Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV
No. 043-2022-SMV/11
Summary: Sanction AI Inversiones Palo Alto S.A. with one (01) reprimand for having incurred one (01) infraction of a minor nature classified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation
| | |
|---|
| Subject | : | AI INVERSIONES PALO ALTO S.A. |
| Matter | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2021035923 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2021035923 and Report No. 184-2022-SMV/11.2 (hereinafter the Report), issued by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Function and competence of the SASCM
- That administrative file No. 2021035923 contains the documentation and information regarding an administrative sanctioning procedure (hereinafter PAS), which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM in observance of the exercise of the supervision function and the sanctioning power of the Superintendency of the Securities Market - SMV established by the Single Concorded Text of its Organic Law, Decree Law No. 26126 (hereinafter, LOSMV), and in the Securities Market Law, Legislative Decree No. 861 (hereinafter, LMV); as well as by the provisions of the Sanctions Regulation approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), and in articles 42 and 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF (hereinafter, ROF-SMV), in the sense that it is a specific function of the SASCM to impose sanctions in a single administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control according to its competences corresponds to said Deputy Superintendency. Likewise, the SASCM has the powers to issue corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infraction;
- Facts, charge and arguments of the Subject
- Facts
- That, according to the charge formulated, it was determined that AI Inversiones Palo Alto S.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) failed to timely submit a material event to the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV);
- Charge
- That, as a result, by Official Letter No. 3795-2021-SMV/11.2 of September 22, 2021 (hereinafter, Charge Letter), a charge was formulated against the Issuer for not having timely communicated the material event regarding the appointment of Paredes, Burga & Asociados Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada, a member firm of Ernst & Young, as audit firm for the 2021 fiscal year; an event that should have been communicated on March 31, 2021, the date on which its appointment was approved at the general shareholders' meeting; however, it was communicated as a material event on April 5, 2021. This non-compliance is classified in subsection 3.1, numeral 3, Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Arguments
- That, by document presented on October 6, 2021, the Issuer presented its corresponding arguments, stating the following:
- The reason for the late communication was a technical failure and that at the moment they became aware of it, they remedied it, through the regularization document and the material event of April 5, 2021.
- Likewise, the Issuer states that the purpose of the classification of the imputed infraction is to protect minority shareholders of companies with dispersed shareholding; in turn, the Issuer expresses that it does not have dispersed shareholding or minority shareholders, and that the agreements were agreed unanimously by the partners; therefore, there would be no minority shareholder rights in danger or violated.
- Finally, conducting an analysis of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation, the Issuer states that it has no record of sanctions, recidivism, damage to the public interest, intentionality, benefit, and that there is a regularization; consequently, it requests that the minimum extent of the penalty be applied in consideration of the principle of proportionality;
- That, by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS, the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law - Law No. 27444 (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG) was approved, which contains common rules for the actions of the administrative function of the State and regulates all administrative procedures developed in the entities, including special procedures. Likewise, numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG indicates the criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction: (a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction, (b) The probability of detection of the infraction, (c) The severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal asset, (d) The economic harm caused, (e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, (f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and, (g) The existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender;
- That the charge formulated and the new criteria regarding the graduation of the sanction have been subject to evaluation in the Report, which has been brought to the attention of the SASCM;
- That, in observance of the provisions of numeral 5 of article 255 of the TUO of the LPAG, by Official Letter No. 720-2022-SMV/11, the Report was sent to the Issuer, so that it could submit its arguments within five (05) business days of notification. In this regard, it is necessary to indicate that, to date, these have not been presented;
- Issues to be determined
- That, in the present administrative procedure it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether or not the Issuer incurred in the infraction indicated in the Charge Letter and Report.
