectiveness of internal control and risk management systems |
| The internal audit service assesses: the bank's compliance with risk policies and control; the reliability (including integrity, accuracy and completeness) and timeliness of financial and management information; the continuity and reliability of electronic information systems; the functioning of the human resources department; the existence of norms of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the bank's internal provisions concerning the bank's operations, including methodologies, principles, rules and instructions of the authorized body regarding the organizational structure and management of the bank |
| The bank determines the person or department responsible for checking the capital assessment procedure |
| The Regulation on the Internal Audit Service establishes: the goals and scope of activity of the internal audit service; the status of the internal audit service in the organization, its authority, duties and relations with other services; the accountability of the internal audit service. |
| The Regulation on the Internal Audit Service is approved by the board of directors |
| In the Regulation on the Internal Audit Service, management grants the right of initiative and permits the employee of the internal audit service to have direct access to any employee of the bank, to check any activity or any unit of the bank, and also to have access to any records, files or data of the bank, including management information and minutes of all advisory and decision-making bodies that may relate to the performance of his duties |
| The Regulation on the Internal Audit Service provides for the conditions under which the internal audit service may be engaged in providing consulting services or performing other special assignments |
| Internal audit includes, among other things: financial audit, the purpose of which is to assess the reliability of the accounting and information system and the financial reports prepared on their basis; compliance audit, the purpose of which is to assess the quality and compliance of systems created to ensure compliance with laws, subordinate acts, methodologies and procedures; operational audit, the purpose of which is to assess the quality and compliance of other systems and procedures, analyze organizational structures and assess sufficiency for performing assigned duties; management audit, the purpose of which is to assess the quality of management's approaches to risks and control within the bank's set goals |
| The management of the internal audit service prepares a plan for performing all assigned tasks |
| The audit plan includes the schedule and frequency of planned internal audit work |
| The audit plan is based on a methodological assessment of risk control |
| In the risk management assessment, the internal auditor's perception of the bank's main activity and related risks is documented |
| The management of the internal audit service records in writing the principles of the risk assessment methodology and regularly updates them to reflect changes in the internal control system or in the work process taking into account new areas of activity |
| In the risk analysis conducted by the internal audit service, the bank's areas of activity and units are checked, as well as the internal control system |
| Based on the results of the risk analysis, a multi-year audit plan is prepared taking into account the degree of risks inherent in a particular type of activity |
| The plan takes into account expected developments and innovations, the usually higher degree of risk in new types of activity and the intention to subject all important types of activity and units to audit within reasonable timeframes |
| The audit plan includes time for performing other tasks, such as specific checks, issuing conclusions and training. This plan also includes a section listing the necessary resources for staffing and other needs |
| The audit plan is drawn up by the internal audit service and approved by the board of directors |
| For performing each audit task, an audit program should be prepared. The audit program sets out the purposes of conducting the audit |
| All procedures for performing audit tasks are documented in the relevant working papers. They reflect the results of the checks conducted with emphasis on the assessments in the conclusion |
| For each assignment, a written audit conclusion is prepared |
| The audit conclusion sets out the purpose and scope of the audit. It also includes conclusions and recommendations |
| The bank's management should ensure timely fulfillment of the recommendations of the internal audit service |
| The internal audit service tracks the fulfillment of its recommendations and prepares a report at least once every six months to the bank's management and the board of directors, depending on the corporate governance mechanism |
| The head of the internal audit service ensures compliance with internal audit standards |
| In particular, the head of the internal audit service ensures the development of the audit plan, program, methodologies and procedures for the activity of the internal audit service |
| The head of the internal audit service ensures the professional competence and training of personnel and the availability of necessary resources |
| The internal audit service regularly reports to the board of directors and advises it on the effectiveness of the internal control system and the achievement of the goals of the internal audit service, including informing management and/or the board of directors about the progress of the audit plan |
| The board of directors reviews the organization (both in terms of personnel and in other respects) of the internal audit service, the audit plan, reports on the work performed, a summary of the recommendations of the internal audit service and the status of their fulfillment |
| The bank establishes the procedure for control (including conducting repeat inspections) over the implementation of measures to eliminate violations identified by the internal audit service; submission by the internal audit service at least once every six months of information on measures taken to implement recommendations and eliminate identified violations to the board of directors and the executive body |
|---|
| The board of directors of the bank is responsible for the existence of an appropriate compliance risk management policy. The board of directors of the bank is responsible for implementing the policy by ensuring effective resolution of issues of the compliance service by the management board of the bank. The board of directors may delegate these powers to an appropriate committee under the board of directors. |
| The management board of the bank is responsible for implementing the compliance risk management policy and ensuring compliance with the compliance risk management policy and providing a report to the board of directors on the effectiveness of compliance risk management. The management board of the bank is responsible for developing the compliance risk management policy containing the need for compliance by the management board and employees of the bank with the basic principles of compliance risk management. The management board ensures compliance with the compliance risk management policy and takes corrective or disciplinary measures in case of detection of compliance risk. The management board of the bank together with the compliance service: annually identifies and assesses problems of compliance risk occurrence and approves the Action Plan for their elimination. The Action Plan contains deficiencies in compliance risk management, the need to revise internal policies and procedures for effective compliance risk management; annually informs the board of directors on the effectiveness of compliance risk management; immediately informs the board of directors about any operations that may lead to losses or loss of business reputation as a result of non-compliance with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan. |
| The compliance service has access to any information necessary for the performance of functions on compliance risk management, within the powers assigned to it on compliance risk management; has official status within the bank, an appropriate regulation, powers and independence. The compliance controller is appointed to the position by the board of directors of the bank. The regulation on the compliance service, among other things, provides for: accountability of the compliance controller to the board of directors of the bank; accountability of compliance participants to the compliance controller in terms of compliance risk management; duties and powers of the compliance controller and compliance participants; independence of the compliance controller and compliance participants in terms of the functions assigned to them on compliance risk management; relationships of the compliance service with other divisions of the bank and the internal audit service; the right to conduct inspections and identify possible violations of the compliance risk management policy and to engage internal and external specialists to perform this task; the right to freely express and disclose the results of inspections to the management board and, if necessary, to the board of directors of the bank. The compliance service has the right on its own initiative to cooperate with any division of the bank and to obtain access to any files and reports necessary for the performance of its duties. |
| The resources necessary for the compliance service must be sufficient and appropriate for effective compliance risk management. The compliance controller and compliance participants have the necessary qualifications, work experience, professional and personal qualities to perform their duties. The compliance controller and compliance participants possess knowledge of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, internal rules and procedures of the bank |
| The professional skills of the compliance controller and compliance participants are maintained through regular and systematic training. |
