Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision SMV
No. 040-2021-SMV/10
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10 is declared unfounded
| | |
|---|
| Regulated entity | : | Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. |
| Subject | : | Reconsideration appeal against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10 |
| File No. | : | 2017033599 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
Administrative file No. 2017033599, Report No. 036-2019-SMV/10.3 issued by the General Intendancy for Prudential Compliance, as well as the reconsideration appeal filed by Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10; and
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name Comisión Nacional Supervisora de Empresas y Valores (CONASEV) is replaced by Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal provisions shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
Facts
- By Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10 of December 29, 2017 (hereinafter, the Resolution), Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. (hereinafter, BVL) was sanctioned with one (01) warning sanction and a fine of 3 UIT, for having incurred in two (02) minor infractions classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments, in force at the time the facts occurred (hereinafter, the Sanctions Regulation), for failing to submit material event information within the period established by the regulations, regarding the material event of December 31, 2014, through which they communicated the Resolution of the General Intendancy for Supervision of Entities No. 85-2014-SMV/10.2 (RIGSE), as well as the material event of March 15, 2016, regarding the amendment of the BVL's Bylaws as a consequence of the capital increase agreement;
- By brief filed on January 22, 2018, the BVL filed an appeal against the aforementioned resolution;
On the classification of the challenge filed
- The BVL filed a brief challenging the Resolution, which it classified as an appeal; however, it should be noted that Article 32, numeral 17[1] of the SMV's Organization and Functions Regulation, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF, establishes that in the case of imposition of sanctions for the commission of infractions of timeliness rules, as corresponds in the present case, the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision acts as the sole administrative instance;
- In this sense, pursuant to Article 84, numeral 3[2] of the Single Ordered Text of Law No. 27444 – General Administrative Procedure Law, approved by Supreme Decree No. 006-2017-JUS (hereinafter, the TUO of the LPAG), the challenge brief filed by the BVL must be considered as a reconsideration appeal;
On the arguments raised by the BVL
Regarding the material event referring to the RIGSE through which the SMV authorizes the BVL to carry out complementary securities clearing and settlement activities
- The BVL states that pursuant to Article 2 of the RIGSE, it was established as an obligation of the SMV to disseminate the resolution in the RIGSE on the SMV Portal. Notwithstanding this, the BVL argues that in compliance with the duty of transparency, it communicated the resolution by the SMV as a material event on January 7, 2015; even though the SMV itself had the express obligation to disseminate to the market the resolution it itself issued;
- On the other hand, the BVL notes that as indicated in the recitals of SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01, which approves the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information (hereinafter, the Material Events Regulation), the SMV has the purpose of ensuring the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through regulation, supervision and promotion; likewise, it is stated that legal entities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (RPMV) and the issuer of registered securities are obliged to submit the information that the aforementioned law and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of such information;
- In this context, the BVL states that the protection of investors and market transparency require that all information that may affect the securities registered in the securities market, as well as information related to the issuer, be published on the SMV Portal;
- Therefore, according to the BVL, since it is an obligation to ensure market transparency, it is necessary that, in general terms, the SMV itself timely and adequately disclose the information it produces and that may influence the quotation of the securities under its supervision. In this way, according to the BVL, the SMV will fulfill its own purpose, which is, among others, to ensure market efficiency;
- In this sense, the BVL states that having determined the purpose of publishing material events, it should be noted that Article 46 of the TUO of the LPAG provides that the Administration is prohibited from requesting from regulated persons the submission of information or documentation containing it, which the requesting entity generates or possesses as a product of the exercise of its public functions conferred by Law or which it must possess by virtue of any procedure previously carried out by the regulated person;
- In this way, the BVL states that the purpose of bringing to the market's knowledge the resolution by the SMV was fulfilled when the SMV itself published its own resolution on the SMV Portal, which is why the BVL was no longer obliged to communicate to the market through the SMV Portal information that the SMV itself generated and that by virtue of the administrative act itself (expressly declared) it was obliged to communicate;
- In this sense, the BVL states that in the event it failed to submit the material event, this has not caused economic harm to any investor, nor has it had any kind of repercussion in the market, nor has it caused harm to the public interest, nor has the protected legal interest been affected, precisely because it was the SMV's obligation to publish the resolution in the RIGSE;
