SMV Deputy Superintendence Resolution
No. 033-2021-SMV/10
Summary: Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of 9.09 UIT equivalent to S/ 36,814.50 (Thirty-six thousand eight hundred fourteen and 50/100 Soles), for having incurred in four (4) infractions: two (02) of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 and in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not keeping the Investment Register of a Fund in accordance with the regulations; and for the Investment Committee having failed to hold all the sessions of the 2017 fiscal year, respectively; and two (02) minor infractions typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not timely submitting two material events.
Likewise, the archive of the charge referring to the preparation of the financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year of a fund and of the management company itself, without observing accounting standards, is declared.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2021011926 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2021011926, and Report No. 525-2021-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the defenses presented by Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A.;
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
I. FACTS
- Through Report No. 198-2021-SMV/10.2, the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities communicated to the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance (hereinafter, IGCP), the indications of a possible infraction by Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. (hereinafter, Macrocapitales SAFI), in that it would have failed to comply with the provisions of the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, the Regulation), the Financial Information Regulation and Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Financial Information Regulation), the Norms on the preparation and presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by entities supervised by the Superintendence of the Securities Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV-01 (hereinafter, the Norms) and the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, Regulation of Material Events), in force at the time the events occurred;
- Under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, TUO LPAG), approved by DS No. 004-2019-JUS, through Official Letter No. 1305-2021-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges), notified on March 31, 2021, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Macrocapitales SAFI regarding the facts evidenced in the investigation carried out;
- By letter of April 21, 2021, Macrocapitales SAFI presented the requested defenses;
- The charges formulated against Macrocapitales SAFI and the defenses of the latter have been evaluated in Report No. 525-2021-SMV/10.3 issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendence;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title and in article 230, subsection 2, of the TUO LPAG, through Official Letter No. 1885-2021-SMV/10, the administrative file referred to in Report No. 525-2021-SMV/10.3 was made available to Macrocapitales SAFI for its review;
II. ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED
- In the present administrative procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendence of Prudential Supervision, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not Macrocapitales SAFI incurred in infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter Sanctions Regulation), in force at the time the events occurred, for non-compliance with article 38 of the Regulation, in relation to compliance with the obligation to communicate material events
- Whether or not Macrocapitales SAFI incurred in infraction of the provisions of Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, for having failed to observe article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the investment fund named "Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I" (hereinafter, the Fund), regarding obligations related to the sessions of the investment committee of said fund.
- Whether or not Macrocapitales SAFI incurred in infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred, for having failed to observe article 88 and Annex F of the Regulation as well as article 9 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund, regarding having an investment register of the Fund.
- Whether or not Macrocapitales SAFI incurred in infraction of the provisions of Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred, for having failed to observe the provisions of article 85 literal a) and article 132 of the Regulation, article 1 of the Norms, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37 and 4.38 literal b) of the Conceptual Framework for Financial Information" (hereinafter, Conceptual Framework), and paragraph 15 of IAS 1, regarding audited financial information of itself and of the Fund;
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on Macrocapitales SAFI;
III. ANALYSIS
-
- First charge: Non-communication of material events
On the regulations
- Article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation states the following:
"Article 38° Deadline for the appointment of Auditors
Companies obliged to present audited financial information must communicate, as a material event, the appointment of their independent auditors no later than June 30 of each year. Likewise, they must communicate as a material event the date on which the audit work will begin.
(…)";
- Likewise, according to article 9, numeral 9.1 of the Regulation of Material Events, it provides that:
"Article 9.- Opportunity to report material events
9.1. The Issuer must report its material event as soon as such event occurs or the Issuer becomes aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it has occurred or has been known. This information must be communicated to the SMV before any other person, entity or media, and simultaneously when applicable to the Exchange or the entity administering the respective centralized negotiation mechanism. This, regardless of whether the information has been generated or not in the Issuer itself.";
On the facts
- According to the material event of April 7, 2017, Macrocapitales SAFI communicated the appointment by its Board of Directors of the firm Ernst & Young (EY) as External Auditors of the management company for the 2017 and 2018 fiscal years, having for such agreement the authorization conferred by the shareholders' meeting of the company, through delegation of powers;
- Likewise, according to the material event of April 10, 2017, Macrocapitales SAFI communicated the appointment by the Surveillance Committee of the Fund of the firm EY as External Auditors of the Fund for the 2017 and 2018 fiscal years, having for such agreement the authorization conferred by the general assembly of participants to the Surveillance Committee of the Fund, through delegation of powers;
- Also, through notarial letter of March 14, 2019 that Macrocapitales SAFI addressed to the audit firm Paredes, Burga & Asociados S.C.R.L., representative of EY, the management company stated:
"At the beginning of 2017, Macrocapitales and the Fund requested the Audit Firm the issuance of two technical-economic proposals to provide the audit services of the Financial Statements corresponding to the 2017 fiscal year of the Fund and Macrocapitales. The acceptance of said proposals was ratified by Macrocapitales and the Fund in January 2018, starting the audit work of Macrocapitales and the Fund on February 6, 2018."
(…)" Our emphasis.
- However, as a result of the review of the material events submitted by Macrocapitales during 2018, it was determined that it failed to report as a material event the date on which the audit work would begin regarding the financial statements as of December 31, 2017, both of the Fund and of the management company itself;
- Therefore, Macrocapitales SAFI was charged with having failed to comply with the provisions of article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation by not having reported two material events referring to the start of the audit work regarding the financial statements as of December 31, 2017, both of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI;
On the Defenses Presented
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that in application of article 26), literal a) of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation), it expressly acknowledges that it failed to timely communicate the material events referring to the start of the audit work regarding the financial statements as of December 31, 2017, both of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI;
- The management company indicates that for the SMV to apply the sanction criteria referred to in article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, it proceeds to clarify the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, without implying that it is not acknowledging having committed said infraction;
- In this regard, Macrocapitales SAFI states that in compliance with the provisions of article 140[1] of the Regulation and numeral 11[2] of Annex 1 of the Regulation of Material Events, on April 7, 2017, it communicated as a material event the appointment of Ernst & Young (EY) as its External Auditors for the 2017 and 2018 fiscal years and that, on April 10, 2017, it communicated the appointment of EY as External Auditors of the Fund for the 2017 and 2018 fiscal years, by the Surveillance Committee of the Fund;
- Likewise, Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that on March 28, 2018, in compliance with the provisions of articles 85 and 133 of the Regulation and numeral 10 of Annex 1 of the Regulation of Material Events, on April 7, 2017, it sent to the Registry the audit report to the Financial Statements of the 2017 fiscal year issued by EY and communicated as a material event the audit report to the Financial Statements of the Fund corresponding to the 2017 fiscal year;
- Macrocapitales SAFI maintains that based on the foregoing, it is verified that at no time did it intend not to communicate the start of the audit work and that, on the contrary, at all times it chose to disclose the corresponding information within the deadlines and conditions established in the applicable regulations;
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that with the infraction committed, no economic damage would have been generated nor would it have a repercussion in the market. Likewise, that no illicit benefit was obtained nor did this act cause damage to the public interest or the participants. On the other hand, it adds that it must be taken into account that, being a material event, the probability of detection of the infraction is high; therefore, it is not possible to affirm that it committed this infraction assuming that it would not be sanctioned by the SMV, but rather that it was an error without any intention that has not generated any type of advantage or benefit for the company;
- Regarding recidivism, Macrocapitales SAFI adds that in the year prior to the date of the commission of the infraction, that is, between February 6, 2017 and February 6, 2018, the company had not been sanctioned for the commission of the infraction under analysis and that in that sense it does not have the status of recidivist;
- With respect to mitigating circumstances of responsibility, Macrocapitales SAFI states that it has expressly acknowledged its responsibility; therefore, it indicates that according to literal a) of the aforementioned article 26, if the SMV decides to sanction it with a fine, a 50% reduction of the same would correspond;
- Macrocapitales SAFI adds that likewise, it is in the assumption of the mitigating circumstance referred to in literal b) of article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation since it has contributed to the clarification of the infraction;
- Finally, Macrocapitales SAFI specifies that it has proceeded to correct its systems and internal controls to avoid similar situations in the future. However, it emphasizes that said omission does not respond to a deliberate intention on its part to fail the responsibilities inherent to it as a company supervised by the SMV; nor to contravene any existing legal provision; even less to the intention to hide or generate a negative impact on the market or for its benefit;
Analysis of the defenses
- On the matter, having Macrocapitales SAFI expressly acknowledged the commission of the facts charged, it has been demonstrated that said company failed to comply with the provisions of article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation by not having reported two material events referring to the start of the audit work regarding the financial statements as of December 31, 2017, both of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI;
- Consequently, Macrocapitales SAFI has incurred in two (02) infractions classified as minor typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the events occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a minor nature "Not timely providing, or doing so incompletely, or without observing the technical specifications approved by the SMV or without communicating the approval by the corresponding corporate body, to the SMV, the Exchange, the products exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism or any other entity or subject of the securities or products market, the individual or consolidated audited financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report, additional audit report, material events, annual reports."[3];
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that the acknowledgment of the infraction as well as the sanction criteria developed by Macrocapitales SAFI will be analyzed in the section of the Evaluation of the Sanction of this resolution;
- Second Charge: On the sessions of the Investment Committee of the Fund
On the Regulations
- According to article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund as of June 16, 2016, it is established that:
"Article 11.- The sessions of the Investment Committee
11.1 The sessions of the Investment Committee shall be held at least once every two (2) months to evaluate and approve new investments or divestments of the Fund, as well as to evaluate the evolution of the existing investment portfolio and to carry out the other activities provided in article 10 above. Without prejudice to this, the Investment Committee shall meet whenever the needs of the Fund require it."