| To achieve the goals, the compliance service performs the following functions: exercises control over the compliance of the bank's activities, as well as the actions of its employees in the financial market with the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market; exercises control over compliance by bank employees with the rules for carrying out activities in the financial market and standards for conducting operations (transactions) in the financial market established by the internal documents of the bank, decisions of the bank's management bodies on issues of the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank investigates facts of violation by bank employees of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market, internal documents of the bank regulating the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank considers claims of clients and counterparties regarding transactions (operations) to the bank or actions of its individual employees in the performance of their official duties on issues of the bank's activities in the financial market; independently or jointly with other divisions and officials of the bank develops and submits to the management recommendations on eliminating identified violations and deficiencies in the work of individual employees and divisions of the bank whose activities are related to operations (transactions) in the financial market, as well as recommendations on optimizing the work of these divisions; controls the organization of work in the bank to familiarize all bank employees with the requirements of the bank's internal documents regulating the bank's activities in the financial market, based on the list of official duties of employees; provides consultations upon requests regarding the compliance of a specific operation (transaction) or part thereof with the requirements of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market; carries out monitoring of compliance risk. The results of monitoring are presented in the form of a report in accordance with internal compliance risk management procedures; carries out training of personnel on problems related to the occurrence of compliance risk, the need for interaction in solving problems related to the occurrence of compliance risk; develops internal guidance for bank personnel on compliance risk through the approval of internal policies and procedures. The procedure for current reporting of the compliance service is determined by the internal |
| documents of the bank. The compliance controller informs the management board of the bank: about identified cases of violations by employees of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan on state regulation of the financial market and financial organizations and standards of professional activity in the financial market, internal documents of the bank regulating the bank's activities in the financial market; about measures taken by the heads of the inspected divisions of the bank to eliminate the committed violations and their results, or about the failure to take such measures; annually submits a report on compliance risk control to the board of directors of the bank. When performing their functions, the compliance controller and compliance participants: ensure complete documentation of each inspection fact and draw up conclusions based on the results of inspections reflecting all issues studied during the inspection, identified deficiencies and violations, recommendations for their elimination; ensure the availability of documents (or information about their location) allowing to monitor the progress of control work and ongoing inspections, and also verify the correctness of their results; ensure the safety and return of documents received from the relevant divisions; observe the confidentiality of the information received; submit conclusions based on the results of inspections to the management and relevant divisions of the bank for taking measures to eliminate violations, as well as for the purposes of analyzing the activities of individual bank employees. |
| Conducting bank borrowing operations |
| The risk management division conducts monitoring of bank borrowing operations conducted during the reporting period at least once a quarter in order to determine the concentration of the bank's credit risks and on a consolidated basis, including by borrowers, sectors of the economy, countries/regions |
| The risk management division conducts monitoring and provides at least once a quarter to the management board and at least once every six months to the board of directors information on the bank's credit risk, including on a consolidated basis, by borrowers, sectors of the economy, countries/regions |
| The board of directors has approved procedures for measuring and forecasting credit risk for short-term, medium-term and long-term periods |
| The procedures for measuring and forecasting credit risk, among other things, provide for the use of credit risk models including the following parameters: the level of expense (loss) upon the occurrence of credit risk, distribution of assets by degree of credit risk, forecast of changes in the distribution of assets by degree of credit risk, interrelation of credit risks of various assets, forecast of the possible size of risk on accepted obligations related to credit risk, distribution of sectors and countries with which the bank's credit risk is associated by degree of credit risk, preparation of reports on the above parameters of the credit risk model |
| The credit risk ranking policy, among other things, provides for: the frequency of assigning corporate ratings based on quantitative and qualitative factors; establishment of credit limits and interest rates on loans, taking into account borrower ratings; frequency of monitoring losses by ratings; making a decision to issue a loan when the borrower meets the minimum acceptable rating level |
| The internal credit analysis policy, among other things, provides for: periodic verification of the reliability of ranking (distribution by levels) of loans, additionally on a consolidated basis; periodic verification of the reliability of formation of provisions (reserves) in accordance with the internal documents of the bank, regulatory legal acts of the authorized body; periodic verification of the reliability of ranking (distribution by levels) of off-balance sheet operations of the bank related to derivative instruments, forward currency transactions, financial obligations |
| The internal credit analysis procedures provide for: annual verification of at least fifty-one percent of the volume of the bank's loan portfolio; the division and employees of the bank carrying out internal analysis and responsible for verifying the results of internal credit analysis; qualification requirements for persons performing functions on conducting credit analysis |
| The credit analysis procedures determine: the frequency of submission to the board of directors and management board of reports on the results of credit analysis; the form and additional information indicated in the report on the results of credit analysis; the procedure for monitoring the implementation by bank divisions of decisions taken by the board of directors or management board based on the results of consideration of reports |
| The country risk assessment policy determines: methods for assessing country risk, including taking into account sovereign ratings of international rating agencies; frequency of collecting information from external sources on the political and economic situation in each country; methods for establishing the bank's own country ratings, the possibility of their prompt adjustment; methods for establishing credit limits by country and the frequency of their revision |
| Provision of mortgage housing loans issued to individuals, and mortgage loans secured by real estate or provided for the purpose of real estate construction |
| The bank's credit policy on loans related to real estate provides for: geographic regions of lending; diversification of the bank's loan portfolio; limits on loans related to real estate - by types and geographic regions (for example, limits on riskier loans); terms and conditions for types of loans; procedure for issuing and approving loans; procedure for managing loans, including documentation, issuance, control over collateral, repayment and analysis of the loan; program for informal and formal assessment of real estate value; the obligation of the bank's management to control the loan portfolio and ensure timely and complete submission of reports to the board of directors |
| For experimental-design and construction projects and completed commercial objects, the credit policy also provides for: requirements for conducting feasibility studies and sensitivity and risk analysis (for example, sensitivity of projected income to changes in economic variables, including interest rates, vacancy rate or operating expenses); minimum requirements for initial investment volume, technical maintenance by the borrower of own capital (for example, cash or investments, unencumbered property); minimum requirements for own capital, cash flow and degree of coverage of debt servicing of the borrower or the underlying asset; standards of acceptability and limits on non-amortizing loans; pre-lease and pre-sale requirements for income-producing property; pre-sale requirements and minimum requirements for commissioning of one structural unit of a constructed building for loans related to non-income assets; minimum conditions for loan agreements |
| Market factors of supply and demand that should be taken into account include (among others) the following: demographic indicators, including dynamics of population size and employment; zoning requirements; current and projected vacancy rates, construction and absorption speed; current and projected lease terms, rental rates and sale prices, including leasing of part of the premises; current and projected operating expenses for various types of projects; economic indicators, including trends and diversification in lending; valuation trends, including discount and direct interest rates for income capitalization |
| Loans related to real estate reflect all relevant credit factors: value of the pledged property; overall creditworthiness of the borrower; availability of secondary sources of debt repayment; availability of additional collateral or credit-enhancing funds (for example, guarantees or mortgage insurance). Loans related to real estate issued to legal entities also reflect the following credit factors: production capacity of the borrower or income from the underlying asset - for adequate debt servicing; volume of shares invested in the property |
| The standards cover the following points: maximum loan amount depending on the type of property; maximum loan repayment periods depending on the type of property; schedules of gradual loan repayment; structure of setting interest rates for various types of mortgage loans; limits of the loan-to-value ratio depending on the type of property |
| The procedure for managing a loan for a real estate portfolio contains: type and frequency of financial reports, including requirements for verification of information provided by the borrower; type and frequency of collateral valuations (official and other types of value assessment); closing of the credit transaction and transfer of loan funds; payment procedure, including interest; management of escrow amounts; management of pledged property; procedure for actions in case of non-repayment of the loan; timelines for procedures for selling pledged real estate in judicial/extrajudicial order |