- Therefore, the BVL considers that it has not incurred in a sanctionable infraction and in this sense, requests that the warning sanction imposed be left without effect;
Regarding the Material Event referring to the amendment of the BVL's Bylaws agreed at the Mandatory Annual General Meeting of Shareholders of 03.15.16
- In this regard, the BVL declares that the Resolution ignores the efforts made by the BVL on March 15, 2016, the same day of the Mandatory Annual General Meeting of Shareholders (hereinafter, the Meeting), in order to communicate the aforementioned material event through the structured formats of MVNet. Whereas, according to the BVL, faced with different attempts to communicate to the SMV the material events through the structured formats of MVNet administered by the SMV itself; the BVL, after having made the pertinent telephone inquiries to the SMV's technical area, at 9:23 pm on March 15, 2016 informed as a material event, through letter GCSC-037/2016[3] (hereinafter, the Letter), all the agreements adopted by the Meeting, which corresponded to the agenda or motions previously informed on 03.01.16;
- In this sense, the BVL states that it communicated to the market the information related to the capital increase, such as: Type of capital variation, concept of modification, type of security, period, currency, amount of increase, new amount in the account, for both Class A shares and Class B shares;
- Likewise, the BVL states that on March 16, 2016 it communicated as a material event, through the SMV's structured format, all the agreements it had already informed through letter GCSC-037/2016[4], only that it was done through the SMV's structured format. On the same date, a clarification of material event was communicated indicating the number of bonus shares generated by the capital increase approved by the Meeting[5]. That is, the BVL states that it complied with informing as a material event all the agreements adopted at the Meeting, including those referring to the amendment of the Bylaws;
- Additionally, the BVL indicates that it had problems sending the material events through the structured formats of MVNet. As a consequence, Mr. Tulio Freire, who at that time held the position of Central Corporate Manager and was the BVL's Stock Exchange Representative, sent an email to Mr. José Espinoza of the SMV informing about the matter. The BVL adds that the telephone records of the SMV show the calls made by the BVL to the SMV on March 15, 2016 during the night, so that the SMV could guide it to communicate its material events;
- Notwithstanding this, which according to the BVL demonstrates compliance with the submission of material events through a letter (given the aforementioned technical impossibility) and subsequently through the structured formats, the SMV considers that the material event under evaluation was submitted on May 12, 2016 and not on March 15 or 16, 2016;
- Likewise, the BVL states that the SMV maintains that pursuant to Article 7, numeral 3 of the Material Events Regulation, the obligation to report a material event shall only be understood as fulfilled if the issuer has observed not only the corresponding technical specifications, but also the requirements established in the aforementioned regulation, from which the integral application of the provisions established therein follows;
- In this sense, the BVL states that, despite having demonstrated that there were indeed technical difficulties attributable to the MVNet system administered by the SMV, the SMV itself attributes such difficulties and maintains that the BVL has not accredited that it had technical problems in the MVNet System for sending the material event under evaluation through structured formats due to a fact attributable to the SMV, but on the contrary this would have been due to facts attributable to the BVL;
- In this way, the BVL indicates that the SMV prioritizes compliance with formal requirements, despite the fact that it made all possible efforts to communicate the material events on the same day the agreements were adopted. It also states that for the BVL it did not mean any advantage, or there was any reason to submit the material events through a letter, if the MVNet was available for use;
- Likewise, it states that communicating the material events through the letter of March 15, 2016 had as its main purpose to timely and adequately communicate to the market the information related to the capital increase adopted, as well as other agreements that may influence the quotation of the securities issued by the BVL; and to comply, despite the technical inconveniences, with the regulations on the communication of material events;
- The BVL adds that sending the letter was the last resort given the impossibility of using the MVNet, however for the SMV, disregarding the principle of informality, only compliance with formal obligations prevails, which moreover depended on the suitability of a technical support that is administered by the SMV itself;
- In this way, the BVL refers to what was resolved by the Constitutional Court[6] in reiterated Jurisprudence: *"For its part, the General Administrative Procedure Law provides among the principles of its norm IV, precisely, that 'Administrative authorities must act with respect to the Constitution, the law and the right, within the powers attributed to them and in accordance with the purposes for which they were conferred'. Likewise, it establishes, within the framework of the principle of informality, that 'Procedural rules must be interpreted in a manner favorable to the admission and final decision of the claims of the regulated persons, so that their rights and interests are not affected by the requirement of formal aspects that can be remedied within the procedure, provided that such excuse does not affect the rights of third parties or the public interest'. It is also indicated that 'The procedures established by the administrative authority must be simple, and all unnecessary complexity must be eliminated; that is, the requirements demanded must be rational and proportional to the purposes sought to be fulfilled';";