On the facts
- During the inspection carried out on Macrocapitales SAFI from October 29 to November 20, 2018 (hereinafter, the Inspection), the SMV inspection team reviewed the Minutes Book of the Investment Committee of the Fund, specifically the sessions of the Investment Committee, which were held during 2017;
- In this regard, it was observed that in 2017 the Investment Committee of the Fund only met on four (4) occasions: 04/20/2017, 05/29/2017, 09/12/2017 and 12/13/2017, when at least six (6) sessions should have been held and the first of them, at least, should have been held on February 28, 2017, in accordance with article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund;
- Therefore, it was charged that Macrocapitales SAFI would have failed to comply with the provisions of article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund;
On the defenses presented
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that in application of article 26, literal a) of the New Sanctions Regulation, it expressly acknowledges that the Investment Committee of the Fund met only on the following dates 04/20/2017, 05/29/2017, 09/12/2017 and 12/13/2017 during the 2017 fiscal year, when at least six (6) sessions should have been held, in accordance with the provisions of article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund;
- On the other hand, Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that for the SMV to apply the sanction criteria referred to in article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, it proceeds to clarify the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, "(…) without implying that we are not acknowledging[4] having committed it";
- In this regard, Macrocapitales SAFI specifies that the lateness in holding the sessions was due to an involuntary error in the call to the sessions, since it considered that they should be held quarterly;
- Macrocapitales SAFI adds that, at the close of the 2016 fiscal year, the Fund completed making the investments in the companies that currently make up its portfolio, so during the 2017 fiscal year, the Investment Committee had completed the tasks related to analyzing investment opportunities or strategies for the Fund, having as a duty to develop the activities indicated in article 31 of the Participation Regulation of the Fund referring to the post-investment value generation period, that is, to evaluate and carry out periodic monitoring of the assets that make up the Fund's investments;
- On the matter, Macrocapitales SAFI states that such activities were not affected by the frequency with which the sessions were held during 2017, since they were carried out quarterly and complying with such purpose since the Fund's investments were between one to two years old;
- Additionally, Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that three (3) of the five (5) members of the Investment Committee during the 2017 fiscal year also served as members of other bodies of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI. Accordingly, it details that Mr. Raúl Salazar and Mr. Manuel Salazar served as members of the Advisory Council[5] of the Fund and titular directors of Macrocapitales SAFI, while Mrs. Mónica Com was part of the Advisory Council of the Fund. In that sense, it affirms that the aforementioned persons carried out a permanent monitoring of the Fund's investments from the sessions of other bodies;
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that in that sense, no economic damage would have been generated, nor would it have any repercussion in the market. Likewise, it states that it did not obtain an illicit benefit nor did this act cause damage to the public interest or the participants. It adds that, on the contrary, it was an involuntary act (unintentional) of the company, which does not have the status of recidivist and that it is a detectable infraction since the company must record the sessions of the Investment Committee in the respective minutes book;
- On the aforementioned, Macrocapitales SAFI requests the SMV to evaluate the use of the power granted by article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation referring to the possibility of imposing a sanction corresponding to a lower classification than the one provided and to take into consideration the provisions of literal a) of article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation, referring to mitigating circumstances of responsibility. On the matter, it states that Macrocapitales SAFI has expressly acknowledged its responsibility; therefore, it indicates that if the SMV decides to sanction it with a fine, a 50% reduction of the same would correspond;
- Finally, Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that through a document dated March 18, 2019, Macrocapitales SAFI communicated to the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities that, as a result of the observation indicated in the final report of the inspection visit, it implemented an internal system through which, electronically and automatically, on the corresponding dates, the General Manager, the Investment Manager, and the Operations Manager of the company receive alerts (tasks) referring to the fact that the process of calling the Investment Committee must be initiated;
- Likewise, Macrocapitales SAFI states that its system has been adjusted so that alerts are sent to the new management team of the company, in order to comply with the calls to the Investment Committee every two (2) months, in accordance with the provisions of the Participation Regulation of the Fund and that thus, in 2018, 2019, 2020 and so far in 2021, the sessions of the Investment Committee have been held every 2 months, in accordance with the provisions of the Participation Regulation of the Fund. In that sense, it maintains that they comply with the mitigating circumstances referred to in literals b) and c) of article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation since they have contributed to the clarification of the infraction and remedied the observation formulated by the SMV;
Analysis of the defenses
- In its defense, Macrocapitales SAFI expressly acknowledges its responsibility regarding the imputed infraction. It has also developed the sanction criteria that it considers should be taken into account when determining the sanction imposed;
- In this regard, since Macrocapitales SAFI has expressly acknowledged the commission of the facts imputed as a charge, it has been demonstrated that said company breached the provisions of Article 11 of the Fund's Participation Regulation, incurring an infraction classified as serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Failure to comply with the obligations corresponding to it in accordance with the provisions of the fund's internal regulations, or in the contracts entered into on behalf of the fund with participants and third parties."[6];
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that the acknowledgment of the infraction as well as the sanction criteria developed by Macrocapitales SAFI will be analyzed in the Section on the Evaluation of the Sanction of this resolution;
- Third charge: Failure to keep a register of investments of the Fund in accordance with the requirements of the regulations
On the regulations
- In this regard, Article 88 and Annex F of the Regulation establish:
"Article 88: On the books and records of the Fund
It is the responsibility of the Management Company to keep and maintain updated the accounting of the Funds it manages. For this purpose, for each Fund it must keep at least the following books and records:
(…)
d) A register of investments, in which each of the investments made with the Fund's resources shall be recorded in chronological order, indicating the amount of the purchase or sale, taxes and expenses incurred in the investment operation, as well as the information necessary to identify that the investments made comply with the provisions of the investment policy."
"ANNEX F
MINIMUM CONDITIONS OF TECHNOLOGICAL CAPACITY.
The Management Company must have technological capacity that allows it to normally develop its corporate purpose and comply with its information obligations.
To this end, it must have the following:
(…)
d) Have a computer system that allows the control of balances and movements of investments and the generation of reports necessary for an adequate and timely administration of information oriented to its Fund management activities.
(…)".
(Highlight added)
- Article 9, numeral 9.2, literal d), of the Fund's Participation Regulation establishes:
"Art. 9: Obligations of the Management Company:
(…)
9.2. Specifically, the functions of the Management Company include the activities detailed below:
(…)
d) Information, administrative and accounting activities
ii) Keep the records of the Participants, of the investments, of the deposits and of the orders; as well as the minute book of the General Assembly of Participants and of the Investment Committee. In addition, the Management Company must keep in custody the minute book of the Surveillance Committee".
(Highlight added)
On the facts
- According to numeral 6 of Memorandum No. 001-2018-SMV-INSP-MACROCA of October 22, 2018, the SMV inspection team requested from Macrocapitales the Fund's Investment Register; however, in response the management company delivered a document in Excel format with some information on the Fund's investments[7], a document that does not contain the minimum information established by the regulations;
- In this regard, and in accordance with Article 9, numeral 9.2, literal d), of the Fund's Participation Regulation which states that the management company must keep the Fund's Investment Register, Article 88 of the Regulation, in addition to stating the same, that is, that it must have said register, establishes that in said register each of the investments made with the Fund's resources shall be recorded in chronological order, indicating the amount of the purchase or sale, taxes and expenses incurred in the investment operation, in order to know and adequately identify whether the investments made comply with the provisions of the investment policy. Likewise, it should have had the movement of investments as established in literal d) of Annex F of the Regulation;
- In the present case, according to the information provided to the SMV inspection team, the administrator would not have complied with the provisions of the preceding recital, which limited the scope of the review and evaluation of the management carried out by Macrocapitales, on the sample of investments selected in the Inspection, that is, it has not been possible to verify that they have complied with the provisions of the applicable regulations, the Participation Regulation and the internal manuals of the management company;
- For the foregoing, it was imputed to Macrocapitales SAFI that it would not have complied with keeping the investment register in accordance with the characteristics established in Article 88 and Annex F of the Regulation as well as Article 9 of the Fund's Participation Regulation, to the extent that the investment register as of November 21, 2018 was not delivered to the inspection team;
On the Arguments Presented
- In this regard, Macrocapitales SAFI states that it did make available to the SMV inspection team an electronic Investment Register in Excel format that incorporated the Fund's investments in chronological order, indicating the amount of the purchase or sale, taxes and expenses incurred in the investment operation, as well as the information necessary to identify that the investments made comply with the provisions of the investment policy, in accordance with the provisions of Article 88, subsection d) of the Regulation;
- Likewise, it adds that it provided the inspection team with access to Macrocapitales SAFI's internal system, where it was shown that, in each of the folders of each of the investments, there were documents related to the pre-investment, investment closing and management process, since Fortaleza being a fund that invests in private equity, the extension of the documents (investment contracts, addenda, share registration entries, among others) requires this type of file;
- In this sense, it clarifies that there was no absence of complete information on the Fund's investments that would in any way limit the review and evaluation of the SMV inspection team and that, as can be seen in the Inspection Completion Record dated November 21, 2018, signed by the SMV team, the Investment Register or any of the documents related to the Fund's investments were not indicated as pending information. It attaches the Inspection Completion Record as Annex No. 1 of its arguments;
- Likewise, it rejects the SMV's statement that Macrocapitales SAFI would not have an Investment Register that complies with the conditions provided in the regulations;
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that, without prejudice to the foregoing, since the SMV inspection team had a different interpretation from that of the management company regarding the manner in which the Investment Register should be maintained, and taking into account that the Regulation does not establish a model for the Investment Register, by letter dated March 18, 2019, it requested the General Superintendence of Supervision of Entities to provide guidelines regarding the manner in which, based on its interpretation, the SMV expected Macrocapitales SAFI to maintain the Fund's Investment Register;
- As part of its arguments, Macrocapitales SAFI attaches the letter sent as Annex No. 2. Likewise, it adds that on April 4, 2019, by email, it reiterated its request regarding the guidelines that, based on its interpretation, the SMV expected it to have for keeping the Fund's Investment Register. As Annex No. 3 to its arguments, they attach the email sent;
- In relation to this, Macrocapitales SAFI points out that the aforementioned requests clearly show the willingness it had to clarify this situation and address the requirements made based on the interpretation of the SMV inspection team within the shortest possible time;
- Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that on the same April 4, 2019, the SMV sent them by email a Word file, where Article 88 of the Participation Regulation had been transcribed verbatim, which was not entirely clarifying for these purposes, since the Investment Register that we sent at the time complied with the provisions of the aforementioned article (they attach as Annex No. 4 the email received);
- For this reason, Macrocapitales SAFI states that they communicated by telephone with the SMV in order for them to indicate whether the documents they were adding to the aforementioned register through hyperlinks (contracts of each of the investments, as well as their addenda, share registration entries of each of the companies where the Fund has invested, among others) and the index they were adding were sufficient to lift such observations. On that occasion, it indicates that they were told that the new format of the Fund's Investment Register adapted to the interpretation that the SMV inspection team had, with no future observations being presented in this regard;
- In this context, Macrocapitales SAFI states that on May 27, 2019, it delivered a second Investment Register of the Fund, which was presented in a format adjusted to what was indicated by the SMV inspection team;
- In this sense, it reiterates that it rejects what is indicated in the Charge Letter regarding that Macrocapitales SAFI would not have complied with keeping the investment register in accordance with the characteristics established in Article 88 and Annex F of the Regulation and Article 9 of the Fund's Participation Regulation, as well as that it was not delivered to the SMV inspection team. Likewise, it states that it denies that Macrocapitales SAFI has incurred the infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation;
Analysis of the arguments
- Regarding the facts observed in this administrative sanctioning procedure, it should be specified that the imputed charge refers to the presentation of the Fund's Investment Register at the time of the Inspection, which was requested through Memorandum No. 001-2018-SMV-INSP-MACROCA of October 22, 2018, which was answered by Macrocapitales SAFI on October 31, 2018 by email from an official of the administrator to the inspection team;
- As a result of the review of the Fund's investment register by the Inspection, it was observed that what Macrocapitales SAFI provided was an Excel file referring to an accounting detail of the investments made by the Fund as of December 31, 2017, when what was requested was the Investment Register; in this sense, the referred Excel file did not observe the formalities, nor the minimum content of said register, as established in Article 88 of the Regulation; therefore, it was determined that the Administrator did not keep an investment register that complies with the conditions provided in the regulations;
- It is appropriate to note that Macrocapitales SAFI in its arguments has not supported how the Excel file presented to the Inspection complies with Article 88 and literal d) of Annex F of the Regulation, since it only supports it with its statement, and it should be highlighted that, as stated in its arguments, it was at a later date (May 27, 2019) after the close of the Inspection that it presented it complying with such legal mandate;
- Regarding that Macrocapitales SAFI would have provided the Inspection with access to the SAFI's internal system, it should be indicated that such access in no way replaces the information that the Fund's investment register must contain, precisely because it does not constitute a register according to the provisions of the Regulation and the Fund's Participation Regulation itself;
- In relation to the fact that the Inspection Completion Record did not indicate the pending information of the cited investment register, nor any of the documents related to the Fund's investments, it should be indicated that the fact that this point was not mentioned in the cited record does not prevent observations from being formulated after it following the analysis of the information and documentation collected in the inspection, which effectively occurred through Official Letter No. 990-2019-SMV/10.2 of February 25, 2019, which was answered by Macrocapitales SAFI by letter of May 27, 2019;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to mention that the body empowered by the SMV's Organic Law to interpret the regulations governing the Securities Market is its Board of Directors, in accordance with literal b) of Article 5 of the Single Ordered Text of the SMV's Organic Law, approved by Legislative Decree No. 26126, which is why it is not acceptable to maintain that the inspection team has a particular interpretation of Article 88 and literal d) of Annex F of the Regulation, since as indicated such attribution corresponds to the SMV's Board of Directors;
- Similarly, it is necessary to specify that Article 88 and literal d) of Annex F of the Regulation, in their provisions, do not refer to a model or guide of investment register to be followed;
- Finally, regarding the actions adopted by Macrocapitales SAFI for compliance with Article 88 and literal d) of Annex F of the Regulation, after the notification of Official Letter No. 990-2019-SMV/10.2[8] of February 25, 2019, it is appropriate to note that this will be taken into consideration as the clarification of the facts subject to charge;
- Consequently, Macrocapitales SAFI has not disproved the imputed charge, therefore it has incurred an infraction classified as serious typified in subsection 2.10 numeral 2, of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time the facts occurred, which establishes as an infraction of a serious nature "Failure to keep or maintain updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the corresponding books, records and files."[9];
- Fourth charge: On the presentation of the financial statements of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI
- On the presentation of investments in the Fund's Financial Statements without observing the regulations
On the regulations
- Article 85 of the Regulation establishes:
"Article 85 Information of the Funds
Once the Fund's activities have begun, the Management Companies must send to the Registry the following information for each Fund:
a) Annual audited financial statements, prepared and presented in accordance with applicable accounting standards, on the day following their approval by the General Assembly, which must be held within the period established by Article 11 of the Law.
(…)";
- In this regard, the Standards establish the following:
Article 1.-Application of IFRS by obligated subjects
"(…) legal entities registered in the RPMV, collective fund management companies, and investment funds must prepare their financial statements in full observance of the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) in force internationally, and to the extent applicable, the Financial Information Regulation and the Manual for the preparation of Financial Information.
For the purposes of these standards, legal entities registered in the RPMV shall be understood as brokerage agents, mutual fund management companies, investment fund management companies, securitization companies, risk rating companies, price providers and other entities to which the Superintendence of the Securities Market grants operating authorization."
- Paragraph 15 of International Accounting Standard 1 (hereinafter, IAS 1) Presentation of Financial Statements, indicates:
"Fair presentation and compliance with IFRS
15 Financial statements shall present fairly the financial position and financial performance, as well as the cash flows of an entity. This fair presentation requires the faithful presentation of the effects of transactions, as well as of other events and conditions, in accordance with the definitions and recognition criteria for assets, liabilities, income and expenses established in the Conceptual Framework. It is presumed that the application of IFRS, accompanied by additional information when necessary, will result in financial statements that provide a fair presentation."
- According to the "Conceptual Framework for Financial Reporting" (hereinafter, Conceptual Framework), the fundamental characteristics of financial information are "relevance" and "faithful representation".
"Faithful representation
CC12 Financial reports represent economic phenomena in words and numbers. To be useful, financial information must not only represent relevant phenomena, but must also faithfully represent the phenomena it purports to represent. To be a perfectly faithful representation, a description would have three characteristics. It would be complete, neutral and free from error.
Naturally, perfection is rarely, if ever, achievable. The Board's objective is to maximize those qualities as much as possible.
CC13 A complete description includes all information necessary for a user to understand the phenomenon being represented, including all necessary descriptions and explanations. For example, a complete representation of a group of assets would include, at a minimum, a description of the nature of the group's assets, a numerical description of all the assets in the group, and a description of what the numerical description represents (for example, original cost, adjusted cost or fair value). For some items, a complete description may also entail explanations of significant facts about the quality and nature of the items, the factors and circumstances that may affect their quality and nature, and the process used to determine the numerical description.
(…)
CC15 Faithful representation does not mean accuracy in all respects. Free from error means that there are no errors or omissions in the description of the phenomenon, and that the process used to produce the information presented has been selected and applied without errors. In this context, free from error does not mean perfectly accurate in all respects. For example, an estimate of an unobservable price or value cannot be said to be accurate or inaccurate. However, a representation of that estimate can be faithful if the amount is clearly and accurately described as an estimate, the nature and limitations of the estimation process are explained, and no errors have been made in selecting and applying an appropriate process to develop the estimate.
(…)"
- Paragraphs 4.37, 4.38 and 4.41 of the Conceptual Framework establish the following:
"Recognition of the elements of financial statements
4.37 Recognition is the process of incorporating in the balance sheet or income statement an item that meets the definition of an element and satisfies the criteria for recognition set out in paragraph 4.38. It involves the depiction of the item in words and by a monetary amount and the inclusion of that amount in the balance sheet or income statement totals. Items that satisfy the recognition criteria should be recognized in the balance sheet or income statement. (…)
4.38 An item that meets the definition of an element should be recognized if:
(…)
(b) the element has a cost or value that can be measured with reliability[10]
(…)
Reliability of measurement
4.41 The second criterion for recognition of an item is that it possesses a cost or value that can be measured with reliability. In many cases, cost or value must be estimated; the use of reasonable estimates is an essential part of the preparation of financial statements and does not undermine their reliability. (…)"
On the facts
- Macrocapitales SAFI presented to the SMV[11] the audited annual financial information of the Fund as of December 31, 2017, which includes the Fund's audited annual Financial Statements together with the Report of the independent auditors (hereinafter Report) dated March 16, 2018.
- In this regard, the Audited Financial Statements of the Fund as of December 31, 2017 include as "Financial investments at fair value through profit or loss" the balance of US$ 66,860,049 which represents 99.80% of the Fund's total assets. Likewise, a profit from valuation of these investments of US$ 6,649,723 was recorded in the 2017 period (gain of US$ 12,432,171 and loss of US$ 5,782,448);
- It is observed that the Report issued by Paredes, Burga y Asociados Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada (hereinafter Audit Firm) included a qualified opinion stating the following:
"Bases for the qualified opinion
4. As of December 31, 2017, the Fund maintains investments recorded at fair value through profit or loss for an amount of approximately US$ 66,860,049. The acquisition cost of said investments amounted to approximately US$ 45,274,649, having recorded for these investments a valuation profit in the year of approximately US$ 6,649,723 (gain of US$ 12,432,171 and loss of US$ 5,782,448) and accumulated valuation profits from previous years of approximately US$ 21,585,400 (accumulated gain of US$ 27,922,481 and accumulated loss of US$ 6,337,081), notes 4 and 5. These investments do not have an active market, so their fair value is estimated based on valuation methodologies. The Fund's manager has carried out the valuation of these investments in accordance with the provisions of Annex 4 of the Participation Regulation of the Fortaleza Fund (note 2.2(o)). As part of our audit of the fair value of these investments, as of the date of this report, the Fund has not provided us with:
(a) The duly audited financial information for each of the investments, which is the basis for determining their fair value; nor
(b) The technical support for some of the assumptions used to estimate the fair value of the investments named Promotik S.A.C. and Charlotte S.A., which have a fair value of US$ 7,448,160 and a historical cost of US$ 12,033,398, recording a loss for the year of approximately US$ 3,048,687 and an accumulated loss of approximately US$ 4,585,238. In addition, for these investments Management has not used corroborative methodologies to assess the reasonableness of said market value in accordance with the requirements established by IFRS 13 – "Fair Value Measurement" and used to determine the impairment of the investments.
Consequently, we have not been able to complete all the audit tests that we consider necessary to satisfy ourselves as to the reasonableness of the higher and lower amounts recorded as a result of the estimate of the fair value of the investments as of December 31, 2017.
Qualified Opinion
5. In our opinion, except for the effect of the adjustments, if any, that could result from the disposition of the matters indicated in the preceding paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I as of December 31, 2017, as well as its financial performance and cash flows for the year ended on that date, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB).
(…)”;
- As part of the evaluation carried out during the Inspection, on a sample of the Fund's investments as of December 31, 2017, it was determined that the valuation of the investments detailed in the following table was not supported, and therefore their fair value would not be reliable;
Financial investments at fair value through profit or loss
Fund investments in Promotick S.A.C. and Charlotte S.A.
(Expressed in US dollars)
| | | |
|---|
| Company | % of interest in the company | Amount US$ Invested | Fair Value As of December 31, 2017 US$ |
| Promotick S.A.C. | 45.67 | 6,201,494.00 | 4,918,921.00 |
| Charlotte S.A. | 69 | 5,831,904.00 | 2,529,239.00 |
- They correspond to Fund investments in shares of the companies Promotick S.A.C. (hereinafter Promotick) and Charlotte S.A. (hereinafter Charlotte) with a 45.67% and 69% interest and are presented in Note 4 "Financial investments at fair value through profit or loss" of the Fund's Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017. The balance of the investments in Promotick and Charlotte represent 7% and 4% respectively of the financial investments at fair value through profit or loss (US$ 66,860,049) as well as of total assets (US$ 66,995,914);
- Said observation was supported by the fact that to determine the fair value of the Fund's investments in Promotick, the management company used the earnings multiple methodology, which uses as an input the EBITDA obtained by said company in the period from November 2016 to November 2017; figures that are taken from the unaudited financial statements of Promotick;
- As the Audit Firm indicated in the Opinion, as part of its audit of the fair value of the Fund's investments, it was not provided with the duly audited financial information for each of the investments, which is the basis for determining their fair value, nor the technical support for some of the assumptions used to estimate the fair value of the Fund's investments in Promotick and Charlotte;
- Therefore, to the extent that for the investments in Promotick, said support was not provided to the Audit Firm, the fair value of US$ 4,918,921.00 presented in the Fund's audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017, was subject to a qualified opinion;
- It should be noted that until November 21, 2018, the closing date of the Inspection, Macrocapitales SAFI did not deliver the audited financial information as of December 31, 2017 of Promotick[12] that supports the EBITDA data used in the valuation of said investment, because, according to management's statement, said company had not yet delivered the report of the respective external auditors, as it was still in the process of preparation;
- To determine the fair value of the Fund's investments in Charlotte, the management company used the book value as of November 30, 2017[13] of the shares in said company (Charlotte's net equity multiplied by the Fund's percentage interest in said company), using the unaudited financial statements of Charlotte as the source;
- It should be added that Note 4 "Financial investments at fair value through profit or loss" of the Fund's Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, in the "Valuation methodology" disclosed the following: "Net Assets: This method takes into consideration the net between the assets and liabilities of the company according to the unaudited financial statements. This methodology, as of December 31, 2017, is only applied to the investment in Charlotte S.A.";
- However, subsequently[14], the same Audit Firm issued the Opinion dated July 31, 2018 on Charlotte's financial statements as of December 31, 2017, which contains a qualified opinion due to scope limitations in the evaluation of certain asset accounts for S/ 560,000 and liability accounts for approximately S/ 1,916,000, for which it could not determine whether adjustments are required or not, to both accounting balances and due to an overvaluation of its assets and net equity of S/ 1,883,000.00;
- Had the figures from Charlotte's audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 been considered and considering the adjustments determined by the Audit Firm in its opinion, the valuation of the Fund's investments in Charlotte would be US$ 1,922,310.00, a figure lower than the valuation considered by the management company, as detailed in the following table:
| Charlotte Financial Statement | Net equity of Charlotte S.A. (S/.) | Adjustment proposed by auditors (S/.) | 69% of the equity value (S/.) | 69% of the equity value in US$ (Exchange rate S/. 3.233) |
|---|
| Unaudited | 11,851,000 | | 8,177,990 | 2,529,536 |
| Audited as of 12/31/2017 | 10,890,000 | (1,883,000) | 6,214,830 | 1,922,310 |
- On the other hand, according to article 85 of the Reglamento the management company has the obligation to present audited annual financial statements of the Fund, which, in accordance with article 1 of the Normas, in their preparation must comply with international financial reporting standards;
- In accordance with paragraph 15 of IAS 1, financial statements must present fairly the financial position, financial performance as well as the cash flows of the entity. It also establishes that fair presentation requires the faithful presentation of the effects of transactions, as well as of other events and conditions, in accordance with the definitions and recognition criteria for assets, liabilities, income and expenses established in the Conceptual Framework;
- Likewise, the Conceptual Framework states that the objective of Financial Statements is to provide useful information to their users and one of the fundamental qualitative characteristics of useful financial information is faithful representation (complete, neutral and free from error);
- The Conceptual Framework also establishes that an item must be recognized in the balance sheet or in the income statement when it meets the definition of the corresponding element (assets, liabilities, equity, income and expenses), provided that it meets two conditions, one of which is that the element has a cost or value that can be measured reliably;
- The balances of the Fund's investments in shares of Promotick for US$ 4,918,921 and Charlotte for US$ 2,529,239 presented in the Fund's Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, have been determined based on estimates of their fair value, recording in the 2017 period, due to fair value adjustments, a net loss for both cases of US$ 3,048,687;
- In this regard, the information provided by these balances measured at fair value as well as their effect on the results of the period must be useful to the users of the financial statements and for this they must faithfully represent (complete, neutral and free from error) what they intend to represent;
- Likewise, a complete description (paragraphs CC12 and CC13 of the Conceptual Framework) must include all the information necessary for the user to understand the phenomenon being represented. For example, for some items it may also entail explanations of significant facts about the quality and nature of the items, the factors and circumstances that may affect them and the process used for their determination;
- In the case of the investments in Promotick, the input used to apply its valuation methodology is the EBITDA[15] for the period November 2016 to November 2017 taken from the financial statements of this company; said information is a significant fact for estimating the fair value of these investments that has not been disclosed in the Fund's financial statements;
- As indicated above, until the close of the Inspection, the management company did not have the audited financial information for the 2017 period of Promotick. In the case of the Fund's investments in Charlotte, their fair value has been determined based on the net assets of this company as of November 30, 2017, information that was also not disclosed in the Fund's financial statements;
- For its part, "Free from error" (paragraphs CC12 and CC15 of the Conceptual Framework) means that there are no errors or omissions in the description of the phenomenon and that the process used to produce the information presented has been selected and applied without errors. In that sense, free from errors does not mean perfectly accurate in all aspects;
- In the case of the estimate of the fair value of the Fund's investments in Charlotte as of December 31, 2017, the method that takes into consideration the net assets or equity of the company according to the financial statements of the company in which it has the investment was selected as the methodology; however, in applying the calculation, Charlotte's unaudited financial statements as of November 30, 2017 were used;
- Likewise, subsequently its external auditors issued the opinion on the financial statements of said company as of December 31, 2017, which contains a qualified opinion due to an overvaluation of net equity, which would originate a possible overvaluation in the valuation carried out by the Fund for this investment. In the case of the valuation of the investments in Promotick as of December 31, 2017, the management company did not provide the audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of Promotick, which limits the ability to validate the fair value determined;
- Likewise, the Audit Firm, in relation to the audit of the fair value of the Fund's investments, indicated in its Opinion that it could not complete all the audit tests it considers necessary to satisfy itself as to the reasonableness of the higher and lower amounts recorded as a result of the estimate of the fair value of the investments as of December 31, 2017, because it did not have the audited financial information of the investments and the technical support for some of the assumptions used to estimate the fair value of the investments in Promotick and Charlotte, and therefore issued a qualified opinion;
- It should be added that during the Inspection it was verified that as of that date Macrocapitales SAFI still did not have the audited financial information as of December 31, 2017 of Promotick and that the audited financial information of Charlotte as of December 31, 2017 was issued with an opinion of the Audit Firm that contains a qualified opinion due to scope limitations and due to adjustments not recorded for S/ 1,883,000, which evidenced that to estimate the fair value of the Fund's investments in Charlotte, an equity higher than the one that would have resulted after making the audit adjustments was used as a basis;
- For the foregoing, the value of the Fund's investments in Promotick and Charlotte measured at fair value and presented in the Fund's audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 and the amounts recorded in the results of the year and in these investments in the 2017 period when determining their fair value estimate would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these Fund investments and thus their values would not be reliable;
- Consequently, Macrocapitales SAFI was charged with having breached article 85 literal a) of the Reglamento, article 1 of the Normas, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37 and 4.38 literal b) of the Conceptual Framework and paragraph 15 of IAS 1;
- On the presentation of the investments in Macrocapitales SAFI's Financial Statements without observing the regulations
On the Regulations
- Article 132 of the Reglamento establishes:
"Article 132 On accounting and financial information
The Management Company, in its capacity as a legal entity registered in the Registry, keeps its accounting in accordance with the rules governing such entities and presents its financial information in accordance with the applicable accounting standards."
- In this regard, the Normas establish the following:
"Article 1.- Application of IFRS by obligated subjects
(…) legal entities registered in the RPMV, collective fund management companies, and investment funds must prepare their financial statements in full observance of the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) internationally in force, and to the extent applicable, the Financial Information Regulation and the Manual for the preparation of Financial Information.
For the purposes of these norms, legal entities registered in the RPMV shall be understood as brokerage agents, mutual fund management companies, investment fund management companies, securitization companies, risk rating companies, price provider companies and other entities to which the Superintendency of the Securities Market grants operating authorization."
- Paragraph 15 of IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements indicates:
"Fair presentation and compliance with IFRS
15 Financial statements shall present fairly the financial position and financial performance, as well as the cash flows of an entity. This fair presentation requires the faithful presentation of the effects of transactions, as well as of other events and conditions, in accordance with the definitions and recognition criteria for assets, liabilities, income and expenses established in the Conceptual Framework. It is presumed that the application of IFRS, accompanied by additional information when necessary, will result in financial statements that provide a fair presentation."
- According to the Conceptual Framework, the fundamental characteristics of financial information are "relevance" and "faithful representation":
"Faithful representation
CC12 Financial reports represent economic phenomena in words and numbers. To be useful, financial information must not only represent relevant phenomena, but must also faithfully represent the phenomena it purports to represent. To be a perfectly faithful representation, a description would have three characteristics. It would be complete, neutral and free from error.
Naturally, perfection is rarely, if ever, achievable. The Board's objective is to maximize those qualities as much as possible.
CC13 A complete description includes all the information necessary for a user to understand the phenomenon being represented, including all necessary descriptions and explanations. For example, a complete representation of a group of assets would include, at a minimum, a description of the nature of the group's assets, a numerical description of all the assets in the group, and a description of what the numerical description represents (for example, original cost, adjusted cost or fair value). For some items, a complete description may also entail explanations of significant facts about the quality and nature of the items, the factors and circumstances that may affect their quality and nature, and the process used to determine the numerical description.
(…)
CC15 Faithful representation does not mean accuracy in all aspects. Free from error means that there are no errors or omissions in the description of the phenomenon, and that the process used to produce the information presented has been selected and applied without errors. In this context, free from errors does not mean perfectly accurate in all aspects. For example, an estimate of an unobservable price or value cannot be said to be accurate or inaccurate. However, a representation of that estimate can be faithful if the amount is clearly and accurately described as an estimate, the nature and limitations of the estimation process are explained, and no errors have been made in selecting and applying an appropriate process to develop the estimate.
(…)"
- Paragraphs 4.37, 4.38 and 4.41 of the Conceptual Framework establish the following:
"Recognition of the elements of financial statements
4.37 Recognition is the process of incorporating, in the balance sheet or in the income statement, an item that meets the definition of the corresponding element, also satisfying the recognition criteria established in paragraph 4.38. It implies the description of the item in words and by means of a monetary amount, as well as the inclusion of the item in question in the totals of the balance sheet or income statement. Items that satisfy the recognition criterion must be recognized in the balance sheet or in the income statement. (…)
4.38 Any item that meets the definition of an element must be recognized provided that:
(…)
(b) the element has a cost or value that can be measured reliably[16]
(…)
Reliability of measurement
4.41 The second criterion for the recognition of an item is that it has a cost or value that can be measured reliably. On many occasions, the cost or value must be estimated; the use of reasonable estimates is an essential part of the preparation of financial statements, and does not undermine their reliability. (…)"
On the facts
- From the evaluation carried out on Macrocapitales SAFI's Audited Financial Statements, as of December 31, 2017[17], it is observed that the Opinion of the independent auditors (Audit Firm) dated March 16, 2018, included a qualified opinion, stating the following:
"Bases for the qualified opinion
4. As of December 31, 2017, the Company holds financial assets available for sale for interests in Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I for an amount of S/ 4,338,655, having recorded, in the period, for this asset an unrealized gain, net of deferred income tax of approximately S/ 313,586. As of the date of this report, the audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I present a qualified opinion.
Qualified Opinion
5. In our opinion, except for the effect of the adjustments, if any, that could result from the disposition of the matter indicated in the preceding paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of Macrocapitales Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. as of December 31, 2017, as well as its financial performance and cash flows for the year ended on that date, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)
(…)”;
- The management company is obliged to submit to the SMV the audited annual financial statements of the Fund and of itself, which in their preparation must comply with international financial reporting standards;
- From the evaluation carried out during the Inspection on certain items of the audited financial statements of Macrocapitales SAFI as of December 31, 2017, it has been identified that it maintains a significant investment in the Fund whose fair value of S/ 4,338,665 would have been determined based on the audited financial statements of the Fund at that date;
- These investments represent 62% of the total of the "Available-for-sale financial assets" line item and 48% of the total assets of Macrocapitales SAFI
- According to Note 6 (b) corresponding to the "Available-for-sale financial assets" line item of the Audited Financial Statements of Macrocapitales SAFI as of December 31, 2017, the following was disclosed: "As of December 31, 2017 and 2016, the investments have been recorded at their fair value, which is represented by the unit value of the investment funds, generating an increase in cost, net of taxes, of S/ 497,835 (increase of S/ 564,388 in 2016), recorded as unrealized results in other comprehensive income, (…).";
- According to the audited financial statements of the Fund as of December 31, 2017, the unit value is determined as follows: "The unit value of the participation units at a given date is established by dividing the total net equity value of the Fund by the number of participation units in circulation multiplied by the percentage paid (…)";
- Likewise, the Audit Report on the financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of the Fund included a qualified opinion because the Fund did not provide the Audit Firm with certain supporting documentation corresponding to the determination of the fair value of its investments;
- It should be added that the Fund's investments constitute 99.8% of its total assets;
- As indicated in item 4 of the Letter of Charges, for a sample of the Fund's investments, the amounts recorded in the results of the year in the 2017 period as a consequence of the estimation of the fair value of the Fund's investments in Promotick and Charlotte and, consequently, the value of these investments in the audited financial statements of the Fund as of December 31, 2017, would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these Fund investments and thus their values would not be reliable;
- Consequently, having made entries that affect the results of the year as a consequence of these valuations, the value of the Fund's equity presented in its financial statements would not be reliable;
- Taking into account that Macrocapitales SAFI has disclosed in the notes to its financial statements that it values its investments in the Fund at fair value, which it states is represented by the unit value of the investment funds, and the unit value is determined based on the Fund's equity; it is concluded that the unit value used for the valuation of Macrocapitales SAFI's investments in participation units of the Fund would not represent its value;
- For the foregoing, the fair value of Macrocapitales SAFI's investments in the Fund presented in its audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 and the amounts recorded in these investments and in other comprehensive income in the 2017 period as a consequence of the determination of their fair value would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these investments and thus their values would not be reliable;
- Consequently, Macrocapitales SAFI was charged with having breached article 132 of the Regulation, article 1 of the Standards, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37, and 4.38 literal b) of the **"**Conceptual Framework and paragraph 15 of IAS 1;
- Finally, it should be noted that Macrocapitales SAFI has submitted to the SMV its Special Report dated July 17, 2018 issued by the Audit Firm. Likewise, during the Inspection, Macrocapitales SAFI made available the Special Report of the Fund dated July 17, 2018 issued by the Audit Firm;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to indicate that in the conclusion of each of the aforementioned special reports it is stated that both the Fund and Macrocapitales SAFI have remedied the situations that generated the qualified opinion in their respective audit reports for the 2017 period;
- However, during the Inspection it was verified that the audited financial information of Promotick and Charlotte was not available as of July 17, 2018, the date of the special report of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI;
On the Defenses Presented
- Macrocapitales SAFI states in its defenses that at the beginning of 2017, together with the Fund, it hired the Audit Firm to carry out the audit of the financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year of the management company and of the Fund;
- Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that as part of the audit process the Audit Firm requested the Fund to present the Audited Financial Statements of each of the companies that formed part of its investment portfolio, supporting such request in its methodology for calculating the fair value of investments. It adds that, not having the Audited Financial Statements of the companies Promotick and Charlotte, the Audit Report on the Financial Statements of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI were issued with qualifications;
- Macrocapitales SAFI specifies that the request made by the Audit Firm is not based on any legal, accounting and/or financial requirement and that the foregoing is reinforced by the fact that, in no other fiscal year have the audit firms hired to audit the Fund's financial statements requested from the Fund the Audited Financial Statements of each of the companies in which the Fund has made investments (this, taking into account that such companies were not obliged to have audited financial information). It adds that, in that sense, it will depend on each audit firm to request the information that, in its judgment, is sufficient to calculate the fair value of the investments;
- Macrocapitales SAFI adds that, not having at hand the Audited Financial Statements of the companies Promotick and Charlotte, the Audit Report on the Financial Statements of the Fund and of the management company were issued with the following qualifications, respectively:
"Bases for the qualified opinion
4. As of December 31, 2017, the Fund maintains investments recorded at fair value with changes in results for an amount amounting to approximately US$ 66,860,049. The acquisition cost of said investments amounted to approximately US$ 45,274,649, having recorded for these investments a valuation gain in the year of approximately US$ 6,649,723 (gain of US$ 12,432,171 and loss of US$ 5,782,448) and accumulated valuation gains in previous years of approximately US$ 21,585,400 (accumulated gain of US$ 27,922,481 and accumulated loss of US$ 6,337,081), notes 4 and 5. These investments do not have an active market, so their fair value is estimated based on valuation methodologies. The Fund's manager has valued these investments in accordance with the provisions of Annex 4 of the Participation Regulation of Fortaleza Fund (note 2.2(o)). As part of our audit of the fair value of these investments, as of the date of this report, the Fund has not provided us with:
(a) The duly audited financial information of each of the investments and which is the basis for determining their fair value; nor
(b) The technical support for some assumptions used to estimate the fair value of the investments called Promotik S.A.C. and Charlotte S.A., which have a fair value of US$ 7,448,160 and a historical cost of US$ 12,033,398, recording a loss for the year of approximately US$ 3,048,687 and an accumulated loss of approximately US$ 4,585,238. In addition, for these investments, Management has not used corroborative methodologies to evaluate the reasonableness of said market value according to the requirements established by IFRS 13 – "Fair Value Measurement" and used to determine the impairment of investments.
Consequently, we have not been able to complete all the audit tests that we consider necessary to satisfy ourselves as to the reasonableness of the higher and lower amounts recorded as a consequence of the estimation of the fair value of the investments as of December 31, 2017.
Qualified opinion
5. In our opinion, except for the effect of the adjustments, if any, that could result from the disposition of the matters indicated in the previous paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present reasonably, in all significant respects, the financial situation of Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I as of December 31, 2017, as well as its financial performance and cash flows for the year ended on that date, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)."
"Bases for the qualified opinion
4. As of December 31, 2017, the Company maintains available-for-sale financial assets for participations in Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I for an amount of S/ 4,338,655, having recorded, in the period, for this asset an unrealized gain, net of deferred income tax, of approximately S/ 313,586. As of the date of this report, the audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I present a qualified opinion.
Qualified opinion
5. In our opinion, except for the effect of the adjustments, if any, that could result from the disposition of the matter indicated in the previous paragraph, the accompanying financial statements present reasonably, in all significant respects, the financial situation of Macrocapitales Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. as of December 31, 2017, as well as its financial performance and cash flows for the year ended on that date, in accordance with the International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)
(…)".
- Likewise, Macrocapitales SAFI indicates that, taking into account that the Audit Reports on the Financial Statements of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI were issued with qualifications, in compliance with the provisions of article 42 of the Financial Information Regulation, the Fund hired the Audit Firm for the issuance of special reports in order for it to rule on the remedying and/or persistence of the qualifications indicated in the aforementioned audit reports;
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that on July 17, 2018, the Audit Firm issued the Special Reports through which it concluded that, as a result of the procedures performed, as of the date of issuance of said documents, the qualification incorporated in the Audit Report on the 2017 Financial Statements of the Fund had been remedied and, consequently, the qualification contained in the Audit Report on the 2017 Financial Statements of Macrocapitales SAFI was also lifted;
- Regarding the special reports, Macrocapitales SAFI mentions that there is no legal, financial and/or accounting rule that expressly establishes that the criterion to corroborate the fair value of investments, in case these are shares of companies not listed on the stock exchange, is necessarily through the presentation of Audited Financial Statements;
- Macrocapitales SAFI reiterates that this was a requirement that had not been requested of them in previous years and adds that it was requested discretionally by the Audit Firm knowing that it was not a legal or accounting requirement necessary to support the valuation of investments and that it would not be possible to have the audited financial information of all the companies in which the Fund had made investments, insofar as the Audit Firm was auditing the financial information of Charlotte S.A. and had not completed its audit work;
- Regarding the fact that the Audited Financial Statements of the management company and of the Fund would not present complete and error-free financial information, Macrocapitales SAFI states that according to article 37 of the Financial Information Regulation, referring to the audit report made by the auditor on the financial statements and which, it indicates, is also applicable to special reports, the audit firm is responsible for the content of the audit report it issues, an opinion that is based on the audit work carried out for its issuance and that, in that sense, given the status of independent auditor of the Audit Firm, Macrocapitales SAFI did not have nor could it have had any type of interference in the audit reports issued by the audit firm nor in the information that it considered sufficient to disclose to the market to comply with the provisions of the International Accounting Standards. Therefore, they consider that the SMV should differentiate the responsibility of Macrocapitales SAFI from that corresponding to the Audit Firm for not complying with accounting standards and the conceptual framework for financial information in the audit reports issued by said entity;
- Finally, Macrocapitales SAFI affirms that at no time did it attempt to hide information or obtain an illicit benefit, nor did this act cause harm to the public interest and that it should be taken into account that, being a matter of importance, the probability of detection of the infraction is high; therefore, it is not possible to affirm that the company committed this infraction assuming that it would not be sanctioned by the SMV. Likewise, it states that it does not have the status of recidivist;
Analysis of the defenses
- On the matter, it should be indicated that Macrocapitales SAFI was charged with the infraction type contained in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12[18] of the Sanctions Regulation, because it would have breached article 85 literal a) of the Regulation, article 1 of the Standards, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37 and 4.38 literal b) of the Conceptual Framework and paragraph 15 of IAS 1, regarding the content of the audited financial statements of the Fund as of December 31, 2017, since the value of the Fund's investments in Promotick and Charlotte measured at fair value would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these Fund investments and thus their values would not be reliable;
- Likewise, Macrocapitales SAFI was charged with having breached article 132 of the Regulation, article 1 of the Standards, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37, and 4.38 literal b) of the **"**Conceptual Framework and paragraph 15 of IAS 1, insofar as the fair value of Macrocapitales SAFI's investments in the Fund presented in its audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these investments and thus their values would not be reliable;
- The foregoing paragraphs are based on the information obtained during the Inspection carried out on Macrocapitales SAFI in which it was determined that the fair value assigned in the valuation of the investments in Promotick and Charlotte in the Fund are not supported, so said valuations would not be reliable, insofar as the audited financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of these companies had not been taken into account for their estimation;
- Likewise, the other reason why the audited annual financial statements for 2017 of both the Fund and the management company itself were considered not to be reliable, with respect to the aforementioned investments, is that the external auditors of such financial information, in their audit report, issued a qualified opinion, stating in the latter that the Fund had not provided them, among others, with the audited financial information of Promotick and Charlotte, which constitutes the basis for determining the fair value of the investments;
- Likewise, because the Audit Report on the audited financial statements of the Fund as of December 31, 2017 presented a qualified opinion, it was considered that the value assigned to Macrocapitales SAFI's investments in the Fund would also not be reliable and would not be adequately supported;
- Consequently, the imputation of the charge formulated was based on the fact that in the annual financial information for the 2017 fiscal year it was considered that the value of the Fund's investments in Promotick and Charlotte and of Macrocapitales SAFI in the Fund, measured at fair value and presented in the aforementioned financial statements; and the amounts recorded in the 2017 period when determining this fair value estimate, without having audited financial information of said investments, would not represent complete and error-free financial information, and therefore would not correspond to a faithful or reliable representation of the fair value of these investments;
- Therefore, Macrocapitales SAFI would have breached article 1 of the Standards, paragraphs CC12, CC13 and CC15, 4.37 and 4.38 literal b) of the Conceptual Framework and paragraph 15 of IAS 1. As well as articles 85 literal a) and 132 of the Regulation regarding the Fund and the management company, respectively;
- On the matter, it should be indicated that account has been taken of the fact that the companies Promotick and Charlotte, nor the other companies that form part of the Fund's investment portfolio, are not registered in the RPMV, so the legal obligation to audit their annual financial statements does not apply to them;
- In that sense, not having such a legal requirement, Macrocapitales SAFI was not obliged to require the companies Promotick and Charlotte to present their audited annual financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year;
- On the other hand, it is also considered that as a result of the Inspection there is no analysis and results of whether the valuation made by the Fund's investment in the companies Promotick and Charlotte and therefore the one made by Macrocapitales SAFI in the Fund, was correct or not, regardless of what was indicated in the audit report issued by the Audit Firm;
- Likewise, it is taken into account that the regulatory compliance imputed to Macrocapitales SAFI was carried out having as a premise that the requirement to present the audited annual financial statements of the companies Promotick and Charlotte had a correlation with the grounds evaluated by the Audit Firm, so that, having demonstrated that this is not legally determined, it is not possible to require the observance of the cited imputed standards for the preparation of the financial statements of the Fund and of Macrocapitales SAFI;
- Consequently, having determined that Macrocapitales SAFI was not required to present to the Audit Firm the audited annual financial statements of the companies Promotick and Charlotte, there are no necessary elements to determine that the audited annual financial statements for the 2017 fiscal year of both the Fund and Macrocapitales SAFI would have been prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards, added to the fact that there is no additional analysis that supports that the valuation of the investments in Promotick and Charlotte did not comply with IFRS, so it is appropriate that the charge formulated be archived;
IV. EVALUATION OF THE SANCTION
- Regarding the infractions mentioned in numeral 1 of Section III of this resolution (material facts)
- Considering that in the present case, among others, infractions referring to the breach of the deadline for submitting eventual information are evaluated, the last paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation must be taken into account, which establishes that:
"(…) For the determination of the sanction for non-compliance with the rules that regulate the timeliness in the presentation of periodic or eventual information of the issuer with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market, of legal entities registered in the Registries under the responsibility of the SMV, and other persons obliged to present said information, the Board of Directors of the SMV sets the sanction parameters that develop and specify the sanction criteria established in the aforementioned laws for their better and uniform application".
- In line with the foregoing, account must be taken of subsection 1 of the "Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Rules that regulate the Remission of Periodic or Eventual Information", approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 and its amendment[19] (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria), which establishes that the purpose of said criteria is:
"to establish the sanction parameters that within the framework of the General Administrative Procedure Law, the Securities Market Law and the Decree Law on Collective Investment Management Companies allow sanctions to be applied to issuers with securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market, legal entities registered in the Registries under the responsibility of the SMV, and other persons obliged to present periodic or eventual information for non-compliances in the timely remission of said information that are classified as minor infractions in the annexes of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF-94.10. The criteria developed below apply exclusively to non-compliances with the rules that regulate the remission of periodic or eventual information and do not apply extensively to the other cases investigated by this Superintendency".
- Therefore, to evaluate the sanction to be imposed on Macrocapitales SAFI for the breaches of the deadlines for submitting occasional information described in item 1 of Section III of this resolution, the Sanction Criteria must be applied.
- Likewise, it should be mentioned that the application of the Sanction Criteria observes the principle of proportionality established in the TUO of the LPAG, since it allows determining in a predictable manner for the administered party the sanctions to be imposed on issuers of securities and persons registered in the RPMV for breaches of the deadlines for sending information to which they are obligated by the rules and for omission in sending information requested by the SMV.
- Therefore, and in accordance with the provisions of subsection 3.2 of the Sanction Criteria, the evaluation criteria set forth in Article 348 of the Securities Market Law (hereinafter LMV), in Article 248, item 3, of the TUO LPAG, as well as in subsection 4.1 of the Sanction Criteria, whose observance is mandatory, must be taken into account. Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; b) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; c) Prior sanction record; d) Recidivism[20]; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infringement; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infringement; g) The existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct; and h) The probability of detection of the infringement.
- Accordingly, each of the sanction criteria is evaluated below:
The Seriousness of the Harm to the Public Interest and/or Protected Legal Interest
- According to this criterion, it must be taken into consideration that in the case of the submission of periodic or occasional information, any breach of the rules on its timely submission, that is, the failure to observe the deadlines established for submitting such information, affects the transparency of the securities market, since this safeguards the right of actual and potential investors and the general public to access such information in a timely manner in order to adopt investment decisions or carry out a given evaluation, as well as affects the SMV in the implementation of its supervision and control activities that seek to protect the integrity of the market;
- Therefore, it can be stated that Macrocapitales SAFI has affected the protected legal interest, which is market transparency, since it did not submit the material events described in this resolution;
The Harm Caused and the Repercussion on the Market
- In this case, it has not been evidenced that the infringements incurred by Macrocapitales SAFI have produced a concrete quantifiable harm in the market, that is, it has not been determined that one or more investors have been concretely affected or caused economic damage, and therefore it has also not been evidenced that there has been a repercussion on the market;
Prior Sanction Record
- With regard to the prior sanction record, it should be noted that, in accordance with the Sanction Criteria and Article 17 of the Sanction Regulations, final sanctions imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infringement being sanctioned for any type of infringement constitute a prior record;
- In this regard, from the evaluation carried out it has been verified that Macrocapitales SAFI has the following prior sanction record:
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 006-2014-SMV/10 of April 9, 2014, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of one (01) UIT for having incurred one (01) infringement of a serious nature classified in Annex VI, item 2, subsection 2.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having net equity lower than its required share capital.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 009-2014-SMV/10 of April 11, 2014, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with two (02) warnings and a fine of 5.75 UIT for having incurred (04) infringements of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having submitted periodic information outside the established deadline.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 039-2016-SMV/10 of August 26, 2016, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with one (01) warning for having incurred one (01) infringement of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having communicated occasional information outside the established deadline.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 114-2017-SMV/10 of December 7, 2017, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of four (04) UIT, for having incurred two (02) infringements of a serious nature, classified in Annex XIX, subsection 2, item 2.12 of the Sanction Regulations, for not having complied with the provisions of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing, regarding the submission, within the deadline established by the regulations, of the Compliance Officer's Semiannual Report and the Annual Independent Compliance Report;
- It should be noted that these sanctions have become final at the administrative instance insofar as they were not subject to challenge;
Recidivism
- With reference to recidivism for the commission of the same infringement, the final sanction imposed by the SMV within one (1) year prior to the commission of the infringement being sanctioned is taken into account. It has been verified that Macrocapitales SAFI does not have final sanctions for the commission of the infringements subject to analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure, and therefore recidivism is not configured;
The Circumstances of the Commission of the Infringements
- With regard to the circumstances of the commission of the infringements, it should be mentioned that Macrocapitales SAFI, as an entity supervised by the SMV, is aware of the rules governing the securities market and, in that sense, of the rules obligating it to submit occasional information to the SMV within the deadlines established therein;
- However, Macrocapitales SAFI did not timely submit the two material events detailed in item 2 of Section III of this resolution, which are the subject of evaluation in this sanctioning procedure;
The Illicit Benefit Resulting from the Commission of the Infringements
- In this regard, it should be noted that it has not been proven that Macrocapitales SAFI obtained a benefit directly related to the infringements subject to analysis in this administrative procedure;
The Existence or Not of Intent in the Offender's Conduct
- Regarding the existence or not of intent in the offender's conduct, it has not been evidenced that Macrocapitales SAFI acted with intent in the commission of the infringements;
Probability of Detection of the Infringements
- With regard to the probability of detection of the infringements, it should be noted that in this case the infringements incurred by Macrocapitales SAFI were evidenced as a result of the supervision and control activities carried out by the SMV regarding compliance with the timely submission of periodic and occasional information, in accordance with the provisions of the applicable regulations; therefore, their probability of detection qualifies as high in the case of lateness, with the omission or days of delay determined objectively and automatically;
- Continuing with the analysis, it is appropriate to determine the sanction to be imposed on Macrocapitales SAFI for the commission of the infringements detailed in item 2 of Section III of this resolution;
Warning Sanction:
- In this sense, the Sanction Criteria establish that a warning sanction may be imposed when the following guidelines set forth in subsection 4.2, item (ii) of said criteria are concurrently met: (i) the effect on market transparency is minimal; (ii) the infringement committed has not caused concrete harm to investors or associates; (iii) the offending subject has no prior record or, if it does, these are infringements classified as minor offenses imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infringement being evaluated; (iv) the offending subject has not obtained a benefit from its illegal conduct; and (v) it has not been proven that the offender acted with intent in the commission of the infringement.
