SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 50-2019-SMV/10
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 020-2018-SMV/10 is declared unfounded.
| | |
|---|
| Administrated entity | : | Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. |
| Subject | : | Reconsideration appeal against Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 020-2018-SMV/10. |
| File No. | : | 2017032761 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2017032761, the appeal filed by Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. and Report No. 482-2019-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy for Prudential Compliance; and
CONSIDERING:
- Pursuant to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of Securities Market Supervision, the name of the National Supervisory Commission for Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal provisions shall be understood as referring to the SMV;
- Background
- By Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 020-2018-SMV/10, Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C., hereinafter Magot SAB, was sanctioned with a fine of 6.375 UIT for having incurred two (02) infractions of a minor nature classified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and its amendments (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation) for having submitted periodic information outside the deadline established by the regulations;
- On June 1, 2018, Magot SAB filed a reconsideration appeal against said resolution;
- On the formal requirements
- In accordance with the provisions of Article 207[1] of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 and its amending provisions (hereinafter, Lpag), in force at the time the events occurred, appeals must be filed within fifteen (15) business days of notification of the administrative resolution;
- In the present case, Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 20-2018-SMV/10, hereinafter the Resolution, was notified to Magot SAB via MVNet on May 11, 2018, so that, since the reconsideration appeal was filed on June 1, 2018, it is concluded that it was filed in a timely manner;
- On the qualification of the appeal filed
- Likewise, pursuant to Article 208 of the Lpag, the reconsideration appeal is filed before the same body that issued the act subject to appeal and must be supported by new evidence; however, in the case of administrative acts issued by bodies that constitute a single instance, new evidence is not required;
- In the present case, in accordance with Article 32, numeral 17[2] of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF, the Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision has the power to impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness of submission of periodic and occasional information, so that the reconsideration appeal filed by Magot SAB does not require new evidence;
- On the arguments presented by Magot SAB
- Magot SAB states that in accordance with numeral 3.1 of the Criteria Applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for Non-Compliance with the Rules Regulating the Submission of Periodic or Occasional Information, approved by Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanction Criteria), if it is determined that the infraction committed was the product of a fortuitous event or force majeure, the administrated entity may be exempted from liability;
- Likewise, Magot SAB cites recital 16 of the Resolution, indicating that it reveals a circumstance beyond its will and control, the non-compliance of the auditing firm, for which reason it considers that diligence is ineffective for said circumstance, causing it harm;
- Similarly, Magot SAB considers that in its case a case of force majeure would have been considered, according to the criterion expressed by the cassation judgment No. 1693-2014 LIMA:
"It must be understood as a 'fortuitous event' when it is possible to avoid the damage produced through acts of foreseeability, this can be avoided through normal diligence, whereas it will be 'force majeure' when, even having been foreseen, it was impossible to prevent the damage from occurring, as would be the case with natural disasters."
- In that sense, Magot SAB states that it could be exempted from liability for the non-compliance with the submission of financial information;
- Magot SAB states that interpreting a contrario sensu recital 35 of the Resolution, the intermediary could be subject to a warning, according to numeral ii), literal iii) of the Sanction Criteria, since from a literal reading of the condition established by the numeral and literal in reference, with these regulatory provisions the antecedents would be constrained only to warnings:
35. On the matter, regarding the submission of the annual audited individual financial information as well as the external financial audit report, and the annual report corresponding to fiscal year 2015, and in accordance with the evaluation carried out, it is corroborated that in the present case it is not possible to apply a warning sanction because the requirement established in subsection 4.2, numeral ii), literal iii) of the Sanction Criteria has not been met, since in the cases subject to charges Magot SAB records one (01) antecedent of sanction for the commission of an infraction classified as very serious, in the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infractions being evaluated, so that according to the parameters established in the Sanction Criteria it is not appropriate to apply a warning sanction to the aforementioned stock brokerage firm;
4.2. Guidelines for the application of the Criteria
(i) The application of the following guidelines assumes the non-existence of the aggravating factors developed in point V of this section.
(ii) The warning sanction should be applied when the following are concurrently met: (i) the infraction committed has not caused a quantifiable harm to investors or associates; (ii) there is no repercussion on the market; (iii) the offending subject has no antecedents or, having them, they are not more than three (3) warnings imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction being evaluated;
(Underlined and highlighted by Magot SAB)
Evaluation of the arguments presented by Magot SAB
- According to the arguments of the stock brokerage firm, the basic financial statements and control annexes and external financial audit report corresponding to fiscal year 2015 (hereinafter, the Information) were not submitted in a timely manner due to the non-compliance of the auditing firm, which did not carry out the respective analysis within the corresponding deadline;
- On the matter, it should be reiterated in principle that Article 95 of the Regulation of Intermediation Agents, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 045-2006-EF/94.10, in force at the time the events occurred (hereinafter, Previous Regulation), provides that intermediation agents must submit the Information to CONASEV, now SMV, before February 28 of the following year;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to note that Magot SAB was reminded, through Circular Letter No. 064-2019-SMV/10.2, of the schedule for compliance with the main obligations, among them, that of providing the Information, and in particular, the maximum date for the respective submission;
- The foregoing reflects that Magot SAB had full knowledge of the obligation as well as, clearly, the opportunity at which it should have submitted it; however, this was not observed by said brokerage firm, despite the years it has been in the market; it should also be added that it is foreseeable for said stock brokerage firm to know the possible results in case it does not comply with the established framework;
- However, with the reconsideration filed, Magot SAB seeks to transfer its natural and legal obligation to the auditing firm in charge of reviewing its annual individual financial statement for fiscal year 2015, alleging that it was the latter that delayed the submission; which is unacceptable insofar as, regardless of whether the auditing firm is responsible for preparing the external financial audit report, it is the brokerage firm that is obligated to submit the Information in accordance with Article 95 of the Previous Regulation cited above and is responsible for non-compliance;
- Likewise, it is appropriate to indicate that Article 1315[3] of the Civil Code defines fortuitous event or force majeure as the non-imputable cause consisting of an extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible event that prevents the execution of an obligation, so that the delay in the review and preparation of the Information under the circumstances described by Magot SAB cannot be considered an extraordinary[4], unforeseeable and irresistible event and therefore cannot be regarded as a cause that releases this intermediary from compliance with its obligations as a company registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market of the SMV;
- On the other hand, as regards the fact that for the sanctioned infractions Magot SAB should be eligible for warnings in application of numeral 4.2 of the Sanction Criteria, it must be indicated that, as stated in the Resolution, this is not possible because the requirement contemplated in subsection 4.2, numeral ii, literal iii) of such criteria is not met, since said intermediary has antecedents of sanction for the commission of an infraction classified as very serious;
- It should be specified that the reference made by Magot SAB in its arguments to the aforementioned subsection 4.2, numeral ii, literal iii) was not in force at the time of the commission of the infraction, insofar as said provision was amended by SMV Resolution No. 010-2014-S;V/01 of May 24, 2014; said amendment being the one considered in the Resolution in order to determine the sanction to be imposed[5];
- For the foregoing, it is concluded that the arguments stated by Magot SAB in its reconsideration appeal have not disproved the grounds of the Resolution, which served as the basis for the imposition of the sanction applied to said company;
In accordance with the provisions of Article 32, numeral 17, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- To declare unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C. for the reasons set forth in this resolution.
- To declare that the administrative remedy has been exhausted since Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 20-2018-SMV/10 has become final.
- This resolution shall be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, Article 7 of the Policy on the dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal provisions, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and the provisions of Article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- To transcribe this resolution to Magot Sociedad Agente de Bolsa S.A.C.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Prudential Supervision
-
"Article 207.- Administrative appeals
207.1 Administrative appeals are:
a) Reconsideration appeal
b) Appeal
c) Review appeal
207.2 The term for filing appeals is fifteen (15) peremptory days, and they must be resolved within thirty (30) days." ↑
-
"17. To impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions regarding the timeliness of submission of periodic and occasional information, whose compliance control corresponds to the Superintendency of the Securities Market." ↑
-
Article 1315.- Fortuitous event or force majeure
Fortuitous event or force majeure is the non-imputable cause, consisting of an extraordinary, unforeseeable and irresistible event, that prevents the execution of the obligation or determines its partial, late or defective fulfillment. ↑
-
Outside the natural or common order or rule ↑
-
Subsection 4.2, numeral ii, literal iii) of the criteria, as of May 24, 2014, was amended as follows: "(iii) the offending subject has no antecedents or, having them, they are infractions classified as minor offenses imposed in the four (04) years prior to the commission of the infraction being evaluated." ↑