- Likewise, the BVL indicates that the principle of informality has been recognized in Article IV of the TUO of the LPAG[7] on the principles of the administrative procedure; regarding which it states that Morón Urbina comments that: *"(...) The principle allows the regulated person to achieve the admission of their requests, the recognition of the alleged facts and achieve the success of their claims by saving through various techniques their omission incurred in formal aspects not addressed at a moment. The essential effect of the principle is to give responsibility to the instructing authorities to temper or weaken the rigorism of any adjective requirement that does not affect the public interest, to favor the regulated person in the progress of the procedure. (...) By application of this same principle, it should also be understood that any doubt that arises in the course of the procedure regarding formal requirements (computation of deadlines, legitimacy, decision on whether or not the act is final, classification of appeals, existence or not of legitimacy in the regulated person, the opportunity for submission of a document, suitability of the addressee of a request, exhaustion or not of the administrative route, etc.) must be interpreted with leniency in favor of the regulated person and favoring the viability of their procedural act";
- In this context, the BVL reiterates that it tried by all means to timely communicate the material events, which occurred on March 15, 2016 itself through the sending of a letter, in order to comply with its obligation to communicate the material events, however, for the SMV compliance with formal obligations prevails;
- Despite this, the BVL states that the SMV considers that the obligation to submit the material events has not been fulfilled on March 15, 2016, the date of submission of the letter communicating the material events, but on May 12, 2016, when it was remedied by submitting everything provided for in the regulatory norm;
- In this regard, the BVL notes that remediation has been recognized in Article 134, numerals 1 and 2 of the TUO of the LPAG, referring to observations on documentation submitted[8]; likewise, the BVL states that it is important to refer to the provisions of Article 135, numeral 1 of the TUO of the LPAG, which provides that: "135.1 Once the brief has been entered or the remediation duly made, it is considered received from the initial document, unless the procedure confers registration priority or it is a trilateral procedure, in which case the submission operates from the remediation (...)";
- Furthermore, the BVL specifies that Morón Urbina comments regarding the aforementioned provision that: "On the validity of the remediation act it is important to highlight that it is not an extension of the original deadline, because in truth it is not a new act, nor a renewal of the original act; on the contrary, it is a perfection of the original act that is already deemed submitted. Indeed, the appeal or brief by way of remediation is already entered on the date of its submission only subject to a subsequent condition: its perfection in the terms that the administration requires, under penalty of being deemed not submitted. In this sense, the remediation produces effects from the initial moment and not a posteriori, since in truth it is not a new submission of a document but the correction of an entered document, but due to deficiencies in the authority's criteria it is subject to remediation";
- In this sense, it mentions that in the face of an apparent conflict between the provisions of the TUO of the LPAG and the norm contemplated in Article 7, numeral 3 of the Material Events Regulation, the Law prevails over that approved by the SMV, in application of the principle of hierarchy of the body that issues the norm;
- Finally, the BVL states that according to its arguments, the SMV must consider the obligation to communicate the material events fulfilled on March 15, 2016, and not on the date on which some omissions to what was communicated were remedied. In this sense, the BVL, without intending to disregard the norms to which it is subject and the SMV's sanctioning power, considers that it is necessary for the hierarchical superior to analyze all the extremes of this appeal and evaluate each of the arguments expressed by the Administration itself in the Resolution and finally determine that they have not incurred in an infraction susceptible of being sanctioned;
Evaluation of the arguments presented by the BVL
Regarding the material event referring to the RIGSE through which the SMV authorizes the BVL to carry out complementary securities clearing and settlement activities
- With regard to the arguments expressed by the BVL, it should be noted that within the administrative sanctioning procedure the BVL acknowledged the commission of the infraction; notwithstanding this, in the challenge appeal it states that it did not incur in a sanctionable infraction;
- Without prejudice to the contradiction indicated in the previous recital and as also referred to in the recitals of SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01, which approves the Material Events Regulation, Article 13 of the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 and its amendments (hereinafter, LMV), legal entities registered in the RPMV are obliged to submit the information that the aforementioned law and other general provisions establish, being responsible for the veracity of such information;
- In this context, pursuant to Article 1 of the Material Events Regulation, said regulation has the purpose of establishing the regime for communication and disclosure of material events and reserved information that obliged persons must observe in accordance with the LMV and its regulatory norms, in order to protect investors and promote efficient and transparent markets. It has established, among others, what constitutes a material event, as well as the criteria to determine the capacity for significant influence of information by the issuer;