| The bank assesses the developer's ability to complete the construction project within the specified cost and timelines. When assessing the probability of successful completion of the construction project, the bank takes into account the following risks: failure to complete the project within the agreed timelines leads to financial penalties; bad weather, lack of material or labor resources or work below regulatory requirements that must be redone to pass the acceptance commission may delay completion of construction, increase interest expenses and lead to exceeding the total project cost compared to the initial budget; during construction, suppliers and subcontractors begin to demand higher payment compared to what was agreed or allocated at the beginning of the project; labor disputes or inability of the general supplier or subcontractor to supply goods and provide services; uninsured destruction, demolition of completed construction or buildings under construction; overall financial potential of the borrower and its experience in development and improvement, that is, to find out whether the borrower can actually finish the project within budget and according to construction plans; assessment of the borrower's experience in development and improvement; nature, work experience and financial position of all participating parties; increase in the cost of construction and other materials used in the construction process, entailing an increase in the estimated cost of the construction object; delay in processing title (title-certifying) documents in authorized state bodies (local executive authorities, architecture and urban planning, land resources management, etc.) for the real estate object at the final stages of its construction and commissioning; redevelopment, reconstruction of completed construction or buildings under construction |
| The credit file for a project of bank financing of construction must contain the following documentation: financial information about the borrower arguing the borrower's experience and financial potential necessary to complete the project; construction loan agreement setting out the rights and obligations of the lender and borrower, conditions for disbursement of funds and events of default; registered mortgage agreement on property as a basis for the bank to foreclose on the pledged property or to acquire it into the bank's ownership in cases provided by legislation; legal opinion on the compliance with legislation of title and other documents confirming the right of ownership (use) of land, as well as the right to the financed building (when transferring to the bank's pledge the construction object with the land plot (right of use)); insurance policies and proof of payment of insurance premiums as evidence that the builder has full and enforceable insurance coverage, including for: liability, fire, specific builder's risks and, where applicable, flood insurance; appropriate assessment by specialists holding a license for valuation activities or other assessment showing the market value of the property in its current state and upon completion of construction, as well as upon achieving a sustainable level of occupancy; project plans, feasibility study and construction budget showing development plans, project costs, marketing plans and investment shares; inspection of the property, extensions and soil reports |
| The criteria used by banks in assessing collateral for loans related to real estate are regulated by the internal documents of banks defining credit policy |
| The internal documents of the bank concerning the assessment of collateral for loans related to real estate contain: criteria and procedures for selecting appraisers carrying out assessment of collateral for loans related to real estate; procedures for ensuring the independence of the appraiser; procedures for carrying out the appropriate assessment; criteria for the content of the assessment |
| The assessment: complies with generally accepted valuation standards; the assessment is carried out by an appraiser who has no financial interest in the collateral object; is drawn up in writing and contains a reasoned analysis in accordance with which a decision is made to issue a loan related to real estate; includes analysis and a report with conclusions if the collateral is provided in the form of a building under construction or reconstruction or partially leased in accordance with non-market terms of the lease agreement, and contains unsold areas; is carried out by appraisers holding a license for valuation activities |
| Revaluation of collateral is carried out for loans related to real estate, the collateral value of which exceeds 35,000 monthly calculation indices, with the involvement of an independent appraiser |
| Based on the results of the revaluation, the bank revises the classification of the loan and the amount of provisions for it |
| Revaluation is not carried out in cases of: housing repair; revision of the terms of the loan agreement, as well as provision of new or additional collateral for a loan related to real estate, which may reduce the risk of bank losses |
| The criteria used by banks in revaluing collateral for loans related to real estate are regulated by the internal documents of banks defining credit policy |
| Conducting operations with financial instruments |
| Internal policies for managing operations for the purchase/sale of financial instruments regulate: determination of interest rate risk associated with the structure of assets (liabilities) of the bank; determination of currency risk associated with the structure of assets (liabilities) of the bank; determination of risks inherent in operations with derivative financial instruments; methods for establishing price risk limits, sufficiency of own capital for market risk; models used in measuring the bank's market risk; frequency of submission by the risk management division to the board of directors and management board of a report on the bank's positions on market risk |
| The bank keeps processing of trading operations separate from other market operations |
| The bank tracks income/expenses and risks on balance sheet and off-balance sheet operations exposed to price risk, including on a consolidated basis taking into account subsidiaries |
| The bank conducts daily assessment of income/expenses based on revaluation of urgent exchange positions |
| The bank excludes from the portfolio of financial instruments financial instruments that do not have a current market valuation or calculated price determined by the bank's mathematical models |
| The bank regularly during each operating day conducts assessment of income/expenses from operations with financial instruments |
| The board of directors of the bank has approved procedures for determining the value of a financial instrument taking into account risk |
| The bank conducts assessment of the value of financial instruments based on the risk assessment model and bringing current prices to market, including carrying out stress-testing and back-testing |
| The bank uses the results of risk assessment and regular stress-testing when making decisions on conducting operations with financial instruments |
| The Board or another collegial body with the relevant functions and powers establishes the range of "stop-loss" limits for financial instruments |
|---|
| The internal audit service verifies the correctness of the bank's application of the rules for determining "stop-loss" limits |
| The risk management unit analyzes the adequacy of limits for financial instruments, that is, in accordance with the scale and dynamics of the financial instruments market and the liquidity of the financial instrument |
| The asset and liability management unit, at least once a quarter, monitors money management in subsidiary organizations and carries out management of the assets and liabilities of the bank and subsidiary organizations on a consolidated basis |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers regularly, at least once a quarter, determines the levels of interest rates by maturity |
| The levels of interest rates are drawn up taking into account the influence of factors: the share of doubtful assets with increased risk and bad assets, the size of own capital and provisions, the shares of demand deposits |
| The asset and liability management unit and/or a collegial body with the relevant functions and powers monitors interest rate risk, the main sources of interest rate risk (differences in maturities, loan capital market rates, embedded options) |
| The Board of Directors approved the policy for making decisions on currency positions in accordance with the analysis of changes in exchange rates |
| The risk management unit carries out: comprehensive risk management using various analytical methodologies; assessment of interest rate sensitivity, regularly conducts gap analysis, analysis of the model in which value at risk (or risk income) is assessed; stress testing, the results of which are used in making strategic decisions in the area of risk taking and risk control; analyzes and controls interest rate risk from the point of view of changes in the volumes of periodically recurring income (expenses) |
| The Board: approves procedures for hedging interest rate risk using derivative instruments or other market operations; establishes limits on the gap and the size of interest rate risk, taking into account the adequacy of own capital for risks |
| The risk management unit, at least once every six months, conducts stress testing and uses its results in making strategic decisions when taking risk and controlling risk |
| The bank uses procedures for adequate and timely hedging of currency risk using transactions with derivative instruments or other market operations in accordance with the asset and liability management policy |
| The Board of Directors establishes limits on open currency positions and a limit on the net currency position |
The Instruction was supplemented with Appendix 9 in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 27.10.06 No. 234; set out in the wording of resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 29.12.09 No. 263 (see old wording); amendments were introduced in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old wording)
Appendix 9
to the Instruction on requirements for the availability of risk management systems and internal control in second-tier banks
Report "______"
name of the bank
on fulfillment of the criteria of the requirements of the Instruction for the availability of a risk management system and internal control for the "_____" year
| No. | Name of the corresponding line of the Instruction | List of internal documents (details of the document and the body by which this document was approved) | List of procedures carried out to fulfill the Requirement Criterion | Assessment of the bank's compliance with the criterion of the Instruction's requirement | Bank's note | |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
| Requirements | Criterion of the requirement | |||||
Assessment of compliance with the requirements of the Instruction: ______
First head of the bank (or the person replacing him/her)
signature date
Head of the risk management unit
signature date
Head of the internal audit service
signature date
Head of the compliance office
signature date
Explanations for filling out the table:
The assessment of compliance with the requirements of the Instruction must be carried out using a three-point system of the following criteria: compliance, partial compliance, non-compliance.
