Almaty city
On Approval of the Rules for Selecting Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund
In accordance with the Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 30 March 1995 "On the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan", in order to ensure the efficiency of managing pension assets of the single accumulative pension fund, the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan RESOLVES:
- To approve the attached Rules for Selecting Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund.
- To recognize as no longer in force Resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan No. 173 of 27 September 2017 "On Approval of the Rules for Selecting Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund" (registered in the Register of State Registration of Normative Legal Acts under No. 15947, published on 9 November 2017 in the Reference Control Bank of Normative Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan).
- The Monetary Operations Department shall, in the manner established by the legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, ensure:
- together with the Legal Department, state registration of this resolution with the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
- placement of this resolution on the official internet resource of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan after its official publication;
- within ten working days after state registration of this resolution, submission to the Legal Department of information on the implementation of the measures provided for by subparagraph 2) of this paragraph and paragraph 4 of this resolution.
- The Information and Communications Department – Press Service of the National Bank shall ensure, within ten calendar days after state registration of this resolution, that a copy of it is sent for official publication to periodicals.
- Control over the execution of this resolution shall be entrusted to the supervising Deputy Chairman of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
- This resolution enters into force upon the expiry of ten calendar days after the day of its first official publication.
Chairman
of the National Bank E. Dosayev
|
|---|
| Approved by resolution of the Board of the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 15 June 2020 No. 78 |
Rules
for Selecting Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund
Chapter 1. General Provisions
-
-
- These Rules for Selecting Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund (hereinafter – the Rules) have been developed in accordance with the laws of the Republic of Kazakhstan of 30 March 1995 "On the National Bank of the Republic of Kazakhstan", of 21 June 2013 "On Pension Provision in the Republic of Kazakhstan", and determine the procedure for selecting foreign organizations managing pension assets of the single accumulative pension fund (hereinafter – the Fund), including requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets of the Fund.
- The following concepts are used in the Rules:
- enhanced index asset management – a type of management in which the value of the variability of the deviation of return (tracking error) is from 0.5 (zero point five) to 2 (two) percent inclusive. Enhanced index management assumes a moderate deviation from the main benchmarks of the reference portfolio;
- information ratio – the ratio of the level of excess return to the variability of the deviation of return (tracking error);
- specialized system – software and (or) a special internet resource possessing a database of investment and (or) analytical data necessary for analyzing the activities of external managers;
- specialized mandate – a mandate transferred to external management for the purpose of diversifying assets by applying investment strategies that assume unique investment approaches at the level of individual asset classes, types of management, countries and regions;
- diversification – placement of assets in financial instruments and other property for the purpose of reducing the risk inherent in a particular asset class;
- managerial control – the ability of one legal entity directly and (or) indirectly to determine decisions and (or) influence decisions taken by another legal entity in connection with participation (ownership) in such legal entity;
- exchange market – a set of relations using the trading systems of a trade organizer that carries out organizational and technical support of trades;
- global mandate – a portfolio whose investments go beyond one country (market, region);
- investment due diligence – a set of analytical measures aimed at a comprehensive verification and assessment of the effectiveness of the investment activity of an external manager;
- institutional investor – a legal entity that invests money in financial instruments;
- group of companies – legal entities that together are under the managerial control of one legal entity, or legal entities one of which has managerial control over the other legal entity;
- assets under advisory servicing – assets under the management of an external manager for which the external manager advises the client in terms of investment asset management;
- mandate – a portfolio with defined investment characteristics;
- margin account – an account for conducting operations with derivative financial instruments, opened with a clearing organization and used for the purpose of placing collateral for transactions and conducting settlements on operations with derivative financial instruments;
- operational due diligence – a set of analytical measures aimed at a comprehensive verification and assessment of the effectiveness of the operational activity of an external manager;
- regional mandate – a portfolio whose investments are concentrated within one country (market, region);
- portfolio manager – a person responsible for managing clients' assets;
- external manager – a foreign organization, including a bank, established in accordance with the legislation of a foreign state, specializing in the investment management of clients' assets and carrying out its activities in international financial markets;
- external management – a type of management of pension assets in which pension assets are transferred to the investment management of an external manager;
- external transition management – a type of asset management in which pension assets are transferred to an external transition manager for the purpose of minimizing risks in connection with changes in the structure of the transferred assets before the selection and (or) transfer of assets to the external manager under the relevant mandate;
- external transition manager – a foreign organization, including a bank, established in accordance with the legislation of a foreign state, specializing in the external transition management of clients' assets and carrying out its activities in international financial markets;
- transition period – a time period applied to a portfolio, established in accordance with the Rules for the purpose of bringing it into compliance with the parameters established by the investment management agreement;
- authorized subdivision – a subdivision of the National Bank that carries out management and monitoring of the pension assets of the Fund;
- management of the National Bank – the Chairman of the National Bank, the Deputy Chairman of the National Bank supervising the authorized subdivision;
- level of excess return – the difference between the actually achieved level of return and the level of return of the reference portfolio;
- forex operations – the purchase and (or) sale of foreign currency on the exchange and over-the-counter markets.
