Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV
No. 123-2019-SMV/11
Summary: Reconsideration appeal filed by Casa Grande S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 075-2019-SMV/11 is resolved
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | CASA GRANDE S.A.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2019001232 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2019001232 and Report No. 882-2019-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report) issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Function and competence of the SASCM
- That administrative file No. 2019001232 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervisory function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSM), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulations approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulations), in force at the time of the events and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF, in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to resolve reconsideration appeals against the resolutions it issues;
- Facts
- That, by Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 075-2019-SMV/11 of June 18, 2019 (hereinafter, the Resolution), it was resolved to sanction Casa Grande S.A.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) with four (04) reprimands, for not having timely submitted: (i) the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, (ii) the Management Report regarding the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, (iii) the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, and (iv) the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2017.
- That, by brief presented on July 17, 2019, the Issuer filed a reconsideration appeal against the Resolution;
- That the arguments of the appeal filed have been evaluated in the Report, which has been submitted to the SASCM;
- That, as provided in article 18 of the Sanctions Regulations, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulations), through Official Letter No. 4091-2019-SMV/11, the Report was sent to the Issuer. In this regard, it is necessary to indicate that although said Official Letter was validly notified, the Issuer did not present arguments;
- Issue to be determined
- That it corresponds to determine whether or not it is appropriate to reconsider the sanction imposed in the Resolution;
- Analysis
- Of the Reconsideration Appeal
- That the reconsideration appeal was presented within the deadline established in article 218 of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (TUO of the LPAG); likewise, it has observed the provisions of articles 124, 219 and 221 of the TUO of the LPAG;
- That the Issuer in its reconsideration appeal stated the following:
- The Issuer maintains regarding the charge referring to the late submission of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, that these were indeed sent to the SMV through the MVNet portal by means of a material fact, in accordance with the rules of the matter. Thus, on the date established by the regulations of the matter (02/15/2018), it sent the Interim Financial Statements approved by its General Management (on the same date), in which the Statement of Financial Position, the Income Statement, the Statement of Changes in Equity, the Cash Flow Statement and the Statement of Comprehensive Income could be viewed. Likewise, the Management Discussion and Analysis, the Notes to the Interim Financial Statements and the XBRL Structured File were attached. This has been accredited with the Certificate of submission of the Material Fact, presented to the SMV on February 6, 2019 and which can be viewed on the SMV website.
- The Issuer adds that although there was a regularization on February 19, 2019, neither the Securities Market Law nor the Sanctions Regulations in force at the time of the events state that a regularization of information previously sent constitutes a late submission. Therefore, in the responses to Report No. 339-2019-SMV/11.2, it stated that in this procedure the SMV has violated the Principle of Typicality that informs administrative sanctioning procedures, since, according to numeral 4 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, only conducts expressly provided for in norms with the rank of law through their typification as such constitute administratively sanctionable infractions, without admitting extensive interpretation or analogy.
- Furthermore, the Issuer states that the SMV has transgressed the Principle of Typicality by resolving, in literal (i), numeral 4.2 of the challenged Resolution, that the rectification causes the final rectified version to be the version that should have been presented within the approval deadline, thus generating a lateness in the submission of the referred information, having made an analogical interpretation of the norm, which in fact creates a new infraction applied to the Issuer.
- Likewise, the Issuer states that, under the Principle of Typicality, only conducts expressly provided for in norms with the rank of law through their typification as such constitute administratively sanctionable infractions. The Issuer adds that when imposing sanctions, extensive or analogical interpretation is prohibited and the SMV, by sanctioning it for the commission of the imputed infraction, has applied the norm to a situation different from the factual assumption provided in it; that is, the SMV arbitrarily decided that the fact that occurred in reality (regularization) is typified in subsection 3.1 numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulations, referring to late submission, which is not in accordance with Law, since the submission of a regularization is not expressly sanctioned as an infraction in our current legislation.
- The Issuer adds that the principle of predictability or legitimate expectation established in numeral 1.15 of article IV of the Preliminary Title of the TUO of the LPAG has been violated, which states that the administrative authority submits to the current legal system and cannot act arbitrarily, so it cannot unreasonably and without motivation vary the interpretation of the applicable norms.
- Furthermore, the Issuer states that by sanctioning it for the late submission of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, approved on February 15, 2018, the Administration considers as an additional infraction the late submission of the Management Report presented together with said Financial Statements, despite the fact that in the Manual for the Preparation of Financial Information said Report is considered part of the financial information to be submitted; therefore, it considers that it is being sanctioned twice for the same fact; which is prohibited by article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG.