- In this sense, it should be noted that the classification of the material event made by the BVL presupposes a prior evaluation by it regarding the influence that such information may cause on a sensible investor and therefore the obligation to inform the market within the period established in the Material Events Regulation;
- Thus, the provisions of Article 2 of the RIGSE on the dissemination of said resolution on the SMV Portal do not exempt the regulated person from complying with its obligations established by the LMV and the Material Events Regulation; therefore, the regulated person is obliged to communicate every material event that by its nature has the transcendence and significant influence on the investor's decision and the liquidity, price or quotation of the issued securities, as provided in Articles 3 and 4 of the aforementioned regulation;
- Consequently, the BVL should have communicated the material event referring to the RIGSE as soon as it became aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it was known; thus the BVL should have complied with communicating the material event referring to the RIGSE on January 5, 2015; notwithstanding this, it was communicated on January 7, 2015, that is, two (02) days late, as indicated in the Resolution;
- Likewise, with regard to the argument expressed by the BVL, referring to the fact that according to Article 46 of Chapter I of Title II, On administrative procedure, of the TUO of the LPAG, the Administration is prohibited from requesting from regulated persons the submission of information or documentation that the entity possesses as a product of the exercise of its functions, it should be specified that the aforementioned article establishes that said provision is applicable to the initiation, continuation or conclusion of an administrative procedure; which does not occur in this case, since as specified it is an obligation that must be fulfilled by issuers, in accordance with the provisions established in the Material Events Regulation;
- In this sense, regardless of whether the SMV provides for the publication of its resolutions, this does not replace the duty of issuers and in this case of the BVL, to comply with communicating material events in accordance with the legal framework established for the fulfillment of said obligation;
- Finally, it should be noted that the arguments referring to economic harm, repercussion in the market, harm to the public interest and affectation of the protected legal interest have been evaluated in the Resolution, specifically in recitals 58 to 67, as well as in recitals 73 and 74, which determined the imposition of the minimum sanction for the infraction committed. Therefore, a new evaluation in this regard is not appropriate;
- Consequently, it should be specified that in the Resolution an evaluation of all the arguments presented in the defenses has been carried out, as well as the corresponding assessment of the sanction criteria, imposing a warning sanction since the conditions were met, as referred to in recital 75 of the Resolution;
Regarding the Material Event referring to the amendment of the BVL's Bylaws agreed at the Mandatory Annual General Meeting of Shareholders of 03.15.16
- Regarding the arguments made by the BVL, it must be specified that this is a reiteration of the defenses presented at the time, which have already been evaluated in the Resolution, specifically in considerations 38 to 51 of the aforementioned resolution;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, it should be reiterated that pursuant to Article 7, numerals 2 and 3, the obligation to report Material Facts shall only be deemed fulfilled if not only the corresponding technical specifications established by the SMV (Technical Specifications) have been observed, but also the requirements established in the Regulation on Material Facts, from which arises the obligation to fully comply with the provisions governing the submission of material facts;
- Likewise, as also stated in the Resolution, according to Article 27 of the Regulation of the MVNET and SMV Virtual System, approved by SMV Resolution No. 010-2013-SMV/01 (hereinafter, MVNet System Regulation), in the event of technical problems in the use of the MVNet system for sending information in accordance with the obligations established in the applicable regulations, the supervised entities must report such aspects to the Information Technology Office (OTI) with due support, and this must be done on the same day the events occurred so as not to incur non-compliance, which according to what was evaluated in considerations 42 and 43 of the Resolution was not proven by the BVL;
- It should be noted that, as indicated in consideration 44 of the Resolution, the problems they had with the MVNET System originated from an omission in checking the agenda item option referring to: "Amendment of Bylaws due to Variation of Capital Stock, Equity and/or Investment Shares Account", which is why the corresponding structured file (format) was not enabled in the MVNet system at the time the agreements were communicated;
- In this sense, as specified in consideration 45 of the Resolution, the inconveniences in the submission of the material fact referring to the amendment of the BVL's Bylaws, as a consequence of the capital increase agreement, through structured formats were due to facts attributable to the BVL, since they would not have complied with all the requirements for the communication of the calls, established in the Technical Specifications, as well as the MVNet System User Manual published on the SMV Portal;
- Accordingly, as concluded in consideration 47 of the Resolution, the BVL did not prove that on the date of submission of the material fact referring to the amendment of the BVL's bylaws, as a consequence of the capital increase, there were technical difficulties in the MVnet System that caused the untimely submission of the aforementioned material fact in accordance with the requirements established in the Regulation on Material Facts, but on the contrary, this was due to facts attributable to the BVL;
- Likewise, regarding the fact that the BVL reported as a Material Fact, through the Letter, all the agreements adopted by the Board and that in that sense, it communicated to the market the information related to the capital increase, it should be noted that as can be seen in the evaluation carried out in considerations 48 to 50 of the Resolution, through the aforementioned Letter the BVL did not report the capitalization period, the percentage of free shares, as well as the rights that said shares would have, information that corresponds to the material fact under evaluation; in such a way that notwithstanding the non-observance of the structured formats according to the technical specifications, with the Letter, the BVL did not comply with communicating the material fact in accordance with the provisions of numeral 2.3, literal a) of the Annex of the Regulation on Material Facts;
- With regard to the arguments referring to the principle of informality[9]; it must be specified that the principle, applicable within an administrative procedure, consists in exempting the administered from complying with non-essential forms, that is, those that are not required by administrative public order, in such a way that said principle is not applicable to the present case, since the untimely submission of material facts refers to compliance with an obligation arising from the provisions of the applicable regulations and in which the requirements for its submission have been established and which are applicable to all subjects obliged to submit said information;
- Likewise, regarding the arguments related to the correction of the documentation presented, according to the provisions of Articles 134 and 135 of the TUO of the LPAG; it should be indicated that material facts are not related to the initiation of an administrative procedure of prior evaluation or automatic approval, it is about compliance with the obligations set forth by the regulatory body in accordance with the powers granted to it, and which must be complied with in accordance with the forms and deadlines established and which, as stated, is applicable to all those obliged to communicate the corresponding material facts to the market;
- For the foregoing, it is concluded that the arguments contained in the reconsideration appeal filed by the BVL have not disproved the grounds developed in the Resolution, which served as the basis for the imposition of the sanction applied to the BVL, so it is appropriate to declare the reconsideration appeal unfounded;
- In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 27, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
IT IS RESOLVED:
- To declare unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.A. against the Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10.
- To declare that the administrative remedy has been exhausted as the Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 130-2017-SMV/10 has become final.
- This resolution shall be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of Article 14 of the Regulation of Sanctions, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- To transcribe this resolution to the Bolsa de Valores de Lima S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
"17. Impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness in the submission of periodic and eventual information, whose compliance control corresponds to the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision." ↑
-
"Article 84. Duties of the authorities in the procedures
(…)
3. To direct the procedure ex officio, when it notices any error or omission of the administered, without prejudice to the action that corresponds to them." ↑
-
File No. 2016010608. ↑
-
File No. 2016010608. ↑
-
File No. 2016010751. ↑
-
Judgment of the Constitutional Court in file No. 03908-2010-PA/TC. ↑
-
"Article IV. Principles of the administrative procedure
The administrative procedure is fundamentally based on the following principles, without prejudice to the validity of other general principles of Administrative Law:
1.6 Principle of Informality.- The rules of procedure must be interpreted in a manner favorable to the admission and final decision of the claims of the administered, so that their rights and interests are not affected by the requirement of formal aspects that can be corrected within the procedure, provided that such excuse does not affect the rights of third parties or the public interest.
(…)". ↑
-
"Article 134.- Observations to documentation presented
134.1 All forms or writings presented must be received, notwithstanding non-compliance with the requirements established in this Law, that are not accompanied by the corresponding documents or are affected by another defect or formal omission provided in the TUPA, that merits correction. In a single act and only once, the reception unit at the time of its presentation makes the observations for non-compliance with requirements that cannot be saved ex officio, inviting the administered to correct them within a maximum period of two business days.
134.2. The observation must be noted under the signature of the receiver on the application and on the copy that the administered will keep, with the respective allegations if any, indicating that, if not done, their request will be deemed not presented.
(…)". ↑
-
"Article IV.- Principles of the administrative procedure
(…)
-
- Principle of informality.- The rules of procedure must be interpreted in a manner favorable to the admission and final decision of the claims of the administered, so that their rights and interests are not affected by the requirement of formal aspects that can be corrected within the procedure, provided that such excuse does not affect the rights of third parties or the public interest.
(…)". ↑