Enforcement · SMV · 26 Apr 2021
The Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision rejects the reconsideration appeal filed by Futura Consorcio Inmobiliario S.A. and upholds the fine of 3.06 UIT (S/ 12,393.00) imposed for providing incomplete information in the material event of 15 September 2017 concerning the spin-off approved by its controlling shareholder. The resolution reclassifies the appellant's filing as a reconsideration appeal, finds no violation of the principles of presumption of lawfulness, material truth, causality or reasonableness, and confirms the infringement under item 3.1 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulations.
No. 036-2021-SMV/11
Lima, 26 April 2021
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Futura Consorcio Inmobiliario S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 031-2020-SMV/11 is resolved
| Administered entity | : | FUTURA CONSORCIO INMOBILIARIO S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2019018780 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2019018780 and Report No. 894-2020-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report) issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
“Sanctions are imposed in first instance by the Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision and the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision, each within their scope of competence. (…)”;
“To impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infringements on timeliness in the presentation of periodic and eventual information, whose compliance control corresponds to the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision.”;
On this, the Issuer insists that neither the information relating to the assets that would be in the patrimonial blocks that each new company would receive, nor the information relating to the book value of said patrimonial blocks, were determined on the date on which the omission was incurred.
Proof of this is that the disclosure of the missing information on 12 October 2017 had no impact on the quotation or price of the Issuer's traded securities. The price of its securities maintained the same trend before and after said disclosure, for all its securities.
Likewise, regarding the omission to specify the name of the company that would be at the head of the Issuer's economic group, it states that said information was included in the material event, being obvious to anyone that it would be Breca Inmobiliaria, since its own corporate name carries the description of said line of business. In this regard, it indicates that notorious facts do not require proof, and this is even expressly recognized in article 176 of the TUO of the LPAG.
The Issuer adds that the list of the patrimonial value of the Block would only be definitive at the time of granting the respective minutes, so Breca would have done wrong to inform them about it, for purposes of its disclosure to the market, when the final result could be different;
In relation to the fact that in the present case the capacity for significant influence of the material event subject to charges has not been founded and there is not sufficient evidence, it corresponds to reiterate what is indicated in recital 48, numeral ii) of the Challenged Resolution, which states the following:
“(…)
(ii) The Issuer affirms that it has not been supported why the missing information would constitute a material event. In this regard, it is worth reiterating what was analyzed in the evaluation of the defenses, when referring to the information on the transfer of the patrimonial block, that said information was necessary to have a complete understanding of the spin-off approved on 15 September 2017, and therefore it should also be reported in the material event. Indeed, it was necessary to know the effects that said transfer would have on the Issuer, since it would inform the investor of the possible impact on its financial situation taking into consideration the solvency (in relation to assets and liabilities) of its controlling shareholder. In that sense, we reiterate that in the material event communicated on 15 September 2017, the patrimonial block that would be transferred to the beneficiary company should have been detailed, as it is relevant information for the investor.”
The Issuer in its challenging document has stated that the change of its controlling shareholder does not constitute a material event, as it is part of its economic group.
In this regard, it should be taken into consideration that Breca has “divided” into nine (09) patrimonial blocks, distributed among several companies, one of them being Breca Inmobiliaria, which currently holds control of the Issuer; however, the patrimony it manages is different from that of its former controller, the perception of the management of the business and its finances from the perspective of a reasonable investor may be different, as well as the possible results of its financial statements; all that information and that reasoning of probabilities is taken into account by the reasonable investor and does affect its investment decisions. It should be noted that said argument has also been set forth in numeral (ii) of ground 48 of the Challenged Resolution.
Likewise, there are many variables to take into consideration in a corporate restructuring, which can alter a company's capital structure, its productive capacity, its financial structure, among others. On this, Professor Juan Mascareñas has described various causes that motivate a spin-off or corporate restructuring, for example (i) strategic realignment, that is when the company considers whether its businesses adjust to market demands, (ii) informative effect, thus the transfer of assets via spin-off sends a message to investors regarding the investment strategy; said act can be interpreted as a favorable change in the company's investment strategy or in its operating efficiency. But, otherwise, it could also generate a loss of value, (iii) transfer of wealth, (iv) capital market, where a business conglomerate divides for better management of the capital market, (v) tax reasons, (vi) among others[4].
As we see, the reasons for a corporate spin-off are diverse, and therefore can have diverse results in the company, which obliges the necessary information to be provided to investors, who, based on the circumstances of the spin-off, the value of the transferred assets and the current reality, will generate their own judgment regarding their securities.
In relation to the argument that the material event subject to charges had no effect on the market, it should be indicated that it is not decisive for measuring the significant influence of a material event whether or not there was a fluctuation in the securities, since the materiality of an act does not require a concrete result that implies the fluctuation of a security, but rather that it “has the capacity” to influence the “sale, purchase or retention”. Said evaluation has been carried out in recitals 40 and 41 of the Challenged Resolution, which states the following:
“(…)
In that line, in accordance with what was developed above, it is concluded that regarding the change of the Issuer's controlling shareholder and the patrimonial block that the former would receive, they do qualify as material events as they are material, being able to generate impact on investors, for which they would be within the assumption referred to in article 3 of the Regulations on Material Events; consequently, the principle of lawfulness has been respected.
“(…) it should be reiterated that as has been set forth in the evaluation of the defenses, the Issuer has failed to comply with the securities market regulations by having disseminated incomplete information in the material event of 15 September 2017; information that was only known when the IGSC requested additional clarifications on said material event and on the spin-off agreement approved by the General Shareholders' Meeting of Breca, controlling shareholder of the Issuer.
Likewise, during this administrative procedure, actions have been carried out in the different administrative instances participating in this administrative sanctioning procedure to establish the veracity of the facts subject to the Charge Letter based on the evaluation and analysis of the information disseminated by the Issuer as material events, of the information contained in the defenses presented by the Issuer before the IGCC and of the allegations formulated before this Deputy Superintendency. From this, there are elements and facts that prove that the Issuer provided incomplete information in the material event of 15 September 2017 as has been set forth and analyzed in the evaluation of the defenses of this Resolution.” (Underlining added).
On the other hand, regarding causality, it is necessary to indicate that the sanctioned party is the one who actually committed the infringing conduct, since article 9 of the Regulations on Material Events provides that the Issuer (passive subject) is obliged to communicate the material event as soon as it becomes aware of it.
In that sense, in the present case it can be observed that there is causality between the imputed non-compliance and the passive subject of the infringement, this being the Issuer.
In this sense, such reasonableness has been developed in recitals 50 to 59 of the Challenged Resolution, which explained each of the scopes of the Sanction Criteria established in SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria), in force at the time of the events; consistent with the criteria for the graduation of the sanction established in numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and article 348 of the LMV, having calculated the amount of the sanction to be applied. Consequently, it is considered that the sanction imposed should not be modified.
"41. That, in this sense, regarding the "capacity to significantly influence the decision of a sensible investor to buy, sell or keep a security" as indicated in the referred article 3, it must be taken into consideration that an omitted fact is material if there is a probability that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important when making their investment decision;
44. That, in relation to the Issuer's argument that the book value of the patrimonial block of Breca Inmobiliaria does not qualify as a fact of importance, in a context in which there is no change of the control unit because it is a corporate reorganization within the same group, it should be noted that a "patrimonial block" is constituted by a set of assets, liabilities and business fund destined to the beneficiary company;
45. That, according to the foregoing, the information on the transfer of the patrimonial block is necessary to have a complete understanding of the spin-off approved on September 15, 2017, which includes knowing about the effects that said transfer would have on the Issuer, since it would inform the investor of the possible affectation to the financial situation of the Issuer taking into consideration the financial solvency (in relation to assets and liabilities) of its controlling shareholder. In this sense, in the material event communicated on September 15, 2017, the patrimonial block that would be transferred to the beneficiary company should have been detailed, which was later known with the registration in Public Registries;" (Highlight and underline added).
As indicated above, the material truth in the present case is evaluated taking into consideration the standard of a reasonable investor, which establishes that they are not professionals in the matter, although they have sufficient capacity to understand the meaning of their acts, they have certain knowledge and/or experience about market behavior and the rules that regulate it, they are sufficiently aware of the risk that this implies.
In this extreme, there is no affectation to the duty of proof, since the facts and their probability of affecting the market and their possible repercussion on reasonable investors have been analyzed in the Challenged Resolution.
Without prejudice to the foregoing, it should be reiterated that recitals 43 to 48 of the Challenged Resolution have explained the reasons why it was relevant for the Issuer to communicate in a complete manner the material event of September 15, 2017, subject of the charge; therefore, we consider that the argument of a lack of motivation is not admissible.
In this sense, having determined the administrative responsibility of the Issuer, the sanction was imposed in application of the Sanctions Regulation and the applicable Sanction Criteria, as established in Title V "Determination of the Sanction" of the Challenged Resolution. Therefore, there has been no abusive exercise of the sanctioning power granted to the SASCM, as the Issuer alleges.
On this, it is necessary to reiterate what is indicated in numeral (vii) of recital 48 of the Challenged Resolution, which states: "the argument put forward by the Issuer according to which it was obvious to anyone that the name of the company that would head the group of companies that, within its group, develops its line of business would be Breca Inmobiliaria is also unfounded; since, as already indicated in this Resolution in the part corresponding to the evaluation of the defenses, not all investors have legal knowledge to know that said corporate reorganization would not imply changes of control or fundamental reforms in the direction and ownership of the Issuer and the companies involved in the spin-off process of Breca".
It should be noted that in the present case it is not about proof of notorious facts, as provided in article 176 of the TUO of the LPAG, but about the disclosure of complete and timely information of a material event in the securities market.
On the other hand, it is reiterated that the variation in the price of the securities is not decisive insofar as the regulations on material events only mention the "possibility" of generating a fluctuation in the securities or in the investor's decision to buy, sell or keep a security. It should be noted that this foundation has already been developed in recital 41 of the Challenged Resolution.
Finally, it is important to highlight that the Issuer has a reasonable number of minority investors who require protection, which sharpens its duty of diligence and transparency regarding the information provided. In this regard, as can be seen from its Annual Report for the year 2017, the Issuer had 113 shareholders, holders of common shares and 225 investors, holders of investment shares.
Table No. 1: Shareholding composition of the Issuer
Source: Annual Report for the 2017 fiscal year
In this regard, said argument has already been evaluated in numeral (viii) of recital 48 of the Challenged Resolution, which establishes:
"(viii) Finally, regarding the statement that the patrimonial value of the spun-off block could not be known, it should be specified that subsection 3 of article 372 of the General Corporations Law indicates that the spin-off project must contain: "the explanation of the spin-off project, its main legal and economic aspects, the valuation criteria used..." (Underline added).
As a result, the Issuer cannot claim that it did not know the patrimonial value of the block that was going to be spun off, since this is data that must be presented at the time of communicating the spin-off project. Likewise, as set forth in the Report and in this Resolution, the Issuer had knowledge of the spin-off agreement on September 15, 2017, adopted by Breca, in accordance with the assumption of presumption of knowledge of a material event established in the referred numeral 9.2 of article 9 of the Material Events Regulation, which provides that: "It is presumed that an Issuer has knowledge of a material event referred to it when said event originates in its own organization or controlling shareholder; when it is communicated or informed of the occurrence of the event or it is an event that has been publicly disclosed or disseminated. Additionally, it is considered that an Issuer has knowledge of a material event referred to it that originates in the controlling entity of its economic group, when there are reasonable indications that its main officers have become aware of the event or if the Issuer could reasonably have known it." (Underline added)
Indeed, this presumption has not been rebutted by the Issuer, verifying that according to the Report, at the time of the commission of the infringement subject of the Statement of Charges, Breca was the controlling shareholder of the Issuer; additionally Alex Paul Gastón Fort Brescia, Rosa Augusta Brescia Cafferata Vda. de Fort, Fortunato Juan José Brescia Moreyra, Mario Augusto Miguel Brescia Moreyra and Pedro Manuel Juan Brescia Moreyra were directors of the Issuer during 2017 (Annual Report for the 2017 fiscal year) and directors of Breca (Registry Entry No. 12726447). Such facts reinforce that the Issuer had knowledge through its common directors with its controlling shareholder Breca about the spin-off agreement on September 15, 2017, adopted by said company. Likewise, it is pertinent to note that according to article 371 of the General Corporations Law, the board of directors approves, with the favorable vote of the absolute majority of its members, the text of the spin-off project.
From the foregoing, consequently, there are reasonable indications that the directors of the Issuer qualify as main officers who have become aware of the spin-off project and the spin-off agreement of the General Shareholders' Meeting of Breca, therefore this presumption is valid and has not been rebutted by the Issuer, who did become aware of all the agreements corresponding to the spin-off agreed by Breca on September 15, 2017."
Regarding the Issuer's argument about the content of the public deed granted on December 18, 2017 before Eduardo Laos de Lama, Notary of Lima, in the minutes of said meeting, the following was recorded:
"1.11 Empower Messrs. (a) Jaime Araoz Medanic, identified with National Identity Document No. 09340062, in the name and representation of Estratégica S.A.C., in its capacity as General Manager of the company, (b) Miguel Ángel Salmon Jacobs, identified with National Identity Document No. 08802548, and (c) Gianmarco Tagliarino Rondinelli, identified with National Identity Document No. 41553762; so that any of them, acting individually and with sole signature, can represent the company: (...)".
In this regard, as can be seen from the aforementioned Public Deed, it refers only to the representatives in charge of the formalization of the agreement and not to the assets and liabilities contained in the patrimonial blocks, determined in the Spin-off Project.
In no way can it be considered that the infringement for which it has been sanctioned consists of the untimely delivery of the information to which they are obligated; that is, extemporaneously. This is because the Issuer has not presented to the SMV the information that supposedly should have been included in the communication sent to the market as a material event. Said information was sent by another company of its economic group. Therefore, in no way can it be maintained that they sent the supposedly omitted information, but outside the established term. They simply did not send it, since they do not consider that it was appropriate to do so according to the legal system, for the reasons explained in the appeal of the Resolution.
Likewise, the Issuer states that it has not presented to the SMV the information that is alleged should have been presented, outside the established term. Said information has been obtained by the SMV itself from the Public Registries, in the case of information related to the assets that make up the different patrimonial blocks of the operation to which the communication sent by its company referred, and its value.
In this regard, the Report constitutes a non-binding opinion of the IGCC on the evaluation of the appeal filed by the Issuer against the Challenged Resolution that has been put to the consideration of the sanctioning body for it to evaluate and issue the corresponding pronouncement.
Likewise, the Report is not a procedural act that determines the impossibility of continuing the procedure or that produces defenselessness to the Issuer since this Report does not have the nature of being an act that exhausts the administrative route, which is exhausted once the resolution is issued by the SASCM. Similarly, with the issuance and notification of the Report, no defenselessness has been produced to the Issuer, to whom all its rights and guarantees of due procedure and the exercise of its right of defense have been respected throughout the present administrative sanctioning procedure.
In this framework, this extreme of the arguments presented by the Issuer cannot be admissible and lacks legal basis to be formulated in the present administrative sanctioning procedure, so they must be dismissed.
"The obligation to report a material event shall only be understood as fulfilled if the Issuer has observed the requirements established in this Regulation and in the corresponding technical specifications established by the SMV".
Taking this into account, the Issuer, having communicated the material fact that is the subject of the charges incompletely, would not have presented said information within the established deadline. As a consequence, it would have incurred an infraction that has only one (01) administrative instance, as indicated in the Sanctions Regulation in force at the time the events occurred, which states in its article 10-A the following:
"In the case of infractions for non-compliance with the rules on the timeliness for the submission of periodic or occasional information (...), the Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision and the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision shall act as the sole administrative instance, as applicable, exhausting the administrative remedy."
In sum, in the present case two (02) administrative instances do not apply, so the processing of the appeal filed by the Issuer as a reconsideration appeal is not erroneous, nor does it violate the rights of the administered party. On the contrary, the administration is obliged to correct those appeals that are filed incorrectly by the administered parties.
Finally, what the Issuer states is also incorrect, that it will be deprived of its right to have the Challenged Resolution reviewed by a higher instance. As mentioned in the previous paragraph, for this type of infraction only the reconsideration appeal is available. Furthermore, the Issuer could still challenge this procedure in the judicial venue through a contentious-administrative claim in accordance with the applicable regulations.
Furthermore, it should not be forgotten that there are many variables to take into consideration in a corporate restructuring, which can alter a company's capital structure, its productive capacity, its financial structure, among others.
Lastly, regarding the argument that the material fact that is the subject of the charges had no effect on the market, it must be reiterated that whether or not there was a fluctuation in the securities is not decisive for measuring the significant influence of a material fact, since the materiality of an act does not require a concrete result involving the fluctuation of a security, but rather that it has the capacity to influence the sale, purchase or retention.
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
Register, communicate and publish.
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision
Tax Unit – UIT (2017) corresponds to S/ 4,050, approved by S.D. No. 353-2016-EF ↑
"Article 10-A.- SANCTIONING BODIES
Sanctions are imposed in first instance by the Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision and the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision, each within their scope of competence.
In the case of infractions for non-compliance with the rules on the timeliness for the submission of periodic or occasional information, infractions of the rules on the protection of minority shareholders contained in the General Corporations Law, Law No. 26887, and infractions of the provisions of article 5 of Law No. 29720, the Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision and the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision shall act as the sole administrative instance, as applicable, exhausting the administrative remedy.
The resolutions issued in the first or sole administrative instance, once the administrative remedy has been exhausted, must be published on the SMV's Securities Market Portal. The resolutions must expressly mention the obligation to disseminate the administrative decision." (Underline added). ↑
"Article 223.- Error in qualification
The error in the qualification of the appeal by the appellant shall not be an obstacle to its processing as long as its true nature is deduced from the document." ↑
Mascareñas J. (2005). Mergers and Acquisitions of Companies. Madrid: Mc Graw Hill. P 233-235. ↑
"217.2 Only definitive acts that end the instance and procedural acts that determine the impossibility of continuing the procedure or produce defenselessness are challengeable. The contradiction to the remaining procedural acts must be alleged by the interested parties for their consideration in the act that ends the procedure and may be challenged with the administrative appeal that, if applicable, is filed against the definitive act." ↑
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“Sanctions Regulations, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulations)”
“Regulations on Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter ROF-SMV)”
“The reconsideration appeal filed by Futura Consorcio Inmobiliario S.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 031-2020-SMV/11 is resolved”
“Regulations on Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Regulations on Material Events)”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added