-
- The total permissible volume of pension assets of the Fund transferred to external management to one external manager is not more than 10 (ten) percent of the volume of the portfolio of pension assets of the Fund in foreign currency.
- If the limit provided for by paragraph 3 of the Rules is exceeded, including in the case of a merger of two existing external managers, the authorized subdivision shall eliminate the non-compliance within 3 (three) months from the day such excess arises.
- Pension assets of the Fund are transferred to external management for the purposes of:
- reducing the level of risks associated with types of management;
- increasing the return on management of pension assets of the Fund through the use of the experience, analytical materials, research and technical resources of the external manager;
- improving the efficiency of managing pension assets of the Fund through the application of expertise and consultations in the field of asset management obtained from external managers;
- introducing new asset classes for which there is no experience in independent asset management.
-
- The choice of the type of management (active, enhanced index or passive (index)) and the reference portfolio for the external manager is carried out in accordance with the objectives of managing the pension assets of the Fund and the restrictions provided for by the investment declaration of the Fund, depending on the market situation.
- The external manager or external transition manager is paid a fixed commission fee and (or) a commission fee depending on the results of managing the transferred pension assets of the Fund to external management or external transition management, in accordance with the investment management agreement.
Chapter 2. Procedure for Selecting External Managers of Pension Assets of the Fund, Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing Them to Perform Actions Necessary for Managing Pension Assets of the Fund
-
-
- The organization of the procedure for selecting external managers is carried out by the authorized subdivision.
- The authorized subdivision publishes on the official internet resource of the National Bank, as well as on other information and analytical resources available to potential external managers, information about the planned selection of an external manager, compiles a list of potential external managers, and sends information to potential external managers.
A mandatory condition for considering a proposal of a potential external manager is its consent to the inclusion of the conditions provided for by paragraph 24 of the Rules in the investment management agreement.
-
-
- A potential external manager submits to the National Bank in electronic form and (or) on paper the minimum information requested from a potential external manager, in accordance with Appendix 1 to the Rules. It is permitted for the authorized subdivision to obtain information from a specialized system.
- The authorized subdivision carries out a comparative analysis of all received proposals of potential external managers, taking into account the mandatory requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for management, provided for by paragraphs 12 and (or) 13 of the Rules.
If a potential external manager meets the mandatory requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets, provided for in paragraphs 12 and (or) 13 of the Rules, the authorized subdivision carries out a comparative analysis of the proposals of potential external managers in accordance with the evaluation criteria for conducting a comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers (hereinafter – the Evaluation Criteria) according to Appendix 2 to the Rules for forming a long list of potential external managers (hereinafter – the long list).
When conducting a comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers, it is permitted to use the National Bank's own data on existing external managers of the National Bank's gold and foreign exchange assets and assets under the National Bank's trust management.
For the purpose of clarifying the information submitted by a potential external manager, the authorized subdivision may send additional requests to such potential external manager. If a potential external manager fails to submit additionally requested information, the score for the corresponding criterion in the Evaluation Criteria is not taken into account.
-
-
- For the selection of external managers under global mandates, the mandatory requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets, are:
- experience working with financial instruments in which it is planned to invest the pension assets of the Fund – not less than 10 (ten) years, of which not less than 5 (five) years of experience working under the announced mandate, or if the potential external manager has under management exclusively analogous regional mandates – not less than 5 (five) years of experience working under regional mandates that constitute not less than 75 (seventy-five) percent of the coverage of the global mandate.