- Regarding the submission of the 2017 Annual Report and Annual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, the Issuer states that it is not true that it failed to comply with the deadlines established in the norms of the matter, since in the communication of the material fact (File No. 2018007593) regarding the call to the Shareholders' Meeting for the approval of said financial information, the Audited Financial Statements closed as of December 31, 2017 and the Annual Report for fiscal year 2017 were attached, so the SMV has not managed to disprove its statement regarding the timely submission of the Audited Annual Financial Statements for fiscal year 2017 and Annual Report for 2017.
- Likewise, the Issuer states that on March 22, 2018, the Shareholders' Meeting of the company approved the 2017 Annual Report and the Annual Audited Financial Statements for said fiscal year, and on said date the agreements reached by the Meeting were communicated through a Material Fact (File No. 2018011535), and the Financial Statements and Annual Report for fiscal year 2017 were not sent again because they were approved without modifications, it being necessary to specify that the MVNET system does not allow such submission when there are no modifications, since the boxes for sending said documents are deactivated.
- Furthermore, the Issuer adds that the SMV has not specified the norm that obliges the issuer to resend the Annual Report and Audited Financial Statements sent at the time of calling the Shareholders' Meeting, once they have been approved by the meeting without modifications. Therefore, it is not in accordance with Law that the sanction of reprimand has been imposed for an alleged commission of the infraction typified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulations, in force at the time of the events, referring to not timely providing financial information and annual report.
- Finally, the Issuer adds that the adjudicator, on page 07 of the challenged Resolution, states that it does not correspond to rule on its arguments set forth in the response brief to Report 339-2019-SMV/11.2, considering that the arguments indicated in the first response have been reiterated; which the Issuer considers not accurate, since in said brief additional arguments were raised that have not been evaluated in the corresponding instance; therefore, it requests that in this instance, the Administration rule on each of the arguments set forth in this procedure.
- Evaluation of the Reconsideration Appeal
- That, in relation to the arguments of the Issuer, we must state the following:
- Regarding the late submission of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017 and Management Report
- The Issuer has stated in its reconsideration appeal that the SMV has transgressed the Principle of Typicality by resolving, in literal (i), numeral 4.2 of the challenged Resolution, that the rectification causes the final rectified version to be the version that should have been presented within the approval deadline, thus generating a lateness in the submission of the referred information, having made an analogical interpretation of the norm, which in fact creates a new infraction applied to the Issuer. Likewise, the Issuer adds that the Principle of Predictability or Legitimate Expectation has been violated.
In this regard, it must be noted that in the Resolution no integration method such as analogy has been applied nor has the principle of typicality been violated, since in the present case there has been a late submission of financial information, as the Issuer only presented the correct financial information on February 19, 2018, that is, with 04 calendar days of delay, since said information was approved on February 15, 2018. The version of Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017 and Management Report that were presented on February 15, 2018 was an incorrect version that did not correspond to the economic-financial reality of the Issuer at that date, and therefore was not exact and sufficient information, so its submission cannot be considered timely.
-
- Indeed, considering the Issuer's arguments acceptable would be protecting a situation that eludes compliance with the purpose sought by the regulations of the matter, which is the protection of market transparency, since under such a scheme an issuer could present irrelevant information on the day it is obligated by the regulations and then regularize days later with the correct information. If this were so, for the obligated subjects it would be indifferent to comply or not with the obligation to present exact and sufficient information in a timely manner, and on the other hand, it would make no sense to maintain the regulatory scheme on the requirement of timely submission of information.
- Likewise, the principle of predictability and legitimate expectation is not violated, since according to what was previously stated, the arguments set forth in the Resolution are in accordance with law and there is no unreasonable and unmotivated interpretation of the applicable norms.
- On the other hand, the Issuer states that by sanctioning it for the late submission of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, approved on February 15, 2018, the Administration considers as an additional infraction the late submission of the Management Report presented together with said Financial Statements, despite the fact that in the Norms on Preparation and Presentation of Financial Statements and Annual Report by Entities Supervised by the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by SMV Resolution No. 016-2015-SMV/01 (Norms on Preparation and Presentation of FS) said Report is considered part of the financial information to be submitted; therefore, it considers that it is being sanctioned twice for the same fact; which is prohibited by article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG.
In this regard, it must be stated beforehand that according to numeral 11 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG, "Non bis in idem" is a principle that guarantees that the administered entity is not sanctioned successively or simultaneously for infractions in which (i) identity of subject, (ii) fact and (iii) foundation are identified.
In the present case there is an identity of subject and foundation, but not of fact, since two different conducts are sanctioned. One sanctionable conduct is the late submission of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017 and another very different one is the submission of the Management Report of the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017.
In this sense, what the Issuer states regarding both obligations fitting into the same conduct is not accurate, since the Norms on Preparation and Presentation of FS differentiate between the submission of Individual Interim Financial Statements (Article 4) and the submission of the Management Report (Article 2).
-
- Likewise, article 35 of the Financial Information Regulations, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 0103-1999-EF/94, states that the Management Report shows the financial evaluation and explains the main characteristics of the financial situation, financial performance and main uncertainties presented by the company. This Report comprises the Declaration of Responsibility and the Management Discussion and Analysis. Thus, it is clear that the Management Report is a document different from the Individual Interim Financial Statements, and therefore, it is evident that we are facing two different submission obligations.
- Regarding the late submission of the 2017 Annual Report, Annual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017 and the response brief referring to Report 339-2019-SMV/11.2
- In this extreme, the Issuer states in its responses that in the communication of the material fact (File No. 2018007593) regarding the call to the Shareholders' Meeting for the approval of said financial information, the Annual Audited Financial Statements closed as of December 31, 2017 and the Annual Report for fiscal year 2017 were attached.
Likewise, the Issuer adds that on March 22, 2018, the Shareholders' Meeting of the company approved the 2017 Annual Report and the Annual Audited Financial Statements for said fiscal year, and on said date the agreements reached by the Meeting were communicated through a Material Fact (File No. 2018011535), and the Financial Statements and Annual Report for fiscal year 2017 were not sent again because they were approved without modifications, it being necessary to specify that the MVNET system does not allow such submission when there are no modifications, since the boxes for sending said documents are deactivated. Furthermore, the Issuer states that the SMV has not specified the norm that obliges resending the Annual Report and Audited Financial Statements sent at the time of calling the Shareholders' Meeting.
- In this regard, it must be noted that according to articles 6 and 12 of the Norms on Preparation and Presentation of FS, the Audited Financial Statements and the Annual Report must be submitted to the SMV on the day they have been approved by the corresponding body, with the deadline for their approval and respective submission being March 31 of each year, so what the Issuer states regarding the SMV not having specified the norm that obliges resending the Annual Report and Audited Financial Statements sent at the time of calling the Shareholders' Meeting is not accurate.
- Likewise, the obligation to submit material facts, specifically regarding the call to the mandatory annual shareholders' meeting for the approval of financial information, where the Issuer is obligated to attach a copy of the annual audited financial information and annual report that will be submitted for approval, should not be confused with the obligation contained in articles 6 and 12 of the Norms on Preparation and Presentation of FS referred to above.
- The timely submission as a material fact of the Annual Report and Annual Audited Financial Statements at the time of calling the Shareholders' Meeting does not exempt from the obligation to submit said information on the day of its approval by the meeting, since the financial information that is of interest to the market and investors is the information approved by the general shareholders' meeting of the Issuer. Accepting the Issuer's conduct would be protecting a conduct that violates market transparency.
- On the other hand, it is not accurate to affirm that the MVNET system does not allow the submission of financial information when there are no modifications in relation to the information presented on the date of the call to the shareholders' meeting, since it is feasible in the MVNET system to send the information again.
- Finally, the Issuer requests that the response brief referring to Report 339-2019-SMV/11.2 presented on April 22, 2019 be evaluated. From the review of the referred brief, it is evident that the arguments outlined are the same as those presented in this reconsideration appeal and that have already been analyzed in the previous paragraphs.
- That, from what has been evaluated in the preceding recitals, it is concluded that the arguments presented by the Issuer in its reconsideration appeal do not justify revoking or varying the sanction imposed by the Resolution; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of article 43 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- Declare UNFOUNDED the reconsideration appeal filed by Casa Grande S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 075-2019-SMV/11, in accordance with the considerations set forth in this Resolution.
- Confirm Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 075-2019-SMV/11, which sanctions Casa Grande S.A.A. with four (04) reprimands, for not having timely submitted: (i) the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, (ii) the Management Report regarding the Individual Interim Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, (iii) the Individual Annual Audited Financial Statements as of December 31, 2017, and (iv) the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2017.
- Consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
- Transcribe this Resolution to Casa Grande S.A.A.; and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.A.
Register, communicate and publish,
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision