Resolution of the Deputy Superintendence SMV
No. 053-2017-SMV/10
Summary: Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario are sanctioned in their capacity as members of the Surveillance Committee of the Fondo Latam Perú with a fine of 1 UIT equivalent to S/ 3,850.00 (Three thousand eight hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) each for having incurred one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, for failing to present to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the aforementioned fund the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014.
| | |
|---|
| Administrated | : | Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2016027336 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2016027336, Report No. 766-2016-SMV/10.3 issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance, as well as the defenses presented by Mr. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario; and,
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendence of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
- Facts
- Within the supervision functions assigned to the SMV, an evaluation was carried out of the compliance by the members of the Surveillance Committee of the Fondo Latam Perú (hereinafter, the fund) that was under the administration of Access SEAF S.A.C. former fund management company (hereinafter, access seaf) with the provisions contained in the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 and its amendments (hereinafter, the regulation), in force at the time of the events;
- As a result of said evaluation and under the provisions of the Law of General Administrative Procedure, Law No. 27444 and its amendments (hereinafter, LPAG), through Official Letters No. 4165-2016-SMV/10.3, 4168-2016-SMV/10.3, 4169-2016-SMV/10.3 and 4170-2016-SMV/10.3, an administrative sanctioning procedure was initiated against Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario, respectively, in their capacity as members of the Surveillance Committee of the fund for infringement of Article 107, first paragraph of the regulation for failing to present to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the fund the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014;
- It should be noted that the non-compliance indicated in the preceding recital constitutes an infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time of the events (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation) according to which it constitutes an infraction of a serious nature: “To fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations”;
- The charges formulated, as well as the defenses presented by Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario have been evaluated in Report No. 766-2016-SMV/10.3, which has been submitted to the knowledge of this Deputy Superintendence;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, item 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title, as well as in Article 230, item 2 of the LPAG, through Official Letters No. 5720-2016-SMV/10, 5717-2016-SMV/10, 5721-2016-SMV/10 and 5718-2016-SMV/10, the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario for their review;
- On October 20, 2016, Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante and Emilio Llosa Seminario presented their oral report:
- On October 26, 2016, Mr. Emilio Llosa Seminario presented additional written arguments;
- Issues to be determined
- In the present administrative sanctioning procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendence, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario incurred or not in infraction by not presenting the Annual Report on their management corresponding to fiscal year 2014 to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fund as provided by Article 107, first paragraph of the regulation, subject of charges.
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario;
- Analysis
- Applicable regulations
- Article 107, first paragraph of the regulation provides that it corresponds to the Surveillance Committee to prepare an Annual Report on its management, duly endorsed by its members, which must be presented to the Ordinary General Assembly;
“Article 107 Reports of the Surveillance Committee
It corresponds to the Surveillance Committee to prepare an annual report on its management, duly endorsed by its members, which must be presented to the Ordinary General Assembly. The Management Company must keep a file of these reports.
The report of the Surveillance Committee must be sent to the SMV at the same time as the presentation of the annual audited financial statements.
(…)”
- From the review of the information available at the SMV, it was verified that the members of the Surveillance Committee of the Fund did not present to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fund the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014, as provided by the applicable regulations; therefore, they would have incurred in infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction of a serious nature: “To fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations”
3.3. Regarding Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante
Defenses
- In this regard, he states that Article 2, item 2.24, literal d) of the Political Constitution of Peru provides that “no one shall be prosecuted or convicted for an act or omission that at the time of its commission is not previously qualified in the law, in an express and unequivocal manner (…)”. Likewise, he points out that the purpose of the constitutional mandate mentioned is to protect the freedom and security of natural and legal persons so that agents know in advance and with a sufficient level of detail the conducts that are prohibited by the legal system;
- Similarly, he points out that Article 230, item 4 of the LPAG guarantees the legal good protected by the Constitution by requiring that public entities in the exercise of their sanctioning power observe the principle of typicity;
- In this sense, he states that by virtue of the article mentioned in the preceding recital, only those conducts expressly provided in a norm are punishable. Likewise, he considers that the norm is clear in prohibiting the creation of administrative infractions by extensive or analogical interpretation, since that would mean granting discretion to the authority in the qualification of infractions, generating uncertainty in the agents regarding the conducts proscribed by the legal system;
- On the matter, in order to reinforce his arguments, he cites some authors, as well as pronouncements of the Constitutional Court referring to the fact that the mandate of typification is a manifestation of the principle of legality and to the invalidity of imprecise and ambiguous typifications or with open formulas;
- On the other hand, he considers that the infraction contained in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation is a blank or empty sanctioning norm that lacks adequate typification. In this regard, he states that said provision does not comply with detailing which are the specific conducts subject to sanction, so it results in an insufficient typification or rather, in what has been called an empty or blank typification. Likewise, he points out that this type of generic and imprecise formulations of infractions necessarily entails a violation of the principle of typicity, which requires the necessary normative description of the specific conduct to which an administrative sanction will be attributed;
- In that order of ideas, he points out that the Constitutional Court has ruled against formulations of this type by considering them contrary to the principle of typicity and legality; and therefore unconstitutional. In attention to this, he states that the infraction contained in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation constitutes a violation of the principle of typicity;
- Likewise, he considers that according to Article 10 of the LPAG, an administrative act incurs a cause of nullity when it contravenes the Constitution or norms with legal rank that are part of the legal system. Therefore, he points out that in the present case, any sanction derived from the typification mentioned previously will suffer from a cause of nullity since the alleged norm does not comply with the minimum parameters required by the principle of typicity;
- Now then, he considers that there is no express typification in any norm that sanctions the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative procedure. Likewise, he points out that it is not only illegal to impute the qualification of serious infraction to the mentioned conduct but also that in the denied supposition that some type of responsibility is wanted to be imputed, it should be assimilated to those that derive in the qualification of an infraction of a minor nature since the Sanctions Regulation provides for the sanction of similar conducts under said gradation, such as the timely lack of supply of documentation or information;
- In this regard, he states that in the Resolutions of Deputy Superintendence SMV No. 019-2015-SMV/10, 014-2014-SMV/10, 017-2014-SMV/10 and 035-2014-SMV/10 it can be seen that the SMV imputes the lack of communication of information or documentation under Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, for a certain type of specific information (individual or consolidated audited financial information, individual or consolidated interim financial information, management report, additional audit report, material events, annual reports) and under Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.6 the lack of communication of information or documentation not included within the referred item 3.1;