It is permitted to calculate the work experience of a potential external manager taking into account the work experience of legal entities included with it in a group of companies;
- the aggregate size of clients' assets under the management of the potential external manager (including assets under advisory servicing) – not less than the equivalent of 25 (twenty-five) billion US dollars (hereinafter – the USA);
- the aggregate size of clients' assets under the mandate under consideration under the management of the potential external manager – not less than the equivalent of 1 (one) billion US dollars, or if the potential external manager has under management exclusively analogous regional mandates – not less than the equivalent of 1 (one) billion US dollars under regional mandates that constitute not less than 75 (seventy-five) percent of the coverage of the global mandate.
-
- For the selection of external managers under specialized mandates, the mandatory requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets, are:
- experience of the potential external manager working with financial instruments in which it is planned to invest the pension assets of the Fund – not less than 5 (five) years, of which not less than 3 (three) years of experience working under the announced mandate, or if the potential external manager has under management exclusively analogous regional mandates – not less than 3 (three) years of experience working under regional mandates that constitute not less than 75 (seventy-five) percent of the coverage of the global mandate.
It is permitted to calculate the work experience of a potential external manager taking into account the work experience of legal entities included with it in a group of companies;
- the aggregate size of clients' assets under the management of the potential external manager (including assets under advisory servicing) – not less than the equivalent of 1 (one) billion US dollars;
- the aggregate size of clients' assets under the mandate under consideration under the management of the potential external manager – not less than the equivalent of 150 (one hundred and fifty) million US dollars.
At the same time, the volume of pension assets transferred to one external manager does not exceed 50 (fifty) percent of the volume of assets under investment management under the mandate under consideration under the management of such external manager.
-
-
- The authorized subdivision may approach clients of a potential external manager with a request about the results and quality of management of clients' assets.
- The conclusion prepared by the authorized subdivision on the long list, containing a comparative analysis of the proposals of potential external managers and recommendations on their selection, is submitted for consideration to the Chairman of the National Bank, who, based on the results of consideration, approves the short list of potential external managers with the most advantageous proposals (hereinafter – the short list) by endorsing the conclusion of the authorized subdivision.
The authorized subdivision conducts negotiations with potential external managers from the short list for the purpose of improving the terms of the proposals of external managers.
-
-
- The authorized subdivision conducts an additional assessment of the proposals of potential external managers from the short list according to the Evaluation Criteria for conducting a comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers from the short list within the framework of investment and operational due diligence in accordance with Appendix 3 to the Rules. If the total scores of potential external managers from the short list are equal, the proposal of the potential external manager from the short list that has expressed consent to localize its office in the territory of the Astana International Financial Centre shall have preference.
- When conducting investment and operational due diligence, for the purpose of obtaining additional information about the procedure for making investment decisions and risk control procedures, the authorized subdivision may hold meetings with potential external managers and visit their offices.
- If a potential external manager that has not previously been in contractual relations with the National Bank is proposed for selection as an external manager, a visit to its office is mandatory.
- The decision on the selection of external managers is taken by the Board of the National Bank.
In cases of transfer to a legal successor of the rights and obligations of an external manager arising from the investment management agreement in connection with the reorganization of such external manager, as well as in cases of transfer by an external manager of its rights and obligations arising from the investment management agreement to another legal entity (company), the selection of such persons as an external manager is carried out without conducting the procedures provided for by paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 of the Rules.
-
-
- If an external manager carrying out external management of part of the National Bank's gold and foreign exchange assets and (or) assets under the National Bank's trust management, under an analogous mandate with a positive level of excess return for a period of not less than 3 (three) years, meets the requirements for it, when instructing it to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets, established by paragraphs 12 and (or) 13 of the Rules, then by decision of the Chairman of the National Bank its candidacy is submitted for consideration to the Board of the National Bank as an external manager without conducting the procedures provided for by paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 of the Rules.
- To reduce the risks of concentration of assets in external management within one mandate (but not one type of management), the number of existing external managers is not less than 2 (two) external managers.
- For the purpose of accelerating the process of selecting external managers, replacing existing external managers and increasing competition among external managers, the authorized subdivision may form a reserve list of potential external managers (hereinafter – the reserve list) from among the potential external managers from the short list for subsequent approval by the Board of the National Bank.
The authorized subdivision monitors the activities of external managers on the reserve list and annually updates information within the framework of investment and operational due diligence.