- Whether or not it corresponds to impose a sanction on the Issuer;
- Analysis
- Applicable Regulations
- That article 28 of the LMV states: "The registration of a given security or issuance program entails for its issuer the obligation to inform CONASEV and, where appropriate, the respective stock exchange or entity responsible for the conduct of the centralized mechanism, of material events, including negotiations in progress, about itself, the security and the offer made thereof, as well as to disclose such events truthfully, sufficiently and timely. The information must be provided to said institutions and disclosed as soon as the event occurs or the issuer becomes aware of it, as the case may be". (Underlined added);
- That numeral 5.1 of article 5 of the Regulation of Material Events and Reserved Information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 005-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Regulation of Material Events) states that: "In the Annex that is part of this Regulation, an enumerative list of events, acts, agreements and decisions is included, whose purpose is to facilitate the Issuer's identification, qualification and classification of information that could qualify as a material event." (Underlined added);
- That, in this sense, numeral 11 of Annex 1 of the Regulation of Material Events states that it constitutes a material event: "Appointment and termination of contract with its audit firm." (Underlined added);
- That, consequently, the provisions of numeral 9.1 of article 9 of the Regulation of Material Events would have been breached, which states: "The Issuer must report its material event as soon as such event occurs or the Issuer becomes aware of it, and in no case beyond the day on which it has occurred or has been known (...)". (Underlined added);
- That the non-compliance in the timely submission of material events is classified in subsection 3.1 of numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, which states that it constitutes a minor infraction: "Submit outside the established period, or do so incompletely, or, without observing the technical specifications approved by the SMV or without communicating the approval by the corresponding corporate body, to the SMV, the Exchange, the entity in charge of the centralized trading mechanism or any other entity or subject of the securities market, the individual or consolidated audited financial information, the individual or consolidated interim financial statements, management report, special audit report, material events and annual reports." (Underlined added);
- That, according to article 35 of the Sanctions Regulation, said infraction is punishable by reprimand or a fine of not less than one (1) UIT and up to twenty-five (25) UIT;
- Evaluation of the case
- That the timely submission of material events by issuers of securities registered in the Public Registry of the Securities Market (hereinafter, RPMV) constitutes a fundamental obligation in the transparency of the securities market, so its non-compliance affects said transparency, which is considered a protected legal asset;
- That, in relation to the arguments presented by the Issuer, the following should be indicated:
- Prior to the corresponding analysis, it should be noted that the formulation of the present charge was based on the fact that the Issuer would not have complied with submitting within the established period the appointment of Paredes, Burga & Asociados S. Civil de R.L. as its audit firm for the 2021 fiscal year, approved at the board meeting of June 28, 2021, an event that should have been communicated the same day, however, it was communicated late on September 3, 2021.
- Regarding the technical failure alleged by the Issuer in its arguments, it should be indicated that no further elements or evidence have been presented to support its assertions. In addition, it is relevant to note that it constitutes a fundamental obligation in the transparency of the securities market that issuers of securities present periodic and occasional information in a timely manner even if they do not have dispersed shareholding, so that market participants can make their investment decisions adequately informed, thus the protected legal asset understood as the transparency of the securities market was violated.
- From the review of the Issuer's 2020 Annual Report, it is observed that it has only two (02) shareholders, one majority with 99.99%, and the other shareholder with 0.01% belonging to the same economic group, which must be taken into consideration as part of the determination of the possible sanction.
Table No. 1: Shareholders of the Issuer – 2020 Annual Report
Source: Issuer's 2020 Annual Report
- Regarding the Issuer's request to consider the criteria indicated in article 348 of the LMV, article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation and the provisions of numeral 3 of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG; it should be noted that said criteria will be evaluated at the time of determining the corresponding sanction;
- That, on the other hand, it should be specified that despite having been notified by Official Letter No. 720-2022-SMV/11 on February 17, 2022, so that it could communicate its arguments regarding the Report, the Issuer has not presented any document in this regard;
- That the conduct constituting an infraction by the Issuer has been accredited, by not having timely communicated the information subject to charge; consequently, the administrative responsibility of the Issuer in the present PAS is determined and it corresponds to determine the applicable sanction;
- Determination of the Sanction
- That, before determining the sanction, it should be noted that having decreed the National State of Emergency in order to face the health crisis caused by Covid-19 in accordance with the provisions of article 28 of Urgency Decree No. 029-2020, modified by article 12 of Urgency Decree No. 053-2020 and by article 2 of Supreme Decree No. 087-2020-PCM, the deadlines for the processing of administrative procedures, among which are administrative sanctioning procedures, were suspended from March 21, 2020 to June 10, 2020, with deadlines resuming on June 11, 2020;