- In this sense, he considers that in the present case, since it deals with the lack of remission of the Annual Management Report corresponding to fiscal year 2014 by the Surveillance Committee to the General Assembly of Participants, the conduct should have been qualified as an infraction of a minor nature according to Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Similarly, he points out that it is usual practice of the SMV that sanctioning procedures for non-delivery of information are considered as minor infractions as can be seen in the Resolutions of Deputy Superintendence mentioned previously;
- Consequently, he considers that he has proven that the SMV in those cases in which there has been non-compliance with sending certain information or documentation not indicated in Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation has determined that said facts must be imputed using Annex I, numeral 3, item 3.6 and has not qualified them as serious infractions. Therefore, he points out that not qualifying the present case in the same manner would configure a supposition of discrimination given the indicated precedents, which would configure a cause of nullity of a possible sanction. Finally, he points out that in the worst scenario according to the Sanctions Regulation, the conduct subject to analysis in the present procedure should have been qualified as a minor infraction but under no supposition as a serious infraction;
- On the other hand, he recognizes that the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2014 was not sent, however he considers that said fact does not constitute a non-compliance of his obligations given that in order to execute it, all the elements of the same must be counted such as the compliance deadline;
- Now then, he points out that although Article 39 of the Fund's Participation Regulation provides that the Surveillance Committee must send the Annual Management Reports to the General Assembly, it does not expressly state the deadline to comply with said obligation. Likewise, he states that Article 107 of the Regulation also does not expressly establish the deadline for the presentation of the mentioned Report to the General Assembly of Participants, mentioning only that it is presented to the Ordinary General Assembly;
- In that order of ideas, he points out that it must be considered that the Fund's Participation Regulation, unlike Article 107 of the Regulation, provides that the Annual Management Report of the Surveillance Committee must be presented to the General Assembly and not to the Ordinary General Assembly. On the matter, he considers that in the present case, the provisions of the Fund's Participation Regulation are immediately applicable and that the provisions contained in the Regulation are supplementary to those provided in it;
- Likewise, he points out that the will of the participants of the Fund was to establish that the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee should be presented at the General Assembly, expressly agreeing against Article 107 of the Regulation that provided that said Report is presented at the Ordinary General Assembly, which has a legal deadline for its celebration;
- Similarly, he points out that in case it is considered that Article 107 of the Regulation applies in a supplementary manner to the Fund's Participation Regulation, the provisions of Article 121[1] of the Regulation must be considered. In this sense, he states that supplementary application only proceeds in those cases in which something different has not been established in the Participation Regulation, as occurs in the present case;
- Consequently, he points out that since there is no deadline for the presentation of the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee to the Assembly of Participants, it could hardly be indicated that an obligation has been breached and even less that an infraction has occurred;
- On the other hand, he states that in the denied supposition that it is considered that he has incurred in the infraction imputed as a charge, the Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Norms that regulate the Remission of Periodic or Eventual Information approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments, in force at the time of the events, (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria) must be applied by extension. In this regard, he specifies that although the imputed infraction has not been qualified as an infraction of a minor nature but as serious, he considers that the Sanction Criteria must be taken as a guide by extension for the purpose of qualifying the alleged infraction. Likewise, he considers that according to his defenses, if the imputed fact had a minor nature, it would correspond to apply the Sanction Criteria directly;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, it should be noted that the transparency of the securities market has as its fundamental purpose to safeguard the right of investors and other market participants to access periodic and eventual information in a timely manner. In the present case, it is requested to take into account that the members of the Surveillance Committee are direct representatives of each of the participants of the Fund;
- In this sense, he considers that there has been no real affectation to the right of information of the investors of the Fund and that they were fully informed about the management of the Fund in fiscal year 2014. Additionally, he points out that it must be taken into account that the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee is not a document of public access to the market in general unlike the financial statements, so that being not freely accessible to other market participants, even in the hypothetical case that it had not been sent to Access seaf, it does not violate the transparency of the market in general;
- Regarding the economic damage caused and its repercussion in the market, there is no economic damage caused to any participant or other possible investor of the market nor any other damage derived from the non-timely remission of the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2014. In this regard, he considers that the aforementioned is proven because the participants were always informed of the management of the Fund and because there has been no claim by said participants against the members of the Surveillance Committee;
- Regarding the antecedents, he states that he has no sanctions in administrative venue for infractions that have been imposed within the four (4) years prior to the initiation of the present administrative sanctioning procedure and even before. Likewise, he points out that he has not been notified with any other administrative, judicial and/or arbitral procedure initiated by virtue of the performance of his position;
- Regarding the repetition and/or continuity in the commission of the infraction, he states that the criterion in question is not applicable to the infraction subject to analysis given that the lack of timely presentation of periodic information is configured at a single moment;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, he points out that it must be taken into account that the imputed fact happened within the framework of a situation in which they were the representatives of the participants, so they were fully informed of the management of the Fund during fiscal year 2014;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, he states that he has not obtained any economic benefit from the infraction subject to analysis;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the infractor, he points out that there has been no intention or malicious direction for the configuration of the infraction subject to analysis. Likewise, he states that good faith is presumed and bad faith, malice or intentionality must be proven;
- Similarly, he states that the Sanction Criteria indicate that once the evaluation of the infraction is concluded, the instructing bodies evaluate whether the attenuating circumstances of responsibility contemplated in Article 236-A of the LPAG are configured as long as the existence of any aggravating circumstance has not been determined. On the matter, he points out that as previously exposed, none of the aggravating circumstances has been configured, so it corresponds to apply the mentioned attenuating circumstances according to the principles of reasonableness and proportionality;
- Now then, regarding the principle of reasonableness, he considers that within any administrative sanctioning procedure, the administrated enjoys the fundamental right to be imposed the sanction adequate and proportional to his behavior. In this sense, he points out that if the infraction incurred by the administrated is minor and meets the attenuating circumstances, the sanction imposed must be proportional to the conduct of the administrated and to the effects that the infraction has on the market. Consequently, he states that in the denied supposition that it is considered that he has incurred in the infraction imputed as a charge, the only sanction that would be proportional is the reprimand, any other would be contrary to the principle of reasonableness;