The transfer of pension assets of the Fund to an external manager from the approved reserve list is carried out after the Board of the National Bank adopts a decision on its selection as an external manager without conducting the procedures provided for by paragraphs 9, 10 and 11 of the Rules.
-
-
- Measures related to the conclusion of the investment management agreement and further monitoring of compliance with its terms are carried out by the authorized subdivision.
- The investment management agreement contains the following conditions:
- on the existence of the National Bank's right to early terminate the investment management agreement in the following cases:
failure by the external manager to achieve excess return on portfolio management compared to the reference portfolio;
violation by the external manager of the restrictions established by the investment declaration of the Fund;
introduction of changes to the investment declaration of the Fund;
existence of a resolution of the Board of the National Bank with the provision of written notification to the external manager and indication of the date of termination of the investment management agreement;
- on the existence of the National Bank's right, at its discretion, at any time to replenish (withdraw) the pension assets of the Fund under external management;
- on the submission by the external manager of information on the movement of its personnel responsible for managing the pension assets of the Fund transferred to external management;
- on visits to the external manager by employees of the National Bank and independent auditors for the purpose of checking account operations, as well as obtaining additional information about the external manager, the procedure for making investment decisions and risk monitoring procedures;
- on the prohibition of engaging as brokers or counterparties in transactions with the pension assets of the Fund transferred to external management persons affiliated with the external manager;
- on the responsibility of the external manager for violating the limit of expected variability of the deviation of return (ex-ante tracking error) established in the investment management agreement;
- on the responsibility of the external manager for possible losses caused to the Fund as a result of negligence, deliberate failure to fulfill obligations or fraud on the part of the external manager;
- on the obligation of the external manager to advise, train or conduct internships for employees of the National Bank engaged in the management and monitoring of the pension assets of the Fund;
- on the obligation of the external manager to submit to the National Bank on a regular basis in accordance with the investment management agreement the following reports:
reporting on operations carried out on the previous working day on a daily basis;
portfolio valuation (distribution of assets by various classes and types of currencies, composition of the portfolio at the end of the reporting month, market value of assets at the end of the reporting month);
movement in the portfolio (a list of all transactions concluded during the reporting quarter, sorted by various classes and currencies, maturity, dividend payment and accrued interest);
analysis of portfolio management results (monthly, quarterly and overall portfolio management results in terms of achieved return, portfolio risk indicators and the level of variability of return deviation (tracking error) compared with the benchmark portfolio);
report on the state of the relevant markets and their impact on the portfolio and (or) macroeconomic review;
review of the strategy and explanation of the most important changes in the portfolio structure;
current investment strategy;
contribution of various factors to portfolio return for active asset management;
- on the external manager's reconciliation, at the end of each month or on the date of completion of the transition period, of the composition of the portfolio transferred to external management with the data of the custodian bank(s) in accordance with the investment management agreement;
- on the external manager's submission of information on completed transactions to the custodian bank responsible for consolidated accounting no later than the next business day after approval and completion of the procedures for confirming transactions between the external manager and the broker;
- on the external manager's submission of information and documents on the procedures for approving brokers, as well as agents and counterparties of the external manager;
- on the external manager's submission of information on the existence of the external manager's internal risk management policies and procedures that reduce the risk of abuse and conflict of interest, including those ensuring equal distribution of transactions among clients' portfolios;
- on the external manager's holding, once a year, meetings with the authorized subdivision to present the results of managing the Fund's pension assets, compliance with investment restrictions, assessment of the market situation and its possible impact on the portfolio and on the execution of investment operations with the Fund's pension assets;
- on the external manager's submission of information on measures applied by supervisory authorities and participation in court proceedings;
- on the external manager's submission to the National Bank of full reporting on the portfolio reconciled with the custodian bank(s) as of the date of termination of the investment management agreement;
- on the signing of the investment management agreement in the Kazakh, Russian languages and in the language determined by agreement of the parties;
- on the possibility of making changes and (or) additions to the investment management agreement with the written consent of both parties.
-
- The National Bank, in accordance with the investment management agreement, transfers the Fund's pension assets to external management by transferring money and (or) securities to the National Bank's accounts with the custodian bank(s) intended for external management.
- When transferring the Fund's pension assets to external management, the transition period for forming the portfolio in accordance with the target parameters established by the investment management agreement is taken into account. The duration of the transition period does not exceed 15 (fifteen) working days.
- The Fund's pension assets transferred to external management are kept in the National Bank's accounts with the custodian bank(s) and in a margin account with a clearing broker.
- From the day the Fund's pension assets are transferred to external management, the authorized subdivision conducts daily monitoring of the external manager's activities by checking compliance with the restrictions established in the investment management agreement, monitoring transactions made by the external manager, and assessing the risk and return indicators of the portfolio under external management.
- The authorized subdivision, in accordance with the investment management agreement, holds a meeting with the external manager or organizes a video or teleconference at least once a year, at which the external manager reports on management results, compliance with investment restrictions, and gives an assessment of the market situation and its possible impact on the portfolio and on the execution of investment operations with the Fund's pension assets.
- The performance of existing external managers is assessed on the basis of the methodology for assessing the performance of an external manager set out in Appendix 4 to the Rules. Based on the results of the assessment of the external manager's performance as a whole and by asset classes over the last 3 (three), 5 (five) years and more from the date management began, taking into account the commission fee charged, the management of the National Bank adopts an appropriate decision on replenishing (withdrawing) the Fund's pension assets or continuing (terminating) work with the given external manager, or submitting this issue for consideration by the Board of the National Bank.
- By decision of the management of the National Bank, withdrawal of the Fund's pension assets or early termination of the investment management agreement is carried out without the procedure specified in paragraph 30 of the Rules.
- A report on the results of management by external managers is submitted by the authorized subdivision for consideration by the Board of the National Bank at least once a year.
Chapter 3. Procedure for selecting an external transition manager of the Fund's pension assets, including requirements for them, when instructing them to perform actions necessary for managing the Fund's pension assets
-
-
- To select an external transition manager, the authorized subdivision sends a request to potential transition managers for information on coverage markets, transition management strategies and cost of services by class of instruments and markets and analyzes the proposals received.
- To select an external transition manager, a mandatory requirement for it, when instructing it to perform actions necessary for managing pension assets, is experience in transition management of portfolios of financial instruments subject to transition management – at least 5 (five) years.
The decision to select an external transition manager is made by the Chairman of the National Bank.
-
-
- Measures related to concluding the investment management agreement and further monitoring of compliance with its terms are carried out by the authorized subdivision.
- The investment management agreement contains the following conditions:
- on the National Bank's right to early terminate the investment management agreement in the following cases:
violation by the external transition manager of the terms of the investment management agreement;
decision of the Chairman of the National Bank;
- on the National Bank's right, at its discretion, at any time to replenish (withdraw) the Fund's pension assets under external transition management, if such actions do not affect any unfinished external transition management of the Fund's pension assets;
- on the external transition manager's submission of information on the movement of its personnel responsible for managing the Fund's pension assets transferred to external transition management;
- on visits to the external transition manager by National Bank employees and independent auditors for the purpose of checking account operations, as well as obtaining additional information about the external transition manager, the investment decision-making procedure and risk monitoring procedures;
- on the external transition manager's liability for possible losses caused by negligence, intentional failure to fulfill obligations or fraud on the part of the external transition manager;
- on the external transition manager's submission of information on completed transactions to the custodian bank responsible for consolidated accounting no later than the next business day after approval and completion of the procedures for confirming transactions between the external transition manager and the broker;
- on the external transition manager's submission of information and documents on the procedures for approving brokers, as well as agents and counterparties of the external transition manager;
- on the external transition manager's submission of information on the existence of the external transition manager's internal risk management policies and procedures that reduce the risk of abuse and conflict of interest, including those ensuring equal distribution of transactions among clients' portfolios;
- on the obligation of the external transition manager to submit to the National Bank, in accordance with the investment management agreement, within 10 (ten) working days after the completion of the transition period, the following reports:
reporting on all transactions with securities made by the external transition manager and its affiliated brokers (dealers) and futures brokers during the transition period;
report on the results of the external transition management of the Fund's pension assets, including the difference in the execution price of the transaction, commission fees of brokers, market impact, the difference in exchange rates for currency purchase and sale in forex operations, taxes and lost profit as of the date of completion of the transition period;
report on the state of the relevant markets and their impact on the portfolio;
review of the strategy and explanation of the most important changes in the portfolio structure;
- on the external transition manager's submission of information on measures applied by supervisory authorities and participation in court proceedings;
- on the external transition manager's submission, at the moment of completion of the transition period, of full reporting on the portfolio reconciled with the custodian bank(s) as of the date of completion of the transition period in accordance with the investment management agreement;
- on the signing of the investment management agreement in the Kazakh, Russian languages and in the language determined by agreement of the parties;
- on the possibility of making changes and (or) additions to the investment management agreement with the written consent of both parties.
-
- The National Bank, in accordance with the investment management agreement, transfers the Fund's pension assets to external transition management by transferring money and (or) securities to the National Bank's accounts with the custodian bank(s) intended for external transition management.
The transfer of the Fund's pension assets to the external transition manager is carried out for a period of not more than 12 (twelve) months.
-
-
- When transferring the Fund's pension assets to external transition management, the transition period for forming the portfolio in accordance with the target parameters established by the investment management agreement is taken into account. The duration of the transition period does not exceed 15 (fifteen) working days.
- The Fund's pension assets transferred to external transition management are kept in the National Bank's accounts with the custodian bank(s) and in a margin account with a clearing broker. Placement of the Fund's pension assets in the external transition manager's margin account opened with a third party is allowed if there is an agreement between the National Bank and the external transition manager on the terms of operations on such account or the terms of operations on such account in the investment management agreement.
- From the day the Fund's pension assets are transferred to external transition management, the authorized subdivision conducts daily monitoring of the external transition manager's activities by checking compliance with the restrictions established in the investment management agreement and monitoring transactions made by the external transition manager.
Appendix 1
to the Rules for selecting
foreign organizations managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund,
including requirements for them, when instructing
them to perform actions necessary
for managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund
Minimum information requested from a potential
external manager
- Work experience of the potential external manager in the type of mandate under consideration.
- Volume of clients' assets under (previously under) management of the potential external manager over the last 5 (five) years, including:
- volume of total assets under (previously under) management;
- volume of assets for the type of mandate under consideration;
- volume of assets of institutional clients (including assets of central banks);
- volume of assets in segregated accounts.
- Information on portfolio managers and client relationship managers who will be responsible for the assets transferred to external management.
- Information on personnel movement over the last 10 (ten) years among employees of the investment block of the potential external manager (portfolio managers, analysts and traders).
- Detailed description of the investment process, portfolio management methods, market research, sources of information used and the financial instrument valuation model.
- How active market risk is modeled, monitored and managed (if the type of mandate under consideration relates to active management).
- Availability of specialized software for risk monitoring and management.
- Historical portfolio management results for a similar mandate over the last 5 (five) years with a benchmark portfolio identical or close in type.
- Description of the software used to calculate return and risk, used in financial and analytical reporting.
- Brief description of internal corporate governance.
- Liability of the external manager to the National Bank in case of violation of the terms of the investment management agreement.
- Information on the types of insurance used to protect the client from errors of the external manager.
- Terms of organizing training.
- Information on the expected level of commission fee for external management.
- Audited financial report of the potential external manager for the last financial year.
- Internal policies and procedures of the external manager regulating issues of reducing the risk of abuse and conflict of interest, including ensuring equal and fair distribution of transactions among clients' portfolios, verification of the list and procedures for approving brokers, agents and counterparties of the external manager.
Appendix 2
to the Rules for selecting
foreign organizations managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund,
including requirements for them, when instructing
them to perform actions necessary
for managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund
Evaluation criteria for comparative analysis
of proposals of potential external managers
| | |
|---|
| No. | Evaluation criteria | Score assigned to criteria (significance of the indicator is determined in percent) |
| 1. | Historical portfolio management results (when conducting a comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers specializing in regional mandates and participating in the selection of a manager for a global mandate, the indicators are normalized depending on the coverage of the relevant mandate) | 35 points |
| annual geometric excess return over the last 3 (three) – 5 (five) years (if the excess return indicator for a period of less than 5 (five) years is positive, the indicator is normalized relative to a period of 5 (five) years) | 40 percent | |
| average arithmetic information ratio over the last 3 (three) – 5 (five) years (if the information ratio indicator for a period of less than 5 (five) years is positive, the indicator is normalized relative to a period of 5 (five) years) | 60 percent | |
| 2. | Organization and Assets | 15 points |
| employee participation in the organization's capital structure (employee owned) | 25 percent | |
| average annual change (in percent) of assets under management (outflows and inflows over the last 3 (three) – 5 (five) years or since the start of management) | 25 percent | |
| percentage of the volume of assets for the given mandate under consideration to total assets under management (when conducting a comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers specializing in regional mandates and participating in the selection of a manager for a global mandate, the volume of assets for regional mandates is used. This value is normalized depending on the coverage of the relevant mandate) | 25 percent | |
| share of the volume of assets of institutional investors to total assets under management | 25 percent | |
| 3. | Team | 15 points |
| average work experience of portfolio managers and analysts responsible for managing assets under the relevant mandate | 50 percent | |
| personnel movement among employees of the investment block (portfolio managers, analysts, traders) in the company as a whole (the lowest value is taken into account) | 50 percent | |
| 4. | Availability of a type of insurance of clients' interests against actions or inactions of the external manager | 5 points |
| 5. | Level of commission fee for management | 20 points |
| level of base commission fee (the lowest value is taken into account) | 75 percent | |
| acceptance of the principle of paying a commission fee based on the results of external management upon achieving a positive excess return exceeding similar indicators for past periods since the start of management by the external manager (net new high basis since inception) | 10 percent | |
| acceptance of a condition on the minimum threshold of excess return from which the calculation of the commission fee based on the results of external management begins, not lower than the base commission fee | 10 percent | |
| acceptance of the establishment of a condition for payment of the commission fee based on the results of external management over several years in installments | 5 percent | |
| 6. | Training of National Bank employees | 10 points |
| short-term training lasting 1 (one) - 2 (two) weeks | 50 percent | |
| provision of the opportunity for an internship and (or) secondment lasting from 1 (one) month | 50 percent | |
Note:
- The evaluation of a potential external manager's proposal is the sum of points for all evaluation criteria in accordance with their significance.
- To calculate points, each indicator is subject to normalization relative to the best indicator in the criterion under consideration among all potential external managers.
At the same time, the normalized indicator of a potential external manager is the ratio of the external manager's indicator to the maximum value of the indicator for the criterion under consideration.
- If an external manager manages assets under a declared mandate within another mandate, then the historical results of managing these assets within the other mandate are assessed.
- When assessing the training of National Bank employees, the following system of indicators is used:
| |
|---|
| Indicator (conditions of employee training) | Score assigned to the indicator |
| External manager pays for flight, accommodation, meals | 1 |
| External manager pays for accommodation, meals | 0.5 |
| External manager pays for accommodation | 0.2 |
Appendix 3
to the Rules for selecting
foreign organizations managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund,
including requirements for them, when instructing
them to perform actions necessary
for managing pension assets
of the single accumulative pension fund
Evaluation criteria for comparative analysis of proposals of potential external managers from the short list within the framework of investment and operational due diligence
Table 1. Quantitative analysis
| | | | | |
|---|
| No. | Evaluation criteria | Points assigned to criteria (significance of indicators is determined in percent) | | | |
| Active management | Enhanced index management | Passive (index) management | | | |
| 1. | Historical risk-adjusted return indicators | 40 points | | 50 points | |
| annual geometric excess return over the last 3 (three) – 5 (five) years (if the excess return indicator for a period of less than 5 (five) years is positive, the indicator is normalized relative to a period of 5 (five) years) | 15 percent | 20 percent | 30 percent | | |
| average arithmetic information ratio over the last 3 (three) – 5 (five) years (if the excess return indicator for a period of less than 5 (five) years is positive, the indicator is normalized relative to a period of 5 (five) years) | 30 percent | 30 percent | 50 percent | | |
| Sharpe ratio | 15 percent | 25 percent | 20 percent | | |
| Sortino ratio | 40 percent | 25 percent | - | | |
| 2. | Indicators for assessing the stability of historical results | 30 points | | | |
| Level of variability of return deviation (tracking error) | 20 percent | 40 percent | 50 percent | | |
| Benchmark excess ratio | 30 percent | 40 percent | 50 percent | | |
| Kurtosis coefficient | 10 percent | - | - | | |
| Range of excess return indicator (absolute) | 20 percent | - | - | | |
| Duration of portfolio results exceeding the benchmark (in months) | 20 percent | 20 percent | - | | |
| 3. | Downside risk indicators | 30 points | | 20 points | |
| Variability of return deviation (tracking error) below the minimum threshold value | 10 percent | 10 percent | - | | |
| Average loss | 10 percent | 15 percent | 25 percent | | |
| Duration of unsatisfactory portfolio results against the benchmark (in months) | 25 percent | 15 percent | - | | |
| Maximum loss | 15 percent | 20 percent | 25 percent | | |
| Largest drop in portfolio value | 30 percent | 20 percent | 25 percent | | |
| Duration of portfolio results recovery | 10 percent | 20 percent | 25 percent | | |
Table 2. Qualitative analysis
| |
|---|
| Evaluation criteria | Satisfactory (unsatisfactory) |
| 1. Investment process | |
| 1.1. Formation of the investment portfolio | |
| assessment of the relevant restrictions and limits of the investment strategy of the proposed investment product | |
| use of analytical research and implementation of investment ideas | |
| assessment of portfolio management results for compliance with the declared style | |
| - 1. The decision-making process for buying or selling financial instruments | |
| decision-making model | |
| presence of a clear and consistent discipline for selling financial instruments, as well as procedures for establishing loss limits (stop-loss) | |
| 1. Internal control and monitoring procedures | |
| 2.1. Risk management process | |
| internal procedure or regulations of the external manager for managing portfolio risk | |
| availability of software for managing and monitoring portfolio risk | |
| - 1. The process of executing trading transactions | |
| presence of a best execution policy (Best Execution Policy), including the procedure for selecting and approving counterparties and trading venues | |
| presence of compliance procedures and data reconciliation | |
| settlement of transactions with securities | |
Note:
-
- The evaluation of the proposal of a potential external manager from the short list is the sum of points for all criteria given in Table 1, in accordance with their significance.
- For the purposes of calculating points, each indicator is subject to normalization relative to the best indicator in the criterion under consideration among all potential external managers from the short list. In this case, the normalized indicator is the ratio of the indicator of the external manager from the short list to the maximum value of the indicator for the criterion under consideration.
- When assessing the investment process and internal control and monitoring procedures of a potential external manager within the framework of qualitative analysis, the criteria of which are given in Table 2, the following system of indicators is used:
| |
|---|
| Indicator | Point assigned to the indicator |
| Satisfactory – the process and (or) procedures of the potential external manager correspond to the declared status, are clear and can be easily interpreted | 1 |
| Unsatisfactory – the process and (or) procedures of the potential external manager do not correspond to the declared status, are acceptable, however, there are problems in terms of implementing decisions within the company | 0 |
Appendix 4
to the Rules for Selecting
Foreign Organizations Managing Pension Assets
of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund,
Including Requirements for Them, When Instructing
Them to Perform Actions Necessary
for Managing Pension Assets
of the Single Accumulative Pension Fund
Methodology
for Assessing the Performance of the External Manager
- The assessment of the performance of the external manager is carried out by assigning points to the external manager in accordance with the quantitative and qualitative indicators provided for by this Methodology.
- Quantitative indicators:
information ratio (Information ratio)
| |
|---|
| Information ratio (Information ratio) | Assigned point |
| >1 | 3 points |
| 0.5 – 1 | 2 points |
| 0 - 0.5 | 1 point |
| 0 | 0 points |
| (-) 0.5- 0 | (-) 1 point |
| (-) 1 - (-) 0.5 | (-) 2 points |
| <(-) 1 | (-) 3 points |
- Qualitative indicators:
- staff turnover (Staff turnover)
| |
|---|
| Staff turnover (Staff turnover) in percent | Assigned point |
| > 30 | (-) 0.5 point |
| 5 - 30 | (-) 0.25 point |
| 0 - 5 | 0 points |
- operational risk (Operational risk).
For each fact of violation of the restrictions provided for by the investment strategy established for the external manager in the investment management agreement, as a result of an operational error, 0.2 (zero point two tenths) point is deducted from the assessment;
- compliance with a Code of Business Ethics (compliance with a Code of Business Ethics).
For each fact of violation by the external manager of business ethics, 0.5 (zero point five tenths) point is deducted from the assessment.
In case of systematic untimely execution of client instructions, 0.5 (zero point five tenths) point is deducted from the assessment.
- The final performance assessment is calculated as the sum of points for quantitative and qualitative indicators.