Enforcement · SMV · 31 Jan 2013
The Deputy Superintendency for Supervision of Market Conduct declared unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A. against Resolution No. 108-2012-SMV/11, which had imposed a fine of 25 UIT (S/. 88,750.00) for failing to timely submit information to the SMV and the Lima Stock Exchange. The resolution exhausts the administrative remedy and orders notification to the company and the Lima Stock Exchange.
SMV Deputy Superintendency Resolution
No. 054-2013-SMV/11
|Lima, January 31, 2013 |
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A. against Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 108-2012-SMV/11 is declared unfounded.
| Administered entity | : | Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A |
|---|---|---|
| Subject | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2011017250 |
The Deputy Superintendent for Supervision of Market Conduct WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2011017250 and Report No. 1005-2012-SMV/11 dated December 27, 2012 issued by the General Intendancy for Compliance of Conduct of the Superintendency of the Securities Market;
CONSIDERING:
I. Facts
By Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 108-2012-SMV/11 (hereinafter, the Resolution), notified on July 10, 2012 (hereinafter, Resolution), it was resolved to sanction Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A - Cayalti with a fine of 25 UIT equivalent to S/. 88,750.00 (Eighty-eight thousand seven hundred fifty and 00/100 Nuevos Soles), for not having submitted to the SMV and the BVL the information indicated in said resolution within the period established by the rules;
That, on August 1, 2012, Cayalti filed a reconsideration appeal against the aforementioned Resolution;
That, in observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, paragraph 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title —general principle— and in Article 230, paragraph 2, —special principle applicable to the sanctioning power— of the General Administrative Procedure Law (LPAG), by Official Letter No. 5367-2012-SMV/11 of December 28, 2012, the administrative file to which this Resolution refers was made available to Cayalti for its review;
II. Issues to be determined
III. Analysis
1. Arguments of the Reconsideration Appeal
5. That, the reconsideration appeal filed by Cayalti was submitted within the deadline established in Article 207 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (LPAG) and is signed by an attorney; likewise, it should be noted that said appeal was filed in accordance with the provisions of Article 208 of the aforementioned Law;
6. That, Cayalti based its appeal on the following arguments:
1. Cayalti alleges that the infractions committed qualify as minor, so any affectation they may produce will be of lesser intensity, therefore in application of this criterion the lowest possible sanction should be imposed. It adds that, contrary to what is stipulated in the resolution, the non-compliances did not cause any harm to the public interest or to the market, because there is no evidence proving economic harm.
For Cayalti, the resolution maintains the criterion of implicit harm, by which the harm to the public interest is implicit in the classification, this being contrary to the principles of sanctioning law and specifically to the burden of proof that corresponds to the Administration regarding any aggravating circumstance. Likewise, it states that if the harm or economic damage were implicit in the classification, it would not be possible to sanction with greater intensity the one who caused greater harm, which is illegal according to Article 230 numeral 3 of the LPAG.
2. Cayalti points out that the resolution did not take into consideration that the infractions were remedied, so the sanction should have been reduced to the minimum possible, as it is a mitigating factor.
3. Cayalti states that "The criteria applicable to the sanctioning procedure for non-compliance with deadlines in the submission of periodic and occasional information" can be included in the evaluation of the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, since they regulate the graduation of the sanction based on the criterion of time of delay in the delivery of information, therefore, taking into account that the delay periods in the submission of information were shorter, this should lead to the imposition of the lowest sanction.
4. Regarding the criterion of "Illegally obtained benefit", it states that it had not been proven that the infractions incurred generated any illegal benefit, Cayalti considers that the application of this criterion should have led to a lower sanction than that imposed in the resolution.
5. With respect to the criterion of "Existence or not of intentionality", Cayalti considers that the correct application of this criterion would lead to the lowest possible sanction, to the extent that the resolution stated that it was not evidenced that the company acted with the intention of infringing the regulations.
6. Finally, Cayalti concludes by stating that the resolution limits itself to automatically adding the sanctions that would correspond to each sanction taking into account only the time delay factor to graduate the sanction amounts, without taking into account the criteria cited above;
2. Evaluation of the Reconsideration Appeal
7. That, in relation to the first argument, we must point out that in the Securities Market, non-compliance with submission deadlines, however short, produces a mismatch with respect to all the information that must be presented to the market, which affects in one way or another the transparency of information, to the extent that, in the case of information submission, investors are unable to timely know the information, whether it be material events or periodic financial information, for making their investment decisions; that is, said non-compliance causes the investor who is awaiting the information to be submitted timely to be unable to make informed decisions regarding their securities due to the lack of information in the market, harm that cannot fail to be recognized as generated by the non-compliance with information submission;
8. That, said situation is reflected in the criterion referring to the seriousness of the harm to the public interest and/or legally protected right in the timely submission of information, because the non-observance of the established deadlines generates confusion, disorder and uncertainty regarding the disclosure of said information since, as mentioned, real, potential investors and the general public are deprived, thereby affecting market transparency, a situation that occurs regardless of the possible economic harm that the infraction may cause and that can be quantifiable and therefore concrete;
9. That, in relation to the argument sustained by Cayalti by which it states that the sanction is the automatic sum of sanctions, we must point out that the determination of the sanction has been made through the application of the sanction criteria, which have the purpose of generating predictability for the administered entity upon the commission of infractions, being a minimum parameter to be observed by the Administration within the sanction ranges up to 25 UIT taking into account all the sanction criteria established in the LMV and the LPAG;
10. That, with relation to the argument presented by Cayalti regarding the criterion of economic harm caused to the public interest or to the market, which would not have been correctly applied in the resolution, it should be indicated that numerals 1 and 2 of consideration 29 evaluated the aforementioned criteria in application of the sanction in order to graduate it and impose one that responds to the reasonableness of the case;
11. That, the challenged resolution differentiated the criterion of harm to the public interest and/or legally protected right from the aggravating factor that constitutes the economic harm caused (numeral 2 of consideration 29). However, Cayalti in its reconsideration appeal mistakenly considers that harm to the public interest and economic harm caused constitute the same criterion, therefore it concludes that since the economic harm of someone in particular has not been determined, then it would correspond to a lower sanction than that imposed in the resolution;
12. That, in this regard it should be noted that the purpose of the regulations on timely submission of information lies in investors having the possibility of using it to make investment decisions, thereby guaranteeing a transparent market. Therefore, and as stated in the resolution, the legally protected right is the transparency of information, a parameter different from the economic harm caused, a criterion that tries to identify the concrete harm caused to one or several investors, which must be economically quantifiable;
13. That, it should be noted that the sanction criteria approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 (New sanction criteria) collected by the challenged resolution establish that if proven, among others, the existence of quantifiable economic harm, the minimum amounts to be applied may be increased up to the maximum permitted by the corresponding law;
14. That, for the case of non-compliances in the timely submission of information, being classified as minor infractions in the Sanctions Regulation approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 and amendments, the sanctions to be applied range from a warning or fine, which must be no less than one (1) UIT and up to twenty-five (25) UIT, in accordance with Article 22 of said regulation;
15. That, therefore, in cases where it is detected that any market participant has been economically harmed by the non-compliance in the timely submission of information by an issuer, the latter may be imposed a sanction up to the maximum permitted, that is, up to twenty-five (25) UIT may be applied for each infraction committed;
16. That, with relation to the argument presented by Cayalti that the resolution did not take into account that the company remedied the infractions, which would constitute a mitigating factor for which the sanction should be reduced to the minimum possible, it should be noted that consideration 43 of the resolution states that "...however, in relation to the mitigating factors referred to in numeral vii) of the New Sanction Criteria, which refers to the provisions of Article 236-A of the LPAG, it must be specified that the sanction has been mitigated in cases where the information was presented before the sending of the letter of charges, which correspond to ten of the fourteen infractions;" not being correct what Cayalti states in this regard;
17. That, likewise, the resolution has evaluated in consideration 25, numeral 3 the criterion of "sanction antecedents" in order to measure the sanction and make it proportional to the antecedents that Cayalti has;
18. That, in the criterion of circumstances in the commission of the infraction, the special and determining facts surrounding the commission of the infraction are collected, thus if the existence of a fortuitous event or force majeure is proven, it would correspond to exempt or reduce the sanction. In the present case, Cayalti has not demonstrated that there were circumstances that justify the non-compliance with its obligations;
19.
That, the New Sanction Criteria establish as circumstances to be assessed: the lack of submission of information required by the regulations, the effective date of delivery, among others. It should be noted that in the case of the effective date of delivery, these criteria objectively contemplate an increase in the sanction for the number of days of delay in the submission of information; likewise, an additional amount is considered when the information is not presented until the notification of the letter of charges or issuance of the respective report, as the case may be;
That, with relation to the illegally obtained benefit, in the present case it was not determined that Cayalti obtained any benefit from the non-compliances in the submission of its financial information, since if it had, the challenged resolution could have imposed a greater sanction, due to the existence of an aggravating factor;
That, with relation to the existence or not of intentionality, as stated in the challenged resolution, it has not been evidenced that Cayalti acted with the intention of infringing the regulations, for that reason this aggravating factor was not considered; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of Article 43 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF, as well as the Old Sanction Criteria, and the New Sanction Criteria.
RESOLVES:
Declare Unfounded the reconsideration appeal filed by Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A against Deputy Superintendency Resolution No. 108-2012-SMV/11.
Consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
Transcribe this Resolution to Empresa Agroindustrial Cayalti S.A.A and to the Lima Stock Exchange S.A.
Register and communicate,
[pic]
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency for Supervision of Market Conduct [pic]
Note from RegAlert. AI assistants can read this document in full, and search 70,000+ more, through the RegAlert MCP connector (https://mcp.regalert.today/mcp). Free with an account. How to connect ChatGPT, Claude or Cursor.
The documents this one cites, and the documents that cite it.
“In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of Article 43 of the Regulations of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF”
“Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 054-2013-SMV/11 of January 31, 2013”
More like this from SMV
SMV published 22 documents in the last 30 days. We email you each new one the day it's published.
Source: Superintendencia del Mercado de Valores (Peru) — original document · Summary generated with machine assistance and checked by an AI reviewer before publication; the authoritative text is the regulator's original document. How RegAlert works
In RegAlert: added