Resolution of the Deputy Superintendency of the SMV
No. 006-2020-SMV/10
Summary: Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. is sanctioned with a fine of 15 UIT equivalent to S/ 59,250.00 (Fifty-nine thousand two hundred fifty and 00/100 soles), for having incurred in one (1) infraction of a very serious nature typified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, for having developed a complementary activity without previously having requested authorization from the SMV and in two (2) infractions of a serious nature, typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not having complied with sending to the Custodian the documents representing the shares acquired by the Investment Fund named Enfoca Capital 1 and in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, for not having presented the documentation requested during the inspection.
| | |
|---|
| Administered | : | Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. |
| Subject | : | Administrative sanctioning procedure |
| File No. | : | 2019033632 |
The Deputy Superintendent of Prudential Supervision
WHEREAS:
The administrative file No. 2019033632, and Report No. 027-2020-SMV/10.3, issued by the General Intendancy of Prudential Compliance; as well as the discharges and allegations presented by Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. and,
CONSIDERING:
- According to Article 1 of Law No. 29782, Law for the Strengthening of the Supervision of the Securities Market, the name of the National Supervisory Commission of Companies and Securities (CONASEV) is replaced by that of the Superintendency of the Securities Market (SMV), so that any reference to CONASEV in legal norms shall be understood as made to the SMV;
FACTS
- Within the supervision functions assigned to the SMV, an Inspection visit was made to Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. (hereinafter, Enfoca SAFI) in order to carry out an evaluation of its compliance with the provisions established in the Law of Investment Funds and their Management Companies, approved by Legislative Decree No. 862 and its amendments (hereinafter, the Law) and the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies, approved by SMV Resolution No. 029-2014-SMV/01 (hereinafter, the Regulation);
- As a result of said evaluation and under the provisions of the Single Ordered Text of the General Administrative Procedure Law, Law No. 27444, approved by Supreme Decree No. 004-2019-JUS (hereinafter, TUO of the LPAG), through Official Letter No. 4006-2019-SMV/10.3 notified on August 9, 2019 (hereinafter, Letter of Charges) charges were formulated against Enfoca SAFI for infraction of the provisions established in the Regulation, referring to complementary activities that must be authorized by the SMV, the delivery of physical titles to the Custodian and the delivery of information required during the inspection;
- On September 3, 2019, Enfoca SAFI presented the respective discharges to the charges formulated;
- The charges formulated as well as the discharges presented by Enfoca SAFI have been subject to evaluation in Report No. 027-2020-SMV/10.3 (hereinafter, Report), which has been submitted for consideration of this Deputy Superintendency;
- In observance of the Principle of Due Process contemplated both in Article IV, subsection 1, numeral 1.2 of the Preliminary Title, as well as in Article 248, numeral 2, of the TUO of the LPAG, through Official Letter No. 097-2020-SMV/10, the administrative file to which this resolution refers was made available to Enfoca SAFI for its review;
- On January 20, 2020, Enfoca SAFI presented its oral report;
II. ISSUES TO BE DETERMINED
- In the present administrative sanctioning procedure, in the opinion of this Deputy Superintendency, it corresponds to determine the following:
- Whether Enfoca SAFI incurred or not in infraction for having developed a complementary activity without previously having requested authorization from the SMV, in accordance with the provisions of Article 22 of the Regulation.
- Whether Enfoca SAFI incurred or not in infraction for not having complied with sending to the Custodian the documents representing the shares acquired by the Fund, according to the provisions of Article 81 of the Regulation.
- Whether Enfoca SAFI incurred or not in infraction for not having delivered information required during the inspection, in accordance with the provisions of Article 11 of the Regulation.
- Whether it corresponds or not to impose a sanction on Enfoca SAFI;
- ANALYSIS
- Of the unauthorized activity
3.1.1 Of the Applicable Regulations
- Regarding complementary activities, Article 12 of the Law establishes the following:
"Article 12.- Concept of investment fund management companies
Investment fund management companies are corporations whose corporate purpose is the administration of one or more investment funds.
(…)
Likewise, investment fund management companies under the competence of CONASEV may carry out activities complementary to their corporate purpose provided that there is authorization from CONASEV."
- In this sense, Article 22 of the Regulation states the following:
"Article 22 Complementary activities
The Management Company may carry out complementary activities provided that they are related to its corporate purpose, such as financial advisory, structuring and portfolio management in observance of the regulations issued by the SMV.
The Management Company may carry out complementary activities other than those expressly indicated in the preceding paragraph provided that said activity is not reserved exclusively for another entity, according to the regulations, with prior authorization from the SMV. For this purpose, it must submit a request to the General Intendancy of Supervision of Entities or the body that acts in its place, accompanied by the following documentation:
- Copy of the Minutes of the General Shareholders' Meeting containing the agreement adopted under the suspensive condition that the respective authorization from the SMV is obtained, to carry out a certain complementary activity to its corporate purpose, by the Management Company.
- Description of the risks associated with the development of the complementary activity and the possible impact that these could have on the activities or functions it develops, as well as its patrimonial solvency.
- Detailed description of the activity to be carried out, situations of conflict of interest that could arise and the measures it will implement to mitigate them.
- Draft amendment of the bylaws, if applicable.
- Any other documentation required by the SMV.
(…)"
- Additionally, the second complementary transitory provision of the Regulation indicates:
"Second.- Portfolio management
The portfolio management service by the Management Companies is subject to the regulation approved by the SMV."
3.1.2 Of the Facts Occurred
- During the inspection, through Official Letter No. 1148-2016-SMV/10[1] notified to Enfoca SAFI on February 26, 2016, it was requested to submit the limited partnership agreements, translated into Spanish and in their original language, of the so-called "Enfoca Discovery 1 LP" and "Enfoca Discovery 1 Parallel Fund LP" (hereinafter, Limited Partnerships), which, according to what was verified during the inspection, are under the administration of Enfoca SAFI. Additionally, it was requested to report whether Enfoca SAFI provides administration services for other investment vehicles or autonomous patrimonies, other than the investment funds defined by the Law;
- In response, on March 2, 2016, Enfoca SAFI indicated that with respect to the Limited Partnerships it was the General Partner of both entities and that its activities were limited to the provision of portfolio management services (as General Partner of the described entities) and the administration of the following investment funds: Enfoca Descubridor 1, Enfoca Capital 1 and Enfoca Descubridor 2;
- Subsequently, through Official Letter No. 2219-2016-SMV/10.2[2] notified to Enfoca SAFI on April 18, 2016, among the observations of the inspection carried out, it was noted that the management company, in its capacity as General Partner of the Limited Partnerships, would be carrying out activities that are not contemplated in the Regulation and that would not have been authorized by this Deputy Superintendency, for which it was required to adopt the pertinent measures to comply with the conditions set forth in Article 12 of the Law and, if applicable, with the limitations established in Article 22 of the Regulation, related to the complementary activities that investment fund management companies may carry out and, in general, comply with the conditions under which the authorization of operation was granted by the SMV;
- In response, Enfoca SAFI, through a writing dated May 7, 2016, indicated that the Limited Partnerships in which it participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds, in the terms of the Law and the Regulation. It added that the Limited Partnerships are rather foreign legal entities constituted by the contribution of their partners through which the investment fund business is carried out worldwide, with the General Partner being responsible for managing the investments it makes. Consequently, it argued that the activity of participating as General Partner was not an activity alien, contrary, or incompatible with its corporate purpose;
- Additionally, it stated that its activity as General Partner would constitute, under Peruvian law, a portfolio management activity. In this regard, it added that the only legal provision in which this activity is defined is the Regulation of Intermediation Agents (SMV Resolution No. 034-2015-SMV-01) which states that portfolio management is the activity of managing resources on behalf and at the risk of a third party, through investments in financial instruments. In accordance with this article, according to Article 22 of the Regulation, an investment fund management company may carry out the portfolio management activity as a complementary activity, without requiring the authorization of the SMV.
- In this context, it is noted that the "Form of Amended and Restated Agreement of Limited Partnership" of Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. and Enfoca Discovery 1 Parallel Fund 1 L.P., signed by Enfoca SAFI as General Partner, state in their Article 2 that the management, control and operation, and the determination of policies of both Limited Partnerships correspond exclusively to the General Partner and that it had authority to carry out all the objectives of the Limited Partnerships and to perform all acts it considers necessary, including, without limitation, the power to acquire, manage, sell, transfer, assign, exchange, pledge or dispose of the investments, among others;
- Although Enfoca SAFI states that the activity of General Partner of the Limited Partnerships would constitute portfolio management, according to the provisions of Article 22 of the Regulation, it should be noted that according to the second complementary transitory provision of the Regulation, said activity is subject to the regulation approved by the SMV, however to date the SMV has not issued a norm that regulates this activity for investment fund management companies;
3.1.3 Of the Charges Formulated
- Through the Letter of Charges, imputations were formulated against Enfoca SAFI, since according to the facts exposed by Enfoca SAFI, the Limited Partnerships in which it participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds under Peruvian law, and on the other hand, the complementary activity of portfolio management is subject to the regulation issued by the SMV, which has not occurred, in that sense it was imputed that Enfoca SAFI would have developed a complementary activity without previously having requested authorization from the SMV, as provided in Article 22 of the Regulation;
- Taking into consideration the facts exposed, it was imputed to Enfoca SAFI that it would be incurring in an infraction qualified as very serious as established in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which it constitutes an infraction of a very serious nature: "Carrying out complementary activities to the corporate purpose of the Management Company without having the authorization of the SMV"[3];
3.1.4 Of the Discharges Presented
- Enfoca SAFI states that it is pertinent to verify: i) what type of activities a SAFI is authorized to carry out and ii) what type of activity being General Partner implies:
- What permitted activities does a SAFI have?
It indicates that Article 12 of the Law highlights the following:
- The SMV will exercise supervision of a SAFI when it administers investment funds whose participation certificates are placed by public offering.
- The SAFI may administer mutual funds of investment in securities provided that it submits to the special regulation established by the SMV.
- The SAFI may administer investment funds of private offering provided that it submits to the special regulation established by the SMV and will be obliged to disseminate to the recipients that the SMV does not exercise any supervision over said fund.
- The SAFI may carry out complementary activities to its corporate purpose provided that there is authorization from the SMV.
- The authorization referred to in numeral iv) is regulated in Article 22 of the Regulation;
- In this sense, a SAFI may: a) administer investment funds placed by public offering, b) administer investment funds placed by private offering, c) administer mutual funds of investment in securities provided that it has authorization from the SMV, d) carry out complementary activities of financial advisory, e) carry out complementary activity of structuring and f) carry out complementary activity of portfolio management. Any other different activity must be previously authorized by the SMV, according to Article 22 of the Regulation;
- What is a General Partner?
- Enfoca SAFI explains the legal figure of the Limited Partnership, indicating that it is the vehicle through which the activity of investment fund management is carried out in the industry worldwide; within this, the General Partner is the managing partner, while the Limited Partners are the passive partners, who do not participate in said administration;
- Article 9 of the Securities Market Law (hereinafter, LMV), as well as the First Final Provision of the Law establish that the local and international stock exchange and commercial uses are applicable supplementarily, as the case may be. It adds that these provisions become relevant with respect to its activity, since the entities and acts under questioning are nourished by international commercial reality;
- This idea is reinforced by the fact that the Superintendency of Banking, Insurance and Private Administrators of Pension Funds (hereinafter, SBS) recognizes as an investment fund the Limited Partnership when they carry out their feasibility analyses within the framework of Title VI of the Compendium of Regulatory Superintendency Norms of the Private System of Pension Fund Administration. Moreover, the SBS specifically recognizes the Limited Partnerships managed by Enfoca SAFI as investment funds ("alternative mutual funds", according to the terminology of the cited regulation);
- As proof, it attaches Official Letter No. 56267-2009-SBS of November 25, 2009, where the SBS requests it to comply with certain requirements for the Enfoca Discovery 1 LP fund to be considered as a fund, such as appearing in the prospectus and the regulation as management company and the investments of the fund, in accordance with the investment policy indicated in the Agreement of Limited Partnership, must be made entirely in companies that carry out their economic activities in Peruvian territory, so that the objective of the "fund" is similar to the Enfoca Descubridor 1 fund (private fund) managed by Enfoca SAFI;
- Likewise, it attaches Official Letter No. 49706-2010-SBS of October 28, 2010, where the SBS notifies them of the definitive registration in the Registry of Foreign Investment Instruments of the SBS of the foreign alternative mutual fund named "Enfoca Discovery 1, LP";
- In this sense, Enfoca SAFI reaffirms that the Limited Partnerships in which it participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds in the terms of the Law and the Regulation; however, it indicates that this does not imply that the SMV does not recognize that these figures and/or structures exist and are used in the -Peruvian and foreign- investment fund market. Furthermore, considering that the SBS has already recognized the Limited Partnerships as foreign alternative mutual funds and their manager as management company or General Partner;
- Additionally, Enfoca SAFI states that the activity it carries out as General Partner comprises the management, control and operation, and the determination of policies of the Limited Partnerships, including without limitation, the power to acquire, manage, sell, transfer, assign, exchange, pledge or dispose of the investments, among others;
- Consequently, Enfoca SAFI states that the Limited Partnerships are foreign investment vehicles, which are used to carry out the investment fund activity -in the most literal sense- and are managed by it, through the figure of General Partner, as such;
- To support its statement it cites the following foreign doctrine:
"Funds are organized as limited partnerships or limited liability companies (LLCs) under state regulations. Investors become limited partners (LPs) in the partnerships and commit capital to the fund. A general partner (GP) manages the partnership (…)"[4]
- Enfoca SAFI indicates that it is the General Partner who for its management work charges fees to the Limited Partnership, as it would charge a management or success fee when managing an investment fund placed by public and/or private offering and that under the Limited Partnerships or investment vehicle are the different investments made with the resources that make up the vehicle;
- Likewise, Enfoca SAFI mentions that at the request of the SBS all the investments made by Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. have also been made by one or more of the other investment funds (governed by Peruvian law) that it manages, such as Enfoca Descubridor 1. In this sense, it could not be ignored that in one case (that of Enfoca Descubridor 1) it does private fund management and in the case of Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. it does not. Adopting this interpretation would be incongruous;
- On the other hand, Enfoca SAFI states that:
"Investment funds begin their validity through the efforts of management companies, which are sometimes also known as "general partners" or "advisers", create funds with the purpose of attracting investors (…)"
A management company establishes a fund after several steps, usually simultaneously. First, the management company organizes the fund as a legal entity distinct from itself. Then, it causes the new entity to sign a contract with it. Under the terms of said contract, the management company agrees to provide all the operational and administrative services that the fund requires (…)";
The agreement grants the management company sufficient authority to direct the operations of the fund and the investment strategy"[5];
- It adds that the foregoing summarizes what it does and broadly the activity that any other SAFI carries out with respect to the public investment funds under its administration, and adds that it must be considered that the SBS already recognizes it;
- Considering this, it points out that while Peruvian legislation has established that an investment fund is an autonomous patrimony administered by a SAFI – in the case of public funds – or by an administering company or management company – in the case of private funds – Limited Partnerships are structured under the figure of a legal person incorporated under foreign law that is managed by the General Partner;
- It adds that regardless of the name of the structure adopted, in both cases, the purpose of the vehicles under its administration is to be patrimonies administered by a third party that will be responsible for their management, investment and divestment; consequently, the activity of a General Partner is not alien, contrary, or incompatible with the corporate purpose of a SAFI; in fact, the Limited Partnerships in which it has participated are investment funds that serve investors in the funds to make investments from abroad to Peru;
- Therefore, Enfoca SAFI argues that its activity as General Partner could be circumscribed within the activities of: i) administration of private funds (as in the case of Descubridor 1), where the SMV has no supervisory scope; or, ii) portfolio administration; in neither of these cases would it be necessary to request authorization from the SMV to carry them out;
- Notwithstanding the foregoing, Enfoca SAFI indicates that despite not being applicable because they are not publicly offered investment funds, it has complied with the different provisions of the sector regulations regarding Limited Partnerships and other investment funds;
- The independence of the patrimonies of each fund and investment vehicle from each other, and from its own patrimony, as provided in Article 14 of the Law. Likewise, accounting and recording of operations comply with said provision;
- The administration of each fund is subject to the decisions of the respective Investment Committee, just as the Limited Partnerships are subject to what the Limited Partnership Agreements establish regarding their administration and investments, as detailed in Article 15 of the Law;
- Neither Enfoca SAFI, nor its directors, managers, shareholders with a participation greater than 10% of the capital, the members of the Investment Committee and any person who participates in the investment decisions of the funds or who by reason of their position or position has access to information about them have carried out any of the prohibited activities of Article 17 of the Law, with respect to the Limited Partnerships and other funds under its administration;
- The resources of the Limited Partnerships and other funds under its administration have been invested taking as a parameter the provisions of Article 27 of the Law.
- It has complied with the diversification criteria of the participation regulations of the funds under its administration and the Limited Partnerships, as provided in Article 29 of the Law.
- It has not made prohibited investments with the resources it administers, as provided in Article 31 of the Law;
On the imputed charge
- Enfoca SAFI indicates that according to the Charge Letter, the portfolio administration activity could not be carried out without prior authorization from the SMV. In this regard, it considers that its activity as General Partner cannot constitute an infraction of the Regulation because:
- Administration of investment funds placed by private offering
- The SMV does not exercise any type of supervision or interference regarding the administration of private funds. Consequently, the administration of a private investment fund formed under the Limited Partnership structure should not be under the supervision of the SMV, except for the regulation contained in the Regulation that seeks to distinguish supervised vehicles from those exempt. The SMV must take into account that Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. has an investment object identical to that of the private fund Enfoca Descubridor 1; in this sense, it cannot recognize that for the case of the latter it carries out administration activity but for the case of the former it carries out a prohibited activity;
- The portfolio administration activity is permitted by the SMV
- Enfoca SAFI maintains that in the event it is considered that its activity does not constitute properly the administration of private investment funds, it must be considered that its function as such constitutes portfolio administration under Peruvian law and that this is expressly permitted by Article 22 of the Regulation and that the interpretation made in the Charge Letter is inconsistent;
- Indeed, it mentions that the cited article refers to two types of activities: i) those that do not require authorization from the SMV (first paragraph), and ii) those that require authorization from the SMV (second paragraph). Under the interpretation of the Charge Letter, all complementary activities would be subject to prior authorization from the SMV, which contradicts the sense of the rules; if so, activities as simple as financial advisory and structuring would also need a specific rule to be carried out;
- It adds that the fact that the first paragraph indicates the obligation of the SAFI to abide by the provisions that the SMV may issue in this regard is merely a recognition of the normative power of the SMV. Thus, if the SMV regulates, said regulation must be complied with, but it cannot be understood that the feasibility of developing complementary activities is subject to a specific regulation or prior authorization;
- In this sense, it maintains that portfolio administration is, therefore, an activity that the SAFI can carry out without prior authorization, although subject at all times to the rules that the SMV may dictate for such purposes and that the Second Complementary Transitory Provision of the Regulation does not suspend the portfolio administration service until the approval of specific regulation by the SMV; on the contrary, it warns the administered party that said service will be developed in due course by the administrative entity and that until then it will be governed by the mandatory rules in force of the Peruvian legal system. In other words, the fact that specific regulation for portfolio administration has not yet been enacted does not mean that SAFIs and other market actors can carry out said activity discretionally, which would constitute an erroneous interpretation of the aforementioned Complementary Provision, the Regulation and the LMV;
- Additionally, Enfoca SAFI points out that since there is no date of specific regulation that sets the parameters of the portfolio administration service, the SAFI is obliged to comply with the principles that dictate the regulation of the securities market, such as transparency and broad investor protection. The foregoing is complemented by the self-regulation of the SAFI as administrator and commercial uses and customs, expressly recognized by the LMV and the Law;
- Likewise, it highlights that the portfolio administration activity it would carry out is circumscribed – at present – to the exclusively private sphere, and with the participation of institutional participants as main actors (or investors) and that due to its own characteristics it is exempt from direct supervision by the SMV, as is not the case with public investment funds;
- It also mentions that the structure applied conforms to law and must be subject to a new legality analysis under a possible specific rule that the SMV may issue;
- In this sense, Enfoca SAFI indicates that the SMV cannot impute to it that it is carrying out complementary activities without having prior authorization when from the foregoing it follows that: a) portfolio administration is an activity expressly permitted by the SMV and applicable regulations, b) the only provision where the activity for SAFIs is regulated is in the Regulation and c) no authorization is required to develop said activity, as it is related to the corporate purpose of the administering company;
- Finally, it maintains that the foregoing has legal support in the principle of legality, reasonableness and predictability or legitimate trust, all of them recognized in Article IV of the TUO of the LPAG;
Evaluation of the defenses
- From the provisions of Article 12 of the Law, it follows that investment fund administering companies have as their corporate purpose the administration of one or more investment funds and will be subject to the supervision of the SMV as long as they have as their purpose administering investment funds whose participation quotas are placed by public offering. Additionally, they may administer mutual funds for investment in securities and private offering investment funds provided they submit to the regulation that the SMV issues regarding such funds. Likewise, SAFIs under the competence of the SMV may carry out activities complementary to their corporate purpose provided that there is authorization from the SMV;
- As for SAFIs that do not have as their purpose administering investment funds whose participation certificates are placed by public offering and that are not subject to the supervision of the SMV, they are obliged to disseminate among their recipients that this entity does not exercise any supervision and that therefore their management and services are the exclusive responsibility of the company;
- For the case of Enfoca SAFI, it must be noted that under the cited article and the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Administering Companies, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 042-2003-EF/94.10, (hereinafter, Old RFI), the SMV through CONASEV Resolution 006-2007-EF/94.10 of January 25, 2007 authorized the operation of Enfoca SAFI, in the following terms:
“Article 1.- Authorize the operation of Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A., which may also use the abbreviation Enfoca S.A.F.I. S.A., to administer only investment funds and order its registration in the corresponding section of the Public Registry of the Securities Market”
- Likewise, it is observed that its Public Deed of Incorporation of December 4, 2006, stated as corporate purpose “the administration of one or more investment funds, in any of the forms permitted by the Securities Market Legislation, in accordance with the provisions of Legislative Decree No. 862, Law of Investment Funds and their Administering Companies, and its complementary and related rules. Acts related to the same that contribute to the realization of its purposes are included in the corporate purpose”;
- Subsequently, through Article 22 of the Regulation, in force as of January 1, 2015, certain complementary activities were authorized, which will be analyzed later;
ii) Limited Partnership and General Partner
- In accordance with the proceedings described in this sanctioning procedure, Enfoca SAFI signed the "Form of Amended and Restated Agreement of Limited Partnership" of Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. and Enfoca Discovery 1 Parallel Fund 1 L.P., on June 11, 2010, as General Partner, stating in Article 2 that the management, control and operation, and the determination of policies of both Limited Partnerships correspond exclusively to the General Partner and that it had authority to carry out all the objectives of the Limited Partnerships and to perform all acts it deems necessary, including, without limitation, the power to acquire, administer, sell, transfer, assign, exchange, pledge or dispose of the investments, among others;
- Regarding the figures indicated, as Enfoca SAFI states, these are foreign investment vehicles that can be used to carry out activities similar to those of investment fund management, which, unlike what is regulated in Peruvian rules, operate as a company and are managed by a General Partner;
- Below are some scopes on these figures:
- Gutiérrez states that: "According to Garner, in Black's Dictionary, the limited partnership is an associative or corporate legal structure by which one or more persons join to carry out a business. The constituents of the limited partnership who are in charge of controlling the business of the partnership are personally liable for the debts of the partnership and are known as general partners. Persons who only contribute capital but do not have control are only liable up to the amount of their contribution"[6];
- Likewise, he mentions that: "The general partner is normally a legal entity separate from the hedge fund, and may be, in turn, a limited liability company or corporation. This generally has exclusive responsibility and power over the administration of the business and affairs of the limited partnership (that is, of the fund), including the administration of its portfolio"[7];
- Bastidas indicates that the Limited Partnership "is a type of business company, with one or more general partners, who manage the company and legally assume the obligations and debts. At the same time, in this type of company there are one or more limited partners, who are liable only in relation to the amount of the investments made." And regarding the General Partner, he adds that "it is a partner of a company that has unlimited legal responsibilities for debts and liabilities in general"[8]. Likewise, according to Rall in the Uniform Limited Partnership Act (2001), the default rule is that the General Partner is jointly liable for the obligations of the Limited Partnership, unless otherwise established. However, there are two established exceptions: it is not liable for obligations before its status as General Partner, nor for obligations incurred while it is a Limited Liability Limited Partnership (LLLP) and to have such status it may be indicated in its registration or later, and it is also considered that even in that case the General Partners could be liable for some obligations of the LLLP[9].
- On the other hand, according to the Law, the management of the management company is at the account and risk of the fund's participants, however, it will be obliged to indemnify the funds under its management for the damages caused as a consequence of the execution or omission of the prohibitions contemplated in said law and the participation regulation.
- In this sense, the general rule applicable to General Partners is unlimited liability for the obligations of a Limited Partnership, however, such figure differs from our regulation for investment funds.
- Regarding what Enfoca SAFI indicated, that the SBS recognizes Limited Partnerships as investment funds, such statement is not expressly evidenced in the attached official letters, since Official Letter No. 56267-2009-SBS of November 25, 2009 is the response to a query made regarding the regulatory conditions applicable to the management company of the Enfoca Discovery 1 LP fund;
- Likewise, in Official Letter No. 49706-2010-SBS of October 28, 2012, it is indicated that by SBS Resolution No. 608-2007, which approves Chapter XVI of Title VIII of the Compendium, referring to the Registry of Foreign Investment Instruments and in compliance with the provisions of Resolution No. 008-2007, the foreign alternative mutual fund: Enfoca Discovery 1 LP is definitively registered in the Registry of Foreign Investment Instruments of the SBS;
- In this regard, it is necessary to mention that the objective of the Regulation for the Investment of Pension Fund resources Abroad, approved by SBS Resolution No. 008-2007 and its amendments (hereinafter, Investment Regulation), is to regulate the investment of resources managed by the AFPs in the instruments or investment operations indicated in subsection q) of Article 25 of the Law of the Private System of Pension Fund Administration (hereinafter, SPP Law), that is, in financial instruments issued or guaranteed by States and Central Banks of foreign countries; as well as shares and securities representing rights over shares on deposit registered in Stock Exchanges; debt instruments, participation quotas of mutual funds and risk hedging operations issued by foreign institutions;
- In this sense, the registration in the Registry of Foreign Investment Instruments indicated in Official Letter No. 49706-2010-SBS, was made within the scope of the application of the SBS Investment Regulation, that is, it did qualify to be an object of investment of the resources managed by the AFPs;
- It should be added that the SBS develops its functions within the scope of its competence, which does not imply acceptance or rejection of the similarity of foreign investment vehicles with the legal concepts of mutual funds or investment funds, defined in the LMV and the Law, since regulation in other countries could be different; furthermore, as previously indicated, the objective pursued by the SBS in the Investment Regulation is to establish the parameters and requirements to diversify the investments of the Pension Funds managed by the AFPs, considering that there are various investment instruments or operations, which could even be issued abroad;
- Likewise, it is necessary to point out that regardless of the SBS's pronouncements in matters within its competence, investment fund management companies are subject to the control and supervision of the SMV, so the latter applies the regulations within its competence, without this implying ignoring that in the foreign market different investment vehicles are used that may be regulated under different names and rules, different from those regulated in our legal system;
- Therefore, what Enfoca SAFI stated lacks support, in the sense that the SMV does not recognize that figures and/or structures such as Limited Partnerships exist and can be used in the market – Peruvian and foreign – of investment funds, especially when the Statement of Charges has not mentioned ignorance of these investment vehicles; rather, it was stated that the Limited Partnerships in which Enfoca SAFI participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds according to what is regulated by Peruvian rules;
- Management of investment funds placed by private offering and the portfolio management activity
- In accordance with Articles 1 and 2 of the Law, the investment fund is an autonomous patrimony integrated by contributions of natural and legal persons for investment in instruments, financial operations and other assets, under the management of a management company constituted for such purpose, at the account and risk of the fund's participants. The fund's patrimony is divided into quotas represented in participation certificates that can be placed by public or private offering;
- Likewise, according to the Law, the SMV exercises supervision of the investment fund management company, as long as it aims to manage investment funds whose participation certificates will be placed by public offering, however, they may additionally manage private offering investment funds provided they submit to the regulation approved for such funds;
- In the case of private offering investment funds, as Enfoca SAFI maintains, the SMV does not exercise supervision over them and therefore their management, the information provided to their investors and the other services provided to them are the exclusive responsibility of the management company, however they must comply with the conditions indicated in Article 158 of the Regulation and send to the SMV the information indicated in Article 159 of the Regulation;
- In the present case, considering the above, we can conclude that the Limited Partnerships in which it participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds under the terms of the Law and the Regulation, which is also recognized by Enfoca SAFI in its defenses. Therefore, it is irrelevant that the investments made by Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P. have also been made by other investment funds (governed by Peruvian law) that it manages, such as Enfoca Descubridor 1, since such fact does not determine its similarity to the concept regulated by our rules;
- On the other hand, according to Article 12 of the Law, investment fund management companies may carry out activities complementary to their corporate purpose provided there is authorization from the SMV; in this sense, through the first paragraph of Article 22 of the Regulation, the SMV provided that they may carry out complementary activities provided they are related to their corporate purpose, such as financial advisory, structuring and portfolio management in observance of the regulations issued by the SMV;
- Regarding portfolio management, from a reading of the above and the Second Complementary Transitory Provision of the Regulation, it follows that this activity is subject to the regulation approved by the SMV, which has not been issued to date;
- In this sense, the Statement of Charges has not indicated that all complementary activity is subject to authorization issued by the SMV, since the first paragraph of Article 22 of the Regulation indicates which complementary activities do not need prior authorization from the SMV, so the inconsistency indicated by Enfoca SAFI is not observed;
- Likewise, in the Statement of Charges it was indicated that the complementary activity of portfolio management is subject to the regulation issued by the SMV, which has not occurred, therefore Enfoca SAFI would have developed an activity without previously having requested authorization from the SMV, as indicated in Article 22 of the Regulation. It being understood that complementary activities other than those indicated in the first paragraph of Article 22 of the Regulation, provided that such activities are not exclusively reserved for another entity, according to the regulations, may be carried out by investment fund management companies with prior authorization from the SMV;
- In the case of portfolio management, this is a complementary activity that investment fund management companies could carry out without prior authorization from the SMV; however, as previously indicated, the characteristics and development of this activity are subject to the regulation issued by the SMV, therefore as long as such regulation is not issued, the portfolio management activity cannot be developed, and it is not possible to affirm that a given activity qualifies as portfolio management under the terms of Article 22 of the Regulation. In this context, it should be considered that the prior condition to the issuance of the regulation aligns with the objectives of investor protection and transparency, allowing an entity to provide a service that implies that investors delegate to a third party the administration of the investment portfolio held in the name of each investor and that are not part of a collective investment vehicle. The possible impacts on the patrimonies and portfolios under the ownership of these investors makes it necessary to establish the minimum conditions for the portfolio management service to achieve the stated objectives. For this reason, prudentially, the regulator has established as part of its regulatory framework that for the provision of the portfolio management service by investment fund management companies, the respective regulation must be issued beforehand;
- Regarding what Enfoca SAFI stated, in the sense that the Second Complementary Transitory Provision of the Regulation does not suspend the portfolio management service until the approval of specific regulation by the SMV, it lacks support, since as mentioned above said provision must be interpreted together with the provisions of the first paragraph of Article 22 of said regulation;
- However, Enfoca SAFI could have submitted to the General Superintendency of Entity Supervision (IGSE) a request with the detailed description of the activity to be carried out, which according to it is circumscribed exclusively to the private sphere and with the participation of institutional investors and the risks associated with it, among other requirements indicated in the second paragraph of Article 22 of the Regulation, said body being the one in charge of making observations or granting the corresponding authorization;
- Considering that the Limited Partnerships in which Enfoca SAFI participates as General Partner do not qualify as investment funds under the terms of the Law and the Regulation, so it did not declare them as management of investment funds placed by private offering and that the complementary activity of portfolio management is conditioned to the regulation issued by the SMV, so it cannot be affirmed that the activity it carried out qualifies as such, it was appropriate for said SAFI to request prior authorization from the SMV through a request to the IGSE, pursuant to Article 12 of the Law and the second paragraph of Article 22 of the Regulation, attaching, among others, documentation containing the detailed description of the activity, so that the SMV evaluates aspects such as the risks associated with the development of the complementary activity and the possible impact they could have on the activities or functions it develops, as well as its patrimonial solvency, among others;
- Additionally, no violation of the principle of legality, predictability or legitimate trust indicated in Article IV of the TUO of the LPAG is observed, and regarding the principle of reasonableness, this will be analyzed at the time of analyzing the sanction;
- It should be noted that by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01 the Sanctions Regulation was approved (hereinafter, New Sanctions Regulation), which entered into force on December 19, 2018. Now, in accordance with the principle of non-retroactivity contained in numeral 5 of Article 248 of the TUO of the LPAG[10], which was reflected in Article 2 of said resolution, which provides the following: "Infractions committed before the entry into force of this resolution shall be processed in accordance with the rules in force at the time they occurred, unless the provisions approved by this resolution are more favorable to them," the sanctioning provisions in force at the time the infraction was incurred apply, unless subsequent rules are more favorable;
- Considering the aforementioned principle, in the present case the Sanctions Regulation (currently repealed) applies, unless the New Sanctions Regulation contains provisions more favorable to Enfoca SAFI;
- Regarding the facts subject to imputation, the New Sanctions Regulation also classifies the infraction committed by Enfoca SAFI as a very serious infraction, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification;
- In light of the above paragraphs, Enfoca SAFI has not disproved the charges imputed, so it has incurred an infraction classified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.14 of the Sanctions Regulation; according to which it constitutes a very serious infraction: "Carrying out activities complementary to the corporate purpose of the Management Company without having the authorization of the SMV"[11]
- On the custody of the Fund's investments
3.2.1 On the Applicable Regulation
- Article 81 of the Regulation specifies that:
"Article 81.- Custody of the documents representing the Fund's investments
The Management Company must adopt adequate rules for the custody of the contracts, instruments or rights over assets that make up the Fund's assets, contemplating in the case of real estate, the contracting of fire insurance or others necessary to safeguard the assets.
Securities represented by physical titles must be delivered to a Custodian so that it is responsible for the safekeeping of the documents. The Custodian must perform its activities in accordance with the contract signed with the Management Company."
3.2.2 On the Facts Occurred
- In addition to the provisions of Article 81 of the Regulation, point k of the Participation Regulation of the Enfoca Capital 1 Fund, Investment Fund (hereinafter, Participation Regulation) indicates:
"K. Custody of the Documents Representing the Investments
1. The titles or documents representing the assets in which the SAFI invests the resources of Enfoca Capital 1 shall be delivered by the SAFI to an authorized entity so that, with respect to these, it provides the corresponding custody services.
2; For this purpose, the SAFI shall have the services of the Custodian, which may be changed by the SAFI when it ceases to comply with the requirements to act as such or when the custody contract signed with the SAFI is terminated according to the causes set forth therein, and must previously inform the Surveillance Committee. The new custodian must be duly authorized to provide such services and have a risk classification of no less than B-.
3. For investments in the Peruvian market, the respective Custodian must have authorization from the SMV. For its part, in the case of investments abroad, the Custodian shall be an entity of recognized prestige that is authorized by the competent authority to provide custody services in the market where these investments are traded."
- On this matter, it must be noted that during the inspection, information was requested from Enfoca SAFI regarding the fund named Enfoca Capital 1, Fondo de Inversión (hereinafter, the Fund) as of September 30, 2015, from which it was observed that its investment portfolio included 2,650,003 shares representing the share capital of Enfoca en Comunicaciones S.A.C. (hereinafter, the Shares), whose valuation represented 84.8% of the Fund's total assets[12];
- In that regard, by email of February 1, 2016, during the inspection, Enfoca SAFI was asked to confirm whether the physical certificates representing the Shares were in the Fund's custody or whether they had been dematerialized. Said email was answered the same day confirming that they were physical certificates in their own custody[13];
- Subsequently, by Official Letter No. 2219-2016-SMV/10.2 notified to Enfoca SAFI on April 18, 2016, the observations of the inspection carried out were reported so that it adopt the pertinent measures to remedy them and submit a report of the specific actions or action plan it adopts; among the observations it was stated that the physical certificates would be under the custody of the management company and would not have been delivered to a third entity, as established in Article 81 of the Regulation. Additionally, it was required to place under custody the physical certificates that made up the Fund's portfolio and to submit the respective contract entered into for that purpose;
- In this regard, by letter of May 7, 2016, Enfoca SAFI indicated that it would adopt immediate measures to deliver in custody the physical certificates representing the investments that make up the Fund's portfolio, which at that date were the Shares, and that it was in negotiations with a company specialized in providing custody services and that it would submit the signed contract as soon as possible;
- It should be mentioned that on October 23, 2017, Enfoca SAFI submitted a document called "Custody Services Agreement for Investment Fund Management Companies" entered into with Banco de Crédito del Perú for the purpose of providing custody services to the Fund and other investment funds managed by Enfoca SAFI, which was entered into on June 13, 2013, that is, prior to the inspection carried out. However, in this communication, Enfoca SAFI does not indicate since when it has delivered to the Custodian the physical certificates representing the Shares;
- Therefore, the Shares, which according to what was stated by Enfoca SAFI were represented by physical certificates, were under its custody, when they should have been delivered to its Custodian, who should perform its activities in accordance with the contract signed with the management company, in accordance with the provisions of Article 81 of the Regulation;
- By Official Letter of Charges, imputations were filed against Enfoca SAFI, because it would not have complied with submitting to the Custodian the documents representing the shares acquired by the Fund, therefore, it would not have complied with the provisions of Article 81 of the Regulation. Likewise, it did not comply with the provisions of point k of the Fund's Participation Regulation;
- In that regard, and taking into consideration the facts set forth, Enfoca SAFI would be subject to an infraction classified as serious as established in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which the following constitutes an infraction of a serious nature: "Failure to maintain in the form and conditions provided by the regulations, the fund's assets, or the custody of the certificates or documents representing the assets in which the fund's resources have been invested, as well as the participation certificates"[14];
3.2.4 On the Defenses Submitted
- Enfoca SAFI maintains that, upon reviewing the contracts signed with custodians, it found the document called "Custody Services Agreement for Investment Fund Management Companies" entered into with Banco de Crédito del Perú (BCP), dated June 13, 2013; said contract had as its purpose the provision of custody services to the Fund and other investment funds managed by it. This contract was submitted to the SMV on October 23, 2017;
- It adds that subsequently, on October 30, 2017, voluntarily and without any compliance requirement, it instructed BCP, within the framework of said contract, to proceed to hold in custody share certificate number 17 corresponding to the shares that the Fund held in Enfoca Comunicaciones S.A.C.
- In order to corroborate the foregoing, Enfoca SAFI attaches as Annex C a copy of the proof of delivery of instructions to BCP, with the bank's own receipt stamp dated October 31, 2017;
- Additionally, Enfoca SAFI attaches as Annex D the "Institutional Custody Service Settlement" statement from BCP detailing the custody of the physical certificate corresponding to the Shares as of July 31, 2019;
- Enfoca SAFI states that considering the foregoing, it has demonstrated that it voluntarily remedied the act imputed as constituting an administrative infraction prior to the notification of the Official Letter of Charges, in accordance with the provisions of Article 27, literal f) of the New Sanctions Regulation;
3.2.5 Evaluation of the Defenses
- As Enfoca SAFI maintains, it entered into a "Custody Services Agreement for Investment Fund Management Companies" with Banco de Crédito del Perú (BCP) on June 13, 2013; said contract had as its purpose the provision of custody services to the Fund and other investment funds managed by it, which was submitted to the SMV on October 23, 2017; however, during the inspection it was detected that it would not have complied with submitting to the Custodian the documents representing the shares acquired by the Fund, therefore, it was imputed that it would not have complied with the provisions of Article 81 of the Regulation, stating that on October 30, 2017, it instructed BCP, within the framework of said contract, to proceed to hold in custody share certificate No. 17 corresponding to the shares that the Fund held in Enfoca Comunicaciones S.A.C.;
- It should be added that from the letter of October 30, 2017 that Enfoca SAFI sent to BCP to deliver certificate No. 17 of shares that the Fund held in Enfoca Comunicaciones S.A.C., it is noted that it was received by BCP on October 31, 2017, proving that until that date the physical certificates representing said shares were under the Fund's custody;
- As for the arguments referring to the application of the exemption from liability established in literal f) of Article 27 of the New Sanctions Regulation, for voluntary remediation before the imputation of charges, they will be evaluated at the time of analyzing the sanction;
- It should be noted that the New Sanctions Regulation also classifies the infraction committed by Enfoca SAFI as a serious infraction, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification;
- In that regard, Enfoca SAFI has not disproved the charges imputed, so it incurred the infraction established in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the Sanctions Regulation; according to which the following constitutes an infraction of a serious nature: "Failure to maintain in the form and conditions provided by the regulations, the fund's assets, or the custody of the certificates or documents representing the assets in which the fund's resources have been invested, as well as the participation certificates";
3.3 Denying the delivery of information requested by the SMV
3.3.1 On the Applicable Regulations
- In this regard, Articles 10 and 11 of the Regulation provide the following:
"Article 10 Filing of information of the Management Company and the Fund
The Management Company must maintain, for a period of no less than ten (10) years, an electronic, physical or digital microform file of all books, records and supporting documentation corresponding, the electronic communications referred to in the Regulation and other information of interest.
The electronic, physical or digital microform files that the Management Company prepares in the exercise of its functions or uses to preserve its documentation must be subject to the legislation on the matter."
"Article 11 Supervision Actions
The Management Company must provide to SMV officials the documentation, books, records, recordings, files or any other information referred to in the Regulation and any other information required during inspections and other supervision and control actions.
The Management Company is prohibited from carrying out any action that could hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV."
3.3.2 On the Facts That Occurred
- During the inspection, various information was requested from Enfoca SAFI; however, part of said information was not provided, which was recorded in the Inspection Completion Record dated February 17, 2016;
- By Memorandum No. 02-2016-SMV/10.2.1-INSPENFOCASAFI of February 3, 2016, Enfoca SAFI was requested, within a period of 2 calendar days of receipt, to present various information, however it did not comply with presenting the following information:
- Share Registration Book of Enfoca en Comunicaciones S.A.C.
- Share Registration Book of Enfoca en Medios S.A.C.
- Sworn statements signed by the participants of the private offering funds managed by Enfoca SAFI, in compliance with the provisions of Article 158, literal b) of the Regulation;
- Regarding the funds managed by Enfoca SAFI, according to the individual interim financial information as of September 30, 2015[15], the management company was responsible for the administration of the following investment vehicles: Enfoca Descubridor 1 Fondo de Inversión, Enfoca Discovery 1 L.P., Enfoca Discovery 1 Parallel Fund 1 L.P., Enfoca Descubridor 2 Fondo de inversión and Enfoca Capital 1 Fondo de inversión. Of said collective investment vehicles only the last was registered in the corresponding section of the Public Registry of the Securities Market by Directoral Resolution of Autonomous Patrimonies No. 046-2011-EF/94.06.2.
- Likewise, by Memorandum No. 03-216-SMV/10.2.1-INSPENFOCASAFI of February 10, 2016, Enfoca SAFI was requested, within a period of two (02) calendar days of receipt, to present various information, however it did not comply with presenting the following:
- Escrow contract with BCP for the income from the sale of the investments in Maestro Perú S.A. and the documentation supporting the payment of distributions to the participants for said sale;
- On the Charges Filed
- By Official Letter of Charges, imputations were filed against Enfoca SAFI, since in accordance with Article 11 of the Regulation, the management company must provide to SMV officials the documentation, books, records, recordings, files or any other information referred to in the Regulation and any other information required during inspections and other supervision and control actions. Likewise, it is prohibited from carrying out any action that could hinder, delay or impede the supervision and control actions of the SMV;
- However, in the present case, Enfoca SAFI has not delivered the indicated information despite the requests made, and taking into account that it is the obligation of management companies to deliver information to the supervisor during inspections, documentation that is also within the period established by Article 10 of the Regulation for its preservation;
- In that regard, Enfoca SAFI was imputed with having contravened the cited regulations, therefore it would be subject to the infraction classified as serious, typified by Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, according to which the following constitutes a serious infraction: "Denying or delaying the delivery of books, documents and other information requested by CONASEV during inspections or investigations, not granting the facilities that CONASEV requests in the execution of the supervision and control actions it orders; as well as presenting documentation for the purpose of delaying the procedure, or in any other way obstructing supervision and control actions"[16];
3.3.4 On the Defenses Submitted
- Enfoca SAFI maintains that according to what is stated in the Official Letter of Charges, it has not delivered the corresponding information. In that regard, and in accordance with the provisions of Article 26, numeral 1, literal a) of the New Sanctions Regulation, it acknowledges its responsibility expressly and in writing. It also indicates that within the framework of the inspection a large amount of information was requested, which was timely delivered to the inspection team; in that context, there is always the possibility that some information remains pending, which it requests be taken into account as a mitigating circumstance of the infraction;
- Additionally, it states that the declaration of acknowledgment of the infraction is made precisely, concisely, clearly, expressly and unconditionally, therefore, if the sanction to be imposed is a fine, it must be reduced by 50% in accordance with the New Sanctions Regulation;
- It adds that it is important to note that it has reviewed its internal procedures and its Internal Rules of Conduct in order to prevent that in a future inspection there is a delay in the delivery of information requested by the SMV;
- Finally, without this being considered as an ambiguity to the acknowledgment of the infraction, Enfoca SAFI indicates that it is important to note that the SMV must take into consideration for the determination of the infraction the sanction criteria regulated by Article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with the following:
- Criteria to be considered for the imposition of sanctions:
- Recidivism for the commission of the same infraction: Enfoca SAFI maintains that it is not a recidivist in the commission of the same infraction within the period of 1 year prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned.
- Circumstances of the commission of the infraction: Enfoca SAFI states that it expressly acknowledges the commission of the infraction and that it has taken necessary corrective actions to avoid omissions such as those noted in the Official Letter of Charges. Likewise, it requests that it be taken into account that within the framework of the inspection the vast majority of the information requested was timely requested and presented, and the omitted information represented a minimal part of the total request.
- Illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction: There are no indications that it has obtained any type of benefit. Thus, in the absence of indications giving rise to presuming the existence of an illegal benefit, it corresponds that the administration assume that none have existed and adjust the eventual sanction.
- Probability of detection of the infraction: Since the imputed non-compliances occurred within the framework of an administrative procedure, the probability of the administration detecting the infraction was high.
- Seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest: Enfoca SAFI considers that no material damage to the public interest has occurred.
Evaluation of the Defenses
- Enfoca SAFI has acknowledged that it has not delivered the corresponding information, according to what is stated in the Official Letter of Charges;
- The arguments referring to the application of the mitigating circumstance of liability established in literal a) numeral 1 of Article 26 of the New Sanctions Regulation, for the acknowledgment of its responsibility expressly and in writing, will be evaluated at the time of analyzing the sanction;
- It should be noted that the New Sanctions Regulation also classifies the infraction committed by Enfoca SAFI as a serious infraction, so there is no more favorable provision regarding classification;
- In that regard, Enfoca SAFI has not disproved the charges imputed, so it incurred the infraction established in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- ON THE EVALUATION OF THE SANCTION
- The administrative sanctions that are imposed must take into account the provisions established in the LMV, the Sanctions Regulation and the TUO of the LPAG;
Exemption from liability assumptions
- Said assumptions are indicated in Article 257, numeral 1[17] of the TUO of the LPAG, whose literal f) establishes as a condition exempting from liability for infractions, the voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 255[18] of the TUO of the LPAG;
- From the evaluation of the defenses, it is found that regarding the infraction referring to the custody of the documents representing the fund's investments, Enfoca SAFI indicates that it remedied the act imputed as constituting an administrative infraction prior to the notification of the Official Letter of Charges, in accordance with the provisions of Article 27, literal f) of the New Sanctions Regulation;
- Although from the copy of the document called "Proof of delivery of instructions to BCP", it is observed that on October 31, 2017, Enfoca SAFI would have instructed BCP, so that within the framework of the custody contract entered into, it proceed to hold in custody share certificate number 17 corresponding to the Shares that the Fund held in Enfoca Comunicaciones S.A.C.; said fact originated as a response to the observations found in the inspection visit and that were notified to Enfoca SAFI on April 18, 2016, by Official Letter No. 2219-2016-SMV/10.2, in which regarding the custody of securities it was indicated that the physical certificates would not have been delivered for their respective physical safekeeping to a third entity, as established in Article 81 of the Regulation, requiring it to adopt the pertinent measures for the remediation of the observations, in response to which, by letter of May 7, 2016, it indicated that it would adopt immediate measures. That is, the remediation of the aforementioned observation was not a voluntary act;
- It should be noted that Article 27, literal f) of the New Sanctions Regulation establishes as an exemption from liability the voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of Article 253 of the LPAG and provided that no communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent;
- Likewise, Article 28 of the New Sanctions Regulation[19] regulates the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation excluding some assumptions, among which the aforementioned infraction is not included;
- In that regard, in accordance with the principle of non-retroactivity cited above and taking into account the text of the New Sanctions Regulation, it is not appropriate to apply the exemption from liability for voluntary remediation, set forth in Article 257, numeral 1, literal f) of the TUO of the LPAG;
- Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of Article 255, numeral 1 of the TUO of the LPAG, it is not observed that in the infractions analyzed in the present case any of the assumptions constituting conditions exempting from liability has been configured;
Determination of the sanction
- The determination of the sanction for the infractions that are the subject of this sanctioning procedure shall be carried out in accordance with article 348 of the LMV and article 6 of the Sanctions Regulation, in accordance with article 248, numeral 3[20] of the TUO of the LPAG[21] and the mitigating circumstances of responsibility indicated in article 255, numeral 2 of the aforementioned TUO;
- Within this framework, the evaluation of the sanction must consider: a) The offender's antecedents; b) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest; c) The harm caused and the repercussion on the market; d) Recidivism[22]; e) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; f) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction; g) The existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct; h) The probability of detection of the infraction; and, i) The voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification;
- In this sense, in order to reconcile the criteria of the TUO of the LPAG with those indicated in the LMV and the Sanctions Regulation, as well as for these criteria to be adequately considered so that their assessment observes the principle of reasonableness and the sanction to be imposed is adjusted to them, the following criteria are analyzed;
- With regard to the offender's antecedents, in accordance with the provisions of article 17 of the Sanctions Regulation, the sanctions imposed by the SMV that have become final within the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infraction to be sanctioned constitute the offender's antecedents. In this sense, from the review carried out in said period, it has been verified that, in relation to the infraction that is the subject of this administrative sanctioning procedure, Enfoca SAFI registers the following sanction antecedents:
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 014-2014-SMV/10 notified on June 10, 2014, by which Enfoca SAFI was sanctioned with four (04) reprimands and a fine of 15.05 UIT for having incurred infractions of a minor nature typified in Annex I, numeral 3, subsection 3.1 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- Deputy Superintendency Resolution SMV No. 014-2015-SMV/10 notified on June 1, 2015, by which Enfoca SAFI was sanctioned with a fine of one (01) UIT for having incurred two (02) infractions typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 21 of the Sanctions Regulation for failing to comply with the provisions of articles 120 and 121 of the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies, for not renewing and constituting guarantees.
- In this sense, it can be concluded that Enfoca SAFI does register sanction antecedents that became final within the four (4) years prior to the commission of the infractions that are the subject of this procedure;
- Regarding the seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest, it has not been possible to prove that Enfoca SAFI's actions in the commission of the infractions analyzed in this sanctioning procedure have caused damage to the public interest; however, the legal interest referring to the protection of investors and market integrity has been affected to the extent that the breach of the obligations contained in the Regulation limits the SMV's capacity for supervision and control of investment fund management companies;
- In relation to the above, it should be mentioned that the lack of a request for authorization to develop complementary activities as indicated in the second paragraph of article 22 of the Regulation affects the SMV's ability to effectively monitor the risks associated with the management company's management and to evaluate the possible impact they could have on its solvency or on the authorized activities it carries out;
- As for the failure to deliver the securities represented by physical titles to a Custodian so that it is responsible for the safekeeping of the documents, this increases the risk of disappearance or destruction of said documents, which could affect the fund's participants; likewise, the non-presentation of documents requested during an inspection does not allow the SMV to know their content in order to evaluate whether they comply with the established regulations; thus, among the documentation requested and not delivered was information that would have allowed verifying that prior to the subscription of participation quotas of the private offering funds, the participants were aware of the nature of the fund and the risks derived and assumed from their investment;
- Regarding the harm caused and the repercussion on the market, it should be noted that it has not been possible to evidence that the infractions incurred by Enfoca SAFI in this sanctioning procedure have caused concrete economic harm to market participants or have had a repercussion on the market;
- With regard to recidivism of the infraction, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final, it must be stated that Enfoca SAFI does not present sanctions, within the aforementioned term, for the commission of the same infractions, subject of analysis in this administrative sanctioning procedure;
- As for the circumstances of the commission of the infraction, it should be noted that Enfoca SAFI, in its capacity as a company supervised by the SMV, with authorization to operate since January 25, 2007, is aware of the rules that regulate the securities market and in that sense of the rules that oblige it to request authorization for complementary activities, deliver to a custodian the securities represented by physical titles and present the information requested during an inspection;
- It should be noted that with respect to unauthorized complementary activities, according to the interim financial information, up to the close of the second quarter of 2019, Enfoca SAFI was responsible for the management of the Limited Partnerships. Likewise, it is only as of the close of the third quarter that it is indicated that the management company is only responsible for the management of Fondo Enfoca Descubridor 1 Fondo de Inversión, Enfoca Descubridor 2 Fondo de Inversión and Enfoca Capital 1 Fondo de Inversión; that is, from April 18, 2016, the date on which Enfoca Safi was notified of Oficio No. 2219-2016-SMV/10.2 by which it was informed that it would be carrying out unauthorized activities and that it should adopt the pertinent measures to comply with the pertinent regulations regarding complementary activities, until June 30, 2019, the date on which it no longer managed the Limited Partnerships, more than 3 years elapsed;
- In the case of the delivery to the custodian of the physical titles representing the investments of Fondo Enfoca Capital 1, it should be mentioned that these were delivered on October 31, 2017 to BCP, that is, the infraction was remedied although not voluntarily, before the notification of the Oficio de Cargos;
- On the other hand, regarding the infraction for the non-delivery of information requested during the inspection, it should be specified that although it was acknowledged, to date it has not been presented;
- With regard to the illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infractions, it has not been proven in this administrative sanctioning procedure that Enfoca SAFI has obtained any illicit benefit as a result of having incurred the infractions subject of analysis;
- Regarding the existence or not of intentionality in the offender's conduct, no intentionality has been evidenced in Enfoca SAFI's conduct with respect to the infractions subject of analysis;
- Regarding the probability of detection of the infractions, it should be indicated that in the present case the facts constituting infractions committed by Enfoca SAFI were evidenced within the framework of the inspection carried out on Enfoca Safi from January 26 to February 15, 2016; that is, as a result of an in situ activity, which implies the formation of a multidisciplinary work team, planning activities, sampling and continuous monitoring by the supervisor of the Inspection Division of the IGSE;
- As for the voluntary declaration of the commission of the infraction and the offender's contribution to its clarification, Enfoca SAFI, in accordance with what was indicated in its defenses, has expressly acknowledged its responsibility only for the commission of the infraction referring to denying the delivery of information requested by the SMV, as established in article 255, numeral 2, subsection a) of the TUO of the LPAG, a situation that will be considered at the time of determining the sanction to be imposed. Likewise, it has contributed to the clarification of the imputed infractions;
- Based on the above, it corresponds to determine the sanction to be imposed on Enfoca SAFI for having incurred the commission of one (01) infraction classified as very serious, typified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.14 and two (02) infractions classified as serious typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 and Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the Sanctions Regulation;
- On this matter, article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation**[23]** states the following:
"Article 15.- Concurrence of Infractions
(...). Likewise, when several conducts qualify as more than one infraction, the sanction corresponding to the most serious infraction is imposed."
- In this sense, by application of article 15 of the Sanctions Regulation, a sanction corresponding to infractions classified as very serious would correspond to be imposed on Enfoca SAFI;
- According to article 20 of the Sanctions Regulation, the commission of very serious infractions is sanctioned with a fine greater than fifty (50) UIT and up to seven hundred (700) UIT or with the suspension of the authorization to operate for a term of no less than ten (10) days and up to forty-five (45) days or revocation of the authorization to operate;
- However, in accordance with article 33 of the New Sanctions Regulation, the very serious infraction is sanctionable with a fine of no less than fifty (50) Tax Units (UIT) and up to seven hundred (700) UIT or with the suspension of the authorization to operate for a term of no less than ten (10) days and up to forty-five (45) days or revocation of the authorization to operate, therefore in the analyzed case the provisions of said norm are applicable, as it is more favorable, in application of article 2 of the resolution that approves the referred regulation;
- However, taking into account the sanction criteria analyzed, specifically the fact that it has not been evidenced that the infractions committed by Enfoca SAFI have caused damage to the public interest, nor economic harm to market participants, nor to the market, nor that it has obtained any illicit benefit; and in application of the principle of reasonableness contemplated in article 248, numeral 3 of the TUO of the LPAG which states that the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliances classified as infractions, this Deputy Superintendency considers that it would be possible to impose on Enfoca SAFI a sanction corresponding to the classification lower than that provided for very serious infractions, in accordance with the provisions of article 6, third paragraph of the Sanctions Regulation[24], for which it is proposed to impose a fine sanction applicable to minor infractions, in accordance with article 22 of the Sanctions Regulation[25];
In accordance with the provisions of article 32, numeral 16, of the Regulation of Organization and Functions of the SMV, approved by Supreme Decree No. 216-2011-EF and its amendments, as well as the Sanction Criteria and its amendment;
RESOLVES:
- Declare that Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred one (01) infraction classified as very serious typified in Annex VI, numeral 1, subsection 1.14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94, in force at the time the facts occurred, for having developed a complementary activity without previously having requested authorization from the SMV, in accordance with the provisions of article 22 of the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies.
- Declare that Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred one (01) infraction classified as serious, typified in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94, in force at the time the facts occurred, for not having complied with sending to the Custodian the documents representing the shares acquired by the Investment Fund named Enfoca Capital 1, as provided in article 81 of the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies.
- Declare that Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. has incurred one (01) infraction classified as serious, typified in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.3 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by CONASEV Resolution No. 055-2001-EF/94, in force at the time the facts occurred, for not having delivered requested information, in accordance with article 11 of the Regulation of Investment Funds and their Management Companies.
- Sanction Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A. with a fine sanction amounting to 15 UIT equivalent to S/ 59,250.00 (Fifty-nine thousand two hundred and fifty 00/100 soles) for the infractions detailed in articles 1, 2 and 3 of this resolution.
- This resolution does not exhaust the administrative route, unless it is consented to, and may be challenged before the Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision through the filing of a reconsideration appeal, presented before the same, within a term of fifteen (15) business days counted from the day following its notification.
- In the event that this resolution is not subject to challenge through a reconsideration appeal within the term of fifteen (15) business days from notification and becomes consented to, it must be published on the Portal of the Superintendency of the Securities Market, in observance of the provisions of numeral 1, article 7 of the Policy on dissemination of regulatory projects, general legal norms, regulatory agenda and other administrative acts of the SMV, approved by SMV Resolution No. 014-2014-SMV/01 and by the provisions of article 14 of the Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01.
- Transcribe this resolution to Enfoca Sociedad Administradora de Fondos de Inversión S.A.
Register, communicate and publish.
Omar Gutiérrez Ochoa
Deputy Superintendent
Deputy Superintendency of Prudential Supervision
-
File No. 2016007588. ↑
-
File No. 2016002552. ↑
-
Currently, the referred infraction is contained in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.2 of the New Sanctions Regulation, approved by SMV Resolution No. 035-2018-SMV/01. ↑
-
Two and twenty: Taxing Partnership profits in private equity funds, FLEISCHER, Victor In: New York University Law Review, Volume 38, Number 1, April 2008, page 8. Free translation. ↑
-
The Separation of Funds and Mangers: A theory of Investment Fund Structure and Regulation, Morley, John In; The Yale Law Journal, Volume 123, Number 5, March 2014, pages 11 and 12. Free translation. ↑
-
Gutiérrez Molina, Isabel 2011, "Notes on the historical evolution, legal nature and role of investment funds in the Peruvian capital market: a comparative analysis of this industry", Ius Et Veritas, no. 42, p. 158. ↑
-
Gutiérrez Molina, op. cit., 2011, p. 159 ↑
-
Bastidas Méndez, Carmen 2007, "The Enron case. Main accounting, auditing and corporate governance aspects", RIL Editores, p. 130 (https://books.google.com.pe). ↑
-
Lauris G.L. Rall (2004) A General Partnerís Liability Under the Uniform Limited Partnership Act (2001) http://suffolklawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2004/04/Rall.pdf ↑
-
Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
5.- Non-retroactivity.- The sanctioning provisions in force at the time the administered party incurs the conduct to be sanctioned are applicable, unless subsequent ones are more favorable to it.
Sanctioning provisions produce retroactive effect insofar as they favor the presumed offender or the offender, both in relation to the typification of the infraction and the sanction and its prescription periods, even with respect to sanctions in execution upon the entry into force of the new provision. ↑
-
Currently, the referred infraction is contained in Annex I, numeral 1, subsection 1.2 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
-
In accordance with the individual interim financial information of the Fund as of September 30, 2015 (File No. 2015041837, presented on October 27, 2015). ↑
-
It should be noted that according to the individual interim financial information of the Fund as of March 31, 2016, its investment portfolio was still made up of the same number of Shares (File No. 2016017524, presented on April 29, 2016). ↑
-
Currently, the referred infraction is provided for in Annex VI, numeral 2, subsection 2.7 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
-
File No. 2015041699 ↑
-
Currently, the referred infraction is contained in the typification established in Annex I, numeral 2, subsection 2.1 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
-
"Article 257.- Exemptions and mitigating circumstances of responsibility for infractions
1.- The following constitute conditions exempting from responsibility for infractions:
a) Fortuitous event or duly proven force majeure.
b) Acting in compliance with a legal duty or the legitimate exercise of the right of defense.
c) Mental incapacity duly proven by the competent authority, provided that it affects the aptitude to understand the infraction.
d) The mandatory order of a competent authority, issued in the exercise of its functions.
e) The error induced by the Administration or by a confusing or illegal administrative provision.
f) The voluntary remediation by the possible sanctioned party of the act or omission imputed as constituting an administrative infraction, prior to the notification of the imputation of charges referred to in subsection 3) of article 255
(…)." ↑
-
"Article 255.- Sanctioning procedure
Entities in the exercise of their sanctioning power adhere to the following provisions:
(…)
3. Once the initiation of the sanctioning procedure is decided, the instructing authority of the procedure formulates the respective notification of charges to the possible sanctioned party, which must contain the data referred to in numeral 3 of the preceding article so that it presents its defenses in writing within a term that may not be less than five business days counted from the date of notification.
(…)." ↑
-
Article 28.- Cases in which remediation is not applied as an exemption from responsibility
Remediation prior to the notification of the imputation of charges shall not be considered as an exemption from responsibility, when communication demanding compliance with the obligation has been sent.
The following are not eligible for remediation for the purposes of the provisions of literal f) of article 27:
- The presentation of inaccurate or false information or documentation to the SMV and/or that is disclosed to the market.
- The contravention of market abuse rules, referring to the improper use of privileged information and market manipulation.
- The late or incomplete presentation, or the non-presentation of material facts, financial information and annual reports.
- The carrying out of activities not permitted or providing services or performing activities not authorized by the SMV, in cases where the regulations require having the respective authorization.
- The carrying out of activities that imply the disposal of funds, financial instruments or any asset owned by clients without their authorization or the breach of custody, administration or fiduciary duties that entities authorized by the SMV have.
↑
-
Article 230, numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
-
"Article 248.- Principles of the administrative sanctioning power
The sanctioning power of all entities is additionally governed by the following special principles:
(…)
3. Reasonableness.- Authorities must foresee that the commission of the sanctionable conduct is not more advantageous for the offender than complying with the infringed norms or assuming the sanction. However, the sanctions to be applied must be proportional to the non-compliance classified as an infraction, observing the following criteria that are indicated for the purposes of their graduation:
a) The illicit benefit resulting from the commission of the infraction;
b) The probability of detection of the infraction;
c) The seriousness of the damage to the public interest and/or protected legal interest;
d) The economic harm caused;
e) Recidivism, for the commission of the same infraction within the term of one (1) year from when the resolution that sanctioned the first infraction became final.
f) The circumstances of the commission of the infraction; and
g) The existence or non-existence of intent in the offender's conduct". ↑
22. The sanctioning criteria referring to Recidivism and the Probability of detection of the infringement were introduced by Article 2 of Legislative Decree No. 1272, which amended, among others, Article 230; numeral 3 of the LPAG. ↑
23. Currently set out in Article 29 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
24. Currently set out in the last paragraph of Article 25 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑
25. Set out in Article 35 of the New Sanctions Regulation. ↑