Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV
No. 061-2016-SMV/11
Summary: The reconsideration appeal filed by Agro Pucalá S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11 is declared partially founded.
| | |
|---|
| Administered entity | : | AGRO PUCALÁ S.A.A. |
| Matter | : | Administrative Sanctioning Procedure |
| File No. | : | 2015035672 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Market Conduct Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2015035672 and Report No. 367-2016-SMV/11.2, issued by the General Intendancy of Conduct Compliance (IGCC) of the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision (SASCM);
CONSIDERING:
- Facts
- That, by Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11 (hereinafter, the Resolution), the SASCM resolved to sanction Agro Pucalá S.A.A. (hereinafter, the Issuer) with a fine of 24.21 UIT, equivalent to S/ 93,189.25, for not having timely submitted: (i) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (ii) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (iii) the Audited Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (iv) the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2014; (v) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015; and, (vi) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015;
- That, by document presented on 5 April 2016, the Issuer filed a reconsideration appeal against the Resolution;
- That, the arguments of the appeal filed have been evaluated in Report No. 367-2016-SMV/11.2, which has been submitted to the Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision;
- That, in observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, paragraph 1, numeral 1.2, of the Preliminary Title - general principle - and in Article 230, paragraph 2 - special principle applicable to the sanctioning power - of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (LPAG), by Official Letter No. 3030-2016-SMV/11 the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made known to the Issuer for its review;
- Issues to be determined
- That, it corresponds to determine whether or not it is appropriate to reconsider the sanction imposed in the Resolution;
- Analysis
3.1. On the Reconsideration Appeal
- That, the reconsideration appeal was filed within the deadline established in Article 207 of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444 (LPAG) and is authorized by counsel; likewise, it has observed the provisions of Articles 208 and 211 of the LPAG;
- That, the Issuer based its appeal on the following arguments:
- It presents as new evidence its registration record No. 785 of the Commercial Registry and its Electronic Entry No. 11004524 of the Registry of Legal Persons of the Registry Office of Chiclayo and the copy of Resolution No. 412 of 12 August 2014 issued by the Third Specialized Civil Court of Chiclayo, which details the powers of its current judicial administrator.
- It has not been taken into account that it is subject to a judicial process of Convocation to the General Shareholders' Meeting processed under File No. 1711-2004 before the Third Civil Court of Chiclayo, against CONASEV (now, SMV), at the request of its majority shareholder Cromwell Assets S.A.
- It does not fall within the assumptions of Articles 10 and 12 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94.10 (hereinafter, Sanctions Regulation), since the submission of the required documentation is subject to the holding of the Mandatory Annual Shareholders' Meeting.
- Mr. Luis Alberto Dávila Dávila has the status of Judicial Administrator and was appointed through Resolution No. 412 of 12 August 2014 issued by the Third Civil Court of Chiclayo, whose Thirty-Fourth recital strictly states the powers of procedural, contractual and banking, administrative and labor representation that he has to administer the company; among which are not those of acting as General Shareholders' Meeting, so that in accordance with law, the Judicial Administrator lacks the authority to approve the audited financial information, since the approval of such documentation is exclusive to the General Shareholders' Meeting.
- The Resolution assumes that the judicial situation it is going through is being alleged on purpose, when the cause of the General Shareholders' Meeting not having been held since 1999 responds to a situation that has not been raised, nor depends on its decision, since the holding of said Meeting is subject to a jurisdictional decision and responsibility cannot be attributed to it nor can it be sanctioned for it.
- The Resolution has violated the principles that regulate the administrative procedure, such as the principle of legality, due process, reasonableness, since they ignore what is strictly regulated by the laws of the matter such as the General Corporations Law, the Financial Information Regulation and the Annual Reports Regulation, which require that the submission be approved by the General Shareholders' Meeting.