- That, having determined the commission of one (01) infraction for not having timely communicated the appointment of its audit firm, it corresponds to determine the sanction by evaluating the Criteria applicable to the administrative sanctioning procedure for non-compliance with the rules that regulate the submission of periodic or occasional information, approved by SMV Resolution No. 006-2012-SMV/01 (hereinafter, Special Sanction Criteria); in accordance with the criteria for the graduation of the sanction established in numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and article 348 of the LMV;
- That, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 4.1 of the Special Sanction Criteria, the following is analyzed: (i) the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal asset; (ii) the harm caused and its impact on the market; (iii) the Issuer's sanction record; (iv) the probability of detection of the infraction; (v) recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final; (vi) the circumstances of the commission of the infraction; (vii) the illegally obtained benefit; and, (viii) the existence or not of intentionality in the conduct of the offender, in accordance with the provisions of numeral 3) of article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG and article 348 of the LMV;
- That, in order to determine the fine sanction, it is relevant to note that regarding the severity of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal asset, it should be indicated that the timely submission of periodic or occasional information by issuers of securities registered in the RPMV constitutes a fundamental obligation in the transparency of the securities market, since it seeks to ensure that all market participants make their investment decisions adequately informed. Consequently, although there is no evidence of severity of damage to the public interest, the non-compliance with the obligation to communicate material events within the established period by issuers affects the transparency of the market, which is considered a protected legal asset; even if the Issuer has only two (02) shareholders belonging to the same economic group;
- That, regarding the harm caused and impact on the market, there are not enough elements to measure the harm caused by the infraction committed; however, it is considered that there is an economic damage caused to one or several investors due to the lack of information in a timely manner. Likewise, it is necessary to highlight that the non-appointment of its audit firm within the established period harms the transparency of the securities market, the confidence of investors and the general public since they do not have basic information about the Issuer;
- That, on the other hand, regarding the sanction record, it is established that the offender's record consists of the sanctions imposed by the SMV that became final within the four (04) years prior to the moment of the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned. In application of said criterion, it has been verified that the Issuer does not have a sanction record according to the evaluation carried out in the Report;
- That, in relation to recidivism for the commission of the same infraction, it is verified that there is no recidivism on the part of the Issuer, in the terms referred to in literal b) of article 25 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to the evaluation of the Report;
- That, as for the illegally obtained benefit, there are no elements to determine whether the infraction incurred by the Issuer could have generated an illegal benefit;
- That, as for the intentionality in the conduct of the offender, there is no information to determine whether the infraction incurred by the Issuer has been committed with or without intent;
- That, on the other hand, regarding the probability of detection of the infraction, it should be noted that the lack of timely submission of periodic or occasional information is verified through internal control systems, so there is a high probability of detection;
- That, regarding the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that the Issuer submitted the material event five (5) calendar days late. Likewise, from the review of the Issuer's 2020 Annual Report, it is observed that it has only two (02) shareholders, one majority with 99.99%, and the other shareholder with 0.01% belonging to the same economic group, which must be taken into consideration as part of the determination of the possible sanction:
Table No. 2: Shareholders of the Issuer – 2020 Annual Report
Source: Issuer's 2020 Annual Report
- That subsection (ii) of numeral 4.2 referring to the Guidelines for the application of the Special Sanction Criteria provides that the reprimand sanction may be applied when the following is concurrently met: (i) The impact on market transparency is minimal; (ii) The infraction committed has not caused concrete harm to investors or associates; (iii) The offender has no record or, if any, it involves infractions classified as minor offenses imposed in the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction being evaluated; (iv) The offender has not obtained a benefit from its illegal conduct; and, (v) It has not been proven that the offender acted with intent in the commission of the infraction;
- That, in the specific case, although there has been a delay in the communication of the material event subject to charge, it is noted that the impact on market transparency was minimal. Indeed, it is important to note that the infraction committed has not caused concrete harm to investors; the Issuer has no record, nor is it a recidivist; and, it has not been evidenced that the Issuer obtained a benefit from its illegal conduct or that it acted with intent in the commission of the infraction;