- In his oral report, he additionally points out that the obligation to present the Management Report in charge of the members of the Surveillance Committee was not possible to comply with because the body in charge of convening the ordinary general assembly, the management company, never complied with convening the Ordinary General Assembly in 2015 so that the committee could present the referred report;
- For the reasons exposed, he requests that it be declared that he did not incur in the infraction imputed as a charge related to the preparation and communication of the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee of the Fund corresponding to fiscal year 2014 to the General Assembly;
Analysis of the defenses
- Regarding the arguments presented on the legality of the imputed infraction type, that is, Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a serious infraction to “Fail to comply with its functions or the provisions contemplated in the regulations”, which allegedly infringes article 2, numeral 24, literal d) of the Political Constitution of Peru, as well as contravenes the principle of typicality established in article 230, numeral 4 of the LPAG by constituting an administrative infraction by extensive, analogical interpretation or a blank sanctioning norm, the following must be stated;
- In administrative matters, the description of infracting conduct must allow the administered to know the obligations they must comply with and the consequences derived from their non-compliance. In this sense, this knowledge can be given through the substantive norm and the corresponding sanctioning norm, which has occurred in the present case;
- Indeed, the principle of typicality admits a certain degree of indeterminacy, lesser or greater depending on the case, as long as there exist in the legal system criteria previously established, such as legal provisions (as occurs in the present case) that provide clear and sufficient information about the behavior sought to be sanctioned, allowing the nature and characteristics of an infracting conduct to be foreseen with sufficient certainty, not leaving the administration any margin of discretion, since the elaboration of these criteria only allows a single solution and not several possible solutions;
- It is in this sense that the Constitutional Court has ruled in File No. 2050-2002-AA/TTC, recognizing the possibility of resorting to regulatory “elaboration” in order to eliminate the risk of legal uncertainty, provided that independent regulations not clearly subordinate to the law are not created, as expressed in the following text:
“The principle of legality in sanctioning matters prevents attributing the commission of an infraction if it is not previously determined in the law, and also prohibits applying a sanction if it is not also determined by law (...).
The principle of legality should not be identified with the principle of typicality. The former, guaranteed by ordinal “d” of numeral 24) of article 2 of the Constitution, is satisfied when the provision of infractions and sanctions in the law is complied with. The latter, however, constitutes the precise definition of the conduct that the law considers as an infraction. Such precision of what is considered unlawful from an administrative point of view (...) is not subject to an absolute reserve of law, but can be complemented through the respective regulations (...)”;
- On the other hand, regarding the arguments referring to the absence of express typification in any norm that sanctions the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative proceeding, it should be noted that Professor Muñoz Conde indicates that the legislator selects the most intolerable and most harmful unlawful behaviors for the most important legal goods[2];
- Likewise, doctrine also states that it is impossible to detail all legal types deserving of sanction, as is indirectly raised in the defenses previously set forth, since this is materially unsustainable, so much so that not even the supervised themselves could regulate in their internal manuals all possible situations. On this matter, Professor Muñoz Conde[3] has ruled in favor of what is stated in this recital;
- In this line of ideas, continuing with the analysis, regarding compliance with the principle of legality and the principle of typicality, it is sufficient that from the norm, the one containing the general description of the factual assumption, it is reasonably possible to extract the infracting conduct;
- Thus, in the present case, the infraction type established in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation is validly complemented by the provisions of article 107, first paragraph of the Regulation, which regulates that it is the function of the members of the Surveillance Committee to prepare the Annual Report on their Management, endorse it and present it to the Ordinary General Assembly;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be noted that article 34, literal e) of the Investment Funds Law, Legislative Decree No. 862 and its amendments (hereinafter, investment funds law) in accordance with article 39, last paragraph of the Fund Participation Regulation provide that it corresponds to the Surveillance Committee to prepare an Annual Report on its management that must be endorsed by all its members and presented to the General Assembly;
- Consequently, the non-compliance with the obligation mentioned in the preceding recital is a non-compliance subject to a sanction previously determined in the Sanctions Regulation, insofar as it is classified as a serious infraction. Thus, the discretion of the administration is limited because the determination of the infraction and the corresponding sanction are previously established in the norms;
- Therefore, once the scope of the norms under analysis is thus specified, it presents a sufficient degree of determination to delimit the scope of the non-compliance and its consequence and, in this way, to communicate to the obligated subjects its scope, so it does not constitute a blank or empty sanctioning norm nor does it incur a cause of nullity of the administrative act, as was indicated in the defenses previously set forth, and it would not be violating the principle of typicality and consequently neither the principle of legality;
- Now, regarding the arguments presented referring to the fact that the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative proceeding should be classified as a minor infraction typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.6 of the Sanctions Regulation, it should be noted that the resolutions mentioned as precedents deal with non-compliances with the obligation to present information or documentation to the SMV. In this sense, the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative proceeding refers to a non-compliance by the Fund's Surveillance Committee with the presentation of its respective Report before the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants. Therefore, they constitute two (02) submission obligations with different recipients, since the infractions typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraphs 3.1 and 3.6 are configured as long as the obligation to submit information or documentation to the SMV is not complied with; which has not been questioned against the members of the Fund's Surveillance Committee in the present administrative proceeding;
- On the other hand, regarding the arguments referring to the non-existence of non-compliance, despite acknowledging that the Annual Report on the management of the Surveillance Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2014 was not submitted, it should be noted that it is not correct to state that there is no deadline for compliance with the obligation under analysis, since article 11, literal a) of the investment funds law provides that the Ordinary Assembly is held once a year within the first four months of the fiscal year, so compliance with the obligations contained in article 107, first paragraph of the regulation must be carried out until the holding of the aforementioned Assembly. Likewise, even if said position were valid, the Report in question was not presented at any time before or after the start of the present administrative proceeding;
- Now, with reference to the arguments referring to the supplementary application of article 107 of the regulation and the provisions contained in article 39 of the Fund Participation Regulation, it should be noted that according to article 121 of the regulation, supplementary application only occurs insofar as different provisions have not been established in the Fund Participation Regulation. As stated in the defenses, the difference would lie in the fact that the Fund Participation Regulation has provided that the Report under analysis be presented to the General Assembly and not to the Ordinary General Assembly, so, as it states, the provisions of the Fund Participation Regulation apply immediately since the provisions contained in the Regulation are supplementary insofar as it was expressly agreed against article 107 of said Regulation;
- Regarding what was stated in its defenses, it is necessary to highlight that even if the position expressed regarding the reading on the applicability of the Participation Regulation and not the Regulation were accepted, since the aforementioned Participation Regulation did not distinguish whether it is the Ordinary General Assembly or the Extraordinary General Assembly; said position does not invalidate the commission of the infraction, since the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014 was not presented by the members of the Fund's Surveillance Committee either to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants or to the Extraordinary General Assembly of Participants, so its argument lacks support. Likewise, the Report in question was not submitted for approval to the Assemblies of Participants convened by the Surveillance Committee in which matters related to the liquidation of the fund were discussed;
- Regarding the fact that the management company never complied with convening the Ordinary General Assembly of 2015 so that the Surveillance Committee could present its Management Report; it should be noted that through file No. 2015002355, the management company communicated as a material event of January 22, 2015 the call for the ordinary assembly of participants to be held on February 6, 2015. Likewise, through file No. 2015004188, it communicated as a material event of February 6, 2015 the results of the agreements of said assembly. It should be noted that Mr. Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza presents defenses related to said assembly, which will be evaluated in the following recitals;
- On the other hand, with reference to the application by extension of the Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Norms that regulate the Submission of Periodic or Eventual Information approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments, it is important to note that it is not possible to grant what is requested since these apply exclusively to non-compliances with the norms that regulate the submission of periodic or eventual information to the SMV and do not apply extensively to the other cases investigated by the SMV. Without prejudice to this, the analysis set forth will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed as part of the analysis of the Criteria and attenuating factors contemplated in article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG and article 236-A of the aforementioned normative body;
- Consequently, considering that none of the arguments presented has disproved the imputed charge, it has been proven that Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante committed one (1) serious infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the sanctions regulation;
3.3. Regarding Mr. Emilio Llosa Seminario
Defenses
- In this regard, it reiterates the defenses detailed in numeral 3.2 of this resolution. Additionally, it states as background of the case the context in which the functions of the members of the Fund's Surveillance Committee were carried out;
- In April 2015, the members of the Surveillance Committee and the participants of the Fund became aware that Access Seaf was in a very bad economic and administrative situation, with the members of its Board of Directors having voted for the initiation of insolvency proceedings and resigned from their positions. This situation affected the rights of the participants since the capacity of said company to develop its functions and comply with the obligations corresponding to it as management company was undermined;
- On April 27, 2015, the Fund's Surveillance Committee met to deliberate on the need to convene an Extraordinary Assembly of Participants to address various aspects related to the liquidation of the Fund;
- On May 11, 2015, at the request of the Surveillance Committee, an Extraordinary Assembly of Participants was held in which they agreed to the liquidation of the Fund, appointed EFIC Partners S.A.C. as liquidating entity and proceeded to determine the liquidation procedure;
- On September 4, 2015, the operating authorization of Access seaf was revoked due to its administrative and patrimonial situation;
- In this line of ideas, the Surveillance Committee would have acted diligently, keeping the participants permanently informed, being also duly informed as they themselves are representatives of the participants. The activities in question would have been carried out during a long process of coordination between the members of the Surveillance Committee and the participants because the composition of the Assembly included foreign participants and even access seaf itself, which made the process not expeditious;
- On the other hand, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it states that the situation experienced by the Fund during the administration of Access seaf represents one of a sui generis nature and absolutely atypical in the Peruvian market. In said situation, the members of the Surveillance Committee and the participants directed all their efforts to remove Access seaf from the administration of the Fund to avoid damages from the negligent management of said company and proceed to the liquidation of the Fund. In this sense, it states that the attention of the members of the Fund's Surveillance Committee was focused on the coordination and process of removal of Access seaf;
- Consequently, for the reasons set forth, it requests that it be declared that it did not incur the infraction imputed as a charge related to the preparation and communication of the Annual Report on the Management of the Surveillance Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2014 to the General Assembly;
Analysis of the Defenses
- For the case of defenses that are similar to those set forth in numeral 3.2 of this resolution, the evaluation carried out in said numeral must be reiterated for these purposes;
- Now, the Minutes of the Surveillance Committee of April 27, 2015 and General Assemblies of Participants of April 14, 2014 and May 11, 2015 and the complementary arguments referring to the context in which the functions of the members of the Surveillance Committee were carried out, will be evaluated as elements forming the circumstances of the commission of the infraction at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed in the analysis of the Criteria and attenuating factors contemplated in article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG and article 236-A of the aforementioned normative body;
- Consequently, considering that none of the arguments presented has disproved the imputed charge, it has been proven that Emilio Llosa Seminario committed one (01) serious infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the sanctions regulation;
3.4. Regarding Mrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo
Defenses
- In this regard, it reiterates the defenses detailed in numeral 3.2 of this resolution. Additionally, it states that it has been erroneously understood that the non-compliance with the obligation contained in article 107 of the Regulation has configured the infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation. Likewise, it states that after having reviewed the Sanctions Regulation, it considers that the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative proceeding is not typified as an administrative infraction, which fails to comply with the provisions of article 3 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Similarly, it states that the text of the typified infraction is general and imprecise since it does not detail which are the specific conducts subject to sanction, so it is a blank or empty sanctioning norm. In this regard, it states that under the infraction typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, the members of the Surveillance Committee of an investment fund could be sanctioned for the non-observance or omission of any of their functions or obligations contained in the Regulation or in the Fund Participation Regulation. In this sense, it states that for example there could be the case that the eventual non-compliance with article 100, literal c) of the Regulation referring to “propose the audit firms for their election in General Assembly” would be subject to a sanction for the commission of the infraction mentioned previously;
- Likewise, it states that the members of the Surveillance Committee of an investment fund have multiple functions and/or obligations which arise from the Regulation and the corresponding Participation Regulation, so the non-compliance with any of these considers that it should not be assimilated to such an open and imprecise typification as that regulated in Annex I, numeral 2, subparagraph 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation. Similarly, it questions whether it is reasonable that not attending a Surveillance Committee can also be considered as non-compliance with its functions and therefore be subject to a fine of between twenty-five (25) and fifty (50) UIT;
- Now, it states that the infraction imputed as a charge is the typical “catch-all” infraction in which arbitrarily and unforeseeably it seeks to include all those conducts or actions whose omission, non-observance or non-compliance has not been validly typified as an infraction subject to sanction. ;
- Likewise, it considers that the principle of typicality comes from a double necessity, on the one hand, from the general principles of freedom formally established in the Constitution and which have a direct relationship with the establishment of the Rule of Law and on the other hand a evident correlate in legal certainty since it allows the administered to have certain knowledge of the consequences of the acts they perform;
- In this sense, it states that for the exercise of the punitive function of the Public Administration, the clear, express and prior establishment by law of the sanctionable conduct is necessarily required, which cannot be subject to extensive or analogical interpretation;
- On the other hand, regarding the inconsistency of the sanction, it considers that the financial information that is submitted to the SMV, unlike the Annual Management Report on the Management of the Surveillance Committee, is indeed public information. In this regard, it questions how it is possible that the eventual non-compliance with the submission of financial information to the regulator is typified as a minor infraction and the non-compliance with the presentation of the Annual Report on the Management of the Surveillance Committee, which is a private document, is typified as a serious infraction. Similarly, it states that there is no consistency or proportionality in the graduation of the sanction sought to be imposed and that it would be an error to subsume the conduct subject to analysis in the present administrative proceeding within an open legal type empty of content;
- Additionally, it states that another example is that the conduct consisting of “Not designating the audit firm, or not communicating its change, within the period provided in the regulations”, is typified as a minor infraction, according to Annex I, numeral 3, subparagraph 3.4 of the Sanctions Regulation. However, according to the interpretation used in the charge letter, the eventual non-compliance with article 100, literal c) of the Regulation cited previously could be susceptible to being typified as a serious infraction;
- Consequently, it considers that the imputation contained in the charge letter is not consistent with an adequate graduality of the infractions typified in the Sanctions Regulation;
- Additionally, it considers that the Criteria and attenuating factors contemplated in article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, article 348 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, lmv) and article 230, numeral 3 of the lpag are applicable to the present case; indicating the following recitals;
- Regarding the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, since the Annual Report on the Management of the Surveillance Committee is not a public document, the omission of sending it to the General Assembly does not violate the principle of transparency whose objective is to protect the right of investors to timely access sufficient and truthful information;
- Regarding the damage caused and its repercussion in the market, it states that the case of the Fund's Surveillance Committee is particular and must be analyzed as such, since unlike what occurs with funds in which there is a greater number of dispersed participants, in the Fund each of the members of the Surveillance Committee is a direct representative of each of the participants;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it states that the SMV must consider that the Surveillance Committee is an independent body appointed by the participants of the Fund, unlike Access seaf and the Investment Committee of said company. Said body watches over the interests of the participants and in the present case it is not the one that has behaved inappropriately in the market. Likewise, it has promoted the adoption of adequate measures to achieve an orderly transfer of the fund in favor of an adequate and diligent administrator. Similarly, it states that there has always been a perfect alignment of interests between the Surveillance Committee and the participants of the Fund, the latter being the investors that the SMV seeks to protect with the present administrative sanctioning proceeding;
- Consequently, for the reasons set forth, it requests that it be declared that it did not incur the infraction imputed as a charge related to the preparation and communication of the Annual Report on the Management of the Surveillance Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2014 to the General Assembly;
Analysis of the Defenses
- In the case of the defenses that are similar to those set forth in numeral 3.2 of this resolution, it is appropriate to reiterate the evaluation carried out in said numeral for these purposes. Notwithstanding this, it should be clarified that this administrative proceeding deals solely with the breach of the Vigilance Committee's duty regarding the Annual Report on its management, and not with the other duties it may have under applicable regulations;
- Now then, the Vigilance Committee Minutes of April 27, 2015 and General Assemblies of Participants of April 14, 2014 and May 11, 2015, and the complementary arguments related to the Criteria and mitigating factors contemplated in Article 348 of the LMV and Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with numeral 3 of Article 230 of the LPAG and Article 236-A of the aforementioned body of norms, will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed;
- Consequently, considering that none of the arguments presented has disproved the charge imputed, it has been established that Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo committed one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation;
3.5. Regarding Mr. Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza
Defenses
- In this regard, he states that in the Ordinary Assembly of Participants of March 22, 2013, he was proposed as a member of the Vigilance Committee of the Fund, a position that according to the Fund's Participation Regulation had a two-year term;
- On the other hand, he states that the obligation of the Vigilance Committee is to present the Annual Report on its management directly to the General Assembly of Participants, and it is not its obligation to report to the SMV on this matter;
- Additionally, he considers that the Criteria and mitigating factors contemplated in Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, Article 348 of the LMV, and Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the offender's contribution to its clarification, and the principles of administrative sanctioning power, are applicable to this case; stating the following considerations;
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, according to Article 20 of the Fund's Participation Regulation, whose provision is similar to the Regulation, Ordinary General Assemblies must be convened by the Management Company. On the other hand, Extraordinary General Assemblies may be convened by the Management Company or by the Vigilance Committee. In this regard, he specifies that in this case the Vigilance Committee did not have the authority to convene an Ordinary General Assembly;
- Likewise, according to the Fund's Participation Regulation, Ordinary General Assemblies had to be convened by the Management Company within four months of the close of the corresponding fiscal year, in order to address the points indicated in Article 21 of the aforementioned Participation Regulation. Those matters are reserved for the Ordinary General Assembly and not for the Extraordinary General Assembly;
- In that sense, as can be verified from the material facts presented by Access SEAF during 2015, it failed to convene an Ordinary General Assembly including as an agenda item the approval of the Vigilance Committee Report, so the members of said body were unable to comply with presenting it. Similarly, he states that during that period the Fund went through a delicate situation, so efforts were focused on finding a solution to liquidate it;
- Consequently, circumstances arose that prevented the Vigilance Committee from complying with its obligation, which would have produced an event beyond the control of the accused that constitutes an exceptional situation of force majeure, warranting exemption from liability and archiving of this administrative proceeding;
- On this matter, by virtue of the principle of predictability indicated in the Preliminary Title, Article IV, numeral 1.15 of the LPAG, he considers that the decision in Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 129-2015-SMV/11 of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, which archived the imputation regarding which the situation indicated in the preceding consideration was verified, should be taken into account;
- On the other hand, he states that the inconveniences originated due to the Fund's inability to sell an investment that the participants and members of the Vigilance Committee understood could be made, which was not timely informed by the Management Company to the participants, members of the Vigilance Committee in question, and lawyers. For this reason, he states that trust in the Management Company was lost by the participants, and it also led to financial problems reflected in the loss of liquidity of the Fund;
- Likewise, he states that these problems were reported by the Vigilance Committee in the Annual Report on its management for the 2013 fiscal year presented to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of April 14, 2014, as well as in the various sessions of the Vigilance Committee during 2012 and 2013, which were reflected in various events during 2014;
- Similarly, he states that the financial problems caused the auditing firm BDO to suspend its services to the fund due to non-payment of fees, with the Management Company proposing that it would handle the financial information. This event led to the non-approval of the financial statements by the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of April 14, 2014, since it had only 30% of participants according to what was communicated through a material fact entered in file No. 2014014106;
- Likewise, he states that the fund had outstanding accounts payable to various suppliers since September 2013, including the law firm where he works, so in August 2014 continuous legal advice ceased. To support what was stated in this consideration, he attaches emails;
- The described situation would have caused the Management Company, on its own decision, to invest its own resources in seeking a solution, until its parent company decided not to continue providing funds. The described context led to the departure of the persons in charge of the General Management in July and August 2014;
- For these reasons, in March 2015 it was no longer possible for him to communicate fluidly with officials of the Management Company in the country, whose only representative was its General Manager. To support what was stated in this consideration, he attaches emails;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, he states that the participants whose representatives were members of the Vigilance Committee had been making coordination to find a solution to the situation the Fund was going through. However, he states that having been a lawyer for the Management Company and the Fund, it could be considered that he maintained a conflict of interest, so he did not participate in such coordination;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, he states that the regulation of the securities market is governed by the control that the State must exercise in the economy as established in the Constitution. Thus, the State through the SMV regulates and supervises the securities market in order to stimulate the growth of wealth to ensure the proper functioning of the securities market through the proper functioning of its institutions, generating confidence in it. Likewise, he states that Article 1 of the LMV provides as the purpose of the norm the promotion of orderly development and transparency of the securities market, as well as the adequate protection of the investor. In this case, he understands that the purpose pursued by the obligation to present the Annual Report on the Management of the Vigilance Committee is the protection of investors, that is, the participants;
- On the other hand, he states that it is important to consider the nature of the Fund, which was registered under the Simplified Regime and whose participants qualified as Institutional Investors according to the Regulation of the Institutional Investors Market approved by SMV Resolution No. 021-2013-SMV/01. In this sense, he considers that the Fund could qualify as a fund that issues securities by private offering according to Article 5 of the LMV, so if it had not been registered it would not require SMV supervision because the level of professionalism of its participants did not require tutelage. Therefore, he states that being a fund that in principle would not require tutelage, there is no affectation to the public interest or protected legal interest;
- Regarding the damage caused and its repercussion on the market, he states that the purpose of the Annual Report on the management of the Vigilance Committee was to inform the participants of the management carried out by said body during the completed fiscal year. Likewise, he states that the Regulation and the Fund's Participation Regulation do not establish the minimum content of said Report. However, he states that the Vigilance Committee had the function of overseeing the management of Access SEAF regarding the Fund, so the content it would have presented would be to ensure compliance with the provisions of applicable regulations and the Participation Regulation;
- Subsequently, he states that he was appointed as a member of the Vigilance Committee representing Latam Growth Fund Limited, a venture capital fund managed by Access Management Holding Inc. as a result of a co-investment agreement with Access SEAF as set forth in Articles 2, literal q) and 47 of the Fund's Participation Regulation and according to the information available on the website of Small Enterprise Assistance Funds – SEAF. In this regard, he states that his appointment was made by virtue of the legal advice provided by the law firm that is part of Access SEAF in order to provide legal support to the decisions of the Vigilance Committee and to prepare reports on the legal structures of the investments the fund made;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, he specifies that although the Annual Report on the Management of the Vigilance Committee could not be presented to the Ordinary General Assembly, this did not prevent the participants from becoming aware of the management carried out. In the case of Latam Growth Fund, awareness was through Access SEAF;
- Consequently, for the foregoing and given that the Vigilance Committee Report is not public in nature, he considers that there is no general affectation to the market, especially since no participation quotas of the Fund were offered;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality, he states that the omission to present the Annual Report on the Management of the Vigilance Committee was not an intentional conduct but was due to the fact that he did not have the opportunity to present it to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants because it was not convened for that item;
- Regarding the typicity of the infraction, he states that from the reading of Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19, it is not expressly clear what conducts are subject, making it necessary to refer to the Regulation to review all the obligations that each of the subjects to whom they are applicable have. Notwithstanding the foregoing, he states that it should be considered that the infraction is typified in a type by reference because it is an empty or blank norm. In this sense, he considers that the sanctioning provision is contrary to the principle of typicity since the indeterminacy and generality of the fact considered illicit will result in the SMV being the one who typifies the punishable fact in each case;
- Regarding reasonableness and proportionality, he states that the fault imputed as a charge is classified as serious and could be sanctioned with a fine of 25 to 50 UIT, which he would have to pay with his family patrimony, being totally disproportionate as he is a natural person and by virtue of the arguments previously exposed;
- Given the foregoing, he states that a natural person cannot be sanctioned in the same way as a legal person that has established prudential requirements, especially when dealing with an open sanctioning type that covers all obligations applicable to members of the Vigilance Committee. Likewise, he considers that if he is sanctioned for an infraction classified as serious, it would affect the performance of his profession as a lawyer and would constitute an impediment to holding various positions in the securities market and the financial system. Similarly, he states that the foregoing is disproportionate if one considers that it is an open type, that no damage has been generated, and that there were circumstances that prevented compliance with the obligation;
- On the other hand, he requests the application of Article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation in order to impose a sanction corresponding to infractions of a lower classification. Likewise, he states that it is not coherent that he was initially granted the minimum period to present his defenses given that he was charged with the commission of a serious infraction that is complex due to the magnitude of the damage that could be generated to his person;
- Consequently, for the reasons set forth, he requests the archiving of this administrative sanctioning proceeding or, if applicable, to propose a sanction of reprimand corresponding to infractions of a minor nature;
Evaluation of the Defenses
- For the case of the defenses that are similar to those set forth in numeral 3.2. of this resolution, it is appropriate to reiterate the evaluation carried out in said numeral for these purposes;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, regarding the arguments referring to the fact that the non-compliance was generated because Access seaf, when convening the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants, did not include as an agenda item the approval of the Report subject to analysis, it is important to note that the Managing Company defines the agenda of the Assemblies based on the information that was previously delivered. Consequently, since the Supervisory Committee did not comply with submitting the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014, Access seaf could not have established the approval of the aforementioned Report in the agenda of the agreements to be adopted;
- Likewise, regarding the fact that the approval of the Annual Report on the management of the Supervisory Committee is reserved to the Ordinary General Assembly and not to the Extraordinary General Assembly, it should be noted that as indicated in the preceding recital, the omission of the approval of the aforementioned Report was generated by the omission of its presentation as acknowledged in the defenses previously set forth. In that sense, the omission of the aforementioned presentation cannot be considered an external fact, and even the Report of the Supervisory Committee in question was not presented for consideration of the Extraordinary General Assembly of Participants, therefore, what was argued in its defenses is not an exempting cause of responsibility either;
- On the other hand, with reference to the arguments regarding the nature of the Fund, it should be specified that according to article 32, last paragraph of the regulation, from the registration in the Public Registry of the Securities Market of funds placed by private offering, they must subject to the provisions established in said normative body; which consider duties of diligence in order that the markets be transparent and integral, with the objective of protecting investors in general;
- Likewise, regarding the arguments referring to the fact that the minimum term was granted to present its defenses, it should be noted that according to article 12, third paragraph of the sanctions regulation, the General Compliance Intendancies may grant a term of between five (5) and fifteen (15) days from the respective notification. In this regard, the term initially granted was extended at the request of the party through Official Letter No. 4488-2016-SMV/10.3 notified on August 12, 2016, therefore no right of the administered has been violated;
- On the other hand, it should be specified that from the review of the Annual Report of the management of the Supervisory Committee corresponding to fiscal year 2013 presented to this Superintendency, it was verified that the Supervisory Committee indicated at that opportunity the judicial situation of the problems mentioned in its defenses, as well as what was stated regarding the approval of the financial statements mentioned in its defenses;
- Now, from the review of the emails presented in its defenses, the financial difficulties that generated payment defaults to suppliers are observed, among them for the provision of legal services. However, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza continued to hold the position of member of the Supervisory Committee of the fund, therefore by continuing to exercise it he had to comply with the respective obligations, among them those referred to the preparation of the Annual Report on the management of the Supervisory Committee;
- Regarding the communication problems, it should be noted that said situation will be analyzed at the time of evaluating the sanction to be imposed, without prejudice to which it should be noted that from the emails presented in its defenses the queries made between Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Mr. Richard Russell in his capacity as an official of Access seaf are appreciated. Likewise, he did not present evidentiary means that accredit that the other members of the Supervisory Committee of the fund held meetings without his participation, which at the extreme would not undermine the fulfillment of the obligation;
- Now, the remaining arguments related to the Criteria and mitigating factors contemplated in article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG and article 236-A of the aforementioned normative body, will be evaluated at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed;
- Consequently, considering that none of the arguments set forth has disproved the imputed charge, it has been accredited that Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza committed one (1) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the sanctions regulation;
- EVALUATION OF THE SANCTION
- With respect to the criteria to be taken into account to impose the sanction, we must point out that article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation establishes that the administrative sanctions that are imposed must take into account the criteria established in article 348 of the LMV and numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG, as well as the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction, the contribution of the offender for its clarification and the mitigating and exempting factors of responsibility established in article 236-A of the LPAG;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) Background of the offenders; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, included within the criterion of the LMV referred to the repercussion in the market and the damage caused; c) The economic damage caused; d) The recidivism in the commission of the infraction; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illegally obtained benefit; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender; h) the probability of detection of the infraction; i) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the contribution of the offender for its clarification; j) The voluntary correction of the act or omission constituting the infraction prior to the notification of the corresponding charges; and k) The error induced by the administration by an act or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision;
- In relation to the background of the offender, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, in force at the time of the commission of the infractions, the sanctions imposed by the SMV and that obtained firmness within the four (4) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned are considered as background of the offender;
- In this regard, it has been verified that Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario do not register sanction backgrounds;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal good, which includes the damage caused and the repercussion in the market, it has not been possible to accredit that the action of the members of the Supervisory Committee has caused damage to the public interest or has had repercussion in the market;
- As for this criterion and what was stated in the defenses that the Report of the Supervisory Committee is not public in nature, therefore it is considered that there is no general affectation to the market, it should be indicated that article 107 of the Regulation provides as an obligation of the administrators that the referred report be sent to the SMV at the same time of presentation of the annual financial statements, therefore it must be specified that although it is periodic information that does not constitute public information, it must be considered that said report contains information for purposes of supervision and control by the SMV, to the extent that it includes the evaluation of the Supervisory Committee of the compliance by the managing company of the management of the investment fund in accordance with the provisions of the respective participation regulation, whose information cannot be substituted by other documentation presented to the SMV;
- In that sense, by not having complied the members of the supervisory committee with their obligation to prepare and present timely to the administrator in the Ordinary General Assembly their report, it limited the capacity of the latter to comply with the indicated obligation; and being the same information that helps the SMV to fulfill its objectives of ensuring the integrity of the market, said legal principle has been affected to the extent that said report was not sent;
- It should be indicated that the mentioned report is not limited to reiterating situations or facts that are communicated through material facts, management reports, investment statements or annual memory; on the contrary, it aims to expose the result of the management of the administered funds, therefore the reports of the supervisory committee jointly with the compliance reports and the audited financial reports, among others, constitute elements that contribute to the regulator fulfilling its objectives of protection to investors, participants and as mentioned, to the integrity of the market;
- Likewise, in the present case it has not been possible to evidence that the action of Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario has caused a concrete economic damage to the market participants;
- With reference to the recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (01) year from which the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became firm, it must be stated that it is not observed that in the present case the assumptions that could configure a recidivism of the infractions matter of this resolution are present;
- As for the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it must be mentioned that the members of the Supervisory Committee of the Fund are aware of the norms that oblige them to present an annual report on their management to the Ordinary General Assembly; however, they did not comply with said obligation;
- It should be indicated that the economic and financial situation and administrative problems that the managing company was going through, and that according to the defenses, directly affected the economic viability of the Fund; implied a demand and a duty of greater diligence to all the members of the Supervisory Committee that would lead them to fully comply with all their obligations and responsibilities;
- The non-presentation of the Annual Report on the Management of the Supervisory Committee does not allow evidencing the management carried out by the referred committee with the objective of protecting the interests of the participants. The annual management report constitutes a unique and objective document from which the participants and persons who could be linked to them are duly informed and can adopt investment and management decisions duly founded on a concrete basis; furthermore, as mentioned previously, to contribute to the SMV fulfilling its supervision and control activities, and therefore its objectives of protection to investors and market integrity;
- Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be mentioned that as part of the administrative sanctioning process, it is observed that the members of the Supervisory Committee adopted a set of measures that sought to safeguard the interests of the fund; it being necessary to consider that in the present case, the members of the Supervisory Committee have a link with each of the participants of the Fund. However, it must be specified that the role of the supervisory committee is a fiduciary one in which the members of this committee do not act in representation of the particular interests of the investor who elected them but rather their action must be carried out taking into account the general interest of the set of participants, regardless of whether any of these participants maintain their investments or decide to transfer them in the secondary market;
- On the other hand, it should be indicated that regarding the probability of the detection of the infraction, it should be noted that in the case analyzed it was possible to detect the infractions determined as a result of the supervision and control activities of the SMV regarding the compliance by the members of the Supervisory Committee of the Fund;
- Regarding the illegally obtained benefit, it has not been accredited in this procedure that Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario have obtained any benefit by incurring in the imputed infraction;
- In relation to the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, it must be specified that no intentionality has been evidenced in the conduct of Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario regarding the infraction matter of analysis;
- Likewise, as for the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infractions and the contribution of the offenders for their clarification, Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario, have acknowledged that they did not present the report matter of charge; however they consider that they have not committed infraction; from which it follows that they do not recognize the commission of the infraction imputed as a charge. On the other hand, it should be indicated that they have contributed to the clarification of the facts matter of charges through the presentation of the corresponding defenses;
- In addition to what is indicated in the preceding recitals, and in accordance with the provisions of article 236-A of the LPAG, it is not observed that in the present case any of the assumptions that constitute exempting conditions of responsibility have been configured
- In this regard, in relation to the evaluation of the exempting factors of responsibility established in article 236-A of the LPAG, it should be indicated that Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario did not correct the omission constituting infraction contained in the Charge Official Letter, before the notification of the latter;
- Likewise, in the present case it has not been evidenced that the infracting conduct by Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario has been generated by an error induced by the administration by an act or administrative provision, confusing and illegal;
- Consequently, Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario have incurred in one (01) infraction qualified as serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, for which in application of article 16 of the Sanctions Regulation it would correspond to sanction each of them with a sanction corresponding to infractions qualified as serious;
- However, considering the analysis carried out regarding the sanction criteria contemplated both in the LMV and in the Sanctions Regulation, such as that the members of the Supervisory Committee were direct representatives of each of the participants of the fund, the circumstances that surrounded the commission of the infraction, that the Supervisory Committee convened the Extraordinary Assembly of Participants to adopt agreements referred to the liquidation of the fund, and in application of the Principle of Reasonableness contemplated in numeral 3 of article 230 of the LPAG, which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance qualified as infraction, as well as the provisions of the third paragraph of article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, it corresponds to impose on Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario a sanction applicable to minor infractions according to article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation, corresponding to each of them the application of a warning sanction;
- In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendment.
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by not having complied with presenting to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fondo Latam Perú the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014.
- Declare that Mr. Emilio Llosa Seminario has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by not having complied with presenting to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fondo Latam Perú the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014.
- Declare that Mrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by not having complied with presenting to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fondo Latam Perú the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014.
- Declare that Mr. Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza has incurred in one (01) infraction of a serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, item 2.19 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, by not having complied with presenting to the Ordinary General Assembly of Participants of the Fondo Latam Perú the Annual Report on its management corresponding to fiscal year 2014.
- Sanction Mr. Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante with a fine of 1 UIT equivalent to S/ 3,850.00 (Three thousand eight hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 1 of this resolution.
- Sanction Mr. Emilio Llosa Seminario with a fine of 1 UIT equivalent to S/ 3,850.00 (Three thousand eight hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 2 of this resolution.
- Sanction Mrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo with a fine of 1 UIT equivalent to S/ 3,850.00 (Three thousand eight hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 3 of this resolution.
- Sanction Mr. Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza with a fine of 1 UIT equivalent to S/ 3,850.00 (Three thousand eight hundred fifty and 00/100 Soles) for the provisions of article 4 of this resolution.
- According to article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms, the offender to whom the sanction of fine has been imposed for the commission of very serious, serious or minor infractions may request from the Administration Office a reduction of the amount to be paid, provided that it accredits the fulfillment in a prior and joint manner of the requirements indicated in the referred article.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision through the filing of the reconsideration or appeal resource, presented before the same, within the term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the case that this resolution is not subject to challenge through reconsideration or appeal resource within the term of fifteen (15) business days of notification and becomes firm, it must be published in the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on publicity of normative projects, legal norms of general character and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 10-A of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amending norms.
- Transcribe this resolution to Messrs. Silvia Jennifer Dávila Oviedo, Víctor Mauricio Pinto Morante, Luis Ernesto Vargas Loayza and Emilio Llosa Seminario.
Register, communicate and publish
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
"Article 121.- Simplified Regime
(...)
Articles 70 and 72 of Chapter II, as well as Chapters III, IV, VI and VII of Title III of the Regulation shall be of supplementary application for Funds registered under the Simplified Regime when no different provisions have been established in the Participation Regulation. In the case of Chapter IV, the supplementary application must be subject to the provisions of article 27 of the Law." ↑
-
"From the wide range of antijuridical behaviors that occur in reality, the legislator selects according to the principle of minimum intervention those most intolerable and most harmful to the most important legal goods and threatens them with a penalty, describing them in the factual assumption of a penal norm, thus fulfilling, in addition, the requirements of the principle of legality or legalized intervention." (Francisco Muñoz Conde, General Theory of Crime, Second Edition, page 31). ↑
-
"This does not mean that the legislator has to describe with all exactitude and even its most intimate details the behaviors that it considers should be punished as a crime. That would suppose an exasperation of the principle of legality that, taken to its ultimate consequences, would lead to an overwhelming casuistry that, in any case, would always leave some factual assumption outside the legal description." (Francisco Muñoz Conde, General Theory of Crime, Second Edition, pages 31 and 32) ↑