- It should be noted that a warning sanction does not apply for the commission of the infringements subject to charge, under the cited subsection (ii), since it does not meet the requirement of having a prior sanction record for a minor infringement because, as stated, Macrocapitales SAFI has a prior sanction record for the commission of a serious infringement; In this sense, in accordance with the Sanction Criteria, a fine amounting to 6.18 UIT, equivalent to S/ 25,029.00 (Twenty-five thousand twenty-nine and 00/100 Soles), should be applied for the infringements described in item 2 of Section III of this resolution;
- Likewise, it should be noted that in this procedure the existence of aggravating factors contemplated in subsection 4.2, item (vi) of the Sanction Criteria has not been determined;
- Regarding the infringements mentioned in items 2 and 3 of Section III of this resolution
- In order to determine the sanction corresponding to the infringements indicated in items 1 and 3 of Section III of this resolution, the provisions of the LMV and the Sanction Regulations must be taken into account, in accordance with the TUO LPAG;
- In order to reconcile the criteria of the TUO LPAG with those indicated in the LMV and the Sanction Regulations and for these criteria to be adequately considered so that their assessment observes the principle of reasonableness and the sanction to be imposed is adjusted to them, the following criteria have been analyzed:
Offender's Prior Record
- In accordance with the provisions of Article 17 of the Sanction Regulations, the offender's prior record consists of sanctions imposed by the SMV that have become final within the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infringement being sanctioned;
- As regards the infringement referring to the lack of sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee for the 2017 fiscal year, Macrocapitales SAFI has the following prior infringement record:
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 006-2014-SMV/10 of April 9, 2014, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of one (01) UIT for having incurred one (01) infringement of a serious nature classified in Annex VI, item 2, subsection 2.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having net equity lower than its required share capital.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 009-2014-SMV/10 of April 11, 2014, through which MACROCAPITALES SAFI is sanctioned with two (02) warnings and a fine of 5.75 UIT for having incurred (04) infringements of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having submitted periodic information outside the established deadline.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 039-2016-SMV/10 of August 26, 2016, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with one (01) warning for having incurred one (01) infringement of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations for having communicated occasional information outside the established deadline,
- It should be noted that these sanctions have become final at the administrative instance insofar as they were not subject to challenge;
- Regarding the infringement referring to the Fund's investment registry, it has been verified that Macrocapitales SAFI has the prior sanction record mentioned in preceding subparagraph c) and the following:
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 114-2017-SMV/10 of December 7, 2017, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of four (04) UIT, for having incurred two (02) infringements of a serious nature, classified in Annex XIX, subsection 2, item 2.12 of the Sanction Regulations, for not having complied with the provisions of the Rules for the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing, regarding the submission, within the deadline established by the regulations, of the Compliance Officer's Semiannual Report and the Annual Independent Compliance Report.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 027-2018-SMV/10 of May 16, 2018, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of 3.59 UIT, for having incurred two (02) infringements of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations, for not having submitted periodic information within the deadline established in the applicable regulations.
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 052-2018-SMV/10 of October 17, 2018, through which Macrocapitales SAFI is sanctioned with a fine of 3.4608 UIT, for having incurred five (05) infringements of a minor nature classified in Annex I, item 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanction Regulations, for not having submitted occasional information within the deadline established in the applicable regulations;
- It should be noted that these sanctions have become final at the administrative instance insofar as they were not subject to challenge;
Recidivism
- With reference to recidivism for the commission of the same infringement, the final sanction imposed by the SMV within one (1) year prior to the commission of the infringement being sanctioned is taken into account. It has been verified that Macrocapitales SAFI does not have final sanctions for the commission of the infringements subject to analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure, and therefore recidivism is not configured;
On the Seriousness of the Harm to the Public Interest and/or Protected Legal Interest
- In this case, it has not been possible to prove that Macrocapitales SAFI's conduct in the commission of the infringements analyzed in this sanctioning procedure has caused harm to the public interest;
- However, through its conduct Macrocapitales SAFI has placed at risk the legal interest relating to market transparency, since supervision of the internal regulations of a public fund must not cease to be observed, in particular that its Investment Committee complies with said regulations and ensures that the sessions where the investments made are discussed are held in accordance with the frequency established therein.
- Likewise, it should be noted that according to the Fund's Participation Regulations, the sessions of the Investment Committee are held, among others, to a) Analyze investment and divestment opportunities in accordance with the Fund's investment guidelines and Policy, and adopt such decisions, b) Evaluate and monitor the assets comprising the Fund's patrimony, for which it must remain informed about the development of the Fund's investment portfolio, c) Supervise the management of the Fund's treasury, d) Approve the Fund's investment and divestment strategy, according to the proposals made by the general manager of the Managing Company, e) Supervise the valuation of the Fund's investments, f) Propose to the Managing Company, when pertinent, the need to use indebtedness for the Fund; and, g) Define the Fund's treasury strategy; from which it follows that the purpose of said sessions has a broad scope, and is not limited only to what is indicated in the aforementioned subparagraph a); therefore, according to the nature of the fund, its investment objectives, the circumstances and factors that could affect it, in this case, the Participation Regulations established a minimum frequency for the holding of said sessions, which was not complied with, thereby affecting the legal interest of investor protection;
- Likewise, through its actions Macrocapitales SAFI has placed at risk the transparency that must govern as a managing company regarding the proper maintenance of its records, in particular, the investment registry observed. Likewise, by not having an investment registry, it limits the managing company's ability to maintain adequate control of the investments made, as well as affects the fact that adequate control of the investments made is maintained in relation to the investment policy, which affects the legal interest of investor protection;
On the Economic Harm Caused and the Repercussion on the Market
- It has not been possible to evidence that the infringements incurred by Macrocapitales SAFI have caused concrete economic harm or have had a repercussion on the market;
On the Repetition and/or Continuity in the Commission of the Infringement
- In accordance with the provisions of item 7 of Article 248 of the TUO LPAG, it is not observed that in this case the assumptions that could configure a repetition and/or continuity of the infringement subject to this administrative sanctioning procedure are present;
On the Circumstances of the Commission of the Infringement
- With regard to this criterion, it should be noted that Macrocapitales SAFI, as an entity supervised by the SMV, is aware of the rules governing the securities market and in that sense, is aware of the obligations contained in the Law, the Regulation, the Financial Information Regulation, the Rules and the Material Events Regulation;
- In the Inspection carried out, the activities being carried out by Macrocapitales SAFI were evaluated, identifying that in the 2017 fiscal year it did not hold part of the sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee required by the latter's internal regulations;
- Likewise, in the aforementioned inspection the Fund's Investment Registry was reviewed, determining that it did not comply with the provisions of the Regulation, which led to the conclusion that it did not have an investment registry, a situation that is mandatory for every administrator of a public fund;
On the Illegally Obtained Benefit
- It has not been proven in this administrative sanctioning procedure that Macrocapitales SAFI obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred the infringements subject to analysis;
On the Existence or Not of Intent in the Offender's Conduct
- No intent has been evidenced in Macrocapitales SAFI's conduct regarding the infringements subject to analysis;
The Probability of Detection of the Infringement
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infringements, it should be noted that the facts constituting the infringement committed by Macrocapitales SAFI, which are analyzed, were evidenced as a result of the supervision and control actions carried out by the SMV regarding the regulations governing the activities of stock brokerage firms. The infringements were detected as part of an inspection carried out at Macrocapitales SAFI's offices, and as a consequence of the review and analysis of the information and documentation delivered by the fund managing company only in this proceeding. Therefore, the probability of detection of the infringement was low;
Voluntary Declaration of the Commission of the Infringements and the Contribution of the Offenders to Their Clarification
- Macrocapitales SAFI has expressly acknowledged its responsibility for two infractions charged: 1) the failure to hold all the sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee for the 2017 fiscal year; and 2) the failure to communicate two material events regarding the start of the audit work on the financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of both the Fund and Macrocapitales SAFI;
- Likewise, Macrocapitales SAFI has contributed to the clarification of such facts by stating that in the case of the first infraction it was due to an involuntary error in the convening of the sessions since it considered that they should be held quarterly; it also refers to facts that would demonstrate that such circumstance did not essentially affect the Fund's investments that had been made between one to two years prior;
- Similarly, Macrocapitales SAFI states that with respect to the failure to communicate the observed material events, it has corrected its systems and internal controls to avoid similar situations in the future;
- On the other hand, regarding the acknowledgment of the infraction for not having an investment register of the Fund in accordance with the requirements of the Regulation, it must be noted that Macrocapitales SAFI has denied the commission of such infraction, limiting itself to stating how the facts occurred as set forth in its defense;
- As for the exemptions and mitigating circumstances of responsibility, it must be noted that it is not observed that any of the assumptions constituting conditions exempting from responsibility have been configured in this proceeding;
- With regard to mitigating circumstances of responsibility, it must be noted that in this case the mitigating circumstance contemplated in literal a) of numeral 2 of article 257 of the TUO LPAG is configured, referring to the fact that if once the administrative sanctioning procedure has begun the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing, as explained and developed below;
- As for the acknowledgment of responsibility by the offender, in accordance with the aforementioned literal a) of numeral 2 of article 257 of the TUO LPAG, article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation states that it must be expressly and in writing, once the administrative sanctioning procedure has begun. Likewise, said article establishes that such acknowledgment must be made precisely, concisely, clearly, expressly and unconditionally, and must not contain ambiguous or contradictory expressions;
- In this case, Macrocapitales SAFI has expressly acknowledged its responsibility for three of the four infractions charged: 1) the failure to hold all the sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee for the 2017 fiscal year; and 2) the failure to communicate two material events regarding the start of the audit work on the financial statements as of December 31, 2017 of both the Fund and Macrocapitales SAFI;
- Consequently, in application of the second paragraph of literal a)[21] of numeral 2 of article 257 of the TUO LPAG, in accordance with numeral 1, literal a) of article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation, it would correspond, if the most serious infractions are those for which responsibility was acknowledged and if, in this case, the sanction to be imposed is a fine, to reduce the amount of the fine by fifty percent (50%);
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, Macrocapitales SAFI has stated that, in application of the aforementioned article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation, it must be considered as a mitigating circumstance of responsibility that it has remedied the infraction referring to the failure to hold all the sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee for the 2017 fiscal year that it has acknowledged;
- In this regard, Macrocapitales SAFI states that, as a result of the observation indicated in the final report of the SMV inspection visit, it remedied said infraction because on March 18, 2019 it communicated to the IGSE that it has an internal electronic system that automatically reports alerts to the general management, the investment manager, and the operations manager of the company so that the process of convening the Fund's Investment Committee is initiated;
- Macrocapitales SAFI states that in the years 2018, 2019, 2020 and so far in 2021, the sessions of the Investment Committee have been held every 2 months, in accordance with the provisions of the Fund's Participation Regulation, thus complying with the mitigating circumstance of literal c) of article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation;
- On this matter, it must be noted that the remediation alleged by Macrocapitales SAFI has not been proven because it has not demonstrated that it held the other two missing sessions of the Fund's Investment Committee corresponding to the 2017 fiscal year, a fact that supports the charge formulated;
- It is appropriate to mention that the Inspection was carried out from October 29, 2018 to November 20, 2018, and as a result of said inspection, through Official Letter No. 990-2019-SMV/10.2 of February 25, 2019, Macrocapitales SAFI was informed of the incidents or observations identified during it, among them, the one referring to the observance of the number of annual sessions of the Investment Committee;
- It should also be noted that the internal system that sends alerts to certain officers of the management company to comply with the convening of the Investment Committee is a circumstance subsequent to the fact subject to charges, which does not remedy the two missing sessions of the 2017 fiscal year;
- Macrocapitales SAFI has expressly acknowledged in its defense its responsibility for having incurred in three (two material events and the one related to the sessions of the Investment Committee for the 2017 fiscal year) of the four infractions charged, one of which is included among the most serious infractions among the four incurred, so that, in application of article 26, numeral 1, literal a) of the New Sanctions Regulation, the amount of the fine applicable to this infraction must be reduced by fifty percent (50%); this prior to determining whether this is the most serious infraction for which the sanction of a fine must be imposed in the administrative sanctioning procedure initiated;
- In the case of the infraction for the failure to communicate two material events, according to the Sanction Criteria, a fine of 6.18 UIT, equivalent to S/ 25,029.00 (Twenty-five thousand twenty-nine and 00/100 Soles), would correspond to be applied; however, in application of the aforementioned article 26, numeral 1), literal a) of the New Sanctions Regulation, the amount of the applicable fine must be reduced by fifty percent (50%), so it is reduced to 3.09 UIT, equivalent to S/ 12,514.50 (Twelve thousand five hundred fourteen and 50/100 Soles);
- On the other hand, Macrocapitales SAFI has additionally incurred in the commission of two infractions of a serious nature referring to the sessions of the Fund's investment committee for the 2017 fiscal year and the one referring to the Investment Register of said fund;
- In accordance with article 21 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the date of the events, said infraction is punishable by a fine of more than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) Tax Units (UIT) or with suspension of the authorization to operate for up to twenty (20) days;
- It should be noted that the New Sanctions Regulation states that said infraction is punishable by a fine of not less than twenty-five (25) and up to fifty (50) UIT or with suspension of the authorization to operate for up to twenty (20) days. It must be noted that said norm will be the applicable one in this case as it is more favorable. Likewise, it must be noted that given the acknowledgment made with respect to the infraction regarding the sessions of the Fund's investment committee for the 2017 fiscal year, the calculation of the fine that would correspond for said infraction must fluctuate between 12.5 UIT and 25 UIT; that is, 50% of the range established for serious infractions, while for the infraction referring to the investment register the sanction can be a maximum of 50 UIT as such infraction has not been acknowledged;
- Finally, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO LPAG, which states that sanctions must be proportional to the non-compliances qualified as infractions, and considering that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed have caused harm to the public interest, nor that they have had an impact on the market, or that the management company has obtained any illicit benefit from their commission, that no intentionality was evidenced in its actions nor harm to the participants, and that the management company is not a repeat offender with respect to the referred infractions; this Deputy Superintendency considers that it is possible to impose on Macrocapitales SAFI a sanction corresponding to a classification lower than that provided for serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation;
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF.
RESOLVES:
Article 1.- Declare that Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for failing to observe article 88 and Annex F of the Regulation as well as article 9 of the Participation Regulation of the investment fund named Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I, by not keeping the Investment Register of said fund in accordance with the regulations.
Article 2.- Declare that Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for failing to observe article 11 of the Participation Regulation of the investment fund named Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I, by the Investment Committee of said fund having failed to hold all the sessions of the 2017 fiscal year.
Article 3.- Declare that Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the date of the events, for failing to observe article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation and Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments and article 9, numeral 9.1 of the Material Events and Reserved Information Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01, by not having timely communicated as a material event the start date of the audit work for its audited financial information for the 2017 fiscal year.
Article 4.- Declare that Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred in an infraction of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, in force at the date of the events, for failing to observe article 38 of the Financial Information Regulation and Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 103-99-EF/94.10 and its amendments and article 9, numeral 9.1 of the Material Events and Reserved Information Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01, by not having timely communicated as a material event the start date of the audit work for the audited financial information for the 2017 fiscal year of the investment fund named Fortaleza Fondo de Inversión de Capital Privado I.
Article 5.- Declare that Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has not incurred in an infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.12 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, so it is appropriate to archive this charge.
Article 6.- Sanction Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. with a fine of 6.00 UIT equivalent to S/ 24,300.00 (Twenty-four thousand three hundred and 00/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions contained in articles 1 and 2 above.
Article 7.- Sanction Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. with a fine of 3.09 UIT equivalent to S/ 12,514.50 (Twelve thousand five hundred fourteen and 50/100 Soles) for the commission of the infractions contained in articles 3 and 4 above.
Article 8.- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative remedy, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision by filing a reconsideration or appeal in the case of the infractions described in articles 1 and 2 of this resolution, and a reconsideration appeal in the case of the infractions described in articles 3 and 4 of this resolution, filed before the same, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
Article 9.- In the event that this resolution is not challenged by means of a reconsideration or appeal within fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes final, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
Article 10.- Transcribe this resolution to Macrocapitales Perú Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
"Article 140 Subjection to the Material Events Regulation
The Management Company is governed by the Material Events Regulation and the provisions issued on the matter by the SMV. The Management Company has the obligation to inform the Registry of the material events regarding the Management Company and the Funds it manages while it maintains Funds registered in the Registry" ↑
-
"Annex 1
(...)
11. Designation and resolution of contract with its audit firm" ↑
-
It should be noted that said legal type has been included in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.10 of the New Sanctions Regulation, which considers as a serious infraction the failure to communicate material events. ↑
-
It is understood that it is an error because the word it intended to use is "disregarding", taking into account that throughout its defense it states that it expressly acknowledges the commission of the charged infraction. ↑
-
The Fund's Participation Regulation establishes that the Advisory Council is a support body in charge of contributing to the post-investment value generation process, whose session frequency is biweekly. ↑
-
It should be noted that said infraction type has been included in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.24 of the NEW SANCTIONS REGULATION, which states that it is a serious infraction to "Fail to comply with the other obligations that correspond to it in accordance with the provisions of the fund's participation regulation and the regulations on the matter, or in the contracts entered into on behalf of the fund with the participants and with third parties." ↑
-
By letter of May 27, 2019, that is, after the end of the Inspection (11/20/2018), Macrocapitales submits the Investment Register in Excel format (documents 13 and 14 of file No. 20180041501).
↑
-
Official Letter by which the IGSE made observations, among other topics, on the Fund's Investment Register, which generated Macrocapitales SAFI's response by letter of May 27, 2019. ↑
-
It should be noted that this infraction type has been included in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.6 of the New Sanctions Regulation, which states that it is a serious infraction to "Fail to keep or maintain updated, in the manner required by the regulations, the accounting, books, registers and corresponding files." ↑
-
Information is reliable when it is complete, neutral and free from error. ↑
-
File No. 2018012343 on March 28, 2018. ↑
-
As recorded in the Minutes of completion of the inspection visit, where the information pending delivery is indicated: "Audited Financial Statements of Promotick S.A.C. as of 12/31/2017". ↑
-
The company Charlotte S.A. maintains negative EBITDA for said period and therefore the earnings multiples methodology, used in the valuation of the other investments, would not have been applied. ↑
-
The Fund's Audit Report is dated March 16, 2018. ↑
-
Corresponds to earnings before taxes, interest, depreciation and amortization. ↑
-
Information is reliable when it is complete, neutral and free from error. ↑
-
Submitted to the SMV with file No. 2018012430 on March 28, 2018. ↑
-
"Submit to the SMV, to the Exchange, to the Products Exchange, to the entity in charge of the centralized negotiation mechanism, to the investor or in general to any other participant in the securities or products market, financial information prepared without observing the International Accounting Standards in Peru or the International Financial Reporting Standards, as applicable, the technical pronouncements issued by the country's accounting profession, accounting standards established by the supervisory and control bodies or without observing the norms contained in the Financial Information Regulation ↑
-
SMV Resolution No. 010-2014-SMV/01 of May 22, 2014, in force since May 25, 2014. ↑
-
The sanction criteria referring to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infraction were introduced by article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272, which modified, among others, article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
-
Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of responsibility for infractions
(...)
2.- The following constitute mitigating conditions of responsibility for infractions:
a) If once an administrative sanctioning procedure has begun the offender acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing.
In cases where the applicable sanction is a fine, it is reduced to an amount not less than half of
its amount. ↑