- With regard to the holding of the General Shareholders' Meeting, the Issuer reiterates that its holding depends on it being convened by the Third Civil Court of Chiclayo and that although by Resolution No. 412 of 12 August 2014 it was convened for December 2014, it was left without effect, at the request of the plaintiff company, Cromwell Assets S.A., by Resolution No. 430 of 11 December 2014 issued by the same Court.
3.2. Evaluation of the Reconsideration Appeal
- With regard to the arguments set forth by the Issuer, the following should be indicated:
- The Issuer has stated that, being involved in the judicial process on the convocation to the General Shareholders' Meeting - which to date has not been held - it has been prevented from approving the Audited Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014 and the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2014, as well as the interim individual financial statements and their respective management reports; and, therefore, from complying with its obligation to submit them to the SMV.
- In observance of the applicable regulations, a first difference must be drawn between the documents that would not have been submitted by the Issuer, grouped within those of annual periodicity: (i) the Audited Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; and, (ii) the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2014, which should have been approved by the highest body of the legal person; that is, by the General Shareholders' Meeting.
- In this sense, regarding the General Shareholders' Meeting, Article 111 of the General Corporations Law (LGS)[1] states that it is the supreme body of the company and that the shareholders constituted in a duly convened general meeting, and with the corresponding quorum, decide by the majority established by law the matters within their competence. Along these lines, Article 114 of the LGS[2], regarding the purpose of the Mandatory Annual Shareholders' Meeting, indicates that it is part of it to rule on the social management and economic results of the previous fiscal year expressed in financial statements of the previous fiscal year.
- From the copies of the resolutions issued by the Third Specialized Civil Court of Chiclayo and sent by the Issuer; as well as those found in the Judicial File Consultation service (CEJ) of the Judiciary, the convocation to the General Shareholders' Meeting is verified, which was left without effect at the request of one of the shareholders by validation and judicial order.
- That is, the holding of the Issuer's General Shareholders' Meeting is subject, among others, to having the current and complete list or register of shareholders of the Issuer and - due to the special situation in which the Issuer finds itself - to the subsequent issuance of a judicial resolution, it is a situation of force majeure, since it is independent of the Issuer's will and the cause that originates it is not attributable to it; consequently, a situation of force majeure is identified, in accordance with numeral 3.1 of the Criteria applicable to the Administrative Sanctioning Procedure for non-compliance with the rules that regulate the submission of periodic or eventual information[3], which are part of the Sanctions Regulation.
- In this framework, it is appropriate to declare partially founded the reconsideration appeal filed by the Issuer against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11, with regard to the sanction imposed for the non-submission of the Audited Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; and, the Annual Report corresponding to fiscal year 2014 and to proceed with the archiving of the sanctioning procedure in this respect.
- Regarding the following information: (i) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (ii) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (iii) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015; and, (iv) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015, it should be indicated that the applicable regulations state that these must be approved by the bodies that administer the company and not by the General Shareholders' Meeting; in strict observance of Article 8 of CONASEV Resolution No. 103-1999-EF/94.10 which states that the financial statements of individual interim and consolidated interim periods must be endorsed by a collegiate public accountant and the legal representative of the company, with clear identification of their names and registration number of the first named.
- That is, the obligation to approve the interim individual financial statements falls on the General Manager, since in accordance with Article 188 of the LGS, it is the latter's attribution to represent the company, with the general and special powers provided in the Civil Procedure Code.
- It is verified that the Issuer has a Judicial Administrator, Mr. Luis Alberto Dávila Dávila since 12 August 2014, who exercises the attributions and obligations provided in Article 671 of the Civil Procedure Code[4]. In addition, by communication of 18 September 2014 sent to the SMV and disclosed as a material fact on 27 October 2014[5], the Issuer represented by its Judicial Administrator - Mr. Luis Alberto Dávila Dávila - reported that Mr. Maxs Ayora Inoñán held the position of General Manager of the Issuer[6].
- From the foregoing, it can be concluded that the Issuer has had since 12 August 2014 a visible and identifiable figure of its General Manager, so arguing that this obligation was subject to the holding of the General Shareholders' Meeting lacks foundation, since the approval and subsequent submission of the interim individual financial statements and their management reports did not require the holding of said Meeting.
- That, from what has been evaluated in the preceding recitals, it corresponds to reformulate the amount of the sanction and impose the fine of 14.42 UIT[7], equivalent to S/ 55,517.00 (Fifty-Five Thousand Five Hundred Seventeen with 00/100 Soles) on the Issuer for not having timely submitted: (i) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (ii) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (iii) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015; and, (iv) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015; and,
In accordance with the provisions of numerals 14 and 22 of Article 43 of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF;
RESOLVES:
- To declare PARTIALLY FOUNDED the reconsideration appeal filed by Agro Pucalá S.A.A. against Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11, in accordance with the considerations set forth in this Resolution.
- To reform Article 2 of Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11, in order to modify the fine imposed on Agro Pucalá S.A.A. from 24.21 UIT to 14.42 UIT, equivalent to S/ 55,517.00 (Fifty-Five Thousand Five Hundred Seventeen with 00/100 Soles).
- To confirm Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency SMV No. 020-2016-SMV/11, in the respect of the sanction imposed for not having timely submitted (i) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (ii) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 December 2014; (iii) the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015; and, (iv) the Management Report corresponding to the Interim Individual Financial Statements as of 31 March 2015.
- To consider the administrative remedy exhausted.
- To transcribe this Resolution to Agro Pucalá S.A.A.; and, to the Lima Stock Exchange.
Register, communicate and publish,
Roberto Pereda Gálvez
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Market Conduct Supervision
-
"Article 111.- Concept
The general shareholders' meeting is the supreme body of the company. The shareholders constituted in a duly convened general meeting, and with the corresponding quorum, decide by the majority established by this law the matters within their competence. All shareholders, including dissidents and those who did not participate in the meeting, are bound by the agreements adopted by the general meeting. ↑
-
"Article 114.- Mandatory Annual Meeting
The general meeting shall mandatorily meet at least once a year within the three months following the end of the fiscal year.
Its purpose is:
1. To rule on the social management and economic results of the previous fiscal year expressed in the financial statements of the previous fiscal year.
2. To resolve on the application of profits, if any;
3. To elect, when appropriate, the members of the board of directors and set their remuneration;
4. To appoint or delegate to the board of directors the appointment of external auditors, when appropriate; and,
5. To resolve on other matters within its competence in accordance with the bylaws and on any other matter set forth in the convocation." ↑
-
"3.1 Exemptions from liability
If it is determined that the infraction committed was the product of a fortuitous event or force majeure, the sanctioning bodies of the SMV may exempt the administered entity from liability." ↑
-
"Obligations of the administrator.-
Article 671.- The administrator is obliged, as appropriate to the asset or company, to:
1. Manage the seized company, subject to its corporate purpose; 2. Make ordinary and conservation expenses;
3. Comply with the corresponding labor obligations;
4. Pay taxes and other legal obligations;
5. Prepare the balance sheets and sworn statements required by law;
6. Provide the Judge with the information required, adding observations on its management;
7. Make available to the Court the profits or fruits obtained; and
8. The others indicated by this Code and by law." ↑
-
File No. 2014040189. ↑
-
It should be noted that Mr. Luis Alberto Dávila Dávila was appointed as provisional administrator of Agro Pucalá S.A.A by Resolution Four Hundred Twelve of 12 August 2014 issued by the Third Specialized Civil Court of Chiclayo. This appointment is also registered in Entry C00030 of its Registry Entry No. 11004524 of the Registry of Legal Persons of the Registry Office of Chiclayo. ↑
-
Value of the UIT (2015): S/ 3,850 (Supreme Decree No. 374-2014-EF) ↑