- That, therefore, having concurrently met the provisions of subsection (ii) of numeral 4.2 of the Guidelines for the Application of the Special Sanction Criteria, this Deputy Superintendency considers that the Issuer should be imposed one (01) reprimand for the non-compliance incurred;
- That, finally, in this PAS the mitigating factor referred to in literal a) of article 26 of the Sanctions Regulation is not applicable, because the proposed sanction is not a fine, but a reprimand; notwithstanding this, the acknowledgment of responsibility expressed by the Issuer was taken into consideration in the evaluation of the determination of the sanction;
ON THE NEED TO ISSUE A CORRECTIVE MEASURE
- That, in the evaluation of the present PAS it has been determined that the minor infraction committed by the Issuer, referring to the appointment of its audit firm outside the established period, has generated damage to the public interest, to the transparency of information and to the protection of investors, as indicated in this Resolution;
- That it is the duty of the SMV to do what is necessary so that the market knows the consequences that have been generated for the Issuer regarding the infraction in which it has incurred. Thus, it corresponds to the SMV to apply a measure that prevents more time from passing without the market knowing the consequences that have been generated for the Issuer. This with the purpose of respecting the principle of opportunity. In addition, it corresponds to reinforce the transparency of information and the protection of investors, which are two of the fundamental principles of the securities market that the SMV must safeguard;
- That it must be reiterated that the present PAS refers to the appointment of its audit firm outside the established period; therefore, in merit of what is stated in this Resolution, it is necessary and timely for the market to know about the result of the evaluation of said infraction, even if it is the pronouncement of the first administrative instance of the SMV;
- That, in that line of reasoning, having determined in the present PAS that the Issuer has affected the transparency of information of the securities market and the protection of its investors, it becomes necessary to issue an administrative measure, in addition to the imposition of a sanction for the determined infraction. Said additional measure must have the purpose of correcting, repairing or trying to repair the altered situation, so it corresponds to issue a corrective measure;
- That, in accordance with article 1 of both the LOSMV and the LMV, it is the purpose and duty of the SMV "to ensure the adequate protection of investors". Thus, article 1 of the LOSMV provides:
"Article 1. Definition, purpose and functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV)
The Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) is a specialized technical body attached to the Ministry of Economy and Finance whose purpose is to ensure the protection of investors, the efficiency and transparency of the markets under its supervision, the correct formation of prices and the dissemination of all information necessary for such purposes, through regulation, supervision and promotion. It has legal personality under internal public law and enjoys functional, administrative, economic, technical and budgetary autonomy, constituting a budgetary unit. Its operation is governed in accordance with the provisions contained in this Law and its regulation of organization and functions. The functions of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV) are the following: [...]"
In article 1 of the LMV it is established:
"Article 1.- Purpose and Scope of the Law.- The purpose of this law is to promote the orderly development and transparency of the securities market, as well as the adequate protection of the investor.
The following are included in this law: public offerings of securities and their issuers, publicly offered securities, brokerage agents, stock exchanges, securities clearing and settlement institutions, securitization companies, mutual funds investing in securities, investment funds and, in general, the other participants in the securities market, as well as the supervisory and control body. Unless expressly stated otherwise, its provisions do not reach private offerings of securities. […]"
- That, regarding the function and responsibility of the SMV, it is necessary to take into account that article 7 of the LMV provides:
"Article 7.- Control and Supervision. - The National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is the public institution entrusted with the supervision and control of compliance with this law. […]"
- That, regarding the SMV's power to issue corrective measures, the provisions of article 358 of the LMV are applicable:
"Article 358.- Precautionary, provisional and corrective measures
CONASEV is empowered to issue precautionary, provisional and corrective measures with respect to natural or legal persons under its jurisdiction, regardless of whether a sanctioning procedure has been initiated or not. […]"
- That, regarding the definition or scope of corrective measures, the provisions of article 19 of the Sanctions Regulation are applicable:
"Article 19.- DEFINITION.- Corrective measures are those mandates aimed at restoring, reversing, repairing, or restituting that situation altered by non-compliance with the regulations under the supervision of the SMV. These measures may be issued prior to the initiation of an administrative sanctioning procedure or at the time of the determination of administrative liability.
Corrective measures may consist of obligations to give, do and not do, and must precisely and indubitably establish the task incumbent upon the administered party, identifying those obligated to comply with them. Corrective measures must be issued by means of a duly reasoned decision and observing the principles of Proportionality and Reasonableness."
- That, regarding the timing of the issuance of corrective measures, according to article 21 of the New Sanctions Regulation the following is provided:
"Article 21.- CORRECTIVE MEASURES ISSUED BY THE DEPUTY SUPERINTENDENCIES
The corrective measures established at the time of the determination of administrative liability are issued by the corresponding Deputy Superintendents.
In Annex XX of the Regulation, the corrective measures that may be issued are mentioned by way of example.
The Deputy Superintendents may issue corrective measures, including for very serious infractions."
- That, likewise, regarding corrective measures, it is necessary to refer to the provisions of article 251 of the TUO of the LPAG:
"Article 251. - Determination of liability
251.1 The administrative sanctions imposed on the administered party are compatible with the issuance of corrective measures conducive to ordering the restoration or repair of the situation altered by the infraction to its previous state, including that of the affected goods, as well as with compensation for damages caused, which are determined in the corresponding judicial process. Corrective measures must be previously typified, be reasonable and adjust to the intensity, proportionality and needs of the legal interests protected that are intended to be guaranteed in each specific case. […]"
- That, regarding the typification of corrective measures in Annex XX of the New Sanctions Regulation, the following is established:
"[…] ANNEX XX
On Corrective Measures
In accordance with the provisions of article 21 of the Regulation, the SMV, when determining administrative liability, may issue the following corrective measures:
[…]
2) The presentation as a material event of the information determined by the SMV."
- That, regarding the competence or power of the SASCM to issue corrective measures, numeral 12 of article 43 of the ROF-SMV establishes:
"ARTICLE 43.- The specific functions of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision are:
[…]
12. To issue, modify or revoke precautionary, corrective and/or provisional measures, ex officio or at the request of a party, in cases submitted to its knowledge; […]"
- That, in accordance with the previous article, regarding the competence or power of the SASCM to issue corrective measures, numeral 13 of article 43 of the ROF-SMV also establishes the following:
"ARTICLE 43.- The specific functions of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision are:
[…]
13. Within its scope of competence, to impose sanctions in the first administrative instance for the commission of infractions whose compliance control corresponds to the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, with the exception of infractions of the rules on the timeliness of the presentation of periodic or occasional information. The respective sanction resolution may order the application of corrective measures aimed at reversing the situation altered by the commission of the infraction; […]"
- That, therefore, based on the foregoing, and in observance of the principles of proportionality and reasonableness, the purpose of the SMV and of the LMV must be fulfilled - to ensure the adequate protection of investors. Considering this, for transparency, it is necessary that the market know in a timely manner (principle of timeliness) about the consequences and responsibilities that have been generated for the Issuer;
- That, in that sense, based on the foregoing in this Resolution, it is appropriate to issue as a corrective measure that the Issuer proceed to disseminate through the material event channel - considering the definition of material events provided in the regulation on the matter - this Sanction Resolution;
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 12, 13, 14 and 36 of article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- To declare that Al Inversiones Palo Alto S.A. has incurred in one (01) infraction of a minor nature, typified in subsection 3.1 of numeral 3 of Annex I of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, for having failed to timely communicate the material event regarding the appointment of Paredes, Burga & Asociados Sociedad Civil de Responsabilidad Limitada, a member firm of Ernst & Young, as the auditing firm for fiscal year 2021.
- To sanction Al Inversiones Palo Alto S.A. with one (01) reprimand, as provided in article 1 of this Resolution.
- To issue as a corrective measure that Al Inversiones Palo Alto S.A., in accordance with article 21 and numeral 2 of Annex XX of the Corrective Measures of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01, disseminate this Resolution as a material event once it is notified, within a timely period.
- To order that compliance with the corrective measure issued in article 3 of this Resolution, by Al Inversiones Palo Alto S.A., be verified by the Intendencia General de Supervisión de Conductas of the SMV, within the framework of its competences.
- In the event that this Resolution is not subject to challenge, it must be published on the Securities Market Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (www.smv.gob.pe), in observance of the provisions of numeral 1 of article 7 of the Policy on publicity of regulatory projects, general legal norms and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of the last paragraph of article 14 of SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- This Resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, and may be challenged by filing a reconsideration appeal before this Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision, within a period of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification, as it is a single-instance administrative procedure.
- To transcribe this resolution to Al Inversiones Palo Alto S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision