Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV
No. 129-2023-SMV/11
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Obras de Ingeniería S.A.C. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 015-2023-SMV/11 is declared partially founded
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | OBRAS DE INGENIERÍA S.A.C. |
| Matter | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2022022679 |
The Deputy Superintendent (e) for Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2022022679, which contains, among others, the reconsideration brief of March 15, 2023, filed by Obras de Ingeniería S.A.C. (hereinafter, Obras de Ingeniería) against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 015-2023-SMV/11 of February 21, 2023 (hereinafter, the Challenged Resolution) which resolved to sanction Obras de Ingeniería with a total fine of 15,697 UIT; and Report No. 1377-2023-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter, the Report), issued by the General Intendancy for Conduct Compliance (hereinafter, the IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision (hereinafter, the SASCM); as well as, having heard the oral report held by the representatives of Obras de Ingeniería on November 30, 2023;
CONSIDERING:
- FUNCTION AND COMPETENCE OF THE SASCM
- That administrative file No. 2022022679 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter, PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervision function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV, established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and in the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861, approved by Supreme Decree No. 020-2023-EF (hereinafter, TUO LMV)[1]; as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to resolve reconsideration appeals against the resolutions it issues;
- FACTS
- That, by means of the Resolution, it was resolved to sanction Obras de Ingeniería with a total fine of 15,697 UIT equivalent to S/ 70,203.00 (Seventy Thousand Two Hundred Three and 00/100 Soles), for having incurred eleven (11) infractions of a minor nature typified in subsection 3.1 numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation;
- That, by brief presented on March 15, 2023, Obras de Ingeniería stated that: "We request the Deputy Superintendent for Market Conduct Supervision to admit our appeal, elevate it to your hierarchical superior for resolution, the terms and forms established in the applicable norms";
- That, by Memorandum No. 1141-2023-SMV/11 of March 16, 2023, the SASCM informed the Superintendent of the Securities Market of the brief presented on March 15, 2023 by Obras de Ingeniería, in order to determine whether it should be processed as a reconsideration appeal or not, in accordance with applicable regulations;
- That, by Memorandum No. 1295-2023-SMV/06 of March 28, 2023 addressed to the Superintendent of the Securities Market, the Legal Advisory Office (hereinafter, OAJ) issued a legal opinion in the sense that "(…) the sanctioning procedure for infractions of the norms on timeliness for the remission of periodic or eventual information is of single instance. In that sense, (…) it corresponds to the SASCM to redirect ex officio the mentioned appeal brief and process it via reconsideration appeal (…)". This opinion was ratified by the Superintendent of the Securities Market by Memorandum No. 126-2023-SMV/02 of September 27, 2023, remitting the appeal to this SASCM for processing;
- That, by Memorandum No. 3991-2023-SMV/11 of September 29, 2023, the SASCM requested the IGCC to evaluate the brief presented on March 15, 2023 by Obras de Ingeniería, in accordance with the second paragraph of article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation[2], and other applicable provisions;
- That, by Official Letter No. 4467-2023-SMV/11 of September 29, 2023, the SASCM informed Obras de Ingeniería that its brief presented on March 15, 2023 should be redirected as a reconsideration appeal for the SASCM to resolve;
- That, the arguments of the reconsideration appeal filed by Obras de Ingeniería have been evaluated in the Report of October 16, 2023 by the IGCC; which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation[3], by Official Letter No. 4739-2023-SMV/11, notified on October 17, 2023, the Report was sent to Obras de Ingeniería, so that it could submit its arguments regarding it, within five (05) business days;
- That, by brief of October 26, 2023, Obras de Ingeniería stated that it was in agreement with what was proposed by the IGCC and requested to make use of the word, within the framework of the provisions of the fourth paragraph of article 18 of the Sanctions Regulation, in order to reiterate its arguments orally and have them considered for the issuance of the final resolution;
- That, by Official Letter No. 5249-2023-SMV/11 of November 20, 2023, the use of the word requested by Obras de Ingeniería was scheduled for November 30, 2023. At said hearing, the representatives of Obras de Ingeniería made use of the word before the representatives of the SMV, and the respective minutes were signed;
- ISSUES TO DETERMINE
- That, it corresponds to determine whether or not to reconsider what was resolved in the Challenged Resolution;
- ANALYSIS
- Of the reconsideration appeal
- That, first, it must be specified that the administrative sanctioning procedures related to the timeliness in the presentation of periodic and eventual information must be processed in single instance, that is, in charge of the SASCM, as indicated in article 43 of the ROF-SMV[4];
- That, in accordance with the provisions of article 218[5] of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444, General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG), the reconsideration appeal must be presented within the term of fifteen (15) peremptory days from notification of the challenged administrative act, and must comply with the requirements provided in articles 124, 219[6], 221[7] of the same Law;
- That, in the present case it is appreciated that the Resolution was notified on February 22, 2023 to Obras de Ingeniería, and the appeal was filed on March 15, 2023, that is, it was presented within the legal term established;
- That, it must be indicated that the other requirements for the filing of the reconsideration appeal, established by article 221 in concordance with article 124[8] of the TUO of the LPAG, have been verified and complied with; therefore, the evaluation of the present reconsideration appeal proceeds;
- That, Obras de Ingeniería stated in its reconsideration appeal, the following:
- Regarding the relevance of the sanction criteria, Obras de Ingeniería states that the SASCM has limited itself to pointing out the sanction criteria without explaining whether they affect the evaluation carried out for the determination of the imposed sanction, so it develops them as follows:
- Regarding the severity of the damage to the public interest and protected legal good, Obras de Ingeniería mentions that the Challenged Resolution determined that there is no evidence of severity of damage to the public interest but does not elaborate on that argument, so "it is not identified that it had been considered, sufficiently, to determine whether it corresponds to impose a fine sanction (…)".
In this regard, Obras de Ingeniería indicates that it corresponds not only to evaluate the severity of the damage but also whether said damage occurred or not, so, in summary, it refers that: (i) its securities (corporate bonds) were excluded from the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV) by General Intendancy Resolution SMV No. 088-2022-SMV/11.1 (hereinafter, Exclusion Resolution), and that (ii) "the Bondholders were correctly informed of the effects of the Simple Reorganization, the implementation of the AGR, the consequent extinction of the Bondholders' Syndicate and the termination of the functions of the Bondholders' Representative". In that context, Obras de Ingeniería adds that the imputed facts did not generate damage to the market, and that, therefore, the imposition of a fine sanction would not be proportional to the effects generated.
- Regarding the economic damage caused and its repercussion in the market, Obras de Ingeniería argues that its only investors in the public offering market were the bondholders, who were included in the preventive insolvency proceeding, so it requests to take into account that "it is not reasonable to impose the Fine considering that the facts subject to the administrative sanctioning procedure have not generated any economic damage or a repercussion to the securities market".
- Regarding the probability of detection of the imputed infractions, Obras de Ingeniería mentions that the qualification of detection of infractions and the incentive to commit them will always be inversely proportional, likewise, it specifies that within the framework of the preventive insolvency proceeding (hereinafter, PCP), "a new relationship was generated with the Bondholders where the information provided to them was in line with compliance with the PCP".
- Regarding the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the imputed infractions, Obras de Ingeniería asserts that "it could not benefit, under any circumstance, as a consequence of the commission of the facts that gave rise to the administrative sanctioning procedure".
- Regarding the circumstances of the commission of the imputed infractions, Obras de Ingeniería requests to reevaluate the circumstances of the infractions based on what was mentioned in the first criterion developed, since "It is not possible to affirm that the situation of OBRAINSA generated by the PCP is unrelated to the behavior of OBRAINSA in relation to compliance with its regulatory obligations in securities market matters, since the PCP modified the relationship of OBRAINSA with the Bondholders".
- Regarding the application of the criteria of reasonableness and proportionality, Obras de Ingeniería cites the principle of reasonableness and adds that the sanctions imposed on administered entities must be coherent with the true effects of the infracting conducts of the administered entities. Likewise, it indicates that from the principle of proportionality it is deduced that "at the moment of ordering sanctions or corrective measures, these must be determined using objective criteria that do not give rise to arbitrariness". In that sense, Obras de Ingeniería considers that the Resolution did not take into account the following:
- Whether the fine that is intended to be imposed, as a corrective or dissuasive measure, is the most adequate for said purposes, since, in the particular case of Obras de Ingeniería: (i) it has no corrective effect, since the facts imputed in the administrative sanctioning procedure cannot be reversed; and, (ii) it has no dissuasive effect since, to date, it does not have securities registered in the RPMV.
- The existence or not of a sanction that is equally suitable as the one intended to be imposed, and that is less burdensome for the infractor, being in this case the sanction of reprimand.
- Whether the fine intended to be imposed is directly and reasonably proportional to the damage generated by the infraction committed, since no damage would have been generated to the bondholders or to the securities market.
- Regarding the application of other mitigating conditions, Obras de Ingeniería indicates that, according to the TUO of the LPAG and article 26 of the Sanctions Regulation, the following constitute mitigating factors: (i) the contribution of the infractor to the establishment of the infraction and (ii) the correction made after its requirement or the beginning of the administrative sanctioning procedure. In this regard, Obras de Ingeniería considers that the Challenged Resolution did not adequately assess its behavior to clarify the circumstances that gave rise to the imputed facts, as well as its efforts to correct the non-compliances subject to analysis.
- Regarding the sanction of reprimand, Obras de Ingeniería affirms that it complies with the conditions indicated in numeral 43 of the Resolution, with the exception of numeral (i) referring to the affectation to transparency in the market being minimal, due to the delay greater than one (01) day; however, it states that the degree of affectation could not be measured based on the period of time, since "there has been no affectation to the transparency of the securities market as a consequence of the facts imputed to OBRAINSA. Therefore, the affectation to market transparency is not only minimal but nonexistent".
- Evaluation of the reconsideration appeal
- That, regarding the arguments of Obras de Ingeniería, the following must be stated:
- In attention to what was argued by Obras de Ingeniería, it must be specified that, throughout the present PAS, the commission of the infractions subject to analysis has been verified, which were in turn recognized by Obras de Ingeniería in its brief presented on June 16, 2022. This recognition of administrative responsibility was considered as a mitigating factor for the calculation of the imposition of the fine sanction imposed in article 2 of the Challenged Resolution; however, it was identified that by brief of March 29, 2022 (File No. 2022012637), Obras de Ingeniería requested the SMV the exclusion of the securities called "First Issue of the First Corporate Bond Program of Obras de Ingeniería S.A." (hereinafter, Corporate Bonds) from the RPMV and from the Securities Registry of the Lima Stock Exchange.
Regarding the request for exclusion of the corporate bonds presented by Obras de Ingeniería, by General Intendancy Resolution SMV No. 088-2022-SMV/11.1 of December 19, 2022, the following was resolved:
"Article 1.- Order the exclusion of the securities called «First Issue of the First Corporate Bond Program of Obras de Ingeniería S.A.» from the Public Registry of the Securities Market in charge of the Superintendency of the Securities Market – SMV.
Article 2.- Pronounce in favor of the exclusion of the securities indicated in the preceding article, from the Securities Registry of the Lima Stock Exchange.
(…)".;
- From the foregoing, although the eleven (11) non-compliances subject to analysis constitute minor infractions, it is important to highlight that Obras de Ingeniería ceased to be a company supervised by the SMV since March 29, 2022, so in the present Resolution it will be evaluated whether the imposition of a fine sanction: (i) complies with the purpose of special prevention and, (ii) whether it is directly proportional to the severity of the facts constituting said infractions, in accordance with the principle of reasonableness established in numeral 3 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG.
- Regarding whether the imposition of a fine sanction complies with the purpose of special prevention
On the matter, it must be stated that the imposition of sanctions on administered entities aims to generate a negative incentive, that is, it seeks to induce them to comply with the obligations legally conferred on them and, thus, discourage the violation of protected legal goods. In this order of ideas, the application of an administrative sanction has as its purpose special prevention, in which it is intended to punish the infractor to prevent a new similar action in the future and, general prevention, understood as a general preventive measure that alerts other subjects about the effects that non-compliance with their general obligations would have[9].
That being so, it is observed that the imposition of a fine sanction would not comply with the purpose of special prevention, since Obras de Ingeniería does not have securities registered in the RPMV, so it does not have the status of supervised by the SMV and could not commit a new similar infraction again as it is not obligated to comply with the norms related to the securities market.
- Regarding whether the imposition of a fine sanction is directly proportional to the severity of the facts constituting the infractions subject to analysis
It is necessary to indicate that, according to the Practical Guide on the administrative sanctioning procedure, approved by Directoral Resolution No. 002-2017-JUS/DGDOJ, the content of the principle of reasonableness "is directly linked to the principle of proportionality, that is, to the applicable adequacy between the severity of the fact constituting the infraction and the sanction applied".
Thus, although the non-compliances in the timely presentation of periodic and eventual information constitute a concrete violation of the transparency of the securities market, it is also true that the facts are of little significance or materiality, because the communication processes established in the bond issuance with the designation of the bondholders' representative were complied with and the bondholders were aware of the events that were developing. Likewise, it is worth mentioning that, in the insolvency process, there are also mechanisms for information and disclosure to participants, including the publication of a bulletin by the National Institute for the Defense of Competition and the Protection of Intellectual Property - INDECOPI. Furthermore, no complaint has been filed against Obras de Ingeniería indicating harm to the Bondholders.
Similarly, it should be noted that, before the exclusion of Obras de Ingeniería from the RPMV, 99.92% of the shareholding was concentrated in OB CONSTRUCTION S.A.C.
- That, according to what has been indicated, and from the evaluation carried out by this Deputy Superintendency, and considering that at the date on which Instruction Report No. 954-2022-SMV/11.2 was issued, where fine sanctions against Obras de Ingeniería are proposed, its securities were registered in the RPMV, currently being its securities excluded, it corresponds that, in accordance with the principle of reasonableness and the "Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Norms that regulate the Remission of Periodic or Eventual Information", approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 and its amendments, the reconsideration appeal filed by Obras de Ingeniería against the Challenged Resolution be declared partially founded in the extreme of the determination of the sanction for the commission of eleven (11) infractions committed; and, consequently, the fine sanctions imposed in the Challenged Resolution be varied, for reprimand sanctions, in accordance with the considerations set forth in the present Resolution, and that the reconsideration appeal be declared unfounded in the other extremes, in accordance with the considerations set forth in the Resolution;
- That, considering this, it corresponds to impose eleven (11) reprimands on Obras de Ingeniería for the eleven (11) infractions committed, which were determined in the Challenged Resolution; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 22 and 36 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- Declare PARTIALLY FOUNDED the reconsideration appeal filed by Obras de Ingeniería S.A.C. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 015-2023-SMV/11 of February 21, 2023 in the extreme of the determination of the sanction for the commission of eleven (11) infractions committed, in accordance with the considerations set forth in the present Resolution, and UNFOUNDED the reconsideration appeal in the other extremes, in accordance with the considerations set forth in the cited resolution.
- Modify Article 2 of Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 015-2023-SMV/11 in the extreme of the imposition of a total fine of 15,697 UIT equivalent to S/ 70,203.00 (Seventy Thousand Two Hundred Three and 00/100 Soles) and reforming it, it corresponds to impose as sanctions on Obras de Ingeniería S.A.C. eleven (11) reprimands for the commission of eleven (11) infractions of a minor nature typified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/0.
- Consider the administrative route exhausted.
- Transcribe the present Resolution to Obras de Ingeniería S.A.C.
Register, communicate and publish,
Carlos Rivero Zevallos
Deputy Superintendent (e)
Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision
-
By Supreme Decree No. 020-2023-EF, published on February 10, 2023 in the Official Gazette El Peruano, the Single Ordered Text of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861, was approved. ↑
-
"Article 18.- RECONSIDERATION AND APPEAL RESOURCE
(…)
If a reconsideration appeal is filed, the Deputy Superintendent notifies the administered entity of the report of the General Intendancy of Compliance that contains the opinion on the appeal filed, so that it formulates its allegations within a term no less than five (5) days, counted from the day following the mentioned notification.
(…)" ↑
-
«Article 18.- Reconsideration and appeal resource
The sanctioned party may file a reconsideration or appeal resource against the decision of the respective Deputy Superintendency, except in cases that are processed in single instance, where only a reconsideration appeal may be filed.
If a reconsideration appeal is filed, the Deputy Superintendent notifies the administered entity of the report of the General Intendancy of Compliance that contains the opinion on the appeal filed, so that it formulates its allegations within a term no less than five (5) days, counted from the day following the mentioned notification.
(…)» (Underline and emphasis added). ↑
-
«Article 43.- The specific functions of the Deputy Superintendency for Market Conduct Supervision are:
(…)
14. Impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness of the presentation of periodic and occasional information, whose compliance control corresponds to the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision;
(…)». ↑
5. «Article 218.- Administrative appeals
218.2 The term for the filing of appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days and they must be resolved within a period of thirty (30) days». ↑
6. «Article 219.- Reconsideration appeal
The reconsideration appeal shall be filed before the same body that issued the first act that is the subject of the challenge and must be supported by new evidence. In the case of administrative acts issued by bodies that constitute a single instance, new evidence is not required. This appeal is optional and its non-filing does not prevent the exercise of the appeal». ↑
7. «Article 221.- Requirements of the appeal
The written appeal must state the act being appealed and must comply with the other requirements set forth in Article 124». ↑
8. «Article 124.- Requirements of written submissions
Every written submission presented before any entity must contain the following:
1. Full names and surnames, domicile and National Identity Document number or foreigner's card of the administered party, and, where applicable, the capacity of representative and of the person represented.
2. The concrete expression of what is requested, the factual grounds supporting it and, when possible, the legal grounds.
3. Place, date, signature or digital fingerprint, in case of not knowing how to sign or being impeded.
4. The indication of the body, entity or authority to which it is addressed, understood as such, as far as possible, the authority closest in rank to the user, according to the hierarchy, with competence to hear and resolve it.
5. The address of the place where notifications of the procedure are to be received, when different from the real domicile stated under numeral 1. This designation of domicile takes effect from its indication and is presumed to subsist, as long as its change is not expressly communicated.
6. The list of documents and annexes accompanying it, indicated in the TUPA.
7. The identification of the file of the matter, in the case of procedures already initiated.» ↑
9. Board of Directors Resolution No. 10 of 2013 [Environmental Evaluation and Enforcement Agency – OEFA]. Guidelines for the application of corrective measures provided in literal d) of numeral 22.2 of article 22 of Law No. 29325 - Law of the national environmental evaluation and enforcement system. March 22, 2013. ↑