The assessment "compliance" is given when the bank fulfills the criterion of the Instruction's requirement without any significant shortcomings.
The assessment "partial compliance" is given when shortcomings are discovered that are not considered sufficient for serious doubts to arise regarding the bank's ability to achieve compliance with a specific criterion of the requirement.
The assessment "non-compliance" is given when the bank fails to fulfill the criterion of the Instruction's requirements.
If certain criteria of the Instruction's requirement cannot be applied to the bank, the assessment of compliance with this criterion of the requirement is not carried out and is marked with the corresponding entry "not applicable".
In the column "Bank's note", justifications and reasons for "partial compliance" and "not applicable" must be given.
Completion of all columns, except for column 6, is mandatory.
The Instruction was supplemented with Appendix 10 in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 29.12.09 No. 263; amendments were introduced in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old wording)
Appendix 10
to the Instruction on requirements for the availability of risk management systems and internal control in second-tier banks
Credit risk monitoring matrix
Table 1. Ratio of the value of collateral in the form of real estate to the loan portfolio
| Actual indicators | Stress test: Recommendations of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan and the authorized body on stress testing methodology in bottom up format | Probability (factors/conditions) and degree of impact on the financial stability of the bank, from the point of view of the bank's board | Measures taken to eliminate negative trends (filled in if the limit established by the bank's internal documents is exceeded) | Comments | ||
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | ||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
Table 2. Classified assets (except interbank loans) and non-performing loans
| Actual indicators | Stress test: increase in the share of loans with overdue payments over 90 (ninety) days by 20 (twenty) percent in the next quarter. Amount of provisions for classified assets (in tenge) | Probability (factors/conditions) and degree of impact on the financial stability of the bank, from the point of view of the bank's board | Measures taken to eliminate negative trends (filled in if the limit established by the bank's internal documents is exceeded) | Comments | ||
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | ||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | Probability (factors/conditions) and degree of impact on the financial stability of the bank, from the point of view of the bank's board | Estimated value of the coefficient in the next quarter according to the bank's board assessment. Description of the fluctuation by changes in reserves or changes in the loan portfolio | Comments |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | Probability (factors/conditions) and degree of impact on the financial stability of the bank, from the point of view of the bank's board | Estimated value of the coefficient in the next quarter according to the bank's board assessment. Description of the fluctuation by changes in reserves or changes in the loan portfolio | Comments |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
4 Ratio of restructured loans (a loan for which the original terms of the agreement were changed due to the deterioration of the borrower's financial condition) to the loan portfolio
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | Total amount of overdue restructured loans (in tenge) | Bank's forecast of an increase or decrease in the next reporting quarter. Factors taken into account | Estimated value of the coefficient in the next quarter according to the bank's board assessment. Description of the fluctuation by changes in restructured loans | Comments |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limit established by the bank's internal documents | Share of unsecured loans with overdue payments over 90 (ninety) days | Share of unsecured loans classified as doubtful of the fifth category and bad | Bank's board assessment of the ratio of unsecured loans to the loan portfolio in the next quarter | Reasons for the increase or decrease in the coefficient |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
Decision matrix
| No. | Violation | Reasons that led to the violation | Units, persons responsible for eliminating the violation | Decision of the board of directors and (or) the board on measures taken to eliminate the identified violation | Negative impact on the bank | Decision of the board of directors and (or) the board on planned measures based on the results of stress tests | Deadline for eliminating the violation | Revised deadlines | Date of elimination of the violation | Note |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
Credit risk assessment matrix
| Low | Moderate | High |
| The growth rates of the loan portfolio are supported by economic and demographic trends at the local, regional and (or) republican level, as well as by the level of competition. The growth was planned. | The growth rates of the loan portfolio exceed the economic and demographic trends at the local, regional and (or) republican level, as well as the level of competition. To a certain extent, the growth was not planned or exceeds planned levels. | The growth rates of the loan portfolio significantly exceed the economic and demographic trends at the local, regional and (or) republican level, as well as the level of competition. The growth was not planned or exceeds planned levels. Growth may be observed in new products or non-local borrowers. |
| The bank depends on interest on loans and commissions on operations for the majority of its income, but the sources of income within the loan portfolio are diversified. | The bank depends on interest on loans and commissions on operations for the majority of its income, but the sources of income within the loan portfolio are not diversified. | The bank depends to a significant extent on interest on loans and commissions on operations. The bank may target credit products with higher risk due to their potential profitability. Credit income is highly vulnerable to cyclical trends. |
| The ratio of the size of reserves for classified loans and contingent liabilities to classified loans and the loan portfolio is significant. | The ratio of the size of reserves for classified loans and contingent liabilities to classified loans and the loan portfolio is moderate. | The ratio of the size of reserves for classified loans and contingent liabilities to classified loans and the loan portfolio is insignificant. |
| Interest rates are set depending on risk, and the remuneration is well balanced. | Interest on loans is set depending on the level of risk, while there are cases of insignificant inconsistencies between risk. | Risk is not taken into account when setting the interest rate on loans. |
| The lending policy includes conservative collateral requirements. Collateral valuations are conducted in a timely manner and are sufficient. | The lending policy includes acceptable collateral requirements. The practices used by the bank lead to moderate deviations from these policies. Collateral valuation is insufficient or reflects inadequate protection. | Collateral requirements are liberal; if the policy includes conservative requirements, there are significant deviations. Loan collateral is insufficient, collateral valuation is rarely conducted or reflects inadequate protection. |
| Deviations in loan documentation and (or) collateral documentation are insignificant and have a minimal impact on the risk of losses. | The level of deviations in loan documentation and (or) collateral documentation is moderate, but deviations are corrected in a timely manner and usually do not expose the bank to significant risk of losses. | The level of deviations in loan documentation and (or) collateral documentation is significant. Deviations from policy are not eliminated in a timely manner, and the bank may be exposed to increased risk of losses. |
| The bank's portfolio is sufficiently diversified and does not have large concentrations. Concentrated exposures are usually not interrelated. Concentrations comply with internal limits. | The bank has an insignificant portfolio concentration, while concentrations are not interrelated. Concentrations comply with norms but may approach limits. | The bank has a significant concentration in its portfolio. These exposures may be interrelated with each other or with moderate concentrations in the portfolio. The level of concentration exceeds internal limits. |
| Earned and uncollected interest relative to the loan portfolio is insignificant. | Earned and uncollected interest relative to the loan portfolio is moderate. | Earned and uncollected interest relative to the loan portfolio is significant. |
| The level of coverage of problem and bad loans with provisions (reserves) is high. Provision expenses are stable. | The level of coverage of problem and bad loans with provisions (reserves) is moderate, but provision expenses may need to be increased. | The level of coverage of problem and bad loans with provisions (reserves) is low. Special provisions may need to be created to ensure an acceptable level of coverage of loan losses. |
| Income for the quarter and for the year significantly exceeds credit losses (bad loans). | Coverage of net credit losses (bad loans) by income is moderate. Annual income provides adequate coverage, but quarterly coverage may show some tension. | Coverage of net credit losses by income is low. Income for the quarter and for the year provides minimal or inadequate coverage. |
| The level of loans with overdue debt of 90 (ninety) days in the bank's loan portfolio is low, and the trend is stable. | The level of loans with overdue debt of 90 (ninety) days in the bank's loan portfolio is moderate, and the trend is stable or slightly increasing | The level of loans with overdue debt of 90 (ninety) days in the bank's loan portfolio is high or moderate, while the trend is rapidly increasing. The level exceeds the limit established by the bank. |
| The level of non-performing loans in the bank's loan portfolio is low, and the trend is stable. | The level of non-performing loans in the bank's loan portfolio is moderate, and the trend is stable or slightly increasing. | The level of non-performing loans in the bank's loan portfolio is high or moderate, and the trend is rapidly increasing. |
| Classified loans constitute a low percentage of loans and capital and are not reclassified into the worst of the categories (doubtful or bad). | Classified loans constitute a moderate percentage of loans and capital and are not reclassified into the worst of the categories (doubtful or bad). | Classified loans constitute a high percentage of loans and capital or a moderate percentage of loans and capital, while the trend is rapidly increasing or loans are reclassified into the worst of the categories (doubtful or bad). |
| The ratio of the size of bad loans to the loan portfolio is low. | The ratio of the size of bad loans to the loan portfolio is moderate. | The ratio of the size of bad loans to the loan portfolio is high. |
| The bank's practice of reclassifying loans (by term, extension, refinancing) causes no or little concern in the transparency of reflected problem loans, overdue loans, non-performing loans and loss indicators. | The bank's practice of reclassification (by term, extension, refinancing) causes some concern regarding the accuracy and transparency of reflected problem loans, overdue loans, non-performing loans and loss indicators. | The bank's practices of reclassification (by term, extension, refinancing) cause significant concern regarding the accuracy and transparency of reflected problem loans, overdue loans, non-performing loans and loss indicators. |
Credit risk control matrix
| Elements of process organization | Strong | Acceptable | Weak |
| Development (revision) of strategy, policy and internal documents in the area of credit risk management | Strategic and (or) business plans are consistent with the bank's conservative risk appetite and ensure an appropriate balance between loan quality targets, growth and profitability objectives. Processes for introducing new products and initiatives are elaborated, tested and approved before their introduction. | Strategic and (or) business plans are consistent with the bank's moderate risk appetite. The pursuit of income may lead to transactions with a somewhat inflated level of risk. On the whole there is an appropriate balance between loan quality targets, growth and profitability objectives. New products and initiatives may be introduced without sufficient testing, but risks are well identified. | Strategic and (or) business plans contribute to the taking of excessive levels of risk. The pursuit of income dominates in planning activities. The bank engages in new products and initiatives without conducting sufficient preliminary expert examination. |
| Credit policy | The credit policy defines the bank's lending strategy, permissible levels of risk, as well as standards for granting and approving loans and risk selection. | The policies are basically adequate. In some area improvement of policies and procedures may be necessary, but the improvement on the whole is not critical. | The policies have some shortcomings and need improvement in one or several areas. The policies are not sufficiently clear to adequately communicate the objectives regarding the portfolio, risk tolerance, as well as the policy for granting/approving loans and risk selection. |
| Board of Directors and Management Board | The Management Board promptly identifies and controls credit risk arising, including on off-balance sheet items of the bank. The Board of Directors and the Management Board of the bank actively participate in risk management and ensure the availability of appropriate internal policies and procedures; the Board of Directors understands, analyses and approves them. | On the whole the Board of Directors and the Management Board adequately carry out monitoring and control of credit risk and approve appropriate policies and procedures. The Management Board works sufficiently effectively, responds to and identifies credit risks arising, including on off-balance sheet items. There are some deficiencies in the activity of the Board of Directors and the Management Board in relation to credit risk management; these problems are acknowledged and resolved. | The Board of Directors and the Management Board do not ensure the availability of a satisfactory process for managing credit risk arising, including on off-balance sheet items of the bank. The policies and procedures for credit risk management are inadequate; the bank's Management Board does not demonstrate the ability to correct these shortcomings. |
| Credit Committee | The Management Board effectively manages the bank's activity. Members of the Credit Committee and credit officers have sufficient knowledge to effectively manage the risks taken. The scope of responsibility and accountability is delineated; corrective measures are taken in the event of violations. | The Management Board adequately manages the risk taken, but improvements can be achieved in one or several areas. Members of the Credit Committee and credit officers have on the whole the knowledge necessary to effectively manage the risks taken, but additional knowledge may be necessary in one or several areas. Clarification regarding duties and accountability may be required. On the whole, corrective measures are taken in the event of violations. | The Management Board does not adequately manage the bank's activity. Members of the Credit Committee and credit officers do not possess sufficient knowledge and (or) experience to effectively manage the risks taken. The lines of responsibility and accountability may be unclear. Corrective measures are insufficient to address the causes and problems. |
| The bank's procedures in the area of assessment, monitoring and control of credit risk in the bank | A regular analysis is conducted of the adequacy of the applied methodologies and processes for credit risk management described in the Policy and accompanying internal documents. The Management Board identifies and promptly responds to negative trends in the quality of the bank's credit portfolio, which occur, among other things, as a result of changes in market conditions. The Management Board provides the Board of Directors with timely and sufficient information on any significant deviations in the bank's credit activity. The measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are effective and are aimed at reducing the negative impact of that deviation on the bank's financial stability. | The Management Board has an adequate system for identifying negative trends in the quality of the credit portfolio and adequately responding to signals which occur, among other things, as a result of changes in market conditions. The information on any significant deviations provided to the Board of Directors is satisfactory and effective for maintaining the bank's financial stability. The measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are adequate, but there are some areas requiring improvement and control by the Board of Directors and the Management Board. | The Management Board inadequately responds to negative trends that have arisen in the quality of the credit portfolio. The Board of Directors does not receive sufficient information enabling it to monitor and adequately control negative trends in the quality of the credit portfolio. The measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are ineffective; the Board of Directors and the Management Board have not demonstrated their ability to resolve the problems. |
| Policies for granting and approving loans | The bank effectively identifies, tracks and reports significant deviations from the policy for granting and approving loans, both individually and in aggregate at the portfolio level. Insignificant deviations from the established policies and procedures are noted. | The bank identifies, tracks and reports significant deviations from the policy for granting and approving loans, individually for each loan. Among the shortcomings there may be persistent deviations or inability to comply with the established policies and procedures, which may entail adverse consequences for the bank. | The bank confirms significant deviations from the policy, but does not report on them on an individual basis or in aggregate at the portfolio level, and (or) does not analyse their impact on portfolio quality. |
| Credit analysis | Credit analysis is thorough and timely, both at the time of granting the loan and after its approval. | Credit analysis properly identifies the main risks and is conducted within acceptable timeframes. However, work on assessing risks after loan approval needs to be strengthened. | Credit analysis is insufficiently conducted; the main risks are inadequately taken into account. Credit data are verified untimely. |
| Models used in credit risk assessment | Internal risk assessment models, as well as those for identifying problem loans, are accurate and timely. Internal models qualitatively subdivide credit risk, both for problem loans and for rated loans. The applied model is constantly improved taking into account international experience and newly identified patterns. The bank periodically reviews limits taking into account internal ratings of borrowers. Procedures for controlling established limits and restrictions on operations conducted by the bank are clearly defined. | Internal risk assessment models, as well as those for identifying problem loans, are adequate. One or several areas require improvement; nevertheless, the internal models adequately identify problem loans and loans for which deterioration in quality is observed. It may be necessary to expand the distribution of ratings to ensure early warning, risk-based pricing or capital allocation. The model is regularly reviewed for its adequacy to the market situation and the bank's position and is adjusted as necessary. The review of limits and restrictions on operations conducted by the bank is carried out regularly. | Internal risk assessment models, as well as those for identifying problem loans, are insufficient and require improvement. Problem loans may be identified inadequately; there is a possibility of distortion in the reflection of risk. The distribution of ratings is insufficient to subdivide risk for rated loans for early warning purposes or for other purposes (setting loan rates, forming provisions (reserves) for loans, capital allocation). These models are applied sporadically, as necessary. |
| Information used for management and internal control | The management information system provides adequate and timely information on the credit portfolio. The Board of Directors and the Management Board receive appropriate reporting for analysing and understanding the credit risk profile in the bank. The management information system facilitates the work of preparing reports on deviations. | The management information system may need minor improvement in one or several areas, but the Board of Directors and the Management Board on the whole receive appropriate reporting for analysing and understanding the credit risk profile in the bank. The management information system facilitates the work of preparing reports on deviations, and its infrastructure allows special (non-standard) requests to be provided in a timely manner. | The management information system has shortcomings requiring attention. The adequacy and (or) timeliness of the information provided may be insufficient. Information on portfolio risks may be incomplete. As a result, the Board of Directors and the Management Board may not receive appropriate or sufficient information for analysing and understanding the credit risk profile in the bank. Reporting on deviations needs improvement. The management information system may not provide special (non-standard) requests in a timely manner. |
| Portfolio diversification | Diversification management is active and effective. Concentration limits are set at acceptable levels. The bank identifies and reports on risk concentrations and takes measures to limit, reduce or otherwise mitigate risk. | Diversification management may need improvement, but is adequate. Risk concentrations are identified and reflected in reports, but may not reach limits or other threshold values. The Management Board takes measures to limit or reduce concentrations at the level of individual loans, but measures at the portfolio level may be absent. | Diversification management is passive or absent. The bank may not identify risk concentrations and (or) identifies them but takes inadequate measures or does not take measures to limit or reduce risk. The Management Board does not understand risk correlations. Concentration limits, if any, are violated or are revised upward. |
| Contingency action plan | The contingency action plan is developed and effective. The plan includes reasonable assumptions, scenarios and crisis management planning, and also takes into account the bank's needs for additional resources. | The contingency action plan is adequate. It corresponds to the current condition, regulates procedures for resolving necessary issues and contains an adequate level of detail, including analysis of situational scenarios. The plan may require improvement in certain areas. | The contingency action plan is inadequate or does not exist. The plan may exist, but it does not take into account the bank's needs for additional resources, and therefore is inadequate. The plan may not take into account the expedient use of funds or their availability in a crisis situation. |
| Internal audit service | The internal audit service periodically conducts internal reviews of credit risk management processes in order to ensure their compliance with credit policies and procedures, assesses the credit administration process, the determination of the accuracy of the internal credit rating system, as well as the procedure for monitoring loans. The results of the review are used to identify weak points in the credit risk management process, in internal rules and procedures, as well as to identify any deviations and exceptions from policy, procedures and limits. | The internal audit service periodically and selectively conducts internal reviews of the processes described in the credit risk management policy. The results of the review are used to identify weak points in the credit risk management process, in internal rules and procedures, as well as to identify any deviations and exceptions from policy, procedures and limits. | The internal audit service formally checks compliance with the requirements of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, including regulatory acts of the authorized body, in the conduct of the bank's operations, including regulatory acts in the area of credit risk management. It does not participate in the credit risk management system in the bank. |
Summary conclusions:
| Assessment of the quality of credit risk control | Level of credit risk assessment | ||
| Low | Moderate | High | |
| Composite credit risk | |||
| Strong | Low | Low | Moderate |
| Acceptable | Low | Moderate | High |
| Weak | Moderate | High | High |
Low — The Board of Directors and the Management Board promptly identify and control credit risks arising, including on off-balance sheet items of the bank. The Board of Directors and the Management Board actively participate in risk management and ensure the availability of appropriate internal regulations. The requirements of policies and procedures are supported by risk monitoring procedures, reports and management information systems which present all the information necessary for its analysis and for timely and proper response to ongoing changes. Bank employees comply with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, internal rules and procedures, and perform their functional duties in accordance with job descriptions. Internal control systems are adequate and correspond to the size and activity of the bank. Some deviations from established internal rules and procedures are noted, but they are not significant. Credit risk management is considered fully effective for establishing, tracking and controlling risks. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activity are sufficient.
Moderate — credit risk management in the bank is sufficiently effective, but minor deficiencies are observed in it. It reflects rapid response and the ability to successfully manage risk which may arise in the course of implementing the strategy. Although the bank may have some deficiencies in relation to credit risk management, these shortcomings are identified and corrected in a timely manner. On the whole, control by the Board of Directors and the Management Board, internal rules and procedures for risk monitoring and control, reporting and management information systems are considered satisfactory and effective for maintaining the bank's stable operation. On the whole, risks are under control to a sufficient degree not requiring additional control by the bank's risk management. The internal control system shows some shortcomings or deficiencies, but they are all corrected in the course of the unit's normal operation. Employees of the internal audit service may make recommendations for their improvement, but the noted deficiencies will not have a significant impact on the unit's reliable and stable operation. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activity are adequate.
High — the bank lacks procedures for effective credit risk management which do not allow identifying, tracking, monitoring and controlling potential credit risk. Risk management elements are considered fully insufficient, and the Board of Directors and the Management Board do not demonstrate the ability to correct these shortcomings. The professionalism of specific employees and of the bank's Management Board is called into question. Systematic violations of internal policies and procedures are observed. The internal control system may be so weak that it negatively affects the bank's financial stability. Immediate concern must be shown regarding the reliability of accounting, financial reports and potential losses which may appear if immediate corrective measures are not taken. Shortcomings in credit risk management procedures and in internal control systems require immediate and thorough attention by the bank's risk management. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activity are inadequate.
First executive (or person acting in their place)______ ______ ______
(surname, name, patronymic if any) (signature) (date)
Head of the risk management unit
(surname, name, patronymic if any) (signature) (date)
Executor:______ ______
(position, surname and name) (signature)
The Instruction was supplemented with Appendix 11 in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 29.12.09 No. 263; amendments were introduced in accordance with resolution of the Board of the AFN of the RK dated 31.01.11 No. 8 (see old wording)
Appendix 11
to the Instruction on requirements for the availability of systems
for risk management and internal control
in second-tier banks
Liquidity risk monitoring matrix
Table 1. Asset structure (in tenge)
| Name | Reporting quarter | Share of total assets, in percent | Previous quarter | Share of total assets, in percent | Limits established by the bank's internal documents |
| Total assets | х | ||||
| Cash | |||||
| Funds with the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan | х | ||||
| Loans granted to banks and organizations conducting certain types of banking operations | |||||
| Investments in securities | |||||
| REPO transactions | |||||
| Investments in affiliated legal entities | |||||
| Loans to clients | |||||
| Investments in real estate (bank buildings) | |||||
| Other assets | х |
Table 2. Analysis of ratios:
| Actual indicators | Bank's assessment: | ||||
| Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limits established by the bank's internal documents, in percent | Assessment by the bank's management of the balance of 10 (ten) large deposits at the end of one month (in tenge). Reasons for increase or decrease | Assessment by the bank's management of the balance of 10 (ten) large deposits at the end of three months (in tenge). Reasons for increase or decrease | |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
| Indicators | Reporting quarter, in percent | Previous quarter, in percent | Limits established by the bank's internal documents |
| Ratio of liquid assets / total assets | |||
| Ratio of liquid assets / total deposits | |||
| Ratio of loans / deposits | |||
| Bank assets used as collateral (encumbered) / total assets |
Table 3. Analysis of the structure of liabilities (sources of funds), thousand tenge:
| Name | Reporting quarter | Share of total liabilities, in percent | Previous quarter | Share of total liabilities, in percent | Limits established by the bank's internal documents |
| Total deposits | х | ||||
| Current accounts | |||||
| Time deposits | |||||
| Demand deposits | |||||
| Borrowings on the local interbank market | |||||
| Foreign borrowings | |||||
| Own securities of the bank | |||||
| Loans received from related parties | |||||
| Subordinated debt |
Table 4. Sources of financing, thousand tenge:
| Name | 7 days | 30 days | 60 days | 90 days | 180 days | More |
| Cash | ||||||
| Current accounts | ||||||
| Deposits | ||||||
| Unencumbered securities | ||||||
| Loan repayments in accordance with the repayment schedule | ||||||
| Sale of assets (securitization, REPO transactions and others) | ||||||
| Sources of financing from persons related to the bank by special relations | ||||||
| Total amount from the indicated sources of financing |
Table 5. Payments on obligations (use of funds), thousand tenge:
| Name | 7 days | 30 days | 60 days | 90 days | 180 days | More |
| Maturity of deposits / withdrawals | ||||||
| Maturity of other debt | ||||||
| Payments to persons related to the bank by special relations | ||||||
| Off-balance sheet obligations | ||||||
| Obligations to provide loans | ||||||
| Credit lines | ||||||
| Derivative financial instruments | ||||||
| Total payments |
The bank's actions in the event that the volume of funds used exceeds the sources in any period of time for meeting liquidity needs.
Main points of the contingency action plan.
Presentation of information on sources and use of funds in foreign currency in the form of Table 5 in the event the bank has currency risks capable of affecting liquidity.
Decision matrix
| No. | Violation | Causes that led to the violation | Units, persons responsible for eliminating the violation | Decision of the Board of Directors and (or) the Management Board on measures taken to eliminate the identified violation | Negative impact on the bank | Decision of the Board of Directors and (or) the Management Board on planned measures based on stress-test results | Deadline for eliminating the violation | Revised deadlines | Date of elimination of the violation | Note |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
Liquidity Risk Assessment Matrix
| Low | Moderate | High |
| Funding sources are unlimited and provide a competitive advantage. | Sufficient funding sources are available, providing the possibility for effective liquidity. | Funding sources and the level of liabilities indicate current and future difficulties in managing long-term liquidity. |
| Funding sources are diversified. There is no or insignificant dependence on wholesale funding sources or other sensitive funding sources. | Funding sources are generally diversified, however a small number of funding sources is observed. There are no significant concentrations. There is moderate dependence on wholesale funding sources. | Borrowings may be concentrated in a few sources, in sources with common investment objectives. Significant dependence on wholesale funding sources is observed. |
| The ability to increase liquidity through the sale of assets and (or) securitization is high, and the bank has an established reputation for access to these markets. | The bank potentially has the ability to increase liquidity through the sale of assets and (or) securitization, but has little experience in accessing these markets. | The bank demonstrates little ability or potential to increase liquidity through the sale of assets and (or) securitization. Lack of experience in accessing these markets or a poor reputation may call this transaction into question. |
| The volume of wholesale liabilities with embedded options is low. | Some wholesale funds have embedded options, but their potential impact is insignificant. | Material volumes of wholesale funds have embedded options. Their potential effect is significant. |
| The bank will not experience funding difficulties in the event of a change in the market situation. | The bank is not strongly dependent on funding difficulties in the event of a change in the market situation. | The bank's liquidity structure indicates dependence on changes in the market situation. |
| Support from the parent organization (major participants) is strong. | Support from the parent organization (major participants) is adequate. | Support from the parent organization (major participants) is insufficient or absent. |
| The risk of loss of capital (profit) due to the structure of liquidity risks is insignificant. | The risk of loss of capital (profit) due to the structure of liquidity risks is manageable. | The potential risk of loss of capital (profit) due to the high cost of liabilities or an unplanned decrease in assets may be significant. |
Liquidity Risk Control Matrix
| Elements of the process organization | Strong | Acceptable | Weak |
| Development (revision) of strategy, policy and internal documents in the area of liquidity management | Optimization of liquidity management processes described in internal documents is carried out on an ongoing basis (as the external and internal environment of the bank changes). The process is interconnected with the development of the bank's strategy, business plan, risk management policy and other technological processes. | It is carried out on a periodic basis and includes the development of internal documents that take into account the specifics of the bank's liquidity management. The policy in the area of management and control over the liquidity level is supported by internal documents containing standards and instructions that constitute methodological support for its implementation. | It is carried out from time to time and includes the development and approval of internal documents describing procedures for managing and controlling the liquidity level. |
| Board of Directors and Management Board | The Management Board promptly identifies and controls liquidity risk. The bank's Board of Directors and Management Board actively participate in risk management and ensure the availability of appropriate internal policies and procedures; the Board of Directors understands, analyzes and approves them. The Board of Directors and Management Board understand all aspects of liquidity risk. The Management Board identifies and promptly responds to market changes. | On the whole, the Board of Directors and Management Board adequately monitor and control liquidity risk and approve appropriate policies and procedures. The Management Board works quite effectively, responds to and identifies liquidity risk. Some shortcomings are observed in the activities of the Board of Directors and Management Board with respect to liquidity risk management; these problems are recognized and addressed. The Board of Directors and Management Board have a reasonably sound understanding of the key aspects of liquidity risk and adequately respond to market changes. | The Board of Directors and Management Board do not ensure the availability of a satisfactory liquidity risk management process. Liquidity risk management policies and procedures are inadequate; the bank's Management Board does not demonstrate the ability to correct these deficiencies. The Board of Directors and Management Board do not fully understand or prefer to ignore the key aspects of liquidity risk. The Management Board does not foresee or take timely and necessary measures in response to market changes. |
| Liquidity risk management policy | The policy approved by the Board of Directors effectively regulates liquidity risk management procedures, allocation of responsibility and accountability. The Board of Directors receives timely and sufficient information regarding the bank's exposure to liquidity risk. Measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are effective and aimed at reducing the negative impact of this deviation on the bank's financial stability. | The policy approved by the Board of Directors adequately regulates liquidity risk management procedures, allocation of responsibility and accountability. There may be minor shortcomings. Information on any significant deviations provided to the Board of Directors is satisfactory and effective for maintaining the bank's financial stability. Measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are adequate, but there are some areas requiring improvement and control by the Board of Directors and Management Board. | The policy approved by the Board of Directors is inadequate or incompetent. The policy has a deficiency in one or two significant parameters. The Board of Directors does not receive sufficient information to monitor and control the bank's exposure to liquidity risk in an adequate manner. Measures taken to eliminate an identified deviation are ineffective; the Board of Directors and Management Board have not demonstrated their ability to resolve the problems. |
| Internal documents regulating the process of assessment, monitoring and control of liquidity risk | The liquidity risk management process is effective in identifying, monitoring and controlling liquidity risk. The policy demonstrates a sound culture with effective experience over a long period. | The liquidity risk management process is generally effective in identifying, monitoring and controlling liquidity. Insignificant shortcomings due to the complexity of the risks assumed are easily correctable. | The management process is ineffective in identifying, monitoring and controlling liquidity risk. |
| Contingency action plan | The contingency action plan is developed and effective. The plan includes reasonable assumptions, scenarios and crisis management planning, and also takes into account the bank's needs for additional resources. | The contingency action plan is adequate. It corresponds to the current condition, regulates procedures for resolving necessary issues and contains an adequate level of detail, including analysis of scenarios. The plan may require improvement in some areas. | The contingency action plan is inadequate because it does not take into account the bank's needs for additional resources or does not exist. The plan may not take into account the appropriate use of funds or their availability in a crisis situation. |
| Information used for management and internal control | The management information system provides adequate and timely information on exposure to liquidity risk. The Board of Directors and Management Board receive appropriate reporting to analyze and understand the liquidity risk profile in the bank. | The management information system may need minor improvement in one or several areas, but the Board of Directors and Management Board generally receive appropriate reporting to analyze and understand the liquidity risk profile in the bank. The management information system adequately captures concentration points and risk growth and provides timely, accurate and effective information. | The management information system has shortcomings requiring attention. The adequacy and (or) timeliness of the information provided may be insufficient. Information on exposure to liquidity risk may be incomplete. As a result, the Board of Directors and Management Board may not receive appropriate or sufficient information to analyze and understand the liquidity risk profile in the bank. |
| Information used for assessing and planning the liquidity condition | The bank uses information systems and analytical procedures that make it possible to measure the liquidity risk associated with the bank's operations reflected on the bank's balance sheet. The management information system provides complete information on the bank's claims and liabilities and contains historical data. | The necessary information is stored in information databases and is available to all employees involved in the forecasting process in the required volume. At the same time, the bank uses historical data to determine actual maturity and demand dates. The bank has a sufficient volume of historical data to conduct statistical estimates of possible write-offs and inflows of funds during the day, taking into account other factors. | Only actual information is used to calculate indicators characterizing the bank's liquidity level, which is available to individual employees. Updating of information is not regulated by the bank's internal documents. |
| Level of automation of activities at different stages of liquidity risk management in the bank | Information technologies are integrated into business processes and fully automate them, providing the opportunity to improve the quality and efficiency of the bank's work. Information systems contain reliable information with the necessary level of detail for carrying out all liquidity risk management procedures. | The bank uses software products that make it possible to build mathematical and statistical models to obtain forecast values of outflow (inflow) of funds to client accounts and actual maturity and demand dates of assets. Information systems store a significant archive of historical data on the bank's assets and liabilities. Updating and supplementing of information occurs regularly. | Work is performed using standard Microsoft office applications. There is a system for recording transactions performed. |
| Internal audit service | Employees of the internal audit service possess the necessary experience and skills to assess the effectiveness of the bank's liquidity risk management system. The internal audit service regularly reviews the implementation by the bank's units and the effectiveness of the agreed liquidity risk management structure. | The internal audit service reviews the implementation by the bank's units and the effectiveness of the agreed liquidity risk management structure. A small number of shortcomings does not affect the effectiveness and reliability of its results. | In the course of its activities, the internal audit service does not review the implementation by the bank's units and the adequacy of the agreed liquidity risk management structure. |
Generalized conclusions:
| Assessment of the quality of liquidity risk control | Liquidity risk assessment level | ||
| Low | Moderate | High | |
| Aggregate liquidity risk | |||
| Strong | Low | Low | Moderate |
| Acceptable | Low | Moderate | High |
| Weak | Moderate | High | High |
Low - The Board of Directors and Management Board promptly identify and control liquidity risk. The Board of Directors and Management Board actively participate in risk management and ensure the availability of appropriate internal regulations. The requirements of policies and procedures are supported by risk monitoring procedures, reports and management information systems that provide all necessary information for its analysis, timely and proper response to ongoing changes. Bank employees comply with the requirements of the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, internal rules and procedures, and functional duties are performed in accordance with job descriptions. The internal control system is adequate and corresponds to the size and activities of the bank. Some deviations from established internal rules and procedures are noted, but they are not significant. Liquidity risk management is considered fully effective for identifying, monitoring and controlling risk. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activities are sufficient.
Moderate - Liquidity risk management in the bank is sufficiently effective, but minor shortcomings take place. Liquidity risk management reflects rapid response and the ability to successfully manage risk that may arise in the course of implementing the strategy. Although some shortcomings in liquidity risk management may be observed in the bank, these deficiencies are identified and corrected in a timely manner. On the whole, control by the Board of Directors and Management Board, internal rules and procedures for monitoring and controlling risk, reporting and management information systems are considered satisfactory and effective for maintaining the bank's stable operation. On the whole, risks are under control to a sufficient degree that does not require additional control by the bank's risk management. The internal control system shows some shortcomings or deficiencies, but they are all corrected in the course of the unit's current work. Employees of the internal audit service provide recommendations for their improvement, but the noted shortcomings will not have a significant impact on the reliable and stable operation of the unit. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activities are adequate.
High - The bank lacks effective liquidity risk management procedures that do not allow identifying, tracking, monitoring and controlling potential liquidity risk. Risk management elements are considered fully insufficient, and the Board of Directors and Management Board do not demonstrate the ability to correct these deficiencies. The professionalism of specific employees and the bank's Management Board is called into question. Systematic violations of internal policies and procedures are observed. The internal control system may be so weak that it negatively affects the bank's financial stability. Immediate concern must be shown regarding the reliability of accounting, financial reports and potential losses that may arise if immediate corrective measures are not taken. Shortcomings in liquidity risk management procedures and in internal control systems require immediate and careful attention by the bank's risk management. Measures aimed at reducing negative trends in the bank's activities are inadequate.
First executive (or person acting in their place)______ ______ ______
(surname, name, patronymic if any) (signature) (date)
Head of the risk management unit
(surname, name, patronymic if any) (signature) (date)
Executor:______ ______
(position, surname and name) (signature)
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
A newer document in RegAlert replaces this one.
“Resolution of the Board of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations dated 30 September 2005 No. 359”
“To recognize as having lost force: 1) Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 112 of 5 June 1998”
“2) Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 434 of 6 December 2003”
“2. To introduce the following amendments to Resolution of the Board of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations dated 30 September 2005 No. 359 “On approval …”
“annual control of the existence of risk management and internal control systems in a bank having a banking holding company and (or) major participants of the bank, including assessments of the compliance of said systems with the requiremen…”
“in accordance with Resolution of the Board of the Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan on Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Market and Financial Organizations No. 359 of 30 September 2005”
Amended 2 times · last 2014-02-26
More like this from NBK
NBK published 6 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: National Bank of Kazakhstan — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added